Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutReport 1PARTIES OF RECORD BARBEE MILL WATERCRAFT LIFTS Alan Foltz Waterfront Construction, Inc. 205 NE Northlake Way ste: #230 Seattle, WA 98105 (contact) Updated: 08/06/10 LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC Robert Cugini Barbee Mill Company 3905 Lake Washington Blvd N Renton, WA 98056 tel: ( 425) 226-3900 (owner/ applicant) (Page 1 of 1) City of Renton 1-'lanning Division t ' JIJr. 2 8 IOJU PROJECT DESIGNED BY Waterfront C0115U1Jc~ian Inc. /p, i:-c:: Ir' ie'::DW/ TIIIS DOCUM['IT ,s PROPfttETARY "ROPERTY OF WATERFRONT U l_S ~ I.£ CONSIRUCIION INC, AND IS NOT TO Ht: USFD, IN WHOLf OR IN ~ PART, FOR ANY OTHER PROJECT Wl..,-HOUT THE l'IRIPU; AUTHORIZAT•ON CF WATERFRONT CONSTRUCTION INC. LAKE WASHINGTON JOB SITE tJ !~th Sr Kennyd.alie ,, N '.QridSt N 31 ,,t Gt N--1.?nd Pl N '61h •;1 VICINITY MAP/NO SCALE LEGAL DESCRIPTION 1/4 SEC; NW-32-24-5 TAXLOT #: ."'i.)4270 0011 LAT; 47.526985 (47' 31' 37.15" N) LONG: -122.205604 (122' 17.' ?0.17" W) HILLl/1ANS LK WN GARDEN OF EDEN #2 "LOT O" RENTON LOT LINE ADJUSIMENl NO LUA-96-15jLLA-LND-.30-0152 REC NO 20061002900012 SD LOT LINE AOJUSTMENT OAF LOTS 1 THRU 13 :N Rl OCK A OF HILLMANS LME WASHINGTON GARDEN OF EDEN DIV NO 2 PLAT TGW SH LOS ADS AND TGW THE NWLY 25.00 FT OF BNSF RCW LY BTWN TWO LNS DRAWN PLW & DIST 25.00 AND 50.00 FT NWLY AS MEAS AT R/A FR MAIN TRACK C/L BOUNDED ON THE \IORTH BY TH.:: C:LY C:XTN OF THE NORTH LN OF LOT 1 AND SOUNDED ON THE SOUTH BY THE ELY EXTN OF THE SOUTH LN 0' ,_QT U OF SD HI! I MANS LAKE WASHINGTON GARDEN OF EDEN DIV 2 PURPOSE: PROVl0E OUT OF WAFR BOAT MOORAGE icD~A~T~U-M-, c_o_c_o_.o~· EST 1919 PROJECT NAME: BARBEE MILL CO. INC. ADJACENT OWNERS: CD BARBEE FOREST PRODUCTS INC .390! LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA. 98056 (ti BOYDSTON fONY 3901 LAKE WASHINGTON 3LVD N RENTON, WA. 98056 REFERENCE #: . -··-·- SITE LOCATION ADDRESS: 3905 LAKE WAS1-,INGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA. 98056 DWG#: 10-37022-A.1-1 LAKE rnREs-:- PARK LLJ _J s w VJ KlNMORE JUANITA ,<IRKLJ\ND MEDINA BELLEVUE JOB SITE RENTON AREA MAP/Scale:1 "=3miles .3 MILES 0 3 \AILES 1 MILE PROPOSED: INSrALL (2) NEW BOATLIFTS, (1) JETSKI LIFT ANO ( 1) PLATFQR)II LIFT JOINT USE PIER JN: LAKE WASHINGTON NEAR: RENTON COUNTY: KING STATE: WA APPL BY: BARBEE MILL CO. INC. c/ o ROBERT CUGINI SHEET: 1 OF: 3 ;oATE: 6-29-10 t I Note: Boatlift frames are 10' x 14' overall with four (4) -1' sq. foot pads. Platform Lift uses boatlift frame, with a 10' x 20' fully grated platform. Dock mounted Jetski Lift Framing is 4' x 6' overall. I I I I I I CD BARBEE FOREST PRODUCTS INC 3907 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA, 980515 ---7 / I I I /.+------------S 88"49'09n E -------- !1 g/ @; J, & I fl . I ~I 2"! (2) I 34' 1 JOB SITE 3905 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA. 98056 PROPOSED JETSKI LIFT OHWL 21.80' @ FACE OF BULKHEAD EXISTING ROCK BULKHEAD " I _!:; I !J,/ /::; "'! I-------118'-6" ,t% J'I EXISTING DOLPHINS /..!:...f:,). -· --~p-;;, I N 9~·49'35" W t44.69' ly_ -- EXISTING BOATUFT EXISTING PIER EXIST!NG DECK ROPOSEO MmGATION: 3901 (3) 12" CREOSOTE WOOD MOORING PILES PER (DOLPHIN) TO BE REPLACED wrrH (1) 12" STEEL PILE PLOT PLAN 40· 30· 20· 1 o· o· SCALE: 1"=40' ® 80YOSTON TONY LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA; 98056 40' I. ,, REF'E~CE g: / / I ,i / lfifij I~ [fij = ~ / I APPLICANT: BARBEE IilLL CO. INC. c/o ROBERT CUGINI 'PROPOSEO: INSTALL (2) NEW BOATUFTS, (1) JETSKI LIFT AND i.!_2 PLATFORM LIFT, NEAR/AT: RENTON SHEET: 2 OF: J QATE:_6-29-10 _ IDWG#: 10-37022-A.2-J n ~~ lJ ~ i7i s~~o t-.J§ :00 z ~ ~:.~fil' ~~y,vi~ ~~~i3-i] m o"""i o ~:ou'i;r~ .S;; rj1:lzm& C1 ~~9~0g §?~b,;~ & ---I ID;,;,~ Z 0 !r1~c 8 g5i;:;~\l ::)c~~s:'.':" ~ ~----1.00~ ci,:i!z.,,-o"' :::s z ::ej ~:\ -3!o~ ~;;!~~ Zoo ~~ z -c 0 ill -· ::, '<~ :J 3· 0 CQ -,., o::O s· en er, ::i c· r+ :J 0 -... * I Note: Boatlift frames are 10' x 14' overall with four (4) -l' sq. foot pads. Platform Lift uses boatlift frame, with a 10' x 20' fully grated platform. Dock mounted Jetski Lift Framing .is 4' x 6' overall. l_ 7'-1~" 1 (2) PROPOSED FREE STANDING BOATLIFTS 14'-2" ~ 7'-2" 35'± T-------, I PROPOSED JETSKI LIFT PROPOSED PLATFORM LIFT EXISTING PLANTING PLAN OHWL 21 .so· @ FACE OF BULKHEAD EXISTING ROCK BULKHEAD f-------+-------87'-6" ------>--------------- OHWL 21 .80' EXISTING FULLY GRATED PROPOSED MmGAllON: (3) 12" CREOSOTE WOOD MOORING PILES PER p ~ REPLACED WITH (1) 12~STEEL PILE (DOLPHIN) -~ L -------------N 88"49'35" W 344.69' EXISTING PILING PROPOSED MITIGATION; (3) 12" CREOSOTE WOOD MOORING PILES PER (DOLPHIN) TO BE REPLACED WITH (1) 12" STEEL PILE DETAIL VIEW LAKE BOTIOM EXISTING FULLY GRATED PIER _[ 2'-7" (2) PROPOSED FREE STANDING BOATLIFTS SCALE, 1 "~20· PROPOSED JETSKI LIFT ELEVATION VIEW EXISTING PILING 20· 15· 10· 5' o· SCALE: 1 "=20' 20' EXISTING RAMP REFERENCE u, / EXISTING ROCK BULKHEAD / \ !/ ·i !, fi EXISTINO SPAWNllffi=l GRAVE~ ~ !APPLICANT: BARBEE MILL CO. INC. c/0 ROB~UGINI PROPOSmlNSTALL (2) NEW SOATLIFfS, (1) JETSKI LIFT AND _l!.2_ PLATFORM LIFT. NEAR/AT; RENTON SHEET: 3 OF: 3 DATI;_ 6-29-10 QWC#:10-~~022-A.3-1 " I 11 '~~G ~}~gg 'OC 111 ~;;!t o9:ti;:i;l, "D .,-,~O~-, ~ VJ :0 ,"'1 -N-~a C ;gz~ C?i eS~na n---< c::i 8 soc)~ 0 ::!:~~2 ~L ~ -i:;r D 5r:::';\G m s~=<~ :<; a a'< "-~:;:R :c::=.· 0~ M;; " QC NS z {) ;1; ~: 2 '< 3 0 (C -f'l CJ ::0 <· (1) (ii. :::i a. r-f- :o 0 :::i -:c • Cl) .~ • • Barbee Mill Company, Inc. c/o Robert Cugini Parcel: 334270 0011 NW 32 24N 05E City of Rent Fr on ~,anninn o,·v· . " 1s1on ,JUL .:! 8 ZU10 STATE OF WASHINGTON DEPARTMENT OF ECOLOGY Northwest Regional Office• 3190 160th Avenue SE• Bellevue, Washington 98008-5452 • (425) 649-7000 November 18, 2010 Robert Cugini 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N. Renton, WA 98056 Re: City of Renton Local Permit LU Al 0-050, ECF, SM, SMC Robert Cugini -Applicant Conditioned Shoreline Conditional Use Permit 117 Dear Robert Cugini: City p Ofr. Yc1nr( 'Tel){, · tng D· . On tv1310 N, . 17 01/ 22 2010 ffrl /f;'rt; /l;'ff (Jfi ~/tJ) On October 29, 2010 the Department of Ecology (Ecology) received the Renton decision on your Shoreline Conditional Use Permit for two] 0-foot by 14-foot freestanding boatlifts, one 10-foot by 20-foot freestanding boatlift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift on an existing joint use dock serving three lots along the Lake Washington shoreline. Each of the freestanding watercraft lifts would rest directly on the lake bottom on four 12-inch by 12-inch footpads. In addition to installing the new lifts, the applicant will remove six, 12-inch diameter creosote-treated piles and replace them with two steel piles. By law, Ecology must review Conditional Use Permits for compliance with: • The Shoreline Management Act (Chapter 90.58 RCW) • Ecology's Conditional Use Permit approval criteria (Chapter 173-27-160 WAC) • The Renton Local Shoreline Master Program After reviewing Conditional Use Permits for compliance, Ecology must decide whether to approve, approve with conditions, or disapprove a Conditional Use Permit. After reviewing Conditional Use Permits for compliance, Ecology must decide whether to approve, approve with conditions, or disapprove them. Our Decision: Ecology approves your Conditional Use Permit provided your project complies with the conditions required by Renton and the following Ecology conditions: • The applicant hereby authorizes Ecology staff and their designees to have access to the subject property for the purposes of compliance inspection and monitoring. Such right of access shall begin from the date of the receipt of this letter, during construction, and extend for a period of five years following project completion. Ecology staff must provide reasonable verbal notice to the applicant or their designee prior to coming onto the site. --G-• 0 Robert Cugini November 18, 2010 Page 2 of2 Please note, however, that other federal, state, and local permits may be required in addition to this shoreline permit. What Happens Next? Before you begin activities authorized by this permit, the law requires you to wait at least 21 days from the "date of receipt" -the date you receive this letter or the date the City of Renton receives their copy of this letter. Date ofreceipt is defined in RCW 43.21B.001 as follows: (1) "Business days" means Monday through Friday exclusive of any state or federal holiday. (2) "Date ofreceipt" means: (a) Five business days after the date of mailing; or (b) The date of actual receipt, when the actual receipt date can be proven by a preponderance of the evidence. The recipient's sworn affidavit or declaration indicating the date of receipt, which is unchallenged by the agency, shall constitute sufficient evidence of actual receipt. The date of actual receipt, however, may not exceed forty-five days from the date of mailing. This waiting period allows anyone (including you) who disagrees with any aspect of this permit, to appeal the decision to the state Shorelines Hearings Board. You must wait for the conclusion of an appeal before you can begin the activities authorized by this permit. The Shorelines Hearings Board will notify you by letter if they receive an appeal. We recommend you contact the Shorelines Hearings Board before you begin permit activities to ensure no appeal has been received. They can be reached at (360) 459-6327 or http://www.eho.wa.gov. If you want to appeal this decision, you can find appeal instructions (Chapter 461-08 WAC) at the Shorelines Hearings Board website above. They are also posted on the website of the Washington State Legislature at: http://apps.leg.wa.gov/wac. If you have any questions, please contact Barbara Nightingale at (425) 649-4309. Sincerely, /c+-~ Geoff Tallent, Section Manager Shorelands and Environmental Assistance Program GT:cja By certified mail: 7009 2820 0001 7154 3399 cc: Gerald Wasser, Associate Planner, City of Renton Alan Foltz, Waterfront Construction Inc. Denis Law Mayor r ;.J ·'-.J._, October 27, 2010 Department of Community and Economic Development Alex Pietsch, Administrator State Department of Ecology Northwest Regional Office 3190 160th Ave. SE Bellevue, WA 98008-5452 SUBJECT: Shoreline Management Substantial Development Permit for Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts File No. LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC Dear Sir or Madam: Enclosed is the Shoreline Substantial Development Permit for the above referenced project. The permit was issued by the City of Renton on October 26, 2010. A Determination of Non-Significance-Mitigated was issued by the City's Environmental Review Committee on August 30, 2010. The appeal period ended September 17, 2010, no appeals of the threshold determination were filed. We are filing this action with the Department of Ecology and the Attorney General per WAC 173-14-090. Please review this permit and attachments and contact me at (425) 430-7382 if you have any questions or need additional information. Associate Planner Enclosures: Shore.line Substantial Development Permit Notice of Application SEPA Checklist SEPA Determination DNS-M Mitigation Measures DNS-M Advisory Notes cc: Office of Attorney General Karen Walter, Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Jennifer Henning, Current Planning Manager Barbee Mill Company/Owner Robert Cugini/ Applicant Alan Foltz/Contact Plot Plan Hearing Examiner Decision Legal Description Copy of Master Application Project Narrative Neighborhood Detail Map Renton City Hall • 1055 South Grady Way • Renton, Washington 98057 • rentonwa.gov DEPARTMENT OF COMI JITY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOrMENT ___ _.. .... ...--.... f Citv of. ~=:11 t tJs1 PLANNING DIVISION SHORELINE MANAGEMENT ACT OF 1971 PERMIT FOR SHORELINE MANAGEMENT EVALUATION FORM & DECISION DATE OF PERMIT ISSUANCE: LAND USE ACTION FILE NO.: DATE RECEIVED DATE OF PUBLIC NOTICE: TYPE OF ACTION(S); October 26, 2010 LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC July 28, 2010 August 6, 2010 Conditional Use Permit Variance Permit .-~CONC""""'""""'U-,:Rc;:RE_C_E_ DATE Pursuant to Chapter 90.58 RCW, staff recommends that the City of Renton grant a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit and a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit. This action is proposed on the following application: PROJECT NAME: PROJECT MANAGER: OWNER/APPLICANT: CONTACT: PROJECT LOCATION: LEGAL DESCRIPTION: SEC-TWN-R: WITHIN THE SHORELINES OF: APPLICABLE MASTER PROGRAM; Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts Gerald Wasser, Associate Planner Robert Cugini, Barbee Mill Company, 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N., Renton, WA 98056 Alan Foltz, Waterfront Construction, Inc., 205 Northlake Way, Suite 230, Seattle, WA 98105 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N. See Attachment A NW 1/4 of SEC 22 -TWN 24N -R SE Lake Washington City of Renton PROPOSAL DESCRIPTION: The applicant requests approval of a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit and a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit for the installatio_~ two 10-foot by 14-foot freestanding boatlifts, one 10-foot by 20-foot freestanding boatlift ~ with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock which serves three lots in the Residential -8 dwelling units per acre (R-8) zone. Each of the freestanding watercraft lifts would rest directly on the lake bottom on four 12-inch DEPARTMENT OF COM UTY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT PLANNING DIVISION SHORELINE MANAGEMENT ACT OF 1971 PERMIT FOR SHORELINE MANAGEMENT EVALUATION FORM & DECISION DATE OF PERMIT ISSUANCE: LAND USE ACTION FILE NO.: DATE RECEIVED DATE OF PUBLIC NOTICE: TYPE OF ACTION(S): October 26, 2010 LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC July 28, 2010 August 6, 2010 Substantial Development Permit Conditional Use Permit Variance Permit Pursuant to Chapter 90.58 RCW, staff recommends that the City of Renton grant a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit and a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit. This action is proposed on the following application: PROJECT NAME: PROJECT MANAGER: OWNER/ APPLICANT: CONTACT: PROJECT LOCATION: LEGAL DESCRIPTION: SEC-TWN-R: WITHIN THE SHORELINES OF: APPLICABLE MASTER PROGRAM: PROPOSAL DESCRIPTION: Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts Gerald Wasser, Associate Planner Robert Cugini, Barbee Mill Company, 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N., Renton, WA 98056 Alan Foltz, Waterfront Construction, Inc., 205 Northlake Way, Suite 230, Seattle, WA 98105 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N. See Attachment A NW 1/4 of SEC 22 -TWN 24N -R SE Lake Washington City of Renton The applicant requests approval of a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit and a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit for the installation of two 10-foot by 14-foot freestanding boatlifts, one 10-foot by 20-foot freestanding boatlift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock which serves three lots in the Residential -8 dwelling units per acre (R-8) zone. Each of the freestanding watercraft lifts would rest directly on the lake bottom on four 12-inch City of Renton Department of Comm1 , Economic Development Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts DATE OF PERMIT: October 26, 2010 Shoreline Management Permit WAl0-050 ECF, SM, SMC Page 2 of 3 by 12-inch footpads. The existing fully-grated dock is 4-feet, 4 1/2-inches to 7-feet, 10 3/4- inches in width and 118-feet, 6-inches in length with two 27-foot fully-grated finger docks. The proposed project also encompasses the removal of six 12-inch diameter creosote-treated wood piles and replacing them with two vibratory pile-driven 12-inch diameter steel piles. All work would take place within the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife fish window for this section of Lake Washington, July 16 through December 31. The following section/page of the Master Program is applicable to the development: RMCSection Description Page 4-3-090] Urban Environment 3-25 4-3-090K General Use Regulations for All Shoreline Uses 3-26 4-3-090L Specific Use Regulations 3-27 4-3-090M Variances and Conditional Use permits 3-39 4-9-1901.1, 2, 3, 5 Variances and Conditional Uses 9-54 Development of this project shall be undertaken pursuant to the following terms and conditions: 1. The applicant shall comply with the mitigation measures imposed by the Environmental Review Committee in its Determination of Non-Significance -Mitigated issued on August 30, 2010; 2. The applicant shall prepare a restrictive covenant with the appropriate signatures of the property owners and recorded with King County. The document shall specify ownership rights and maintenance provisions for the watercraft lifts. The restrictive covenant shall contain a statement that the covenant shall remain with the property and can only be released by written permission granted by the City of Renton. A copy of the restrictive covenant shall be provided to the Planning Division project manager for review and approval prior to recording with King County. Building permits for the watercraft lifts may be issued only subsequent to recording the restrictive covenant; and 3. The applicant shall comply with all construction conditions of State agencies and all construction conditions provided in the application submitted to the City. This Permit is granted pursuant to the Shoreline Management Action of 1971 and pursuant to the following: 1. The issuance of a license under the Shoreline Management Act of 1971 shall not release the applicant from compliance with federal, state, and other permit requirements. 2. This permit may be rescinded pursuant to Section 14(7) of the Shoreline Management Act of 1971 in the event the permittee fails to comply with any condition(s) hereof. City of Renton Department of Comm ~ Economic Development Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts DATE OF PERMIT: October 26, 2010 Shoreline Management Permit WAl0-050 ECF, SM, SMC Page 3 of 3 3. Construction permits shall not be issued until twenty-one (21) days after approval by the Washington State Department of Ecology or until any review proceedings initiated within this twenty-one (21) day review period have been completed. I Date "' C. E. "Chip" Vincent, Planning Director Planning Division APPEALS: Appeals of Shoreline Substantial Development Permit issuance must be made directly to the Shorelines Hearings Board. Appeals are made by filing a request in writing within the twenty-one (21) days of receipt of the final order and concurrently filing copies of such request with the Washington State Department of Ecology and the Attorney General's office as provided in section 18(1) of the Shorelines Management Act of 1971. All copies of appeal notices shall also be filed with the City of Renton Planning Division and the City Clerk's office. EXPIRATION: Unless a different time period is specified in the shoreline permit as authorized by RCW 90.58.143 and subsection J1 of RMC 4-9-190, construction activities, or a use or activity, for which a permit has been granted pursuant to this Master Program must be commenced within two (2) years of the effective date of a shoreline permit, or the shoreline permit shall terminate, and a new permit shall be necessary. However, the Planning Division may authorize a single extension for a period not to exceed one year based on reasonable factors, if a request for extension has been filed with the Planning Division before the expiration date, and notice of the proposed extension is given to parties of record and the Washington State Department of Ecology. DEFINITION OF COMMENCEMENT OF CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES: the construction applications must be submitted, permits must be issued, and foundation inspections must be completed before the end of the two (2) year period. Attachments: A. Legal Description B. Plot Plan cc: Attorney General's Office Karen Walter, Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Dept. Robert Cugini/ Owner(s)/Applicant Alan Foltz/ Contact City of Renton Official File Legal description HJLLMANSLKWN GARDEN OF EDEN #2"LOT D" RENTON LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT NO LUA-96- 153LLA-LND-30-0152 REC NO 20061002900012 SD LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT DAF LOTS 1 THRU 13 IN BLOCK A OF HILL.MANS LAKE WASHINGTON GARDEN OF EDEN DIV NO 2 PLATTGW SH LDSADS AND TGW THE NWL Y 25.00 FT OF 8NSF ROW LY BTWN TWO LNS DRAWN PLW & DIST 25.00 AND 50.00 FTNWLY AS MEAS AT RIA FR MAIN TRACK C/L BOUNDED ON THE NORTH BY THE ELY EXTN OF THE NORTH LN OF LOT 1 AND BOUNDED ON THE SOUTH BY THE ELY EXTN OF THE SOUTH LN OF LOT 13 DF SD HILLMANS LAKE WASHINGTON GARDEN OF EDEN DIV 2 t I Note: Boatlift frames are 10' x 14' overall with four (4) -I' sq. foot pads. Platform Lift uses boatlift frame, with a 10' x 20' fully grated platform. Dock mounted Jetski Lift Framing is 4' x 6' overall. p [ G) BARBEE FOREST PRODUCTS INC .3907 LA.KE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA, 96056 ---7 I I / µ:__----------S 88'49'09" E -------- JOB SITE 51 ff I JI (2) 3905 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA. 98056 1/ -I ;;, I "'I , I /? .~I I 34' 1 EXISTING PROPOSED JETSKI LIFT OHWL 21.80' @ FACE OF BULKHEAD "I ~1 JU',). _ ..... --,@-;;_ \ N 8~49'35" W ~4'.i:69' )!l EXISTING DECK t 1111rfiti::it11111111liilli!iilii,{ EXISTING PIER ROPOSED MmGATION: 3901 (3) 12" CREOSOTE WOOD MOORING PILES PER (DOLPHIN) TO BE REPLACED wrrH (1) 12" STEEL PILE PLOT PLAN 10· 30· zo· 10· o· SCALE: 1"=401 @ BOYDSTON TONY LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA. 98056 40' EXISTING ROCK BULKHEAD ~ ./, / City of Rehto Planning )livision / J7i 8 LUIO IRi ~ (G /fi ow~ [Q) R_EFERENCE U: APPLICANT: BARBEE MILL CO. INC. c/o ROBERT CUGINI 'PROPOSED, INSTALL (2) NEW BOATLIFTS, (1) JETSKl LIFT AND (12 PLATFORM UFT. N_sAR/AT: RENTON SHEET: 2 OF, 3 DATE: 6-29-=-10 ___l!)I//Qt_1Q_~37D22-A2-1 0 ~i :.-~~vi ~.=jco :r· gg 0..., 0 C: ~~ZAi ~>zz;§:: a z o "\\L z-<· vi~- ~~~~~ ;g r, O"'.""'i o ~ ;,J vi i:is;;; <.... r1-o ~~ ~ ~29~(): g60"0~ ~ ..... :;,;, '" "' o~~o~ ~ O;c -uC D B;afiiS:lp,._ r:i:, ~S.8=i!§· .:: g~::/~- ~,:::.C~~ ;u:C--<" ~ ::j,Q~ 11~:~ :: ~ z ~ -I y> (\. .:\= f r::tf STATE OF WASHINGTON DEPARTMENT OF ECOLOGY Northwest Regional Office• 3190 160th Avenue SE• Bellevue, Washington 98008-5452 • (425) 649-7000 November 18, 2010 Robert Cugini 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N. Renton, WA 98056 Re: City of Renton County Permit LUAl0-050,ECF, SM, SMC -Approved Robert Cugini -Applicant Shoreline Substantial Development Permit 368 Dear Robert Cugini: City of R Ptar.n;ng o enton 1v1s;011 Nov 2 2 lUiO On October 29, 2010 the Department of Ecology received notice that the City of Renton approved your application for an SDP. Your permit is for twolO-foot by 14-foot freestanding boatlifts, one 10-foot by 20-foot freestanding boatlift with a fully grated platform, and one dock- mounted jet ski lift to be installed on an existing joint-use dock serving three lots along the Lake Washington shoreline. Each of the freestanding watercraft lifts would rest directly on the lake bottom on four 12-inch by 12-inch footpads. In addition to installing the new lifts, the applicant will remove six, 12-inch diameter creosote-treated piles and replace them with two steel piles within the shoreline jurisdiction of Lake Washington. By law, local governments must review all SDPs for compliance with: • The Shoreline Management Act (Chapter 90.58 RCW) • Ecology's Substantial Development Pennit approval criteria (Chapter 173-27-150 WAC) • The Renton Local Shoreline Master Program Local governments, after reviewing SDPs for compliance, are required to submit them to Ecology. Your approved SDP has been received by Ecology. What Happens Next? Before you begin activities authorized by this permit, the law requires you wait at least 21 days_ from the "date of receipt" -the date you receive this letter. Date of receipt is defined in RCW 43.21B.001 as: (1) "Business days" means Monday through Friday exclusive of any state or federal holiday. Robert Cugini November 18, 2010 Page2of2 (2) "Date of receipt" means: (a) Five business days after the date of mailing; or (b) The date of actual receipt, when the actual receipt date can be proven by a preponderance of the evidence. The recipient's sworn affidavit or declaration indicating the date of receipt, which is unchallenged by the agency, shall constitute sufficient evidence of actual receipt. The date of actual receipt, however, may not exceed forty-five days from the date of mailing. This waiting period allows anyone (including you) who disagrees with any aspect of this permit, to appeal the decision to the state Shorelines Hearings Board. You must wait for the conclusion of an appeal before you can begin the activities authorized by this permit. The Shorelines Hearings Board will notify you by letter if they receive an appeal. We recommend you contact the Shorelines Hearings Board before you begin permit activities to ensure no appeal has been received. They can be reached at (360) 459-6327 or http://www.eho.wa.gov/ If you want to appeal this decision, you can fmd appeal instructions (Chapter 461-08 WAC) at the Shorelines Hearings Board website above. They are also posted on the website of the Washington State Legislature at: http://apps.leg.wa.gov/wac. Other federal, state and local permits may be required in addition to this shoreline permit. If you have any questions about this letter, please contact Barbara Nightingale at ( 425) 649-4309. Sincerely, ~cfr~T~ Barbara Nightingale, Regional Shoreline Planner Shorelands and Environmental Assistance Program · By certified mail: 7009 2820 0001 7154 3382 cc: Gerald Wasser, Associate Planner, City of Renton Al Foltz, Waterfront Construction Inc. STATE OF WASHINGTON, COUNTY OF KING } AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLICATION Pl:BLIC NOTICE Linda M Mills. being first duly sworn on oath that she is the Legal Ad vcrtising Representative of the Renton Reporter a weekly newspaper. which newspaper is a legal newspaper of general circulation and is now and has been for more than six months prior to the dale or publication hereinafter referred to. published in tk English language continuoPs!;• as a weekly newspaper in King County. Washington. The Renton Reporter has been approved as a Legal l'\cwspaper by order or th: Superior Court of the State of Washington for King County. The notice in the exact form annexed was published in regular issues of the Renton Reporter ( and not in supplement form) which was regularly distributed to its subscribers during the below stated period. The annexed notice, a: Public Notice was published on September 3, 2010. The full amount of the fee charged for said foregoing publication is the sum of $115.50 / ·. ?~//;?~ -indaM. Mills --=- Legal Advenising Representative, Renton Reporter SubscrilJ.ed and swor}\,tO me this 7th day September. 2010. ~;~ r the State of Washington, Residing ,,,,,,,\\\\.\\ ..C, s-11 l• :::..::-<) I"\_ t:: G '' f;-::.'·. )'~?> ~ t-·~. / ·/ ,, ,;. /, '' ' . ( ;,..,,/_1',:·,.\r-~- 1,,, '\/()TICE OF ENVIRO'I\IE'lll\L DETER\111\,HION Ec'/VIRONMENTAL REVIEW C'OMMITTFE AND P!iRLIC HEARING RENTO'I, WASHl'.\GTON The Em1rnnmen1..1J Review Cornrninee ha, i",uL'<l a Determination of Non- Signiticance-.\1itigmed for the follo,.,,ing proJcCl under the autho1ity of the Renton tvlunicipal Code. Barbee r-.'lill Watc-rcr~1ft Lifts LUAI0-050, ECF. S\L SMC l,ocatinn: ?,Y05 Lni...e W,:bhington Bhd .',;. i\pplio.:;inr rcq1{c~ts SEPA Re\ it"\\ :mtl approval of a Sho,..:linL' Suh'slantial De,-cloprnent P.:rinit nnd :1 Shoreline Conditional L'sc Permit for Lhe 1n\tallation of \'.aten:rafl lift<. in a:'...,ocia1ion 1,1,ith an cxi<..ting joint use dock in the R-8 zone. Appeal:-. of Lhe cnvirurunental dererrnina!ion rnu,;t he filed in writing on or hcfore S·OO p.m on September J 7, 20 I 0. Appeal<. mu"t be filed in writing together Y.ith the required fee v.:ith: Hearing Examiner, Ciiy of Renton. 1055 South Grady Way. Renton, WA 98057. Appeal<. to the Examiner are gm·emed by City of Renton Municipal Code Section 4-8-1 I O.B. Additional informution regarding the appeal proce"s may be obwined from the Renton Ci1y Ckrk·c; Office, (425) 4?.0-6510. A Public Hearing will be held by the Renton Hearing Examiner in the Council Chamber<.,, City Hall, on September 28. 2010 at 9:00 a.m. to cnnsidcr the Shoreline Suh:-.Lanti:.il Development Permil and Short'iinc Conditional Use Permit. If the Environmental Determination is appealed, the appeal will be heard as part of this public h.:aring lntcrc ... tcd panics arc invitl!d to attend the public hcaiing. Puhfo,hed in the Renton Rep.mer on Septemh.:r .3, 20 l 0. #4004 l 7. ' . f REPLY TO ATIENTIONOF Regulatory Branch Mr. Robert Cugini Barbee Mill Company, Inc. DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY SEATTLE DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS P.O. BOX 3755 SEATTLE, WASHINGTON 98124-3755 NOV -8 2010 3905 Lake Washington Boulevard North Renton, Washington 98015 J-l A 10 --O'j) Reference: NWS-2010-904 Barbee Mill Company Dear Mr. Cugini: We have reviewed your application to install two ground-based boatlifts, one ground-based platform lift, and one suspended watercraft lift at an existing pier; and remove three 3-pile creosote-treated dolphins on an existing log boom and replace with three single steel piles as mitigation, in Lake Washington at Renton, Washington. Based on the information you provided to us, this "Letter of Permission" (LOP) permit authorizes your proposal as depicted on the enclosed drawings dated September 15, 2010, which are made part of this permit. In order for this LOP authorization to be valid, you must ensure that the work is performed in accordance with the enclosed Letter of Permission General Conditions and the following special conditions: a. You must implement and abide by the Endangered Species Act (ESA) requirements and/or agreements set forth in your Reference Biological Evaluation Specific Project Information Form, dated July 21, 2010, and the RGP 1 Appendix A form submitted on July 12, 2010, in their entirety. You must also comply with the conditions included in the enclosed General Implementation Conditions. The National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) concurred with a finding of "may affect, not likely to adversely affect" based on these documents on September 24, 2010 (NMFS Reference Number 2010/03901). Failure to comply with the commitments made in these documents constitutes non-compliance with the ESA and your Corps permit. The NMFS is the appropriate authority to determine compliance with ESA. b. In order to meet the requirements of the ESA programmatic letter of concurrence for selected activities in the Lake Washington/Lake Sammamish Basins (U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service reference number 13410-2009-1-386) you must comply with the applicable conservation measures in the enclosed document titled Enclosure I, Conservation Measures for Activities Covered under the Lake Washington Programmatic Consultation Letter of Concurrence. If you cannot comply with these conservation measures, you must, prior to commencing construction, . . -2- contact the Corps, Seattle District, Regulatory Branch for an individual consultation in accordance with the requirements of the ESA. The USFWS is the appropriate authority to determine compliance with ESA. c. In order to meet the requirements of the ESA and for the protection of Chinook, steelhead, and bull trout, the permittee may conduct the authorized activities from July 16 through December 31 in any year this permit is valid. The permittee shall not conduct work authorized by this permit from January 1 through July 15 in any year this permit is valid. We have reviewed your project pursuant to the requirements of the ESA and the Magnuson- Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Act in regards to Essential Fish Habitat (EFH). The Corps has determined that this project will comply with the requirements of the above laws provided you comply with special conditions "a" through "c" listed above. Any change in the plans for this work will require that you submit revised drawings to this office and receive our written approval of those changes prior to conducting the work. Also, we have completed an approved jurisdictional determination for your project area which can be found on our website at http://www.nws.usace.army.mil/ click on Regulatory, Regulatory/Permits, Recent Jurisdictional Determinations. If you object to any terms or conditions of this LOP or the jurisdictional determination, you may request an administrative appeal under our regulations 33 CFR 331 as described in the enclosed Appeal Process Fact Sheet and the Notification of Administrative Appeal Options and Process and Request for Appeal form. Your authorization to conduct the proposed work under this permit expires 3 years from the date of this letter. Within 30 days of completing the authorized work, you must fill out and return the enclosed Certificate of Compliance with Department of the Army Permit form to the address indicated on the form. Your signature on this form is our assurance you have conducted the work and any required mitigation in accordance with the terms and conditions of this LOP, including all special conditions. Please remember that failure to comply with the terms and conditions of this LOP, including any special conditions, will invalidate your authorization and could result in a violation of Federal law. Thank you for your cooperation during the permit process. We are interested in your experience with our Regulatory Program and encourage you to complete a customer service survey form. This form and information about our program is available on our website at: www.nws.usace.arrny.mil (select "Regulatory'' and then "Regulatory/Permits"). While this project will not require further authorization from us, please note that it must comply with all State, local, and other Federal requirements that may apply. A copy of this letter without enclosures is being furnished to Alan Foltz, Waterfront Construction, 205 Northeast Northlake Way, Suite 230, Seattle, Washington 98105. -3- If you have any questions about this letter or our regulatory program, please contact Susan Powell at telephone (206) 764-5527 or via email susan.m.powell@usace.army.mil. BY AUTHORITY OF THE SECRETARY OF THE ARMY: Enclosures Anthony 0. Wright Colonel, Corps of Engineers District Engineer ' {s l\l I PROJECT OESIGNED BY: Waterfront Cmstruction Inc. THIS OOCUl,A(NT IS PROPRIO'ARY PROPERTY OF WATERFRONT CONSTRUCTION INC., ANO JS NOT TO BE USED, IN WHOLE OR IN PART. cOR AN'I' OTl!ER PROJECT WllHOUT THE l'/RlnEN AUTHORIZATION Of WATERFRONT CONSTRUCTION INC. LAKE 1/'jASHINGTON JOB SITE N :O.h Sl VICINITY MAP /NO SCALE LEGAL DESCRIPTION 1/4 SEC: NW-32-24-5 TAXLOT H: 334270 0011 LAT: 47.525985 (4T 31' 37.15" N) LONG; -122.205604 (122" 12' 20.17" W) HILLMANS U< WN GARDEN Of EDEN #2 "LOT D" RENTON LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT NO LUA-96-153Ll..A.-LND-J0-0152 REC NO 20061002900012 SD LOT LINE ADJUST~ENT DAF LOTS 1 THRU 13 IN BLOCK A OF HILLMANS LAKE WASHINGTON GARDEN OF EDEN D\V NO 2 PlAT TGW SH LDS ADS AND TGW THE NWLY 25.00 FT OF BNSF ROW LY BTWN rwo LNS DRAWN PLW & DIST 25.00 AND SO.OD ti NWLY AS ME.AS AT R/A FR MAIN TRACK C/L BOUNDED ON TH£ NORTH 8Y THE ELY EXTN OF TH£ NORTH LN OF LOT 1 AND BOUNDEO ON THE SOUTH BY THE ELY EXTN OF THE SOUTH LN OF LDT 13 OF SD HILLMANS LAKE WASHINGTON GARDEN OF EDEN DIV 2 ;J ', PURPOSL PROVIDE OUT OF WATER SOAT MOORAGE PROJECT NAME: BARBEE Mill CO. INC. DATUM: COE. 0.0' EST 1919 ADJACENT OWNERS: CD BARBEE FOREST PRODUCTS INC 3907 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA. 9B056 @ BOYDSTON TONY 3901 LAKE WASHrNGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA. 98056 3905 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON. WA. 9B056 DWG/j: 10-37022-A.1-1 LAKE FOREST PARK KENMORE JU/:INITA KIRKLAND * I BELLEVUE JOB SITE RENTON AREA MAP /Scale:1 "=3miles 3 MILES 0 .3 MILES 1 MILE REVISED 9-15-10 PROPOSED: INSTALL (2) NEW BOATUFTS, (1) JE1SKI LIFT AND (1) PLATFORM LIFT. JOINT USE PIER IN: LAKE WASHINGTON NEAR: RENTON COUNTY: KING STATE: WA APPL BY~-BARBEE MILL CO. INC. c/o ROBERT CUGINI SHEET: 1 OF: 3 DATE: 6-29-10 t I p c 0 BARBE.E f'OREST PRODUCTS INC 3907 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON. WA. 98056 f---7 I / I ;/ ~ -----S 88'4.9'09n E ------------------- ff/ ::; JOB SITE fs I ~I cf (2) .3905 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON. WA. 98056 f!i I fl . I r., I ,,, :: I "' I r 34' 1 PROPOSCD JCTSKI LIFT OHWL 21.80' ~ FACE OF BULKHEAD -~ I .!J' I ,'/;/ 1,a·-6ft P,'I "'I EXISTING DOLPHINS EXISTING PIER 'pf(OP0SED MITTGATION: 3901 (J) 12" CREOSOTE WOOD MOORING PILES PER (DOLPHIN) TO BE REPLACED WITH (1) 12'' STEEL PILE (FOR 3-DOLPHINS) PLOT PLAN 40' 30' 20· 1 o· o· SCALE: 1 "=40' 0 BOYDSTON TONY LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA. 98056 40' ; / .' I I I / ,/ I I I REVISED 9-15-10 REFERENCE PLICAN:SSTc',ccB"cAR"B"'E'=E"'M"1",,"--,,c"o"". ",N',!CU. ",-/'o.::j,!R,fOB;;EhR~T-c~u~G=1NI PROPOSED: INSTALL (2) NEW BOATLIFTS, (1) JITSKI LIFT ANQ.J.!2 PLATFORM Liff NEAR/AT: RENTON SHEET: 2 or: 3 DATE: 6-29-10 DWJ1L 10-3702_2-A.2-1 c 0 g 'I ... ~~iii C~CU t,,§§ ~gz~-<::::: ~!z.z~-<.. 0-<,n-~ , "" oS~!' , -.-.Ic =',::0 ~~-~· e > " " ,:;:l~z!!I ~ ~~~!~~ §?~O-.,q; ?i -,:.Ew::urr z n:::i"'~i2 g 95cr::3n o ~~~~ ~ a a -rz...,_ ".3 ~~~{' -O" or< ~:~ :U:'j ' * I OHWL 21.80' (2) PROPOSED FREE STANDING 80ATUFTS 14'-2" -j 7'-2" --35'±'-c----- PROPOSED JETSKI LIFT EXISTING PLANTING PLAN OHWL 21.80' @ FACE OF BULKHEAD T PROPOSED PLATrQRM LIFT 27' EXISTING ROCK BULKHEAD J_ 7'-1c>i· t 87'-6" __ __jr--------lf---- PROPOSED MITIGATION: EXISTING PILING (3) 12" CREOSOTE WOOD MOORING PILES PER (DOLPHIN) ~E REPLACED WITH (1) 12" STEEL PILE (FOR 3 DOLPHINS) !:'..._________________ .Jl, _&, L PROPOSED t.imGATION! N sa·49'3sH w J44.69' (3) 12" CREOSOTE WOOD MOORING DETAIL VIEW --PILES PER (DOLPHIN) TO 13t. REPLACED 1m (1) 1r STEEL PILE (FOR J DOLPHi~S) SCALE: 1"=20' (2) PROPOSED FREE STANDING 8DATUFTS EXISTING FULLY GRATED PIER PROPOSED JETSKI LIFT I 2'-r 20'± EXISTING PILING VIEW 20· 1s· 10" s· a· 20' SCALE: 1 '=20' / 1, .... \ -""'-< -------------- EXISTING ROCK BULKHEAD I/ REVISED 9-15-10 REFERENCE ;APPLICANT: BARBEE MILLCO.-INC. ~OBCTH CUGINI 1PROPOSE0: INSTALL (2) NEW BOATLIFTS, { 1) JETSKI LIFT ANO ill PLATFORM LIFT. J'IEAR/AT: REf\JJ:ON SHEET: .3 OF: J .PA~_;_§_-29-10 DWG#:10-37022-A.J-l 0 ~~ :,3' ~ r;; f~~g o....,oc: ~~z~ ~>Z~~ g ~fl;~ ~~~1i~ ~g'= ' e >""'" ;;l:::Jz~& 'l }29!Go §qo,,~ ~ n:I;~~~ ~ ~~c;~f; 0 ~ggi~~ ~ ~~!=lo~ . g~z"'s-z~~!0 z=1P52 r,'z!~~ ·~ z ~- City of Renton Pla1111ing Division PROJECT DE5'G'ED ~.' [Rl ~ cc ~ ~ ~ ~ [Q) Waterfrmt (on5m;ct1on Inc. THIS DOCUMENT JS PROPRIETARY PROPERTY OF WAITRFRONT CONSTRUCTION INC., AND IS NOT TO BE USED, IN WHOLE OR IN PART, FOR AN!" OTHER PROJECT Wm-tOUT THE WRITTEN AUTHORIZATION OF WATERFRONT CONSTRUCTION !NC. ,:~;:-,;· '.. VICINl1Y MAP /NO SCALE LEGAL DESCRIPTION 1/4 SEC: NW-32-24-5 TAXLOT IJ: 334270 0011 LAT; 47.525985 (47 31' 37.15" N) LONG: -122.205604 (122" 12' 20.17" W) HILLMA.NS LK WN GARDEN OF EDEN #2 nLOT On RENTON LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT NO LUA-96-153LLA-LND-30-0152 REC NO 20061002900012 SD LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT OAF LOTS 1 THRU 13 IN BLOCK A OF HllLMANS LAKE WASHINGTON GARDEN OF EDEN. DJV NO 2 PLAT TGW SH LOS ADS AND TGW THE -NWLY 25.00 FT OF BNSF ROW LY BTWN TWO U>JS DRAWN PLW & DIST 25.00 -AND 50.00 FT NWLY AS MEAS AT R/A FR lviA.rN TRACK C/L BOUNDED ON THE . NORULB'l'---THE--El't-EXTN. OF-lHE--NORTH lN-OF ..LOT--1--AND .......... . BOUNDED ON THE SOUTH BY THE ELY EXTN OF THE SOUTH LN OF LOT 13 OF SD HILLMANS LAKE WASHINGTON GARDEN OF EDEN D!V 2 PURPOSE:PROV1DE OUT OF WATER 30AT. MOORAGE DATUM: COE o.o· EST 1919 ADJACENT OWNERS: G) BARBEE FOREST PRODUCTS !NC 3907 I.AKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA. 98056 G) BOYDSTON TONY 3901 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA. 98056 PROJECT NAME: BARBEE MILL CO. !NC. REFERENCE #: SITE LOCAllON ADDRESS: 3905 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA. 98056 DWG#: 10-37022-A.1 ~ 1 ,,··-~· :;_;f0 LAKE FOREST PARK EXHIBIT 2 KENMORE JUANITA KIRKLAND w __J f- ~ w U) JOB SITE RENTON AREA MAP /Scale: 1 "~3miles 3 MILES 0 3 MILES 1 MILE PROPOSm INSTALL (2) NEW BOATI.IFTS, (1) JETSKI UFT AND (1) -PLA.TFORM UFT. JOINT USE PIER IN: LAKE WASHJNGION NEAR: RENTON COUNlY: K!NG STATE: WA APPL BY: BARBEE MILL CO. INC. c:./o ROBERT CUGINI SHEET: i OF: 3 t Bontlift frames are 10' x 14' over11ll with foul"_ (4) -1' sq. foot pads. Platform Lift uses boatlift frame, with a 10' :x 20' fully grated platform. Dock mounted Jetski Lift Frnming is 4' x 6' overall. ,., I £/ . ::; if I JI ~I // I I I I I I I I (2) I 34' 1 p I ~~~~~~~~S-B~B~"~E JOB SITE 3905 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA. 98056 PROPOSED JETSKI LIFT OHWL 21.BD' @ FACE OF BULKHEAD EXISTING ROCK BULKHEAD _(;? ( ,ff I I, ;:s I ~1 11a·-c . ;Jl!','I EXISTING N BB'49'35" EXISTING PIER -1 EXISTING JETSKI LIFT EXIST!NG DECK ROPOSEO MmGATJON: 3901 (3) 112" CREOSOTE WOOD MOORING PILES PER (DOLPHIN) TO BE REPlACED WITH (1) 12" STEEL PILE ' PLOT PLAN 40' 30' 20· 10· o· SCALE: 1 '=40' @ BOYDSTON TONY LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA; 9B056 40' 0 8AR8EE FOREST PRODUCTS INC 3907 lAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA, 96056 ---7 /7/ I I / I I I I I I /! / / REFERENCE fl: I I APPLICANT: 8AR8EE MILL CO. INC. c/o ROBERf-CUGIN[ 'PROPOSED; INSTALL (2) NEW BOATLIFTS, (1) JETSKI LIFT AND (11 PLATFORM LIFT. NEAR/ AT: RENTON SHEET: 2 OF: 3 j)flT[•. 6-29-10 ~-JQll'G#: 10-37022cA.2-1 tr: ·~-~i'\5~ ~ d'f f ~;,; 1'1-.::::::: :::i>Z=S:::::::: f~f' [ij~ ~~~,;::}, ~ ~~in~!l-' 2 ' ~ ~ f35~ ~ ,2~~n o 05-1::t~ ul 3i O 'IJ"' 0 ~[!j:'tl& z R:i!ri~2 B 'zoc::SJl"'I ~::i!JJ~t ~ C . C, n;il-~ ::J,,,z S- ~~~ff'I ~~p~· · 2,..., ii ~~ , m >< :c I-I OJ I-I -I w ~e: Boaflift frames are 10' x 14' overall with four (4) w 1' 5Q, footipads. Plntform Lift uses boatlift frame, with a 10' x 20' fully grated platform. Dock mounted Jetslci Lift Framing is 4' x 6' overall. J_ 7'-10~"- (2) PROPOSED FREE STANDING BOATLIFTS 14'-2" --i 7'-2" 35'± ,._ ___ __, T 27' PROPOSED JETSKI LIFT PROPOSED PLATFORM LIFT EXISTING PLANTING PLAN OHWL 21.BO' @ FACE OF BULKHEAD EXISTING ROCK BULKHEAD I a7'-6" --+-------i---- OHWL 21.80' EXISTING FULLY GRATED i PROPOSED MmGATION: (3) 12" CREOSOTE WOOD MOORING PILES PER (DOLPHIN) ~ REPLACED WITH (1) 12" STEEL PILE p ------~Ji £ 1 , N BB'49'35" W 344,69¥ :PROPOSED MmGATION: -- -i(3) 12'" CREOSOTE WOOD MOORING PILES PER (DOLPHIN) !TO BE REPLACED WITH (1) 12~ STEEL PILE DETAIL VIEW EXIST!NG FULLY GRATED PIER _[ 2·-r (2) PROPOSED FREE STANDING BOATLIFTS SCALE: 1 ":20' EXISTING PILING 20· 1s' 10· s· o· SCALE: 1 "=20' PROPOSED JETSKI LIFT 20' 1/ / / \ --------.... < -""+ EXISTING RAMP REFERENCE ff: EXISTING ROCK BULKHEAD EXISTING SPAWNING GRAVEL APPLICANT: BARBEE MILL -CO. INC. c/o ROBERf CUGINI PROPOSED: INSTALL (2) NEW BOATLIFTS, (1) JCTSKI LIFT AND i.!