Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPH - Appeal of Rezone Denial-Peterson (10/18/76) cee °")/ ,c _- RENTON CITY COUNCIL Regular Meeting October 18, 1976 Municipal Building Monday , 8 : 00 P . M. Council Chambers MINUTES CALL TO ORDER , Mayor C. J. Delaurenti led the Pledge of Allegiance and called the regular meeting, of the Renton City Council to order. ROLL CALL OF RICHARD M. STREDICKE, Council President; GEORGE J. PERRY, EARL CLYMER, COUNCIL WILLIAM J. GRANT, KENNETH D. BRUCE AND ROBERT E. McPETH• Council Presi- dent Stredicke announced Councilwoman Seymour-Thorpe indicated she would be arriving late. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY CLYMER,. COUNCIL EXCUSE PATRICIA SEYMOUR-THORPE. CARRIED. Councilwoman Thorpe arrived at 8:55 p.m. as later indicated. CITY OFFICIALS CHARLES,;J. DELAURENTI , Mayor; G. M. SHELLAN, City Attorney; DEL MEAD, IN ATTENDANCE City Clerk; D.W. CUSTER, Administrative Assistant; GORDON Y. ERICKSON, Planning Director; WARREN GONNASON, Public Works Director; HUGH DARBY, Police Chief; TED BENNETT, Deputy Finance. Director; RICHARD GEISSLER, Asst. Fire Chief; L. WARREN, Asst. City Attorney; SHARON GREEN, Personnel Director. PRESS. IN . DON SMITH, Renton Record Chronicle; MARK PELLEGRINO, Greater Renton ATTENDANCE News: MINUTE APPROVAL MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY BRUCE, COUNCIL APPROVE MINUTES OF OCTOBER 18, AS WRITTEN. CARRIED. PUBLIC ;MEETING , This being the date set and proper legal notice being given, Mayor Oly"mpi.c. View,-,'“Delaurenti opened the public meeting to consider the 10% petition to Annexation ' ' annex the area of Olympic View located between SE 164th Street (S.27th St. ) and SE 165th Street, south of the present city limits east of Benson Road S. Letter from City. Clerk Mead noted the 10% letter of intent to . annex properties to the city was presented to Council on 10/11/76, petition having been certified valid by the Planning Department with 89.7% of assessed valuation represented by signatures. Upon presenta- of the ,petition to annex, Council set this date for preliminary meeting ... ; ,.with the initiating property owners. The letter explained that pursu- ant' toRCW' 35A.14. 120 the Council would need to determine whether to / accept the letter of intent; require adoption of the city's proposed zoning regulations and Comprehensive Plan; require assumption of any pre-existing bonded indebtedness, if any; and whether to authorize circulation of the 75% petition. Olympic View , Planning Director Ericksen explained the request for annexation is 75% Petition . the result of L.I .D. 300, sanitary sewers and involves approximately Authorized . . .. " 2.2 acres with existing valuation of over $200,000 and estimated popula- tion of 20 to 25 people in single family residential area; that the , purpose of the annexation is to obtain sanitary sewers. Sandra Hodge, 10619 SE 164th St. , spoke for the annexation explaining the purpose of the annexation being to obtain sewers. Upon inquiry by Stredicke, Mrs. Hodges, on behalf of petitioners, accepted pre-existing bonded . • indebtedness and city' s zoning and Comprehensive Plan for area. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY PERRY, PUBLIC MEETING BE CLOSED. CARRIEC.. MOVED BY PERRY, SECONDED BY STREDICKE, COUNCIL AUTHORIZE CIRCULATION ' OF 75% PETITION. Councilman McBeth inquired re "squaring off" annexa- • tion. to 108th and was advised by Planning Director Ericksen that there had been no interest. MOTION CARRIED. PUBLIC HEARING 'This being the date set and proper notices having been posted, published Harold Peterson and mailed, Mayor Delaurenti opened the public hearing to consider the Appeal of appeal by Mr. & Mrs. Harold P. Peterson of rezone denial by the Planning Zoning Denial Commission of property located at 762 Monroe Ave. NE .from GS-1 to SR-1 . Letter from Planning Director Ericksen explained Planning Commission review at its public hearing meeting on 9/8/76, for the 20,000 sq.ft. of property with access on Monroe Ave NE for the proposed use of a two lot short subdivision with one lot of 8,000 sq. ft. and one lot of 12,000 sq. ft. The letter noted that at ..the conclusion of the public hearing and receipt of input. from interested parties, the Commission denied the rezone on the basis that it would be detrimental to the surrounding neighborhood.. Planning Director Ericksen pointed out the area on maps, being near intersection of Monroe NE and NE 7th St. , that pipestem lot was planned., R-1 single family to west of Monroe and GS-1 • Renton City Council 10/18/76 Page 2 PUBLIC HEARING - Continued Appeal of to east, that lot size is 7,200 sq.ft. Harold Peterson, 562 Bronson Rezone Denial . Way NE noted duplex and four-plex buildingswithin two blocks of prop=•' Harold Peterson erty in reportedly R-1 zone and asked approval of rezone. Mrs. Deane Peterson noted considerable expense and time involved in attempt to subdivide property in order to sell portion And improve existing house, :' and noted information from surveyor of 4,800 sq.ft. lots in area and inability to .attend Commission hearing due to• illness. Mike Smith, 3402 NE . 7th, noted that, with .the possibility of adoption of the Zoning Examiner system, this could possibly be his last opportunity to speak before the ,,council . on a 'zoning matter and had prepared slides and charts. Smith . 'called .attention to few remaining trees in area and felt subdivision • would have long-term detrimental effect on neighborhood. Arthur Stern, 3513 NE17th St. , agreed with Mike Smith and objected to lots being divided. Grace Fisher, 770 Monroe Ave. NE, objected to off-street build- ing in. the area as it would lessen property values. Kay Adams; 758 Monroe Ave. NE, objected to subdivision as surrounding her home with streets on three sides and reducing her privacy. MOVED BY CLYMER, SECOND BY PERRY, COUNCIL CLOSE HEARING. CARRIED. MOVED BY CLYMER, SECONDED BY STREDICKE, COUNCIL CONCUR IN RECOMMENDATION OF THE PLANNING COMMIS- SION AND DENY REZONE. CARRIED. CONSENT AGENDA The following Consent Agenda items, previously distributed to all Council • . members, are considered routine and are enacted by one motion unless removed for separate consideration by Council action. Proposed Merger Letter from King County Boundary Review Board announced proposed mer- Portion KCF'PD ger of portions of King• County Fire Protection Districts No. 25 and , No. 25 & No. 10 No. 10, announcing hearing scheduled 12/9/76. Recommendation: Refer -. to the Board of Public Works and Fire Department for• investigation 'and report back. • • Conference _ Letter from Asst. Fire Chief Geissler requested permission for attendance Request ' at the 1976 Fire Prevention Engineering Conference at :Issaquah on Fire Department 11/15 - 19/76; registration $65 for 'the four days. . Recommendation: Council approval per Resolution No. 2063. Proclamation Proclamation of Mayor Delaurenti declared the week of 'October 18 - 24, George Reed Week 1976 as. George Reed Week as ,a tribute to the outstanding professional