Press Alt + R to read the document text or Alt + P to download or print.

No preview available

The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutLUA72-712 ' F' ), I\ AtIV- tr\$)).- ,rJ Affidavit of Publication '')/ STATE OF WASHINGTON COUNTY OF KING ss. Stella Greenwood being first duly sworn on • oath, deposes and says that she is the chief clerk of THE RENTON RECORD-CHRONICLE, a tri-weekly newspaper. That said newspaper is a legal newspaper and it is now and has been for more than six months prior to the date of publication referred to, printed and published in the English language continually as a tri- weekly newspaper in Renton, King County, Washington, and it is now and during all of said time was printed in an office maintained at the ' aforesaid place of publication of said newspaper. That the Renton • Record-Chronicle has been approved as a legal newspaper by order of the Superior Court of the County in which it is published, to-wit, King County, . Rezone from R-2 to R-4 Washington.That the annexed is a ___ ' CITY OF -. - - •voice=-approval,- disapproval as it was published in regular issues (and RENTON , opinions on same. not in supplement form of said newspaper)once each issue for a period NOTICE OF CITY OF RENTC PUBLIC HEARING Delores A. Mea BY City Cie ' of ona consecutive issues, commencing on the • RENTON DATE OF PUBLICATION Decemb CITY COUNCIL • 1,.1972. ' . 1 Dec. 72 NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN Published in the Renton F day of , 19 ,and ending the that the Renton City Council.has cord-Chronicle December 1, 19) fixed the 11th day of December, R1550., 1972, at 8:00 p.m. in the Council day of , 19 ,both dates Chambers of the Renton Munici- inclusive, and that such newspaper was regularly distributed to its .pal 'Building, Renton, Washington . subscribers during all of said period.That the full amount of the fee Ilse the time and place following:a public hearing to consider the • Appeal of planning commis, char ed for the foregoing 8. G sion decision to rezone proper- g g g publication is the sum of$ , which ty from R-2 to R-4 (located on has been paid in full at the rate of per folio of one hundred words the NE corner of the intersec- for the first insertion and per folio of one hundred words for each tion of N. 3rd St. and Pelly subsequent insertion. Ave. N) `\ Any and all intefested per- \\A QK qtr . sons are invited to be present to chief clerk . 4 . Subscribed and sworn to before me this day of Dec. 72 9 //e t 4H l� tt Ru• n and for the State of Washington, �`1 Fi\.r.(74.4 F fiQ g • . ir . • . gat Renton,King County. :.`?,:' �. —Passed-5y tituret,1955, known as Senate Bill 281, effective 1g1+: t. Junggpthy,JI 55. Co• ', :'`'` s ff. „. —Western. Co. rules for counting words and figures, adoptedb the newspapers of the State. •�o� ' ,c., r AC '1, s _ - /NRtliNlat�id.�adiAeNPtDiI. >•_.. 1 ,A _ 1 !,I , i N S •' it \ ) C , D a 4 z 5 i . , c I \ Si 1 ` ____ 6_- .. ST. J _ — �.�.. _ - el 4 I i r_ 5 i4., Q. �' \\\ ' >0, y s ''t4 ,'ere'' j / __ 5 - SW MINI n 1 �v .1 s ��' i / 4 t l\ , PM . , _.t__ z ' . i Y PACIFIC CAR / p.•�l ` N. y. an i ST x 1 I. ..: ..:..n.r r , r 7 •`�r. man �.�?.c i 0,a \t 1 f w >�� Q� Mr Oscar Schmuland j ,ei Dr and • O\ `t • •a® .3 Rezone : R-2 to R-4 and , ; 1 i .° RV j s rS•ecial Permit for Clinic cl- if( 115#',41 ' -2 - on elm w •�.:n 's'v n .x• 1PO Inn : =Al \\ '1,., I t ": k t•I MI F 1 I 1 a I:WI MII WI ' E•WErVa • � .7;l ) 0 .1,0 .1:mii �� 31.14. ,4„,-..-4,..H.W._79 . po-,a,, ,tti ,wap / ,, , ., ,i.R „,,' 1 ' i ‘ ' Of A.. QFitla r( / �ma,•_Ramos. • • N ..'.I i ,m,A7 milmi,E1P, OM WE .4.66111.3„4„m 174.,:m 110.71:lilt I /I' . I , r t i 1 p.m us- -am os.l.,..,11F/ Mr, mg \ Al U plc a VqV uY p . 1� 24: y � ,WC Il11 ' i , 1 j© 1, �' .. // irl, se!! ; •y u Art i rsToalNe ``\_ �,/ '' rEw .. Li Tin \ s � j -2 SENIOR JUN/04 '�-:�v�. r asir �= Arr,ck-4r . \�.,.- ', '� 1 \ \.,.1 P . HIGH HIGH '.� F>♦La ' MP AMTI MINIM �\ 'U'U'U x _1 SCHOOL SCHOOL OW MEWS 1'� irm rmI r • • Mr.0 , Iro ti,j >a.:_ Qmrs4iw, ems' ppp�p 3 ao p0 - 5 Cs x 111 man i1i wan, Cam_iniri ,y 1 'Q�� a W73,Q��>Eli.�QI��- 4� ., Mb 4 sus I Y+>¢t•�n ��_ IBA ! �.!� f� ue.Mlla pater AM ,\\4.... cL F asp t" �' nlos - '. �� r • ;: nt n �l y. -f � N ', fan 3 ©an sim .,o. • 1 i ; {sue 4411W �? gil . t Q �.—\..., 1 & cm• r- ' �n 2, an, r=f1e \ ' E 4 REZONE: R-2 to R-4 and SPECIAL PERMIT i Schmuland, Dr. and Mrs . Oscar, Rezone from R-2 to R-4 , and Special t x Permit for medical clinic in R-4 ' zone; property located on the NE corner of the intersection of N. 3rd St. and Pelly Ave. N. , t APPLICANT Dr. and Mrs Oscar Schmuland TOTAL AREA 1/4 acre i 1 , 3 PRINCIPAL ACCESS Pelly Avenue North . EXISTING ZONING R-2 i. EXISTING USE Single Family Residential ; PROPOSED USE Medical Clinic ' t i COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE PLAN High Density Multi-Family41 F COMMENTS. ' 4 C i t r, P r G f , OFR�-v Uti� pAR o ,24 THE CITY OF RENTON 2 o MUNICIPAL BUILDING 200 MILL AVE.SO. RENTON,WASH. 98055 0� co AVERY GARRETT, MAYOR • OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK DEL MEAD, CITY CLERK 04h.„SEP..00 tr� January 23, 1973 Dr. Oscar Schmuland 115 Pelly Ave. North Renton, Washington Dear Dr. Schmuland: We forward herewith copy aE Ordinance #2763 changing the zoning classification on your property from R-2 to R-4. We also enclose original Declaration of oRN Restrictive Covenants attached for your records. Sincenl.y yours, CITY OF RENTON Delores A. Mead \ : City Clerk I") DAM/mc Attachment (2) • • CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON ORDINANCE NO. 0'17 • AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON, • CHANGING THE ZONING CLASSIFICATION OF CERTAIN • • PROPERTIES WITHIN THE CITY OF RENTON FROM RESIDENCE • DISTRICT (R-2) TO APARTMENT HOUSES AND MULTIPLE • DWELLINGS (R-4) • WHEREAS under Chapter VII , Title IV (Building Regulations) • of Ordinance No• 1628 known as the `Code of General Ordinances of the City of Renton" , as amended , and the maps and reports adopted in conjunction therewith , the property hereinbelow described has heretofore .been zoned as Residence District (R-2) ;' and WHEREAS a proper petition for change of zone classification . of said property has been filed with the City Clerk on or about October 4 , 1972 ' , 'which petition was duly referred to the Planning Commission for investigation, study and public hearing ; and a public hearing having been held thereon on or about October` 25- , 1972 , /;I.k5ix • . - TA/MxIcixMumtzwzimmx3s1m4xmimakimmetxtmox2ma-xtmxx.21);x2. Z;xa, and said matter having been duly considered by the Planning Commission • and said zoning request being in. conformity with the City' s Comprehensive Plan, as amended , and the City Council having duly considered all matters relevant thereto , and. all parties having been heard appearing in support thereof or in opposition thereto , and a public hearing before .the City Council have been held thereon on or about December 18 , • 1972 ; NOW THEREFORE , BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY . OF RENTON, WASHINGTON, AS FOLLOWS : SECTION I : The following described property in the City of Renton is hereby rezoned to APARTMENT HOUSES AND. MULTIPLE DWELLINGS (R-4) as hereinbelow specified; the City Engineer and the Planning Director . are hereby authorized and directed to change the maps of the Zoning Ordinance , as amended , to evidence said rezoning , to-wit : Lots 25 and 26 of Block 6 , Renton Farm Plat, according to the plat recorded in Volume 10 of plats , page 97 , records of King • County, Washin.n-ton• 1 nca t ri On p.,l i y St b 2„a 3 _.._ J .. .. +.��. �• vy V. v 4t11 J L• N. Subjct to cel L.djt1 restric-C]_ve covenants running with the laid, a copy of which is attached hereto and made a part of this Ordinance as if fully set forth. - 1 - , . SECTION II : This Ordinance shall be in full force and • effect from and after its passage , approval and legal publication. PASSED BY THE CITY COUNCIL this 15th day of January , 1973. • (,(1e2- ) 0, -71/(- - iJg "mxNmal§wCity Clerk Delores A. Mead, 1973 . APPROVED BY THE MAYOR this 15th day of January •, (g4 . 1A-ei.,/lAW---- Garrett ,very' Mayor Approved as to form: • Z / aNtA dif-fr4tt 14, 7 Gerard. M. Shellan, City Attorney • Date of Publication: 1/M-1/73 • - 2 - DECLARATION OF RESTRICTIVE COVENANTS :(7 O CO , WHEREAS, Oscar Schmuland and Wanda Schmuland are the owners of the following real property in the City of Renton, ' County of King, State of Washington, described as follows : Lots 25 and 26 , Block 6 of Renton Farm Plat, according to plat recorded in volume 10 of plats , page 97 , County of King, State of Washington AND, WHEREAS, the owners of said described property desire to impose the following restrictive covenants running with the land as to use, present and future, of the above- described real property; NOW, THEREFORE, the aforesaid owners hereby establish, grant and impose restrictions and covenants running with the land as to the use of the land hereinabove described with respect to the use by the undersigned, their successors, heirs and assigns, as follows : HEIGHT RESTRICTION No building or structure shall be constructed exceeding a maximum height of twenty-five (25) • feet. OCCUPANCY Occupancy of the building constructed on said property shall be limited to separate or combined offices for a maximum of four (4) doctors and/or dentists. CONSTRUCTION START Construction shall commence within three years and be completed within one year thereafter. In the event that construction is not undertaken within the three-year period, said property shall revert to former R-2 zoning, and said restrictive covenants shall become void, without further action or hearing thereon. These covenants shall remain in full force and effect, unless otherwise changed or amended by the parties in writing, for a period of twenty (20) years from date hereof. Any violation or breach of any of these restrictive covenants may be enforced by proper legal procedures in the Superior Court of King County by either the City of Renton or any property owners adjoining subject property who are adversely affected by said breach. Notary Certification on OSCAR SCHMULAND Page 2. WANDA SCHMULAND - Page 1, - , • STATE OF WASHINGTON ) • County of King ) • t'') On this n _ day of t r / , 1973 , before me personally appeared Oscar Schmuland and Wanda Schmuland, -- the persons who executed the within and foregoing instrument, and CD said instrument to be the free and voluntary act and Cr') deed of said persons for the uses and purposes therein mentioned. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed my official seal the day and year first above written. •OS +yu9 *`'ram ` w A' �,ffi:`Y • Qvitittd Notary Public in and for themeS;t4e• f;t\ :a Washington, residing at , -"l e, :y • • • • • • • • - Page 2 - • ...= . ....._ ,. . ., . .... . . . . , • , . . • . . # ,. ., c.-7..) L--1 L.,.... C.:.,.: • 1 1 cos .P. "...:..0006...,: :. ., •^—.- ". .'f.,,,111, i',t's. -..' ' ,7.',:i-••,."--'1'" -4.: .. :--- % tor't ".... r- -•— .''..-•‘'. .• .,.. (41 7. ,—. . A,•.. 4' li-1 ,.:fi:- C.—.) n---f •*- ';',','• ' l' 1 °'‘-'--fr."-- ' r---1 t-.-{ ..... lfl mri 0 ...... 19 c.) 7 " 197) ,. . 0 L.,..„„L„...,. .. . .,_ 1----- ..---: ,-----.1 :•—.,:,7: -.-..z —.) KG il..:C..i...".',-TY, '. ' —• .<1.,ED for Retord at Request °‘ RENTC MLiNICIPAL BLDG. -...,.,;.w.v,-4.2 ..........—/,-i€4414+L—E.../4 :'-flf.'"t1Tfet"----•—• RENTON, WASH.. 9805' ` .. ._... , • RENTON CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING January 15 , 1973 Municipal Building Monday 8 : 00 P .M. Council Chambers MINUTES FLAG SALUTE AND Mayor Avery Garrett led the Pledge of Allegiance and called the Renton City CALL TO ORDER Council Meeting to Order. ROLL CALL OF CLYMER, SCHELLERT, DELAURENTI, PERRY, STREDICKE, BRUCE and GRANT. COUNCIL MEMBERS AVERY GARRETT, Mayor, DEL MEAD, City Clerk, G. M. SHELLAN, City Attorney, GWEN MARSHALL, Finance Director, GORDON ERICKSEN, Planning Director, BERT McHENRY, Acting Director of Engineering, M. C. WALLS, Fire Chief, HUGH DARBY, Police Chief, JAMES FRASER, Acting: Personnel Director, VIC TeGANTVOORT, Street Superintendent, BARNEY RUPPERT, Building Director, JACK LYNCH, Admin- istrative Assistant to Mayor and VERN CHURCH, Purchasing Agent. MINUTE APPROVAL MOVED BY GRANT, SECONDED BY SCHELLERT, MINUTES OF JANUARY 8, 1973 BE APPROVED 1/8/73 AS PREPARED AND MAILED. CARRIED. Award to Mayor Garrett presented award to Dr. Rudy Cumberbatch for excellent service Dr. Cumberbatch to the City of Renton as member of the Board of Trustees of Renton Area Youth Services (RAYS). Award to Award presented to Kenneth Bruce by Mayor Garrett for his service as Renton Kenneth Bruce City Council President during the year 1972. Vouchers Finance Committee Chairman Schellert recommended payment of Warrants No. 2917 #2917 - 3163 through 3163 which have previously received departmental certification as to receipt of merchandise and/or service, totaling $206,665.89. MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY GRANT, COUNCIL AUTHORIZE PAYMENT OF VOUCHERS. CARRIED. Councilman Grant noted inquiry re Warrant disposition dated 12/31/72, Estimate No. 2 for contract C.A.G. 3012-72 Downtown Improvement Project to determine if West Coast Electric complying with provisions of Affirmative ,Action Program. ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY BRUCE. AND CARRIED THAT. COUNCIL CONCUR IN . LEGISLATION COMMITTEE REPORT TO PLACE SCHMULANDREZONE ORDINANCE ON SECOND AND Ordinance 2763 FINAL READING. City Clerk read ordinance changing zoning classification from Schmuland Rezon R-2 to R-4 for medical clinic in North Renton Dr. and Mrs. Oscar Schmuland. Restrictive covenants having been recorded, it was MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY CLYMER, ORDINANCE BE ADOPTED AS READ. Roll Call vote resulted in 6 AYE.. with Stredicke casting dissenting vote: MOTION CARRIED, ORDINANCE ADOPTED. Legislation Committee report recommended first reading with referral back to Lotto-O'Neil committee on Lotto-O'Neil property rezone changing classification from rest- Rezone dential R-2 to business B-1, property located on Garden Ave. N. Mr. M. Lotto, 7812 S.Sunnycrest Rd. explained property planned for Valu Village facility who were anxious to start construction. Planning Director Erickson explained set back requirements. Clerk read letter from Erickson reporting contacting property owner to the north, Mrs. Vera 0. Ausman, who submitted letter objecting to rezone. Mrs. Ausman, 222 Meadow Ave. N. , being present explained her objection was to parking lot next to her apartment. MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY PERRY, AND CARRIED ORDINANCE BE PLACED ON FIRST READING ONLY. Following reading, it was MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY GRANT, ORDINANCE BE REFERRED BACK TO LEGISLATION COMMITTEE AND SUBJECT BE REFERRED TO THE COMMUNITY SERVICES COMMITTEE. CARRIED. Retirement Age Legislation Committee report recommended resolution be read and adopted setting mandatory retirement age for non-uniform personnel at age 65. MOVED BY CLYMER, SECONDED BY GRANT, AND CARRIED THAT THIS MATTER BE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE. CORRESPONDENCE & CURRENT BUSINESS City Clerk presented bid opening January 12, 1973 Refuse Disposal with five bidders. MOVED BY PERRY, SECONDED. BY CLYMER, MATTER OF GARBAGE CONTRACT BE Bid Opening 1/12 REFERRED TO PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE, BOARD OF PUBLIC WORKS, ENGINEERING Garbage DIRECTOR AND REPORT BACK TO COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE. CARRIED. Contract Claim for Damages filed by.Mark C. Endresen, tire damage, was read. MOVED BY Claim SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY CLYMER, CLAIM BE REFERRED TO THE CITY ATTORNEY AND Endresen INSURANCE CARRIER. CARRIED. RENTON CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES Page 2 1/15/73 CORRESPONDENCE AND CURRENT BUSINESS - Continued Acknowledgment Card acknowledging sympathy was read from Mr. and Mrs. Charles Delaurenti of Sympathy in appreciation of kindness at time of family loss. Amusement Application from Snappy Tavern for amusement device was read. MOVED BY License GRANT, SECONDED BY SCHELLERT, AND CARRIED THAT THIS BE REFERRED TO THE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE WITH POWER TO ACT. Taxi Service Letter from J. J. Abraham, President of 0 K Cab Inc., re emergency taxi service was read, letter being in rebuttal to Councilman Clymer's inquiry of last week on responsibility of taxi company to furnish service to Renton Hill during snow conditions. Mr. Abraham reported not being in competition with emergency services, having suffered considerable loss due to collison damage from snow conditions. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY CLYMER AND CARRIED THAT THIS LETTER BE REFERRED TO THE TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE. AUDIENCE COMMENT Mr. Abraham of 0 K Cab Co. , being present, further explained past experience J. J. Abraham in being unable to come back down Renton Hill during snow. APPOINTMENTS Mayor Garrett's appointment of Mrs. Evelyn Carue, 4312 N.E. 4th St, to the Mrs. E. Carue Planning Commission for a six-year term expiring January 1, 1979, replacing Planning Mr. Douglas, was read. MOVED BY DELAURENTI, SECONDED BY GRANT, AND CARRIED Commission THAT THIS MATTER BE REFERRED TO THE FINANCE AND PERSONNEL COMMITTEE FOR REPORT BACK. Harold Woodin Reappointment of Mr. Harold Woodin, 10607 112th Ave. S.E., to the Fire Civil Fire Civil Service Commission for a six-year term expiring January 1, 1979 by Mayor Service Garrett, was read. Roll Call vote on motion by Delaurenti, second by Grant to confirm appointment resulted in AYE 2: Delaurenti and Grant, NO 5: Clymer, Schellert, Perry, Stredicke and Bruce. Motion Lost. MOVED BY CLYMER SECONDED BY STREDICKE AND CARRIED TO REFER APPOINTMENT TO THE FINANCE AND PERSONNEL COMMITTEE, following established Council procedure. Municipal Arts Reappointments by Mayor Garrett to the Municipal Arts Commission were read, Commission three-year terms expiring January 1, 1976 for Mrs. Barbara Shinpoch, 361 Maple Ave. N.W. , Mrs. Ellen Hickok, 3331/2 Renton Ave. S. , Mr. Gerald Edlund, 7 Appointees 10026 S.E. Carr Road, Mrs. Charmaine Baker, 3713 Meadow Ave. N. , Mr. Randall Rockhill, 141 Capri Ave. N.E. , Mrs. Peggy Cummins, 13572 S.E. 161st P1. and Mrs. Hazel O'Harra, 9847 S. 187th St. , Renton. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY CLYMER, REFER APPOINTMENTS TO THE FINANCE AND PERSONNEL COMMITTEE FOR RECOMMENDATION. CARRIED. OLD BUSINESS Councilman Clymer presented petition representing 75 persons from Windsor Hill: requesting restoration of bus service to route which existed prior to new Bus Metro service. Two petitioners were present, Mrs. Agnes Carroll, 574 Bronson Transportation Way N.E. and Mrs. Phyllis E. McGerry, 551 Windsor Pl.N.E. Mr. Frank Cenkovich & Routing 2625 Benson Rd. S.urged new schedule be given consideration. MOVED BY PERRY, SECONDED BY CLYMER, AND CARRIED THAT MATTER OF BUS ROUTING WITHIN THE CITY LIMITS BE REFERRED TO THE TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE FOR REVIEW AND RECOMMENDA- TION. Committee of Council President Clymer presented Committee of the Whole report concurring Whole . in recommendation of thelabor Negotiations Committee and ratifying the terms of the contracts between the City and the Renton Police Guild and the City Labor and the Renton Firefighters Local #864. MOVED BY GRANT SECONDED BY PERRY Negotiations TO CONCUR IN RECOMMENDATION OF COMMITTEE OF WHOLE RATIFYING THE AGREEMENTS. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY SCHELLERT TO AMEND MOTION TO REMOVE RENTON FIREFIGHTERS LOCAL #864 AGREEMENT. Roll Call Vote resulted in AYE 3: Schellert, Delaurenti and Stredicke. NO 4: Clymer, Perry, Bruce and Grant. Amendment Motion Lost. ORIGINAL MOTION CARRIED. Committee of the whole report recommended that the contract documents between Labor the City and the Police Guild and the City and the Firefighters Local #864 Negotiations be referred to the Labor Negotiations Committee for documentation into proper Agreement legal form. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY BRUCE, TO CONCUR IN RECOMMEN- Police & Fire DATION OF COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE. Mr. Larry Weiss, Chairman of Firefighters Negotiators, reported agreement had been reached and needed to be reduced to legal language. MOTION CARRIED. INTER-OFFICE MEMO - • TO: DATE January 1I, 19/J FROM: Del Aeart, tasty Clerk _ RE: Restrictive_ Covenants - Dr. Oscar Schriuland Property Rezone Ordinance The covenants regmired in connection with the above-captioned property rezone have'now been filed with the King County Auditor and the proposed rezone ordinance is now ready for its second and final reading, first reading having been held on January 8, 1972. Del RENTON CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING January 8, 1973 Municipal Building Council Chambers Monday 8 : 00 P .M. MINUTES FLAG SALUTE AND Mayor Avery Garrett led the Pledge of Allegiance and called the Renton CALL TO ORDER City Council meeting to order. ROLL CALL OF CLYMER, SCHELLERT, DELAURENTI, PERRY, STREDICKE AND GRANT. MOVED BY CLYMER COUNCIL MEMBERS SECONDED BY PERRY, THAT ABSENT COUNCILMEMBER BRUCE BE EXCUSED. CARRIED. CITY OFFICIALS AVERY GARRETT, Mayor, DEL MEAD, City Clerk, G. M. SHELLAN, City Attorney, IN ATTENDANCE GWEN MARSHALL, Finance Director, GORDON ERICKSEN, Planning Director, BERT McHENRY, Acting Director of Engineering, DEL BENNETT, Airport Director, M. C. WALLS, Renton Fire Chief, HUGH DARBY, Police Chief, GENE COULON, Park Director, VIC TeGANTVOORT, Street Superintendent, BARNEY RUPPERT, Building Director and JACK LYNCH, Administrative Assistant to Mayor. MINUTE APPROVAL Upon inquiry by Council President Clymer for additions or corrections to 12/18/72 minutes of December 18, 1972, MOTION BY STREDICKE, SECOND BY DELAURENTI, AND COUNCIL APPROVED to add to Page 1, last paragraph "Moved by Stredicke, seconded by Delaurenti, Ordinance replealing 20 utility tax be adopted as read. Carried." IN MOTION BY STREDICKE, SECOND BY DELAURENTI, AND CARRIED, failing motion be added to Page 4, paragraph 9, "Moved by Stredicke, seconded by Delaurenti, to hold an open public vote." IT WAS MOVED BY CLYMER, SECONDED BY DELAURENTI, MINUTES OF DECEMBER 18, 1972 BE APPROVED AS AMENDED. CARRIED. Award to Mayor Garrett presented award to Mr. and Mrs. Don Holm for Mr. Holm's 12 years Mr. Don Holm of service to the citizens of Renton with the Juvenile Court Conference Renton Attorney Committee. In acceptance Mr. Holm looked forward to further community service as Renton School Board Member. Award to Award presented to William .Grant by Mayor Garrett for his service as Renton Wm. Grant City Council President during year 1971. Vouchers Finance Committee Chairman Schellert recommended payment of Warrants No. #2638 - 2916 2638 through 2916 in amount of $171,180.62, having received prior depart- mental approval. MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY CLYMER, AND CARRIED THAT COUNCIL AUTHORIZE PAYMENT OF VOUCHERS. ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS Legislation Committee Chairrrlan,Perry requested procedure of reading complete ordinance for first reading, with second and final readings combined and Ordinance Reading title only read. Legislation Committee report presented, recommending final Procedure reading (first reading 12/18/72) and adoption of an ordinance changing the penalty fee from $100 to $500 maximum amount to comply with the Optional ORDINANCE 2760 Municipal Code recommendation. Upon reading, IT WAS MOVED BY SCHELLERT, Penalties SECONDED BY CLYMER, TO CONCUR IN COMMITTEE REPORT AND ADOPT ORDINANCE AS READ. CARRIED. Roll Call vote resulted in unanimous Council approval and ordinance adopted. • Ordinance re Legislation Committee report recommended placing on first reading and refer- Schmuland Rezon ring back to committee an ordinance changing zoning classification from R-2 to R-4, Schmuland rezone, North Renton, asking to be notified when restrictive covenants filed. MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY GRANT, TO CONCUR IN RECOMMENDATION OF COMMITTEE AND PLACE ON FIRST READING. CARRIED. Upon reading, MOVED BY CLYMER, SECONDED BY DELAURENTI, AND CARRIED THIS ORDINANCE BE REFERRED BACK TO LEGISLATION COMMITTEE. City Clerk advised restrictive covenants filed with her and ready for recording. ORDINANCE 2761 IN A MOTION BY CLYMER, SECOND BY DELAURENTI, AND CARRIED Council concurred in Funds for PEP report of Legislation Committee placing following ordinances on first,second and final readings: An ordinance appropriating and transferring from the Surplus Cash, Emergency Employment Fund $53,003.33 into Phase I and II Salaries for PEP Employees. Following readings, it was MOVED BY CLYMER, SECONDED BY SCHELLERT TO ADOPT ORDINANCE. Roll Call vote resulted in unani- mous Council approval and ordinance adopted. Renton City Council Meeting Minutes Page 2 January 8, 1973 ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS - Continued ORDINANCE 2762 Finance Committee Report recommended adoption of ordinance correcting Budget Amended transposition of figures in Council changes incorporated into 1973 Budget in amount of $27,000. MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY CLYMER THAT COUNCIL CONCUR IN FINANCE COMMITTEE REPORT AND REFER MATTER TO LEGISLATION COMMITTEE. MOTION CARRIED. Legislation Committee report placed on readings, an ordin- ance amending Ordinance No. 2754 re adoption of Annual Budget for the Year 1973. MOVED BY DELAURENTI, SECONDED BY SCHELLERT, ORDINANCE BE ADOPTED AS READ. Roll Ca11 vote resulted in 5 AYE with Stredicke casting dissenting vote, Ordinance Adopted. Resolution 1832 Legislation Committee report recommended the following resolutions be read LID 277 and adopted: City Clerk read resolution creating LID 277 with intention Hearing 3/5/73 to install sanitary sewer lines in vicinity of N.E. 10th St. between Sunset Blvd. N.E. and Edmonds Ave. N.E. setting hearing date of March 5, 1973. MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY DELAURENTI, AND CARRIED THAT RESOLUTION BE ADOPTED AS READ. Resolution 1833 City Clerk read resolution declaring intent to install sanitary sewer lines LID 278 in vicinity of Earlington Gardens, west of Lind Ave. S.W., creating LID 278 Hearing 2/26/73 and setting hearing date of February 26, 1973. MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY GRANT AND CARRIED TO DISPENSE WITH COMPLETE READING AND ADOPT RESOLUTION. Resolution 1834 City Clerk read resolution making certain salary adjustments due to 1972 Transfer Funds negotiations by transfer within the current fund. MOVED BY SCHELLERT, Salaries SECONDED BY GRANT AND CARRIED THAT THE COUNCIL ADOPT RESOLUTION AS READ. Resolution 1835 City Clerk read resolution transferring and reimbursing the book fund from Transfer Funds the Branch Library Building