HomeMy WebLinkAboutWWP2700381(2) SAN-1 Sanitary Sewer Project S-381
Duvall Ave, N. E. Sanitary Sewer Ext , Arbitration l of 2
BEGINNING
OF FILE
FILE TTu SA
N I
. �
•
• �JA �
F
Construction Industry
Arbitration Rules
ATH.RII AN CONSULTING
FN(ANFFRS COt7NCIL.
AMERR'A.N INSTITUTE OF ARCIIITEm
AMERICAN SOCILTY OF
CIVIL ENGINEERS
AMURICAN SOCIETY OL
LANDSCAPF ARCIIITF.C'TS
AMERICAN SUBCON'TRAC"IONS
ASSOCIATION
ASSOCIATED BUILDERS.AND
CONTRACTORS,INC.
ASSOCIATL'UGENERALCONTRACTORS
ASSOCIATF.DSPFCIALTT
CONTRACTORS,INC.
CONSTRUCTION SPL.CIFIt'ATIONS
INSTITUTE.
NA'I-IONAL. ASS(M%I ION OF
HOML BUILDERS
NA TION.AL SOC II:T)'OF
PROFESSIONAL FNGINFF RS
American
Arbitration 4,...„I,J
Jm11.[IJfCI
Association 1Jnrr.1, tY&e
Whop a mutt is wtthduwn o,settled,the refund Q.,Deposits
Jali be nstde in xcwdance with the refund Weed I'he AAA MAY teywk the putks to deposit in ad
irk wave sw:h wuO of money,as it deems necessary to
defray the expert of the whnri tin,Indurbus
rho AAA,in tilt terns ,I exuesnt hmddup on tire the ulntralm•i lee,If any.awl hall rtuder an a
is I Ill any party.nay dear or rtduet the.dasar aountsug to,he parka and temm any unatpended
nlntive It, hatsnct
49.Fee When Oral Hearings are Waned 53. Interpretation and Application of
Where all Oral hearings It w.ncJ and Stawn Rules
17. the AJmu ixtealm fee Schedule calf aril) The anntram, dull mlerl"o.usd apply lhcse Rules
ursolar as lltey fatale to ilk atbnratui s powers
and dunes When there a more than one nbnntor
nit expenEfspeses o and a JnlNtme arises alum then,concenung the
The expenses the p of wuntws for titre nee cull he nkanmg Or apptcalwn of an)suds Rojas.it dull
pals by the parry producing xudh witnesses be deeded by a malooly vole.If first a,. obtain
able.airlift an m immIn of a party ma! sofa the
the clot an the n tilt t ut,s maul•tl Any is mwal yuestiou to the AAA for firal de.wuu All Other
And di between
the Pa tie old shall be pwukd eyoah Roles shall be interpreted and applied by the AAA
ly belwtnt me pank>ordennt arks,unless they
staff othethn t agree,and&tall be paid for by the
fesp,a&tile parties dimity to the reporting agency. EXPEDITED PROCEDiIM
54. Nolice by Telephone
All othaf expanses Ill the arbivatmn,inclwfing rc- the panws shall accept all nulhces slum the AAA
yuued Iusrhng and ether expenses Of this atbnia' by telephone Such notices by the AAA suit wb
for and of AAA representhfulaa,and the expenses w4uently be confun•A in writing to Its parties.
Of any witm or the crkt Of any proofs produced Notwithstanding It,,[adult to confines in willing
at the ditto teyucst Ill lite arhitgWL Shall he any notsc of obje%tion hereunder,the piwading
bsnse equalli by Ilk parses,unlou they agree shall itortetheleube valid if notix hu,w lsct,bten
ollulmae,eI antes,ht asbil at O sit the award a,
sew an s such expenses Or y fan there'll against preen by hdephont.
any sprdted piny or parfks 55,Appointment mid giro.. tplal&fcatiotu of
Arbitrators
51.Arbitrator's Fee The A.A.A&sill whin sunuftaneuu&y to aa.:h party
[forest the parties agate to temys of wmpcilutiun, III tilt disport an Identical lot of five member.of
nxniben tit on National Panel of Construction tilt Construction Aabuutidn Panel of Asbinaton.
Arhnratws"knew without compannhlfao for thorn whichont arbitrator wall he apptswtc&tact,
the fins d. of senile park shall have the tight Id strike Iwo series flan
the tilt sin a peferupmry bans The has a retmsi"
Thereafter,compensation shall be based upon tee to the AAA within ten days iron,the son of hamd.
aineunl of vervme m,oived and the numtwr Ot hear tilt.If for any reason the appshinhhknl c mitt Ia
mph.An apprupj Me Jahh sir and Oaks arrange na he front the list,she AAA shall haw&N.what,
mints will be dsscu,•>d by the admmsuusur with sty W INIAt Iht appointment tram 4"whet
the parties SAJ the asbnragolsl.If the part*%fad mamisais of the Panel wuhuut The wbmaswmrdaJ,
w agree m the ecru.ul compensation.an apphu htwnul lists.Sus,appOuaincru shall he wlyed so
plate arc call the rsuNtsm.l by the AAA,and Jlsyu.lnbcatnon I'll the reasons speed-wd in Sactwn
asnutdom ecd in wiling w tilt lumen 19 the pucks dull he given hsomc by teleplu ne
by the AAA of elk appointment Of the arbitrator
Any anangenknt tut the cwnpensatiat of an aabr. The parties gush twisty the AAA,by lakpMme,
nawr dull bt made through the AAA and not Jr wotiut seven days of any Objections to tilt arbna.
Wily by the arbntaw,wish the parties the Ietma art appointed.Any ubjrvuria by a party to w.h
Ofnmlpvnsatwn of utuUs,abuuto",O,aTnbv athinator shall be runfsrmtd in wining m the AAA
nil dull bt dhoti,,' wnb a copy to the other par yi"1
16 17
1 W Tu a Amid Plat!of Htu• Mlron n1.a•ne:an be tiered at the lone of Ilhnp.
The aibar.tor sluil fix tilt date,unit.and pfast ni
the heannp the AAA will mlufy me IBrllaa by the admmwwuvt lee is SSW. uhleu to adjust,
teftpllmu,wren dayl m aJvnuc of the tq W4 I ment ut a.cuNang with the 1011,dult a loon as
date Fwtnal N.ll,e of Ikatmg all be tent by 11w an Amount:an he duekoed
AAA to the pans
$7,The Heatitt>f OTHER SERVICE CHARGES
Generally.the heaan slid plemntalnms ai the $50 ftayabk by cub Party to,tadt mr jurI and
patties shall be:umpielad within one Jay The At wblaquent bralurp will o tither ekdtd by the
bnmlul,for SOOJ Cauat vhown,may siheduk an AAA or held An A heuuwt town provided by the
Additional healuy to be held wrthm five days. AAA
58.Time of Award
Wikwothemw ApreeJ forty fhepartus,thf AwafJ POSTPONEMENT FEES
duil IN mAeled not late than line bosuxss days
front eha date of the Clump of the heamp Sok-Arbitrator Cases,
.. _. - S50 payable oy a party text,auwls ask.,Jµntw
aronl t any wheduled Iltanry
ADMINISTRATIVF FEE SCHEDULE SIW payable by A party Cawmr,a m.,,w ,r,bw
quart Adrtutruiv nt of any wbeduled htarulp
A filing la of S.a00 well be pad at the unw file
,ax A.mlimi-d Throe-Arbeirstor Caern,
S"S payable by a Party filst:.mane an adlouln
the hdan(e of the AJmmotiulae fee of the AAA rnent of any"refuted hemlrp
u heard upon the amount of am It Chun A"a,wna
te¢knn as dtwiuted when the,halm and;ounttt S I SO pay able by a parry :auuna;a wamd of sob.
aunt are❑hd a,ld a due aIiJ pay able pnot ru file quaint Allounul"t of Alp uhed ded healing
newt of appomtman of the neutral atbnralor
In those Baum and wummclanns wlu,h are not REFUND SCHEDULE
for a mwlelary aniounl,an appn.prute ad:nnue
it'M fee wdt be 101trnrined by the AAA.pay If the AAA o notified that A uw Iwa been Willed
ails prior to su,h iwnae of ap""Onint or withdrawn before a luf of Arbitrators has boon
sent out.Ali the fa in evicea of MU will be it,
Amount of CWm Fea rw Clam funded.
or Countaviaun aCoontenlsam
S11„S2uinto Pt lnununmt 520,11 It the.AAA a notifrod Ihat A:am has burn wiilad
t 20.000 to 140.000 t 600,Vlw 2a w eAota of wrlll'Jl an better the urlpinel due dale 10,the
oea t20.aaf return of the(AM 161.Iwo tloadx of the far in ea
S40.0W 1U Sab.Wt s Mail plea I_t A raja icu 111 S`Otf wd!be refunded
,wit tat.{win
taa,daa la s la Bait S band,aka hw a oaotu If the AAA a matted that A<aw w aetried or w Ilh-
usa1.SW.OW I Jrswndaurt or lcdi.wmpaprMheannw<vofktertsx
f fet.aW w 11AKKUmt S I.100,ptua 6ti of evaa. tr al team iw hours be((m the data artd time Art for
ulet$I°O.Wt the first helrow.one-thud of new tee In niece of
thIme the:Iamb(,nwltmiam euemds Sj mdltun, SZW will be mfulfJod.
an approphdte fee wall be deltrmmed by file AAA 1
It there are more than two fumes ,pNmlj,,4 in
the abd+atlon..an Additional RK At file aJmmo-
tnllw fee will be due for tail additional!raw.
senled party
u
19
• • •
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNt 1' • RENTON, WASHINGTON
V 7 Mar M•Ks aw w rat a F snsar • aar,w waa+,armi aIM, M�11
F LAWRENCE 1 WARRFN, ar•+.roar. DANIEL KELL000, aaw•wrt a•r angaft•
e DAVID M DEAN, u•nawr all alroAaa•
..a•. MARK NARRER, aaa.a*ue an>?I V
"to St►ltw ZANETTA L FONTES. •aan•w.all 411 ra•
July 15, 1906 MARTHAA FRENCH, ..•sear••
TO: ' in Clements, finance Directnr
FROM Lawrence J. Warren, City Attorney
RE: Sanitary Sewer Project - Duvall Avenue N.I.. - CAG 077-85
Dear Dan:
The contractor on the Duvall Avenue Sanitary Sewer Project,
CAG 01*r-85, filed a request for arbitration. The claim
was for nearly $30,000.00 plug attorney's fees. The Public
Works Department felt that rnme extra compensation was
justified and had offered a total of $10,000.00 which included
forgiving a $3,000.00 counterclaim.
settled the case on the eve of arbitration for $10,000.00
plus forgiving the $3,000.00 counterclaim,
1 Would you please forward to me a Treasurer's Check made out.
to Shoreline Construction Company and to Panl Chemnick, its
attorney.
1f you have any questions, please let me know.
-� Lawrence 1. Warren
L,JW:nd
cc: Mayor
OF �E •
z PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
DESIGNiuTgrTY ENG" VERING • 235-2631
4"ICPAL WALOING no MILL AVE SO MINTON,WASN 9a055
t
P
iFp SE P'CMg
BARBARA Y. SIQNPO�
MA YO*
MEMORANDUM
DATE: June 25, 1986
TO: Larry Marren, City Attorney
FROM: Don Mona hare,
9 Design Engineering
SWJECT: Shoreline Construction Co.
Deer Larry: --ted in your '--
As
Locator
is:
Memo o/ Juno 16, the Puget Power Underground
Locator
Tel Stolorn
loutiag Inc.
21fOB S.E. 16th Place
1312-66 '41Y WshtagtM 4BBt7
:ref
cc: Dick ibughton
a
OF R�t
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY a RENTON, WASHINGTON
L ,p{t eHlp Wl•H .00[M[tM[� • NMt014 NIi[I�Htill NNt 1N-MH
LAWRENCE 1.WARREN, err snows. DANIEL KELLOGO, ssMns•t un snaeer
Pr DAVID M.DEAN, s[ptu,t MTV Anawer
o MARK E. aARRER, sseuwT atr ATte•rr
�fo SEo�t 2ANETTA L. FONTES,Aanarw,at.•nower
June 16, 1986 MARTHA A. FRENCH,waslw atv A,- v
TOe Don Ilonagiv . Fh. inav
FROM, Lawrence J. Warren, City Attorney
RE% Shoreline Construction Co.
Dear Don;
Please reweber tm do two things for we on Shoreline:
1, Get a copy rf the State Force Account rates; and
2. Get .m the name of tt,e Pt a-_ Power Underground
Locator that suprosedly notified Shoreline
of the location ,f the City'b electrical ines,
if you can, please talk to him and see if he
will appear at the hearing on July 15th.
Lawrence J. Warren
LJW:nd
� I �
J�N 1 7 19c$
0 kE•
` PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
v R
}} DESIGN/UTILITY ENGINEERING • 235-26Ji
f+ MUNICIPAL BUILDING 300 MILL AVE.SO RENTON.WASH."055
t"'
,rEO SEP1E4t
BARBARA Y, SHINP(,(•, dune 4, IgRb
MAYOR
MEMORANDUM
TO: tarry Marren, City Attorney
FROM: Don Monaghan, Resign Engineer
SUBJECT: Shoreline Arbitration
Attached is a copy of a ^*.= from Dave Tibbot to myself regarding Items
2, 3, and 4 of Mr. Suzuxi's claim in the rrbitration. This reeao is a
res It or a phone conversation between Mr. Suzuki and Rave.
Since Mr. Suzuki failed to provide a formal written claim outlining the
damages incurred together with the facts associated with the claim and his
Justification for said claim, no determination of justification could be
mode.
You have experienced the ambiquity of Mr. Suzuki's claims at our first
hearing and, therefore, know why it is essential that a claim be provided
in writing.
Even though we may no_ be successful , we should try to get it across that
just because Mr. Suzuki whines about something that gives him c problem,
that is not grounds for a claim in arbitration unless formally submitted
and rejected per the contract ranuirements.
The items probably would not have been allowed had he been represented
by an attorney and now that he is, they should be thrown out.
If that does not work, it may not hurt the overall cause to hammer on the
substantial errors in his claim as well as his administration errors in
filing the claim.
P.S.: Enjoy your vacation.
:ckd
Attachment
SPEED LETTER
TO: /. DATE:
PROJECT: w
SUBJECT: .� !y
OF RE'
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
} DESIGN/UTILITY ENGiNEER'NG 0 235-263',
b 1 > MUNICIPAL BUILDING 700 MILL SVE.SO. RENTON.WASH 9BOSS
Pa
rf0 SCv1L�
BARBARA Y. SHINPOCH
MAYOR
MEMORANDUM
TO: Richard C. Houghton, Public Works Director
FROM: David Tibbot, Protect Engineer
SUBJECT: Duvall Ave. N.F. Sewer CAG 007-85
Enclosed are copies of Shoreline Construction Company's request
for extra compensation, on refusal, and Shorlines request for
arbitration.
Does this matter now go to the Attorney or what?
attach:
OT:jw
� 11F ��,I • •
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
W� 'Pt 7 .lr El,bI'tfIR 235 263.
z r
kS MUNICIPAL BUILDING 2W Mlll AVE SO RENTON.WASH 8t1055
e
P
ilti, SE piE�
HARBARA T SHINPUCH
MAVOR
MEMORANDUM
Aprrl It, eve«
Larr) Warren, Cttp Attorne,,
pnn '!on.tyhaa, I'tan Ilnalnoer
Su&IsIY: shoreline Cleita
A+hRMr,l Is .1 ..... rt 'JnvrI no Conxt rilet too Cotapany's rl.aln and trq,Ivat
I'nr arl.lttnrw. 1.1 r.un to*e note in" the ""I') alarm Which ue denied,
. .a ]e+'! than Slu,onrl.�rn, and now apf'eata to oe In cxoexx of Slrr.no0,lf0,
arc! gruwtllry.
AI%n. I could like to rnr Fade ar an arh+e nrt inn Item, the roxt of the
ve1,01t9 to tia, punt, ntatton rlertrirAl syntem Awl ul' by Fttoreline
I AIry•tnx)n,,ttaly $1.10'.)01. Th+a item hax net horn ferpallp putaw^rt
ulth ShneeUnA: houe�er, your ad-ire on what need% t� I� done to include
It as part Of the arl.ltfati M Wnuid he 414mociuted,
r flrf
.At 1 ar•hnent
cet R. C. Houghton
FOR USt IN WASN,NWON "A"
AmericaiPArbitration ASWiation
CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY ARBITRATION RULES
DEMAND FOR ARBITRATION
nett April 9, 1986
TO CITY OF RENTON
Municipal Buildinn
l ed�rrtt, }pQ 01411 Avenue cnuth
Renton, Washicat: 1 98055
I l¢r and%I a*n
_(206) 235-2631
't'R 1 4 19a
Nn+a1,almant a Nrt} to an,r>u•uwn adttanxnt,W1Va1Md¢!,vrlfte0 cMtIK,.
October.: 3 1985
under the Cttllsnuctrvn Indwn+ Athltratm RWnt,hoehy demander athnt,n.m
thttelMdel
N{II'Rt OfM.WiT1 QyyKXl Condition
t1.AIM(WRk1.11it SOUJI] tm,.•.,n, . .,,,, In exeees of ten tMmatici clollars ($10,000)
plus other attna to be pr"jwl at the tim of hearing.
Rnry.n.A„•'.:
lh P,
tli'aR1Nt.I(kn l at\)t'I Sni Penton, Bellevue or Seattle, Waehinat
1:•v air herek', nuhhed Iha, nand u(this Demead at v,nt 1404 with
t inx-,,,ne irh iw.•,n has,- Oitr - .,.��•.,__ . Red®ma}tNfls.
rs o! .err 'ratan Mttotne,
J tt•.c r.,:rt t T.,. . ,- .o d ,,ic•¢rxh@,lun .•r thl uhRR 1ten 1114et k.16at p the Arhm uJNv,
R : I ,.. 1 a, a,nwr�ma rtaicnteta Ituh anon char att."I'me IV,"the Adm,tlMtra.ut
r
•„ : �:,, _.:?kz�:#A�'!„1Is._:k�ttwrrst 9,t4Z�... _.
(206) 483-0600
y. <, kneL at..thiA tum
1.It, ,nq state ._ ... . .__ Itp(t,dc
lttq,it;ew ._. _ _........_....__. . ..,...�_,..._.��
SECTION 1-02 BID PROCEDURES 01ORDITIORS •
1-0E.2 PLANS AIL 5PECIFIDA110Y5
LDELETE PAM4RAPM 3 AM A :SEE SECTION 1-04.141
1 1-02.1B PVBI.:C OPENINGS O BIDS [REPLACEMENT SEC719N1
L
SEALED 8305 WILL E RECEIVED BY THE CITY OF IIENTON, WASn:NGiOM, BY FILING WITH THE CITY DLER., MUNILSPAL
BUILDING, RINTO., WASHINGTON, AS PER CALL FOR BI05 AND 11" BE OPENED AND PUBLICLY READ FLOOD
L,
SECTION 1-0O AMID AID EXECUTION OF EANTRACT
L1-03.1 CONSIDEMTIDN OF BIDS LADDITIOMAL SECT;ONI
L ALL B.DS RILL HE B GED ON TOTAL SUM OF ALL SCHEDULES IF PRICES. NO PARTIAL 810E WILL BE ACCEPTED, THE CITY
RESERVES THE RIGHT HOWEVER TO AWARD ALL OR ANY SCHEDULE OF A BID TO THE LOWEST BIDDER AT ITS CISCRETION.
L_ SICTIOR 1-04 SCOPE OF THE WOR
111 1-04.5 PROCEDURE AMC R101EBT,BY THE COMMCTOP IRBWCIMEIR SECTIDNI
i
l ANY QUESTIONS ARISING BETWEEN THE IMGPECTDR AND THE CONTRACTOR OR HIS SUPERINTENDENT OR fUHEWAW. AS TO THE
MEANING AMC INTENT OF ANY PART OF THE PLANS APE SPECIEICATIDMS OR ANY CONTRACT DOCUMENT. SMALL BE ININEDIATELT
BROUGHT 10 THE ATTENTION OF THE %BLIC WORKS DIRECTOR OR HIS REPRESENTATIVES FOR INTERPRETATION AND ADJUSTMENT.
t I IF WARRANTED.
FAILURE ON THE PART OF THE PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR OR HIS REPRESENTATIVE TO DISCOVER AMC CONDEMN DR REJECT
IMPROPER, DEFECTIVE OR INFERIOR WOW OR MATERIALS. SMALL NOT BE CONSTRUED AS AN ACCEPTANCE OF AWAY BOOM NOW ON
MATERIALS. OR THE PAR• OF THE IMPROVEMENT IN WHICH THE GAME WAY HAVE BEEN USED.
TO PREVENT DISPUTES AID LITIGATION. 17 15 FURTHER AGREED BY THE PARTIES HERETO THAT THE PUBLIC WORKS 01 FCTOR
HIS REPRESENTATIVE SHALL DETERMINE TKE QUANTITY APO QUALITY OF THE SEVERAL FINDS OF WORK EMBRACED 1N THESE
IMPROVEMENTS. HE SHALL DECIDE ALL QUESTIONS RELATIVE TO THE EXECUTION OF IRE WOMB Alt THE INTERPRETATION OF T
PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS,
IN THE EVENT TXE CONTRACTOR 15 OF THE OPINION HE WILL tE DAMAGED BY SUCH INTERPRETATION, HE SHALL, WITHIN 3
QAYS, NOTIFY THE ENGINEER AND THE CITY CLERK IN WR;TING OF THE ANTICIPATED NATURE AND AMOUNT OF THE DAMAGE OP
DAMAGES. TIME IS OF THE ESSENCE IN TEE GIVING OF SUCH NOTICE. IN THE EVENT AN AGREEMENT CANNOT THEN BE PElw.NED
WITHIN 3 GAYS. THE ,:ITY AND IKE COWRALTON WILL EACH APPOINT AM ARBITRATOR AID THE TWO SHALL SELECT A TX3ND
WITHIN 30 DAYS THEN'AFTER.
