HomeMy WebLinkAboutLUA66-314 •
----
--------,-,, ,_,.. ---7,0----- --_____
._ .
-__
------------..:_
_--
_-
-
7 . . • _____2‘.7,. .„...i
. ,
,
, ,
,
i
":y Nay'13;;:1966
Mr'. Geor."e Butko"
10657.Rainier Avenue South
Seattle, Washington
Re' ' Appeal of Planning Commission
• decision regarding rezone
Dear Mr. Butkot
The Renton City Council, at Its regular meeting of, May 16, 1966 has , •
denied your request for continuation of hearing date and:;has concurred : : ' ,
in the Planning Commission denial of the rezone. ?,s.the City Attorneys •
has '.coni'irmed,the..rezone;cannot be allowed being• in conflict with:the
• , '
jy5 Comprehensive Plan°and''it.,was felt that'no new evidence could be.,
introduced in pursuance:of the present:.request'..for.R-3 which•'would alter
the, situation as it now exists:
attach herewith excerpt from the Minutes of the above-mentioned
meeting.
Yours very truly, •
CITY- OF RENTON:. ,
Helmie W Nelson.
City Cleric
HWN�din
" Enclosure '
ec: D. .Felker
Attorney at.Law u
• May .9,. 1966
Mrm''George Butko• •• ,
-.- „ ,. 10657 Rainier Avenue South,
Seattle, Washington , ' •
Dear Mr. ButIco:. :.
• The Renton:City Council, at ite regular meeting of May 2, ,1966 has
set the;date'' of May 16th for hearing 'on, your' appeal."'of planning .
' `••Commission, decision relative'to denial of rezone, "Lots. 11 to' 149 • - • ' ' '
:Block 7, Levy Code .074, Sec. 21437, Tax Lot'.1137, Earlington.,
�r Your.presence, is invited for discussion 'of the matter.,"
�� .. • Yours very truly,', •' '
' • CITY:OF RENTON. -
Helmie W. Nelson,
City, Clerk. .
•
- I WN/dm..
e66.,/ ,,zid
:� . ��,- '66-x-e--e-ti,, • :,.,.., . , ,-:. .
• c
APPLICATION FOR CHANGE OF ZONE,..IN.,THE CITY OF RENTON
FOR OFFICE USE ONLY
Application No, : e- 5iy/16. Sec . -Twp . -R.
Date of filing : •/- 7_ 6/n Area Map
Planning Coin. :Aciiionr j �) Kroll Page
Date : </ P7—(ok. Receipt No . -2 27
City Council ' s Action
Date : Ord. No . :
APPLICANT TO ANSWER ALL THE OLLOWING QUESTIONS NEATLY & ACCURATELY
Name of Applic nt Address 1ks 7
Telephone No . -ra.--3-' .3 /'ram
Property petitioned for rezoning is Sit �;ed n FYI Street ,
between �1 Street and ,F% Street .
Legal Descrip ion ' of Subject Property
Ld r // t: a / y — L3C6 ck 7 L EUNi de o 7 )- /
07/c/ 3 / / /FX L6t " 37
fa y l�l � �y 8 / ' y r -L 4.)
is l / � ° / / �/vFL-
•
•
_Existing Zoning 1 Zoning Requested i
What are the uses you propose to develop on this property?
Number of permanent off-street parking spaces that will be provided on this
4 property? ,/7 - � .,,,, Number Required
. Q NOTE TO APPLICANT: The following factors are con-
, ct“ sidered in reclassifying property . Evidence or addi-
tional information you desire to submit to substan-
tiate your request may be attached to thesesheets .
1. In wha way is this proposed ®change in zoni g in the public'2interest?
6P
2 . On what basis is there a real need in thisco. munityc- for more zoning of
the type you request?