Pac-8 Conference career, being honored by Canadian Province of Saskatchewan who have also Player. designated' the week honoring Renton's former football player (1955-57). Planning Letter from Planning Director Ericksen requested authorization for Commission attendance 11717 & 18/76 at the Planning Association. of Washington . Travel Request Fall Conference in Wenatchee of three' Commission members Gist, S'choles. . and Wik. Sufficient funds budgeted. Recommendation: Referral to the Finance and Personnel Committee. Consent Agenda MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY BRUCE, COUNCIL APPROVE. CONSENT AGENDA Approval AS PRESENTED. CARRIED. , • CORRESPONDENCE AND CURRENT BUSINESS • Friends of Youth Letter from Planning Director .Ericksen reported Planning Commission Halfway House . . recommendation for' approval of the Friends of Youth application for a special revocable permit' to _operate a halfway house for. up to eight teenage boys in an SR-1 zone on property located at' 1919 Talbot Road S. The letter noted the permit was subject to the' limitations included in • proposed covenants between the Friends of Youth and the neighborhood including 24-hour supervision, screening of resident youths. for compati . . bility, provisions for physical maintenance of the property and parking on-site as required and setting-up- a neighborhood advisory council with • - yearly review by the Planning Commission of the special :three-year permit. Friends of Youth City Clerk Mead read—letters of protest to the Planning Commission Contined. decision to grant special permit for halfway house at 1919 Talbot Rd.S. from: Mrs. Dean Ringer, Mr. Si. Mrs. Atteo Pegararo & Mrs. Marconi , Mr. & Mrs. Adolf Koestl , Edward A. Lohre, Mr. & Mrs. Marian Hamilton, Mrs.' &.Mrs. Orville Nelson, iMr. & Mrs. Ermo Gregoris , Mr. & 'Mrs. Tom F.Warren, Mr.& Mrs. Gene Barnes,. Mr. & Mrs. Guy Engle and Mr.& 'Mrs. Barry Mort. Letter from Mr. and Mrs. 'Edward A. Lohre appealed the decision of the , Planning Commission re Griffin Group Hom on Talbot Hill . Renton City Council 10/18/76 Page 2 PUBLIC HEARING - Continued Appeal of to east, that lot size is 7,200 sq.ft. Harold Peterson, 562 Bronson Rezone Denial Way NE noted duplex and four-plex buildingswithin two blocks of prop- Harold Peterson erty in reportedly R-1 zone and asked approval of rezone. Mrs. Deane _Peterson noted considerable expense and time involved in. attempt to subdivide property in order to sell portion and improve existing house, and nOted information from surveyor of 4,800.'sq.ft. lots in area and inability to attend Commission hearing due to illness. Mike Smith, 3402 NE 7th, noted that with the 'possibility of adoption of the Zoning Examiner system, this could possibly be his last opportunity to speak before. the • council on a zoning' matter and" had prepared slides and charts. Smith called .attention to few remaining, trees in" area and felt subdivision would have longterm detrimentaT 'effect on neighborhood. Arthur Stern, 3513 NE 7th St. , agreed with Mike Smith and objected to lots being divided. Grace :Fisher, 770 Monroe Ave. NE, objected to off-street build- ing in the area as it .would lessen property values. Kay.Adams, 758 Monroe Ave. NE, objected to subdivision as surrounding her home with streets' on three sides and reducing her privacy. MOVED BY' CLYMER, SECOND BY PERRY,, COUNCIL. CLOSE HEARING. CARRIED. MOVED BY CLYMER, SECONDED . BY STREDICKE, COUNCIL CONCUR IN RECOMMENDATION OF THE PLANNING COMMIS- ON AND DENY REZONE. CARRIED. CONSENT AGENDA The following Consent Agenda items, previously distributed to all Council members, are considered routine and are enacted by one motion unless removed for separate consideration by Council action.. Proposed Merger Letter from King County Boundary Review Board announced proposed mer- Portion KCFPD ger of portions of King County Fire Protection Districts No. 25 and No. 25. & No. 10 No. 10, announcing hearing scheduled '12/9/76. Recommendation: Refer to the, Board of Public Works and Fire Department for investigation and report back. Conference" 'Letter from Asst. Fire Chief Geissler requested permission for attendance Request at 'the 1976 Fire Prevention Engineering Conference at Issaquah on Fire Department 11/15 - 19/76; registration $65 for the four days.' Recommendation: Council approval per Resolution No. 2063. Proclamation Proclamation of Mayor Delaurenti declared the week of October 18 - 24, George Reed Week 1976 as_ George Reed Week as a tribute•to the outstanding professional Pac-8 Conference career, being honored by Canadian Province of Saskatchewan who have also Player designated the' week, honoring Renton's former football player (1955-57) . Planning Letter from Planning Director Ericksen requested authorization for Commission attendance 11/17 & 18/76 at the Planning Association of Washington • . Travel Request Fall Conference in Wenatchee of three Commission members Gist, Scholes and Wik. Sufficient funds budgeted. Recommendation:.. Referral to the. Finance and Personnel Committee. • Consent Agenda MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY, BRUCE, COUNCIL APPROVE CONSENT AGENDA Approval AS PRESENTED. CARRIED. .. CORRESPONDENCE' AND CURRENT BUSINESS Friends of Youth Letter from Planning Director Ericksen reported Planning Commission Halfway House recommendation,..for approval of .the Friends of Youth application for a special revocable permit to :operate a halfway house for up to eight • teenage boys in an SR-1 'zone on property located at 1919 Talbot Road' S. The letter noted the permit was subject to the limitations included in proposed covenants between the Friends of Youth and the neighborhood including ,24-hour superv,ision, 'screening of- resident youths for. compati- bility, provisions for physical maintenance 'of the property and parking on-site as required and setting-up a neighborhood advisory council with yearly review by the Planning Commission of the special three-year permit. Friends of Youth City Clerk Mead read letters of protest to the Planning Commission Contined decision to grant special permit for halfway house at 1919 Talbot Rd.S. from: Mrs.. Dean Ringer, Mr. & .Mrs. Atteo Pegararo & Mrs. Marconi , Mr. & Mrs. Adolf. Koestl,, Edward A. Lohre, Mr. & Mrs. 'Marian Hamilton, Mrs. & Mrs. Orville Nelson, Mr. & Mrs. Ermo Gregoris, Mr. & Mrs. Tom F.Warren, . Mr.& Mrs. Gene.Barnes, . Mr: & Mrs. Guy Engle and Mr.& Mrs. Barry Mort. . Letter from Mr. and Mrs. Edward A. Lohre appealed the decision of the Planning 'Commission re Griffin .Group. Hom on Talbot Hill . L,( RENTON CITY COUNCIL Regular Meeting October .18, ; 19,76 Municipal Building .. Monday:;:' 8: 00 P . M. Council Chambers, MINUTES CALL TO ORDER Mayor- C. J. Delaurenti led the Pledge of Allegiance and' called the regular, meeting of the Renton City Council to order.• • ROLL CALL OF RICHARD M. STREDICKE, Council President; GEORGE 'J. PERRY, EARL CLYMER, COUNCIL t. . WILLIAM J. GRANT, KENNETH D. BRUCE AND ROBERT E. McBETH. Council Presi- dent Stredi'cke announced Councilwoman Seymour-Thorpe indicated she would be arriving late. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY CLYMER,. COUNCIL EXCUSE PATRICIA SEYMOUR-THORPE. CARRIED. Councilwoman Thorpe arrived 'at. 8:55 p.m. as later indicated. CITY OFFICIALS ,CHARLES J. DELAURENTI , Mayor; G. M. SHELLAN, City Attorney; DEL MEAD, IN ATTENDANCE , City Clerk; `D.W. CUSTER, Administrative Assistant; GORDON Y. ERICKSON, Planning Director; WARREN GONNASON, Public Works Director; HUGH DARBY, Police Chief; TED BENNETT, Deputy Finance Director; RICHARD GEISSLER, Asst. Fire Chief; ,L. WARREN, Asst. City Attorney; SHARON GREEN, Personnel Director. . PRESS IN , DON SMITH, Renton Record Chronicle; MARK PELLEGRINO, Greater Renton ATTENDANCE News.. MINUTE APPROVAL MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY BRUCE, COUNCIL APPROVE MINUTES OF OCTOBER. .18, AS WRITTEN. CARRIED. PUBLIC,;MEETING.. . This being the date set and proper legal notice being given, Mayor Olympic View: .., , Delaurenti. opened the public meeting to consider the 10%. petition to Annexation ' ' r annex the area of Olympic View located between SE 164th Street (S.27th St. ) and SE 165th Street, south of the present city limits east of Benson Road S. Letter from City Clerk Mead noted, the 10% letter of intent to annex properties to the city was presented to Council on 10/11/76, :'; ; petition having been certified valid by the Planning Department with 89:7% of assessed valuation represented by signatures. Upon presenta- of the petition to annex, Council set this date for preliminary meeting with the initiating property owners. The letter explained that pursu- ant .to RCW 35A.14. 120 the Council would need to determine whether to accept the letter of intent; require adoption of the city's proposed • zoning regulations and Comprehensive Plan; require assumption of any pre-existing bonded indebtedness, if any; and whether to authorize circulation of the 75% petition. Olympic View, Planning Director Ericksen explained the request for annexation is 75%. ,Petition the result of L.I.D. 300, sanitary sewers and involves approximately Authorized` ` ` ' 2.2-acres with existing valuation of over $200,000 and estimated popula- tion of 20 to 25 people in single family residential area; that the ,,:purpose of the annexation is to obtain sanitary sewers. Sandra Hodge, 10619 SE 164th St. , spoke for the annexation explaining the purpose of the annexation being to obtain sewers. Upon inquiry by Stredicke,' ' ' Mrs. Hodges, on behalf of petitioners, accepted pre-existing bonded • indebtedness and city' s zoning and Comprehensive Plan for area. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY PERRY, PUBLIC MEETING BE CLOSED. CARRIEC.. MOVED BY . PERRY, SECONDED BY STREDICKE, COUNCIL AUTHORIZE CIRCULATION ' ' OF 75% PETITION. Councilman McBeth inquired re "squaring off" annexa- t.ion. 'to 108th and was advised by. Planning' Director Ericksen that there had been no interest. MOTION CARRIED.. .. PUBLIC HEARING This being the date set and proper notices having been posted, published Harold Peterson and mailed, Mayor Delaurenti opened the public hearing to consider the Appeal of appeal by Mr. & Mrs. Harold P. Peterson of rezone denial by the Planning Zoning Denial Commission of property located at 762 Monroe Ave. NE from GS-1 to SR-1 . Letter from Planning Director Ericksen explained Planning Commission • review at its public hearing meeting on 9/8/76, for the 20,000 sq.ft. of property with access on Monroe Ave NE for the, proposed use of a two lot short subdivision with one lot. of 8,000 sq. ft. and one lot of 12,000 'sq.. ft. The letter noted that at the conclusion of the public hearing and receipt of input from interested parties , the Commission denied the rezone on the basis that it would be detrimental to the surrounding neighborhood. Planning Director Ericksen pointed out the area on maps, being near intersection of Monroe NE and NE 7th St. , that pipestem lot was planned', R-1 single family to west of Monroe and GS-1 r• 4 OF - v `, o THE CITY OF RENTON • MUNICIPAL BUILDING 200 MILL AVE. SO. RENTON,WASH. 98055 . CHARLES J. DELAURENTI MAYOR • , PLANNING DEPARTMENT • A 235-2550 • • 4TFDSE131-4O • October 18 , 1976 • The Honorable C : J . Delaurenti , Mayor Members of City Council • Renton , Washington • RE : HAROLD P . PETERSON APPEAL OF PLANNING COMMISSION DENIAL OF REZONE FROM GS-• 1 TO SR- 1 - PROPERTY • LOCATED AT 762 MONROE AVENUE N . E . Dear Mayor and Council Members : • • . The Planning Commission reviewed the above noted request at • its . public hearing meeting on September 8 , 1976 . The prop- erty has the following characteristics : • • Property Location--762 Monroe Avenue N . E . • Total Area--±20 , 000 square feet • Principal Access--Monroe Avenue N . E . Existing Zoning--GS- 1 • Proposed Use--a two lot short subdivision • Comprehensive Plan--Single Family Residential • The applicant requested the rezone in order to divide the property into two lots . The present lot is approximately . 20 ,000 square feet in area , and the resulting subdivision proposed would make one lot of 8 , 000 square feet and one lot of 12 ,000 square feet . • • At the conclusion of the public hearing and receipt of input from interested parties , the Planning Commission took the • following action : MOVED BY TEEGARDEN, SECONDED BY GIST, THAT THE HAROLD PETERSON APPLICATION FOR REZONE BE DENIED ON THE BASIS THAT IT WOULD BE DETRIMENTAL TO THE • SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD. MOTION CARRIED UNANI • MOUSLY. Very tr, ly ,yours , • , a 7v rd n Y r cksen Plannin irector GYE : wr Attachments r.. , i , ,_ _ •i S.•I q F) a W II lr\ •I: ' i•• • ® G } W t I I b 1 'J -�3 ' ^.,:fit ,, ,.. i_._ It _1 �Z � �, s s sow e a�#1 c� 1 NI . . -e: A .---„ ,_- , . f� 0 r a y I 3 .. j. z c 1nw. t . _ .me. f N!•In+G,-1-1' III r�\• .e:muivi�emT.s - V[[��a :v. IRk 1.k x 4t`=m$ %4'1 4�', x, c .lryl�Z'ElidS ¢-la �4,om® Ail,, ♦,. w C l a I I44 d©�. `�• T++�� }iiv t a .' - .o r,l'°i 1' °i. j. ' I a t I y. 1 !r"f x'ASP:, !., 49 a^ rs' A 3 . ,, i ,,, ., ,, , ' „ow.1 0 ggl u� •� a S€ �� t it t' is'�a I�= �J���#�L �t�� '�! r r " 2 " II. - r 13-1 Y, ,, ta� o D D , 71. . 10 > sir ,, fill 9 - yl�, �.n i'; 14' � �'r;.53h'1 n©a©© W ., lougaii.4 gl a it w 1,.. II •A r ` • I " ' ` 'e , ..•� 3 L 1! '� '-,T �® "1 _ I F. t.M, . I.NE I f �70 III, Z ((�yy]� h. 1 ,^ 1..—r. r r N.1 IC 5T ' . . O IO r. '� ...;��e ;1i I"�;1.1.�!f•� ' I '.1. ',�ti� ,11 -y.r.. I 1 w r, ,t) .. If 'I, . I 1' Miler4 • , I .... . fit, o , -t, ItilWRIM {111 1 ice: f a. rex 1 in _�a. 642011 Q i .. s®cema®ea♦a♦®.� :, ; i\ f ;44 a ooh®� I o r . l ' T `` MI: 4 1 • f�.n r.e1�,O•r� 1��i' tQ,f. _or, k ,:.................................N ._ J w w r,, . a�S' �14••', 1, r a,, �i 1�. TM ii- SE...�H� .....' `- l;Nt..„ . Jtl ,to aa,. •. ee�1E 1, V 720W EV I �P e = ;[�15:,.. ,� �� i i ��®}+fir ...n, a.Q i --, ` 'f ill ' WV. •.1 d -O7sN■T. _ -.. _-� 1'r m� me as �I♦ I 1.- e 1 r, ;.._•1, i., rI\ , ao , t , •5A. � 6'•' 1 .