The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About06/19/2013 - Minutes ' �' � • Renton Library Advisory Board Cityof,: ,' ' "C ;�� ,,.�,.s- � �� .�� Meetin Minutes g City Hall, Council Conference Room June 19, 2013^' S:30 p.m. I. CALL TO ORDER Chair Lynne King called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m. In Attendance Members: Lynne King, Catherine Ploue-Smith, Erica Richey, Suzi Ure City Staff: Terry Higashiyama, Diane Wagner KCLS Staff: Judith Zelter Guest: Bekka Martin, KCLS Children's Librarian; Rocale Timmons, City of Renton Senior Planner; Pattie Holt, REACH Center of Hope Absent Members: Laurie Beden City Staff: Peter Renner 11. APPROVAL OF AGENDA A motion was made by Suzi Ure, seconded by Erica Richey,to approve the agenda with one amendment. The amendment presented was to switch the order of Item Six/City Report and Item Seven/ KCLS Report. All were in favor, motion carried, amended agenda approved. III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Suzi tJre made a motion, seconded by Erica Richey,to approve the April 10, 2013 meeting minutes. All were in favor, motion carried, minutes approved. IV. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS/PUBLIC COMMENTS None. V. B4OARD COMMUNICATIONS None. VI. KCLS REPORT/JUDITH ZELTER Judith introduced Bekka Martin, Children's Librarian. Bekka said she started in Renton in January of 2013 and comes from the Des Moines/Kent area. Bekka stated that the summer reading program/Dig into Reading began June 1. By tracking their minutes, children are eligible for halfway prizes and finishing prizes. Programs are set up by age groups such as newborn to five years of age and five to twelve years of age. There are %way prizes for those elementary students who finish 500 minutes of reading. When students have read 1,000 minutes,they can go to the library to collect their finishing prizes. All preschool finishers will be entered into a drawing for a set of five passes to the Woodland Park Zoo and family . . � � City of Renton Library Board Minutes June 19, 2013 Page 2 of 3 Membership to Kids Quest Museum or a stack of books. All elementary finishers will entered into a drawing for a Sony Reader. One reader will be given away at each Library. Bekka passed out a flyer for Summer Reading Program which lists story times and events at the Cedar River Library. Bekka also said the Library2Go vehicle will be at schools and neighborhood picnics along with other summer activities Judith introduced herself the group and talked about her personal Library history, likes, passions, etc. She discussed different event such as the recent Place at the Table. In honor of television series Downtown Abby they recently had someone dressed clothing who discussed setting a proper table. She said 23 library patrons attended. There will be another Place at the Table presentation titled "Building Your Urban Pantry—Canning 101". Judith provided a copy of the Briefing Paper, "Libraries, Publishers, and Public Access to E- Books. E-books have become very popular but until recently, major publishers have refused to sell or license e-books to public libraries. Judith talked about the campaign to make Congress aware that maintaining equal access to materials needs to be safeguarded and monitored. Judith said they participated in the Farmer's Market the first opening week and had 250 patrons stop by the booth. She also said the Library ho9sted a naturalization ceremony where they had 27 participants from 16 to 17 different countries. And,Judith said they will have a presence at the summer lunch program with ten sites set up so far. VII. CITY REPORT/Terrv Hi�ashivama Terry introduced Rocale Timmons, City of Renton Senior Planner. Rocale has been with the City for six years and just finished her Masters' degree. Rocale explained that should would be working on the Highlands Library and Vanesse Dolbee, City of Renton Senior Planner, will be working on the Liberty Park Library permitting. Rocale passed out a copy of a power-point presentation prepared for the Library Permitting Sequencing. Rocale discussed the properties, site plans, elevation schematics, environmental review process, street vacations, mitigation, lot-line permit, appeal process, land use, and review, shoreline plans and concerns, hearing examiner/public hearing, permitting needs, schedule, and sequencing for both libraries and answered questions from the group. Terry mentioned the Sunset Area Planned Action received the 2013 Governor's Smart Communities Award for Outstanding Achievement in Creating Livable and Vibrant Communities award. VIII. DISCUSSION/ACTION ITEMS Terry talked about the South King County Health Initiative. This is a collaboration with the City of Renton, Valley Medical, Highline Hospital, and many of the South King County cities with the goal of providing better eating and exercise options. A forum is scheduled at the Renton Community Center in September, 2013. More details coming soon. _�•��!l�.�+� . � ,��F H:\\Boards and Commissions\Library Board\2013 Minutes\June 2013 . � � • City of Renton Library Board Minutes June 19, 2013 Page 3 of 3 IX. OLD BUSINESS Discussions continued about the Retreat and the Library Card Campaign and the plans to distribute Library Card applications throughout the community. Lynne introduced Pattie Holt from the REACH Center of Hope. Pattie is the Center of Hope Librarian. She developed the Library in the Center of Hope and provides patrons with many of the Reading opportunities in the Center. She works with families on making available books based on age and need and provides book packages for all ages. X. NEW BUSINESS None. XI. INFORMATION Terry briefly mentioned upcoming events such as the 4th of July celebration, Renton River Days, Neighborhood picnics, etc. XII. ADJOURNMENT A motion was made by Suzi Ure, second by Erica Richey,to adjourn the June meeting. All were in favor, motion carried, the meeting adjourned at 7:05 p.m. r Yl Signat re NEXT REGULAR MEETINGS �� JULY MEETING Wednesday,July 17,2012,5:30 p.m. Renton City Hall,Council Conference Room,7th Floor Telephone 425.430.6574 � � � AUGUST MEETIIVG Wednesday,August 21,2813,5:30 p.m. Renton City Hall,Council Conference Room,7th Floor Telephone 425.430.6574 �!�.� . H:\\Boards and Commissions\Library Board\2013 Minutes\June 2013 SI GN-I N SHEET � � � �''��s 0 � ��`� :�. ,. __ , RENTON LIBRARY ADVISORY BOARD DATE: ' • ' • • ' ' � Name Address City/Zip Phone/Email �o you wisn tospeak? PLEASE PRINT LARGE& CLEAR Yes No �� `t�`7 � NU C-HAN l%S � �� I �� ii � /� �� /� � y � � ' �r ` � �.-1{N-I J �M � � � M � uD �� N � Z�.c:eh ! �� i �' �� , �� ,�� Pa�'�"1 � R,1� ��'� �.`�-i e, hd��" ' }- ��,�e�' osr �ape � rna�I. cor� � �.� l , , � , L.� �rac� �,r cc+or 1.��.�C�Ca �� U�✓�.�/ �-��✓'a/y ,�Y1�►n'► �'Q✓�'1c.1ff1✓I��CC�l,O/q X � � / ,J M0.r��►� � . � . �� ,�� p�o�.P_ �.�� H:\Boards and Commissions\Library BoardWleeting Sign In Sheet 2013 � � � June 12,2013 Mayor Denis Law Renton City Hall 1055 S. Grady Way K i N G Renton,WA 98057 COUNTY LISRARY Mayor Law, The King County L.ibrary System and Miller-Hull Partnership have examined the request by the Algona-Pacific Renton City Councii to laok infio the possibility af piacing the Renton Library entry door on the Auburn south side oF the building.We have concluded this is nat feasible for saveral reasons. Bellevue Blatk Diamond Building Structure:As discussed, structural upgrades to the building require cross-bracing eotheit along the exterior column line.The configuration of these braces is determined by the column Boulevard Park height and the midpoint between colum�s.The resultant geometry makes introduction of an Burien entry door on the south side difficult as it encroaches on the tolerances the architects feel are CarnaTion appropriate given their experience with renovation projects. Covington oes moines Functiona[ity:The entry facing the parking lot remains the best locatian for library Duval) functionality.This position allows for the staff workroom to be adjacent to the patron entry and Enumclaw book drop. By enabling the majority of material to b�returned directly to the workroom via Fairwood Automated Materials HandEing equipment,staff is able to increase the rate of materiai Fa3ECity processing. Furthermore,placing an entry on the south side of the building in the middle of the Federa�way space creates poor circulation and diminishes the overall function of the Library's inter(or space. Pederal way 320th Foster Safety and Accessibility:As mentioned at Council sessions and pub[ic meetings,having the � �reenbridge entry facing the parking (ot improves visibility fram the entry to the parking lot and vice versa. Issaquah It also narrows the approach to the building from the ADA parking stalis. Additionally,the current edestrian brid e is not ADA com liant er TCC Ai17.1-2009: • Kenrtsore P 9 p P Kent 303.4 Ramps.Changes in the level greater than half-inch in height shall be ramped Kingsgate and shall comply with section 405 or 406{the existing pedestrian bridge level change Kirkland is approximately 18 inches.)This is dictated by the elevation of the parking �ake Forest Park lot/hardscape and the elevation of the library floor. lake Hills 405.2 Slope Ramp runs shall have a running slope greater than 1:20 and not Library Connection @ Crossroads steeper than 1:12{the existing pedestrian bridge slope is approximately 1:40,less I.ibrary Connection @ 5outhcenter than the t'equired 1:20.) Maple Valiey 405.8 F[andrails. Ramp runs with a rise greater than six(6)inches shall have Mercer Island handraifs complying wifih section 505(the existing pedestrian bridge rise is Muckleshoot approximately 18 inches.There are gua�drails but no handrails.) , Newcastle Because the bridge is a suspended structure,it is also more prone to ice during w+nter weather Newport Way (as reported by staff.)This is a hazard but nat one discussed in the code. North eend Redmond Environmental impact:The entry in the current building is locaYed over the river.In order to Renton compiy with best practices over an active safmon habitat,the entry area cannot be Renton Hlghlands appropr'sately lit.Typically, public buifding entries are well-lit to create a welcoming and Richmond eeach identifiabfe landmark but aiso to provide safe and secure access to the building. By reloca#ing Sammamish the entry to the parking lot side,we wili be able to increase ligh#ing levels for patron safeiy. Shoreline Skykomish River Viewing:We ha�e heard from many patrons that the reason this Library is so spetia{ Skyway and unique is its location over the Cedar River.We agree! In order to maximize��people space" snoguaim;e in areas where the river can be seen from tha interior, it makes sense ta reEocate the entry, vaileyView vestibuEe and subsequent circulation space.As such,using the south facing frontage for an Vashon additional entry and vestibule would decrease the usable interior library space. White Center ' � Woodinville If i can answer any other questions or provide additional information,please feel free to Woodmont contact me, Sincerely, King County library System �� 960 Newport Way(vW � 1 Issaquah,WA98027 �Yt.�;9 ' . 425-3693200 Bill Ptacek `—I�.' Library Director _._....... - _ . __ � April 29,2013 Renton City Council Minutes Page 126 Ms.Palmer requested that the motion be amended so that the results of the , audit are reported back to the Committee of the Whole instead ofthe Finance i Committee. *At Council's request City Clerk Walton re-read the motion as follows:"MOVED '. BY PERSSON,SECONDED BY ZWICKER,COUNCIL APPROVE THE SCHEMATIC ' DESIGN FOR A RENOVATED REPLACEMENT LIBRARY OVER THE CEDAR RIVER, APPROXIMATELY 19,500 GROSS SQUARE FEET IN SIZE,FOR A MAXIMUM CITY CONTRIBUTION AMOUNT NOTTO EXCEEDTEN MILLION FOUR HUNDRED � THOUSAND DOLLARS($10,400,000); DEEM THAT THE GUIDING PRINCIPLES ' ESTABLISHED FOR THE PRELIMINARY DESIGN PHASE HAVE BEEN FULFILLED; DIRECTTHE ADMINISTRATION TO PROCEED WITH RETAINING CONSULTANT(S) TO CONDUCT AN INDEPENDENT REVIEW OF THE PRELIMINARY PROJECT BUDGET; PERFORM A PROJECT COST AUDIT DURING THE CONSTRUCTION � PHASE AND REPORT RESULTS BACK TO THE COMMIITEE OF THE WHOLE."* Mr.Corman requested that an amendment to the motion be made to have the KCLS architecture team consider adding an additional door that opens from the , , entrance airlock area directly onto the bridge as part of the design. MOVED BY CORMAN,SECONDED BY PALMER,COUNCIL AMEND 7HE MOTION IN ORDER TO ASK THE KING COUNTY LIBRARY SYSTEM ARCHITECTURE TEAM TO CONSIDER ADDING A SECOND DOOR THAT OPENS FROM THE ENTRANCE ; AIRLOCK AREA DIRECTLY ONTO THE BRIDGE AS PART OF THE DESIGN.** �. Discussion ensued regarding the justification for the additional door;the fact that it was just a recommendation to consider adding the additional door; : clarification on where exactly the additional door would be located in relation to the current design under consideration for approval; and concern tliat this motion could be done as a separate motion that included other items Council deemed necessary to add to the proposed design. Community Services Administrator Terry Higashiyama invited King County ; Library System Director Bill Ptacek to speak about the impacts of this request. Mr. Ptacek stated that KCLS would consider the request, but noted that a large cross beam is located in the area where the new door is being proposed. Ms. Briere called for the question. **AMENDMENTTO MOTION CARRIED. Mayor Law asked.for further discussion on the first motion. Mr.Taylor reiterated his concern that he believed voting to approve the schematic design was premature. Mr.Corman remarked that he did not believe waiting an additional week would change the outcome of the vote. Ms. Palmer agreed with both Mr.Taylor and Mr.Corman and remarked tfiat she felt better knowing that there would be an independent audit. *MOTION CARRIED. . .._.. , ... . . . . — - ---- _.. _, .. , - ,- --- ._ .. .. ; II � ; ' ��'�� '� - . , CCiMMITfEE t)F THE 1NHOLE .�I-� ��1,��C�I�.� ' CC1MMt1TEE REPf3RT i _ ,�- 3- ��13 � . �� i , lune 3,2013 ' - � , , . . I Purchase and Saie Agceement for the`Nighiands Li6rary,Parcel _ � �The.Cornmittee of the Whole recommends_concurrence in the staff recomrnendatian that , , the fu(I Council authorizes the Mayor and City Clerk to sign the Purchase and Sale Agreement � �� for the- Nighlands Library parcel, iri essentially the form presented to �the Committe.e of the Whole on:June 3,2013. - • � - - ; � ,,The property is located between.Sunset Baulevard N:E.,and 5unset La�re and N,.E. 10`h Street, . { Tlie property is approxirriately 16,072 square.feet. Tlie purchase price is $382;460:53 plus ' , e reimbursement of the'Se(le�for.demalition af the ane structure an the property, abatem nt. , , i � � of any hazardaus.materials within.the building, and � pra rated share afthe cast of a Phase I environmenta.l repart: � , � _ � . , ' , R ndy Corman,Council President � , s ,� • • DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY D nCityof �,� AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT Q��OQ� ;�� ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW COMMITTEE MEETING AGENDA TO: Gregg Zimmerman, Public Works Administrator Terry Higashiyama,Community Services Administrator Mark Peterson, Fire&Emergency Services Administrator � C.E. "Chip"Vincent,CED Administrator FROM: Jennifer Henning,Current Planning Manager MEETING DATE: Monday,June 17,2013 TIME: 3:00 p.m. LOCATION: Sixth Floor Conference Room#620 Renton Library at Liberty Park (Vanessa DolbeeJ LUA13-000255,ECF,SM,SA-H Location: 100 Mill Avenue S Description: The applicant is requesting SEPA Environmental Review, Hearing Examiner Site Plan Review, and a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit for the remodel of the existing Renton Main Library located at 100 Mill Ave. S. The 22,400 SF library is currently constructed over the Cedar River and is located across three different parcels including Liberty Park and the parking lot on the south side of the Cedar River. Overall,the area of work would impact 37,630 SF and the remodeled library would be 19,680 SF following renovations. The site's zoning is primarily Center powntown (CD). The proposed improvements to the building would include seismic upgrades, demolition of existing building envelope, and installation of new envelope and associated site improvements. The existing vehicular access and parking is not proposed to be changed. All but one tree is proposed to be retained. The applicant submitted the following studies with the application: a � Stream Study and Habitat Data Report, Regulated Material Survey, Geotechnical Engineering Study, Technical Information Report. The site is located in the Aquifer Protection Zone 1, flood hazard area, Shoreline of the state and a habitat conservation area: • cc: D.Law,Mayor J.Covington,Chief Administrative Officer D.Jacobson,Deputy PW Administrator-Transportation N.Watts,Development Services Director� L.Warren,City Attorney� Phil Olbrechts,Hearing Examiner D.Pargas,Assistant Fire Marshal� 1.Medzegian,Council , _ • � -- -------_ —_.__ DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY ' Gityof E + �_; , �� ^�""-f : �,��.s,,..,�� ;.. ...�..�>-.: ,, , AND ECONOMtC DEVELOPMENT ----�"' ��`��;:; -i � ° � '°' '� ` �:��,��,�� ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEIN COMMITTEE REPORT' � ERC MEETlNG DATE: J u n e 17, 2013 I Project Name: Renton Library at Liberty Park i Project Number. LUA13-000255, ECF,SM,SA-H Project Manager: Vanessa Doibee,Senior Planner Owner: City of Renton, 1055 South Grady Way, Renton,WA 98057 A licant:. Gre Smith Kin Coun Librar S stem 960 New ort Wa NW Issa uah WA � �F g , b �Y Y Y , P Y , q , 98027 - Cont-act: Maaike Post, Miller Hull Partnership, 7�Columbia St.-Sixth floor,•Seattle,WA 98104 Project Location: 100 Mill Avenue S � Project5ummary: The applicant is requesting SEPA Environmental Review, Hearing Examiner Site j Plan Review, and a Shoreline Substantiaf Development Permit for the remode! ; of the existing Renton Main Library located at 100 Mill Ave.5. The 22,400 SF � library is currently constructed over the Cedar River and is located across three different parcels including Liberty Park and the parking lot on the south side of the Cedar River. Overall,the area of work would impact 37,630 SF and the remodeled library would be 19,680 SF following renovations.The site's zoning is primarily Center powntown (CD).The proposed improvements to the building � would inctude seismic upgrades, demolition of existing building envelope,and � installation of new envelope and associated site improvements.The existing vehicular access and parking is not proposed to 6e changed. A!I but one tree is propased to be retained.7he applicant submitted the fallowing studies with the application: a Stream Study and Habitat Data Report, Regulated Material Survey, GeotechnicaE Engineering Study,Technical Information Report.The site � is located in the Aquifer Protection Zone 1,flood hazard area,Shoreline of the j state and a habitat conservation area. Exist. Bldg.Area SF: 22,400 SF Proposed 1Vew Bldg.Area(footprintJ: 19,680 SF Propased 1Vew B/dg.Area(grossJ: 19,680 SF Site Area: 37,630 SF Total Building Area GSF: 19,680 SF STAFF Staff Recornmends that the Environmental Review Committee issue a RFCOMMENDATION:� Determinat9on of Non-Significance- Mitigated(DNS-M). �� . � �1 k • . r1.. „I ... Project location Map ERC Reportl3-000255.docx � I I ! _ ---------- .... ... . .. . .........: , •.. City of Renton Department of Community&Economic Development Environmental Review tommittee Report RENTON LIBRARYAT L18ERTY PARK LUA13-000255,ECF,SM,SA-H Report of June 17,2013 Page 2 af 13 PART OME: PROJECT DESCRIPTfON/BACKGROUND The applicant is requesting SEPA Environmental Review, Hearing Examiner Site Plan Review,and a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit for the remodel of the existing Renton Main Library located at 100 Mill Ave.S. The 22,400 SF library is currently constructed over the Cedar River and is located across three different parcels including Liberty Park and the parking lot on the south side of the Cedar River. . Overall,the area of work would impact 37,630 SF and the remodeled library would be 19,680 SF following renovations. The subject site is focated over the Cedar River;the river itself does not have zoning. However,zoning is j applied on bath the north and south banks of the river.The north shoreline is zoned Commercial Arterial (CA}and the south shoreline is zoned Center powntown (CD). The site's main entrance, parking lot, and access is along the south shoreline. Due to the Library's primary access and the majority of the development along the south shoreline, City staff has determined that the CO zone would be applicable to the subject development. Because the subject property is locatec!within the Center powntown (CD) zoning designation,the proposal would be subject to the Design District "A"standards and guidelines. King County Library System (KCLS} has proposed to remode) or rehabilitate the existing library which was � constructed across the Cedar R'sver between 1956 and 1966. The existing library is partially located in j Liberty Park but fronts on Mill Ave. S. The site is surrounded with civic uses such as the City of Renton Fire � � Station and old City Hall on the south side of the river and Liberty Park on the north side of the river. The ! applicant has indicated that all work would occur within the area of existing development on the site and I public access wfluld be maintained off of Mill Ave.S. ; The proposed library renovations include the following: ' • Demolition of existing masonry and glass building envelope. • Retention of existing concrete structure, roof framing, and site work. • Installation of new building envelope: aluminum window system with glazed panels and a metal pane[wall assembly. . • Demolition of portions of existing roof framing anci replacement in specific areas at a lower height. • Removal of the existing rooftop mechanical unit near the west end of the building. � New rooftop mechar�ical unit{similar in scale to existing unit}with screening near the east end of the building where it would be less visible from the parking lot anci main entry. • New mechanical, electrical,and lighting systems within the building. • Addition of insulation,sheathing, and roofing to existing roof assembly. • Relocatian of building entry to the west to face the existing parking lot. • 5eismic upgrade required by code including below-grade concrete a6utments on either side of the building and steel brace frames in both directions.Approximately 900 cubic yards of excavation materiafs and 360 cubic yards of fill would be required for the installation. • New hardscape, utility routing, and vegetation to address new entry location as well as repair . associated with concrete abutrnents_ • Sandbfasting of existing structural concrete to remove painted finish. • Re-routing of existing under-slab mounted utiEity piping to address new utility penetrations. ; • New exterior enclosure for refuse/recyciing area and mechanical equipment. ERC Reportl3-000255.docx � i -- ----......._..