Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutadams file � Denis Law Mayor � July 6, 2017 City Clerk-Jason A.Seth,CMC Monique Adams 17811 98t''Avenue South Renton, WA 98055 , Re: Request for Code Compliance Violation Hearing Case No.: CODE-16-000518 (Sanitary Drainage System) Dear Ms. Adams: The hearing that you requested to confest the validity of both Code Compliance Violation Findings dated lune 22, 2017, as referenced above has been scheduled for Tuesday, July 25, 2017, on the 10:00 a.m. docket. The hearing will take place in the Council Chambers on the seventh floor of Renton City Hall. The address is 1055 S Grady Way in Renton. Please note that more than one hearing will be held starting promptly at 10:00 a.m. If your case is called and you are not present, your appeal may be automatically denied. I have enclosed a copy of the case file for your review. If for some reason you do not plan to attend, or you have any questions, please call Jason Seth, City Clerk in advance of the hearing date at 425-430-6502. Sincerely, � Jason A. Seth City Clerk cc: Hearing Examiner Craig Burnell, Building Official Donna Locher, Code Compliance Inspector Tim Lawless, Code Compliance Inspector Robert Shuey,Code Compliance Inspector 1055 South Grady Way, Renton,WA 98057 • (425)430-6510/Fax (425)430-6516 • rentonwa.gov CITY OF RENTON ��,�,� �� DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AND ��� ��� ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT REPORT TO THE HEARING EXAMINER, EXHIBITS Project Name: Project Number: Code Compliance Appeal Hearing CODE16-000518 Date of Hearing Staff Contact Violator Violation Location TBD Rob Shuey Monique Adams 17811 98th Ae S 425-430-7235 Renton WA 98055 The following exhibits were entered into the record: Exhibit 1: Appeal Request Dated 06-20-17 Exhibit 2: Renton Code Compliance Narrative Dated 06-30-17 Exhibit 3: Notice of Violation from King County Dated 06-01-16 Exhibit 4: Warning of Violation Dated 08-11-16 w/ USPS Tracking Exhibit 5: Inspection Findings Email from Rob Shuey to City Attorney Dated 11-29-16 Exhibit 6: Notice of Violation from King County dated 02-21-17 Exhibit 7: Notice of Violation &Order to Correct form City of Renton Dated 06-20-17 CITY OF ___../1/i "�,.�:_ �� o� ��% � NOTICE OF RENTON MUNICIPAL CODE VIOLATION The City has elected to establish a non-judicial hearing and determination system to enforce violations of the Renton Municipal Code. Therefore a code violation fine consistent with RMC 1-3-2 (F) is imposed, not including any costs, fees or assessments.You may respond in the following manner: ` , I deny creating, permitting to exist, maintaining or failing to eliminate the violation(s) and I am requesting a � hearing to contest this Notice of Violation. Appeal requests must be received by the Renton City Clerk's office within 10 days of the date of this Finding of Violation. Please send me a hearing date. I promise to appear on that date. The administrator must prove by a preponderance of the evidence that I committed the violation. I understand that the hearing will be held in accordance with the procedures prescribed by RMC 1-3-2(E). The administrator shall decide whether the opportunity to be heard will be in writing and/or in person. The City is not required to call witnesses to testify at the hearing. Failure to attend the scheduled hearing makes the Notice of Violation final and I may be subject to additional costs if I fail to withdraw or resolve my appeal prior to the hearing date. I also understand that the City has not waived any rights or remedies under the law. I admit that I have created, permitted to exist, maintained or failed to eliminate the violation(s)and do not need � or want a hearing. Therefore, I have enclosed a check or money order [please do not send cashJ in the amount of$ . I understand I am required to bring the property into compliance with the City of Renton Municipal code no later than the date noted on the attached notice of violation. I also understand that if compliance is not achieved within the prescribed time, I may be issued additional Findings of Violation and/or criminally prosecuted. NSF checks will be treated as failure to respond. PLEASE REMIT YOUR PAYMENT TO: C��� Il� -��;�C���l� .� City of Renton �lGu�c��� ���'1� ATTN: Finance, 15C Floor 1055 S. Grady Way ��� �� ���� � �L� Renton, WA 98057 PLEASE PRINT YOUR INFORMATION BELOW: 1� �/�u C���.e� FIRST NAME f , MIDDL NA /INITIAL LA T ME ! / � I � • ADD � ���� � CI STATE , _ 9 Z� UM R HOME NUMBER WORK NUMBER SIGNATURE 0� DATE: /� EXHIBIT�, RENTON CODE COMPLIANCE CODE16-000518 NARRATIVE June 30, 2017 Address: 1781198th Ave S Renton, WA 98055 Violator: Monique Adams RMC Violation: RMC 4-5-130(A), IPMC 506 • 506.1 General. Plumbing fixtures shall be properly connected to either a public sewer system or to an approved private sewage disposal system. • 506.2 Maintenance. Every plumbing stack, vent,waste and sewer line shall function properly and be kept free from obstructions, leaks, and defects. June 1, 2016: The City of Renton was provided documentation from King County Environmental Health Services that an inspection was performed at 1781198th Ave S revealing that unpermitted work was performed in the past. The Inspection performed by King County was in response to complaints received by neighbors who stated that the septic system had failed and a foul odor was coming from the property. See attached King County Notice of Violation dated 06-01-16, attached. August 11, 2016: A Warning of Violation, CODE16-000518, was issued to Monique Adams, the person in possession of the property, for violating the City of Renton's International Property Maintenance Code Section 506. The compliance date was September 10, 2016. Attached. November 29, 2106:After receiving a number of complaints from neighbors about the foul odor coming from the property, Rob Shuey was asked by the city attorney's office to go out to the property, and with Monique Adams permission, walk the back yard to see if there is any sign of a failed septic system. He contacted Monique and she agreed to allow him on the property to look at the drain field area. Mr. Shuey emailed the results of the site inspection to Alex Tuttle, City Attorney. See the email and photographs, attached. February 21, 2017: The City received a copy of the Notice of Health Code Violation issued to the property by King County Environmental Health. The notice described the violations as an unpermitted and unlawful discharge of sewage upon the ground surface and failure to comply with the requirements of the King County On-site Sewage Regulations, attached. EXHIBIT� 1 June 20, 2017:A Notice of Violation & Order to Correct was hand delivered by Rob Shuey to Monique Adams. It was explained to Monique that the Notice and Order along with the $250.00 fee were being assessed for continuing to be in violation the City of Renton's International Property Maintenance Code Section 506, attached. June 22, 2017:The City Clerk received an appeal request from Monique Adams, attached. The city's position is that Monique Adams has been aware that the septic system is in violation of both the City of Renton and King County for over a year. According to King County, because there is a sewer main in the street in