_2 PLATFORM UFT. NEAR/AT: RENTON SHEET: 3 OF: J DATE;6~29-1Q DWG#, 10-:;7022-A._3-1 8 z, "TI~ vi l> tc..o ~-· gp, 0''1QC ::oO;;,;.;:::_ ~;z§i,f ~~p ilih; o'.:l~;E~.., ..., :r oo-----. ~'.;)vi~~ ;;!1Jzrr1<: ';i;/~o~~n ""'-"°' <:::) ::Or-,"""' 3 *Clo]~ (")~~~-= o=tc,--,,r-. Zo(l):o,:-'r ~~8~~ c:-1· 0 g~z;;r z~!~- l:=-j~;o f'li,l"';;J z~2 , m >< :c 1-1 c:, ~ .,::. I~ 188.5 Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts -Homes Served by Joint-Use Dock 0 94.24 188.5 Feet e f ~~ ~~ t ~ ... (' ~~ ';'.+-t, v°' 3342700410 3818 334270041 5 1129 33427004)2 3824 This map is a user generated stat ic output from an Internet mapping site and is for reference only. Data l ayers that appear on this map may or may not be accurate , c urrent, or otherwise reliable. City of Renton, Washington THIS MAP I S NOT TO BE U SED FOR NAVIGATION La kes and Rivers Parcels Zoning Resource Conservation Residentia l 1 du/ac Resi dential 4 du/ac Residential 8 du/ac Res idential Manufactured Homes Residential 10 du/ac Residential 14 du/ac Residential Multi-Fam ily Residential Multi-Fam ily Traditional Residential Multi-Family Urban Cer Center Vi llage Center Downtown Urban C enter -Nortt' Urban Center -Nortr Commercial Office/R Commercial Artenal Commercial Office Commercial Ne1ghbc lndustnal -Light lndustnal -Medium lndustnal -Heavy Street Names Rights of Way Streets Roads Jurisdictions Bellevue Des Moines I ssaquah Kent 1: 1,131 @8.5" X 11 " Notes Enter Map D escription 0 m >< :c """'4 m ... - U1 ...., u B4 -29 T24N RSE W 1/2 COR ---R-& C -;""" • lr-s-.l. ____ _ ::===::'::::;==·--=,-,;:;;R-~Bt--=======-=lsl1 __:_:-~ R-8 ~===-:~:s:c:==-==:'.:=;":::::::-_j';:::::-=::=i~ ~= ZONING MAP BOOK PW TECHNICAL SERVICES PRINTED ON 11/13/09 Thi<bomofftk•p>piK,..,....._;o,-.,<11 .......... , .... """"""''""'--·-.. ........... ___ ......... ,,.. ............. --·-·""°"'_'_""" -'R-1>; -----; --' / ; N~~ -J D4 -05 T23N RSE W 1/2 0 200 !SJ 1:4,BOD EXHIBIT 6 CA CA • RC RC R-8 'R-8 __ c~ 32 T24N RSE W 1/2 5432 DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT EXHIBIT 7 ENVIRONMENTAL (SEPA) DETERMINATION OF NON-SIGNIFICANCE APPLICATION NO(S): APPLICANT: PROJECT NAME: -MITIGATED (DNS-M) LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC Robert Cugini, Barbee Mill Company Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSAL: The applicant requests SEPA Review for the installation of two 10 ft by 14 ft freestanding boatlifts, one 10 ft by 20 ft freestanding boatlift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock. LOCATION OF PROPOSAL: LEAD AGENCY: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd N City of Renton Environmental Review Committee Department of Community & Economic Development The City of Renton Environmental Review Committee has determined that it does not have a probable significant adverse impact on the environment. An Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) is not required under RCW 43.21C.030(2)(c). Conditions were imposed as mitigation measures by the Environmental Review Committee under their authority of Section 4-6-6 Renton Municipal Code. These conditions are necessary to mitigate environmental impacts identified during the environmental review process. Appeals of the environmental determination must be filed in writing on or before 5:00 p.m. on September 17, 2010. Appeals must be filed in writing together with the required fee with: Hearing Examiner, City of Renton, 1055 South Grady Way, Renton, WA 98057. Appeals to the Examiner are governed by City of Renton Municipal Code Section 4-8-110.B. Additional information regarding the appeal process may be obtained from the Renton City Clerk's Office, (425) 430-6510. PUBLICATION DATE: DATE OF DECISION: SIGNATURES: Terry Higashiyama, Administrator Community Services Department September 3, 2010 August 30, 2010 /fl/ 72d }1-& f2._·?7c---+. -'=----'"'----I-='----- / Mark Peterson, Administrator Date Fire & Erner cy Services Date Economic Development Date Date DEPARTMENT OF COMMUN!, { AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT EXHIBIT 8 DETERMINATION OF NON-SIGNIFICANCE-MITIGATED MITIGATION MEASURES APPLICATION NO(S): APPLICANT: PROJECT NAME: LUA10-0SO, ECF, SM, SMC Robert Cugini, Barbee Mill Company Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSAL: The applicant requests SEPA Review for the installation of two 10 ft by 14 ft freestanding boatlifts, one 10 ft by 20 ft freestanding boatlift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock. LOCATION OF PROPOSAL: LEAD AGENCY: MITIGATION MEASURES: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd N The City of Renton Department of Community & Economic Development Planning Division 1. A hanging silt containment curtain shall be installed around the project area prior to commencement of work and shall remain in place until project completion 2. Construction shall take place only during the Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife approved construction window forth is portion of Lake Washington, from July 16 through December 31. ERC Mitigation Measures .Page 1 of 1 DEPARTMENT OF COMM UNI 1 1 AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT EXHIBIT 9 • DETERMINATION OF NON-SIGNIFICANCE-MITIGATED ADVISORY NOTES APPLICATION NO(S): APPLICANT: PROJECT NAME: LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC Robert Cugini, Barbee Mill Company Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSAL: The applicant requests SEPA Review for the installation of two 10 ft by 14 ff freestanding boatlifts, one 10 ft by 20 ft freestanding boatlift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock. LOCATION OF PROPOSAL: LEAD AGENCY: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd N The City of Renton Department of Community & Economic Development Planning Division Advisory Notes to Applicant: The following nates are supplemental information provided in conjunction with the environmental determination. Because these notes are provided as information only, they are not subject to the appeal process for environmental determinations. Planning: 1. The site is designated Residential Single Family in the City's Comprehensive Plan. The site is zoned Residential -8 dwelling units per acre (R-8). 2. The Shoreline Master Program Designation is."Urban". 3. Construction activities shall be restricted to the hours between 7:00 am and 8:00 pm, Monday through Friday. Work on Saturdays shall be between the hours of9:00 am and 8:00 pm. No work shall be permitted on Sundays. 4. The approved State of Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW) fish window is from July 16 through December 31. 5. Project requires approval of a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit for the watercraft lifts. 6. Existing Joint Use Pier was previously approved (LUAOl-015, ECF, SV). 7. Previous conditions of approval continue to apply to the existing pier and to the addition of the boat lifts. Plan Review 1. The properties are served by the City of Renton Water Utility. 2. Cross connection control, inspection, and certification is required for any water service to the dock. 3. A water service permit is required if water service is extended to the dock. ERC Advisory Notes Page 1 of 2 4. The properties are served by the City of Renton Wastewater Utility. 5. The parcels have onsite drainage to Lake Washington. No further facilities are triggered by this proposal. 6. All plans shall conform to the Renton Drafting standards. 7. For any utility work, a construction permit is required. When plans are complete, submit three (3) copies of the drawings, a construction estimate, application and appropriate fee to the 5th floor Customer Counter at City Hall. ERC Advisory Notes Page 2 of 2 DEPARTMENT OF COM NITY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT EXHIBIT 10 il-vof.,. ~ ·r·'-. ·1.·· r· c ·. ·· r'. 1 U;i~:: -'. • ) •,-,.d;· -·-,,... J --.-_"\, PLANNING DIVl::>IUN SHORELINE MANAGEMENT ACT OF 1971 PERMIT FOR SHORELINE MANAGEMENT EVALUATION FORM & DECISION DATE OF PERMIT ISSUANCE: LAND USE ACTION FILE NO.: DATE RECEIVED DATE OF PUBLIC NOTICE: TYPE OF ACTION(S): LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC July 28, 2010 August 6, 2010 Substantial Development Permit Conditional U_se Permit Variance Permit Pursuant to Chapter 90.58 RCW, staff recommends that the City of Renton grant a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit and a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit. This action is proposed on the following application: PROJECT NAME: PROJECT MANAGER: OWN ER/ APPLICANT: CONTACT: PROJECT LOCATION: LEGAL DESCRIPTION: SEC-TWN-R: WITHIN THE SHORELINES OF: APPLICABLE MASTER PROGRAM: Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts Gerald Wasser, Associate Planner Robert Cugini, Barbee Mill Company, 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N., Renton, WA 98056 Alan Foltz, Waterfront Construction, Inc., 205 Northlake Way, Suite 230, Seattle, WA 98105 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N. See Attachment A NW 1/4 of SEC 22 -TWN 24N -R SE Lake Washington City of Renton . --· ---- PROPOSAL DESCRIPTION: The applicant requests approval of a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit and a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit for the installation of two 10-foot by 14-foot freestanding boatlifts, one 10-foot by 20-foot freestanding boatlift lift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock which serves three lots in the Residential -8 dwelling units per acre (R-8) zone .. Each of the freestanding watercraft lifts would rest directly on the lake bottom on four 12-inch City of Renton Department of Comi, Barbe Mill Watercraft Lifts DATE OF PERMIT: 1 & Economic Development Shoreline Management Permit LUAl0-050 ECF, SM, SMC Page 2 of 3 by 12-inch footpads. The existing fully-grated dock is 4-feet, 4 1/2-inches to 7-feet, 10 3/4- inches in width and 118-feet, 6-inches in length with two 27-foot fully-grated finger docks. The proposed project also encompasses the removal of six 12-inch diameter creosote-treated wood piles and replacing them with two vibratory pile-driven 12-inch diameter steel piles. All work would take place within the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife fish window for this section of Lake Washington, July 16 through December 31. The following section/page of the Master Program is applicable to the development: RMCSection 4-3-090J 4-3-090K 4-3-090L 4-3-090M 4-9-1901.1, 2, 3, 5 Description Urban Environment General Use Regulations for All Shoreline Uses Specific Use Regulations Variances and Conditional Use permits Variances and Conditional Uses Page 3-25 3-26 3-27 9-54 Development of this project shall be undertaken pursuant to the following terms and conditions: 1. The applicant shall comply with the mitigation measures imposed by the Environmental Review Committee in its Determination of Non-Significance -Mitigated issued on August 30, 2010; 2. The applicant shall prepare a restrictive covenant with the appropriate signatures of the property owners and recorded with King County. The document shall specify ownership rights and maintenance provisions for the watercraft lifts. The restrictive covenant shall contain a statement that the covenant shall remain with the property and can only be released by written permission granted by the City of Renton. A copy of the restrictive covenant shall be provided to the Planning Division project manager for review and approval prior to recording with King County. Building permits for the watercraft lifts may be issued only subsequent to recording the restrictive covenant; and 3. The applicant shall comply with all construction conditions of State agencies and all construction conditions provided in the application submitted to the City. This Permit is granted pursuant to the Shoreline Management Action of 1971 and pursuant to the following: 1. The issuance of a license under the Shoreline Management Act of 1971 shall not release the applicant from compliance with federal, state, and other permit requirements. 2. This permit may be rescinded pursuant to Section 14(7) of the Shoreline Management Act of 1971 in the event the permittee fails to comply with any condition(s) hereof. City of Renton Department of Co1111 Barbe Mill Watercraft Lifts DATE OF PERMIT: 1 & Economic Development Shoreline Management Permit LUAl0-050 ECF, SM, SMC Page 3 of 3 3. Construction permits shall not be issued until twenty-one (21) days after approval by the Washington State Department of Ecology or until any review proceedings initiated within this twenty-one (21) day review period have been completed. C. E. "Chip" Vincent, Planning Director Planning Division Date APPEA15: Appeals of Shoreline Substantial Development Permit issuance must be made directly to the Shorelines Hearings Board. Appeals are made by filing a request in writing within the twenty-one (21) days of receipt of the final order and concurrently filing copies of such request with the Washington State Department of Ecology and the Attorney General's office as provided in section 18{1) of the Shorelines Management Act of 1971. All copies of appeal notices shall also be filed with the City of Renton Planning Division and the City Clerk's office. EXPIRATION: Unless a different time period is specified in the shoreline permit as authorized by RCW 90.58.143 and subsection J1 of RMC 4-9-190, construction activities, or a use or activity, for which a permit has been granted pursuant to this Master Program must_ be commenced within two (2) years of the effective date of a shoreline permit, or the shoreline permit shall terminate, and a new permit shall be necessary. However, the Planning Division may authorize a single extension for a period not to exceed one year based on reasonable factors, if a request for extension has been filed with the Planning Division before the expiration date, and notice of the proposed extension is given to parties of record and the Washington State Department of Ecology. DEFINITION OF COMMENCEMENT OF CONSTRUCT/ON ACTIVITIES: the construction applications must be submitted, permits must be issued, and foundation inspections must be completed before the end of the two {2) year period. Attachments A: Legal Description cc: Attorney General's Office Karen Walter, Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Dept. Robert Cugini/ Owner(s)/Applicant Al~n Foltz/ Contact City of R_enton Official File AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAILING STATE OF WASHINGTON) ) ss. County of King ) Nancy Thompson being first duly sworn, upon oath, deposes and states: That on the 4th day of October 2010, affiant deposited via the United States Mail and Certified Mail Return Receipt Requested a sealed envelope(s) containing a decision or recommendation with postage prepaid, addressed to the parties of record in the below entitled application or petition. ·nlV)A.,C JI~ Signature J SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me this r day of {l)!'__/-r-tzh _ _), 2010 . . l'. No ry Public in~ or the State of Washington R ' iding at /Z.L. q rz ....... -\ , therein. ' Application, Petition or Case No.: Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts LUA 10-050, ECF, SM. SMC The Decision or Recommendation contains a complete list of the Parties of Record • • HEARIN<; EXAIVII~ER'S REPORT October 4, 2010 OFFICE OF THE HEARING EXAMINER CITY OF RENTON REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION APPLICANT/OWNER: CONTACT: LOCATION: SUMMARY OF REQUEST: SUMMARY OF ACTION: DEVELOPMENT SERVICES REPORT: PUBLIC HEARING: Robert Cugini Barbee Mill Company 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N. Renton, WA 98056 Alan Foltz Waterfront Construction, Inc. 205 Northlake Way, Ste. 230 Seattle, WA 98105 Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts LUA-10-050, ECF, SM, SMC 3905 Lake Washington Boulevard North Shoreline Conditional Use Permit and a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit for the installation of two 10-foot by 14- foot freestanding boatlifts, one I 0-foot by 20-foot freestanding boatlift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock which serves three single-family residential lots in the R-8 zone. Development Services Recommendation: Approve The Development Services Report was received by the Examiner on September 21, 2010. After reviewing the Development Services Report, examining available information on file with the application, field checking the property and surrounding area; the Examiner conducted a public hearing on the subject as follows: MINUTES The following minutes are a summary of the September 28, 2010 hearing. The legal record is recorded on CD. The hearing opened on Tuesday, September 28, 2010, at 9:44 a.m. in the Council Chambers on the seventh floor of the Renton City Hall. Parties wishing to testify were affirmed by the Examiner. The following exbibits were entered into the record: Exhibit No. 1: Yellow file containing the original Exhibit No. 2: Vicinity Map and Area Map application, proof of posting, proof of publication and other documentation oertinent to this reauest. Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts File No.: LUA-10-050, EFC, SM, SMC October 4, 2010 Page 2 Exhibit No. 3: Plot Plan Exhibit No. 5: Aerial Photograph -Homes Served by Joint Use Dock Exhibit No. 7: ERC Determination Exhibit No. 9: ERC Advisory Notes Exhibit No. 4: Detail View and Elevation View Exhibit No. 6: Zoning Map Exhibit No. 8: ERC Mitio:ation Measures Exhibit No. 10: Shoreline Substantial Development Permit The hearing opened with a presentation of the staff report by Gerald Wasser, Associate Planner, Community and Economic Development, City of Renton, 1055 S Grady Way, Renton, Washington 98057. The existing dock is approximately 118.5 feet long and includes a 31 foot ramp and an 86.5 dock section. There are some creosote piles located on the property and the applicant would be replacing them with steel piles. The project consists of the installation of three boatlifts and one jet ski lift. Two of the boatlifts would be 10 x 14 feet, they would be freestanding, resting on the lake bottom. Each would have four 12-inch footpads. The third boatlift would be 10 x 20 feet and would be a platform lift and fully grated. The ERC issued a Determination of Non-Significance -Mitigated, with two mitigation measures. There were no appeals. There are 5 criteria listed in the Renton Municipal Code for approval of a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit. This use is compatible with other permitted uses within the area. There are many other docks and watercraft lifts in the vicinity. This project is not associated with a public shoreline, there is access to Lake Washington via a public trail located immediately to the north of this project. Docks and watercraft lifts are generally associated with residential uses along the lake, both the existing dock and the proposed 10 x 20 foot platform boat lift are fully grated would minimize impacts to the ecological functions in critical areas. The Examiner questioned if these new structures would aid in the preservation and enhancement of the natural character of the shoreline. Mr. Wasser continued that they might not be enhancing the shoreline but they do provide a mitigation for light transmission. Conditional uses may be authorized provided that the applicant demonstrates that the use is consistent with RCW 90.58.020 and the master program, that the proposed use will not interfere with the normal public use of public shorelines, that the proposed use of the site is compatible with other autlwrized uses within the area, that the proposed use will cause no significant adverse effects to the shoreline environment and that the public interest suffers no substantial detrimental effects. It appears that the applicant has met all the criteria. Further in granting all conditional use permits consideration should be given to the cumulative impact of additional requests for like actions and the proposed watercraft lifts are compatible with adjacent residential properties. Watercraft lifts are not uses currently set forth in the Shoreline Master Program, therefore a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit would be required. The lifts do provide a secure moorage for watercraft and are commonly used in this area. Watercraft lifts are not specifically prohibited by the City's Shoreline Master Program. Alan Foltz, 205 NE Northlake Way, # 230, Seattle 98105 stated that there are two boat lifts and one jet ski lift plus an additional freestanding boatlift with a platform on top. That is a design that was recently permitted with Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts File No.: LUA-10-050, EFC, SM, SMC October 4, 2010 Page 3 the City of Renton for the Seahawks. It was suggested as a safety measure, piers today are built 2'6" above ordinary high water, which is a substantial distance above the high water when the lake is down leaving approximately 4 feet to get onto a very small vessel. The platform lift can be positioned from tbe bottom of the lake up to deck level, which offers a big safety feature for people who are boarding smaller vessels. The Examiner questioned tbe shadows on the lake that would be cast when there are boats on top. Mr. Foltz agreed but stated that tbere would be no more shadowing tban with boats tied to a dock. A large amount of light does go under tbe boats that are out and above the water. There is quite a bit of water depth under the entire pier structure. With the existing piling and booms for heavy weather protection, they would be removing three 12-inch diameter piles and would put in a single steel pile. This would reduce the area and still allow the retention of the boom. Storms can be quite strong on the south end of the lake, the booms have been very substantial in this area and work very effectively. This is a joint use pier, which is meant to reduce tbe number of private residences that would be allowed into one pier structure that would accommodate the three ownerships oftbe joint use arrangement. In a joint use arrangement all owners are responsible for the maintenance of the structures. The Examiner asked if one of the lots were sold and tbe new person wanted their own pier. Mr. Foltz stated that there would be no way to do that. Two piers are not allowed on a single property. Regarding the sewer lines and other underwater materials, a call for locate would be placed prior to any construction in the water. No additional power would be needed for the piers, they are solely operated by solar power. Neil Watts, Development Services Director stated that tbe underwater sewer line is outside tbe area of the dock and would not be affected by these boatlifts. The Examiner called for further testimony regarding tbis project. There was no one else wishing to speak, and no further comments from staff. The hearing closed at 10:09 a.m. FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATION FINDINGS: I. The applicant, Alan Foltz for Barbee Mill Company, filed a request for a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit as well as a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit to install tbree (3) boatlifts and a jet ski lift in Lake Washington. 2. The yellow file containing the staff report, the State Environmental Policy Act (SEPA) documentation and other pertinent materials was entered into tbe record as Exhibit # 1 . 3. The Environmental Review Committee (ERC), the City's responsible official issued a Determination of Non-Significance-Mitigated (DNS-M). 4. The subject proposal was reviewed by all departments with an interest in the matter. 5. There was no opposition from tbe public regarding the subject proposal. Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts File No.: LUA-10-050, EFC, SM, SMC October 4, 2010 Page 4 6. The subject site is located at 3905 Lake Washington Boulevard North. The subject site consists of an approximately 8,870 square foot lot. The subject site is located west of Lake Washington Boulevard on the shoreline of Lake Washington. 7. The map element of the Comprehensive Pian designates the area in which the subject site is located as suitable for the development of single family residential uses, but does not mandate such development without consideration of other policies of the Pian. 8. The subject site is currently zoned R-8 (Residential -8 lots per acre). The site is developed with a single family home. 9. The subject site was annexed to the City with the adoption of Ordinance 1800 enacted in October 1959. 10. The subject site and the two adjoining lots to the north, 3907 and 3909 Lake Washington Boulevard, currently share a joint-use dock. The new facilities, the two boatiifts, the platform lift and jet ski lift would continue to be used jointly by the three homes. 11. In addition to installing the new lifts, the applicant will be removing six, 12-inch diameter creosote- treated piles and replacing them with two steel piles. 12. The existing dock varies from approximately 4.5 feet to just under 8 feet in width. Two finger piers, approximately 7'2" by 27 feet long, extend to the north, approximately 14 feet and SO feet from the western end of the long dock. 13. Each of the boatiifts will be free-standing supported by four 12-inch square footpads resting directly on the lake's bottom. The lifts will be open structures with no covers. The platform lift will be fully grated to allow the passage of light to the water. The platform lift is intended to allow boarding of smaller craft when the lake's level is down during an approximately eight (8) month period. The jet ski lift will be dock-mounted. 14. The two boat lifts will be located on the north side of the dock between the two finger piers. The jet ski lift will be located on the shoreward side (east) of the easternmost finger pier. The platform lift will be located on the north side of the dock, again, eastward of the eastern finger pier. 1 S. The lifts will be delivered by barge and all work will occur from the barge. It would take approximately one to three days for installation. 16. Code requires a five foot side yard setback from the property line. The proposal meets this requirement. 17. Any work in the lake will occur during the Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife "fish window" that runs from July 16 to December 31. A silt fence will be installed around the work area. 18. Lake Washington's shoreline is classified as a Shoreline of Statewide Significance and therefore any development adjacent to it is subject to the City's Shoreline Master Program. This section of the shoreline is designated as an Urban Shoreline. This section of shoreline and a portion of the lake bed are privately owned. 19. Other boatlifts have been approved along other areas of the Lake Washington shoreline in Renton. • Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts File No.: LUA-10-050, EFC, SM, SMC October 4, 2010 Page 5 20. A sewer line is located in the lake bed outward from the work site and will not be affected by the installations. CONCLUSIONS: 1. The criteria for approving a Shoreline Conditional Use permit are twofold. There are City criteria and those City criteria require compliance with additional State criteria. Those criteria are as follows: Renton: Section 4-9-190.I.5: 5. Conditional Use: a. Purpose: Upon proper application, a conditional use permit may be granted. The objective of a conditional use provision is to provide more control and flexibility for implementing the regulations of the Master Program. With provisions to control undesirable effects, the scope of uses can be expanded to include many uses. Decision Criteria: Uses classified as conditional uses can be permitted only after consideration and by meeting such performance standards that make the use compatible with other permitted uses within that area. A conditional use permit will be granted subject to each of the following conditions: i. The use must be compatible with other permitted uses within that area. ii. The use will not interfere with the public use of public shorelines. iii. Design of the site will be compatible with the surroundings and the City's Master Program. iv. The use shall be in harmony with the general purpose and intent of the City's Master Program. v. The use meets the conditional use criteria in WAC 173-27-160. Washington State: WAC 173-27-160: Review criteria for conditional use permits. The purpose of a conditional use permit is to provide a system within the master program which allows flexibility in the application of use regulations in a manner consistent with the policies ofRCW 90.58.020. In authorizing a conditional use, special conditions may be attached to the permit by local government or the department to prevent undesirable effects of the proposed use and/or to assure consistency of the project with the act and the local master program. (I) Uses which are classified or set forth in the applicable master program as conditional uses may be authorized provided that the applicant demonstrates all of the following: (a) That the proposed use is consistent with the policies ofRCW 90.58.020 and the master program; (b) That the proposed use will not interfere with the normal public use of public shorelines; Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts File No.: LUA-10-050, EFC, SM, SMC October 4, 2010 Page 6 ( c) That the proposed use of the site and design of the project is compatible with other authorized uses within the area and with uses planned for the area under the comprehensive plan and shoreline master program; ( d) That the proposed use will cause no significant adverse effects to the shoreline environment in which it is to be located; and (e) That the public interest suffers no substantial detrimental effect. (2) In the granting of all conditional use permits, consideration shall be given to the cumulative impact of additional requests for like actions in the area. For example, if conditional use permits were granted for other developments in the area where similar circumstances exist, the total of the conditional uses shall also remain consistent with the policies ofRCW 90.58.020 and shall not produce substantial adverse effects to the shoreline environment. (3) Other uses which are not classified or set forth in the applicable master program may be authorized as conditional uses provided the applicant can demonstrate consistency with the requirements of this section and the requirements for conditional uses contained in the master program. ( 4) Uses which are specifically prohibited by the master program may not be authorized pursuant to either subsection(]) or (2) of this section. 2. The comprehensive plan calls for single family uses in this area of the shoreline and the area is zoned for residential uses. Many residential properties along Renton's Lake Washington shoreline are served by docks and piers. Boatlifts are becoming more common and a number of lifts have been approved in the last year or two. The lifts are proposed for the private areas of lake shoreline and the adjacent uplands although they are located in the lake. Generally they are non-intrusive visually and as noted, have become a more common element of already permitted pocks and piers. In this case the joint-use element of this dock-lift complex does get a bit on the commercial or industrial side of the scale with the long dock, two finger piers and the four lifts. At the same time, the joint-use nature has prevented two more parallel docks from being constructed into the lake just north of this site. The lifts should not present an unusual obstacle to navigation as the dock already extends out into the lake in this area. 3. The proposed lifts should not interfere with public use of the shoreline, particularly since this is a private shoreline. Again, the dock is already permitted in this area. 4. The next series of criteria are contained within the Washington Administrative Code. One of the paramount goals is to protect the ecology of the shoreline. The applicant proposes a fully grated deck for the larger platform lift and the other lifts are open structures. The lifts will be out in the lake and not affect the actual shoreline, although the lifts will obviously permit and encourage boating on the lake. 5. The lot is private and extends out into the lake. The proposed lifts will serve this lot and its two northerly neighboring lots. Private uses are permitted in this area of the shoreline. The use is similar to those uses permitted in an urban shoreline. The use should not impair the public use of this section of the lakeshore or the water in its vicinity. 6. The lifts should not interfere with any uses that might occur in this area of the lake. The comprehensive plan designates this area as suitable for residential uses and the usual complement of accessory uses. On a lakeshore property, piers, docks and similar uses including the proposed lift would be considered reasonable accessory uses. • ' Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts File No.: LUA-10-050, EFC, SM, SMC October 4, 2010 Page 7 7. The proposed lifts should not create any significant adverse affects on the shoreline environment. The pier and lifts should not further harm the public interest. 8. As noted in earlier decisions, the analysis of cumulative impact or impacts is hard to judge. This is an urban shoreline of Lake Washington and piers have been an accepted accessory use of waterfront property and others already exist in Renton and surrounding shoreline areas. The lifts and pilings would be located shoreward of the pier's end. Any number of docks already protrude out into the lake from many of the homes along the shore. Clearly, there have had to be impacts to water quality and habitat as a result of motor boating and docks shading the lake and some of the shallow areas. This additional action will probably not have much of a significant effect on the lake or shore. 9. Since lifts are neither permitted nor prohibited outright, it requires review under the Conditional Use criteria. The proposed use is generally consistent with the criteria noted above. 10. The only issue that should be clarified is the nature of the relationship between the three parcels and the joint use nature of the dock and the new lifts. The sale of any of the homes should not be permitted to upset the joint use agreement nor be used to justify the installation of any new dock or lifts for any of the two remaining parcels. Restrictive covenants should be executed that specify that the dock and lifts located at the subject site shall be the only dock and lifts allowed for any of the three parcels and that no additional docks or lifts shall be permissible at any of the three parcels. The covenants shall also specify ownership and access rights and maintenance. RECOMMENDATION: The Conditional Use Permit and the Shoreline Substantial Development Permit for the hoatlifts, platform lift and jet ski lift should be approved subject to the following conditions: 1 . The applicant shall comply with the mitigation measures imposed by the Environmental Review Committee in its Determination of Non-Significance -Mitigated issued on August 30, 201 O; 2. The applicant shall prepare a restrictive covenant with the appropriate signatures of the property owners and recorded with King County. The document shall specify ownership rights and maintenance provisions for the watercraft lifts. The restrictive covenant shall contain a statement that the covenant shall remain with the property and can only he released by written permission granted by the City of Renton. A copy of the restrictive covenant shall be provided to the Planning Division project manager for review and approval prior to recording with King County. Building permits for the watercraft lifts may be issued only subsequent to recording the restrictive covenant. 3. The applicant shall comply with all construction conditions by the State agencies and all construction conditions provided in the application submitted to the City. 4. Restrictive covenants shall be executed that specify that the dock and lifts located at the subject site shall be the only dock and lifts allowed for any of the three parcels and that no additional docks or lifts shall be permissible at any of the three parcels. As noted above, the covenants shall also specify ownership and access rights and maintenance. Having reviewed the record in this matter, the Examiner now makes and enters the following: Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts File No.: LUA-10-050, EFC, SM, SMC October 4, 2010 Page 8 ORDERED UilS 4th day of October 2010. FREDI.KA HEARING E TRANSMITTED nns 4th day of October 2010 to the parties ofrecord: Gerald Wasser Robert Cugini Alan Foltz 1055 S Grady Way Renton, WA 98057 Barbee Mill Company Waterfront Construction, Inc. 205 Northlake Way, Ste. 230 Seattle, WA 98105 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N. Renton, WA 98056 TRANSMITTED TIDS 4th day of October 2010 to the following: Mayor Denis Law Jay Covington, Chief Administrative Officer Julia Medzegian, Council Liaison Marty Wine, Assistant CAO Gregg Zimmerman, PW Administrator Alex Pietsch, CED Administrator Jennifer Henning, Current Planning Manager Stacy Tucker, Planning Division Dave Pargas, Fire Marshal Larry Meckling, Building Official Planning Commission Transportation Division Utilities Division Neil Watts, Development Services Janet Conklin, Development Services Renton Reporter Pursuant to Title N, Chapter 8, Section lOOGofthe City's Code, request for reconsideration must be filed in writing on or before 5:00 p.m., October 18, 2010 Any aggrieved person feeling that the decision of the Examiner is ambiguous or based on erroneous procedure, errors of law or fact, error in judgment, or the discovery of new evidence which could not be reasonably available at the prior hearing may make a written request for a review by the Examiner within fourteen (14) days from the date of the Examiner's decision. This request shall set forth the specific ambiguities or errors discovered by such appellant, and the Examiner may, after review of the record, take further action as he deems proper. An appeal to the City Council is governed by Title N, Chapter 8, Section 110, which requires that such appeal be filed with the City Clerk, accompanying a filing fee of $250.00 and meeting other specified requirements. Copies of this ordinance are available for inspection or purchase in the Finance Department, first floor of City Hall. An appeal must be filed in writing on or before 5:00 p.m., October 21, 2010. If the Examiner's Recommendation or Decision contains the requirement for Restrictive Covenants, the executed Covenants will be required prior to approval by City Council or final processing of the file. You may contact this office for information on formatting covenants. The Appearance of Fairness Doctrine provides that no ex parte (private one-on-one) communications may occur concerning pending land use decisions. This means that parties to a land use decision may not communicate in private with any decision-maker concerning the proposal. Decision-makers in the land use process include both the Hearing Examiner and members of the City Council. f Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts File No.: LUA-10-050, EFC, SM, SMC October 4, 2010 Page 9 All communications concerning the proposal must be made in public. This public communication permits all interested parties to know the contents of the communication and would allow them to openly rebut the evidence. Any violation of this doctrine would result in the invalidation of the request by the Court. The Doctrine applies not only to the initial public hearing but to all Requests for Reconsideration as well as Appeals to the City Council. B4 -29 T24N RSE W 1/2 COR !-r ·---·-,R-~ '";:=~~~~=!R=-8~·=!=!==~:=:!~~ ---L.-I ! ; r Nllnl!a. >----~Ui : )-,1 ( /-} ! 1 ' : 1~-r '1 :-/-i i r/"Tr ; !R~! ! ·-· ~-~; iR-S ! l : : 1 i / _1_1_µ_;1u ,~-1 : :---- _L __ ,-.!-·; Jl,8-.-· ~-' I R-(! / ( ( ; i' I I i '1: { '..', I 1 • , ; ';'I' i J I J I ! '' ; : ··:~M~J,.~ ' ' CN 1 , 1 : uRHi 11 r: i ! ·-· i i i iR-8 ! ! i i ,_, _[Ji! ; /; i j ! ~t) ''7'7ff'; (_'.J-_i -·~(~' =;==;~'9f:::!:k,~ ,,,,, ZONING MAP BOOK PW TECHNICAL SERVICES PRINTED ON 11/l3/09 'IN,_,_,..l<a .... _.--i .............. __ ndl,MIHan "'" ___ ... ,""' ..... _ --~-..-aq,~-..... D4 -05 T23N RSE W 1/2 1),0. 200 400 Hd 1,eei 1:4,'800 CA EXHIBIT 6 __ ./ CA-- / .--L R'f--, ,---~--·- R-1 RC C4 32 T24N RSE W 1/2 5432 i ! Note: 1 Boatlift frames ·are 10' x 14' over·an with four (4) R 1' sq. foot\pads. Platform Lift uses boatlift frnme, V11,ith a 10' x 20' full)' grakd plafform. Dock mounted Jetsld Lift I Framing is 4' x G' overall. I I L.-, 7'-10~" r (2) PROPOSED FREE STANDING BOATLIFTS 14'-2" ~ 7'-2" J5'± .__ ___ __, T PROPOSED JCTSKI LIFT PROPOSED PLATFORM LIFT EXISTING PLANTING PLAN EXISTING RAMP >------+--------87'....:5" -----+---------+---- EiXISTING FULLY GRATED PIER I , PR©POSED MmGATION: EXISTING PILING / \ , (.3)112" CREOSOTE WOOD MOORING PILES PER (DOLPHIN) ~IBE REPLACED WITH (1) 12' STEEL PILE p~ &c:::::::::::::::::::::::::;::::,, & & ------ ---r-------1, I -----N 88'49 135" w 344.69' --= iPROPOSED MmGAllON, OHWL 21.80' j{3) 1~" CREOSOTE WOOD MOORING PILES PER (DOLPHIN) DETAIL VIEW ·ro sE REPlACED WITH (1) 12" STEEL PILE ' EXISTING FULLY GRATED PIER _[ 2'-7" (2) PROPOSED FREE STANDING BOATLIFTS SCALE: 1"=20' PROPOSED JETSKI LIFT ELEVATION VIEW REFERENCE: #: EXISTING ROCK BULKHEAD EXISTING SPAWNING GRAVEL \ EXIST/NG PILING 20· 15' 10' 5' Q' 20· !APPLICANT; BARBEE MILL CO, INC. C/o ROBERT CUGINI PROPOSED, INSTALL (2) NEW BOATLIFTS, (1) SC.ALE: 1 "=20' JCTSKl LIFT ANO i.!_1 PLATFORM LIFT. NEAR/AT: RENTON SHEET: 3 OF: 3 QATE: 6-29-10 IDWG#: 10-37022-A.3~1 ------· ~---·---~· --------- ~ IL1 >~~vi s~co :r· ~8 ~~~~ 1~~~, o~~-u, ·o ~:ro~:;-, ;o ~gi,j"'O~ ~ ;:;Ii, i:!1& n ~e~i!n ~ o~--1~~ Cl ~:.:io.,,\J\ 0 :Em::Ofr :z: 8=-r,~c ~ z:::C i::TT1p,_. ~§8]3 ~ 9:t~~-~ 3 ~::e}!;~ _::ooM z=Jr;u r, ri! ,.,, ;;i Zoo ~~ z ~ ::r: .... 