___._...__.. . . • . .... ..:...................... .. .... .. ... .....__ _._.. ._�.� ` L7ty of Renion Department of Community&Fconomic Development Fnvironmenta!Review Committee Report j RENTON UBRARYAT USERTY PARK iUA13-000255,ECF,SM,SA-tI Report of June 17,2013 Page 3 of 13 The majority of the renovations includes upgrades to the existing building and structure to bring the building into compliance with today's building codes and regulations. The applicant has proposed minimaf modifications to the existing site,with the exception of required utility upgrades and rehabilitation foNowing necessary structural upgrades. For example,the proposed concrete abutments would require below-grade work along both the narth and south edges of the building.As such,these disturbed areas would be re-landscaped and hard scraped following constructian. Offsite improvements ir�clude the ' replacement of the sanitary side sewer pipe from the fibrary to the manhole at the intersection of Mill Ave. 5 and S 2nd St. The public sidewalk along Mill Ave.S would be updated as a part of a 2014 city of Renton sidewa(k improvement project and would not be included in the remodel to the library.�'he existing vehicu(ar access and parking is not praposed to be changed. Ali but one tree is proposed to be retained. The existing building spans the Cedar River, a shoreline of the State. As such,the project is subject to the Shorefine Master Program regulations. The site is located in the ShoreEine High lntensity overlay a4ong Cedar River Reach B. Overall,the existing building is considered to be a non-conforming structure. However,the proposal wou[d be reducing the size of the building bringing is more into canformance then the existing situation. In addition to being located over the Cedar River,the site is located in a seismic hazards area and the Aquifer Pratection Zone 1. 7here is also a 100 year flood plain and a floodway associated with the Cedar River and the banks of the river have been identified sensitive and protected slopes. Based on the project application material, no work is proposed below the ordinary high water mark � of the Cedar River and therefore no work would accur in the f[ood plain or floodway. ` 7he appEicant submitted the following studies with the application: a Stream Study and Habitat Date � Re art Re ulated Material Surve Geotechnical En meerin Re ort Technical Infvrmation Re ort. � P , g Y� g� g p , P ! i PAR7'iWO: ENVIRONMENTAL REViEW In compliance with RCW 43.21C.240,the foilowing environmental {SEPA)review addresses only those project impacts that are not adequately addressed under existing development standards and environmental regulations. A. Environmental Threshold Recommendation . Based on analysis of probable impacts from the proposal,staff recommends that the Responsible Officials: fssue a DNS-M with a 14-day Appeaf Period. B. Mitigation Measures 1. The appticant shalf comply with the recommendations included in the Stream Study and Habitat Data Report,prepared by Talasaea Consultants, Inc.,dated February 28, 2013 and revised May � 10, 2013. 2. The applicant sha{I comply with the recommendations incfuded in the Geotechnical Engineering Study prepared by GeoEngineers, dated December 20,2012. � � C. Exhibits � � Exhibit 1 Vicinity Map � Exhibit 2 Title Sheet � ERC Reportl3-000255.docx � _ . -------..... _... ....--......__�.._.... ... - - -. ........... . ......:. ., ......... ....--._--......--.... .. � City of Renton Department of Community&fconomic DevelopmenY £nvironmental Review Committee Report RENTON LlBRARYAT UBERTY PARK LUAi3-p00255,ECF,SM,SA-H Report of June 17,2013 Page 4 of 13 Exhibit 3 Architecture Site Plan Exhibit 4 Demolition Plan Exhibit 5 T.E.S,C. Plan � Exhibit 6 Civil Site Plan ' Exhibit 7 Landscape Site Plan Exhibit 8 Conceptual Landscape Plan i Exhibit 9 Tree Inventory Plan i Exhibit 10 Building Elevations,Sheets A-201 and A-202 Exhibit 11 Muckleshoot 7ribe Comments � D. Enviranmentallmpacts The Proposal wa.s circulated and reviewed by various City Departments and Divisions to determine whether the applicant has adequately identified and addressed environmentol impocts anticipated to occur in conjunction with rhe proposed development. Staff reviewers have identrfied that the proposal is likely ta have the following probable impacts: 1. Earth ° � Impacts:The existing site topography consists of steep sfopes along the north and south edges o€ � the river channel. The grades of the river banks range from elevation 45 at the top of the slope to � elevation 26 at the river bottom. Beyond the river banks the site grades to the north and south of � the buildings is relatively f(at. Based on the City's critical areas maps,the river banks are considered � to be either a sensitive slope or a protected slope dependent upon the gracfe at the specific location. In addition,the library is tocated in a seismic hazard area. The applicant submitted a Geotechnical Engineering Study("Geo-#ech") prepared for the Liberty Park Library by GeoEngineers,dated December 20,2012. The primary purpose of the building ; upgrades is to bring the existing structure into compliance with current seismic code requirements. As such,the provided Geo-tech particularly focuses on the necessary structural upgrades needed to j bring the existing buifding into compliance with the seismic standards. Pursuant to the provided I study,the existing building is constructed similar to a three-span bridge structure with girders spanning between faundations lacated on the river banks and two interior piers that are Eocated within the river. To evaluate the subsurface conditions at the subject site,GeoEngineers completed two borings on � October 22,2Q12 to depths o�F 51.50 feet be[ow the existing ground surface. The soil types encountered consisted of undocumented fill and recent alluvium deposits. More specifically the fill consisted of laase to medium dense/very soft to soft silty sand/silt with variabEe gravel and cobb@e content,and organics. The fill extended to depths of 15 feet belaw existing grades.The alluvium deposits cansist of inedium dense to very dense silty sand with varying amounts of gravel and medium dense to dense gravel with varying amounts of si{t and sand. Occasional cobbles are anticipated to be present in the alluvium deposits. The Geo-tech also addressed groundwater conditions and found groundwater in both the borings at approximately 20.50 feet below grades. The report concludes that groundwater[e�eis are expected to fluctuate in response to water levels in the Cedar River and would very as a function of season, precipitation, and othe�factors. ERC Reportl3-000255.docx • T '___"'".._....__"..""_"'............ .. . . ..._'""" "........ .. . . ......... . ......_ ., .._ .......... .. .. ......... .... . . ""�"..:..... � � . .. . .. . ..""".:.. � . • I City of Renton Department of Community&fconomic Development Fnvironmental Review Committee Report � RElYTON LlBRARYAT UBERTYPARK LUA13-OOOZ55,ECF,SM,SA-N Report of lune 17,2013 Page 5 of 13 GeoEngineers cancluded based on the soil analysis,that the site soils are moderately to highly susceptible ta liquefection under the design earthquake event. Given the slopes focated along the ' banks of the Cedar River both setttement and lateral defarmation of the foundations elements {towards the Cedar River) may occur pQtentially resulting in excessive foundation deformation. � Furthermore the potentially liquefiable soils present a risk to the exis#ing building through loss of i foundation support, potential foundation settlernent,and lateral deformatian of soils towards the Cedar River.i"he Geo-tech recommends the use of ground improvements to meet seismic . settiement and building performance tolerances. The preferred ground impravement option is a system comprised of closely spaced augercast piles to mitigate the liquefaction potentia(at the Cedar River banks on the north and south sides of the building.Approximately 900 cubic yards of sail wpuld be excavated to install the below-grade concrete abutments or augercast piles and 360 cubic yards of fill would be used vn site above the abutments. Pursuant to the provided report,the purpose of the ground improvement is to provide a `block' of improved sail that would resist seisrrzic latera(earth pressure acting towards the river and to provide improved bearing of the spread footings currently located on the river banks. GeoEngineers further conclude that the soil exploration indicated that the soils located belvw the river bottom�elevation have a low risk of liquefaction,therefore, no additional improvements of the interior piers is considered to be � necessary. The above ground improvement option is expected to mitigate potential liquefaction hazards in the immediate vicinity of the foundation elements located on the river bank and provide � ancharage to the building to help resist seismic fateral forces. fn addition to the above ground improvement recommendations the prov'sded Geo-tech includes recommendations for augercast piles,earthwork including clearing and site preparation,subgrade preparation,structural fill, materials, reuse of on-site soils,fill placement and compaction criteria, weather considerations,temporary slopes, utility trenches and additional geotechnica!services recommendations. Based on the recommendations included in the provided report;staff recommends as a mitigation measure that the applicant cvmply with the recommendations included in the provided Geotechnical Report prepared by GeaEngineers. Mitigation Measures:The appficant shall comply with the recommendations included in the Geotechnical Engineering Study prepared by GeoEngineers, dated December 20, 2012. Nexus:SEPA Environmental Review, RMC 4-3-050 Critical Areas Regulations, RMC 4-4-060 Grading, Excavatinn and Mining Regufations. 2. Water a. Wetland,Streams, Lakes lmpacts:The existing building spans the Cedar River,a shoreline of the State. As such,the praject is subject to the Shoreline Master Program regulations. The site is located in the Shoreline High Intensity overlay along Cedar River Reach B.The ordinary high water mark(OHWM)for the Cedar River at the projeet location is general associated with the 34 foot above mean sea IeveE(ams(} contour line and the 100-year FEMAfloadplain is located at elevation 39.62 arnsl. 7he proposed rehabilitation work would be limited to the library structure above the river only, no work would occur within the regulatory floodplain or below the OHWM. Due to the project's locatinn,over the Cedar River,the applicant submitted a Stream Study and Habitat Data Report prepared by Talasaea Consultants, lnc.,dated February 28, 2013. The study was prepared pursuant to the requirements of the Renton Municipal Code for both the Shoreline ERC Reportl.3-p00�55.docx � � . City of Renton Department of Community&Economic Development Environmentaf Review Committee Report RENTON LlBRARY AT LlBERTY PARK LUA13-000255,ECF,SM,SA-N Report of June 17,2013 Page 6 of 13 Master Program and the Critical Areas Regulatians. The report icfentifies and describes the river, . � critical species and habitat on or adjacent to the project site,provides a regulatory review of local, I Sate and Federal regulations and praposes mitigation for irnpacts to critical areas and habitat. ' Pursuant to the provided Steam Study,the Cedar River is located in the Cedar-Sammamish watershed (WRIA—8) and is approximately 100 feet wide. The water depth at the site was observ.ed to be approximately 18 inches in the summer of 2012 and 3 feet in the fall of 2012.The in-stream substrate consists of clean gravel and coble, however no natural pools,woody�debris,or ; other fish habitat features were observed in the vicinity of the project by 7alasaea. The stream study identifies the shoreline riparian habitat.in the vicinity of the library building to be very narraw (30-50 feet max}, ancf adjacent to urban impervious surface on the left bank and a baseball field/City park on the right bank. The riparian habitat downstream is dominated by invasive species including reed canarygrass,Japanese knotweed, and Himalayan blackberry. Tree species within the existing riparian habitat include: sycamore, black cottanwood, and horse chestnut.The upstream riparian habitat is similarly daminated by Himalayan blackberry, with s[ightly improved salmonberry habitat located on the left upstream bank. The Stream Study concludes that there would be no direct impacts to the Cedar River,adjacent riparian habitat or State Shoreline area anticipated during or aiter construcfiifln, resulting in no net Ioss of ecologicai functions.This conclusion is based on the following reasbns: l)all work would ' occur within the footprint of the existing development for the library and would stay above the ; 100-year flood plain and above the OHWM;2)the footprint of the existing disturbed/developed ' area within the shoreline zone wou(d not be expanded as a result of the project; 3) all existing � shoreline vegetation wou{d remain intact;4) portions of the existing library structure would be i demolished which would result in a net reduction of approximately 1,700 square feet or 7 percent � of the library structure's building itself and adjacent pedestrian bridge; 5) Best Management ` Practices(BMPs� would be implemented during construction to minimize temporary construction �. impacts to the aquatic environment; and 6)the project would comply with all applicable City � ordinances including, but nat limited to,stormwater management requirements,and those related to traffic, noise and aesthetics during and after construction. � 1"he St�eam Study provides a list of recommend BMP's which are intended to be employed during construction to ensure adequate protection of water quality and the aquatic and shareline environment. The BMPs are divided into a set of general goals which have been defined to guide construction activities and ensure adequate protection of the aquatic and shoreline environment. Suggested specific BMPs are listed after each goal in the study, which is not intended to be an exhaustive list but instead.a tist of BMPs which shall be implemented as needed to meet the identified goals. The study has identified that implementation of BMPs would be the responsibifity of the constructor to identify the appropriate�BMPs for the difFerent phases and types of work being conducted at the site. The following is a list of goals provided in the Stream Study: . Goal 1:Trash, construction%demolition debris,and other contaminants shall be kept out of the river and shoreline environment at a11 times during construction. Goal 2:Dust Control, including minimizing,containment and collecfiion of dust. Goal 3:General worksite management including proper storage of materials and construction debris and worksite cleanup. Goal 4:Work timing and schedufing in order to prevent debris from entering the aquatic environment. ERC Reportl3-000255.docx ..... - --........ .... . � .... . . .. ....... . .. . _. . ._::.: City of Rentort Department of Community&Economic Development Environmental Review Committee Report RFNTON UBRARY AT LlBERTY PARfC LUA13-000255,ECF,SM,SA-H Report of June 17,2013 Page 7 of 13 Goa! 5:Stomwater managemenfi BMPs shall be implemented in accordance with the 2009 King j County Surface Water Design Manual (KCSWDM) and a"femporary erosion and sedimentation I control plan. � j In addition to the proposed BMPs,Talasaea has identified that the applicant wou�d contribute � . $22,7Q0 to a vegetation conservation fund,which is administered by the City of Renton to meet the ' requirements of the Shoreline Master Program RMC 4-3-095F. 1"his amount has been calculated ! based on the actual area of shoreline buffer contained within the project limits, which includes any ! area landward of the OHWM. The total shoreline bu�Ffer area contained within the pro�ect limits is ! apprbximately 18,130 SF. This area was multiplied by a dollar amount of$1.25/SF to cafculate an ' amounfi for what it would hypothetically cost to restore an area of shoreline buffer equal to the ' area within the project limits. Based on the recommendations included in the Stream Study,staff recommends the applicant comply with these recommendations as mitigation for the subject prflject. . On June 12, 2d13,the City received comments from the Mucklesfioot Indian Tribe Fisheries Division (Exhibit 11}. These comments include a request for lighting review and specific light bulbs to be used at the new library to reduce the potential impacts of artificial fighting on the fish. [n addition, ' , they have requested a wood management plan and a copy of tf�e stormwater report. i'heir comments expressed concerns about the gabion baskets located in the Cedar River below the existing building and construction noise impacts. Finalfy, their comments appeared to be supportive of the fee-in-lieu option for the shoreline master program required mitigation. � Mitigafiion Measures:7he applicant sha11 comply with the recommendations incfuded in the Stream 5tudy and Habitat Data Report,prepared by Talasaea Consultants, Inc., dated February 28, 2013 and revised May 1d,2013 Nexus:SEPA Envir�onmental Regulations,Critical Areas Regulations b. Storm Water fmpacts:A Technical Information Report(TIR)was submitted with the application, prepared by Miller Hull Partnership, LLP dated May 10, 2013. The report complies with the 2009 King County ; Surface Water Manual and the 2009 City of Renton Amendments to the KCSWM, Chapters 1 and 2. � The TiR indicates that the existing.site consist of 0.793 acres of impervious area and O:Q71 acres pervious area. Foilowing the rehabilitation of the library,the site would consist of 0.788 acre impervious area and 0.076 acres pervious area. The TIR identified three distinct areas with different drainage patterns. The existing library builcEir�g roof runoff discharges directly to the Cedar River through piped outfafls. The parking Int to the j south is collected in onsite catch basins and is routed to river out�alls in the near vicinity of the site. Finally, the park property within the site work limits to the north discharges to existing piped outfalls to the River. The proposed drainage system at the site has been identified to remain relatively unchanged, as the project is primarily a building rehabilitation project. Runoff from the � site would be conveyed to existing storm systems in the parking lot and the park area to the north. �The roof drainage from the library would continue to utilize existing outfalls to the Cedar River. Portion of the existing drainage system onsite are proposed to be removed to make room for the new library entrance improvements. A small amount of new catch basins and conveyance piping would be installed in the parking lot to convey runoff to the existing system to the south. Pollution generating surface wouid be basically unchanged;therefore,.no water qual�ty mitigation is proposed ta be installed as a part of the project. ERC Reportl3-Q00255.docx . . ._ ....