Fund to the Book and other Library Material Fund, Library amount of $14,250. MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY STREDICKE AND CARRIED RESOLUTION BE ADOPTED AS READ. Resolution 1836 City Clerk read resolution setting the date of February 5, 1973 for a public Hearing 2/5/73 hearing on the vacation of a portion of a certain alley approximately back Vacation Alley of Standard Service Tire and Second South of Logan Street. MOVED BY DELAURENTI, SECONDED BY SCHELLERT, AND CARRIED TO ADOPT RESOLUTION AS READ. CORRESPONDENCE & Application for location approval for pool tables, novelty games and music CURRENT BUSINESS machines at Private Social Club by Rainier Vending & Amusement was read. MOVED BY GRANT, SECONDED BY STREDICKE, AND CARRIED THAT APPLICATION BE REFERRED TO Machines Request THE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE AND REPORT BACK TO COUNCIL. Bid Opening 1/4 City Clerk reported bid opening of January 4, 1973 LID 276 Kennydale Indus- LID 276 trial Sanitary Sewer Project (tabulation attached) . MOVED BY SCHELLERT, Kennydale Sewer SECONDED BY DELAURENTI AND CARRIED TO REFER MATTER OF BID OPENING TO THE Industrial PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE FOR RECOMMENDATION. (Rebid project) Claim for Damage Claim for alleged damages,by Vera M. Jewell1was read. MOVED BY SCHELLERT, Vera M. Jewell SECONDED BY GRANT AND CARRIED THAT CLAIM BE REFERRED TO THE CITY ATTORNEY AND Auto Tire INSURANCE CARRIER. Claim for Damage Claim from United Leasing & Investments alleging damage to the Penney Build- United Leasing ing basement due to broken lead in pipe, was read. MOVED BY DELAURENTI, SECONDED BY SCHELLERT, AND CARRIED TO REFER CLAIM TO CITY ATTORNEY AND THE INSURANCE CARRIER. Summons & Summons and Complaint was read by the City Clerk showing Greenwood Savings & Complaint Loan Assoc.,Plaintiff vs. Central Puget, Inc. and City of Renton, promissory #761105 note forclosure. City's interest being portion of land helf for possible future extension of Lind Ave. S.W. MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY DELAURENTI AND CARRIED THAT THIS MATTER BE REFERRED TO THE CITY ATTORNEY FOR RESPONSE. Condemnation Notice in Condemnation was read by City Clerk showing The State of Washington SR-169 as Petitioner vs. William A. Hess and Dorothy E. Hess et al including the Widening City of Renton, property located on Renton-Maple Valley Highway. MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY CLYMER AND CARRIED THAT THIS MATTER BE REFERRED TO THE CITY ATTORNEY. Lotto-O'Neil Letter from Planning Director Ericksen presented Planning Commission Rezone recommendation for rezone from R-2 to B-1 of property owned by M.W. Lotto and Wm. O'Neil, located on Garden Ave. N. between Bronson Way N. & N.2nd. i r DECLARATION OF RESTRICTIVE COVENANTS ' WHEREAS, Oscar Schmuland and Wanda Schmuland are . the owners of the following real property in the City of Renton, County of King, State of Washington, described as follows : • . . • Lots 25 and 26 , .Block 6 of Renton Farm Plat, • according to plat recorded in volume 10 of . plats , page 97 , County of King, State of Washington . AND , WHEREAS , the owners of said described property desire to impose the following restrictive covenants running with the land as to use, present and future, of the above- described real property; • . NOW, THEREFORE, the aforesaid owners hereby establish, grant and impose restrictions and covenants running with the land . ' as to the use of the land hereinabove described with respect. to ' the use by the undersigned, their successors, heirs and assigns, as follows : HEIGHT RESTRICTION • No building or structure shall be constructed . ' exceeding a maximum height of twenty-five (25) feet. . OCCUPANCY - Occupancy of the building constructed on said • property shall be limited to separate or combined offices for a maximum of four (4) doctors and/or ' dentists . CONSTRUCTION START • • Construction shall commence within three years and • be completed within one year thereafter. In the . event that construction is not undertaken within . the three-year period, said property shall revert to former R-2 zoning, and said restrictive covenants . shall become void, without further action or hearing . thereon. . • These covenants shall remain in full force and effect, unless otherwise changed or amended by the parties in writing, for a . period of twenty (20) years from date hereof . Any violation or breach of any of these restrictive covenants may be enforced by proper legal procedures in the Superior Court of King County by either the City of Renton or any property owners adjoining subject property who are adversely affected by said breach. . /‘ /; —.%- -c_-cam:__---�-_th`--- - Notar_ � CeH.fi cation o.n 5 OSCAR SCHMULAND Page 2. i , - j • ' WANDA SCHMULAND • • • STATE OF WASHINGTON ) • County of King ) On this day of ' ' = r , 1973 , before me personally appeared Oscar Schmuland and Wanda Schmuland, the persons who executed the within and foregoing instrument, and acknowledged said instrument to be the free and voluntary -act and deed of said persons for the uses and purposes therein mentioned. IN WITNESS WHEREOF , I have hereunto set my hand and affixed my official seal the day and year first above written. • • Notary Public in and for the State of Washington, residing at• • • • • • • • • • • • • • -_Page 2 - 44--( 1/ RENTON CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING December 18, 1972 Municipal Building Monday - 8 : 00 P.M. Council Chambers MINUTES FLAG SALUTE AND Mayor Avery Garrett led the Pledge of Allegiance and called the Renton CALL TO ORDER City Council meeting to order. ROLL CALL OF BRUCE, GRANT, CLYMER, STREDICKE, PERRY, DELAURENTI AND SCHELLERT. • COUNCIL MEMBERS AVERY GARRETT, Mayor, DEL MEAD, City Clerk, G. M. SHELLAN, City Attorney, CITY OFFICIALS GORDON ERICKSEN, Planning Director, BERT McHENRY, Acting Director of IN ATTENDANCE Engineering, VERN CHURCH, Purchasing Agent, VIC TeGANTV00RT, Street Supt. , M. C. WALLS, Fire Chief, BERNARD RUPPERT, Building Director, HUGH DARBY, Police Chief, DEL BENNETT, Public Works Administrator and JACK LYNCH, Administrative Assistant to the Mayor. MINUTE APPROVAL Mayor Garrett asked for minute approval of Public Hearings on December 1, 12/1/72 and 6, 1972 along with regular Council Meeting on December 4, 1972. • 12/4/72 There being no additions or corrections, it was MOVED BY BRUCE, SECONDED 12/6/72 BY CLYMER AND CARRIED, THAT THE MINUTES BE APPROVED AS PREPARED AND MAILED OUT. Vouchers Finance Committee Chairman Schellert recommended payment of Warrants No. 2212 - 2637 2212 through 2637 in. amount of $325,677.10 plus LID 270 Revenue Warrants LID 270 Cash R-14 and R-15 in amount of $3,940.89 and Cash Warrants #31, 32 and 33 in & Revenue same amount, having received prior departmental approval. MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY GRANT, COUNCIL AUTHORIZE PAYMENT OF VOUCHERS. CARRIED. PUBLIC HEARING 1 This being the date set, and public notice having been duly published Rescheduled and posted according to law, the public hearing was called to order by from 12/11/72 the Mayor,and City Clerk read Planning Commission recommendation to grant Dr. and Mrs. rezone from R-2 to R-4 for property located on the NE corner of the inter- O. Schmuland section of N.3rd St. and Pelly Ave. N. for Dr. and Mrs. Oscar Schmuland, Rezone R-2 to R Clerk also read petition approving of clinic planned for this location which carried five signatures, having read protest petition at 11/20/72 meeting. Planning Director Ericksen presented slides showing area. Attorney Vern Shansey of 4208 Stone Way N. , Seattle, showed architect's drawing of proposed clinic. MOVED BY GRANT, SECONDED BY BRUCE, AND CARRIE' THAT PUBLIC HEARING BE CLOSED. MOVED BY GRANT, SECONDED BY CLYMER, THAT THE SCHMULAND REQUEST FOR REZONE BY GRANTED WITH STIPULATIONS RECOMMENDED BY PLANNING COMMISSION (Height restriction of 25 ft, with occupancy limit_a to four offices) . MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY GRANT, TO AMEND' MOTION TO INCLUDE COVENANT WHEREIN CONSTRUCTION TO START WITHIN THREE YEAR PERIO, OR PROPERTY REVERTS TO ORIGINAL ZONING. Dr. Schmuland, being present, indicated agreement with covenant. MOTION TO AMEND CARRIED. MOTION AS AMENDED CARRIED. MOVED BY DELAURENTI, SECONDED BY CLYMER, REFER REZONE 1 TO LEGISLATION COMMITTEE FOR PROPER ORDINANCE. CARRIED. ORDINANCES & Legislation Committee Chairman Perry presented committee report recommend- RESOLUTIONS ing first reading for an ordinance updating the general penal code to the requirements of the optional code city from $100 to $500, maximum fine. Legislation Following reading by the Clerk, it was MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY Report GRANT, TO CONCUR IN THE RECOMMENDATION OF THE LEGISLATION COMMITTEE AND REFER THE ORDINANCE BACK TO THE LEGISLATION COMMITTEE. CARRIED: Ordinance 2755 An ordinance creating a special cumulative reserve fund to receive monies Cumulative Fund for paths and trails was placed on first reading. MOVED BY SCHELLERT, fund for trails SECONDED BY GRANT AND CARRIED THAT THIS ORDINANCE BE PLACED ON SECOND AND FINAL READINGS. Following readings, it was MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY GRANT, ORDINANCE BE ADOPTED AS READ. Roll Call vote was unanimously affirmative. Ordinance adopted. Also placed on first reading was an ordinance deleting the 2% utility tax. Ordinance 2756. MOVED BY GRANT, SECONDED BY BRUCE, AND CARRIED TO PLACE ORDINANCE ON SECOND 2/, Utility Tax AND FINAL READINGS. Follin readin Repealed owg g, roll call vote resulted in unani- mous approval and ordinance adopted. ,Renton City Council Minutes 12/18/72 'Page 2 ORDINANCES & RESOLUTIONS - Continued Ordinance 2757 Letter from Accounting Supervisor Bennett explained need for appropriation Appropriation & and transfer of $8,431.25 of excess revenue in the Waterworks Utility : Transfer - Metro Fund into Acct. 401/534.31.42 to cover the cost of payments to Metro. Ordinance placed on readings in MOTION BY SCHELLERT, SECOND BY DELAURENTI, AND CARRIED. Following readings, MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY DELAURENTI THAT ORDINANCE BE ADOPTED AS READ. Roll call vote was unanimously affirma- tive and ordinance adopted covering the Metro payments. Ordinance 2758 An ordinance transferring $653 from the current fund into the Engineering Transfer for Administrative-Conference Acct. 015/532.10.33.01 ($608) and Traffic Engi- Schooling neer Conferences and special schooling Acct. 104/542.60.33.01 ($45) to reimburse expenditures for PEP Program employee,was placed on first read- ing, having Finance Committee recommendation. MOVED BY DELAURENTI, SECONDED BY PERRY, TO PLACE ORDINANCE ON SECOND AND FINAL READINGS. Following readings, it was MOVED BY DELAURENTI, SECONDED BY PERRY, TO ADEPT ORDINANCE AS READ. Roll call vote was unanimously affirmative and ordinance adopted. Ordinance 2759 An ordinance appropriating and transferring excess revenue into Waterworks Earlington Utility - Earlington Gardens Sanitary Sewer Account in amount of $20,000 Gardens & and Waterworks Utility - LID Sanitary Sewers Account $6,000 was placed LID 276 on readings in MOTION BY STREDICKE, SECOND BY BRUCE, AND CARRIED. After Fund Transfer & ordinance read, it was MOVED BY DELAURENTI, SECONDED BY STREDICKE, TO Appropriation ADOPT ORDINANCE AS READ. Roll call vote was unanimously affirmative. Legislation Committee report/having Council concurrence, recommended the Resolution 1829 following resolutions be read and adopted: A resolution transferring Transfer Funds $5,846.25 from Houser Way - Urban Arterial to Houser Way - Forward Thrust Account. MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY GRANT, RESOLUTION BE ADOPTED AS READ. CARRIED. Resolution 1830 Resolution transferring $37,453 from the general UAB Account to Current Transfer Funds Fund for the purpose of reimbursing Engineering salaries for regular city employees who worked on various UAB Projects, was read. MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY BRUCE, RESOLUTION BE ADOPTED. CARRIED. Resolution 1831 A resolution levying a service charge on the City's Utility. Dept. in the Service Charge - amount of 1% of the gross value of the Utilities Plant improvements Utilities Plant including its capital assets with control of said department, was read. MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY DELAURENTI, RESOLUTION BE ADOPTED. CARRIED. Council Recessed MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY GRANT, COUNCIL RECESS. CARRIED. Council Recessed at 9:25 P.M. and reconvened at 9:40 P.M. Roll call resulted in all members of the Council present. CORRESPONDENCE & CURRENT Notice .in Condemnation(and for Trial Setting) in Superior Court - State BUSINESS of Washington, Petitioner, vs. Stoneway Concrete, Inc. , .City of Renton Renton Concrete Products, was read. Engineering Director McHenry advised Condemnation upon receipt of map from the State, right-of-way would be checked. SR 169 Area City Clerk Mead reported December 8, 1972 bid opening Earlington Gardens sanitary sewers, Proposed LID. 278 (tabulation attached) . MOVED BY BRUCE, . Bid Openings SECONDED BY STREDICKE, AND CARRIED THAT THE BIDS BE REFERRED TO THE PUBLIC Earlington WORKS COMMITTEE FOR STUDY AND REPORT BACK. (See later Committee Report) Gardens Sewer City Clerk reported bid opening December 13, 1972 for surplus equipment Surplus Equipment sale with eight bidders on various items (tabulation attached) . MOVED BY Legal SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY GRANT, AND CARRIED THAT THE BIDS BE REFERRED TO THE Publications FINANCE COMMITTEE. City Clerk reported on December 18, 1972 bid opening for 1973 Legal Publications for the City with two bids received (tabulation attached) . IT WAS MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY SCHELLERT, AND CARRIED THAT THE LOW BID OF RECORD CHRONICLE BE ACCEPTED FOR 8 POINT TYPE AT $2.35 PER COLUMN INCH FOR FIRST PUBLICATION AND $2.10 PER COLUMN INCH FOR ADDITIONAL PUBLICATIONS, AND ON MORE THAN AN EVEN INCH, THE BID OF 27Q PER LINE ON FIRST INSERTIONS AND 24Q PER SUBSEQUENT INSERTIONS BE ACCEPTED. Transfer of- • • Letter from Mayor Garrett listed transfer of funds within the budget Funds ' classes for the period June 12, through November 14, 1972 as required by Resolution No. 1232 and authorized by the Mayor, Council concurrence not . being required. A4E .4 • 4Rtm/ CITY OF RENTON NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING • BY RENTON CITY COUNCIL NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Renton City Council has fixed the llth day of December , 19 72 , at 8 :00 p.m. in the Council Chambers of the Renton Municipal Building, Renton, Washington as the time and place for a public hearing to consider the following: Appeal of planning commission decision to rezone property from R-2 to R-4 (located on the NE corner of the intersection of N . 