0:, .... -I .i::,. CITY OF RENTON DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNTY & ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT -PLANNING DIVISION AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAILING On the 21st day of September, 2010, I deposited in the mails of the United States, a sealed envelope containing Preliminary Report to the Hearing Examiner documents. This information was sent to: Name Alan Foltz Robert Cugini -Barbee Mill (Signature of Sender): STATE OF WASHINGTON ) ) ss COUNTY OF KING ) Dated: 'J:rph:-,ViA,-r:·-,, I )( ,j((i. ' Representing Contact Owner/Applicant ,j,/ ,,d ;;,,if(/ ( , Notary Publi<ln and tor' the State of Washington Notary (Print): ____ _:_/ i...:·...:'..c'./~. __.-....:..,•' ""'.""""-''s.,:I_' ----------- My appointment expires: DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT HEARING EXAMINER PUBLIC HEARING September 28, 2010 AGENDA COMMENCING AT 9;00 AM, COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 7TH FLOOR, RENTON CITY HALL The application(s) listed are in order of application number only and not necessarily the order in which they will be heard. Items will be called for hearing at the discretion of the Hearing Examiner. PROJECT NAME: North Renton Professional Bldg PROJECT NUMBER: LUAl0-003 PROJECT DESCRIPTION: The applicant is requesting a Rebuild Approval Permit for a non-conforming medical office use and office building, located in the Residential 8 dwelling units per acre (R-8) and Residential 10 dwelling units per acre (R-10) zones. PROJECT NAME; Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts PROJECT NUMBER: LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC PROJECT DESCRIPTION: The applicant is requesting approval of a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit and a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit for the installation of two 10-foot by 14-foot freestanding boatlifts, one 10-foot by 20-foot freestanding boatlift with a fully grated platform, and one dock- mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock which serves three single-family residential lots in the R-8 zone. HEX Agenda 9-28-10.doc PUBLIC HEARING A. PUBLIC HEARING DATE: Project Nome: Owner/Applicant: Contact: File Number: Project Manager: Project Summary: Project Location: Exist. Bldg. Area SF: Site Area: HEX Rpt.10-050.doc City-, Renton Department of Community & Economic Development PRELIMINARY REPORT TO THE HEARING EXAMINER SUMMARY AND PURPOSE OF REQUEST September 28, 2010 Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts Barbee Mill Company, 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N., Renton, WA 98056/Robert Cugini, Barbee Mill Company, 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N., Renton, WA 98056 Alan Foltz, Waterfront Construction, Inc., 205 Northlake Way, Suite 230, Seattle, WA 98105 LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC Gerald C. Wasser, Associate Planner The applicant is requesting approval of a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit and a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit for the installation of two 10-foot by 14-foot freestanding boatlifts, one 10-foot by 20-foot freestanding boatlift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock which serves three single-family residential lots in the R-8 zone. Each of the freestanding watercraft lifts would rest directly on the lake bottom on four 12-inch by 12-inch footpads. The existing fully-grated 118- foot, 6-inch dock is comprised of a ramp (4 feet, 6 inches in width, and 31 feet long), and dock (7 feet, 10 3/4-inches in width and 86 feet, 6-inches in length) with two (7-foot, 2-inch wide by 27-foot long) fully-grated finger docks. The proposed project also encompasses the removal of six 12-inch diameter creosote-treated wood piles and replacing them with two vibratory pile-driven 12-inch diameter steel piles. All work would take place within the Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife fish window for this section of Lake Washington, July 16 through December 31. 3905 Lake Washington Boulevard North N/A Proposed New Bldg. Area (gross): N/A 8,870 sf N/A Project Location Map City of Renton Department Community & Ee Barbee Mill vyatercraft Lifts ic Development Preliminary Report to the Hearing Examiner LUAW-050 ECF, SM, SMC Report of September 28, 2010 Page 2 of8 ~ B. -EXHIBITS: Exhibit 1: Project file ("yellow file") containing the application, reports, staff comments, and other material pertinent to the review of the project. Exhibit 2: Vicinity Map and Area Map Exhibit 3: Plot Plan Exhibit 4: Detail View and Elevation View Exhibit 5: Aerial Photograph -Homes Served by Joint Use Dock Exhibit 6: Zoning Map, Sheet C4, WY, Exhibit 7: ERC Determination Exhibit 8: ERC Mitigation Measures Exhibit 9: ERC Advisory Notes Exhibit 10: Shoreline Substantial Development Permit GENERAL INFORMATION: 1. Owners of Record: Barbee Mill Company, 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N., Renton, WA 98056 2. Zoning Designation: 3. Comprehensive Plan Land Use Designation: Residential-8 dwelling units per acre (R-8) zone Residential Single Family (RSF) 4. Existing Site Use: Joint use dock in association with a single-family residence 5. Neighborhood Characteristics: North: Townhouses (Conner Homes at Barbee Mill) -COR zoning East: BNSF Railroad tracks, Lake Washington Blvd. N., single-family residences -R-8 zoning South: Single-family residences -R-8 zoning West: Lake Washington 6. Access: Lake Washington Boulevard North 7. Site Area: 8,870 sf 8. Project Data: Area Comments Existing dock/pier area: 1,200 sf N/A HEX Rpt.10-050.doc City of Renton Department Community & Ee Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts Report of September 28, 2010 ic Development Preliminary Report to the Hearing Examiner WAl0-050 ECF, 5M, SMC Page 3 of 8 ~II o_, __ H1_s_To_R_1CA_L/_B_A_cK_G_R_o_u_ND_: _____________________ J Action Annexation Comprehensive Plan Zoning Shoreline Variance Shoreline Permit Land Use File No. N/A N/A N/A LUA 01-015 LUA 01-015 Ordinance No. 1800 5099 5100 N/A N/A APPLICABLE SECTIONS OF THE RENTON MUNICIPAL CODE: 1, Chapter 2 Zoning Districts -Uses & Standards Date 10/14/1959 11/01/2004 11/01/2004 01/24/2003 04/10/2002 Section 4-2-llOA: Development Standards for Residential Zoning Designations 2. Chapter 3 Environmental Regulations and Special Districts Section 4-3-050: Critical Areas Regulations Section 4-3-090: Shoreline Master Program Regulations 3, Chapter 9 Procedures and Review Criteria Section 4-9-190: Shoreline Permits 4. Chapter 11 Definitions APPLICABLE SECTIONS OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN: L Land Use Element: Residential Single Family objectives and policies. 2. Environmental Element: Fisheries and Wildlife Resources objectives and policies. DEPARTMENT ANALYSIS: 1. Project Description/Background J The applicant, Robert Cugini, requests approval of a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit and a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit for the installation of two 10-foot by 14-foot freestanding boatlifts, one 10-foot by 20-foot freestanding platform boatlift, and one dock- mounted jet ski lift. The boatlifts would be pre-manufactured and would be uncovered. Both the freestanding boat and platform lifts would each rest on four 12-inch square footpads directly on the lake bottom. The freestanding platform boatlift would have a fully grated platform that would allow an intermediate level for safe boarding of smaller watercraft vessels during the approximately 8 months of the year when the lake is at low water levels. All of the proposed watercraft lifts would be in association with an existing 118-foot, 6-inch long fully- grated dock comprised of a ramp (4 feet, 6 inches in width, and 31 feet long), and dock (7 feet, 10 3/4-inches in width and 86 feet, 6-inches in length) with two (7-foot, 2-inch wide by 27-foot long) finger docks. The joint use dock serves three detached single-family residences (3905, 3907, and 3909 Lake Washington Boulevard North). The proposal is located within the waters of Lake Washington, a Shoreline of Statewide Significance. The proposal also includes the removal of six 12-inch diameter creosote treated wood piles (two dolphins with configurations of three piles each) that would be replaced with two 12-inch steel piles. A vibratory HEX Rpt.10-050.doc City of Renton Department Community & Ee Ba__rlJ.ee Mill Watercraft Lifts ic Development Preliminary Report to the Hearing Examiner LUAl0-050 ECF, SM, SMC Report of September 28, 2010 Page 4 of 8 2. 3. extraction/insertion system would be used for this activity, and the applicant proposes to install an in-water silt curtain for containment. Delivery of the lifts would be accomplished via construction barge. Installation of the watercraft lifts would take approximately one to three days, and would be conducted during the Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife fish window for this section of Lake Washington, July 16 through December 31. Environmental Review Pursuant to the City of Renton's Environmental Ordinance and SEPA (RCW 43.21C, 1971 as amended) on August 30, 2010 the Environmental Review Committee (ERC) issued a Determination of Non-Significance -Mitigated (DNS-M) for the Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts. A 14-day appeal period ended on September 17, 2010. As of the date of this report, no appeals of the threshold determination were filed. Compliance with ERC Mitigation Measures Based on an analysis of probable impacts from the proposal, the Environmental Review Committee (ERC) issued on August 30, 2009 the following mitigation measures with the Determination of Non-Significance -Mitigated: 1. A hanging silt curtain shall be installed around the project area prior to commencement of work and shall remain in place until project completion. 2. Construction shall take place only during the Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife approved construction window for this portion of Lake Washington, from July 16 through December 31. 4. Staff Review Comments Representatives from various city departments have reviewed the application materials to identify and address site plan issues from the proposed development. These comments are contained in the official file, and the essence of the comments has been incorporated into the appropriate sections of this report and the Departmental Recommendation at the end of the report. 5. Consistency with Shoreline Conditional Use Criteria: RMC Section 4-9-190.1 lists 5 criteria that the Hearing Examiner is asked to consider when making a decision on a Shoreline Conditional Use application. These include the following: (1) The use must be compatible with other permitted uses within the area. The applicant proposes to install two 10-foot by 14-foot freestanding boatlifts, one 10-foot by 20-foot freestanding boatlift, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in conjunction with an existing joint use dock in association with three single-family residences on the shore of Lake Washington. The waterfront in the immediate vicinity of the proposed project along this portion of Lake Washington is currently being developed with residential water-dependent uses. Additionally, water-dependent uses exist to the south and to the north. The site currently does not include watercraft lifts. Other recently approved docks and boatlifts include: a single-family dock and boatlift located at 3405 Lake Washington Blvd. N. (LUAl0-011); a HEX Rpt.10-050.doc City of Renton Department Community & Ee Barbee M_ill Watercraf!: _L_ifts_ ·~ Report of September 28, 2010 ic Development Preliminary Report to the Hearing Examiner WAl0-050 ECF, SM, SMC Page 5 of 8 single-family dock and boatlift at 3411 Lake Washington Blvd. N.; a joint use dock and four mooring pilings in association with two townhouse units located at 4057 and 4063 Williams Avenue N (LUA09-045); a dock and boatlift in association with a single family residence located at 3707 Lake Washington Blvd. N. (LUA09-006); and a boatlift in association with an existing single family residential dock located at 3709 Lake Washington Blvd. N. (LUA08-047). (2) The use will not inte,fere with the public use of public shorelines. The subject site is along private shoreline. The proposed boatlifts and jet ski lift would be installed in association with an existing joint use dock located along the shore of Lake Washington. The proposed project would meet City of Renton. development standards and Building Code requirements. The proposed use would provide full time moorage opportunities for the property owners and transient moorage for their guests. The proposal would not alter the public's ability to access the shoreline. Nearby public access to the Lake Washington shoreline is provided within the Barbee Mill Plat located to the north via a trail along the south side of May Creek. (3) Design of the site will be compatible with the surroundings and the City's Master Program. The proposed boatlifts and jet ski lift would be associated with an existing joint use dock. The proposed watercraft lifts are compatible with other properties in the surrounding area in that individual docks and joint use docks with associated watercraft lifts are found on many individual waterfront properties. The City's Shoreline Master Program (WAC 173-26-230 b) states the design and construction shall avoid or, if that is not possible, shall minimize and mitigate the impacts to ecological functions and critical areas resources. The existing joint use dock is compatible with the objectives and policies of the City's Master Program as an accessory water use to existing residential uses. The fully grated design of the existing joint use dock and proposed 10-foot by 20-foot platform boatlift mitigate and minimize impacts to ecological functions and critical areas resources. (4) The use shall be in harmony with the general purpose and intent of the City's Master Program. The City's Shoreline Master Program gives preference to uses which preserve the natural character of the shoreline; result in long-term over short-term benefit; and, protect the resources and ecology of the shoreline. The existing dock is a residential accessory use often associated with waterfront residences. Boatlifts and jet ski lifts are commonly associated with residential docks and provide a way of securing watercraft to docks. The existing dock is fully grated allowing light to pass through. The proposed 10-foot by 20-foot platform boatlift would be fully grated as well. These enhancements would aid in the preservation of the natural character and would protect the resources and ecology of the shoreline while resulting in long term benefit. (5) The use meets the conditional use criteria in WAC 173-27-160, to provide o system within the Master Program, which allows flexibility in the application of use regulations in a manner consistent with the policies of RCW 90.58.020. In authorizing a conditional HEX Rpt.10-050.doc City of Renton Deportment Community & Ee ~arbee MH! _~atercraft lifts ic Development Preliminary Report to the Hearing Examiner ... _WAl0:050 ECF, SNI, SMC Report of September 28, 2010 Page 6 of 8 use, special conditions may be attached to the permit by local government or the department to prevent undesirable effects of the proposed use and/or to assure consistency of the project with the act and the local master program. (A) Uses which are classified or set forth in the application master program as conditional uses may be authorized provided that the applicant demonstrates all the following: i) That the proposed use is consistent with the policies of RCW 90.58.020 and the master program. Lake Washington is classified as a Shoreline of Statewide Significance. Watercraft lifts are often considered appurtenances to residential docks in that they provide a more secure moorage for watercraft. RCW 90.58.020 allows for alterations of the natural condition of the Shorelines of the State in those limited instances when authorized. To this end, single-family residences and their appurtenant structures are allowed. ii) That the proposed use will not interfere with the normal public use of public shorelines. The subject site is a single-family residential private property on the shore of Lake Washington. No interference with the normal public use of public shoreline is anticipated to occur as the site does not directly abut a public shoreline. Further, the proposed use would not preclude normal and customary use of the waters of Lake Washington. iii} That the proposed use of the site and design of the project is compatible with other authorized uses within the area and with uses planned for the area under the comprehensive plan and shoreline master program. The subject site is designated Residential Single Family in the City's Comprehensive Plan which allows for high quality single-family projects. The Shoreline Master Program permits joint-use residential docks. The proposed watercraft lifts are similar to other bo~tlifts and jet ski lifts approved and/or used in the vicinity; watercraft lifts offer a secure method of moorage for watercraft. As noted previously in this report, joint-use docks and associated watercraft lifts have recently been approved in the vicinity. iv} That the proposed use will cause no significant adverse effects to the shoreline environment in which it is to be located. This section of Lake Washington is designated as Urban Environment in the Shoreline Master Program regulations and is being developed with residential uses. If the watercraft lifts are installed. and maintained according to all required state and local permits, the use is not expected to cause significant adverse effects to the shoreline environment. Staff recommends as a condition of approval that a restrictive covenant specifying ownership rights and maintenance provisions for the watercraft lifts shall be prepared with the appropriate signatures of the property owners and recorded with King County. The restrictive covenant shall contain a statement that the HEX Rpt.10-050.doc City of Renton Department Community & Ee Barbee Mill Watercraft lifts 'iC Development Prelimina,y Report to the Hearing Examiner LUA10-D5D ECF, 5M, SMC Report of September 28, 2010 Page 7 of 8 covenant shall remain with the property and can only be released by written permission granted by the City of Renton. A copy shall be provided to the Planning Division project manager for review and approval prior to recording with King County. Building permits for the watercraft lifts may be issued only subsequent to recording the restrictive covenant. v) That the public interest suffers no substantial detrimental effects. Because the site is a private residential single-family use and watercraft lifts are the only proposed uses on the site at this time, it is not anticipated that any significant detrimental effects would occur. The proposed watercraft lifts would be associated with an existing dock and no adverse impacts to shoreline views are anticipated. (B) In the granting of all conditional use permits, consideration shall be given to the cumulative impact of additional requests for like actions in the area. This residential site is similar to other properties in the immediate vicinity. The proposed watercraft lifts are compatible with the adjacent residential properties. The applicant proposes to locate the proposed watercraft lifts in conjunction with an existing dock and it is anticipated that no adverse cumulative impact would occur based on this proposal. Completion of this project would not promote future construction or other activities that would not otherwise occur without its completion; and no additional interrelated or interdependent actions that could affect species regulated under the Endangered Species Act will occur because ofthis project. (C) Other uses which are not classified or set forth in the applicable master program may be authorized as conditional uses provided the applicant can demonstrate consistency with the requirements of this section and the requirements for conditional uses contained in the master program. Watercraft lifts are not uses currently set forth in the Shoreline Master Program. Therefore, this project requires a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit. Watercraft lifts provide a secure moorage for watercraft and are commonly considered an appurtenance to residential docks. The criteria discussed in this report have demonstrated the applicant's request is consistent with the requirements. (D) Uses which are specifically prohibited by the master program may not be authorized pursuant to either subsection (A} or {BJ of this section. Watercraft lifts are not specifically prohibited by the City's Shoreline Master Program. HEX Rpt.10-050.doc City of Renton Department Community & Ee Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts ,;c Development Preliminary Report to the Hearing Examiner LUAl0-050 ECF, SM, SMC Report of September 28, 2010 Page 8 of 8 I_H. SHORELINE SUBSTANTIAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT A Shoreline Substantial Development Permit is required for the proposed dock and a boatlift or two mooring pilings on either side of the dock. The following sections/pages of the Master Program are applicable to the development: RMCSection Description Page 4-3-090.J Urban Environment page 3-25 4-3-090.K. General Use Regulations for All Shoreline Uses Page 3-26 4-3-090.L Specific Use Regulations page 3-27 4-3-090.M. Variances and Conditional Uses page 3-39 4-9-190.1.1, 2, 3, 5 Variances and Conditional Uses Page 9-54 Pursuant to chapter 90.58 RCW, staff recommends that a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit be granted subject to the following condition: (1) The applicant shall comply with all construction conditions by the State agencies and all construction conditions provided in the application and modifications submitted to the City. The Shoreline Substantial Development Permit for the Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts project is provided in Exhibit 10. RECOMMENDATION: ] Based on the analysis contained in this report, staff believes that the proposed project is consistent with criteria necessary for Shoreline Conditional Use and Shoreline Substantial Development Permits. Therefore, staff recommends approval of the Shoreline Conditional Use and Shoreline Substantial Development Permits for the Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts, Project File No. LUAl0-050 ECF, SM, SMC subject to the following conditions: 1. The applicant shall comply with the mitigation measures imposed by the Environmental Review Committee in its Determination of Non-Significance -Mitigated issued on August 30, 2010; 2. The applicant shall prepare a restrictive covenant with the appropriate signatures of the property owners and recorded with King County. The document shall specify ownership rights and maintenance provisions for the watercraft lifts. The restrictive covenant shall contain a statement that the covenant shall remain with the property and can only be released by written permission granted by the City of Renton. A copy of the restrictive covenant shall be provided to the Planning Division project manager for review and approval prior to recording with King County. Building permits for the watercraft lifts may be issued only subsequent to recording the restrictive covenant. 3. The applicant shall comply with all construction conditions by the State agencies and all construction conditions provided in the application submitted to the City. HEX Rpt.10-050.doc t I City ot Renton Plarming Division PROJECf DES,G'ED SY IRi ff"~ (C ~ ~ ~ ~ [g) Waterfrmt Con5truction Inc. 1 c;, THIS DOCUMENT IS PROPRIETARY PROPERTY OF WATERFRONT CONSTRUCTION INC .. AND IS NOT TO BE USED, IN WHOLE OR IN PART, FOR ANY OTHER PROJECT WITHOUT THE WRITTEN AUTHORIZATION OF WATERFRONT CONSTRUCTION INC. LAKE WASH1NGTO/\!. · JOBi. SITE VICINITY MAP /NO SCALE LEGAL DESCRIPTION 1/4 SEC: NW-32-24-5 TAXLOT #; 334270 0011 LAT: 47.526985 (47" 31' 37.15" N) LONG: -122.205604 (122' 12' 20.17" W) HILLMANS LK WN GARDEN OF EDEN #2 "LOT O" RENTON LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT NO LUA-96-153LLA-LND-30-0152 REC NO 20061002900012 SD LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT OAF LOTS 1 THRU 13 IN BLOCK A OF HILLMANS LAKE WASHINGTON GARDEN OF EDEN DIV NO 2 PLAT TGW SH LOS ADS AND TGW THE NWLY 25.00 FT OF BNSF ROW LY 81WN TWO LNS DRAWN PLW & DIST 25.00 AND 50.00 FT NWLY AS MEAS AT R/A FR MAIN TRACK C/L BOUNDED ON THE NORTH BY THE ELY EXTN OF THE NORTH LN OF LOT 1 AND BOUNDED ON THE SOUTH BY THE ELY EXTN OF THE SOUTH LN OF LOT 13 OF SD HILLMANS LAKE WASHINGTON GARDEN OF EDEN DIV 2 PURPOSE: PROVIDE OUT OF WATER BOAT MOORAGE PROJECT NAME: BARBEE MILL CO. INC. DATUM: COE o.o· EST 1919 ADJACENT OWNERS: G) BARBEE FOREST PRODUCTS INC 3907 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA. 98056 2 BOYDSTON TONY 3901 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA. 98056 REFERENCE #: SITE LOCATION ADDRESS: 3905 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA. 98056 DWG#: 10-37022-A.1-1 lAKE FOREST PARK w _J ~ w U) EXHIBIT 2 KENMORE KIRKLAND MEDINA BELLEVUE RENTON t I AREA MAP/Scale:1 "=3miles 3 MILES 0 3 MILES 1 MILE PROPOSED: INSTALL (2) NEW BOATLIFTS, (1) JETSKI LIFT AND (1) PLATFORM LIFT. JOINT USE PIER IN: LAKE WASHJNGTON NEAR: RENTON COUNTY: KING STATE: WA APPL BY: BARBEE MILL CO. INC. c/o ROBERT CUGINJ SHEET: 1 OF: 3 DATE: 6-29-10 t ' Note~ Boatlift frames are 10' x 14' overall with four (4) -l I sq. foot pads. Platform Lift uses boatlift frame, with a 10' x 20' fully grated platform. Dock mounted Jetski Lift Framing is 4' x 6' overall. I I I I I I CD BARBEE FOREST PRODUCTS INC 3907 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA. S6056 ---7 I I I I I-+--____________ s_a~~E-_______ _ §I f} I @; "'; f; ;;; . I ""I ". :::I (2) I 34' 1 JOB SITE 3905 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA. 98056 PROPOSED JETSKI LIFT OHWL 21.80' @ FACE OF BULKHEAD EXISTING ROCK BULKHEAD "' I .f? I .~! "I "I r-------11 s'-6" ..%', I EXISTING DOLPHINS J!:4). _ ..... -.. IF:f_-:, I N 8~49'35" W t'.i'.69' jlLr---_-::_.L.....---, EXISTING BOATLIFT EXISTING PIER EXISTING JETSKI LIFT EXISTING DECK ROPOSED MmGATION: 3901 (3) 12" CREOSOTE WOOD MOORING PILES PER (DOLPHIN) TO BE REPLACED wrrH ( 1) 12" STEEL PILE PLOT PLAN 40· 30· 20· 1 o· o· SCALE: 1 "-40' @ BOYDSTON TONY LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA; 98056 40' I REFERENCE u, / / / / / I / I / IAPPLICAITT:BARBEE -MILL CO. INC. c/o ROBERT CUGINI PROPOSED; INSTALL (2) NEW BOATLIFTS, (1) JETSKI LIFT ANO ~ PLATFORM LIFT. NEAR/AT: RENTON SHEET: 2 OF; 3 DATE: §::29~ _ IDWG#: 10-37022 A.2-1 n ~" cl VI;!; ,,. :!ii ;/ {ll ~-~~8 ~g~~ ~:,.Z~~ "z n "el': ~~~vi(\) ~i6~~ i:,:;,vi~Q ;:;j-o o!~ aZ~ ~es"'" o"' ..... ~~ ~!40]\.J'\ g~~~2 ~o~gp,_ ;JSg:.!c,;· R~-:_o::3 5,..,z"ls- z~§:jf'i ~~w~ . ~:~ ·~ z m >< :::c '""' O:I '""' -4 w t ' Note: Boatlift frames are 10' x 14' overall with four (4) -I' sq. foot pads. Platform Lift uses boatlift frame, with a 10' x 20' fully grated platform. Dock mounted Jetski Lift Framing is 4' x 6' overall. J_ 7'-1~" I (2) PROPOSED FREE STANDING BOATLIFTS 14'-2"-i7'-2" 35'±'-c-----, I 27' PROPOSED JETSKI LIFT PROPOSED PLATFORM LIFT EXISTING PLANTING PLAN OHWL 21.80' @ FACE OF BULKHEAD EXISTING ROCK BULKHEAD 1-------+-------87'-6" ----',----------+----- OHWL 21.BD' EXISTING FULLY GRATED PROPOSED MmGATION: (3) 12" CREOSOTE WOOD MOORING PILES PER (DOLPHIN) ~ BE REPLACED WITH (1) 12" STEEL PILE p~\t. ~.!=:::==:;::;;::;;;:;;;;:;:;~~ L -------------N 88"49'35" W 344.6-;' PROPOSED MmGATJON, EXISTING PILING (3) 12" CREOSOTE WOOD MOORING PILES PER (DOLPHIN) TO BE REPLACED WITH (1) 12" STEEL PILE DETAIL VIEW SCALE: 1 "=20' (2) PROPOSED EXISTING FULLY FREE STANDING BOATUFTS GRATED PIER ..[ 2'-7" EXISTING PILING 20· 15· 10· 5' o' SCALE: 1 ",,,,20' PROPOSED JETSKI UFT 20' EXISTING RAMP REFERENCE / EXISTING ROCK BULKHEAD / \ !APPUCANT: BARBEE MILL CO. INC~o ROBERT CUGINI PROPOSED:INSTALL (2) NEW BOATLIFTS, (1) JETSKI LIFT AND i!2 PLATFORM LIFT. NEAR/AT: RENTON SHEET: 3 OF: 3 j)bfE, 6-29-10 IDWG#, 10-37022-A.3-1 n Da sl~~ >a ::O:::c:::, _-ig g Oaoc z< 0 M-C- > zz< ~!';~ S~-01 ~ Cl 18 =z-, a-~~ "~ ~,~ 2"~" ,.,,_.~~ "::l O "\l\f\ ~m;;o~ :::::/"'~~ I c:;"1\1 g~~~ -ip 0~ :i'!z""'-,..., :E ::s ~!~0 z ~Qi;) !"1 M..., ;a zoo oz z " m >< :::c 1-1 ta lo-I -t .1:1,, ~ RENTON. Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts -Homes Served by Joint-Use Dock L~k WJ~. 0.0 0 City of Re nton, W ashi ngton 0 .02 0.0 Miles Thi s m ap is a user generated static output fro m an Internet mappin g site a nd is for refere nce only. Data layers that appear on th is map may or may not be accurate, current, or othe rwise reliable . T HI S MAP IS NOT TO BE USED FOR NAVI GATION Lakes and Rivers Parcel s Stree t N ames Rights of W ay Streets Roads Ju ri sdictions Bellevue Des Moines Issaquah Kent King County Mercer Island Ne wcastl e RENTON SeaTac Seattle ffl Tu kwi la )( Aeria l (Ma r ch 2010) :J: • Red . Band_ 1 11"""4 • Green: Band_2 OJ • Blu e: Band_3 ~ l _ 1: 1,179 @ 8.5" X 11" 0 Notes Enter Map De sc ription B4 -29 T24N RSE W 1/2 COR I/ R-8 R-8 "·'!='==:;=al R-8 I i ~·as,,,si .; ~ /' ' ., f'l I u· J ~I ====:=;:;;;R-8::.::::=:::=====1~1 . ~ ::=I ====~~:·====~{ R--8 !/£al ~ /~~; ~,/~~~~~~:~;~~~~~ R--8 J N33roSI ~ I R-8 I ~=::;;;;, .... ==:'.. 111=.;;R:,;;·B~..i 1~=::::::;,;;;;=;;;•c:::::=:=::====:::::::1 R-8 N31 .. SI il.\=...,,.a===< LE __ · ____ R--s ____ .1~::-:510 ~====CN====~ ~------"''-=·---- ~.;;.;~i:~I ==::;;,;;;-;:;;.=R=-s=· ====9=·~1 .,__,,_cN_ 11,,;,;.;;...il/ ::: I~ R-8 '---..J CN ZONING MAP BOOK PW TECHNICAL SERVICES PRINTED ON 11/13/09 T~, doc,meat ~, .,,plvc <0p,0<eoLat,on, noc fl''""'""d"''"""""''"""'·""'""°"'do, '"""""'''''"""'"'" .. "'""""''""'""'''"'""" n,,,,..,~'""'""""'°'c'""',,...,.'"'"°''"°"" " ,_a 0 200 400 s I,,,, 1 ·4,800 EXHIBIT 6 CA CA ' R-8 I") "" RC .... N R-8 "'" H N "" H ~ ::c UI t"1 R t"1 R-1 ... i::, ~-·;,,---+------ R-8 R-8 N A R-8 I C4 32 T24N RSE W 1/2 5432 74 92 9~ 82~'·:83~ _'1 ' 26124N R4E 81 -94W> ~-c1 C2 36 T24N R4E j2'-, , 1 T~N""R4E I RESIDENTIAL ~ (RC) Resource Conservation [ R-: (R-1) Residential 1 du/ac ·~ ,H I (R-4) Residential 4 du/ac ~ (R-8) Residential 8 du/ac JI 1-R~~~J (RMH) Residential Manufactured Homes ~ (R-10) Residential 10 du/ac El (R-14} Residential 14 du/ac I RM+j (RM-F) Residential Multi-Family [RM-i-j (RM-T) Residential Multi-Family Traditional I '<1-1-u I (RM-U) Residential Multi-Family Urban Center T23N R5E 35 T23N R5E 36 /!>B?Hl ,f s33 ~~-~--~ !;j 101_ J 7 a 4 r°22NBSE ::'-3 r22N ASE 2 r22N R5E 1T2 MIXED USE CENTERS ~ (CV) Center Village uc-·,1 I (UC-Nl) Urban Center -North 1 LC-t~2I (UC-N2) Urban Center -North 2 I-[DJ (CD) Center Downtown COMMERCIAL [ crlR--j (COR) Commerclal/Offlce/Residential ~ (CA) Commercial Arterial ~ (CO) Commercial Office [~ -I (CN) Commercial Neighborhood INOU~!~-l~L ~ {IL) Industrial -Light ~ (IM) Industrial -Medium 0 (IH) Industrial -Heavy -----Renton City Limits -·-·--Adjaeenl City Limits KROU PAGE PAGE# INDEX DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT EXHIBIT 7 ENVIRONMENTAL (SEPA) DETERMINATION OF NON-SIGNIFICANCE APPLICATION NO(S): APPLICANT: PROJECT NAME: -MITIGATED (DNS-M) LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC Robert Cugini, Barbee Mill Company Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSAL: The applicant requests SEPA Review for the installation of two 10 ft by 14 ft freestanding boatlifts, one 10 ft by 20 ft freestanding boatlift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock. LOCATION OF PROPOSAL: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd N LEAD AGENCY: City of Renton Environmental Review Committee Department of Community & Economic Development The City of Renton Environmental Review Committee has determined that it does not have a probable significant adverse impact on the environment. An Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) is not required under RCW 43.21C.030(2)(c). Conditions were imposed as mitigation measures by the Environmental Review Committee under their authority of Section 4-6-6 Renton Municipal Code. These conditions are necessary to mitigate environmental impacts identified during the environmental review process. Appeals of the environmental determination must be filed in writing on or before 5:00 p.m. on September 17, 2010. Appeals must be filed in writing together with the required fee with: Hearing Examiner, City of Renton, 1055 South Grady Way, Renton, WA 98057. Appeals to the Examiner are governed by City of Renton Municipal Code Section 4-8-110.B. Additional information regarding the appeal process may be obtained from the Renton City Clerk's Office, (425) 430-6510. PUBLICATION DATE: DATE OF DECISION: SIGNATURES: Terry Higashiyama, Administrator Community Services Department September 3, 2010 August 30, 2010 '6 I ?.;iJ Ju J2._·____,__,,=---""---l---"''-----~~- 1 T Mark Peterson, Administrator Date Fire & Erner cy Services Date Economic Development Date Date DEPARTMENT OF COM MUI\,, / AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT EXHIBIT 8 DETERMINATION OF NON-SIGNIFICANCE-MITIGATED MITIGATION MEASURES APPLICATION NO{S): APPLICANT: PROJECT NAME: LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC Robert Cugini, Barbee Mill Company Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSAL: The applicant requests SEPA Review for the installation of two 10 ft by 14 ft freestanding boatlifts, one 10 ft by 20 ft freestanding boatlift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock. LOCATION OF PROPOSAL: LEAD AGENCY: MITIGATION MEASURES: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd N The City of Renton Department of Community & Economic Development Planning Division 1. A hanging silt containment curtain shall be installed around the project area prior to commencement of work and shall remain in place until project completion 2. Construction shall take place only during the Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife approved construction window for this portion of Lake Washington, from July 16 through December 31. ERC Mitigation Measures Page 1 of 1 DEPARTMENT OF COMMUN,, I AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT EXHIBIT 9 DETERMINATION OF NON-SIGNIFICANCE-MITIGATED ADVISORY NOTES APPLICATION NO(S): APPLICANT: PROJECT NAME: LUA10-0SO, ECF, SM, SMC Robert Cugini, Barbee Mill Company Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSAL: The applicant requests SEPA Review for the installation of two 10 ft by 14 ft freestanding boatlifts, one 10 ft by 20 ft freestanding boatlift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock. LOCATION OF PROPOSAL: LEAD AGENCY: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd N The City of Renton Department of Community & Economic Development Planning Division Advisory Notes to Applicant: The following notes ore supplemental information provided in conjunction with the environmental determination. Because these notes ore provided as information only, they are not subject to the appeal process for environmental determinations. Planning: 1. The site is designated Residential Single Family in the City's Comprehensive Plan. The site is zoned Residential -8 dwelling units per acre (R-8). 2. The Shoreline Master Program Designation is "Urban". 3. Construction activities shall be restricted to the hours between 7:00 am and 8:00 pm, Monday through Friday. Work on Saturdays shall be between the hours of 9:00 am and 8:00 pm. No work shall be permitted on Sundays. 4. The approved State of Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife {WDFW) fish window is from July 16 through December 31. 5. Project requires approval of a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit for the watercraft lifts. 6. Existing Joint Use Pier was previously approved (LUAOl-015, ECF, SV). 7. Previous conditions of approval continue to apply to the existing pier and to the addition of the boat lifts. Plan Review 1. The properties are served by the City of Renton Water Utility. 2. Cross connection control, inspection, and certification is required for any water service to the dock. 3. A water service permit is required if water service is extended to the dock. ERC Advisory Notes Page 1 of 2 4. The properties are served by the City of Renton Wastewater Utility. 5. The parcels have onsite drainage to Lake Washington. No further facilities are triggered by this proposal. 6. All plans shall conform to the Renton Drafting standards. 7. For any utility work, a construction permit is required. When plans are complete, submit three (3) copies of the drawings, a construction estimate, application and appropriate fee to the 6'h floor Customer Counter at City Hall. ERC Advisory Notes Page 2 of 2 ---· --,tyof , r I r ---· "" DEPARTMENT OF COi UNITY EXHIBIT 10 AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT PLANNINC:i UIVl!:>IUl'II SHORELINE MANAGEMENT ACT OF 1971 PERMIT FOR SHORELINE MANAGEMENT EVALUATION FORM & DECISION DATE OF PERMIT ISSUANCE: LAND USE ACTION FILE NO.: DATE RECEIVED DATE OF PUBLIC NOTICE: TYPE OF ACTION(S): LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC July 28, 2010 August 6, 2010 Substantial Development Permit Conditional Use Permit Variance Permit Pursuant to Chapter 90.58 RCW, staff recommends that the City of Renton grant a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit and a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit. This action is proposed on the following application: PROJECT NAME: PROJECT MANAGER: OWNER/ APPLICANT: CONTACT: PROJECT LOCATION: LEGAL DESCRIPTION: SEC-TWN-R: WITHIN THE SHORELINES OF: APPLICABLE MASTER PROGRAM: Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts Gerald Wasser, Associate Planner Robert Cugini, Barbee Mill Company, 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N., Renton, WA 98056 Alan Foltz, Waterfront Construction, Inc., 205 Northlake Way, Suite 230, Seattle, WA 98105 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N. See Attachment A NW 1/4 of SEC 22 -TWN 24N -R SE Lake Washington City of Renton PROPOSAL DESCRIPTION: The applicant requests approval of a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit and a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit for the installation of two 10-foot by 14-foot freestanding boatlifts, one 10-foot by 20-foot freestanding boatlift lift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock which serves three lots in the Residential -8 dwelling units per acre (R-8) zone .. Each of the freestanding watercraft lifts would rest directly on the lake bottom on four 12-inch City of Renton Department of Co, Barbe Mill Watercraft Lifts DATE OF PERMIT: ity & Economic Development Shoreline Management Permit LUAl0-050 ECF, SM, SMC Page 2 of 3 by 12-inch footpads. The existing fully-grated dock is 4-feet, 4 1/2-inches to 7-feet, 10 3/4- inches in width and 118-feet, 6-inches in length with two 27-foot fully-grated finger docks. The proposed project also encompasses the removal of six 12-inch diameter creosote-treated wood piles and replacing them with two vibratory pile-driven 12-inch diameter steel piles. All work would take place within the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife fish window for this section of Lake Washington, July 16 through December 31. The following section/page of the Master Program is applicable to the development: RMCSection 4-3-090] 4-3-090K 4-3-090L Description Urban Environment General Use Regulations for All Shoreline Uses Specific Use Regulations 4-3-090M Variances and Conditional Use permits 4-9-1901.1, 2, 3, S Variances and Conditional Uses 3-25 3-26 3-27 9-54 Development of this project shall be undertaken pursuant to the following terms and conditions: 1. The applicant shall comply with the mitigation measures imposed by the Environmental Review Committee in its Determination of Non-Significance -Mitigated issued on August 30, 2010; 2. The applicant shall prepare a restrictive covenant with the appropriate signatures of the property owners and recorded with King County. The document shall specify ownership rights and maintenance provisions for the watercraft lifts. The restrictive covenant shall contain a statement that the covenant shall remain with the property and can only be released by written permission granted by the City of Renton. A copy of the restrictive covenant shall be provided to the Planning Division project manager for review and approval prior to recording with King County. Building permits for the watercraft lifts may be issued only subsequent to recording the restrictive covenant; and 3. The applicant shall comply with all construction conditions of State agencies and all construction conditions provided in the application submitted to the City. This Permit is granted pursuant to the Shoreline Management Action of 1971 and pursuant to the following: 1. The issuance of a license under the Shoreline Management Act of 1971 shall not release the applicant from compliance with federal, state, and other permit requirements. 