----------............... . .... ......... . .. . . . .:- . _. _ . • i City of Renton Deportment of Community&Economic Development Environmental Review Committee Report . " RENTON LlBRARYAT LIBERTY PARK LUA13-000255,ECF,SM,SA-H Report of June 17,2013 Page 8 of 13 The Tlit included an upstream and downstream analysis,which concluded that there was no known drainage that enters the site from upstream and that there were no know drainage compfaints within % mile of the site. As such no mitigation was proposed for downstream drainage probiems. The Library is located over the floodway of the Cedar River and any work within the floodplain or � the floodway wauld have to comply with City adopted flood hazard regulations in the Critical Areas Ordinance and FEMA Nationa! Flood Insurance Program regulations.This alsa intiudes compliance ; with the National Marine Fisheries Biological Opinion Reasonable and Prudent Alternatives I regarding the National Flood Insurance Program compliance with the Endangered Species Act, as i they relate to development in the FEMA floodplain. FEMA regulations require that when a : structure is located in the 100-year floodplain, any substantial improvements (i.e.when cost of ' improvements exceeds 50%of the appraised value of the structurey require the structure to be � brought up to current floodplain development standards. Any improvements within the ffovdplain or floodway,_such as placement of fill, piers or supports as part of the seismic retrofit work within the floodplain or floodway,wiil need to compfy with FEMA floodplain requirements. Based on the provided TIR, no work is being proposed within the base flood elevation or within the FEMA flooclway. Special consideration of design has been made to ensure that no alteration within these zones would occur. � In addition,the TIR indicated th�t a Temporary Erosion and Sediment Control (TESC}Plan woulcE be provided including the following: � 1. The praject would pravide sediment protection at the existing catch basins and maintain existing hardscape areas until areas would be re-paved. �. For the period between November 1 through March 1, disturbed areas greater than 5,000 � square feet left undisturbed for more than 12 haurs must be covered with mulch,sodding, � or plastic covering. A cortstruction phasing plan would be provided to ensure that erosion I control measures are installed prior to clearing and grading. 3. There shall be limits to tributary drainage to an area to be cleared and graded. Delineated ' dimension,stake and flag clearing limits. i 4. Revegetate areas to be c{eared as soon as practicable after grading. ' Mitigation Measures: No further mitigatian required. Nexus:N/A _ 3. Vegetatian Impac#s:The existing site is currently vegetated with ornamental landscaping and lawn areas in the vicinity of the existing structure. Scattered around the site are deciduous and coniferous treesJshrubs(see Wildlife and Stream sections far riparian vegetation information).The existing site contains 16 trees of which all will be retained with the exception of one 12-inch diameter cherry tree located in the southeast corner of the site. The removed cherry tree is propased to be repfaced with a 2-inch caliper river birch tree. !n addition,to the 12-inch cherry tree,one street tree along Mill Ave.S is proposed to be removed. This is a result of the sanitary sewer line improvements required for the project. This tree would be replaced in the same locativn with a 2- inch caliper Northern Red Oak. tn addition to the new trees, the applicant is propasing to revegetate all disturbed areas on the project site. In the SEPA checklist,the applicant has indicated that the planning palette would � include native and non-native adapted/drought tolerant species including such plants as maidenhair fern, kinnickinick, deer fern, mock orange, salmonberry etc. ERC Reportl3-000255.do�x � .__ .. .... .. .. . — _..._..... . . ...... . ... . . ....................... -. .-.._..-. . � ----.. City of Renton Department of Community&Economic Development Environmenta!Review CommitYee Report RENTON LIBRARYAT L/BERTY PARK LUAI3-000255,FCF,SM,SA-H I Repart of June 7.7,2013 Page 9 of 13 . Mitigation Measures: No further mitigation required. ( Nexus: N/A . � ;. 4. Wildlife I i Impacts:The applicant submitted a Stream Study and Habitat Data Report, prepared by Talasaea I Consultants, Inc., dated February 28, 2013 with the application. The Habitat Report included a ; habitat assessment to determine the extent, functions,values,and existing conditions of the � critical habitat on the site.7he Habitat Report identified that the Cedar River is known to support � Federa(ly-listed (threatened)Chinook salmon and steelhead trout,along with coha salmon,a � Federally-listed Candidate species,and sockeye salmon, a State Candidate species. Bull trout are listed in the Priority Habitat and Species(PHS) database as species of commercial and recreation interest. Pursuant to Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife(WDFW}Salmonscape and StreamNet, the subject portion ofi the Cedar River is a documented spawning/rearing area for fall Chinook, •: coho, and sockeye, and is a documented rear area for winter steelhead. Bull trout are confirmed to be located in the area however cutthroat trout are not documented in the area by Salmonscape or ; StreamNet. � Talasaea conducted a fiefd investigation on July 9 and Noverrtber 2, 2012. During the field . ; investigation,Talasaea completed a characterization of the habitat within the project site. Based on this characterization,the area directly beneath the library does not receive direct sunlight and is ' mostly devoid of vegetation. The left bank between the library and Brvnson Way N (downstream) i contains reed canarygrass within the streambed and floodplain. Japanese knotweed and i ' Himalayan blackberry dominate the left and right bank slopes. Sycamore trees are located on top � of the left bank adjacent to the parking lot. Black cottonwood and horse chestnut trees are growing on the right bank. The upstream riparian habitat is similarly dominated by Himalayan blackberry,with sfightly improved salmonberry habitat located on the left upstream bank. The Habitat Report identifies that the area's highly urbanized conditions results in witdtife species typically fiound in urban and residential areas, such as birds and small and medium-sized mammals. � The Habitat Report conctudes that the riparian vegetatian in the project area provides only minimal buffer for the fish-bearing Cedar River and is of relatively low value to the watershed as a whole. Moreover,the assessment concludes that the project would not result in direct impacts to the � riparian habitat during or after construction, resulting in no net loss of eco[ogical functions and values. This is a result of a combination of limiting the renovation to the area of existing development and not expanding the existing disturbed/develaped area within the shorekine zone. i �inally,the study states that a parCion of the library structure over the river would be demolished ; which would result in a net reduction of the library footprint over the �iver and BMPs woulci be ' implemented during construction tv minimize temporary construction impacts to the aquatic environment. � i Chapter 7 of the Stream Study and Habitat Data Report is a literature review evaluating the effects ' of light on salmonid predation to evaluate the possible pre-existing efifect that the library may have on salmonid predation. Both studies evaluated found that predation is lowest under dark conditions,and increases as light and visibility increases. Furthermore Talasaea contacted Hans Berge,the King County expert on fish and the Cedar River watershed. Mr. Berge re(ayed that shade . does not contribute to increased predation, but that excess light does contribute to increased ERC ReporCl3-000255.docx ._......._ ....... .. .. ........ .... .... . .... _._.._._......_ . -- _...------..._. __ - �- - _.. ....... ..... :�-: City of Renton Department of Community&Economic Development Environmental Review Committee Report RENTON LIBRARY AT tlBFRTY PARK LUA13-000255,ECF,SM,SA-H Report ofJune 17,2013 Page 10of 13 predation. 7alasaea concluded that the information indicated that the area under the library may � provide a refuge for salmonids because predation would be higher upstream and downstream of. : the library where the river is always illuminated by sunl'rght and the lights of surrounding urban � area. Moreover,Talasaea concludes that given the general [ack of natural shade along this reach of ' the Cedar River,the shadow of the library across the river is likely to have beneficial effect, if any at all. Based on the recommendations included in the Habitat Data Repart,staff recommends the � appSicant comply with these recommendations as mitigation for tF�e subject praject. Mitigation Measures:7he applicant shall comp[y with the recommendations incEuded in the i Stream Study and Habitat Data Report, prepared by Ta(asaea Consultants,lnc,, dated February 28, ' 2013 and revised May 10, 2013 I Nexus:SEPA Environmental Regulations,Critica)Areas Regulations j 5. Light and Glare Impacts:The rehabilitated library structure would be designed with interior and exterior lighting. Based on the provided SEPA checklist,the applicant has indicated that the project would use ciownlights with excelfent shielding and cutoffs. These types of lights would be incorporated into a!! spaces interior ancf exterior. The check list indicated that the placement af exterior fixtures in the pfaza would contain the light to the plaza and would not impact the river or night sky. Light levels would meet but not exceed illuminating Engineering Society recommendations to provide the industry standard amount of light and minimize aver lighting the space. Automatic cantrols would be implemented to turn off non-critical lighting after-hours to further reduce light impacts. ; Mitigation Measures: No further mitigation required. ' Nexus:N/A 6. Parks and Recrea#ion � Impacts:The subject project is(ocated within Liberty Park in downtown Renton. However,the � project fimits restrict the area of impact to primarify the library building and a small area on both � the north and south sides of the buifding. The north side of the library is located in Liberty Park and I' construction impacts woufd extend approximately 30 feet north of the north edge of the existing � building. This would resuft in temporary construction impact to a small plaza area and trail access to the walkway along the river in this Iocation. There are othec access locations to the river trail which would not be impacted by the subject project and no impacts are anticipated to any recreational uses in the park. The construction impacts are temporary in nature and are not anticipated to have an adverse impact on Liberty Park. Mitigation Measures:f�o further mitigation required. Nexus:N/A 7. Transporta#ion lmpacts:The site is surrounded by Mill Ave S, Branson Way N, and S 2"d Street. Under current condition,the site is primarily access by vehicles from Mill Ave. S,to the existing surface parking . lot. However,there is also a parking lot located in Liberty Park, which is accessed off of Bronson Way N,which may also be utilized by people using the tibrary.The proposed site access and parking . facilities are primarily proposed to stay the same. The existing surface parking Iot along Mill Ave. S i would lose four parking stafls folEowing the project's construction.Trips associated with the project � are not anticipated to change, as the existing use is not changing. The public sidewalk along Mill ' ERC Reportl3-OOO.Z55.docx � • , • - -------------- -----........ . . .....__: ;� City of Renton Department of Comm�nity&Economic Devefopment Envirortmenta!Review Committee Report RFNTON llBRARYAT LIBFRTY PARK LUA13-000255,ECF,SM,SA-N Report of June 17,2013 � Page 11 of 13 � . i Ave.S would be updated as a part of a 2014 City of Renton sidewafk improvement project and ' would not be included in ti�e rehabilitatian of the library. � Mitigation Measures: No further mitigation required. . Nexus: N/A E. Comments of Reviewing Departments � i The proposal has been circulated to City Department and Division Reviewers. Where applicable,their �� comments have been incorporated into the text of this report and/or"Advisory Notes to Applicant." � ✓ Copies nf all Review Comment's are cantained in the Official File and may be attached to this report. ' 'I The Environmental Determination decision will become final if the decision is not appealed within the 14-day appeaE peridd (RCW 43.Z1.C.07S{3);WAC 197-11-680). Environmental Deterrr�ination Appeal Process: Appeals of the environmental determination must be filed in writing together with the required fee to:Hearing Examiner,City of Renton, 1055 South Grady Way, Renton,WA 98057,on or before 5:00 p.m. on July 5,2013. RMC 4-8-110 governs appeals to the Hearing Examiner and additional information regarding the appeal process may be obtained from the City Clerk's Office, Renton City Hall—7th Floor, (425}430-6510. ADVlSORY NOTES TO APPtfCANT The following notes are supplemental information provided in conjunction with the administrati�e land use action. 8ecause these noCes are provided as information only, they are notsubject to the appeal process for the land use actions. . ; Plannin�: � .� ; 1. RMC section 4-4-030.C.2 limits haul hours between 8:30 am to 3:30 pm, Monday through Friday. unless atherwise approved by the Development Services Division. 2. Commercial, ii-iulti-family, new single family and other nonresidential construction activities shall be restricted to the hours between seven o'clock(7:00)a.m. and eight o'clock{8:00) p.m., Monday through Friday.Work on Saturdays shall be restricted to the hours between nine o'clock(9:00� a.m. and eight o'clock(5:00) p.m.No work shall be permitted on Sundays. 3. Within thirty(30)days of completion of grading work,the applicant sha11 hydroseed or plant an appropriate ground cover over any portion of the site that is graded or cleared of vegetation and where no further construction work will occur within ninety(90)days.Alternative measures such as mulch, sodding,or plastic covering as specified in the current King County Surface Water Management Design Manual as adopted by the City of Renton may be proposed between the dates of November 1st and March 31st of each year.7he Development Services pivision's approval of this work is required prior.to final inspection and approval of the permit. 4. A 1Vationa) Permit Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit is required when more than one acre is being cleared. 5. The applicant may not fill, excavate,stack or store any equipment,dispose of any materials, supplies or fluids,operate any equipment,install impervious surfaces, or compact the earth in any ERC Reportl3-000255.docx • • • ---- -------...---------- --. , City of Renton Department of Community&fconomrc Development Environmenta!Review Committee Report , RENTOfV LlBRARYA7'Lf13ERTY PARK LUA13-p00255,ECF,SM,SA-H Report of June 17,2013 Page 12 of 13 � way within the area defined by the drip line of any tree to be retained. 5. The applicant shall e�ect and maintain six foot(5') high chain link temporary construction fencing � � around the drip lines af a!I retained trees, or along the perimeter of a stand of retained trees. � Placards shall be placed on fencing every fifty feet(54'} indicating the words, "NO TRESPASSING— Protected Trees" or on each side of the fencing if less than fifty feet(50'). Site access to individually protected trees or groups of trees shalE be fenced and signed. Individual trees shall be fenced on four(4)sides.In addition,the applicant shall provide supervision whenever equipment or trucks are moving near trees. Plan Review—SanitarvSewer: 1. Sewer service is prouided by the City of Renton.There is an 8-inch sewer main in Mill Avenue South with a manhvle at the intersection with 5outh 2"d Street.The existing sewer service connection extends 5outherly to this main. 2. The project is required to cut and cap the existing side sewer at the property line as part of the demolitian permit. 3. A new side sewer is shown on the preliminary drawings and shall be installed to the updated building as condition af the building permit. Plan Review--Storm Draina�e: ! 1. The FEMA approved 100-year base flood elevation at the Renton Library over the Cedar River is elevation � 39.62 based upon the NAVD 88 Datum per the FEMA approved 2006 Cedar River Letter of Map Revision tLOMR}Case No.06-10-6596P. � 2. The Library is located over the floodway of the Cedar River and any work within the floodpiain or the ! floodway would have to compfy with City adopted ffood hazard regulations in the Critical Areas Ordinance ' and FEMA National Flood lnsurance Program regulations.This also incfudes comp[iance with the National Marine Fisheries Biological Opinion Reasanable and Prudent Alternatives regarding the National Flood Insurance Program compliance with the Endangered Species Act,as they relate to development in the FEMA floodplain.. ' 3. FEMA regu[ations require that when a structure is located in the 1oo-year floodplain,any substantial improvements(i.e.when cost of improvements exceeds 50%of the appraised value of the structure) require the structure to be brought up to current floodplain development standards. Any improvements - within the floodplain or floodway,such as placement of fill, piers or supports as part of the seismic retrofit work within the fl�odplain or floodway,wi11 need to comply with FEMA flaodplain requirements. 4. The applicant must show the 100-year base fload elevation(39.62 NAVD 88 patum)on the construction plans. 5. A drainage plan and drainage report was submitted with#he site plan application.The report complies with the 2009 King County Surface Water Manual and the 2009 City of Renton Amendments to the KCSWM, Chapters 1 and 2. A final TIR is required with the building permit. Plan Review—Transportation/Street: 1. A 12-foot sidewalk with cut-outs for street trees is not required to be constructed with the project. 2. A traffic study was not required for this project as the use is the same with a smaller building. Plan Review—General Comments: 1. All construction utility permits for drainage and street improvements will require separate plan su6mittals. All utility plans shaN conform to the Renton �rafting Standards. Plans shafl be prepared by a licensed Civil Engineer. FRC Reportl3-000255.docx i � • -------......----- ._... . .._. .. .. . .. ..... ......_.:. • �ty of Renton Department of Community&Economic Development Environmental Review Committee Report ; RfNTON LlBRARYAT LlBERTY PARK � LUA13-000255,EtF,SM,SA-H � Report oflune 17,2013 � Page 13 of 13 2. Separate permits are required for the water meter installation, side sewer connection,and storrn water connection. � Fire: 1. The fire hydrant and fire flow requirements for the proposed [ibrary are adequate as they exist. 2. 7he existing automatic fire sprinkler system will be required to be modified for any tenant improvement work. 3. The existing fire department apparatus access roads are adequate. 4. 7he existing automatic fire alarm system shall be replaced with an all new system as the existing system cannot meet current fire code requirements.System shall be fully addressable and full detection is required. . S. Exiting shall meet all current buifding and fire code requirerrtents. � � Police: � i Recommendations: Due to the renovation vs.new construction,this review waufd be better served by ! a security survey following the cornpletion of the improvement project. CFS would remain about the . same since there will be no additional structurai space added. ERC Reportl3-�00255.docx . i , � � # II I ► � � I . . � � �� gP �� Z . > ti ¢ �S � , r BASEBALI FIELD J'T p- ' �� TENi�t(S COURTS : qR � R� JONES �¢ . ...—. _•.—..---. . PARK _ BASKEtBALL � ' y� � COURT�S . �p�� ' . � @�o � upARK RNER AR3C . �'. ' . �5 ��' \ ��' � '� g�� ,� CE"q �. RENTOP4 � ' 0Q`� � ��` CENTER� R 5 2NO ST � 5 2Np ST '' ,�� ' LINEPTYP� • �S�p� . • ( EXiSTlNt3 � �' y . o��cE .�.� yo BUlIA1NG � CAf2C0 � ' . CFp,,,�R 7HEATf2E sn R�FR , � � ¢ ,�A�y . � a � a �' � t�J��R �.+�� '� �"i��4�� ¢ � � ��Ytfl{i`1 �V4�',10f1 � ' m � �o� {T S 3t20 ST `'� ��fit� �}�y iY11�5[� "'�� LV i3 . ✓ � � �� . � . �� ViCIN1TY MAP '1" = ZOQ' � ��=zoo,_o„ ��HI�3IT �. o� �oo� aoo� aao� eoo� CONSULTANT LlST SHEET INDEX ��R ;,,,G, � F�.IENT�N L��RAFaI( at LIBEI�TY ��[�K �,�,SA� �E�� t,�,�.�: t � RENTON,WASHINGTOIV � � � '��r�� ,��c'�� ,�,� Ti�,� �r,z�K . F¢�ts1f17t51 . . Mb20iqMp 1UF1 EIRVET . pug� C110 OW0111�W�PW1 . . ��a�,,, cm'T.es.