Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutERC Report and Exhibits_Joos Family Pier_16-000316DEPARTMENTOFCOMMUNITYANDECONOMICDEVELOPMENTCITYOF—‘Renton0ENVIRONMENTALREVIEWCOMMITTEEREPORTERCMEETINGDATE:June6,2016PARTONE:PROJECTBACKGROUNDProjectName:JoosFamilyPierProjectNumber:LUA16-000316,ECF,SM,MODProjectManager:JillDing,SeniorPlannerOwner:JoosFamilyLLC,4057WilliamsAvenueN,Renton,WA98056Applicant:PaulJoos,JoosFamilyLLC,4057WilliamsAvenueN,Renton,WA98056Contact:RebeccaHenderson,MarineRestoration&Construction,LLC,P0Box884,Kirkland,WA98083ProjectLocation:2909MountainViewAvenueN(ParcelNo.334210-3953)ProjectSummary:TheapplicantisrequestingaShorelineSubstantialDevelopmentPermitandEnvironmental(SEPA)Reviewfortheconstructionofa140-footlongpierfortheprivateuseofasinglefamilyresidentialpropertyowner.Themainwalkwaywillbeginwitha3’-ll”widthforthefirst30feet.Theremainderofthewalkwayistobe5’-ll”.Thepierwillhavea5’-ll”by23’-l”elianda1,-li”by23’-l”fingereli.Theproposedpieristobeconstructedwithgalvanizedsteelpiles,galvanizedsteelcaps,ACZAtreatedstringers,glulamsides,andThru-Flowplasticgratingtoallowforlightpenetration.Theproposedpierhastwo10”diametermooringpiles.Theapplicantproposestoinstallafreestandingboatliftandafreestanding8-footby10-footgratedplatformlift.Asmitigationforthisproject,theapplicantproposestocreateamorenaturalbeachandtoimplementaplantingplan.Theproposedshorelineworkentailsbankstabilizationbehindtheordinaryhighwaterline,theremovalofdebrisandaconcretebulkheadandsteps,theplacementof50cubicyardsof2”minusspawninggravel(1W’minusgravelmaybeusedif2”minusgravelisunavailable),andinstallationofnativeplantings.TheprojectsiteislocatedwithintheShorelineResidentialdesignationandiswithinLakeWashingtonReachE.ThesiteiszonedResidential-8(R-8).Exist.Bldg.AreaSF:3,520sfProposedNewBldg.Area:951sfSiteArea:45,349sfTotalBuildingAreaGSF:4,471sfSTAFFStaffRecommendsthattheEnvironmentalReviewCommitteeissueaRECOMMENDATION:DeterminationofNon-Significance-Mitigated(DNS-M).ProjectLocationMapERCReport_JoosFamilyPier_16-000316 CityofRentonDepartmentofCommunity&EconomicDevelopmentEnvironmentalReviewCommitteeReportJOOSFAMILYPIERLUA16-000316,ECF,SMReportofJune6,2016Page2of5PARTTWO:ENVIRONMENTALREVIEWIncompliancewithRCW43.21C.240,thefollowingenvironmental(SEPA)reviewaddressesonlythoseprojectimpactsthatarenotadequatelyaddressedunderexistingdevelopmentstandardsandenvironmentalregulations.A.EnvironmentalThresholdRecommendationBasedonanalysisofprobableimpactsfromtheproposal,staffrecommendsthattheResponsibleOfficials:IssueaDNS-Mwitha14-dayAppealPeriod.B.MitigationMeasures1.AfinalplantingshallbesubmittedatthetimeofbuildingpermitreviewthatshallincludenativetreesandshrubsthatwilloverhangtheshorelineforreviewandapprovalbytheCurrentPlanningProjectManager.Allplantingsshallbeinstalledandinspectedpriortobuildingpermitfinal.C.ExhibitsEnvironmentalReviewCommitteeReportBiologicalEvaluation/LakeandSurveys&Assessments,datedExistingSitePlanExistingSitePlan(largerscale)ProposedPlanViewProposedElevationViewProposedSectionDetail(for3’ProposedSectionDetail(for5’ConnectionDetailProposedBeachMitigationSectionA2:ShorelineSectionB2:ProposedBulkheadProposedPlantingMitigationPlanEmailCommentsfromKarenWalterdatedMay18,2016CommentResponsetoKarenWalterprovidedbyapplicant,datedMay24,2016AdvisoryNotestoApplicantD.EnvironmentalImpactsTheProposalwascirculatedandreviewedbyvariousCityDepartmentsandDivisionstodeterminewhethertheapplicanthasadequatelyidentifiedandaddressedenvironmentalimpactsanticipatedtooccurinconjunctionwiththeproposeddevelopment.Staffreviewershaveidentifiedthattheproposalislikelytohavethefollowingprobableimpacts:1.EarthImpacts:Theproposedprojectincludestheplacementof50cubicyardsof2-inchminuswashedroundspawninggravelalongtheshorelineoftheprojectsite(1Y2inchminusgravelmaybeStreamStudyReport,preparedbyMarineApril15th2016Exhibit1Exhibit2Exhibit3Exhibit4Exhibit5Exhibit6Exhibit7Exhibit8Exhibit9Exhibit10Exhibit11Exhibit12Exhibit13Exhibit14Exhibit15Exhibit1611”wideportionofpier)11”wideportionofpier)ERCReport_JoosFamilyPier_i6-000316 