3rd St. and Pelly Aver;- N) n D 11 1 1( 1): Any and all interested persons are invited to be present to voice approval , disapproval or opinions on same. CITY OF RENTON /(6LA„,, 7 �c De'l-ores A::. .,Mead,. City Clerk DATE OF PUBLICATION pec.e n'i b-e /,/97Z C E R T I F I C A T I O N STATE OF WASHINGTON) ) . ss . COUNTY OF KING ) I, hereby certify that three (3)' copies of the above notice were posted by Me ,in three conspicuous places on the property described and one ,copy was posted at the City Municipal Building, Renton., 'Washington on date of , , 19 • • Signed ATTEST %Nota..ry, Public, in a,nci for the State of Washington , 'residing at Renton . Minutes Renton City Council Meeting 11/20/7 • Page 2 CORRESPONDENCE & CURRENT BUSINESS - Continued • CAG 1946-72 Letter from Acting Engineering Director McHenry recommended Final Payment of S.W. Grady Way Signals & Illumination. Project with final in amount of $5,936.58 to contractor General Service Electri with payment of retained amount of $5,719.07 if after .30 dad or liens are filed and proof of payment of tax liabilities .a MOVED BY BRUCE, SECONDED BY CLYMER, CONCUR IN RECOMMENDATIOI ENGINEERING DIRECTOR McHENRY. CARRIED. Police Department Letter from Police Chief Darby reported public auction to d.; Auction 12/9/72 unclaimed property December 9,. 1972 at 10:00 a.m. to be pa in legal.. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY PERRY, TO AUTHOI • IN BOTH LOCAL NEWSPAPERS OF ADD 2 COLUMNS BY 5 INCHES. CAR Reimbursement to Letter from Finance Director Marshall requested reimbursemeJ ' Street Dept. Street Department Maintenance Account for asphalt used in cc Resolution 1826 with Arterial Street and Forward Thrust projects to be accoi • (See Below) resolution. MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY BRUCE, TO CONCUi OF FINANCE DIRECTOR AND REFER TO LEGISLATION COMMITTEE FOR i LEGISLATION. CARRIED. Bicycle Letter from Renton Police Officer's Guild President Caldwel. Registration bicycle registration program which has been in effect for ti 1,800 Down in conjunction with the Police Department, suggesting manda 3,600 To Go registration of bikes following safety check. Mayor Garret was read commending the Guild and advising consideration of ordinance when research completed. Supervisor of Accounti Bennett was asked by Mayor Garrett to check with Police Off prepare notice to be included with utility billings. • Surplus Items Purchasing Agent Church's request to dispose of listed surp by bid call was read. MOVED BY DELAURENTI, SECONDED BY CLY REFER COMMUNICATION TO FINANCE COMMITTEE FOR REVIEW AND REP • MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY PERRY, SUBSTITUTE MOTION TO COMMUNICATION TO LEGISLATION COMMITTEE FOR PROPER RESOLUTIO MOTION FAILED. MOTION TO REFER TO FINANCE COMMITTEE CARRIE Schmuland Appl. Letter from Planning Commission presented application for r No. R-712-72 Dr. & Mrs. Oscar Schmuland from R-2 to R-4 for property lc Public Hearing NE Corner of the intersection of N.3rd St. and Pelly Ave. E 12/11/72 read letter of protest from Evelyn M. and Albert W. Rosenst protesting petition bearing 16 signatures. MOVED BY STRED1 BY PERRY, DECEMBER 11, 1972 BE SET AS APPEAL DATE FOR PUBL1 ON SCHMULAND REZONE APPLICATION. CARRIED. City Clerk regt notify petitioners and applicant. Financing Request to finance Kennydale Industrial Sanitary Sewer Proje was read from Southwick, Campbell, Waterman Co. along with Garrett's response advising financing had been arranged. Candy Cane Sales Permission having been granted for additional agenda item, Cystic Fibrosis Mead read request for special permit to sell candy canes ox 12/2 - Christmas December 2, until Christmas by Cystic Fibrosis Juniors aff. the National Foundation. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY 1 PERMISSION BE GRANTED. CARRIED. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECO! MATTER OF ORDINANCE REGULATING SOLICITATIONS BE REFERRED TC Solicitations SAFETY COMMITTEE. CARRIED Legislation Legislation Committee Report recommended reading and adopt. Committee Report tion for the transfer of $544.00 to provide payment for asj Continued in connection with arterial and Forward Thrust Projects. r SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY STREDICKE, TO CONCUR IN COMMITTEE RI Resolution 1826 Following reading, MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY DELAUREI Fund Transfer TION BE ADOPTED AS READ. PROCLAMATIONS November 27, through December 2, 1972 was proclaimed Rentoi Renton Aerie 1722 1722 Fraternal Order of Eagles Week in Proclamation of May( Fraternal Order Garrett for 65 years of growth and service in the City, •urc of Eagles Week citizens to take cognizance and participate in observance. 11/27 - 12/2/72 DELAURENTI, SECONDED BY BRUCE, TO CONCUR IN PROCLAMATION Oi CARRIED. a t► RENTON CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING tuber 20, 1972 Municipal Building P.M. Council Chambers MINUTES SALUTE AND Mayor Avery Garrett led the Pledge of Allegiance and called the Renton 'O ORDER City Council meeting to order. 'ALL OF BRUCE, SCHELLERT, DELAURENTI, PERRY, STREDICKE, CLYMER and GRANT. "L MEMBERS i APPROVAL MOVED BY BRUCE, SECONDED BY DELAURENTI, APPROVE MINUTES OF November '72 13, AS PREPARED AND MAILED OUT. CARRIED. )FFICIALS AVERY GARRETT, Mayor, DEL MEAD, City Clerk, G. M. SHELLAN, City Attorney 'ENDANCE GORDON ERICKSEN, Planning Director, BERT McHENRY, Acting Director of Engineering, VERN CHURCH, Purchasing Agent, JACK LYNCH, Mayor's Admini- strative Assistant, DEL BENNETT, Public Works Administrator, HUGH DARBY, Police Chief, VIC TeGANTVOORT, Street Superintendent, TED BENNETT, Accounting Supervisor, BERNARD RUPPERT, Building Director and CLARK PETERSEN, Library Director. 1NCES & MOTION CARRIED, which was MADE BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY STREDICKE, ITIONS TO ACCEPT RECOMMENDATION OF LEGISLATION COMMITTEE REPORT, which placed the following ordinances on their second and final reading having been placed on first reading November 13: (1) An ordinance changing zoning classification from R-2 to B-1 of Franklin Life Insur- ince 2751 ance Company property located south of South 2nd St. and easterly Franklin of Safeway #335. MOVED BY DELAURENTI, SECONDED BY STREDICKE, ORDINANCE Insurance BE ADOPTED AS READ. Roll Call vote resulted in ALL AYES, CARRIED. (2) An ordinance changing zoning classification from GS-1 to R-1 of ince 2752 the Jay Holmes Property located N.E. 10th St. between Monroe Ave. N.E. ? Jay Holmes and Olympia Ave. N.E. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY DELAURENTI, irty ORDINANCE BY ADOPTED AS READ. Roll Call vote resulted in ALL AYES, CARRIED, ORDINANCE ADOPTED. Legislation Committee report also recom- mended first, second and final reading on an ordinance establishing a ince 2753 special fund to be known as the Library Construction Fund, Account No. 308/572/50.0G and Limited General Obligation Bond Fund 1972, Account :ruction No. 204/519/60 in accordance with Ordinance No. 2735. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY DELAURENTI, CITY CLERK BE INSTRUCTED TO READ ORDINANCE BY TITLE ONLY FOR FIRST READING. CARRIED. Following reading, MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY DELAURENTI, ORDINANCE BE PLACED ON SECOND AND FINAL READING. Following reading, MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY DELAURENTI, ORDINANCE BE ADOPTED AS READ. Roll Call Vote resulted in ALL AYES, ORDINANCE ADOPTED. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY BRUCE, RESOLUTIONS BE PLACED AS ITEM (i) ON AGENDA. CARRIED. 7PONDENCE ZRENT City Clerk Mead reported Bid Opening on November 16, for L.I.D. 276 FESS Kennydale Industrial Sanitary Sewer Project, May Creek to N. City Limit (see attached) . MOVED BY PERRY, SECONDED BY STREDICKE, REFER )ening BIDS TO THE PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE FOR REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATION. ?76 CARRIED. yard City Clerk Mead reported Bid Opening on Highlands Branch Library Con- iands struction Project November 14, (see attached) : Recommendation of ,h Library Library Director Petersen was read asking acceptance of low bidder isch Busch Construction in amount of $167,845 plus Alternate #2 making a `_ruction Co. total of $169,484 plus tax which was in concurrence with Architects 3idder Callison Associates and The Board of Trustees of Renton Library. Report of Board of Public Works was read recommending acceptance of low bid of Busch Construction plus Alternate #2 (Parking Lot Lighting) MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY PERRY, COUNCIL CONCUR IN RECOMMENDATION OF LIBRARY DIRECTOR AND BOARD OF PUBLIC WORKS AND AWARD CONTRACTOR TO BUSCh CONSTRUCTION CO. CARRIED. -'ook A representative of Lindbrook Construction Co. Inc. of Lynnwood inquired :ruction re affirmative action filed with LID 276 Project bid of 11/16/72, being ' advised bids referred to Public Works Committee. f♦ SI ' � � 4 OF R. A - ti o U \% Z PLANNING DEPARTMENT • RENTON,WASHINGTON _ o MUNICIPAL BUILDING • RENTON,WASHINGTON 98055 • BA 8-3310 9ys�°Apr ITAA-pF<,x3 November 16 , 1972 The Honorable Avery Garrett , Mayor Members of the City Council Renton , Washington Re : Planning Commission Recommendations Gentlemen : The Planning Commission has completed its review of the applica- • tions as noted below: SCHMULAND , DR. AND MRS . OSCAR , Appl . No . R-712-72 ; rezone from R-2 to R-4 ; property located on the NE corner of the intersection of N . 3rd St . and Pelly Ave . N . Total Area -- 1 /4 acre Principal Access -- Pelly Avenue North Existing Zoning -- Existing Use -- Single_-Family Residential Proposed Use -- Medical Clinic Comprehensive Land Use Plan -- High Density Multi -Family Upon completion of the public hearing on the subject applica- tion , the Planning Commission recommended that the Schmuland request for a rezone to R-4 be forwarded to the City Council inasmuch as said request is in compliance with the Compre- hensive Land Use Plan . It was further moved to amend the motion to include a height restriction of 25 feet., as well as limiting the occupancy of the building to a maximum of four offices . This recommenda- tion is incorporated into the motion recommending approval of the special permit application , as noted below. SCHMULAND , DR. AND MRS . OSCAR , Appl . No . SP-713-72 ; special permit for medical clinic in R-4 zone ; property located on NE corner of the intersection of N . ,3rd St . and Pelly Ave . N . Upon completion of the public hearing on the subject appli - cation , the Planning Commission recommended that the special permit be granted in the R-4 zone for the medical clinic for . 1 - . • //110 Avery Garrett , Mayor Members of the City Council Page 2 Dr. Schmuland , that a height restriction of 25 feet be maintained , that there only be a maximum of four offices , and that the development be in accordance with drawings and documents submitted with the application . Very truly yours , ( ann /r. on ricksen ' g iirector GYE : bmi Attach . cc : City Attorney \ 1 1 :t;` Renton, Washington November '2, '1972. , ' The Renton City Council Municipal Building 200 Mill Avenue South Renton, Washington 980% Gentl aman — — -- — In reference to a petition submitted to the Planning Commission on October 25, 1972, we are requesting that the members of the Renton City Council either deny or modify the rezone and special permit request of Dr, Oscar Schmuland to build a Medical- Dental Clinic at North Third and Pelly Avenue. - Our main objection is the rezoning of this area from the present R-2.zoning to R-4. We believe the building can be modified to meet with R-2 zoning provisions. The opposition stated at the Planning Commission Hearing that only this particular property would be rezoned, but we know full well, once this request is granted, anyone else may request the same. In view of the fact that nearly 100% of the homeowner's that signed this petition have paid taxes in this city and state for over - a half century, we believe these people's wishes should be considered as the top priority in this matter. Sincerely, era . v _ , Evelyn M. Ro s ens trom Albert W. Roseristrom 309 Pelly Ave No. Renton, Wa. 98055 • ��ram, ,`� Jj� _ ti 74('Pcil‘CEillEil / d\ 1kEd Z.b Y O 1 , y t Z ?