THE FINDINGS AND DECISION OF lcT BOARD OF ARBITRATORS SMALL BE FINAL AND BINDING ON THE PATTIES, UNLESS THE I
AGGRIEVED PANTY. WITHIN 1D DAYS, CHALL %SES THE FINDINGS AND DECISION BY SERVING Am FILING A PETITION FDA I
REVIEW BY THE SUPERIOR COUNT OF KING COUNTY. WASHINGTON. THE r%)U DS FOP THE PETITION FOR REVIEN ARE LIMITED TOI
ROWING THAT THE FINDINGS AND DECIS70NI R
1. ARE POT RESPONSIVE IC THE QUESTIONS SUBMITTEDI
B. IS CONTRARY TO THE TERMS OF THE C0071ALT DR ANY COMPONENT THEREOF:
3. IS ARBITRARY AMD/OR IS %CT BASED UPON THE APPLICAALE FACTS AND THE LAS CONTROLL:NG THE ISSUES
SUbKTTED 10 ARBITRATION.
SUPPLEMENTAL BPECLFIUATIOh REV0*10/851 PAGE 3
�-ra.s cP}�DyBQ • •
L• THE BOARD OF ARBITRATORS SMALL SUPPORT ITS DECISION BY SETTING FOMF :N PRITING THEIR FINDINGS AID =WLUSID6
LBASED ON THE EVIDENCE ADDUCED AT AM SUCH HEARING.
THE ANSITMTION SWILL BE CONDUCTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE STATUTES OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON AND COURT
DECISIONS GOVERNING SUCH PROCEDURE.
THE COSTS OF 6lCn ARBITRATION SMALL BE BONNIE EQUALLY BY THE CITY AID THE CONTRACTOR UNLESS 17 IS THE BOAW'S
MAJORITY DP:H/uN THAT THE CONTRACTOR S FIRING OF THE PROTEST OR ACTION 1S CAPRICIOUS OR nIHOLR REASONABLE
FOUNDATION, IN THE LATTER CASE, ALL COSTS SHALL BE BORNE BY THE COMPACTOR,
THE VENUE OF AM SLIT SHALL BE IN KING COUNTY, BASMINGTON, ANC IF THE CONTRACTOR IS A MOM-RESIDENT If THE 61AII
OF WASHINGTON. HE SMALL DESIGNATE AN AGENT, UPON OWN PROCESS MAY BE SERVED. SHORE CDMMNCING BONG UNDER THIS
'. CAM WLT.
1-0A.10 USE OF MATERIALS FDUM ON THE PI161ECT IABSITIONAI SECTIDNI
ALL SALVAGE MATERIAL AS NOTED ON THE PLANS AND TAKEN FROM AM OF THE DISCARDED FACILITIES SMALL. AT THE
ENGINEER'S DISCRETION, BE CAREFULLY SALVAGED AID DELIVERED TO THE CITY SHOPS. ALL SALVAGED MIER FIRE
HYDRANTS, VALVES AM APPURTENANCES. CATCH BASINS, AID STORK AID SANITARY MANHOLE COVERS SHALL BE SALVAGED AND
DELIVERED TO THE CITY SHOPS.
AM COST INCURRED IN SALVAGING AM DELIVERING SUCH ITEMS SHALL BE CONSIDERED IWIUENTAL TO IKE PROJECT AND NO
COMPENSATION BILL SE MADE.
1-04.12 WASTE SITES [ADDITIONAL SE,'TION'
ALL RAMERIALS DES::NATED BY THE ENGINEER TO BE MASTED SHALL BE HAULED. DUMPED, AID SPREAD AT THE LOCATIONS
SELECTED BY THE CONTHACTOB.
THE CONTRACTOR SHALL HAVE THE REAPDNSIBILITY OF OBTAINING HIS DIM, V.STL SITE. ALL NON: INCLUDED 1H THIS SECTION
SHALL BE CONSIDERED TO BE INCIDENTAL TO OTHER ITEMS OF WORK AID NO TUNRHER COWL16ATION WILL BE MADE.
THE ROUTE TF..[N -1 THE WASTE SITE SHALL BE RA7MAIF"') SOLELY BY THE COMPACTON IRA A MANNER AS DESCRIBED SELOWI
IMF CONTRACTOR SHALL BE PREPARE) TO USE WATER TRUCKS. PIriER SWEEPERS, AHD RELATED EGLIPMENT AS DEEMED
NECESSARY BY THE PUBLIC MAKS DIRECTOR TO ALLEVIATE THE PROBLEM OF LOST SPOILS ALONG THE ROUTE, PROMPT
RES70PATION OF THE ROUTE IS MANDATORY.
THE CONTRACTOR SHALL SECURE ALL NECESSARR PERMITS AND APPROVALS FOR ANY WASTE SITE TO BE USED. COPIES OF THE
PERMITS AID APPROVALS ARE TO BE SUBMITTED TO THE ENGINEER PRIOR TO STARTING AM WORM,
1-04.13 HOURS OF WORK IADDITIDNAL SECTION[
THE WEARING HOURS 'OR THIS PROJECT WILL SE LIMITED TO WEEKDAYS DURING THE PERIOD FROM MOO A.N. TO 5M00 P.M.
THE MOWS OF NOW MAY SE CHANGED AT THE DISCRETION OF THE ENGINEER WHEN IT IS IN THE MEREST OF THE PUBLIC OR
THE COMPACTOR DUE TO REASONS OF SAFETY. HEALTH. ON WELFARE.
1-O6.14 COMRACTOP'S COPIES OF CONTRACT DOCLwENTS IADDITIOHAL SECTION
THE CDNTAACTOP WILL BE SIPPLI10 BY THE OWNER WITH 5 SETS OF PLANS AM SPECIFICATIONS. AT LEAST ONE COMPLETE SET
OF CONTRACT DOCA.ENTS, INCLUDING ONE FULL SIZE SET OF DRAWINGS, SHALL BE KEPT AT THE SITE OF CONSTRUCTION IN
SDED CONDITION AM AT ALL TIMES AVAILABLE TO THE OWNER AND THE ENGINEER. ADDITIONAL COPIES OF THE CONTRACT
DOCUMENTS. IF REQUIRED. WILL SE FURNISHED BY THE OWNEF MET COST OF REPRODUCTION.
SUPPLENFMAL EPECI`ICAIJOM REV105,'15'85I PAGE 4
when a varier is wmhdawn is,seriled,live refund 52.Deposits
shAl he mwde in ac.udaewe with the refund wheal The AAA may eywre the partial,to deposit tit Ad
ute vans such wins of momey as it deans brim any to
defray the expense of the arbitration,including
The.AAA.it,Ihe s..nt of extreme hardship tin the the armualnrs fee,if any, ,,it stun ra„der An ac.
pan ul ant party,may deter tit nedu,,the idiom cmunmhg to the parties and teluin Any une..pended
wtiallvc lea. balance.
49.Fee%hen Oral Hearings are Waived 53. Interpretation and Application of
M unt all Oral heatngs are waived under Secttun Rules
Tile Athnator shall interpret andaptiv these Rules
Um AJnumsltatire Fee Schedule shall apply.
insular as they elate to the arbitrahn's powers
and duties %Ten there u news,than uwm arbitrator
]he Expenses,s and A dlticmnac Arius unung them concerning the
five expenses the p rt producs cur tither side shall he Ov at.:nt of apphcalu n of any sucl Rules,n shall
Paul by the party producing sorb wunesss,s be deaded by
A m apnnv we.11 tut u unubtam
Able,ceder an arbitrator at a party play refer the
Illt cost of tire stenographic rtcotd,it any a nude question to the AAA for final decision.All other
and all tramcnpu themuf.shall be prorated equal. Rules shall'•interpreted and applied by the AAA,
ly belwaen Ihe parties ordering copes,unless they
shall other a rw agree,and shall be,Paul for by the
responsible patties directly w the report le agency EXPEMED PROCEDURES
34. Notice by Telephone
All ether expenses of the uxpenson,including edit re- The panes shall accept apt notices from the AAA
yuiaJ Uarco)g and ocher expenses of the arbna' by telephone Such notices by the AAA dull sub•
mr and at AAA tepuni n Atum,and die expenses sequently bt confirmed in willing to the panm.
of any witness or the Lovt of any ptwty Imodueed Nolwuhslaadutg the failure to confirm in writing
a1 lire direct rmiwbt of the atbilraior,shall be Any notce:or bleclum hereunder,the proceeding
bone equally by the parties,unkss they agree shall rwnethelessbevAblit nutee has.in ft i.baen
otherwise m unkm der arbitrator in Ihe award as given by telephout:
senses such expenses us any part thereof agwital
any specified party Or patties. 55, Appuinuneni and Qualifications of
Arbitralon
51.Arbitrator's Fee The AAA shall ushnut sunulanasmly toeach pony
Units;the parries agree to terms tit compensation, to the dispute An identical list ill'five nrembeu of
nvembms of tilt National Parer oil f'+m$ItwCllOn tilt fonsrruaiuu Arbitration panel of Albuaturs,
Arbitrators wilt serve without cwnpenwtiun for torn whuch one arhuatur sh.n be aorsyww 1y.Fad+
it,,first day of service puny shall have lh<right to sr like Iwo tunics from
the list on a peremplury bays.The list is ictuniable
Tlwrealtei,compensation shall be based upon lie in the AAA within tan drys from Ihe date of matb
amount of strrtee involved and tie rumbas of hear Mg.If for any reasons the Appointment cannot be
trip.An appropriate daily rate and other arrange. made fnun the ItL the AAA shall hart the author
events will be dtscusted by the adnunutMiul with it, to make the appointment trout Among Other
lilt parties and lire Aihitahattff If the Perim fad members of•hc Panel without the w.rmrsussnol Ad.
to agree to the tell"$of cwnpaivalon,as 1ppro. dunanal Intl, Such appointment shall be wbpe t to
pirate rate dull be established by the AAA,and doquall ication for the reasons specified Section
cwnmu waled to writng to the pence$. 19 The parties shell be firm notice by telephone
To,the AAA of lilt Appointment of tie arbilntor.
Any artatgeultnt for the annlanaton Of an ubl- The partial shall will) the AAA,by telephuM,
talor sh:dl'it made through lilt AAA and nut di- wnhm seven days of Any oblaatwons to the ubrtnr
iecth,by the asbmator w..h the pores The resins, ter appumed Any objections by as party tit such
ofcwnpanwtion of neutral Atbmatan on ATabu. arbitrator shalt be"I mall in—until o the AAA
RAI dull be dentiwl with a ropy to the other partyfuq.
16 17
1f T'av f<J2�rc3t '7,L [:..i�yea+A(&rbV
76 Yrrr c`uaeDrrr� roams.
56.Tittle mid Plan of Hearing Wien no unounl can W stated at the fallout tilling.
The ubnsatot droll fix the date.flow,and place of the sdmmsdtaf0e :cc is S500 tubito to adfust.
the tw ang. The AAA will mn0y the panes by ment in Accordance with the sc:wdule as soon as
telephone,eewn days in adwace of the Imaung An unuum can be du.lowd
dam Fonual Notice u1 Ikatmg will be sent by th.
AAA to the parses
OT HLR SFRVICF CHARGES
57.The Hearintf
Generally,the beatuit;and pewntatussls of the S50 payable b) each party I,•, each second and
pulses$hW be completed wothrn one day.Toe at. subeyuent hearuq%loch Ia either clerked by the
brttatur,fro gaud uuw shawr,may wheduk an AAA a held at a hearing rwtn prarsWed by the
addohmal healing to be held wltlon five days AAA
bb.Time of Award POSTPONEMENT FEES
links othentw agreed wOy the panws,tht awed
shall he rendered not IAItr than 6w b%u cta days
from the dam of the Joang of the heuugl. Sole-Arbitrwor Cases:
S50 payabW by A parry Gist cauursg an adpnsm
merit of my scheduled heannil
ADMINISTRATIVE FEE SCHEDULE $I W Payable by a play uussug a wcoad or subm
yuent Ad)omnmeal of any scheduled huring
A fsbrng fee at S1W.,it be paid at the time the
case o tnsttamd Tha Arhilralar Caaex:
S'S payable by A pan fuse causut;at,adloum
The balance of the admmntrabwt tee of the AAA total of any schlickl td Imarasg
is based upon the amount aI each JAun and coun.
terclaun As dtaclased when the Dann and counter $150 payable by.pain Amusg a sewn)„i.ubw
claim am tiled,and a due and payable pilot to the quell Admmumnenl of A. scheduled h.a row
notice of Appointment of the neutral atbitmtor
In those JAuns and.owirvlAans%hmh ate not REFUND SCHEDULE
for a mWlelay antWsnl,ar appolnlAte Admmu ' If the AAA as nulifrea that A case hats ban witted
tuust(a will bt dttctooned by%lit AAA,pa) crr wnhdrnwn betute a left u(Arbikaturs has been
able pour to such nouct M appointment will out,all the fee in excess of$200 will be le-
.amount at Clasen Tee tee Clam lundcd.
at Cuuntndum or Counterclaim a l $:nWtn 1
If the AAA is matdwd that a caw has been wilted
1 ew ea w ' pit.m r Irao et S
t r.vW w Sau.esu t.exv.% of rthdnwn before the vaginal out dew fro the
cw 11o.000 +ttW r,of the lust lit,twu•s,nNs of the fee m ta
$40 kou to$10.000 $low,pas Ls.sea ea<a i ova of SSW will be refnsnded
oat S40,000
Sa0,000 m 1160,000 1Law.put"W auw% It the AAA is nunfied IhAi a.aw u wttkd a with.
oses 3101.006 416%ndurmg or tallowmg a Pit having conference
S Iho,ow W S$.W am 11.400,pWa 4.1 W.%,wet W At ItW A0 haWs httors the dale And time col oar
.wa S160.W0 the fuse heanng,one thud of the fee y0 excess of
S2,00%d1 be lefmafed.
NTmrctht dauna wuwamlAun eacadx$S mdhun. 'f
an approprett fee wdl be demtmmed by the AAA !
It there am most than I%u pa lws wprewultd in
the atbnratMI,us additional Ityl of the Wmuus
omen Iee%0t be due for each aduanwsal rtpm-
wnted party
Ig 19
OF
c PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
(yESIGN _'I iLltr ENGINEERiNi, • 2]526]`
00, �. MUNICIPAL LOING 300 MILL AVE SO RENTON,WASH 99065
c
P
I FO sf'lk a
BARBARA Y, SHINPOCH
MAVON
MEMORANDUM
DATE April 11, 1906
I'0: Larry Warren, City Attorney
FROHt Don Monaghan. Design Fnqinter
SUIdICTZ Shoreline Claim
Atte,'huu is a copy of Shoreline Construction Comhany'a Maim and •equert
for arbitrator. P1e440 take note that the initial claim which we denied,
was lea, than $10,000-.00, and now appayarn to be in excess of $10,000.00.
and growing.
Al,,,, 1 would like to in,lude as an arbitration item, the ,,at of the
repairs to the pump atw on electrical syateia duq up by Shoreline
lapprmxamate l} $3,30", 0). This item has not he" formall} pursued
"tth Shoreline; however, your advice on what need% to be done to incIddt
it as part of the arbitration would he appreciated.
ter
Attachment
cc% R. C. Houghton ,
SHORELINE CONSTRUCTION CO.
General Contractors
S1 OR EC'374 Nc
.1Mf Ylawnm.W�_--.,wN Motl M416.R
1 0".m 1Ym4.ft*=n.y.an Mil
Ap it 11, 1986
City of Amitnt
Public works Department
Mnicipal Building
200 !till A%*. South
Blanton, Ulf 98055
Attn: Dave Tultetts
10: F.xcavate TrOnCh for Na Llv:ctrical Lint:
for Purr Statim on Duvall Av ,
2 Hrs - 580D Case tatcktrc:
w/operator @ $62.00/hr _ $124.00
Rental of 20 KW Diesel Powered Generator
Set - 24 hrs oontu•uws use = 100.00
30 gals of Diesel @ $0.%9/gal 29.07
Stan.Ilry - One tk** 60.00
1MAL AKXM M. $313.07
INTRNl/YY1l.'N MNINNIANIMIM
DATF: 11r1: :i�, i`Iwn
Till Pon Monaghan
FROM: Dave Tihhotl-
SUBJB KT1 Duvall Av.c N.R. Sever - Jim Suzuki
Mr. Suzuki is claiming he deserves extra compensation for three items in
addition to the Infamous ground water. They are as followsz
1• November 11 Time lost due to adiusting the first run of pip^ or
the misallignment of the existing S" stub. Three (31 hours of
rrow time.
mew
2. November 13 3" transits waterway moved in toward sewer at manhole
hl. Manhole was moved to Fast sn that the noxt run of pipe would not �3
conflict with waterme in. rwo and one-half f2 1/21 hours of crew time.
t. December Ih Power�tel••phono quy'eervice pole on line. Arranged for
power and teleuhone r•. panics to hold pole while contractor dug p{st. dd
Two and one-half 12 1 :) hours o` crew time.
I belit"O Item 1. holds no merit as this is only t, he expected nn start
up and is even mentioned in the contractor's proposed work schedule.
Item may have soee but seems sj,eciws.
Item 3. - the pole is shown on the prints and although we made an effort
to have it moved try the telephone company, it did not create a change of
condition.
Should these be added to the arbitration, paid off, or what?
:mf
n.
FOR USE IN WASHINGTON STATE
America* Arbitration Association
CONSTRUCTION INOUSIm . e\NHITRATION RULES
DEMAND FOR ARBITRATION
;,\It April_4, 1986
lu I�anMl CITY OF REN-ON
r n eLM1 ,yny.el...n IT tamaer..
Municipal Building
lAdd.c*,t .240 pill Avenue Sawth - -.--- ---
Renton, Washington 98055
It m end%islet -
I TPIfP11o.Mt (206) 235-2(331 --
-- — -- ArR 1 4 iP^:_
\tuYd .la.nwul.a Parly L•ell nhlTalh'n if lCrlrMnl\nnlalntd In a N.Illetl♦.nntKl.
daled" October 3, :985 _ _ .. .. _,iwoadanp for xhtlntlon.
e)dtr the l unaUw Twit lellml \Athttanon Rdes.htleh\'demands ArMlralnm
Ihrmundet
""'RI (wI I)ISPt It Owned Cyyl1itions
41AM OR RI111 1 d,l Idil 1,.._.,.,. • n:. In excess of ten thousand dollars ($10,000)
plus other s\ms to be proved at the time of hearing.
\, io re, •._ ..i.._ a•„ Vi' 1, wrw....IM1NhP em,lxvr
. , . _, .. •,.el., e. r,n�, m-u.adn tlrha•x•
Pkeyr
nit... st"O, _..
.i bib•,nrn 1,1•,r, 11nUh _..___,
I In
lit \itl\1.11n \I1 ltlnl 1VI1' Renton, Bellevue or Seattle, Washington
nnlrTvd Ihp .wprr•,d ..,n Alhlban n \Wcnrut .md rd rill Iklnend mt bpnR fded with
the \+nern�or Northwest R<gionnl 1/tl1a.
a111, 11M erynnt gut It 11-e minunfa'a+nm 'l nM 10"trltn,n I "del `r,lnui „1 the Atelmewll
Kok"L. .... ,', b it an nlnNSt1u05441rt l r'it InT ICvlu d",All',nit Ito Ron.the Mlnnnlslfehn
\vx•..la knm,,., SBORELINE C(NSTPBCTtON CO,
\Jdren no:,.c urr:l u,rwltnr.m•n.x',th rhl\.a;r. P.O. Box 358
1 it) And State b`oadinv, T„jg, _�'A hit 98072
ht'rh.m. 12061 4113-Ot00
Nwlx.a All w...o None at.this time
Add1o,
ltl\ and State
..tmw IN tht.Ikn 1d lbc wt Alrlp.:
SECTION 1-07 BID PROCEDURES E wITICNS
1-0OP.? PUNS AM 6Pf CIf 1LATI1)
LDELETE PAWAGRAPH 3 AND A )SEE SECTIDN 1-04.141
1-02 15 PUBLIC OPEN1„SM OF BIDS IREPLAGEENT SECTION)
SEALED BIDS WILL BE RECEIVED BY THE CITY OF UNION, WASHINGTON. By FILING WI7N THE CSTY CLERK. MUNICIPAL
BUILDING, RAIDN, EIASHINUMN, AS PER CALL FOP BIDS Aft WILL BE OPENED AID PUBLICLY READ ALOUD.
SAMION 1-03 AWARD AND ENECUTIOR OF COETIRACT
L 1-03.1 CONSIDERATION OF BIDS IADDITIONAL SE TIONI
ALL BIDS WILL BE BASED ON TOTAL SUN OF ALL SCHEDULES OF PRICES. NO PARTIAL 9106 WILL of ACCEPTED. THE CITY
RESERVES THE RIGHT HOWEVER TO AWARD ALL OP ANY SCHEDULE OF A $10 TO THE LOWEST BIDDER AT 116 DISCR'T10N.
MRlpl 1-0A COPE OF THE BDAE
111 I 1-04 6 PROCEDURE AND PROTEST BY THE CONTRACTOR (REPLACEMENT SECTIONI
ANY QUESTIONS AlI6ING BETWEEN THE INSPECTOR M THE CONTRACTOR OR HIS EUPERIMEHOEMT 04 FOREHAN AS 10 THE !
MEANING AM INTENT OF ANY PART CF THE PLANS AM SPECIFICATIONS OR AM COMPACT DOCUMENT. SHALL BE INEDIAIELY
BROUGHT TO THE ATTENTION OF THE PUBLIC WOWS CIRECTOR OR Nl6 REPRESENTATIVES FOR INTERPRETATION AND ADJUSTMENT,
IF WARRANTED.