�.nm • - »sssm,Kxq can rnamEEnnn • aMw.r�xnn T!QS/Y1i05 � ' •Frx4s.114e/M LLW IAMicIPEbIIEYI�W . CenletRMP�w Ll.N OOKKERUKL`fmAG➢EPLW � �� OfLO ME6�1'lHfl➢RYNA . 1fwAdlnMdPaM�MI� ' . 110�sM�.lMflo �� 9nW.1fA111q � � TN]u64I.Y01 k101 R00&PUW I � CM4t�IWM /e901 9U0.09106EYA710K� �d� 1 . . . ��M�LLEYN� a�+K� ' GY6EXGkffil /r3�1 EUIEa0RE1tlAWPEELEYAlI0N4 •�� . � ctupNkran.rL+N•.nbe . � 11]RnQ�MSM]01 �� . � sni.al�wtn iee 2�?I�s1m F �� . �09�,�,� �. . Sp�r/awwp . �me..u� � m . ne'�"'mu�ae ' . � t ' • . r.�m�s�w � 3 � poYR lihbml� ��,.a�� 0 5 . .�"�'°'�a..�"'"`°'a m o- � • . �.��»� J � °�R rR aaw.aw ' . ra muaw� � a.— Z a . �� f�9 � 'a'd vi . ��x�� a . . ea�awi�Am��ne . O J N W � vare4mviwn:i - F,.., � w � I � • s`�i��ier» . +� a a fA ,; �na a.ar+c.� F w U �.�� . v f Q r��=�,�� s.��w.� g ��-7 T�1Wm.�R o . �1 �a ��nW � � � , � UaNqNc . , � � � rn�awxry.s�I�tao . 4 � SmM1�flNigMSIm unAelma T4 t01S11.1611 �p, � . !u NU77]1N . . 'M inxscawn W�d:lwwNM.wtl � R� If1iRWOR4 4 __ IAHMvMeNweh �'�'� 1Wf/usMs�.t81a ? i • 3eNk.SbfNqt�1911N 1R i4KINl6v5 �J� ' � eamta �� . . � � �KY , ACOIIQIIC�LlNCR1EER �t0.PMR �� emw tA�0�M1Ohld�N00 N Oau fla 0 Se�16.11MYqb�MNi • • ,F if s � � � F M1�1oh�Y�wM � �'�tq �m�YiXRY HAACYIME _ Mmh CwNAn9 �Kr� �a • SllPi1�M90BYN Owp�,fiM1p n410] . MaY10 � � � FeY M17L8111 py.�p Poo4QCaiInNm ' �Myy COBTE9TMAi1NG ;y �y . � T � 'C � A�P�9 B�Y�.�4+K9�M101�� Sr�� 'I,,yv o��/� ' On4t�as 4f0101 '� r� Pt 10LNL100] Ch�Mk " � � �, �,�',� �'I��ni�7g t��vlsion ��-�--„� „�.� ,,� � . � . F�AR "'� �D�� TRLE SHEET ; � � . � • �VICINITY MAp 1"=200' �,--, ,—� /'� /\ � �•�� R 10D' ROV t�Q B00' � ��ll �.��\/ ��l ��0� '. ull `1�� S 1 EXHIBIT 2 � � . ' , - ----...... _ _.. .. . .---: ................... _... .... ..._ ---�----._.. . ._ ...__..._, , ---._.. ..-----------........... . .....-.._.....___.._ .__. -...----..._..._.._.. ........_. i i . - � . - , � � /� \ � ,L��-•* z`.`•:?. � . "i ` � � L�'�,�� i vi�o� /,� �. ...,:��`z`�.� :''i:•:, ,g ' ,` `�` , , .'�'�w.."�� P � ':"�' 1�'-•.'v�� '�'�.�`' APN:1 OS-8017 � "�.+"°,""�.a.,on. /,' Q� �,' ��.unm ,.L t ' �c� � .I V � "i.w."w.�'�" i / �r�,� • ae•nw...um 4 \ ,�. ' � ti mu�°isn � wenumeur�nw..�am ' , {'1 ` ��, i ,/�, �O �� ' � \ �`:C,�:::'y;M_ `'.�� \�� :`,+.� �exss � ' a+aes+�.l. ` �a / � / � �'` �/`\ ,�` �`,~� ��,,�5,.�� 3• � �� ' �r'r. � i ``�`.� �� `�'` . �`��yr��`' . .,I APN:1723059045 . . ti�� / / /'' � ``� �E��, �� R� • i / . `� I �� `, \ '\� 1 ''� .I I {� � '` \��: ♦\ ,.( � \\ �� / �' . �.,� 7.i.:^; �,�`�> � � _ . ; .,�,,:�.� ,.�. .� ' \: ��,. � I � ,•- .�"'�. ,. �'"'``\,�z� ` `\�^\'!\/ r� \\ �F ��.._'�I - �. ' � �4t� ' ; � �\. �,r . �. . <� . I ` �\ �'.='��:�.�_ �l�c' •ti1 1 ��.,� •-1 ;' ::'�'��-:m,`. :'�',:.••,' ; . 1 �i 1rl ..'\`^.,'7[, •.-��'�\ ` . ' ' :i.".. i ��'c�'w.�!� '"✓ �� - - !..�.'" j . ��i �� ',� .i�:�+:-,, �•�. `,�� _ r.�, � . � 1 i ;� r � ��'`'•^\ " .n `? !.��:�.':.�.,."^'.,::,�..'.:�.. � i '� I�I V •�` •.�i�.?�;�:.` '"FJIISTINGI-STORYBUIL'DING'.:.. . �• �. m /• � I � `:i: _ :�>R •\h.� �',,�• 1 !� _ 70BEALTEftED ``� .� `` � � i. •� �` ..� � 1��.:�Y % " 'i.�'::'..m�c��irnauanr�i�+arcnuuc� . .. .t''>. . � t .• ., �. x � � • � :�. ( r i _. �,; ',r� ': ��.�:.��,;::: -� ,� ,� - { ��..�..__- :i M C� z �j l . '''�'� _,��'\'t` ' I :� � '?:� ' .. "�'�.iu...�.�""'�.w��.q.:m�r� ' . . . . �^�" ��':4.'�'�'�'. u.l a � Il] � �,\ � '.��R�C.:`r"�"'',a;� ,d�'r �:``..•:"��\'�\) � � �r � I 1�j ` �., �:� \y. - -G1WbR o�is��iein cMwublp0� \.��\\i-�h`�\+.,`' . � � Z O . � �,�� ''�t4�Y, . .. Y� �.,\\:"\\`�. W � � -�� ,[�±�� ~� . . �Z`'�\� �.� ��:aj t'�� Z m � p�„'� � . - . . �� '\ L"�` .-�,'�,�� j � I . , ��.�� ``.�,,<.♦ O vi � � �� ... _ . - _ •'`��::� •: 1"' ►-' � � � .:� -,%` a I i �-�-,. � - - . �„�,�-. .r. Z � �n I ...� ��u /: q :' W 4 .�,�°'' �,��:,�•'• � J I >f �—�'�' =.�.`` _ _ - J�:` � g .—, � ��;� �`"'*,,�n�° ,� / ,,: �� o i . � •; . �`� - . .• , , �,.- � � ��, a'�,, �> . ..�~ M� � �I �� _ � �'�� '�• � ��;,�:�, : ' I o �j 1 �.' � � "",�° ;:• �,�..., `�'~�. � ° I � ? �;� ,,�,-'�`'� �' � ��'^,�� ,: �,��,� .� � • .3 w �I' •�`l ` ^�' [p� � ,� eMn� p�xCAMFM9�M811IN11 \ ' � J I a / '�� 'i Y`' .Y /'fA �`�.p '� , �' .\ .�'�� \ � `4./ p4pqw � � . J �o I'„i ce.TMo''�„ `�'�-1.'�."�' .!� "+�', �an ,,` :.� �z.\ �`h�, . I �g ` �'�.._ ' '�.. a"• � `1�,�,m,� ` , ,1� z �^T�.. � �y . � I j •�, i -. ,, � , 1r�: .l:Y��ti ��`'�'J . . �''°��y/ l`�T� R"4�� ' xa n..��n� o« f i � � � I"� �� I�a n i asoo-oo�a-`"' r jl ;':/j`�%'�`a �j�.t7�ifi�� V�S��r� � . ,: �` ! . '-f� ,.r'" -'-%• : s•�;/� `"��\�:. I -� ;•..,�. _ ��.:.•�'lr'' -----_.�i' f`�:�.;��'f/�'J.'�.a•. � i �J., .�. .�`/;�� ----___:;` ,�'(� •!✓:,;-r✓ ;' '\::. NfAR F 1�1� , r�� ..�\.. ,�;`. � :f � • r� % `, ' r.,''',.' ,-- . � '^ � '`` t / i i.l{\ i. �� _•1"-�,`�'t�, s.ieni � . , �:r� >' ! .1' ij ;• �._- ..-, i.a.o.K I � �i .�,`,� / � �. .r �:, :. . � oi.nn: � . � .,.-..` P / * `•-- \� �+� c�i.ewa:.�� . � . --._ .F `' , r' � I r;'. I �`p .—:%`�'. /-`' ff:��;( " _, � �: �� MwRa.n"a• i � , f` . . ^ ' .'..,. ). .�._ ':f �`3 �,,��• ; .;'� ;',� ., ��s��[�p � � 'r �_�.a- i,- ��! /�'�,` ��f % �,• ExfsTING �r:'�rr. �,.a• r • '-t.:_ .`� /. ' "� , r' ;�J ' BUILDING w i - � y�"�i` p� �_.r. - -..� � �_r r �1',;r�. � '� _.� r---� ARSITE�LAN t ,` • t ``:A� �' �� e t� ea '.�",�"w,�`-4-j-p_....'",:��,...1...'_._...,'—"r" ,'�.,�� 8�UTH2ND � � � ^+r . '_— � �� L� ;r �?`,�.NJ::�:^•'�'- ------ - ----- � srneEr E .� ,�.�',:3-^y �J r•-.•�..:k:f . . . �� SfTEPLAN , ..� ... .;-� ;- . . . �-003 ,'�� 'y"}`'.:. I ,�� vte..�.-0. J EXHIBIT 3 . _, Z o o � .� �� _ 12� � - � - � � l �,°� � ..... - �; � � o � �� _ — --- --�''`��yy'!d'�n��vr��°°� � �� , �• ti � _ ..._�. yd� 5i��b� �, t5oe6tlMN��381"�7-'� � � � t� ,�t �*t��x�� r {� �� +� �yp1N'� �� '�� s� _ �.�.�81'� �� ° � �. ti x � 1 t 1 �x.��"'�'c '�?' G �S'� 'i � . . � 1 �� a,�� a; � m�=:, � Q � ��. , `�l� , �, � 6 y` . ` ��:�€�� . . W' •.�'�-+ � � ��'.A� � �� r ° � ,l 1 � � � �o;t '��'� , �� w� , �� s ��g � `"�, �� g �+ '��.s� ��Q �� r��'�'� �� ,� � � �,� �� $�,��. C� � .� � � � �� ` a ��.. �.� . , . � �, � �� /,� � � . � �l a � �Y`s$ °g��, ', � � ' � } � �� :�_.� �..,(,� �,� 1 tA � f �' � ��,/{ . ' ��.. �� - � � „ Y . ,' `�; .�,.. ,, f, - � � �f �''��."�'...��:�� '' f � `` � �' � � � '.'l�,_ '�' ,. 'f:!l `�\'`'�' l � ;-,�'1� '•<.: �, .t l l `�g - � '{ +:�st:�'*�� !��') f�/ � ;�` i V+ ,� ��2 +� __;-� +r+'ary �� ..'.�y��Y��t=:Y�:'��.,'rf ' � , �t �� "a,� ,_,..---"" t i�-ac^�. ��r��.};;•35�.;�h' �� 1 � 4 .'Y':..�„ � � l. i�' ..� . a i.i._. :'i,,:::...+��hr � �� ' 6. �� '#Y.J 4*� ,�,�L ��" iyr,l'.< �:ia��, �':.a!�i;�..� r 1 } �,` C t j"� a� 1 S , :;�:;:. '�' / } * k�, .�'�. ••S" � S~ ��'��ti:"•�:�.�'�.'�i:$;i:i�`�:^• .N��'+ p (�.�"/ �♦ �8 y� y �' .: "'�. j� S , %.p �u n : ••• `:�i�• � ��yg fI}/i�:, r afj�� i � ,;<?.�i%i,?�:'g:;::.': sk 4y,;�p,. �{�'��;L - �._� " �Z, �/ ii�'r,:�G�. .�.'.r,vi.:;"%.`';�.:�"4�� a'tai.?3a ?y`4}�" +T olr. yj1'• ' .._ � . :�• �`.�'if,"`:y..�g��>`:!:!?�".�'i::;i:;;" t�:.4 ..� �,,,�,� f�'+ �c •.��; �\. 1 !�� "'�.v 3$.:: .. ... ,�!. d�. Z ' ";=e ''�,... �.r �ra' �l r� .�ti'>';:`��-,,;:r ��'`' i,�1 � p'0'^��'le��.-jJ. cy i�e,.� '�# '� � �:y.a; r?<"',=`'i:z. "«.�. � Z .e ',.9'v . F.� _ :� ;:�n.�:-.>r::>.�:.:^:�i'`::�'�;`. ,;,. �i:`.' �;,, ,`7` •�.-/ ,.� �; g� . � .`, - �''�'�>;ir5,<:i;:.s:':E>%=;:s�:':.'" ;%.. .�'. ''�:i.�.�' � �r/�, .� . :-� , . . p� Y� �,Tt� .� �,/f..;. �.�l.,;:;{;�.;;ri;i;k:� :al.. `i� ._�'' �',. ;,h�'' �=,;�� •' I� ,�_t .��; �' . y5 3 � .�� i�gy' :�'�;.t a.+°�'''- ) ,� P:R.j'�<' ':i. 7" �:� p„�h' ,E e$ Y J, f. e�4• ;:s�:2(-';� ;�':ij:�.':{i; f, .�.,A;,,` 'y'�y� p`�,...y � � /, {_�;:`A', �;^ t J� V�#' .,S 1 �a v„ '�� *'� •r -,:i;`" t �"iti>;; ��: iC' "/. `;>`x:;<��;;r;,�: ..:�::::;>:;��.<.. ..t 4 1 q ,/'� .�. °:w;%>":�fi.:.:.r�:-� ::e��w:�::.. �t,"•s�. ,. � ;� , �;, x ,. `t��ix':�'.:.;x.._.,.�:::, -::�;;��5:�:::.�>�>��,;<,.: s , ;,,4,� �i ", $n .L: ;:1::' :':'iay""i:a`z' ,.i,�..:+'.,iis�`�;'�k,e.rr:! f 'j. •n .,.c-� ',d J' ='S: '!.i .� w_. �„ r � � :;�3v, :+i�• .��•-. '� ,slt �+y,, •� :'•s';i:: •.�:�'z: p `i�- •�- �':i>�: :.<�'. �.,. s"�;:� � •r• ,� .:'r�:;::; ><r��:`;,. i � �tt��" .,.:.. �::t:> .vti. �L '� e` � �:�:.. ?r3::;�:..:�:<-�:�<..4 /.�. f a-4� .'9:�:: ':Y�:;`^ i�ix.,.�.�i:� .,vy.:t-.... ��' •�•�• •�M Ci / '� ".i'!:i.j•n��fi�'f o:Ji� ?::v::: 'tg`l<' �j f j.� .Y�"'s �T• �t;,a:' '�T• r}:.:•:1�. •7 �``�. ! �� ' na i n' �' '':7. i:."r'>:: ;•::;x;...:,r..',:`,x'f•'.`:;3,�-N�';,...:,?F:,c;:s �i ':�`"' ,:..r�€.�:� �`a• .f. .'��,~.:';ti::•.. a � r::k. f . �A'.x A J �� Y`�z�. .i .: y,�' � . `�:�.�:r.' i .7.. :``�Fii% �e '�.1-_ !l." i�'sr^�::: <?i'; .;,'f,,.:.. '10-./' � � r.�' .� �l.':.`>�'�`•:>..,.;: �,'"��'i:i?`:.;.; t �� p. �/� :��.:�. 'i,'.''i�'•`'':2�y{:i?a' ^.:3r':i:*' ;;:t:.;�;' � ':� f'' .�y t� /.� j..�, ;.:�;K:; :.�.�'�,::t. � '`f 4.:. �.��;',�--�,•,x � ^C :S:�F:.'T ::'r;.�.� / �, �:�+. . t - •';S?:; t '.�:.M, '� .g� �� i h3� >:::�::: ^''��:��'`��ii`� :! .r.� t. ::3 �' �� 1� .j� ��:�:�", x�i�:�- �':4>'� ��I�ri�� a.5„Y,•��{ !�: "`S:r �a, r F 1�' t ,z:�::.:: ;.::::�.::';;,;:; ,.�...:�.:.�' , .� .:<.;:` ,:'' �� ; �,,�;!. � �T� n4 i'••y,I.'':i•i us.: i;Jii?!'�":'.•.�'�i,U��`ni::�c ,5:.;:;�� .J�� t '. 1�4 �a�3! jr�/ i t t '�s:% ,;�::;3>% :i4:;".:, '�'r,::9yr' r '>\.< '-0: t. �.} �e.". •f!1 'r ��;r:�>':%: :;�:': '=.:t.:.:; � �+�� '�, r�, 1 :.s:;a..: ;.;r.:.y"�',:H:� _ ��-�-:t= . i.. f�'� w;�:i;; Y,� ';iit>wi. l Y�;, ,� / �>S�' Y.+ / �y�'.Y:•' •, / �1 :9�i�. i '`i+:: .�:r�^;� ti':�. :.�� 1 �:�: =�: �;:` �' � �, r•: ,.,.:. ..,.., ��. j� k , 1 � ��3 �- ��;� ,f. ��:• •�i. ..�,, �'�� `� . t� Y• �/ . /' i 1' :�. ,'u• t � �,y �A [� '!f . � :�y. f •.`'+F.;;;: � �'�'` .3�•. 1 - hi��"''.. .�s.4�`� �• 1 �"t> . �{' � � 'i, ,.4 !t ,Y-' :S„ �J � f .� � I ( . / 4 •'':.``i'r..i � s.�- +-�s � ! ��r/ /� 4�r'� �y ::'`e g+�,H p ^i• � � ! ,. /� � / `'4� �4�:`i:+,:�.`"� !~ �.+,• i a. �'�,. �4 'i Y i ::R ?�x.c . ,� � � �{ �"�:. :�-�:-':..'��••,ti .sa- , q �€a'��, �(�,.;�y�i t' "L3j � 4.�XT�^,::''�;,," c I '�..�. o� , J J� ,: ' , �� : �. r,- ' r - �• ; � �� I � � � .:�::::>.y .a: : � zk. .: `� / 'Eg� Y�. / / � . -` '-� '}�:` �� r� s' � a �'a` � �5�....o �`a. 1 t �r . ,f'�; '^?-c , 1,••ri � g d,:,�•�.,:�-` � � i ��g i 1 � • ;� � ,�c1t-� l�"'�:<. -;� �� '� � , � ' f1 1 ? '�i'r_,. ��,,,.�'. .�,�. � ��g �,. �� ,� �', , � � Jf ,J�1 ..J � f !3 . .r;�.,r��;:x, �^ `i i1,�"" �ga� 1�^�,'� . �;� '$ � _.J..�r S .. .� „- �; ' a . r � . ,. . `'"�.�`t,� �f� � +j t. ax�. ; �� 4�1� i ' `, �. �� f� ' f j.�': �� j � � �� :�' F�a t�`� . �'s n .� 1 �° �}.� � �`_ :� 7E �,� e � `�' ! �S�! � ' ;.¢ � 6�.k � •�,�'y�y�� .c�� a��.. a a ' R�,t,,�E'��`;/ � (� � 1 �ti ` 3 • } �e' . ,%%Y=. �S B�_p t�g5 '�c l�51 ' i� '`~• / �� I o�'�E �� } '�i � \� t�*^ �tfie�r�r.'ttiq�' s �f>�,�af�`'� � � p{Q�tii (;,�i.%., $_�. 1 ��`` ''�. ��t �.�*�S � a � ` f� � ,�9x �''.�l�. �d'��, .8 ��`�}E¢`Yi �i'�.• � s,��.a . ��,-',...T..t�'.t. "\ l , `\ ro '4-'1'�.u.-�¢�+r"" �� n� s j ...---'�a'�r�J�d � ...�"'""'...�- N ' �` t \ r' t�r L• Y"D 4" s"^'Ys ,nn� ..-,�;:,..-..� �.�� t 4 '� i;� r�,l� "�`-' �' ,.,,._-- ,b}� 'h � � �..�,��r,.5„?`'�_ � 1 ..: ` �,,,_.�.• d�ea ` /� `� �.� .�� /^�-', �r � � - �,..--"'` �.�>t�� ' � « `,�""' �.---- E '€- �`'�°S `•:�"Y�`�"",r,n. �- sY� � . �i.�` Y . � ' �� g ='� �^°S,��inW �� ,_� ` ' . ?�. �~ � ��z =----- C 4�� _,�,....�- ` � ��----�.-'- , ��4 a�:�b _._---- , ; " � '1 '.� , �-...�, �., , . . C'`�� j -�--'`" � , , .c., _..::'-,----`"" 1 �� , 6,�� .C"- � � ' . � , `�. f�`��.� �, ; . . . . .�, , . G . R UZ � . _ . ..�� ,i` � �;� C.? na t i 4 �* � O��+a,� F s� �� $�� '' ' -"�...._.,:-�� 1N31��w� � , ��.-••� ... �- �� '�' �Np1��`H�S �` ,.--„"'" ' x< � �t��{� +t3,"xa.f� ke,pe6`�N` d��'�'010�� S t ,�---- ��Q�;�.r�� , x��,,�N �,�� \ `d � ��£� � �� ,� t � - � � � a�:� � t�= c �'�- , � �: � � �9 i „ \ y �l ,��, '�.f��Y�� .�tf) � �'L,,,,,,�-��n"'�{{j``` �� .. '�j , �� 1'�`t A ` ��` � �� '�Y ,� 4°° � � � � � �� g� ��g�� t � . �1 � �� g�� g � � � �� ,a, �y , � � . � . � 10� � � ,/ , � �t � . � � � �� '`;��' `� � � , .f � �' . �� . �,%;,,. ��. ;�,�,,;° ��._ �' ;� 1� �� ;� �;,�,�,j t;� �� , _ p�, . 3 ^"`J � � �fr� ( l / �-��i"'v! t' � . ;q ,*! `1; �� E ��l( � / �...:.�� ['}��1 R� � � �l. �/.f i t � f f/ ,` {':� + � �� }� .�'f tr,( � i � t:: t �y�� ':� � �� •�,(.i j �: , s� 1 , .� �•� + / /.• 1i� , n, +s� '�` ;� f ' / ..- ,�' / �''� � ! r. g' ygt �-' '�''.'�a,�,� r ; 1 F. . � � '`� Y: ,.� 1 /' < �' , ` ' : �i' r'`, s ,' f � � � .�% n� J� .� v..-�.,_ � . ��. ��' " { y '�':L' ��'{; `.a q , '_ , ,J �A ' .: �.�,�� t,�x :��\'.,. 1 ..,+�.., "` 1' ��.�� a.��'�`r"4 �' �' . } ,�. � 't . _---' � iy� ` /�., � l ,' .j.r.� : "" `'��.�' ��;'� ' I��/:; .�' f� ` �.�•� ''�!:��.,,,i 'z b',z`\�y,°��<;'�,r ; %` M;�� r' '� �~ 1'•�..,.` �~�+. ''+'. r E. ,�. R t i i/ i }.;:. f"w!` �� \ : .t, +� � � 4 � �4" ,',' t� N j i( <✓r` ,')' ��`�`. .�.�� ,r, , �"- 3 /�ri ` 1�� t � �\�/�%�..('�.M1._. � ''. � ��0.�"�.ey fe �` :: $ � J � "r yy '4 � . � '`:% . ' :;� .i�� , : L.. ' �'y`r� "�• `rs�='y�� F �Y ;t� : �, , , �;,. �'y''� �y g .r', - /f l � �+T��`�i,"`o'��.. Jr� ,,.. . �'r . �,. ,,.. }� � � 2 �.t . `E% :'' ' '"�` .,,�\,� , �5'.� :�� ;`t � ( 1� e f - r �7'`�! �. . �� ".�`•.,, ' k . a t /f f i� � 1 �Jx/,�!,. F �` �.: �. "r., ^�c• •" � /•d'� I y f �' T �° ' ':,f. . � ^ s ,-��;.. ^� :� �+�' t'a; � !� �r � .. � � 1,'i �'',, ,��;,'..._$!:.`~�� i ' /.� r 1 ` // �� . �.a"' r \ ur��.....�_ . .:.� .�-�� ' . . �f�#a�f ��` //,��/ , J�.. � I� /J �� i?�'�:.�":�t ��: �r. � �.I '@ -.; ♦ .r�;� ,r : , p� / ) .y �� :s r j � J .6�•-, '•� �4' : y J � j , , t �ib ;;�( ' r✓� :y,_' :•`� �,`+,.+. fi="`'y': ili� �y4+f/- 1 � : �` � �.r, d�i •� \' ~ ' � 1. `7�� ''� ; �i .jI 7 . ,. dr�� / . '��:. +�yr. .�r`��(/ '�r_ j '' i � If � y��.;t�:�.� � �:�r� � ��; �� .��` ,'; � � fl f � ♦ t4.-� � 'r� �'. �.�� l ,. . ,' �/ ,,�T r��;,�t - . f ,� S �:�. � ��.�:��:��-.. ... . �f /' . �Il� te P�tl� f I I'�,h• �!� l /�� ?J,. 1e .-� � �t�ti�� Q��1• � ac,� rr'1 � / C j`�,R. :� � f,'--� ,� `` a �`��ea ', .�r�,,�:- � �r• >��,. �,�,� '� j ��r� j , f J ''�� -y� �♦ l:; � ��, �"�..`:.–:— ��'�. ?,�,j�` �z�� ?i r � ;�� r,� a.�� . . 1J / r/� . � '�1f� )`l� ,j ;_ .��R;�`�J '! y y��i� '��,� s � / � �r �� S� :j��t l••, `'1'4:� '-A�,'1� 3:"'\r - �y�.'i}��. ` } :,. j , � �p},4 �., .,,, ,, . . �, , � , ,� ;. . ..� , k� .��: r f�/.., '�'�I ` ..�,�� '� ,� �� ' ; ! �( r �. � *a L'4 . ,f'� .3"1'� �, �i�'1 �\ / :/ j` "�f ♦�� ; �` F5� 4� �h� ).�,C \ � {'yg f/ )f�k! . l{�' � �e �`�` -"� w '�0. t , ��s .�'^ (+� f S. �y % ti `x� �\ $f�.�l ,tc�'�.,� `'` � , �* �= l� �j'a�c��y i'a.%OO� �1 �'�c Y.�j ,`i ir d' t �'�; ,N" :��,+� E j ~ �r., �E a�.'il • ��1 ,3$ �y.,n+��n I' 2 �.�1 r.,�,� �i'�':N. � � \� fi �i�* �� 1.%`3' ti'* `'�y-.-c ,` ,,� `� �� 4 '�/ z � ,ek4' `,'1 ; �'gy�' `';�'.�*�sa�s.ri M '�.`-"° � � `� ', g lf �''-is��. g 41 G#g _ '� �Y=��...1� v, �°\ � / `\ e rJ `"::1-�"" g� ! ^�l..o.^ .-•-.-""`-� �+ ♦>.`� \ � � �rr�i t* .S°�"f��' �� rE r" ��.,.r-""'�."`��g�3 `� i. f 9 l {' � '# k.r_ i y� :�# ,� __�-.- �, +�"'i'�ga � (�•\ `\ � x'aY \• „! ..��,�1 1 r . ,�„_..�.-�--�' :�'�'y'��d'�z �� N'�`�'ws°., ,.;il��*""x� k, i'�}¢R ^ � ..-„-� '�� :3�9'iR y . . ` / a -.�.... � . �t�t�,�+�,yo�tta^YUl4d V . � �ao� � �i ..-- Yi°5 � -''�y'� . �` � . ��."i� . � `\: �'+~ _,..-�-� � 4 � -"'-;"' � �\ . ✓er ��'"" � � ��~ � • �,'..,.- i ' \�� a -''�ir � . ' ' \ �� g �� k : .� �� , , , � �' � :__—"� - � � �� o � �'. - - � Ng � _ _ _-- � , l z �a � , _-___ � t, � � 1 £��jd"�ld 31\S ��oat ' t` � ' t '�� ,� i. � •�,3� os3nr�^ "'� � .� �` ` `� . - ��°� �� oesdM'�0� gi'i 1'Q • --' ---� � .. �� °t�i��,�t� �$��'��{�� d1,s.�3 ay��}� � _ . . . ��`} � � ; 1*��'9,�N wo� °�� . � .� �_ �e �_ s� �� . � � �� 1�,P�� Sy,+� e � S. � � 1, (��1 �� '��h � - �� .L3""` � a... x.s e_,. +�'��F� �' { '� � .r.. � g �-=`�� '� � � e ? ' ,`rJ p �Yp�� ,��'f�� 5 k� i 1 ^�+^�� ^ � �1 � i�p k 1 $�1 � ��'S '3 9� �� , ' � .�' M �i �n s �pg, i ; l' � �M �r,"��,g� eE � YE � � T� , i _ 4 , 1 �".�` '"��~}'��r, ��`¢,$�"$� ��i�� - ,I �� _ �!�C� �'� � r _x `�'�_ � �.�►' � �� , ::�t::� �� . :.:� � °` ��!`:�:. �- �d`� - � �:-:r:�: � �, , � � �� f.. _F . � , �a.� � � . �� _� j � y � Q � �' � Q �' t�! �. , � '" '�i � , � � i� ,� � rf� � ,' i �, 1<� � - t� � t ,;'��'��`?�.,� • ,(.�` ` � ��a �' � � '� 8n t'�� :��'��• '�t� ,�`/,ffl 1 �'' ,. . ' /r'• ` f y{ "�w Q F` x E� ?�-✓• `r/!/ f /��^�' �� 'CSS �2 lprrr ,'•� �'. ' /j...•�'! /�.�*r1'��'� � J�; '� � °#� {� � , /r � t ! 7 r It.•', � 1 S�� ._ . ",- :';'>. , � � , •s:�: N , "` �" ' ,,,:�'� r � � ,:: � .� t ��1� f�+� t � � ._.— � �.. F� � Y� � h� �� '1 { � w� i t 6 /%�. ti �� ', .;� � � � �:t,, � .'` ' �,�.?I'� "` •/i� / —�,..' ,'. ,�z�I,' � �� / !:�`` �p� f;(�„ �� Y+ ,�` .;"�/ � : a.� '�� .� �� ''• __ - ' 4�'' p�r +e ��''«..__� . . ' —' "' r . � � J ` � Y � ` T . ^ �� 'Y J i�� }'.��'y , ';f�,4 ��`�"i�� t" �y �* ��,R� n r�� . t��''��. .f 'Y f r l! St '��•k'� ��'. og @�S; � � � r, �.:�� ' . . ' L� Y 'i t �j�ji , � r`� • �. .� �! ,�";_ i'�� Y� � ��k��A....Y�.. ii .t;��' � ;�`-y� •j' '� '�,,-'` . � ., v"1 �: �`l..-^ �`1_:�:'t yr�� ,v , �:/, �'�� ' ' t' .�� .�. 1� '.2-', .-'^`� "�.h ,,.. , S�iw:' , ! ��a '/✓ � �`., i:�},'.t. /''ti'��' •. ` :� .� .j�'�� ' ,�� }:" �,; .;,:.Tlf:;11 t :�.; *{��'��.�.,� �':" ��}� .�� '�y i �s `� ''� ie'L��F' r � � � i .�`1NkX��,:n:��:•/'. :i ,� � �;:�W�,'._�� ,�� r . ;i t i t�.�rr f.;- `/�'°� - .�1 �_''��::.��:"�§ �R` '��`� 1 � , 3 t� ¢ r �" ' / Y Z, .+�.;.`-`. .i.: \ �`r:�:� ,� .� . � �s�iq f �Y".;;y:�l� �� :r�/ 1 f , f t �y3'��'.' �.._f� f: g_` .,�� ' 1.i' . ` �. �r�-= ::�;';j ,�,�J„ r � r'�'�,!:'':.� ,1 F�� r?�iy' 1 , ♦ �:. :��J(�/f• 5 /� ,�: � # � ��/�'ci� 'N;�'i'; i;�.�'�!- �'f ' f `, /` +�� y, 1 '�., r.! � / �t � � ' ,\ 4��„ .' Qt'� ,,''t t 'jj� g1( ��Ji�p a t `�� / � � x1� ` 1 2�=. t f;f J �f 76 � ! / .y!' J.'. ,' �. �.6��K,� . ,., ` 4 � t +I. �J�j�( r �a s 1 � r✓. � ^i�� n�.�i ��, � 1 f �!! �f�� `��'� � ( ,�� p• � � �¢ �4;;:� :rT• r '� S1 I I ,f .s �`• o �; �-TM � �� , t,� � �� w "� . , � � � �V" "�'r 9 � <�% ' . � ��@ �r .'�+ � � 5 . r � �R=` �.. � �t '"_-" ', � =i g.,,, � r '�'a"` �� ; �'� VJ i '��d � �� _ a.�m t {;�- -�. � ''�� r. �, ` . .� , f r�� )> ' ry� �' .,"�i� ' � �ya �5 l.,\: a��g •f�/' �(' �i f. �2n �` _ '�Y�S�'�,f.��' . �! . \ � � � !'� / � ,} ¢ /y x .;� R� . r 1 j..• a� �p�� /� '� w \ �i $ Sh �g �s z�R�V �\ r�'¢ie'�'�� r �`./ dg �,,"�� ;'_ �� a�s��. �,�� 8 ,�"i�f '� +b .�� t��a` c ��°��:-1� ' `� '- " �"' �. a' + t y �;�- l �;#' � � ; � 1�.. i � '��,��.�.� �� ' �, '� � ��..3��'��'� ,.,y '�""'` � '� • '1��--- �$ � .��,�n j/ _._.—'�';��'�ii �......----'�� °'�a ' ; *��,' t ,"� � "#' --�"�'" ,� � a , �� ;% � , . r _-�.�r' +,ars „ �� st�:i: . .r' • r',� ` • F`�+ � ^ ; c� "°�`��$; . �:�; SS � +� � . $��' ¢�� ,��`�'`: �� `�;}.---'--'��sY�'� �R��; �:�$ 's4�"t - ��.�.,y,�-- � ,�� . ---� � �;� . � ____,_�_---;- , x � __--_- � �� a� __.--- , _�- , I f_.. � 1 ♦,,\ r'�^ t . / �� Y � ' / ` , `� �� ' �` • , �la4 . '�� . . � . '"{"! i..urx�e+wwi+.v " . �\ '-♦ . � w:.�.,�:n''.� / � � -� / ! • • I N ~ . ��,^ � - . ' . �s2'�0 �t�..°1�'..w� � ,�� I��1.? t�Y � ....... ' . 4C AM AC�IC CAP�XC$7ALS . . � ,i ji,, 'I�,.i `. 'bY„'. ,v' ..;:.ra�Mr µn�+Ai /}(� � •I •Np' � OII�PJ� � • .,��5�•:��n � t[FtlPE�j�T IMIRf i .•--��•—• L1M M 71tlx M+•• �/ \ ' �' 6CY.S�tA � � �i,�^��.4�«"y:�' .iANOI � � HWMICpKA �'i r� '!:�'•,��. 'R:r,i :.�':�,. �asnure�Wa@�1'�-0yf�••. �'� \ , gi� j Q;�� • .l tr0��cs R'6WG�' ' . . �� ;i, �''+151'z��:�"o�'",• ::�i��o �K S""Ef�I.BEt01�' .m�.� � 9ENCtt 0. �i . ��.,""+i..4:�. . rw.:. �If i�� r , a SM9N P[CCF,AQ.E ��' �+ `� Y�� k t r r,�. � :... '�+'� ! � . mamm . `~\ �, .�,�,`..�\'y`� {f,, E BIRttEP/dt ` \' • � ., �y�r, . �\��y�'l` � Y .,;+ x~ � �� . �"". .. �,� \ '" ,,,�J�~ ;I o• !'• ? �',� 1 o PImPO5F0 DEGWNIS fpEE4 "�� . 4�;:• �r i � � . `� 1 �lP� • ��, ` x 5. � r.:�. ' . ...'n '':\,�,,. �� i q' � '�'� �� , i, �i�� }'�ir.� " � G � `�.��'�`'`:� . t,,� i "� ,�'�. '..� y r`5. �� 'j�j=$ennas . Q nm.irres ro Rwm f ` ''�� '„ ' �i •. �� • .y :�• '',4�., I .` `,,�.. a `� 5anc,vkm.s tmm ..M. '�'` . `'• ;` :� �,f:'��`'. �'`+,�' �, f` r'�, un�rae0�OIS�.'�ifL � �`n . i+ '� t�,. ��K•=`t[•`. � ` 1' ,� •n�t. I � �,^ •',; �`, ° " t t �.�w` N � . .` 't�Y�,'`-Y � � 4 �' 4 ' '''.��Ji_ `� �5,� ,;.;��', e:' \ , Q/y Y 3 �r. � J� 1 '�4�T� ~ . ~;+�� ~�..�� J O !' 1`y`� � Q f.7 ��`+ � . f } t � ,��"}`L�i,�\�'t ._� �'�, p�v�t�o . �/ '�;y a � W� ' , � .N �,o-�j Il- a, ',., sE xnwtum :`Y oazr. �,y, ^' S- m tY . � t �wnu aA�. S., s-�j F�`. x �.` , . , �: 4� �s 1— � 2"�'! r ,� '?j, -,� ' ,o aoum \q�, '�'� � �o ' S� �`�'a � �'`.,� � nasr. w vi . i ! j` + .��,�:,:.�': i �''l-.. �'�.,� ' � .\� ��'^�y:��•`�`• - • O � '�j O' � .. � � T ._ . ,� °, _ ,_, ��f�,- .��b . �.�- �� =;�"�,.m �� - � � _ ,� �,� i � r.ri?.a. � J'�'��.ti:��/ ��' •. � �"'�.,. � a UY � vIi , i � _�'�ks'__' � �,, T` �`^�''� � � � ¢ � �S i F ' . b. �Y �'�I r tSIKt ~��ti� • �`.y �.` •I . � Y�I � . �� , � ` t � � � _ ..6��r�yl "+� a� e�,�fFY1h' \ .� � h �\ �� ..f},� : � .L�� +/�6UqfE17T - •��" �" '�/• �r _ i~'-\.` • � • • � � ��' {� �'J� �` �� •�'y (` �,1:�� E ~ '�� ,�.,,� ' � I' � , ,�` �`�`�~s� . ' � •r� �s,, �._.: .�� : ', �=` >'� ' �,°'"�` � � i 1 P' _ , ifr t ' �S:�:�t � ':�`ihy 'Y� , , . � � c 'MKJ, �� •':` F; • 11� � ,i^ y.."ull .°" h— , <, x' �'i ...i �� . ,�;' :-i��.`+.: .a�umu.aev.s+.00 . i � i"" r,+,.!.'r Rl . �'�• , �a�� . . x t»,�.na, aa� � ` E - i `� � � Nt �`�'�� %� iQ t�Dh. . f� �:3:.r EP51 �~�� . I �.,'�j�a•r . a��'�% /.�-�1j i136EMiE5 �F�'f'�� ' . �. , F ` /� � o`� fi"f•+.f}f'. t F�,;'�.ti',�t'. ,,.y. �,�w ':i��' C3� �'�'3��l�i � ' r' t }� � � � 'r •� �,' . ,' '� �..�,. t. . • ,�" ,J ' ' .� r- r" . ��' . ,-'°�� ,� . PEan��ting i�ivisit�rt � -'�� .� f � ��: , ; w' �,r�;. � J ,�p _.. ' / r ' ,y 4�.1 - , . . _ ».np�a� �"�' ' n,� / _' f ' _„.�4.��..p'i �' .��ti'��`__. ^ __� z--�J `~ 7�'1{} �� W �� ' !, s.y�'3, �'rt. :;f• �:�`'ti'•5 r/'M•�PIT LIIR�,r ~\ . �Ii1K11 � .J J,' �� .. � . �7 � ^ �. :�i.��+��1. •.. ` . �_�s .h..'('S.*''z�`•:�.�r.Y :�"�r wti 5 2Nd 5T. `'+� . �:� -'== ..._ _.� ' "��i'�'J�� . ,�-•r - �,�Y'~�.. _. .. _ �L'�,��1�U 1'J L�LJ tANQSC�APE ,."�""---�'..."'�.. �t_ '�'�,7!� . � ��`•''• ',,':- . . . ^\ . SITE PLAN � ... "'. ::".'�':�.. ._, .. .. /�"� . 1�LANOSCAPE 9iTE PLAN "" '' �� y�1�I t—Y-1 • scuc r•zv.v o �� o �o ��FT V.J L'i.00 .. . EXH=BIT ? � .,,,,.,....-►�' ..-•--�""►-�".....� __--�____...__- , ` � ��+ �7' '°d� G a 1�17�,� � �`;i . � �z°' ..1 � s�oi os�s a g � . ��lIS } " 'q, M3� s�Kan�t��twAo� � '��i�� c� ,' � � � i 'j��#�� r� L�6d� t � I , ��,a�sn�-�` �,,� � . ��g� �,�;ar� N°�� . ' � �` � � � � �n,�p � � � � t� a t� I ' " � +n ,•r -�r�"'�, • . � ? � c� �� 3 � .�` � ,1 '= � � ��- � � � �� Q � ' �� q s �� a � � � a�g` $,88 8�i�.�'��e a a�� ' � g � � � � �� 0 � �� § � �� .� >�>� � �� =� �� e�� = r � �� .�� a � ;. �� P n � N �ty � '❑ � . �� / : �� '� ° �--� � . j -�' �� CU � � , � t � ,, .s ` . r � �s{ / t" 1 . , � r . ��..„ , �,, • < o / " _ �� '� � . , s , � J f -t _/ � •j0 ..:..\„! �//��py�'J :! � o ' r�s � t��,�'�r::,E:�'.xJ .� .� ! . _ { `�' a�, � 5 g3a:.,. i P :�i _•,� • ;��•��J ��/� "�' . , , '•f li :t��':•�.�� • . _ ' -__. . _—y;�:-�,�� _,.: . . . � � � . . ��,':1 q��yy,; .,�.• ;;��` ' �y,,• ! , ' ' 'O`}' ..2—��"� :;��' � ` ." .. � `�.' ' . � ' ,.., s;.•: , ; , ,{ .,` �f�� s ,�. � t,; {�, � r_;:'r•�,, . . �`';c�//�� ,:j :; • '�' � ` N .i ✓ !�f f•J„ 1 . '�{ ?f° � \�-Jj . f . - O . . _; ��• ({, '; fi' , • .•'r �p ~'p�t.� . � z , m 4 �jt•+� ':j,• ',3^ .f! , j�� !'��y ��+� . *+� � � {� .v. '_f: �I � ..-.'^Y-�S �i�" � � .1- .. ' —_ '� � �� e �i .�' _� .a^`., :�v'. ,'4. ± � 4� - :.'"�..�.^,'�•_•y ^ -f` � ,'(,.: •`�•� ..�'n�.�7`Y�it�n\�� , • � � 'd • ` f�i :t� _.. ':.�.�a � ti, o . . ,�' ,'r.1'�`y; �;'ii�,�t�:ti� � ��.-. ., t .,� ..z_�r7x Ii/ . r':r, . '.;,..V. ..�[;. � .�._.. �w• , y'':-�- � ,;`}.Y .�:ti'. . '�^.:��rl:, .: 1' ,.,,r.:• . � p`:` .�.. g . �"S y -•. �,', �:.. �'��;. .'` _ t�� '�,�'� ,�.j''� ..,rs.�:..._,:.:�;.v:r'. ' .S�}' .'�Ml v • . e � )f` !:~n.,� '�;^rs;,�; �:'t�e�=.��'�' �t . �s ` �� . � " ';;:�..:, ��; -' 1 % ;�.�� , .. , . �'� �-,`�-.':"'�- s . ��`� ' ''''+-.r�`G�l"� ' ��`�,�' ?`, � '�� • ''��\"��`t�+' . e �;`��'. �. � •r �. � �;�� .,,;• � ``?'a�w�. ' •.,-�,;:..• T:r_ rr.. .' , ^•' 'r`< h� �,.� . :x-.,;y'ti` ` ��f'`��'. 'ti<.,`.?'� . r�•� -��^ � ` :`J.•.t'��`•�`,. . . 'F \, \ Y ? . .•` / -.S�.3�. / ' �'1. .Y'.� f . . �\,� .. f f `�e�". . �.r. I'' . `y f" '�� 'rj- {�� t - �f f �s.},;� .j..�,,f. :', , 't° ; ':-� '�- ��'-' . 4 � ''r� ' l.� . , '�''�:n � '�� ...-- '� •�: , 'ti , t _./ `'�`� :�. f :,��, ?'"��:�;� �, �. � � �'�'�=: . � ��yr- =� ��f��`�;�� .. .;�,. , �.�; , �,r� �y_ .�, C� -;... � '.t i � t `� _� t'• '�� . . � • �(t5 i � . �, ,.. � . . � �� '� . i . , sj %?° ' • .,' �. �'•'i'�'f'`'�' �;' .:�'-', !7' ' � "-�.:=.t--�_ :�Yf 'i . . :...�ry, '� ,.� .. r �� . �,� :.�� ::t � � . . . � -i '��- >-;:i:` �..� � <,x. J �d . : � 1 a. , . ?��+� �::; . .��.. k . , �.,�'� - � �, u� � � i' ' • '�_s" : ' `'� . . `•��'�`d� . , . � i,j' �::f•�.�y . 1 ' d S . ,._ } 4 �� l. , . ".��J i�i•�'., . '� ti.t.�.` �•�•' _ , �... ... � t? '�ynC�.�''�. :�r';J�� ':t. {,'�. i,'� ,t �1,,.. . V5._ I..i.+ ��,�j Z . . �. y e _ �``°�'`` ,.rr'_, / y� �. .`:„ �'y U:'S�' . � � . `\ i, t'�+l •� t.� `:y;- . . .F:��i�; '� { � .I ¢�? � ��r.. .y .� ,., � `, . �� '�,. . : �� : b�b{ `,� r Y,J n.- '� �r� . . , � :. � �'° � ,�� . Z� . .. y4!�, �� ' �I'•'`.-:.��'� ' ,��,i ~ � � ' . yy .� "K•,,.L`^"'. �� . . OS � '.�, /. _:----`y r S} .� U '� `� $ . .'" ;'":�,. _-_ . �,� ..,�,.: �a . .��p�:'�-�`' ,:�� . `�.� ; � -r. f�':�:� ,..-�•�R'^.+9M1 AW SdP�W .. . . . v� .... Zi....�- . .. .tY ..... ' ... �� . ']Y :` . �:5'. \�y" ~b � —^ — �.. .,S.j�Y��,r+" �� .,;. r`�;;:;. .. � . � _:� :,i� _ . 4 �� ___.__� — �, _------ . . . __._..____--- . .� :�/ . ._..___.--- . , ------ , . , . �� j �^� .,�.. . . . . �. . � - :i . � � . � � .: _.. . �� ....._._.. �,oz � .. �as ...� � , ------- -------- _..__.. �� ... E��oE�S � +- __..�.---�- }4�.31l��t�'id 4 Z �' N3nvTitV+oa� �, a �. ___ -" " �;�yi�s=g f �q.�e .L9086VM�N0}.N��3IH.1t1�53� �$�� i '�1��t�E �3 �21�fd��9lll , ,F��s� A�� ,�;p1N3�1 _ � � � � � � � � � �� ' � �I i o � , �n � `� � �� ' S � � � • � � �? N � ` `� �� .� ��(� � 1�" �� t�� s gj9 ++ r t � � l5 5e'6 �� .,�� Sy 1� 1:..�J � ((�� N n� • � ��t� � � � �g �� 3" � � �? � � s��p . �� ° ` ° � � � � i �� + �� . �' CCS � �uui �""� � S�� ' E� � ,s1 � � �4 � �� `� [1,. . a �y �,i,,�C �� 8 $ �� p��=t . � �� 0� � � � � ��Q ��#��d�� b �� s;��3.`n ' . • � � v �'� $ '� t��E Y � AE��i �� a�F� �i � ��t��:��- �% • . �r�r� � �553 � F 6 a r . a f� � � � ,� .- � r � � . . ', , , � . / ' �: � - �t.`� , .`,.;. . � a . . � .., .� � �.�� ., J,, .,< / .`�. tl� �I�- ^,`` t ---� �� - . N' '� ��/� •,f�' },�, j• � f � � �• f I + S —' , f '��.}4'.4: � /y s:�• . +— � y��..—�..«.._ �j— e� ��',y��' .t�.. ` !.'� . cY ,1 .� �.�-��'�'�!^'e��-.s�,`,f�:f- 'f,r' ') � ' J � � �... '�. �(�}..:�`,r.;� !/,` >`.] ..y 1��.� �; � r�' y• t . ;�,� �t . .d-- -�}'`�Lf.,:�'f 4~'�' , r'�?:;'r ;� { i ..�}�• � '. i�M . ... - -- � ;y;.� ; ,: °~ ;t`.�:;-�. � .-`�`' ; '� � � . :.' �. - � , .:,. , .{` . 6 �e ' .d'',',1 f' .��'�;�'�:�'' '•a' ��',`-�`a., �� {�• �'� � .:f ,j.i 'y,. '�� a' �1�i ,1 , ° ,_s`�..t '+k;�: � f' w �•.��'f e'r �`j� f : ...d�l: ^:,,' �,""'� �B rr�' ` .I T'r 't- � z /`� ' • ,,� r z;��f i� �j",,�,,r ..�'-'' ::�, •7.� �';- S:.'r, a 't� � :: r� N ' � � ;'i }� 1� > 1 �'-a:� . . _ ; S fy ��"�,' . : Y �>� }.• _ � � . �T "``7"..--�1" . �` �O ,`r f:�, . i y �"�,:..�- . 'j '�j.�o� -�:l, , - �, a. '' .�1:." + � ri� " ,+.+' r�' ' : = t '' �,7t, i • L/I�'fJ'' �:'rJ: . { � � ..�, � :. - ��;'�s,;' A�� i ' '�' �'�8.: x' /`rj � r �x'' s t��`-�'"�',�`./ ,,�'� •,f-„'✓, �a�a,^�. � � ,) � ~r � �.: :' '� .s -. ._ �'�(..�-�..�4 . 'i �'lf •�iry,�4;��`�:.. � _. � . f Y'r? ify f�t r' . ,, �/� f+. �y..."`�' '.f.�� .s� � �� f} /:'!-' �` �. . J'f t{"�;,; ti-• �,x;.} .' .;�,, ' :> fr , . �1. •;r c._..�w' `v_•�,f ��:_�,., ,/ '5.�;,, ,�!�. - ';i��"r. + �'�'r`p'i:+iT `/��ti- `t�� l;�l�•�''�`'�\ .i'- ��.�i`..JF� .�J, �.�•� ! �•�"`:s'p�@a.+ :3y.,'.- 'r• I ,}r f-'r' .'/�. _ �G,��;��- -iQ`.,./,.;�: :;� . ��i y l.•'�f%' � ,»:� ._i 'f%;",.�' ��,��Q:"�� `--^ k'�V�.'�.„�� y�'l ,� . I ,�� _ y:. . �� j / � � ��. •,.` -!t, :'''fJ'�,• ` u,' t / �.. .. ;�y/�! �'' �,�a, �';.�''�"\-�1 � �I " a�T.Y�.. �'�'.:�.%,'.� ,�� / r _ ��y ��,� .I.f-,�''' •�/•�.r / . 1~ � `�','� r� r, �' '' !. .l'4rp? j }'�F: �" �'t ...,�`.�... � .��,: ..��. _�i,�j��:� . �� : f�.. ; r,` °�y�� '� ,�,:1 r.��-� r , .� . I , �� ,� .�-`: �. ; ju �_ ,n ',.,;:: . ��f.7�3'/ .�°�. x't n�,:�.y 1 �f 'iy`� ;Y�l�i�y_ � •.s;. �:,�, � •f..!.-� . .',�„ � 1 7�,. r' '° , f • .l _ �„ � �: a�-.r ��F� {�� . � �f��, y�,.. i:' I . ;'; r � / ;'`` . :'��1;1 r: . �� E... ''m», - ,- ...--� 'r�$ �y.' .�4' ,� � .r!.. `( / ; �. � �l �a;,,3, : t f . �� ;j,. .:�1.� � � l^�", � . :`"`-, x ;: � • ' • t�'��V � � � �'J `�, ' ` �'"� : ,, :,,��„'' ,.� ,1�jr." .*1 : ,��; 1 . �/ �iY , F' t`�v'J.," � :�`��`•�t �t r':`:.�s f Y, . �'.�``- . . � ,,,, `p:;-_ '` ` •, � � ;r_- _ ;:..,r, 4>>: . �}" �}x • . � �,:�, �._. i ;�:-� �/''� ' �;:'' � � �:` ,. � � ' �� . . .S;�l,� ir,..�'.:t�"'�.... -�^�}" "^.-�_ '�' . .L ' �y _ � � � . ;c^+.'r :, ..,. � � _J /: a�'i. . ' t < ....��t j��'(,ry-d:'�i � },y l � � . . ;:sti.• r F a' 1f'�`'r>'� � :i}� .��{' .y t •. � � A" j± ! �t:�;�- f'ly``''"'r� �. $ . $' � �, � . •�;�1 ,. + K `\ � ` _ i �Y`' "�.�.� °Lr. . .. - . . O f ftt ,�. � : ,.,��`,' .�., �.�;,�, r- � . ' . �j, �l;;; •�'r ` ' � - ' '�.'v 't_.' � �'} � . Z i�''-�.`! . '.� (t'I :x� ' y , r�L' J ,��'"�',¢ t�, � >R • ,`� ' ..,.....-. . . '' i. :B .`` ! � �; / : �` �`v' rv: '��s z . . ,,{;;•.r l•� ,v/ � V t�: ��'"' . . .''�. •,\ rv NP� ± ' .. �L' �'1,1�� `\ � :l� x, � � � �'• � ;''� "'t � 11: � � �-� . �O �•T/ �?;��i . '�' 1_ . �L • .'.,7 /-^ �,.';• }; . {b'3" `� �a:s s.�S,j`,\ �, ,s•� d•s, i ��i' . k � , . "., . - '^��" . r'%�� ;' + .�� 5/ . .. x'�:. . ,.r=.. _ �s• : �S,� ' ' _':`,l.�i'�„i�! �--;{ � '� i �. ',-�„_:.'_--+-:� '��'._.." ' ,f;!*�• , d'� `\ /:.�I ` A c k�'j'" �� r'r(. „��.:-�.. = _"`ia''�Y f'�+"`.., � �._-v}_ F _ ,z�- ^",:�`;: '"_ `,,� ' 'v• ;:� ,�-- raai+T+ala�ta.......;-- : �v.....-----" "�,' , ' " . 6:\�?C`", " ./,";,�.L''..-"E „-"" :;,,?.:>..-"L--^/^-- J _ .�. - -' .�'•,` -f� . � ._. ``� _.._ ,��f— "; _'' '._-' -. .-- 4-' .5•y�tl Ttlri� �-+- !- :.+•�' � � , �\ . f' ^ --�_,._ ---"'_ ' -� ' i ---?"'_._... ,� / �----- / .�r, . . ' � � � • Mqwlw�wMww�,u � n cw+s�fa�JY . a��lu� - wYNwVTIM1x � 1116RMIVi�fO'�OaI �C-I V f V6 � iRR41�E1i��PYR __-_.__.�,,�,BPJMS n . 5 ffgv . . . �R . 4'A' o - s_ ' E�.1^ ' � _�'� �/ � • I I I I . ew�ic� I vunwx�mireiu�e{. rumwt � � I f t 1 1 erwMe� t L�L � x•. 0 1 2 ' 3 q 6 g . Q � � � : m a � W I �1NES7 ELEVA'TIOiY - • } � 1 � vr.i'.o• . . c r ta IIv �a� J F- IC Q o � • . Z m � a� � • . � J y i . F.., h W � i . � � � Wd � N . � � NqM1T0.5tM[x � . � • _�..•.-... ..—��6V�CfE6W[1� � e.�el�oNOVltlMll �–_t1lwMrl�el�lmrt �ia4�MKr ^ e..n�cwnu; rx ..wo� � `""°n �g��7t��p�s�� •� - �5.''� ' ..,�eoe..d+..�.. e��rnuaam � - � � wwMewwrert . hW�iD �� nEF1IEf»INcI � fiNlla�l'101IGUSIIO .f:.. i�r 4 ertg�ass�ipuvr�' . ii;; �.i`�I riFi:' Iqi:. :�c �,� o, ��c �ui .�: i� �r i;:��u� ;��.a _�..nT� i:� iiui�i'i� i�i �� na� ';jJ__ - --�-7" --F":- • - `�.'I'= .:-r..�r —`�� . `-' -�:.. r�: _ -j�-�q�l=(,.�m�-��-slrn.a`j.�- -i=.-. >,,.7;1'.{{' r _..�___—___ _�._..__�_—_—___ ___—___ _—_—,_.._ �r_:K',�.�� L' - !'� �"�T• .1 H-��Np1� oncd o. ' _1_1' '_ _ U:�_•: ' Y - -E'-6'Y - ••t- ! -� w�oMwrcO° nnA� I I I_II_ l i .�_=;_ , r,'-,, 7:<.• � . ��'-,-'.T--t�-�'�=_.�t'-=4,��= r' . =-��.:k!_ {i=.�;1=i �- �J r ��_�,.. -,�_ �I`I!� i 'ir'i�.. ------ � --------------------- -- �. U- L, ��-u.-u��= � �m _ - •'I��'-�_ I:t:l=T=I I-i '•�-� �'r .T� �� 7= ' -r�-i°�_'�r�-?-� a , 1?� , � '7�L='P_I��' .t--11-f1=.[�-�r.lrlll.-�'-1-��,..�TE'n - "1�_��::;1='i-'�-'-��-'7--�- ^'1=j�:'Lj�"�; • 1 r"' l'. h:' i . .'.c=�il��:-�.-r�=-:�-��- ••��'- -•�+ at_ -J=1-LF_ �_�l_� �, ,�L-� l,T'= .��_r_ . � -r�. T,��'�i=rr_RL�� r��;�.c -r�r;'��-; -� _ • r'-'.'.i'�,U-�ji-`.{'-i r � •.��=•�=``�, t:i:i_:�-1��1�.-j�i��i I;t�F�L'r�q;�1i�'J i f.=.�=�:�r'�`!='.iC��'�... .(�' :i�� 3 - ��`=qr ...dcl'- r �-qE9 tiJ•- -��L-1=-1-IF-'iyl rM�'•Prl,;-i'i..q_::I.-4;r-�Jtpn -"L-i�� _ ' '�' _ _ � ,�_,.�. _ _ _ �d �y - ,i. :�� =��.. a,_ .l`"��-�� - ..�..: ;'-�r.. -fi. -J:- r;1..:•,_..,?•.I_�-_jlr-'�_G'i .Li�=°L=ak-• ':I i-ii��:_FilHl��..{tii-�=:'°.�.,:��+1=��:.�'a,;. n-i :• ��:'�� ... �, . ., .;:�:�.�.,:�.t ..•. .�� ..�. .. .•. F;. '_ . �,... . - .� r-, � ,_ ' . �� ..�.,. ..� ..�_. �. ..., ,_.i..�,_i�...�•-C-i:i.:T._�..ft..i._ ['t:r_7•cr: ."�i:'�I'. . .i.,.. . - - - - -- •- - - . n_ i_n a_C,- - - - - �-y ,. .. .�•:'.�. I� r�- .. .I. f- :...� :: ...1'�G:'�`�_f�� If� L� I �� -�tL� .. .. N� _ _ _ ' ' M�� A e C D ODc�rI�IrT(I LJ�IJwSIOf') . r.wo.ic seeai a..� —'� � � � � � Nr�� - M`p"""°_ ` � T 1013 SOl➢FH ELEVATION • BUILDING Z tire,�,�-0• p g ,p �. <�'�� EIEVATIONS - � �� A-201 ; , EXHIBIT iQ � . . � �� . ~�� }W.NA NX • ��M4Ma W . � wePa�rP�bSN . �M:NSTNew� �.W1.�u �1 • . w111m�1I1utT�AL • 'a B.o.4wTREVEfteEAMS� . ` -�-51(L• / �cwrc r�irwa •�W If�iiwM 4MwJr� � s�(J a�ooe ouvennsm�umm � S'�a.a.w —-—-—- -".'S'�n'a� � . rwai , � o i . 1 f 1 1 I ! . . � m . N-F N.P 7F-A' N.P 2P.P 11'.0 Q � "5 5 q 3 2 7 0 , . � � Q � ? t- EAS7 Ei.�VATfON � J � � z�• '( ur.��-o� �_" o . v s tv :a �0 7 m �. S N �L O � ° ,� � a � � Z � �' . W < , LL� � . � . .�,,. ..,„.,��,.,��, �� .��, . �;�� MIY��sMaMnv. fre[I�� O �9�� 16�- 1b J7'o dfEtL•1�nP�f 6HI�I11eeoXPlItCOLNR • I _ .:�- -�. --- � z��.r-�7.T-�,—`-� I �' h•-� -j-[- =�c�:�4'�=arf�38in9we no. nnaronon on ��n,i.=i�.. �j•� --------- ------- --------�----- ------- ', �=-�'--; , .��-A ��=�i. .; i f �c`9 J�1.;;�� 'i. �' I.I.,.]"'. . " I-__�_—_ �=w=.11�t�" Y-G=.1_:j:1�r � `�l-'i� , I,ti `TI'�1 r_.7_'.,i) �r_�-:i'_L �f'i. �:�L- �.r-. '-�'�i-1�"'mAll�M - '�'_- '� �� ,�.-' � � ----- --------------------- �� ,:. �'.,�o L'-. lr P-�.J-:'r.'i 7 Tr _T:� i _ _1_-T•-'-I'JF'��'i��`�' (_��: . ' {_'r."i--i ifT� I"k�;��._� i . . aPh i_;,:...:1 � r'.F'.-. ;,I_�..,l..�i.;J _- 'J'-'!'�i�.-�rT-:'r':'-,_L�IL,��;i�T�:��.rli;rL':. _ .. �� _rZ>.��::i��:�="r:a=i-�r::.- ' �1'�1�. 1�='1•;'•;i:,-*:�.,=..I='ia;ii_-i•-_=_!4=:_�-�i._:i'_.-:�s� � , --1f�1=iE�:=:�•L�_n='-i'=-: T=[=L'i,ai • --�i` i .i i-�i�.i �r-��- it7 i�. .�i ��i��i-r.-i-i•r.; :i-ii.=i•- r.�-r-r:.-Y-I f'7:i i��''i: �I—'i.II' .!: _i_._ ._I:.—._ : i..: . �:�..�..I• -�F�' � _ .. . �: _ .�,,. _ ' _ _ 1;-'i'=;t�!I.;J.��.,,._� );+i: ''l-._r,'.'-.__.,'.I ��.'1a;16'I r!�n,-i:-�•_ I��.I-H-I.:-.'�r.;I�I>4!--'._.- �"_, _ _ _ .'1-.i1=.!-_ ^�-'-I'-It._I I_IIH I�. . .I._IJL-�q_ � L:1_I � �..r,:.;r �� e:rr:�:,,:i�_:,:,��_„_i':i�. . .-.:�i..,:__-i•_.; :;..r..',.':i_'. : i.'�'•�.,_�_�:�i i i,i. ,..J .J...,i��r:;�i�i.��_'1.��i.iL.;I. �•_�. ,:._�.i� ��.t_ii.T..�:' - - . _�:�':"-��::,,-�.�_. -�r._ _ �'�'' L-.:_ r'-.i�:r- _ '.:J"�i.� .. �. �. l I ..:-i=o-i:� .. 7 1,� '�"' .. . . � ^.I' -.F•iq=.��vb;,7�'.�._'I.-"If-'a ql{_ __ .,•' . _'.f--:�=f= _ _ I (i I-�3 i11-"1-1-� �q�1..h��U-�6:I;J L-�.-I�r-n=�1=t i- _r.F:,_-�-�. �n• 'i : �� '�"'F _ c'�f_I,�_;,�..I.�.�.�:i, .�..:.i..11.�__I._i.��il..0• P_� .._.i�.�;�i_:-_.'�t_Y, t::-�.:'_� .. ..-.:�_.I._�l�._:;_a.:lri'!al.l_=�f-_1�'�Ji'I:- ^IL:I'-�c.�'l.liilEl. . . ... _.�_i . c:l_!'sl'... _ _ ° •`�.e�'��t�� Lii�� Cp �o.�r ,.�o.m, pr �� nnrrrg p�vision �� ao o c a A mmr�.uno� AlORTii ELEVAT[ON � �pk ':� ZO�3 BUILDIIYG . 2 im�.na� rc s �a zv �v ELEVATI�NS � . �3�r��p�� A-2o2 : ------ ..------.... .....-- -...----._._ ....__._._... ..._� . .. ...... . .. . .. ...... .._........ _. ,. .._.---� . . -.-_.:. -, .. . ...... ..:... ..--:...� .._._. � vanessa �o�bee EXHIBIT 11 From: Karen Walter<KWalter@muckleshoot.nsn.us> _ Sent: Wednesday,June 12,2013 2:16 PM To: Vanessa Dolbee Cc: Fisher, Larry D{DFW) i Subject: Renton Library at Liberfy Park, LUA13-000255, ECF, SM, SA-H, Notice of Appfication and Proposed Determination of Non-Significance, Mitigated j , Follow tJp Flag: Follow up Fiag Status: Flagged i Vanessa, We have reviewed the Notice of Application materials for the Renton Library redevelopment project referenced � above. This projec#will remodel the existing library located over the Cedar River. When we met with City staff and the consulting team in February 2013,we identified several issues for this pro}ect as noted below and offer recommendations ' where we can based on the information reviewed to date: I I 1. Artificiai lighting-The checklist and the Crifical Areas Report(CAR}discuss how the project will seek to reduce artificiaf fighting impacts in several ways. In addition to the measures proposed,we also recommend that the City use light bulbs which reduce artificial fighting apportunities to#he Cedar River or nighttime sky. Previousfy, we provided information to City public Works staff about potential lighf bulb options that could be used. We also request a copy of the detailed site lighting plan for our review which is proposed to be part of the final construction plans. 2. Stormwater-We need additional information about the details as ta how stormwater will be managed from redeveloped site, particularly for water quality. We request a copy of the Technical Information Report which likely cantains the stormwater management details. 3. Wood management plan-A#the February mee#ing,we indicated that the site should develop a wood management plan to deal wi#h any wood that may approach or be entrained by the existing concrete pifing in the Cedar River. This issue was not addressed in CAR. Wood management is needed to ensure that woad is not I removed from the Cedar River or its banks unless it is abso(utely necessary. Wood is shown being near the site ; from the phatos the Cify provided in February. Wood may no longer be on or adjacent to the site with winter floods; however,the City should plan on wood transported to and through the site with time and future floods. It is fimely to develop a wood management plan now as part of the redeveloped library. Please note that Boeing developed a wood management plan for its Cedar River bridges.We.recommend that the City review it far applicabi[ity to the library site. 4. Gabion baskets-We understand that there is no bank work or modificatians to the existing gabion baskets used to stabilize the river banks located on fhe site. Gabion baskets are subject to failure when exposed to streambed �scour flows, requiring require repair ar replacement with some regularity. When they fail, they can adversely affect fish habitat by adding angular rack to the stream channel fhat can create beneficial habitat spaces for , sculpin and other salmon predators. In addition,the broken metal basket�can entrap adult salmon causing injury or mortality. In the course of a tagging study that included sonic tags, MITFD staff found dozens of live and dead adult salmon an arm's length from the bank inside several failed gabion baskets in the lower Cedar project reach. These fish presumably were seeking hiding cover or slow velocity resting places and were unable to complete their migraUon and spawning cycle in the Cedar River. The gabions also create poor salmon habitat conditions in the lower Cedar River by eliminating the complex natural stream bank habitats characterized by low- velocity areas, vegetation, pools,and undercut banks that are preferred by juvenile and adult salmon and reducing bank sources for spawning gravel. When the gabion baskets in the project araa need repair, other altematives that provide bank sfiability and improve habitat conditions for salmon should be pursued. 5. Construction Noise-The project should seek to minimize disturbance to spawning sockeye and Chinook in the vicinity ftom construction activify, particularly any.piling driving activity that may be needed. 6. Shoreline mitigation-We recognize that the project needs to comply with the City's Vegetafion Conservation provisions from the Shoreline Master Prograrn and there are lirnited opportunities to meet the 100-foot vegetated x � ............. . ...-----..............._.. .. ...... .:...... ...... _ ........ _ .._._:.,...._:._.... - - ---- shoreline buffer requirement. Per#he CAR,the applicant is proposing to pay an"in-lieu-fee"to the City's Vegetation Conservation Fund,which needs to be set up. Further,the CAR identifies several potential sites and actions on page 14 where the in-fieu fee could be spent. We are keenly interested in seeing the lower Cedar River's riparian areas enhanced and request the opportunity to work closely with City staff for this project, as well i as,the overall framework approach to implement the in-lieu program. For this project's in-lieu proposal,we would ; like fo work with the City to verify the extent of the impact area; the proposed fee amount; and the mitigation project area. For example,the$1.25 per square foot rate may be too�ow and only covar the costs of acquiring and planting plants which may not be sufficientto actualiy plant areas if easements, acquisitions, and permits are needed, Once a rate is accepted by the City it is lilcely that others will seek to use the same rate, so it is important to ensure that the in-lieu rate is sufficient to cover all of the mitigation project costs. � We appreciate the opportunity to review this proposal and look forward to the City's responses and coordination. Please ' let me know if you have any questions. ' Thank you, Karen Walter Watersheds and Land Use Team Leader Muckleshoot lndian Tribe Fisheries Division Habifaf Program 39015172nd Ave SE Aubum, WA 98092 � 253-876-3116 � � � i � � z r1v111. I�a�c�t vva��c� ��nw�w.�.rr..��..�`�,.........,.....,.._.........�_� Sentc Wednesday,.7une 12, 2013� PM � Ta: Vanessa Dolbee Cc. Fisher, �arry D(DFW) • Subject; Renton Library at Liberty Park, LUA13-000255, ECF, SM, SA-H, Notice of Application and Proposed Determinatian of Non-Significance, Mitigated Vanessa, We have reviewec!the Notice af Application materials for the Renton Library redevelapment project referenced above. This project will remode{the existing library lacated over the Gedar River. Whsn we met with City staff and the consulting team in February 2013, we identified several issues for this project as noted below and offer recommendations where we can based on the infarmation reviewed to date: 1. Artificial lighting-The cheeklist and the Criticai Areas Repart(CAR}discuss how the project will seek ta reduce artificiai lighting irt�pacts in several ways. In additian ta the measures propased, we alsa recammend that the City use light bulbs which reduce artificia! lighting opportunities ta the Cedar River or night#ime sky. Previously, we provided information to City public Warks staff about potential light bulb options that could be used. We alsa request a copy of the detailed site lighting plan far our review which is praposed to be part of the fina(construction ' plans. _ I 2. 