HomeMy WebLinkAbout10/08/2019 MINUTES
City of Renton
Board of Park Commissioners Meetin •
Tuesday, October 8, 2019, 4:30 pm
At: Tour of Gene Coulon Memorial Beach Park
1. CALL TO ORDER
Chair Tim Searing called the meeting to order at 4:33pm.
2. ROLL CALL
Members Present: Cynthia Burns, Larry Reymann,Tim Searing, Shun Takano,Troy Wigestrand and Marlene
Winter
Members Absent: Al Dieckman, excused
City Staff Present: Kelly Beymer, Community Services Administrator; Leslie Betlach, Parks Planning and
Natural Resources Director; Cailin Hunsaker, Parks and Trails Director;Alan Wyatt, Capital Projects
Manager, Erica Schmitz,Capital Project Coordinator/Park Planner, and Roberta Graver,Admin.Assistant
3. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Marlene Winter motioned to approve the agenda as presented, motion seconded, all in favor, motion
carried.
4. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Troy Wigestrand motioned to approve the August 20, 2019 minutes. Larry suggested adding the word
"speed"to section 4 to clarify the type of excessive infractions.Troy amended the motion to include the
added word "speed". Larry Reymann seconded the motion, all in favor, motion carried.
S. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS/PUBLIC COMMENTS
None
6. BOARD COMMUNICATION
None
7. DISCUSSION/ACTION ITEMS
Parks, Recreation and Natural Areas(PRNA) Plan Update—Statistically Valid Survey—Erica Schmitz
reviewed the highlights of the PRNA update's statistically valid survey results, noting that overall, community
members are satisfied with the parks, recreation and natural areas system (65%), and very few are
unsatisfied (9%). See attached survey memo and PowerPoint Briefing. Board members asked about the
question on safety, and if it was possible to find out the reasons for the answers. The question asked was
about the top priorities for funding. Safety and maintenance were identified as top funding priorities.The
nature of the survey didn't allow for differentiation between those who felt continuing to fund safety was
important versus allocating new resources. One way that safety concerns are being addressed in the
updated plan is through prioritizing park improvements that increase the sense of safety by providing
amenities that draw people to generate a higher level of use and creating or maintaining open sightlines in
parks.The survey,which was sent to 3400 people, resulted in 325 responses and the results confirms what
they heard at the other opportunities of engagement.
Tour of Coulon Projects—Alan Wyatt provided an overview of the structural improvement projects that have
been completed at various locations in the park. Illustrative graphics were furnished to Board Members for
reference of the recently completed projects.The Ivar's deck, Boat Launch, Day Moorage,Sailing Club, and
Trestle Bridge projects received structural improvements. Structural improvements included the replacement
Wheelchair Accessible.American Sign Language(ASL)interpreter available upon request.
For this or other assistance,please call 48 hours in advance:711 (TDD)or 425-430-6600(voice).
Parks Commission Meeting
October 8, 2019
Page 2 of 2
of structural steel and connections, replacement of wood timber decking with light penetration grating and
plastic timber, ungraded electrical service and LED lighting,floatation improvements, and other required
facility upgrades and repairs. Revealed during construction work, extensive deterioration of the foundation
and fasteners and required unforeseen repairs and replacements to the facilities were discovered which
required additional investment and work. In the course of repairing the Trestle Bridge, it was determined that
the Trestle Bridge would require extensive repairs or replacement due to the condition of the existing pilings.
The recognition of capital improvement and maintenance projects and the issuance of the bonds in March of
2019 identified several projects within Coulon Beach Park.A sequencing chart and overview of these
recommended projects on Park Bond and CIP project list was provided to the Park Board. Playground
Equipment Replacement—Renton received a $605,400.00 legislative grant for the replacement of the play
equipment at Coulon Park. Bond projects for consideration include: Swim Beach-erosion of the current
bulkhead will require further investigation and research to determine the scope of repairs. North Water Walk
—meeting the 2028 Department of Natural Resources lease requirement for removal of all wood timber,the
North Water Walk& Picnic Floats are being planned for major improvements including light penetrating
decking, replacement of wood timber with plastic timber, refurbishment of utilities, lighting, and guardrails.
Trestle Bridge—replacement of the existing bridge with a new clear-span (no pilings) bridge similar to the
new Riverview Bridge and an overlook area with interpretive signage. North Bulkhead/Rose Wall-structural
improvements to the North Bulkhead/Rosewall will require further investigation in order to determine the
scope of the repairs or replacement. Parking pavement, shoreline erosion, and irrigation replacement are
anticipated to be scheduled after the bulk of the larger park improvement projects are completed.
8. ADMINISTRATOR'S REPORT
None
9. OLD BUSINESS
None
10. INFORMATION
None
11. ADJOURNMENT
Marlene Winter motioned to adjourn the meeting; motion was seconded, all in favor, motion carried.
Meeting adjourned at 5:51pm.
Minutes oved by:
tt IZ �I� Recorder:
Tim Searing, rd Chair Date Roberta Graver
October 8, 2019
NEXT MTG: 11/12/2019
Wheelchair Accessible.American Sign Language(ASL)interpreter available upon request.
For this or other assistance,please call 48 hours in advance:711 (TDD)or 425-430-6600(voice).
CITY OF RENTON
BOARD OF PARK COMMISSIONERS ;