CityofRentonDepartmentofCommunity&EconomicDevelopmentEnvironmentalReviewCommitteeReportJOOSFAMILYPIERLUA16-000316,ECF,SMReportofJune6,2016Page3of5substitutedif2-inchminusgravelisunattainable).Forshorelinestabilization,6-inchto8-inchcrushedrockwith1Y4inchminusgravel,andtopsoilwouldbeinstalledabovetheordinaryhighwaterline(OHWL).Theuseofasiltcurtainisproposedtomitigateanyerosionthatmayoccurfromtheprojectconstructionandshorelineenhancementactivities.Nofurthermitigationisrecommendedatthistime.MitigationMeasure:Nonerecommended.Nexus:NotApplicable.2.Watera.Wetland,Streams,andLakesImpacts:ABiologicalEvaluation/LakeandStreamStudyReport,preparedbyMarineSurveys&Assessments,datedApril15th2016(Exhibit2)wassubmittedwiththeprojectapplication.TheprojectsiteabutsandiswithinLakeWashington,adesignatedshorelineofstatewidesignificance.TheprojectsiteislocatedwithintheShorelineResidentialdesignationandiswithinLakeWashingtonReachE.Theproposalincludestheconstructionofanewdockandboatliftandstabilizationoftheexistingbulkheadandtheremovalofthedilapidatedfaceoftheexistingbulkheadandtheremovalofdebristhathascollectedalongtheshoreline.Shorelinestabilization(including3-4manrock)isproposedtobeconstructedlandwardoftheexistingbulkheadandthentheexistingbulkheadwouldberemoved.Acovebeachareawouldbeconstructedinfrontofthereplacementshorelinestabilization.Theproposeddockwouldbecomposedofa3-foot11-inchby30-foot,then5-foot11-inchby110-footmaindockstructure.A5-foot11-inchby21-foot1-inchdocksectionwouldbeaddedatarightangletothemaindocksection.Anadditional1-foot11-inchby21-foot1-inchfingerdocksectionwouldalsobeaddedtothemaindocksectiontoprovideaboatslip.Twenty6-inchdiametergalvanizedsteelpilingswouldsupportthedockandtwo10-inchdiametergalvanizedsteelpilingswouldbeinstalledtofacilitatetheboatmoorage.Afreestandingboatliftwouldbelocatedadjacenttotheproposeddock60feetfromthereplacementbulkhead.Anadditionalfreestanding8-footby10-footgratedplatformliftwouldbelocatedadjacenttothesmallfingerdock.Thedockwouldhaveglulamsides,ACZAstringersandgalvanizedsteelcapsandgalvanizedsteelpilings.ThruFlowplasticgrating(43%openarea)wouldbeinstalledonthedock.Thepilingswouldbedrivenwithanimpacthammer,usingathickwoodenblockasasoundattenuationmeasure,thewoodblockwouldbeatleast6inchesthick.TheBiologicalEvaluation/StreamandLakeStudyReport(Exhibit2)concludesthattheproposedprojecthastakentheappropriatemeasurestoavoidandminimizepotentialimpactsandthatnonet-lossofecologicalfunctionwouldresultfromtheproject.Nofurthermitigationisrecommendedatthistime.MitigationMeasures:Nofurthermitigationrecommended.Nexus:Notapplicable.3.PlantsERCReport_JoosFamilyPier_i6-000316 CityofRentonDepartmentofCommunity&EconomicDevelopmentEnvironmentalReviewCommitteeReportJOOSFAMILYPIERLUA6-000316,ECF,SMReportofJune6,2016Page4of5Impacts:AShorelineMitigationPlantingPlan(Exhibit13)wassubmittedwiththeapplicationmaterials.Theplantingplanincludestheinstallationofthefollowingplants:serviceberry,bloodtwigdogwood,Oregongrape,dwarfoakleafhydrangea,subalpinespirea,stonecrop,red-floweringcurrant,birchorAspentrees,smallfruitedbulrushdaggerleafbulrush,iris,lawnandlargeareasofkinnickinnick.Duringthe14-daypubliccommentperiod,staffreceivedthefollowingcommentsfromtheMuckleshootIndianTribe“Theplantingplanshouldberevisedtoincludenativetreesandshrubsthatwilloverhangshoreline.Mostoftheplantsshownadjacenttotheshorelinearetooshort(i.e.kinnickinnick)and/orarenon-native(i.e.WhiteBarkHimalayanbirch(Betulajacquemonti).Arobustplantingplanisneededtopartiallymitigatefortheoverwaterandinwatercoveragefromthenew“972.80squarefootpierandboatliftsindepthslessthan15feetofLakeWashington”(Exhibit14).Thesecommentswereprovidedtotheapplicant;howevertheapplicantelectedtonotrevisetheirplantingplan(Exhibit15).ToaddressthecommentsreceivedfromtheMuckleshootTribeandtoensurethatanyadverseimpactstojuvenilefishspeciesareadequatelymitigation,staffrecommends,asaSEPAmitigationmeasure,thatafinalplantingplanbesubmittedatthetimeofbuildingpermitreview.Thefinalplantingplanshallincludenativetreesandshrubsthatwilloverhangtheshoreline.ThefinalplantingplanshallbesubmittedtotheCurrentPlanningProjectManagerforReviewandapproval.Allplantingsshallbeinstalledpriortofinalbuildinginspection.MitigationMeasures:AfinalplantingshallbesubmittedatthetimeofbuildingpermitreviewthatshallincludenativetreesandshrubsthatwilloverhangtheshorelineforreviewandapprovalbytheCurrentPlanningProjectManager.Allplantingsshallbeinstalledandinspectedpriortobuildingpermitfinal.Nexus:SEPAEnvironmentalRegulationsandRMC4-3-090ShorelineMasterProgram.4.AnimalsImpacts:Wildlifeandcriticalhabitatarelocatednearandaroundthesubjectsiteincludingfishthatareconsideredendangeredspecies.ThesubmittedBiologicalEvaluation/StreamandLakeStudyevaluatethehabitat,species,andpotentialimpactsfromtheproposeddockandshorelinerestorationactivities(Exhibit2).ThestudyprovidesdetailedinformationaboutPugetSoundChinook,BullTrout,PugetSoundSteelhead,andMarbledMurreletmarinebirds.Thestudystatesthatitisunlikelythatmurreletswouldbepresentintheprojectvicinity.Thepotentialdirectimpactscausedbytheconstructionevaluatedtheincreasednoiseandturbidityfrompiledriving.Thepotentialindirecteffectsevaluatedincludedthealterationofjuvenilesalmonmigratorypathwaysforfreshwaterandmarinewaters,anincreaseinsalmonidpredationandreductioninpreyresourcesandrefugeduetoshadingofthesubstratebythepierandboatlifts.Thereportconcludesthatitislikelythat“notake”wouldresultfromtheprojectproposal.TheBiologicalEvaluation/StreamandLakeStudy(Exhibit2)speciesevaluationstatesthatthePugetSoundChinook,BullTrout,andPugetSoundSteelheadtheprojectwouldresultinadeterminationof“Mayaffect,notlikelytoadverselyaffect”andtheMarbledMurreletadeterminationof“Noeffect”wasmade.Thestudyfurtherevaluatedthepiledrivingnoiseandturbidityofinstallingthepilesonthefishandstatesthatin-waterconstructionshouldbelimitedtobetweenJuly16andDecember31,WDFW’sapprovedconstructionwindow.Theproposeddockconstructionsequencingandmitigationproposedbytheapplicantwouldincludetheinstallationofasiltcurtain.ThesiltcurtainshouldminimizeimpactstofishspeciesasaERCReport_JoosFamilyPier_i6-000316 