5tarmwrater-We need additional informatian about the details as to haw starmwater will be managed from redeve(oped site, particularly far water quality: We request a copy of the Technical Information Repork which I likely contains the stormwater management details. 3, Wood management plan-At the February meeting, we indicated thafi the site should develap a wood management plan to deal with any waod that may approach or be entrained by the existing cancret� piling in the Cedar River. This issue was not addressed in CAR. Wood management is needed to ensure that wood is nat removed fram the Cedar River or its banks unless it is absalutely necessary. Woad is shown being near the site firam the photos the City provided in February. Wood may no longer be an ar adjacent to the site with winter flaods; however,the City shauld plan an waod transported to and through the site with time and future floods. !t is timely ta develop a wood management plan now as part of the redeveloped library. Please nofie fihat Boeing developed a wood management plan for its Cedar River bridges. We recommend that fihe City review it for applicability to the library site. 4. Gabian baskets-We understand that there is na bank wark or modificatians to the existing gabion baskets used to stabilize the river banks focated an the site. Gabion baslcets are subject to failure when exposed to streambed scour flows, requiring require repair or replacement with some regularity. When they fail, they can adversely affect fish habitat by adding angular rock to the stream channel that can create beneficiai habitat spaces far sculpin and other salmon predators. In additian, the braken metal baskets can entrap adult salmon causing injury or mortality. In the course af a tagging study that included sonic tags, MiTFD staff found dozens of live and dead adult salmon an arm's length from the bank inside several failed gabiorr baskets 'sn the lower Cedar project reach. These fish presumably were seeking hiding caver ar slow velocity resting places and were unable to camplete their migrafiion and spawning cycle in the Cedar River. The gabions also create poor salmon habitat conditions in the lawer Cedar River by eliminating the complex natural stream bank habitats characterized by low- � velocity areas, vegetatian, pools, and undercut banks that are preferred by juvenile and adult salmon and I reducing bank sources for spawning gravel. When the gabion baskets in the project area need repair, other alternatives that pravide bank s#ability and improve habitat canditians for salmon should be pursued. 5. Canstruction Noise-The praject should seek ta minimize disturbance to spawning sackeye and Chinook in the � vicinity from construction activity, particularly any piling driving activifiy that may be needed. 6. Shoreiine mitigation-We recognize that the project needs ta camply with the Ci#y's Vegetation Gonservation pravisions fram the Shoreline Master Program and there are limited opportunities to meet fihe 100-foat vegetated shoreline buffer requirement. Per the CRR, the applicant is proposing to pay an "in-lieu-fee"to the City's Vegetation Canservation Fund, which needs to be set up. Further, the CAR identifies several potential sites and actions an page 14 where the in-lieu fee cauld be spent. We are keenly interested in seeing the lower Cedar River's riparian areas enhanced and request fihe apportunity to work clasely with City staff for this project, as weN as, the averall framework approach to impiement the in-lieu pragram. Far this praject's in-lieu propasal,we wau4d � like to wark with the City to verify the extent of the impact area; the prapased fee amount; and the mitigation project area. Far exampie, the$1.25 per square foat rate may be too low and only cover the costs of acquiring and planting plants which may not be sufficient to actuaUy plant areas if easements, acquisitians, and permits are needed. Once a rate is accepted by the City it is likely that others will seek to use the same rate, sa it is important to ensure that the in-lieu rate is sufficient to caver all of the mitigation project costs. I We appreciate the appartunity ta revietrv this proposa!and laak farward ta the City's responses and coordination. Please ( let me know if yau have any questions. I Thank you, Karen Walter � Watersheds and Land Use Team Leader ' Muck/eshoot lndian Tribe Fisheries Division Habitat Program 39015172nd Ave SE Aubum, WA 98Q92 253-876-3'!9 6 I.I�I�ARIE � C GE LIVE S ;•=��: � Q� � :_�--�� , �'�_:,, � �� • � AI.A�lnnrial Cen,�irnaen, Chica�o July s,sor; In the rpirit of th� Uriit�d Statcs Ikclaratson of Indiprndence and t!x U�nivrrsa!Dcclaration of Human Rightr, wt beli�ve that libraria an tss�ntial ta a demornatic societ�F,t�try da,n in i»untltsr communities across our nation and tht world millions of childrrn,stueEents and�adultr use libmria to karn, grow and achitve thrir drrams. In addition m a vart array of b�o�s,comprctrrs and other rrsounEs, ls6rary ustrr btnefit fiom tfx�xpert tearhing and,�ialance of librarians and library sta,$to h�lp expand th�ir minds and oprn new urorlds.Wi derlan and a�'irm or�r right to quality libraritr— public,rchvo� ac�ic,and iprcial,trrd urge yonu w thow�vur r�cpport by rigning your nar�u to thu I�etlaration frir tht Right to Libraria. I. LIElU1tILf IbtPOpE,R 7lit INDIVIDUAL. Wlxther devtlaping iki/G w ixaerd iro sc%oo�loo�Eing�r a jobi explori�s peuible caans,bavi�l a bab�er p/anning miremrnt, peoPk ofa!laga txrn to libraria far irutrr�ction,ruppon,axd eaar to co�nputerr ond other mourar to lxlp d�rm kad better IiHrr. 2. LIDItARIYS tUrPOAi LITBIIACY AND LIlELONG LLARNIIi6. Many childna and.�lu ksrn to rrad at rherr uhoo!snd pu6tic k6n:rm vis ua�y timer� mea�rh preje+exr. sumnur nrdiu�tutering snd other ejpomr»itia. Chberr ro„u te t/x k�r�try to karn t!x terbnoJegy and inj6rmation iki![r tbat 1xlp th�m aruuxr thrir questienr,dircaurr�ew ixtrnaer snd l�arr thrir ideas witb otl�nr. j. LliItARIIE tTABN6THBt1 PAMILIBE. . Fantilirs frnd a cgtrt�6rurb�i,uerdconei�spsn tnd a�uaalth sf raorms to l�elp tlirm ksrn,asow siulrlay rogedxr. .+. LIORARIES ARE TRE 6RlAT EQUALIZiR. Librarier xnx peop'k of rcrry age,rd�cttion 4cu�i»come Irvr�sthnicitr uxd�h}7ics1 abilit�For masy jreople,li�ari�s providi motirca that thry cmrld not otherwite a,�r�—rrrat�rra thry aterl te li:.+e,l�ars,w�nr�E andaovrrn. f. LIC1tARIES DUILD COMMUNITIES. Libmria brixg pteplt togttlxr,both in penon a�rd enlinr,m l�aur coMvrrratienr and to lrarn from and 1x[p rach otlxr. Libraria provide n�pport for srniorr>inuni�rtt�u snd otlsers with fperial xKda. ES. LID1tARIES PAOTECT 011R RIGHT TO KNOW. Our right to reac�urk information,andspea�E fmly mxst not be talsrx fertrenu�d Libraries andlibrarians actively defind thi.s most�aric frrtdem ac Suaranued by the Fint Amendment. 7. LIeMRlE3 STRENGTHEN OUR NATION. The�rnnomic lxalth a»d rucauful�ovnnana of oxr nation depe�d on peopk who are Gtrnaa snd infor»ud Sd�oo�pub!'u,academ'u,and tpecisl libraria support thir baric right. H. LIBAARIES ADVANCE RESEARCH AND SCHOLAASHIP. Knowkdgi drowt./Srom knorul«[gi. Wlxthrr doing a ul�ool auigx�nent,r�nEing a cun for cancn, purruing an academic d�grn,or devtloping a monr fuel tf�icunt engine,tcholan and rrxarcixn of al!aga d�prnd on thr,Enowledgr and a�pertite that liMiatria and libmriaxs o,[f'tr. 9. LIBAAAIES HELP US TO BETTER UNDERS'IAND EACH OTHEA. People jS»m all walkr nf l�com�together at libraries to dircwas issues of eommon conarn.Librariet provide programs, coUections,arrd rruaing rpaca to ixlp us ihare and l�arn from our di�"rrences. IO. LIBRARIES PRESERVE OUR NAT[Oti�S CUL?URAL HEAITAGH. � The past is kry w oar futun.Libraria co/l�ct,digitiz�and praerve original and rr»ique hirtorical documenu that belp uc to baur understand our past,prrrtnt and futurr. i I.I�RARIE � C NGE LIVE � , i ;r�_ :� �.��, �� - - ilLA Annual Csttf nnc�, Chicago Jrcly s,sol; Wt dtclst�r and a�"irm our right to qr�ality librarits. .. �' \", � � � si:�..i.�� + _ , , J i � IKEA Renton River Days -µ:�� July 26 - 28 in liberty Park ' �� .�.��`�*` � # .& ��ori �`�kes'�t e st� e�` � �`�at�ii�°`� in this upbeat musical about self-discovery. All shows are Friday 11:00 a.m. -8:00 p.m. at Renton Civic Theatre. Call 425-226-5529 for tickets and Saturday 10:00 a.m. -8:00 p.m. information.Show fimes are: Sunday 10:00 a.m. -6:00 p.m. Saturday,Jluly 27 a 88:00 p.m. Celebrate this year's fesfival theme - Specquackular! Sunday,July 28 at 2:00 p.m. Enjoy the diverse offerings that highlight Renton s passion For tickets call 425-226-5529 for music, art, food and more. With different events and activities for all generations, the festival brings the community together for a mid-summer showcase of fun and entertainment. � � � �� •� Return to Renton Cruise-In u,�u;u,�' � �� Car, Truck & Motorcycle Show � � Sunday,July 7-10:00 a.m.to 3:00 p.m. Downtown Renton (South 3rd St.) i Cruise back in time and check out classic vehicles at the Seahawks Training Camp � 22nd annual Return to Renton Benefit Car Show. Show begins at 10:00 a.m. Entertainment, vehicle displays, food Once again Renton will be decked out in blue and and rafFle. Show headquarters at Piazza Park. Free admission green and 12th Man flags to welcome the 5th annual for spectators and fun for the entire family. Call 425-430-7589 Seahawks Training Camp m Renton beginning in late July. or visit GoRenton.com. Thousands of people will be coming to the Seahawks' spectacular Virginia Mason Athletic Center over a month-long period. Renton residents and businesses are encouraged to post Seahawks cheer cards, which will Downtown Renton Art Anti ue Walk be downloadable starting mid-July at rentonwa.gov � q and to fly 12th Man flags. For more information visit Saturday,August 24-11:00 a.m.to 5:00 p.m. Seahawks.com. The 8th annual Downtown Renton Art & Antique Walk continues to grow and liven up downtown Renton streets with paintings, mulfi-media, pottery, sculpture, crafts and photography displays from over 100 artists. Meet the artists, explore the antiques and re-discover downtown Renton. . �k� ��" �;� Plenty of parking on the street, in the City Center Parking �;_;:��„��';-��;��`�:}'�; Garage (on South 2nd and Logan) and in city lots on Main Ave South, Burnett Avenue South and Wells Avenue South. Visit ArtsUnlimited.org or ca11206-407-8719. American Sign Language(ASL) interpreter available upon request. For assistance with any of these progams, please call two weeks in advance:711(TDD)or 425-430-6700. Visit rentonwa.gov for information. � i (��_� - �frwa`�a5 riV.: ��iwt � �_ � � �/� l � ` � I r � I ( � � 7 �i . Renton's Fabulous 4th of July Co-sponsored by � F' , _ � � Seating begins at'�:0��p:m. h�lovi�s �# ; . s, r ." low-back chairs and blankets in viewing area. ln the event of � Celebrate Independence Day Thursday,luly 4, with friends inclement weather, call the Renton Community Center at and family at Gene Coulon Memorial Beach Park, 1201 Lake 425-430-6700. Cancellafion decisions will be made at Washington Blvd. N. 5:00 p.m on the day of the film. Event Schedule July 19-Transformers-Piazza Park 7:00 a.m. Gene Coulon Memorial Beach Park opens �uly 25-Finding Nemo - Henry Moses Aquatic Center 12:00-8:00 p.m. Free KidZone Activifies August2-HowtoTrainYourDragon-McKnightMiddleSchool 1:00-5:00 p.m. Free rides in Voyageur Canoes 1:30-9:30 p.m. Stage Entertainment August 9-Madagascar 111-Liberty Park 10:00 p.m. Fireworks off the shores of Gene Coulon August 16-Hotel Transylvania-Cascade Village at Parking CVAC Baseball Field Parking at Gene Coulon Memorial Beach Park is limited and Special thanks io our co-sponsors:Rain City Catering, no shuttle service is provided to offsite areas. Parking is ►var's, Renton Housing Authority,St. Mathews Lutheran not permitted on Lake Washington Blvd. Street parking is Church,Sunset Neighborhood Associafion, The Berliner available on Houser Way N. Event parking is available on the Restaurant and Pub, King County Library System, Cascade upper floors of the parking garage at The Landing and in the Village and the Cascade Neighborhood Association. parking lot located at N. 8th St., Park Ave. N., and Garden Ave.N.PaidparkingisavailableatTheBristolApartmentsat Kidd Valley Family Concert Series Southport along Lake Washington, located between Gene �/�/e're back for another sensational summer of free music Coulon Park and Boeing. for everyone on Wednesday evenings at Gene Coulon Street Closure Memorial Beach Park(next to Kidd Valley.)Concerts start Vehicle access to Lake Washington Blvd. will be restricted at 7:00 p.m. beginning at 10:15 p.m.to facilitate safe exit of pedestrians �uly 10.............Renton City Concert Band � and vehicular traffic from Gene Coulon Memorial Beach luly 17.............Jon Casey Park. Lake Washington Blvd. will re-open at approximately luly 24.............Tena DuBerry I D 11:00 p.m. July 31.............Reilly and Maloney Please note: Personal fireworks, alcohol, pets, pop-up August 7 .........The Classical Rejects ' canopies, enclosed tents and table umbrellas are prohibited. August 14 .......Creme Tangerine han�d��r�cr1 and�ko�e� Small umbrellas and umbrella-chairs are allowed. Only small barbeques will be permitted. No nets or poles installed; no projectiles (i.e. frisbees,footballs etc). See event web page for details. No watercraft launching or pick-up July 4, 9:00 to 11:00 p.m. For more information, call 425-430-6600 or visit - rentonwa.gov. Stage Entertainment KidZone Activities Fa rm e rs M a rket sponsored by sponsored by Tuesdays,June 4 to September 24 T " 3:00 to 7:00 p.m. " The Piazza (South 3rd St.and Burnett Ave.S.) ` Enjoy the tastes of summer as Renton welcomes vendors and SANCTUARY Q farmers selling locally grown farm products, including organic •IAtIMENTf AT iN! LANDIMG � � V ,� fruits,vegetables,cut flowers, baked goods, herbs and more! � � . { n.�., .,� �'��'�` , ti`�Y U - V � 8 ♦ �� , �� O� -N`r 1 Fr urnr�er Lunc es 2 ee S 03 Calling ail kids ages 1 to 18! Join us at any of the following locations for free ' lunches this summer. No lunches July 4 and 5. " i..�,�., , '.r�"�:.... June 24 to August 16-Monday-Friday °-;�:�� _ �- ti �° , (unless otherwise notedJ � Royal Hills Apartments(residents only) 3000 Royal Hills Drive SE 11:00 a.m. ' '�'� Highlands Neighborhood Center �`� 800 Edmonds Avenue NE 11:30 a.m. Honey Dew Elementary School 800 Union Avenue NE 11:30 a.m lUly 8 t0 AU9USt 9 Heritage Park Urban Family Center at Creston Point Apartments 233 Union Avenue NE 13445 Martin Luther King Jr.Way S. 11:45 a.m. Lunch 12:00 p.m. Snacks 3:00 p.m. St. Matthew's Church 1700 Edmonds Avenue NE July 8 to August 16 12:00 p.m. West Hill Family Enrichment Center(RAYS) The Renton Salvation Army 12704 76th Avenue S. 720 S.Tobin Street 12:00 p.m. 12:0o p.m. Mobile Truck Stops Compass Veteran's Center(residents only) The Renton School District will be able to offer a"Mobile" 419 S.Second Street Summer Lunch Program at the following sites Monday 1:00 p.m. through Friday. No lunches on July 4 and 5. For more information on specific times visit www.renton- Tiffany Park Elementary School schools.us/Departments/Nutrition_Services/SummerMeal- 1601 Lake Youngs Way SE Program. 12:00 p.m. Arborwood Apartments(residents only) Emerald Heights Apartments 12000 SE Petrovitsky Road I 6830 S. 129th Street 11:15 a.m. 12:30 p.m. Park Hill and Greentree Apartments IUl 10 t0 AU USt 16 6900 5. 125th Street Y g 12:15 p.m. Cross and Crown Lutheran Church 10940 SE 168th Street Renton Housing Authority 12:00 p.m. 970 Harrington Avenue NE (Wednesday and Friday Only) 12:45 p.m. The following sites are ADA Accessible: $kyway Boys&Gil'I5 CIu b Highlands Neighborhood Center,Emerald Heights Apartments, 12400 80th Avenue 5. � The Renton Salvation Army,Heritage Park,St.Matthew's Church, 11:50 a.m. West Hi�l Family Enrichment Center(RAYS),Urban Family Center Stonebrook Apartments at Creston Paint Apartments,Compass Veteran's Center. 12210 SE Petrovitsky Road 11:00 a.m. For more information, cal) 425-430-6694 or visit rentonwa.gov. /� _..�•/ � . • �--- City of .�tt G e n o n � `�r�� .F� ��.-- �. � �� school district ��.� Este vera o ni os en re 1 18 � y a�i I ' os a muerzan rat�s � . � Para almorzar gratis, dirigete a las siguientes direcciones. No habra servicio de almuerzo el 4 y 5 de Julio. Desde 24 de Junio al 16 de Agosto Highlands Neighborhood Center 800 Edmonds Avenue NE-desde las 11:30 a.m. (Lunes a ViernesJ Escuela Primaria Honey Dew 800 Union Avenue NE-desde las 11:30 a.m. (Lunes a ViernesJ Heritage Park 233 Union Avenue NE-desde las 11:45 a.m. (Lunes a Viernes) Iglesia St. Matthew 1700 Edmonds Avenue NE-desde las 12:00 p.m. (Lunes a ViernesJ Edificio del Ejecito de Salvaci6n 720 5. Tobin-desde las 12:00 p.m. (Lunes a ViernesJ Compass Veteran Center(solo para los residentes de este complejoJ 419 S.Second Street-desde las 1:00 p.m.(Lunes a Viernes) Escuela Primaria Tiffany Park 1601 Lake Youngs Way SE-desde las 12:00 p.m. (Lunes A ViernesJ Apartmentos Arborwood(solo par a las residents de este complejoJ 6830 S. 19th Street desde las 12:30 p.m. Desde 8 de Julio al 9 de Agosto En el Urban Family Center de los Apartamentos Creston Point 13445 Martin Luther King Jr. Way S.—desde las 12:00 p.m. (Lunes a Viernes) Refrigerios desde!as 3:00 p.m. Desde e18 de Julio hasta e!16 de Agosto West Hill�amily Enrichment Center(RAYS) 12704 76th Avenue S.-desde las 12:00 p.m. Desde e110 de Julio hasta e116 de Agosto Cross and Crown Lutheran Church 10940 SE 168th Street-desde las 12:00 p.m. (Solamente Miercoles y Viernes) Parada De Almuerzos Moviles: El distrito educativo de Renton ofrecera servicio movil de almuerzo de verano de Lunes a Viernes. No se ofrecera almuerzo!os dias 4 de lulio. Por informacidn especial de horarios visite la pagina web de la Cuidad de Renton rentonwa.gov or rentonschools. us/Departments/Nutrition Services/SummerMealProgram. Apartmentos Emerald Heights 12000 SE Petrovitsky Road-desde las 11:15 a.m. Apartmentos Greentree/Park Hill 6900S.125th Street. -desde las 12:15 p.m. Renton Housing Authority 970 Harrington Avenue NE:desde las 12:45 p.m. Skyway eoys&Girls Club 12400 SOth Avenue S.-desde las 11:50 a.m Apartmentos Stonebrook 12210 SE Petrovitsky Road-desde Ias 11:00 a.m Estos sitios esta preparados para el accesso de si/las de rueda: Highlands Neighborhood Center,Apartementos Emerald Heights,Park Hill/ Greentree,Renton Housing Authority,Skyway Boys&Girfs Club,Apartementos Stonebrook,edificio del Ejecito de Salvatidn, West Hill Family Enrichment Center(RAYSJ,En el Urban Family Center de los Apartamentos Creston Point,Compass Veteran's Center. a��0. �� City of ,�1. ft e n t o n � ��Y' ��-� °�.-,t,.. schooi district W hy It Matters � � _ � � Public libraries are democracy's best kept promise. It is the promise B r i e f i n g P a p e r that information and the pursuit of knowledge are available to all. - - ��• � - The public library provides vital technology, programs and services to enhance the lives of the people who need it most while supporting the " • • • • " dynamic digital economy. When e-books are withheld from libraries, � _ - � _ Libraries, Publishers and Public Access to E-B��CS it undermines a key element of this promise to provide information and technology to the public. Although some publishers are making - - - • • • - progress by launching pilot programs, these pilots are only operating in a few places and have little effect on the majority of public libraries. • • • • - • • • � � _ � �� E-books are increasingly popular, but until recently major publishers refused Libraries continue to have limited access to e-books and are subjected to sell or (icense e-books to public libraries. Many publishers that do sell or to financial gouging. Public libraries operate on tight budgets. Every - • • license are engaging in extreme price gouging, overpricing e-books that dollar spent goes towards providing learning resources to enrich the deter libraries from buying them. Along with the inability to offer e-books community. Amidst increasing budget cuts around the country, comes the inability for libraries to exercise the core function of providing libraries should not have to face price discrimination from publishers. equitable access to information. What Policymakers Can Do Congress needs to be aware that maintaining equal access to materials needs to be safeguarded, and the Urban Libraries Council and other national The relationship between publishers and libraries is continuously changing. While many small, independent N library associations are urging Congress to begin monitoring this issue. publishers are working well with libraries, major publishers have yet to adopt comprehensive policies � addressing equitable access and fair pricing. The recent shifts in some publisher's policies, and the announcement of progressive pilot programs to encourage libraries' access to e-books, are encouraging and O should continue to move forward. Libraries are willing to pay for e-books, but publishers need to continue _ efforts to guarantee access to titles at fair prices. Q Oversight is needed to ensure that publishers do not inhibit access to e-books in public libraries. By denying � - libraries access to e-books, or making them cost prohibitive, publishers have ushered in a major change to public policy-a change that should be fully examined and considered by policymakers and the public at large. ' Local and national leaders need to draw attention to this issue and signal they are monitoring the availability � of e-books to their constituents.We urge policymakers to follow this issue and guarantee that all libraries- and all the communities and constituents who depend on their public libraries to provide unrestricted access � to information -have equal access to e-books at fair and reasonable prices. - � I o�cm�p�um doluc a�,imri.n•n>cic!ur>aJ�p>- cing�h�t�cd di.nn nonunn eimw�icmpor imid- Endnotes `�k unt ut lahora.t doL�rc m,ipna aliyuyam�r.�L sed 'Rainie,L.,Zickuhr,K.,Purcell,K.,Madden,M.,&Brenner,J.(April 4,2012).The rise of e-reoding. 'Petersen,J.(2013,January 24).ALA applauds Macmillan Publishers'entry into library market. � �{ia��i,piva,v�cro c„c ci aauvam ei iu�to Pew Internet.Retrieved from htto libraries oe��intemat.ore?012'01 0�'the-rise-ot=e-readine Retrieved from American Libraries Magazine:h� 'americanlibrariesm�a«arine ure'news'ala� � ��;,�u�„ic,c�e,�rehwn titci�h�e kn�J guh�'r�- _E-books.(n.d.).Retrieved from American Library Association:http:/'w��+.ala.org'research sites' ala-applauds-macmdlan-publishers-enti�-libran-market rca no�r.��1d`�101�""��""""�"'�n ala org research,filts content initiati�u Qlftav201 I 201_'8 zbcwF.s.ios a Larra,G(2013,March 27).Penguin Revisits Librory Pilot Terms.Retrieved from American � ��`�O�"�'°"��of10��011�� 1�n 3 ' sc�:urt a�di�Kme.litr.�d diar.�nvnu:m cmnuJ �njamuri,D.(2012,December 11).The Wrong War Over eBooks:Publishers Vs.Libraries. Libraries Magazine:http�'amencanlibrariesmaYazine ore e-conten�eneuin-re�isiU-hbran- � Forbes.Retrieved from http wH��forbes com s�tes da�id�injamuri/2012�12 I I thz-wrong-��ar- pilo[-[enm � � �"°�10�1°`"�°01°1�'��-��a', y i m�erai.ed diam�olupu:a.\t�ero toti ei ao i� 1 o�er-zbool.s-�ublishers-�s-librarizs Libraries deepen ebook engagement.(2012).Retrieved from American Library Association: `�`>• r °Hachette Book Group To Offer Full Ebook Catalogue to Libra�ies:More[han 5,00 Titles, htto n�ww ala or•ne«s'media�rzsscen[er'americaslibranes soa1�01�ntw-focus-on-zbooks �❑��n:i_�,nio duo dnf"`c•`�c,�rehum ti�at chia � Aa,d guhcrgrcn.no•ta talm�al.�yneHi�t,1 Including New Releases.(2013,May 1).Retrieved from Hachette Book Group:htto:/lwww. '0 Miller,R.(2012,March 1).Fuel forYour Fire:Good data offers a reolity check that's � ��P�i��do�oT,i�a,,,�<<�,rc,u ip.um dv�e� ," ;n' hachettebookerouo com/media-and-oublicitv/breakin¢-news/ involuable for building libraries.Retrieved from School Librery lournal:htto:,'��««. ,.�, „��.,,�„�i�ii�r,��;p+c�n;_chv.�d dia�n ,j:;? s Goldberg,B.(2012,September 14).This lust In:ALA Decries Hachette's 104%Librory schoollibranjournal com sfj/homei893>23-313�fuel for�uur fire�;a�d.html.csp �„i,,,;,�y einnoJ:empor u�"�°°t°��ahore e� .?�� Ebook Price Increase(Correc[edJ.Retrieved from American Libraries Magazine:htt : "Ibid ��'�i��__��j4p�Jpl:fdl.��'��Id111��P��'��' _ americanlibrariesma¢azineor�/e-content/iust-ala-decries-hachette-s-104-librarv-ebook-price- "Simon&Scbusterlaunchesebookpilotprogram.(2013,Apri115).RetrievedfromAmerican � `t" .��«,�„��,;t�u,ioduud°I°ro"�e� � increase-correded Libraries Magazine:http/americanlibrariesmagazine or�ne��s'ala simon-schuster-launches- r`�`,,,,```I�+��Si�h��_�`.��•i"'.m�.+Gm�ai� s Vinjamuri ebooF.-pibFproeram ..:❑�tii;,;,tl�,rcmip.umdolar,it�mci torcm � � ip,mn dalonrt.�mn.camct.tur sad�p�cm.dnr. tcd di.�m nunumy nmind tempor mi idu�d Siam U R B A N . �:,hort cl dnlort m�en.�ahyuram cr.�L�c �nlupui.�.1t�so em et.iceu<aro cl)uslo Suu do- lurcs cc ca rahian Stn cli�a Sa,d gubcrvrcn,ao 125 S. Wacker Drive, Suite 1050, Chicago, IL 60606 � C�UNCIL 312.676.0999 s www.urbanlibraries.org ' INSPIRING LIBRARIES. � ' ' " ' ' �� TRANSFORMING COMMUNITIES. ------- i ,._... , .�,�.ffit �!"F.=iz'#__.:.BF.4sJ._h.:....s"St'a_.�ir. _��5..:�k9E_.�+d(Fir3"�,'C�.�? . �.:-u.;-:��e,�.cs:^�ae:�s:�a:tx'�:a.3�_ �- ,�rx�.a_=v...____._�_" �s�at..^�r�� ' � �.�,.< ., „ o.w-�...�:+,�-�:��' �. � ...-T_�,; , �sH��:'.. .....� ____ ::a'il':tnZ=._.rea':3�.r., _.. ._ C g 'fi��r�., _,.,�.��;;�1:.,>Yc�a4-._ -. _" - -r -. 'd."u>`"-�':a"va3'.Y"u�'� •-'-.n�: .��".S.F��..�s" �>ti e":�+�:i��:?�.k�.'mT`.ez '�"' �'^-a�p �. , aC2i$::.':+i:-a+�_:kk�S��B-�'��.�_a��'+t?.".w4r."!YA$Y@�:^RM1FCrk.4`...S�ci"�. �(@ MessageS Some boak publishers are denying libraries access fio e-books, y while others significantly overprice tities. For exarnpie, under e-books -is fundamentai to , Eq uai access to materials-including qt all citizens have �andom House's policy, bestseller "The Tweive" baries t'n15•51�f om public libraries' mission and criticaf to ensuring th the need. whose print edition costse eBookg�pr��d aY$g 9rg on Amazon, access to the information Y Baker &Taylor and who tin the pubtic from accessing e-books. was priced at $84 to Douglas County on Oct. 31,�2012. • Publishers' policies are preven g have According to a Pew study,' one-fifth of Americans report that they rams are encouraging, but need to be more widely - ook in the past year. The same study found #hat the average Piiot prog read an e b ks in the past 12 months, ;mpiemented. Simon & Schuster's pilot program o�i�ya€fers its #ull reader of e-boaks read an average of 24 baa avera e of 15 books by a non-e-book consumer. cafialogue to three iibraries in the New York Ci Y a compared with an J rrowin e-books from libraries is increc�singiy popular. 76 percer►t of Bo 9 r�_.:,_;..,.�_;�::-.._::,yN_�� ;��:��:.�,.,�-:.-,.�_,p:;---wr�:«_�:�_.::�:�;_--��. =_--.-==:_�:. _�_...._---__ :-: .._ .�.._�: -:_»__a.:�u_�=_�.�-:_:_-��.: � from 67 percent in 2011 and 38 percent m 20 . libraries offer e-books, up t..__.___ _ - ,. � ._ _=== - - -_ _� ._,�_-.___ _...: _ .._,._ ._ .. __ . ._.:. _, _'""' ".�.�..:"'"..:FF.'�"- - _..,.,-.. ,�-,._..�-r--a�,^_-._ .�_"-._._.��.:_'" , -,y..rn-. _.... _ . .{_.,t .'.�... .__:•. - ' _.. .___�._-.. .._._..r._.._.:.: . - .... "'_"" �.—�-...-. .__' . �±�`._"e:.=e. ...-�.,,....... .. n"'_`'""_'"4�+.-'-�`'5A` - BqC�C rOUC1C� Here is where each of the big six publishers currently stand: � ercent af libraries has nearly daubled in the past five years,with 76 p ba�ks last year - Se tember 2012 mare than doubied ' raries � � ��w�� ,�� Yr��s U��: In May 2013, Hachette4 made its entire catalogue available to nonprofit pu �c The presence of e-baoks in lib �� book declined ta 67 percent from 72 percent the year before. and school libraries. However, a new pricing structure rom p offering e-boaks in 2012. Rccarding to the n�Internet Pro�ect, more Americans rea �S often 5 than ever befare, while those who read a p its prices. Unlike rint books, e-bQoks are usually licensed, rather than sa1d,fio libraries and licens�ng ng to be urchased again. p ��i;u�s: All of HarperCollins'titles6 are available for libraries to�purchase, but they come with restrictions. restrict how the e-book is used. �� ' tributar. C�verDrive is a major distributar, An e-book can aniy be lent 26 times before'rt expires and nee ste navels- One way for public libraries to receive e-books is��o a,9 th�h�r distributars such as 3M Cloud and �A�to imes or far two years.The cost for libraries 'ss about � ��e; ,q pilat program'launched in March 2Q�3 made 1,200 titles- mostly crime an my ►'Y offering more than one million titles to libraries 9 u��c's available. Each e-book can be lent either 52 atrons can browse and check aut e-baoks throughreh��os ng another blockade to the p ' a in a 25 each, which is about two to three times more than what consumers would pay for the e book. 360. Libr ►y p ublishers, like Pengu , p $ their e-reader device. However, some p ' tributors digita��Y p�°tect material b refusing to work with certain distributars. Publish�e15 and distributars need to work � �Q iibraries.The publisher put policies it p uin announced its plan$to remove its six-month embargo on tit es access ta e-books y ;a��j�� 3��:: Rlso in March 2013, en9 together to ensure equitable access and fair pricing. Given how manY licensed to libraries and is now offering them immediate y ca ied, and therefare save publishers and authors millions of dollars, it is in everyone s is ositive, its prospect for being a lang- 11 . tested in a pilot into effect almost immediately, affering alefrontlist(new titles} e-books through 3 from being i��e9a Y p ursue a fair business mode�• best interest ta cooperate and p a� erCollins, Macmillan, and Baker&Tayfor, but not t�verDrive. Although the mo p a�or ublishers- Hachette, H p e term solution is questionable given the merger between Penguin and Random House. Although licensing poficies vary by pub�isher,the six m j p d Simon &Schuster-have made it nearly impossib�aVerfar examples) r�y a larg rch 2012, the publisher announced a new Penguin, Randorn House a n . ab ��,�;�� #�a��. Although Random House makes all of its tatles available ta libraries ta purchase, its prices number of e-baoks, including the most in-demand titles. (See Key Messages are high and it charges more far popu�ar items.In n hurt b the rise of ricin structure� for its e-books, raising same prices ��bp�k form�for $65n85 (the a e a(ge pr nfi Publishers worry that e-books in libraries will h Ubl�he s'a�re�Coa ceaned hat th�ey will continue to lo��eaprofits boaks�offered in hardcover are availabie to libranes in retai{ sales, p of wear-and ook cost $28.73 in 2012);lo new children's titles aie priced between $35 and $85 (the average print online book sales and decreasing do not need to be replaced because b by sel(ing e-baoks to libraries, e-books� e�thi�i'fear. children's book in hardcover cast $19.40 in 2012)• Publishers' poliues, until recently, reflect ' h libraries. lete catalogue will be avaiVable to the �� • � _� ,g�, ��s��; In March 2013, Simon &Schuster iaunched a p�i(at program�z with three New York City last few months, same pub�ishers beJ�n P�lot programs to explore more equitable dea s w �� a public libraries through which the publishing company s co p In the are offering the same terms. Iibraries for one year. E-books will be allowed to be (ent an unlimited number of times as long as Even with the new policies, none af them each copy is being used by one borrower at a time.T��p ne�ss�modelrto'�use. Under th s pi�ott se e-boaks to libraries at all until it faund an acceptable ro ram, New York public library users who borrow an e-book will have an option of purchasing P 9 their own personal copy through Simon &Sehuster. �,,,�� -- - -- � ��,��, -- -- - — - - - — - - �' �� - �+}n - � - , � � � � � o � II� � � �3II � �� . f �g . . c �.� r ��1 _ t��l I l��l� ,�:. _�y ��j ' � �iestas de A�Ifabetizacion Blaom, Graw�-Sing tew�prana en �spanol �long Concert Cu¢ntas en Espanof Early l.iteraey Part�es �I/ednesday,Ju1y37, 1 pm Stary t�w�es in Spanish in Spanish Presented by�harlie Hope, Tuesdays,luly 9-August 6, 11 am Thursdays,July 11-August 29, 10:30am �9es 3 and older. All ages welcome. Para familias hispanas con ninos �arn�ly Story 1'lnaes recien nacidos hasta 5 anos. gr�aN VB�aN 21Nt� h�S G80a Wednesdays,lufy T!1-August l, a0am s series de talleres gratuitos. BUdd'I¢S af L'16�Yf Y Pal'IC Al)ages welcome. Las familias aprenden acerca Wednesday,August7, 1 pm �' de Alfabetizacion Temprana Held at Liberty Park in Renton, p y como preparar a (os ninos 11018ronson Way N. -y: para el Kindergarten. Presented by Brian Vogan � ' � � � ��Series of free workshops far Spanish and his Good Buddies. `t,�;-="� : , �; �,�� speaking families with chiidren Sponsored by the City of Renton ��;:;�'�;�:�,w`�i. =� _ newborn to age 5 to learn about and the Friends af Renton Libraries. '� '` Early Literacy and how to prepare ��.�`�1� DIM0�1U1'S their children for Kindergarten. Magieal Wonderland .s Di�asauriosl Sponsored by the KCLS Foundation. S�,Qw and Fan�ily Movie �.�✓s �Songs at Renton � Dig Dinosaurs Concert at Liberty Park , ,�`�r s Market ai'libert Park Friday,a��usr s,a��, � �ty,July 9,5:30pm Y Held at�Liberty Park in Renton, "d af rh�Renton Farrrrer's Marker Sunday,luly28, l:lSpm 1101 Bransan VltayN. �;�;�t�iePiaua,3rd ctnd Burnett. Held at at Liberty Park in Renton for Presented by�ouie Foxx. ��'-'`° IKEA Renton River Da s at the Renton r;. a Pnesented by Marco Cortes. Y Ages 3 and alder. �i� pro ram,a11 a es welcome. Village Merchants Assoriatron Stage. �' :� . Y 9 9 Sponsored by KCLS anc# a.,.. 4�"'" ''''' ' Presented b Nanc Stewart. � ,[tsored by KCLS,the City y y the Cit y of Renton. � , nton a�d the Friends Fami ly program,all ages welcome. �`� ' S onsored b KCLS, ��1-` '�e��on.l�ibraries, 1� y the ��.; ..:.. ..� �� City of Renton and Friends ' �_"`= of Rentan Libraries. �`he treasure Gave �°` �'al¢s Sia�y#elling ,.....,, . . ,.:,�,°��,,,,u 1u1y�0, 1 pm �,,��i''��`� ��toktert Kikuchi- ` �,,., y , ..t.�-_w + 4 ..��h-Nah Tec Asian o�� o p � � `��.Theater, /F � � ` Renton Library ;��ifder, o , � 14Q Mill Avenue 5 'j `-'�'"'4 Renton,WA 98057 ��`w,' - } ��.�:' � 425.226.6043 �.�..rw� .. � .. .. �� j� `�' kcls.argJkids/summer >#, •w . - qa,...' , - y ��,"" _�- fw`lndiukluah with � -_— �5.�;,�, ,,pontattthelibmry ation. �_.by tl�e Aulwm,fnumclaw,Federal way,HigMine,Lake Washingto�, rnank you fo our sponsors: K I N G y ptTahoma5choolDfstr(cts,amlthesedistrlctsassumenoresponxibiliry CdUNTY loifer.in ronsideratio�for the privilege to distribute these King County dp �, tonnect with us ," ��tNghllne lake Washi�ton,Narthshore,Shoreline,5noqualmie Libt2C}'SYstem �/�tjs , �Q� L I B R A R Y 11eTd heimkss from aoy cauxe of action,cfaim or petition fited in any FOunt�atlOn `wODtAN° �' p#U�s disttibutbn of these materlats,induding aU costs,attorney's PARK �..': ; �CIS•�' �;�,:�: ° K � K � � G��NtY \\ �'e�`ARy �� r.�`"��:�.�'�� /� ��' '��yq�,s;`'""-' , �� ,�Y=e ��, ��y-,g �'� \ ,aqe.r.i�'..y 1�'a:;,;;;� `«.d:��.. .r*9 --" �,�;�-,� .:6'��'� _ - ��4` �}.�,- . ., �a.m.' �! 1 ` �4�'�� ..° x h. � � t� � �� t'' 1r � . �_� -a,";::z ,;�"��"Y�; � � y:` , / ;:.�. ur?� � -�. ' - ��a,I� � - , -f �„�" a,�wx'° �,r x.� �i� // ,. ��r � ��" ��*� « \ . +.'�,_ } Y.a _ �, .y�. ' �»r \ ,4 �,¢.._s y,.K - - . 3r't \ '* � \ \ � �oo �� , � , �-� .: \ "' - 1�� ' . &'�.' _ .�:"t ',q�. . _ � , . . 0� �� =:�� $ . ::,a,:t ��. � �' `�= 'i� �� \ ,. � :�:�.��' Y�� i� �i .:�� oo �� \ ;,.,P� 9 ,�4;�r�' � \ r � :,�,,:, � � � �; G�O , �.7 `.y� ��bY�rian`5 ' . - . ,.-f� �ritia�s ..A, . '";:�;�_ rt� � "`°'� ,• � �;;,�;� � � _��"� ' � q��:� . o0 �, �� ._ z �r�,� � F�re � t�� .tw � � r:�.=��.��: � � �� :� � ��oo :_��.=��:=�: / . \ ,� Y jr � °�, e �.. ��'��zt, y ,J, :� �{way'• � •�. �v ° a A �,�; �a .}. � �. �� ,t_�� .�� .,- , �v v , �, ��: � x �� , ��, O� �4 Lib��'rians � � �'� r � s�<��' � �r 1 : �. \ 1n�t;a�s �,� y � � '��% ° r \ '` +� t �� ;��' \� ' '-a�" K��;� � ��pt�� '. �\ o ��. ,: .� �'r��'�� '� a �. x � / � -t� �' \, \\ i„ � . ,_/ � � � � f, � ,�. ,,.a,r s...- \ � \ \ , Renton Library Hosts U.S.�turalization Ceremony! � Page 1 of 1 � My Links i . i ' Judith Zelter A All Sites = Home ►Vews Events Departments Ciusters Committees Manuals Forms&7emplates Renton Libra�y Hosts U.S. Naturalization Ceremony! Staff Directory Statistics S�te Map Search 6/5/2013 I Jo Anderson Cavinta, Diversity Coordinator ; �` Renton Library Hosts U.S. Natui�alization Cererr - � ' 4=� ` - The Renton Library, in partners ip with U.S. Ci Immigration Services, hosted a U.S. Naturaliza Ceremony for 27 new citizens r presenting 16 and their supporters on Wedne�day, May22 - z :;� The ceremony consists of takincq an oath of alie �":�. the United States and receiving'their CertificatE Naturalization. The event took place in a centr the library for all to see. Guest� included SO pl members and friends as well a5 KCLS staff. Pe addressed the audience with opening remarks , welcomed everyone to continue utilizing our resources. A journalist and photographer from 4�5 Magazine to� comments and pictures for their publication. � After the official program, new citizens received a KCLS book bag and U.S. flag, complements�of the Friends c Renton Library and had the opportunity to visit a U.S. Passport and Voter Registration Table. ; i Kudos to the Renton Library Staff for the effort and enthusiasm to make this first event a suc�ess. Upcoming will take place at the Beilevue and Federal Way Libraries. To schedule a ceremony at your br nch, please re� guidelines on the ESL& Literacy intranet page under"Other Resources." g�Pa�es� t https://intranet.kcls.org/News/Pages/Renton-Naturalization-Ceremony.aspx 6/13/2013 k R. h � � � "Wrong War over eBooks: Publisher Vs. Libraries." By David Vinjamuri � Forlae�;, Dec�ml��r 11, 2012 Librari�s and bic�. six publish�rs are ai ��-a�� over� �f3ooks; h�w much they should costr hov�� they can be lent ar�d 4vho o�n�ns them. If yc�u dor7't us>e your public iibrary �i�d ass4�me lhal this daesn't �Pfect yau, you're wron�. l In a sac:iety wl�ere bookstores di�:�appear every day while the number af books av�ii�ble to re�d h�s swelled exponentially, lit�rarie� wifl ��I�y an �ver n�ore ci�ucial role. Even �nore than , in the past, we wil9 de�er7d on iibraries of the fu�ure to heip discover ar�d curate g eat books. Lit�rK3ries ar�e �3lready tr-�nst'arrrtirtt� t:ltc�rr3seivess c�ro��nci t:he caur�try fi� crea e mc�re syr-nl�iotic reiationshi�as with their ro�7�rn�.ar�ities, ��fith book clubs and �s wor-k �nd eeting spaccas for lacaf ritizens. �or pukalishers, the library vlill hc the st�o�r�roar7i of the future. En�uring. that libraTjies have contiriuing access to publi�E�ed tit[es :�i�.��s thEm �� ci�ance to meet this role, but ar1' impartant ol�st�cle rerr7�jins: hov�� eBooks are af�>t��#��ec1 by lit.�r�rit��:5. This coli.lmn is the firsk ir7 �a t�n�jo-p;�rt series r�bo�.Et Iil�rG�ries and their role in the marketing and readership af baol�s. l�his First ��art addG�esses t�ie present conflict. -rhe secand pat�t will loak farw�rel to the future far librarie�a arid put�(isi��rs and the import�nt ch�llenges that they must adclress. Tf��e �:;oi��tion to the current: prit:ii�c� pro��Ic�r7i IieS in u�iderstandir7cJ t:hat the argurn�nt pubii�hers anci librar�i�s �r�e havinc� is the ti•vrong �rg��r�ent. It is E��sed on thc� p�radigrn �f tt�e prinled E�ook �iid as such preser�ts a ,e�-iE��: o� intr�ctable challeng�s for both puk�lishers and libr�aries. By changinc3 tt�e ��odel for pric:i��q aii eBook, t7oth part:ies could find � clear �3n�� equit�bfe resalut:ion to t.i7e curr��nt impa�:�se. 1"h� I�sue Do libraries increase boak sales o�� canni(�alize them? -1 f�is is the i;;uc a� �h�he�>>�� of the sfiruggle between libraries represented by tt�e Arnerican Library Associatior� {whase presid�iit is Ma�ireen Sullivaii) a��cl ti�e Bic� Six pu�lisf7e�-s. The current <_>trugcJle is t��kir7g plr3cca i�� a iar7c�s:,c:��>e tI1r1� LNIII �7e f"c.1fllllicit' �O �IIOSE' Wh0 folEow�ci the travails of tt7e rniEsic industry ov�r the last cle��cie. �'ublishing is ::l�ancin�� d��a�l�atic.aUy as it tries to co�7e with t.l�e ri�:e of eBoc�ks a�id tf�e inc.re�sing power c>f Arna:r_c�n, the decline oF bookstor�s and � flc�od of Ic�w-priced indie titles. In spite af the c�aod ycar tt�at Random Nouse is experier�cing (�ritici�atiiig a mrrt�cr �vith l��n�uin and ju>t having paid em la caes a �5.�)nt)tu�nus eac}i thanks to thc� succ�ss aF o��ce-indie author Et_ James` Fifty P Y Shadea triiogy}, rnost publisher, I�avr�} fo�ar�d it difricult to maintair� sales and profitability ir� t:t�e ci.�rrent ei�vironrner�t. GNf�el:hc�r ktsey'r-e cic�o��r��i c�€� �7ot is �icb��t<<hlc, but nn mainstrean�� publisher is camfartable ir� the currer�t erlviranrr�ent. The laridscape is also shift:ing ft�r lit�r<�riE:as. Tl��e IE�(c�rmz�t:fc�n Age h�s ��osed ntat�ner�us challenges to tt�e public libr��ry� C�S JI�V� l�OtlIT�G:I�� t�circ�itiy ct7ronicles in ,`.l'hc Ucclinc an�i }�aii t�i �t�� ►�ib��ary Empir��." Librar�ies have st:r�uyc�l��c1 fia underst�a��d their r�oEe i�� cc>m��nunities as technology has chanc�ed. Ir� acltiition tc� e��cc�uraging c_f�ildren to read and lending books, they hav� migrated fram providinc� access to on{in� d�tai�ases to cataloging the web then proviciing camputer teri�inals �rzd r7ativ br��cJb�rici �ccess �s the needs of the c�itizenry for in(ormation h3s cI��E�gc�i.i. Tt�e sl7ift i�� reacling t�wards eBaokS presents a ��sarticul�r problem for thc�tn t�E�r_aiise it's i�appei�ii�g witi� startling ra�aidity �ncl pfi�esc�nts significant technc�logicai c}��IIr_}nc�c�s. � - �r I � � �. In acldition to the centr�i issuc of C��ricinc�, lihraries �re stru�gling with the copyright implications of �Baoks, their role �s c��rator�� t�r�ci promot�,rs o� re�ding in �n a�e wi7�re pt�Y�iishing is �x��lt�ding, de�linc7 ��itl� t�cl�rnc�i�e�y int�rti�ecliar�i�s ar�d gair�ii�g �ccess �a ti�� n�wiy avaiEaY.