FAILURE ON THE PART R THE PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR OR NI6 REPRESENTATIVE TO DISCOVER AND CONDEMN OR REJECT
IMPROPER. DEFECTIVE OP INFERIOR NOW OR MATERIALS, SHALL NOT BE CONSTRUED AS AN ACCEPTANCE OF AM SUCH NOW ORI
MATERIALS. ON THE PART OF THE IMPROVEMENT IN WHICH THE SANE NAY HAVE BEEN USED,
TO PREVENT DISPUTES AND LITIGATION. IT 16 FURTHER AGREED BY THE PARTIES HfNETO THAT THE PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR DR
HIS REPRESENTATIVE SHALL DEYEAKINE ' RUANTLII AM DUALITY OF THE SEVERAL E1MUS OF NOW EMBRACED IN THESE
IN'ROVEWNTS, NE SHALE DECIDE ALL WE6149N5 RELATIVE 10 THE DOECUTION OF THE WORK AND THE INTERPRETATION OF 1HE
PLANS AID SPECIFICATIONS,
IN THE EVENT THE CONTRACTOR IS OF 7HE OPINION HE WILL BE DAMAGED BY SUCH INTERPRETATION, HE SHALL, WITHIN 3
DAYS, NOTIFY THE ENGINEER AND THE CITY CLERK IN WRITING OF THE ANTIC1PAIED MATURE AND AMOUNT OF THE GARAGE ON
GARAGES. TIME 15 OF THE ESSENCE IN THE GIVING OF SUCH NOTICE. 1N THE EVENT AN AGREFMEt1T CANNOT THEN BE REACHED
NITHih 3 OJNS. THE CITY AM THE iONiR4TOA WILL EACH APPOINT AN ARWITMATOP AEI THE TWO SHALL SELECT A THIRD
WITHIN 311 DAYS THEREAFTER.
THE FINDINGS AIM DECISION OF THE BOARD OF ARBITRATORS SHALL BE FINAL AM BINDING ON THE PARTIES, UNLESS THE
AGGRIEVED PARTY, WITHIN 10 DAYS, CHALLENGES THE FINDINGS AND BEC15ILN BY SERVING AID FILING A PETITION FOR
REVIEW BY THE SUPERIOR COURT OF SING COUNTY, WASH1N110N. THE GROUNDS FOR THE PETITION FDA REVIEW ARE LIMITED 70
SHOWING THAT THE FINDINGS AND DECISION:
ARE NOT RESPONSIVE TD INC QUESTIONS SLNNITTED;
P. IS COMRART 70 THE TERNS OF THE WMHACI ON AM CONPONM THEAEOM;
3. IS ARBITRARY AND/OP I6 NOT BASED WON THE APPLIGBLL FACTS AM THE LAN CONTROLLING THE ISSUES
SUBMITTED TO ARBITRATION,
t
1
SWPLf HEMq SPKLFIGAIIONN PEV1U6/iQ/B5! PAGE 3
]=A.S Cont HnuWO
THE BOARD OF ARBITRATORS SIAL41PPORT I16 DECISION BT SETTING FOFIH AIM THEIR FINCINGS AM CONCLUSIONS
LBASED ON THE EVIDENCE ADDUCED AT AM' SUCH HEARING.
It* ARBITRATION SMUT BE COMUC7® 1% ACCORDANCE WITH THE STATURES OF THE STATE OF MSNINGION AND COURT
DECISIONS ROVERNINS SUCH PROCEDURE.
THE COSTS OF SUCH ARBITRATION SMALL BE BORNE EQINLLV BY THE CITY AM THE CONTRACIM UNLESS I1 1S 11% BOARD'S
L NARORITY OPINION TRAT THE COMMCTOR'S FILING IF THE PRO"" OR ACTION 1E CAPRICIOUS OR WITMCLR REASONABLE
FOUNDATION, IN THE LATTER WE. ALL COSTS SM LL BE BORNE BY THE CONTRACTOR,
THE VEMUF 6 ANY SUIT SMALL BE IN RING COUNTY. SASMI NGION. AM IF THE COMPACTOR IS A MHrRE51DENi OF THE SLATE�
l_ CF WASHINGTON. HE SHALL DESIGNATE AN AGENT, IRON 1PN1M PROCESS PAY BE SEAVU. WORE COMWHENCING WORD. UNDER THIS I
` COMAMI♦
I 1-04 10 USE OF NATEAIALS FOUND ON THE PNGJECT [ADDITIONAL SLC710NI
ALL. SALVAGE MATERIAL AS NOTED ON THE PUNS AM TAKEN FROM AM OF THE DISCARDED FACILITIES SHALL, AT THE
ENGINEER`S DISCRETION, BE CAREFULLY SALVAGED AM DELIVERED TO 74 C.TT fOPS. ALL SALVAGED WATER RAINS, FIRE
HYDRANTS, VALVES AM APPUMERAMES. CATCH 4SINS. AM STORM AM SANITARY PAMHCLE COVERS SMALL BE SALVAGED AM
DELIVERED It THE CITY SHOPS.
AM COST INCURRED IN SALVAGING AM DELIVERING SUCH. ITEMS SMALL BE CONSIDER® INCIDENTAL 10 THE PROJECT AM M
L EDWENSSATION WILL BE MADE,
1-0e 12 y.STE SITES LADDITIO�IONI
ALL MATERIALS OESIGNATCD BY THE ENGINEER TO BE WASTED SHALL BE HAULED, DUMPED, AM SPREAD AT THE LOCATIONS
SELECTED BY THE CONYRACIDR.
THE CONTRACTOR SMALL RAVE THE RESPOASIGILITV OF OBTAINING HIS OWN WASTE SITE. ALL VOW INCLUDED IN THIS SECTION
WILL BE CONSIDERED TO BE 11CIDENTAL 10 OTHER ITEMS OF WOW AM M FURTHER MWEHSATIDN WILL SE MADE.
THE ROLRE TAKEN TO THE WASTE SITE SRALL BE MAINTAINED SOLELY BY 1HE CONTRACTOR IN A MANNER AS DESCRIBED BELOW,
THE CONTRACTOR SHALL BE PREPARED TO USE MIER TRICKS. ROWER SWEEPERS, AM RELATED EQUIPMENT AS DEEMED
NECESSARY BY THE PUBLIC WORTS DIRECTOR TO ALLEVIATE THE PROBLEM OF LOST SPOILS ALONG THE ROUTE. PAOM'I
RESTORATION OF THE WE 15 MAMATORf.
THE CONTRACTOR CALL SECORE ALL NEC"J.M PERMITS AM APPROVALS FOP AM WASTE .;IE 70 BE USED, COPIES OF THE
PERMITS AM WPPRDVALS ARE ID 8E SUBMITTED TD THE ENGINEER MOM TO STAM M,AM, WORA.
1-04.10 HOUAE OF WORD (ADDITIONAL GECIIONI
THE WORKING NOUNS FOP THIS PROJECT WILL BE LIMITED TO VEEROAYS DURING THE PERIOD FROM 600 A.M. 10 EIQC P.M.
THE MUDS OF WORN MAY BE CHANGED AT THE DISCRETION OF THE EMSNNE€A WHEN 17 16 IN THE INTEREST OF THE P,b-1C OR
THE CONERACIOR DUE TC REASONS OF SAFETY, NLALTH, OR WELFARE,
1-O4.I4 COMRACIUR'S COPIES W fONTWT DOCUMENTS IADOITIONAL SECTIOA
THE CONTRACTOR WILL BE RMIED BY THE OWNER WITH S SETS OF PLANS AM SPECIFICATIONS, Al LEAST ONE COMPLETE 50
OF CDNIMC7 DOCUMENTS. INCLUDING ONE FULL SIZE SET OF DRAWINGS. 6.ALL BE AEPT AT THE SITE OF CONSTRUCTION 1N
GOOD CONDITION AM Al ALL TIMES AVAILABLE TO THE OWNER AM THE ENGINEER. ADDITIONAL COPIES OF THE CONTRACT
OOCURE a, IF REQUIRED, WILL BE fUR41SHED BY L,UL OWMEf NET COST OF PCPRQDmTIQ%.
SUPPLEMENTAL VPECIFISA`10E AEVl96'10+85} PACE 4
NJ,1j,none,nwnbd,.,n a..I Wiled'I se tat and 52.IirlrsnAN,
-,AI he mark no n.urJaae with the refund wined Me AAA may tetra,Ili,panes w dcp,ot u1 all.
nit woe mach soots of money As it deestn rw.rpary.o
defray Otr,vlene of ite mbnalum•indudmg
I he AAA,a,IIM nH,t of evheme IuWshlp.m ells tine athuralIr I tee,tf all ,and self rills. an sit,
pan W aa)party.any Jet, ,,edu.e like Adnms camomg to the partw,and rHuhuny IUMapensed
W 1411 a lee balance
49.Pee Misers 0121 fuming"are Waised 53. Iuerprklalion And Alrysli alias of
Whore all oral selling,a„ wansd under Se,teo Ruks
37_ h, A,in,,nwt t,'a, Pee &"dine dull apply the atbneno.dull"triplet old apply Ilene Rules
unala a,lIM) meat,W the uhuu,oft I,,w,rs
So. LAlwutes And du,ws taken there u nuMe titan one asbnrataf
I h,exla'nws of wnuesr,ear HthH mk 9ull be and J Jlileren:e"„et anonµ thrift.au.e ionµ Ibe
Iuhl by like party pn,dncng such witnesses Inn"µ u,apk,l,,,s,,or any such Ruks.II calf
be sledded by a nryaauy vote.If that u uWblun-
Ihe..nl of list sirnog,.gdn..mwld a any a made. able.Calls.tat nhmalm of a party any lifer the
And all hanaliPIs 16ke1,,dull be prraed etuaf tuenun In the AAA for final Jeussnn.All offer
lY between the parltn ordetanp co flo n,urdcss they Ruin Tall be mleeprateJ and APPIked by the AAA
dull otbe.Wilt asa— and hall be pant fur by the
mspro,ble pastes dur.tls 1.ste mkwnagapcney L.tpEDITEU PROCEDURES
All allot esksense,a,the alMhalor.tn.laJnsµ,a 54. Notice by Telephone
tuned turdusp and o1hH ecpeusn of the a,hnw. The panes shall acep(all n,xama final Use AAA
Or and,d AAA epreuntah,,,,,Jad If,,ewwmses by lefephvre Soh notwei by lie AAA dui;wb
of any wont"tat the s."I ui au ketutml)be Ialfi n it a writes to the parfke,
Pt.e."p'll bed Notwithstanding the fail,,,h,Confirnn u,willing
.aI dls Jae:l by the
al no+ .ulklc tv,, ) A ha MY mtmo a.ohkedmn hemwalrr.the pns.eedi g
Incline initially onto,
l 1 fur b a, l",in they agar Tall lhalehMle"be wllJ if,n eke has,In wo.been
ul6rrwaso.or unlen ills arhrhabn m Ilse aw uJ u�
nexus omi,es,kwnscs o,any Iurl ths',of"µ"list µ,Win by leleplume
any ske,rwd pony or parties, 55. a\s11 soinluaenl laid QuaGlkmiosu of
Affirmation 1 Arbitrator's t ar i he AAA h.R submtl m,kkh,Imou,ly,,each parry
Unless,the Ia,rkes agree to let uh of,ontMl"atNns. to the J"pute an tdenikal list of five mtmbess of
kill a.he"of file Natemal Pmwl,.I t',aI%jj"t on Ile fo.ulludnm A,hnutian Panei,d A,ba,ahns.
At7u11aawn will sort,wribu..I .,anivuubon for hwa,,lad..."alhrtr 1, L lily l'1 l'.aJ,
'Ile first day at service roily shall have the rght In grille Iwn tame,I,wit
de tut on a pemotsbay ha» hike tut o rrluhuDle
IIM,bIII•I,uall(Mn JINN,dIJIt Iy DJYJ nlMal U,C h1 lie AAA within ten drys horn the date of nuih
anwaanl fit aftae Involved and tie nwntH of bran. tag.If for risky raga"the appom(uaeot casino be
mpg•An aptnnapinte dam)rate sal other artatgle. made(ram,the list, be AAA dull late the author
pert wall be shushed by like ahnuosltJlul will sty to make the apponrosken l from Ansonµ odker
like parties gal tie"Whatopw It the PJYlses lad f swHnbets of16Panelwahaat the subrousbu All aJ-
,to agree it,like trots of etawiMusafam,a,alnpso. df inal frig Sash oppnmlal"t halt he wb)"t hs
Pluto fare shall be ealalAu ked.by tilt AAA,said dutssahfkatwn for the alfoo,specdwJ as Se"Wo
Hem,ullkakL sn,,isms to the Iarlies 19 The patlies cull be porn matate by ekphoe
Ill the AAA of like oppumhnHlt of Ile arbaawl.
Ask)atunpHtwnt for the unaspmWhim ul an tj The Parkes Stull nutdy the AAA,by elepbsm,.
floor shall be mark,hrauµh se AAA aN me dal wuhn,totem Jas s r any oblestuns to the arbar,.
IWly by the uhtll"I't%Al.IIM lu.area 'lie tar", tie appnnled All)(Ib)nhon by A party to wish
ofarnpenatNm td tlsutul sitbumh...war Tnba• "ball",Jullh.•n.ufumN m wuhtq"the AAA
oat sell be uenn.al with a,op) to the oth,t pa,gllni
In 17
36 'Time and Plata of Hearing when Iva ain,wxl tin be Iwtdat the Imit a1 Iihng,
11ke nhoubo J all too the date.tnru,and p4l<of the wlmml,lia;ot One u Von.mhle't R,aJlun
doe hea,wy. She AAA well rx,nly Shia panics by mean in aivWdAMv will.like seheduk as U.,is
wieplentt le,en Jay,rn aJwa.e ill the hearing an uuuunt"n be Joohtwd
Jai, l uoual o iye of I luanrg wt0 be xn,by the
A 1A lu lire patiK+
5' !Ile HearingOTHLR SERVWL CHARGES
Leue,ally,the bearxog ind Inl•Xinlin,MO of like SSO payahlt by e,,h lost, tut t>h or mnl and
iwucs shall Ix •xulJ<Icj%ohm vane Jay the At wbmyuenl IttUmg wb%h a CRIM.ktueJ by Ibc
bxulos.hn gextJ case sM+wn,may A-htJuk an AAA M htW m A Mating Rxun psusuled by the
aJJtlmial hewing ro be held%Rivas now Jays AAA.
58 Tblte of Award
11Weuolheo%ix aglted wby llitilaines,the a%aW POSTPONLAIENT FEES
cull be modeled not oft,than file Stillness days
Sown Ship Jai,of the clusmg of din Iinm,; &A-Arbitrator Cases:
SSO payable by a pally Gal auung at aJyuu.,r
merit of any Altedukd team It
ADMINISTRATIVE F ILL SCHEDULE SIWPayableh,ya path.dusinga nsubse.
yuenf adloulnmtro of my ulredukJ htanNg
A idiq Ire.a INA)%ill lhr paid at the Inns the
case it niotawJ TbeerArfotralur Canes.
$1i payable hs a parry lull—ioung an a.11uunl
It.WIAR,,let(its aJunnnlfafne lee led ohs A SA .,will A any wheduled htmueg
is hard upon we anmool nl tall,dann ind.Dun
lel.imn ax JlxtuxJ%lion Ste dawn and nuhlet. S I su payable by a party .IJSIIN a wmnJ or suhsa
dann ae IJeJ.led o Ju, .�d pay aldc point ill tlir yueul IlIWOR maot ill any icheJ4Wd heaniyt
mnur of aiyn=mtmpof nt ❑re uculral arhatialor.
Ilk ihosr'Latin,and cWNltLlums whxh A,e It'll RI UND SCHEIJULL
tut a R NKlary ink..11.1.In atynnpoalc aJntmn In like AAA n tnAilied that a wax has twen willed
Val tce I"%'III be delmttnned by llte AAA,la) Ix WIIIIdI0w11 Mlme•Inl nl AIbllfihNa Ion block,
pftax to inch Rifles o.algNimtnwnl ,anon Dill,all list lee in excess,of 5200 will be for
A numnl I((San. fee lva l latm fomkJ
wt(WnIMClanit nl(9YNIrrCIINw
$1 I'll axl 11 the AAA n fwfthed that a nix has been x Wed
M%dldliwn befine the oxigmal due chat fin like
f!ula]Ih Ilk Nu.uo It blAs sex l2ae rssw
.iHy Rea rrimY of the Ind IwL Iwo-thuds let die fee of<a'
to.,*I to ieni,AYa IS I,mm,piso 1, al eii of S100 vast be itturAtd
..,el NY.txA)
tw!uAi to tibgaaMi tl.ami.pks'd 4"ksok It the AAA a nonfi,,J that a,aw IN Ilkd of will
„..,NanpN Jhatendunngut hJto%mg a pre-Mating cfmteleswe
t IbQWYta ty,WN,Ygi t4ailU.pWa V.al ruYw Mal least Ablowlikottwe file dint and Inot set hx
met ttalasal9 the fou hearing.ant-thud aJ IM fee to tutu at
S:W will be fetunded.
WI:Ie Ohio abrm,of wuntu:launtrtseds fj aidliws, �
an approtmoor tin will be delenntped by the AAA.
11 little lee mutt than twu pullet tepetwoted in
it.atlfosalYm.nt addnxmal IV-;of the sdl"%k
thane net will be does Iva taah addilNxW Stiles.
umud pasty
18 19
OF
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY a RENTON, WASHINGTON
Z roar Oa[ic[wa•s[ ,Da a M aT•fE+ • aev!ea w�a,w,oTa+, aws+ [aa-•[>a
-9 LAWRENCE 1.WARREN, car[TTm•rr, DANIEL KELLOGG, vaaIa+MT 011 A aLr
q e DAVID M.DEAN, +wa+urt 071•TTow
4n P
� MARK F BARBER, gasuwT cT.[noiw[r
yaytE
LANETTA L FONTES, swel"T a+r AT,a ,
March 21, 1986 MARTHA, A FRENCH.•sasT[vT ca,ATroa[er
RECEIVU, '
PAUC WOP.K^
CITY OF RC.,
TO: P.i^hard Houghton
FROM: Lawrence J. Warren, City Attorney
RE: Shoreline Construction Arbitration
Dear Dick:
Apparently Mr. Suzuki does not wish to be prudent and settle
this claim. As per our conversation, because of job pressures,
your department agreed to waive the prompt notice requirement
for arbitration. Therefore, Shoreline Construction's request
for arbitration is timely. You should indicate to Mr. Suzuki
of Shoreline Construction that we are prepared to go to arbitra-
tion and that he should make the necessary contacts with AAA.
We should certainly encourage the use of a single arbitrator to
keep costs down. If he wishes to arbitrate he should make the
next move and ask for arbitration. The AAA will provide us with
a list of arbitrators to rhoose from.
ver -ttuly yours,
Lawrence'J. Warren
1.JW/]v
CC! Mayor Shinpoch
OF RA,
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
RICHARO C HOUGHION 0 DIRECTOR
O MUNICIPAL BUILDING 7W MILL AVE SO RENTON.WASH 98055
6 �e 206 235 2569
\'ro SEp�E
BARBARA k. SHINPUCH
MArDR
MEMORANDUM
DATE: March 19, 1986
TO: Larry Marren, City Attorney
FROM: Richard C. Houghton, Public Works Director
SUBJECT: Duvall Ave. M.E. Sewer Claim for Extra
Compensation for Dewatering
As discussed on 3/11/86. an offer of $2500 was made to Mr. Suzuki
of Shoreline Construction, to settle his claim for extra compensation
as a result of ground water encountered on the project. On 3/17/86
he advised that this offer was unacceptable; but felt $7000 was a
more reasonable figure which would be acceptable to him to settle
all claims.
If that number was not acceptable to us or we felt we could not come
to terms, he would like to proceed with the arbitration process.
Mr. Suzuki was advised that we would probably counter-claim for the
cost of the damage to the Pump Station electrical system (approxi-
mately $3100), if we went to arbitration.
If it is your recommendation that we proceed with arbitration,
Mr. Suzuki has indicated that he would be receptive to having a
single arbiter hear the dispute rather than the normal three
arbiters.
Please advise how we should proceed in this matter.
:mf
GF REM • •
0 OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY a RENTON. WASHINGTON
`' rnT OfY1C[pa ex boa a ew aTlla[T • IIfMTON.Neel�lplgY pmr reewre
eeY LAWRENCE J.WARREN, CITY aT?d V DANIEL KELLOOO. &~,ImvT arY AYT~
a DAWD M. DEAN, •saHTu,r CITY eTT~Y
�rEO SE PTY�O�P MARK E. BARBER, AsaaTW cm ATTaMY
ZANETTA L. FONTES.MeaTexr CITY A"o Y
March C, 1986 MARTHA A. FRENCH,eswTerT CITY erIWSVV
TO: Dick Houghton, Public Works Director
FROM: Lawrence J. Warren, City Attorney
RE: Duvall Avenue N.E. Sewer Project, CAG 007-85,
Request for Arbitration from Shoreline Construction
Co.
Dear Dick:
Cuuld you please provide me with a copy of the plans and
specifications for this job that miqht refer to arbitration.
My initial reaction is that Shoreline Construction should
have stopped work and arbitrated when it encountered this
" changed condition. However, I need to look at the specifi-
cations and I will further need input from your staff about
how the project. was handled.
Lawrence J. warren
LJW:nd
cc: Mayor
OF RFM
i O OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY a RENTON, WASHINGION
V x Yp{T WVKG Wx aaa I"a P Brlq[r • "VIMW.WACIM paa, M-MTa
LAWRENCE J WARREN,Cnr+nowaY DANIEL KELLOGG, +amaT+eT c*Y uroww•
P
DAVID M. DEAN, &%"TAXI CIT.+nowtl
tF0 gEPTE� MARK E. BARBER, +aaar+nT uTv Arro+a•
ZANETTA I. FONTES Asw?"?cm AT, mI,
February 4, 1986 MARTHA A FRENCH.aaanuN,cm+TTom
RECE"D
TO: Dick Houghton, pub is Works Director "LIC WORKS OEP*
FROM: Lawrence J. Warren, amity Attorney CITY OF RENTON
RE: Duvall Avenue N.E. Sewer Extention - CAG-077-85
Damage by Shoreline Construction Co.
Dear Dick:
In reviewing the notes that you have sent to me I believe that
the responsibility for contacting the private eie.trical service
and the resultant damages is on Shoreline Construction. Apparently
the contractor was told where the service was loc..ted and yet dug
in a negligent fashion contacting the service and damaging it.