CityofRentonDepartmentofCommunity&EconomicDevelopmentEnvironmentalReviewCommitteeReportJOOSFAMILYPIERLUA16-000316,ECF,SMReportofJune6,2016Page5of5resultofconstructionactivitiesassociatedwiththeproposedproject.Staffrecommendsamitigationmeasurethatifatanytime,asresultofprojectactivities,fishareobservedindistress,afishkilloccurs,orwaterqualityproblemsdevelop(includingequipmentleaksorspills),operationsshallimmediatelyceaseandtheWashingtonDepartmentofFishandWildlife(WDFW)andtheWashingtonDepartmentofEcologyshallbecontactedimmediately.WorkshallnotresumeuntilfurtherapprovalisgivenbytheWDFW.Inaddition,aspreviouslydiscussedaboveunder“Plants”,theproposedplantingplanasrequitedtobeamendedwouldbenefitfishandotherspeciesbyassistinginrestorationoftheecologicalfunctionofLakeWashington.MitigationMeasures:ProjectconstructionshallcomplywiththerecommendationsprovidedintheBiologicalEvaluation/LakeandStreamStudyReport,preparedbyMarineSurveys&Assessments,datedApril15th2016.Nexus:SEPAEnvironmentalRegulationsandRMC4-3-090ShorelineMasterProgram.E.CommentsofReviewingDepartmentsTheproposalhasbeencirculatedtoCityDepartmentandDivisionReviewers.Whereapplicable,theircommentshavebeenincorporatedintothetextofthisreportand/or“AdvisoryNotestoApplicant.”VCopiesofallReviewCommentsarecontainedintheOfficialFileandmaybeattachedtothisreport.TheEnvironmentalDeterminationdecisionwillbecomefinalifthedecisionisnotappealedwithinthe14-dayappealperiod(RCW43.21.C.075(3);WAC197-11-680).EnvironmentalDeterminationAppealProcess:Appealsoftheenvironmentaldeterminationmustbefiledinwritingtogetherwiththerequiredfeeto:HearingExaminer,CityofRenton,1055SouthGradyWay,Renton,WA98057,onorbefore5:00p.m.onJune24,2016.RMC4-2-110governsappealstotheHearingExaminerandadditionalinformationregardingtheappealprocessmaybeobtainedfromtheCityClerk’sOffice,RentonCityHall—7thFloor,(425)430-6510.ERCReport_JoosFamilyPier_16-000316 t(JoosNewDockandBeachMitigationPlanBiologicalEvaluationlLakeandStreamStudyReportApril15th,2016For:PaulJoos2909MountainViewAvenueNorthRenton,WA98056\49frMARINESURVEYS&ASSESSMENTSr.267HudsonStreetPortTownsendWA98368(360)385-4073marlne.surveys.inc@mait.comFULLDOCUMENTAVAILABLEUPONREQUESTEXHIBIT2 NOTE: Properly information for this site was obtained from a survey and a quarter section.Marine Restoration &Construction LLC has added information from other sources including field measurements and aerial photos.We are not surveyors and can not guarantee great level of accuracy. 4 GRA PH/C SCALE 1”=7Q PARCEL 3342103940 3001 MOUNTAIN VIEW AVE N CONNER,CHARLES MARINE RESTORATION MAIL:P.O.BOX 884,Kirkland,WA 98083 0884 CONSTRUCTION LL (425)576—8661 THIS DRAV,INC IS PROPERTY OF MARINE RESTORA11ON &CONSTRUCTION CLC ANDE—MAIL:INFO©MARINELLC.COM MAY NOT BE COPIED OR REPRODUCED WTHOUT %ITtEN CONSENT I PARCEL 3342103953 2909 MOUNTAIN VIEW AVE N JOOS FAMILY LLC mx I-I I-I U PARCEL 3342103985 2905 MOUNTAIN VIEW AVE N IREIMERS,MILTON &BEVERLY 70’0 35, ——— 70’ \ \ EXISTING SITE PLAN SCALE:1’70’ PAGE 2 of 12 z-J0LUFU)zF-U)><LUc.’JCLU00&72o72O482LU-J0U)1F0I000-IIIEXHIBIT4 Project Description: Construct a dock with glulam sides, ACZA stringers,and galvanized steel caps and 6’diameter piling (20).Drive two 10”diameter mooring piling.Install a freestanding boatlift and a freestanding grated platform lift.Asij mitigation,the applicant proposes to create a more natural beach and to implement a planting plan. Proposed dock sqaure footage:951 NOTE:27’-O’(+/-) LIFT LOCATIONS DEPICTED ARE THE OPTIMUM LOCATIONS.THE LIFTS MAY BE A MAXIMUM OF 5’ (+1-)FROM THIS LOCATION DUE TO SITE CONDITIONS. . 54’-6”(-) 27’-O”- —18-0’ MOORING SOLAR POWER D LED LIGHTS ——, 1—11 ——J—— 50—0” PROPOSED FREESTA JDINC 23’—l” —/LIFT LOCAON. BOATLIFT 5’—ll”J LOCATION 110—0’(+/—)- ‘‘ 140-0’ /, ,,,—BRASS SEWER TAGS TO BE PLACED ON BOTH SIDES‘c%—‘OF THE PIER WHERE THE“SEWER LINE IS LOCATED.—lol.-p,7 --Ia I ——-.