front of the house, the property will not be issued a permit to replace or repair the septic system, and that it is required to be connected to the sewer main. A sewer availability certificate has already been issued for that property verifying that connection to the sewer is allowed. The City requests that the property connected to the sewer system in the street and that the septic system be properly abandoned in place pursuant to King County requirements. I certify under penalty of perjury under the laws of the state of Washington that the foregoing is true and correct. signed on � in Renton, Washington Rob Shuey Code Compliance Inspector 2 Eastgate Environmental Health Services 14350 SE Eastgate Way Public Health Believue, WA 98007-6458 �s 206-296-9791 Fax 206-296-9792 Seattle & Kin COUrit TTY Relay: 711 g }' NOTICE OF VIOLATION TO: 17811 98t''Ave S CASE NO. CO-0086910 Renton,WA 98055 CERT. MAIL NO. NOTICE AND DESCRIPTION OF VIOLATION: An inspection of the property described b�low ("the property")was initially made on March 25, 2015. King County records indicate that you are the owner of the property. You are hereby notified of the following violations of public health rules and regulations observed during the inspection: The drainfield area of the existing septic system for the property was excavatec� revealing that unpermittecl work was performed in the past—a single perforatecl PVC pipe was exiting from the septic tank. As-built records confirm that such construction was not permitted. CODE(S)VIOLATED: BOHKCC 13.04.060 Failatre Prohibitec� ADDRESS AND LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF LOCATION OF VIOLATION: 17811 98"'Ave S-Parcel: 7616800250; SCOTTS TERRACE ADD PLat Block: Plat Lot: 25 CORRECTIVE ACTION REQUIRED: The owner must contract with a licensed septic designer/engineer or a licensed King County master installer to have an approved King County On-Site Sewage System Yepair installed. The repair installation must be approvecl by Public Health Seattle &King County. Ifsanitary sewer is available to the pro�erry, you must connect at this time. DATE COMPLIANCE REQUIRED: July 8, 2016. You are responsible for correcting the public health code violations on the property. If corrections have not been made by the date specified above, a Notice and Order may be issued subjecting you to fines of up to $25 per day until conection is accomplished. In addition, you may be subject to criminal prosecution. If you have any questions,please contact Matt Wilson, Health&Environmental Health Investigatar, at 206-477-2125. Dated this 1 S`day of June, 2016. SEATTLE-KiNG COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH Patty Hayes, Interim Director and Health Officer By: Lynn Schneider, R.S., Supervisor Wastewater Program Community Environmental Health cc: Matt Wilson, Health and Environmental Investigator EXHIBIT 3 Roman Welyczko,Enforcement Coordinator Denis Law Mayor � � Warning of Violation Issued To: Community&Economic Development C.E."Chip"Vincent,Administrator Monique Adams Date:August 11, 2016 17811 98th Ave 5 Code Case No: CODE16-000518 Renton, WA 98055 45 0534 427?3� Owner(Tax-Payer): Monique Adams 9��49���09+6°'"e5g Violation Address: VSpgTRA�ERGA f�r�p�KBpp-222-1811. or 1781198th Ave S R�cE1P M Renton,WA 98055-5734 An inspection of the above premises revealed violation(s)of the City of Renton Municipal Code and Ordinances listed below. Comp�iance or corrective acfion must be completed by September 10, 2016. If voluntary compliance is not achieved,a Criminal Citation MAY be issued. The minimum penalty for the first violation shall be one hundred dollars ($100.00). The minimum penalty for the second violation of the same nature or a continuing violation shall be two hundred dollars ($200.00). The minimum penalty for the third violation of the same nature or a continuing violation shall be three hundred dollars ($300.00). A fourth violation shall constitute a gross misdemeanor and wi►I be submitted for criminal prosecution. �: ,�,�r�, I�ION��Stor ge O�B'ulky Vl/a"�sJte Pivate Property � � ^ �� �' �,��,���4,������ :�x�,��- � - °`�„ .� "h �: � �0 *� "'�� �° '��' ��z�� � � � �� � �` �nves"figa"�ion'Da�e= „ti�� «�-� ,�� ��. _ _ . �_r�«. ,.. -_-_r, �� . � : . __. , �� �. ��"' � ��� .�: - : _, -�, � .�� ,�.�, �0$�11 2d_ 6��__�� Code Cited: CODE 8-1-4 E Code Text: Storage of Bulky Waste: Private Property 8-1-4 E: The City of Renton has adopted regulations that governs bulky waste. The code specifically states "it shall be unlawful for any person in the city to store, maintain, keep, retain,dump or accumulate bulky waste on private property in the city". Bulky waste is defined as "large items of solid waste,including but not limited to items such as furniture, large household appliances, refrigerators, freezers, oven, ranges,stoves, dishwashers,water heaters, washing machines, or clothes dryers:junk vehicles,vehicle hulks or any other oversized solid wastes which would typically not fit into or be permitted for collection as garbage in garbage cans". Corrective Action: Remove and properly dispose of the bulky waste stored outside on the property in the driveway. : '?��X _ ra `�` �-''�r�* ��'s�'a�'3n : �x � � � �.� �-:�� � � �� w . � ` �� �' � "'lnvesfiga�ion�D��e� � (O Gar age Can s . .��� ,� ,,� ��� . . � ._. '.���'yF�;.''���,-�'q�`�. ��_�;�'�"��`'�'' ._.-:�, u _ � . :-` n,.i��` �� �''< �'�` ;,. �., � ° � i,`. w.-e _ Yx.�. .,.,v .rN� ._��rl^s�k 2�.,.��;t _ sar,sL ""�'.::'�`.�_. 1 ' »_ Code Cited: 8-1-4 K Code Text: Unlawful Placement and Removal of Garbage Cans, Recycling Bins and Yard Waste Carts: It shall be unlawful for a person residing in a single-family residence to place garbage, recyclables, or yard waste at the curbside for collection by the City's collection contractor more than 24 hours prior to the regular collection date for his or her single-family residence. It shall also be unlawful for a person residing in a single-family residence to leave garbage cans, recycling bins or yard waste carts at the curbside more than Z4 hours after collection by the City's collection contractor. Further, it shall be unlawful for a person residing in a single-family residence to maintain, place or store any garbage cans, recycling bins or yard waste carts at a location other than adjacent to the residential structure or within a fully enclosed building or garage. Corrective Action: Do not place or store any garbage cans, recycling bins or yard waste carts at a location other than adjacent 1055 South Grady Way,Renton,WA 98057• rentonwa.gov EXHIBIT� Page 1 of 2 �y � '"`�aa. u?° " i*�.: .� i: � x��, `�„ frv ; s -�'� #'.� '�- r i`, ��� � r�:.,�� a-��;e ,i� h �IO���T�IO,��L �ar�age�.ta�,s� ez��'� �:w�� � ��" ,�"���� �' ' ���� x� �� �1 v�g�o�t�?�e�T; � . _x ,w,r; x � � �� t A�. ... -�t.� � ..�.,�� , . .,.. a? _�.-� . ?�.�.���,3 :�c. � '�: :� �`�� , "� . s..�. , u, ; ._ .,� .�t.�;� <. K�� �ZE �s � ��, to the residential structure or within a fully enclosed building or garage. Garbage cans can not be placed in the driveway, and must be placed next to the house or in the garage. ���� ��� ���� � ��. � : , ��VIOL�4TION�3��CSectio�.02�pp icability ��� '``� r �'` �����������g � ��'��� �������,�` �� Invesfigat�oiiDate � . . .. � , . � ry <. �Ol� � .. „ v y��. ,_-:�� � _� . , _���.