2. This permit may be rescinded pursuant to Section 14(7) of the Shoreline Management Act of 1971 in the event the permittee fails to comply with any condition(s) hereof. City of Renton Department of Co Barbe Mill Watercraft Lifts DATE OF PERMIT: ity & Economic Development Shoreline Management Permit WAJ0-050 ECF, SM, SMC Page 3 of 3 3. Construction permits shall not be issued until twenty-one (21) days after approval by the Washington State Department of Ecology or until any review proceedings initiated within this twenty-one (21) day review period have been completed. C. E. "Chip" Vincent, Planning Director Planning Division Date APPEALS: Appeals of Shoreline Substantial Development Permit issuance must be made directly to the Shorelines Hearings Board. Appeals are made by filing a request in writing within the twenty-one (21) days of receipt of the final order and concurrently filing copies of such request with the Washington State Department of Ecology and the Attorney General's office as provided in section 18(1) of the Shorelines Management Act of 1971. All copies of appeal notices shall also be filed with the City of Renton Planning Division and the City Clerk's office. EXPIRATION: Unless a different time period is specified in the shoreline permit as authorized by RCW 90.58.143 and subsection J1 of RMC 4-9-190, construction activities, or a use or activity, for which a permit has been granted pursuant to this Master Program must be commenced within two (2) years of the effective date of a shoreline permit, or the shoreline permit shall terminate, and a new permit shall be necessary. However, the Planning Division may authorize a single extension for a period not to exceed one year based on reasonable factors, if a request for extension has been filed with the Planning Division before the expiration date, and notice of the proposed extension is given to parties of record and the Washington State Department of Ecology. DEFINITION OF COMMENCEMENT OF CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES: the construction applications must be submitted, permits must be issued, and foundation inspections must be completed before the end of the two (2) year period. Attachments A: Legal Description cc: Attorney General's Office Karen Walter, Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Dept. Robert Cugini/ Owner(s)/Applicant Alan Foltz/ Contact City of Renton Official File - ____ D_e:n:is:La_w ______ .......... r City O l Mayor J. 2Jjfil'tl September 21, 2010 Alan Foltz Waterfront Construction, Inc. 20S NE Northlake Way #230 Seattle, WA 9810S Department of Community and Economic Development Alex Pietsch, Administrator SUBJECT: Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC Dear Mr. Foltz: This letter is to inform you that the appeal period ended September 17, 2010 for the Environmental Review Committee's (ERC) Determination of Non-Significance - Mitigated for the above-referenced project. No appeals were filed on the ERC determination therefore, this decision is final. The applicant must comply with all ERC Mitigation Measures outlined in the Report and Decision dated August 30, 2010. Also, a Hearing Examiner Public Hearing has been scheduled for September 28, 2010, where additional conditions of approval may be issued. The applicant or representative(s) of the applicant are required to be present. Enclosed is a copy of the Preliminary Report to the Hearing Examiner for your review. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at (425) 430-7219. For the Environmental Review Committee, ·. ~~ Gerald C. Wasser Associate Planner Enclosure cc: Robert Cugini -Barbee Mill/ Owner(s) Renton City Hall • 1055 South Grady Way • Renton, Washington 98057 • rentonwa.gov NOTICE Of ENVIRONMENTAl DETERMINATION AND PUBLIC HEARING == OF A DETERMINATION o~ NON·SIGN!RCANCE. MITIGATED (DNS-M) l'OSTI:0 TO NOTIFY "ff'cRESTl:0 l'ERSOMS DF 4N (N\IIRONMENTAl KllO"I l«bMMIIIW•IM<nltUtt, W>l~ !Cl'. SM. SMC UJc.A-,._, """' Luo w ......... -N OEScltlPTION, , ----W'A....._ ....... ,.-.. 011<>!,-,o./oot"1<4-.._ .. _"""l>Godttol,""'....,_, .. ,,,_ __ ,_.a ... .....,_ .. ..........._ ,.,,,_ --..... ,llft .. __ ... ___ ...._...,..., ...... -~.,...,...,,,_ """IM•-1......_ ............ ~--oonnft!fU-.1<!,_..,_,.., ...... ,batt...,ook,,,,tU• -.. !.l--T1,·mrdnc~1 .... ._ __ ,,""'~"'·._(, ..... , ......... _,,_,il,..l<ncl,..,._r,fNt,10l/+<""'"'"'".,.._, .. ....._._._,....,...lwi1111-17-r_ , ___ 0\'21-i-lona)""....,._""_-. ..,.,_.._..,._,,......,.,.,_of.,. ...,.....,,-....... , ...... ,..._p11o,..,..,...-,,. ... -.... ..,...,,.,.,.. .......... u.....,_.,. Jt<tjpMos.All _ _.. .... ...,.. ......... ,,,.w...,.....,.,~,.,---•••"'-""""" -ol~,w-..,., .. ty!.& __ ,L TH( CITT Of •tNWPI Df\ll~ONMENT"'-Rl'\IIEW COMMITTEE (£"Cl '1A5 OITTRMINEO TIIATT><E PR0P05EO ACTION POE5 tt0T H!oVI: A 5'GNl~ICANT "1M'.~ IMPACT Ot111-l! El>IYIRONMENT -l>ofllH............,_IOe-murtbcllledW\-ron...--"'""""'~-m.on~ 17, 2Dl0 . .lppoool>"""' be ft~ "1 wrili"I IDplhot ,.Id, ..... "'1"',0<! ~ vrit1,: M .. rinl E>:ao,...,,, °"" of A...-., lOSS -G,asfy Woy, R""""', W.O. 91lr51 •........... t,, th< EQmlnot ,,.., -""" 0, Oty of .,,,_ M••~ Cod<-.,., 4+110.8.. Ado-.,1 inf<>nNtlon ,_nlinc th., -I proc=, ,-,. DO ---.... --. °'l' °"'"''Ol'6<,,,l42SJ430-6SUl. A PUBLIC HEARING WILI. Bl' HEID ~ THE l!ENTON HEARJl'IG E:U.MINER A.T 1!15 REGLILJ,.R MEETING IN THE COUNCILCMA"'8El<S Qf'I ntE 711! fLOOA OF CTN MAU. 1055 SOUTH <,11,0.0Y WAY, RENTON, WA.IHll'IGTON. ON St:....-e• .. a n, 2010 AT '1:00 .o.i, TO CONSIDl:R THI: S><Qf!CUNE ~8ST"Al'ITIAL DE\11,lCJl>MENT rE•Mrr ""0 5'!0REIJNE CCNM"IONAl U§!: /'t:SMrr. 'f nfE £/MRONMON'TAL 1.>ITTRMtNATOJN 15 APPEAll(>, TH€ APl"EAL WU 9( HfM!O ..SPART OF THI.S PUBIJC HWIIN(; Pit!-include tht project NLIMBEJI whmn ,oail!ng lo,-~ file idorTtilicmon. CERTIFICATION 1,\.\\~ 1\~ \\9,~\\\\\£\\ , hereby certify that '2, copies of the above document __, w.ere posted in --2_ conspicuous places or nearby the described property on s;gaed ~\ill,~ 1')~._J Date: 9) z / \ \) STATE OF WASHINGTON ss COUNTY OF KING I certify that I know or have satisfactory evidence that 11:i, ,\,. \l,;, y,, frc.n\; signed this instrument and acknowledged it to be his/her/their free and voluntary act for the uses and purposes mentioned in the instrument. Notary (Print): (~, c:· loc/ My appointment expires: /\,·,.c, "q :] '\, ,1. e; ,·.: ---'--='1-J "'-'-'---~,;-"""-'=->~~------- CITY OF RENTON DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY & ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT-PLANNING DIVISION AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAILING On the 1st day of September, 2010, I deposited in the mails of the United States, a sealed envelope containing ERC Determination documents. This information was sent to: Name Representing Agencies See Attached Alan Foltz Contact Robert Cugini -Barbee Mill Company Owner/Applicant /: c,Jt•rit ... '"', Si natur der: ,.,._-' ( g e of Sen ) __ ,d&y_-==~'""'-'/--7)1-<--L-'-~CSZ.J.."""IL'"""L_=-::.. _____ ~= -"~ \ STATE OF WASHINGTO; ) d { ~ , .... ~ ~' ~ .... ~ ~ l ss ~ -.-"1 E ~ ~ .. -COUNTY OF KING ) \ .__. 8-~· ff ~,, -.,. ~ : ,,,, ,.. Of ... " ,.-:=- I certify that I know or have satisfactory evidence that Stacy M. Tucker 1•1111 1111"""''''' signed this instrument and acknowledged it to be his/her/their free and voluntary act for the uses and purposes mentioned in the instrument. Dated: .,l,; 1 ,J,;v,.\.i, \ 1 ,lc1c Notary flijblic in and for the State of Washington Notary (Print): ____ 1'--'-1-'-· . .::.4,._· c..· .1<.:.::.f..::"'::cb"-"-',·,c..·-------------- My appointment expires: . Prpj~ct ~<;1me:, _; Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts ... ,, .. Project Number:' · LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC template -affidavit of service by mailing Dept. of Ecology * Environmental Review Section PO Box 47703 Olympia, WA 98504-7703 WSDOT Northwest Region * Attn: Ramin Pazooki King Area Dev. Serv., MS-240 PO Box 330310 Seattle, WA 98133-9710 US Army Corp. of Engineers* Seattle District Office Attn: SEPA Reviewer PO Box C-375S Seattle, WA 98124 Boyd Powers * Depart. of Natural Resources PO Box 47015 Olympia, WA 98504-7015 KC Dev. & Environmental Serv. Attn: SEPA Section 900 Oakesdale Ave. SW Renton, WA 98055-1219 Metro Transit Senior Environmental Planner Gary Kriedt 201 South Jackson Street KSC-TR-0431 Seattle, WA 98104-3856 Seattle Public Utilities Real Estate Services Attn: SEPA Coordinator 700 Fifth Avenue, Suite 4900 PO Box 34018 Seattle, WA 98124-4018 AGENCY (DOE) LETTER MAILING (ERC DETERMINATIONS) WDFW -Larry Fisher* 1775 12th Ave. NW Suite 201 Issaquah, WA 98027 Duwamish Tribal Office* 4717 W Marginal Way SW Seattle, WA 98106-1514 KC Wastewater Treatment Division * Environmental Planning Supervisor Ms. Shirley Marroquin 201 S. Jackson ST, MS KSC-NR-050 Seattle, WA 98104-3855 City of Newcastle Attn: Steve Roberge Director of Community Development 13020 Newcastle Way Newcastle, WA 980S9 Puget Sound Energy Municipal Liaison Manager Joe Jainga PO Box 90868, MS: XRD-OlW Bellevue, WA 98009-0868 Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Dept.* Attn: Karen Walter or SEPA Reviewer 39015 -172"' Avenue SE Auburn, WA 98092 Muckleshoot Cultural Resources Program * Attn: Ms Melissa Calvert 39015 172nd Avenue SE Auburn, WA 98092-9763 Office of Archaeology & Historic Preservation* Attn: Gretchen Kaehler PO Box 48343 Olympia, WA 98504-8343 City of Kent Attn: Mr. Fred Satterstrom, AJCP Acting Community Dev. Director 220 Fourth Avenue South Kent, WA 98032-5895 City of Tukwila Steve Lancaster, Responsible Official 6200 South center Blvd. Tukwila, WA 98188 *Note: If the Notice of Application states that it is an "Optional DNS", the marked agencies and cities will need to be sent a copy of the checklist, Site Plan PMT, and the notice of application. template • affidavit of service by mailing j ¢ City of , r 1_ t;IJ I CJ fl OF ENVIRONMENTAL DETERMINATION AND PUBLIC HEARING ISSUANCE OF A DETERMINATION OF NON-SIGNIFICANCE -MITIGATED (DNS-M) POSTED TO NOTIFY INTERESTED PERSONS OF AN ENVIRONMENTAL ACTION PROJECT NAME: Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts PROJECT NUMBER: LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC LOCATION: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd N DESCRIPTION: The applicant requests SEPA Review for the installation of two 10-foot by 14- foot freestanding boatlifts, one 10-foot by 20-foot freestanding boatlift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock which serves three single-family residential lots in the R-8 zone. Each of the freestanding watercraft lifts would rest directly on the lake bottom on four 12- inch by 12-inch footpads. The existing fully-grated 118-foot 6-inch dock is comprised of a ramp {4 feet, 6 inches in width, and 31 feet long), and dock (7 feet, 10 3/4-inches in width and 86 feet, 6-inches in length) with two (7-foot 2-inch wide by 27-foot long) fully-grated finger docks. The proposed project also encompasses the removal of six 12-inch diameter creosote-treated wood piles and replacing them with two vibratory pile-driven 12-inch diameter steel piles. All work would take place within the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife fish window for this section of Lake Washington, July 16 through December 31. THE CITY OF RENTON ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW COMMITIEE (ERC) HAS DETERMINED THAT THE PROPOSED ACTION DOES NOT HAVE A SIGNIFICANT ADVERSE IMPACT ON THE ENVIRONMENT. Appeals of the environmental determination must be filed in writing on or before 5:00 p.m. on September 17, 2010. Appeals must be filed in writing together with the required fee with: Hearing Examiner, City of Renton, 1055 South Grady Way, Renton, WA 98057. Appeals to the Examiner are governed by City of Renton Municipal Code Section 4-8-110.B. Additional information regarding the appeal process may be obtained from the Renton City Clerk's Office, (425) 430-6510. A PUBLIC HEARING WILL BE HELD BY THE RENTON HEARING EXAMINER AT HIS REGULAR MEETING IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON THE 7TH FLOOR OF CITY HALL, 1055 SOUTH GRADY WAY, RENTON, WASHINGTON, ON SEPTEMBER 28, 2010 AT 9:00 AM TO CONSIDER THE SHORELINE SUBSTANTIAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT AND SHORELINE CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT. IF THE ENVIRONMENTAL DETERMINATION IS APPEALED, THE APPEAL WILL BE HEARD AS PART OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING. .. FOR FURTHER INFORMATION, PLEASE CONTACT THE CITY OF RENTON, DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY & ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AT (425) 430-7200. DO NOT REMOVE THIS NOTICE WITHOUT PROPER AUTHORIZATION Please include the project NUMBER when calling for proper file identification. Denis Law Mayor September 1, 2010 Alan Foltz Waterfront Construction, Inc. 205 Northlake Way #230 Seattle, WA 98105 r t, - City o 1 ·211wn Department of Community and Economic Development Alex Pietsch, Administrator SUBJECT: ENVIRONMENTAL THRESHOLD (SEPA) DETERMINATION Barbee Mill Watercraft lifts, LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC Dear Mr. Foltz: This letter is written on behalf of the Environmental Review Committee (ERC) to advise you that they have completed their review of the subject project and have issued a threshold Determination of Non-Significance-Mitigated with Mitigation Measures. Please refer to the enclosed ERC Report and Decision, Part 2, Section B for a list of the Mitigation Measures. Appeals of the environmental determination must be filed in writing on or before 5:00 p.m. on September 17, 2010. Appeals must be filed in writing together with the required fee with: Hearing Examiner, City of Renton, 1055 South Grady Way, Renton, · WA 98057. Appeals to the Examiner are governed by City of Renton Municipal Code Section 4-8-110.B. Additional information regarding the appeal process may be obtained from the Renton City Clerk's Office, (425) 430-6510. Also, a Public Hearing will be held by the Renton Hearing Examiner in the Council Chambers on the seventh floor of City Hall, 1055 South Grady Way, Renton, Washington, on September 28, 2010 at 9:00 a.m. to consider the Shoreline Substantial Development Permit and Shoreline Conditional Use Permit. The applicant or representative(s) of the applicant is required to be present at the public hearing. A copy of the staff report will be mailed to you prior to the hearing. If the Environmental Determination is appealed, the appeal will be heard as part of this public hearing. Renton-City Hall .-1055 South Grady Way • Renton, Washington 98057 • rentonwa.gov Alan Foltz Page 2 of 2 September 1, 2010 The preceding information will assist you in planning for implementation of your project and enable you to exercise your appeal rights more fully, if you choose to do so. If you have any questions or desire clarification of the above, please call me at (425) 430-7382. nvironmental Review Committee, Associate Planner Enclosure cc: Robert Cugini -Barbee Mill Company/ Owner(s) ERC Determination Ltr 10-050.doc Denis Law · ···· 0 City 0-----~M:a:yo:, ____ ................. r) l -_! ::B r l'Wll September 1, 2010 Washington State Department of Ecology Environmental Review Section PO Box47703 Olympia, WA 98504-7703 Department of Community and Economic Development Alex Pietsch, Administrator Subject: ENVIRONMENTAL (SEPA) DETERMINATION Transmitted herewith is a copy of the Environmental Determination for the following project reviewed by the Environmental Review Committee {ERC) on August 30, 2010: DETERMINATION OF NON-SIGNIFICANCE -MITIGATED PROJECT NAME: Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts PROJECT NUMBER: LUAlO-OSO, ECF, SM, SMC LOCATION: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd N DESCRIPTION: The applicant requests SEPA Review for the installation of two 10 ft by 14 ft freestanding boatlifts, one 10 ft by 20 ft freestanding boatlift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock. Appeals of the environmental determination must be filed in writing on or before 5:00 p,m. on September 17, 2010. Appeals must be filed in writing together with the required fee with: Hearing Examiner, City of Renton, 1055 South Grady Way, Renton, WA 98057. Appeals to the Examiner are governed by City of Renton Municipal Code Section 4-8-110.B. Additional information regarding the appeal process may be obtained from the Renton City Clerk's Office, {425) 430-6510. Please refer to the enclosed Notice of Environmental Determination for complete details, If you have questions, please call me at {425) 430-7382. Associate Planner Enclosure Renton City Hall • 1055 South Grady Way • Renton, Washington 98057 • rentonwa.gov Washington State Departm Page 2 of 2 September 11 2010 .,' Ecology cc: King Cou~ty Wastewater Treatment Division Boyd Powers, DE!partment of Natural Resources Karen Walter, Fisheries, Muck[eshoot Indian Tribe Melissa Calvert, Muckleshoot Cultural Resources Program Gretchen Kaehler, Office of Archaeology & Historic Preservation Ramin Pazooki, WSDOT, NW Region Larry Fisher1 WDFW Duwamish Tribal Office US Army Corp. of Engineers / DEPARTMENT OF COMMUll11TY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT DETERMINATION OF NON-SIGNIFICANCE-MITIGATED MITIGATION MEASURES APPLICATION NO(S): APPLICANT: PROJECT NAME: LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC Robert Cugini, Barbee Mill Company Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSAL: The applicant requests SEPA Review for the installation of two 10 ft by 14 ft freestanding boatlifts, one 10 ft by 20 ft freestanding boatlift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock. LOCATION OF PROPOSAL: LEAD AGENCY: MITIGATION MEASURES: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd N The City of Renton Department of Community & Economic Development Planning Division 1. A hanging silt containment curtain shall be installed around the project area prior to commencement of work and shall remain in place until project completion 2. Construction shall take place only during the Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife approved construction window for this portion of Lake Washington, from July 16 through December 31. ERC Mitigation Measures Page 1 of 1 DEPARTMENT OF COMMUl\11TY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT DETERMINATION OF NON-SIGNIFICANCE-MITIGATED ADVISORY NOTES APPLICATION NO(S): APPLICANT: PROJECT NAME: LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC Robert Cugini, Barbee Mill Company Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSAL: The applicant requests SEPA Review for the installation of two 10 ft by 14 ft freestanding boatlifts, one 10 ft by 20 ft freestanding boatlift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock. LOCATION OF PROPOSAL: LEAD AGENCY: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd N The City of Renton Department of Community & Economic Development Planning Division Advisory Notes to Applicant: The following notes are supplemental information provided in conjunction with the environmental determination. Because these notes are provided as information only, they are not subject ta the appeal process for environmental determinations. Planning: 1. The site is designated Residential Single Family in the City's Comprehensive Plan. The site is zoned Residential -8 dwelling units per acre (R-8). 2. The Shoreline Master Program Designation is "Urban". 3. Construction activities shall be restricted to the hours between 7:00 am and 8:00 pm, Monday through Friday. Work on Saturdays shall be between the hours of 9:00 am and 8:00 pm. No work shall be permitted on Sundays. 4. The approved State of Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW) fish window is from July 16 through December 31. 5. Project requires approval of a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit for the watercraft lifts. 6. Existing Joint Use Pier was previously approved (LUAOl-015, ECF, SV). 7. Previous conditions of approval continue to apply to the existing pier and to the addition of the boat lifts. Plan Review 1. The properties are served by the City of Renton Water Utility. 2. Cross connection control, inspection, and certification is required for any water service to the dock. 3. A water service permit is required if water service is extended to the dock. ERC Advisory Notes Page 1 of 2 4. The properties are served by the City of Renton Wastewater Utility. 5. The parcels have onsite drainage to Lake Washington. No further facilities are triggered by this proposal. 6. All plans shall conform to the Renton Drafting standards. 7. For any utility work, a construction permit is required. When plans are complete, submit three (3) copies of the drawings, a construction estimate, application and appropriate fee to the 5th floor Customer Counter at City Hall. ERC Advisory Notes Page 2 of 2 DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ENVIRONMENTAL (SEPA) DETERMINATION OF NON-SIGNIFICANCE APPLICATION NO(S): APPLICANT: PROJECT NAME: -MITIGATED (DNS-M) LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC Robert Cugini, Barbee Mill Company Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSAL: The applicant requests SEPA Review for the installation of two 10 ft by 14 ft freestanding boatlifts, one 10 ft by 20 ft freestanding boatlift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock. LOCATION OF PROPOSAL: LEAD AGENCY: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd N City of Renton Environmental Review Committee Department of Community & Economic Development The City of Renton Environmental Review Committee has determined that it does not have a probable significant adverse impact on the environment. An Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) is not required under RCW 43.21C.030(2)(c). Conditions were imposed as mitigation measures by the Environmental Review Committee under their authority of Section 4-6-6 Renton Municipal Code. These conditions are necessary to mitigate environmental impacts identified during the environmental review process. Appeals of the environmental determination must be filed in writing on or before 5:00 p.m. on September 17, 2010. Appeals must be filed in writing together with the required fee with: Hearing Examiner, City of Renton, 1055 South Grady Way, Renton, WA 98057. Appeals to the Examiner are governed by City of Renton Municipal Code Section 4-8-110.B. Additional information regarding the appeal process may be obtained from the Renton City Clerk's Office, (425) 430-6510. PUBLICATION DATE: DATE OF DECISION: SIGNATURES: er Public War s Department Terry Higashiyama, Administrator Community Services Department September 3, 2010 August 30, 2010 f6/ ?JrJ)u )')"-----------f---b,.__lL_~~--- • Mark Peterson, Administrator Date Fire & Erner cy Services S,l1o} H·::, Date Economic Development ~·- Date Date DEPARTMENT OF CO .... /IUNITY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT TO: FROM: MEETING DATE: TIME: LOCATION: ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW COMMITTEE MEETING AGENDA Gregg Zimmerman, Public Works Administrator Terry Higashiyama, Community Services Administrator Mark Peterson, Interim Fire & Emergency Services Administrator Alex Pietsch, CED Administrator Jennifer Henning, Current Planning Manager Monday, August 30, 2010 3:00 p.m. Sixth Floor Conference Room 11620 THE FOLLOWING IS A CONSENT AGENDA 109 Logan Avenue Mixed Use LUA10-047, ECF, SA-A (Wasser) Location: 109 Logan Avenue S. Description: The applicant is requesting Environmental (SEPA) Review and Administrative Site Plan Review for the development of a mixed use project in the CD Zone. Barbee MIii Watercraft Lifts (Wasser} LUA10-0SO, ECF, SM, SMC Location: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd N. Description: The applicant requests SEPA Review for the installation of two 10 ft by 14 ft freestanding boat lifts, one 10 ft by 20 ft freestanding boatlift with a fully grated platform, and one duck-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock. cc: D. Law, Mayor J. Covington, Chief Administrative Officer S. Dale Estey, CED Director• W. Flora, Deputy Chief/Fire Marshal• Richard Perteet, Deputy PW Administrator -Transportation C. Vincent, CED Planning Director • N. Watts, Development Services Director• L. Warren, City Attorney • F. Kaufman, Hearing Examiner D. Pargas, Assistant Fire Marshal J. Medzegian, Council DEPARTMENT OF COM MU Y AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW COMMITTEE REPORT ERC MEETING DATE: Project Name: Owner: Applicant: Contact: File Number: Project Manager: Project Summary: Project Location: Existing Dock. Area SF: Site Area: STAFF RECOMMENDATION: August 30, 2010 Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts Barbee Mill Company, 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N., Renton, WA 98056 Robert Cugini, Barbee Mill Company, 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N., Renton, WA 98056 Alan Foltz, Waterfront Construction, Inc., 205 Northlake Way, Suite 230, Seattle, WA 98105 LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC Gerald Wasser, Associate Planner The applicant requests SEPA Review for the installation of two 10-foot by 14- foot freestanding boatlifts, one 10-foot by 20-foot freestanding boatlift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock which serves three single-family residential lots in the R- 8 zone. Each of the freestanding watercraft lifts would rest directly on the lake bottom on four 12-inch by 12-inch footpads. The existing fully-grated 118-foot 6-inch dock is comprised of a ramp (4 feet, 6 inches in width, and 31 feet long), and dock (7 feet, 10 3/4-inches in width and 86 feet, 6-inches in length) with two (7-foot 2-inch wide by 27-foot long) fully-grated finger docks. The proposed project also encompasses the removal of six 12-inch diameter creosote-treated wood piles and replacing them with two vibratory pile-driven 12-inch diameter steel piles. All work would take place within the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife fish window for this section of Lake Washington, July 16 through December 31. 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N. Approx 1,200 sf Proposed New Dock Area (footprint): Proposed New Dock. Area (gross): 8,870 sf Total Building Area GSF: N/A N/A N/A Staff Recommends that the Environmental Review Committee issue a Determination of Non-Significance -Mitigated (DNS-M). ERC Reportv2 City of Renton Department of Commu & Economic Development BARBEE MILL WATERCRAFT LIFTS Report of August 30, 2010 PART ONE: PROJECT DESCRIPTION / BACKGROUND ironmentaJ Review Committee Report LUA10-0SO, ECF, SM, SMC Page 2 of6 The applicant, Robert Cugini, requests Environmental (SEPA) Review, approval of a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit, and a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit for the installation of two 10-foot by 14-foot freestanding boatlifts, one 10-foot by 20-foot freestanding boatlift, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift. The boatlifts would be pre-manufactured and would be uncovered. Both the freestanding boat and platform lifts would each rest on four 12-inch square footpads directly on the lake bottom. The freestanding platform boatlift would have a fully grated platform that would allow an intermediate level for safe boarding of smaller watercraft vessels during the approximately 8 months of the year when the lake is at low water levels. All of the proposed watercraft lifts would be in association with an existing 118-foot, 6- inch long fully-grated dock comprised of a ramp (4 feet, 6 inches in width, and 31 feet long), and dock (7 feet, 10 3/4-inches in width and 86 feet, 6-inches in length) with two (7-foot 2-inch wide by 27-foot long) finger docks. The dock serves three detached single-family residences on Lake Washington Boulevard North (3905, 3907, 3909, and 3979 Lake Washington Boulevard North). The proposal is located within the waters of Lake Washington, a Shoreline of Statewide Significance. The proposal also includes the removal of six 12-inch diameter creosote treated wood piles (two dolphins with configurations of three piles each) that would be replaced with two 12-inch steel piles. A vibratory extraction/insertion system would be used for this activity, and the applicant proposes to install an in-water silt curtain for containment. Delivery of the lifts would be accomplished via construction barge. Installation of the watercraft lifts would take approximately one to three days, and would be conducted during the Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife fish window for this section of Lake Washington, July 16 through December 31. Questions and comments were received from the Muckleshoot Indian Tribes Fisheries Division. These questions and comments dealt with the existing previously approved joint use dock, the platform boatlift, and the removal of creosote treated pilings and their replacement with steel piles. Responses were made under separate cover and are included as Exhibit 6 of this report. A Shoreline Variance for the existing joint-use dock was approved by the Hearing Examiner in 2002 (LUAOl-015, ECF, SMV) for use by three abutting properties. On January 24, 2003 the City issued a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit for the dock. I PART TWO: ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW In compliance with RCW 43.21C.240, the following environmental (SEPA) review addresses only those project impacts that are not adequately addressed under existing development standards and environmental regulations. A. Environmental Threshold Recommendation Based on analysis of probable impacts from the proposal, staff recommends that the Responsible Officials: Issue a DNS-M with a 14-day Appeal Period. ERC Reportv2 City of Renton Department of Commu ~ Economic Development Env1 1entaJ Review Committee Report BARBEE MILL WATERCRAFT LIFTS LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC Report of August 30, 2010 Page 3 of 6 B. Mitigation Measures c. 1. A hanging silt containment curtain shall be installed around the project area prior to commencement of work and shall remain in place until project completion 2. Construction shall take place only during the Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife approved construction window for this portion of Lake Washington, from July 16 through December 31. Exhibits Exhibit 1 Exhibit 2 Exhibit 3 Exhibit 4 Exhibit S Exhibit 6 Neighborhood Detail Map Plot Plan Detail View and Elevation View Zoning Map Aerial Photo Muckleshoot Indian Tribes Questions and Planning Division Responses D. Environmental Impacts The Proposal was circulated and reviewed by various City Departments and Divisions ta determine whether the applicant has adequately identified and addressed environmental impacts anticipated to occur in conjunction with the proposed development. Staff reviewers have identified that the proposal is likely to have the following probable impacts: 1. Water (Streams/Lakes} Impacts: The project is proposed over the waters of Lake Washington within the designated Inner Harbor area. Lake Washington is a Shoreline of Statewide Significance and is included as a Shoreline of the State. The shoreline designation for Lake Washington at this location is "Urban Environment" (RMC 4-3-090G). Lake Washington is a perennial salmonid-bearing body of water. May Creek, also a Shoreline of Statewide Significance, is located to the north of the proposed project approximately 240 feet. The project as proposed would not adversely affect May Creek. The applicant submitted a Lake Study for the Barbee Mill Community Dock Project (LUA08-028 ECF, SM) prepared by Marine Surveys & Assessments and dated March 20, 2008. Because this Lake Study was completed for a property in proximity to the subject site, staff has accepted it with modifications made by the applicant (letter dated July 22, 2010 by Waterfront Construction) as a valid representation of this section of Lake Washington conforming to the requirements for Stream and Lake Studies (per RMC 4-8-120A). The proposed watercraft installation as well as removal of six creosote treated wood piles and replacement with two steel piles would occur on lands covered by water. Therefore, sediments could be dispersed within the lake, potentially affecting water quality of the lake. The Construction Mitigation Description submitted for the proposal indicates that all materials, equipment, and personnel would arrive at the site via construction barge. The removed creosote treated piles would immediately be placed on the construction barge and transported to an acceptable receiving facility for disposal. ERC Reportv2 Oty of Renton Department of Commu: & Economic Development BARBEE MILL WATERCRAFT LIFTS Report of August 30, 2010 ironmental Review Committee Report WAl0-050, fCF, SM, SMC Page 4 of 6 Staff recommends as a mitigation measure that a hanging silt curtain be installed prior to the commencement of installation activities, in order to contain any suspended sediments resulting from the watercraft installation and vibratory pile insertion/extraction activities. Such silt containment curtain shall remain in place until work has been completed. Mitigation Measures: A hanging silt containment curtain shall be installed around the project area prior to commencement of work and shall remain in place until project completion. Nexus: SEPA Environmental Regulations, Shoreline Master Program. 2. Wildlife Impacts: While the Lake and Stream Study submitted with the project application was evaluated for the Barbee Mill Community Dock Project to the north, its description of wildlife in this area is pertinent to the proposed project. Bird species observed near the project site include hawks, herons, eagles, quail, osprey, cormorants and songbirds. Salmonids observed near the site and known to be present in southern Lake Washington include Puget Sound Chinook salmon, Coho salmon, sockeye salmon, steelhead trout, bull trout, and cutthroat trout. Puget Sound Chinook, Puget Sound steelhead and bull trout are all listed as threatened under the Endangered Species Act (ESA). In order to diminish or eliminate impacts to wildlife, especially salmonids, the Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife has established a construction window for this portion of Lake Washington. The construction window allows for overwater construction to occur only between July 16 and December 31. Staff recommends as a mitigation measure that the applicant be required to adhere to the Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife approved construction window for this portion of Lake Washington when installing the boat lifts, and when installing or removing the piles. The proposed project includes the installation of watercraft lifts in association with an existing fully-grated joint use dock. In addition to the watercraft lift installation, the applicant is also proposing to replace six creosote-treated piles with two steel piles. A hanging silt containment curtain would be installed (see Section 1. Water, above). The silt containment curtain is expected to minimize impacts of suspended sediments to fish species as a result of installation activities associated with the proposed project. In addition previous site mitigation was required during permitting and construction of the existing pier. This includes planting in the nearshore area, addition of spawning gravels, and piers with grating to allow light transmission. The removal of the creosote coated wood pilings and replacement with steel piles is considered to be a beneficial impact, offsetting impacts to wildlife resulting from the installation of the watercraft lifts. Comments regarding the previously permitted joint-use dock (LUAOl-015, ECF, SV) and the current proposal were received from Muckleshoot Indian Tribes Fisheries Division. Specifically, the Tribe requested verification that previous mitigation (planting of shoreline vegetation) was accomplished. The applicant and owner have responded via email to the Tribe (Exhibit 6), verifying that plantings were done in compliance for the previous U.S. Army Corps of Engineers permit (#200200724). In addition, monitoring of the health of the plants occurs on a regular basis, as has replacement of plantings that have been damaged by a resident beaver. The Tribe also comments on the need for the replacement of dolphins with steel piles, and the need for a new grated watercraft platform lift. The replacement piles are intended to help protect the moorage from ERC Reportv2 City of Renton Department of Commu & Economic Development BARBEE MILL WATERCRAFT LIFTS Report of August 30, 2010 ironmental Review Committee Report LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC Page 5 of 6 winter storms (with prevailing southwest winds). The platform lift is considered to be necessary to allow residents to board watercraft during times that the lake level is lowered. As the platform is fully grated, no additional impact is anticipated. Therefore, no further mitigation is required. Mitigation: Construction shall take place only during the Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife approved construction window for this portion of Lake Washington, from July 16 through December 31. Nexus: SEPA Environmental Regulations 3. Noise Impacts: Construction activities associated with the project would result in short term noise impacts. A diesel powered tug boat with barge-mounted crane would be delivered to the site in order to install the pre-fabricate watercraft lifts. In addition, a diesel powered vibratory driver would be used for both extraction of the existing dolphin piles and installation of the two new steel piles. Both the tug and vibratory driver would have muffled exhaust systems to reduce noise impacts to surrounding areas. The duration of work is expected to be 1 to 3 days, further diminishing noise impacts resulting from construction activities. Vibratory pile hammers are generally used in situations where noise is a concern, as in residential areas. The vibration rates range from 1200 to 2400 vibrations per minute and result in substantially less noise than traditional pile driving activities. Mitigation Measures: No further mitigation required. Nexus: N/A 4. Aesthetics Impacts: The addition of the four watercraft lifts to the existing joint-use pier would add elements that would sit approximately 3 feet above the water level. The watercraft lifts would not be covered, and are not expected to adversely affect views in the surrounding residential area. The two boat lifts and one jet ski lift would parallel the existing finger piers on the dock, and would be an expected view to an observer. The proposed platform lift would appear to be an extension of the existing pier, and is proposed closest to the shoreline. This lift would be fully grated, allowing light passage to the water below. Mitigation Measures: None required. Nexus: N/A E. Comments of Reviewing Departments The proposal has been circulated to City Department and Division Reviewers. Where applicable, their comments have been incorporated into the text of this report and/or" Advisory Notes to Applicant." v' Copies of all Review Comments are contained in the Official File and may be attached to this report. Environmental Determination Appeal Process: Appeals of the environmental determination must be filed in writing on or before 5:00 PM, September 17, 2010. ERC Reportv2 City of Renton Department of Commu & Economic Development BARBEE Mill WATERCRAFT LIFTS ironmental Review Committee Report WA10-0SO, ECF, SM, SMC Report of August 30, 2010 Page 6 of 6 Renton Municipal Code Section 4-8-110.B governs appeals to the Hearing Examiner. Appeals must be filed in writing at the City Clerk's office along with the required fee. Additional information regarding the appeal process may be obtained from the City Clerk's Office, Renton City Hall -7th Floor, 1055 S. Grady Way, Renton WA 98057. ADVISORY NOTES TO APPLICANT The following notes are supplemental information provided in conjunction with the administrative land use action. Because these notes are provided as information only, they ore not subject to the appeal process for the land use actions. Planning: 1. The site is designated Residential Single Family in the City's Comprehensive Plan. The site is zoned Residential -8 dwelling units per acre (R-8). 2. The Shoreline Master Program Designation is "Urban". 3. Construction activities shall be restricted to the hours between 7:00 am and 8:00 pm, Monday through Friday. Work on Saturdays shall be between the hours of 9:00 am and 8:00 pm. No work shall be permitted on Sundays. 4. The approved State of Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW) fish window is from July 16 through December 31. 5. Project requires approval of a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit for the watercraft lifts. 6. Existing Joint Use Pier was previously approved (LUA01-01S, ECF, SV). 7. Previous conditions of approval continue to apply to the existing pier and to the addition of the boat lifts. Plan Review 1. The properties are served by the City of Renton Water Utility. 2. Cross connection control, inspection, and certification is required for any water service to the dock. 3. A water service permit is required if water service is extended to the dock. 4. The properties are served by the City of Renton Wastewater Utility. 5. The parcels have onsite drainage to Lake Washington. No further facilities are triggered by this proposal. 6. All plans shall conform to the Renton Drafting standards. 7. For any utility work, a construction permit is required. When plans are complete, submit three (3) copies of the drawings, a construction estimate, application and appropriate fee to the 61h floor Customer Counter at City Hall. ERC Reportv2 -:c • Cl) -~ • • • • Barbee Mill Company, Inc. c/o Robert Cugini Parcel: 334270 0011 NW 3224N OSE EXHIBIT 1 City Of Ci _enton J1vision /1/j t I Note: Boatlift frames are 10' x 14' overall with four (4) -1' sq. foot pads. Platform Lift uses boatlift frame, with a 10' x 20' fully grated platform. Dock mounted Jetski Lift Framing is 4' x 6' overall. "' I /;:1 I .fl I "I "'I SI 15 I JI l1i I ti I CD BARBEE FOREST PRODUCTS INC 3907 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA. 95056 --------------------------------------7 ff--__ ---_ _ S 88"49'09• E ------------------------ (2) I 34' 1 JOB SITE 3905 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA, 98056 PROPOSED JETSKI LIFT OHWL 21.80' @ FACE OF BULKHEAD EXISTING ROCK BULKHEAD PROPOSED PLATFORM LIFT 11s'-6" ~,'I EXISTING DOLPHINS I I I ' 0 ~~ :.-~;Jin S.':':ifi8 "~0 ~b~~ N~ ~;;:: >.:,,. zZ §zn .... ~ z-<' v,h:; ~~!;3~ :8 '.§.~Vi~.,~ 2 " ~ ~ g;gz~ ~ ;ae8:e::0.o oR-1=!~ 'Z:i ~--<O,:,v, fi <ro"2 z '1"',..,o rri <,'locc3r--. o Ul V>"'& ~ ;J~ti=<cS· . R{-~~ :,:lrr,:Z: - g:t:~~?; z~pr;f r-,i;l,..-,:o;; z oE1 "z ~ =··----~-= \ N 8~-!-49'3C W t44.691 1 ,.--------~----, // l l z-< EXISTING BOATLIFT EXISTING DECK ~ llll~iliiiili/!ittiillllii( EXISTING PIER EXISTING JCTSKI LIFT ROPOSEO MmGAllON: 3901 (3) 12" CREOSOTE WOOD MOORING PILES PER (DOLPHIN) TO BE REPLACED wrTH (I) 12" STEEL PILE PLOT PLAN 40' 30· 20· 1 o· o· SCALE: 1 "=40 1 @ BOYDSTON TONY LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON, WA, 98056 40' I, /, REFERENCE #: / I I / /I APPLICANT: BARBEE MILL-CO. INC, c/o ROBERT-CIJGlNI 1PROPOSED: INSTALL (2) NEW BOATUFTS, (I) JCTSKI LIFT AND {1) PLATFORM LIFT, NEAR/Al: RENTON SHEET: 2 OF: 3 DATE: 6-19-:)0 __ J!)_WG#: 10-37022-A.2-1 m >< ::c 1-1 Dl 1-1 -f "' t ' Note: Boatlift frames are 10' x 14' overall with four (4) -l' sq. foot pads. Platform Lift uses boatlift frame, with a 10' x 20' fully grated platform. Dock mounted Jetski Lift Framing is 4' x 6' overall. J_ 7'-1CJi" I (2) PROPOSED FREE STANDING BOATLIFTS 14·-r ---i ?'