Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutTutor-Additional Hearing Docs II this shopping cart is found off Safeway Property Please call for cart pickup (877)511 -CART Safeway If this shopping cart is found off Safeway Property Please call for cart pickup (877) 511 -CART GOOD MORNING EVERYONE MY NAME IS MARK JOHNSON, I MANAGE RAMCO SERVICES, WE ARE A CONTRACTOR FOR SAFEWAY FOR THERE CART RETRIEVAL PROGRAM ALONG WITH OTHER STORES IN THE CITY OF RENTON I WOULD LIKE TO ADD THAT WE ARE IN THE CITY OF RENTON 4 DAY A WEEK , TWO FULL DAYS MONDAYS AND THURSDAY AND MORNINGS OF TUESDAY AND WEDNESDAY. JUST LAST MONTH WE PICK UP OVER 279 CARTS WITH ALL THE STORES WE SERVICE IN THE CITY LIMITS 179 FOR SAFEWAY 40 QFC 11 U WAJ I MAYA 32 WALMART 12 SUPER FOOD SAVER (SAARS) 5 GROCERY OUTLET ITS NOT FOR THE LACK OF EFFORT, ITS JUST THAT WE CANT COVER EVERY STREET IN THE CITY ON A DAILY BASIS, **EXAMPLE WE CAN COVER A STREET ** RAINIER AVE PICK UP ALL THE CARTS AND CAN GO BACK 5 MINUTES LATER AND THERE'S MORE CARTS AND THAT'S JUST RAINIER AVE, WE HAVE THAT PROBLEM ALL OVER THE CITY ITS VERY FRUSTRATING FOR US TO GET THE CART WRITE UP TUESDAYAFTERNOON THAT MR ZELLNER SENDS ME AND SEE THAT WE HAVE CARTS ON THERE, IT MAKES US LOOK LIKE WE AREN'T DOING OUR JOB, WHICH IS FAR FROM THE TRUTH, WE FIND THEM AT BUS STOPS, ALONG THE ROAD SIDEWALKS, HIDING IN BUSHES, BEHIND BINS AND BY HOMELESS AREAS WE HAVE PUT ON THE CARTS OUR #800 TAGS IT HAS BEEN SUCCESSFUL, WE DO GET CALLS FROM THE PUBLIC THEY GIVE US AN ADDRESS AND WE PICK THOSE UP THE FOLLOWING DAY, SOME TIMES WE HAVE TO HUNT THEM DOWN, EITHER PEOPLE MOVE THEM FROM THAT AREA OR THEY JUST GET THE ADDRESS WRONG BUT ITS HELPING US RETRIEVE THE CARTS IN CLOSING SOME STORES SEEM TO DON'T CARE THEY HAVE CARTS OUT ON THE STREETS FOR SOME REASON, IVE TALKED TO THEM TO NO AVAIL SO OK THAT'S THERE DECISION SO FOR THOSE STORES, THEY SHOULD BE FINED, I AGREE ON THAT BUT THE STORES THAT MAKE A SINCERE EFFORT I DON'T THINK SHOULD THANK YOU Chapter 6-27 SHOPPING CART REGULATION Page 1 of 4 CHAPTER 27 SHOPPING CART REGULATION SECTION 6-27-1 Purpose 6-27-2: Declaration Of Nuisance 6-27-3 Definitions 6-27-4 Shopping Cart Signage 6-27-5 Impoundment And Fines 6-27-6 Disposition Of Carts 6-27-7 Illegal Possession Or Accumulation Of Carts 6-27-1 PURPOSE: It is the primary purpose of this Chapter to provide for the prompt retrieval of lost, stolen or abandoned shopping carts in order to promote public safety and improve the image and appearance of the City It is a purpose of this Chapter to have the owners and operators of businesses providing shopping carts use the means available to them to deter.prevent or mitigate the removal of shopping carts from their business premises. and to retrieve any carts that may be removed despite these efforts It is a further purpose of this Chapter to prevent the illegal removal of shopping carts from the business premises to prevent the continued possession of illegally removed carts. and to prevent the accumulation of illegally removed carts on public or private properties. (Ord 5145.6-13-05. Ord 5786, 3-7-16) 6-27-2 DECLARATION OF NUISANCE: Retail establishments provide shopping carts for the convenience of customers shopping on the premises of the businesses- A shopping cart that has been removed from the premises of the business and left abandoned on public or private property throughout the City constitutes a public nuisance and a potential hazard to the health and safety of the public:each lost. stolen or abandoned cart shall constitute a separate violation. Shopping carts abandoned on public and private property can create conditions of blight in the community obstruct free access to sidewalks. streets and other rights-of-way, interfere with pedestrian and vehicular traffic on pathways driveways public and private streets. and impede emergency services It is for these reasons that such lost. stolen. or abandoned shopping carts are hereby declared to be a public nuisance which shall be subject to abatement in the manner set forth in this Chapter.or in any other manner provided by law For purposes of this Chapter any shopping cart located on any public or private property other than the premises of the retail establishment from which such shopping cart was removed shall be presumed lost. stolen. or abandoned,even if in the possession of any person unless such person in possession thereof is A. An authorized agent' or B Retail Establishment personnel or C Enforcement personnel: or D An authorized customer (Ord 5145.6-13-05 Ord 5786. 