� � _. �:. I 2016 Code Cited: RMC 4-5-130 Section 102.2 Applicability-Maintenance Code Text: 102.2 Maintenance. Equipment,systems, devices and safeguards required by this code or a previous regulation or code under which the structure or premises was constructed,a�tered or repaired shall be maintained in good working order. No owner, operator or occupant shall cause any service,facility, equipment or utility which is required under this section to be removed from or shut off from or discontinued for any occupied dwelling,except for such temporary interruption as necessary while repairs or alterations are in progress.The requirements of this code are not intended to provide the basis for removal or abrogation of fire protection and safety systems and devices in existing structures. Except as otherwise specified herein,the owner or the owner's designated agent shall be responsible for the maintenance of buildings,structures and premises. Corrective Action: There is no approved septic service to your residence. if the septic system is not repaired pursuant to King County Public Health Notice of Violation Case No.C00086910 within 30 days (09-10-16) of the date of this Warning of Violafion,occupants will be ordered to immediately discontinue occupancy of this residence as a dwelling unit and remain out of the dwelling unit until approved septic service is again restored pursuant to King County Public Health requirements. In the event the septic service is not repaired on the date noted (09-10-16),the building will be posted "DO NOT OCCUPY"and the City of Renton will employ all means necessary to vacate and secure the building from occupancy. Issued By: Rob Shuey Code Compliance Inspector 425-430-7235 rshuey@ rentonwa.gov Page 2 of 2 P R I O R 1 TY� FLAT RATE ENVEtOPE ONE RATE *ANY WEIGHT` � ■'■ A I L � APPLY PRIORITY MAIL POSTAGE HERE �-----+ .��inuiuiy��convmic �evelopment Department "�'"`""""—�-- — _�� � ity of, � i ,� _*° � .�r.. � '. )55 South Grady Way i s�'-�UNITEDSTdTES entan WA 98057-3232 '�POSTdL SERVKE. USPS TRACKtWG # � �g �� > �� � 9114 9014 9645 0534 4272 3T �� Date:Au, Monique Adams Code Cas 1781198th Ave S Renton,WA 98055 Owner(7 Violstio 178119' . x For Intarnatlo�al shipments,the mazimum wo�9ht Is o�bs. EP14H JUIy 2013 OUt@C b1►11@t1SI0Il:l0 X 5 Robert Shuey From: Robert Shuey Sent: Tuesday, November 29, 2016 1:24 PM To: Alex Tuttle Subject: 17811 98th Ave S Attachments: DSCN2005.JPG; DSCN2006.JPG; DSCN2007.JPG Hi Alex, per our conversation last week, I went out to the subject address and with the permission of Monique Adams, the resident, I walked the back yard to see if there were any sign of a failed septic system. These signs may include water leaching or puddling above the septic tank or drain field and/or foul odors. As you can see by the attached photos, there is an indentation where a trench was dug (with leaves gathered in it) to make repairs to the septic system. I walked the length of the trench and didn't see any obvious sign of leaching liquid, nor was there any water running at the downhill end of the trench,where I would expect to see an issue if there were one in regards to leaching. I did however observe the foul odor of a septic system as soon as I stepped out of the basement door into the back yard, which is right next to the lid if the septic tank. If you look at photo 2005, under the leaves is the lid to the septic tank. I asked if there was a tight fitting lid on the tank and she seemed to think there was. I explained that the odor can only come from one of two places,a loose lid on the septic tank, or a leaching area. I told Monique that the complaints we have been receiving regards the odor. I suggested that she place some black plastic over the lid and then cover that with dirt to see if it resolves the odor issue. Due to the leaves everywhere, my inspection was very limited, but the ground was fairly dry, and I believe that if there were a leaching problem in the drain field, I would have found it. I didn't uncover the septic tank lid as I didn't have the tools or protection to feel safe to do so. According to Monique,the house is for sale and they are looking for an investor to purchase the house so she can buy it back from them. She clearly wants to stay in the house, and expects whoever purchases the house to make the repairs required by King County. Please call me if you have any questions. �� ��� Code Compliance Inspector,City of Renton Development Services Division Desk 425-430-7235 Email rshuey(�rentonwa.�ov Advisorv: Please be advised the City of Renton is required to comply with the Public Disclosure Act Chapter 42.56 RCW. This act establishes a strong state mandate in favor of disclosure of public records. As such, the information you submit to the City via email, including personal information, may ultimately be subject to disclosure as a public record. Ct717E CQMPLlF#NCE prt��;rasa�infcarrn�ti+an @ http://rentonwa.gov/living/default.aspx?id=200 PARKltVC; E�VEC7�tCEPUlEi�T�nfarrrsat�t�n @ http:J/rentonwa.�ov/living/default.aspx?id=6642 t313i1DlNta � 5EGN PER[013l1"S infeartr,�tiear� @ _h_ttp://rentonwa.�ov/business/default.aspx?id=1000 1 EXHIBIT� ��" � '° � .11�11� �"(n M� ,� w j > . +,�•���� . i� �; ,:R��P� 4 ;" ` e `a, �M �.. ���� � � ���� �� � �� �"�� � � � �s���� � „"!A" ' � .. .,� ��' •>w�r ��i � r �� �' � 4' �' ' '' �r r��' €; . � a p � � T 1� �� „� � ' 4 `� %f� 'p1��'. � +£3 . � � S�' �t. 'T.A< e,,,� .. {' � �d ��� `��. R ��� �'� � . �f a��� � � W � , �� � 9 i � � F � � . ' �������� a ,.�., , ^y� � � � � � � , rz,. . ,. M °'� �. � { � "�. �. ' „t . �..r *�1�'�r.�� i's"',`ti`,"a � � y�1 . � . *,M����° � �'°rai�Z`�t; '� ^ i i � � �, ` t i1�°e " {Mr =w���S '"� �8� `" ��d �a � t+4 �� x ar � � Y � t' e ; � r mF y � r � ,�%� �'�' �V��''x� t �` m� ��V . ,y��r4 f�a°<n��'�. `�,a @ 8 ♦ t�' # e 1 � '� ,, ' i,e x� � ) ira" a+�,�m �'e �s' ' �` ��, �"�S�` ��` !AM �1K'a a�'r' r � f+W y�'�`Qe� � �r�^�i a� �� ,� ' +- � ,. : � �� "`� ,� � ,�+� �, `��'�* r� � " . � °.�� ��"��+ ` ��",R�,�"',`i'"q� ',��° `"'",�n�bn � � �R�,`, � � {�"� ��� �� ,?.� '� q�+�:����.tli ,'��*k^ t� `M .� i�.�:�, � �+� rt "a`�I������i " � �. �s; ���4„ ���'il�j p�+ '��, y��. i� � r. k+`sk� :,. ��� r � � ,M.yj�14'��,� ":�g` ,. t w+'�.a�rti, v.Ak��C�a�ir�a ?..�r� ��4'*`�w �... �� *'�"��,��,'���¢M�V�."�.� '�,y>�;�� . ` � �� '� xk i��' ��r�M�'�� a �"�1 y�''��,. �y f . ..y�� .�� �,�t' .a'�4� ���"�* w`� � �q a � � F� � ^�. "' a""�^ . �y � ,. m c. ��Yt � �'1��� "�'t+P�j w'{/'�1�. �4 x��a .� y�� t� ,#�`�k-e,+��¢"�� _�'' s y�; r �_,��t,�!�' ".u*- kie �� � A , �T �w '#�.S+�e � � � � ikt�a �� r `�► �" *` ^� � `"� �� � ���e`�+ �"�,�� a��'". `a �A �•y�, � +�ra� w«a�1�b t +'"�`�,�� �w'�o r . ��r � •��"'T.: x +A:.:"�`}�����a � sM,s?���, y �}�� ��,d+ a.�( y- c�Y.�e. �.."'�^ a�; .� �� 'Y�y�. ,� ,�.�h ��' r�y����. .�, � �r p� ,�^ �,�s�,S�`` '�^ � R+ �' ,"^�,'�. ' ' ''�� �°�`+��'y�z �'"'�tk�, fi�•��� �., °r.�' � ��1 � �v� �`� 'Y$� °�^t„�.�, � , �, ���? v ���.�* 1�4�' �'. . ,� �M �"k�n�r'� � �a�°"�1��!"� y� � �,�^a, �� "� *�j.� ��' „ �C�z�, �►*a..aa �'�'�p,. .�°",,��� '�����^ {t �-�^y'3 �� -', r���:����,►",��,�"_,�� � �.;.'�.tr'��z�+ � ����+..,��� . �"' c- �� ��,� � .`,��� '� �a '�� . ��i �'1�� +� ,er��` c��v �" `'��� � �°"`� � ��`�"�M �` ���' ,"ty� ,y�,,•r �" ik � `"M+�" ..��y �"�t�� ,. �"�� ��. � "'�'*"�e�,�T� �4i' '4�,.'