3 . Do ybu:.consider::theepropertyl involved ih this• application to,__be more
suitable for the uses permitted in the proposed zone than for the uses per-
mitted in the present classification? Please explain. y
4 . What provision would you make to protect adjacent and surrounding prop-
ert*ef from the detrimental effects of any uses permitted in the proposed
zone? T
7.i:;
t u' I
. 1 ,
AFFIDAVIT
I /
being duly sworn , declare that I am the
owner of property involved in this application and that the foregoing
statements and answers herein contained and the information herewith sub-
mitted are in all respects true and correct to the best of my knowledge
and belief.
Subbed and sworn to me this
day of;- 196-4 .
Notary Public in and for the State
of Washington, res . ing at Renton.
(Name) (Name of owner)
7r/ �_
(Address)
(Mailin address)
°6 -5-7 2 S
(Ci ( State)
(Telephorloi
(OFFICE USE ONLY)
CERTIFICATION
This is to certify that the foregoing application has been inspected
by me and has been found to be thorough and complete in every particular
and to conform to the rules and regulations of the Planning Department
governing the filing of such application.
Date received ,196 By:
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION
RENTON, WASHINGTON
A PUBLIC HEARING WILL BE HELD BY THE RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION AT ITS REG-
ULAR MEETING IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS , CITY HALL, RENTON WASHINGTON, ON
April 27 , 19 66 AT 8 : 00 P.M. TO CONSIDER A PETITION FOR Rezone
From R-I to R-3
FOLLOWING DESCRIBED PROPERTY: Property located on the SE corner of
Earlington Street and 4th Ave. West.
The Northeasterly 81' of:
Lots 11 through 14 , Block 7 , Earlington Plat .
ANY AND ALL PERSONS INTERESTED OR OBJECTING TO SAID Rezone
ARE INVITED TO BE PRESENT AT THE PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING ON April 27 ,
19 66AT 8 : 00 P.M. TO VOICE THEIR PROTEST OR OBJECTION TO SAME .
PUBLISHED April 13 , 1966 JAMES DENZER ,SECRETARY
RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION
CERTIFICATIO N
I , JAMES MAGSTADT , Hereby certify that three ( 3) copies of the above
document were posted by me in three conspicuous places on the property de-
scribed above as prescribed by law.
Signe -
ATTEST :
Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting 5-16-66
PUBLIC HEARING: Appeal of Planning Commission Decision on rezone of George Butco property
The Clerk reported request by Mr. Douglas Felker,who has been retained by Mr. Butco,
that the Hearing be continued for sixty days to 7-18-66. Moved by Garrett, seconded
by Schellert, that the petition for continuation be denied. In ensuing discussion
it was pointed out that the zoning requested was not in agreement with the City's
Comprehensive Plan and that there were objectors who were prepared to submit protest
at the hearing and it was not felt that any new facts could be presented since the o ,s
at time of the Planning Commission d nial of the rezone. The pending motion carried.
The Hearing was declared open. There were no new communications and audience
comment for or against the proposal was invited. Mr. Ericksen advised that a petition
with 18 or 20 signatures had opposed the rezone and in view of request of property
owner for the extension all parties had been so advised which has probably accounted
for the absence of representatives. After further discussion regarding the fact that
the property could not be rezoned being in conflict with the Comprehensive Plan and
confirmation of same by the City Attorney, and discussion relative to the fee paid
by the applicant and action of the Planning Department in notification of imminent
denial, it was moved by Morris, seconded by Pedersen, that the hearing be closed.
Carried. Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Perry, to concur in the denial of the
rezone as per the previous Planning Commission ruling. Upon inquiry, it was pointed
out that the property is located on the S.E. corner of Earlington St.,at its inter-
section with 4th Avenue West near the Earlington Elementary School. The pending
motion carried.
PUBLIC HEARING: Emergency Ordinance appropriating $15,000.00 unto Airport Fund for
purchase of Parcel "A" made available through revision of the inner
harbor line.
This proposed Ordinance was introduced and placed on first reading on May 9th. Tha
Hearing was declared open, and the Clerk reported no new communications had been
received. Audience comment was invited and as none was forthcoming, it was moved
by Morris, seconded by Schellert, that the hearing be closed. Carried. Moved by
Delaurenti, seconded by Schellert, that the proposed Ordinance be referred to the
Ordinance Committee for recommendation. Carried.