� - '- • ( . . .. - ( • ' . '' '',. ' .. - ...' • '.'.- , EFIETON.•'''T.r.1.31-M.IGTON .."... ,', ': .. • • ' . . . . . OCTOBT. ,5,- 1972 -• .7'. •'' . /-\(i• • . .. ' ., . . . . , . . PLANNING DEPART1',ENT • . • \J . • RSITTON "I.TUNICIPAL BUILDING . . . .' . RE.NTON, 11-IASItINGTON 98055 WE THE 1.7.-3DSIGNI•ID DO 1-7.273/ OBJECT TO TITT.'4_, PROPOS7D REZTAING OF THE' CORNER LOT ON . .. . . THEi5tt71-5-1-i—TH -- .-1.RM'T. AND PELL/ ATLIIITS, FROM R®2 TO 13,--4: . , . . NAM ADDRMS . . . .. , „.4.1 t 1./ /7 , /(// iee.,/-&/' a/1 .. • • . . a ///...,e.:14...t.,A_ • . • c----; -,, . . -.3 I /-( I( •( .. . . ., , .c • 1 , . I' .. . . ,• . • . . . . .. 7 ,-•,-,7:3.- - (,, ' /1-"..,/:::,6-/./..:(.".z.-1-4/ - 1-1, ---, •', , i ". . . . , r -7 /).._ V ,, ',:e6-/(w.--t. . „ • _.) . , ,-) . , •c) Z, 7-___ "-A2 P.A l.- d-,-)`--?-- - -_-_-; } . . . • . ,'‘ i . • , . , . . . /,./,Zi_•,i ,,,,, (2)i i .'7 "Z‘icalf • C/ . . . .•-•-4,4_ . EA.. l ,..._... c„, ...../ /f /t • i I ..i ' ) ./.' - • ,....; .) .'''-7 '''-.7 / ''.S' i .• ' '1) 1 /*-1 , , „' / / 7- ,.../ ./..: ,...' Z../ se-•-•••— -L..../ , ?______. '•-•-•-C.,----;-''.-...,(..„,-"- ‘.........1 .C.••••... - I . • . . • , . '77. <-, .,:'".' -15 . , . , .. , 7 --; 7 . ( `_ ' .-!/' '.-- -- . • ii..--• 7 ...!....-,./_----./r ._,L, r r--- Th- '3 7 ' - '-'. • , r. , • .. c'f1-1. ....,,:: , r. .,,_(•---•' ,,,-1 ;-) / • .•. ---/- • . . _- / 1 — 7 ,a' ••'• i- /i',..-••--''-• • -i••'.." ,,.' . . ,.., •. . . . . • , ' ../' / ., , f:-. i i_ . .. l ( (j. 7 — - 01_,/s•-)•—<-.) i ‘, ,,..,1 — --;- _( - L.( • ' - (.; — --.- ‘... • 2;_)- ..---/•/>: '! ,)(A2/4‘••-• -11 • . _---, . •IV,11, -L./.....'•,. 7›,.456<:, t. 11../ ,,/----,1,1 , • . / .-•., /:/.2 11.....0 ' "4-7-1—''' •ii - I• 3 o 5 p,,.../..„,:y- • ., • •; . --k___ L-, - -.. ,,,,,,--)._e„..---,,r:::_ . . -_:,-- , r (-„„--_____________./, < •,,,, 4,, \, _,,,;--,,_:, 7 V._e,-6 if eq,-(.}4-. : ,., • /, 0 4\ c •3 , ,,,/,,,.... cy.,...2\-- 1 1, ....,,,,-,...... ,....,., ..„. Lug! • . , ..., ...._ liic,_) k..c..\ ,,, ,=.:il • , )- -, ,_, ,, . .,..• , . . , , f • . . . . ,,.../7.' s',..C..I/ 0\/ , . . .. .' ..,:, \\ • V3( 7 .' .;. • \<:'z..z....1:?1\11'r.I'''---) • , • ., ' •I . • ' :.', Renton Planning Commission Meeting October 25 , 1972 Minutes - Page 2 • ' • Page 2 , 4 . ( b) , 2nd paragraph , the statement "The height of the berm may also have .to be reduced to . 22 feet . " was made by Commissioner Scholes and should have been the • last sentence of Par . 4 (b ) ( 1 ) . • MOVED BY SCHOLES , SECONDED BY MOLA , THAT THE MINUTES OF • THE MEETING OF OCTOBER 11 , 1972 , BE CORRECTED AS PRE- VIOUSLY STATED BY THE CHAIRMAN . MOTION . CARRIED UNANI - MOUSLY . Mrs . Seymour called the attention of, the Commission to a recent California ' Supreme Court decision regarding the requirement of Environmental Impact Statements for private construction that may have a significant impact on the. environment. Following a discussion , it was moved by Seymour , seconded by. Scholes , that the minutes - of the meeting of October 11 , 1972 , be corrected to re- . . flect the introduction of the report of the State - • • • Supreme Court decision in the State of California . MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY . ACTION : . MOVED BY MOLA , SECONDED BY SCHOLES , THAT THE MINUTES OF - . THE MEETING OF OCTOBER 11 , 1972 , BE APPROVED AS. CORRECTED . MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY . • • 3 • PUBLICHEARING ITEMS • REZONE APPLICATION 1P4 - (a ) SCHMULAND , DR. AND MRS : OSCAR , Application No .• . R-712-72 ; rezone from R-2 to R-4 ; property located . on NE corner of . intersection of N . 3rd St . and Pelly . • Ave . N . • • • The Chairman described the application . He noted that the applicants are also asking for a Special Permit to • allow them. to build a medical clinic on this property . • The Planning Director pointed out that _ the Property is presently .zoned R-2 -- the designation for the low density multiple residence zone which allows duplexes and apartments . The long range use , as indicated on the Comprehensive Plan , is high density multiple . The adjacent property is indicated as commercial , and there is .presently some commercial to the east. The property is approximately 1 /4 acre . The Planning. Director noted that a medical clinic would • • be allowable in a multiple residential zone by Special Permit , with • approval by the Planning Commission and • establishment of special controls which might apply . Dr . Schmuland had requested rezoning of the property to an R•-4 classification since the front yard setback . would be ten feet rather than twenty feet as required under the R-2 classification . The Planning Director then reviewed the property char- acteristics . Vicinity map and site plan were displayed , and slides of the property were shown . The architect • then submitted elevation drawings as requested by the Planning Commission Chairman on the field trip . Mr. Ericksen noted that the proposed structure would be approximately the same height as the house located to Renton Planning Commission Meeting October 25 , 1972 Minutes - Page 3 the north of the subject property . In response to a question raised by Commissioner Scholes" on the field trip , Planning Director stated that the Parking and Loading Ordinance would require improvements and up- grading of the alley for the access and parking as proposed. Scholes asked if parking requirements for this facility had been met . Planning Director stated that the plan provides fo.r one space for each two hundred square feet of gross floor area as required by 'ordinance . . .. . Commissioner Scholes asked if there has been a precedent setting case that would allow exception from the front yard depth limitations in the R-2 and R-3 Zones . The Planning Director replied that he knows of no recent ex- ceptions . Some other clinics built in the past have utilized their front yards for parking and , therefore, have maintained a.. larger setback than as shown by appli- cant.. . . . A petition signed by 16 adjacent property owners raising objections to. the proposed rezoning was presented to the Chairman . Chairman asked that the petition be entered into the record. . Chairman asked for audience comments in favor of the application Mr. Vern "Shansby , 4206 Stone Way 'North Seattle , repre- " : senting ' th.e applicant, stated that applicant has been a dentist for . 18 years in Renton at his, present location . '. The floor" space to be used for dental office facilities is approximately 3 ,000 square feet , of which approximately : 50% would be for the applicant ' s own practice . Rezone was requested due to the front yard setback . To permit 19 parking spaces required , the building " was raised to two • stories to accommodate parking on the ground level be- { neath the structure . Mr. Shansby stated that the existing plantings will be retained , if possible , and other land- scaping and plantings will be provided . He stated further that the setback is actually as much as 13 feet rather than the .10 feet as required by code in an R-4 Zone . , Chairman Teega'rden said he was under the impression a medical clinic had to have at least an , R-3 zoning category . . to qualify for Special Permit. ' Mr. Ericksen noted that. ' R-2 does allow apartments , hotels , professional offices and mobile home parks by Special Permit upon examination and public hearing . R-3 ' and , also , R-4 ' does include the word "clinics " ; however, setback requirements must be met in the particular zoning requested . He noted also that the use of the setback area for parking has been a problem in the past. Commissioner Scholes asked about improvements of the alley . The applicant ' s architect stated that the applicant will provide the improvements on the alley as required by the City. Dr. Schmuiand then noted that the .City of -Renton would not only benefit from the usage of the clinic for dental health , etc. , but tha.t the proposed building would beautify the area as well . w • • • Renton Planning Commission . Meeting October 25 , 1972 • Minutes - Page 4 . • • Chairman next asked for comments opposed to the pro- posed rezone . • • • • Mr... A. J . Brattus , 323 Pelly N . , stated that many people . in the area are retired . and on a fixed income and are concerned about the value of the property being increased and taxes being raised . Discussion then followed with comments by Commission and staff members , and Mr . Stredicke of. the City Council , regarding possible in- creases in the assessed valuation of property adjacent to property being rezoned. ' iMrs . Lavina Kessler , 310 Pelly Ave . N . , owner of the adjacent property (to the north ) went on record as being opposed to the rezoning . She objected to the height of . the proposed building and the ten foot setback . Further discussion ensued regarding interpretation of the code in reference to "clinics " and "professional offices " , and Planning Director stated he felt that • basically the difference would be determined by intensity of use as well as the density. Mr . Shansby indicated that the . applicant' would be willing to specify that the • clinic would be used by no more than four doctors or • • • dentists if intensity was . a matter that concerned, the • • Commission . Scholes inquired as to the feasibility of moving the building .forward or backward . The architect , William Rigg , 4208 Stone Way North , Seattle , indicated it could be moved back to twenty feet ; however , the building is restricted by the parking requirement . • Frank Sankovich , Renton , of the American Association of Retired Persons , spoke on behalf of the nearby residents urging that the rezone be denied . • At the conclusion of the discussion ; it was MOVED BY HUMBLE , SECONDED BY SEYMOUR , THAT THE HEARING ON THE . - REZONE APPLICATION BE CLOSED . MOTION CARRIED UNANI- ' MO U S L Y . • • • ACTION : • • MOVED BY SEYMOUR THAT THE REQUEST FOR A REZONE FROM R-2 TO R-4 BE. DENIED. • • • Discussion followed regarding the legality and advisa- bility of suggesting alternatives . Mola noted that if the rezone were denied , then the applicant could possi - bly have to put the parking in the front yard and he felt that the landscaping as proposed in the front yard would be more desirable . Humble stated that the Compre- hensive Plan shows the area as R-4 , the applicant is applying for an R-4 rezone , the property is abutting B-1 zone ; therefore , the rezone would be hard to deny. Chairman stated that in his opinion the neighbors are opposed to the clinic regardless if it is built on the • • requested R-4 or - a modified R-2 as suggested by Seymour and Scholes . Seymour stated her opinion that the Com- prehensive Plan is a guide to future growth of the area and does not mean that a- requested rezoning would be automatically given just because it agrees with the • - Comprehensive ' Plan . • She -felt that the 'proposed rezone may be premature and , therefore , should be denied at • • this time . Renton Planning Commission ' Meeting October 25 , 1972 Minutes .- Page 5 SCHOLES SECONDED THE MOTION BY SEYMOUR THAT. THE SCHMULAND APPLICATION FOR REZONE FROM . R-2 TO R-4 BE DENIED , PRIMARILY - BECAUSE THIS IS NOT THE APPROPRIATE TIME FOR SUCH AN 'UP- GRADING IN ZONING . • On the motion , Chairman called for. a roll call vote , . with • the following results : Humble - No. _ Nola - No • Teegarden - No Scholes = Aye • Seymour - Aye MOTION FAILED ACTION : • MOVED BY HUMBLE , SECONDED BY MOLA , INASMUCH AS THE REQUEST IS IN CONFORMANCE WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN , THAT THE SCHMULAND REQUEST FOR 'REZONE TO R-4 BE RECOMMENDED TO THE CITY COUNCIL. . After further discussion , SCHOLES MOVED TO AMEND THE MOTION TO INCLUDE A HEIGHT RESTRICTION OF 25 FEET , AS WELL AS LIMITING THE OCCUPANCY OF -THE BUILDING TO A MAXIMUM OF FOUR OFFICES . SECONDED BY SEYMOUR. Seymour asked for clarification from the applicant . Mr. • • • Shansby stated the applicant will so stipulate that the building will not exceed a 25 foot height limitation , and will also stipulate that there will be a maximum of offices for four doctors and/or dentists in the building . AMENDMENT TO MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY . Question on the original motion , which was to grant the proposed rezone from R-2 to R-4 , subject to the amendment. ' Seymour listed her reasons for objecting . to the rezone . Vote was . taken with these results : MOTION CARRIED . One dissenting vote by Seymour . SPECIAL PERMIT' APPLICATION - (b ) SCHMULAND ,' DR . AND MRS . OSCAR , Appl . No . . SP-713-72 ; special 'permit for medical clinic in R-4 zone'; property ' located on NE corner of intersection of N . 3rd St . and . Pelly Ave . N . . Chairman asked if there was any further discussion required . . As there were no -further comments , it was' MOVED BY 'MOLA , SECONDED BY SEYMOUR , THAT THE HEARING ON THE SPECIAL PERMIT BE CLOSED. MOTION CARRIED . ACTION : MOVED BY MOLA, SECONDED BY SCHOLES , THAT' THE SPECIAL PERMIT BE GRANTED .IN THE R-4 ZONING FOR THE MEDICAL CLINIC FOR DR. SCHMULAND , AND THAT THE HEIGHT RESTRICTIONS AS STATED - 25 FEET ; BE MAINTAINED , AND THAT THERE ONLY BE A MAXIMUM . OF FOUR OFFICES , AND. ALSO THAT • IT• BE IN ACCORDANCE WITH • . THE DRAWINGS AND DOCUMENTS SUBMITTED WITH- THE APPLICATION . NOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY . , ..40-1,tilar 43 -).