.Y��an\ �'�gy 'G � ���4 �{�� {�`� . � .y�, � � �A����� ,y �°r..�, � ��'"y� 1 ,:��.. :��� �"^.te � y � �'� ���' � F�p�... .�ipf�"�,"" w�¢$j.��,�,`'A� ��'{�. &' . �'� } '4°i"�`;. .,,.�*����.. �' A . '(�% +� ,,,t'r� . :+�"�°� t ",�. .. fi� .#'�t�d7 ,'�r �w ;"' �����""� '� ���p. {*.�4w a .:�,��" ���a, � � -..�t�� �`y�� �`�. �� �`'�"" � � �'��#,. 'Y,�'g M . � �,„,��� r*► rdm� Ak ` ��j^ �I " � � �Y �»�" T ,T' T�,.alr � t � � � m t"e�'.^'..`� �� � �,.. ». �,` � �.�M` T�t y7` �y""'^'�`�,y �a ���, ���� ,,; �� � ,y„� �N. .s b ,�.„ ;� ' �_►: -, _� �.',� . �,�y� � '� � , � "� . ���m�°�� � � �� ���� y �,��y�, } �K�.� � -!�"�r .,,�,f � �* �}"^ �,� � +�����`� ;. � L �" � «� � �, ` � �» � +.., . � iM - � � ►� ,r,` � ,�� r��� ,��� „"��.�� � �, -�. "��►�" '� a �,*�, < `,�,��»+_ '��`' ��" ' `���,�`►� ' #� � °"�' �yr �,�:�`�`� ,,..�� �� . �:' � �.��_�,��, �-,� �.� / ,� � t ,��� ,µ� �"'���°� � P � Att..: 9 �1��. �. �.�5,° . .i,,� . #�� * �a�� �„w � ��/",N � s�y ,��. ;�F�"�.. :I .r � Y „,�� 'AF� »?'� s d�M"°4°' �.. �� � � �ik§,d,..fi ��,�� ��. °r. �' ��� � . . �{ . .« , g; T , ,,,� �, y.t ��t�t Y¢ ,'r,...�+P'�6 ., •. �ai��, ' y'�� ,�'i� `�v y''�� .� �;:,ap,��l�^w,��t.,.kt��'�, �;��W�c� ., s"�Ft�a�, ��'Y s �. �iea�� , � � �p,.paY T Y 1 ` ' �}�� t�. . y`y��,w. "� � � .� a�v���� .^°' � ,� , �'� ,�,� �,�:�*�.. ���� •t� r����w�. .."t�.�" `.,,� 4 �.�� �t�' .1�r���: � '� � �'.�� *�*� '�� `� R � � � ,,� �` „ �c�• . t "���' ,�, i�`�.."+#.��1, �� �� ,�+� `� ^� w, � � ��� "�. � i.s.� �'h` . , ,�. z�, �� •� �'�<.. �r �� � � w.:����^�•'" #�� ���J' i � .. ��� � � .� e�k�1.�;*��'"�,R�, .��� �fl��+�. . . 4�� S T' �i�M.fYr� � ' :� , �` � ttp # � v � �� yt� ...� � � . r�� r. � . �k ti.± 1� . . � �� a�.��:. "'^�� .�' � > ' As'� o �W �`w„£� ��y„� . .�*+'"' � a . Y • „ t . �} },� ��^'+ ��� �� "�k � �, � ��s � �'�^"'�.L S � `}� - F ��"' ��� � , ~� �► r� + ' � `� � �. , ,�� :� r'"'�r`� �' �� '�iM `�' '�"�° �' �'�" �' �� �r " � ,`�'�w - �� a "i�.. "4 ta,i s � �: — ., x r . �w ++�`t �r+,.sr, "��+�'^�T�►��`"+"„�"'' �x� ,�,'�, �'"� ` r�� 1 � y�r �V i ���.:� � � � �� 4�*, " �, a��� � � � �� ` y�� �. � �,..�,. ��'�,„ '"""I�"" �. � �. �� i ' ``�'���jfiJ���� ,: ��,�. '� � �� c � ..y a �+� , �" � �� �"� � � � � � `„ � � �',I(.� t �' :��'��' '' , �'��i��. K�'� � �,. ` ,�,���.a►�� � �. , � �+��y � � `° �� � � � ��� `��`� ,�; �,� ,�� � 1,;��� � ° 'r'�.' < � �, ' ,��a ������,�1�1„�. ����w � 4, ; . ,� '�: � .�► �. � �` ���..�'�►�,� i ���, � ��� �� �� w4� �r, `� , ,�, t�,,�� � ��' � `�""k §� ��9 `� f'd'p �A� � �.1 �r� '1"� i y� . �n � '�P F� ,d'1� ��8 1 �#�� ,,�! P "' ��d * �. ✓~ �',� ���� , � � P _ � I N' � ::� �" � x�'' � . .j ��.. � � ,�;,�>. � � � � y �.$,: � � �� ����,��,� ' " � F � 4 t �:: �� �l��s� �� �;�, :C� �'�. , .;i� �_a- �, ...� �w. �t,.� � �.� "�'�q� � +i .fi'�� �{ ,�*�� , �,.� ��.� � � � � � ,�1„ , .#� p �,.��,�, � �' ;`� ' � a � � o- . i �p .. � � .«�a� � �� � � , � 'S'�'�� ��'F � ,� ���`: ��� • ��7���� � 1 �� .�_ �, .�+. .�, �. .� � ` �� � �'� �`�� �� �F ��� � �, ,�r �� '� � � � � • �� � : . . � * . � .�� `� � .� ,„�.k� �. ""�v� � � � �1 � u� �� _ , .:� R� ��i��s r*'+� �` � � �" ' � �!y�., " ��� � � � � � � � � �� �� ; � �' � IllAY�a� ��' �``��.��� "' ���� , # . � � ,rr w1��' ,8 � � � ` :> � ���* �� � � ��m ,���� ,� �.�- ���, � � �. ,� � .+�� �.� �►.� n.:�.� ,�w, �'��� ..� �. .r,�"` �� � ���,�.� �;� �`� �,� ��� ;�' � � �*: .x �� g. �r:.i 'k`� p� � � 6�f ��.. �+t fRk !.ap � ;� �pY �"� � ���' � y ���y #� � � ` ��p. �♦� � l h 'h ,�* 1.� a > ��N�' � �,:,� �� � 5� � '1"r. ,g+ � � ��IL.�e�� �.."� Y,� �y ,,�' ��,��q� `�� ' ,.ai ' �. �� �*�w � � �^E v� i NI ,.� C J� �V <� � '�e (,j ��.m� q+� ��� � f '1� ' ���, �� �, ,�. � � +�"�� ��+1 � ti� ,R�• ,� � < s `�r%,�'�}� , . ,�s •.�:��{ .�S •� '-i�*yy�`�'��` � ".��' � *�`$ � �^ �' �.«C� � �, � �y,�f�,s �•�� �4 ��� � ���,. X�';� � � .w'�y,, �� '� f +� �v��^' "/��t i� . � { � � s ;� ,z„�,<� z�� �,� . '�� , . � . �"` y � "{ X:� �} � � ��` �� � #,�� � '� . m�, � `�� � �'� � yu�� `X g� 'li��`� �.7^ �. �y,'�. ��� � '� � , ��... ��r, �,`�;: ,`��� . ���, ��w pi R- �.4..� w°,,�'•.w�� ���;'� :b'...� �� �,.r� I�j;' .. ��', �tit� .�.� � �� a'da. � S"` �s �" � �'�#.� ��+�'�,, � `4" • 's� *y��'ia �i � �,,. ,� ,�!` �� < w ".:� "`. ¢p `..�,. "., #" �.° fi+,.�'"w� �fi� �'�:;✓.�.t ^���� � ,•, / . .r°!",'.� � � '..{"� ,��'-�� �n.s� t a 5e ` �� r "� � �" .�.f ;2 ,,,.,r 1k i�vy �;�"� Af . � ,6f , � t «� � �- � ,��.,�,r� �r � " °" ;�� '� �' _ 1 � � � �y -m s .° .� �,� i '� ,k � '�{aC� ��`,'�� ��� �`.�?r �c .�'���� � �. � � �� , +�� 't t Lt, P,. 4�+ 1 �������� .. �F� {n -. � � ,� I► '� 3`t"����! , .� j� 4�$ � . �' .�, � �` y�� : c `.t s y i ..; -.r .�^ r^s Nd" ,f�f> i �fi + r '� T � 'A i+'z� "t�y 1 '� ,�`� '�.� �""�' � " " ' � '� ��` �"• � "- � ����' a� � tf b ,� .+t � ��, + 'y E , ���,� a)?�' . � �,}.- 4 � 'm' ����� � �.t.,�'*� a..}�'".a`-�,�t"eT,z �� �r,d`�� t�r�� a"�y��`/e* r` r� �'�p�� 1 ,�,M1 t p �� ��ic�����:.� ��i'" � , ��� ��'��w� �'��,� ..� �F ���.4<r�� �.`�,tr'���i�. .{��7���r"� � ��,� 1 c l. "+y +��� , �� ,z���, _�j."�� F� y��g .. , s ' �$ �"fi' r .� � ��•�� �„ �14 �-�6�; �� ��� PG � y � }.. i � �� t �." "�.. t.� �' F " �tt 4 2.{yg6'G °� �. '�; ,`,� �j._ � ��" •�.� ��`"�����+�t#�-^4'�`Y�� �',���� � � Z* .� vr.,+.' , �:." '�, . � �'��P-i. � xs_h��'_ �'4- 'r�' . � �",;r� s" 4veTu,-a'F'" `'rM �.{ �.�,'.�� �`�� �`�° ,I�p-.�C' - t( + *�.,�`� �,-`�� ..t` � �G��# + , r-R., f "�t�� . �b �Y,f AW.7' :��,�� ,; �.��. � i ,"� �� ��,�..E 'C y �'"��.���..� �... ..- +. ���� , �� � s�.#°.�_.�'G .4 ,� ' F� L` * � ����w �� � ��,�`.„ Yy � i�. �''"^�' �' Afl •r�..�,'aka` _ � '�hvta" ,� `t , ��� „.�+, 1 1 '��'�i � . ��y�. '-� � ;Ill� . 1�'' �;�. „i�. �, r-.y �, � �t.'s'{i�a . � �.+a .. }' . «:� _ �€ 'i'.'t ,'" s�'� € �r, R f�"� � .� `� � � �' _§�1' � 'b ^^. � 'y ,° � �� '� M a`�.�a6�� � � 7k' � , § f:i+'` �i L,r' 'r i'•�?,� y. �ra'�����i�` •"a�f,��r�i � x���r �I�§.�y �4�'� '�.. �jy�' � ��.��� ,,��H AGx'�+�'�. „k �a> �,��,{` �i� ,�.f ,� � . � . ^1M�Y"��� .��.!''k� � '..�,y„� ��J""��...1 ..y..�� +. � °�` 'l.:"s „ . 2,"", 'Y�;�� +�, � ;g`;' � �s A ' �`. a �� � , ._ .:. . �..�` , f .� . �� � x - x' ��' �•.'°`�;� ,� � �;.�� �,'. �•� y, � .. 7�..� � ,k: ���^' ���b��� � � �ti� ��� �� { .�� ,I. ' � � s,�.. .,_ s�'&�+y�,3` r` �� ��3�� s,.� aY .y�N`^° � �,� `�� w �� , �.W! �- . � � - a y ` �• � ' �f^� '. �: , .� ��.. � �s�,;�� � �,, ����`�a �1"� � �� "'�, �� a� .<t� ��.�t '� �'�r'�� .� � : ��r, � �:� � y�a � '�' � 1 d, � � i'`� � � ��',W� pf��� . � �`gc"`"'�'"'`�� ^ ""i��"_ � `1`A }.- .�v'� �..� ��.� Wf;". L ac...�, � .A�� �,� .�' , � � y�. �"� �". b � ad � " .�1� �� £.� � "a"3�� L?��v"�4.+.� � a i.^j� ,�.1 ��t� ;u�,� a%S�` "� F a� � ,�,-'.if ' /�- .t. �' � ( . , "b..�: "O . � i�. ♦ . ° � '"�-P t ���� y�'��� <. ���� b- � r °�afl� � � �� ;��: � � ` $�q.} �� �� ,�', � �� ..q; �+ �°,��,�� '�. {:-� i�R � 7` `�� 4 ..r r 'r }R:� s�� g � '��: � # ,a�3'.� � A� t 1 �'4 Si �a.��� .. � _ ' '=: '� + 4r ;��w! �:: �:!" �/" ' �, ��" ���, g "p k ,a �.. . 4 'e:` .,�4 ' � k f . . m '+ �„ v «a yy ' r�w.-m:+ �'.0. j 4 .� t{ . �. ' '�" �.'Y� � � . ....:� �`�` u'L �' i +f i�,�.,� �'� }` � . �,_ �t< tt-w �'" �, � �,�,.,.���, {� �n 'm—^'=='"�- - -.., �' �, '>t '4 E� 1 / �*P e` ,. � `r � � ? }�Y . �°„� rL�3� . ,�,,�r �t < � x ',+-4 �" ^�q�`��;, p�� �•-p. t t,s.. r�,n i.