-2" Js'±'c----------1 T 27' PROPOSED JETSKI LIFT PROPOSED PLATFORM LIFT EXISTING PLANTING PLAN OHWL 21.80' @ FACE OF BULKHEAD EXISTING ROCK BULKHEAD !-------+-------87'-6" -----\,----------+----- EXISTING FULLY GRATED PROPOSED MmGATION: (DOLPHIN) (3) 12" CREOSOTE WOOD MOORING PILES PER ~ BE REPLACED WITH (1) 12" STEEL PILE _P_~------~ -.i>.!==::;:;;::;=;;=:;;:!_ 18, L N 8B"49'35" W 344.69' OHWL 21.80' PROPOSED MmGATION: (3) 12" CREOSOTE WOOD MOORING PILES PER (DOLPHIN) TO BE REPLACED WITH (1) 12" STEEL PILE (2) PROPOSED EXISTING FULLY FREE STANDING BOATLIFTS GRATED PIER _[ 2'-7" DETAIL VIEW SCALE: 1 "=20' EXISTING PILING 20· 1s· 10· s· o· SCALE: 1 ~ =20' PROPOSED JETSKI LIFT 20' EXISTING RAMP REFERENCE U: / EXISTING ROCK BULKHEAD \ -_], EXISTING SPAWNING GRAVEL / APPLICANT: BARBEE MILL CO. INC. c/o ROBERT-CUGINI PROPOSED, INSTALL (2) NEW BOATLIFTS, (1) JETSKI LIFT ANO ill PLATFORM LIFT. NEAR/AT: RENTON SHEET: 3 OF: 3 DATE: 6-29=1_0 DW§j/;1.Q=}.7022-A.3-1 ·, I "ti ':'...I vi 11 ~~~0 ;c-""'gg 'OC Oz< a ~:e, ~~~~ -<' vi 111 °0 ~~:::i., ...,~oe:, -~-~~ ··~ 11 ~~s~n ~-< ~ ~0--0\J'i ~me52 ~:~\) OVl'°& SB::.!g· • 0 ~Z"''3 ;i;t!'.' ~o,..,, c,ra "" r"'1 ;; <oo ~ m >< :::c '""' Cl '""' -I w S(T-E ,' B4 -29 T24N RSE W 1/2 [;J ' I ,_. R-8 ,_. R-8 R-8 ·-· Nl?ll,Sl COR R-8 ·-· " R-8 ,_' R-8 R-8 n H EXHIBIT 4 CA CA R-8 R-8 ' ~ N .., N ---'"' .===:::J ~ R·l ~ Ul t"1 •. t"1 .... i::l ·-· R-8 ,-, I ;:::=:::0i;~. ;=:==~======;1 R-8 R-8 R-8 r-,-~~· ·-· R-8 ,..,. R-8 1~,-~ ;::=~=========~ ZONING MAP BOOK PW TECHNICAL SERVICES PRINTED ON 11/13/09 n.,ooc"""'"'g''""'"'",....'""'""""' ""'"'"~' "'"''~"'"'""· ,00~1>mdoo ,..,.bostmlNn;aa...,...,,~b"""'°''"'""'"''"=' n-., """" '"''"'""' "" '"' '"'""'""'"""'""" N31r1S1 ,_. R-8 R-8 ,_. R-8 R-8 R-8 N28!t\PI N27111"4),R-8 R-8 d CN 9. CN CN 1~ R-8 0 200 400 ~ IF,et 1:4,800 CN R-8 R-8 32 T24N RSE W 1/2 5432 ZONING MAP BOOK 74W :'.":..::t ' 92 ·2sT24N R4E Sf:_.:. ·1 94W 'c.,· -:c 1 22N R4E RESIDENTIAL I-Re ·1 (RC) Resource Conservation [ R-: (R-1) Residential 1 du/ac a (R-4) Residential 4 du/ac [ _R-~ J (R-8) Residential 8 du/ac 93 r:::r0"~ (RMH) Residential Manufactured Homes ~ (R-10) Residential 10 du/ac [-R~]4-I (R-14) Residential 14 du/ac I PtHI (RM-F} Residential Multi-Family IRN-T I (RM-T) Residential Multi-Family Traditional I ~r-1-u I (RM-U} Residenf1al Multi-Family Urban Center MIXED USE CENTERS [£:2] (CV) Center Village IUc::=:0] (UC-Nl) Urban Center-North 1 jJ:-N2I (UC-N2) Urban Center -North 2 c:EJ (CD) Center Downtown COMMERCIAL 36 833 J7 INDUSTRIAL L_:_~J (IL) Industrial -Light ~ (IM} Industrial -Medium QQ (tH) 1-ndustrial -Heavy -----Renton City Llmits I :o~_J {CORI Commercial/Office/Residential ____ Adjacent City Limits ~ (CA} Commercial Arterial ·~ (CO) Commercial Office [_ c:: ] (CN} Commercial Neighborhood KROLL PAGE PAGE# INDEX 1~ Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts, LUA10-050, ECF, SM, SMC 0.0 £ 'I -~ f '-.) City of Re nton . Washington 0 0.02 0 .0 Mi les This map is a user generated static output from an Internet mapping site and i s for refere nce only. Data layers that a ppea r on this map may or may not be accurate. current. or otherwise reliable. THIS MAP IS NOT TO BE USED FOR NAVIGATION Lakes and Rivers Parcels Street Names Rights of Way Stre ets Roads Jurisdictions Bellevue Des M aines I ssaquah Kent King County Mercer lslan Newcastl e RENTON SeaTac m Seattle >< Tukwila sid2 .sid :c 1--t • Red: Ban< 0:, • Green. Ban, 1--t • Blue· Banc -t u, 1: 1,131 @8.5" X 11" 0 Notes Enter Map Description Gerald Wasser EXHIBIT 6 From: Karen Walter [KWalter@muckleshoot.nsn.us] Friday, August 20, 2010 3 08 PM Sent: To: Gerald Wasser Subject: Barbee Mill Watercraft lifts (at Cugini Joint Use Pier), Notice of Application and Proposed Determination of Non-Significance -Mitigated Mr. Wasser, In response to the City's Notice of Application materials for the above referenced project, we are submitting the questions and initial comments to this project that we previously sent in response to the Letter of Permission Notice from the Corps of Engineers. We have not yet received a response to these questions about the project; therefore, it is prudent to send them to City as well since there was no new information in the City's packet to answer the questions we raised below. The existing dock project described below was permitted by the City via permit# LUAO 1-015. We appreciate the opportunity to review this proposal. Please let me know if you have any questions. Thank you, Karen Walter Watersheds and Land Use Team Leader Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Division 39015172"d Ave SE Auburn, WA 98092 253-876-3116 From: Karen Walter Sent: Monday, August 09, 2010 4:37 PM To: Susan Powell Subject: LOP NWS-2010-904, Barbee Mill Company boatlifts Susan, The Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Division has reviewed the above referenced Letter of Permission to install two boatlifts, a jetski lift and a platform lift to provide private boat moorage to four residences. We have some questions about this project and an initial comment as noted below: 1. Previously, the Corps issued a 404 permit to construct a joint-use pier and ramp to serve three waterfront lots and plant native shoreline vegetation under permit 200200724 (Cugini). Were the native plants actually planted and is there a copy of the as-built drawings and/or monitoring plans for these plants? If so, we would appreciate a copy of these documents to verify the previous mitigation required for the pier and ramp. 2. As noted in the question above, the original joint pier was constructed to serve three waterfront lots. The pending Corps permit is to provide moorage for four residences. Where exactly are the four residences that will obtain moorage if the latest Corps permit is approved? 3. As far as the proposed LOP is concerned, the project proposes to install a grated platform boatlift just past the existing ramp where the existing pier begins from the shore. While grated, this platform lift will result in more over/in-water coverage than the proposed freestanding boatlifts. Please explain why a third free standing boatlift without a platform cannot be used to provide moorage instead of the proposed platform lift. It seems the jetski lift could be relocated and a third freestanding boatlift without a platform could be constructed where the jetski lift is proposed, resulting in a project with less impact than what is proposed. 4. The proposed LOP project also is seeking to replace 3-12 inch diameter creosote wood mooring piles per dolphin for the two outermost dolphins shown on Sheet 2 as mitigation. What is the purpose of the mooring piles and associated log booms? Do these dolphins need to be replaced anyway? Why not replace the two most landward dolphins to get rid of some of the vertical structure in the nearshore environment? 5. Instead of the replacing the two existing dolphins with a single 12 inch diameter steel pile, we recommend that all of the dolphin mooring piles and log boom structure shown along the southern edge of the property in Sheets 2 and 3 be removed as mitigation for the increase in overwater coverage as a result of the new lifts and their associated watercraft. This mitigation measure would reduce inwater structure that potentially provides salmon predators with ambush habitat while meeting the project's purpose since the new lifts will be providing moorage at the existing dock. We appreciate the opportunity and look forward to the Corps responses to our comments. We may have additional comments subsequently. Please let me know if you have any questions. Thank you, Karen Walter Watersheds and Land Use Team Leader Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Division 3901517:z"d Ave SE Auburn WA 98092 253-876-3116 2 Gerald Wasser From: Karen Walter [KWalter@muckleshoot.nsn.us] Friday, August 20, 2010 3:08 PM Sent: To: Gerald Wasser Subject: Barbee Mill Watercraft lifts (at Cugini Joint Use Pier), Notice of Application and Proposed Determination of Non-Significance -Mitigated Mr Wasser, In response to the City's Notice of Application materials for the above referenced project, we are submitting the questions and initial comments to this project that we previously sent in response to the Letter of Permission Notice from the Corps of Engineers. We have not yet received a response to these questions about the project; therefore, it is prudent to send them to City as well since there was no new information in the City's packet to answer the questions we raised below. The existing dock project described below was permitted by the City via permit# LUA01-015. We appreciate the opportunity to review this proposal. Please let me know if you have any questions. Thank you, Karen Walter Watersheds and Land Use Team Leader Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fishen·es Division 39015172'6 Ave SE Auburn, WA 98092 253-876-3116 From: Karen Walter Sent: Monday, August 09, 2010 4:37 PM To: Susan Powell Subject: LOP NWS-2010-904, Barbee Mill Company boatlifts Susan, The Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Division has reviewed the above referenced Letter of Permission to install two boatlifts, a jetski lift and a platform lift to provide private boat moorage to four residences. We have some questions about this project and an initial comment as noted below: 1. Previously, the Corps issued a 404 permit to construct a joint-use pier and ramp to serve three waterfront lots and plant native shoreline vegetation under permit 200200724 (Cugini). Were the native plants actually planted and is there a copy of the as-built drawings and/or monitoring plans for these plants? If so, we would appreciate a copy of these documents to verify the previous mitigation required for the pier and ramp. 2. As noted in the question above, the original joint pier was constructed to serve three waterfront lots. The pending Corps permit is to provide moorage for four residences. Where exactly are the four residences that will obtain moorage if the latest Corps permit is approved? 3. As far as the proposed LOP is concerned, the project proposes to install a grated platform boatlift just past the existing ramp where the existing pier begins from the shore. While grated, this platform lift will result in more over/in-water coverage than the proposed freestanding boatlifts. Please explain why a third free standing boatlift without a platform cannot be used to provide moorage instead of the proposed platform lift. It seems the jetski lift could be relocated and a third freestanding boatlift without a platform could be constructed where the jetski lift is proposed, resulting in a project with less impact than what is proposed. 4. The proposed LOP project also is seeking to replace 3-12 inch diameter creosote wood mooring piles per dolphin for the two outermost dolphins shown on Sheet 2 as mitigation. What is the purpose of the mooring piles and associated log booms? Do these dolphins need to be replaced anyway? Why not replace the two most landward dolphins to get rid of some of the vertical structure in the nearshore environment? 1 5. Instead of the replacing the two existing dolphins with a single 12 inch diameter steel pile, we recommend that all of the dolphin mooring piles and log boom structure shown along the southern edge of the property in Sheets 2 and 3 be removed as mitigation for the increase in overwater coverage as a result of the new lifts and their associated watercraft. This mitigation measure would reduce inwater structure that potentially provides salmon predators with ambush habitat while meeting the project's purpose since the new lifts will be providing moorage at the existing dock. We appreciate the opportunity and look forward to the Corps responses to our comments. We may have additional comments subsequently. Please let me know if you have any questions. Thank you, Karen Walter Watersheds and Land Use Team Leader Muck/eshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Division 3901517:z"" Ave SE Auburn WA 98092 253-876-3116 2 Gerald Wasser From: Gerald Wasser Sent: To: Thursday, August 26, 2010 10 32 AM 'Karen Walter' Cc: Jennifer T. Henning Subject: FW: Barbee Mill Watercraft lifts (at Cugini Joint Use Pier), Notice of Application and Proposed Determination of Non-Significance -Mitigated Attachments: Barbee Mill (1).htm; Mitigation documentation.him Hello Ms. Walter: Thank you for your comments and questions on LUAl0-050, Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts. Your questions would more appropriately be answered by the Army Corps of Engineers. However, I have contacted Waterfront Construction, Inc. and they have provided me with emails which were sent to Susan Powell with responses to your questions and comments. I am forwarding the correspondence from Waterfront Construction, Inc. to you. Should you have additional questions, please contact me. Jerry Gerald C. Wasser, Associate Planner Department of Community & Economic Development City of Renton 1055 South Grady Way Renton, WA 98057 (425) 430-7382 FAX (425) 430-7300 gwasser@rentonwa.gov From: Peter Zuvela [mailto:Peter@waterfrontconstruction.com] Sent: Thursday, August 26, 2010 10:09 AM To: Gerald Wasser Cc: Alan Foltz Subject: RE: Barbee Mill Watercraft lifts (at Cugini Joint Use Pier), Notice of Application and Proposed Determination of Non-Significance -Mitigated Gerald, Attached are two email strings from Alan Foltz regarding these same questions. The one titled "Barbee Mill (1 )" is from Alan to Susan Powell with the Army Corps responding directly to Karen's questions below. The second is from Robert Cugini regarding the housing situation. Hope this helps. Let me know if you need anything more from me. Thanks, Peter Zuvela Permit Coordinator Waterfront Construction, Inc. 205 NE Northlake Way, Suite 230 Seattle, WA 98105 Phone: (206) 548-9800 Fa,: (206) 548-1022 1 From: Gerald Wasser [mailto:GWasser@Rentonwa.gov] Sent: Thursday, August 26, 2010 9:09 AM To: Peter Zuvela Subject: FW: Barbee Mill Watercraft lifts (at Cugini Joint Use Pier), Notice of Application and Proposed Determination of Non-Significance -Mitigated Hello Peter: I am forwarding the comments (below) from Karen Walter at the Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Division to you. would like to respond to Karen Walter as early as possible this morning. Gerald C. Wasser, Associate Planner Department of Community & Economic Development City of Renton 1055 South Grady Way Renton, WA 98057 (425) 430-7382 FAX(425)430-7300 gwasser@rentonwa.gov From: Karen Walter [mailto:KWalter@muckleshoot.nsn.us] Sent: Friday, August 20, 2010 3:08 PM To: Gerald Wasser Subject: Barbee Mill Watercraft lifts (at Cugini Joint Use Pier), Notice of Application and Proposed Determination of Non- Significance -Mitigated Mr. Wasser, In response to the City's Notice of Application materials for the above referenced project, we are submitting the questions and initial comments to this project that we previously sent in response to the Letter of Permission Notice from the Corps of Engineers. We have not yet received a response to these questions about the project; therefore, it is prudent to send them to City as well since there was no new information in the City's packet to answer the questions we raised below. The existing dock project described below was permitted by the City via permit# LUA01-015. We appreciate the opportunity to review this proposal. Please let me know if you have any questions. Thank you, Karen Walter Watersheds and Land Use Team Leader Muck/eshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Division 39015172'd Ave SE Auburn, WA 98092 253-876-3116 From: Karen Walter Sent: Monday, August 09, 2010 4:37 PM To: Susan Powell Subject: LOP NWS-2010-904, Barbee Mill Company boatlifts Susan, The Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Division has reviewed the above referenced Letter of Permission to install two boatlifts, a jetski lift and a platform lift to provide private boat moorage to four residences. We have some questions about this project and an initial comment as noted below: 2 1. Previously, the Corps issued a 404 permit to construct a joint-use pier and ramp to serve three waterfront lots and plant native shoreline vegetation under permit 200200724 (Cugini). Were the native plants actually planted and is there a copy of the as-built drawings and/or monitoring plans for these plants? If so, we would appreciate a copy of these documents to verify the previous mitigation required for the pier and ramp. 2. As noted in the question above, the original joint pier was constructed to serve three waterfront lots. The pending Corps permit is to provide moorage for four residences. Where exactly are the four residences that will obtain moorage if the latest Corps permit is approved? 3. As far as the proposed LOP is concerned, the project proposes to install a grated platform boatlift just past the existing ramp where the existing pier begins from the shore. While grated, this platform lift will result in more over/in-water coverage than the proposed freestanding boatlifts. Please explain why a third free standing boatlift without a platform cannot be used to provide moorage instead of the proposed platform lift. It seems the jetski lift could be relocated and a third freestanding boatlift without a platform could be constructed where the jetski lift is proposed, resulting in a project with less impact than what is proposed. 4. The proposed LOP project also is seeking to replace 3-12 inch diameter creosote wood mooring piles per dolphin for the two outermost dolphins shown on Sheet 2 as mitigation. What is the purpose of the mooring piles and associated log booms? Do these dolphins need to be replaced anyway? Why not replace the two most landward dolphins to get rid of some of the vertical structure in the nearshore environment? 5. Instead of the replacing the two existing dolphins with a single 12 inch diameter steel pile, we recommend that all of the dolphin mooring piles and log boom structure shown along the southern edge of the property in Sheets 2 and 3 be removed as mitigation for the increase in overwater coverage as a result of the new lifts and their associated watercraft. This mitigation measure would reduce inwater structure that potentially provides salmon predators with ambush habitat while meeting the project's purpose since the new lifts will be providing moorage at the existing dock. We appreciate the opportunity and look forward to the Corps responses to our comments. We may have additional comments subsequently. Please let me know if you have any questions. Thank you, Karen Walter Watersheds and Land Use Team Leader Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Division 39015 172'" Ave SE Auburn WA 98092 253-876-3116 3 From: Alan Foltz Sent: Thursday, August 26, 2010 9:55 AM To: Peter Zuvela Subject: FW: LOP NWS-2010-904, Barbee Mill Company boatlifts From: Alan Foltz Sent: Tuesday, August 17, 2010 3:56 PM To: 'Powell, Susan M NWS' Subject: RE: LOP NWS-2010-904, Barbee Mill Company boatlift:s Page 1 of4 Susan, In that you are on vacation this week, I am also mailing this response to your attention, along with the the site survey and photographs mentioned, supportive to our response, and Karen's questions. We do not have any records on the former permit compliance, as built drawings, or follow through on the mitigation requirements. I hope that the photos I am mailing are supportive to our application for the lifts. Please let me know if I can help in obtaining any details from Barbee Mill regarding the earlier permits. I will be leaving Friday, returning on September 9th. I hope to hear from you at that time. Sincerely, AJ.an foltz@waterfrontconstruction.com -----Original Message----- Frorn: Powell, Susan M NWS [mailto:Susan.M.Powell@usace.army.mil] Sent: Tuesday, August 10, 2010 10:45 AM To: Alan Foltz Subject: FW: LOP NWS-2010-904, Barbee Mill Company boatlifts Hi Alan, please respond to the comments/questions below from the Muckleshoot Tribe. Question #2 refers to the number of houses. I thought there was four, Karen thinks there's three, you said sornetning about up to nine condos. Please provide further information on exactly what the housing situation is at the site. Thanks, Susan -----Original Message----- Frorn: Karen Walter [mailto:KWalter@muckleshoot.nsn.us] Sent: Monday, August 09, 2010 4:37 PM To: Powell, Susan M NWS Subject: LOP NWS-2010-904, Barbee Mill Company boatlifts Susan, The Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Division has reviewed the above referenced Letter of Permission to install two boatlifts, a jetski lift and a plat:orm lift to provide private boat rnoorage to four residences. We have some questions about this project and an initial comment as noted below: 1. Previously, the Corps issued a 404 permit to construct a joint-use pier and ramp to serve three waterfront lots and plant native shoreline file://C:\Documents and Settings\gwasser\Local Settings\Temporary Internet Files\Conte... 08/26/2010 Page 2 of 4 vegetation under permit 200280724 (C~gini:. Were the native plants actually planted and is theYe a copy of the as-bui~t drawings and/or rno~ilori~g plans for these plants? ::::f so, we would appreciate a copy of these docurr.ents to verify the prev.:.-ous mitigatior. required for the pier and ramp. • The joint use p.:._er pe::::-mits were established by others, not Waterfront Construction. From our understanding however, we can respo~d to the questions asked: • There are four waterfront lots fbr the joint use pier. See Survey drawing shows Lots A through D. • We do not have the associated planting plan, though have attached photos of the site ~oday with plantings presumed to be in fol~owing of tb.e p~anting plan. • We do not have the pier as built drawi~gs, however the Waterfront Construction permit drawings for the lifts rep~esent the pier structure accurately. 2. As noted in the question above, the original joint pier was constructed to serve three waterfront lots. The.pending Corps permit is to provide moorage for four residences. Where exactly are the four residences that will obtain moorage if the latest Corps permit is approved? • Please see the attached survey showing the ~ot line adjustments and the four lots participating with the joint use p~er. 3. As far as the proposed LOP is concerned, the project proposes to install a grated platform boatlift just past the existing ramp where the existing pier begins from the shore. While grated, this platform lift will result in more over/in-water coverage than the proposed freestanding boatlifts. Please explain why a third free standi.ng boatlift without a platform cannot be used to provide rnoorage instead of the proposed platform lift. It seems the jetski lift could be relocated and a third freestanding boatlift without a platform could be constructed where the jetski lift is proposed, resulting in a project with less impact than what is proposed. • The free slanding platforn l~ft is proposed as a safety measure to allow an intermediate elevation between the fixed pier height above OHW and the lake level in winter when the lake level is down approx. 2' fron OHW. In winter, the lake level can be as much as 4'-7'' from the pier decking, making it awkward, diffi~ult, and unsafe for senior residence members to board small boats which are low to the water. There is very litt2.e impact from the proposed, as che platforffi is fully grated, as is the existing pier. 4. The proposed LOP project also is seeking to replace 3-12 inch diameter creosote wood mooring piles per dolphin for the two outermost dolphins shown on Sheet 2 as mitigation. What is the purpose of the mooring piles and associated log booms? Do these dolphins need to be replaced anyway? Why not replace the two most landward dolphins to get rid of some of the vertical structure in the nearshore environment? • The purpose of the existing piles and the log boom is to protect the moorage from southwest winter storms which are severe in the area, as the sea fetch extends all the way from the southwest side of lower Lake Washington in Renton. file://C:\Documents and Settings\gwasser\Local Settings\Temporary Internet Files\Conte... 08/26/20 I 0 Page 3 of 4 Removal js not an optio~. Tt1e existi~q strcctu::es are ln good condition. The proposed p11rpose is ~or tie Corps RGPl ::equirea ~it~gation, as o~hcr optio:1.s of the RGPl have been es~ablished on the site. The outer end of this nrotective system was elected solely for ~he ~itigation, as with the south adjacent prope::ty being only 20' t-/-away, Lhere is little accessibil.:._ty fo::::-a barge or equipment to work witl1 the nearshore pylons. 5. Instead of the replacing the two existing dolphins with a single 12 inch diameter steel pile, we reconunend that all of the dolphin mooring pi.les and log boom structure shown along the southern edge of the property in Sheets 2 and 3 be removed as mitigation for the increase in overwater coverage as a result of the new lifts and their associated watercraft. This mitigation measure would reduce inwater structure that potentially provides salmon predators with ambush habitat while meeting the project's purpose since the new lifts will be providing rnoorage at the existing dock. • As nentioned in the oriqinal applications, removal of the existing protective log system is not an option for our client. It was elected as a viable form of ~itigation for the proposed lifts, in that other mitigation for the property has already been applied to the site. With the deep water th=oughout the entire end, that area for the proposed lifts, mostly at 20' depth, and at 10'~ at the nearshore the positive impact of your suggested handling is lik.e~y minimal to the effect would result in shallow waters. We appreciate the opportunity and look forward to the Corps responses to our comments. We may have additional comments subsequently. Please let me know if you have any questions. Thank you, Karen Walter Watersheds and Land Use Team Leader Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Division 39015 112nd Ave SE Auburn WA 98092 2 5 3-8 7 6-3116 file://C:\Documents and Settingslgwasser\Local Settings\ Temporary Internet Files\Conte... 08/26/2010 Page4of4 file://C:\Documents and Settingslgwasser\Local Settings\Temporary Internet Files\Conte... 08/26/2010 From: Alan Foltz Sent: Wednesday, August 18,2010 9:20 AM To: 'Powell, Susan M NWS' Cc: 'Robert Cugini' Subject: FW: LOP NWS-2010-904, Barbee Mill Company boatlifts Page 1 of 1 Hi Susan: When you return, in addition to yesterday's response regarding the Muckleshoot Tribe questions, please note the attached comment on performed mitigation from our client, and the two photos showing the mitigations completed with regard to the pier permitting. This should resolve any concerns of the Muckleshoot Tribe and Corps interests. I 'II be back on the 9th of September. Possibly this permit can be moving along and close to issue at that time. Sincerely, Alan foltz@waterfrontconstruction.com Thank you Robert for your quick assistance with the above information and drawings. Susan is on vacation presently. The documentation should allow continuation and issue of the Corps Permit. Regards, Alan From: Robert Cugini [mailto:robertc@barbeemill.com] Sent: Tuesday, August 17, 2010 5:25 PM To: Alan Foltz Subject: RE: LOP NWS-2010-904, Barbee Mill Company boatlifts OK, here is the status, there were three houses built that relate to the pier. These had conditions of natural plantings and native buffers. We have met or execeeded all work that was required for both the houses and the pier construction. Additionally we vault and oil seperate all storm water from the site. All native plantings are in and being maintained (See Attached pictures). Additionally all upland plantings outside of the buffers were also done in native plantings. I'm very happy with the results. Additonally on ajoining lots there are two additonal structures, a small house, we call the "Little House" which was the the orginal guard house for the Mill. It dates to the orginal use of the site around 1917. It was renovated about 15 years ago. Native plantings have been installed instead of lawn lakeside. Additionally there is a Boat house on a seperate lot which houses a 56 foot boat, At the very northern end which currently has all the permits necessary for a renovation. We are planning on doing this work the next available fish window that equipment is available. At this time no mitigation has been done because the work has not yet been started. There are mitigation measures required in these permits and we intend to do everything required. Michael Lloyd is handling that process and Baylis Architects are the project designers. These are all seperate legal properties. The permits for the dock relate to the three home constructed, as it was "Joint use" All mitigation requirement have been fullfilled, other than monitoring the health of the plant material, and replacing what the beaver chews up. Let me know if you need any additional clarification. Hope that helps file://C:\Documents and Settingslgwasser\Local Settings\Temporary Internet Files\Conte... 08/26/2010 PROJECT LUA-10-047, ECF, SA-A 109 Logan Avenue Mixed Use City of Renton Department of Planning / Building / Public Works ENVIRONMENTAL & DEVELOPMENTAL APPLICATION REVIEW SHEET (Continuation) POLICE RELATED COMMENTS 10 Police Calls for Service Estimated Annually CONSTRUCTION PHASE Theft from construction sites is one of the most commonly reported crimes in the City. To protect materials and equipment it is recommended that all materials and tools be locked up when not in use. The site should have security lighting, and any construction trailer or storage area should be completely fenced-in with portable chain-link fencing. The fence will provide both a physical and psychological barrier to any prospective criminal and will demonstrate that the area is private property. Construction trailers should be kept locked when not in use, and should be fitted with heavy-duty deadbolts with a minimum 1-1/2" throw when bolted. Glass windows in construction trailers should be shatter-resistant. Toolboxes and storage containers should be secured with heavy-duty padlocks and kept locked when not in use. "No Trespassing" signs should be posted on the property during the construction phase. These signs allow officers, upon contact, to provide a verbal warning to trespassers that should they be contacted on the property again, they could be cited and/or arrested. COMPLETED COMPLEX All exterior doors should be made of solid metal or metal over wood, with heavy-duty deadbolt locks, latch guards or pry-resistant cylinders around the locks, and peepholes. If glass doors are used, they should be fitted with the hardware described above and additionally be fitted with a layer of security film. Security film can increase the strength of the glass by up to 300%, greatly reducing the likelihood of breaking glass to gain entry. Access to the back of the buildings should be limited, preferably with security fencing, as these areas could be vulnerable to crime due to the lack of natural surveillance by business customers or tenants. It is recommended that the commercial areas be monitored with recorded security alarm systems installed. It's not uncommon for businesses to experience theft and/or vandalism during the hours of darkness. An auxiliary security service could be used to patrol the property during those times. It is important to direct all foot traffic into the main entrance of the building. Any alternative employee entrances should have coded access to prevent trespassing. Security Survey Page 1 of 2 10-047 Payphones are not recomm¥ .. ded for this mixed-use building. I ere are payphones in the business complex, it is recommended they be outgoing use only. Public payphones tend to attract drug traffic and having only the ability to call out on payphones severely hinders this type of activity. All areas of this project need to have adequate lighting. This will assist in the deterrent of theft from motor vehicle (one of the most common crimes in Renton) as well as provide safe pedestrian travel for customers of the complex. The structure should have a building number clearly posted with numbers at least 6" in height and of a color contrasting with the building. Unit numbers for the dwellings should also be illuminated so that they are easily located. This will assist emergency personnel in locating the correct location for response. Landscaping should be installed with the objective of allowing visibility -not too dense and not too high. Too much landscaping will make customers, employees, and tenants feel isolated and will provide criminals with concealment to commit crimes such as burglary. It is key for a business complex to have appropriate lighting and signage. "No Trespassing" signs should be posted in conspicuous locations throughout the property, including entrances to the property and parking areas. I highly recommend that the developer have a Renton Police Crime Prevention Representative conduct a security survey of the premises once construction is complete. Security Survey Page 2 of 2 10-047 City of Ren,on Department of Community & Economic Development ENVIRONMENTAL & DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION REVIEW SHEET REVIEWING DEPARTMENT COMMENTS DUE: AUGUST 6, 2010 APPLICATION NO: LUAl0-047, ECF, SA-A DATE CIRCULATED: JULY 23, 2010 APPLICANT: Amrik Kamoh & Angie Singh PLANNER: Jerry Wasser PROJECT TITLE: 109 Logan Avenue Mixed Use PLAN REVIEWER: Arneta Henninger SITE AREA: 10,000 square feet EXISTING BLDG AREA (gross): 1,270 square feet LOCATION: 109 Logan Avenue S PROPOSED BLDG AREA (gross) 13,690 square feet SUMMARY OF PROPOSAL: The applicant is requesting Environmental (SEPA) Review and approval of an administrative Site Plan Review for the construction of a mixed use project consisting of two 3-story, 36 to 40-foot tall buildings on a 10,000 square foot site located in the Center Downtown (CD) zone, Downtown Core area, and Urban Design Overlay District 'A'. The proposed buildings would include 11,268 square of residential space with a total of 10 residential units, 2,422 square feet of commercial space, and 11 partially covered and surface parking spaces. Access to the site would be provided via a driveway off of Logan Avenue$. The site is located within a seismic hazard area. A. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT (e.g. Non-Cade) COMMENTS Element of the Probable Probable More Environment Minor Major Information Impacts Impacts Necessary Element of the Probable Probable More Environment Minor Major Information Impacts Impacts Necessary Earth Housina Air Aesthetics Water Uaht/Glare Plants Recreation Land/Shoreline Use Utilities ; Animals Trans""rtation / Environmental Health Public Services ~ Energy/ Historic/Cultural Natural Resources Preservation Airport Environment 10,000Feet 14,000Feet ID U:S .J.S17.f)1akd.._ -"J«_ B. POLICY-RELATED COMMENTS C. CODE-RELATED COMMENTS We have reviewed this application with particular attention to those areas in which we have expertise and have identified areas of probable impact or areas where additional infor ation is needed to properly assess this proposal. Date Gerald Wasser From: Gerald Wasser Sent: To: Thursday, August 26, 2010 10:32 AM 'Karen Walter' Cc: Jennifer T. Henning Subject: FW: Barbee Mill Watercraft lifts (at Cugini Joint Use Pier), Notice of Application and Proposed Determination of Non-Significance -Mitigated Attachments: Barbee Mill (1).htm; Mitigation documentation.him Hello Ms. Walter: Thank you for your comments and questions on LUAl0-050, Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts. Your questions would more appropriately be answered by the Army Corps of Engineers. However, I have contacted Waterfront Construction, Inc. and they have provided me with emails which were sent to Susan Powell with responses to your questions and comments. I am forwarding the correspondence from Waterfront Construction, Inc. to you. Should you have additional questions, please contact me. Jerry Gerald C. Wasser, Associate Planner Department of Community & Economic Development City of Renton 1055 South Grady Way Renton, WA 98057 (425) 430-7382 FAX(425)430-7300 gwasser@rentonwa.gov From: Peter Zuvela [mailto:Peter@waterfrontconstruction.com] Sent: Thursday, August 26, 2010 10:09 AM To: Gerald Wasser Cc: Alan Foltz Subject: RE: Barbee Mill Watercraft lifts (at Cugini Joint Use Pier), Notice of Application and Proposed Determination of Non-Significance -Mitigated Gerald, Attached are two email strings from Alan Foltz regarding these same questions. The one titled "Barbee Mill (1)" is from Alan to Susan Powell with the Army Corps responding directly to Karen's questions below. The second is from Robert Cugini regarding the housing situation. Hope this helps. Let me know if you need anything more from me. Thanks, Peter Zuvela Permit Coordinator Waterfront Construction, Inc. 205 NE Northlake Way, Suite 230 Seattle, WA 98105 Phone: (206) 548-9800 Fax: (206) 548-1 022 I From: Gerald Wasser [mailto:GWasser@Rentonwa.gov] Sent: Thursday, August 26, 2010 9:09 AM To: Peter Zuvela Subject: FW: Barbee Mill Watercraft lifts (at Cugini Joint Use Pier), Notice of Application and Proposed Determination of Non-Significance -Mitigated Hello Peter: I am forwarding the comments (below) from Karen Walter at the Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Division to you. would like to respond to Karen Walter as early as possible this morning. Gerald C. Wasser, Associate Planner Department of Community & Economic Development City of Renton 1055 South Grady Way Renton, WA 98057 (425) 430-7382 FAX (425) 430-7300 gwasser@rentonwa.gov From: Karen Walter [mailto:KWalter@muckleshoot.nsn.us] Sent: Friday, August 20, 2010 3:08 PM To: Gerald Wasser Subjep:: Barbee Mill Watercraft lifts (at Cugini Joint Use Pier), Notice of Application and Proposed Determination of Non- Significance -Mitigated Mr. Wasser, In response to the City's Notice of Application materials for the above referenced project, we are submitting the questions and initial comments to this project that we previously sent in response to the Letter of Permission Notice from the Corps of Engineers. We have not yet received a response to these questions about the project; therefore, it is prudent to send them to City as well since there was no new information in the City's packet to answer the questions we raised below. The existing dock project described belowwas permitted by the City via permit# LUA01-015. We appreciate the opportunity to review this proposal. Please let me know if you have any questions. Thank you, Karen Walter Watersheds and Land Use Team Leader Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Division 3901517z>d Ave SE Auburn, WA 98092 253-876-3116 From: Karen Walter Sent: Monday, August 09, 2010 4:37 PM To: Susan Powell Subject: LOP NWS-2010-904, Barbee Mill Company boatlifts Susan, The Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Division has reviewed the above referenced Letter of Permission to install two boatlifts, a jetski lift and a platform lift to provide private boat moorage to four residences. We have some questions about this project and an initial comment as noted below: 2 1. Previously, the Corps issued a 404 permit to construct a joint-use pier and ramp to serve three waterfront Jots and plant native shoreline vegetation under permit 200200724 (Cugini). Were the native plants actually planted and is there a copy of the as-built drawings and/or monitoring plans for these plants? If so, we would appreciate a copy of these documents to verify the previous mitigation required for the pier and ramp. 2. As noted in the question above, the original joint pier was constructed to serve three waterfront lots. The pending Corps permit is to provide moorage for four residences. Where exactly are the four residences that will obtain moorage if the latest Corps permit is approved? 3. As far as the proposed LOP is concerned, the project proposes to install a grated platform boatlift just past the existing ramp where the existing pier begins from the shore. While grated, this platform lift will result in more over/in-water coverage than the proposed freestanding boatlifts. Please explain why a third free standing boatlift without a platform cannot be used to provide moorage instead of the proposed platform lift. It seems the jetski lift could be relocated and a third freestanding boatlift without a platform could be constructed where the jetski lift is proposed, resulting in a project with less impact than what is proposed. 4. The proposed LOP project also is seeking to replace 3-12 inch diameter creosote wood mooring piles per dolphin for the two outermost dolphins shown on Sheet 2 as mitigation. What is the purpose of the mooring piles and associated Jog booms? Do these dolphins need to be replaced anyway? Why not replace the two most landward dolphins to get rid of some of the vertical structure in the nearshore environment? 5. Instead of the replacing the two existing dolphins with a single 12 inch diameter steel pile, we recommend that all of the dolphin mooring piles and log boom structure· shown along the southern edge of the property in Sheets 2 and 3 be removed as mitigation for the increase in overwater coverage as a result of the new lifts and their associated watercraft. This mitigation measure would reduce inwater structure that potentially provides salmon predators with ambush habitat while meeting the project's purpose since the new lifts will be providing moorage at the existing dock. We appreciate the opportunity and look forward to the Corps responses to our comments. We may have additional comments subsequently. Please let me know if you have any questions. Thank you, Karen Walter Watersheds and Land Use Team Leader Muck/eshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Division 39015 172"° Ave SE Auburn WA 98092 253-876-3116 3 From: Alan Foltz Sent: Thursday, August 26,2010 9:55 AM To: Peter Zuvela Subject: FW: LOP NWS-2010-904, Barbee Mill Company boatlifts From: Alan Foltz Sent: Tuesday, August 17, 2010 3:56 PM To: 'Powell, Susan M NWS' Subject: RE: LOP NWS-2010-904, Barbee Mill Company boatlifts Page I of 4 Susan, In that you are on vacation this week, I am also mailing this response to your attention, along with the the site survey and photographs mentioned, supportive to our response, and Karen's questions. We do not have any records on the former permit compliance, as built drawings, or follow through on the mitigation requirements. I hope that the photos I am mailing are supportive to our application for the lifts. Please let me know if I can help in obtaining any details from Barbee Mill regarding the earlier permits. I will be leaving Friday, returning on September 9th. I hope to hear from you at that time. Sincerely, Alan foltz@waterfrontconstruction.com -----Original Message----- From; Powell, Susan M NWS [mailto:Susan.M.Powell@usace.army.mil] Sent: Tuesday, August 10, 2010 10:45 AM To: Alan Foltz Subject: FW: LOP NWS-2010-904, Barbee Mill Company boatlifts Hi Alan, please respond to the comments/questions below from the Muckleshoot Tribe. Question #2 refers to the number of houses. I thought there was four, Karen thinks there's three, you said something about up to nine condos. Please provide further information on exactly what the housing situation is at the site. Thanks, Susan -----Original Message----- From: Karen Walter [mailto:KWalter@muckleshoot.nsn.us] Sent: Monday, August 09, 2010 4:37 PM To: Powell, Susan M NWS Subject: LOP NWS-2010-904, Barbee Mill Company boatlifts Susan, The Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Division has reviewed the above referenced Letter of Permission to install two boatlifts, a jetski lift and a platform lift to provide private boat moorage to four residences. We have some questions about this project and an initial conunent as noted below: 1. Previously, the Corps issued a 404 permit to construct a joint-use pier and ramp to serve three waterfront lots and plant native shoreline file://C:\Documents and Settings\gwasser\Local Settings\Temporary Internet Files\Conte... 