#.4.47-eal r Ciir-/ _ (a" 3 o 79' 7.2( ///..,,, .-,_,--A.„- -e.c--.7. .S-_,e,_--7„.,.....-- .L._______c'_-__tr-f -D •-- _,, --K- ------- X-Z- - , / '!H (5,,,L a_ec_a ‘Laxe Z- O ieL7II • ;. A.,L.Cmt,. ....4,<__61? a_ ..,..e,--1,' i 74-0_ /, -;)6_,I.L__4(.,e... . • ( ,.._ id-tc2-6-1,e_. I 0 • ,._cz , a or 3 1 3 :17 7_4 4: - '-X_ )24Vi : Z • -f' . --q,--5---0 cf-Z,61 / ,a- Le, .)Zd , . r . --- )'.> 0-- --- R ---:-A-7> . ----, W- , c.)---------------- —- , — — 9-1.9-12---- i3E.c \--6*----::------"'--b _ • ' sf CITY OF RENTON NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING BY RENTON CITY COUNCIL. NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Renton City Council has fixed the llth day of December , 19 72 , at 8 :00 p .m . in the Council Chambers of the Renton Municipal Building , Renton, Washington as the time and place for a public hearing to consider the following: • Appeal of planning commission decision to rezone property from R-2 to R-4 (located • on the NE corner of the intersection of N . 3rd St. and Pelly Ave,. N) • Any and all interested persons are invited to be present to voice approval , disapproval or opinions on same . CITY OF RENTON Al ..�� . f /7/` 4• � Delores A. Mead, City Clerk DATE OF PUBLICATION CERTIFICATION• STATE OF WASHINGTON) ) ss . COUNTY OF KING ) I, hereby certify that three (3) copies of the above notice were posted by me in three conspicuous places on the property described and one copy was posted at the City' Municipal Building, Renton , Washington on date of , 19 Signed ATTEST: Notary Public in and for the State of Washington , residing at Renton . Minutes Renton City Council Meeting 11/20/72 Page 2 CORRESPONDENCE & CURRENT BUSINESS - Continued • CAG 1946-72 Letter from Acting Engineering Director McHenry recommended acceptance Final Payment of S.W. Grady Way Signals & Illumination Project with final payment in amount of $5,9.36.58 to contractor General Service Electric, Inc. , with payment of retained amount of $5,719.07 if after .30 days no claims or liens are filed and proof of payment of tax liabilities is received. MOVED BY BRUCE, SECONDED BY CLYMER, CONCUR IN RECOMMENDATION OF ACTING ENGINEERING DIRECTOR McHENRY. CARRIED. Police Department Letter from Police Chief Darby reported public auction to dispose of Auction 12/9/72 unclaimed property December 9, 1972 at 10:00 a.m. to be published in legals. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY PERRY, TO AUTHORIZE PLACEMEN IN BOTH LOCAL NEWSPAPERS OF ADD 2 COLUMNS BY 5 INCHES. CARRIED. Reimbursement to Letter from Finance Director Marshall requested reimbursement to Street Dept. Street Department Maintenance Account for asphalt used in connection 1 Resolution 1826 with Arterial Street and Forward Thrust projects to be accomplished by (See Below) resolution. MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY BRUCE, TO CONCUR IN REQUEST OF FINANCE DIRECTOR AND REFER TO LEGISLATION COMMITTEE FOR PROPER LEGISLATION. CARRIED. Bicycle Letter from Renton Police Officer's Guild President Caldwell explained Registration bicycle registration program which has been in effect for two years 1,800 Down in conjunction with the Police Department, suggesting mandatory no-fee 3,600 To Go registration of bikes following safety check. Mayor Garrett's reply was read commending the Guild and advising consideration of bicycle ordinance when research completed. Supervisor of Accounting Services Bennett was asked by Mayor Garrett to check with Police Officers and prepare notice to be included with utility billings. Surplus Items Purchasing Agent Church's request to dispose of listed surplus items by bid call was read. MOVED BY DELAURENTI, SECONDED BY CLYMER, TO • REFER COMMUNICATION TO FINANCE COMMITTEE FOR REVIEW AND REPORT BACK. • MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY PERRY, SUBSTITUTE MOTION TO REFER COMMUNICATION TO LEGISLATION COMMITTEE FOR PROPER RESOLUTION. SUBSTITU9 MOTION FAILED. MOTION TO REFER TO FINANCE COMMITTEE CARRIED. Schmuland App1. Letter from Planning Commission presented application for rezone for No. R-712-72 Dr. & Mrs. Oscar Schmuland from R-2 to R-4 for property located on t - Public Hearing NE Corner of the intersection of N.3rd St. and Pelly Ave. N. Clerk 12/11/72 read letter of protest from Evelyn M. and Albert W. Rosenstrom and protesting petition bearing 16 signatures. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECO D 1 BY PERRY, DECEMBER 11, 1972 BE SET AS APPEAL DATE FOR PUBLIC HEARING ON SCHMULAND REZONE APPLICATION. CARRIED. City Clerk requested to notify petitioners and applicant. Financing Request to finance Kennydale Industrial Sanitary Sewer Project LID 276 was read from Southwick, Campbell, Waterman Co. along with Mayor Garrett's response advising financing had been arranged. Candy Cane Sales Permission having been granted for additional agenda item, City Clerk Cystic Fibrosis Mead read request for special permit to sell candy canes on City street. 12/2 - Christmas December 2, until Christmas by Cystic Fibrosis Juniors affiliated with the National Foundation. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY DELAURENTI, PERMISSION BE GRANTED. CARRIED. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY PERRY MATTER OF ORDINANCE REGULATING SOLICITATIONS BE REFERRED TO THE PUBLIC Solicitations SAFETY COMMITTEE. CARRIED Legislation Legislation Committee Report recommended reading and adoption of Resolu Committee Report tion for the transfer of $544.00 to provide payment for asphalt used Continued in connection with arterial and Forward Thrust Projects. MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY STREDICKE, TO CONCUR IN COMMITTEE REPORT. CARRIE, Resolution 1826 Following reading, MOVED BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY DELAURENTI, RESOLU- Fund Transfer TION BE ADOPTED AS READ. PROCLAMATIONS November 27, through December 2, 1972 was proclaimed Renton Aerie No. Renton Aerie 1722 1722 Fraternal Order of Eagles Week in Proclamation of Mayor Avery Fraternal Order Garrett for 65 years of growth and service in the City, urging all of Eagles Week citizens to take cognizance and participate in observance. MOVED BY 11/27 - 12/2/72 DELAURENTI, SECONDED BY BRUCE, TO CONCUR IN PROCLAMATION OF MAYOR. CARRIED. r._. RENTON CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING November 20, 1972 Municipal Building 8: 00 P.M. Council Chambers MINUTES FLAG SALUTE AND 'Mayor Avery Garrett led the Pledge of Allegiance and called the Renton CALL TO ORDER City Council meeting to order. ROLL CALL OF BRUCE, SCHELLERT, DELAURENTI, PERRY, STREDICKE, CLYMER and GRANT. COUNCIL MEMBERS MINUTE APPROVAL MOVED BY BRUCE, SECONDED BY DELAURENTI, APPROVE MINUTES OF November 11/13/72 13, AS PREPARED AND MAILED OUT. CARRIED. CITY OFFICIALS AVERY GARRETT, Mayor, DEL MEAD, City Clerk, G. M. SHELLAN, City Attorney IN ATTENDANCE GORDON ERICKSEN, Planning Director, BERT McHENRY, Acting Director of Engineering, VERN CHURCH, Purchasing Agent, JACK LYNCH, Mayor's Admini- strative Assistant, DEL BENNETT, Public Works Administrator, HUGH DARBY, Police Chief, VIC TeGANTVOORT, Street Superintendent, TED BENNETT, Accounting Supervisor, BERNARD RUPPERT, Building Director and CLARK PETERSEN, Library Director. ORDINANCES & MOTION CARRIED, which was MADE BY SCHELLERT, SECONDED BY STREDICKE,' RESOLUTIONS TO ACCEPT RECOMMENDATION OF LEGISLATION COMMITTEE REPORT, which placed the following ordinances on their second and final reading having been placed on first reading November 13: (1) An ordinance changing zoning classification from R-2 to B-1 of Franklin Life Insur- Ordinance 2751 ance Company property located south of South 2nd St. and easterly Rezone Franklin of Safeway #335. MOVED BY DELAURENTI, SECONDED BY STREDICKE, ORDINANCE Life Insurance BE ADOPTED AS READ. Roll Call vote resulted in ALL AYES, CARRIED. (2) An ordinance changing zoning classification from GS-1 to R-1 of Ordinance 2752 the Jay Holmes Property located N.E. 10th St. between Monroe Ave. N.E. Rezone Jay Holmes and Olympia Ave. N.E. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY DELAURENTI, Property ORDINANCE BY ADOPTED AS READ. Roll Call vote resulted in ALL AYES, CARRIED, ORDINANCE ADOPTED. Legislation Committee report also recom- mended first, second and final reading on an ordinance establishing a Ordinance 2753 special fund to be known as the Library Construction Fund, Account No. Library 308/572/50.06 and Limited General Obligation Bond Fund 1972, Account Construction No. 204/519/60 in accordance with Ordinance No. 2735. MOVED BY STREDICKE, Fund SECONDED BY DELAURENTI, CITY CLERK BE INSTRUCTED TO READ ORDINANCE BY TITLE ONLY FOR FIRST READING. CARRIED. Following reading, MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY DELAURENTI, ORDINANCE BE PLACED ON SECOND AND FINAL READING. Following reading, MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY DELAURENTI, ORDINANCE BE ADOPTED AS READ. Roll Call Vote resulted in ALL AYES, ORDINANCE ADOPTED. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY BRUCE, RESOLUTIONS BE PLACED AS ITEM (i) ON AGENDA. CARRIED. CORRESPONDENCE & CURRENT City Clerk Mead reported Bid Opening on November 16, for L.I.D. 276 BUSINESS Kennydale Industrial Sanitary Sewer Project, May Creek to N. City Limit (see attached) . MOVED BY PERRY, SECONDED BY STREDICKE, REFER Bid Opening BIDS TO THE PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE FOR REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATION. LID 276 CARRIED. Bid Award City Clerk Mead reported Bid Opening on Highlands Branch Library Con- Highlands struction Project November 14, (see attached) . Recommendation of Branch Library Library Director Petersen was read asking acceptance of low bidder to Busch Busch Construction in amount of $167,845 plus Alternate #2 making a Construction Co. total of $169,484 plus tax which was in concurrence with Architects Low Bidder Callison Associates and The Board of Trustees of Renton Library. Report of Board of Public Works was read recommending acceptance of low bid of Busch Construction plus Alternate #2 (Parking Lot Lighting) MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY PERRY, COUNCIL CONCUR IN RECOMMENDATION OF LIBRARY DIRECTOR AND BOARD OF PUBLIC WORKS AND AWARD CONTRACTOR TO BUSCB CONSTRUCTION CO. CARRIED. Lindbrook A representative of Lindbrook Construction Co. Inc. of Lynnwood inquired Construction re affirmative action filed with LID 276 Project bid of 11/16/72, being advised bids referred to Public Works Committee. ti riCiiitu9 PLANNING DEPARTMENT © RENTON,WASHINGTON .� ' MUNICIPAL BUILDING CD RENTON.WASHINGTON 98055 0 BA 83310 mom • • 9 �9sA November 16 , 1972 CRT CAPITAL OE The Honorable Avery Garrett , Mayor Members of the City Council Renton , Washington Re : Planning Commission Recommendations Gentlemen : The Planning Commission has completed its review of the applica- tions as noted below: SCHMULAND, DR. AND MRS . OSCAR , Appl . No . R-712-72 ; rezone from R-2 to R-4 ; property located on the NE corner of the . intersection of N . 3rd St. and Pelly Ave . N . Total. Area -- 1 /4 acre Principal Access -- Pelly Avenue North Existing Zoning -- R-2 Existing Use -- Single Family Residential Proposed Use -- Medical Clinic Comprehensive Land Use Plan -- High Density Multi -Family Upon completion of the public hearing on the subject applica- tion , the Planning Commission recommended that the Schmuland request for a rezone to R-4 be forwarded to the City Council inasmuch as said request is in compliance with the Compre- hensive Land Use Plan . It was further moved to amend the motion to include a height restriction of 25 feet , as well as limiting the occupancy of the building to a maximum of four offices . This recommenda- tion is incorporated into the motion recommending approval of the special permit application , as noted below . SCHMULAND , DR. AND MRS . OSCAR , Appl . No . SP-713-72 ; special permit for medical clinic in R-4 zone ; property located on NE corner of the intersection of N . .3rd St . and Pelly Ave . N . Upon completion of the public hearing on the subject appli - cation , the Planning Commission recommended that the special permit be granted in the R-4 zone for the medical clinic for Avery Garrett , Mayor Members of the City Council Page 2 Dr . Schmuland , that a height restriction of 25 feet be maintained , that there only be a maximum of four offices , and that the development be in accordance with drawings and documents submitted with the application . Very truly yours , ��,�. L. p' r on . /Eri cksen (//// 44 /P1ann ' g Director GYE : bmi , Attach . cc : City Attorney. / APPLICATION FOR CHANGE OF ZONE IN THE CITY OF RENTON FOR OFFICE USE ONLY Appl . No . N- 7 . - 7;2- Plan . Com . Action Apiproye9( Receipt No . Appeal Filed l/- 3- 70., • Filing Date City Council Action Hearing Date JQ-a5-7 Ordinance No , $ Date APPLICANT TO ANSWER ALL THE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS NEATLY AND ACCURATELY : Name Dr. & Mrs Oscar Scimliland, Address 115 Pelly North Telephone No . RA6-3600 Property petitioned for rezoning is located on Pelly Strout • between oo r , and Fourth -St-rent Nor .. - Total square tage in property 10,212.5 -sq. ft. LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY rt,Dt0-3 i rr t._, � '� = _ I ) t.ro ,�vc: � .C� eaC=. y • • • • • • • Existing Zoning x2 2 Zoning Requested R 4 • What are the uses you propose to develop on this property? A prof„„iorai bu di n �royi i n i?a.