-C, (60’-O”(+/-)-1 -——[,SANITARY SEWER LINE — TO BE LOCATED BY A r’ . —NOTE: 20 Property information for this site was obtained from a survey b and a quarter section Marine Restoration &Construction LLC 3,has added information from other sources including fieldO measurements and aerial photos.We are not surveyors and can ,,/0/- .not guarantee great level of accuracy. “1Z OHWLGRAPH/C SCALE ,‘EXISTING WATER --. ‘PUMP O REMAIN.ri ii .11 Ii I40’0 20’40’ m _____ x I-I I-’-J PROPOSED PLAN VIEW =‘“SCALE:1=40’ I PAGE4ofI2 MARINE RESTORATION &CONSTRUCTION LLC -MAIL:P.O.BOX 884,Kirkland,WA 98083 —0884 PHONE:(425)576—8661 THIS DRAAINC IS PROPERTY OF MARINE RESTORATiON &CONSTRUCTiON LLC ANDE—MAIL:INFO@MARINELLC.COM MAY NOT BE COPIED OR REPRODUCED ThOUT WRITTEN CONSENT I,,x I-I I-Iall NOTE:-_____________ LIFT LOCATIONS DEPICTED ARE THE OPTIMUM LOCATIONS.THE LIFTS MAY BE A MAXIMUM OF 5’ L-FROM THIS LOCATION DUE TO SITE CONDITIONS. PAGE 5 of 12. MARINE RESTORATION &CONSTRUCTION LLC -MAIL:P.O.BOX 884,Kirkland,WA 98083 —0884 PHONE:(425)576—8661 ,THIS DRAY,INC IS PROPERTY OF MARINE RESTORAI1ON &CONSTRUC17ON LLC ANDE—MAIL:INFO@MARINELLC.COM MAY NOT BE COPIED OR REPRODUCED PTHOUT WRITtEN CONSENT Project Description: Construct a dock with glulam sides, ACZA stringers,and galvanized steel caps and 6”diameter piling (20).Drive two 10’diameter mooring piling.Install a freestanding boatlift and a freestanding grated platform lift.As mitigation,the applicant proposes to create a more natural beach and to implement a planting plan. Proposed dock sqaure footage:951 2—0” OHWL 140’—O” I -‘ 4-6” ,—PROPOSED FREESTANDING BOATLIFT/IN 4—6”WATER DEPTH AT THE LANDWARD MOST SIDE. 11O’—o”(+/—) 9,-7”(+/) \PROPOSED FREESTANDING 8’XlO’ GRATED PLATFORM LIFT IN 7—1”(+/—)WATER DEPTH AT THE LANDWARD MOST SIDE. PROPOSED ELEVATION VIEW SCALE:1”=20’ PROPOSEDTOPVIEWSCALE:1/2’1-0”5J”X12”GLU—LAMBEAMATTACHEDTOEACHSADDLEUSING34”THRUBOLTSLOWVOLTAGELIGHTS(20)“THRUBOLTSON3’CENTERS(TYP)SEECONNECTIONDETAILONPAGE9.PLASTICTHRU—FLOWCRATINC2X3STEELANGLEBRACKETNAILERS3x6x16GALVANIZEDSTEELSADDLE“THICK(TYP)2X3STEELANGLEBRACKET5i’X12’CLU—LAMBEAMATTACHEDTOEACHSADDLEUSING3/4”THRUBOLTS3x6x16GALVANIZEDSTEELSADDLETHICK(TYP)VANIZEDSTEELPLATESCALE:1/2”=1-0”PAGE6of12MARINERESTORATION&CONSP.O.BOX884Kirkland,WA98083—0884PHONE:(425)576—8661EFAX:(425)576—8669EXHIBIT718”O.C.PLASTICTHRU—FLOWCRATING2’—6”1—6”GALVANIZEDSTEEL“I’BEAMNEWGALVANIZEDSTEELPILES(TYP)PROPOSEDSECTIONDETAIL PROPOSEDTOPVIEWSCALE:1/2’=1-0”5,l”X12”GLU—LAMBEAMATTACHEDTOEACHSADDLEUSING%“THRUBOLTSLOWVOLTAGELIGHTS(20)PLASTICTHRU—FLOWGRAllNG2X3STEELANGLEBRACKET2X4NAILERS15’O.C.SEECONNECTIONDETAILONPAGE9.PLASTICGRATING2X3STEELANGLEBRACKET5,1”XJ2”GLU—LAMBEAMATTACHEDTOEACHSADDLEUSING3/4”THRUBOLTSW6X15GALVANIZEDSTEEL“I”BEAM“GALVANIZEDSTEELPLATENEWGALVANIZEDSTEELPILES(TYP)PROPOSEDSECTIONDETAILSCALE:1/2”1-0”MARINERESTORATION&COPAGE7of123’THRUBOLTSONCENTERS(TYP)3x6x16GALVANIZEDSTEELSADDLE“THICK(TYP)5,—il”2’—6”THRU—FLOW3x6x16GALVANIZEDSTEELSADDLE“THICK(TYP)OHWLP.O.BOX884Kirkland,WA98083—0884PHONE:(425)(425)576—8661576—8669EXHIBIT$FAX: mx I-I 03I-I -I 5)X12 GLULAM BEAM (24F—v8) 6 3X6X16X)CALV STEEL SADDLE CALV.STEEL PILE 3X6X16 GALVANIZED STEEL SADDLE 1/2”THICK (TYP.) STEEL NOT TO SCALE CONNECTION DETAIL PAGE 8 of 12 MARINE RESTORATION MAIL:P.O.BOX 884,Kirkland,WA 98083 —0884 &CONSTRUCTION LLC (425)576—8661 E—MAIL:INFO@MARINELLC.COM PHONE: 3”MARINE 55 SCREW LASTIC THRU—FLOW CENTERS—TYP. 0 CONNECTION DETAIL 5,Y”X12” GLU—LAM )GALV.STEEL AT EACH BOLT CONNECTION N.T.S. 3’THRU-FLOW GRATED PANEL 12X60X1.2 THRU—FLOW PANEL FASTENED AT 10 PLACES EA. N.T.S.5’THRU-FLOW GRATED PANEL N.T.S. THIS DRAWiNG IS PROPERTY OF MARINE RESTORATION &CONSTRUCTiON LLC AND MAY NOT BE COPIED OR REPRODUCED WIThOUT WRITrEN CONSENT I IMITIGATION:BEACH ENHANCEMENT SEQUENCE: -MOBILIZE TO THE SITE. -ERECT SILT CURTIAN. -CONSTRUCT BANK STABILIZATIONBEHIND THE BU LKH EAD AND THE ORDINARY HIGH WATER MARK. -REMOVE THE EXISTING BULKHEAD AND DEBRIS.r—50 CUBIC YARDS OF 2”MINUS SPAWNING GRAVEL ‘- -PLACE ROCKS,PLANTS,AND AND SPAWNING GRAVEL AS (i”SPAWING GRAVEL MAY SUBSTITUTED IF 2”‘ WORK WINDOWS AND PLANT SURVIVAL DICTATES.MINUS IS NOT OBTAINABLE.) .‘. —‘S __________ S ,53 ,6 / ).. ROCK STEPS OHWL “1 /‘..-___J -..FLAT WASHED GRANITE EXISTING PUMP TO REMAIN ‘.Srn-,,‘NOTE: I-I GRAPH/C SCALE 70’0 5’10’ —I I PROPOSED BEACH =10’MITIGATION SCALE:1=10’ PAGE 9 of 12 MARINE RESTORATION &CONSTRUCTION LLC MAIL:P.O.BOX 884,Kirkland,WA 98083 —0884 PHONE:(425)576—8661 THIS DRAY,ING IS PROPERTY OF MARINE RESTORAI1ON &CONSTRUCTiON LLC ANDE—MAIL:INFO©MARINELLC.COM MAY NOT BE COPIED OR REPRODUCED WITHOUT WRIflEN CONSENT Property information for this site was obtained from a survey and a quarter section.Marine Restoration &Construction LLC has added information from other sources including field measurements and aerial photos.We are not surveyors and can not guarantee great level of accuracy. MITIGATION:BEACH ENHANCEMENT SEQUENCE: -MOBILIZE TO THE SITE. -ERECT SILT CURTIAN. -CONSTRUCT BANK STABILIZATIONBEHIND THE BULKHEAD AND . THE ORDINARY HIGH WATER MARK. -REMOVE THE EXISTING BULKHEAD AND DEBRIS. WORK WINDO WS AND PLANT SURVR/AL DICTATES CONC E TE STE PS SECTION Al:EXISTING SHORELINE SCALE:NTS FLAT WASHED SOUND CANITE SOCK STEPS ø OUIC YARDS OF 2”MINUS SEE PAGE II FO PAUJNING CRAvEL (111 MINUS MAY PLANTING DETAILS BE SUBSTITUTED IF 2”MINUS IS NOT MAXIMUM SLOFE IS l/4 x 4TTAINALE).