SIGN-IN SHEET
Tuesday, November 12, 2019, 4:30 pm
At City Hall, 1055 S. Grady Way, Renton 98057
Do you
Name Address Email Phone wish to
speak?
PLEASE PRINT Yes No
z
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
z
R r
y. ;3•
�v
0
fi�
P 4
P.
jr
d
�r
` rr fi�w.a
O � n
W
4--j
/r1 V)
ll N •—
E 4-j
a, O C
Q O V
Q) �
> N
.O c
Q
=3 O
V) � � t�A cu
� > Q
Q � a
+6 � p N
cn O N +I .—
Ln
4—J cu
Q `r' Ln O ca ca
Q 4 N a
V) N cu
a
a,
�- Q •? tvp O ,cn v E
� _
.��, Q Q C,UO N
U O w
O M °
O _ V Cu a
•— �
Q O cn> =3 ja
� r
— +-+
cu
c� O ate-+ V) c O •— (� a-J . � cu
V N C6 ,
� � � " cu
OV) — —0 Vro
N =3 N
S `r' (1) (3) 0 Q
LL J■■A Q i i
Lr) V)
� J i
� U
a � M
� M
n
V
_v v
a 4Z
v t '
v
L
0 � 4—J
L U J c6 c0
co `�
t
U U Y w —
co
a�
a
LU
- w
L
3 �
z 2
U i
r6
ro N
L U
2 O
O
o
Q7 co
io
O �
A
C i
u
f--
armo
eEwaY 2e
a °�
M
•— M
cu cn -� u
Q N
� N
m ro � N O O U
N O O O
O � a) — �
—• —
� U O ^
N N — bn
V c Q U O c �
GC aA Ln m a)
E
a) o v o +� N
u v v + a)
E
� vi v� _ —
CA N +� > N +
L c Q
m N c aJ > 7
GNOME
.- _ Q O _ E
_p -
N >O � N v � 4-1
m O O
N �
� Fu
_ m � ate-.+ •c—�i�
iJ aJ � � N � ,_ � Q
L m O Q Ln
aJ
N
N E
_ N
N � +J N — .N
N L O N p N
,0 0 a) " M p
_ -j a
•LL - > Q DC DC ro � 2 2 L v LL
N 0 V
CT O
� M
a-J >` 4-;
a-J U dJ
C6
=3 4Ln-j � 4�+
O >' O O
E Q
>
O E .E
O — -�
4-' C6 c n
= " E
> L
v �
• Q0 O m 4A
V _ V), 0- c6
•— cn +, J -
s ago0 o 0
CL
N �' •— O 4�
Q •— La Ln
m (L)
L — O L-
.v 4
Ecn C6 cn E QLMM _�
� � � � t�A CAA � � •�
i c6 un > O O4-J OD o o
( E p n � O
O U C6 m •— cam/
Ul C:
V O c z 4J
� i �
� •Cn
h Vf M 0 cn > bn o
a�
c� •`n .— � aJ
E cn O .—
�
� > m n cn oc a
� Q ca V O � Q
J i L O a
4-1
4-4
- n
a�
a�
\ u' Ln
a)
E Ln � •L c6
.— a� E N
>� t�0 O
> InN 4A
Os
U
tn cn o a�
O
LPL c6 c6 � �>, cc •—
Nf tlo ' N v �
Q) m > J
Q) O
_ U — p L >
�••� `� 'E can Q � ate--+ 0
.� Ln
Ln
N � O a�
O OU Ln -0 ( v � O mO O
c6
a--+ L " = : � •cn
p � �' � C6 � � �, � � U
V cr' L U U O .U
Zi m -P Ln Q V) C: a�
° O >- � O E
N Ln 4 ca E c6
o
•� 0 � � +�-+ � � � � � ate--+ � > � ,
N , C= p � � —
\ c6 cn : }; O cj U
O }, m N Ln
N
C6 .—
Ln
Q � a--+ LL m Q E v) L 0
J i 0 N U M
O •=3 =34-1
N C6 rn
41
m4-1 a� •N
4-1O
a-J a--+ ate--+ � U
4-JO •cn .�
4-1
� CAA Q N
•� ca4-1
M > 4—JO
E —
cn U 4-J c6
a� W
+� t�A O C: p
•v a--+ te
ate-+ Q Q a -+
O a� � a�
�
_ cn
ate-+ O �_ �
O
• -0 can O
E
� cn
> •>
p O c6 Q 0 c6
m
LL
o?f
N
Y
i
fC
a
0
a�
I em
? LM
oa
ca
N
o u
� M
OJ a-1 M
NO Q1
o
00
O N
cn ° o
0l u O
c (N
v a
O � rara
�
j o
N •
0� v)
m O
ra
O r
LL
O + M
Z 00.E Ln
O v
� o
N
` � O
v 0� E o o a a
+, -0 -C � s
co +�
O + � � � >- —
� o 0 0 ra
4�j v to
v
Z i O O 4-1
N N O O
° 2
r3- :3 _ Ln
aJ
O c� O L� L
O
Q1 N 0- O Cr O
o
° I
L L L
> � O
O O
O N O oC
O
N O
i
N di U
J i O
z
� U
M
� M
� n
N '
X
v °J
O
� o
_0 o
o Ln Ln Ln
i
0 N
0
O o Ln
aJ U N
i � m
a o
s '
a L �
a)
Ln
o
Na
00
0
n
i J � p a
V v 1 m
LL
a E Ln
o •
v
o
o
cn O N O Gl
O +�+
U N •�
N LnLn
n L s
p O Q to
4L 0-
O
L oLn
v O
Ln
Ln v �° o
L o
c� o o L
O U
L O N L O
8
O O 4-
/► 0 s oc
O
� o
Q cn i 4_
0 � a' U
J i O "
� z
41 j U
� M
� M
OJ N
QJ
o °
o
� o
a
� N
o, v O
O u o
v
� a
•� � 00.1 •� � o
• un 01 N
� a �
un Qj
°' ;, o o f L
a U m, o o a
a� f Q0 m
O `ti E
L
a � �
N QJ i cn Q)
p +
O °1 Ln
p E E -'• Ln
OJ ° U O O N i
� U N
QJ 4-- O i
U cc
L 41
v L Q N O ' G
O N QJ � +� cn i O
L N L / L
Q 1 fB 0 L
O +, N
i N Q O 4�
LL
v E w O s —
E V) O
O 4�
L a_'
0 m U
ON ON ON ON ON ON ON ON ON ON ON ON ON ON
L O 00 O O Ol r-i Ln m 00 r1 r-i OI�t o N
a 00 r- r- r- d m N m m N N N r1 r1 4�
� U
M
L M
O o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 \ M
lD 00 dl m N Ln 00 m Dl m Ln N It* r1 Ln
V r- Ln Ln m m N r1 r1 r1 ri r1 r1 r1 r1
i.r
L
lD M m Ln Ln 00 M O lD o o m o 0
(n lD Ln ma) r1 N N N 00 dl r-i O1 lD
v
a 00 0 0 0 0 0000 0 00 0 0
O r1 N O Ol Ln r1 oo lD Zt Ln rl N
i.r I, lD Ln m m N r-i r1 r1 r1 r-i r1
v 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
O lD N 00 r1 r1 Il I�t r- O r1 I- O Ln
v a Ql lD �t Cn m m r1 r1 r1 N N r1 r1 r1
o �
0 0 0 0000 0 00 0 0
Q 1 = Ln Ln I- O Ln I- I" m Ol ri O Ln r-i w m
i.r r- Ln Ln m r1 r-i r1 r1 r1 r-i r1 r1
�► o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
I- T* 00 lD Ln 00 O 01 Ln m lD
i A; • Ln Ln Ln m m r-i N r1 r1 r-i r-i .�
a o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 +O
+
a N lD r-i � m Ln O lD o '00, 0 0
Ln m N r-ir-ir-iM Ln r-i N lD I� M i
L
o 0 0 o 0 0 0 0 0 O'o, 0 0 0 0
v r • 00 00
W lD Ln OCn N r-irH r1 r1 r1 r-ir�-I Y
L a Ln CL
C
Lr) to o
00 0 0 0 0 0000 0 00 0 NO vi
v •— Dl O Cn dl lD rl N Ln m O r M r-i O
N I, lD lD I�t I�t N N N N N r-i
v
a o 00 0 0 0 0 0000 0 0, 0
oo Ln 00 N m rn 00 a) r- N T* 00 00 r-ir- 00 °
L v lD Ln T* m m r1 r1 r1 r1 r1 r1 r1 3
O
o
0 0 0 0 0000 0 0 0, 0 0
I" O O I- r- � 00 r- 00 Cn lD lD r-iLn s
O w lD T* m N r1 ri ri N r-i r-i r-i
O
O � �
O o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Nolo 0 Nolo Nolo Noloo 0 41
c
O N 00 � 00 � r-i 00 00 I- lD Ln N O
t I- Ln Ln Cn Cn N ri r1 r1 r1 r-i r-i r-i
•
O E
v a1 OO � co co L Mcu
y
L O L C ro v Q OL Oro O
-C aCJ
O Y v +1 ca L ro � CO v 0 ++
O 3j C >• -0L D' ,} L t 4- L a O M
L
iro
• `�OOOJ L }O O Q ro > fo U N �
r_3 a�
bLO x C
QU >` Q >` QO Co (u • +- C
a � ( + `O 04 C ° 4r_a ZT a O °o O OO C0 .
} Q O c>, o 0a, M o
vCO o c C � v o� O .
ra ro (U ro- W f1 TT , nl to a"'I •� L N 41 V n�
i
Q
fC
L
z
W
0
(L)
I em
? LM
J i v 0
U
M M
N � �
a x
v CU
O
a �
a �
v
a �
o
a o
N
N
� N
i
O
U
VI
o o rr
00
� N �
O o
S N
� Y
L
cn Q-
4J 4+
4
+ ra
a� o
Y! ro a
E �
+, ro o
cc+ O s
Or-I c�
� o a
4- ai
Ln
� — Ln L ar
0
s O o
a �
c
O O O L
o
v E' o
� � N
a 0 1=
v
a � �
m U
v M
_a M
M
a l°\p o0\l
L Ln
00
a
o
a
a o
Ln
a o 0
o
_ o
Ln
vi
00
Lm a }
v a Q o `°
a L
or1i
Ln Ln
o ,nto
> lqt
�.
- v
Ln
Ln
100,
v
v
41 o s
w (Z Ln *'
rJ
0
OJ \ \ `^
0 0 ++
lD a) O O
o � Ln G1
T n
N E i
L
Y ro _ L
a v O C
roL O 4+
cu
Q r N O O
Q�1 �O N y en
a co c v OD
c coo 4 O Q.
O c O4-1 C
.� O 1
01 c a y o =
4
O c M 4
N U.