3-7-16) 6-27-3 DEFINITIONS: Except as otherwise expressly set forth herein the following words and terms as used in this Chapter shall have the following meanings A Administrator.The Administrator of the Community and Economic Development Department. B Authorized Agent The owner, or an employee or authorized agent of the owner.entitled to possession of the shopping cart. http://www.codepublishing.com/WA/Renton/ 07/24/2018 Chapter 6-27 SHOPPING CART REGULATION Page 2 of 4 C. Authorized Customer A customer of the owner of the shopping cart. having the written permission of the owner or owner's agent to remove the shopping cart from the owner's premises D. Cart Patrol and Retrieval Company A contracted agent who recovers shopping carts on behalf of retail establishments within a one half(1/2)mile radius of the contracting retail establishment(s) no fewer than two(2)times per week. E Enforcement Personnel.Any police officer. code enforcement inspector. or designated staff employed by the City of Renton. F 'Identification Sign or-Cart Sign'.A clearly visible sign fastened to each cart that provides ownership information required by this Chapter. G. Impounded Cart:Any shopping cart collected by authorized City personnel. regardless of whether or not the shopping cart is being transported to or is stored within City facilities. H. Lost. Stolen. or Abandoned Shopping Cart:A shopping cart that is either 1 Removed from the premises of a retail establishment by any person without the written permission or consent of the owner of the shopping cart or the retailer otherwise entitled to possession of such cart:or 2 Left unattended. discarded or abandoned upon any public or private property other than the premises of the retail establishment from which the shopping cart was removed regardless of whether such shopping cart was removed from the premises with permission of the owner: 3. For purposes of this Chapter. any shopping cart located on any public or private property other than the premises of the retail establishment from which such shopping cart was removed shall be presumed lost. stolen. or abandoned even if in the possession of any person. unless such person in possession thereof is either a. The owner. or an employee or authorized agent of the owner entitled to possession of said shopping cart. or b. An officer. employee or agent of a cart retrieval service hired by the owner to retrieve such carts:or c City enforcement personnel retrieving.storing or disposing of said cart pursuant to the provisions of this code. d A customer with written permission from the owner or agent of the owner to take the cart off premises I Owner Any person or entity that owns. leases possesses. or makes more than ten(10)shopping carts available to customers or the public in connection with the conduct of a business J Parking Area A parking lot or other property provided by a retail establishment for the use of customers of said retail establishment for the parking of customer vehicles. The parking area of a retail establishment located in a multi-store complex or a shopping center shall include the entire parking area used by the multi-store complex or shopping center. K. Premises.Any building property or other area upon which any retail establishment business is conducted or operated in the City of Renton including the parking area provided for customers in such retail establishment. L Retail Establishment:Any business located in the City of Renton which offers or provides shopping carts for the use of the customers of such business regardless of whether such business is advertised or operated as a retail or wholesale business. and regardless of whether such business is open to the general public, is a private club or business. or is a membership store M Security Measures Physical impediments or methods to prevent removal of shopping carts from the premises of the retail establishment including. but not limited to 1 Electronically-activated self-braking wheels. 2 Poles mounted to shopping carts.which prevent their removal from the interior of the retail establishment 3 Utilization of a cart patrol and retrieval company 4. Dedicated security personnel: and 5 Other measures deemed appropriate and effective by the Administrator http://www.codepublishing.com/WA/Renton/ 07/24/2018 Chapter 6-27 SHOPPING CART REGULATION Page 3 of 4 N Shopping Cart or Cart A basket which is mounted on wheels or a similar device generally used in a retail establishment by a customer for the purpose of transporting goods of any kind (Ord. 5145. 6-13-05.Ord 5786. 3-7-16. Ord 5843. 6-12-17 Formerly 6-27-5) 6-27-4 SHOPPING CART SIGNAGE: A Identification Signs on Carts Required. Each shopping cart made available for use by customers shall have an Identification Sign permanently affixed to it that includes the following information in accordance with RCW 9A.56.270 as now enacted or hereafter amended 1 Identifies the owner of the shopping cart or the name of the business establishment. or both. 2 Notifies the public of the procedure to be utilized for authorized removal of the cart from the premises. 3 Notifies the public that the unauthorized removal of the cart from the premises of the business or parking area of the retail establishment. or the unauthorized possession of the cart. is unlawful and 4 Lists a current telephone number or address for returning carts removed from the premises or parking area to the owner or retailer. B Notice to customers Owners shall provide written notice to customers that the removal of shopping carts from the premises is prohibited Such notice may be provided in the form of flyers distributed on the premises. notice printed on shopping bags. direct mail. notices on business websites or any other means demonstrated to be effective Additionally all owners shall display and maintain conspicuous signs on the premises near all customer entrances and exits and throughout the premises. including the parking area warning customers that removal of shopping carts from the premises is prohibited by state and City law (Ord 5145, 6-13-05. Ord 5643.. 12-12-11: Ord 5786. 3-7-16 Formerly 6-27-6) 6-27-5 IMPOUNDMENT AND FINES: A. Impoundment of Shopping Carts The City may immediately impound any lost.stolen or abandoned shopping cart within the City.or any cart within the City to which the required Identification Sign is not affixed B. Impounded Carts Owners identified on Cart Signs will be informed that they have fourteen (14)days in which to retrieve the cart(s)from the City C. Notification of Impounded Cart: The City shall utilize the required Cart Sign to notify the owner of each impounded cart. absence of the required Cart Sign shall relieve the City from this responsibility D Fines The City shall issue a one hundred dollar($100)fine to the owner of each lost. stolen. or abandoned cart impounded by the City. unless the fine is eligible for deferral Each cart impounded by the City shall constitute a separate violation. E Fine Deferrals. Within any calendar month the Administrator shall defer fines for the first three(3)impounded carts owned by any business that. prior to the impoundment. has implemented the following criteria If four(4) or more shopping carts under common ownership are impounded within a calendar month no fines shall be deferred by the Administrator 1 Affixed the required identification sign to each impounded cart. and 2 Implemented security measures. as defined in this Chapter to prevent removal of shopping carts from the business property. (Ord 5145. 6-13-05 Ord 5786. 3-7-16: Ord 5843:6-12-17 Formerly 6-27-7) 6-27-6 DISPOSITION OF CARTS: A Disposition of Carts: Carts impounded by the City which are either held for more than fourteen (14)days following the date of notification or carts without an Identification Sign may be disposed of or sold by the City B Appeals 1 Filing of Appeal Any owner aggrieved by any adverse decision of the Administrator pursuant to this Chapter may appeal such decision within fourteen (14)calendar days following the date of such decision by filing with the Hearing Examiner or City Clerk a written notice of appeal briefly stating the grounds for such appeal The notice of decision shall be deemed filed on the date the appeal processing fee has been paid No appeal shall be accepted for filing and processing by the Administrator unless accompanied by the appeal processing fee http://www.codepublishing.com/WA/Renton/ 07/24/2018 Chapter 6-27 SHOPPING CART REGULATION Page 4 of 4 2 Notice of Hearing. If the appeal is timely filed. the Examiner shall cause the matter to be set for hearing The appellant shall be provided not less than ten (10)calendar days written notice of the date time and place of the hearing The Hearing Examiner shat conduct the hearing pursuant to the provisions of RMC 4-8-110 (Ord 5145.6-13- 05.Ord 5786. 3-7-16 Formerly 6-27-8) 6-27-7 ILLEGAL POSSESSION OR ACCUMULATION OF CARTS: A. Any person removing a shopping cart from the premises of an owner.without the written permission of the owner or the owner's authorized agent. shall be guilty of shopping cart theft. which is a misdemeanor. pursuant to ROW 9A.56.270. B Any owner or lessee of residential property that knowingly allows one or more shopping carts to remain on the leased property without written permission of the owner of the shopping cart or the owner's authorized agent. is guilty of possession of stolen property in the 3rd degree.which is a gross misdemeanor. except if the owner or lessee contacts the owner of the cart(s)weekly until the cart(s)are removed and asks that the carts be retrieved. keeping a record of such contact. C Any owner of multi-family housing which allows an accumulation of three(3)or more shopping carts upon the multi- family premises has committed a code violation punishable according to the terms of RMC 1-3-2 There shall be an exception for the owner of any multi-family housing who has sent a letter to all tenants. on a quarterly basis. advising the tenants to not leave shopping carts on the premises of the multi-family property and who has kept a record of such letters The owner of the multi-family housing to claim this exception must also contact the owner of the carts weekly until the carts are removed and ask that the carts be retrieved keeping a record of the date and time of such contact. D. Any owner of commercial or industrial property which allows the accumulation of one or more shopping carts not maintained as part of the business. has committed a code violation punishable according to the terms of RMC 1-3-2 The owner of the commercial or industrial property may claim an exception from this code violation. To claim this exception.the owner must contact the owner of the carts weekly until the carts are removed and ask that the carts be retrieved. keeping a record of the date and time of such contact (Ord 5145. 6-13-05'. Ord 5786. 3-7-16. Formerly 6-27-9) Mobile Version • http://www.codepublishing.com/WA/Renton/ 07/24/2018 Lynne Hiemer From: Lynne Hiemer Sent: Tuesday,July 24, 2018 9:30 AM To: Donna Locher Subject: All the Safeway Letters sent July 5, 2018 July 5, 2018 Davy Chen Safeway Store#0366 2725 NE Sunset Blvd Renton,WA 98056 RE: Renton's Shopping Cart Regulations—Fine Deferrals Dear Davy Chen: The City of Renton has adopted revisions to Municipal Shopping Cart Regulations that would allow up to three fine deferrals in any given calendar month for businesses that have affixed an identification sign to each of their carts and implemented at least one defined security measure.The revisions are intended to provide some relief from fines while ensuring compliance with the basic principles of the Regulations. Within any calendar month the Administrator will defer fines for the first three (3) impounded carts owned by any business that, prior to the impoundment, has affixed identification signs to their carts and implemented a security measure (as detailed below). If four(4) or more shopping carts under common ownership are impounded within a calendar month no fines will be deferred by the Administrator(i.e., a business would be issued fines for the first three impounded carts and any carts subsequently impounded within the calendar month). 1) Affixed permanent identification to shopping carts: Identifies the owner of the shopping cart and/or the name of the business establishment, and lists a current telephone number and/or address for returning carts; 2) Implemented security measures: Physical impediments or methods to prevent removal of shopping carts from the premises of the retail establishment including, but not limited to: • Electronically-activated self-braking wheels; • Poles mounted to shopping carts, which prevent their removal from the interior of the retail establishment • Utilization of a cart patrol and retrieval company; • Dedicated security personnel; and • Other measures deemed appropriate and effective by the Administrator. To be eligible for fine deferrals, a business must request verification of eligibility to our Code Compliance Division.The request should detail how your business is compliant with the eligibility requirements. City staff will need to verify the presence of cart signs and confirm your method(s) of security measures (the method of verification will vary depending on the security measure). To date,the City has allowed fine deferrals to occur without demonstrated compliance with the aforementioned criteria; effective August 1, 2018 the City will cease to allow fine deferrals except for those businesses who have demonstrated compliance. 1 Our shared goal continues to be the confinement of shopping carts to each store's respective premises. In advance, thank you 'for your understanding and cooperation. Sincerely, . �1 ✓vii C.E. "Chip"Vincent,Administrator Community and Economic Development Department Cc: Shane Moloney,City Attorney Safeway Accounting Department 2 July 5, 2018 Doug Carter Safeway Store#3319 4300 NE 4th St Renton, WA 98059 RE: Renton's Shopping Cart Regulations—Fine Deferrals Dear Doug Carter: The City of Renton has adopted revisions to Municipal Shopping Cart Regulations that would allow up to three fine deferrals in any given calendar month for businesses that have affixed an identification sign to each of their carts and implemented at least one defined security measure. The revisions are intended to provide some relief from fines while ensuring compliance with the basic principles of the Regulations. Within any calendar month the Administrator will defer fines for the first three (3) impounded carts owned by any business that, prior to the impoundment, has affixed identification signs to their carts and implemented a security measure (as detailed below). If four(4) or more shopping carts under common ownership are impounded within a calendar month no fines will be deferred by the Administrator(i.e., a business would be issued fines for the first three impounded carts and any carts subsequently impounded within the calendar month). 3) Affixed permanent identification to shopping carts: Identifies the owner of the shopping cart and/or the name of the business establishment, and lists a current telephone number and/or address for returning carts; 4) Implemented security measures: Physical impediments or methods to prevent removal of shopping carts from the premises of the retail establishment including, but not limited to: • Electronically-activated self-braking wheels; • Poles mounted to shopping carts, which prevent their removal from the interior of the retail establishment • Utilization of a cart patrol and retrieval company; • Dedicated security personnel; and • Other measures deemed appropriate and effective by the Administrator. To be eligible for fine deferrals, a business must request verification of eligibility to our Code Compliance Division. The request should detail how your business is compliant with the eligibility requirements. City staff will need to verify the presence of cart signs and confirm your method(s) of security measures (the method of verification will vary depending on the security measure). To date,the City has allowed fine deferrals to occur without demonstrated compliance with the aforementioned criteria; effective August 1, 2018 the City will cease to allow fine deferrals except for those businesses who have demonstrated compliance. Our shared goal continues to be the confinement of shopping carts to each store's respective premises. In advance, thank you for your understanding and cooperation. Sincerely, C.E. "Chip"Vincent, Administrator 3 • Community and Economic Development Department Cc: Shane Moloney,City Attorney Safeway Accounting Department 4 July 5, 2018 Marc Dahm Safeway Store#1563 200 S 3rd St Renton,WA 98057 RE: Renton's Shopping Cart Regulations— Fine Deferrals Dear Marc Dahm: The City of Renton has adopted revisions to Municipal Shopping Cart Regulations that would allow up to three fine deferrals in any given calendar month for businesses that have affixed an identification sign to each of their carts and implemented at least one defined security measure.The revisions are intended to provide some relief from fines while ensuring compliance with the basic principles of the Regulations. Within any calendar month the Administrator will defer fines for the first three (3) impounded carts owned by any business that, prior to the impoundment, has affixed identification signs to their carts and implemented a security measure (as detailed below). If four(4) or more shopping carts under common ownership are impounded within a calendar month no fines will be deferred by the Administrator(i.e., a business would be issued fines for the first three impounded carts and any carts subsequently impounded within the calendar month). 5) Affixed permanent identification to shopping carts: Identifies the owner of the shopping cart and/or the name of the business establishment, and lists a current telephone number and/or address for returning carts; 6) Implemented security measures: Physical impediments or methods to prevent removal of shopping carts from the premises of the retail establishment including, but not limited to: • Electronically-activated self-braking wheels; • Poles mounted to shopping carts,which prevent their removal from the interior of the retail establishment • Utilization of a cart patrol and retrieval company; • Dedicated security personnel; and • Other measures deemed appropriate and effective by the Administrator. To be eligible for fine deferrals, a business must request verification of eligibility to our Code Compliance Division. The request should detail how your business is compliant with the eligibility requirements. City staff will need to verify the presence of cart signs and confirm your method(s) of security measures (the method of verification will vary depending on the security measure). To date,the City has allowed fine deferrals to occur without demonstrated compliance with the aforementioned criteria; effective August 1, 2018 the City will cease to allow fine deferrals except for those businesses who have demonstrated compliance. Our shared goal continues to be the confinement of shopping carts to each store's respective premises. In advance, thank you for your understanding and cooperation. Sincerely, C.E. "Chip"Vincent, Administrator _ 5 • Community and Economic Development Department Cc: Shane Moloney,City Attorney Safeway Accounting Department 6