+ W8 ;.. —6 E^ ... ®1 I z. -L_� i. .AC .f, ..1 \ a\t_I.. • MS __ litir' c •1 �.. j 1 r P . PETERSON '' IR. Mill� "�� I I _ J H A R O L Dh,r,o �0m ; REZONE M stl�Rd I _ -. min , t WAIVER ; moor a �Q 150• .m f f Gs. } I ` I 2_ft .,. o3 J. / I . I ? r 1 I •"h, 19 ! I f x , }, .1. , MI zo I , REZONE: Harold P. Peterson; Appl . No: R-882-76; Rezone from GS-1 to SR-1; property located at 762 Monroe Avenue N.E. WAIVER OF OFF-SITE IMPROVEMENTS: Harold P. Peterson; Appl . No. W-883-76; Application fo.r waiver of off-site improvements for a two lot short plat; property located at 762 Monroe Avenue N.E. APPLICANT Harold P. Peterson TOTAL AREA ±20,000 sq.ft. PRINCIPAL ACCESS Monroe Avenue. N.E. EXISTING ZONING GS-1 (35,000 sq. ft. lots) . EXISTING USE Single Family Residence PROPOSED USE A Two Lot Short Subdivision COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE PLAN Single Family Residential District COMMENTS ' Penton Planning Commission Meeting September 8 , 1976 Page Seven Discussion among the Commissioners ensued , and the fol - lowing items were considered : impact on the home immedi - ately adjacent , proximity to an elementary school and park in the vicinity , and parking provisions . Mr . Holm advised that immediate adjacent owners to the south , north , and west had been contacted ; and no objections were indicated . IT WAS THEN ACTION: MOVED BY TEEGARDEN, SECONDED BY SCHOLES, THAT THE FRIENDS OF YOUTH APPLICATION BE CONTINUED, FOR TWO WEEKS AND REFERRED TO THE SPECIAL STUDIES COMMITTEE FOR STUDY AND REPORT BACK AT THE SEPTEMBER 22, 1976, MEETING . Further discussion followed regarding possible impact on the single family residential area , the social issues involved , and the size of the staff . On the question , • a roll call vote was requested with the following results : GIST -- AYE MOLA -- AYE SCHOLES -- AYE TEEGARDEN -- AYE WALKER -- NO WIK -- NO MOTION CARRIED. ' A five minute recess was declared at 11 : 25 p .m. The meeting resumed at 11 : 30 p . m. with all members in attendance . .jf REZONE : $, HAROLD P . PETERSON ; Appl . No . R-882-76 ; Rezone from GS-1 to SR-1 ; property located at 762' Monroe Ave-. N . E . The item was presented for consideration . Associate Planner Smith pointed out the site location on the vicinity map , noted zoning and Comprehensive Plan desig- nations of the property and neighborhood , and described land use in the vicinity . The applicant proposes to subdivide the approximate 20 ,000 square foot site into two lots , a front and rear parcel , with the rear parcel Ito be in .a pipestem configuration . An existing home is situated on the front parcel . Slides , maps and aerial photographs were viewed and described . Chairman Garrison called for comment from the applicant , but it was noted that he was not present . Questions of the staff followed concerning the Council ' s proposal regarding pipestem lots and the requested zoning and its requirements . The Chairman invited comments in favor of the proposal , but received none .. He then called for comments in opposi - tion . Arthur Stern , 3513 N . E . Seventh Street , Renton , inquired regarding the meaning of GS-1 zoning and asked whether the applicant would be able to meet requirements for the I:cnton Planning Commission Meeting September 8 , 1976 Page Eight location of his driveway to the proposed rear parcel . He was advised of the GS-1 definition by the Planning Director , who noted that the proposal fo.r the driveway does meet require- ments . Mr . Stern indicated concern regarding the reduction of the lot sizes, afnd objected to the planned location. of the : driveway to the back lot . Michael Smith , 3402 N . E . Seventh Street , Renton , noted that he had been asked to represent his neighbors in speaking in opposition. to the proposed rezone . He stated they are opposed for two reasons : this rezone would have a long-term detri - mental effect on the surrounding properties , and the sub- dividing of the property into a pipestem lot is not good planning and/or land use . He described the area as very unique due to its country-like character and the only section in that neighborhood which has been developed in accordance with its zoning . Concern was expressed regarding a possible domino effect should the proposal be approved , resulting traffic on three sides , increased density in the area , and depreciation of property values . The provision for access ' was also questioned . A petition containing 15 names urging denial. was presented . Questions of Smith by the Commissioners followed relative to lot sizes in the immediate vicinity , the quality of utilities i'n the 'area , and the number of people present in opposition . Ebb Munson , 809 Monroe , Renton , indicated his objection to the request. for a, waiver of off-site improvements . Discussion among the Commissioners ensued relative to the character of the neighborhood . Regret was expressed over the absence of the applicant . IT WAS THEN MOVED. BY TEE- GARDEN , SECONDED BY SCHOLES , THAT THE PUBLIC HEARING BE CLOSED . MOTION CARRIED . ACTION: MOVED BY TEEGARDEN, SECONDED BY GIST, THAT THE HAROLD PETERSON APPLICATION FOR REZONE BE DENIED ON THE BASIS THAT IT WOULD BE DETRIMENTAL TO THE SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD . MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. It was requested that the staff notify the applicant of the Commission ' s action and his right of appeal to the City Council , WAIVER OF OFF-SITE IMPROVEMENTS ; C, HAROLD P . PETERSON ; . Appl . No . W-883-76 ; Application for Waiver of Off-site, Improvements for a Two Lot Short Plat ; property located at 762 Monroe Ave . N . E . There was a brief discussion concerning the effect of the denial of the rezone request upon this application . IT WAS THEN ACTION: MOVED BY SCHOLES, SECONDED BY WALKER, THAT THE HAROLD PETERSON REQUEST FOR WAIVER OF OFF-SITE IMPROVEMENTS BE CONTINUED . It was noted that action on this item would be appropriate , if the rezone is .not appealed and that would not be known for approximately ten days . Shelton Fisher , 770 Monroe Ave .' N . E . , requested that the residents be notified if an appeal is made . On the question , MOTION CARRIED. e • 1,6 0 F ?3 , 1976 % Tu : Renton Planning Commission 6, 12.:R6 ) RE: Harold P. Peterson Rezone • „13 i•. . ! • , • \NV Mr. Chairman, Members of the Commission: '-• DEO" We , the undersigned , are opposed to the Harold P. Peterson rezone , from GS-I to SR-I (Appli. R-882-76) . This rezone would be detrimental to the surrounding properties and not in the best interests of the community. NAME . ADDRESS 241 • • Wte ///1;i5. Ric pif_ILEL --)1k71741 34-02- 7 e ••.4 . d1-41<TE)/ - 3 3QQ _ALE. r.1-6 • / - ) ://). .• -4. - • •• 7/- 6. • ' _ 62Z1 ( •• ••17 el 76/ 77. t.• •. -r 1 (.. . 3 .22 3 •• (7 67 •; ,>‘ • /11• ") '12/ ) ' • . ,3 -,4y f1-4- . ,.) '64e• 1. //. fe"-- • ;‘) ' //() •A/2::. • )// I /„,A,/ ;74 A_, „L / • , rt 41' x4 1Ji • 75 • . . • • , ye) v(,/, "• -‘4t •••• ••'' /z-e -Cc,/ • • • • • • • •. • • • . , . • , . . . , . • . . . . . . . . . . ' . • . . . September 20, 1976 . . . . . . • . • . . • . . . _ City Council ' • . . P.rt.on, Washngtor, . . . . . . . . . Honorable Mayor, Members of the City Council : • . • . .. . . . , , On behalf of my neighbors, I •hereby request that the CoUm- il deny . . the Harold P. Peterson appeal of the Planring Commission decision of September 8,1976, RE:ApPlication No. R-.. 