�a Per i hr Sri .i sta_ nr_phvrai.e an q • Number of permanent off-street parking spaces that will be provided on property?' 19 Number required 19 NOTE TO APPLICANT : The following factors are considered in reclassifying property . Evidence or additional, infor- mation you desire to submit to substantiate your request, may be attached to this sheet . (See Application Procedure sheet Item No . 2 for specific requirements) . 1 . In what . way is this proposed change in zoning in the public _ interest? It .conforma to the City of Renton's comprehensive plan. • • 2. On what. basis is there a real need in this community for more zoning of the type you , request?, Again: to conform to the City of Renton . comprehensive .plan. • • 3. What provision will you make to protect adjacent and surrounding properties from the detrimental effects of any uses permitted 'in the proposed zone? • the property, but not limited to e se back areas. t-cNt OF • • R `/// ��+ Renton Planning Dept . QLi o ® 1967 r e I9, �'� seee�eaeee •L9' eeOew ee 2o,DFPp910" ../ Renton, Washington November 2,- 1972 The Renton City Council Municipal Building 200 Mill Avenue South Renton, Washington 98055 „. _ In reference to a. Petition submitted to' the Planning Commission on October 25, 1972, we are requesting that the members of the Renton City Council either deny or modify the rezone and special Permit request of Dr. Oscar Schmuland to build a Medical- Dental Clinic at North Third and Pelly Avenue. Our main objection is the rezoning of this area from the present R-2 zoning to R-4. tie believe the building can be modified to meet with R-2 zoning provisions. The opposition stated at the Planning Commission Hearing that only this particular property would be rezoned, but we know full well, once this request is granted, anyone else may request the same. In view of the fact that nearly 100% of the homeowner's that signed this petition have paid taxes in this city and state for over a half century, we believe these people's wishes should be considered as the top priority in this matter. Sincerely, .Z4.. pt . Evelyn M. Ro s enstrom Albert W. Rosenstrom 309 Pelly Ave. No. Renton, Wa. 98055 ,eEa? 4: gab .. RENTO3 rASHINGTON OCTOB& 25, 1972 PLANNING D PARTHENT RETITON MUNICIPAL BUILDING R. dTON, WASHINGTON 98055 - WE THE UT Da.SIGNED DO HEREBY OBJECT TO THE- PROPOSED REZONING Or HE CORNER LOT ON THIRIFATOIr AND PELF,I ATKIUE FROM R-2 TO R-,4: 11AM,3 ADDRESS c) bje4/ Cie /f4 . _ 31If 1`� . /=� , _. 5,.� Jam- ., l: i I . '�L , v r r it-Ou- . J f J� � � / ! • • Ll / 3 /• i, J r J 1 c7 ,.../ /7 --). 9 9• ' ' „ . , �t/ / 1 1 !�, L'1~`•-- - r- /; i' • C/.-r.,--('� .liA I .5 ! '1 Y;' �;: - /f1-,� c " ) L��CI�L �. U / y�4 ' • 1 , (..4?/7";7 —714,"AA s...j Z66,,G,-,r1f...,,r`.--- j 1 . • - . : . . . 3.0 i /-;-;/) . 44,- , ---r%',,,, , ..3 '? -'---7 (L7. t'-7--rt-tj . '1,,,,r1;TE-1\15:n - 40., ., p -../ \\7'--. f f-- w lit N.1\iIN6 b-- - . . / . Renton Planning Commission Meeting October 25 , 1972 Minutes - Page 2 . Page 2 , 4. ( b) ,. 2nd paragraph , - the statement "The height of the berm may. also have to . be . reduced to 2 2 feet . " was . • made by Commissioner Scholes and should have been the - last sentence of Par . 4 (b) ( 1 ) . - MOVED BY SCHOLES , SECONDED BY MOLA , THAT THE MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF OCTOBER 11 , 1972 , BE CORRECTED AS PRE- VIOUSLY STATED BY THE CHAIRMAN . MOTION -CARRIED UNANI - MOUSLY . . Mrs . Seymour called the attention of• the Commission to a recent California Supreme Court decision regarding • . the requirement. of Environmental Impact. -Statements for . _. private construction that may have a significant impact on the. environment . Following a discussion , it was moved by Seymour, seconded by Scholes , that the minutes of the meeting of October 11 , 1972 , be corrected to re- flect the introduction of the report of the State - . Supreme Court decision in the- State of California . MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY . ACTION : • 'MOVED BY MOLA , SECONDED BY SCHOLES , THAT THE MINUTES OF • THE MEETING OF OCTOBER 11 , 1972 , BE APPROVED AS CORRECTED . MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY .• 2 3- PUBLI-C HEARING ITEMS • • . REZORE APPLICATION . 10 . - (a ) SCHMULAND , DR . AND MRS . OSCAR , Application No . . • R-712-72 ; rezone from R-2 to R-4 ; property located . on NE corner of intersection of N . 3rd -St . and Pelly . Ave . N . • The Chairman described the application . He noted that; • the applicants are also asking . for a Special Permit to . allow them to build a medical clinic on this property . • The Planning Director pointed out that the property is presently .zoned R-2 -- the designation for the low - density multiple residence zone which allows duplexes and apartments . The long range use , as indicated an the Comprehensive Plan , is high density multiple . The adjacent property is indicated as commercial ,• and there is presently some commercial to the . east. The property is approximately 1 /4 acre . • . • The jlanning Director noted thatfa medical clinic would be allowable in a multiple residential zone by Special . Permit, with • approval by the Planning Commission and • establishment of special controls which might apply . Dr. Schmuland had requested rezoning of the property to an R-4 classification since .the front yard setback would be ten feet rather than twenty feet as required • • under the R-2 classification . The Planning Director then reviewed the property char- acteristics . Vicinity map and site plan were displayed , and slides of the property Were shown : The architect then submitted elevation drawings as requested by the - . Planning Commission Chairman on the field trip . . Mr . Erickson noted that the proposed structure would be approximately the same height as the house located to !ry . Renton Planning Commission Meeting October 25 , 1972 Minutes - Page 3 the north of the subject property . In response to a question raised by Commissioner Scholes on the field trip , Planning Director stated that the Parking and Loading Ordinance would require improvements and up- grading of the alley for the access and parking as proposed. Scholes asked if parking requirements for this facility had been met . Planning Director stated that the plan provides for one space for each two hundred square feet of gross floor area as required by ordinance . Commissioner Scholes asked if there has been a precedent- setting case that would allow exception from the front yard depth limitations in the R-2 and R-3 Zones . The Planning Director replied that he knows of no recent ex- ceptions . Some . other clinics built in the past have utilized their front yards for parking and , therefore , have maintained a larger setback than as shown by appli - cant. . A petition . signed by 16 adjacent property owners raising objections to the proposed rezoning was presented to the Chairman . Chairman asked that the petition, be entered into the record. Chairman asked for audience comments in favor of the application . • . Mr. Vern Shansby , 4206 Stone Way North ,' Seattle , repre- senting the applicant , stated that applicant has been a dentist for 18 years in Renton at his present location . The floor space to be used for dental office facilities is approximately 3 ,000 square feet , of which approximately 50% would be for the applicant ' s own practice . Rezone was requested due to the front yard setback . To permit 19 parking spaces required , the building was raised to two stories to accommodate parking on the ground level be- neath the structure . Mr. Shansby stated that the existing plantings will be retained , if possible , and other land- scaping and plantings will be provided . He stated further that the setback is actually as much as 13 feet rather than the 10 feet as required by code in an R-4 Zone . Chairman Teegarden said he was under the impression a . medical clinic had to have at least an R-3 zoning category to qualify for a Special Permit . Mr. Ericksen noted that R-2 does allow apartments , hotels , professional offices and mobile home parks by Special Permit upon examination and public . hearing . R-3 and , also , R-4 does include the • word " clinics " ; however, setback requirements must be met in the particular zoning requested . He noted also that the use of the setback area for parking has been a problem in the past. Commissioner Scholes asked about improvements of the alley . The applicant ' s architect stated that the applicant will provide the improvements on the alley as required by the City . Dr. Schmuland then noted that the .City of -Renton would not only benefit from the usage of the 'clinic for dental health , etc . , but that the proposed building would beautify the area as well . .' • Renton Planning Commission Meeting October 25 , 1972 • Minutes - Page 4 . • • • Chairman next asked for comments opposed to the pro- posed .rezone . • Mr. A. J . Brattus , 323 Pelly-N . , stated that many people in the area are retired and on a fixed income and are concerned about the value of the property being increased • and taxes being raised . Discussion then followed with comments by Commission and staff members , and Mr . Stredicke of the City Council , regarding possible in- creases in the assessed valuation of property adjacent . to property being rezoned. . • Mrs . Lavina Kessler, 310 Pelly Ave . N . , owner of the adjacent property (to the north ) went on record as being •• opposed to the rezoning . She objected to the height of the proposed building and the ten foot setback . Further discussion ensued regarding interpretation of . the code in reference to "clinics " and "professional - offices" , and Planning Director stated he. felt that • basically the difference would be determined by intensity ' of use as well as the density . Mr . Shansby indicated that the applicant' would te willing to specify that the clinic would be. used by no more than four doctors or dentists if intensity was a matter that concerned the Commission . Scholes inquired a's to the feasibility of • ' moving the building forward or backward . The architect , William Rigg , 4208 Stone Way North , Seattle , indicated it could be moved back to twenty feet ; however , the • . building is restricted by the parking requirement. Frank Sankovich , Renton , of the American Association of Retired Persons , spoke on behalf of - the , nearby residents urging that the rezone be denied . At the conclusion of the discussion , it was MOVED BY HUMBLE , SECONDED BY SEYMOUR , THAT THE HEARING ON THE . REZONE APPLICATION BE CLOSED . MOTION CARRIED UNANI MOUSLY . • ACTION :• . MOVED BY SEYMOUR- THAT THE REQUEST FOR A REZONE FROM R-2 TO R-4 BE. DENIED. • • Discussion followed regarding the legality and advisa- bility of suggesting alternatives . . Mola noted that if the rezone were denied , then the applicant could possi - bly have to put the parking in the front yard and he • felt that the landscaping as proposed in the front yard would be more desirable . Humble stated that the Compre- hensive Plan shows the area as R-4 , the applicant is • applying for an R-4 rezone , the property is abutting B-1 zone ; therefore , the rezone would be hard to deny . Chairman stated that in his opinion the neighbors are opposed to the clinic regardless if it is built on the requested R-4 or a modified R-2 as suggested by Seymour • and Scholes . Seymour stated her opinion that the Com- prehensive Plan is a guide to future growth of the area and does not mean that a-. requeste.d • rezoning• would be automatically given just . because it agrees with the • • • Comprehensive. Plan . She felt - that the proposed rezone • may be premature and , therefore , should be denied at • • this time . • / • Renton Planning Commission Meeting October 25 , 1972 Minutes - Page 5 SCHOLES SECONDED THE MOTION BY SEYMOUR THAT THE SCHMULAND APPLICATION FOR REZONE FROM R-2 TO R-4 BE DENIED , PRIMARILY • BECAUSE THIS IS NOT THE APPROPRIATE TIME FOR SUCH AN UP- GRADING IN ZONING . On the motion , Chairman called for a roll call vote , with the following results : Humble - No Nola - No Teegarden - No Scholes - Aye Seymour - Aye MOTION FAILED ACTION : MOVED BY HUMBLE , SECONDED BY MOLA , INASMUCH AS THE REQUEST IS IN CONFORMANCE WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN , THAT THE SCHMULAND REQUEST FOR REZONE TO R-4 BE RECOMMENDED TO THE CITY COUNCIL . After further discussion , SCHOLES MOVED TO AMEND THE MOTION TO INCLUDE A HEIGHT RESTRICTION OF 25 FEET , AS WELL AS LIMITING THE OCCUPANCY OF THE BUILDING TO A MAXIMUM OF FOUR OFFICES . SECONDED BY SEYMOUR. Seymour asked for clarification from the applicant. Mr. Shansby stated the applicant will so stipulate that the building will not exceed a 25 foot height limitation , and will also stipulate that there will be a maximum of offices for four doctors and/or dentists in the building . AMENDMENT TO MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY . Question on the original motion , which was to grant the proposed rezone from R-2 to R-4 , subject to the amendment . Seymour listed her reasons for objecting to the rezone . Vote was taken with these results : MOTION CARRIED . One dissenting vote by Seymour . SPECIAL PERMIT APPLICATION ( b) SCHMULAND , DR. AND MRS . OSCAR, Appl . No . SP-713-72 ; special permit for medical clinic in R-4 zone; property located on NE corner of intersection of N . 3rd St . and Pelly Ave . N . Chairman asked if there was any further discussion required . . As there were no further comments , it was MOVED BY MOLA , SECONDED BY SEYMOUR, THAT THE HEARING ON THE SPECIAL PERMIT BE CLOSED. MOTION CARRIED . ACTION : MOVED BY MOLA , SECONDED BY SCHOLES , THAT THE SPECIAL PERMIT BE GRANTED IN THE R-4 ZONING FOR T-HE MEDICAL CLINIC FOR DR. SCHMULAND , AND THAT THE HEIGHT RESTRICTIONS AS STATED - 25 FEET - BE MAINTAINED , AND THAT THERE ONLY. BE A MAXIMUM OF FOUR OFFICES , AND ALSO THAT IT BE IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE DRAWINGS AND DOCUMENTS SUBMITTED WITH THE APPLICATION . MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY . RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION PUBLIC HEARING MEETING OCTOBER 25, 1972 STAFF REPORT Dr. and Mrs. Oscar Schmuland have applied for a rezone from R-2 to R-4 on property located at the northeast corner of the inter- section of N. 3rd Street and Pelly Avenue N. The proposed rezone is in compliance with the Comprehensive Land Use Plan and has been requested in conjunction with a Special Permit application to allow a medical clinic in a residential zone. A medical clinic could be allowed by Special Permit under the existing R-2 zoning classifi- cation; however, Dr. Schmuland has requested rezoning of the property to an R-4 classification because of the front yard setback requi-re . ment which- -would be ten feet rather than twenty feet as required under the R-2 classification. Andover Investment Company has applied for Site Plan Approval of a proposed warehouse in Earlington Industrial Park located north - of .'S.W.. 7th Street'and .west. of Seneca. Avenue S.W. extended norther- ly. The proposed warehouse would be adjacent to the existing Hormel Packing Company. The proposed plan is in conformance with ordinance requirements, however some revisions to the landscape plan were requested. by Commissioners on the October 21st field trip. The request was that landscaping, be provided along the railroad right-of-way. ., The staff. recommendation is to provide- a three foot wide planting strip along the railroad right-of-way and plant 26 .: Lombardy poplar trees at 15' on center with gravel groundcoverr. This three feet, when combined with the graveled railroad right- of-way, will provide adequate space for tree growth. The poplar trees are columnar trees which will grow to 50 - 75 feet tall with. ' an approximate spread of - 6 ' - (these trees are planted around the . High School Stadium) . . They have provided a screened area near the . rear of the building for garbage container storage. B & H Leasing have applied for Site Plan Approval for an office - . building for the fixed-base operations and scheduled air taxi - services of Fancher Flyways to be located at the southwestern corner of the Renton Municipal Airport. The proposed plan is in conformance with ordinance requirements, however we have requested that landscaping be included on the west side of the proposed building and: that the westernmost driveway be moved easterly. The owners have agreed to both suggestions and will be discussing these with their designers. and with the Commission at the Public Hearing. - meeting. John D. O'Donnell has applied for, Site. Plan Approval for two ' . proposed warehouses' in Earlington Industrial Park, located north of SW 10th 'Street and between Thomasand Powell Avenues SW. The proposed plan is in conformance with ordinance requirements, how- ever we have requested additional landscaping along the north . property line. The architect has agreed to discuss the possibili- ty with the owners 'and give the Commission an answer at' the Public' Hearing meeting. We also recommend, that the railroad right-of-way be screened with a 3 ' wide planting strip planted with Lombardy poplars as in the case ofthe Andover Investment Company, and that the southerly end of the railroad right-of-way be landscaped. to within 20 ' of the southerly line of the westerly building. RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION ADMINISTRATIVE MEETING OCTOBER 11, 1972 MINUTES COMMISSION MEMBERS PRESENT: James E. Denzer, Don Humble, Anthone Mola, Arthur D. Scholes, Patricia Seymour, Clerk Teegarden, Norman L. Ross. CITY STAFF. PRESENT: Gary Kruger, Planning Department; Jim Magstadt, Planning Department; Lyman Houk, Engineering Department. The October 11, 1972 Administrative Meeting of the Renton Planning Comission was called to order by Chairman Teegarden at 8 :05 p.m. 1. ROLL CALL was taken by Secretary Mola. All commission members responded present. 2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Chairman Teegarden announced that the commission will delay approval of the minutes of the public hearing of September 27, 1972 until the commission members have had a chance to review them. ACTION: MOVED BY SEYMOUR, SECONDED BY DENZER, THAT THE CORRECTED MINUTES OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 13, 1972 BE APPROVED. MOTION CARRIED. 3. NEW ITEMS REZONES (a) Schmuland, Dr. and Mrs. Oscar, Appl. No. R-712-72; rezone from R-2 to R-4; property located on NE corner of intersection of N. 3rd St. and Pelly Ave. N. Jim Magstadt described the rezone application noting that it has been requested in conjunction with a special permit applica- • tion (Appl. No. SP-713-72) to allow a medical clinic in a resi- dential zone. The proposed rezone is in compliance with the Comprehensive Land Use Plan. Vicinity map and site plan were displayed. Slides of the property were shown. • SITE APPROVAL (c) Andover Investment Co., Appl. No. SA-709-72; site Plan approval for warehouse in M-P zone; property located on north side of SW 7th St. and west of Seneca Ave. SW, extended northerly, Earlington Industrial Park. Jim Magstadt reviewed the development and presented slides. The proposed warehouse would be adjacent to the existing Hormel Packing Company. A discussion was held on the dumping of refuse and the location of dumpsters in the Earlington Industrial Park Area . The staff was asked to check on the storage requirement in the ordinance and to determine whether the commission could require these areas to be screened. ,1 • • AFFIDAVIT I Dr. Oscar Schmuland and Wanda Schmuland being duly sworn, declare that I am the owner of the property involved in this application and that the foregoing statements and answers herein. contained and the information . herewith submitted are in all respects true and correct to the best of • my knowledge and belief. • Subscribed .and sworn before me this g r°- day of rC er , 19 -72.JF Notary Public in and for the State of Washington, residing at C6v0 . Luco (Name o- Notary blic) % �G (Signature of er) q X)• ' 014) 50#/e (Wei. 61b70-3 /9Y/5i _ (Address) / (Address) . (City) (State)406. • (11 • • s• " 9j (Telephone) (FOR OFFICE USE ONLY) • CERTIFICATION • This is to certify that the foregoing application has been inspected by me and has been found to be thorough and complete in every particular and to conform to the rules and regulations of the Renton Planning Department governing the filing of such application. • Date Received , 19 By: 6Ffirn ; o: `"t '�• Renton 'Planning Dept. �'r Revised May 1970 ' • NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING • RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION RENTON, WASHINGTON A . PUBLIC HEARING WILL BE HELD BY THE RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION AT ITS REGULAR MEETING IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS, CITY HALL, RENTON, WASHINGTON ON October 25 , 19 72, AT 8 : 00 P .M. TO CONSIDER THE FOLLOWING PETITIONS : 1 . Rezone from R-2 to R-4 , file No . R-712-.72 , and Special Permit for medical clinic in residential zone , file No . .SP-713-72 property located on the northeast corner of N . 3nd Street and Pelly Ave . N . . Legal description on file in Planning Department Office . 2. Site 'Plan Approval in M-P Zone , file NO . SA-709-72 , property located on • S. W. 7th street, west of Seneca Ave S .W. extended . Legal description on file in the Planning Department Office . 3 . Site Plan Approval in M-P Zone , file No . _SA-711 -72 , property located on S. W. 10th street between Thomas Ave . S. W. and Powell Ave . S. W. Legal description on file in the Planning Department Office . 4. Site Approval in a P-1 Zone , file No . SA-710-72 , property located at the Southwest corner of the Renton Municipal Airport. Legal description on file in the Planning Department Office . • ALL PERSONS INTERESTED OR OBJECTING TO SAID PETITIONS, ARF INVITED TO BE PRESENT AT THE PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING ON October 25, '1972 AT 8 : 00 P.M. TO VOICE THEIR PROTESTS OR OBJECTIONS TO SAME . PUBLISHED OJ 1v3, Ia 7 RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION CERTIFICATION I , Richprd D . Hansen , NEREBY CERTIFY THAT THREE COPIES OF THE ABOVE DOCUMENT WERE. POSTED BY ME IN THREE CONSPICUOUS PLACES ON THE PROPERTY DESCRIBED ABOVE AS PRESCRIBED BY LAW. ATTEST : ,Subscribed and sworn SIGNE po before me, a Notary public, " on the to day of Oc t e,( .• 19 'r— 1 in f I u F - cr 1a 4: jZ 5 tl 1 I t L-g lit [iil 1 1 ! 0 % \ l 1 4 .4', 2ys] no. WI Sm 2Z,. �� _ .F j I tin m1 too Eill ma cm oat moo _ ,t_ f' i ,, I au Ts © s S� 1�T ESE` PACIFIC CAR. 4� 1 x , \\ 1: - , ' ii>WM •wIl�m.,Q� Dr and. Mrs . Oscar Schmuland , ? O� �. ;'i��•:' Rezone: R-2 to R-4 and /, ©� s S•ecial Permit for Clinic ///1\ 'qL ''s ‘ . = 61•!ll ' a — - r /ter.rm..., 6�OVsesIkalot C.yCQIzit ioro ma 1>t. I • 4 1 ` E! R�1's5 vt 7 4.1 [� I� 3 111101111 \\ • cr 1 , -.1 .3-mina- • n �� rye . hif, �. .:• F 0> �I its .ny � > �' J'I 'a LLB- 1 �: , ,' \MI .1,1 Wi 19411-17 ,IND lit=. 71. A AZ 25,41°71 .\ I • I t. AIR?o . AY ♦1 WI N1- ,� , sT @ills Et J + / / d , .. paV a� wila 1 1 INF . kim • ?, � III Ia '� �� Ti�mill �� e �.�, .� ,+ W s MA '1°61111 Et !� j ... , aIm ? a�r .. ` f,. , i' LIBERTY E3.1'lltot ,�, {{ �. emu ..E'4 IJq� t 1 �`..• Y'�� • ?La r. i ,., tmoo Eng sEn ��mom k PA}irt� i, ©�' PFro " _If. 't ��" f 5f1 'Tia\ i F��A �no air mill dlamp .�... I / /mai Neu 5.� �� r i SPNfoR Jf/NfoR f�v 4 to r� n� �� liradt. \•., it ! ,. ammo { fH/GH NIGM , ��1 D cr.0 SCNooL scN°pf_ t�,•tt to owor noadonmoo m� �5_.= Fm \ F 4 is a+ ��+ t>alao Qo.�+� e� il , s c�rv' 5 - z sPm t. t sue. o,r �, s• W ib CIE I n MN h ©.�, NENNI s� I �•,,� .a 1p MI M1 cam ,,, F OW Fill— al& S tS' E nii 'Liow 7f.�pain Tim morn LI'I. �� lurr'I�� x- ice,. f a l is sn W,� �I'm �iar_ s I> Eu >m11=tj NWW1 FIRM WWI Noe V---it,I' W-1�in=min 1., i 1 ,iiii. • f i� „�' �'iY�• ",t P� `� �� I ■ + �! III as \._ ' , ; l 1 }, REZONE : R-2 to R-4 and SPECIAL PERMIT 1 i i i Schmuland, Dr. and Mrs . Oscar, Rezone from R-2 to R-4 , and Special Permit for medical clinic in R-4 zone; property located on the NE corner of the intersection of N. 3rd St. and Pelly Ave. N. { i APPLICANT Dr. and Mrs Oscar Schmuland TOTAL AREA 1/4 acre PRINCIPAL ACCESS Pelly Avenue North - EXISTING ZONING R-2 r l EXISTING USE Single Family Residential i" PROPOSED USE Medical Clinic f COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE PLAN High Density Multi-Family COMMENTS -. 1 F 3 • 5. •I 41 1 1 W Y I 11 ,\ ol- °- IINI Z 5 \.1\\ 0.1 _1G Z`—IA='i 6 61•�.' wi \ 1 •• '1. 4 • .11 1 1.1111111111. it__L AL_t Ci.44 \\\\ 51_, 1 4i_IM ix ii £ \ • r ©`m •}[ PACIFIC CAR 74,r'� ti I , 17 am _il Qi ar @t !_�7T 7'•�'1[' �.- .r�.r.. rr. '': Wf7 ato •��.. :t...v-:,..: i. # ` (�W>:IWI WI ini ha Dr and Mrs. Oscar Schmuland ; ., �,' �O -a�di, - Rezone: R-2 to R-4 and �; 3 e---, e—ttt I..•ar •. 3' • `,, /, ��' CI:t;•®M' Special Permit for Clinic 1 . `�, t I tr�i' t;eta;l m -rtsur Cf:�1 I L7 7•aill.a� _r• v■ f' likalilliiil' / • } \ 1 1/ IE!�.R1f11t+ 7 s7 7 L1 we-TM �. N t ! Z rt1.Ic.>at i��Y �.,.1; ca E. \\ tt -asi�„m an •,7.`�'s7 q Irri! r_,z mc_mac± • ,.• g. '. , Q� aril. #®.yr..�v 3fi_7Qi !,�I �• _ • 'p�`,. 1 LIM , Lei c6• .1 �7 .d; �; �dir�a1��eu. ` III \\\• ,.4..;',, ) Taitl •d1.1r tl as an ii' • 7.a» arlCM Mr` 33��Q', Eno rum%Im• j.ur, ,..2-,1,1 tme.w TIN fissw; ty,rp. ,-1.mil et m ttttt��d ..„tr.,.., _� \, aet F '-•s1 d.� C7[ tL'.s:•'•(f_�•H .e.--t ,r, - [tiaC 'SI nit,®IJ Q.`i.a.'�nL'a=fie._ lr' /44:ici, 1 a> >f 3.a) a.� al c 't♦eFj ��; ti 111611 ttn 'a s� ttr t�"� /pp r;•a 1 'VViPi .• ii Minitel-flail-i' N' ♦_ �:41r, s lam a >�../ - ' �, TIL -1 , d, [11•1,.M ME Rai© try 1 rir d •11 !1�'iii ' .�'II�� 1�r ' _CM • \ \ilgrt itkl:� MI= S ° �321W <'.• 'Y1O MON • 2ir.VIM. J _�.... ,.. . Enmo �1��t.\ ham �►� �` ��!}Y B. I,.� Iri 'INS' MItn �� kip• PJIRK _ .M WV i r twi o Mil ta•m^ _ • m `\ // \ D R_2vill m� ' �• _om M 2. �� ., i` �_ SD 1/1 SENIOR JUNIOR '.� •�-� .'' i1y�I m� �'4�' \ 'Y NIGH HION an•R� • �S Cm 75°A \ ,f! SCHOOL SCHOOL ;or 17� Y 11. / EL:: -n .routtelte moron orn� rieear I� �ttlltn ItaaliRl non Z it �7�7aihm7 �71P��7 ' .... im -;ate _ on or vosor (y. - -roos- • _ roomy>�*� t' I III Milli 1i;lA a �,a�I�,Q� �'. • Ijrt1a_=n OWW,W��nWr.itirrt> �a rson � Eli._ =armina • I 30 • Q��1 t�7 PUN /1r .�1 �rige"' .O 1P F. r 1I _ • c>.. .. .� �! �i'��ti1t7 Cast o., NEE isr tin Ei. CW1.51• e= .s� • � aFi �d4 ��Masi: !� \ r-1- - } rm m.P.- `+gy m 1 Iml ?.:' -.• • ` "`. 'Q � \._, , �' �,�r _fit.:\O� a _ . Y , t REZONE R=2 to R-4 and SPECIAL• PERMIT - Schmuland, Dr. and Mrs. Oscar, Rezone from R-2 to R-.4 , and Special f Permit for. medical clinic in R-4 zone; property located on the NE • , corner of the intersection of N. 3rd St. and Pelly Ave. N. • APPLICANT Dr. and Mrs Oscar Schmuland TOTAL AREA 1/4 acre t • PRINCIPAL ACCESS Pelly Avenue North EXISTING ZONING R-2 EXISTING USE Single Family Residential PROPOSED USE Medical Clinic •• COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE PLAN High Density Multi-Family COMMENTS • o