The Cityts responsibilities have been discharged and the contractor
must bear the resultant responsibility for damages.
If you believe that I do not have an adequate working knowledge of
the facts, or there is any further information that you wish to
share, pease let me know,
Lawren7 J•Warren
LJW:nd
Encl.
Co. Mayor
OF RE
� 1�
t"f Z PUBLIC WORKS DEP,.RiMENT
RICHARC C HOUGHTON • DIRECTOR
MUNICIPAL lUILDINO =0 MILL AVE So RENTON,WASH 9805E
EP January 28, 1986 2D6 135 7569
JED SE r�E�
BARBARA Y. SHiNROC�
MAYOR
MEMORANDUM
TO: Larry 'dar,en, City Attorney
FROM: Dick Houghton, Public Yorks Director
SUBJECT: Duvall Avenue N.E. Sewer Extention - CAG-077-85
on necember 23, 1985, Shoreline Construction Co., the City's contractor
on the Above referenced project, dug up and broke the underground
electrical service to the Eastgate Sewage Pump Station. The short
circuit resulting from the broken wires, also, damaged the Puget Power
transformer supplyinq the se lice. This service is considered to be
a private commercial service and is owned by the City and Punet Power
will not maintain or repair it. The total costs of repairing this
service are not in vet, but are expected to exceed $6,000.
Shoreline Construction Company disclaims any responsibility for this
incident because the service was not marked on the ground at the time
of the breakage. (RCN 19.122)
Please review the enclose narratives prepared by our project manager,
David Tibbot, to see if tlr city has basis for a claim for damane
against Shoreline Construction Company.
---_hick Mougbton
DT:ckd
Attachments
DUVAII AVENUE N.E. SEWER EXTENTION
CAG-077-85
Narrative of cvents leading to damage on December 23, 1985:
1. Initial location for project by One Call" locatinq service was preformed
on or about November 7, 1985. In telephone conversation with Ted Seaborn,
Locating Inc., Puget Power's subcontractor for utilities locations, on
January 28, 1986, I received the foilowinq informrtion:
The location company lnq for the initial locate on November 1, 1985,
states a secondary d"p was located, but was noted (??ours??).
Mr, Seaborn also said this servir was marked again for the City when
ioinq water service transfer but could not find that record at the
time of our conversation.
2. On the day o° the incident, the contractor forman, Juan Bergrud, asked the
City's inspector, Abdoul Gafour, about the location of the electrical
service as shown on the project plan at centerline Station 21f90f, but he
could find no markina on the ground at this time. Apparently the original
markings done by Mr. Seaborn had been obliterated by weather or the
construction operations in the intervening six weeks, and the contractor
had made no effort to preserve or record them. The City's inspector
informed the contractor excavator operator that the crossinq was as
shown on the plans directl, across from the power pole with the service
transformer which was located across Duvall Avenue N.E. from the excavations
and that he would call "One Call" and ask for an immediate relocate.
Mr. Seaborn informed me that he did not receive the request that morning
but that he drove by and saw the telephone company locator, who had
radio communicatior, locatinq and that he then stopped and spoke with the
fomnan, Mr. Bergrud, and informed him that the service was private and
he could not locate it aqain but that it was directly across from the pole.
The City's locator, Rick Kokko, arrived and attempted to locate the service
working back from the meter head but lost the signal 50 feet from the meter
and before the cross',.,. About one hour later at approximately 11:00 a.m.,
the excavator struck the service directly across from the power pole as
indicated and broke the conduit and severed one of the four wires inside.
aF.122.tM� 1 n0 N1 m Ituvlw,.Nrgulun m—.h11+y.
11,122A14 Inlw,. 11 I, the mice of yb,
t kgda4rc hat,rduWs IiyuW,,or other stancn And r audmg SIR,
in ePJ,YnIg Ihu C he tuper to Aulgn "Purubdams for lo. nor bmnCd Iu ppy, wwcrs, condo,,, ,Jbk,, ,alvas,
Canng and kcepng Amtuip c reward, ,d utd,ty kKnikMs• Ime., 1Im, manhole,. Al11ChMenb, a+d those parts of
pweCyrng slid rcpanmg daurJgt eo cAm Mg um(cr
gnaund lAC'lnW`, And pweclmll the publ,, htA!!h and Potts w aneMrr,hhn ground
.AICi1 hcun In,...Upton m allhq wn Kn 1131 "floc number )'wa,,,e wrcar' mean, a ur+ae
dAmagc lu e1nini um1Cr r ,aw,c'! IR thnWlgh Whi,h a perwn An nod, WLblw, Ano rtyu¢,;
Y Y YM}old 1)7Jcrhfln ;{vNJ, r*j IRAtkin" of und"ggwtld taPhht, 11Ykw a tea 1
Iaagf �
N.122.92111 IAgiailiew I mco the ;untea( dearfe
riW(uI1IW Wherune. the defimbon, In ilia, wc1WM April)
1wkr of rtea\alfaF In aFntF a whir-
thnwYh.wl chi,agsie, pFaad facihtke —TYr fr wtier---_Mailer,
1 t 1 'Nu,lne„it')" uK,m,an) des other than SalYr. 11"wilte" WASi" uµa NeLuc orrmr• r .ails
6,. tiumLty.w.,legs,kwal.,Wla,w ledcrAl hulWa MA\alnM. the saCJ,a,w ,hall prvnwle RAA,V of it,
t a "lhu ) wb<dukel Caifolle" nen, of tat;.,Atwn 11 all oFPan of
rage owlu,k+ the wlaauntwl weukening of undtrgFwnd licil,ue, Ihn,ugA a tine number Nulty
fe mrcoil,u (aleral"j,upp or,,d an tltedargnwnd fnews, wr,,,V Ir no one nun,be, kwalen "wore n Avadabw
1w,wu.lu.y1. ual,errr,wM, .a rk+lrmYPut ,4 anY umlcr- 110l,e ,hall be pmrtled md,wduallY Io ,More nr tore,or
geoaaW protsy;tive Cantles, hwwY. or other prwtctnc unelcrgnwmt tacontes known In or s,spxlyd of kav,ng dc`wt,w the ursannro,Partial w cwnpltne,ill any un uaitrgr'wfW facdine, u,tMa kin area or papered c%cA,
dcrgtolt vA(Aol,t)la the client that the prof'owner or ration The mmCa shill be wtnmunwJKd In the owner the ANNIed unlit) oW nil Jelet nomm. lbal rtp,us are w umlergr+wrld (aclhbt+mw k,s itwn IWU WNARVU,VIA,,
tty 1' .,, nWWe then ten bulol"I dA)s btfwr the Khtdirkd dJe.
131 Fnprgcmy' Pavans any c,nWmop Wn„dwing a fur commrnccmem of etcasanon, unit„ ne Aerw lse clear sad pnaal dAtrger to lift w priMCrlY. w a cYs Agteed by the porbn
Ionic'sers,Ct•exiage ('port tnvllst of the mauve pro,Wed ror In this iitibun.
IA) "f.tcaraluA'' means An$UpCtalum,n Wtnsh eetih, tie owner of the umle'gnwnd fatdn) shall pl,W,dc the
ruck or other matnrul wt w bchw the grnum)is ",d etca,Alnt will,reaauaabl) accuratt iafwrpatxM AN Ill it,
,W oeher%lae J„ptaCtd D) An) "'elan,, cC,ept the Ohng hwawbk undrrywund faaiktkv by awfasY marking the
ut seal IV,, than,u<Wc ,whc, ,n Jeph Iitt agrieubuul hwabeM of the fwJ,hta. 11 there art skUllfeed but
purplFes, w nwd And 11110 mJlntenJlKe than dot, mu wnlocatAble urukrgrtwnd facdn...the owner of sm:h 1A
tkur4e list wrymat rond ar,IS,or d"'S,thew ItnC. elllllt,+kJII prW Idt IDC C\l'a`aew Wilk She DeII:rVdllAble
let eca,atw' means an) ptrsan *Ito engage, d, Inh,rmatiun A, to their hwal\aM, fhc owner of ,he us,rr>ith ,n ruasatnM dclgnwnd faCibly ptu`nhnY the Information Shull rc.
Ibi 'HknbtuU 141111 y' means An)umkrYnwmY facil. >pond m,later than IWa bustle.day,.Ilitr,be eewetp if
It) whnh e' rndtea,dl in the prol"t peal., n, bells la� the mnnt w belom the at,asabon Sloe.At,he Option of
Cared WsdWn the at,,Io Proposed c,.Cavulnln tke oFker,unku wherFruu agreed b) Ow penkt. Fur.
(71 'Idtnufled but unhwalable umfergmmnd YacAhb' ''hors ,hall not esula(c until Al known fuiltlK, hAvt
means an umkegru out facdny whnh ha,been Wcw,l,u',f hen ill.+rk.d fAen marked tit the Ow�gr d the wader but Caaraw be 6oCAYN W Itk ISA:,rrnabk ae4Y,Jl, vu*d fadMy, the curivatw a labillim bit for m. ,.
M 'lrwa/able u nItognwnd lac,:,t)' ream An in, 41nefy Ike Mtkinp f.,A,.don AA111 have the ,Oh, to
derground fa ilgy Fhrch Can be fKkl maded Wah rea KvIne compensiuun Storm the ownm 01 the under
sonable A"'Utge) ground fact),,) for(sutf.......j It the owner of the un
Iva 'MArkhtg' owam the use of »rakes, pmnn. or dargiuund fac,ln) does no, hwJ,a ,ix bnliltes in
wker Aeart) uknbfwble mnlctwb w xSloss IS., bdd lo, aanrd4tur With the'section
Gabon of undergrownd facdnhn,U, wccorda" woft the the owtw, of the undrrgruu,W tae,he) sh.,N ha,c the
Current In" a•Wk standard of the An,encaP puhlw right to went a.mpensaluu. hw cents MCm ced in V.
wwk.aawiali,M Mtrkuss shall Include WenbfwAbun \p.MdiPg IJ eats\11101 maNall I'll,kin (hJn FU t IN.,,,knit+ IPd,eabng lbt spA'I(K IYpa Of She undrrge<,und
laee)iH neea dal%prow ali in t ew v,tlon tram the......lwAn owner of undcrgro,o d f chiles is nor relined a,
tail) 'pet.as mete An rminWuJl, 4 stntr,hip•Iran tnduale the ptneme 'If es,s.ag wev,tt Ialerala IV IF,
cOoh h,rhkr,) bilivilo Cwryxatm., a ,4yt. A 14J a punrnlmes If the presnncY or distils sir we lalml,w
C,Mnt),w oily wWuunM w toxtrumentakly of A ,wit. App'hewn e,on the ate of the cna»lrutlhM prolac,ran
and its emplesm.agents,or legal repentn4liwe be driermr Not frum iht prtarnse of tuhr, vi bk (wh
t 11I 'N<AWnable actwrAC) means Wealwn *,thin tics, such as bulWMgs, manhole,, or meter and)unction
twee(-(QUI Itwhe, of the outside dimenauns .d D\nh Ni:" in or ,,it ...I to She consbuaam sic
side,U)an Ymrcrgr,wml tacdltY f•mttil1mv etvl,ati'mx Jrt exempt fron, the I'm tC•
IQ, 'l.tnkrgtewnd lwalil)' OVA" an) rich, twrwel rruimmentx for rwtihtatnM PoUw d M this wimi a.
Of geared bekw grauPd for use in wnneClkM wnb the If the tscivitw, whrk performing Par eatteant, d'.
stwAgc w Con •)AML of WAlm sewage,ewtrom, 1,;W Craven uiuktgrCwnd lAeiltllt, which ere nor Wrmnied,
phunl,or(Cletin,M c CotnmuIWAIKMs,eAblesn,on, rk,• the tacavelw 4bAll swat eacay.vmg In lht vKlml)of the
bK energ), petroleum product,, gas, pasty, vapor. faetluy and Ilnmedutcl) tad) the owner w oper,lw of
rl nil It k<It
F•eJ'
N I.aml%I All. Nrvvatte INwih..,lwpptrr, 19,126,916
.itch faedltic%,or the(me numb" locator uncr 119"A 10,122.IIMI I%eMpthn from "alkf MW ~kit* rc-
IA7{ 1 Oiirratert, for prefrrn o.nrn. Vn e,ca"ItnM of Ic„
Omit I.Ole Irhhc, In tcrto Jl depio IM prnalc mMI,MP
14,122.I40 1"drtgmuad hirpmo,i4aliflyd fn hill we mcletal proper;, shall be e%empt front the rcyrlrenvnl,
roatrarl--f%ra,alms dot of rraviamlik care-- of Rl'W 19.122.OW. If the e%covatlom n M•tnp Pe,.
1uiNn h 1. daaotes—Alluant., Onto. III Protect foorowd M the peru,n or In clnpiry c"of the per,,. whn
snit, (hit. mdr,atc in hod or co tract (Jacunvent, the own,m nccupte,the proper,on which the civa%atont I,
emmence of underground facilities km,wn h% the protect being perfumed 11997< 114 1 61
.net b,be kxatnl within the pmpwnl area of excava 19.123.n�6 f nJ prwdlka—TMk daalaM--
tan The following shall be deemed changed w differing
ute conditkMs. 1 siding reaMdie,hill of eckda I I) Am pcf%,m Abe t o
la) Am undtryp,wnd faolit% mil Identified n%required Inge, am provmom td ill,, chapter. and whWh t%,d;mam
by This chapter or other P".moo of law,and malts to d+oagc to undatpnwod faedttwn it cub"v1 la
(b) An urldcrprlwod WI.t% mil heated, a, mquorcd .r nvd prmehy of mr owner Tban,wle th,u,ami dollar,h,r
M TM,chaplet or other Pnromn ill inw, lot theprulanc1 each vI latt,ri Ali proolim metered in ouch action,
nwner or e%cavauw if the protect owocr or c%cavator 1, ,hall be dep,wand M the gtncAvol fool
akaa uttifn Ol Any escu mr who wlfally m mllmowJ, dam
12) Nil tac+valar ,haft u,t rcawnabk care In avod Apt, a fkld marked umtc,prownd fa tht% ,hall bar liable
damaging undcrprownd fac,htm. An exca,ahtr%hull hit Treble the noel, t ascnin In rcpin%c m A*fa"Infl%to
fa) Drkritow the prcsot location ill umkrpnwnd fa- the IJeddy In thx coin,m which an e%eavata fool,to
clidtes which hale bee"marked, orrdy known undcrpnwnd liedih owner, ,r the rem•
(Fit Plan the e%ca,atbn In Jvmd damage to nr mw numb" ko:ator ,crdce am dam:lge or the umkrp,wnd
ficdil) %hall be dclnwd wilful and itahcuws And ,hall
mtrr ootrfr nct with umlcrpround fncihbc,m mot mar be yNbKcl In IMNC damp" for cool, Incurred in rc
the a%enratom Area.and parting w rekxating the fanhis
(c)Pro ,u vnle ch support for underpnwol facddrA in I IT"to chapter dmx not Aft en an,cod remedfe,fin
and"at the atmtructwn area, in,ludmp during backfill peruatal'"iury or for pnoptrtt danulpe.Incindmp that in
aprrat .ins,IS may be rca„mably Ircce,%ar% far tin M„ amkrpmuhd White%, am dnc, Or,chapter create an%
Itclioat of,uch facililiea_ new civil Mot obc,for wch damage 11997 c I W{ 7
(IF If an undetprmtnd facthq n damaped and ouch
damage Is the consequence of the failure to fulfill on 19.122,MM Want of aMNkalkM MA arr6hlg tP
aMfpaliln under this chapter, The pane falling to per
form that obit alma %hall be liable for tiny damp 'lol�a' Tina me*Jt hot or'foe or l" V dci igwn ,d
g ,tt 'hWpact chapter may be walrcd for Inc n rave datgnalyd
hit\ cl9a,r in as C%C:IvalMn tYMiril'1 whw'h allcfapt, 10 pCN1mR by an Ynderghwtd facddy owner ,Ilk M,p1ti to
ARMIIr IMMbh,m"loco indrmmfrcathM to,hift the ,III or part in(that umkrgnvAnd faeiln% owner,loan u•
nammnk cori%epueaces of IleMlry, different from tin dcrgnwml fa,;Ihliev, I19R7 c lit 4 R 1
frmaliti of tins chapter IN agatn,l public policy and
u,ienfercwbk. Norhtnlpt in thl,chaplet irmtol,the par I9.122,9M 4%eobOy--19M c Idol. If an% pea.
lic,to an excavatien contract irtmt contracting with re lnnn of Ihi, w Ir 114 aplthcafnm to ant PcrxM in III
speel to The aihtcatton of rule fox changed ,r differing cum,tam< I, MW inrdlid. the remainder of the act or
vole erMdduMa the Appikaturan of the
(7) In an actho Moro hl under thn,Kti,M, the Ie Affected
114 to other Pawn% Ir clr
Y f P rumslamvF n mu af(ccled (19t7 l 117§91
raihflg Mr1Y n entitled ro eclumnhlr ;mvrnr,c fee,
1 Mot 144i Al
loops. KAU
19,122.0611 Oaoapr m wadtgrairad facMly--No- 1AIRII►SAlA;.1NSIMIN1 IONS ANDSU'PPLD:RS
filk+Ilan M t%caahr— -Rogan a relocation of faril- Of WINE ANTI%I%1 1 KVII I AGFY
4y 11) An excavator whn. tit -'A v,wr,c of r%cJ,J(hvw,
cottlacin or damagt•,An undcrgnwnd favdo%shall notify hctwm
lite utility owning or oloratmp,uch facihiy and the one to Nola Purpwe
Iwrober hKator ,cr,ll0 If the damage cause, A tmtr IY 12a0 10 Itek.l.w
m
IY plwalnw,
ge %cmmintun,the c%cavaur can INAW ,aeplwt,,iai the damage shall to I k..wh th,mkwww P,mInn,
ai,o alert the approprialr kcal Pubitc %ifely 46crlcil, IY llanv confiner, rnalwarA
and take all appvPriatl' ,lem to c(nurc The puhlk IY iv awl Alh.11',h., I..o,
vftiy No damagsd underground Fulfill, mat be lturrcd IY Ivan +ouwaoaft Ar r.vievir.own ar I.ww.a,:vrlan.,r
vid o I%"paired w relocated tY I vnat e„d acm%m lillYY,o x»hw
I4 I N eM likes,wk
12l the owner of the umkrgrtwrd facilitm,dAftl%F d rY 17n tit 411c�Ala1 I-A, lr9
,hall arrange For repine,M nkcattlM as wort a%m prac.
Ica a may permit Ike rxtA%Anne to do maroon rope, 19,12n.676 fhrpate. t 11 The kgnlatilrc ec„tin ic,
or Mkwati n at A mulaalh acceptable prpx 119R7 c 147 that NO uppocr, and whAmic doinbmnn of nmli
I y I tcvcrape, and wlltt ate Inlcm,wd M the goal „f bed
nit!to I fink It Kim—a It%
' INTER-OFFICE MEMO pp
DATE
FROM1ni:.
Rtt FAMW" MW STATICN
ATT7kl M IS A OOPY OF' IM Mn SICC PARTS US@0 70 R$PAIR MTATMj' V#M ..
CtWrR '"C DUO UP (""IT, AND Ctfr P3" M SMTI(N.
ra^- �r
NOLET ELECTRIC; INC. /ji11
P.O. Box 486 \��� yy ENVOACE
12020 S.E S?nA
BELLEVUE, WASHINGTON 98009 3674
a Phone 747.68W wn '-7
Contractota Lit.0244-01 NOLTE 12018A {..-J
CNATRBE of iifi/fI - mx TRACT O L%TI%
ATTM _
r�s N
c., ;'a. •p'�F }I'1lCE'`AM_ OINiT - -
- — _
1 _ — TOTAL OTHER
NiM, AalEa .
i w 1
rem. v
,
y _ nAvts p -
r — TOTAt AROR
TOTAL OTHER
y W IOTA, MATERIALS
n .,,fK Met1r011aealtt W �•r 1 r Mr tM.n W xeYRlf I y INTWK M�'., 1
�R WI t 1Ww yy ♦let At l'%'Eu /aff1 t
t t6r• Uitpweer fiif l4 tMe'lMexftw. Ti}74L• •��a My,
Q TAX
1-7L j �/Nil, t
TOTAL
DAMAGE CLAIM BILL rc+ vison a
P.O. Box 329 Renton WSW 980S7
' 235-2911
C1ty of Renton
200 Mlil Ave. So. N J
photon. Washington 98055 «ow 82307
39
1/30/86 KJ
Costs to repair that ware _°•__•'
= :�-rE'ea�atf`Avec 7t:£. an IEJ?3J
MATERIAL 1 43.80
LABOR 669.71
EQUIPMENT 58.13
TOTAL UAMACE CLAIM $371.64
FAINT. U.C.
��.-�1.�'.��_.r�....a.. .ram.-....�..-�• . .. uw. --. .....� ..��.�..r.r...�..r..r�w.s��.r..rr�
/ f1
ri
2
L
5
BEFORE THE 44ERICA4 MURMON &S"CiATION
6
S43REL14E CONSTRUCTION COMPANY )
7 ) NO. e5 E110 0111 96
end )
ARBITRATION BRIte Or
THE CITY OF RENTON } THE CITY OF RENT04
9 ,
,0
11
12 I. FACT%
,
4horeline Construation anntreoted with the Ctty j
to gen'on in inetell + eewar tine tlbha Duvall Avanie Va,th«xst.
The 1oh aaniistri of ex^tviting ant lsving eignteen hunt^ed
15
16 !1401) feet o• sever line. Nat long after Sho�oIt ,-
17 Construntion begin work it ran into ground Meter. Shorol1 n^
id brought in two (2) sxltli nueos to hindIr thn ground wtt+e
�9 The pu9Ds did not operate in a ^onststent basis, erner' -n^inx
20 i nuaber of ieahentoal itfftculttes. TherWter rein Ini snow
21 shut lOwn the lab fo^ <veryi weekt. 9n the 1tt.• the
22 aontreotor returned in the job, it brought out a lerq-, ^ w.mt
�3 but still hid problesls operating the pulp on it consistent
Mall.