08/26/2010 Page 2 of 4 vegetation under permit 200200724 (Cugini). Were the na~ive plants actually planted and is there a copy of the as-bui]t drawings and/or monitoring plans for these plants? If so, we would appreciate a copy of these documents ~o verify the previous mitigation required for the pier and ramp. • The joint use pie~ permits were established by others, not Waterfront Construction. From our understanding however, we can respond to the questions asked: • There are four waterfront lots for the joint use pier. See Survey drawing shows Lots A through D. • We do not have the associated planting plan, though have attached photos of the site today with plantings presumed to be in following of the planting plan. • We do not have the pier as built drawings, however the Waterfront Construction permit drawings for the lifts represent the pier structure accurately. 2. As noted in the question above, the original joint pier was constructed to serve three waterfront lots. The pending Corps permit is to provide moorage for four residences. Where exactly are the four residences that will obtain moorage if the latest Corps permit is approved? • Please see the attached survey showing the lot line adjustments and the four lots participating with the joint use pier. 3. As far as the proposed LOP is concerned, the project proposes to install a grated platform boatlift just past the existing ramp where the existing pier begins from the shore. While grated, this platform lift will result in more over/in-water coverage than the proposed freestanding boatlifts. Please explain why a third free standing boatlift without a platform cannot be used to provide moorage instead of the proposed platform lift. It seems the jetski lift could be relocated and a third freestanding boatlift without a platform could be constructed where the jetski lift is proposed, resulting in a project with less impact than what is proposed. • The free standing platform lift is proposed as a safety measure to allow an intermediate elevation between the fixed pier height above OHW and the lake level in winter when the lake level is down approx. 2' from OHW. In winter, the lake level can be as much as 4'-7" from the pier decking, making it awkward, difficult, and unsafe for senior residence members to board small boats which are low to the water. There is very little impact from the proposed, as the platform is fully grated, as is the existing pier. 4. The proposed LOP project also is seeking to replace 3-12 inch diameter creosote wood mooring piles per dolphin for the two outermost dolphins shown on Sheet 2 as mitigation. What is the purpose of the mooring piles and associated log booms? Do these dolphins need to be replaced anyway? Why not replace the two most landward dolphins to get rid of some of the vertical structure in the nearshore environment? • The purpose of the existing piles and the log boom -is to protect the rnoorage from southwest winter storms which are severe in the area, as the sea fetch extends all the way from the southwest side of lower Lake Washington in Renton. file://C:\Documents and Settings\gwasser\Local Settings\Temporary Internet Files\Conte... 08/26/2010 Page 3 of 4 Removal is not an option. Thi exi.sting st~uctures are in good condition. The proposed purpose is for ~he Corps 2.GPl required mitigationr as other options of the RGPl have been established on the site. The oute~ end of this protective system was elected soleJ.y for the mitigation, as with the south adjacent property bei~g only 20'+/-away, there is little accessibility for a barge or equipment to work with the nearshore pylons. 5. Instead of the replacing the two existing dolphins with a single 12 inch diameter steel pile, we recorrunend that all of the dolphin mooring piles and log boom structure shown along the southern edge of the p~operty in Sheets 2 and 3 be removed as mitigation for the increase in overwater coverage as a result of the new lifts and their associated watercraft. This mitigation measure would reduce inwater structure that potentially provides salmon predators with ambush habitat while meeting the project's purpose since the new lifts will be providing moorage at the existing dock. • As mentioned in the original applications, removal of the existing protective log system is not an option for our client. It was elected as a viable form of mitigation for the proposed lifts, in that other mitigation for the property has already been applied to the site. With the deep water throughout the entire area for the proposed lifts, mostly at 20' depth, and at 10'+ at the nearshore end, the positive impact of your suggested handling is likely minimal to the effect that would result in shallow waters. We appreciate the opportunity and look forward to the Corps responses to our comments. We may have additional comments subsequently. Please let me know if you have any questions. Thank you, Karen Walter Watersheds and Land Use Team Leader Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Division 39015 172nd Ave SE Auburn WA 98092 253-876-3116 file://C:\Documents and Settings\gwasser\Local Settings\Temporary Internet Files\Conte... 08/26/2010 Page 4 of 4 file://C:\Documents and Settings\gwasser\Local Settings\Temporary Internet Files\Conte... 08/26/2010 From: Alan Foltz Sent: Wednesday, August 18, 2010 9:20 AM To: 'Powell, Susan M NWS' Cc: 'Robert Cugini' Subject: FW: LOP NWS-2010-904, Barbee Mill Company boatlifts Page 1 of 1 Hi Susan: When you return, in addition to yesterday's response regarding the Muckleshoot Tribe questions, please note the attached comment on performed mitigation from our client, and the two photos showing the mitigations completed with regard to the pier permitting. This should resolve any concerns of the Muckleshoot Tribe and Corps interests. I 'II be back on the gth of September. Possibly this permit can be moving along and close to issue at that time. Sincerely, Alan foltz@waterfrontconstruction.com Thank you Robert for your quick assistance with the above information and drawings. Susan is on vacation presently. The documentation should allow continuation and issue of the Corps Permit. Regards, Alan From: Robert Cugini [mailto:robertc@barbeemill.com] Sent: Tuesday, August 17, 2010 5:25 PM To: Alan Foltz Subject: RE: LOP NWS-2010-904, Barbee Mill Company boatlifts OK, here is the status, there were three houses built that relate to the pier. These had conditions of natural plantings and native buffers. We have met or execeeded all work that was required for both the houses and the pier construction. Additionally we vault and oil seperate all storm water from the site. All native plantings are in and being maintained (See Attached pictures). Additionally all upland plantings outside of the buffers were also done in native plantings. I'm very happy with the results. Additonally on ajoining lots there are two additonal structures, a small house, we call the "Little House" which was the the orginal guard house for the Mill. It dates to the orginal use of the site around 1917. It was renovated about 15 years ago. Native plantings have been installed instead of lawn lakeside. Additionally there is a Boat house on a seperate lot which houses a 56 foot boat, At the very northern end which currently has all the permits necessary for a renovation. We are planning on doing this work the next available fish window that equipment is available. At this time no mitigation has been done because the work has not yet been started. There are mitigation measures required in these penmits and we intend to do everything required. Michael Lloyd is handling that process and Baylis Architects are the project designers. These are all seperate legal properties. The permits for the dock relate to the three home constructed, as it was "Joint use" All mitigation requirement have been fullfilled, other than monitoring the health of the plant material, and replacing what the beaver chews up. Let me know if you need any additional clarification. Hope that helps file://C:\Documents and Settings\gwasser\Local Settings\Temporary Internet Files\Conte... 08/26/2010 City of Renton Department of Community & Economic Development ENVIRONMENTAL & DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION REVIEW SHEET REv1Ew1NG DEPARTMENT: &c~,GIY\ 1 c U"'V. COMMENTS DUE: AUGUST 20, 2010 APPLICATION NO: LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC DATE CIRCULATED: AUGUST 6, 2010 APPLICANT: Robert Cugini -Barbee Mill Company PLANNER: Jerry Wasser PROJECT TITLE: Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts PLAN REVIEWER: Kayren Kittrick SITE AREA: 8,870 square feet EXISTING BLDG AREA (gross): N/A LOCATION: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd N PROPOSED BLDG AREA (gross) N/A SUMMARY OF PROPOSAL: The applicant requests SEPA Review and approval of a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit and a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit for the installation of two 10-foot by 14-foot freestanding boatlifts, one 10-foot by 20-foot freestanding boatlift lift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock which serves three lots. A. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT {e.g. Non-Code} COMMENTS Element of the Probable Probable Mo,e Environment Minor Major Information Impacts Impacts Necessary Element of the Probable Probable More Environment Minor Major Information Imparts Impacts Necessary Earth Housina Air Aesthetics Water Liaht/Glore Plants Recreation Land/Shoreline Use Utilities Animals Tronsoortation Environmental Health Public Services Energy/ Historic/Cultural Natural Resources Preservation Airport Environment 10,000Feet 14,DOOFeet B. POLICY-RELATED COMMENTS C. COOE-RELATEDCOMMENTS We have reviewed this application with particular attention to those areas in which we have expertise and have identified areas of probable impact or areas where additional information is needed to properly assess this proposal. Gerald Wasser From: Karen Walter [KWalter@muckleshoot.nsn.us] Friday, August 20, 2010 3:08 PM Sent: To: Gerald Wasser Subject: Barbee Mill Watercraft lifts (at Cugini Joint Use Pier), Notice of Application and Proposed Determination of Non-Significance -Mitigated Mr. Wasser, In response to the City's Notice of Application materials for the above referenced project, we are submitting the questions and initial comments to this project that we previously sent in response to the Letter of Permission Notice from the Corps of Engineers. We have not yet received a response to these questions about the project; therefore, it is prudent to send them to City as well since there was no new information in the City's packet to answer the questions we raised below. The existing dock project described below was permitted by the City via permit# LUA01-015. We appreciate the opportunity to review this proposal. Please let me know if you have any questions. Thank you, Karen Walter Watersheds and Land Use Team Leader Muck/eshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Division 39015 172"" Ave SE Auburn, WA 98092 253-876-3116 From: Karen Walter Sent: Monday, August 09, 2010 4:37 PM To: Susan Powell Subject: LOP NWS-2010-904, Barbee Mill Company boatlifts Susan, The Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Division has reviewed the above referenced Letter of Permission to install two boatlifts, a jetski lift and a platform lift to provide private boat moorage to four residences. We have some questions about this project and an initial comment as noted below: 1. Previously, the Corps issued a 404 permit to construct a joint-use pier and ramp to serve three waterfront lots and plant native shoreline vegetation under permit 200200724 (Cugini). Were the native plants actually planted and is there a copy of the as-built drawings and/or monitoring plans for these plants? If so, we would appreciate a copy of these documents to verify the previous mitigation required for the pier and ramp. 2. As noted in the question above, the original joint pier was constructed to serve three waterfront lots. The pending Corps pemnit is to provide moorage for four residences. Where exactly are the four residences that will obtain moorage if the latest Corps permit is approved? 3. As far as the proposed LOP is concerned, the project proposes to install a grated platfomn boatlift just past the existing ramp where the existing pier begins from the shore. While grated, this platfomn lift will result in more over/in-water coverage than the proposed freestanding boatlifts. Please explain why a third free standing boatlift without a platform cannot be used to provide moorage instead of the proposed platform lift. It seems the jetski lift could be relocated and a third freestanding boatlift without a platform could be constructed where the jetski lift is proposed, resulting in a project with less impact than what is proposed. 4. The proposed LOP project also is seeking to replace 3-12 inch diameter creosote wood mooring piles per dolphin for the two outermost dolphins shown on Sheet 2 as mitigation. What is the purpose of the mooring piles and associated log booms? Do these dolphins need to be replaced anyway? Why not replace the two most landward dolphins to get rid of some of the vertical structure in the nearshore environment? 1 5. Instead of the replacing the two existing dolphins with a single 12 inch diameter steel pile, we recommend that all of the dolphin mooring piles and log boom structure shown along the southern edge of the property in Sheets 2 and 3 be removed as mitigation for the increase in overwater coverage as a result of the new lifts and their associated watercraft. This mitigation measure would reduce inwater structure that potentially provides salmon predators with ambush habitat while meeting the project's purpose since the new lifts will be providing moorage at the existing dock. We appreciate the opportunity and look forward to the Corps responses to our comments. We may have additional comments subsequently. Please let me know if you have any questions. Thank you, Karen Walter Watersheds and Land Use Team Leader Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Division 39015 172"" Ave SE Auburn WA 98092 253-876-3116 2 DATE: TO: FROM: SUBJECT: CITY OF RENTON FIRE PREVENTION BUREAU MEMORANDUM August 18, 2010 Developmental Services David Pargas, Assistant Fire Marshal Land Use Barbee Mill Dock 1. No Fire Code requirements noted for this personal Dock associated to a residence .. City of Renton Deportment of Community & Economic Development ENVIRONMENTAL & DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION REVIEW SHEET REVIEWING DEPARTMENT: 'F i ((. COMMENTS OUE: AUGUST 20, 2010 APPLICATION NO: LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC DATE CIRCULATED: AUGUST 6, 2010 APPLICANT: Robert Cugini -Barbee Mill Company PLANNER: Jerry Wasser PROJECT TITLE: Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts PLAN REVIEWER: Kayren Kittrick SITE AREA: 8,870 square feet EXISTING BLDG AREA (gross): N/A LOCATION: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd N PROPOSED BLDG AREA (gross) N/A SUMMARY OF PROPOSAL: The applicant requests SEPA Review and approval of a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit and a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit for the installation of two 10-foot by 14-foot freestanding boatlifts, one 10-foot by 20-foot freestanding boatlift lift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock which serves three lots. A. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT (e.g. Non-Code) COMMENTS Element of the Probable Probable More Environment Minor Major Information Impacts Impacts Necessary Element of the Probable Probable More Environment Minor Major Information Impacts Impacts Necessary Earth Housina Air Aesthetics Water Liaht/Glare Plants Recreation Land/Shoreline Use Utilities Animals Tronsoortation Environmental Health Public Services Energy/ Historic/Cultural Natural Resources Preservation Airport Environment 10,000 Feet 14,000Feet 8. POLICY-RELATED COMMENTS C. CODE-RELATED COMMENTS We have reviewed this application w;th particular attention to those areas in which we have expertise and have identified areas of probable impact or areas where additional information is needed to properly assess this proposal. Signature of Director or Authorized Representative Date City af Renton Department of Community & Economic Development ENVIRONMENTAL & DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION REVIEW SHEET REVIEWING DEPARTMENT: Pr--r{r"Y~ I Svcs COMMENTS DUE: AUGUST 20, 2010 • ,._J APPLICATION NO: LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC DATE CIRCULATED: AUGUST 6, 2010 APPLICANT: Robert Cugini -Barbee Mill Company PLANNER: Jerry Wasser PROJECT TITLE: Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts PLAN REVIEWER: Kayren Kittrick SITE AREA: 8,870 square feet EXISTING BLDG AREA (gross): N/A LOCATION: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd N PROPOSED BLDG AREA (gross) N/A SUMMARY OF PROPOSAL: The applicant requests SEPA Review and approval of a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit and a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit for the installation of two 10-foot by 14-foot freestanding boatlifts, one 10-foot by 20-foot freestanding boatlift lift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock which serves three lots. A. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT (e.g. Nan-Cade} COMMENTS Element of the Probable Probable More Environment Minor Major Information Element of the Probable Probable More Environment Minor Major Information Impacts Impacts Necessary Impacts Impacts Necessary forth Housina Air Aesthetics Water Unht/Glore Plants Recreation Land/Shoreline Use Utilities Animals TranstJortatian Environmental Health Public Services Energy/ Historic/Cultural Natural Resources Preservation Airport Environment 10,000Feet 14,000Feet B. POLICY-RELATED COMMENTS I\ \ \.ii) C v1tV'\~e.--.:;\, C. CODE-RE LA TED COMMENTS We have reviewed this application with particular attention to those areas in which we have expertise and have identified areas of probable impact or areas where a~ditionol info~/ftG"tion ~s needed to properly assess this proposal. Date \ CITY OF RENTON MEMORANDUM Date: August 9, 2010 To: Gerald Wasser, Planning From: Kayren K. Kittrick, Development Engineering )q} Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts Subject: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd N LUA-10-050 EXISTING CONDITIONS WATER-The properties are served by City of Renton water. SEWER-The properties are served by City of Renton sanitary sewer within the plat. STORM-The parcels have onsite drainage to the lake. No further facilities are triggered by this development. STREETS-The access street to the parcels is paved. CODE REQUIREMENTS WATER 1. Cross connection control, inspection and certification is required for any water service to the dock. 2. A water service permit is required if water service is extended to the dock. PLAN REVIEW -GENERAL 1. All plans shall conform to the Renton Drafting Standards. 2. A construction permit is required. When plans are complete three copies of the drawings, a construction estimate, application and appropriate fee shall be submitted to the City Hall sixth floor counter. RECOMMENDED CONDITIONS None CC: Neil Watts PRCommen1s10-050.doc City of Renton Department of Community & Economic Development ENVIRONMENTAL & DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION REVIEW SHEET REVIEWING DEPARTMENT: ---ILL{] ,---, Ke 1 1 'w COMMENTS DUE: AUGUST 20, 2010 APPLICATION NO: LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC DATE CIRCULATED: AUGUST 6, 2010 APPLICANT: Robert Cugini -Barbee Mill Company PLANNER: Jerry Wasser CITY OF RENTON PROJECT TITLE: Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts PLAN REVIEWER: Kayren Kittrick SITE AREA: 8,870 square feet EXISTING BLDG AREA (gross): N/ A LOCATION: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd N PROPOSED BLDG AREA (gross) N/A R SUMMARY OF PROPOSAL: The applicant requests SEPA Review and approval of a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit and a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit for the installation of two 10-foot by 14-foot freestanding boatlifts, one 10-foot by 20-foot freestanding boatlift lift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock which serves three lots. A. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT {e.g. Non-Code) COMMENTS Element of the Probable Probable More Environment Minor Major Information Impacts Impacts Necessary Element of the Probable Probable More Environment Minor Major Information Impacts Impacts Necessary Earth Housina Air Aesthetics Water Unht/Gfare Plants Recreation Land/Shoreline Use Utilities Animals Transnortation Environmental Health Public Services Energy/ Historic/Cultural Natural Resources Preservation Airport Environment 10,000Feet 14,000Feet B. POL/Cf-RELATED COMMENTS C. CODE-RELATED COMMENTS ~ I 1\k,,v-..C c:\i:,Xl. We have reviewed this application with particular attention to those areas in which we have expertise and have identified areas of probable impact or areas where additional information is needed to properly assess this proposal. Date r I City of Renton Department of Community & Economic Devefopment ENVIRONMENTAL & DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION REVIEW SHEET APPLICATION NO: LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC DATE CIRCULATED: AUGUST 6, 2010 APPLICANT: Robert Cugini -Barbee Mill Company PLANNER: Jerry Wasser PROJECT TITLE: Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts PLAN REVIEWER: Kayren Kittrick SITE AREA: 8,870 square feet EXISTING BLDG AREA (gross): N/A RE LOCATION: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd N PROPOSED BLDG AREA (gross) N/A SUMMARY OF PROPOSAL: The applicant requests SEPA Review and approval of a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit and a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit for the installation of two 10-foot by 14-foot freestanding boatlifts, one 10-foot by 20-foot freestanding boatllft lift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock which serves three lots. A. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT (e.g. Non-Code) COMMENTS Element of the Probable Probable More Environment Minor Major Information Element of the Probable Probable More Environment Minor Major Information Impacts Impacts Necessary Impacts Impacts Necessary Earth Housinq Air Aesthetics Water Liaht/Glare Plants Recreation Land/Shoreline Use Utilities Animals Tran5aortation Environmental Health Public Services Energy/ Historic/Cultural Natural Re5ources Preservation Airport Environment 10,000Feet 14,000Feet 8. POL/CY-RELATED COMMENTS C. CODE-RELATED CDMMENTS /{)(l1,-1..f We have reviewed this application with particular attention to those areas in which we have expertise and have identified areas of probable impact or areas where additional information is needed to properly assess this proposal. / a Date! City of Renton Department of Community & Economic Development ENVIRONMENTAL & DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION REVIEW SHEET REVIEWING DEPARTMENT: Pox-/L.<:.~ COMMENTS DUE: AUGUST 20, 2010 APPLICATION NO: LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC DATE CIRCULATED: AUGUST 6, 2010 APPLICANT: Robert Cugini -Barbee Mill Company PLANNER: Jerry Wasser PROJECT TITLE: Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts PLAN REVIEWER: Kayren Kittrick SITE AREA: 8,870 square feet EXISTING BLDG AREA (gross): N/A LOCATION: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd N PROPOSED BLDG AREA (gross) N/A SUMMARY OF PROPOSAL: The applicant requests SEPA Review and approval of a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit and a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit for the installation of two 10-foot by 14-foot freestanding boatlifts, one 10-foot by 20-foot freestanding boatlift lift with a fully grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock which serves three lots. A. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT (e.g. Non-Code) COMMENTS Element of the Probable Probable More Environment Minor Major Information Impacts Impacts Necessary Element of the Probable Probable More Environment Minor Major Information Impacts Impacts Necessary Earth Housinq Air Aesthetics Water Liaht/Glare Plants Recreation Land/Shoreline Use Utilities Animals Transoortation Environmental Health Public Services Energy/ Historic/Cultural Natural Resources Preservation Airport Environment 10,000Feet 14,000Feet We have reviewed this applicatio with particular attention to those areas in which we have expertise and have identified areas of probable impact where additional infi m ion is needed to properly assess this proposal. f3-1_t,-/D Date NOTICE OF APPLICATION AND PROPOSED DETERMINATION OF NON-SIGNIFICANCE-MITIGATED (DNS-M) DA.rt: lANO U5f NUMl!CR: PROJECT NAME: August 6, lOlO lU"'10--0SO, ECF. SM, SMC a.,~e• Mill Watortrlft LIits PROJECT OfSCRll'TION: The applicant requrm SEPA R"iow and app.,,val of a Shorellnr Sub,tantl•I Development Permit illd a Shor•lin• Conditional U•• Permit fur \h<, ln«allatjon of two 10-foot by 14-foot r,o.,landlne boau,ru, on• 10-loot by W-kot lroe,tandlng boatllft lift with• fully grue<I platfarm, and on• daci-l'n<lunted jet sl<l llft In O!S<>Clatlon with an existing joint use dock which"'"'"' th<O• lot, In th• Resldenllal -3 dwollln& unit, p.r acre (R-H) tone. Each or the tr.e,tandlni wat£rcrah lift, would ro,t di~ly on lhe lake Oouom on !our 12-ind, by 12-lnch footpads. Tho btSllng fullv-grat•d docX ;, 4-feet. 41/7.·lnches to 7-feet. 10 l/4-inche, In width and 118-feet, 6-inches in l•n!Jlh wtth two U-f<:>o1 lully-gmed ~ager dock<. T1'e pro!)Osed project al,c @noompn .. , the removal ol ,ix ll-lnch dlameior c:r,o,ote-treated wood piles aod repladng them .,.;th lwo vibr.oto')' pjle·d;fven lHnch dlamft1er steel pil••- All wo,1,. would take ~ace wilhln !he Wa,hlngton D•partment ol Fish Md WIidiife fish window for this section of t..lke Washington, July 16 through Oecombar 31. fROJECT LOCATION: 3905 lake Wa,hin11ton &!vd. N. OPTIONAL DETERMINATION OF NON·SIGNlflCANCE, MITIGATUl IONS-Ml: As tho lud ~n<'/. the City of Ren Ion NI, determined that sl11n1nc:r.nt envi,onmental Impacts are unHl<oly to re1u~ from the !>(Opo••d project. neref<lro. as permitt•d under the RCW 43.UC.110, t/1e City of lien ton is using the Optional DNS·M p,oce., to gl"'! n01ice that, ONS-- M Is likelv to he l!!ued. Common! period, for the pm;ect aod 1he proposed ONS·M are lnte3r.1ted into • ,ingle comment ""rlod. There w,11 be no tommem p,nod l<lliowrng the issuance or the Thre,hold Ol!lermlnatlon of Non· Sl1mftc•nco-Mltlg•ted (ONS--M]. A 14-day appul ptrlod will follow the 1 .. uan<0 o/ the ONS--M. PERMIT APP!.ICATION DAn: NOTICE OF COMPllITE APPIJCATION: APl'LICANT/PROJECT CONTACT FERSON: Permits/Review Reque,tedt July28,Wl0 A~gu,t 6. W10 Alan FolU, Waterfront Con,tn.,ctlon, Inc.; 201 NE Northlalco Way t210; Seattle, WA 98105 Envlronmemal (SEPA) lttvlow, Shorollne Su'ost.,,t!al Oe"'!k>pment Perml!. Shoreline C<mdlUoool UH ParmH: othor Permits which may be requl.-..1: Sulldlnii, Army Corps, Ooportmanl al fl,h & Wlldllfo, and Department ol Ecol<>['( Fumils Req.,.,sted Studies: Lake Stu,fy LC>CllUon whortappllmlon may bo revlawod: Oopartrnenl of Community & Economl< o .. elopm1n1 (Cf.DI-Plano Ing Olvls!on, Sl><t~ Hoo, Renton City Hall, 105S South Gr .. Jy Way, Ron Ion, WA 98057 Pueuc HEARlNG· · Publlc hraclns t< tcoli'lveb 1chedul,,d fpr ~•mJ>er11 2010 b<%rr thf Renton Hearin• Examinu "1 !\pn\Qo Cgunfll ChJmbm. Hearing, beHin at 9:00 a.m. on the 7th floor of the eew Renton City Hall located •t lOS5 Sout/l Grndy Way. ~ \'OU would like to be mad! • party ol ft<:Ord to rece;.,e further Information on thi, propo,ed proj<rt, complete th~ fo,m ml r>turn to: City of Renton, C£0 -Plannme OM.<loo, 1055 Sc. Grad\' Way. Renton, WA 9S057. N•m•/filo No. Darbee MIii Watorcrnfl Uft,/lUAllJ-0~, ECF. SM. SMC MAILING ADDRESS: TELEPHOriE riO.: CON~IITTJIICY OVUVlEW: Zonlna/l.amd u,o: Envlronmant,I Docum•nt, th,t Ev:ilu:>te the Prop<>1ed Project: Devolopmenl Rogul•tlorut u,ed For Project Mlci13tl0<1: The <object ,;te 1, d<>·gn,ted Re,keotial Sl~le '•mily (RSI on th• Cityol ~entoo Comprohen>f'IH Landu,~ Map Md Rddential a \R·~I on the Cit'(s ZomngM,p. Environmental iSEPA) C~.er..kl1St The project will h, subi~ct to tho Clty"; SEPA ordiNe<e, HMC 4-l·llOA, RMC 4. 3-090, RI\IC 4-9-190 and 01herappikabl, codu ,nd reJulaHon, ,s appropr;ate Th, following Mitigation Mosure, will l;k•ly be :mpo,ed on the propmed proj,ct The,e reo:imm,nded M,tiy,tlon Mearn,,, addres, project lml>!'cts not co•ered by e,lsling cod•• aod reg~latlOM as d!od al><J,e. NI wark shall be occomplished wiChln /he ,oa,tn,<lian wmdow estab~sMd by rh• wa,hinyran o.-pmtmtnr af Fish & Wrld/tfe /or rhi• ••cr,an of <oke Washington 51/t~omoonmenr cvrtoins ,hall be pia,td o•ounri all .. ark areo, and st,o/1 remain ,n p/a<e unM completion of th• pro,ocr; and Vibratory p~e-drMng systems shall b• 1JSed ta Ins Call new ,1,,1 poling,. Comrr,eots on th• abovo application muit be 1ubmitto,d In wr~lnJ to 6•raold WHnr, A.,oc!ate Pl;,nner, CED - Plannln1 Olwlffl!n, 1055 Saulh Grady Way, RM tan, WA 98057, by 5:00 PM an Aull"<l 10, 2010. This mattu 1, al,o lenlatlvtily ,cho,duJ.od for a publlc hoarin1 on S.pt~mber 21, 201.0, a! 9:00 a.m •• Couoc! Chambers, ~nth Floor, ~enton City Hall, l05S 5oulh Gndy Way. Renton. tr you aro lnter.,,ted In attor>dlnf the hoorin&, plu•• contact lhe Development Se Mees Oivi,lon to ensure that th• ho a ring has oat be,n ro<eheduled at j425) 430-71.82. If commen1' canno1 bo ,ubmllt!!d in wr;tme by the doto ir><l..:ated above. you ma\' ,till ,ppur at the headng and pre,ent your comment< on the proposal before the He1rin11 E,aminer. II you h..,e q""<tion, ab,;ut this propo<al, o,w1,h lo be made • party of record and ,-,,coi•e addl\ional information hy m•II, pleo1" contact th• project m,nasM. Anyor,e who submits wrltleo common LS will aulornali<ally become• party of rMord aod will be notified of any dKlsion on thi, pro]«!. CONTACT PERSON: Gerald C. Wasser, Associate Planner;Tel; (425) 430-7382; Eml: gwasser@rentonwa.gov CERTIFICATION I, \\.,\\\ j\\ \\'ls. ) \ \ \ '\ (\{ . hereby certify that ·? copies of the above document were posted in "2 conspicuous places or nearby the described property on Date:.__,,,c,,,.\+/ ..... 1 ... 0 +/ _.\_._[: ___ , ____ _ Signed: '\\\\~\\~\ X 1\\~\\\ \( STATE OF WASHINGTON 55 COUNTY OF KING I certify that I know or have satisfactory evidence that _~l'l~,~,,~h~,~'\~e-·~·.l>~, ~E~i·,~·~·· .. K----- signed this instrument and acknowledged it to be his/her/their free and voluntary act for the uses and purposes mentioned in the instrument. D ~~ ..... , !'!"'l"""CV#Jc""1r"'--'"·~· l.) ' Notary Public in a'nd for the State of Washington Notary (Print): My appointment expires: ;:, -, l<. ----~'--'--~=-.>--------- CITY OF RENTON DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY & ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT-PLANNING DIVISION AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAILING On the 6th day of August, 2010, I deposited in the mails of the United States, a sealed envelope containing Acceptance Letter, NOA, Environmental Checklist, & Site Plan PMT documents. This information was sent to: Name Representing Agencies See Attached Alan Foltz Contact Robert Cugini Owner/Applicant 300' Surrounding Property Owners See attached ""'"'"'"'· .. (Signature of Sender): _, ~ti ?YJ ~ STATE OF WASHINGTON ) ) ss COUNTY OF KING ) I certify that I know or have satisfactory evidence that Stacy M. Tucker signed this instrument and acknowledged it to be his/her/their free and voluntary act for the uses and purposes mentioned in the instrument. Dated: t''oc-,..,\-r-·alkl<' s i Notaryblic in ~nd for the State of Washington Notary (Print): ____ \-\'-'-'-. -'-,.-'-'-......_:.,_,.._·.=.c-.. ' ~· -------------- My appointment expires: Project Name: Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts Project Number: LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC template -affidavit of service by malling Dept. of Ecology * Environmental Review Section PO Box 47703 Olympia, WA 98504-7703 WSDOT Northwest Region * Attn: Ramin Pazooki King Area Dev. Serv., MS-240 PO Box 330310 Seattle, WA 98133-9710 US Army Corp. of Engineers* Seattle District Office Attn: SEPA Reviewer PO Box C-3755 Seattle, WA 98124 Boyd Powers * Depart. of Natural Resources PO Box 47015 Olympia, WA 98504-7015 KC Dev. & Environmental Serv. Attn: SEPA Section 900 Oakesdale Ave. SW Renton, WA 98055-1219 Metro Transit Senior Environmental Planner Gary Kriedt 201 South Jackson Street KSC-TR-0431 Seattle, WA 98104-3856 Seattle Public Utilities Real Estate Services Attn: SEPA Coordinator 700 Fifth Avenue, Suite 4900 PO Box 34018 Seattle, WA 98124-4018 AGENCY (DOE) LETTER MAILING (ERC DETERMINATIONS) WDFW -Larry Fisher* 1775 12th Ave. NW Suite 201 Issaquah, WA 98027 Duwamish Tribal Office* 4717 W Marginal Way SW Seattle, WA 98106-1514 KC Wastewater Treatment Division * Environmental Planning Supervisor Ms. Shirley Marroquin 201 S. Jackson ST, MS KSC-NR-050 Seattle, WA 98104-3855 City of Newcastle Attn: Steve Roberge Director of Community Development 13020 Newcastle Way Newcastle, WA 98059 Puget Sound Energy Municipal liaison Manager Joe Jainga PO Box 90868, MS: XRD-OlW Bellevue, WA 98009-0868 Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Fisheries Dept. * Attn: Karen Walter or SEPA Reviewer 39015-172nd Avenue SE Auburn, WA 98092 Muckleshoot Cultural Resources Program * Attn: Ms Melissa Calvert 39015 172nd Avenue SE Auburn, WA 98092-9763 Office of Archaeology & Historic Preservation* Attn: Gretchen Kaehler PO Box 48343 Olympia, WA 98504-8343 City of Kent Attn: Mr. Fred Satterstrom, AICP Acting Community Dev. Director 220 Fourth Avenue South Kent, WA 98032-5895 City of Tukwila Steve Lancaster, Responsible Official 6200 Southcenter Blvd. Tukwila, WA 98188 *Note: If the Notice of Application states that it is an "Optional ONS", the marked agencies and cities will need to be sent a copy of the checklist, Site Plan PMT, and the notice of application. template -affidavit of service by mailing 334270001103 BARBEE FOREST PRODUCTS INC PO BOX 359 RENTON WA 98057 362916002003 DENISON STEVEN+ELIZABETH 1100 N 38TH ST RENTON WA 98056 334270041802 HERTEL MARSHA JANICE 3836 LK WASH BLVD N RENTON WA 98056 362916001005 KOLESAR LARRY+SUSAN M 1030 NORTH 38TH ST RENTON WA 98056 334270041208 PETETI J scon 3824 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON WA 98056 362916003001 RANZ MARK K 1106 N 38TH ST RENTON WA 98056 334270010005 TASCA JAMES G 14805 SE JONES PL RENTON WA 98058 322405900505 BNSF PO BOX 961089 FORT WORTH TX 76161 334270041000 DENNEY ROBERT K+NANCY H 3818 LAKE WASH BLVD N RENTON WA 98056 334270042503 HUNT THOMAS R+CARYL J 1125 N 40TH ST RENTON WA 98056 334270011003 NELSON FRITZ W 3825 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON WA 98056 362916007002 PIPKIN GARY C & YVONNE M 1120 N 38TH RENTON WA 98056 334270012506 SIVESIND R STANLEY RIGGS JAYNE 3821 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON WA 98056 334270008009 ZILMER MARK E+ROSEMARY 3837 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON WA 98056 334270007001 BOYDSTON TONY 3920 NE 11TH PL RENTON WA 98056 334270012605 ERIKSON BRUCE E+ MARY R 3815 LK WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON WA 98056 334270041505 HUNT TIMOTHY ALLAN+HUNT JEN 1129 N 40TH ST RENTON WA 98056 334270042701 NICOLI BRUNO I+LISSMAN OLGA 3404 BURNED AVE N RENTON WA 98056 334270041406 QAASIM TASLEEM+HAMID 3830 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD N RENTON WA 98056 362916004009 TANNER MARGARET A 1108 N 38TH ST RENTON WA 98056 NOTICE OF APPLICATION AND PROPOSED DETERMINATION OF NON-SIGNIFICANCE-MITIGATED (DNS-M} DATE: LAND USE NUMBER: PROJECT NAME; August 6, 2010 LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC Barbee Mill Watercraft Lifts PROJECT DESCRIPTION: The applicant requests SEPA Review and approval of a Shoreline Substantial Development Permit and a Shoreline Conditional Use Permit for the installation of two 10-foot by 14-foot freestanding boatlifts, one 10-foot by 20-foot freestanding boatlift lift with a ful!y grated platform, and one dock-mounted jet ski lift in association with an existing joint use dock which serves three lots in the Residential -8 dwelling units per acre {R-8) zone. Each of the freestanding watercraft lifts would rest directly on the lake bottom on four 12-inch by 12-inch footpads. The existing fully-grated dock is 4-feet, 4 1/2-inches to 7-feet, 10 3/4-inches in width and 118-feet, 6-inches in length with two 27-foot fully-grated finger docks. The proposed project also encompasses the removal of six 12-inch diameter creosote-treated wood piles and replacing them with two vibratory pile-driven 12-inch diameter steel piles. All work would take place within the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife fish window for this section of Lake Washington, July 16 through December 31. PROJECT LOCATION: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N. OPTIONAL DETERMINATION OF NON-SIGNIFICANCE, MITIGATED {DNS-M): As the Lead Agency, the City of Renton has determined that significant environmental impacts are unlikely to result from the proposed project. Therefore, as permitted under the RCW 43.21C.110, the City of Renton is using the Optional DNS-M process to give notice that a DNS- M is likely to be issued. Comment periods for the project and the proposed DNS-M are integrated into a single comment period. There will be no comment period following the issuance of the Threshold Determination of Non- Significance-Mitigated (DNS-M}. A 14-day appeal period will follow the issuance of the DNS-M. PERMIT APPLICATION DATE: NOTICE OF COMPLETE APPLICATION: July 28, 2010 August 6, 2010 APPLICANT/PROJECT CONTACT PERSON: Alan Foltz, Waterfront Construction, Inc.; 201 NE Northlake Way #230; Seattle, WA 98105 Permits/Review Requested: Other Permits which may be required: Requested Studies: Location where application may be reviewed: PUBLIC HEARING: Environmental (SEPA) Review, Shorellne Substantial Development Permit, Shoreline Conditional Use Permit Building, Army Corps, Department of Fish & Wildlife, and Department of Ecology Permits Lake Study Department of Community & Economic Development (CED)-Planning Division, Sixth Floor Renton City Hall, 1055 South Grady Way, Renton, WA 98057 Public hearing is tentatively scheduled for September 21, 2010 before the Renton Hearing Examiner in Renton Council Chambers. Hearings begin at 9:00 a.m. on the 7th floor of the new Renton City Hall located at 1055 South Grady Way. If you would like to be made a party of record to receive further information on this proposed project, complete this form and return to: City of Renton, CED-Planning Division, 1055 So. Grady Way, Renton, WA 98057. Name/File No.: Barbee Mill Watercraft Ufts/LUAl0-050, ECF, SM, SMC NAME:-----------------------------------~ MAILING ADDRESS: TELEPHONE NO.: CONSISTENCY OVERVIEW: Zoning/Land Use: Environmental Documents that Evaluate the Proposed Project: Development Regulations Used For Project Mitigation: Proposed Mitigation Measures: The subject site is designated Residential Single Family {RS) on the City of Renton Comprehensive Land Use Map and Residential -8 (R-8) on the City's Zoning Map. Environmental (SEPA} Checklist The project will be subject to the City's SEPA ordinance, RMC 4-3-llOA, RMC 4- 3-090, RMC 4-9-190 and other applicable codes and regulations as appropriate. The following Mitigation Measures will likely be imposed on the proposed project. These recommended Mitigation Measures address project impacts not covered by existing codes and regulations as cited above. Alf work shall be accomplished within the construction window established by the Washington Department of Fish & Wildlife for this section of Lake Washington Silt containment curtains shall be placed around all work areas and shall remain in place until completion of the project; and Vibratory pile-driving systems shall be used ta install new steel pilings. Comments on the above application must be submitted in writing to Gerald Wasser, Associate Planner, CED - Planning Division, 1055 South Grady Way, Renton, WA 98057, by 5:00 PM on August 20, 2010. This matter Is also tentatively scheduled for a public hearing on September 21, 2010, at 9:00 a.m., Council Chambers, Seventh Floor, Renton City Hall, 1055 South Grady Way, Renton. If you are interested in attending the hearing, please contact the Development Services Division to ensure that the hearing has not been rescheduled at (425) 430-7282. If comments cannot be submitted in writing by the date indicated above, you may still appear at the hearing and present your comments on the proposal before the Hearing Examiner. If you have questions about this proposal, or wish to be made a party of record and receive additional information by mail, please contact the project manager. Anyone who submits written comments will automatically become a party of record and will be notified of any decision on this project. CONTACT PERSON: Gerald C. Wasser, Associate Planner; Tel: (425) 430-7382; Eml: gwasser@rentonwa.gov PLEASE INCLUDE THE PROJECT NUMBER WHEN CALLING FOR PROPER FILE IDENTIFICATION ,f -'I Lu 0-0SO City of Renton LAND USE PERMIT City of Rent P1 -on anning Division MASTER APPLICATION JUL t 8 LV10 PROPERTY OWNER(S) TELEPHONE NUMBER AND E-MAIL ADDRESS: NAME: Barbee Mill Company PROJECT INFORMATION ADDRESS: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N. PROJECT OR DEVELOPMENT NAME: CITY: Renton, WA ZIP: 98056 Barbee Mill Company V,4/"/"~Nff J?