82-76 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . This rezone application was before the Planning Commission at a • , public hearing on September 8, 1976 and after due consideration was . rejected because it would have been. detrimental to the surroumling properties . . . . . . • . . We reaffirm our opposition and ask the City Council to sustain the , deci.s.ion of ,the. Planning Commission. , • ... -6;i-C•?)-4->--- . . . • - 4!,..T.,-- =,..•„7::.N\ . Sincerely, • • • •s:- --A . • . P---'• . .. .. ) . . . 0".. C• .1. c ... . • • . ' . 4 rt , • ,•'" 13 -111 • leel4411/ ' .. • . 'cc'' . \IX''' c.•,..:'- .'34‘*. ' . Michael L. Smith '4,--T, •.,-, „,\ ". ic... ...? • -Cr, . e,' c • • — 31402 N . 7-f,-.:n S t..,.. \'., ..... co- i. ,..- .t • C., . -... ...1 ,i . • ....• -,..".. . . . . . . . • . . . . . . . . . . ' . . . • . . . . • .. . . . . . . • • . , . . . • • . • . . . . , . . . . • . • . . • . . . . • . , . . . . • . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . . . . • . . • . • • . . . . . . . . . , . . . . . . . . • . , . . • . . . . • . . • ov. -v RE THE CITY OF RENTON �� �r MUNICIPAL BUILDING 200 MILL AVE. SO. RENTON,WASH. 98055 0 CHARLES J. DELAURENTI ' MAYOR ® PLANNING DEPARTMENT 0 �� 235-2550 4T�® SE PI%•• September 10, 1976 Harold Peterson 562 Bronson Way N. E . Renton , WA 98055 . RE : APPLICATION FOR REZONE - #R-882-76 Dear Mr. Peterson : The Planning Commission at its September 9, 1976 public hearing denied your application for, rezone of the property located at 762 Monroe Avenue. N. E . The Commission , after consideration of the facts of the proposal , determined that the request was not compatible with surrounding land uses , and that further subdivi - sion . of the property would be detrimental to adjacent properties and the unique character of the area . You have the option of requesting to the City Council an appeal of 'this ruling within ten ('10) days from the date of the ruling . Such an appeal must be submitted in writing to the Planning Depart- ment. If you have further questions , please contact this Department . • Very truly yours , Gordon Y . Ericksen P1 nilpg D/irec or% ' , Michael L . Smith Associate Planner MLS : vb' . !r//2 • CITY O,F RENTON NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING BY RENTON CITY COUNCIL NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Renton City Council has fixed the 18th day of October , 19 76 , at 8:00 p.m. in the Council Chambers of the Renton Municipal Building, Renton, . Washington, as the time and place for a public hearing to consider the following: • Appeal of Planning Commission Denial of Rezone from GS-1 to SR-1 for property located at 762 Monroe Avenue N.E. Any and all interested persons are invited to be present to voice approval , disapproval or opinions on same. CITY OF RENTON l_teu6 Delores A. Mead, City Clerk DATE OF PUBLICATION September 24, 1976 CERTIFICATION STATE OF WASHINGTON) ) ss. COUNTY OF KING ) I , hereby certify that ( ) copies of the above notice were posted by me in ., conspicuous places on the property described and two copies were posted at the Renton Municipal Building, 200 Mill Ave, South, Renton, WA on date of 19 . . Signed . ATTEST: Notary Public in and for the State of Washington, residing in Renton 6/76 CITY OF RENTON NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING . BY RENTON CITY COUNCIL NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Renton City Council has fixed the _lath day of ber ,. 19 76 at 8:00 p.m. in the Council Chambers of Octo Renton, Washington, as the time and place f the Renton Municipal Building, � for a public hearing to consider the following: Commission Denial of Rezone from GS-1 Appeal of for property located at 762 Monroe Avenue N.E. to SR-1 p p i • PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE SENT TO ALL OF THE ATTACHED PEOPLE ON 9/28/76. J. Truman are invited to be present to voice approval , Any and all interested persons disapproval or opinions on same. CITY OF RENTON Delores A. Mead, , City Clerk DATE OF PUBLICATION � nn 19 -6 r y—--_. .._ -. September 20,1976 City Council Renton, Washington Honorable Mayor, Members of the City Council: On behalf of my neighbors, I hereby request that the Council deny the Harold P. Peterson appeal of the Planning Commission decision of September 8,1976, RE:Application No. R-882-76. This rezone application was before the Planning Commission at a public hearing on September 8, 1976 and after due consideration was rejected because it would have been detrimental to the surrounding properties . We reaffirm our opposition and ask the City Council to sustain the decision of the Planning Commission. 2� ���112�� , Sincerely, re 4101/L7-7 cc sci Michael L. SmithJ L`-c��lG^ 3402 N.E. 7th St. �'! �' - � � �F September 8 , 1976 • ,!,'�� pEC[I\,'EFD 26 ` 'V TO: Renton Planning Commission 'Er 6, 1976 2i RE: Harold P. Peterson Rezone .a /, /-° /1,. t Mr. Chairman, Members of the Commission: -,G DEPA,/ We, the undersigned, are opposed to the Harold P. Peterson. rezone , from GS-I to SR-I (Applbb R-882-76 ) ., This rezone would be detrimental to the surrounding properties and not in the best interests of the community. NAME ADDRESS 1 / 7N , mire 9 /7.7/7S. / )71c:KA Cit.- L . r rn,ru �- 4)2 it), L=:. —..,--- i 'n� e n,fs• .1 0 . 2 .4.47 y - •33-•.. h. 7 i 5-(, . ..777a. , ..-ci /,12,. ,. `. . '..)2,-/ 91:--) t\----e4''')1.1Z:5'7122 ../kitir.,,,,7( .:3)::•3:)-2' ,)7 c- 5 '_,-1 /% LPL / y ,.`:c{ / • . _%� _3/ 77 //- Ze- L /(i . (.) - ?/J.,- . ;;J i = l r; .7� ,.„ ..,./L - j n.4-g- r,-.<•.e ,vL Renton City Council 9/20/76 Page 2 CORRESPONDENCE AND CURRENT BUSINESS • • CONSENT AGENDA MOVED BY PERRY, SECONDED BY THORPE., COUNCIL APPROVE ALL ITEMS ON THE APPROVAL CONSENT AGENDA AS PRESENTED. Bicentennial Letter from Soroptimist International of Renton, Corresponding. Air Park Secretary Olive A. Stritmater, supported full credit to the Kiwanis Club of Renton for their years of work and funds raised toward the new park at Renton Airport, noting the name Kiwanis Bicentennial Air Park would be most appropriate. MOVED BY PERRY, SECONDED BY SEYMOUR-THORPE, COUNCIL REFER LETTER TO THE AVIATION COMMITTEE. CARRIED. Horizons '76 Letter from Lew Innocenti , Chairperson of the Renton Bicentennial- Committee Diamond Jubilee Committee noted the last regular meeting of that committee and recommended formulation of a Renton Horizons '76 Committee, to which over 15 community volunteers have pledged sup- port. Mr. Innocenti announced the following charter: Coordinate and implement objectives from Renton's Town Meeting 5/8/76 at Renton High School ; 4th of July Picnic at Liberty Park annually; Community interest in community events for community and national pride. MOVED BY PERRY, SECONDED BY SEYMOUR-THORPE, COUNCIL REFER THIS MAT- TER TO THE MAYOR'S OFFICE FOR RECOMMENDATION. CARRIED. Harold