� r p� �� " � s � ��; � " > � �, Q � ��. _ � � '�k"�f tt � � � K F,p, -� '�'��� •y ' � � . . . �6 '� � ��. �+ � �2�F}1�4 i��`� �"`���'^��}�5 '�, Q` "�� � ���� , ��` ���� 4,1�' � �����"� _ ��a�� '� �� .� � �� � �� '�..�,� '"� �,.��""+ y^ �s e� .+`�, '� 'ti` �� . � . t�'`�"���.�::: ���w �+t��"�"�. '��. �'• 4 �iv 'v. �'i'�±�:�` �I{� �.}' �P'� '. (`'�z ,�,L"� -`a_ . ��a €w. *�,�*'+�� ."�.�^ � � � . I... Ra`'� Y � �1r � �d'l�{{; f • f��Rs � �f r ° r ���' oC*�,'�Y .: � '�;"�� �`:+.�`'.°.�" " �,.. at` ��.' e �''�'�" t rt. ,k t �f �"t �,t ' , � ?}� ;° q � �'' 'V� ''`"1F u a � �:. n. .�g . :;1 '� �� � ��� y ��,� �°����� �� ��� �y� �'�•`�"9R' � j � 4 �f- '�'+� �. i � 3"�' e .�,�' . r�.� '�, 6�� 14� E�� �, �,���� s��(� � r � �.��':� .d 1•"�y° '�; � t ,����. � w� � ra s i i� ,uc e t , ''�r � � �t �� er� ��, r h,y,�A+ �. . ' ��,� ��t�t � t M, ; � � �" �e�4*`'� � +� :',o�r; < ' � � � ��� TGw,r��!!� �k�� � �'l�� � � . 2'i m t� � �� '� '� r��' �r � � - ���, � F �t � .� � � ���� � y � ��5. �� ' '� �t�,`t ��� ' a�}�r . f � :' ��� .i " � `-��t +�'��,- r�� �. �' 6 s � , � ��� f�j�a� n� t.a;� s�,,�Y'��'r� �� � r 4�' �,� `y�,=r�"�xa, ��' a t� (�.�y� �„� �. �� �k� f � 'S �'� � g��'�'��"�a 8 �.�'�� �r� ♦ �;�' �� �C , �s�.�, ��• t ,r � �� ,�9, ; . � , . , `� . ., ., > � � �c � � `,'g"ez=' �� t� a t ��,G �v' "� "�"�` � ��� i t *",y � ro � � �, � � �+� '��^ �t� lt `+ `� *' � r ,.i � <�y, .. � �. � . ,r 4-j- �;� �' �� �, 1 +t aa� � �`� � ;�jt � "'�` r�+�,'4 .� i+��'� , i-� + �' `���ty� �� � '� �'��., �� �, . l-`� 'y. . � � � � � �� �. . ` f ':S�'���� �� ��� }^4 �� �� �'� � *�� , � '��,y,, �' y� �� *� HI�� � ;� ��t, Y 9 . £ ,�L r� �.;� � 6' ,=-7 c ,,l 4a'�M� `4k°1�;f �.� �Yi! 7 '� . . a-$''p vii� �..�•��, � #5 � t J,r ; � q '� Y f e A�k S� � i �l .f- �,t �p � £'m�` � w °��J" ,��a r�' r �kny�� �y��;!!�Y,��4�,�. v���� .`y��� �.`�r �� �:w��. �+,..$.�� } •I�j �' '��' ,�r^ 5i ,�-� / i.r 4 1�,t}�,p ��i � � �..r�.v� �.�p�' ���' A�.. �i'�-��+' � y,' - .�v� tY �",�,'p,. $��' �'$� y�,,� ..�, s � y y r � • _`m.'S. � �`3 � � z Y � �,le�,� .:.,� �,� t1,�r 'yk.:q��. ��f�� �1d� ,'p. .,��/ {} . �"' i',�' Py�; bi4 � s � t 3� �: k �:J h� [ e � f`! f �*�* � � "�hJi W a }r `'� �i ,� � �k. � k.}' ��i. '& � �R� r � �^ �'�.� �� �i,+� �M� ,y��� a �� �, r1 � A�� � w�1.�'�M,� r, .+�, ,�'-�,' aa, " P� .. j't �'r r-3� A.f�,��, x �- '�'J'.e; '�w J, �. k;y< n :. ° � ' "� r� ., � �'� � � �� x � �'h t •� �a � � � �' yY� Y � " ,^,. � 97�'6 ,ba �s � x R ° � t . . . �. �.�'� � � � '�` � #� '���t r....{ � q.r� tk �' °` . �'�r'�� �.�� , ,� �"r t� .�lq ���� � ���� x - } - (,3-,��,r,�� �a �Cr 5"yq'14�y f 4 i ��; , rr �e*�, �� ��l���� �l. . ��� �r j L a �f 1 �4,�,� �°� �`�' ',Q� / �'.,� �' � ,. .+ '�r e*i r4 r" :�'� ��" . � � +{ ,.�c � •��t �. g<'t +' �i d� .:� . �,� ,�� �+�_ �ics, �� . � t� �"f ��� . , dX.�y�,r�.��` "'� . � ��� � ` d � � AFw -�, . y< �� �� �` ��N� ��r.��y � ,r `'�,, - �i,,,� ��; i, ' �„ � '�°�'�.. �p�`� ��, '�T f'`* � %:� s `&p�+� ti l, �',�; J e�, �• �� , � * ��' r . �'� >..� ,,,� ��w � . ��,„- d�� � � �'g-, � y ,�;✓ . '� . � A; •�RX 'I �'i�.� �}V} ,.��' �la �i- r � ""�. ,y�. � ) Y �~ +y�yr (�,f � � �,� �' �p"`� ��44 � S.,f ���r ^ , , v � � 9i sr�(f�� �aY'�'. ^�iµ ,..r � �. �t` A.'¢ ,y� . 7. �' � � y�x� � �,���#,.,, �a `r" • �;� ,a�,�.� 1'4 h � �, «r. ��� 1 ..$ ' , " - ��� ��`�^�-� � `�" , . .._. . , . �s�4 ��,� .`. �.af ' �r � ,;.;� r.. �s^ .. '� � 2'� . � k� � .. w ,�'^ ., .. .. ��xt. � . � � � �y � 5_ r . 4. �� � � '�� � '�� ��, � $ � � �f� ���� "'�s�� I ' � 'b "`�+' ��~ #�k� , k" .,.� ,e ,/�r .��� ,,.+'�.. . . i� '� � Fr r� „ �` ',.`"' ` � �`"�!°�:� � � , � r` :� � . . . s, �� � , ,- ,�� , .. . . ,,, _ ,. : !4x j , ; , , `�„ g r� «�r� 'y��,,s,�" +' ,��� '�F°�� 9 ,a . . ,> . � .,� w ��� �, � �.� . ���; ,��, � i � �$ , � � *' � � , � ( � �.,��` !# .4 )�' �'° �`, � '�T .§' E` � �t � i "� ,?P��y *� i� �� .��� ' 1��1 �µ � * �. 5�+. � � 4�' � �V . 5 �� �, t �'� �� � • � � � �i� � ,� �. 11 � ��, r �'�.�} i� � �`� �d�" �: �*� �� .�." - � �a;:'� �' �.� � �� ��� i�`�-y � (( `�,_ ` t � ,� �� �'� ��� ^.�,i �k � �l "A�'"�1 �n� ��f� *�,f �,� X A�� .�' �, � � �:`�,� � � p�� ,� �,��4 A A��+, �: 4yf '��`��' I' � 'p,�l��� t � �� � � i �` � ��T��. � ���;� � � i����. 1�. �+°�,�' ,� `t �"� � 'l�' }, � �' `r � � t � ``� � ,�`� "°� ` ' y ..,'�Q, 1wt, ����" .Jf���� � � 4 Miw . A . x y�. � �.�' �, . ?�� ' '��` c�� r� „ '' ,� �� ' ,� ` ` �� ,� �� ,;� ` ���� ��„ f Y �"t' � �!�y'�#y ` � Y' M � � < ��� � " '�� - � �"�� '� ��` �� � y � r�.- ��:. j;�. .¢ � ;� �� � � .�.,"N�+�t ,�;�. �' �':d � . ,'� �,� �'�� �'f ,� ��e{• .�, �i�l z '�� ,..� ��,�; ;w fi� t U r�```���� ��.,. i c '��t �l�+J � � �' , � 4�1� �ty'� ��. �� �3��� �'� ,�D�� ` �•��„ �,��?t�;� �� `'` '�` .,� f .^ .'��': '� �°�e' � }.,,�� � `� }�� � !� � � '+, t�,"` � �` � �� { � ' � � �� ��C 4j��}� f [ p � g l��� �•��' �I"C `!+, {*i��� . . Y� +��g R }� �y�,• �' / ', '.�� '�# � � � � '� Lwy�Q`- *�'}f��°� f �s..7 f 1���1� .�Y x�*�y�� .,, ��r ASy °� 1� ( �. °� .y �d;�"°"'��_.,,t ��, !�",p'rr ��� ����i � 'rrt��� �", * � �`L�'� � ,� � �.1 t • , � �.,�. .� y��� .,a � y>:�,t� �`a"� "'� �. �'� � T.�"�,:� ' � .� ��'"� � n�.,�'� � �� �� , , . 4 , � �'�` � �� `; a � , �;�� .�;a�#��'�, ��. �" , ��l�{;P^lP� "'--�l st� t ! .a . 4^� .«�t�' ��° '� �f'�t,* � �r� � � � . -'` � .. ��1 � ..._� r+� rt x�`� t,.� ' � '�+ °�i.rd �' ��� , ��, '�°�i� na � y, `� � �t ,,t • ;�' . .��\� .¢ ��r � � �+� . A_ '� »�i + �� �� '�.!! �t � � �..�� ''�'t � ��� �� ,�`�, ;, � `�"�r �"'� t � i �' $e. � �� a�a� ��' x � �' �t �+. +:?�'�' � �Y,-�,• �+ + ". t.,�,r *�,� +�,��.y�! S n;�l`'„�� .+s q! � � � � �' � ,�,... _ . �, ,��� ''� �,,� � <q }, ��,� � ��° �y .cs��bgr�� Y «i� '� � � .4,� ,la, � 4F��' �f� � (r�-r'��p' ni� '{� �..'���'M.�x"'h�k t r�� si��.. E �M '^} � '�. �a','c ��� g:�M k�R- � �I . 6 '� .. 4 A, �« .. �e:. yy �IM����` 1 °' ���,,j��,�f�4'r��j ��� i ����H� ".t�j� y�a:. � $�� � �.�'���,�}r •�' � ��}� ' . � �:. ��l\1 �� <.*•���d �t ��a.'"`T i��� 4.��''�� .y�S j'+ ,� � >.� f} � �{ �'+v� '^� � o, ��� as�rt,� ,�. �'at��� �,d�' � 1� � �}�� � � ��. .t��° � �� � '. 9 ����, �� R i����µ� �f � �xl 4'� * �p� ,�� ��� J�' �, µ� � ��` � r �i6 rt� " �", , - „ °.�. �' � a +t � r T `��' ��° �w��,'".�'"° �'��_ '��" �„$��� •'� �„� �y �, , � J,p� , .�j��,'.+f� � �' � . �"y�� "� (�—� � � � -�- � •` .S�,7,�"���i%t���" ��' ��V. �+;�� . ���,."!'i �,,�,� g r X � , � � " �v# � SY� �°� �a.�'i,Ft M� �"'y�' �w;Tr.� � •�p � �' ��' �� & � „� �, �� ,, � '� ' ��� '��,'�,,�'� � �, �,� �` .�,,, �� ,�� � � � ',' ��,.� ��1' ��.'�� ���'�` `!��`*� '� �y������� S �� � � �, >,,, � `� � � x�� �`� � ��`� � �, ` ���� �G ,� ���, � � �. �i� ✓""� ,�� t�� �'� $ t� � AG�' �q r��� • ��v�� . ������ � �� '�,N� gk���� { �.t1� r �,F.'1 �`�Pi @�i�.'�„J^,�� � ��' �k�1�, � y �� 4/ �4 Af� �W'!� xr��,��:-���- �Y ��� ��1+ '�' '�,l A�4 ^y.,��-�.4 '� R� � . � .:>�,� ��� ��� .. . t �Y��, ��Y rc�4'� , ' y 4 3�� �L..� }`� � � 1�' �i"' . l�r .a1 i � 't! Yi�. � !�"A�� �F�.���2�� k.�� �,$ � � 1�•�' . ��j �1"e ��r �� � �Y`°$' �eA_ '^# � }� ,p�� �j� . ` i / '-�5�'�"� + Tf��. �' F'�5 � i. 1 y� Y• ���c � �� 4 �" VR 1 � � 't ��y�� � �`, �� � !� �i��r� � � �� ^� '�"� s, ( .' � r ,�` . f y,,�1 a � l,, � � � a �y "J� � � `_< � .� q ` � tl�y� � a�4 ;+,;u i�v�t �,���Cy,t�_' �l,p ..� �+���< �, � �� �� � +, �/�$ �4''�.,�, w», S�° � n .� •'�'`" S ' � �, �s ;� r . tt1. � ?`��'� w ', ��; ".+� 1 a'���P ' ' 1� �k ,�,� r .�.' �r ��" ,� " � � ,� �� , y ti� �. f ti i P�' � ��l � �",�...