COMMUNICATIONS:
Application was read from Edna Loss, owner of Spot Tavern, requesting license to
operate a Shuffleboard device at said place of business. Moved by Poli, seconded
by Perry, to refer the application to the Police and License Committee with power
to act. Carried.
A letter from City Engineer Jack Wilson reported regarding petition for vacation of
a portion of 10th Place North, between "J" and "K" Streets, that the petition was
signed by owners representing 63.15% of abutting property owners which percentage
failed to meet minimum two-thirds requirement according to R.C.W. 35.79. Applicants
will be notified by the City Clerk.
A letter from Building Director Johnson recommending granting of a Revocable Permit
to Standard Oil Company for a sign was read. The installation will be made at
Reid and Cooks at the corner of Burnett and 3rd Avenue and is in accordance with
allowances under provisions of City Ordinance. Moved by Morris, seconded by Poli,
to concur with the recommendation allowing use of right of way publicly owned as
provided by Ordinance. Carried.
A letter read from the Record-Chronicle advised that the Record-Chronicle Publishing
Company purchased the Renton Enterprise May 4, 1966 and the Record-Chronicle will
publish legals for the City for the remainder of this fiscal year at the same rate
as was charged by the Enterprise. Inquiry and discussion ensued as to legal status
of the City's publications and City Attorney Shellan advised that the City should
receive written confirmation that the Record-Chronicle has assumed the obligations
of the Enterprise and of the City's contract for legal publications in its purchase
thereof. The Clerk advised that the hew Valley_Times would' circulate generally in the
valley area. Also, the City has previously been advised that the Valley Publishing
Company was the new owner and would be publishing the City's legals. Moved by .
Pedersen, seconded by Schellert, that assuming the Enterprise has been purchased by-
the Record Chronicle and the 'Chronicle has assumed obligations of'thc £nterprig `,'
the City has no objections otherwise to publication-by the Chronicle. Mr: Miller stated
public notices will reach the public as befores subscription lists having been also
assumed. The pending motion carried,
-2-
itkitCA/
If)* -142
/ jig4''S '
Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting 5-16-66
PUBLIC HEARING: Appeal of Planning Commission Decision on rezone of George Butco property
The Clerk reported request by Mr. Douglas Felker,who has been retained by Mr. Butco,
that the Hearing be continued for sixty days to 7-18-66. Moved by Garrett, seconded
by Schellert, that the petition for continuation be denied. In ensuing discussion
it was pointed out that the zoning requested was not in agreement with the City's
Comprehensive Plan and that there were objectors who were prepared to submit protest
at the hearing and it was not felt that any new facts could be presented since the ones
at time of the Planning Commission denial of the rezone. The pending motion carried.
The Hearing was declared open. There were no new communications and audience
comment for or against the proposal was invited. Mr. Ericksen advised that a petition
with 18 or 20 signatures had opposed the rezone and in view of request of property
owner for the extension all parties had been so advised which has probably accounted
for the absence of'representatives. After further discussion regarding the fact that
' the property could not be rezoned being in conflict with the Comprehensive Plan and
confirmation of same by the City Attorney, and discussion relative to the fee paid
by the applicant and action of the Planning Department in notification of imminent
denial, it was moved by Morris, seconded by Pedersen, that the hearing be closed.
Carried. Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Perry, to concur in the denial of the
rezone as per the previous Planning Commission ruling. Upon inquiry, it was pointed
out that the property is located on the S.E. corner of Earlington St.,.at its inter-
section with 4th Avenue West near the Earlington Elementary School. The pending
emotion carried.
PUBLIC HEARING: Emergency Ordinance appropriating $15,000.00 unto Airport Fund for
purchase of Parcel "A" made available through revision of the inner
harbor line.
This proposed Ordinance was introduced and placed on first reading on May 9th. The
Hearing was declared open, and the Clerk reported no new communications had been
received. Audience oomment was invited and as none was forthcoming, it was moved
by Morris, seconded by Schellert, that the hearing be closed. Carried. Moved by
Delaurenti, seconded by Schellert, that the proposed Ordinance be referred to the
Ordinance Committee for recommendation. Carried.
COMMUNICATIONS:
Application was read from Edna Loss, owner of Spot Tavern, requesting license to
operate a Shuffleboard device at said place of business. Moved by Poli, seconded '
by Perry, to refer the application to the Police and License Committee with power
to act. Carried.
A letter from City Engineer Jack Wilson reported regarding petition for vacation of
a portion of 10th Place North, between "J" and "K" Streets, that the petition was
signed by owners representing 63.15% of abutting property owners which percentage
failed to meet minimum two-thirds requirement according to R.C.W. 35.79., Applicants
will be notified by the City Clerk.
A letter from Building Director Johnson recommending granting of a Revocable Permit
to Standard Oil Company for a sign was read. The installation will be made at
Reid and Cooks at the corner of Burnett and 3rd Avenue and is in accordance with
allowances under provisions of City Ordinance. Moved by Morris, seconded by Poli,
to concur with the recommendation allowing use of right of way publicly owned as
provided by Ordinance. Carried.
A letter read from the Record-Chronicle advised that the Record-Chronicle Publishing
Company purchased the Renton Enterprise May 4, 1966 and the Record-Chronicle will
publish legals for the City for the remainder of this fiscal year at the same rate
as was charged by the Enterprise. Inquiry and discussion ensued as to legal status
of the City's publications and City Attorney Shellan advised that the City should
receive written confirmation that the Record-Chronicle has assumed the obligations
of the Enterprise and of the City's contract for legal publications in its purchase
thereof. The Clerk advised°that the hew Valley 'Times would' ci;rculate generally in the
valley area. Also, the City has previously been advised that the Valley Publishing
Company was the new owner and would be publishing the City's legals. Moved by .
Pedersen, seconded by Schellert, that assuming the Enterprise has been purchased by-
the Record Chronicle and the .Chronicle has assumed obligations of thc: Enterprft'e
the City has no objections otherwise to publication-by the Chronicle. Mr.: Miller stated
public notices will reach the public as beforef subscription lists having been also
assumed. The pending motion carried.
-2-
/
Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting May xJ 1966
COMMUNICATIONS:
Petition - Hospital property zoning - Continued
Mr. Archie Graham, 408 I Street, on behalf of the Petitioners,stated they did not
want their neighborhood to be turned into a commercial area, they prefer the quiet
and lack of vehicular traffic and monetary loss to the hospital is not a factor of
consideration when the cost figure of a million dollars is involved. It was felt
a residential development such as Monterey would enhance the area but not high rise
apartments as R-4 would permit. Vote was taken on the pending motion and the Chair
ruled the motion passed. Roll call was requested by two Council Members and vote was
taken as follows: Aye: Hulse, Bruce, Trimm, Perry, Delaurenti and Morris. No votes:
Schellert, Dahlquist, Gianini, Garrett and Poli. The motion to deny the Planning
Commission recommendation carried.
Recess was declared at this time. After the recess, roll call was taken with all
Council Members present as previously listed.
A__
A letter was read from Mr. George Butco requesting consideration by the Council of
rezone of his property from R-1 to R-3, appealing decision of Planning Commission
denial. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Poli, that May 16, 1966 be set as date
for hearing on the appeal. Carried.
A letter read from J. D. Bixby, Director of Facilities, The Boeing Company, called
attention to application of several months ago to purchase a strip of land along the
East bank of the Cedar River, upon which an appraisal has now been secured by the
City. Due to critical parking needs it was requested the matter be given early
attention. Moved by Perry, seconded by Bruce, to refer the letter to the Property
Committee. It was pointed out that in Committee of the Whole meeting it was urged
that the property be leased and not sold. The motion to refer carried.
A letter from Sven Johnson recommended granting of Revocable Permit to Rick Trujillo,
Flowers & Interiors, for a sign extending over the public walk, projecting from the
corner of the building at Second Avenue and Burnett Street, 60% of the structures in
the block being non-conforming. Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Perry, to concur in
the recommendation. Carried.
A letter from Acting Building Director Sven Johnson recommended that Revocable Permits
be granted to Richfield Oil Company for sign replacement at 1520 Bronson Way and at
101 Rainier Avenue, the latter to be moved northerly 11 feet and raised to 30 ft. base
clearance. Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Poli, to concur in the recommendation
with proper Hold Harmless and Insurance requirements to be observed. Discussion en-
sued regarding rental fees for use of the public property and City Attorney Shellan
recalled past experiences of unsuccessful attempts at trying to impose such rental
fees on equitable basis and subsequent passage of regulating Ordinance covering signs
projecting over and upon the public properties which provides for Revocable Permit
with 30 day termination notice . The pending motion carried. Moved by.Delaurenti and
seconded by Hulse, the Hold Harmless and Insurance be required on the Flower Shop sign
also. Carried. Attorney Shellan statelthat each case should be given consideration
on its own merit, with School or non-profit organizations warranting such discretion
as the Council may deem proper. Moved by Dahlquist,,.,seconded by Poll, to require by
policy a hold harmless agreement to be executed and insurance on all Revocable Permits
for commercial signs. Carried.
A letter from Sven Johnson, Building Department, requested fund transfer to purchase
secretarial equipment required due to division of the Building and Engineering Departments
as follows: From Current Fund: Building Maintenance, Dept. 1800, Acct. 417, Materials and
Supplies, $723.04, unto: Building Maintenance Dept. 1800, Acct. 606, Capital Outlay,
Machinery & Equipment. Moved by Perry, seconded by Bruce, to concur and refer to the
Law and Ordinance Committee for proper Resolution. Carried.
A letter from James W. Ashley, President, Highlands Merchants Association, requested
installation of adequate mercury vapor lights on Sunset Boulevard East between 10th
and 12th Avenues and especially at the intersection of Sunset and 12th Avenue in the
vicinity of Jack's new Drive-In. Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Hulse, to refer the
request to the Light and Power Committee to report back. Carried.
A letter from 0. C. Scott, President of the Greater Renton Chamber of Commerce, advised
that the Chamber at this time could not support Initiative 226 financially and the City's
invitation to contribute to such support must be declined. Mayor Custer advised he had
extended written invitation to the Chamber to participate.
-3-
I i/ L) ,_( 7t/u---a„„J-- '' ,_--4 ' E&--c--,,,,i-J_ 1,,e_ej
___-(---c}----- ----2,--z----1_07 (1___-e,- ---c-/- (-,":7------ ----2--)--\-e„ 7' ,_,-.-L__4
jl`-c J
, p., e_--,_,,,— . /2„.„..L.7
& ,
71.-E-y(,,,=‘,. ,__el' , / \___f ,&--( --(_.--c}----0----2--i
G w /
U
lj CL----r-A--------, ___6,,c",_,
A_-e----(_ ' (,-% . )
C ‘ "j1----A/1-"J.2,./ 7-6i-C-.--)
r 5 ' a .i),__,,,_,_, Ak____-,/_.7 ,,--) i ,
,,_,- .),„„_-,,, _...0____,„ , c_-___,,-
Ye
—__c,C Gv c---C t—a— -2 / C CGS 2 ,Kc` e_,` GL,.,
,46,
) ,,e.,___,,_, /7;
,,,, , 1 .zi_c____,__c(___e_p ?,(1 Ilk_
� // -, rev-c-----c
___J) ' 1 Ly .,,,4,)---c---r,e , 61----"L'-`-" P Q
' i * 04
, . ____,,___e_d (:,L----e_- .___7-.2,7_ k?"--- zy/ -, --4-e
vy-7./<'/`��-yam.,2��"J-� ���� . � �il�_Cj_'/�j✓�� ., �L/�`-"Ci`—�'
•
• e3-', 'r-r2 .
___,:,„.,_,72, d_y___7- '_ . -----r-:----0-----7--1-4 . -
d__:_) e_._),77
d--c_r7) -- , _
„7,... ,„_,...,..7„:„,i2zw,-. , (,9/: _ . _ , ., . .
. . , ,.. no.m:__,1 , /_i__tr:/„.4 7 . ' , ,i7 - .
, .
, ,
1 . .
• .
. ,
-)r-)7 . ii.
___ . - , I.i-r-7er ni '.:--,n7T2.-e.)---2-2 . ie._ 7- ,
_i,v "7, __,„,,,, . . zi A, : , ,--,-- -,_.-?_,. .2 ,,) . 3- , \,t4 . ,
-. -y. r E(
?22) -) i.p.
7 _
• fr --)fil ----,.( 2.) 7-r1 ,y,
Z (,,_e:1- -...,
,2 .., /
-- r- --....-
--) )
'
,, i•
/.?
,..).Z.:f2 bl-:7,2 2- 75-, ,,yr.c,,:c• , If,2r)1 2 2/7/.; .1/Z 2 t 1'777-
:2.7
,7?7 -1(,)//e —
:2 c c a i ,‘44.,(,..--).,
--0,- ,,..._t.....'' , /
‘-'"7-1•77,,,A.:;---1-e-• -2,2„,__ ,,,
;, _,7, y . , A. .1
6 •-. 0 C S / -'t../d/ td. ' ''
',
I '--7--
/"•" / — )1
i 7 --:.—.)/ ' qk — ‘0'•41
/ - ;),—,/.--, ..? .. ...t _7 2, .; 27----.,,. .--:_--- ---;;--v-,z) ---N
- it' „ • - 1 ' i.C ' ,
- i ft( 1, -''')---?,/ T-7 - •,( ' /i .---7 • ---), -3 9,, --c), •,), ,)--1,r, ' •rill/(: 0 1,. •
1 ) 1-19-5-,--- t's 1---74----4-KG-(2).•
71-7' -) 1 ?? ', 1) il t.,iv • r,-x
' ().', 1." --) .-Fr -- ,
l'• 7,; (-).-- p7?269 X..-
.....V.21,0" ii)tia..)v- f, ^ 141->1/_---6,75 (2 47 17
/ :I / ./
._ '7 /
r) ri
-------,.,_, -- --_-t. ,fly ------,y,-- - 77-7--,7„....? ,, c.,. -.=---?r,-,1.-,---,-,-27 _
—IT. --
____.,.... i .•-• •
ft..e.-7? --rervZ%:77
7 4'.2//7./4- ;r4g.- .ae---/ e-- ----.":_ l‘_,7/7.1 -- ,,. --,•• ,/i .,,,, ,,, vi)., ...,
LA- C./..•
- 0 2717 V - ), 2---,. -.•
J11 / -ju.0
. ..!' --.77?0} 7_2 ill —9. '2,__J
,--,47. .11 Qe 1
L -Th--)likr-nk.-170,
--t-'7271, )7 -5 62-3------ -,,-/- ,
c
' A4,,...a
- — - 6' (h , ,V,/
a l.' ,
-...
ri
. . . .
. . , . ..
. . . , .
. .
_ .. . .
. ,..
. .
_r yl-•,t 4-0
. . ‘
A • • ,
•
.
1 : -7,e2../ '. 7:94'14' "' .
..
,17 ti i . . . ; I -' -4�C...a', ./ �u-�Y`�' Wes' ' j/ ' e ',[:T'✓(�
J 1�C' , ( /lr J/ Efl}CrL�d.i . eidi.iT/1A/:
.. (.(,- 'ea- /mil/
r r�'1 J.
��'-Lt -, JI,• / �rJ(,A%iE'LCG'Il '' j dC�iG�{L L �/ " �Z •rsv( J GLi + . i • '
4 `/-' RP- w&s /
/4o '
vJ
OT P/ -- A,. / r o "
R'i re, Ut//7- N