P. Peterson ,0 Letter from Harold and Deane Peterson, 562 Bronson Way N.E. , .regis- Rezone Appeal : tered appeal of the Planning Commission denial of application for - GS-1 to SR-1 rezone of property located at 762 Monroe Ave. between N.E. ,Sixth and N.E. Seventh. The letter explained plan to divide the lot into two sections, providing pipestem egress and improve the existing house and garage on the front lot. The letter further explained procedure followed and objections to the denial . Upon advice from City Attorney Shellan, it was MOVED BY PERRY, SECONDED BY STREDICKE, COUNCIL SET PUBLIC HEARING FOR DATE OF OCTOBER 18, FOR APPEAL OF PLANNING COMMISSION DENIAL OF THE PETERSON REZONE. CARRIED. Peterson Rezone Letter from Michael L. Smith, 3402 N.E. 7th St. , requested Council Denial Request deny Harold P. Peterson appeal of the Planning Commission decision of 9/8/76,at which time Peterson request for rezone was denied. Mr. Smith's letter noted request made on behalf of his neighbors. MOVED BY PERRY, SECONDED BY SEYMOUR-THORPE, COUNCIL REFER LETTER TO THE PUBLIC HEARING. CARRIED. Economic Letter from Mayor Delaurenti presented proposed Resolution authoriz- Development ing the Mayor and City Clerk to make application for certain Economic Administration Development Administration funds on behalf of the city for four projects listed from the Local Public Works Capital Development and Investment Program of PL 94-369. The letter recommended application be made for 100% financing of each of the four projects in a total amount of $3,670,000. The letter noted .the SW 43rd project being joint with Kent and EDA application would be made by Renton and shared " equally with Kent. The letter explained the allocation of grant funds will be made by computer on a "point basis" without regard for local priority and against all other applications submitted, noting the city's best interests would be served by submitting several applica- tions in order that one or more may be funded. City Clerk Mead Resolution #2065 read the Resolution authorizing grant applications for the new main Authorizes EDA fire station, SW 43rd St. improvements., Talbot Hill pump station Funding Application and water tie line to Rolling Hills, and the Cedar River Trail System.. Fire Station, etc. MOVED BY PERRY, SECONDED BY BRUCE, COUNCIL APPROVE RECOMMENDATION OF THE MAYOR AND RESOLUTION AS READ AUTHORIZING MAYOR AND CITY CLERK TO MAKE APPLICATION FOR EDA FUNDS. CARRIED. AUDIENCE COMMENT Nancy Berry, President of the Renton Chapter of National Organization . for Women, inquired of the organization's letter which had been ores- Bicentennial ented to the Saturday 9/11/76 Council meeting. Miss• Berry called Airpark attention to the proposed name, of "Amelia Earhart Park," and was advised by Mayor Delaurenti the letter was referred to the Aviation Committee and would be discussed at their meeting 9/21/76. City Vehicles Ralph Hart, 125 Wells Ave. N. , objected to city personnel driving city cars back and forth to work. Mayor Delaurenti advised the matter has been reviewed in the past and a few employees are allowed to take cars home because of emergency calls, and that the matter would be further reviewed. • RENTON CITY COUNCIL Regular Meeting September 20, 1976 Municipal Building Monday, 8: 00 P . M. Council Chambers MINUTES CALL TO ORDER Mayor C. J. Delaurenti led the Pledge of Allegiance and called the regular meeting of the Renton City Council to order. CITY COUNCIL RICHARD M. STREDICKE, Council. President; ROBERT E. McBETH, KENNETH ROLL CALL D. BRUCE, GEORGE J. PERRY AND PATRICIA M. SEYMOUR-THORPE. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY SEYMOUR-THORPE, ABSENT COUNCILMEN WILLIAM J. GRANT AND EARL CLYMER BE EXCUSED. CARRIED. CITY OFFICIALS CHARLES J. DELAURENTI , Mayor; DON CUSTER, Administrative Assistant; IN ATTENDANCE GWEN MARSHALL, Finance -Director.; DEL MEAD, City Clerk; RICHARD GEISSLER, Asst. Fire Chief; WARREN GONNASON, Public Works Director; GERARD M. SHELLAN, City Attorney; GORDON Y. ERICKSEN, ,Planning Director; CAPT. BOURASA, Police Department Representative; VERN CHURCH, Purchasing Agent; Tom Touma, Design Engineer. PRESS. IN ATTENDANCE DON SMITH, Renton Record Chronicle MINUTE APPROVAL Council President Stredicke noted correction to name of Seattle P. I. Reporter, John Wilkins. MOVED BY STREDICKE, SECONDED BY McBETH, COUNCIL APPROVE MINUTES OF SEPTEMBER 11 , 1976.AND SEPTEMBER 13, 1976 AS WRITTEN. CARRIED. PUBLIC HEARING This being the date set and proper notices having been posted, L. I. D. #288 published and mailed, Mayor Delaurenti opened the public hearing Whitman Crt.N.E. to consider the final assessment roll in amount of $158,340.69 Street and for Local Improvement District No. 288, construction and installa- Lighting tion of street and street lighting improvements and incidentals in the vicinity of Whitman Court N.E. City Clerk Mead read letters of protest from I. D. Investments and J. W. Dalpay. Letter from John E. Phillips of Hillis, Phillips, Cairncross, Clark & Martin, representing Dura Development, Inc. , responsible: for payment of L.ID 288 assessments of Mueller and Dunham, and S. Delong, object ed to the assessment on basis of 5/16/74 agreement with the City setting total sum of $110,000 for the improvements with assessment on those two parcels of $74,877 rather than the $92,125 set forth in the final assessment roll notice. Mr. Phillips' letter asked amendment of the roll . Public Works Director Gonnason confirmed the agreement referred to by Mr. Phillips and noted alternatives, also explaining increased cost of project due to increased acquisi- tion. and condemnation costs, asking Council instruction to prepare revised assessment roll with $58,463 city participation and that hearing be continued 30 days and referred to committee. MOVED BY Hearing Continued McBETH, SECONDED BY BRUCE, COUNCIL INSTRUCT THE PUBLIC WORKS DEPART- to October 25, 1976 MENT TO PREPARE REVISED ASSESSMENT ROLL, CONTINUE PUBLIC HEARING FOR 30 DAYS AND REFER THE MATTER TO THE PUBLIC WORKS AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE FOR FURTHER CONSIDERATION. Mayor Delaurenti set the date of October 25, 1976 for public hearing. MOTION CARRIED. CONSENT AGENDA The following Consent Agenda items, previously distributedto all Council members, are considered routine and are enacted by one motion unless removed for separate consideration by Council action. Appointment Letter from Mayor Delaurenti announced appointment of Terry Lee . Terry L. Treadwell Treadwell to the permanent position of Police Officerwith the Renton Police Department effective 10/1/76, having successfully completed his six months probationary period. Council concurrence recommended. Auditor's Report The forty-ninth Examination of the City from January 1 , 1975 to of Examination December 31 , 1975 by the Office of the State Auditor was filed with the City Clerk and is. available for inspection. (Information) Damages Claim Claim for Damages was filed by Clyde W. Downing, 31424 West Lake C.W. Downing . Morton Dr. , Kent, for