�I� w�alth of self-��ul�iisl�c�d wc�r�k<;. �'I�e �ibr�ry �'��s�aectiue Tl�� ee��tr�l issue �or lil�r�r�ies is si;-r��-�ke: th�y (ac�li{�ue tP��t ��tit��holding eE�c�c�ks frc�m fibraries er�tir�ly, Pricing tl��err� t�i�ti�r or Is��itir�c� ier�ci�, �II u��cl�r��ir�e �� libr�ry's �c�re missic�n, F2c�t�in Nesbit, af the Columbus (C7H) hle�rr.�pc�lit<�n l_itar<�r-y 5y�tea�n t.c�lc1 r7�e tl�at �ft��ough h�er e�ook circulatior� of SOO,OQO lends ��r�uaiiy is nnly 3 ��rc�nk of th� syste�m's tot�l, that number is growing by rr�ore than �00% a year. "(�lu� it`s at least 1C7°!o of aur� budc�et." �3�tween the cast af eBaoks �nd � technolagy ct�rn�7oner�t, ��rcaviciinr� accc�ss tc� eE�ooks is thr�e i.imes as ex��nsive for her as �hysi�:ai t�c�c�i�s�. This pricing prc�sstar� is si�nificant �r�rl it`s laeing feEt �crcat,s th� cauntry. .larr�ie L.aRi�e, Dir�ector of tt7c� Douc�l�s Caianty l_ibr�ries i�� Calorada tc,ld me th7at, C s��j a clecre�se ir� cJse tf�at ��J�s l�arci tc� ��x�tair� ��c�c�se o��r/it�r�r-res a�� C�usy. Th�r� 1 !oc�kc��d �t our ir7�rer�tctry aracl re�/rzrcl t1��t tt�t� ��rrat�/t�ta�t rs tt�r�L��s v✓� sl�ift vur�dofl�rs to eE3c�o�<s, I ar1� buyir�� fe4^ver� itc�rns t�et.�r�usc� tf�e �rices G�re so r��trcl� t�i,l7er-. TF3� cF��1ie��c}e to libr�ries is r�c�t ir�<}igs7ificant. Foi.�r r�� t�7e six p��k�iisl�ers ��re not providing cE3c�oks to libraries at any �rice, Tl�e c�tl�er tvr� - i��ndom Nous�� anci t�ar�erCollins leaci th� ind�jstry with two dif�ei-ent rr�c��els. R��nclorr� 1-�c�use �cijustec4 eBoo4: �ricinc� iri 2012. �'Jhile the pric�s or� so�� oc�ks v�ere {n�vcrr��, t:l�� tx��t: E�c�p�€lar t"stl�s incr��aseci in price -- st�n�e dran�atically. �uthor J��tin Cronin's xaast-�pc�c�{yptic L�estsellcr "'T"he T�.��Iv�" whase pri��t ee�ititin casts the Dougl�� Cau��ty Libi�c�rie�� v15,S1 fro�n F33ker &T�ylor and whose eBook is priced �t $9.9� or� Amazon wa�a pricec! 4:it ��3� to Dc�u�{as C:ounty oi7 actober 315�. H�rper�Collins ��ne�nv�rhil� ��t�s �c:ic��f:c�ci a ciiffier��;��. n�c�d�l, selling eBc�nks tc� librarie� �t co��surt�er {�rices I�ut c:V�ctronic�!!y !in-sitin� tlter�n to 2Ei l�ncl�; and tf�efi� r�quiri��g that th� t�oak be repurchased. ��bir� IVesbitt sties tl�is as f�ire�� ta lil�ra�-i4�, but she ��oints out that il's stiil ��r��ch mai�e �x�e�7siv� tl�ar7 �r�iE�t. t}�c�k�, „I r�et fc�rty to fiPty (encls frarrl a bestsel(er in lik�r�ry birrding. B�.it �t I�c3��t they're ��I��yirlc�.,, And tl�at's the bic�ger �rc�blen�. A� c�etai(t}d i�c�lou�, tf�e r�^st of tl-�e E3ig Six aren`t playing -_ at least not nationally. �i�ti�t's a bi� vt,��;r�c� ssc�r� for lib��arses, as fully 80°l� of le��cls - �nd an impartar�t par� oF tP�eir traPfic - cc�r�es fro�T� b�stsellers, 1�'Ut�ile it s�err�s like(y th�t most of l:h� r�ther �auk�lishers wifl event:u�illy play, tJ�e� lc�r•r��s rnr�y b� �vors�a t.h�n t.17c>se r�ff�r��i by R�ndom Nr�t�s� ar�d Marpc�rCoflins, � Publis�7�rs wor�s�y tl��t Sil�r�r-yf �i3oo4:s �xvi,C I��a�-t tt�<�ir �C3oc�k sale�. T��y have less fr�ictior� �i�an pf�ysical be�oks, �'hen l:h�y s��ak a� fri�tic.��, E:�uL�li4E��rs ��e�n that h�c�rr�c�v�rers c�or�'t t�olcl eB<�raks (�te, they arriv� inst:K��l.ly Fc�r tl�� c�xt: �<�trr�r� ir� lir�e, tk�ey nev�r 4�.lear- out �nci tt�ey don"t �ven req�aire a tri�a to the lii�rar}�, �!-o sor��e extent, p��lishcrs may �Iso sec eE3oak� �� a w�y to irn�rdve a �ituaCior� th�t th�y itiere r7ever r��ily I��ppY witPi: unrestrictec! I�ndinc� af i��tail-priced bc�aks (more aGi lhis l��t�r). I l�lkad le� Skip �ye, the VF' c�f A<�<�ci��7ic: �' l.ik�r��r�y t�<�I�ss ��r�c� n�ark��tir�� ft�r R�r�dorra House. Dye sec�n�ted c}enuinely su��r��-ti�f� of tl�c� n-�issio�-� c�F ��tsl�lic lil�rar�ies anci uery so�hsstic�tecl in �iis cJesire ta use resea��c17 tc� cletern�irie thr� t��c�i�r�t of fricliari tl7�t �ct��ally exists in library systerr�s. I-le saicl tt�at the I;<z«dom f{ouse i; "�orr�i�t �gr�ostic" L�ut 3cknawledgecl that, We w�nt� ihr«crc�h and lc�r�kc�cl aC our^l��ici�� ncf ti��t{�r3tc�ct to mal<c sure that if3� i-i:�t�t vatc�e c`orzversati�n ��at� 17��ppertir7y tJ�t��4r��rt nt�,�1ihr��y1 ��tr�c�rts ��r�d us. Sc��t�e titl�s �ve��t u� �s n7�cl�t �� 2CJ0°lo, sc�r�r�� ti�er�t cic�s�,rr� i�� ar-ic�, �.; ' � • C)ye and others vvha work for t�ig publishers �nd cleai �vith �F3ooks have anotfier chaf(enge that library directors da not: layers of i�riariage�T�ent that already believe lhat eBoaks rnay kill large publishing houses and view their� groUvt�i as more of a tfireat th�r� an o��portunity. A big part of the problem is d{�ta - there'S � p�jucity of it. Dye has reviewed the P�� uer,<�r� on library usage exten�iv�ly lo inf�>r�r� prir..ing dec:iC�inr�s. But if the ins:�tittatit>nal k�ias among publishers is ta see eBooks �s +more thrc�{-�t than opportunity, title anci library-specific data wil! be needeci ta prove that eitf�er friction or c��r�nii��lizatian are lEss thar� exp�cted ir� arder to justify consume�� pricing fo�� libraries. Where �he �ig Six F��t�(��E��rs ��rsd �-cada}/: R�ndam_H_o.��5�, - Sells eBoaks ta litara��ies tt�rauc�I� multipie distributors. Prices were �3djusted in 2Q1.2, Althouc�h s7m� ��ric:es +-dere Icalvered, the distributor prit:e to libraries fc�r� same papular titles such as SO Sh�des Of GrEy rai�ge up to �8� for a sin�le eE3ook coE�y - ove�� 8 times the price af the eE3aak on 1lr�r�azon. H�r�erCol.l.i._ns - Sells eBoaks t�a libr�ries ti�ra�.Eyli rr�uEtiple distrik��.�fiars. On sorn� papular titl�s it h�s r��ric�cd c�3c�c�l, t«.��c �c,^r,•�I�ntl," �ftLr �.nrliich tlie iibrary n7�ast re��urcl�asc_� th� baok. P�nquin - Peng�ain (slatcd to m�rgr_� with Ranciorn House} is conducting u��;�< <,f cL��vk salcs to libraries witt� the Nr�vYo��k PuL�lic Library �>y�,terr7. e8oaks �vif1 becorne available six months �fter their ��t.�blicat.io�i date. 1Nt�i1e ��rici��g ��ill k7e �:�i�7iilar to physical books, �Fl� E700�CS WIII only be �v�iiable to ti�� libr��ry for or�e year, ��Ft.er �vhic.h they will n�ed to be repurch�sed. Hac�h�tte - (J��ly sells older eF3ooks t� libr�ric�s {thro��gh the distributor Overdriv�). Hachette increased prices far these olde�- eBooks by �u, ,.�,cr�.t`�c ��I�'?(�{i; i�� ()�iah,��. Ma_cmi..11_an. - Daes i�ot currentiy seil eGook�a to ii�raries. Macmil4an has announced a ics� c�f cBc�ok sal�s to libraries but not �i-�nounced ci�tails. Simon Se Schuster - Sin7oii and Schuster does not yet sell ebooks ta libraries. Accc�,�ciin�� c� Carul�-n R�idy, CEO, "VUe have i7ot yet fc�unci <� l�uSIi1E',5�, model that rnakes ��s happY. That's w�hy we're riot in it.,, �v�#ua�inr�. '�he Argc�rr�er��; Publisl�ers rnake t.hree k�a�:7ir_ �rc}��rnet�ts r`or eit:l��er r-�isinc� �rices on eE3ac�ks or limiting tf�ieir- cJist:ril�ution: � e�molis t]on't l�s'��,r C�u� - Thi, arc��rne«t is overstated. The libraries I spake to �>aic� th�t print be=:,t:sellers see rx�or� t�7tjr� 2f> lent�s over their lifetime, up t� 50 or more before the book �vould need to ��e r�c�tired. gi L'BOOIiS ��CiC$ I�{�Cf'. �T"�..'t�l@�.?t3�I� - P€.IIJIISII�C5 may r�ot have checked aut a �c�pular baok frorr� their libr-ary rec:ently. Aft.�r sic3ning up an �j fist, a patran get�> � call wher� the book becomes �v�ailabl� anc! if �,he doesr�'t g�t to th� libr�ry th�t samc day someane else on the li�t may ge�. tl�� book. At the encl of t�er rentai period she wiii al�7o get �j c�ll if the bot>k is not. r��tE.�rr�f:�ci r�rec:isely on time. The librar-ians I spake �}Jith said that a bonk ir� I�igl� d�m�ncl ivould s��nd very few days in limbo. This may account for one or t�vo additiona! e�3ook i��nc4s over the course of a year, but not , rnc�re. � You C�n ��c�rrrauv �F.3�e�6c� i�'i�:3�cs�� Vis��:i�°�� E�e �it�rary - Hc�re th� publishers have a more vaiid ar�umen�. �i l�e remc�val of the neeti ta visit tiie library �ould ��ttract an entirely ciifferer3t: cc�nsurner to laorrow eBc>aks, In � L��.irvey coi�ciur.teci by the Ai_.A and C7verdriv�, 31�lo afi eF�oaf: libr��ry borrc�v�r�rs say th�t they ��rarely or neve�-" visit the physicaE library, bvthile 3G�,'o said tfiat they hacl p�irchased a boa!< �fter borrowing tl�e sai��e title frc�rYi tl�e lil�rary, aver half saici th�t tt�ey'd ctarir>ider r------- —— — — — — — — -- .� � � • II � �aurch�sing an eE3ocsk frai�r� ��« onlin� retai{Lr if it lv�s nat available Fram � libr�ry. Whi(e libraries are very c�i�t:c�r��=r-s�rvie.�� oj-ie�7tcci, it'� nat clear to rr7e why �:hey wc�islc# ��a��rt ta di�inrern��i�t� t�tc�rnselve�> {rc�n� the Ient�ing tr�ns�etiar�. F;orrc�v�rers will 1�e mc�re reluct�r7t to visit tl�� (il�rary k�r�� that t�Ecessary visit giv�s th� library tl�� c�ppor�tunity to pr�t�r�ate a �.�ariet}� of c�the�� servic�s. l.ik�r�ri�s hav� 1:hree counter-c�rga��nents to ��ul>!is>I��er �c�ncerns: � �ibr�t-i�s Atso �iu�r �ud� - Libr�ri�:s t7��ve a v�lid poirtt wl��en they suyc�est that ali I th� rn�r�in analysis dr�ne by puialishc�r� c�i�� t.f�eir� most v�l�.i�ble bor�k�� ignor�s ti��y f�ct I that libr�ries buy thousai�ds of titfes eacii ycar ��hich s�e �ew or nc� lends. Unlil<e physical boaksellers, t}��y cic� r�c�t �ui�> or rc�turr� ti�ese tities. Uniike �nmazon, t��y I I��ve ta �ay the pi.3bli{:,i�er wF�ery t.hey ��t.�rcl�a�>e tl�� tit.l�, nc�t:j��st wh�n they I�nd it out tc� their r��cJers. �s c�ist��ers, Istar�ri�s fee! tt��t th�ir risk ;3rofile I�as ��ot been ade�u�tely appi�e�iatec! by �«k�lsst��r5. � �.iL�r•arie� ��i��ulafi� 5al�s- Tl�is i� ��<�rt:ly tr��. The 4ib�-aries �oi��t ta d�ta 1've �lre�cly q��otecf shov�inc� tl��t a sic�}r�iFic�r�t r��r�nk��r c�� rc�cl�rs gts or� ta buy books they`vc borrowed. I'vc �xar��i��eci t11e data �r1c! it su�gests two thinc�s. I c> �estse{1�rs F�r�o�t��y ��a ��a��il��ii�e. Tf�c��cJh survey rt��>�arc.h iS notariously �aor �t ��rcclicting �actual �7urci�as� beh�vit�r, the AL_A/�vc�rdrive study shoetifs lha� over half of e-brarro�r�ers rnic�ht cansidcr �ruy a bests�iler I th�y couldn't finci �t. a IiY3r�ary. Fvc�n if this ��umkaer is srr�alier in �r�ctice, I librari�s �rabal�iy dan't incr��se s�les far boaks already on the bestseiler iists� o �.ib�arie� N�1� s��u�.° A,�.��I�ors ��a�i t�ld�r Tit1�s: Mast �ig Six p��blishers are hc�pelessly u��sc�p��istic�Eec� vuitt� pricinc�. T��ey p��ve�-sely discour�t Eaestseilers a��d er�d up ch�r-yi��g a t�iaher pr-scc for� nelv �s��d unknov��n autk�ars. By r�er�iovir�c� tf�e price k�urdl� to ful!-book sarnplir��, libraries can help these ��uthars b�Eilr� fsal(owir7g �� wc�rci-of-�rnc��ith s�leG>. a i�i�r�ries �?�serv� [�ic� �u��+�n7�r• �ricinc� 1�k�i� argC�ment is true b��t irrel�vant I ��i�der curr�nt ia�v. Li}araries �sse�-t fit��t �ItP�o�agh they are s��rialler tha�7 Am�zon, Barn�s �x Nohic �nr.i distriE3i��.ors, lik� Inc7rarr�, ti��=y r�r� still bic� customer�. They deserve lawer pr�icc�s than indiviciitai cc�ns��ners r-�sther than #iigher fi�rices. The prablen7 is that tt�is is an arg��rr�ent tEiat assur��es that libraries Q��vr� wh�t they t�uy. it's tr��e for pt�ysica! l�ool:s - v�fl�icla is �N1�y lil�r�iries r-eeeive pre(crer�ti�l prici��g to . ordinary consumers. But it is s�ot tr•��c� f�r €�f'�oaks. Libr�ries Iscense c�E�ook� r�ti�er than buying them, Th�as, liE�rarie�� rc� tr-r�xat�d like rc�seil�rs ratt�er than e�7d us�rs. I T`h� Re�l �rol�ler� - �atF� �ic�� r� Fbsx�li�� it�e t�l�•ar�� rg�.�a��:nt I The ��rgu��r�e��t k�e#v�een lik7r�ri�s arx9 ��{i<_71�=�rs i�� rt�ve�� sc> ciiffic��l�: to r�solve for � � � a �;� f- ��It , •�ar�cii �n in tf7�ir n� otiatic�ns. Tl�e �re sin��al�. reason: ht�tt� sides �rc. �r�ing �s � y � c� 9 Y ti�e�tinc� eF:3c�oks like p�zysical p��opes-ty, r�c�t s>Ft�Uar� . �f lii� con�pels tt�ei�� to create c1i�Ficult a��d camplic�(:�d sch��:, for r��rrci�.�ci��c� ll�� c�w��rsl�i� �xperie��c:��. But tt�e c�at� tt> deterrr�ine an equita�le price to s�l! e�E3c�c�k� ta lil�r�rie:s in this scc�n�rio arc� �(mosl I im�aossible ta collect. Sa the side� remain d��diocl: ai�tl guid�d by tl7cir nwn �are-existinc� I beii�fs rather t}�an fact. The sin�p(� fact is tliis: ��oc�lcs ��-� �icer�s�€�, �sc�fi �a}cg Physicral k�c7oks �r� sc>lci f:o lil��r�3rie�:> �a«c:lc�r �`�c� Fir�i �;;.�it�. i��,�irin4;, es�aE:>li<_si�ec� E.�nd�r t.i�e I �uprcme Ca�irt rtaling in F3obf�s-��1e�r;iii Cc�. v. Str-��ist; in 1.�08. In ti�ris case a ��tabli�fi�er, �3oY�bs-1�'I�rrill, s��ed Macy'� wt��r� tt��y viol�tecr t��L ��s�.4blistier's copyric�ht (and a coli��sive ir�c��stry �ricinq �r�ctice} t�y �ricir�� t� (�c��k el�ver� c�r��:�� r�c�e�- tt�e p��L�1isP��r-rr�anclated ret�il {�rice of nne doil�r, �i"he cc�ur�t r�.sl�� tl��t cert;�i�� 3�cts of capyrigf�t do t�c�t surviv�� _� � � the fir-st sa#e: in p�rticular-, tf�� awnefi� after the �irst sale r�nay res�ll or- iend tt7e book for any price. (Ca1eb Crain write� � much bett�� su��r�r�n�r�y of tt3e law �rid its current irr�plications than T can ia� his blog Srer�l,�Gr�cr�.,rr,t�Itrr;rr��,y 1'��,�ti�ri��,r;;) it is tP�is First Sa1� doctrir�e t�►at allorflls bookstores to discount �nd lit�raric�s to Ic�as�ci. UncSer current i�w, thouc�h, cE.�3oc�i<s arc� not banl<s - nat und�r copyric�ht 1�,�•�f, at ie�st. Ii�stead, tP7ey're solc�i uncler a t�s� lir.en�e, jGist li{<e softt��re. Ti�is is4>ue g�ts a iitt.le can�plex l��caus� tl�t� pricing rigl�ts af the cc�p�,�ric�}�t hcEci�€� �rc� nc�t aY�soiute -- as ti�e ��stice C?ep�rtmer�� t�as r�c�t��►� cs�at,�isl�t�1 - b��t tP�ey dc.� ct�r��-�r�tly inc(uc9e tl�� ri�ht �:o treat iil�rarie:� �s resellers r�ther tt�ar� a t�i.�yers. L^v�l�i(� I k>eiieve t:��t libr�r-ies st7e��lci ��rc�rr�ote a �e4t c�se ta ct7alleE�ge tl�is {aV✓, the f�tv l^Lrill not cl�a��r�� sooE�, Ir� the sr��antit��e, though, thir�king of eC�aaks as softwar� pair7ts to � simpler, ancl surprisin� mos�e equitable �F�ay tc� s�ttie t�� curr�nt publi yh�r dispute. i �cslution. �ta�rc�e i.it�rari�s ��r Ler�c� ��.��c� c�t� �:c�s�-�er-Ci�c Thei•e is one numb�r th�fi libraries ran e��sily calcul�te �vhich publisher� will underst�nd: tt�e I c.ast-p�r-circ.ulation, This n�ar�7b�r is sirnpl�a ta r�ic.ul��te. It is th� n��77k�er of lend�:y �nd j ciivid�cl by th� cosfi o� ��e boaks iet7t. -'�i�is ri��m��t� i� soi-newhere in ihe 50 cent tra Y>1.00 I r-ar�c�e �ccor�iinc� to both p��l�lish�rs ar�ci liY�rarie.>. lt c�n b� c�lculat�cl sepa��teiy by pzj�lisl7er- a��c! ever� split I��t��ve�r� i�e£ts�11e��X; �rac3 cicler �itles. Ii � � I � II . � � • . 6/19/2013 � r �� t�� S�quencin� Renton Library Advisory Board Wednesday, June 19, 2013 .....-------------- __�., City of�� _ u�' °�� ! J ,��, �,;._ ` ' I '---�-�""= ; ;C'_..,, �.�3 � '�'�� ,�,� �..I��..��_�� L.'� �.t��l�� The new libraries will be located: � Over the Cedar River at Liberty Park � r�i ij�� , y. , � � On Sunset Boulevard in the Highlands u � �:s�� RE Trt o N � ,�.`�.�� r� > n�a�n ot rn��-cxvv �r;��°, 1 r • � � 6/19/2013 �'�d�� ►�� ibr�r� �'�'�'� �ll�C �� .:�. � ��i�_.___�_ I�r!�I--�, `,� T• �unurm°' •-t�—U [w ' '\ ' _' ... .:.:,f , � /. . . i '_:' :.._..� . :_ . . .. ! ._ ... „_ -i'�:. .-+ri--rn—s.—. ....-v'-�r._.—�—.-r.--_z- . .-�r—�-.�--r:—r—r— _" � �' .. - �� r+a��v ' ;_ _; _ __ - _ _ _— � — 1— '�— `� -� . . �--�- {-- •- -, � . - � — a _...,_. }, ' i` -_ _� � `�. �.- ; . - - ---r-�- -- ---------- __- .:�..---� -____._�-. : . --------------------- ----=--- �'�• { . �_. .._.�',;�; � � . � a : � . ,��uw�no� � - - �r—�� r �� E¢��t� °�� SEPA Environmental Review °e° Site Plan Review �4� Shoreline Substantial Development Permit �s� Building Permit (4 —6 weeks) �S� � �, ♦ a ♦ R E O r+�,�,� �? ni�c.n or ri�r cc��•v �`� � � • • � 6/19/2013 C�d�r R�ve� �.i��ry S�hed��e �v�rvi��►r a Notice of Complete Application—May 29, 2013 � SEPA Determination—June 17, 2013 • DNS-M with 3 mitigation measures related to geotechnical analysis, stream and habitat mitigation and lighting. o SEPA Appeal Period will end on July 5, 2013 � Public Hearing—July 9, 2013 at 9:00 am • Hearing Examiner Decision issued with two weeks after public hearing closed(14 day appeal period) • Shoreline Substantial Development Permit Decision • Sent to Department of Ecology for 21 day appeal period _ti�� O • �'' RENTON 'r,�, �� aNftAD UF Yl1t Cl'tYC y j�� ° �v�� a��°�� q�� o� Land Use Entitlements have all been submitted concurrently. �� Building permit application may be submitted at any time. Issuance, pending final land use approvals. �iSy ��r.� ♦ i a � R E O ''�,C�,, � nu[+n or nir r,rAer �'I 3 � M ' # �� :'�� .:#' •• .. 7�� . �� " �, ` � r� .��;y «w `�r . '►�O��t� �,�� .�f; � �. � r.arrcaw �� s �� :,,��``f �,�'�'' g'_ �cs� c�t: � �' }}}44y��T. : 1oca�� c�� '�//4 o�� c�� y� ��'�R .�,�r' Q'P'�!!..'�7 �1 �� "M ��l��c�-^:�� 5!l�El+�!�.:'.�°."^.':��.-r�54.�IMll�il9RTr"."L":�#��" \ ' •�� E1�""... ._— � ' '! r''�l` ,�. �{ '.'�1 'i' `s . . .. .. . . i� r ,'� , , ... x �- � : . . . � � �, . � ` • • i � ' i ' � . ! � ,. . � ! � • „ • . • • i ' � � I • . • • • � ' � � • � � i � � 6/19/2013 �i�hlands T�-�at� �pp�r�v�ls � February 2012 — City held the Pre- '' application meeting � HUD Disposition Approval, February 2012 � June 3rd - Council approval of purchase & sale agreement and schematic design for new Highlands Library @ June 17th — Council approval of Street Vacation of NE 10th St ��z � V. `� R E N N. ;r� o� .\IIlAP O�ltl!ct'ktt 1�� d ��x�� °r� Lot Line Adjustment (4-6 weeks) r�o preliminary Planned Urban Developrr�ent (16 weeks) �� Phase 1 Site Plan Review � Phase 1 Design Review � Right of Way Dedication �@� Street Vacation Compensation Approval (4 weeks) �� Rental Housing Incentive Request (6 weeks) °�� Sunset Area EIS Addendum (2 weeks) iS�` U 'v '� s ' R E N N r,�� ,� nnc�n ct n�r,r.�ac� �`�, 5 r � � . 6/19/2013 �i�rary - tV��d�d P�rr��t� �� Phase 1 Final PUD (4-6 weeks) �� Phase 1 Construction Permit (4-6 weeks) Q�� Phase 1 Building Permit (4-6 weeks) .�� "s � � i ♦ RENTON �r,�, �� nrnnoe r�it ereei 'L�� hl��ds m ��+��a��°�� Land Use Entitlements can be done concurrently or separated out. �� Construction and building permits can also be separated out. \`�Y ��j V� > RE-N N �'�� , nur�n o� rui��cae� 1'�� 6 " , -+�. .. � . f �.. -�'°` . � a � � � � r� _ - Q�� ' , �� ' .., � .. h � { ��a y a o -� �� ° �eO � � Cx�c�@,; �w� � G�@ � � � � ` � � ° � t�3 �O� ' ' �� VVC�JUIJUU e O � D O O UVO � f , � _ � �. _ � ; , . _ ,- � �� . � j l ,. �_ � . ' _ 1 � / . � .� . . i ` i � � I � �� /// � ! ��!��' --,�... .%�� '. ' � . . \' �,� , - � • 1 � j -� , , ' �---_----�\ � ^ I.'.�'�;�•'- _� _ ; ---_, ' �' ��..-. ' � _ �, �r .� � l _ . - � � , �. ��__-- � :� � � ,� ,. .- , . T �, � , �"_ - - ,, %�� . ,`� � ;�`'`�, , _ ,� �� ;� � , ; _-� � ,�' � <�� . , �� ; �;�� 'r� e�^'b,y �� ;; � ,�� , � �i� � � � _ � � �' ' � � I ;� � , /, � � '�'�,�: - ,� � �, rentonwa.gov,� � ' � � ,, c�t� �t � � � . . . � . � � �n on �� Ev�ent Schedule 7:00 a.m.-Gene Coulon Memorial Beach Park Opens 12:00 p.m.-8:00 p.m.- Free KidZone Activities 1:00 p.m.-5:00 p.m.-Free Rides in Voyageur Canoes 1:30 p.m.-9:30 p.m.-Stage Entertainment 10:00 p.m.—Fireworks from the shores of Gene Coulon Memorial Beach Park Sta�e En�ertainment 1:30 p.m. Renton City Concert Band 3:15 p.m. Parrot Ambassadors 4:30 p.m. Convergence Zone Bluegrass Band 6:00 p.m. African All Stars 7:15 p.m. Official Welcome&National Anthem 8:00 p.m. Oncore,R&B Dance Hits (Stage located in grass amphitheater north of Ivar's and Kidd Valley) I Food will be available at the Beach Concession Stand,Ivar's and Kidd Valley.Visit the Event Information Booth,located north of Kidd Valley,for summertime community event information. Parking Parking is not permitted on Lake Washington Blvd. Street parking is available on Houser Way N. Event parking is available on the upper two floors of the parking garage at The Landing and in the parking lot located at N.8th St.,Park Ave.N.,and Garden Ave.N. Paid parking is available at The Bristol Apartments at Southport along Lake Washington, located between Gene Coulon Memorial Beach Park and Boeing. Courtesy drop-off,pick-up,unload and load available in the Boat Launch area;access to Boat Launch wiil not available between 9:45 p.m.and 11:15 p.m. Street Closure Vehicle access to Lake Washington Blvd.will be restricted beginning at 10:15 p.m.to facilitate safe exit of pedestrians and vehicular traffic from the park. Lake Washington Blvd.will reopen at approximately 11:15 p.m. Please note:Personal fireworks,alcohol,animals,pets,pop-up canopies,enclosed tents and tabie umbrellas are orohibited. Small umbrellas and umbrella-chairs are allowed. Only small-size barbecues will be permitted.No nets or poles installed,no projectiles (i.e.frisbees,footballs,etc).See event web page for details. Launch restriction hours on July 4th: No launching or pick-up of watercraft 9:00 p.m.-11:00 p.m. Stage Entertainment KidZone Activities sponsored by sponsored by �� `��E tne SANCTUARY `e �w.� . � o�»� �r � �, Call 425-430-6600 or visit rentonwa.gov.