� � 'r q .. s. ;� 4, .� � r a � j� `��� ���� ���� „4 �� � '� � � A� �, ` x�7� . � �'",','� � �� x' � i� � l i , � .�0�#� � ,�t�. #y� ..*r� '� ,� �.�� .a ' l a ; ✓ �' I � � a�-. . �, � �, FNy ) 4 �,'� V(`.[ �� � r � a 'e' " d � P 4}�,y i , � < � � "`4, k• �^" j x#' � � �7 itt A� { ��� � ��` � � �,`p, �1�' �'� y �� J'.1 9 � � � f ,'� ; f �� �...:T t, f � �' �,, � n, t �„, , ����[ �r�l'���� *".,�j�W�;?i ;� v"�P�' � �'4 �#�. ����{�� �' i�N, a r �r`"r�r . " '� � t. '% , • ,� r � ���,a�'��,� ���.1. ,� P � ���� �r��j�.��r��' :� �p�� . � � '+ . . g� `iXer ! i 4 ) '4 J ���y � Y� � t1" ���,�''+X#�f'�;. �,�,�+;`kPy�f�'�'tG',,���:, •�<<a _f�q. �,,' ' d. , �,�r �,�, # ' '�A. .��� * ,.j�t5�; h y� � �,�/ '� �' ��� � � � � b��4 �Y�� � � �`i�' ,�1 � ¢��i,� ,rs t � �J� t ,� ra � �'�' � #�� �, , ,�� 7C� y � �z b�.f � '� ,.,F �' �' g� � �..�, ��t . ,r " ' .P '�� ," �� 1, ' ,�Y'""' �a aT r„�..�. ��,• � � :., r , r 4�/�+� ` � � ' I�, t � �; ��.�- �..�r� >�� � ri� � �; . � ,� �� � E �'���( �'���r- Y"T�+'�k� � � �. -g �, � � � .�rfy� s, ;Ra �t `� �.�,,'�:�� , �., �e y.,'r +�' ,�3".I�� �,� p � ,�R3�•!^,i� '� � 1 � 7 � ✓ f, i �• ,� --�f ArE� � •�ny� i���, 4* .�Sj',,: •r j P r f/�" d� " �' �ti '�� k , ��t Mi�•. ,�'� �.� ,�N� �'"`,����' �s "g�" . t � , �r F��, �. x,,�+lMi� .� ^w�,� ,w�'v�. ... ��,., � �:'�t S' ' • � �` '',-•�-, ' �v "t �X � ��`� �' � � �"!►!►^ `�""��a ^�, J3' � ^� q �7 '��,�8 '�����e��`� �,,i{ , ,a �.. . 1� ' . � � � �j, �����? ��.' .,t �,.ay* �� e y� r �- � �. e. ,re s �t `l�R�4 r �Y r��p.�3� A��yt � �f"`iF��r ��= r ,#.,`§�� � a,� .�,���� � K� ��,�,� � �.' �� ,,gf x ;�a.. � . �,. � �y � � j $, i * ��'� �� 4¢ r� �A ., i x. ��.'��yq AC�Y / d ;� 1�,�� f r i� r', � d�i Y�``$ �` � '/ + �,3+, y 'M�+�.�`'+ �R�t�� '° ,� � � �:�� �•�r �`; �}''� � , �� "�y �"o ,�, ` .,�° «�.� r. .�. > „ , . +, � {�+""d'� .; L+ "� �'4"�' t ��� r . . 'alr�j, ��X. � ., � ,r F`" ,� ,� �r. ���.� � j°k•�" �° ��� r '� �,3 �3��`�� �� � �� � �, � "� � ��r �� � '� ,� � . :y';. '� ,� '{ ,� . ys � � �� �' '� � � �i� .:��'� � � � �� � $ P w �'� � ��S:;i � � � t t� , ' P n�' ���w - �+� .j° � �' ��, , *a�q . �� � t, f � � � � . ,,�� 5�� �{,.� � f �y� � a�t, %� ±` � � "� �' � n, � ` �� ,�< � ����r � �� �"�f� �� , � ,� � ,� � "�� � ��f�g#f ,'�' �� y "#;.� •�, �' � • 4 ' �� . � � �k � +� �l �i"".,, ♦f• ,j r '�1 �/�.: 4y � ffi � � ''"� ��� � ,y, �^� � y ��� !� j�,,&: '��� �.'3 . . . ��� . . ���P.r.�f�"�r����.',� �v�,,"C' �I.:�.� � �� � "�r Y��, "'�� . ��s�� t � � '�+,`$ ,.,, /�a'����c .,r T ���t .� r, I��� �✓., � ,+� �,r�, r, #��'� �,� ,�`,. . `� �"( �� �p�, r.�5ro��f���,�,�„° ' ��y �r, ��� �' �� � � � �V���% � '4� #'�r• �/ �� � �A�',a � ��, � i�} �' �� i a r ���'�y��� y��� � . + ,� �s� � . �+ �f �(,� °�i'"�*„/�"r �rx,� ��L �y !� �i f ,�g�, �j �� fi�„7'��"a� �'� � '?► r°�b� ,Y ; "�� �} � '�-, � � � F.,. ��i,4 �qt�� �r,�+ ,'�' ` '�p ' r �.•�r � . � q�•�te�t , "�. < .J;�`.,�'�� ^t �; q�s e� �+ �,� �„� . - . � y • ' > i6 i , � � � , �� , �, : _ �. < 1.11� , i�� �Yh' d�. .�, � n. < � �yr.; 11 ���L � 1r� �� �e ` .' ' �` �i'i �,.h.. , � _ ......... .. ------ -____._.. ___. Retum to: Seattle-King Counry Department of Public Health Attention:Environmental Health Enforcement Coordinator 401—Fifth Avenue,Suite 1100 Seattle,Washington 98104 CONFORIIED COPY Public He�.lth � Seattle & King Caunty 20170221000239 KC ENYIRQN HEii C 77.00 PqGE-001 OF 005 02/21/2017 11:49 NOTICE OF HEALTH CODE VIOLATION Grantor: Seattle-King County Department of Public Health, also known as Public Health—Seattle&King County Grantees: Earl A_Love and Noreen D.Love,husband and wife Legal Description(FnIl): QSTR:NE 31-23-5 LOT:25 SCOTTS TERRACE ADD Lot 25,Scott's Terrace,as per plat recorded in Volume 72 of Plats,Pages 39 and 40, Records of King County,Washington. Situate in the County of King,State of Washington. Properiy commonly known as: 17811 98th Avenue S,Renton,WA 98055 Assessor's Tax Parcel ID Number: 761680-6250-01 Y. Notice of Health Code Violation: T'he Seattle-King County Departrnent of Public Health,pursuant to Board of Health Rules and Regulations No. 7, Chaptex 1.08 of the Code of the King County Board of Health ("Health Code"),which authorizes the abatement of violations of public health rules and regulations,prescribes civil penalties,authorizes the recovery of the cost of any abatement work,provides foz the recovery of penalties and costs through the filing and foreclosure of liens, and provides for the public notification of health code violations by the filing of violarion notices,hereby causes this Notice of Health Code Violation to be filed against the above-described real property("the Property"). II. Description of the Violation and the Issuance of Notice and Order: Case Number CO 0086910 a. Unpermitted and unlawful discharge of sewage upon the ground surface at the Property,in vioIation of Health Code Section 13.04.060;and NOTTCE OF HEALTH CODE VIOLATION—PAGE 1 OF 3 Case Number C00086910 EXHIBIT� ___ b. Failure by the owner or occupant of the Property to compIy with the requirements of the King County On-site Sewage Regulations(Health Code Title 23)and the lawful orders of the Directoz of the Seattle-King County Department of Public Health("Director")to cease and abate said unlawfuI discharge before November 26,2016,as set forth in the Director's Notice and Order dated August 26,2016, and served upon the Property owner by and through the Duector's duly authorized representatives pursuant to Heaith Code Chapter 1.08. The AuAwst 26,2016 Notice and Order is attached as Exhibit"A"and incorporated herein by this reference. III. Description of Corrective Work Required: "Fhe owner or occupant of the Property is required to cause the failing onsite sewage system or system components on the Property to be lawfully repaired or upgraded as follows: (a) Desien bv on-site site sewage system(OSS)desi er or professional engineer:Obtain the services of state of Washington-licensed OOS designer or professional engineer to prepare and submit,to the Health Officer,an OSS site design application in accordance with Health Code Chapters 13.28(Design),13.64(Repairs and Remodeling),and 2.18 (Director Regulated Activities—7'itle 13 (On-Site Sewage))to repair or replace the failing OSS or system component(s)at the Property; (b) Repair bvi cert�ed master installer:Obtain the services of a King County-certified OSS master installer in accordance with Heaith Code Chapter 13.20 (Permits and Certificates) to obtain an OSS construction permit from the Health Officer and complete repairs or replacement of the failing OSS according to an approved and current site design application. An OSS construction permit from the Health Officer must be obtained before starting any work to repair or upgrade the OSS serving the Property; (c) Filine of notice on title before sale or transfer of the Propertx: Tn accordance with Health Code sections 13.Sb_054 (Notice on Title) and 13.56.005 (Operation and Mazntenance),cause a notice on title to be recorded with the Kiz�g County Recorder's Office before sale or transfer of the Property. The notice on title shall include alI of the owner's responsibilities for OSS operation and maintenance specified under Health Code section 13.56.005; (d) Operation and maintenanceperformance monitorin�inspection and report bv a licensed OSS Maintainer before sale or