/l;J TELEPHONE NUMBER: 425-226-3900 PROJECT/ADDRESS(S)/LOCATION AND ZIP CODE: 3905 Lake Washington Boulevard N., Renton, WA 98056 APPLICANT (if other than owner) NAME: Barbee Mill, Robert Cugini KING COUNTY ASSESSOR'S ACCOUNT NUMBER($): 334270 0011 COMPANY (if applicable): Barbee Mill Company EXISTING LAND USE(S): Residential ADDRESS: 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N. PROPOSED LAND USE(S): Residential CITY: Renton, WA ZIP: 98056 EXISTING COMPREHENSIVE PLAN MAP DESIGNATION: TELEPHONE NUMBER 425-226-3900 1Jnkn8Wfl R.s-F CONT ACT PERSON PROPOSED COMPREHENSIVE PLAN MAP DESIGNATION (if applicable): Unknown NAME: Alan Foltz, Agent EXISTING ZONING: R-Residential R-"'6 COMPANY (if applicable): Waterfront Construction, Inc. PROPOSED ZONING (if applicable): N/A ADDRESS: 205 NE Northlake Way, SITE AREA (in square feet): 8,870 Sq Ft SQUARE FOOTAGE OF PUBLIC ROADWAYS TO BE Suite 230 DEDICATED: N/A CITY: Seattle, WA ZIP: 98105 SQUARE FOOTAGE OF PRIVATE ACCESS EASEMENTS: N/A PROPOSED RESIDENTIAL DENSITY IN UNITS PER NET ACRE (if applicable): N/A Q:web/pw/devsetv/forms/planning/masterapp.doc 06/21/10 Pl ECT INFORMATION conti , NUMBER OF PROPOSED LOTS (if applicable): NIA NUMBER OF EMPLOYEES TO BE EMPLOYED BY THE NEW PROJECT (if applicable): N/A NUMBER OF NEW DWELLING UNITS (if applicable): PROJECT VALUE: $39,000.oo 4-boatlifts, See oermit drawinas. IS THE SITE LOCATED IN ANY TYPE OF NUMBER OF EXISTING DWELLING UNITS (if applicable): ENVIRONMENTALLY CRITICAL AREA, PLEASE INCLUDE N/A SQUARE FOOTAGE (if applicable): SQUARE FOOTAGE OF PROPOSED RESIDENTIAL 0 AQUIFER PROTECTION AREA ONE BUILDINGS (if applicable): N/A 0 AQUIFER PROTECTION AREA TWO SQUARE FOOTAGE OF EXISTING RESIDENTIAL 0 FLOOD HAZARD AREA sq. ft. BUILDINGS TO REMAIN (if applicable): N/A SQUARE FOOTAGE OF PROPOSED NON-RESIDENTIAL 0 GEOLOGIC HAZARD sq. ft. BUILDINGS (if applicable): N/A 0 HABITAT CONSERVATION sq. ft. SQUARE FOOTAGE OF EXISTING NON-RESIDENTIAL X SHORELINE STREAMS AND LAKES N/A BUILDINGS TO REMAIN (if applicable): - 0 NET FLOOR AREA OF NON-RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS (if WETLANDS sq. ft. applicable): N/A LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY (Attach legal description on separate sheet with the following information included) SITUATE IN THE NW QUARTER OF SECTION ~.TOWNSHIP 24N , RANGE 05E ' IN THE CITY OF RENTON, KING COUNTY, WASHINGTON. TYPE OF APPLICATION & FEES Staff will calculate applicable fees and postage: $ AFFIDAVIT OF OWNERSHIP I, (Print Name/s) B 01:;><elZ:-"I Cu 6 i N \ declare that I am (please check one)_ the current owner of the property involved in this application or X the authorized representative to act for a corporation (please attach proof of authorization) and that the foregoing statements and answers herein contained and the information herewith are in all respects true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief. I certify that I know or have satisfactory evidence that R~n-0 <1~Y\\ signed this instrument and acknowledged it to be his/her/their free and voluntary act for the uses and purposes mentioned in the instrument. (Signature qt, O~~r/£,epresyntaf e V,ce yrt-U~ Q:web/pw/devserv/forms/planning/masterapp.doc Notary Public in and for the State of Washington Notary (Print) My appointment expires: ti2Jl:: OJ,) W \ ( 2 06121/10 Project: PROJECT NARRATIVE Barbee Mill Company Joint Use Pier Lifts Section NW 32, Township 24N, Range 05E LAT: 47.526985N LON: 122.205604W Waterbody: Lake Washington, County: King Parcel: 334270 0011 City of Renton Planning Division Land Use Permits Required: Shoreline Substantial Development Permit and SEPA Determination Zoning: R-Residential Proposed Activity: The placement of: * two (2) free standing boatlifts (JO' x 14' overalJ, with four ( 4) -1' sq. foot pads); * one (1) free standing boatlift with grated platform (boatlift frame with fully grated 10' x 20' platform); * and one(!) jetski lift (with 4' x 6' overall support frame) attached to the existing Joint Use pier structure. Mitigation proposed involves removal of six 12" Dia. Creosoted wood piles, to be replaced by two 12" steel piles, an enhancement to the two existing outboard pylons. A vibratory extraction, insertion system will be used for this activity, with a silt curtain for containment. See permit drawings. The grated platform lift will allow an intermediate level for safe boarding of smaller vessels when the lake is at low water levels. The pier structure, with deck level at 2' -6" plus above OHW by regulatory requirement, is up to 4 '-6" above lake level during approximately eight months of the year when the lake level is lowered by the Corps of Engineers. Estimated Construction Cost: $ 35,000.00 Construction Access: Applicant: Date: All proposed construction (lift placement) is waterward of Ordinary High Water OHW). The lifts are all fabricated off site at contractor's facility, transported to the pier site by Contractor's barge, and positioned at the existing pier site by barge mounted crane. Barbee Mill Company, Inc Attn: Robert Cugini Barbee Mill Company 3905 Lake Washington Boulevard North Renton, WA 98056 Mail to: Alan Foltz, Permit Coordinator, Agent Waterfront Construction, Inc. 205 NE Northlake Way, Suite 230 Seattle, WA 98105 Foltz@waterfrontconstruction.com July 21, 2010 Conditional Use Permit Justification Barbee Mill Company Free Standing and Dock Mounted Lifts Reasons to favor the proposed free standing and dock mounted lifts are summated by their usage intent. The free standing fully grated platform lift will allow a variable intermediate level for safe boarding of smaller vessels when the lake is at low water levels. The existing pier structure, with deck level at 2 '-6" above OHW, directed by regulatory requirement, is up to 4' -6" above Jake level during approximately eight months of the year when the lake level is lowered by the Corps of Engineers. In that the lifting mechanism, functioning with contained (NON Toxic) hydraulic cylinders, operated with a solar powered hydraulic pump system, can position the fully grated decking at any elevation from close to lake bottom to pier deck elevation, the platform can be positioned for best safety locations of many uses. The two free standing boatlifts as well as the dock mounted jetski lift will provide safe access for water craft, allowing their storage out of turbulent waters during storms and high frequency boat traffic wakes. With the platforms'fully grated decking, it offers the same light transmission as the fully decked pier structure. The platform lift is low profile to the water and pier, thus does not generate a reflection or visible distraction to the neighborhood. 7. A: Comprehensive Plan The purpose and objectives of the proposed lifts are compatible with the General Purpose, Objectives and Policies of the City of Renton ... The continued protection ofRenton's natural systems, natural beauty, and environmental quality. • Policy EN-57 regulates sensitive areas through regulations addressing uses. The safety measure to prevent damage to boats by mooring at compatible deck elevations, or persons from the danger of falling when traversing elevations from small boats to the pier offers a major safety enhancement. • Policy EN60 encourages preservation through regulations which will provide for public health and safety. The health and safety afforded by use of the platform lift as a transition from water based vessels to the pier eliminates a safety hazard for approved visitors. 7. B: Purpose and Need The proposed lifts are an enhancement to the safety of boat access and moorage at the pier. 7. C: Effect on Adjacent Properties The primary purpose and safety benefits of the platform lift protect human safety and maintain integrity of small boat vessels. The platform lift offers the most practical way to achieve safety. No effect to adjacent properties is anticipated. The proposed lifts do not block the view from neighboring properties. They do not interfere with neighboring property water access, or neighboring enjoyment of the recreational uses of the lake. RMC 4-9-190H.5, WAC 173-27-170 Jnstifications: City of fl Pian . enton 1v: The proposed use is in harmony with the general purpose and intent of the City's nmg Division Master Program. J" . v: The proposed use meets the conditional use criteria in WAC 173-27-160. vL z 8 LU/0 City of o Pi-. qenton anning O .. iv1s1on Ji.Ji • BARBEE MILL COMPANY JOINT USE PIER CONSTRUCTION MITIGATION DESCRIPTION L z 8 LU/0 Proposed Construction: Installation Date: Hauling, Delivery: Minimization Measures: Special Hours Proposed: Preliminary Traffic Control Plan: Proposed Mitigation for the Corps of Engineers: Permit Coordinator The placement of two free standing boatlifts, one free standing boatlift with a grated platform top, and one jetski lift, attached to the existing Joint Use Pier structure. The grated platform lift will allow an intermediate level for safe boarding of smaller vessels when the lake is at low water levels. The pier structure, with deck level at 2' -6" plus above OHW by regulatory requirement, is up to 4' -6" above lake level during approximately eight months of the year when the lake level is lowered by the Corps of Engineers. As permits allow. One to three days will be required to place the lifts. All lifts to be pre assembled/constructed off site. Lifts to be delivered by water with construction barge. With the proposed delivery and placement oflifts, there is no need to address negative dust, traffic, erosion, mud, noise, delivery, or other noxious characteristics. None. Not required. To completely satisfy the Corps RGPl Programmatic for lift installations, two 3-pile creosoted dolphins (6- piles) will be replaced with two only steel piles within the same existing (reduced) footprints. Waterfront Construction, Inc. Agent for Barbee Mill Company King County Property Description for parcel number 3342700011 Page I of2 HOME NEWS SERVICES D1REC:TORY CONT/\CT KCGIS Center www.KingCounty.gov/GIS ty of Renton Piannin9Division Jl,L ;; 8 LUIU KCGIS Parcelfl_~ii~i:=--: -A;~~~~~;:-inf;~;:;;;ti~-;;for parcel n~-;:;,b~~~~~rrJr -·-···-· ... ifii Property Report Districts and Development Conditions Report Find Your Council District Find Your Watershed KCGIS Center King County GIS Center King Street Center 201 S. Jackson St Suite 706 Seattle, WA 98104 giscenter@kingcounty.gov + 47.59909 N -122.33136 W + 47" 35' 56.72" -122" 19' 5290" Taxpayer name Mailing address BARBEE FOREST PRODUCTS INC Parcel number Tax Account number 3342700011 334270001103 POBOX359 RENTON WA 98057 .. Levy code -·---.ll®: ·-···-·"· .. -·--"~···-·-· Jurisdiction RENTON -------· Present use Single Famity(Res ... ___ us1:1t~one)__ App~;3i~e~_ .':'.'=!!':!.~. . . --~~.411,000 Address(es) at this 39.05 LAK.E WA.SHINGTON BLVD N 98056 . parc;e1 ... ·---·····-···-····-······---- Legal description HILLMAN$ LK WN GARDEN OF EDEN #2 "LOT D" RENTON LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT NO LUA-96- 153LLA-LND-30-0152 REC NO 20061002900012 SD LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT DAF LOTS 1 THRU 13 IN BLOCK A OF HILLMANS LAKE WASHINGTON GARDEN OF EDEN DIV NO 2 PLATTGW SH LDSADS AND TGW THE NWLY 25.00 FT OF BNSF ROW LY BTWN TWO LNS DRAWN PLW & DIST 25.00 AND SO.DO FT NWLY AS MEAS AT RIA FR MAIN TRACKC/L BOUNDED ON THE NORTH BY THE ELY EXTN OF THE NORTH LN OF LOT 1 AND BOUNDED ON THE SOUTH BY THE ELY EXTN OF THE SOUTH LN OF LOT 13 OF SD HILLMANS LAKE WASHINGTON GARDEN OF EDEN DIV 2 Parcel description Property name Property R -RESIDENTIAL .typy, --------------------· Present Single Family(Res ~~e ____ Use/Zone) ___ _ Lot area 8,870 sq. ft (0.20 a~res) Plat HILLMANS LAKE WASH name GARDEN OF EDEN NO. 02 .............................. Plat A block ----·--· ------. ····"'··--·--·······-- Plat lot 1-13 & Q-S-T-NW-32-24-5 R Water WATER system DISTRICT Sewer PUBLIC _ system, ___ Access PUBLIC Street PAVED surface Residential building description Building_·--···----1 of 1 Year built 2006 Year renovated O ......... ·-········ Stories -------------···-·-""' Building grade 11 - Excellent -----------·--·-----·-·- Condition Finished basement gra~e ... ~.Y~~~·~·~···· 9 -Better Total living sq. ft. 2,650 1st floor sq. ft. 1,150 Half floor sq. ft. ----·· .... o, .................. . 2nd floor sq. ft_ 1,390 Upper floor sq. ft. ___ Q __ _ Total basement sq. 610 ft. Finished basement 110 ~q,_~,- Basement garage sq. o Attached garage sq. 420 _ftc:· _________ _ Op.en.pore~. s.q .. f'.t.. 60 Enclosed porch sq. 0 ft. Deck sq. ft.__ 80 Bedrooms 3 ---------·----.. ---------- Baths ,2,. -··· _ ...... . 1/2 baths 1 3/4 baths 0 Single story o fireplace --~-----·--···-·· .. ~.'!.~.!.:~!'?.IX.~~-epla.~ 1 Free-standing 0 firepi.l:11?~ Percent brick or O stone -------· ·---·-----·-···-·· Daylight basement __ ·------·--- Heat system Forced Air Heat sou,,rc,_e, ........ -....... . Gas --c;cc-~---,-----;-,,-;----,-------------------------Taxable value historv Tax year Tax status.J. Taxable value reason 2010 TAXABLE I NONE OR UNKNOWN Appraised value Taxable value ·-$1~094~000{iandj--------· $1,094,00ci (land). · · http://www5.kingcounty.gov/KCGISReports/property_report.aspx?PIN=334270001 l 3/24/2010 King County Property Description for parcel number 3342700011 Page 2 of2 + $1 317 000 (improvements) + $1 317 OOQ (improvements) $2,411,000 (total) $2,411,000 (total) Related resources King County Assessor: Submit a request to corr~t.Jnformation in this report King County Assessor: eReal Property Report King County Assessor: Quarter Section Map (PDF fom1at requires Acrobat) King County GIS: Property information ft\J;t King County GIS: Districts and Development Cond_itions Report (a detailed report about the location of this property) King County DOES: Permit Applications Report (for unincorporated areas only) King County Treasury Operations: Property Tax Information for this prcperty King County Recorders Office: Excise Tax Affidavits Report King County Recorders Office: Scanned images of plats. King County Recorders Office: Scanned images of surveys and other map documents. Open iMAP to this property (requires a high speed internet connection) 9Jten Parcel Viewer to this property (any connection speed, but less features than iMAP) Search: ··---------------·--··---·-··---------------·---·-·------·------·-------·------·-·----------- Address or parcel number: IGolJ Reset I 0 search by condo name example address: 8621 428TH AVE SE I example pare.el number: 0942000860 This report was generated on 3124/2010 12:32:58 PM Contact us at giscenter@kingcounty.gov. Links to external sites do not constitute endorsements by King County. By visiting this and other King County web pages, you expressly agree to be bound by terms and conditions of the site. © 2009 King County http://www5.kingcounty.gov/KCGISReports/property _report.aspx?PIN=3342700011 3/24/2010 tiij PIONEER NATlt _AL TITlE INSURANCE A TICOR COMPANY Filed for Record at Request of AFTER RECORDING HAIL T01 't!NIHAN. l\i'ERS & McATEER. P.S. 13ch rLOOn SE/·,·, ,-TOWER / ,_ ____ ,__,..··---- Quit Claim Deed (CORPORATE FORM) THEGRANTOR BARBEE MILL CO., INC. for and in consideration of conveys and quit claims to BARBEE FOREST PRODUCTS, INC. the following described real estate, situated in the County of KING l[VfHUf ITA.l!U'S u c a 3 .. a rH ·s~ . cJiVISIONOf ' •• , " ~ I t::f'TION~ •. tH{l:.; Q, LLL\J' :, KING COUNl Y 10901 [) 3.00 *''"''*3. 00 55 P'Olt:M LS7R City of Renton Planning Division JUL :6 8 ,~\O State of Washington including any interest-therein which grantor may hereafter acquire: Lots 1-13 with adjacent shorelands of Block A Hillmans Lake Washington Garden of Eden #2, Volume 11, page 64. IUNGCO!Mfy MO Exetsf TAX DEC27 '1994 ·E080547' lN~.·iSv.''.;/$'f,;s WHEREOf, said corporation has caused this instrument to be pecuted ~-111-.proper officers . and its l:\."f,,.,,,,L, .;ea! to be bercunto allixed this ,?.o day of t!l:.Y.£. u f;_,)f._ • 19 811••'" · . . .. -r,-· . . -'!I~,,.. .. . ·. ·· . BARBEE"MILL CO. . INC·. " :: \, ;.., ······--·----------. ---3:: ., -·-·--··-·--.,._ ' ........... ,, ',s;.-e:.,,_. By ____ Q4._ . • .. ~-... ...:'. ......... .' ..... ~ ..... :.... . . ·• Prti<d.'!#J. ..... . By __ .. ··--'--·--· ··-·· : ..•. _····---·- .,. -4 h.F~~ ~-.: sr~1~~or--~~~.·,.n~~(iT_ON, lss. ~,~~,~:-~,~~;\,~~~~~ ... ..:~ Coun~f.>f ;~1;!;..h ! dayof /)1/A.u,//Y-/Cflr/ ,beforeme,theund~~ a N~:y. ;:~,li?jn and,for tj,e 1 ~~1 W~:;x.~~m~O,' ~led to, · ;i &-a~ -/!!«1t~d-~ • Secretary, respecti~el~, of th• ....,--, 1~rl teat executed the loregomg instrument, and acknowledged the said instrument to be the free an!l ,J'C'wt':.'' J · deed of said corporation, for the uses and purposes therein mentioned, and on oath stated that :" c.". autli,,rized to execute the said instrument and that the seal allixed is the corporate seal of said f corpo::at i . · · 1 Witness n, ,_ band and official seal hereto affixed the day and year first above w ·uen. · · ·:,: · · ·· . . . . \/ ~ [ II r -:i/i~.'tJ:J:J:t:~:- ~ ~ . il1\i ~"H -•~£i i'A!i1 ., ~·-··· ·:,;,,.,..,,,,,.~ .. ,. 20061002'1•0111.. 21)/007 fNS]l'?UUENT: NIK(}Jj TOTAL STAT/or,I 0TM-A10LG .~: (,$ $CCON_O INSTRUMENT). 4!ETHOD USE]!: F1£U) 1'5'"AVERS£ W7H AC7LJAL ,/ .,/: ~~#5::'o~rs AN£) ANCL£5 PORTION OF THE SW 1/4 OF THE NW 1/4 OF SECTION 32, TOWNSHIP 24 NORTH. RANGE 5 EAST, CITY OF RE:NTON. STA TE: OF WASHINGTON. LOA-9"t,-_ 1 !53LLA W.M. LND-~0-0152 Dl. RR SPIKE -"=> ('0/9J) ~ A ~ DATE ~J~VEY:.llCroBER 1993 LEGEND .::' • "SE:_r/1/r RE$AA ~:' C,4.P LS 19470 .:· '!.F'ouNO 1/4!·'REBr'R ,1c ·• CAP LS ~':'y2S1.fl -~(- a~77oJ··~ 7:ve ON_,(, ... ,,,.,, .APPROX $HOR€UNl!-0 SET8ACJ(: GRAPHIC SCALE .. .:· ,,,,·-==~ ·;;il~G ; KC$··-~~·"~•, ·'" __ /J 1/15 9r,-€·-~ .. SEc. .1f= r. 3.,;,. ~..-,It 5 E.,. w"faf ~M ),a,,( A ii c o LOT AodREss&$ LOT A ~79 U(}WA LOT 8 .JS09\:K WA. (.OT C 3907 LI< WA. LOT D 39~ LK WA. -· .J· f .}N[!B:.;49'09"W ~t.:_··i:.-¥ .,.-···· ·.,,..,_,, ' "' ;;; <-; --.... ,,;/c· -N;~!i(og•w --- 7';····.:' __ _.,--',,:l'.:::..: _ ':;.-- ~ ~/~,:~=~~j~~ -· . .-,.,.,,_" ___ , ...• ~·- C.D. l-flt.UJA 0r•/$ (}JV 12 LOT 1 ... Bt.OCK A UN0£R AHO U~ Tl-£ IIEST J.5 rECT Of' Ti,i.: (AST 19.17 m:T. Will-! THE UST LINE OF LOT A lHROUGI-I D. IHCUJSZVE. SAID UN.E BEl~G TI-IE NEW ~T LINE OF Tli( ~AllROAO RIGHT Of-" "IA':. !RECORDER'S CERTIFlCA TE No. iied for record th!s...l:...day cf &:f:. 20/i:i at..@ii, in book.2J1i..af~~ poge~ at the reque:;t M2Yoic H IoumQ 0 SURVEYOR'S CERTIF1CA 1E This mop correctly represents c survey mode by me or under my direction in conformcmc:e with the requirements of the Survey Recording Act at the request of R~Cuglni ULU. w ~ -.. JI -in NOV., 1999 ~ c:: .. ,.,t ,.,f~ certic:ote No, 9470 Mgr. Nfj(j"4B°$T'W NM"45"5T'W S30~'r7"w s3s,~•54•w 26t".J.i9' [UEAS)l.261.12!' ~ .. 7!°' ..... J .. t 962.St• (MEAS)_ ......... ! 114-2. 43' (MEAS) 4,JSI. 43' (IJ£~~ -! Pl MON LAKE WA. BL VO RENYi::JN MON p89J FO<INO COPPER 71< (6/93) 1 ~E COR 32-24-5 J IN CONCRt:T'E: ROAO N 1/-4 COR 32-24-S UNDER LA YER ASPH.AL RENTON /.ION ,11834 (10/21/93) (6/93) ,/ ' 0 / INTER. N 40th ST ~ P .... RK AVE" N. W/ TAO(" IN CAS£ {I0/2f/9J) FOUND ewe •(i ,{t!OT 1/1tf CQR o:: ""''-'/ ,2--· 469.38' (,~OS) '-"-54' • / i S 8fi,•09 E q..\; .,.',. tf;.,. N. 40th STREET \-.: / ,(Y f ,--------~ G ·• / . / /!· #J'l-{',f)/ ,{" .-:;Q, FOUND COPPER TACK . , ·; ~ • ';, fN CONCRE:TI: ROA() ·v· :.-,':;,_ ./;" =_=f? ·-;:, ,,...-~,--__ J.,. -.· ,:»~-mS'J',. AND UllUTr--EI\SDEN-"f B)I! on::,l:if" RENTDN RfC ,-tio.eo·&, o.o2"o7..tJE7 _,,· W S1c£L RING AS CASE BL ',,t) .le N 407H ST tl\/TERS€CTl0N (10/21/93) {'.~'C@tiflCA TE- ' (11€) NUtEIJY CERTIFY 7HAT I AU (IIF .AR£) 1UE OW>ll:R(S) IN FFI SfJ.IPl£ OF 111£ LANO ~y PLA17ED /ff 7HfS LDT UJJC IUU.IS71ENT. ~ I '• s~PHmk:~ ANO ~6£.FORE ME ::/re/1~~8:tnJf .fL~·l1ffe'X£CUTEti fRt :YRW ANO ;mm ms1oo$T, '" AN0:;1tCKNO~.:SAJO ~~T TO BE THE: FREE AND VOLUNTARY ACT At(B" Off{} 1'F SAJ0 -"CORP.c#A T!ON. Fi:R!'f'HE USES ANO PURPOSE.S 711£:REJN 'jff~~ Aft #td!/'~ Jlt7:&~~fit-!if¥AMSS~OF.IHAVE- .,:'·~~~/!~~~/t:.JM_ND-~~ Ml' ~O!-'--"•-Sf.A!-. TH£ DAY AND , ,---. ··. · ----/ ,1JJi"1!ibc~A "" ........ ~ TOUMA ENGIN~'§"'' 15 &-LAND SURVEYORS . _,; ' STAT~-1,.1SHJNGTS)N, ~;sl~Q .. · lfi:' ~ -· --··' '~-----· J,.R8£E: ioRE:ST PRooDcrs. JN(l! 0 LO.t LIN/i: AO.JUST/dENT f•,./ .:: ___ ... -,., $1Xrolt1m;r~!Zlr1CE-102•1CS'<"t.W,,#OJ2' OT:!JD.>.T.:i001 .-. ,.,,.,.,.,..". ~-· -=~,-r-" I""' -· l I Pfflll#t(05)2Sf-F"4'"(~:15)Z51--(,JQS CHKO. BY ~---.:_ ~u=~·'.,.-.. M, 1-• 40" 0~ 2 <-=,,,"·-,~ •. , I I ,,-/'.-.:. ~ ISSJ . ,. ,, 2006 HOit '/ObO Jz_ PORTION OF THE SW 1/4 OF THE NW 1/4 OF SECTION 32. TOWNSHIP 24 NORTH, RANGE 5 EAST. W.M. CITY OF RENTON, STA TE OF WASHINGTON. LEGAL DESCRIPTION "l.13/oO,f LUA-96-753LLA LND-30-0152 OFGoV,~ N"""', 'i!iif ,2-2<-'!f / / / /./ 0 .,,_, STREET LO,• o:.,> '4 //i'l 4 <n~ /,..-,·······•,.. ,.,_::,. ; 4 • 'O$,.W 60594 1/1'51H "'" , ·,, ~· -//N88<9 ----"'I;. """'-· . I ·~~~~:/ \/, -;, } , ,.,.,.-""" .. ,.. lob t ttwwgh tJ, Btod< A. l'illrMns Loks Washln9tor. G«do<i of Eden ,Z.. occon:l",n.g to th,e plat thereof ~ec.:,nl.ed in Volurrw 11 of P'krls, pugs 64, :_:::-c:._ -=-~ ~ ',t~~J) ,, .,,,::.----· ,:;; ·--. ·" 1' / ;''!/' ;~,¢ .i: .. ., ,,> ,/' .,;:>-· j::1,!•• I.,~-~,_,,,. Z¢"'---,-,"""' _.,, .. ·"" ''"' r·,"' i~. .·. :ji'.,,,, :i :·1 .0 __ .. ~· . .,,_ -~;:::i;q ,.sc ~~~~~ f----=--=-.::;, E~-==~? ~. ,,· ~-:~' ,(, P::=__-i_(, I !-::: --==---=-: ;?:; /// '{, ,: -~'-';' .. ' ··w/ /. ~,.-- . .• ! ~-i ' TH TREET < I ,' ~B~W'-~ ~-,,'""·"·'··· ,s· <' I I I I ,,-. / i}jo. / I , ,,t,l'?:1,/ I I I '~, J '~ .,' .,,,· ~ ... :-~~;w;:;~ /./ 1314'.'tB"'h•"" 36TH STREET\ NOTcS: 1. N€W ROCK 8Ul.JG-IEAO APPROi,g;> PER SP-92-147 OF TH€ CITY OF RENTON. . 2. £)(JST1N(; HOUSE P£R LUA-96-025-$1.le OF THE: CITY OF RE:NT~ .X IIQOCl8,I DECK ANO BOAT H<Xl'5E £NCRO.ACHIJEJ{1S HAltE BEEN SHOYW PlfRSiJANT TO RCW S8..t7.255 MD SHAU. 8£ DISCI..OSED IN A 1111.E RfYORT BY A 117LC INSURER AM) ISSlJcD AFTER 7HE FJJ...JNC OF 'lHtS SHORT Pl.AT. <_;'.=" CORNER In Klng Cuunty, Wash1ngtr,r,: TOGETHER 111TH odjooent .shorelond-5'; ANO ~.:o; =:::,. 2rr!n':i~ Uie:~~ R~!;"' ~cw,~~e ~t wide Se<lttls s.tt Un• 8n,r.c:t, Un& fli¢t ,,, Way. ~ 50.0 feet w!de on tOQd'l side of said r,:,iway ,;on,pqny".s m,;,ln trod< «!ntoer!"ine. o.s """ Lo=t.ed and COl\lfflUcto,d Ul'f>", ow,, <Jnd <icroN Gov«TJment I..Dt 2 of Section J2. Township 24 Nonh, fl<r>g,o 5 East, W.M., In K",ng County, W=hingt,on, being " port;;., of the same 100 foot ,rid,:. .trip of lond de=ril>e<I In WQm:111ty Ow,;l from !tie Loloeo Wcwlin,gtoo Llll>d Company to 111.e Norltlem Poclllc: Roi"'")' ComPO'\Y recorded February J. 1'904 under Recordin<;l Number 28709.3, lfe>g be-tween '"" lines drawn paral~ with ar'ld distant, r~ly.25.(1 feet ond 50.0 feet ~oo.t.-iy, as roaosu,,rd at rii;lht ongl"" !n,m said moln V(J,:;!r. -~Wliiee,. bc>unde<:I oo ttkle north by the e,;ister1y e>rtcnsion of the nortll -~1lna of -O>t 1, CD. Hilmon's ~ Washin,gl<m c,,r,:1.,, af Eden Dhn:oion -:~,~ 2.?acoat<llng t<:> the plat th..-eof reoorded h Volume 1 L of Plots. , . -~*'&ii, in king Count~ Wosr.tngton. ond bounded or, the s,o,,th by u,,, ._,, ·:,,.~ter1y ei<tensian or the :,oott, line of Lot 1J, c.o. HJlmon's l...ikt: ' -~nqtoo Gorden of Edffl Orns;on No. 2. <l(;CO(d">"l(I to the pl.:.t thd<:Gf -.~ in 'lo/....., 11 of Plots, poge 6+, in kC"9 County, Woshhgt...,_ -:";··:::,~~,~~~: :.-::~: ,f "'f.,· r:~~~J,~:z~:~~~ ...... ,, .. -:-· _,,· "I.ill CXAMINEO ANO jppRO}(o "ll-llS f:_oAY OF OC.To.B'D;;: A.O., 2()()1, Sc.<>T'T N<,SU,. ····-·,,._/ 0..+.,._ ~ /i.DJG toiJJ)rAS&S:So# liPOd. ";;J,;A,§sis:SiW ~--'"""·• _,.,.~------, 5~""IZ.'"TD-Ooo'S -5~:&.¥os-9"6C-~ "'u=' TOUl,/A £NGIN££RS""- IS 4< LAND SURVEYORS -;..·;efE F'.b"',;£s_l PR6~6ors. INC)'' '°+?f'LIN!f:.''Ao:Jfis'.~N_Tj'",f N!$T ¥AU.e'Y ~ r".Mlt 0~. SY Q,',"rr. .:· JOO NO. /.'. !iW1Hl!7fS1-'L<(:(.=£-"/CZ•l<Df"f, IM!!l!Wf2 DT ~J", _zi:}01 679-gbl-9.J'I f"'IO'IE" ("3) ~ FM ("25) 251--0625 CHKD. BY SC,\(£ SHE.ET ·.'.• UT 1•-=• 2,/01'2 ,.,._,,!," .. WATERFRONT CONSTRUCTION, INC. 205 NE NORTHLAKE WAY, SU!TE 230 SEATTLE. WA 861 05 W"ATER.FR.ONT July 22, 2010 Attn: City of Renton Development Services Division !055 South Grady Way Renton, WA 98045 Re: Barbee Mills LLC Proposed Watercraft Lifts Joint Use Pier (EXisting), 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N. Lake Study Comments ?i!YofRento ____ _ r)la . n nnmg D .. • iv1s1011 JUL i 8 lUIO As suggested by the city reviewer, we are pleased to submit as reference, the Luke Study prepared in 2008 for the pier structure associated with the Barbee Mills North Property joint use pier to the North at 4205 Williams Avenue North. The major change for the proposed watercraft lifts of this application being the location: The Barbee Mills established joint use pier site at 3905 Lake Washington Boulevai:.Q North...,_ The Lake Study comments still apply with Revision of Items 1, 3, 4 and 7. updated below, and as marked in the document. It is hoped that this document will facilitate the watercraft lift proposal review, maintaining a rea1istic perspective to the application review costs and proposed lifts, as the proposed lifts have minimal impact on the environment. Comments relative specifically to the proposed watercraft lifts are reviewed below. 1. Project Location and Description: Tbe proposed project is for the placement of watercraft lifts at the existingjoint use permitted pier structure, permitted under LUA 01 015. Proposed: * two (2) free standing boatlifts (I O'x 14, overall, with four ( 4) -1' sq. foot pads). * one {I) free standing boatlift with grated platform (boatlifi frame with fully grated JO' x 20' plalform). * one (1) jetski lift, dock mounted (with 4' x 6' overall support frame). Mitigation Proposed: Mitigation proposed involves removal of six 12" Diameter creosoted wood piles, which combined, make up the two outboard dolphins on the south side of the property. See Permit Drnwings. To maintain the existing prntective boom, two 12" diameter steel piles will be placed in the same footprint of the existing dolphins, offering a 66% footprint reduction. A vibratory extra(.iion, insertion pile driving system, barge mounted, will be used for extraction of the pylon piling, and insertion of the two steel piles, with use of a silt curtain for containment. Noise levels will be minimal, as both the diesel tug used to position the barge, and the diesel powered vibratory driver have muffied exhausts. Noise levels will be no higher than those ofa diesel powered motorvehick, such as a bus or truck. Noise to be minimized by use of equipment only for the proposed construclion duration. As can be noted from the former permitted pier pro_ject, site mitigation presently includes an acceptable planting plan, spawning gravel, and pier grating ... mitigation activities that would have been acceptable to the Corps for the proposed watercraft lifts. The proposed mitigation of pylon removal/ reduction is suggested in the Corps RGPl Programmatic as an acceptable fonn of mitigation for watercraft lift placement. 3. Shoreline Restoration of the site has already been accomplished. See Pcnnit Drawings. 4. Vegetation Cover has already been established at the site. See Mitigation Proposed, above. 7. Tree and Vegetation Protection: Not applicable to Watercraft Lift activities proposed. Alan D. Foltz Permit Coordinator Waterfront Construction, Inc. A.gent for Barbee Mills LLC Seattle (206) 548-8800 Toll Free (BBB) 927-7784 Fsx (206) 546-1 022 BARBEE MILL JOINT USE PIER PROPOSED WATERCRAFT LIFTS 3905 LAKE WASHINGTON BLVD. I. PROJECT LOCATION AND DESCRIPTION Project Purpose and Location: ;r The sed project is a community use dock intended to facilitate access to Lake Washington ill community residents. The Barbee Mill community, a new major waterfront subdivision, is ently under development by Conner Homes at Barbee Mill LLC C'Conner Homes") along the eastern shoreline of Lake Washington in the City of Renton in Section 32, Township 24N, 05E; Latitude 47.S"N, Longitude 122°W (Attachment I). The community dock would k lo d at 4205 Williams Ave N, Renton, WA 98056, the lakefront community center parcel (the ;'subJ roperty") and the "applicant" for the requested shoreline substantial development permit. Two bodies of water are adjacent to, or flow ugh, the Barbee Mill community: Lake Washington and May Creek. The subject property is lo along Lake Washington, a Shoreline of Statewide Significance as provided in RMC 4-3-090Fl, a Shoreline of the State under RMC 4-11-190. This Standard Stream or Lake Study is prep in accordance with the requirements of RMC 4-8-120D with respect to the Lake Washington oreline of the subject property and the 100' of adjoining Jakeshore lots both to the north and to the th of the subject property's property lines (the "Study area"). May Creek, which flows through community, is a Shoreline of the State (RMC 4-3-090F2), however, as the subject pro neither May Creek nor a 100' wide butTer along either side of May Creek, no stream or lake is required v..'ith respect to May Creek for purposes of this application. Proj escription: The Barbe ill community is being developed by Conner Homes at Barbee Mill LLC on the approximately e site of the former Barbee Mill Company lumber mill. To restore the former industrial site to a el suitable for a residential waterfront subdivision, the mil( buildings were demolished; fill soils w removed from behind the bulkhead; asphalt paving, a pier, the wooden bulkhead and piling assoc1 with the mill operation were removed; and extensive shoreline restoration was completed purs t to 5ale of the site to Conner Homes. The shoreline restoration wa"i completed by the Barbee Mi ompany in conjunction with vacation of the land. The applicant for regulatory permits was Cugini, Barbee Mi11 Company; tbe name of the project wa,;; Barbee Mill Beach Restoration. Upon completion, the Barbee Mill community will ve 114 multi-story paired homes, a pond, walking trails and lakefront open space for the use of re · ents. Lots 23 through 48 are lakefront lots; the subject property is situated between lots 30 31. The subject property has approximately 90' of lakefront with a sloping protective bcnn rock about 5' high along the shoreline. A coir roll installed as part of the site remediation exten ong the toe of the berm with a row of large logs along the shoreline just waterward of the coir A drainpipe outflow extends from the bank about midway along the subject property shorelin ithin a 15' wide public drainage easement that crosses the parcel. Under the proposed project plan, a new 1480 sq.ft. community dock would be constructe bout .. midway along the subject property shoreline (approximate coordinates of 47.5302 122.20515°W). The proposed dock would provide safe and convenient Barbee Mm _ --· hington from the lakefront community center pared for residents and guests of the Barbee Mill c munity. Jn addition to a landing and day moorage facility for watercraft., the dock would be a suita place for launching canoes and kayaks, sun-bathing, S\'r·imming, fishing, water skiing and an umber of other water sports and activities. In deciding upon a proposed dock location, Cmmer es required a site that would not impair the general public's use and enjoyment of the lake, uld not interfere with the use of existing or future neighboring docks or piers, and that would not e a navigation hazard to boaters, but that would be a convenient location for Barbee Mill comm · residents. The proposed dock will have a 6 1 by 1 1 main walkway and an 8' by 56' "T", fully grated to lessen shading impacts, with the bottom of dock 18" above the Ordinary High Water Line (OHWL). Construction methods employed on the ·ect will be minimally disruptive to wildlife and the environment. Construction site access will be foot or by boat, with all materials and equipment delivered to the site by barge; the barge will be red so as to prevent grounding on the lake bottom. All dock sections will be prefabricated delivered to the site. Glu-lam stringers ·will be used to allow the longest spans possible between · s; the smallest number and diameter of steel piles will be used to minimize the amount of struc in the water and the disturbance to the substrate; and piles will generally be set with a vibr pile driver. Silt containment curtains wi(] be installed around the work area and other similar management practices will be implemente:d to minimize the opportunity for erosion during · e driving activities. 2. LAKE CLASSIFICATION As a Shoreline of Statewide Significance (RMC 4-3-090F), Lake Washington is included in the definition of a Shoreline of the State (RMC 4-11-190). Lake Washington is a Class 1 lake as it is a perennial salmonid-bearing body of water classified as a Shoreline of the State (RMC 4P 11- l 90SI ). 3. SHORELINE RESTORATION AND OHW MARK Shoreline Restoration: Prior storation of the beach in conjunction with vacation of the land, the Lake Washington shoreline along area was heavily bulkheaded, back-filled and covered with impervious asphalt paving. Numerous p1 substantial quantities of concrete rubble and other shoreline debris were on site. Pursuant to the site re upland and in-water structures including the timber bulkhead and piling were removed, shoreline ru removed, fill soil was excavated to subgrade elevations, toe rock and a temporary quarry spall erosion rm were installed, and sand, gravel and rock materials were used to construct a beach to mimic natu ·tions. No additional excavation, grading, clearing or fill material will be required for the proposed do project. OHWMark: The Ordinary High Water (OHW) mark for Lake Washington is the line of mean high water (RMC 4-11-150 Definitions 0). The Lake Wa~hington water depth is controlled by the Army Corps of Engineers at the Hiram M. Chittenden Locks and is at 21.8' of lake elevation. In the course of the Barbee Mill Beach Restoration site remediation, pennancnt toe rock was installed along the OHWL. As of March 20, 2007, the date the SCUBA survey was conducted for purposes of identifying flora, fauna, substrate types and other qualitative information relative to the, Biological Evaluation for this proposed dock project, coir rolls were located along the OHWL. Barbee Mil' 4. VEGETATIVE COVER OF THE SITE Study area includes no wetland or flood hazard area~; it does include Lake Was.hington ripari eas. Prior to the Barbee Mill Beach Restoration project, riparian vegetation was found to be genera bsent within the Study area as the shoreline behind the bulkhead was paved. In unpaved areas, veg ·on noted included Juncus effusus (soft rush) and Iris pseudocaris (a non- native iris). After excava the fill soil and removing the bulkhead during the beach restoratio11: process, the beach was recons to mimic natural conditions with sand, gravel and rocks. In the course of the SCUBA sutvcy, Myr nonnative plant, was found along a11 the Tract WL. llum spicatum (Eurasion Milfoil), an invasive sec..1s. No planting is proposed below the riparian vegetation was planted along the newly restore ch including through plantin in the coir rolls. The upland redevelopment required extensive regr · and clearing; a mitigatio planting plan was agreed upon that includes planting along the L ashington shoreline. anting along the shoreline in accordance with this mitigation plan has ady commenced. e following species arc included in the preliminary plant list for the shoreh buffer 7.one: Trees: Amelanchier alnifolia erviccbcrry) Fraxinus latifolia (Orcgo Ash) Pinus contorta (Shore Pine Salix sitchensis (Sitka Willo Shrubs: Cornus sericea (Red-osier Dogwo Cornus sericea 'F/aviramea 1 (Y cllow vig Dogwood) llelictotrichon sataecetum (Blue Oat Grm Mahonia aquifolium (Tall Oregon Grape) Mahonia nervosa (Low Oregon Grape) Ribes s.anguinewn (Red Flowering Currant) Symphoricarpos albus (Snowberry) Gronndcovers: Allium cernuum (Nodding Onion) Armeria marilima (Thrift) Arctostaphylos uva-ursi (Kinnikinnik) Fragaria chiloensis (Beach Strawberry) Symphoricarpos mollis (Trailing Snowberry) The following species are included in the planting plan for the uplan center parcel: Trees: Cercidiphy/lumjaponicum (Katsura Tree) Betula pendula (European \Vhite Birch) Acer circinatum (Vine MapJe) Barbee Mill - 'Deleted: 1 iseum (Paperbark Maple) is dolabrata (False Arborvitae) Pennisetu alopecuroides 'Little Bunny' (Little Bunny Fountain Grass) flex crena/a ' of/ Touch' (Soft Touch Holly) Aca!Uhus mo (Bears Breech) Mahonia aqui ium (Oregon Grape) Cistus sa/viifoli (Sage-leafRockrose) Cornius sto/onife 'Kclseyi' (Kelseyi Edtwig Dogwood) Rosia 'Guacamole' uacamoie Hosta) Symphoricarpos alb (Common Snowberry) Hydrangea macrophy 'All Summer Beautyr (All Summer Beauty Hydrangea) Euphorbia polychroma ushion Spurge) He/leborus or ientalis (Le ten Rose) Heuchera micramha 'Palac Purple' (Coral Bells) Euphorbiapolychroma (Cu ion Spurge) Helleborus orientalis (Lenten ose) !Jeuchera micrantha 'Palace P le' (Coral Be1ls) lavandula angust(folia (English avender) Agapanthus 'Blue Giant' (Blue Gi t African Lily) Hemerocalis 'Chicago Royal Robe' oyal Robe Daylily) Pernettya mucronata (Heath) Groundcoven:: Pratia pedunculata (Blue Star Creeper) Fragaria chiloensis (Beach Strawberry) Arctostaphylos uva-ursi (Kinnikinnik) Cotoneaster dammeri (Bearberry Cotoneaster) 5. ECOLOGICAL FUNCTIONS OF LAKE WASHINGTON ALONG STUDY AREA Until relatively recently, the industrial structures and use of the site limited the ecologicaJ functions that would othervr"ise have been provided by Lake Washington and its adjacent riparian area. As a result of the extensive site restoration work., including removal of the wooden bulkhead, large pier and numerous pilings, excavation of fill soil from behind the bulkhead, and reconstruction of the beach to mimic its natural state, the ecological functions of the portion of the lake within the Study area should be greatly enhanced. Recently planted riparian vegetation will help stabilize and protect the newly restored banks from erosion. Much of this new vegetation will be overhanging, providing shade and predator protection for fish and aquatic invertebrates. The newly planted riparian vegetation will add significant organic matter to the lake substrate in the form of leaves and woody debris that fa1l and wash in, providing an additional source of food, shelter and shade for aquatic invertebrates and fish. This increased vegetation will also provide food and shelter for terrestrial insects, and in turn provide an additional food source for birds and animals that feed upon them. The addition of riparian vegetation to this formerly near-barren site should also help water quality by filtering pollutants, removing nutrients and reducing sediments in any nmoff from the adjacent upland development. The significantly sma!Ier design of the proposed new dock as compared to the structures removed, together with increased overhanging vegetation, may facilitate the migration of juvenile salmon. Barbee Mill . 6. FISH OR WILDLIFE USE OF AREA Birds: Birds observed on or near the site include hawks, herons, eagles, quail, osprey, connorants and ,songbirds. Before the mill structures were demolished, an osprey nest was successfully relocated from the top of the old -mill sawdust collector to a platform built on a 25 1 pole over tbe water not far from the original nest site. The osprey have accepted the new nest and a video camera records their activities for viewing over the lntemet. Allhough the bald eagle is no longer on the list of threatened or endangered species under the Endangered Species Act (ESA), bald eagles continue to be protected by the Bald and Golden Eagles Protection Ac.i and the Migratory Bird Treaty Act. The only eagle nests observed near the project site arc two nests approximately 0.65 mile from the site on the opposite shore. Mammals: The only wild mammals reported as observed in the area are deer. Fish: Salmonids observed at the site include salmon and trout. Salmonids known to be present in southern Lake Washington include Puget Sound ehinook salmon, coho salmon, sockeye salmon, steelhead trout, bull trout and cutthroat trout. Puget Sound chinook, Puget Sound steclhead and bull trout are all listed as; threatened under the ESA. Other fish observed at the site include bass, black crappie, bluegill, pumpkinseed sunfish, tench and yellow perch. The shoreline remediation ~was <l:e~ign~d. to be_ consistent with Wa~er ~~sourc~ Inventory A_rea (WRIA) 8 Conserv~i~n __ Ploo:i recommendations. As a result of the remediation, shoreline that was previously unsuitable habitat for fish and other aquatic life due to extensive shoreline modifications and industrial use of the site has been restored. The restored gravel substrate and gently sloping bottom should provide favorable habitat for winter rearing of salmon fry. The new gravel substrate should be suitable habitat for benthic invertebrates which would likely attract juvenile salmonids. The shallower water along the recently restored shoreline should provide some level of protection from larger predators. At the present time, the area has no living woody plant with a trunk six inches or greater in diameter or any other plant fa] 1 within the definition of"Trce" in R.."1C 4-11-200. This is likely because of the prior asphalt paving o and industrial use of, the area and subsequent excavation and regrading in accordance with the app upland development plan. Trees will be planted within the Study area pursuant to the plantin d landscaping plan upon completion of the upland development site work. The :'Tract E'' parcel re the community dock is proposed has already been developed \.vith a community center and Jan ing. , Trees planted in accordance with these landscaping plans pave trun~-. l~~:~ ~~-~ ___ si_~ in~~e ' ~-i~_~tt:~---~)'. pI_w:i~i11g th~ remaining vegetation following completion of rno~i of the major cons ~ projects, trees and vegetation will be less likely to be damaged during the construction process. ·~ Barbee Mill - 'WATERFRONT July 22, 2010 Attn: City of Renton Development Services Division I 055 South Grady Way Renton, WA 98045 Re: Barbee Mills LLC Watercraft Lifts Lake Study Comments WATERFRONT CONSTRUCTION, INC. 205 NE NORTHLAKE WAY, SUITE 230 SEATTLE, WA 8B1 05 City of Renton Planning Division JUL 2 B 1010 As suggested by the city review, we are pleased to submit the Lake Study prepared in 2008 for the pier structure associated with the proposed watercraft lifts at the site. Basic Lake Study comments still apply as depicted in the draft copy received from City records. It is hoped that this document will facilitate the watercraft lift proposal review, maintaining a realistic perspective to the application review costs and proposed lifts, as the proposed lifts have minimal impact on the environment. Comments relative specifically to the proposed watercraft lifts are reviewed below. I. Project Location and Description: The proposed project is for the placement of watercraft lifts at the existing joint use permitted pier structure, permitted under LU A O I O 15. Proposed: * two (2) free standing boatlifts (I O'x 14' overall, with four (4) -1' sq. foot pads). * one (I) free standing boatlift with grated platform (boatlift frame with fully grated 10' x 20' platform). * one (I) jetski lift, dock mounted (with 4' x 6' overall support frame). 