. Y di U
o a
' W+
fC
i
0 E
(1) C
em
F I? LM
N
O
a
o � z
� � U
� M
� � M
O a N
N
a
Q U O N
� � o
O U N
T*
i v �
v
>11
0
a - N
v a v
U � i
O O O
O
N N
U c _ o
O oa
v v
c
O N
a
aU m
L v —
p
Q1 O N 801
�
L a v M L
o
� U � °dam. �
c� to
U Q1 N Y
om
4-
i O o a
O v N 4+
v v
O Ol o
O O i11 Lr) o v
S 8111
f0
o O N s
Qj + :f: C1A t1A
Qj + cB co v
O N dJ C1A U co
O `� O V) to = �O O 41
L }' i i N O O
O j O O > U N
O � LL
4- fB + M i
U �, N Co +-+
O N N i p ++
�
a cB c6 > O O
U
O i C6 = GJ O
t10 O
Q� O O i
4- N o o z o c
ZZ v —
U O D O
L ++
J i p O
•i, z
M
M
en
� n
V X
N
V O
v
a � F
3
o N F
v o o F
a � F
000
F
v o L o
00
a w
L
a�
Lm O a E o
wV +�
v
v v Y
O O `� a
Ln
0� Ln
E
rn
1
Ln O 00
� •3
N
a E � N N
O E o
- O +
QJ N 0 N N O 41 41
Q Q O O
0 GJ
OLn O w E E Ln
ai
M VI
L L
O 0 U O } O
O 0 O O
U Q O L
Cr
N j i •a N 0
L fB N Q a V) fB L
i � m O 4- O
N
u mLL
3 a�i
a� c�
0
O O
Q } Q - a--+ N L U a�
L ON ON 0N ON ON 0N ON 8< 0 0 0 0
L L c-I Ol M lD lD M M rl Ln lD Ln
m rl rl rl rl N rl rl rl rl rl ++
v v
4-1L M
00 L m
lD Ln N o N rl o o N o o
N r-I r-I r-I r-I dl I� � dl Ol
� O �
a►i 00 0 0 0 0 o 0 0 0 o L
L' C 00 I� lD lD V
v
� O
� O
4-j 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o o p0[
v N O� �N-I �N-I lD 00 Ln 00 r-I Ln M M C
� v u
o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 41
O V) O rn � a) a) cn Ln rn � cn U
N � � rn rn m Ln m N m N H
O p +_
S O O O O O O O O O O O E
a +., � o0 00 00 � oo n oo n Ln m
a m
+. O 0 O O O O o 0 O 0 ;
a lD N N rH O O O 00 N 00 a) 00 -
41 v L N rl rl rl rl rl rl 00 r-I 00 Ql 00
L m
H O
v
p a L o L 0 0 o o ^ o 0 0 0
v N N r-I rl O M c-I rl rl O L
O1 4-1 4 L T� L
p \ o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 m
0 o O
lD M
i LnLn \N m � � Ln Lrn M c» lD cn Ln to V,
a Z .a a
� � N
QJ a 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 of
a) Ln lD 00 �t M rl lD Ol r-I dl r
zS C N rl rl rl rl rl rl c-I a.+
a v Qj u
LV a aIn 00- 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o
0N � oo L m oo O
N rl rl O a►, �' 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
a�
kn
- v
f0
v o 0 0 o o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 `
p 41 � N N rl O Ol n lD Ln
� • N rl rl rl rl �
a
s v m
O o c o In .�
j � .� N LO (Lo (o � E L
U O
•I_+ Off[ vl 0 E ra O
v v N v o +� L O N �•
N Q O L
a + I O co L L
N a O Y L c ro v a o c o ° W n o ni
+�
v c c +, = Y + Y L w c c- u c o0
L (o p v
. vp> � Co L
3
O
o u 4- - 0 In
OO NCL QuN
O O " qO O V >> p (o Co fo � Ln
O
Of OC
L c l6 c u N Co O 4O
hAro
� Q � � 0 O � LOLoL _ c � � � �
L
f� N 4 TOS � O m ro - n l AJ n
is >
N i
� N
�Lm
i �
3
O
u
W
em
F I? LM
_ � I tN
� J i O � u
q M
Q.1 .v M
o
o
v a
v
Q)
� v
cr
a m
°
a m
�
i o m
v V o
� O
m
W a �
1 �
v E
Oo
L 0 3
0l Q a
a
o
O u) o o
0� v m o o
m m
Q frl N N N N o ++
Q N
0 6l
rl o
O
V� o, ■ o
a Q
u NY C
-
i
+ O
> B B Ln
Q L Ln
O • CL
} �O co Y p L 6 +� L O m
1►+ Q > L L 'v N Q N cn O ILO E +� O u +,
v v -- L L E
n C ++ N N um N Ln L N 'x Ln p
A O bn
C i i +J n Q N ^ O bz 3
} } N m O N N O O O N L C
p L \ •In p L �` Q •L ++
O v O LJ C _0 _0 " N N N O �•
Ln
> V L +" L Q O
I►J i- 'c6 O 4- > (� L N +J i
O J Q E m ° Q- m v
U L Q) Q L p U V
v, 'E v
Ln
) ° ) O O N 3
L
L 3
° cn m
a Q > v
O s
a, 4-j m
Q
401
401
oa
401
x
W
fC
i
G1
0
I em
? LM
o 0 0 0 0 10R, o 0 o M
++I l0 l0 O Ql M M Ln Ln
Q m w w lQ w w P% w w l0Ln
M
a O
un N
U
(B o
M
cB o M
O ^ o
z N fV N
CLv
i
N
O
L
O U �
�
V) o o O
00
:_ v m
a )
U �
a
o
a
L fB c,7
N L
!-
N Y
E
CL
+ Q
W :: E
-F 0
v-
�■■+ � � o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 �
Ln I'o Ln Ln o 00 00 lzt o
> If) N N M re) N >
O
� al I:zj- +
E 00 0 `° � c0 Lr) a ni
Ql O Ln O
N +=
Q1 i 3 Q
z z c 0
L
A \ C,
m ++ w M N CO w l0 M N M M
col l0 w w w w w w w w I� M
a cn
a v �
o
a--+ I I
fu
m L.0
v ^ N Ln
N N N ° N N �
z
N
N N
II a ■
a
pII v N
■
L
0 0
a o R a) � m
m
a m
a
v 0
N41
p V
N i
• a '�
vi
CL
_v x - - 0
Ln
N a 0
v o Lnr-1 u) rn � rnry) r- (.00 0
Lr) cn V) L L
c
V v ++
a Q N N O
+�+ 0 3
V) w 4 , 0 E
L ate, =3 0 0
0 v 0 z
L a O
o -
w •
J L . CD M M M N N N
v
v v u
� en
+- M
4 a C en+.,
Q O-0 O
C L Y
Ln
13
O s C6 ro
Q Ca r-I
O O Q O N (\0 -0aJ
coN t1A 1 ro C of L cn
V C cu ca ca `~ E O C
ca a O Q O O E aJ
1 ro L ° E
N v — 0 C nA o v v ca v E
L O C ca co C O
v Ca C6 (A
C U ro rco: a i 0 " N O
a�.+ • N Oro a1 C L ro ro Q U m V N
v co N o a O O N
V N bz Q tin W O
v o N .� o tin o ro ,� °
C C M c 0 -0 Q - v L
v > a1 0 O co a L aJ `^ " a1
cr v qp o 0 o n _� C o ,� o _�
• L +� l6 u Y O
4-1 � � 0 2 o Z O U E Z � 4- d U a E O
LnMO
-'
v L
o 0 0 0
6-1 N 1�
Ln LnLn
■
V
v o 0 0 0
M N N
Ln
W � = N
v ,_,
v
t o +�
o � E N
° a 0
4-j °�' 0 N bD m
OH co ° a o
O a H a Ln r
0 � � • +1
V svVW 0a sL�• • aj E N
va
Q4-1 � �O O
(U � -
-a v � v v co Ln
O O 4- O ca
4-1
•O Ln - ma. oLn
4-1
�
a, 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
L 00 l�D r i o0 F, lD Ln Ln �* N
4 4-j
N a v
� s o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
�►+ a) 00 lD lzt M M M N N r-I
to
M1•
4-1 r_
v °
4-1a nA s
ca tip
+�
,a^ o N O L
v' a, L �°
+., b o
ca C L v,
a N u0A C C in O
N
QJ Q1 co 0 O ro C Q i
• - C O tuD p L
O • C C C L U
w 3-n
(6 +' -R — O O Y N c0 I j,
f0 rl r-i qT en LM P% 00 P% M
o t/fI w w lG Ln l0 N Ln Ln W M
� H n
Q o
v p
L � N
4-J
i
O +-�
O
O O
� � z o
bL Z- m
V � i
N
W_ ■ 0
o
a 3 vi w
ru
Ln
L
r 0 to
Z p i
O Ln
v p i m
Q � S
w vi 0
o
s � N
v
-_4-1 N
3 w C
'M C s
X ,� o
a wl
aL
� p � ® a
•� N o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
� wL11 Ll1 O Oo 00 �
� � N I:zj- lzt L11 N N M M N �
L m Rt + s
N N lD I_f) a--' a--' ++
Co O W =5 m N +s+ M
O Ln N 3 OD
O v i � o Q.
•� z O > c
Q1 z L o
a � Qj
4 a)
� a)
f0 �i M
V�I l0 w LA W l0 w Ln w Ln w
.Un
� ® ri
QJ Q c •.
V 4 N
o
N o
a v O z o N
00
N o
O a"' m o
v a i
cv
Z m m N
O },
z 0 MO - � o
v
M +_+ z E
O — 4'
i 4-0
(A
0 -Cc' o O � m r14
0
i a �•
o
.0
v � 0
� o
Ln 3
cn L
Ln O x .. .. o
w .
Ln
CL
OD
c� a
N o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
N
O i 0 N N N � � s
CU3
O U o
•� }
w
a o
0 0 0 0 0 0 0
O H N cal Ln Ln Ln
��+ M
a �
o
O N
L �. N
a a ■
a UI �
i O
V
� O M1.
— z
a U m o
un o E
0�1 0000 4;
co rn
v N L
L"' � i N
m O
N
v
v 0� (U
_ Lu u
Ln
CL
a w
• N
N i cB N of O
Ln
{� Q N V O +u
0tio
v + NCL
N N } N p d0
O 0 +� O +� ;+- O
_ c� c�
Ql 0 N U N s
fB
O c� vi O s
N d) vi i O a
.� 0 o N o
O
� O °, i m u
> L
.w
a — m
O n I n n Ln Ln Ln �A �A U
� (� M
en
� o
a _
c�
N
O
� Q
o E o
— o
v
L N
0� O
� z
0-01
O
N o`- m L
-Q; L.- can
O O �•
a � N
•— o
v
0 3
a O N m x
O
� ,v z a,
s
a O
� o
E
O � N cv \ �
v o o
N m
W L
L Q o
v O L Q
M +1
�j O Z c�
i O
CL
1
4� s
� ca +�
Ol N L
a►+ i . v O
X
� W
O Y o
a +=
� va� ai
0 a o
0
o n 0 ° "0
O OLn
LnO O — Q' E
O .3
Ln 4,
•� —
— O c� O c� '� O co O
0 }, N N ++ s
N c tzo i cn U — 4;
u c� ai
QJ U a) � �
L.- N � � M x 0 -0
O O M
OJ Q c� U N N O O = Q
O U — O O_
Ln
0 cn 0 Q 0 O
4
Ln U
a" M
G�1 M
� M
h n
Q1
r-I
N
a.7upjjodwl JsagbiH a3uajaodwi JsaM07
N
0
U
a
tn
v
3
0
i v � — i v a
O, -73 p z p 0, i 0, O — v O
i
C ] N j S O O j
W v �
� 4Jv
aO o o, C o, +� O
a
z -Q vLn
Qj
I a o, o .� o, o a, 'n �' C i Q- v CL
U N cn O as., '4", i iS, i S U ' 0Q, a
i Q-jO 4- S a 0, a L 0, p i O
a 4- N rU 4- U Ln 0, p 4, ,
In QJ CC
a
° 4- aa a oo v ° - Wo v xo o
a- 4 4- 0 Ln a u aQj � o', Ln v .a a °�' c v
Q o = a � S p
�. a, +� o,
0, j 0, 2 C L 0, r- 0 0 cn Z3 4- Qj ��,
h U
+. M
O M
to ^ ^ M
C
L L 4—
C a1 = O O O .'n cn
Q Q ++ a- '+
fa
(6 i .E E N
_ _ _
_N O - cn
U Q N (6 � 4.1
N c6
E V1 c6
c6 • 41 O
41 O GJ X z 01 j z
w
ro
I Ln
Ln
ro
L Y
� L
� Q
O ,}
L
N E
N
u Z
U
Q
C6
N
a3uaodwi jsagbiH j a3uopodwi jsam07
E
E in
L to
� � v
o • ca
_CL ca • ro
L
>
�i (B
N O
L
U a
Qi _
N
QU
U
U
Q
N N
C: C:
O O
a-J �--+
L) a-J
•� U V
N N
N x Q
C
X
N W W O
O N N ra
Q a)
cu U E
C
O C W O
U
Q� a) 06
a U U
2 �
i E E 3
v
S U
'�►+ M
4�j M
n
t� Q1
v
Qu
L -Z i ri 0) 00 O 00 N Ln
ON N r-I N
L p
O a''
O �
v a
N
m
V .~ v m 00
Ln i o o ^ o\' Lrn
Rt
� o
Z � a)
r
0 p �
v N
o
�,
LO
m Lr) o r..
o
Ln
a �
� (Lr) o O 8— 5.O •— 'o
Ln
i
L
0 v G
•� O L Oy
GJ a
L �
}i
m O L
U Vf
•� v m
CL ° *'
p� CC °
L■ W O °+�
U O (D E o0 6
— 0j m > o r--i Ln O (U
cn O V) a W
O L O
0
z
� � z �
0 O ~ 0
4 �° a
J CL
as
OD
li _ ° o a
ON 0
a ro E o c
U
QJ M
L M
v
U
i rl rl rl N 00 ri 00 M M M
� Q
O H
m
L
o a
o
L.- i r" o
N
o
401 00
LM i Q0
O a 1-0
ol
N
v o
-1►+ � 00 M1.
L Lf) O
N o 0 0 0 °
N M N
O o o
o 0: +_+
00L
U d .°
m i
Q
4.0
O
O aJ `^ v
•2 ai o
O O G! ° Q-
V O o
u
L S
O
v O L
N
v s �;
a L mO
• i m C �+
O Q ° +�
vi
j � r
v O s o
S.■ i 4
a > Q u � � O o
of O v�i can m m O ai s
a W
GJ LU tw
ca
0 O ~ z 3 �
C, O
CL
4-0
4-1
_ 3 3
v
S a,
Q `a
0� N o
u
0 0 � �
-AL—A
S U
M
M
I�
O
4J
cu
V Q GJ r-I rl r-I N
Q �
m 41 j
tn
MW w
LM
O
M
•Ln o\' L o
. O
Lo
U o 00
Q � Ln Ln LO
I11 Ln
Ln Ln Ln
00 No,
O � o
L a i
V1-0
•� 4� L tin
a V to 4•
U v, y
• EE 2 'F
•� � O s o �
r
CL
•� v W o
U = c rn + * E
i ca v (U k.o �n � +� +� 0 3
v v C0 0 1O �
> O rl Ln O o
O N as
° t �
Ea z z
O
O O o a,
4,
V `' `°
4� as
4-j 4s ni
a 3 0 06 to
O � > �° a
OJ o
4 �V N a)
E
v N ws �
_ — —
v
L U
M
Q �
L
O OJ i rl n N O N 1-
V
Q 0
�ILM
v
a
O
s O
00
U
aLn 00
'n \' Ln
v a Ln o o L Ln
Ln Ln
u' 'n "m1.10
O ,n
o � o
0 v GJ a m It 0
d
•� � Q L � � N o � �
O d cr) o
V a o "' °° O
((►► Ln a
i •O M +� L
O u
U_ v, �
•� '�
L
a m 0
O 2
}a I.- u
V L
i O
v C.
•� ) o
•� > Q .0 L L
� v�i v�i cB cB O
z =
a O 0 � �° �
_ CL
O 406 as
0 s
a O = � 3 c
} O = -
0� ra = O ,o
V O
Q
v m c
N s
m
LL
o2S
N
Y
i
fC
om
L
0
401
�L
0
9L
om
V) • U
� - M
v -
i O
� v o
V)
o a, N o
i nE N
Ln
N
a)
00
aJ
Ln
0 0
Lr)
Ln 0
O
0
o o
0
C a
o
v o
O' °' _
o o N
a �
In aQj : �• Y
a C.
— — Of
CS
t o
o _ u —
m0
4-, D � s
O 4-j o14-
Qn N > o
O �
E
i o
O ° of
� �
� i o
N�
i Q � 4' E
p >
o a
v
Ln
• a� 4 4 E
O Q 47- C: s m rZ
Y L
U coif U U - M14+
Qj Iv VI fB aJ O
QJ aJ N +� ° f6 } L o Ov
C, } J
4-1 � � x a)� o � � � � � � 0 0
Q) i aJ � N w +-, Q lZA svf
U aJ � N Y a
a o +� aJ +, +, CU
QJ QJ i OU N O >' Q (A � G1
QJ N m � OC
f6 C1A Q W N o Y
_ aJ _
+ +'
O N •. � U
� � n
O 0 '
N
Ln
Ln
N
S
00 0
Ln
0
C.
z
v � o
� 0 0
v� a�
v .v
L
jV)
L
Ln a
v +� E w
v � s
6l
fC O
O 0 O 4+
41 •. N O
N •� > G1
v .
0 .. O
a
N
4�
(U
o
' E
� tn
� o =
Ln lj p Ln vI Ln Ln V Y
In w
O Q O — 3 o 9
N v Ln E c 0 0
i N m E Lno a, s o 0
+-' X x O O O O O
°J u ao u
C: a
cn
u oc O a � oc
a,
L C a
V) •• •• U
> M
p
Lm
O
O Q1 0
O
V)
V)
O �
� N
O S
•� a
a z
� o
v p 01) o o
4�j o cv o
00 rn a
4�j Q- Q0
Ln O
OJ O 1-0
00
z
� O � Lr) cu
} a
O o
� +�
o �
v � L
N N td
� Y
Q
L w to
> s o
i u o
O a)
a 0 s
a o
V) >
Q o
N O
j E c S
N O
N O O
• o �
J >
o a
V
•� `~ c� N N U O Y L
cn p > N i p +-'
OJ Q + O O o >
V) C6 � � C]A Q i O u ,S
Cn � -
� � 0- rZ O N 3
0O O cn 0 u s Or s
O O ° - M ° o
•� V) tDLO
o
2 .. M r 4-
J Q 0 o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ..
�i r r-I O lD r-I 00 O O d' M N >%
lD I- lD Ln Ln lD lD lD � lD m m 4+
y
� � U
QJ
Len
QJ m
4-+ >C o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 01.01 N M
Qj L \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ O n
I- lD I" N M O 00 I- N I�t lD O >
lD lD Ln Ln It It It* m MQj Ln
�..1
0 � O • �
o 0
0
O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
N M In Ln In O Ln N O �t 00 Ln
0 lD qt lD u1 I�t N C
4 O 4�
vv
L.
3 4J o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
\ Y
��, rl qt 00 r-i N O lD q t Ln In Ln C
\ M � � � M M M M N N s
Z v i r� Ln 4�
rMLv
4-1
O O
QJ Q1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 �
O 4-) lD M rr) u1 � n M c n O Il lD
U 00 Ln I�t Ln Ln I�t t 4 Ln �t N N 3
L a, 4.jo x
Ob4o .� o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
s a
m m dl m O r- D> 00 O O O O a)
Q1 l0 Ln M M M M M M
O Qj j 4 Q.
.� 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Ln O M In N lD M m N O lD Ol 00 � u
• l0 Ln Ln M M M N M M
Qj
1 O
Qj x }+
iJ L- 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o i
r-I lD Ln N O 00 u1 rl I;t It* a) n
lD M M M N M N r i r-I
L
a Q, a
L to
1.01 0 0 0Nolo 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Ln U rn m rn oo o r-1 oo un m o -td
L
4J > lD Ln rn cn c» M cn cn M N to
� v a
Ln rz Qj ELn
_
La, 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3
5 N cn N O O rn I�t I�t lD * 00 am s o
In m m M C
S
�■■� v a
Qj
t o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
3 I� lD M r i Ol 00 O O N r1 N Ln >
I� lD t Ln M M M r_ Gl
4-1
O p
t o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O
Ln Q) = l9t m r1 m N N In N In I�t In O 4�
Ln Ln E
�i/ 4—
O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 W >
Ln 00 n Ln Ln Ln M N O 00 lD N O O a
• lD Lr) M cn cn M
a O7 _
� Y
Ln >-
QJ S 3 L c6 Y L
QJ a) N N
a--
Qj
O Q� Ln v -O D Ln v W In
v }' � co c }; v c0 O u
O ro c c to c Y
4-+ O x 4 1 > c0 c O O
�.4 4� � L � � g � ro t c c- 'u 0 Q � s � co
a Q � +- N �O c0 cn > c Y O Q
c0 c0 O C
U cB - _0 +� cL6LL O N c0 Qj
L Gl
v c� c + c zs x c L ca c
U to L c co A N N c N L N _ O _N O
i O ul Obz
a� : O
• S QJ OL a N c u pp cn >,
Q m I- tw -7p cc c ca O *'
V ON ON ON ON ON ON ON ON ON ON ON O ..
Ln O Ln rnI�D In In r- m m 00 rn >,
Ln M N N M N N N M M N rH ++
U
M
�`• M
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 01.01 M
L \ 0 \ 0 \ \ \ \ \ \ \ y n
a Ln oo M D> Ln O 00 Ln �t N I�t I�t >
^ M M M N N m r1 N N N N N a i..�
0
o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 s
a 00 M rl dl Ln N It* 00 N 00 O I�t
m I�t N rI M N N N N r1 M N C
O c
V a
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0� 0 Y., N I, Ln O r- lD M Ln 00 O Ln 0000 C
v N r1 N N r1 r1 N r1 r1 N r1 S
0
o 0 0 0 0NoloNolo 0 0 0 0Nolo
rML N I�t O M N Ln T* I�t M N O I�t -0
M N M M N N N rl M N N N
3
O =
O
a 0 0 0 Nolo 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
v � o � 00 00 � r- o � � � oo � �
rv` • M N N r1 N r1 N N r1 N r1 —i 0,v a L
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
�v O lD Ln Ln N M l Ln Ln r1 T* I- 00 D t�
' N M N N N N N N r1 r1 N r1 m
a N
o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o al
I" D> I�t M lD I- d> M Ln N N V
4-1 cu
L
o
N o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
e'n M Ln Ln I, Ln Ln r, n r, Ln 00 L
aN M N r� r� r� r1 r1 r1 r� rl ri mQ
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o 3
lD rn m 00 n lD n M m I�t N 00 Z
O M N N N N N N N N N N c-I CO
o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0100, 0 0
ca, O
I- lD O r1 00 r1 lD lD N I- Dl I�t >
N N M N ri N N N N ri rl rl al
O
•� o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0100, O
0 0 0 0 Ol Ol OR Ol � � s
M O r" r- r" N r" r" 00 lD O rn
M M N N N N ri rl rl N N rl
O O
a 4' 1
Q o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o >
m 00 I- M M N r1 r1 r l O O lD O a
v • N N N N N N N N N N N r1
O
(U
Y
NO C Y ar
U L a L S
C N 5 Y a v C � N L o 0 o
•F..� (6 Y +� ro O U U L 4O C >
(UL U Q ocinU O v M
ra C6 C6
v ra C O �, m N N - i
{.� C C w QJ L +' a Q1 = O Y Q-
i a) aJ Lu C U C6 L Q O O O C
O Ln _L N O N p `^ U L f6 fLC ++ O
• wo C aJ �, L O a L N Li' O (n Q >,
� U
ice+ •� o 0 0 0 0 o o o 0 0 0 0 0 0 OR M
�► �► N Ln O Ol N N rH O m 00 r- m O lD rH m
N N m N N N rV N N N m rl N n
o v
o a
o
� o
V o 0 0 0 0 0 o 0 0 0 0 0 0
(n T� N 00 I�t 00 qzt r1 00 00 I� lD Ln N O
r*, Ln Ln m m N rH r l r i r i r i r-I rH
v a aj co
a
t o
'v ra
a v ° VI
a v t ;
a � •=' � o
tn
v W W L O
L C ra
a1 = CL
c � a'
ci
L L QU
O 0 � Q cvo t
Q 1 O O `n C r6 N L dA +'
f�^ Y p (U v Y N O O Y
Q1 V v O O ra N > U O +s+
Y W '. � �n ro � u c c L u o �
+1 to N L p N Z O
O ro ra w
ro L v o o a •° v o 3 a � 3
+� a Y u c E tin ro Q ,- O
(n N r6 O J N a L v�cu ° S
i.r L tUD •� M p 0 c C p
aJ C Q Q N a O ra i
v O C ra tUD LnN L 4J c
G
O r6 O in ro ra �n + N E ro G1
ro 0
Y >. rraa o v o v c af°i
a Y L ro O ra o u +, u _ a
Q 1 ra CL -0Q ra _ra Q +' C +, ro O
c ro> O ra tn O D_ D_ QJ +' L
Q1 Ln Q v > ro +' ra E v ^_! C6 O of
> ro oC C O O v 0 E �
•V N ra Q O ra LU O § °
V D N O Q ~ + �
V� a •`-' N �' 0 L
ra
u O
01 rya ro �
o C .0
a ra u O
a C 3
cn :3 O ++
i � s
� M
i
a
L
z
i
O
w
O
em
F I?
O
N M
Q1
o
O
� N
a
v •kn °J
0
O •� N m
4 > o
O � m
N , z
a �
L v a m
0 3
+-, O o
cn U �
a C
O
U
4=101 s
L � � _0 O
Q � O v�
' 41
E
O •� -o c� bA -o V Y
Ln
•�►+ .{� C N C C L � f6
L v Q +21kn
c 0 3 c
Q N v u o 0
O N 3
v v N
Q- L X i W S O
c N L O 7 6
a- — 0 O O a- Y ++
S c6 L co C i O >
Q 4- 0- 0 �, O >, L S
L Q N co X u co 4- 0
Q
L
co Q) Q) �
co O L N O
`� 4 Q >• 0
ON
ON ON
J i y1 0 �t 0 m �,
O d 4�
Q 0
O M
M
em
1.01 N L O O �n N M
Q lD Ln I�t
r •
O
o 0 0 0 0
O L Ln M O m rl
Q.1 � � Lnm d'
Lm
o 0 0 0 0
Q Ln Ln d' I�t m
v
i 0 0 0 0 0
a Ln r- r- Ln Q0
a O
a 00 o Nolo 00 a) 0
vIn lD � M M �,
a O
D a 0 0 0 0 0 0
Ln
O Ln I N
a a
� O 0 0 0 00 r14
0 0 a
•v 0 0)
L
m
O k �
OJ Ol Ln 010,
Ln000 .01 L
4-1 110 L m m
•� 3 lZ Ln 100, o1010
s
o
Op '• Ln Ln Ln u, mE c
41 v c 0 0 0 0 0 a o
O °�n° Ln m � ai
'� 0
V)
o
0 0 0 100,
0 s S
O
S ^ lD u1 u1 Ln p GOl
+ 41
N
0 0 0 0 0 a
00 N lD rl 00 O a
- Ln Ln d m V C
dA
Q Y
Q 1 (6 bA S E
N (6 ++
cT5 C6 Y L 41
(II
OQ ra C co U O O
Q tw c
L Ln L 0 M
01 °J L, Ln v o c
a� v T �, 3 so D s u r.. a
Ln co v a L o o w p N c
ro
O c
N i
7 p N
co x O O '�
L Q U C 'E wco
i aJ Qj c v — N a O O O
O Q 0
a o o +•'
4�+ M
M
Q1
.j
a
v
. Ln vn
O
E
to
m
ma)
O
r
v a 0
M
VI r
CA L o
O CL m ai
m
a V,, o
O _
N ' U
Z) v G1
cB � to s
v O Y
c�
a 0 3 s
cc N 0
C ° >.