damage to water heater allegedly due -to unsched- uled water meter removal . Refer to City Attorney and Insurance Carrier. Fire Pumper Truck Letter from Michael L. Smith, Chairman of the Fire Station, Advisory Committee, noted item inadvertently "omitted from special report by the committee, approved by Council 9/11/76, and requested referral of the following item to the Public Safety Committee for considera- tion: One new pumper be purchased as soon as possible, preferably before 1978. '' d CITY OF RENTON NOTICE "OF PUBLIC HEARING BY RENTON CITY COUNCIL NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Renton City Council has fixed the 18th . day of October , 19 76 , at 8:00 p.m. in the Council Chambers of the Renton Municipal Building, Renton, Washington, as the time and place for a public hearing to consider the following : Appeal of Planning Commission Denial of Rezone from GS-1 to SR-1 for property located at 762 Monroe Avenue N.E. • Any and all interested persons are invited to be present to voice approval , disapproval or opinions on same. CITY OF RENTON Delores A. Mead,y 7?1 City Clerk DATE OF PUBLICATION _jep t-entilei= 24, 197 6 . CERTIFICATION STATE OF WASHINGTON) ) ss. COUNTY OF KING ). I , L e si e A.. P)))) , c hereby ce,i,ti fy that 5 vcn ( 7 ) copies of the above notice were posted by me in e✓2/7 conspicuous places on the property described and two copies` were posted at the Penton Municipal Building , 200 Mill Ave, South, Renton, WA on date of ,Se , , 19 7'6 . Signe __ Zeleii#24 ATTEST: Notary Public in- and for"the State of Washington , residing: in Renton 6/76 rp a /-,z-, /1-'i //ea7/>7 s .00OT/O/� �Gr /-/eri,7 c- er /b7, /9Z O 4/ '6?e7l O/ P/ / 7� �� iSSfcr� e 0'7r25-'ezcrle ,7-/U G5_ / // ,S, er17 QTed 1/ 77Z %1 e a G �J` � p / J �crJ 7�, 027 /9'e U' l��s" ��J' • /,1e /c'c f rf %/ -. z5f71 erji 7 S./1/ - 14,5/ ife'r et 'yf m i. 7 4't • /yeu/per71, r / E / 4._ (f • /K1, 7L S/ /6 4 t ' Z-as-7 4.71 ) 'orr dre 7T 5/ . %ezo7 ifb,v'e'r 0/yi ,222c drP. �' r_ cc-:-,. Gordon Ezicksen I • 010 _ n RECEIVE® 4a R.,,,,,„,, ). ,.. SEP 15 1976 ..., CITY OF REN-TON MAYOR'S OFFICE ��ca, / /cy <''p e4 l RECEIVED E CITY of RENTONI �9 7 i.— � O Y -121 Y.Z �'✓ ' Se --- 4 , :,..4 li/L-4-7--, .4-1. ,P/-7 6.)-:, ,,,./ .-/ . 24,,,d;t0',4,,„zi- .:6-tfiTi.-,- , 2./. i„J a./enfi.o€A, ..7 ✓ `c i- %L,` , 4v.-C:,.1.-&-ram- ,, _'- -I leiLl.p? - /.� /- , &d a_,L,i, A X, .-.-4,0/,_} P-I .11-A-i ou 444f-t,t--* .w_,0,-(7:-/f-' 72/ - 7z-c-e,/,,Lti ,,..42, -111 a_ J �� C-"444 ,LLB-A,1 .i20y o 70 . irk-? V% ✓t/Lz - / frd `" a,„Lel ,-4/ 6je4f --41-ez,L4_, 0_:,..,a,,,.,,,,,,, ,L) -I.i le-.-Li ..,-(___ _.€,4,/ /.. ..7kt_aLeA.e__- ) .A..i,. 1_,rzez ./z..4_, G1- /2-64--?/4-gl-e,La-) L.�C%ctl�?—�iPi1-e--el----66-¢/' .1�c�c.y C.'c-Lt-C.1- �,e___O___> : "y_____`-44-2-4--) -ice /1 ek- --el/) ,_rojtj_J -7/Lo _2 (1-et- q7,4,64J V,„, -,<-:°-1 - ,- 7,C-e- a_,,," .....r.„,,,, 0/ ,..e_i eA_Le____ _L./___ C-0---0 .-c.- ,'-jth,e,, AA:6-4 ---4,2 ---- 666gc. _d___t/i, , i _i___e_e_ ,- G J /. _zi' ,, _Guy GG(zoi ,..-----n..„4-ik.e- ,_,___4_, --Pi-Le-7v-, _,4 ty22_,A, .,/.. .12,i 4.;7 LA- Le4---d- ot-gxy-a-zlie e __a_..,_,,,,,,,a dLe__, c...., , 61.-,,a.A _714, _ ..,_,,,k- �/4 �� ,4 C �� • , t2sN •4 - kr tk, • \t, p L \ •P' c. , . . . '%. 4. , )\ _ q N„ _ . . _, 1\ qtrf r10 , .o.It k . :),)1,, Kt ., • ,,,,*.i.i„- i t :, ,i,, , . . ,ii ,. „\. ,, , , \ \ ' R„ ( r . , , , N , i ' k , ,T , tli ,, 1 4,, , i,,,., .k. N\ p : z .:- \ • - :- • t - i. ,-: 'N k l'' . ' - ' V I • , \ : ; Vg: \k , t . . ' \ Ll . 1 ''-' ' r) N' I \ t ' k k ' \ . q . N . , _ . . _ . 4 ' l'° ' \ _ \ \ \ • N,). _. . . _ , . - k-_- , ., . - • - .4 - — - _ ) . 1 r14 § • , .k- 1 , .. _q • : ,. . cl . . . . \ ! , \. .' \,\ ',. . . m K V ,, IN. \ , ' \ r\,` \4N ,' � hy>' k. tr. r1‘. .44 � ` � N oV\ ' ; . s'' \ \ - L 4\\° � `fie • \ 0 : ., , q)C11 40 - ' s ( 1° , i. \ tq ' ,), t, J., 4. ,6. t,,-* k - 5 4. 0 Sk ' ' . q \:\ 1 �� ..4t -,4 .7,2.. .3re.,o _ f. (' boa 6 O) (14 :14:- , i At&IQS6 7teee-4 ,,GE I.L. a-41 "I"6%4--4-' d)4-6.1' /,,L?""- , 1 . _ /LIA-' - __e_a"-/"A-4,Le eA. t' "d . t k c ''' ' - '. q 1 , ( . ' 4J- . , 'k , A \ )-\N�y�)\\. � mLat r 0. ,q , ,, _ . ((• *. rn T, \-- p \ L ' , e s - ,- ‘ ‘ s ) r.. “ w ..r , ,\\,\. \• \\ - \I ) , 0\. , Q , - , &, ,,, -' ) , ' F k L q ''\\W'' \ 1 C\ • ' N • ' k‘LA --1 \"N - r 4 1 - k- ‘, , . - ,,- L 't * . Lr,t N_ ' ( N1 ,1 ‘ -- 't' 4. h,,, k . , q '. .s,, \ , ,,- ,,, , . . , - ,, ' 7 ( ('L L L C -U \1/4 KY . L ,.. . -''\, ', q ' ( 44, ') , IN ' '''' t,4t\ ' rt' IP ' ' . \ ,',/ Is ,,4-, ' 4 4 4 0 i ''c k k 4 \ '\ > 1 qi I No g ) �lr � it r .� , r 0 . . . . ED 'k ' ,. • . ! . . • .. . , !i , • . . ,' - Sp [1 . .. ' . . . 1 5 1976 ' -v- (4, ,?.> . • 0 1114 OR' ,,,,U„, L mmICIPAL BUILDING 200 MILA1/E.SO. RENTORL:A SCH17 1:0°0055°1P1C • 17-g:if.f,'.:f!.Z'''" 8 4 1/4.,V OA CHARLES J. DELAURENTI ) MAYOR ® • PLANNING DEPARTMENT '19,3 235-2550 p 1 4'0 SE PI'' , 41- ,-) 0 . • September 10 , 1976 • L . . 1 i'': j• . ) ji-ard-17-ete-i-S-on . • ( ,562 Bronson Way N. E . Renton , WA 98055 RE: APPLICATION FOR REZONE - #R-882-76 . • - • . , D,gar Mr. Peterson : ' . . ' • , • • , . ,. The Planning Commission at it September 9, 1g76 public .heating denied your application for ieone of the property locatedat. ; .. 1,1 ," ''''' • ' '• • 462 Monroe Avenue N . E . The Commission , after consideration of . the facts of the proposal , determined that the request was • ..Ctl ' :,,,: ..,, — compa_title with surroundifig land_uses , and that further subdiyi - Csfon of the 157-4-e-rty—Vibillt—V0-0-#1T-W41. ,t_OLadjace -it ,properti- _, and thell'unique charactervo-rthe ai'ea . ,, . .e :. - • • . , • 4. . - ....'., : You have the option of requesting to the City Council an-:apis-e-a",i—c, 1 . ,,: , • '- , .. of this ruling 'within ten ( 10) days from the date of the ruling . 4 Such an appeal must be in writing to the Planpin.g Depart iment: _ .. . . _ , . . —............. .ef. If you have further questions , please contact this Department, , . , . Very truly yours , , . . . . Gordon Y . Ericksen • . • . P1 ninolyrec-coy / Z r / ..._./..(..,,_----.r. -:".----- ---•-/-- . . . ( if.m / Michael L . Smith • . . Associate Planner . ', .• , ,, —.,. . . . . . ' i ' • , , . .. . . ' , • . . • . . . , �. .'j Renton Planning Commission Meeting September 8 , 1976 Page Seven Discussion among the Commissioners ensued , and the fol - lowing items were considered : impact on the home immedi - ately adjacent , proximity to an elementary school and park in the vicinity , and parking provisions . Mr . Holm advised that immediate adjacent owners to the south , north , and west had been contacted ; and no objections were indicated . IT WAS THEN ACTION: MOVED BY TEEGARDEN, SECONDED BY SCHOLES, THAT THE FRIENDS OF YOUTH APPLICATION BE CONTINUED FOR TWO WEEKS AND REFERRED TO THE SPECIAL STUDIES COMMITTEE FOR STUDY AND REPORT BACK AT THE SEPTEMBER 22, 1976, MEETING . Further discussion followed regarding possible impact on the single family residential area , the social issues involved , and the size of the staff . On the question , a roll call vote was requested with the following results : GIST -- AYE MOLA -- AYE SCHOLES -- AYE TEEGARDEN -- AYE WALKER -- NO WIK -- NO MOTION CARRIED. A five minute recess was declared at 11 : 25 pin . The meeting resumed at 11 : 30 p .m. with all members in attendance . REZONE : B. HAROLD P . PETERSON ; Appl . No , R-882-76 ; Rezone from GS-1 to SR-1 ; property located at 762 Monroe Ave . N . E . The item was presented for consideration . Associate Planner Smith pointed out the site location on the vicinity map , noted zoning and Comprehensive Plan desig- nations of the property and neighborhood , and described land use in the vicinity . The applicant proposes to subdivide the approximate 20 ,000 square foot site into ( two lots , a front and rear parcel , with the rear parcel to be in a pipestem configuration . An existing home is situated on the front parcel . Slides , maps and aerial photographs were viewed and described . Chairman Garrison called for comment from the applicant , but it was noted that he was not present . Questions of the staff followed concerning the Council ' s proposal regarding pipestem lots and the requested zoning and its requirements . The Chairman invited comments in favor of the proposal , but received none . He then called for comments in opposi - tion . Arthur Stern , 3513 N . E . iSeventh Street , Renton , inquired regarding the meaning of GS-1 zoning and asked whether the applicant would be able to meet requirements for the M .r' Renton Planning Commission Meeting September 8 , 1976 Page Eight location of his driveway to the proposed rear parcel . He was advised of the GS-1 definition by the Planning Director, who noted that the proposal for the driveway does meet require- ments . Mr . Stern indicated concern regarding the reduction of the lot sizes and objected to the planned location of the ; driveway to the back lot. , Michael Smith , 3402 N . E . Seventh Street , Renton , noted that he had been asked to represent his neighbors in speaking in opposition to the proposed rezone . He stated they are opposed for two reasons : this rezone would have a long-term detri - mental effect on the surrounding properties , and the sub- dividing of the property into a pipestem lot is not good planning and/or land use . , He described the area as very unique due to its country-like character and the only section in that neighborhood which has been developed in accordance with its zoning . Concern was expressed regarding a possible domino effect should the proposal be approved , resulting traffic on three sides , increased density in the area , and depreciation of property values . The provision for access was also questioned . A petition containing 15 names urging denial was presented . Questions of Smith by the Commissioners followed relative to lot sizes in the immediate vicinity , the quality of utilities in the area , and the number of people present in opposition . Ebb Munson , 809 Monroe , Renton , indicated his objection to the request for a waiver of off-site improvements . Discussion among the Commissioners ensued relative to the character of the neighborhood . Regret was expressed over the absence of the applicant. IT WAS THEN MOVED BY TEE- GARDEN , SECONDED BY SCHOLES , THAT THE PUBLIC HEARING BE CLOSED . MOTION CARRIED . ACTION: MOVED BY TEEGARDEN, SECONDED BY GIST, THAT THE HAROLD PETERSON APPLICATION FOR REZONE BE DENIED ON THE BASIS THAT IT WOULD BE DETRIMENTAL TO THE SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOOD . MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. It was requested that the staff notify the applicant of the Commission ' s action and his right of appeal to the City Council . 7 WAIVER OF OFF-SITE IMPROVEMENTS ; C, HAROLD P . PETERSON ; Appl . No . W-883-76 ; Application for 1laiver of Off-site Improvements for a Two' Lot Short Plat ; property located at 762 Monroe Ave . N . E . There was a brief discussion concerning the effect of the denial of the rezone request upon this application. IT WAS THEN ACTION: MOVED BY SCHOLES, SECONDED BY WALKER, THAT THE HAROLD PETERSON REQUEST FOR WAIVER OF OFF-SITE IMPROVEMENTS BE CONTINUED . It was noted that action on this item would be appropriate , if the rezone is .not appealed and that would not be known for approximately ten days . Shelton Fisher , 770 Monroe Ave . N . E . , requested that the residents be notified if an appeal is made . On the question , MOTION CARRIED. 017 RP • it THE CITY OF RENTON J ®© 7 MUNICIPAL BUILDING 200 MILL AVE. SO. RENTON, WASH. 98055 n milCHARLES J. DELAURENTI , MAYOR • DELORES A. MEAD CO CITY CLERK 04) 4Q 41-tO SEP1E� • September 21 , 1976 Mr. and Mrs. Harold Peterson 562 Bronson Way Renton, WA 98055 • • ' • Re: Public Hearing for Appeal of Denial of Rezone from GS-1 to SR-1 by the Planning Commission ' • Dear Mr. and Mrs. Peterson: The Renton City Council , at its regular meeting of September 20, 1976, set.0ctober 18; 1976 for a Public Hearing. on your appeal as set forth in your letter of September 14, 1976. Enclosed is a Notice of the Public Hearing which you are invited to attend. Very truly yours, CITY OF RENTON • 0(k041.4.) il)V,,e1,0(-- Delores A. Mead • City Clerk DAM:j t Enclosure • cc CITY OF RENTON NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING BY • RENTON CITY COUNCIL - NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Renton City Council has fixed the 18th day of October , 19 76 , at 8:00 p.m. in the Council Chambers of the Renton Municipal Building, Renton, Washington, as the time and place for a public hearing to consider the following: Appeal of Planning Commission Denial, of Rezone from GS-1 to SR-1 for property located at 762 Monroe Avenue N.E. • Any and all interested persons are invited to be present to voice approval , disapproval or opinions on same. CITY OF RENTON eallette Delores A. Mead, l City Clerk DATE OF PUBLICATION " September 24, 1976 INTER—OFFICE MEMO TO: I as Phpl i ps, Public Works Dept. DATE September 21 , 1976 FROM: Del Mead, City Clerk RE: NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING - Appeal of Planning Commission Denial of Rezone from GS-1 to SR-1 for property located at 762 Monroe Ave. N.E. Harold Peterson Property - October 18, 1976 Enclosed are 10 copies of the above-captioned Public Hearing Notices. Please post on and around property in that vicinity. Return the certification to this office. Thanks. CITY OF RENTON - NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING BY RENTON CITY COUNCIL NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Renton City Council has fixed the 18th day of October , 19 76 , at 8:00 p.m. in the Council Chambers of the Renton Municipal Building, Renton, Washington,, as the time and place for a public hearing to consider the following: • Appeal of Planning Commission Denial. of Rezone from GS-1 V to SR-1 for property located at 762 Monroe Avenue N.E. • Any and all interested persons are invited to be present to voice approval , , disapproval or opinions on same. CITY OF RENTON Delores .A.. Mead, City Clerk . DATE OF PUBLICATION September 24, 1976 ,