2. Mitigation Proposed: Mitigation proposed involves removal of six 12" Diameter creosoted wood piles, which combined, make up the two outboard dolphins on the south side of the property. See Permit Drawings. To maintain the existing protective boom, two 12" diameter steel piles will be placed in the same footprint of the existing dolphins, offering a 66% footprint reduction. A vibratory extraction, insertion pile driving system, barge mounted, will be used for extraction of the pylon piling, and insertion of the two steel piles, with use of a silt curtain for containment. Noise levels will be minimal, as both the diesel tug used to position the barge, and the diesel powered vibratory driver have muffled exhausts. Noise levels will be no higher than those of a diesel powered motor vehicle, such as a bus or truck. Noise to be minimized by use of equipment only for the proposed construction duration. As can be noted from the former permitted pier project, site mitigation presently includes an acceptable planting plan, spawning gravel, and pier grating ... mitigation activities that would have been acceptable to the Corps for the proposed watercraft lifts. The proposed mitigation of pylon removal / reduction is suggested in the Corps RGP I Programmatic as an acceptable form of mitigation for watercraft lift placement. 11.lan D. Foltz Permit Coordinator Waterfront Construction, Inc. !I.gent for Barbee Mills LLC Seattle (206) 548-9800 Toll Free [888) 827-7784 Fax [206) 548-1 022 ., DRAFT#2 LAKE STUDY Barbee Mill Community Dock Project For: Conner Homes at Barbee Mill, LLC 846 -108"' Ave NE Bellevue, WA 98004 At: Barbee Mill 4205 Williams Ave N Renton, WA 98056 Parcel #051850 0120 (Pending) Prepared by: Marine Surveys & Assessments 521 Snagstead Way Port Townsend, WA 98368 Phone: (360) 385-4073, Fax: (360) 385-1724 EMmail sea@cablespeed.com March~ 2008 Barbee Mill Community Dock Project • 2 DRAFT#2 Table of Contents Lake Assessment Narrative Page 1. Project location and description ..................................................... . 2. Lake classification. 3. Shoreline restoration and OHW mark ............................................. .. 4. Vegetative cover of the site ........................................................... .. 5. Ecological functions of Lake Washington along study area ........ . 6. Fish or wildlife use of area ................................................................ . 7. Measures to protect trees and vegetation .................................... . 8 ........................................................................................................... .. 9 ............................................................................................................ . Attachment Number Page I. Site map ............................................................................................ . 2. Grading plan .................................................................................... .. 3 ................................... " ....................................................................... . 4 ........................................................................................................... .. 5 ............................................................................................................ . Barbee Mill Community Dock Project • 3 DRAFT#2 BARBEE MILL COMMUNITY DOCK PROJECT LAKE STUDY ASSESSMENT NARRATIVE I. PROJECT LOCATION AND DESCRIPTION Project Purpose and Location: The proposed project is a community use dock intended to facilitate access to Lake Washington for Barbee Mill community residents. The Barbee Mill community, a new major waterfront subdivision, is currently under development by Conner Homes at Barbee Mill LLC ("Conner Homes") along the southeastern shoreline of Lake Washington in the City of Renton in Section 32, Township 24N, Range 05E; Latitude 47.5°N, Longitude 122°W (Attachment 1). The community dock would be located at 4205 Williams Ave N, Renton, WA 98056, the lakefront community center parcel (the '"subject property") and the "applicant" for the requested shoreline substantial development permit. Two bodies of water are adjacent to, or flow through, the Barbee Mill community: Lake Washington and May Creek. The subject property is located along Lake Washington, a Shoreline of Statewide Significance as provided in RMC 4-3-090FI, and a Shoreline of the State under RMC 4-11-190. This Standard Stream or Lake Study is prepared in accordance with the requirements of RMC 4-8-120D with respect to the Lake Washington shoreline of the subject property and the 100' of adjoining lakeshore lots both to the north and to the south of the subject property's property lines (the "Study area"). May Creek, which flows through the Barbee Mill community, is a Shoreline of the State (RMC 4-3-090F2), however, as the subject property abuts neither May Creek nor a 100' wide buffer along either side of May Creek, no stream or lake study is required with respect to May Creek for purposes of this application. Project Description: The Barbee Mill community is being developed by Conner Homes at Barbee Mill LLC on the approximately 22 acre site of the former Barbee Mill Company lumber mill. To restore the former industrial site to a parcel suitable for a residential waterfront subdivision, the mill buildings were demolished; fill soils were removed from behind the bulkhead; asphalt paving, a pier, the wooden bulkhead and piling associated with the mill operation were removed; and extensive shoreline restoration was completed pursuant to sale of the site to Conner Homes. The shoreline restoration was completed by the Barbee Mill Company in conjunction with vacation of the land. The applicant for regulatory permits was Robert Cugini, Barbee Mill Company; the name of the project was Barbee Mill Beach Restoration. Upon completion, the Barbee Mill community will have Il4 multi-story paired homes, a pond, walking trails and lakefront open space for the use of residents. Lots 23 through 48 are lakefront lots; the subject property is situated between lots 30 and 31. The subject property has approximately 90' of lakefront with a sloping protective berm of rock about 5' high along the shoreline. A coir roll installed as part of the site remediation extends along the toe of the berm with a row of large logs along the shoreline just waterward of the coir roll. A drainpipe outflow extends from the bank about midway along the subject property shoreline within a 15' wide public drainage easement that crosses the parcel. Under the proposed project plan, a new 1480 sq.ft. community dock would be constructed about• midway along the subject property shoreline (approximate coordinates of 47.53022°N, 122.20515°W). The proposed dock would provide safe and convenient access to Lake Barbee Mill Community Dock Project • 4 ·· i Formatted: Justified J DRAFT#2 Washington from the lakefront community center parcel for residents and guests of the Barbee Mill community. In addition to a landing and day moorage facility for watercraft, the dock would be a suitable place for launching canoes and kayaks, sun~bathing, swimming, fishing, water skiing and any number of other water sports and activities. In deciding upon a proposed dock location, Conner Homes required a site that would not impair the general public's use and enjoyment of the lake, would not interfere with the use of existing or future neighboring docks or piers, and that would not pose a navigation hazard to boaters, but that would be a convenient location for Barbee Mill community residents. The proposed dock will have a 6' by 172' main walkway and an 8' by 56' "T", fully grated to lessen shading impacts, with the bottom of the dock 18" above the Ordinary High Water Line (OHWL). Construction methods employed on the project will be minimally disruptive to wildlife and the environment. Construction site access will be by foot or by boat, with al1 materials and equipment delivered to the site by barge; the barge will be moored so as to prevent grounding on the lake bottom. All dock sections will be prefabricated and delivered to the site. Glu-lam stringers will be used to allow the longest spans possible between piles; the smallest number and diameter of steel piles will be used to minimize the amount of structure in the water and the disturbance to the substrate; and piles will generally be set with a vibratory pile driver. Silt containment curtains will be installed around the work area and other similar best management practices will be implemented to minimize the opportunity for erosion during pile driving activities. 2. LAKE CLASSIFICATION As a Shoreline of Statewide Significance (RMC 4-3-090F), Lake Washington is included in the definition of a Shoreline of the State (RMC 4-11-190). Lake Washington is a Class 1 lake as it is a perennial salmonid-bearing body of water classified as a Shoreline of the State (RMC 4-l 1- 190SI ). 3. SHORELINE RESTORATION AND OHW MARK Shoreline Restoration: Prior to restoration of the beach in conjunction with vacation of the land, the Lake Washington shoreline along the study area was heavily bulkheaded, back-filled and covered with impervious asphalt paving. Numerous piling and substantial quantities of concrete rubble and other shoreline debris were on site. Pursuant to the site remediation, upland and in-water structures including the timber bulkhead and piling were removed, shoreline rubble was removed, fill soil was excavated to subgrade elevations, toe rock and a temporary quarry spall erosion control berm were installed, and sand, gravel and rock materials were used to construct a beach to mimic natural conditions. No additional excavation, grading, clearing or fill material will be required for the proposed dock project. OHWMark: The Ordinary High Water (OHW) mark for Lake Washington is the line of mean high water (RMC 4-11-150 Definitions 0). The Lake Washington water depth is controlled by the Army Corps of Engineers at the Hiram M. Chittenden Locks and is at 21.8' of lake elevation. In the course of the Barbee Mill Beach Restoration site remediation, pennanent toe rock was installed along the OHWL. As of March 20, 2007, the date the SCUBA survey was conducted for purposes of identifying flora, fauna, substrate types and other qualitative information relative to the< Biological Evaluation for this proposed dock project, coir rolls were located along the OHWL. Barbee Milt Community Dock Project • 5 ------\ Formatted: Justified ~ DRAFT#2 4. VEGETATIVE COVER OF THE SITE The Study area includes no wetland or flood hazard areas; it does include Lake Washington riparian areas. Prior to the Barbee Mill Beach Restoration project, riparian vegetation was found to be generally absent within the Study area as the shoreline behind the bulkhead was paved. In unpaved areas, vegetation noted included Juncus effusus (soft rush) and Iris pseudocaris (a non- native iris). After excavating the fill soil and removing the bulkhead during the beach restoration, process, the beach was reconstructed to mimic natural conditions with sand, gravel and rocks. ln the course of the SCUBA survey, Myriophyllum spicatum (Eurasion M_ilfoil), an invasive nonnative plant, was found along all the Tract E transects. No planting is proposed below the OHWL. Native riparian vegetation was planted along the newly restored beach including through plantings in the coir rolls. The upland redevelopment required extensive regrading and clearing; a mitigation planting plan was agreed upon that includes planting along the Lake Washington shoreline. Planting along the shoreline in accordance with this mitigation plan has already commenced. The fol1owing species are included in the preliminary plant list for the shoreline buffer zone: Trees: Amelanchier alnifo/ia (Serviceberry) Fraxinus /atifo/ia (Oregon Ash) Pinus contorta (Shore Pine) Salix sitchensis (Sitka Willow) Shrubs: Cornus sericea (Red.osier Dogwood) Cornus sericea 'Flaviramea' (Yellow Twig Dogwood) Helictotrichon sataecetum (Blue Oat Grass) Mahonia aquifo/ium (Tall Oregon Grape) Mahonia nervosa (Low Oregon Grape) Ribes sanguineum (Red Flowering Currant) Symphoricarpos a/bus (Snowberry) Groundcovers: Allium cemuum (Nodding Onion) Armeria maritima (Thrift) Arctostaphylos uva.ursi (Kinnikinnik) Fragaria chiloensis (Beach Strawberry) Symphoricarpos mollis (Trailing Snowberry) The following species are included in the planting plan for the upland portion of the community center parcel: Trees: Cercidiphyl/um japonicum (Katsura Tree) Betula pendu/a (European White Birch) Acer circinatum (Vine Maple) Barbee Mill Community Dock Project • 6 . : Deleted: , -- DRAFT #2 Acer griseum (Paperbark Maple) Thujopsis dolabrata (False Arborvitae) Shrubs: Pennisetum alopecuroides 'Little Bunny' (Little Bunny Fountain Grass) !lex crenata 'Soft Touch' (Soft Touch Holly) Acanthus mollus (Bears Breech) Mahonia aquifolium (Oregon Grape) Cistus salviifolius (Sage-leafRockrose) Cornius stolonifera 'Kelseyi' (Kelseyi Edtwig Dogwood) Hos/a 'Guacamole' (Guacamole Hosta) Symphoricarpos a/bus (Common Snowberzy) Hydrangea macrophylla 'All Summer Beauty' (All Summer Beauty Hydrangea) Euphorbia po/ychroma ( Cushion Spurge) Helleborus Orienta/is (Lenten Rose) Heuchera micrantha 'Palace Purple' (Coral Bells) Euphorbia po/ychroma (Cushion Spurge) Helleborus orientalis (Lenten Rose) Heuchera micrantha 'Palace Purple' (Coral Bells) Lavandula angustifo/ia (English Lavender) Agapanthus 'Blue Giant' (Blue Giant African Lily) Hemerocalis 'Chicago Royal Robe' (Royal Robe Daylily) Pernettya mucronata (Heath) Groundcoven: Pratia pedunculata (Blue Star Creeper) Fragaria chi/oensis (Beach Strawberry) Arctostaphylos uva-ursi (Kinnikinnik) Cotoneaster dammeri (Bearberry Cotoneaster) 5. ECOLOGICAL FUNCTIONS OF LAKE WASHINGTON ALONG STUDY AREA Until re]atively recently, the industrial structures and use of the site limited the ecological functions that would otherwise have been provided by Lake Washington and its adjacent riparian area. As a result of the extensive site restoration work, including removal of the wooden bulkhead, large pier and numerous pilings, excavation of fill soil from behind the bulkhead, and reconstruction of the beach to mimic its natural state, the ecological functions of the portion of the lake within the Study area should be greatly enhanced. Recently planted riparian vegetation will help stabilize and protect the newly restored banks from erosion. Much of this new vegetation will be overhanging, providing shade and predator protection for fish and aquatic invertebrates. The newly planted riparian vegetation will add significant organic matter to the lake substrate in the form of leaves and woody debris that fall and wash in, providing an additional source of food, shelter and shade for aquatic invertebrates and fish. This increased vegetation will also provide food and shelter for terrestrial insects, and in tum provide an additional food source for birds and animals that feed upon them. The addition of riparian vegetation to this formerly near-barren site should also help water quality by filtering pollutants, removing nutrients and reducing sediments in any runoff from the adjacent upland development. The significantly smaller design of the proposed new dock as compared to the structures removed, together with increased overhanging vegetation, may facilitate the migration of juvenile salmon. Barbee Mill Community Dock Projecf • 7 DRAFT#2 6. FISH OR WILDLIFE USE OF AREA Birds: Birds observed on or near the site include hawks, herons, eagles, quail, osprey, connorants and ,s~ngbirtj~~ J~~fo~~ the_ ~ill structures _w_ere qemolished, fill osprey nest was successfully?e_lo_~_a;e~ from the top of the old mill sawdust collector to a platform built on a 25' pole over the water not far from the original nest site. The osprey have accepted the new nest and a video camera records their activities for viewing over the Internet. Although the bald eagle is no longer on the list of threatened or endangered species under the Endangered Species Act (ESA), bald eagles continue to be protected by the Bald and Golden Eagles Protection Act and the Migratory Bird Treaty Act. The only eagle nests observed near the project site are two nests approximately 0.65 mile from the site on the opposite shore. Mammals: The only wild mammals reported as observed in the area are deer. Fish: Salrnonids observed at the site include salmon and trout. Salmonids known to be present in southern Lake Washington include Puget S0W1d chinook salmon, coho salmon, sockeye salmon, steelhead trout, bull trout and cutthroat trout. Puget Sound chinook, Puget Sound steelhead and bull trout are all listed as threatened under the ESA. Other fish observed at the site include bass, black crappie, bluegill, pumpkinseed sunfish, tench and yellow perch. The shoreline remediation ,~as _4~s_igt}~~-J~--~~--~<?-~~~t-~_1;1J_~i~ __ W !lter _R~our_c_e__Ix1ye_~!~ry _f\_r_~_a_ (~) .. ~--Gi;,~set:".'~~-i<?!l ?t~ _ recommendations. As a result of the remediation, shoreline that was previously unsuitable habitat for fish and other aquatic life due to extensive shoreline modifications and industrial use of the site has been restored. The restored gravel substrate and gently sloping bottom should provide favorable habitat for winter rearing of salmon fry. The new grave] substrate should be suitable habitat for benthic invertebrates which would likely attract juvenile salmonids. The shallower water along the recently restored shoreline should provide some level of protection from larger predators. 7. MEASURES TO PROTECT TREES AND VEGETATION At the present time, the Study area has no living woody plant with a trunk six inches or greater in diameter or any other plant falling within the definition of"Tree" in RMC 4-11-200. This is likely because of the prior asphalt paving over, and industrial use of, the area and subsequent excavation and regrading in accordance with the approved upland development plan. Trees will be planted within the Study area pursuant to the planting and landscaping plan upon completion of the upland development site work. The :'Tract E" parcel where the community dock is proposed has already been developed with a community center and landscaping.~ Trees planted in accordance with these landscaping plans ,)lave trunks less than_ six inches __ in diamete1; __ By _planting _the remaining vegetation following completion of most of the major construction projects, trees and\. vegetation will be less likely to be damaged during the construction process. Barbee Mill Community Dock Project • 8 : Deleted: ,-. ---------=-,) ·· r Formatted: Font: Not Bold, Not L_!t_a(lc, -~~ und~rlin~ _ -. --, Deleted: The dock ania will be landscaped upon completion ofthe , proposed community dock construction. \ j Deleted: will likely ···--_ ·-___ =:=) \( Deleted: at the time of plant:i.cg ] PLANNING DIVISION ENVIRONMENTAL CHECKLIST City of Renton Planning Division 1055 South Grady Way-Renton, WA 98057 Phone: 425-430-7200 Fax: 425-430-7231 PURPOSE OF CHECKLIST: ~;~~ of Rento 1 ,c,r,ning Oivisior The State Environmental Policy Act (SEPA), Chapter 43.21C RCW, requires all governmental agencies to consider the environmental impacts of a proposal before making decisions. An Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) must be prepared for all proposals with probable significant adverse impacts on the quality of the environment. The purpose of this checklist is to provide information to help you and the agency identify impacts from your proposal (and to reduce or avoid impacts from the proposal, if it can be done) and to help the agency decide whether an EIS is required. INSTRUCTIONS FOR APPLICANTS: This environmental checklist asks you to describe some basic information about your proposal. Governmental agencies use this checklist to determine whether the environmental impacts of your proposal are significant, requiring preparation of an EIS. Answer the questions briefly, with the most precise information known, or give the best description you can. You must answer each question accurately and carefully, to the best of your knowledge. In most cases, you should be able to answer the questions from your own observations or project plans without the need to hire experts. If you really do not know the answer, or if a question does not apply to your proposal, write "do not know" or "does not apply", Complete answers to the questions now may avoid unnecessary delays later. Some questions ask about governmental regulations, such as zoning, shoreline, and landmark designations. Answer these questions if you can. If you have problems, the governmental agencies can assist you. The checklist questions apply to all parts of your proposal, even if you plan to do them over a period of time or on different parcels of land. Attach any additional information that will help describe your proposal or its environmental effects. The agency to which you submit this checklist may ask you to explain your answers or provide additional information reasonably related to determining if there may be significant adverse impact. USE OF CHECKLIST FOR NONPROJECT PROPOSALS: Complete this checklist for nonproject proposals, even though questions may be answered "does not apply." IN ADDITION, complete the SUPPLEMENTAL SHEET FOR NONPROJECT ACTIONS (part D). • 1 • 06/09 C:\Documents and Settings\alan\Desktop\My Letters\Barbee Mill, Cugini lift\Env Cklst.doc For nonproject actions (actions involving decisions on policies, plans and programs), the references in the checklist to the words "project" "applicant," and "property or site" should be read as "proposal," "proposer," and "affected geographic area," respectively. -2 -06/09 C:\Documents and Settings\alan\Desktop\My Letters\Barbee Mill, Cugini Lift\Em, Cklst.doc A. BACKGROUND I. Name of proposed project, if applicable: Barbee Mill Joint Use Pier Watercraft Lifts 2. Name of applicant: Barbee Mill Company, Robert Cugini 3. Address and phone number of applicant and contact person: Barbee Mill Co., 3905 Lake Washington Blvd. N., Renton, WA 98056 Alan Foltz, waterfront Const. Inc., Agent, 205 NE Northlake Way, Ste. 230, Seattle, WA 98105 4. Date checklist prepared: May 25, 2010 5. Agency requesting checklist: City of Renton 6. Proposed timing or schedule (including phasing, if applicable): In work window of Permits, as received. 7-16 to 12-31. 7. Do you have any plans for future additions, expansion, or further activity related to or connected with this proposal? If yes, explain. None Known 8. List any environmental information you know about that has been prepared, or will be prepared, directly related to this proposal. Critical Areas Report by Cedarock Consultants Lake Study Report formerly approved for the pier structure as permitted by others. 9. Do you know whether applications are pending for governmental approvals of other proposals directly affecting the property covered by your proposal? If yes, explain. None known. I 0. List any governmental approvals or permits that will be needed for your proposal, if known. Corps RGPI Permit, WDFW HPA Not Required per WAC 220-110-224. Renton SDP, SEPA, BP, Critical Areas Permit. 11. Give brief, complete description of your proposal, including the proposed uses and the size of the project and site. The placement of two free standing boatlifts, one free standing boatlift with a grated platform top, and one jetski lift, attached to the existing Joint Use Pier structure. .3. C:\Documents and Settings\alan\Desktop\My Letters\Barbee Mill, Cugini Lift\Permlts\Env Cklst.doc 06/09 12. Location of the proposal. Give sufficient information for a person to understand the precise location of your proposed project, including a street address, if any, and section, township, and range if known. If a proposal would occur over a range of area, provide the range or boundaries of the site(s). Provide a legal description, site plan, vicinity map, and topographic map, if reasonably available. While you should submit any plans required by the agency, you are not required to duplicate maps or detailed plans submitted with any permit applications related to this checklist. See Information on Permit Drawings Attached. B. ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS 1. EARTH a. General description of the site ( circle one); flat, rolling, hilly, steep slopes, mountainous, other------~ b. What is the steepest slope on the site (approximate percent slope?) N/A c. What general types of soils are found on the site (for example, clay, sand, gravel, peat, muck)? If you know the classification of agricultural soils, specify them and note any prime farmland. Residential landscaping in narrow yards between condos and bulkhead. d. Are there surface indications or history of unstable soils in the immediate vicinity? If so, describe. None known. e. Describe the purpose, type, and approximate quantities of any filling or grading proposed. Indicate source of fill. NIA f. Could erosion occur as a result of clearing, construction, or use? If so, generally describe. No g. About what percent of the site will be covered with impervious surfaces after project construction (for example, asphalt or buildings)? h. Not applicable. Proposed measures to reduce or control erosion, or other impacts to the earth, if any: None Proposed. -4 -06/09 C:\Oocuments and Settings\alan\Desktop\My Letters\Barbee Mill, Cugini Uft\Env Cklstdoc 2. AIR a. What types of emissions to the air would result from the proposal (i.e., dust, automobile, odors, industrial wood smoke) during construction and when the project is completed? If any, generally describe and give approximate quantities if known. Muffled diesel exhaust of barge crane during placement of pre constructed lifts. b. Are there any off-site sources of emission or odor that may affect your proposal? If so, generally describe. c. Proposed measures to reduce or control emissions or other impacts to air, if any: Efficient use of equipment during placement of lifts. 3. WATER a. Surface Water: I) Is there any surface water body on or in the immediate v1cm1ty of the site (including year-rormd and seasonal streams, saltwater, lakes, ponds, wetlands)? If yes, describe type and provide names. If appropriate, state what stream or river it flows into. Yes. Lake Washington. 2) Will the project require any work over, in, or adjacent to (within 200 feet) the described waters? If yes, please describe and attach available plans. Delivery and placement of lifts from barge. See plans attached. 3) Estimate the amormt of fill and dredge material that would be placed in or removed from surface water or wetlands and indicate the area of the site that would be affected. Indicate the source of fill material. NIA 4) Will the proposal require surface water withdrawals or diversions? Give general description, purpose, and approximate quantities if known. 5) Does the proposal lie within a 100-year flood plain? If so, note location on the site plan. 6) Does the proposal involve any discharges of waste materials to surface waters? If so, describe the type of waste and anticipated volume of discharge. No discharges. -5 -06/09 C:\Documents and Settings\alan\OesktoplMy Letters\Barbee Mill, Cugini Lift\Env Cklstdoc b. Ground Water: 1) Will ground water be withdrawn, or will water be discharged to ground water? Give general description, purpose, and approximate quantities if known. No 2) Describe waste material that will be discharged into the ground from septic tanks or other sources, if any (for example: Domestic sewage; industrial, containing the following chemicals ... ; agricultural; etc.). Describe the general size of the system, the number of such systems, the number of houses to be served (if applicable), or the number of animals or humans the system(s) are expected to serve. NIA c. Water Runoff (including storm water): 1) Describe the source of runoff (including storm water) and method of collection and disposal, if any (include quantities, if known). Where will this water flow? Will this water flow into other waters, If so, describe. 2) Could waste material enter ground or surface waters? If so, generally describe. No d. Proposed measures to reduce or control surface, ground, and runoff water impacts, if any: None proposed 4. PLANTS a. Check or circle types of vegetation found on the site: x deciduous tree: alder, maple, aspen, other --evergreen tree: fir, cedar, pine, other -x-shrubs _x_ grass __ pasture crop or grain wet soil plants: cattail, buttercup, bullrush, skunk cabbage, other water plants: water lily, eel grass, milfoil, other other types of vegetation b. What kind and amount of vegetation will be removed or altered? None c. List threatened or endangered species known to be on or near the site. None known d. Proposed landscaping, use of native plants, or other measures to preserve or enhance vegetation on the site, if any: None Proposed. Already applied as mitigation for other projects. -6 -06/09 C:\Documents and Settings\alan\Desktop\My Letters\Barbee Mill, Cugini Lift\Env Cklst.doc 5. ANIMALS a. Circle any birds and animals, which have been observed on or near the site or are known to be on or near the site: Birds: hawk, heron, eagle, songbirds, other ________ _ Mammals: deer, bear, elk, beaver, other __________ _ Fish: bass, salmon, trout, herring, shellfish, other ______ _ b. List any threatened or endangered species known to be on or near the site. Salmon c. Is the site part of a migration route? If so, explain Unknown to be. d. Proposed measures to preserve or enhance wildlife, if any: None proposed. 6. ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES a. What kinds of energy ( electric, natural gas, oil, wood stove, solar) will be used to meet the completed project's energy needs? Describe whether it will be used for heating, manufacturing, etc. None b. Would your project affect the potential use of solar energy by adjacent properties? If so, generally describe. c. What kinds of energy conservation features are included in the plans of this proposal? List other proposed measures to reduce or control energy impacts, if any: 7. ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH a. Are there any environmental health hazards, including exposure to toxic chemicals, risk of fire and explosion, spill, or hazardous waste, that could occur as a result of this proposal? If so, describe. I) Describe special emergency services that might be required. Emergency Service Listing Numbers are posted on Barge and Permit Package. 2) Proposed measures to reduce or control environmental health hazards, if any: None proposed • 7 • 06/09 C:\Documents and Settings\alan\Desktop\My Letters\Barbee Mill, Cugini lift\Env Cklstdoc b. Noise I) What types of noise exist in the area which may affect your project (for example: traffic, equipment, operation, other)? Quiet Shoreline residential area. 2) What types and levels of noise would be created by or associated with the project on a short-term or a long-term basis (for example: traffic, construction, operation, other)? Indicate what hours noise would come from the site. Diesel exhaust from tug and barge mounted crane as used. 3) Proposed measures to reduce or control noise impacts, if any: Minimal use of equipment. 8. LAND AND SHORELINE USE a. b. What is the current use of the site and adjacent properties? Private Residential Has the site been used for agriculture? If so, describe. c. Describe any structures on the site. Condominiums d. Will any structures be demolished? If so, what? No e. What is the current zoning classification of the site? R-Residential Single Family f. What is the current comprehensive plan designation of the site? Unknown g. If applicable, what is the current shoreline master program designation of the site? Not known h. Has any part of the site been classified as an "environmentally sensitive" area? If so, specify. No 1. Approximately how many people would reside or work in the completed project? Not Applicable • 8 • 06/09 C:\Documents and Settings\alan\Desktop\My Letters\Barbee Mill, Cugini Lift\Env Cklstdoc J. Approximately how many people would the completed project displace? None k. Proposed measures to avoid or reduce displacement impacts, if any: None proposed I. Proposed measures to ensure the proposal 1s compatible with existing and projected land uses and plans, if any: None proposed 9. HOUSING a. Approximately how many units would be provided, if any? Indicate whether high, middle, or low-income housing. b. Approximately how many units, if any, would be eliminated? Indicate whether high, middle, or low-income housing. c. Proposed measures to reduce or control housing impacts, if any: None proposed 10. AESTHETICS a. What is the tallest height of any proposed structure(s), not including antennas; what is the principal exterior building material(s) proposed. Approx. 3' above dock level. b. What views in the immediate vicinity would be altered or obstructed? No obstructed views c. Proposed measures to reduce or control aesthetic impacts, if any: None proposed 11. LIGHT AND GLARE a. What type of light or glare will the proposal produce? What time of day would it mainly occur? No change. No reduction or increase. b. Could light or glare from the finished project be a safety hazard or interfere with views? No • 9 • 06/09 C:\Documents and Settings\alan\Desktop\My Letters\Barbee Mill, Cugini Lift\Env Cklstdoc c. What existing ofl~site sources oflight or glare may affect your proposal? d. Proposed measures to reduce or control light and glare impacts, if any: None proposed. 12. RECREATION a. What designated and informal recreational opportunities are in the immediate vicinity? Boating in Lake Washington b. Would the proposed project displace any existing recreational uses? If so, describe. No. c. Proposed measures to reduce or control impacts on recreation, including recreation opportunities to be provided by the project or applicant, if any: Lifts provide added protection of recreational boats. 13. HISTORIC AND CULTURAL PRESERVATION a. Are there any places or objects listed on, or proposed for, national state, or local preservation registers known to be on or next to the site? If so, generally describe. No. None proposed. b. Generally describe any landmarks or evidence of historic, archaeological, scientific, or cultural importance known to be on or next to the site. None known c. Proposed measures to reduce or control impacts, if any: None proposed 14. TRANSPORTATION a. Identify public streets and highways serving the site, and describe proposed access to the existing street system. Show on site plans, if any. b. Neighborhood streets. Lake Washington Blvd. Is site currently served by public transit? If not, what is the approximate distance to the nearest transit stop? Unknown c. How many parking spaces would the completed project have? How many would the project eliminate? None -10 -06/09 C:\Oocuments and Settings\alan\Desktop\My Letters\Barbee Mill, Cugini Lift\Env Cklst.doc d. Will the proposal require any new roads or streets, or improvements to existing roads or streets, not including driveways? If so, generally describe (indicate whether public or private? No e. Will the project use ( or occur in the immediate vicinity of) water, rail, or au transportation? If so, generally describe. No f. How many vehicular trips per day would be generated by the completed project? If known, indicate when peak volumes would occur. g. Proposed measures to reduce or control transportation impacts, if any: None proposed 15. PUBLIC SERVICES a. Would the project result in an increased need for public services (for example: fire protection, police protection, health care, schools, other)? If so, generally describe. No b. Proposed measures to reduce or control direct impacts on public services, if any. None proposed 16. UTILITIES a. Circle utilities currently available at the site: electricity, natural gas, water, refuse service, telephone, sanitary sewer, septic system, other. b. Describe the utilities that are proposed for the project, the utility providing the service, and the general construction activities on the site or in the immediate vicinity which might be needed. None proposed C. SIGNATURE I, the undersigned, declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of Washington that to the best of my knowledge the above information is true, correct, and complete. It is understood that the lead agency may withdraw any declaration of non- significance that it might issue in reliance upon this checklist should there be any willful misrepresentation or willful lack of full discl~s~ /art. Proponent Signature: ~ 4 ~ NamePrinted: 4J.,,fA( a B~u d~ I Date: (/~ J Y P, ;//,?/t? I } -11 -06/09 C:\Documents and Settings\alan\Desktop\My Letters\Barbee Mill, Cugini Lift\Env Cklst.doc D. SUPPLEMENT AL SHEETS FOR NONPROJECT ACTIONS (These sheets should only be used for actions involving decisions on policies, plans and ro rams. You do not need to fill out these sheets for ro·ect actions. Because these questions are very general, it may be helpful to read them in conjunction with the list of the elements of the environment. When answering these questions, be aware of the extent the proposal, or the types of activities likely to result from the proposal, would affect the item at a greater intensity or at a faster rate than if the proposal were not implemented. Respond briefly and in general terms. 1. How would the proposal be likely to increase discharge to water; emissions to air; production, storage, or release of toxic or hazardous substances; or production of noise? Proposed measures to avoid or reduce such increases are: 2. How would the proposal be likely to affect plants, animals, fish, or marine life? Proposed measures to protect or conserve plants, animals, fish, or marine life are: 3. How would the proposal be likely to deplete energy or natural resources? Proposed measures to protect or conserve energy and natural resources are: 4. How would the proposal be likely to use or affect environmentally sensitive areas or areas designated ( or eligible or under study) for governmental protection; such as parks, wilderness, wild and scenic rivers, threatened or endangered species habitat, historic or cultural sites, wetlands, flood plains, or prime farmlands? Proposed measures to protect such resources or to avoid or reduce impacts are: 5. How would the proposal be likely to affect land and shoreline use, including whether it would allow or encourage land or shoreline uses incompatible with existing plans? Proposed measures to avoid or reduce shoreline and land use impacts are: -12 - C:\Documents and Settings\alan\Desktop\My Letters\Barbee Mill, Cugini Lift\Env Cklst.doc 06/09 6. I-low would the proposal be likely lo mcrease demands on transportation or public services and utilities? Proposed measures to reduce or respond to such demand(s) are: 7. Identify, if possible, whether the proposal may conflict with local, state, or federal laws or requirements for the protection of the environment. SIGNATURE I, the undersigned, declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of Washington that to the best of my knowledge the above information is true, correct, and complete. It is understood that the lead agency may withdraw any declaration of non- significance that it might issue in reliance upon this checklist should there be any willful misrepresentation or willful lack of full disclosure on my part. Proponent Signature: ~ Name Printed: Date: -13 -06/09 C:\Documents and Settings\alan\Desktop\My Letters\Barbee Mill, Cugini lift\Env Cklst.doc Printed: 07-28-2010 Payment Made: CITY OF RENTON 1055 S. Grady Way Renton, WA 98055 Land Use Actions RECEIPT Permit#: LUA 10-050 07/28/2010 10:34 AM City of Renton Planning Division JUL ~ 8 LG1D Receipt Number: R1003359 Total Payment: 5,000.00 Payee: BARBEE MILL CO., INC. Current Payment Made to the Following Items: Trans Account Code 5010 007.345.81.00.007 5019 007.345.81.00.016 5024 007.345.81.00.024 Payments made for this receipt Description Environmental Review Shoreline Subst Dev Conditional Approval Fee Trans Method Description Amount Payment Check 20035 5,000.00 Account Balances Amount 1,000.00 2,000.00 2,000.00 Trans Account Code Description Balance Due 3021 5006 5007 5008 5009 5010 5011 5012 5013 5014 5015 5016 5017 5018 5019 5020 5021 5022 5024 5036 5909 5941 5954 5955 5998 303.000.00.345.85 000.345.81.00.0002 000.345.81.00.0003 007.345.81.00.004 007.345.81.00.006 007.345.81.00.007 007.345.81.00.008 007.345.81.00.009 007.345.81.00.010 007.345.81.00.011 007.345.81.00.012 007.345.81.00.013 007.345.81.00.014 007.345.81.00.015 007.345.81.00.016 007.345.81.00.017 007.345.81.00.018 007.345.81.00.019 007.345.81.00.024 007.345.81.00.005 007.341.60.00.024 007.341.50.00.000 650.237.00.00.0000 000.05.519.90.42.1 000.231.70.00.0000 Park Mitigation Fee Annexation Fees Appeals/Waivers Binding Site/Short Plat Conditional Use Fees Environmental Review Prelirn/Tentative Plat Final Plat PUD Grading & Filling Fees Lot Line Adjustment Mobile Home Parks Rezone Routine Vegetation Mgmt Shoreline Subst Dev Site Plan Approval Temp Use, Hobbyk, Fence Variance Fees Conditional Approval Fee Comprehensive Plan Amend Booklets/EIS/Copies Maps (Taxable) DO NOT USE -USE 3954 Postage Tax Remaining Balance Due: $0.00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 . 00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00