-1’MINU \EOTEX]HLE ROCK SECTIONA2 SHORELINE .:.:.SCALE:NTS PAGE 10 of 12 MARINE RESTORATION &CONSTRUCTION LLC MAIL:P.O.BOX 884,Kirkland,WA 9808.3 —0884 PHONE:(425)576—8661 THIS DRARJNG IS PROPERTh OF MARINE RESTORATiON &CONSTRUCTiON LLC ANDE—MAIL:INFO@MARINELLC.COM MAY NOT BE COPIED OR REPRODUCED BThOUT BRITTEN CONSENT EMERGENT PLANTS.SEE PLANTING PLAN ON PAGE FO MORE DETAILS.— TOP SOIL MITIGATION:BEACH ENHANCEMENT SEQUENCE:EXIST IN -MOBILIZE TO THE SITE. -ERECT SILT CURTIAN. -CONSTRUCT BANK STABIUZATIONBEHIND THE BULKHEAD AND THE ORDINARY HIGH WATER MARK. -REMOVE THE EXISTING BULKHEAD AND DEBRIS. -PLACE ROCKS,PLANTS,AND AND SPAWNIGN GRAVEL AS WORK WINDOWS AND PLANT SURVIVAL DICTATES. Ezzzzzzz m x I-I I-I—I I-I SECTION SI:EXISJYNG BULKHEAD SCALE:NTS —LOOSE ROCK DEBRIS AND CONCRETE QT flM O DnDQn 5ULKHEAD TO E REMOVED AFTER I I’’SHORELINE STABILIZATION HAS SEEN ________ COMPLETED BEHIND THE OHWLBULKHEAD SCALE:NIS MARINE RESTORATION &CONSTRUCTION LLC MAIL:P.O.BOX 884,Kirkland,WA 98083 —0884 PHONE:(425)576—8661 THIS DRAWING IS PROPERTY OF MARINE RESTORATION &CONSTRUCTION LLC ANDE—MAIL:INFO©MARINELLC.COM MAY NOT BE COPIED OR REPRODUCED WITHOUT WRITTEN CONSENT CONCRETE BULKHEAD LOOSE ROCK / AND DEBRIS./ERODED SOIL MAXIMUM SLOPE IS 1/4 Sø CU5IC YARDS OF 21 MINUS SPAWN IN 2 SUSTI ATTA INALE) MINUS MAY 2-4 MAN WASI-IED ROUND GRANITE ROCKS,SEE ‘EACH MATERIAL SPECS. SEE PAGE IT FOR PLANTING DET4ILE TOP SOIL _1I1 MINUS •RAVEL •:CEOTEXT1LE \.• Il 311 CRUSHED PAGE 11 of 12 MARINE RESTORATION &CONSTRUCTION LLC PHONE:(425)576—866 THIS DRAWING IS PROPERTY OF MARINE RESTORATiON &CONSTRUCTiON LLC ANDE—MAIL:INFO@MARINELLC.COM MAY NOT BE COPIED OR REPROOUCED WITHOUT WRITTEN CONSENT LEGEND: PLANTS. TYPE: 1,AMELANCHIER ALNIFOLIA SERVICEBERRY QTY: 2.BETULA JACQUEMONTI BIRCH 5-6’ 3.ARCTOSTAPHYLO UVA-URSI KINNIKINNICK 3 PLANTS: TYPE: 8.RIBES SANQUINEUM RED FLOWERING CURRENT SIZE:SYMBOL: 0 1.5 CALIPER 4.CORNUS SANGUINEA BLOODTWIG DOGWOOD 183 UTY: #1@2’OC SIZE: #5 9.SCRIPUS MICROCARPUS SMALL FRUITED BULLRUSH 5.MAHONIA NERVOSA OREGON GRAPE 10 12 #5 10.JUNCTUS ENSIFOLIUS DAGGERLEAF RUSH #1 30 NOTE: Property information for this site was obtained from a survey and a quarter section.Marine Restoration &Construction LLC has added information from other sources including field measurements and aerial photos.We are not surveyors and can not guarantee great level ofaccuracy. SYMBOL: 6.HYDRANGEA QUERCIFOLIA DWARF OAKLEAF HYDRANGEA 11.IRIS TENAX #1@2’OC IRIS #1 7.SPIREA DENSIFOLIA SUBALPINE SPIRAEA 16 #5 12.SEDUM SPALHIFOLUM STONECROP (MIXED) #1 * #2 4”FLATS IIIII4”FLATS 13.SEDUM OREGANUM STONECROP (MIXED)- OTHER MITIGATION:‘: THE APPLICANT PROPOSES TO CREATE A MORE NATURAL BEACH AND TO •‘,2 ‘-•. PLACE 50 CUBIC YARDS OF 2’MINUS SPAWNING GRAVEL (1”MAY BE ‘:‘,- : SUBSTIUTED IF 2’MINUS IS NOT AVAILABLE).,‘•“2 .. f EXISTING PUMP TO REMAIN x I-I I-I -I I U STONE PATHWAY PROPOSED PLANTING GRAPH/C SCALE MITIGATION PLAN MAIL:P.O.BOX 884,Kirkland,WA 98083 —0884 SCALE:1”=15’ 0 7.5’15’ 7”=15’ PAGE 12 of 12 JillDingFrom:KarenWalter<KWalter@muckleshoot.nsn.us>Sent:Wednesday,May18,20162:23PMTo:JillDingCc:Heller,ChristaH(DFW)Subject:RE:CityofRenton(SEPA)NoticeofApplication-JoosFamilyPier-LUA16-000316,ECF,MOD,SMJill,ThankyouagainforsendingustherequestedprojectmaterialsfortheproposedJoosFamilyLLCprojectat2909MountainViewAveNinRenton.WehavereviewedthisinformationandofferthefollowinginitialquestionandcommentsintheinterestofprotectingandrestoringtheTribe’streaty-protectedfisheriesresources:1.MoreinformationisneededregardingtheproposedLEDlightsonthepier(Page4ofdrawings).Artificiallightscanadverselyaffectsalmonbycreatingconditionsthatfacilitatepredation(seeattached).Thedetailsneededareasfollows:a.Theneedforthelightsatthepier;b.Thetotalnumberandlocationoflightsproposed;c.Thestyleandwattageoflights;d.Thewavelength/spectrumoflightbulbstobeusedFromthisinformation,wewillevaluatethepotentialimpactsfromtheproposalandwillmakeanyrecommendationsnecessarytoavoid/minimizelightingimpacts.2.Theplantingplanshouldberevisedtoincludenativetreesandshrubsthatwilloverhangshoreline.Mostoftheplantsshownadjacenttotheshorelinearetooshort(i.e.kinnikinnick)and/orarenon-native(i.e.WhiteBarkHimalayanbirch(Betulajacquemonti).Arobustplantingplanisneededtopartiallymitigatefortheoverwaterandinwatercoveragefromthenew—972.80squarefootpierandboatliltsindepthslessthan15feetofLakeWashington.3.Werequestacopyofthe“as-built”plansfortheproject,includingalloftheproposedmitigationandallofthesubsequentmonitoringreportscompletedforthisprojectwhentheyaresenttotheregulatoryagencies.Weappreciatetheopportunitytoreviewthisproposalandlookforwardtotheresponsesandadditionalformationsothatwemayfullyevaluatethisproject.Pleaseletmeknowifyouhaveanyquestions.Thankyou,KarenWalterWatershedsandLandUseTeamLeaderMuckleshootIndianTribeFisheriesDivisionHabitatProgram39075772ndAveSEAuburn,WA98092253-876-3776OriginalMessageFrom:JillDing[mai1to:JDingRentonwa.gov]Sent:Monday,May09,20166:23AMTo:KarenWalterSubject:RE:CityofRenton(SEPA)NoticeofApplication-JoosFamilyPier-LUA16-000316,ECF,MOD,SMHiKaren,EXHIBIT141 Seetheattacheddocumentsyourequested.PleasenotethattheBiologicalEvaluationandStreamandLakeStudyisonereport.JillOriginalMessageFrom:KarenWalter[mailto:KWalter@muckleshoot.nsn.us]Sent:Thursday,May05,20166:36PMTo:JillDingSubject:FW:CityofRenton(SEPA)NoticeofApplication-JoosFamilyPier-LUA16-000316,ECF,MOD,SMJill,WereceivedthisNOA/ODNSearliertoday.Wewillneedmoreinformationtofullyevaluatethisprojectforpotentialimpactstosalmon.Pleasesendusacopyofthesiteandmitigationplans;thestreamstudy;andbiologicalassessment.Accordingtothechecklist,thesedocumentsweresubmittedwiththeapplication.Thankyou,KarenWalterWatershedsandLandUseTeamLeaderMuckleshootIndianTribeFisheriesDivisionHabitatProgram39015172ndAveSEAuburn,WA98092253-876-3116From:SabrinaMirante[SMiranteRentonwa.govjSent:Thursday,May05,20163:39PMTo:DOE(misty.blair@ecy.wa.gov);DOE;DNR;ErinSlaten;KarenWalter;LauraMurphyCc:JillDingSubject:CityofRenton(SEPA)NoticeofApplication-JoosFamilyPier-LUA16-000316,ECF,MOD,SMNOTICEOFAPPLICATIONANDPROPOSEDDETERMINATIONOFNon-significance(dns)AMasterApplicationhasbeenfiledandacceptedwiththeDepartmentofCommunity&EconomicDevelopment(CED)-PlanningDivisionoftheCityofRenton.ThefollowingbrieflydescribestheapplicationandthenecessaryPublicApprovals.DATEOFNOTICEOFAPPLICATION:May5,2016LANDUSENUMBER:LUA16-000316,ECF,MOD,SMPROJECTNAME:JoosFamilyLLCPierPROJECTDESCRIPTION:TheapplicantisrequestingaShorelineSubstantialDevelopmentPermitandEnvironmental(SEPA)Reviewfortheconstructionofa140-footlongpierfortheprivateuseofasinglefamilyresidentialpropertyowner.Themainwalkwaywillbeginwitha3’-ll”widthforthefirst30feet.Theremainderofthewalkwayistobe5’-ll”.Thepierwillhavea5’-il”by23’-l”eliandal’-li”by23’-l”fingereli.Theproposedpieristobeconstructedwithgalvanizedsteelpiles,galvanizedsteelcaps,ACZAtreatedstringers,glulamsides,andThru-Flowplasticgratingtoallowforlightpenetration.Theproposedpierhastwo10diametermooringpiles.Theapplicantproposestoinstallafreestandingboatliftandafreestanding8-footby10-footgratedplatformlift.Asmitigationforthisproject,theapplicantproposestocreateamorenaturalbeachandtoimplementaplantingplan.Theproposedshorelineworkentailsbankstabilizationbehindthe2 ordinaryhighwaterline,theremovalofdebrisandaconcretebulkheadandsteps,theplacementof50cubicyardsof2”minusspawninggravel(1X”minusgravelmaybeusedif2”minusgravelisunavailable),andinstallationofnativeplantings.TheprojectsiteislocatedwithintheShorelineResidentialdesignationandiswithinLakeWashingtonReachE.ThesiteiszonedResidential-8(R-8).PROJECTLOCATION:2909MountainViewAveN,Renton,WA98056OPTIONALDETERMINATIONOFNON-SIGNIFICANCE(DNS):AstheLeadAgency,theCityofRentonhasdeterminedthatsignificantenvironmentalimpactsareunlikelytoresultfromtheproposedproject.Therefore,aspermittedundertheRCW43.21C.110,theCityofRentonisusingtheOptionalDNSprocesstogivenoticethataDNSislikelytobeissued.CommentperiodsfortheprojectandtheproposedDNSareintegratedintoasinglecommentperiod.TherewillbenocommentperiodfollowingtheissuanceoftheThresholdDeterminationofNon-Significance(DNS).Thismaybetheonlyopportunitytocommentontheenvironmentalimpactsoftheproposal.A14-dayappealperiodwillfollowtheissuanceoftheDNS.PERMITAPPLICATIONDATE:April25,2016NOTICEOFCOMPLETEAPPLICATION:May5,2016APPLICANT/PROJECTCONTACTPERSON:RebeccaHenderson,MarineRestoration&Construction,LLC/P0Box884/Kirkland,WA98083/425-576-8661/info@marinellc.comPermits/ReviewRequested:Environmental(SEPA)Review,Modification,ShorelineSubstantialDevelopmentOtherPermitswhichmayberequired:BuildingPermitRequestedStudies:CriticalAreasReport,HabitatReport,Stream/LakeStudyLocationwhereapplicationmay3 bereviewed:DepartmentofCommunity&EconomicDevelopment(CED)-PlanningDivision,SixthFloorRentonCityHall,1055SouthGradyWay,Renton,WA98057CONSISTENCYOVERVIEW:Zoning/LandUse:ThesubjectsiteisdesignatedCOMP-RMDontheCityofRentonComprehensiveLandUseMapandR-8ontheCity’sZoningMap.EnvironmentalDocumentsthatEvaluatetheProposedProject:Environmental(SEPA)ChecklistDevelopmentRegulationsUsedForProjectMitigation:TheprojectwillbesubjecttotheCity’sSEPAordinance,RMC4-2-11OAResidentialDevelopmentStandards,RMC4-3-090ShorelineMasterProgramandotherapplicablecodesandregulationsasappropriate.CommentsontheaboveapplicationmustbesubmittedinwritingtoJillDing,SeniorPlanner,CED-PlanningDivision,1055SouthGradyWay,Renton,WA98057,by5:00PMonMay19,2016.Ifyouhavequestionsaboutthisproposal,orwishtobemadeapartyofrecordandreceiveadditionalnotificationbymail,contacttheProjectManager.Anyonewhosubmitswrittencommentswillautomaticallybecomeapartyofrecordandwillbenotifiedofanydecisiononthisproject.Acopyofthesubsequentthresholddeterminationisavailableuponrequest.CONTACTPERSON:JillDing,SeniorPlanner;Tel:(425)430-6598;Eml:jdingrentonwa.govSabrinaMirante,PlanningSecretaryCityofRentonICEDIPlanningDivision1055SGradyWayI6thFloorIRenton,WA98057Phone:425.430.6572IFax:425.430.7300Ismiranterentonwa.gov<mailto:smiranterentonwa.gov>[cid:imageOOl.png01D1A6E4.60320460]4 MARINERESTORATION&CONSTRUCTIONLLCP.O.Box884Kirkland,WA98083-0884Phone:(425)576-8661May24,2016To:KarenWalter,WatershedandLandUseLeaderMuckleshootIndianTribeFisheriesDivision,HabitatProgram39015172ndAveSEAuburn,WA98092Applicant:JoosFamilyLLC4057WilliamsAvenueNorthRenton,WA98056Siteaddress:2909MountainViewAvenueNorthRenton,WA98056Re:Pierconstructionapplication.ProjectNumber:LUAJ6-000316DearMs.Walter,MarineRestoration&ConstructionLLCareactingasagentsfortheJoosFamilyLLCforpermittingpurposesonly.ThisletterisinresponsetocommentswereceivedinanemaildatedMay18,2016.Wewilladdressthecommentsintheorderthatwereceivedthem.(tJMoreinformationisneededregardingtheproposedLEDlightsonthepier(Page4ofdrawings).Artificiallightscanadverselyaffectsalmonbycreatingconditionsthatfacilitatepredation(seeattached).Thedetailsneededareasfollows:a.Theneedforthelightsatthepier;b.Thetotalnumberandlocationoflightsproposed;c.Thestyleandwattageoflights;U.Thewavelength/spectrumoflightbulbstobeusedFromthisinformation,wewillevaluatethepotentialimpactsfromtheproposalandwillmakeanyrecommendationsnecessarytoavoid/minimizelightingimpacts.”Theapplicantisproposingtoplacetwosmallsolarpoweredlightsattheendofthepiertoaidinpiervisibilitytoavoidhazardsinnavigationandpromotethegeneralsafetyofboaters.ThepierextendsonehundredandfortyfeetoverLakeWashington.Thesmallsolarpoweredlightswillemitenoughlightsothatthedockwillbevisibletoboatersatnightbutwillbebeamedupwardssoasnottoilluminatethelake.Wehaveattachedacopyofanexampleofthetypeoflightthatisproposedforthedock.EXHIBIT15 Pathwaylights,suchastheexampleattachedwiththisletter,directlightupwardawayfromthelake.SmallsolarLEDlightssuchasthisareverylowwattageandassuchproducealowamountoflumens.Thisparticularlightproducesapproximatelysevenlumensasperthemanufacturer.“2.Theplantingplanshouldberevisedtoincludenativetreesandshrubsthatwilloverhangshoreline.Mostoftheplantsshownadjacenttotheshorelinearetooshort(i.e.kinnikinnick)and/orarenon-native(i.e.WhiteBarkHimalayanbirch(Betulajacquemonti).Arobustplantingplanisneededtopartiallymitigatefortheoverwaterandinwatercoveragefromthenew—972.80squarefootpierandboatliftsindepthslessthan15feetofLakeWashington”TheBiologicalEvaluationperformedMarineSurveysandAssessmentsIncstatesthefollowingregardingtheproposedprojectonpagefourteen:“Allmeasureshavebeentakentoavoidandntinimizepotentialimpactsresultingfronttheproposedprojectthroughconservationmeasuresabove.InconsiderationoftheunlikelyintpacttoESAspeciesasweltastheproposedshorelinemitigationplantingsuggestedbelowtoenhancethehabitat,wedeterminethatnonet-tossofecologicalfunctionwillresultfrontthisproject’sunavoidableimpactsduetoits’waterdependentuse.”TheArmyCorpsofEngineersplantinglists(boththelistfortheAbbreviatedBiologicalEvaluationforWatercraftLiftsinLakeWashingtonandLakeSammamishandtheplantlistfortheRegionalGeneralPermit3)containthebroad“Birchspecies”nomenclature.Asweunderstandit,thisgeneralizationofthetermallowstheuseofvariousspeciesofbirchtrees.Theapplicanthasalreadyspentmorethanhehadbudgetedforonprofessionallandscapedesignersandabiologistfirmtocreatethisplantingmitigationplan.Theapplicantproposes,asdoesthebiologist,thattheproposedplantingplan,removalofinvasiveplantspecies,theremovalofdebris,theshorelineenhancement,andtheinstallationoffiftycubicyardsofspawninggravelshouldbegoodmitigationfortheproject.