24
Over the weekend of der,uiry ' end 9, the oontreotor vtt
25
26 Vinq to operate the largtr DOID t0 is to oueb dawn the wate-
27 tni hove the trench 9ewsterel for work on 4snday. However,
2E the generator railed over the weekend and thQ iitlh was
ARBITRATION BRIEF OF Inoawl,\I ue
THE CITY OF RENTO4 PAST
l,LM'1
pereitted to fill with water %gain on Sunday. The followinq
2
Monday most of the day was %Dent lewatering the lite%.
3
The contractor exoerienoe3 me^hanioat problees on
a
Decesbsr 13 and 14 and January S and S. The only real day of
5
consistent pueoing was January 9 and that one day solved the
6
water oroblee. If the weekeni pumping teal taken elect, even
7
the January 9 lowatering Weill have been unneeessa^v.
6
Early in the job, unlsrgrounl utilities were looatel.
9
One such utility ran from a power pole it right angles across
t0
, "It path of the oxeavation. This utility line was sastly
11
locatei because of the power pole, 4111tionally the
12
contrsctor's job for.aan was informal by a "itv Tn9n•,tor of
13
the crossing. The crossing is alsa shown the olann. Rather
14
•Aan hall iigginq this wall 00rtion 01' the ax^avat!ln, 'ha
i5
. .• ^actor usel Dower sJuipeent %ni hit and rtDp=i out the
16
electrical service. 'the 7tty was requtrel to rs0laoe the line
17
at i :est of Three Thousani "'terse 'iunlred Dollars !g3,tn?,011,
18
IT. ISSUES
19
1, Ts dswatering inti4entsl to the ex^_avatton for
20
installation ,r "w.r lines?
21
2, if the leweter'ing of the sew— litch Is oat
22
tneidental, can the contra-tor recover for lost tiee causel
23
orlsarily by intie.luste or inoperstivs equioean'?
24
1. Ts the oontraotor requiral to reimburse the S:tv
25
for daeags causel by 1t4:ginq up a known ele^tri^.al utility
26
line?
27
26
WA1wW a uuocc.rs
�RnTTR q'"*n4 49'cr ter anoa+en 41 u.
• _ eI�IM .�VeVCIM IY•.
KYr1
1
IIT. ADT41RITIES
2
/. Ts dewaterin� inct.lentsl to the axe�r�tton for
3 nsiisll'+tiiOn of sewer lineat-J"'
4 Shoreline Construetim and the City of Renton entered
5 into a written contract for the sewer project, which eontraet
6 is identified as C4OI77-95. As ! •rt of that contract is a
7 section entitled Supplemental Specifications and the first
8 paragraph of that section is entitled Standarc Soeeifications.
9 l dopy of that section is attachel hereto as Exhibit 1 . The
10 first paragraph thereof states:
11 "The Stardarl Soecifteittons for Road, 9rid-e and
4anicipal Construction preoarel by the Wishington
12 State Department of Trinsportstion and the
Washtngt.os State lhaotar of the 4martoin Public
13 Works 41so.istion 1154 editton shell be hereinafter
referrsi U ai the 'staniard aoecirtcattons• ant
14 sail soeciftestiona together with the laws of th4
State of Washington and the orlinai-i and chi-tt-
15 of t!ts City of Renton, so fir, as spcltcable, are
herebv inoluled in thew speetftr.rtona is though
16 quotel in their ertirsty and shall apply exceot as
amended or, suoerseiei by the special orovtsions
17 herein."
18 Then later ' n that saae section is inrl-ale the following note:
19 "41TE: The special and eloolem"ntil orovtsions
hereinafter contitned shall be in illitton to or
20 snail suosrseie provisions of that itandarl
specifi^atton in eonllict herewith."
21
The special orovtsions section of that contract
22
containel s section dealing with sanitary sewer tnstallatton,
23
a copy of that section is attached hereto as Exhibit 2, which
24
stat+dl:
25
"The unit price per ltnsar foot shall eonitttute
26 cosplete compensitton for all labor, material,
fittings, tools, and equi.psint neoessary for its
27 Installation: ineLiitnq axcavaticn, beldtnq,
bickfilling, pliiinq of Pipe, and mechaninatly
28
waaaa4 a Nuonc,f.a.
ARSITRATTON WET OP anor+n 41 taw
THE MY OF RENT04 - POE 3 ~a°'rc°ws>t..ro.awua
as+ro",wwaawro„asu
a+wY/a
tempinS the b+rkfill material. No further
2 compensation will be made."
3 The standard specification also include similar
a language in section 1-04.1 attached hereto as Exhibit I. That
t section states:
6 "The special provisions maV desr_ribe work that is
not covered by the specifications. The work shall
7 be performed in accordance with the spe^tal
provisions and in socordsnca with the
6 specifications Insofar as applicable. All costs
incurred in the oerformsnce of the work ahajbe
9 �1pn�e1iu���Y,- in the unit r c f r_th! work. Any work
tea in
by t e special provision but does
10 not hav! a unit orine shall. be considered
incidental to the construction, and all costs &hill
1t be includ!i in the unit oriess that are in the
contract." (emphasis added)
12
The standard specifications under section 7_17 entitled
13
Sanitary 5l we^s contains languag, requiring the contractor to
14
keep the exc av atiors+ free from water during construction. A
15
copy of that apeeifloetton is attached hereto as Exhibit 4,
16
That section states:
17 "The Contractor shall furnish, Instill, and opeate
18 all necessary equipment to keen excavations abov-
the roandRtion level Ore* from water during
19 construction, end >hall dawa er an spose of the
water so as not to cause injury to public or
20 orivate property or nuisance to the public. 4e
5h111 it all times hays available stiff to tent
21 pumping equipment in good working condition for all
!mergencies, including power outage, and shall have
22 available at all times competent workman for the
operation or the oumping equipment." (emphasis
23 added)
24 Later in that same section of the standard
25 specifications is 7-11,5(51 entitled Pa_ my !nt . A aoov of that
26 section is attached hereto as Exhibit 5. That section
27 requires Via,. oayment be ride for certain installations per
26
wanM1 a lwtow rs,
AXIBITRI1TP04 SAIEv :1v anaM+M"tur
THB CITY OF RENTON - P 0E 4 waw.rceaew
ae wn awwa.P^Mn
linear foot, in this case for PVr. lower pick per linear foot.
2
The section thereafter goes on to may:
3
"The unit contract price Der cubic v►rd for 'Trance
4 Excavation' shell be hull nomoenaation for all
excavation, removal t �w►Meer, bickfillinq, and all
5 other work -CM11 tsl EO the construction of the
sewer trench, and will be paid for as oroviiei in
6 Section 2-09 for Structure Excavation Class B.e
(emphasis added)
7
The contract and specifications specifically spell out
a
that the unit price per linker foot for this sever line was to
9
include complete compensation including dew►terint of the
10
excavation. As such any dewatering that was necessary on this
11
job is not a legitimate source or additioncl compensation.
12
? If the iewwtering of the sewer ditch is not
13 nc en ► can �'c'o-nEric�r;Zec"ove—r—tror
lost ties ,causer mar y or
to noperatCv� elu oment'f--'�
t5
Even if Shoreline Constru^_tion's claim is not incluied
16
in its per linger foot bid price for the sewer installation,
17
it still should not be allowed additional co%Dansstton beotuse
18
the majority of its claim was caueed by the failure of its own
19
equipment to properly operate. Shoreline Construction could
20
not keep its pumps operating on any continuous basis. 9e^44ne
21
the pumps were not operating the ditch filled with water.
22
9ecause the ditch filled with water no additional pine could
23
be level.
24
A reasonably prudent contractor would have been delayed
25
only aomentarlly by encountering this water flow. 4
26
reasonably prudent contract would have hooked up a
27
s,ttficiently steed and owttlnq pump and kept the ditch cloar
26
w OM a xtuocc.►e,
4RBITRATI04 BRIEF OF 4eww."1 k4e
THE CITY OF RENTON - PAGE 5 UM r ow a" to toi.w
swiss�,on ak,'
e14M+.
of water. Because Shoreline Construction did not have
2
adequate operational equipment on the job, it took nearly five
3
(5) days to complete the dewstering process that would have
4
taken a reasor.ably oruient contract little or no time.
5
Shoreline Construction, by not having adequats operating
6
equipment on the job violated the specirications of this job.
7
The supplemental specifications at section 1-04. 11, eopY of
B
which is attached as Exhibit 5, states as follows:
9
"The contractor alone shall at all times be
10 responsible for the a.iequaey, ef£tetencv, and
sufficiencV of his and his suhcontracto�ls olant
11 and equipment. The owner shall have the right to
make use of the contractor's plant and equipment in
12 the performance of any work on the site of the
work."
13
k similar provision was previously quoted rrom Exhibit 4
14
which statel:
15
"He shall at all times have available eirftetent
16 oumotnq equipment in good vorking nonditicn for all
emergen,^tes, including power outage, and shell have
17 available at all times competent workmen for the
operation of the pumpinq equipmant."
16
4s a good example, the ecitra^to• tried to install a six
19
inch pump over a weekend to dewater the tren^h. The pump
20
failed to operate over the weekend and the ^.ont.'a^tor was then
21
required on 4onliV to soend the entire day dewate-inq the
22
trench. earlier the contractor had attempted to use two
23
smaller pumas Ind neither of them operated on any eonelatent
24
basis. Rather than removing the water from th- trench through
25
oontinuous pumping, water was ♦flowed to aooumulate in the
26
ditch and therefore, prevent pipe laying. The aontrantor•s
27
claim for extra compensation in this case is caused by its own
28
WARM a MUCCIC CC
4RRITR4TI34 RRTEF OF anawnaruw
THE C1TY OF RENTOY - P40E 5 Mw Wa,p+r- saso�Q%
aNW".e�10ft UM.
VM1
breach of the specifications and Ste Inability to have
2
operating equipment suf"cient for dew%te-inq available at the
3
job site. Once the six Inch pumo was operational and operated
a
on a consistent basis, the water problem was Quickly resolvai
5
and construction proceeded. The contractor is responsible for
6
Its own damages.
T
1. Is the contr_s�c_'_,_rre�utred to reimburse the
a City or +sale- caule� y ing up a nown
a eetriT utilit�lIrkP7
9
The contractor in its exeavatlon hit a City of Renton
t0
buried powsr line and dameged it. The ^,ttv had to expeni ove-
11
$1,300.00 to repair the line. Copies of the tnvoites are
12
%tt%ohed h-reto as Exhibit- 1 ani R.
13
The supolementtl sneeifiretions At section 1-57, 17
14
attschod hereto as Sxhibit 0 inform the contractor, is follows:
15
Ltostion tni dtasn%lons shown on the oltn* eo^
16 existing underground faetlitie3 %r" In accori%n^.e
with the best %vtil%ble infbrmttion with,+•
17 uncoverinq and measuring. The owner foes not
guarantee the site All location of exittinq
18 facilities.
19 It shall be the tontr%ctor`s responsiDilit� tt
contact all public and private co%o%ni%s having
20 utilities and/or facilities in the vicinity of the
construction %rat.
21
Call before you diq
22 The 48 Hour Locators
1-8�'1-4?V-4555
23
If, + n the prosecution of the worK, it Dethmes
24 ne^essiry to interroot extltihq surrtce dratntge,
sewers, underdrains, conduit, utilities. similar
25 undergreuni structures, or Darts thereof, the
tontrsttor shall be responsible for, %ni shall take
26 %ll necessary precautions to orote�t an! Drovtit.
temportry servioss for same,"
27
�t
28
*ARM%+UUMG.P.4
MITRATION SPI£F OF •1100"1114"""
THE CITY OF 46NTON - P1O£
NhtW.MUM\GI W Nt'
HYM'1
4dditionally, RN 19. 12?.030 requires the execution
2
contractor to obtain It marking of conflicting utilities and
3
states as follows:
4
"Excavators shall not exoavxte until all known
5 facilities have been esrked. ')nee marked by the
owner of the underground facility, the excavator to
6 responsible for matntatning the markings. . . ."
7 RCd 19.122.040(1 ) states:
"Project owners shall tndionte in bid or contract
doauaents the existence of undargrounf facilities
9 known by the project owner to be loaatei within the
proposed area of excavxtion.
tO
a e a
tt
(2) 4n excavator shall use reasonable care to
tp avoid damaging underground fa^ilitiee.
13 a a e
14 (3) If an underground facility is demagei and su^h
iamage is the oonsequenae of the railure to fulfill
15 an obligation under thin —hater, the party railing
to perform that obltgutton shall oe ltable for env
16 damages . Any clause in an excavatton contract
which utr,empts to all00%te liabilt.ty' or rhqutree
17 indemnification to shift the economic eonsequen xe
.r liability, different from the provisions of this
is chapter Is against public policy and unenforceable.
Nothing in tht" ^hapter prevents the narties to an
19 excavation cone act from iontr%oting wt.t.h resoect
to the allocation of risk for ehangad or differing
20 site conditions.
2t ;4) In any action brought under this section, the
prevailing party to entitled to reasonable
22 attorney's fees."
23 The location of the underground electrical wire was
24 shown on the plane ant pointed eat to the contractor by a City
25 Inapector.
26 The contractor not only violated the apsetfioet'.o^.s, it
27 violated the state lav by failing to use. 4dequute !are in its
28
xraww a e4uooc,►.A
4P9tTW104 ARIEe OF etl4auNaaruwx
TBE CITY OF RENT0N - F47E a wa>wtwa.reeaoaes
awls.,erexes"m amp
waeih
akoavating and by thereby daaaging the "ttv' s ucdergroun '
2
power wire.
3
IV. su"XRY
a
The dewatering operating for which the contractor is
5
seeking cospensition is Incidental and included in its orica.
6
Several contract spetifiaations make that statement.
7
Even if the dewatering wa, not incidental, the majority, if
8
not all of the *oats clalmed by the contractor were due to its
9
own inability to have operating and operational DUaoe of
10
adequate capacity on the job. 4 reasonable Drudent contractor
11
would havi been dslayed little, if at all, by encountering
12
this rater. Finally, the oontra^ter is resnonsible to tha
13
City of Renton for the cost of reoairinq the un4ergroun1
14
electrical cable that it hit and th• City's attorneys fees.
15
DkTE9: 4ay , lgR6.
t6
Respectfully submitted,
17
18
19 LIM541'z-7:11MER-
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
MMKIN a Uttocc.PX
ARBITRATION BRIEF OF .ndMnmu.
THE CITY OF RENTON - F43E 9 nwow wx c wr'
,»uo
CITY OF RENTOF
SPIN
A CDPY OF THESE SIANDANC S►ECIFIU•:OO IS Oh FILE IN THE OFFICE OF THE PUSLIC WORKS OIRECTOR. NUh'^.;PAL
EUILCIK. RENTOh, VASHINGTON 55055, WHERE THEY PAY RE ERAPIMM ANC WPIED r AM INTERESTEC PARTY,
WHERMP REFERENCE IS ODE IN THE STANDAM SPECIFICATIONS TC THE OWIEF ON STATE, SUCH REFERENCE SHALL SE
CONSTROC TO REM THE CITY OF RENTON. ANC WHERE REFERENCE IS MALE IC THE EMG:NEEF. SUC- REFERENCE SPA- WE
COMFtftV TO MEAN THE DIRECTON OF PUSLIC WORKS, CITY OF RENTON. 00 HIS DULY AUTHDRIEEC RAPRESEWTATIVE.
NDNDN.+.Mlbdg Aar gwu�'E
Alommomow RRF WFNEI>tp MR
STANDARD PLANS
THE STANDARD PLANS FOP ROIL ANC GRIM CONCTRCTION WY THE WASHINGTON 170E 0:+.TTNENT OF TMNSPORTATION ANC TIE
WASHINCTON STATE CPAMN OF THE AMERICA% rCIC NDRES ASSOCIATION IREv,OYDTASI ARE HERESY INCLIDED IN THESE
SPLCIFICAT:OK AS THOUGH OUOTED IN THEIR ENI!WN AIL` SMALL APPLY ENCEPT AS AMEND® ON SIEEIR a SY THE CITY OF
PEN'TOI, STAICARC FLAP: SOUK HEREIN.
A f " OF THESE STANCAM PLANS AND CI'.Y OF RENTON STAMMV PLANS 1S ON FILE IN TIE OFFICE OF THE PUASC WON.R
DIRECTOR, WUR:C:PAL R;ILCING, IE"S. VASHIkMON OEM. WHERE THEY WAY K EFAP NED ANC COP:m NY ANY INTERESTED
PAR",
"WINGS
NEACINSS TO PARTS, SECTIONS. FORMS, AFTICLES ANC EUMART:CLES ARE INSERTED FCP ;n Ma%:ENCE OR NEFEREMC'E CN.Y ANC
SHALL NOT AFFICI THE IMTt~ATIOM OF THE WhTRA7 DOCUPAWTS.
�MAL ANC SRlC1Al RNDV'E20K LTRIETtAE
THI NEW w MOSA&ZQN1 Ii..a M L W•, THE STANDARD SRWCTRTEATSWRS. WIIESS ,.Sfr..lE.
A NDENISIR 21MWIr ON A lA4lU%.AWl WSNY.AMINO, FNE/WWMIOROND HWMEEN APA NO KNACS. OF
P iRSi7FiGRiiWM•1+SISEND.--a" "0421E AM MA1DES -ANC2TEONAL gwaww' SHE
SNANAW1000-EERIER AM IOU GL AN ALDITiRI,TO.IA EIANNN WC:IFICAIIOMS PRIORI WHERE SKTIOS ARE MAKEC
'S1E4/NEW&414 E51R. TA SPEOEPAAW-•RK WAS"AdL I6 JA A SUSAUENT NO MO.STANDARD EPKWIL&IM S.
i- ti ljii I
CITY LF IENM
OUVA'..I An ME $EVER MIN
MT lllh 61 TO ME nor 61
$EVEP PFIGUfCT No. 6 - an
NIMAL PIOVISIOS
1-07.15 PROTECIIIW AM MESTORATION OF FROERTY ISWPLLEEMT-ALKCTIQ$j
PRIMIE PROPERTY WCk AS PLANIM, $1401$S, IKE$, FERQ6, AM LOQpRIFS WITHIN THE HULIC NIEaT-O-WAY $TWEE SF
REMOVED AM RESIOREC 70 THE SATISFACTION OF THE NOPEATY OFFER. IT SHALL SE TIE WITMCTOPS RESPONSIBILITY TO
NOTIFY EACH PROPERIY OFFER VFEM 11 16 MFCFSAPV TO MIRDVE SUCH INPROVEREMTS TO FACILITATE THE CONTRACTORS
PROMISE. ARE TO PFMOW TH06E INFROVEIENTS 10 LOCATIONS RRINASTED BY THE PRO^FfiTY -I4,EP OR TO AESTDPE THEN IN
THEIR ORIGINAL LOCATION IN AS MAP DPIGIML WNTITION AS FMII1LIYY.
qLH RENDVAI AM RESTORATION 6'WL SE WNSIDERF[ INCIDENTAL TO THE PPIOUECT AM NO FURIMEN CONPLNSATIOk HILL BE
ODE.
IR-02 Reyvel oT at runune spE_Q$yffucllens ISUPPLEFEHTAL SEClIgh
tiyvot an e+smosl of the .alstlrq onitoiy same+ Lift stoilan, ut *mil, an"! ".hot,, what be Canal doled
INC ldent•t to the pnol•cl and no adds t ionsl Pa YManl shall to yds.
RAJ-AL X4 HO16 ffALI TRAiM6MT
"M MYNENI II&ACEIEM BEC710h]
TIRE $10 111H 'ASPHALT SMOULDER TRATNENT", PEP SOWRE YARD SHALL MF FULL 0DWFHEATION FOR OIL MTMAL AND LLWP
PEOUIRED FOP SITWINWS SURFACE 7AAIAEM1 CLASS '$' APPLIED TO ROADWAY' SHOULDERS, AFC DRIVEVAY APPICACHES, AS
SHOWN OH THE PUNS OF WHERE DIRE ZIED by THE ENGINEEN.
Z-¢.L!•LIM U-S
Z-U.6 MYRENT it 'EQlC!!l
MHOVING APO PLLAYINt .NO CULVER16 WILL OF CONSIDERED •MCEDENIAL TO THE PROJECT AM NO FUPINEP WNPENSA110H
Fill BE FFOF
ML► CULVERT PIPE FOP MNtiA,ES IN THE DITCH $EC710W, AS SHOWN ON THE DETAIL SLUM HEREIN, WILL BE CONSIULRED
INCIDENTAL 10 THE BID MCI OF THE MOVIES. it$" ON BA" AND AD FIPTHEP WHINY SHALL BE WE,
L-11.P Voll"Ils ISUR'LEFEMAL UCTjQRj
P.V.C. el
P.V.C. ewer pips she confe n. to A.S,T.R. ODWA s.cept a .tne�+a p.n.+^•e. FNnp.� palest. for
P.V.C. pipe Mol, wNon to A.P.T.M. Dl$n.
f,ttlnps shell be of the N.• fite'lot end ctoo. as tns pip..
All e.co.won, plat inp of pips. end y"filtin$ 0.11 s. don. In otcnrdan .Rr &tot. Rt Osh,"$ton
hqt, 6tpnoe Ns for Can tructlon Work, p.rl C of the latest editlor.
Exhlk�l+ 2-
1-17.E GOINTINUEC • •
To Ineuro a note•tleht connects P bestoen P.Y.C. Vivo and can.reta Mhpj,as MuplliNg. or a nsbbor
rip corresponding to a awe, ,to shell be sod un Ups etheMiaa apacifidd.
NBOPIRSOMMOMMOSENN.
7-/7.611111 PIPE EDOING l6EPFU EMK SECTION)
PIP- 110116M1.9 notarial for PIK pipe Mall be pigs" to se Copt, of In be(.as the setts of the pspa no ul.nd tree
.p to S' "Pire crown d, ." pipes..
The hwM-plaeed bedding around the pipe and to a point 6' inch.. ebo.. cries, .resit be foot-taac" until is
in,"o-d mg. The remaining bec Efill shell be noshanl.sit, towed nth herd cM,etod eecha^Ke! or pneunot`c
tame-,. to on density.