7t 0 s
— C O
•1►, cc N Y
v M
M i
A 0 O °v
r/ ) Q) -, m
m
_ — a
4 E
m w
o c� H
c�
O o
> o
/V�/` aj
O � L
4-
0 0
3
m a'' s a
1 L
r^ 4 y
v, 4J
o a
' W+
fC
i
(L) C
%0 E
N fC
L
� O
�L L
em
F I? LM
o a
�L
a
vNi M
� Q1
N
>
i
O.J
o
O '1'
z `n o 0
O o
O �
vro
v V)
v
v
L v
4�j v
a O
4
Oj O
O �
O
v
o
O c�
O O �, Q Z
O c� t o
O N LU
ra
U LL,
4J O
N >Ca z a aN+ +'
`� f6 O O
Q
Q �
=3 U U fB `1 VI
N N i s N p O
}, >• O p fB i to .1 _ +- t
O N Czp O O N a
> Z U O
0-
0 i O O E Q
s C m r, 0 0 a
v N M
N
Lm
O 4�, N
O —
b v
i
i-'
> =5
o
Q0 o
O Q0
in
a
L 4�j
a�
s
v
N o s
o
s
N tLo Y
L — tLo U tLo f6
Q Q
aN+ 3
N ON O O
i O Q
47-
O � N
O : '�� �O0
Q
m v > N
N N a + fC
__I-z O � •� Q N
hf1 CL
a
J L ON ON o 0 0 0 0' o 0 0 0 0
M M ri O 00 Ql Ln r-I r-I Dl O r\
Ln M M Ln N d' ri M N N ri 4�
v v u
S ° M
M
0 0
cm0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o
S I.i O Ln 00 Ln lD 00 N i- ro lD �* N
Ln M m m Cn m N m N N N i..�
Q a •
v 4-2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
M O O 00 O lD r" 00 ( 1 � Dl
i Ln Ln It m m N ri N N N ri
� a
° 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
O ° lD r- m n O Ln I�t O Ln lD m rn
v M M N M N N N ri ri ri
O O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
V Ln ItIt M It m N N N ri N ri
a ° •
4-1
1.
4
o 0 0 0 0 0N O 0 0 0 0 0 0
lD a m Ol m N 01 m rn ri m � N� N M N N N N N r-I r-I
v s v
+-1
V0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
a a O . lD d> Ln N Ln lD lD lD ro N N r,
I�t M Cn ro N N N N N N ri ri
� v
O O 100,
O OR
O O O O O O 100,
o
1 > m N N N � m m N � � � l�D
L v a N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
ri I�t M Ln lD 00 I- O lD lD lD
4-1 v Ln I�t M M m r I N N ri ri ri
Ln
N
o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 +'
a N N r-I O lD M Ol Ln 00 lD Ln lD t
Ln I�t It It m m ri N N fV ri ri u
4-1
v Qa! Ln C o 0 100, o 1010, 0 0 0 0 0 0
'^
• I- N ri N N Ln Ln lD O lD O m >
•� a � � M M N N N r-I r-i ri r-I �
o 1800 0 0 0 1.01 0 0 0
m Ln r- Ql rn lD I�t m ri ri lD m
a M Cn m m m N N M N ri ri
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
00 00 lD Ln N D> lD q�* m ri lD Ln 0
j • m m m m N N N N N ri ri
QL
v/ • ao Q) L L! ° > Z C �O O N Y
+v.+ +.+ 1 O Q L N vi u
^ U U LU
aA L of NC V
O L r0 C O C L k
a cn (U — ro
ro E 0
L r6 Ln >, N [6 0
- o o � o L v L 3 o u nn v
-� o E ro = o �; Q o 3
+ ro " u Y rba 4„ Q E ra Q to 0 ao
Ln aro v L I N QJ U (U E c E L c w S Q
ra
ao O U i a--� i 0
Y C
v v *' ro c t c- o v n v O
i > a O O 0 a>, ro E �' +� a�i
v >
v L 0- -5- 2 - :� ca + 0
o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
a00 00 lD N Ln O> lD -�t c-I lD Ln M U
' M M M �i N N N N r-I c'M N M
en
,U M
L Q1
a
0 0 ' 0 0 O O O O O 0
N N r- s
I� I O
rn
.� • N rl rl rl rl Vf
v
v
a
m
v ° �
V
m
o �
v a m
M o tn
r•
4Q Y c
V) 1- O
v V C Q. �
Q 1 O 4'
o
>.
c
E
v cu ° E m
Na, � E ra
v L Ora
C
v o _ n 0 3 c
> > " > � � E aJ N O o n o
L v v O v ra ca ca +� Q o
a N L - �' a L N u v o ,� o
L N -C O O N
O
C O > Q Q Qu L O s
• N O in N ro
M i
ai aJ ro +, (a C
c6 ro
to O ca to +- +�, v C m
4.1
�► Q Q N Q D_ D_ 4.1 a1 � ro - C `- -aa Q a .� (-
L a ° o vi
U O L
i N fa W L GJ
u O
(a �• i
QJ O O i
L
M L
LM
ca
L
M- Aft w
E E
O O
i
U LM U 01
QJ N 00 N 00
E
GJ ' GJ
W V N U N
3 w k _w w k6
Q
O
O Q
O O
U V
t N S N
3 00 w
•
4-0CA
p O v� •
i p
� � tD
N N
i
COMMUNITY SERVICES
DEPARTMENT
M E M O R A N D U M
DATE: September 13, 2019
TO: Don Persson, Council President
Members of Renton City Council
VIA: Denis Law, Mayor
FROM: Kelly Beymer, Community Services Administrator
STAFF CONTACT: Erica Schmitz, Capital Project Coordinator, x6614
Leslie Betlach, Parks Planning and Natural Resources Director
x6619
SUBJECT: Parks, Recreation and Natural Areas Plan Briefing#3
Introduction
This memo provides an updated status on the Parks, Recreation and Natural Areas Plan (the Plan)
and progress made since the project team last presented to the Committee of the Whole on May
13, 2019. The memorandum format, as requested by Council, will briefly recap the Plan process.
The City is updating the Plan with guidance from staff, partners, and community members,
including the City's Inclusion Task Force. The Washington Recreation and Conservation Office
(RCO) requires that agencies have an adopted parks plan every six years to be eligible for grant
funding. The Plan was last updated in 2011. This Plan update kicked off in January 2019 and is
scheduled conclude in January 2020 in order to renew grant eligibility.
Since last presenting to the Committee of the Whole on May 13th, the project team has engaged
the community in the planning process with a second open house, including an online open house,
and a community survey. These engagement activities and the resulting public input are briefly
described below. Additionally, Inclusion Task Force members are leading a second round of
inclusive community discussions about the Plan.
Alongside the engagement, the project team has advanced the technical components of the plan
including a Natural Areas Evaluation Tool and the analyses of access to park and recreation
opportunities. The project team is also preparing for upcoming public engagement activities. The
Steering Committee will convene September 12th to discuss project prioritization. The third and
final Open House, October 3rd from 6:00-8:00 pm at the Renton Community Center, will invite
community members to prioritize categories of projects included in the Plan and will also include
an online open house.
The Draft Plan will be available for public review and Council consideration this winter.
Council President Persson
Page 2 of 5
September 13,2019
Community Survey
A statistically valid survey was conducted between July 10 and August 15, 2019 by EMC Research
among 325 residents in the City of Renton.The overall margin of error is +/- 5.4% at a 95%
confidence interval. Surveys were mailed to randomly selected addresses, and respondents had
the option of taking the survey online or via mail. The survey was offered in English, Spanish, and
Vietnamese. Following are key takeaways from the survey findings. For an executive summary of
survey results, see Attachment A.
Residents are satisfied with parks, recreation, and natural areas in Renton
The majority of residents are satisfied overall with the parks, recreation, and natural areas system
in Renton. 64% of all residents rate their overall satisfaction as a 4 or 5 [on a scale of 1 (Not at All
Satisfied) to 5 (Extremely Satisfied)]. More than half(57%) of residents are also satisfied with the
number of parks and natural areas available in their neighborhood. 62% of all residents are
satisfied with how well maintained and clean the parks, recreational facilities, and natural areas
a re.
Usage of neighborhood parks and natural areas is highest
Half(52%) of all residents frequently visit (10+times a year) a local neighborhood park. More than
half(58%) also use multi-use paved trails regularly (at least five times a year), and more than half
(56%) of all residents say they walk or hike a Renton trail at least five times a year.
Safety and community outreach are improvement opportunities
Safety in parks, recreational facilities and natural areas, as well as communication and outreach,
are potential improvement areas. Nearly three-quarters (73%) consider safety to be important
(giving a rating of 4 or 5 on a 1-5 scale). Comparatively,just over half(52%) say they are satisfied
with the safety of parks and natural areas. There is also a large gap between how important
residents rate communication and outreach. 57% of residents rate communication and outreach
as a 4 or 5 on a scale of 1 (Not at all Important) to 5 (Extremely Important). 42% rated their
satisfaction level with how Renton is doing this aspect as a 4 or 5 on a scale of 1 (Not at all
satisfied) to 5 (Extremely satisfied).