transfer of the Propertv:Obtain the services of a King County-licensed OSS Maintainer before selling or transferring title to the Property,in accordance with Health Code sections 13.60.030(Operation and Maintenance at Time ofSale). OSS operation and maintenance reports must be submitted to the deparnnent at the following address: Seattle-King County Deputment of Public Health Environmental Health Services Division—On-site Wastewater Program 14350 SE Eastgate Way Sellevue,WA 98007 —and— (e) Repair or renlacement of OSS if found to be failine:If the on-site sewage system is found to be in a condition of failure as described under Health Code Sections 13.08.152 (Definitions—Failure) and 13.04.060 (Failure prohibdted), the owner is required, under Health Code Title 13,to have the system repaired or replaced by a certified OSS master installer in accordance with a design prepared by a licensed OSS designer or professional engineer and appmved by the Health Officer's authorized representative, and under a permit issued by the Health Officer. NOTICE OF HEALTA CODE'VIOLATION--PAGE 2 OF 3 Case Nutnber C00086910 _ __ _ _ _ _ ____ In wiiness whereof I have hereunto set my hand this ��sr day of FE6,�v�4R y ,2017. SEATTLE-KING COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH Patty Hayes,RN MN,Director Jeff Duchin,ivID,Health Officer BY: �(/`�����Y/` . Roman V.Welyczko Environmental Health Enforcement Coozdinator STATE OF WASHINGTON) )ss COUNTY OF KING ) Roman V.Welyczko being first duIy swom on oath deposes azi d says: That he is a professional employee of the Seattle-King County Department of Public Health and as such is qualified and authorized to act on its behalf,and on its behalf,makes this verification: That he has read the above and foregoing Notice of Health Code Vioiation,knows the contents thereof and believes the same to be true and just. Given under my hand and officiai seal this�day of ,2017. MARY ALICf ALIENBAGH � Notary Pubiic State of Washington � iwy Commission explres ��/�"� /9G/Ge /4GG�I/3f�'C� July 24, 2017 . NOTARY PUBLIC in and for the State of Washington, Reszding at K�f't /th. �/—� My Commission Expires 7` L�— i / NOTICE OF HEALTH CODE VIOLA'I'ION--�AGE 3 OF 3 Case Number C00086910 _ __ . _ _ , - � . i . _ .. EXHIBI7 A Environmen�tal Flealth Services Dlvfsion . a01 Flkh qvenue,Sulte ziDO Public Heal.th.� seatqe,wA 9s1aa-zats • Seattie 8c King Couutq 206-2D5-4394 Fax 206-296-0189 "17Y ReYay:711 www.ldngmunty.gov/heahh� � . SEATTLE-KiNG COUNTY CASE NO. CO-0686910 UEPARTMENT dF PUBUC HEALTH Environmental Health Services Division NOTICE OF HEALTH CODE VIOLATION; V' CIVII.PENALTY ORbER Eari A.Love&Noreen D.Love �N�T�CE AND ORDER) . CERTIFIED MAIL NO.7009 2820 OOS 2700 7869 TO: Earl A.Love&Nordeen D.Love R�: Health Code violation(s)upon the reai prope.rty("the Property"}described befow and located at: 1781198�`Ave S • Renton,WA 98055 YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED BY THE DlREC7'OR OF THE SEATTLE-KtNG COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH("DIRECTOR")PURSUAI1tT TO CHAPTER 1.08 OF THE CODE OP THE KING COUNTY BOARD OF HEALTH(BOARD OF MEALTH RULES AND R�GULATIONS NO.7,SECTION 202),OF THE FOLLOWING VIOLAT'ION(S}: Repair of the On-site Sewage System(pS5)on the Property without a required 055 construction permit and without the supervisfon of a certified OSS master installer. Allowing the on-site sewage system on the Property Yo remain in a condition of failure due to the discharge of sewage or effluent to the ground surface or the contamination of ground water or surface water by inadequatety treated efFluent,in vfolation of BOH 13.04.060 and'13.08.152;and Failing to cause the on-site sewage system on the Pruperty to be repaired or replaced by a licensed on- site sewagesystem master installer in accordance with the requfrements of the King County Board of Health On-site Sewage Regulations,Title 23 of the Code of the King County Board of Heafth,in violation - of BOH 13.04,060 ADDRESS AND LEGAL pESCRIPTION OF LOCATION OF VIOLpTION: 1781198�'Ave S Renton,WA 98055 Tax Parcel No.7616800250 SC017S TERRACE ADD . Plat Lot:25 GODES AND SECTIONS: Code ofthe King County Board of Heaith{"BOH")Section(s) BOH 13.OS.152 Failure-defrnition BOH 13.04.060 Failure prohibited BOH 13.20.010 Permits-general BOH 13.z0.030 Instalier certification 80H 13.28.010 Appiication submittai,review approval BOH 13.64.010 Repairs of failing O55 BOH 2.18.02p Fee schedule-Fees pertaining to Titfe 13 ' THE DiRECTQR HAS DETERMIMED THAT FAILURE TO CORRCT THE V10LATIONS STATEp pBOVE WILL CAUSE IMMEDIATE AIVD IRREpqR.qg►.�HARM. . COMPLIANCE RDER—CORRECTIVE ACTION E ULRED—pENAL FOR NONC PL(ANCE: You are hereby notified and ordered by the Director to undertalce the following correcCions to bring the Property into compliance wi#h appficable code provisions: No later than Pfovember 26�' 2016 have the failing on-site sewage system.or system component lawfuliy repafred or upgraded as follows:(a) Desi n b OSS desi ner or Arofessional enEineer: Obtain the services of a State of Washington-licensed on-site sewage system designer or professional engineer to prepare and submit;to the Environmental Health Services Eastgate District Office,a 05S site design applitation in accordance with BbH NOTICE AND ORDER PAC`zE 1 OF 2 • C00086910 Chapters 13.28,13.64,and 2.18 to repair or replace the failing on-site sewage system or system component on the Property;and ' (b) Renair bv master installer:Obtain the services of King County-certified O55 master installer in accordance wit�BOH Chapter 13.20 to obtain an OSS construction permit from the : Director and complete repairs of replacement of the failing on-site sewage system or system component according to an approved and current site design application. An OSS construction permit from the Environmental Health Services Eastgate Disirict Office must be obtained before commencing any work to repair or upgrade the on-site sewage system serving the Property. CIVIL PENALTY:NOTICE OF LIEN . Failure to complete any ofthe above-described corrective action�s)on or before November 18"'.2016 will subject you to the assessment of civil penatties in the amount of$25.00 uer dav as a result of the above-described viola#ion(s). If any of the above-described corrective work is not completed in accordance with this or any supplemenYal or amended Notice and Order,the Director is authorized to abate the violation(s)by pusing the corrective work to be done and charging the costs thereof as a lien against the Property and as a joint and separete personal obligation of any person in violation. !n . the event of non-compliance,the Director will bil!you for any civil penalties assessed on account ofthe viotation(sJ. Civil penalty bills are due and payable 30days from receipt. The Director will charge any unpaid civil penalty as a lien against the Property and as a joint and separate personai obiigation of any person in violation. MISDEMEANOR• Under Heatth Code section 1.08.050,each willful or knowing violation of public heafth rules and regulations is a misdemeanor punishable by a fine notto exceed five hundred doliars{$500.00)and/or imprisonment in the county jail for a term not to exceed ninety(90)days. Each day such violation continues shall be considered an additional