7-17.31 BIA Gur.a. Line Pre brads IREPIACENM WHOM
OONSIALIC710N STARING SHALL BE PROVIDED By THE CDNTRA Feg GORVEVOA L PROVIDED IN SECTION 1-05.5171 OF THE
SUPLENEMAL FPFCIFICA110N5.
THE LASER IETHOO OF ESTABLISHING LINE ANC GRACE My BE USED AB SPECIFIED INSECTION i-05.5111 OF THE GUPLFMMAL
SPECIFICATIONS.
L17JALt 14,LQe bait Cn"Ktlong ISW'LEKNTAL SECTION)
TEES/STU&S
metalled Ishere shown on the plans ar es dlracted by tee Et Ihyb,.
TM bid price per path Too ShRl be c.eplete conpanNtlon for ell 111 Nl.ribll fitNngg end
ebulp. t ..empary for c.plgq ins[.lLNon.
The unit bid price par L.F. for 6' enoer pips .hail be topt.le c.pmpatlon G. •: t o",
noterlals, fitting. end esulm,rt necessary for ..pill. In Ptella one lnet"Ing aecerptlo,s &adding,
bac Nfill. placing Pipes reht.el end nptrecormnt of concrete cufoa. Butur., drl.omye. one, eldootN.
No tunnalinp andor ten cures.. putters, MCwa1N .r drl.wsyg bill be sltood.
SES11011 7-i7.5 PArNEM I6tFPLF1EMAL 6[I�IUN�
MyNEM FOR FIRE INSTALLED SHALL BE MADE ON THE FOLLONING BOSS"1LE OKYI
®MITION OF P1% 1NSf4yyED PERCEM OF STD PR3d
PIPE INSTALLED AM N`1 TESTED, 80.0%
PINE INSTALLED AND TESTED. 50.0S
PIPE INSTALLED. TESTED. TIE-INS
AN SERVICES INSTALLED AM CLEAN
LIP CONPLEIED. 100,01
1
r11 ?Rani{ (II M WM► 4I0►r a rim Wt*b taa
IAa !I'OPE. (4 111E WOIK nee,nrN MA M ndcmN b, ,,Caen.hangc wile, 1M .,.k.hall Iu perltpmed
11 aplµl.allle Yoil prOO and.1110n IA[+1M11111'In.
141AC1 kmane of CagO If lot I.npnwl doln,nlnn teal .ro) change for items's, d, C. 1. aM t abtwe
The muintt of tM Cualrxci d w prmolic a O.pk, 1- TA, ,"mracl.+• touai
pCrfumame of.n prrrrla uu( 1hrlwwl nalud ng umiungnd rlar\.tan ai�+x able
,hill lurnuh all labor. mauruh. loch, Wu,p,mm. In rap na1:.m. wTN1i+a, aM ad,mimeM •III bC mddt aM the ovJun O11141lod b)a.nutn Chan Z g(In
lit NO l" oar lih u to panpku all ll M µl.ark TM and..1M Ia,1 ,I glua..N r'
4 fYll Iw. Iw NI unit,and nuleruh ropatrcd h,(Way nnllditr tar.1p4 1)w ryan, a. I I ,41 .JI he be agrefrr,1h of the ryn.ea II 1M Damn
are unable to o, the Vapaar wd Jun m,l,e fM eytlna Wr adlwbrleM b) uv**
awdiakals of I Wrict DKVOON, pia Spacial Pfilabrw, Ynn w (.11 .cI,w b)Caabinhing the ,ub by Oahe,"am,Oar b)wing furce
r� daft" u.vYM,aW sap"lltf low a.k Uvn,.a1Nrc.,pr,al<
f M.,attract Iwm. plain. gleo.l pr"..aon,. .ph+lwal,"n+. addenda. and Mhn Ant W.It,lk I YMfµYw 1W adw,,at I mllinwAl 111 V)any dllKlpq,
NUrhlWn.IA,CT f A`tM ,'4clfrminanau Inuit Inc I' lacer alb,Phan a.han
mcMaf awumfM+arc all ec¢arul )Crib of a runrraei. am .. reywre' Aa Pr eg Yle
n,ng m .nm n M1Wpg a lhuugA mrura** m dl 7My arc ,Mrndal 10 M wdtr wdl It,ewhwW b) IM En+nra nimWni IMt IM(,xunae,u Dula auuCn
pkmenrarr sod niex.nbe a c,I Mc,r+w\ Aay wit\ ,,nuren,1 that Ma Ice,. nuwe ad prnleal av prwdad a\eel...0 I tia v
oma,N(n.n,the dewaphoa OF to,.,at but It ekarl)Implied snail W fur.vJ W h. lot Cunuxlor .hall nilwead .:: the .w\ .N. 111tlpI ni a change ,udrr
the(:wnractu x%though it had been sMe ildalb dated aW,.cd b) IM Ing,nar It udereal wall* M Ihf Fnpncer,the t,ntn.clw vMll
In cast OF day.rrpaMKf. Nara +ad gutern oy<r aI 1MatM) vupp:emala!
p(.wJ..Ili lM.ark nrtwe acmd hvvpl a1.d.ppnaN change,nder
gain.atusn.+halt g..ern ortr lan. tin
skftlAinwn. .rW .pec,al pit.dO,,. Mtl Chawit h, .heA arc 1 hall ly tasted ,ul MId Nake+ need wl M cv,dewN b)
gwem ann ,peer, Ikd and p4m lM tM plain w l 1.mg+,h1" dw.,vn ' .ubrn eh.age I ,er aM atoll br halt
a:alpha Me um,nine.ni n i nw w
aAdl p.em 1wa waled Jmrcmpw. In ua nt all amh,gun) Oar dnpum ,wa, <•+nran nnm iM(nmuchn.tall a.glwm laa wa\Iu IMf iMn.IN.m 1hf MW
'Awls .n of be pn.nuw 1J tM.wd,idu Ito dnp,an.A the Lwrelar) rdl h ua\f..ahou, mrthn nw,c,yr,kin
howl 101.1 I"..A -, sag ft~ ►) a►e (aswun:ear
Ito.! '!gec*M Paanafr-Cah W item )air 11101111104 accepn 1111 111111 and aWn„nl of • change "Net b,
TM ypea,ai prwupuu 1-1)deunbe.art that n Ma tpxleS M ihf VMd"A"un aad M ur.�=eat .d t change wde6 bi, aaepamc n ..ph is ,Ialr wm"tg. w h)
1M .wk +hail be pe,iwmN to ac,andlmr wlh Ito +iww ml �t a Iadu,r ,. prWal as Mov,drd ,n Ili,. .wn,m ♦., .natig, ank, aIIepitd by the
M
1.cwd+me .nh Ito .pn,Malnna m.aat a.apTNnaC t,mlraa hu ,tall M 1.11 alwtabk xdu+imeM hu 10) .,Oat eha**W w Iagmral by ('t7
,. d1C chang<urdar
Tice (.1...tw al*., ,vela. soy .,,den yr +cal under d,muam. n,n,u.Ipm,
n uk,peulron.w delennmahm Ina.Ito Vaginal,b) failure to r"r,i in prov,&4
WIN I l r Inn Woman,At
C ra 1
It r aunw dnagrcry .,Ili fM tarnu a cwwhhwu of 1 .tangc urdc. w S 7
�4 (Uneu alha ,,ten Of wal oNel,the(1W1.1tw+Mai
iM Slau (W. lnr ngM 10 Inaba eMftp. ,I the w.uk .µNIA 1M gfMlal I ImeaMµlel) sou ,Calal mdwv 10 the protow I**uee, .d niwfv befwe k
u,pe,d fail"Indl at an)bind dun**tM p"rea of the teal Ito CMngn 11Yy perfwmreg lbe.Oak.
tMlWle W I an Mn IIm,1ed 1. W.IMa IN caked.,dart of rrtetpt,d the larder,nic.,df a .C,Nen au<e,I
a kktI,.of an, pull. J IAe.,.it. pfwet
b a ulu•e w decra+e Juanf.t.m 1. WdWn .W ukMar tu). .e1 pewW.ng .nuen outwe Of pruet. pn.uk a
c ,:lunge In.00..6uhan,And w dcagm. .nucn ueteatCM.phdy.ag iM wara.t p,uupm.prwNug nnµkRKM an
d. tail McthM or manta,Of pfrfw,MMf,d Ina M1rY. hkma c Of the Mutate,C."M Ad A.),.d an)1ktm,sad en etpMlC ad the
< xddaw at An) nr..V6. a W,tw„ut„me Id an,I uw.nvd And
f St1te4u,..kd fq,hlw,ca.ipmCld.rutcmk.WI II ,w van.., a Knipe hall pi,im l aM the UYHfa<l,p,Uypk a.:tittle M.W"M of IM"IWI
g dtrcctrng a krahan w delay,n 1'4 perfum.,we ad 1M.wk iOtrum ttcra load.+.r04oinaA)
C tang"sill M.1 torn m a umla change urda mqd as prmllkd Mrcm M two.(an".'" luwex+a .Aangr wJ<, .0 wMv woes.n oral u t", AM
lkkted iiii.µem'i 1AK..III be pad fiat at pwrdfd m Shl.una 1 1/9\•N lu,lt..I a .Hall kpcp 4.0 and<.u.pkx mpd>ul 1M .al+ aid addiloanal tone
04, Ynwicd fM(unnta.dw+Mai pfrnnt the !'µ.net( to tale x.e+.W tta.e ,hard+
Ix,aud w decra.N 4..nn,,v le.-W lAnr m al " prrienl Of,M sad an) wMr mpd+ tM tAp~ datiau Mwc.sar) W .."I m natwlmg it,
wgtaal wntacl u d a mapn des+ .ill be p.W fw a, pn.,dcd,n Shywn toes {inns,
tJlgnraM w uedam",d 21,penaw w WM of the Original foMrn w.0 a Inaf.n a.:pnunb rall M<..IwIN 4y toe I**1Mer li tM Fng,nee,hM+,M prueei W
14
MS/laRl sI M1Ys —'__—_
. 4n All maMu CA.nd rpher alms....connerlN m llt
D,tm Ir:P•uhk a mwrmum u! I
1h<uu.,,l„m 'M'M farm«n Ihev
wrlAac..nAl J-he
.Wc>.r 11i mtler4l a yylA1 corm I«M'hb And Pllrl sells ZM lu he bfMA shall Af
Mrrel,x11Auy1 Aa.J
afe 4 uaN In G d t,hr
MII W t Inarmah 1 su." rht Iue W the •t.qe .> AI B<'I Auk>,AAl, nP,'Pe run 91 �..nl.W
P l0 bra w bell, M1
Np< .J IAe verKA Ir sW II k+s, Ip leer + u rryuveA low aaacp xlyn used..In<ndkJmenl na 1mJ
of I.on1nt be Mkd m .mR n<I as udl frmr ID[ "A% JWYrbed b c^,urc umlwm orlarclr I
«e W Nbl. ,ry 1, a man rays+ neMA Y MP rMxcmenl > Iqur1 ahn 1
u lrnr nne.nn Fr. aca<s> « and Pwnlun shall he m.Jr • mrwYwnl 'a4r' loh,kj A,� sAall be r<.•n,WWv by rem.x al u(Juurnp W Ae M.b.".1
m<m.. AlW 1 M+U br Pr, ." ,,all Arc A 1'v mvpu:p b.rM. ! Pwrdc.dealmtc AteJ PuN ur An Ynh mw<nlrnl I,(.
u.Wun. «rana< ,Atli be k,e to cm Nr fr« .Jbnla x.v .rW '••manh•dc..n ur her arualh`WI Ing>-Mllol At ur[.N let o I MI AI..re>h+II be
v we,x.Imo,om. nnv W N.v rn allrr m 1[u11M •r t"Al"I nil l amugrdalnan el ''•to a-.d roanMa aM ad f n e A, p w,beano 1 A Hrem
< .� ]•i].]ItI X All 4 e.aP'uhN m the rea.ry 1 hew
n0«YN MI YftplYrr LQyAltMmtm m A... liYklp Aar ar P* 11.rWaM%.m
(11i ara1M AY<Irr1 LWrY<I Wn aM _
rY1a11114M MM, rn MYblli.M Paa. ),I]'y hY1NY AaYr w ("Al,
'SAWrYrYW 1WIKte: SYr y bet And grade rrnn:J x
rrl�nrYRt�,,, naruN<M Y4A ell D..
peal The /'arurMWrtMed Mbar«, PI""NtN bs the I npm«r In a maala:
1 < ° 6<r.rrrKW b thAB C." h
ahwt,reM aA.L M'YWe ull m+lenal> y, f neap of nr +nd It Ade rn An 1u n1d Imrnala of a taut pr+d< hire au to the JnrA .Acre Ik. ,hab
Iu Pw.Jr WIC Aor�x«I Ib[ mu1. euaunp P°Pcn, uhlnlryu�Pm[^I Ma<.•us 1„ aI An h rYy thore Ih+n M 1«I M1w Pp rlcd rn nrmll .rr rap a•NWrIIup in 1 P.rrntn <,, AMI ma (q ka IAan the b+ller bavlda A
'MY.a.rllbrMlNM of ahwm IreMh f h</.NolaYlr In" cka t e du MN h +pta sAAll be..nN.ml,cbtc\ «brl r
N AlW rn the
I r brY1Ja aArlluaa'
je 'Aer X-M Ywrbreal. lunnclmp, Io".1 Jubn I ua aI<YP',�awA shall he emus went
mtlbud ul aar.nild:,Anp 1At sat\..nualcnl At
A p rcn`'A aAtW. `"uu rttrtdtd la•fwr ale+fell tluPite'J.III,I n r 1Af bltlfr bu,rJ.
ledeul vIrIY yadH
Shoeing 1n PNn+bk AKaI,,4t<. IAr.nucn+r"t-AI At rwlnG; wth he p rtv n,.:LN
leas Inn•uN of mwrable Ire lnX.,ea •wA Ans "'yet Pro. Ant,
Shoeing tlh
Y'dure
� MP Jumel<n a Mh tAldJa,< Moo. ,A+II be A...:..n )'1)..Mtl1 I.ya
,ntW. :e bn ru-ndA be,,.. Ihr Irum lkoblr 14M d the Game. of IN ano.,._s A(Ier an low
rttanurlWAbn top r, the Pere. unity ru.urn.bl/ bin grade Imr ha. been aN+bluhN. the y
un 4 Je Y tAr Itdd'np w We sYPPuI m.Ieu+l dulurbed Ib/1,,,Tsang rr+r wa1 da'xalartl I«MA ,h(�mul h. the ehlADiuhN hn[ low •h,ll be La, Y4hm
mrnuraAm
llalnapet reluhmp Inm .m Mlyter ahIo" Ihr Pi, :and WI An At aIII'pI"`rl..,nd wAer lute, n And XrAJ< n oh, PolAfy,
rfaPnv MLp ul IAr I rnir.<1•v X •u lulurr Iu.My< +ball be theAll PPe lAW lwnnp.m Lh c, 6 ..caul r,A'he YrP wrl d T•All INlyti boo hJe m the tremh lu IAc
iaAe hkr. nrut>tann styli be rem I'npllwApl a'an+Mb+Kn Ynlil 1 >Pnlbed hoc AN.karan.e under,.14 PNlntr d Iht ,u prmxk A m,mmurn W v P.M i.e yata w be b icAAll ha>b«n r.m AraJf .h+11 Oe JAM In '�M ben .flee ......On Mit a Ile he aMB er 1?rftp m Jwm.n. a cable Math to.At
I'My, hxl..n n p ro the IwrMtanorl k Ise uyN ru xm.A or Ana I,AA"of th' _u n.unabic A ,cl, no- .:,.Ila ul rtnomrnp :h<Mra..I. MAW the PPrnad. Jelnmrrt<I M IAe F m m[ "r hnr MP'n M.t< All MPA,Ah.11 ,Yrt/AARK. —9
un4nyN I.I sucA.dduNNla1 dceth n nu. It 'Mlileer «.+<alrun Arid peas'",m IAr 4!aW br rynlwm 1.r
hwyda bw maleru4 tyll br J IoIYuN As the[In `ball he 'Ar Sfxljn.ny shall be lalp lu A Plana,wnhm the Ilmu+IA+' 6dl01 -�Pnw t" mamlklxn W 'aPKN W♦1+ +PMwN Nm pincer ltn,uu.hk Iruf bet AM r
pr.dr .• ,dhal bedlnp And MP'nlhe 11my, bwhn: shall naauer.ImllAn It wll c.se'AW lxa PPr,(,Inp MPr At
Ir4 raua'he r PR IMt X(
D, I.en N flit tY teaf.imp Immolt be br."At Iver, I.
Ihr IIp 1 IY�POY1e r.wrw.l.n matrn.l. w A/n,n Ace<nXIhrMW +, nne>uts 1,j h tnpel Arc Y amf 1�
.nd Xud< udAln the hmN*+1eJe III
m.en hoe a'IA end, hIA IAa
E Ineer, a lwtndu means umG.mn rA "nJ•Nnr..Nn Aeran lu de.fArP nsAY .aIY (rwn tAr n1- h
potolIon run•aNW, w W;pz n 1 p-ti.d MMmI un+lwmu nr
' ` It MR rn IN PnlPr c.<rt.AyN1Ip rl4rr, ThIc 1 ^X^u,<rraf MtsadN.u,A y.nAMe d wK i/. A W
].1).AIIR Pip y�yy +^ AI the brae ul bac\hfl
v W�� .
^rYc b/r.kukl (Asa I A„'he
uwb Orn, tl of IAc AMIC meinot eeoull on.
n<Budd,ap ,J 1br A.k clh It.uurr vwrcm[m•.n 1 I k.a
A".xuwnt, MII bt lo. a'ta>luwn sn 11, ei"iAl`ur Jean nP',unless wAA'"A uP of Ihr lth t P P Y be
•A911 nul esar<J l001
.d he
led M arwud.rwr ur,h The S,.ed.rd Pla.,h,n m 11 "'e .0 Yf<•nn«nun ", " b.the!n R PI
IA,
lrry4 A'"mNA aahm the h.e W 'he t' Jok The nn Ihr uunn - pr'u'tr.AAA ll It IaW rpp
PWI> 1. .. nJ,IylI.Mk.k Auer PP M+il 4 rnalaheJ u11h X +e.11 w from uNJealpna "pAg ride
!.(aWlnp.lass u aMan(or rI Mpr.uM as.h,w,n m the.SlarW.rd If no
•"ni n Mn n the hil a IN 1 14 h, pip
IriAI'nl rka.u.hoe pod P(iIA iIas B R.Ah P .JA PCmN.r rlu u+rd cmt W ,�P'Pr .hall 4P\Ilertde lAhen wld
n foe peubk PPe.(.lau ! N>Aall Ae P: ,:d +n apPwcd t he BYddrYp W uA+leyfr .lass sh.11 beWinp>MII IS 4w, h\Arre MPcirnea arc lu be la M nph11Y el.y.d MuyWe unll.um >uppwt ahwrp he<nlve MP wflnl IAc MPr,num.rn an Amy n1,n sRa1hN cocas.
i4 :urvr> tAAli hr p AAW 1Aan rnanl e,:AJclb Au Well, ahw, radrua W
348 arhaered "oh A arts .,, tanpem ndNh.rP Il+�rn 1m~mrer,
Aepda.
149
17
-- _. _.. . H,VRAt1 SyTVFILt
'Nall M Innn l�w;U pry yr<am, tMn tM Ax<ra ye bey\phx+uh aMns rbe cower
of be ppt,and the m:emum lame abail tr tru<that v wd ax xpec,hd under 7'1T.3 Payaeawe
Snuam 1.11 liAlU. naxmtm roll N.n N.k(nr.wh of,bc lo6.w,my had dam,ar,,r-Irwiodtd m 1
7-i`.](YIF' OMar TM Abwawrea Pro lk-1,and peymtnl wol be made undo. M
All We'll of %a,wa„r bow Ma mclrulN m thr IV,(r:I'.'I'll br,Aker on., i .4wCuRopIt(Rr A t' Stier PIP- Inch ilun,', W,Lre,,r flag
atcuohl m wmpmmy aI",bk ke\gt An t"A",t or o l aihm, I boor � Roni-rcd 1."I,4rc, Hp; imh Man'' per imur too,
Y PI icr 'Axfana,u('<rntnt Scut,hpe In Olam ('tau pv hMar fwl
(law.' Mad l"' Imam .haft be malt fur vch m141 aal, And m ti tort hall 'Ir St al Sewn h tyrm hMi d Irm d,il ul the +wi all yen „ aqr woven and ntu M In 'Sw\ In n.,n,
nga hall In .Per Imtu IqN
uPea.clan,rd ira dgm'nR n 'hucok hon Serer P
1.17„lean. I 'Ap1("url,pawa,<.rtw PI In Ikam' Ptr LM., hn,i
Plryyny t-aWaag fewer 1'IP, p In Uwm^fall$,"ar loon
h 'moos Sew,P,pe.'per haca,hha
W nUi .horn m d Plea or a nt.k.,Rra u, I the to ,,, Alf be v
u1a!(be t ! - 'TrtmA�f-.a+atnMu p..r.ubr.xard
a playRed un rM rnki end roh flan x ,.,,,rate Purr half 4 uwd,n i y` i
Nnrny+h<ow' hte rn,M wrtr to a+t ehA1 the+,p•.:n.rti the pPc ra ttuupka.y I ` �'�n Te7a M/1a
Mkd aryl,bw,ayly Mugged "'�k rYY., bmav"U1R
"A7310I IkMttw Tea la Fkadk Pyrt Oft Pea aimmoksm"k"I et 7 "elYallM.
All aw,tarl rnw<rr.onrlru.led or fka,W,: type rh..il be Irxted for d fk,iam wn rc IM om er< pr, irnc.l r,aa for
kxr than 4r dap after the thneh baahll alai Cungclroa hAr been canlpind .loo I • 1111wmxuhon ha all talk n nwluwi awl 'Icrt,nR krr, Plpe" .half be lull
d.Amcltr,.: the ,eA1.1w plc.hull nut he,dw"od bx , c than t pen<m 74, Icr,,rxyvod rn Berton ! I. 441
ryu'pmrm rchuud br..mdun the lea\text shall be,otnf.ted bf paibnY A mawlrelahroogb the. npkhd +Yt
pKlrter le,
( 1 ,�LlrMar7a7M Bet a.paRR(,•latwwnnitb.((IRM ytRRR
,hail be ranaurid un, m+nb•dt lo-nwnAWe 6Aur alld aM:l be d.wx after Ibt het I r
Me ban"I lo" ry 11u.hM ur1 rah rater TM famlra1,or N I M reymrd, I he r rtnlal�I��ee A�l R
,,playa.w I.r A+< ad ,,parr aay wntau,a le,hn to r r d�dlW dNia aarMe}Iarlrrtnt,t(IR,j♦Mg Qt��t rtiban h 1 F iwer the ^P and hI r@trt rM
R sRt<mwyA In r,wl oaaade df may 4 anap<d we tM Wxu of drrt.I i '(1u-rrat(W+r C"Ahall br
n,4wrcn,em � Mrd hu as ap-i,M1td,0 1e.oon n.tq e y.
7.17.144 IakxtNaw Imprawn
TM I ng Mar m,ry a1 h".opam rcyuoe uu,u Ali ,arowv rarer hla< Ile ma{ra td
b7 tM are .d . rele"ton.Amara tlimt MAI A,,tAOU ue TM:.w1* meal,.,! rn
rnAlmy IN rmtWl o.aph'Ihul xhall I but.III rM uu ar o1 the wnnarl It.,
I he t oentaclor Mail bey,All w aw:urr<d,a wrrabny An, ktKw aor,haow
dunnR ukromn olrlrctr,n orirdrny the.mo of Any Alwohmal Wc,l,aln myraeeam
:hat m.I be(.".,d by Ibe knRmeer Io wsly the anal"I at W w,d dth,.MI
Ibe t\aarrg w Mall be hApunuble tar At coal, retuned In Any tak,ww
nqp ,on per ..rod u}ely fm 11e beMhl of the co.uratror
7-0.4 A(f1lMrawll�
pM onRrh of xrer,ui+t rdi 41M number of Irarar(ttI W uhnpkld,mtalba,.
matured crony the ,melt Arad wdl ImWda IM knyth throogh ahoy%, tax and
map The rwmbtr of hnear feel oll 4 W.,urcd I,,"Ike fewer of anardone w
c<nr<r.J manMdr Ar I.the loud,IAec of latch twum And„radar type m,rcir,<,
TM.umr<1c<War( (ur puRymy exru.ny xtrtr prpex.,It be mwawted by thr
,ubr, wrdx 104¢1,d A,+penbed or Sntum'0:A
The length of ieamg u., P.P. In e,url.umAnce w,rh Setl,.wl ' 17 )14l u41 be
the r%onte,of ontat far, wmphld lmlal/ataw A,k.,Qy loud
tauaA,am o,f the xrcr«ew.h will be"'caw led,be AAme u mfulture tacaaalam,
CWaa b,b)the cubic yard Aa ap>.hd or Sttlh,a
l5A
15G
� E CONTIISA3
ALL DIFIIDTION6 O RE.ZVO1.1D HOLIDAYS 10 T1i STANDARD SPECIFICATIONS 'E DELETED AD ECU. RELOBNIM HOLIDAYS
NMLL E AC FOLLDBS:
In YLAA'S "I. LIICOL.N'S BIRTHDAY, SANOMSTON'S OPTDAV. IODRIAL DAY. ,MLY A, LAMA DAY, VETERANS
DAY. TWALOGIVING AD THE DAY FOUABING. AND CMPJVT%AA EYE AND CHAIM" DAY. TE DAY BSDRE
QAISTMAS SHALL E A HOLIDAY DSM, CHRISTMAS DAY OCCURri ON A TMDAV OR FRIDAY. THE DAY AFTER
-�AISiMAS SMALL E A HOLIDAY ST[N CHNISTRS6 DAY OCCURS ON A MORAY. VEDEDAY. OR TNRDAY. WHEN
COU611ME DAY OCCURS ON A BATUHOAV, TIC TO PECDING WORKING D416 SMALL E CO FIND AS HOLIDAYS,
UEM 04XSTMS DAY OCCURS ON A RMDAI'. THE TO DWING DAYS FOL.l.OR1NG SHALE OBERVED AS HOLIDAYS.
TE CONTRACTOR IS EXPECTED TO DILIGENTLY PRDECUTE THE BOND TO COMPLETION IN ALL PARIS AMC EQUIREKEM'S. THE
PROJECT IMLL E COMPLETED PITMIN TE TERM NOT® IRA TE CALL FOR BIDS, PROVIDED, HONEVER, THAT THE LITT SHALL
HAVE THE RISKY UPON REOIEST OF TE PUBLIC OWS DEPARTMENT, CITY OF RENTON, BA, TO DFTEIC Tot TIME OF COWE710M
U SAID DNS, D WENSION SHALL E WJ1D UNLESS THE GAPE E IN DRITIHO AMC ACCOMPANIED h THE WRITTEN CONSENT
TO NFM VYINSION R THE WIT ON THE DD OF THE CONTRACTOR. TIE LOST 1N WLACING IMPROPER OW DP
MATERIAL SHALL HOT FURNISH AM GROUNDS TO THE CONTRACTOR FOP CLAIMING AM INTENSION U TIME FOP THE COMPLETION
OF THE OW. AM SHELL ACT RELEASE THE CONTRACTOR FROM DAMAGE OP LIABILITIES FOR FAILURE TC COMPLETE Tot OA
BITMIN Tit TIE REQUIRED.
"B.B UOLICATET DAMAGES [ADDITIONAL SECTION)
TE LIQUIDATED DAMES DO HOT INCLUDE. AND ARE IN ADDITION TO, DAMAGE$ FROM COSTS FOR INSPECTIDN, piEF•:F:in,
LEGAL EXPENSE, AMC COURT COSTS INCUPREC BEYOND CON'TRAT COMPLETION DATE. TE COST OF ADDITIONAL IMSPLZ'::n AN
SUPERNISION SHALL E AM MOUNT EQUAL TO ACTUAL SALAMI COST PLUS IOC PERCENT FOP OVER".
I-06.11 OVERTIME OR P OMEF HT' '--;F 1ADDITINLAL 6ELTIONJ
MEN THE CONTRATTOF PERFORMS COW1.._.,ION OW OVER THE ACCERH S MOM PEP DAY OR AO HOURS PEP DEER, OR ON AM
CITY HOLIDAY, ANC TE OR REMPIS INSPECTION, TEN TE CONTAECTOF SMALL REIMBURSE THE CITY AT THE RATE OF FSO
PEP HOUR, THE CITY SMALL HAVE TE SOLF ALTHOP:TY IN DETEWINING TE NECESSITY OF HAV:MG TE OVERTIME
INSPECTION, AMC SMALL NICIVV THE CONTRACTOR OF 176 INTENT TO EOUIRE SA:C INSPECTION. GA:C COSTS N:LL BE
DDUCTD FROM MONIES DUE TE CDNTMCIM OM SACK MUNTMLV MIMIC.
"S.11 WNTRAMP'S PLA19 A!P, EQUIPMENT IEPLACEEN: SEC-ION!
T t AIM ENE
,. I1r '#'AYNITCMSHS! 9 ♦RANT
he
TKE. USE B1 TE DBNIF O SUCM PANT AMC EOU:PWKT AMA- E COEICEREL AS EXTRA OR. AND PAID FDA ACCORDINGLY.
EITEP THE ONNEF NOR THE ENC:NEIF ASSURE ANY "DNSIEILITY. AT ANY TIE, FOP THE ECUPITI OF THE SITE FROM TE
TIME CONTRACTOR'S OPEMTIOME HAVE COMMENCED UNTIL FINAL ACCEFIANCE OF THE OW V Tot ENG:EER AMC THE OMEA.
TE CONTRACTOR SMALL EMPLOY SLCN MEASURES AS ADDITIONAL FENCING. BARRICADES. AMC %%TCMEN SERVICE, AS E DEEMS
0=01ARY FOP TE PUNLIC LAFET AMC FOR TE PROTECTION O THE SITE AND HIS PLANT AMC EOLIPENT, TKE OPEN HILL
E PRDVIDD %EYE FOR ALL FENCED. CECiRE AREAF.
L- x h164 (o
N'w DAMAGE CLAIM L 11w11.0n co.. •
P.0. Box 329 Renton wµ" 98057
r 235-2911
city of Renton
200 MR11 Ave. So.
Ilanton, Washington 98055 mop 30-38928
1230739
1130/86 Kd
Costs to repair uAdergreuld'fatfllties that were
1M11TERIAL 1 43.80
1ABOR 069.71
E IOU PMENT 58.13 --- —
TOTAL DAMAGE CLAIM $371.64
(MINT. U.G.
a.n Boa
Ex I� , h1 + 1
NOLET ELECTRIC; INC.
P.O. box .as JL INVOICE
12020 S E. 32no
BELLEVUE,WASHINGTON 98M 3674 ,
PROM 7474%W
" Contractors Lic.8244-01 NOLTE 1201BA --
YOI..M.F tY%W[OiP M.
CHARGE C—//!/Oj �.EiTOIti �• Av WOR oNTRACT OE[tgA
.. 7c S
tn't�n GdA 9POSr' ,� 4.—.L-"
ATTN: --_--
_,.3'i. :o: -, ,MATERU1l'�=�a ,;'•..'}L PRICE AMOUNT. ' _:-:__'...; SCR ON _W011K" `c._:,x':5
.. . .. _.
— --__0E_ �-F
TOTAL OTHER
-- _ —,,.a�51tiG — 5;..�..wtawa 6571"r:.,:. HRs: RATN •AM . ;E T ..
-- TOTAL LABOR "
TOTAL OTHER •`"
CIIN . TOTAL MATERIALS
ESN•^ t.. .--1 ypna Y171E tS .�
i 1NE"moo ll Ct 0<Tr yp %114# nXs k �,•.
rW YT 0[ft Ws 1� [8'SA1614TdXU .. _ -- __ -_.
RAR [ M m bMY MTEXEEIMDp HX —�. 1pT4L'
' l t uD EwT1pRyTI[El N1F[tWNl n,••t
[ TAX
TOTAL Opp
�-1S ODRTIIMLQ
C. SASEI[M6 - OLLTIVATR ARMM AK OTHER SLPFACE ALL CULT:WTSD ARIAS. EITHER AEIICULTVMA 09
LOOPS. AND OTHER SURFACE IWWVFAVTL VNION APE DAHAGIL n ACTIONS E THE CONTRACTOR SMLL E RISTOW AS WAAL'
AS POSSIBLE TO THEIR COUGIML CONDITION.
PRIDE TC 04AVATI001 0% AN EASEMENT OP PRIVATE RIPET-OFylr, THE CEM%LrYOR SNKLL STRIP TOP SOIL FROr THE TREK,
ON CONSTRICTION AREA AMC STOO.FILI 17 IN SIGN A MANIA THAT 1T MT SE REPLACED F HIM. VON COiLET/0P OF
CONSTRICTION. O INAHENTAL TREES AND SKESSEW SM.I E CAMLILIV REHCM6 VITA THE SARAN SUMCLOCTNS 7410 POCT6
WAPNED IRA BUOAP Alt REPLANTED IA TWIP ORIGINAL POSITIONS WITHIN AB HOURS. ALL WOUBSERN OR TRIES DESTRCYI.
OR OAMEO. SHILL SE REPLACE r THE CONTRACTOR MEN PRIMAL EF EQUAL SAUTE AT EO ADDITIOAL COST TO THE
OVER. 10 TIE FVW THAT Il 15 NECESSARY TC TRENCH THOM" ANY LARN AREA. THE SOD SHALL SE CAREFULLY MR AND
POLLS ANC REFLACB AFTER THE TENCHES HAVE SEEN MCKFILLS. TEE LANK AREA SHILL SE CLEANED W @REE➢ING OR
OTHER REANS, OF ALL EAPTN AEC DEBRIS.
of COMTMCTOP SHALL US RIMEP WEEL FEIIPPENi SINCLAP TO THE SHALL TM.?CST-TYPE 8ALPHO6 USQ ET SIDE SEWN
COHRPACTDRS POP ALL pR. 1NCLLDINK OCAWTION AND SAPFILLN ON EASWI -5 OR PICOTS-*f NAY WEICH PAVE LAM
AREAS. ALL EMIG. MAKING. MIL SORES, OR OTHER TOiOMM OSETACLE6 SHALL SE RINUVFD V, TIE CONTIACTDP ARE
INPOIATELY REPLACED, AFTER THE TRENCH IS SACKFILLS, IN THEIR ORIGINAL POSITION. THE CONTRACTOR SELL NOTIFY
THE DEEPER AND ERNOPEATV OREA AT LEAST SA HOURS IN ADWHCE O AW AR DONE ON EASEMENTS OR RU6MS-• '.
DAME TO FXI971MG FTOXTURES ORS:DE O EASfHENT ARIAS TMT MY PESULT FPO DEVATERIMG AND/OP OTHER
CONSTRUCTION ACTIYITT UNDER THIS COMA^. SHALL E RISTORIF TO THEIR ORIGINAL COKITION OR SETTER. THE OPIGIML
COMCITION SHALL E ESTABLISHED n PMTOOAPNS TAKEN Aft/DP INSPECTION MDE PRICA TG CONSTRUCTION. ALL LION WDR
6HALL E DOME TC THE SATISFACTION OF THE PIIOPE TT OEMRS AND THE OWNER AT THE EXPENSE O THE CWTRATOP.
C. MET$. TIE CONTRACTOR WILL ASSVIE ALL PESPN.MCSILITY OF MS70MTI0% OF THE SLPFACE OF ALL STnrS
ITIAVELLS WYE: NSED ST HIP IF DREADED.
IN THE EVENT THE CONTRACTOR DOES NOT NAY[ LAMP OR HATERIAL 1MMECIATELY AVAILAE.r TC RARE RICESSAW RIPAIRS.
THE CONTRACTOR SHALL SC INFOM THE DINNER. THE DINNER WILL RAPE THE NECESSAR` RIPA:RS AND THE COST IF SUCH
REPAIRS SHALL E PAID W THE COINALTOR,
1.07,17 U111L]TIES AND STMILAP FACILITIES IADI:TIDW. SE.^IW:,
lOM1NISPEIlNSSIEMRK bORI iA TEi PLANS FM EHIPILNS IPOEIVYAO PACTL.TTIES'AME h ALLOOAECE YET" TEE"BAST
AMASSAi�wyISEEWENM' '/ETNCIR IIICPVERTRK'YHC MEAEORINR. THE SIRlP DOE®MOT WMHIAMIE THE S'ft AK lOUTTON EF
MEwfANMQRtb.
IT SEEFRlT!!T!'f�'Yf'I"' A:1 P'IBIIC rED PFi"Il CiNWAA:E; HAN:N:: YiIu1:K AHQ'OF
FASSlRES1�'TYA MISS S wE TDHEMpI75HH"I
CALI 60RE YOU DIG
THE AS MR LLCATOS
IUD-426-1SY
aW'Nso-q ^PRSSl0011011 OF -THt Haw, IT SE'CEMEF MECESSAF TE ENRIWNIT VUSTINE 9ESy(:1 WIAINAE, so"
UVSHEPMNET'6MV T,I^`tLITIE6� SIMILAR LADCRGACM MODEMS, ON RAMS TIEMO, THE CONTNW-TOR 001 1, E
USIO 64410 MA NM SASE VIA&Ay S11016 AY PAW.406 70 MR016Ci W PROVERS TQP.MAAY WV.IIAE FOP fAME.
Exh. bRf q
of kA. • ,
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
DESIGN/UTILITY ENGINEERIN, 235 2631
� R MUNICIPAL BUILDING 200 Mlll AVE.110. RENTON,WASH.90055
u9 e
Qp
♦tto SEr1E0
BARBARA Y. SHINPOCH
MAYOR
MEMORANDUM
January 29, 1986
10: Richaro C. Houghton, Public Works Director
FROM: Davin Tibbot, Project Engineer
SUBJECT: Duvall Ave. N.E. Sewer CAG 007-85
Enclosed are copies of Shoreline Construction Company's request
for extra coml,ensation, on refusal, and Shorlines request for
arbitration.
Dose this matter now go to the Attorney or what?
attach:
DT:jw
SHORELINE CONSTRUCTION CO.
General Contractors
SN OR EC'374NO
I SSIS WaoPn,tlP$nonomiM Potl 3d&�81Lf4K
n J Pn.lsS Woannal4.Wnnryron MOtt
J_-,.Uar% .9EFi
City of Renton
Public Works Department
municipal Building
200 Mill Avenue South
Renton, WA 96055
Attn: D, G. Monaghan, P. E.
Re: S-381 Duvall Avenue N. E.
Sanitary Sewer
Subj: Changed Condition,
Ground Water
Gentlemen:
By way of a letter dated and hand delivered to you on
November 15, 1985, Shoreline Construction Co, notified the
City of Renton that Shoreline had encountered a pre-existing
subsurface ground water condition which was an unknown phystoV
condition that differed materially from those ordinarily
encountered and generally recognized as inhering in work in
the particular locale of this sewer line construction.
Ground water was first encountered during trenching on
November 13th, around Station 8+00. At first, it wax not
known how severe a problem it would become nor how far and
how long it would continue. After a day or so of pumping,
the flow of ground water into the trench excavation did not
diminish and caused Shoreline to believe that it had encountered
a significant volume of water: which, as it turned out, it had,
After almost two days of settinq up wells, pumps, generator,
etc, plus almost four days of slow and touch goinj to install
pipe: rather abruptly, the existing ground became impervious
around Station 10+70 and ground water was not encountered
again to the terminal Station 23+37, It can now be said that
about 230 lineal feet of this sewer line was in water and about
260 lineal feet was impacted by water.
The fact that this ground water condition was unknown and
not even suspected by this contractor; or for that matter, by
the City of Renton, can be attested to. Several other contractors
who had bid to the City on this project, when contacted recently
stated that they had not included any allowance for ground water
in their bid because there was no indication that water would
be encountered on this project.
This unexpected ground water condition was materially
different from what might ordinarily be encountered, considering
this particular locale. The fact that it was a large isolated
pocket further indicates that it was of an unusual nature, If
this pocket of around water had only extended a few Feet, it
would not have impacted the costs significantly, but it extended
some 260 feet and certainly impacted costs significantly.
Although this 260 feet amounts to 15% of that run of sewer, the
focus should be directed to the more significant issue that it
caused a substantial increase in cost. The entire run of sewer
along Duvall Ave, was estimated to take 11 crew days to install,
and it can now be said that it could have been constructed in no
more than 13 crew days if this unexpected ground water had not
Leer encountered. Due to this water, it took a total of 18 crew
days, which includes the 5+ days spent dealing with the water
and fighting through the 260 feet section affected by this water.
These 5+ days amounts to about 30% of the 18 crew days expended,
which is a significant percentage. In terms of the over-run,
which relates to cost, the 5.5 days spent through the ground
water area minus the 2 days that it could have been installed
in if water had not been encountered, divided by the 13 days
the total run could have been completed in, again assuming no
water amounts to 27%; which is a relatively high percentage for
any over-run.
Partly because of the foregoing which indicates that there
was a substantial increase in cost, but more importantly because
this ground water condition clearly falls unler the Changed
Cuudition clause of the contract, Shoreline Cons'-ruction Co.
requests the City of Renton give favorable cons..:eration to a
fair and equitable adjustment in payment to this contractor for
having performed the work. It can reasonably and logically he
argued that if the City of Renton had known about this existing
ground water condition prior to the bidding for this project
and had so informed the bidders, then the prices bid and the
cost to the City would have been accordingly higher. Since
this situation was a true "unknown" to both the City and to the
contractor, the appropriate price adjustment should properly
and necessarily be made now, after the fact.
For this writing, Shoreline will se- forth what it believes
to be the cost of labor and equipment to handle the ground water
encountered plus the difference in cost of labor and equipment
between what it actually turned out to be vs, what it could have
been if ground water had not been encountered. This should
represent the cost over-run attributable to this changed condition.
Crew Hours Cost of Cost of
Date Lost Labor Equipment
Nov. 13 2� Hrs. $ 374.65 $ 312.50
Nov. 14 4y Hrs. 674.37 562.50
Dec. 05 5� Hrs. 698.77 587.60
Dec. 06 7 Hrs. 889.35 875.00
Dec. 09 5� Hrs. 667.01 656.25
Dec. 1.0 3 Hrs. 371.30 375.00
950.00 Dewaterinq
Equipment
$3,675.45 $4,418.75
Plus 20% 735.09
$4,4.0.54 a 44,418.76- S8.829.30
We will be happy to furnish ycu with any information reaardinq
the above cost at your request and to meet with you to answer any
questions you may have.
Very truly yours,
SSHO'R�ELINE CONSTRUCTION CO.
C.:'James T. Suz uki
�-�ce�t_
JTS/ys
� 1a
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
DESIGN/UTILITY FNGINEERiNG 0 235 2631
MUNICIPAL BUILDING 200f 'LL AVE.SO RENION,WASH.941055
e
04P
41Ee SEPI F.
BARBARA Y. SNINPOCM
MAYOR
January 23, 1986
Shoreline Construction
P.D. Box 358
19545 Woodinville-Snohomish Rd.
Woodinville WA 48072
Attention: James T. Suzuki
bear Mr. Suzuki:
Your request for extra compensation for "changed condition, ground water,"
is hereby denied.
Section 7-17,3(I)A of the standard specifications stales in paragraph 6:
the Contractor shall furnish, install, and operate all
necessary equipment to keep Pwravation above the
foundation level free from water during construcU on,
and shall dewater and dispose of the water so as not
to cause injury to Public or private property or
nuisance to the Publir. lie shall at all timds havr
available sulficient Pumpinq equipment in qood workinq
condition for all emergencies, includinq power outage,
and shall have available at all times ccimpetent work-
men for the operation of the pumping equipment.
Section 7-17.5 includes the rost of "removal of water" in the unit price
for "Trench Excavation" as specified in Section 2-09. Section 2-09 is
modified by the special provision to include the price of "Structural
Excavation Class B" in the unit price bid for pipe per lineal foot.
This lanquage stems clear that de-watering, wh -her expected or not, is to
be covered by the unit price of the pipe and acy additional costs are the
contractor's responsibility.
Very truly yours,
David R. Tibbot,
Project Engineer
:mf
SHORELINE CONSTRUCTION CO. , q
Generei Conmecrors 1.9p
SM OR EC'VA NC
iw+ewwr".w..s"e�w.w•r xa.esun�..
January 27, 1986
City of Penton
Public works Department
Municipal Building
200 Mills Avenue South
Renton. WA 98055
Attn: David R. Tibbnt, Prolect Engineer
Re S-381 Duvall Avenue
Sanita,.v .Se`mr
Gentlemen:
Shoreline Construction Co, acknowledges receipt of Your
letter dated January 23, 1986 which denies the request dor
additional comnensacinn for "Canged Conditions, Ground b'ater".
Subsequent telephone calls to you after receiving your
letter have revealed that agreement cannot be reached. There-
fore, Shoreline Construction Co. requests arbitration, as the
method set forth in the contract to resovo the differences.
!ery truly yours,
Shoreline Constr ction Co.
�'�James T. Suzuki
R
SHORELINE CONSTRUCTION CO.
General Cortractors
SN OR EC-lr+No
r O b•ra 11rM+.N.0.„ :N072
January 7, 1986
City of Renton
Public Works Department
Municipal Building
200 Mill Avenue South
Renton, WA 98055
Attn: D. G. Monaghan, P. E.
Re: S-181 Duvall Avenue N. E.
Sanitary Sewer
Subj: Changed Condition,
Ground Water
Gentlemen:
By way of a letter dated and hand delivered to you on
November 15, 19RS, Shoreline Construction Cn, notifirel the
r,ty of Renton fiat Shoreline had encountered a pre-exist my
subsurface ground water condition which was an unknown physical
���ndition that differed materially from those ordinarily
.•ncountervd and uenerally rectx;nized as inhering in work in
the particular locale of this sewer line construction.
Ground water was first encountered during trenching on
W,vember 11th, nroun4 Station 6+40. At first, it was not
known how seVerp a emblem it would become not how far and
h"W lomt it would continue. After a day or so of pumping,
the flow of grnund water into the trench excavation did not
diminish and caused Shoreline to believe that it had cncount.erod
-1 significant volume of water; which, as it turned out, it had.
After almost two days of .ettinq up wells, pumps, generator,
etc, plus almost four ' .ya of slow and tough gernq to install.
Pipe; rather abruptl,,, the existing ground bec;tme impervious
around Station 10+70 and ground water was not encountered
again to the terminal Station 2.3+17. It can now be said that
about 230 lineal feet of this sewer line was in water and about
260 lineal feet was impacted by water.
•
The fact that this ground water condition was unxnown and
not even suspected by this contractor; or for that matter, by
the City of Rent-,n, can be attested to. Several other contractors
who had bid to : e City on this; project, when contacted recently
stated that they had tint included any allowance for ground water
in their bid because there was no indication that water would
be encountered on this project.
This unexpected ground water condition was materially
different from what might ordinarily be encountered, considering
this particular locale. The fact that it was a large isolated
pocket further ._,dicates taat it was of an unusual nature. If
this pocket of ,,rnuod water had only extended a few feet, it
would not have impacted the costs significantly, but it extended
some 260 feet and c-rtainly impacted costs significantly.
Although this 26" tent amounts to 15% of that run of sewer, the
,,cus shoWI feet-d to the more significant issue th;,t it
caused a F. . �•/�nti:•i vicrease in cost. The entire run of sewer
Along Duval ; Ave. was estimated to take 11 crew days to in .�all.,
and it can now be t;,A that it could have been constructed to no
more than 13 crew days if this unexpected grnund water had not
been encountered. Due to this water, it took a total of 18 crew
days, which includes the 54 days spent dealing with the water
and fighting through the 260 feet section affected by this water.
These 5* clays amounts to shout 30% of the i8 crew clays expended,
which is a significant percentage. In terms of the over-run,
which relates to cost, the 5.5 days spent through the nround
water area minus the 2 days that it could have been installed
in if water had not been encountered, divided by the 13 days
the total run could have been completed in, again assuminq no
water amounts to 271; which is a relatively hiqh percentage for
any over-run.
Partly because of the foregoing which indicates that there
was a substantial increase in cost, but more importantly because
this qround water condition clearly falls under the Changed
Condition clause of the contract, Shoreline Construction Co.
requests the City of Renton give favorable consideration to a
fair and equitable adjustment in payment to this contractor for
havinq performed the work. It cin reasonably and logically be
argued that if the City of Renton had known about this existing
ground water condition prior to the biddinq for this project
and had so informed the bidders, then the prices bid and the
cost to the City would have been accordingly higher. Since
this situation was a true "unknown" to both the City and to the
contractor, the appropriate price adjustment should ,oroperiv
and necessarily be made now, after the fact.
For this writing, Shoreline will set forth what it believes
to be the cost of labor and equipment to handle the ground water
encountered plus the difference in cost of labor and equipment
between what it actually turned out to be vs, what it could have
bren if qround water had not been encountered, This should
represent the test over-run attributable to this changed condition.
Crew Hours Cost of Cost of
Date Lost Labor Equipment
Nov, 13 A His, $ 374.65 $ 312.50
Nov, 14 4� Hrs. 674.37 562.50
Dec. 05 5y Hrs, 698.77 587.60
Dec. 06 7 Hra. 899.35 875.00
Dec. 09 5k lirs. 667.01 656.25
Dec. :0 3 Hrs. 371.30 375.00
950,Ou Dewaterino
Equipment
$3,675.45 $4,418.75
Plus 20% 735.09
$4,410.54 a 44,418.76-
We will be happy to furnish you with any information regarding
the above cost at your request and to meet with you to answer any
questions you may have.
Very truly yours,
SHORELINE CONSTRUCTION CO.
I
t/ f
JTSJya r James T. Suzuki
�h
uF kE. • •
� MT
U OR ° PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
DESIGN/UTILII\' ENGINEERING 0 2 2631
Zo MUNICIPAL BUILDING 200 MILL AVE.SO. RENTON.MASH.9tai66
9 b'
�P
�rf0 SEPtE�
BARBARA Y. SHINPOCH
MAYOR
January 2J, 1986
Shoreline Construction
P.O. Box 35R
19505 Woo"'-villr-Snohomish Rd.
Woodinvil to 98072
Attention: James I. Suzuki
Dear Mr. Suzu'li:
Your I'P,luect for extra compensation for "changed condition, ground water,"
is hereby denied.
Section 1-17.3(I)A of the standard specifications States in paragraph 6:
the COnlractor shall furnish, install, and operate all
nrrPssary equipmeent to keep excavation above the
fmmdation Iry 01 free frost water during crnstruction,
and shall dewater and dispose of the water so as not
Io cause injury to public or private property or
nuisanrr to the public. 110 shall at all times have
available ;nificient Pumping equipment in good working
londil.i It inr all raMrgencies, including power outage,
and shall have available at all times competent work-
men for the operation of the pumping equipmP,,t.
Ser tion 1-1l'S includes the cost of "removal Of water" in the unit price
for "Ir011rh Excavation" as specified in Section 2-09. Section 2-09 is
modified by the Special provision to include the price of "Structural
txravatioo Class 8" in the unit price bid for pipe per lineal foot.
,his langnagr seems clear that de-watering, whether expected or not, is to
be ,'nvered by the unit price of the pipe and any additional costs are the
contractor It responsibility,
Very truly yours,
David R. Tibbot,
Project Engineer
:mf
SHORELINE CONSTRUCTION CO. �nfr e
Genoral Confreows
SN 09 EC'374 NO
11MSnsMnwlY L.�wM11W M&W wxt
P O 0"WO 11sMwIM,.W.*.4 r Apl}
January 27, 1986
City of Penton
Public works Department
Municipal Building
200 Mills Avenue South
Renton. NA 98055
Attn: David R. Tibbot, Project Engineer
Re . S-381 Duvall Avenue
Sanitary sever
Gentlemen:
shoreline Construction Co. acknowledges receipt of your
letter dated January 23, 1906 which denies the request dnr
additional compensation for "Canged Conditions, Ground Hater".
Subseouent telephone calls to you after re:eivinq your
letter have revealed that agreement cannot be reached. There-
fore, Shoreline Construction Co. requests arbitration, as the
method set rorth to the contract to resove the dif€eren„es.
Very truly yours,
Shoreline Construction Co.
I
'.I l V—k-f
James T. Suzuki t`
L
OF RF
far R
z
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
g DESIGN nlTiu Tv ENGiNEE jiNG 0 235-2631
t+ MUNICIPAL BUILDING 2000LLAVE SO. RENTON.WASH.99055
W`P
,rEO SEe E
BARBARA Y. SHINoOG
MAVJR
MEMORANDUM
January 29, i986
TO: Richard C. Houghton, Public Yorks Directoorr
FROM: David 7it`bot. Project Engineer .�I
SUBJECT: Duvall Ave. N.E. Sewer CAG 007-65
Enclosed are copies of Shoreline Construction Company's -equest
for extra compensation, on refusal, and Shorlines req- for
arbitration.
Dose this matter now go to the Attorney or what?
attach:
DT:jw
SHORELINE CONSTRUCTION CO.
General Contra,.fors
SH-OR EC'37 CNO
ty+[,,..p•n,.x,$na _..PAW TY 011I x
r tI 9+.TA Feeein,.il. w,M.nKOn W72
January 7, IYRb
City of Renton
Public Works Department
Municipal Building
200 Mill Avenue South
Renton, WA 98055
Attn: D. G. Monaghan, P. E.
Re: S-381 Duvall Avenue N. E.
Sanitary Sewer
Subj: Changed Condition,
Ground Water
Gentlemen:
By way of a letter dated and hand delivered to you on
November 15, 1985, Shcreline Construction Co. natifie.d the
City of Renton that Shoreline had encountered a pre-existing
subsurface ground water condition which was an unknown physical
condition that differed materially from those ordinarily
encountered and generally recognized as inhering in work in
the particular locale of this se, ar line construction.
Ground water was first encountered during trenching on
November 13th, around Station 8+40. At first, it was not
known how severe a problem it would become nor how far and
how loran it would continue, filter a day or so of pumping,
the flew of ground water into the trench excavation did not
diminish ,nd caused Shoreline to believe that it had encountered
a significant volume of water; which, as it turned out, it had.
After almost two days of setting up wells, pumps, generator,
etc, plus almost four days of Glow and tough going to install
pipe: rather abruptly, the existing ground became impervious
around Station 10+70 and ground water was not encountered
again to the terminal Sta.tioi, 23+37, Tt can now be said that
about 230 lineal feet of this sewer line was in water and about
760 lineal feet was impacted by water.
The fact that this ground water condition was unknown and
not even suspected by this contractor; or for that matter, by
the City of Renton, can be attested to. Several other contractors
who had bid to the City on this project, when contacted recently
stated that they had not included any allowance for ground water
in their bid because there was no indication that water would
be encountered on this project.
This unexpected ground water condition was materially
different from what might ordinarily be encountered, considering
this particular locale. The fact that it was a large isolated
pocket further indicates that it was of an unusual nature. If
this pocket of ground water had only extended a few feet, it
would not have impacted the costs significantly, but it extended
some 260 feet and certainly impacted costs significantly.
Although this 260 feet amounts to 15% of that run of sewer, the
focus should be directed to the more significant issue that it
caused a substantial increase in cost. The entire run of sewer
along Duvall Ave, was estimated to tale 11 crew days to install,
and it can now be said that it could have been constructed in no
more than 13 crew days if this unexpected ground water had not
been encountered. Due to this water, it took a total of 1R crew
days, whicl, includes the 5+ days spent dealing with the water
and 1-ightina through the 260 feet section affected by this water.
These 5+ nays amounts to about 30% of the 18 crew days expended,
which , a significant percentage. In terms of the over-run,
which relates to cost, the 5.5 days spent through the ground
water area minus the 2 days that it could have been installed
in it water had not been encountered, divided by the 13 days
the total run could have been completed in, again assuming no
water amounts to 27%; which is a natively high percentage for
any over-run.
Partly because of the foregoing which indicates that there
was a substantial increase in cost, but more importantly because
this ground water condition clearly falls under the Changed
Condition clause of the contract, Shoreline Construction Co.
requests the City of Renton give favorable consideration to a
fair and equitable adjustment in payment to this contractor for
havin,,1 performed the work. It can reasonably and logically be
argued that if the City of Renton had known about th:- nxisting
grour.i water condition prior to the bidding fcr this project
and had so informed the bidders, then the prices bid :-nd the
cost to the City would have been accordingly higher. Since
this situation was a true "unknown" to both the City and to the
contractor, the appropriate price adjustment should properly
and necessarily be made now, after the fact.
For this writinq, Shoreline will set forth what it believes
to be the cost of labor and equipment to handle the ground water
encountered plus the difference in cost of labor and equipment
between what it actually turned out to be vs. what it could have
been if ground water had not been encountered. This should
represent the cost over-run attributable to this changed condition.
Crew Hours Cost of Cost of
Date Lost Labor Equipment
Nov, 13 24 Hrs, $ 3'4.65 $ 312.50
Nov, 14 4k Hrs. 674.37 562.50
Dec, 05 5� Hrs. 698.77 587.60
Dec. 05 7 Hrs. 889.35 875.00
Dec. 09 5h Hrs. 667.01 656.25
Dec. 10 3 Hrs. 371.30 375,00
950.00 Dewatering
Equipment
$3,675.45 $4,418.75
P1uF 20% 735.09
$4,410.54 + J4,418.76= t8.829.30
tie will be happy to furnish you with any information regardinq
the above cost at your request and to meet with you to answer any
questions you may have.
Very truly yours,
SHORELINE CONSTRUCTION CO.
s -
(.>.�/YYJe.�I.I i
Suz
uki
' f
.l r
� ames T. Suzuki
JTS/ys
I�
� Ir
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
z
_ DESIGN/UTILITY ENGINEERING 0 235 2631
'p $ MUNICIPAL.BUILDING z00 MILL AVE.SO. RENTON.WASH.99055
9q b.
oq P
�rf0 SEpl
BARBARA Y. SHINPOCH
MAV04I
January 23, 1986
Shoreline Construction
P.U. Box 358
19545 Woodinville-Snohomish Rd.
Woodinville MA 98072
Attention: Jew s T. Suzuki
Dear Mr. Suzuki:
Your request for extra compensation for "changed condition, ground water,"
is hereby denied.
Section 7-17.3(1)A of the standard specifications states in paragraph 6:
the Contractor shall furnish, install, and operate all
necessary equipment to keep excavation above the
folodation level free from water during construction,
or. ' shall fewater and dispose of the water so as not
to cause injury to public or private property or
nuisance to the public. IM shall at all times have
available sufficient Pumping equipment it :good working
condition for all emergencies, including power outage,
and shall have available at all times comp
nsork-
anen for the operation of the Pumping equip tent
Section 7-17.5 includes the cost of "removal of water" in the unit price
for "Treoch Excavation" as specified In Section 2-09. Section 2-09 is
modified by the special provision to include the price of "Structural
Excavation Class B" in the unit price !id for pipe per lineal foot.
This lanquage seems clear 114t de-watering, whether expected or not, is to
be covered by the unit i:rtre of the pipe and any additional costs are the
contractor's responsibility.
Very truly yours,
David R. Tibbot,
Project Engineer
:of
' iw
SHORELINE CONSTRUCTION CO.
General Confracfors n 1Pwj
�N OR EC-•374 NO
1 M.f wnmMn.ill,Snennm.,n P.,U M .Mlmx
a o Po.lSS W�ppin.l�..W.Mx�Ma+W72
.7amOry 27, 1986
City of Penton
Public works Department
Municipal Building
200 Mills Avenue South
Renton. WA 98055
Att;.: David R. Tibbot, Project Engineer
Re . S-381 Duvall Avenue
Sanitary Sewer
Gentlemen:
Shorelir.i Construction Co. acknowledges receipt of vour
letter .gated January 23, 1986 which denies the request dor
additional compensation for "Canged Conditions, Ground Water".
Subseouent telephone calls to you after receiving your
letter have revealed that agreement cannot be reached. There-
fore, Shoreline Construction Co requests arbitration, as the
method set forth in the contract to resove the differences.
Very truly yours,
Shoreline Corstrllction Co.
L
ait 4.G.L
James T. Suzuki `,/\
IMrsNDP►IC6 MpgAAMuu11
UATi,; A{;n i 10. 1986
TO: Don Monaghan
FROM: Dave Tibbot
SUWRWT: Duvall Av.e N.M. Sewer - ,lie Suxuai
Mr. Suauki to claiming he deserves extra compensation for three items in
addition to ttr .nfamous ground eater. The, are as fcllows:
1 . No:rrnher li Time lost due to adjusting the f,rst run of pipe for
the misailignrient of the existing A- stub. Three 131 hours of
crew time.
2. November 13 3' tra"ite waterway muved in toward sewer at manhoie
•1. Manhole was -.wed to Fast so that the next run of pipe would no,
conflict with waterma in. Two and one-halt (2 1!2) hours of crew time.
3. Deco Sher 16 Powet/telephone guy;servire pole on line. Arranged for
larwor Ind telephone companies to hold pole while contractcr dug lost.
Two and one-hey' 1! 12) hours Of crew time..
I believe Item 1. )Old% no merit as this is only to be oxpectrd fin ¢tart
up and is ev.n mentioned in the contractor's proposed work schedule.
Item ?. may havo some merit, but seems specious.
Item I. - the pole is shown on the prints and although we made an effort
to have it moved by the telephone com;i&ny, it did not create a change of
condition.
Should these be added to the arbitration, paid off, or what:
:mf
�• $ a � o
.MAN OAY3
r
. 'r •f'.t.w.../ :m.. ai f. �.'frw.ry arr ,•e.
T
a
e ,
, `.` T\. _. _. .,. •r 3A, 9te0- - wM %NA{ iGy' Ile0.
6
CIO
lC
•'. f ... .Y• 'N ) Vt..l M.J
11 r ...n .r..0 a.. .:.....,uy rs r.fie M• fw<ro.
71
15
4w+
14 ! },
15
a
n
i \ a
ex
VA \r
M
1
9a+cc S- ...,n... .c..
0
2D \
t..�.
.. ..
n..� a..
24 f ,, r
�- - � • �
�� � �. �r
.� � '" �
'`w�-��,. _ •.// ^/
(� J // �I
� f�
f ^�
• I
�^
1
i
-"`�'�'+' .� �,.•++..�^-erg �---% 4
/'
n
r�
:_�
i
• I
PZ? �
T, FFn 1 i
t
Nbq
SHORELINE CONSTRUCT ON CO.
General Contractors
SN OR EC-3Jn,NO
1%t5 Wootl�n,ne 5iw5omnn PM WO72
o D an.]5B WooEn.11ln,N�Mnpron
290tRa1$�r _�. 19R�
City of Penton
mUcipal Building - Public d`orks rlept.
200 Mill Avenue
Renton, wA 98053
Attn: Mr. David R. T4bbot
Re: S-381 Duvall Ave. N. E.
Sanitary Sewer Installation
Gentleaen:
Ch Nov4mter 13, 1985, Wednesday, our sewer excavation operation
enc ntered a sudden and rather Revere around water condition that has
materially impeded construction proyzess. we hereby eiive van this written
notice as a follow up to our verbal notice that the added costs of having
to handle this velure of grvzA water is be}ond the c vmtract requirements
and will have an effect on our performance-, both in time and cost.
We will certainly do whatever we can to minimize these acts and will
work with you and }our inspector regardim this problem. To meet the
recuirements of the contract, we are forwarding this letter for your files.
welcome any s•.gy.st`_ans and help that lou are able to offer in our mutual
attempt to minimize the cost ix%3& t from this problem.
For toe sake of formality, ,n of course, must reserve anv and all right_
that the contract provides for adjustrnents.
lery truly voirs,
sol�tJr>£ ary�. ro.
JTS/ys ✓ Jaatq T. Stg2glki
SAN-1 Sanitary Sewer Project S-38i
Duvall Ave. N . E. Sanitary Sewer Ext, Arbitration 2 of 2
,PAQE 1 �.t N'�ll�kl vi-" .#.j 1!ti4.lf
4r.ik ?iMd• r`.EF,'N:TT,ii CA F. imT
P^�tk uLlRTt �...Cadaolasn f-�sr e#t� X-iNa �t7:waer k`-Vt e• ta uwwi teuaas -
L'} }Nt4F1E.i lr+r6
lea
i t :1 6gy.iT_
. TTJ 4YATC TIP
I
a id4`
,
�,. NTU'Tia�
;3 # $dh#c SrE. �+I:.�kt`r� C1lY. , . .,,... �q p�., s,! � - - 'F,#y,3`•�F,,...
is
Tar�, ir � thxlsk . #M6Ltibd. :+� t2', 1Ldwr1 •
�a FoG S 4Ad�Y `V TµXW4 Y.,�7 1 �eAAWB',TYf tffi di n #AXllk tl ,* l
. i. IYGAT' rw -rppQ"k " V' :l`k' i ,Nr+lti"': �TJ4�y; �� � ..
f Er Y " k'�Al.{r "-r7.Yr o1 �,:..i1.R•1 tlN �V14oJh •�- 144
t*srlt AND FEA JF 1*1 #M 4 cot.4o'lQw t� fit,# y ir` R .1Rk ffi. r
"'MkPi
;I7¢ 8>'°X4.t1«Ip'k 1 YwAidt ULY4L�EL rVl?N CTFo'' `IHE `SNy�d,d. T>.4A'7N rTlla».:',
TAi:,1'w E"IR[r Ttk4'tkA," `'ttr a`,.XX amTNC
SIT 4xK � ' ' IT ?M., for • .
IF
r " 'r. l a .0 I r • .' .I � Y f`t. S �i
fq At' .pykic'
rIf,IF
LLL
ENDING