“3.Werequestacopyofthe“as-built”plansfortheproject,includingalloftheproposedmitigationandallofthesubsequentmonitoringreportscompletedforthisprojectwhentheyaresenttotheregulatoryagencies.”Wewillgladlysubmitacopyofany“as-built”drawingsandmonitoringreportswhentheyaresenttoregulatoryagencies.Ifyouhaveanyquestionsorcommentsontheproposedworkpleasecallusat425-576-8661oremailusatinfo@marinellc.com.Respectftilly,TylerSomersDrafierMarineRestoration&ConstructionLLC SolarPoweredStainlessSteelPathwayLight(2-Pack)$23.50/eachPRODUCTOVERVIEWModel#21070Internet#203802922Solarpathwaylightsareweatherproof,solarpoweredandareperfectforilluminatingpathwaysandwalkways,docksanddecks.AnintegratedsolarcelllocatedonthetopofeachlightrechargestheincludedNiMHbattery.Thebatterypowersthelightforupto8hoursthroughthenightandisrechargedduringtheday.Aninternalsensorensuresthelightturnonatnight.Stainlesssteelconstructionisresistanttowearandcorrosion.Bracketandscrewsareincluded.Theselightsaregreatforsafetylightsalongtheedgesofdeckordocksandcreatingaperimeterlinealongdriveways.LEDsaremoredurablethanconventionalglasslightbulbsandaremoreefficient.SolarpowerandLEDlightsmakethisfloodlightagreatchoiceforaccentingyouryard.Thisitemiscoveredbyaoneyearmanufacturerã€TMswarrantybutwithpropercarecanlastformanyyears.Theselightsmeasure4.5by4.5in.soldinpacksoftwo.ExpandedViewOpenClick •Solarpoweredsonowiringneeded•Runsupto8hoursonasingledayssolarcharge•Amorphoussolarpanelwillchargeevenonovercastdays•WeatherresistantstainlesssteelconstructionInfo&Guides•InstructionsIAssembly•ProductBrochure•SDS•WarrantyYouwillneedAdobe®Acrobat®ReadertoviewPDFdocuments.DownloadafreecopyfromtheAdobeWebsite.SPECIFICATIONSDimensionsProductDepth(in.)4.5ProductLength(in.)4.5ProductHeight(in.)1ProductWidth(in.)4.5DetailsAdjustableLampHeadNoLightingKitNoBulbTypeLEDMotionSensorNoBulb(s)IncludedYesMountingTypeGroundDusktoDawnYesNumberofBulbsRequired2ExteriorLightingAccessory.NumberofHousingsLandscapeLight1TypeIncludedExteriorLightingProductWalkwayandPathLightingOutdoorLightingFeaturesWeatherResistantFixtureColor/FinishStainlessSteelPowerTypeSolarFixtureMaterialStainlessSteelProductWeight(lb.).5lbGlass/LensTypeClearReturnable9ODayLandscapeLighting.Walk&PathLightingWaterproofNoApplicationLightSourceLEDWeatherResistantYes ADVISORYNOTESTOAPPLICANTLUA16-000316—------——-RentonApplicationDate:April25,2016SiteAddress:2909MountainViewAveNName:JoosFamilyLLCPierRenton,WA98056-2518PLAN-PlanningReview-LandUseVersion1IEngineeringReviewCommentsContact:RohiniNairI425-430-7298Irnair@rentonwa.govRecommendations:AstreetmodificationrequesttoallowtheROWwidthandstreetimprovementsonMountainViewNAvetoremainasexistinghasbeensubmittedbytheapplicant.Thestreetmodificationrequestinthecorrectformatshouldbesubmittedbytheapplicant.PlanningReviewCommentsContact:JillDingI425-430-6598Ijding@rentonwa.govRecommendations:1.RMCsection44030.C.2limitshaulhoursbetween8:30amto3:30pm,MondaythroughFridayunlessotherwiseapprovedbytheDevelopmentServicesDivision.2.Commercial,multifamily,newsinglefamilyandothernonresidentialconstructionactivitiesshallberestrictedtothehoursbetweenseveno’clock(7:00)a.m.andeighto’clock(8:00)p.m.,MondaythroughFriday.WorkonSaturdaysshallberestrictedtothehoursbetweennineo’clock(9:00)a.m.andeighto’clock(8:00)p.m.NoworkshallbepermittedonSundays.3.Withinthirty(30)daysofcompletionofgradingwork,theapplicantshallhydroseedorplantanappropriategroundcoveroveranyportionofthesitethatisgradedorclearedofvegetationandwherenofurtherconstructionworkwilloccurwithinninety(90)days.Alternativemeasuressuchasmulch,sodding,orplasticcoveringasspecifiedinthecurrentKingCountySurfaceWaterManagementDesignManualasadoptedbytheCityofRentonmaybeproposedbetweenthedatesofNovember1standMarch31stofeachyear.TheDevelopmentServicesDivision’sapprovalofthisworkisrequiredpriortofinalinspectionandapprovalofthepermit.4.ANationalPermitDischargeEliminationSystem(NPDES)permitisrequiredwhenmorethanoneacreisbeingcleared.5.Theapplicantmaynotfill,excavate,stackorstoreanyequipment,disposeofanymaterials,suppliesorfluids,operateanyequipment,installimpervioussurfaces,orcompacttheearthinanywaywithintheareadefinedbythedriplineofanytreetoberetained.6.Theapplicantshallerectandmaintainsixfoot(6)highchainlinktemporaryconstructionfencingaroundthedriplinesofallretainedtrees,oralongtheperimeterofastandofretainedtrees.Placardsshallbeplacedonfencingeveryfiftyfeet(50’)indicatingthewords,“NOTRESPASSING—ProtectedTrees”oroneachsideofthefencingiflessthanfiftyfeet(50’).Siteaccesstoindividuallyprotectedtreesorgroupsoftreesshallbefencedandsigned.Individualtreesshallbefencedonfour(4)sides.Inaddition,theapplicantshallprovidesupervisionwheneverequipmentortrucksaremovingneartrees.7.ThispermitisshallcomplywiththeBaldandGoldenEagleProtectionAct.ThepermittedisresponsibleforadheringtotheU.S.FishandWildlifeServiceNationalBaldEagleManagementGuidelines(2007)andbryourU.S.FishandWildlifeServicepermit.TechnicalServicesCommentsContact:AmandaAskrenI425-430-7369Iaaskren@rentonwa.govRecommendations:Boundarysurveyshowingeasementsonthepropertywasnotprovided.Unabletodetermineiftherequestedlocationforthestructureislocatedwithintheeasementsofrecordperthetitlereport.EXHIBIT16Ran:June02,2016Page1of1