Priorities for Investment
Residents do not want to decrease funding to any existing services, facilities, or amenities. The
survey tested a number of potential investments.There were no potential investments for which a
plurality said the City should invest less or not at all. 68% of residents are in favor of Renton
investing more in a year-round farmers market, and 57% of residents suggest Renton should invest
in enclosing the aquatics center. Over a majority (58%) of all residents support investing more to
remove invasive plant species in natural areas and 52% support investing to acquire more land to
expand natural corridors. There is less interest overall in increasing investments in recreation
programming, but there is also little call to invest less.
Council President Persson
Page 3 of 5
September 13,2019
Open House #2 and Online Extension
The second Community Open House for the Parks,
Recreation and Natural Areas Plan was held June 4th b
from 3:00 to 7:00 pm in the Renton Pavilion Events l
Center and coincided with the opening day of the -
Renton Farmers Market. The open house was adapted in
an online format that was available in English, Spanish,
and Vietnamese from June 4t" to June 30t", extending
participation opportunities. Approximately 150
community members participated in the in-person open
house and there were 364 responses to the online open
house, with 186 responses completing all online
questions. The Open House and online extension were
promoted to community members through a variety of
communication channels; for a summary, see
Attachment B. Open House #2, June 4, 2019
Key themes emerged from input received at the open house and through the online open house
and are summarized below. For a summary of the in-person and online open house, click here.
• The goals established in the 2011 Parks, Recreation and Natural Areas Plan were
confirmed as important by the community. Goal B, "Creating a Connected System",
Goal E, "Ensuring a Sustainable System" and Goal F, "Promoting Health and
Community Through Programming" were most emphasized by participants as "Very
Important".
• Nature, especially animals, spending time in nature, hiking or observing wildlife were
highlighted by community members as important features of the parks, recreation
and natural areas system.
• Access to water, especially paddling and viewing points, was also a common theme.
Participants are interested in exercise opportunities in parks, especially fitness
equipment, and opportunities for play.
• City-wide events and arts and culture events were prioritized higher than other event
types by respondents in both the in-person and online versions of the open house.
• The highest priority park type according to respondents was natural areas.
Natural Areas Evaluation Tool
Management of Renton's natural areas is an important need. Findings from the public involvement
process indicate that residents feel strongly about balancing public access to natural resource
areas with the need to protect and conserve these important assets. When urban natural areas
like those in Renton are untended, they typically do not function as stable, healthy ecosystems.
Council President Persson
Page 4 of 5
September 13,2019
Without management and intervention, these natural areas are more likely to be on a long-term
trajectory of deterioration.
Heightened management and maintenance of natural resources is recommended. The future
management and maintenance of natural areas within the city will require coordination to ensure
efficient and strategic use of resources. The Natural Areas Evaluation Tool, developed for the
updated Plan, will support the community and City staff in gradually improving stewardship of
Renton's natural areas. This tool utilizes a systematic continuum approach to prioritizing and
managing these areas. The approach begins with inventorying natural areas and moves into
stabilization, at which point the natural area is no longer deteriorating, and then improvement,
and gradually, restoration and maintenance. The tool provides guidance about the maintenance
activities and restoration that are needed at each phase of the continuum. The tool also provides
prioritization criteria that will help the City identify the natural areas to focus on first. The Natural
Areas Evaluation Tool will be an appendix to the Plan.
Access Analysis
Access to parks and facilities is one of the key analyses informing recommendations in the Plan.
The project team reviewed and improved the analysis conducted in 2011, by refining and updating
the street and trail network and access points. These analyses identify areas that are within a 10-
minute walk (about % mile) to developed parks, natural areas, sports fields and trails. Each analysis
measures the 10-minute walk based on paths of travel along streets and trails and access points
into parks. The analyses also accounts for barriers such as dead-ends and highways.
In recent years, providing parks within a 10-minute walk has emerged as a national standard
backed by the National Recreation and Parks Association (NRPA), the Trust for Public Land (TPL)
and the Urban Land Institute. Renton was a leader in this methodology, having first applied it in
2010, long before this approach became the national best practice. Renton continues to advance
the industry standard by evaluating access to specific facilities that are important to the
community.
• Developed Park Access: A base-level analysis identifying the locations in Renton that have,
and do not have a developed neighborhood, community or regional park within a 10-
minute walk (1/2 mile). The Valley,Talbot, Benson and East Plateau Community Planning
Areas contain the largest unserved areas. Pockets in other parts of the city exist as well.
• Developed Park Access and Residential Density: Identifies areas planned for higher density
commercial or residential development. Due to the anticipated increase and intensity of
use, a higher density of parks (within a 5 minute walk or% mile) is proposed.
• Natural Area Access: Proximity to natural areas is examined. Ready access to nature is
primarily located in the Valley and Cedar River Community Planning Areas, along with the
north (May Creek) and southeast (Soos Creek) edges of the City.
• Sports Field Access:The combined locations of the City of Renton and the Renton School
District sports fields provides much of the City with access to fields within a 10-minute
walk. The largest gaps are in Valley,Talbot and Benson Community Planning Areas.
Council President Persson
Page 5 of 5
September 13,2019
• Trail Access: This analysis map illustrates the 10-minute walk access to either a formal
trailhead or other trail entry, with the goal of identifying areas for signage or trailhead
improvements.
Goals and Objectives
Public input received and technical analysis completed to date have substantially confirmed that
the 2011 Plan goals and objectives have succeeded as long-term guidance for the system. The
only major changes are to address equity within the goals and to add an objective to develop and
implement a consistent system of wayfinding signage to help users navigate the parks, recreation
and natural areas system.
Next Steps
Public Outreach
• Currently, members of the Mayor's Inclusion Task Force are completing the second phase
of inclusive community outreach.
• The full Inclusion Task Force will receive an update and lessons learned in November.
• The Steering Committee is meeting September 12 to weigh in on prioritization of project
categories for the updated plan.
• The third and final Community Open House is October 3rd from 6:00—8:00 pm at the
Renton Community Center and will focus on community preferences and priorities.
Spanish and Vietnamese interpretation will be available.
• An Online Open House will replicate the open house activities in English, Spanish and
Vietnamese.
Plan Update Process: Council Action Needed
• A final Committee of the Whole Briefing is requested for late October/early November to
inform council members about the plan before it moves to the SEPA process. Topics
covered will include level of service, park concept plans, the project list and cost model,
recommendations, implementation plan, and the results of the third Open House and
second phase of inclusive outreach.
• The draft plan will begin the SEPA process in early November, concluding at the end of
December.
• The plan is targeted for council adoption by the end of January 2020 and certification by
March 2020, in order to meet RCO deadlines for grant eligibility.
Thank you for the opportunity to provide this update. Please let us know if you have any
questions about the contents of this memo or the plan update in general.
Attachments
Attachment A: EMC Research Community Survey Executive Summary
Attachment B: Outreach for Open House#2 and Online Open House
ATTACHMENT A
EMC
research
TO: Interested Parties
FROM: Ian Stewart, EMC Research
RE: City of Renton Parks, Recreation, and Natural Areas Community Survey
DATE: September 4, 2019
Summary
Most residents are satisfied with parks, recreational programming, and natural areas the City of Renton
provides. Local neighborhood parks and natural areas get a high amount of usage. Most recreational
programming is used at least once yearly by a plurality of residents, although there is some variation
across demographics. Safety and communication are opportunity areas to focus on.
Looking forward, there is no strong call to pare back on investments for any park, programming, or
natural area priorities that were tested. However, only a few priorities tested over a majority wanting
more/new investment: a year-round farmers market, enclosing the aquatics center, removing invasive
species in natural areas, and acquiring land to expand natural area corridors.
Ivey Findings
Residents are satisfied with parks, recreational programming, and natural areas in Renton
The majority of residents are satisfied overall with the parks, recreation, and natural areas system in
Renton. 64%of all residents rate their satisfaction as a 4 or 5 (on a scale of 1 Not at All Satisfied to 5
Extremely Satisfied).There is very little difference in opinion across age groups, gender, ethnicities,
geography, and between households with children vs.those without.
More than half(57%) of residents are also satisfied (4 or 5 on a scale on a scale of 1 Not at All Satisfied
to 5 Extremely Satisfied)with the number of parks/natural areas accessible in their neighborhood, and
62% of all residents are satisfied with how well maintained and clean parks, recreational facilities, and
natural areas are kept.
Usage of neighborhood parks and natural areas is highest
Half(52%) of all residents frequently(10 or more times a year)visit a local neighborhood park. More
than half(58%) also use multi-use paved trails regularly(at least five times a year), and more than half
(56%) of all residents say they walk or hike a Renton trail at least five times a year. Fewer residents in
the South (as defined residents in the planning areas of Benson, Cedar River, and Talbot) regularly visit
(5+times a year) a local park compared to elsewhere in the City (57%of residents in the South regularly
visit a neighborhood park compared to 72%citywide). Fewer residents over the age of 65 and Asian
residents regularly visit (5+times a year) natural areas to walk or hike (40%and 38% respectively,
compared to 56%citywide).
Facilities such as sports courts and fields get less use overall (18%of all residents use a sports court at
least five times year; 17% regularly use a sports field), but a higher proportion of parents use sports
courts regularly(38%of parents say they play on sports courts and fields at least 5 times a year).
A quarter (26%) of seniors regularly (5+times a year)visit the community or senior activity center.
EMCresearch.com
COLUMBUS,OH IRVING,TX OAKLAND,CA PORTLAND,OR SEATTLE,WA WASHINGTON,D.C.
614-268-1660 972-717-7427 510-844-0680 503-444-6000 206-652-2454 202-686-5900
City of Renton Parks,Recreation,and Natural Areas 2019 Community Survey
Recreational programming is valued by residents
Overall most residents take advantage of events and programming put on by the City at least once a
year.There is some variation across demographic groups: Seniors (65+) utilize senior activities at a
higher rate (17% participate in a senior activity or program at least 5 times a year); residents living in the
Northwest (as defined as residents of the City Center, Kennydale, and West Hill) more frequently attend
City-sponsored and cultural events (45%attend a city-sponsored event at least five times a year,
compared to 27%of residents overall); and parents are more likely to cite that someone in their
household participates in a youth sports league (23%of parents say their household participates 5+
times a year in a youth sports league, compared to 9%of residents overall).
There is support to offer more recreational programming. Overall, 53%of residents rate the importance
of offering more recreational programming a 4 or 5 (on a scale of 1 Not at all important to 5 Extremely
Important).
Safety and community outreach are improvement opportunities
While a majority(52%) of residents say they are satisfied (giving a rating of 4 or 5 on a 1-5 scale)with
the safety in Renton parks/recreation facilities/natural areas, and a plurality(42%) are satisfied with
communication and outreach, these are two areas that could receive additional focus.
When asked in an open-ended question what would encourage more use of the system, nearly 1 in 5
said something related to improving safety/security. Furthermore, nearly three-quarters (73%) consider
safety in parks/recreational facilities/natural areas to be important (giving a rating of 4 or 5 on a 1-5
scale). Comparatively,just over half(52%) say they are satisfied (4 or 5 on a 1-5 scale) with the safety of
parks and natural areas.This indicates that while safety isn't a glaring problem at the moment, there is
an opportunity to close that gap and improve residents' perceptions.
The gap between the importance of safety and the perceived safety of parks is widest among women,
residents under<65, residents living in the South or Northwest, and non-white residents.
There is also a large gap between how important residents rate communication and outreach (57%of
residents rate this as a 4 or 5 on a scale of 1 Not at all Important to 5 Extremely important) to their
satisfaction rating with how Renton is doing on this aspect (42%say rated their satisfaction a 4 or 5 on a
scale of 1 Not at all satisfied to 5 Extremely satisfied).
Priorities for Investment
Overall, residents are generally satisfied with how the City handles tax dollars for parks, recreation
facilities, and natural areas, with 60% rating their satisfaction a 4 or 5 on a scale of 1 to 5.There are
really no services, facilities, or amenities residents want to pull back funding from. On a number of
potential investments tested, there were none in which a plurality say Renton should invest less or not
at all.
68% of residents are in favor of Renton investing more in a year-round farmers market, and 57%of
residents suggest Renton should invest in enclosing the aquatics center. A plurality also support
investing in a new all-weather field complex(45%), new multi-generational center (45%), and support
investing in new playgrounds with unique play equipment (43%). Over a majority (58%) of all residents
support investing more to remove invasive plant species in natural areas and 52%support investing to
acquire more land to expand natural corridors.
�IMC'
research
City of Renton Parks,Recreation,and Natural Areas 2019 Community Survey
When it comes to recreational programs, over half(53%) say it is important (4 or 5 on a scale of 1 Not at
all important to 5 Extremely Important) to offer more recreational programming.
This memo summarizes a survey conducted July 10`"—August 15`", 2019 by EMC Research among 325
residents in the City of Renton, WA for an overall margin of error of+/-5.4 percentage points at a 95
percent confidence. Surveys were mailed to randomly selected addresses within Renton city limits, and
respondents were able to respond by either completing a paper copy and returning it via mail, or by
going to a website link and completing the survey online. The survey was offered in English, Spanish, and
Vietnamese.
For the full Community Survey summary, please click here.
MCI
research
ATTACHMENT B
Outreach for Open House #2 and Online Open
House
PARKS, RECREATION AND NATURAL AREAS PLAN
Gov Delivery: emails sent to a list containing over 20,000 addresses, including Boards and Commissions
Peach Jar—flyers to parents of students in all Renton School District Schools (3 languages: English,
Spanish and Vietnamese)
Renton Reporter Calendar
Facebook: Community Services Page; Main City Page (3 languages: English, Spanish and Vietnamese)
Twitter (3 languages: English, Spanish and Vietnamese)
Mayor's Inclusion Task Force members— requested to distribute
Steering Committee members—requested to distribute
City Website: front page banner including link
Neighborhood groups: contacts for each neighborhood association were emailed and asked to
distribute the information to members of their neighborhood association.
Next Door
Renton City News (hard copies mailed with utility bills)
Media Advisory
Let's Go Brochure
Administrative Report
eGrapevine Announcement
Byte of Renton Article and Calendar
A4i n
Rento
+.KS,R EC R EATI r
NATURALa
y
l
S
n, g
1
} `
r
I� Y
Q
N
LU
J
d �Alf-
a z z
0 0
y r
r z
6
11� Y4'
a :
c
m
�J L
L L �
N N [B CL
a-' N
— 0
CO
0 �
_ > J
0 0
- U U N
-1-+ -I-J
M _� L
00 0 0 J > > U N
N cc J hA —
ih cn G 4-J � � � � +�
(A > m m c°n z cn H
0
V
0 0
r r
r z
M A�
CL
too
f " F V
�► m
— —J J
m
u
2
N
u
� U
L
O
O N
+-j DC to
Q �
E a�
X � o 4-1 �_ ca
O w N 0 (at10 D
a) LL w z C c�
w
•� o 0 0 0 0
p Q Q Q U
O -C N dJ N O Ln
Ln 0 0 0 U
0 0
r r
r z
J �
+
•
+Mtge •�� t i• � _
X
� � J
V
CL
y F
m
G1 s
j® c} � m
u
4 m
06
41
ML
W
H o o v
tlo
3 .�
H U Q
Q� +N-+ -j j Q ice+
i 0 0c to r-4
co
i v O O O DC ca
4A �Z ' > N N > N aA 0 41
Q Co o > o
00
s' 4-0 4-1 o can o cvn > ago
M " O v ca O Co C:
QJ I.!) J J LL OJ
Philip Arnold Park PARKS & BOND PROJECTS
Kiwanis Park SEQUENCING
Coulon Park July 1, 2019
North Water Walk
Coulon Park
Trestle Bridge
Coulon Park
Rose Wall/Bulkhead
Coulon Park
Erosion Restore
Coulon Park
Swim Beach
Coulon Park
Bathhouse ?
Coulon Park
Irrigation
Coulon Park
Lighting & IT
Coulon Park
Parking Lot Repairs
HASSLE FREE
•
Bazaa
Vovan&,1 22 & 23
FRIDAY 11am-6pm
SATURDAY 9am-5pm
RENTON COMMUNITY CENTER anct
1715 MAPLE VALLEY HWY
OVER 100 VENDORS D"&k"
FREE ADMISSION
Food, refreshments and
ATM available on site
rentonwa.gov/holidaybazaar
425.430.6700 SHOM OPEN AT LOAM
TREE LIGHTING &ARRIVAL OF SANTA AT 5 PM
Saturday
November 309 2019
2019 PIAllA PARK
233 BURNETT AVE S
r
50 RENTONWA.GOV/EVENTS
r
I
t
L afood
PRESENTED BY
Coulon Park is transformed I thousands of / through
Friday,New Year's Daij in celebration of the holidaljs.
ci I
IN
Opening Night
December •
Gene Coulon Me • / Beach Park
1201 Lake WashingtonBlvd.
#clamlights rentonwa.gov/clamlights
"*� / r �. -� Fes•-
7 1�
DECEMBER 8
K9 CANDY SUNDAY,
9:15AM
� Renton Community Center
CAN
1715 SE Maple Valley Hwy
v
' Travel along the Cedar River Trail before
t, / I looping back to the Center.All runners,
•},' , walkers,families invited—with or
without dogs.
runsignup.com/Race/WA/Renton/
• K9CandyCane5KRunandWalk
FUN NUN Early bird registration begins Aug26,$28
AND WALK
C�v 'Buou VTA VENDING
RACING
Polar
w
wedmesda%, january 1, 11:00am
Gene Coulon Park, 1201 Lake Wash. Blvd. N
Start your New Year by running into the icy waters
of Lake Washington from Coulon Beach followed
by some delicious Ivar's clam chowder.
rentonwa.gov/events
RENTONWA.GOV/EVENTS 53