offense. DUTY TO NOTIFY: You have the duty to notify the Seattle-I<ing County Department af Pubiic Health,Environmental Health Senrices Division of any�actions to correct the above-described code vloiations you have taken since the receipt of fihis Notice and Order. APPEAL: Under Health Code section 1.08.140,any person aggrieved by an order of the Director as set forth above may appeaf the No#ice and Orderto the King County Hearing Examiner by filing a written appeal request with the Environmentai Health Services Administration Office,4015th Avenue,Suite 1100, Seattle,WA 98104 within ten(10)days of the service of the Notice and Order. The appeal request must refer to the IVotice anc!Order,state the decision Geing appealed and the reasons for seel<ing an appeal hearing. The appropriate for.m for appeal is enciosed,or may be obtained from the Environmental Health Services Division,Wastewater Program,14350 SE Eastgate Way,Bellevue,WA 98007,telephone(206)296-4932. DATED#his 26m day of August,2016. SEATTLE-KING COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH Patty Hayes,RN MN,Interim Director David Fleming,MD,Health Officer By: � (� � Lynn Schneid ,R.S.,Supenrisor On-site Wastewater Program Eastgate Public Health Center LS:Iw cc: Earl A.Love&Nordeen D.Love Matt Wilson,Health and Environmental Investigator Roman Welyczko,Enforcement Coordinator,Environmental Health Administration NOTICE AAID ORDER P AGE 2 OF 2 C00086910 ! Denis Law Mayor � � � . . Community&Economic Development C.E."Chip"Vincent,Administrator • • • � � ' • ' � ' • � � . ISSUED TO: DATE:06/20/2017 Monique Adams CODE CASE NO: CODE16-000518 17811 98t''Ave S Renton, WA 98055 OWNER(TAX-PAYER): Monique Adams VIOLATION ADDRESS: 17811 98th Ave 5 Renton,WA 98055 The undersigned City of Renton Code Compliance Inspector hereby certifies and states that a Warning of Violation has been provided to the named violator and the violation was not eliminated. Failure The Violator has created, permitted to exist, maintained or failed to eliminate the following violation(s): VIOLATION 1 IPMC Section 506—Sanitary Drainage System INVESTIGATION DATE: August 11, 2016 The house located at 17811 98t��Ave South is not connected to a public sewer system. On April 6, 2016, King County Environmental Health Services observed the failed sewage system. According to Matt Wilson, King County Health and Environmental Investigator 1, at that time,the on- site sewage septic system (OSS) was exposed and appeared to be in FINDINGS: failure. On February 21, 2017,the King County Department of Public Health declared the septic system a failure. The owner has not taken any steps to fix the septic system, has not applied for any building or construction permits to make the required repairs, and has not connected to an approved sewer or a City of Renton sewer utility. The septic system remains in violation. CODE VIOLATiON: Renton Municipal Code (RMC)4-5-130(A); International Property Maintenance Code (IPMC)Section 506 506.1 General. Plumbing fixtures shall be properly connected to either a public sewer system or to an approved private sewage disposal system. CODE TEXT: 506.2 Maintenance. Every plumbing stack,vent,waste and sewer(ine shall function properly and be kept free from obstructions, leaks,and _ defects. CORRECTIVE AtTION: You are hereby ordered to take immediate action to fix the broken septic system within the next ten (10) calendar days. Such action may include EXHIBIT� 1055 South G�a�ly��Jay,R�nton,L'UA 98057• rentonwa.gov Code Case No: Page 2 of 2 lanuary 25,2017 hiring a licensed contractor to make the necessary repairs and filing a complete application for a building permit, or connecting to the City sewer system. DESCRIPTION AMOUNT VIOLATION FEES: Failure to Maintain Sanitary Drainage System $250.00 • � • : • � � �� � � � � � � � � Pursuant to RMC 1-3-2(C)(2)(b),this Notice of Violation shall be a final determination that the above-listed property is in violation of the Renton Municipal Code, unless: the named Violator requests a hearing in writing, submits a written argument and/or appears at a hearing to contest the finding(s). Payment of$250.00 must be made within ten (10) days of the date of this Finding of Violation. All City codes listed on this Finding of Violation must be brought into compliance within ten (10} days of the date of this Finding of Violation. If the Violation is not corrected within that time, the City may take steps to correct the Violation(s). If the City incurs any expenses in the abatement of the Violation(s), those costs may ultimately be recorded as a lien against the property. I certify under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of Washington that I have issued this Finding of Violation on this date and at the location stated above. I certify that i believe by a preponderance of the evidence that the violator committed the above violation(s). Signed: '�_ �_�.. Date: _f_o � �(' ' � � Issued By: Rob Shuey Code Compliance Inspector (4Z5)430-7235 rshuey@rentonwa.gov ♦ ,�. � 1055 SouTF�Grady 1Afay, Renton,WA 98057 • rentonwa.gov ��� NOTICE OF RENTON MUNICIPAL CODE VIOLATION � The City has elected to establish a non-judicial hearing and determination system to enforce violations of the Renton Municipal Code.Therefore a code violation fine consistent with RMC 1-3-2 (F) is imposed, not including any costs, fees or assessments. You may respond in the following manner: I deny creating, permitting to exist, maintaining or failing to eliminate the violation(s) and I am requesting a ❑ hearing to contest this Notice of Violation. Appeal requests must be received by the Renton City Clerk's office within 10 days of the date of this Finding of Violation. Please send me a hearing date. I promise to appear on that date. The administrator must prove by a preponderance of the evidence that I committed the violation. I understand that the hearing will be held in accordance with the procedures prescribed by RMC 1-3-2(E). The administrator shall decide whether the opportunity to be heard will be in writing and/or in person. The City is not required to call witnesses to testify at the hearing. Failure to attend the scheduled hearing makes the Notice of Violation final and I may be subject to additional costs if I fail to withdraw or resolve my appeal prior to the hearing date. I also understand that the City has not waived any rights or remedies under the law. I admit that I have created,permitted to exist, maintained or failed to eliminate the violation(s)and do not need ❑ or want a hearing. Therefore, I have enclosed a check or money order [please do not send cash] in the amount of$ . I understand I am required to bring the property into compliance with the City of Renton Municipal code no later than the date noted on the attached notice of violation. I aiso understand that if compliance is not achieved within the prescribed time, I may be issued additional Findings of Violation and/or _criminally prosecuted. NSF checks will be treated_as failure to respond. PLEASE REMIT YOUR PAYMENT TO: City of Renton ATTN: Finance, 15Y Floor 1055 S. Grady Way Renton, WA 98057 PLEASE PRlNT YOUR INFORMATION BELOW: FIRST NAME MIDDLE NAME/INITIAL LAST NAME ADDRESS ��N STATE - ZIP CELI NUMBER HOME NUMBER WORK NUMBER SIGNATURE OF V10LATOR: DATE: