Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutLUA67-436 v J U • enforcement of this Chapter. A careful record of such application and plots shall be kept in the office of the building inspector or proper enforcement official. 4-725: AMENDMENTS: (a) The Council may upon proper petition or upon its own motion, after a public hearing thereon and referral to and report from the City Planning .Commission, change by ordinance the district boundary lines or zone classifications as shown on the district maps. (b) The Council may upon its own motion after public hearing and referral to and report from the City Planning Commission, amend, supplement or change by ordinance the regulations herein established. (Ord. 1472; 12-18-53) (c) A petition for a change in use district boundaries or reclassification of property shall be made by the property owner, or somebody authorized on his behalf, on forms provided by and filed with the Planning Commission. The Planning Corn-- mission shall cause an investigation to be made of the matters involved in the petition. The Commission shall then call a public hearing io hear all interested parties on said petition and three (3) notices at least ten (10) clays prior to such hearing shall be posted within or about the circa proposed to be rezoned or reclassified, Following the hearing and after consideration of the facts of the proposal and all other pertin- ent matters, the Commission shall, within thirty (30) clays make a recommendation to the Council . If the Commission, after thorough study of the proposal and the petition, determines that the reclassification or the change in use district boundaries is advisable and in the public interest and tends io further the preservation and enjoyment of any substantial property rights of the petitioner and is not materially detrimental to the public welfare or the properties of other persons located in the vicinity thereof, and is not out of harmony with the purposes and effect of the over-- all plan of the established zone classification and use district boundaries, then in such event, the Commission may recommend that the Council approve the reclassifi- cation or change in use district boundaries of said property. A filing fee of fifty dollars ($50.00) shall be paid by the petitioner upon the filing of an application for a rezoning or change in use district- boundaries. A filing fee of twenty--five dollars ( 25,00) shall be paid by a petitioner upon the filing of an application for any variance, temporary permit, conditional permit or special permit . All filing fees shall be nonrefundable and shall be used to defray the cost of posting, processing and the proceedings in connection with any such petition. The aforesaid filing fees shall riot be applicable to any governmental agency or political subdivision appearing as a petitioner. (Ord. 1920; 11-21-61 ) (1 ) if the Commission, following a public hearing, makes no decision on the petition or sends no recommendation to the Council within thirty (30) days, this may be taken as a disapproval of the petition and the ov'ner may thereupon appeal as set forth hereinafter, if the Commission reco:mniends disapproval of the 1261 -S petition, that decision shall be final unless the owner files Notice•of Appeal to the Council as specified hereinafter. Upon receiving Notice of Appeal the Council shall set a date for hearing of the subject and shall notify the parties it deems most concerned. Three (3) notices, at least ten (10) days prior to any such hearing, shall be posted within or about the area proposed to be rezoned or reclassified. Following this hearing the Council may follow the recommendation of the Com- mission or refer the subject to the Commission for their reconsideration and subse- quent report to the Council,. upon receipt of which the Council shall take final action, granting or denying reclassification, within thirty (30) days thereafter. i .. • (2) All petitions for a change of use district boundaries shall be accorn- �,- ponied by a plat in duplicate, drawn to scale, showing the actual dimensions of the tract to be changed, the size, the use and location of existing buildings and build- ings to be erected, and such other pertinent information as may be required by the Building Inspector. (Ord. 1542; 4-17-56) (3) A petition for change in use district boundaries or reclassification of property cannot be resubmitted to the Building. Inspector, Planning Commission, or the Council for period of six (6) months from the date of disapproval of such petition. • -726: COMPLETION AND RESTORATION OF EXISTING BUILD- INGS: (a) Pending Permits Valid: Nothing herein contained shall require any change in the plans, construction, designated or intended use of a building, for ,_ which a building permit has heretofore been issued, or plans for which are now on file with the Building Inspector, a permit for the erection of which is issued within - one (1 ) month after the adoption of this Code, and the construction of which in either case: - _ (1 ) Shall have begun and been.diligently prosecuted within one (1 ) month from the adoption of this Code, and; ' • (2) Be entirely completed according to such plans as filed within one (1 ) year from the adoption of this Code. -- (b) Nonconforming Uses: The lawful use of any building, structure or land existing at the time of the enactment of this Code may be continued, although such use does not conform with the provisions of this Code, provided the following con- - clitions are met: - (1 ) Unsafe structures: Nothing in this Chapter shall prevent the strengthening or restoring to a safe condition of any portion of a building or structure declared unsafe by a proper authority. 559; 1261 enforcement of this Chapter. A careful record of such application and plats shall be kept in the office of the building inspector or proper enforcement official. 4-725: AMENDMENTS: (a) The Council may upon proper petition or upon its own motion, after a public hearing thereon and referral to and report from the City Planning .Commission, change by ordinance .the district boundary lines or zone classifications as shown on the district maps. (b) The Council may upon its own motion after public hearing and referral to and report from the City Planning Commission, amend, supplement or change by ordinance the regulations herein established. (Ord. 1472; 12-18--53) (c) A petition for a change in use district boundaries or reclassification of property shall be made by the property owner, or somebody authorized on his behalf, on forms provided by and filed with the Planning Commission. The Planning Corn- mission shall cause an investigation to be made of the matters involved in the petition. The Commission shall then call a public hearing to hear all interested parties on said petition and three (3) notices at least ten (10) days prior to such hearing shall be posted within or about the area proposed to be rezoned or reclassified. Following the hearing and after consideration of the facts of the proposal and all other pertin- ent matters, the Commission shall, within thirty (30) days make a recommendation to the Council . If the Commission, after thorough study of the proposal and the petition, determines that the reclassification or the change in use district boundaries is advisable and in ihe public interest and tends to further the preservation and enjoyment of any substantial property rights of the petitioner and is not materially detrimental to the public welfare or the properties of other persons located in the vicinity thereof, and is not out of harmony with the purposes and effect of the over- all plan of the established zone classification and use district boundaries, then in such event, the Commission may recommend that the Council approve the reclassifi- cal ion or change in use district boundaries of said property. A filing fee of fifty dollars ($50.00) shall be paid by the petitioner upon the filing of an application for a rezoning or change in use district boundaries. A filing fee of twenty--five dollars ($25.00) shall be paid by a petitioner upon the filing of an application for any variance, temporary permit, conditional permit or special permit. All filing fees shall be nonrefundable and shall be used to defray the cost of posting, processing and the proceedings in connection with any such petition. The aforesaid filing fees shall not be applicable to any governmental agency or political subdivision appearing as a petitioner. (Ord. 1920; 11-21--61.) (1 ) If the Commission, following a public hearing, makes no decision on the petition or sends no recommendation to the Council within thirty (30) days, this may be taken as a disapproval of the petition and the owner may thereupon appeal as set forth hereinafter. if the Commission recommends disapproval of the 1261 • al petition, that decision shall be final unless the owner files Notice of Appeal to the Council as specified hereinafter. Upon receiving Notice of Appeal the Council shall set a date for hearing of the subject and shall notify the parties it deems most concerned, Three (3) notices, at least ten (10) days prior to any such hearing, shall be posted within or about- the area proposed to be rezoned or reclassified. Following this hearing the Council may follow the recommendation of the Com- mission or refer the subject to the Commission for their reconsideration and subse- quent report to the Council, upon receipt of which the Council shall take final action, granting or denying reclassification, within thirty (30) days thereafter. (2.) All petitions fora change of use district boundaries shall be accom- panied by a plat in duplicate, drawn to scale, showing the actual dimensions of the tract to be changed, the size, the use and location of existing buildings and build- ings to be erected, and such other pertinent information as may be required by the r - Building Inspector. (Ord. 1542; 4--17--56) ' (3) A petition for a change in use district boundaries or reclassification of property cannot be resubmitted to the Building- Inspector, Planning Commission, or the Council for a period of six (6) months from the date of disapproval of such ,'petition, 4-726: COMPLETION AND RESTORATION OF EXISTING BUILD- INGS: (a) . Pending Permits Valid: Nothing herein contained shall require any change in the plans, construction, designated or intended use of a building, for which a building permit has heretofore been issued, or plans, for which are now on - file with the Building Inspector, a permit for the erection of which is issued within . _ one (1 ) month after the adoption of this Code, and the construction of which in either case: _ (1 ) Shall have begun and been.diligently prosecuted within one (1 ) month from the adoption of this Code, and; • • (2) Be entirely completed according to such plans as filed within one (1 ) year from the adoption of this Code. (b) Nonconforming Uses: The lawful use of any building, structure or land existing at the time 'of the enactment• of this Code may be continued, although such use does not conform with the provisions of this Code, provided the following con- - ditions are met: (1 ) Unsafe structures: Nothing in this Chapter shall prevent the strengthening or restoring to a safe condition of any portion of a building or structure declared unsafe by a proper authority. 559; 1261 • • Renton Planning Commission . Meeting December 27, 1967 Minutes ' • Page 4 is narrow and on a hillside. Teegarden stated he felt it would be ,a mistake to allow an apartment 1puilding at the end of such a nar-- row street at this time. Forgaard asked when the Transamerica property to the south and west of the subject. property was rezoned to R-3. . The Planning Director replied this was done in 1963. . Transamerica has indicated it does • not plan to open access to the Renton Hill area or develop their R.-3 area at this time. Comments from the audience were invited. Mr. Jack Newell stated he is the property owner immediately east of the applicant' s property . and is definitely opposed to any multi-family residential develop- , ment .in the area; that he feels the area is an established single family residential zone. • As there were no further comments , it was moved by Stredicke, seconded by Forgaard, that the hearing be closed. Motion carried unanimously. • ACTION: Moved by Teegarden, seconded by Stredicke; that the rezone applica- tion of Albert. L. Duncalf for R-3 zoning be denied. Motion carried unanimously. The Chairman advised the applicant of his right to appeal the decision of the Planning Commission by written notice to the City Council within ten days . (c) Chenaur, Hazel W. , Appl . No. R-436-67 , rezone from R--1 to R-3; property located west- side of 116th Ave. S.E. between S.E. 110th and 112th Sts. (westerly of McKnight Jr. High School) The rezone application was described by the Chairman; and the loca- tion of the property was pointed out by the- Planning Director on the zoning map. The Planning Director indicated that access to• the property was via an undeveloped right' of way. Slides of the property were shown. Photographs of the property submitted by the applicant were passed around among the Commissioners . The Planning. Director stated that in 1956 the property was zoned R-3, but as it was not developed it reverted back to R--1 status under a reversion ordinance in effect at that time. • The Chairman read a petition against the rezone submitted by property owners in the area and bearing 20 signatures . • The Planning Director stated that the existing Comprehensive Plan indicates this area as low to medium density multi-family resi- dential, but that the revised Comprehensive Plan now under study • by the City Council cuts this area back to single family residential. Comments from the audience were invited. Mr. Roger Peterson, 10514 - 113th Ave. S.E. , owner of property westerly of subject property, voiced his objections to the proposed rezone. • Mr. George Rusk, 11029 - 116th Ave. S .E, , stated he owns a house north of 110th which he had purchased with the stipulation the area was R-1, but had found out later that a portion of land nearby was . zoned R-3 upon which two apartment houses have been constructed. • • • &.r • • Renton Planning Commission • Meeting December 27 , 1967 Minutes , Page 5 . . • • • Mr. Rusk stated he was opposed to further apartment development in • the area. Mr. , Robert Hall of Seattle identified himself as attorney for the applicant, Mrs. Chenaur, and gave a brief history of the property �- in question. He stated that his client is asking for the zoning which had previously been granted and which had been lost due to the reversion ordinance then in effect which has since been' re--- pealed. He discussed the undeveloped, access road about which there . appeared. to be some title cloud. . Mr. Hall stated this undeveloped. access according to all information he has been able to get belongs to the City of Renton. He stated the rezone is a logical one; would have no effect on the single family residential area known as Hill-- crest Lane directly to the west as those houses are- below his client' s property and face away from it. He stated further that . cost of development of the property makes it economically unfeasible for anything but multi-family residential use. • • Mr. Bob Harris , 10843 - 116th Ave. S.E. spoke in opposition to ' the rezone due to the immediate proximity of $20 , 000 to ' $40 , 000 homes . • Mr . Jerome Stephenson, 11430 S.E. 112th St. , .asked• how sewer lines could be connected to the property. The Planning Director displayed a sanitary sewer and water lines map for the area, and stated that due to the elevation the developer could get sewers only through the west side of the property by obtaining easements through ad- • jacent properties. He stated further that there are sewer lines along 116th Ave. S.E. but they could not go easterly due to the elevation unless some sort of pumping system was installed. • Mr. Clayton Chenaur discussed the history of the property; the fact that he thought he had the proper zoning, being unaware of the • reversion to R-1 ; . the access problem, the development of sewers , the cost of development being too high for other than multi-family use. ' He stated that the development would be adequately served by sewers and would be screened to protect adjacent residences. ' He urged the Commission to grant the rezone. Stredicke stated that the area, notwithstanding the two existing apartments , has been developed for single family use and he would not be in favor of rezoning for multiple use. • Messrs . Stephenson, Peterson, Rusk, and Harris , previously acknowledged, spoke again in protest against the rezone, as well as Mr. Ronald Wy- let of 11020 - 115th Ave. S.E. Mr. Robert Hall and Mr. Clayton Chenaur spoke again on behalf of the rezone request. • • There being no further comments , . it was, moved by Stredicke, seconded by Teegarden, that the hearing be closed. Motion carried unanimously. 71 ACTION: .i Moved by .Stredicke, seconded by Brower, that the application of Hazel N. Chenaur for rezone from R--1 to R-3 be denied. Motion carried unanimously. Further moved by Stredicke, seconded by Teegarden, that a communica- tion be sent to the City Council recommending_ that the hiahest use of this property be R--i as presently zoned. Motion carried unani mously. Renton Planning Commission • Meeting December 27 , 1967 Minutes Page 6 • • • The Chairman advised the applicant ' s attorney of her right of . appeal of the Planning Commission decision by letter to the City Council within ten days._ Mrs. Hall stated he understood the appeal rights of his client. 5. ADMINISTRATIVE MATTERS • REFERRAL FROM RENTON BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT • (a) Albert Balch and Garden Park, Inc. , request for variance from height limitation. The Chairman stated 'that the Board of Adjustment had referred the above variance application to the Planning Commission and referred the Commissioners to copies of Board of Adjustment Minutes as well as copy of letter from the FAA relative to the matter; such copies in each Commissioner' s folder. ACTION: Moved by Brower, seconded by Racanello, that this matter be con- sidered at the next Administrative Meeting of the Renton Planning • Commission in order to give the Commission time to study the material submitted. Motion carried unanimously. STREET NAME PROBLEM • (b) The Chairman read a letter from Fire Chief M. C. Walls concern- ` ing duplication of street name in Thunder Hill #2 , parcel #26 . The Planning Director stated that this particular street (Thomas Lane) is privately owned and the City has no control over it. He sug- gested the Commission might wish to refer the matter to the Board of Public Works for their review. ACTION: Moved by Stredicke, seconded by Racanello, that a copy of Fire Chief Walls ' letter be sent to the Mayor' s office and to the Board of Public Works for their action. Motion carried unanimously. . APPOINTMENT OF NEW PLANNING COMMISSION MEMBER • (c) The Chairman read copy of a letter from Mayor D. W.. Custer to the City Council appointing Mr. Tony Mola as a member of the Renton Planning Commission to fill the vacancy created by the resignation of Mr. Stanley Stone and requesting concurrence of the Council in this appointment. • RESIGNATION OF PLANNING COMMISSION MEMBER • (d)- Mr. Robert Brower announced that regretfu1ly. this would be his last meeting with the Planning Commission as he had been recalled to active duty with the United States Navy, and stated it. had been a privilege to serve bpi the Commission. SITE PLAN APPROVAL (Request for Information) (e) Stredicke asked if site plans had been submitted for the approval of the Planning Commission for the church located at 7th and M. The Planning Director replied that this church had submitted their site plans as well as a variance request for parking and had received approval of the site plans on March 28 , 1962 . He stated • • :l:jit1utes - Renton City Council Meeting (Cont.) 2-5-68 r,ayor Custer introduced a group of students from Renton High School Boys Club who are attending the Council meeting in participation of Student Government Week. Attendance on a voluntary basis included about 25 youths who will also be coming to City.Hall during the coming week for two hours daily to observe operation of various departments. A mock City Council meeting will be conducted by the group on Saturday, February 10th, between 10:00 a.m. and noon and Councilmen and Depart- ment Heads were invited to attend. P3 LIC HEARING: Hazel W. Chenaur appeal of R-3 rezone denial on property located on the West side of 116th Avenue S.E. between S.E. 110th and S .E. 112th Streets. V This being the date set, the hearing was declared open. Letter from Planning Director Erickson reported Planning Commission recommendation that,since detrimental effects could be anticipated arid such rezone not being in the best interest of the surrounding residential area, R-1 be considered the best and highest use for this property. Petition containing approximately 20 signatures was attached objecting to the rezone which document had been submitted to the Planning Commission. Mr. Robert Hall, 419 Securities Building, Seattle, Attorney representing Mrs. Chenaur, stated that the proposed use is felt to be the fullest and best for the property noting the proximity of other multiple dwellings in the immediate vicinity and apartment directly behind the proposed development. He added that such housing is greatly needed, that the plans meet with the presently existing Comprehensive Plan and that the property had once been rezoned to R-3 but reverting according to an ordinance which had a one year construction commencement provision, since repealed. Topography of the area was outlined with embankment division from singly family area being noted and Attorney Hall stated developers would be able to furnish parking as required and would be willing to work out any further matters required or desirable. Film slides were shown by the Planning Director after which Councilman Shane . inquired regarding apparent drainage problems noted when visiting the site and also in regard to sewering the area. Planning Director Ericksen advised that all such details have to be worked out prior to occupancy of the premises and all Departments concerned must approve the particular portion of the proposal which is under their jurisdiction. Discussion ensued regarding conformancy of procedures on various applications submitted and Planning Director Ericksen noted that the Commissions actions are uniform and on the basis of the Comprehensive standpoint. Specific detrimental effects were noted to be traffic congestion and loss of privacy to individual property owners on the lower sites. The Planning Director noted the project does not meet with the proposed Comprehensive P1m .gloved by Morris, seconded by Edwards that the hearing be closed. Carried. Moved by Morris, seconded by Perry, that the appeal be denied in concurrence with the Planning Commission recommendation that R-1 is the best and highest use for the property. A dissenting voice vote brought request for roll call which resulted as follows: Aye: Morris, Schellert, Delaurenti, Perry, Trim, Edwards, Maxin and Bruce. No: Garrett, Grant, Shane and Barei. The motion carried denying the appeal. C0;u 1UN ICAT IONS: Application from Mr. Robert H. Schlosser, Mgr.,Cougar Den, 219 Main Avenue South, requested that Mutual Amusement Company be granted required license to operate an additional pinball device at said business location. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to refer the matter to the Police and License Committee with power to acts, whLch:•carried after.:inquiry regarding the legality of pinball machines and their comparison to punch boards. Discussion ensued wherein the City :Attorney advised of Supreme Court ruling, based upon Attorney General's Opinion that they are both gaming devices and where chance predominates over skill the activity is outlawed and illegal with the three elements under which court decisions are determined being 1. consideration is paid to participate; 2. must be some kind of reward; 3. element of uncertainty exists. In further discussion City Attorney Shellan stated the City has a right, which goes back to common rule law, to license under its police power and can im- pose a license or regulatory fee. Councilman Shane felt the pinball and punch board devices should be treated equally and moved, with second by Schellert, that if pinballs are illegal they be taken out tomorrow. It was subsequently moved by Morris, seconded by Bruce, to refer the matter to the Law and Ordinance Committee to report back. Moved by Barei, seconded by Perry, to table the matter. Carried. Letter from Vern Church, Purchasing Agent, reported that specifications are now prepared and requested permission to call for bids for equipment which has been provided for in the 1968 budget, February 26th was recommended as the bid opening date. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to concur in the request and recommended bid opening date. Discussion ensued regarding the City maintenance program for city streets and the • possibility of contracting such work. It was noted that cities usually do their own Maintenance, and after further discussion regarding operation of the city equipment, budget, and departmental administration, question was called for on the pending motion to poncur in the bid call and opening date and the motion carried. -9- Minute's - Renton City Council Meeting 2-19-68 'COMMUNICATIONS : (Cont.) Letter from Jack Wilson, City Engineer, submitted. statement in sum of $383.88 due Cornell, Howland, Hayes and Herr_yfield for work in connection with Well No. .8 to January 24, 1968. Approval for payment was recommended. Moved by Morris, seconded by Bruce, to refer the payment to the Auditing and Accounting Committee with power to act. Carried. Claim submitted by Donna and Rodney Stewart was read requesting reimbursement of $49.87 for damage to water tank elements when water was shut off and water drained out of the tank. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to refer the Claim to the City Attorney and Insurance Carrier. Carried. Document from Robert J. Hall, Attorney for Mrs. Hazel W. Chenaur, requested Council reconsideration of rezone denial noting grievance that all evidence had not been presented at the hearing, particularly exhibit of photographs and color slides as shown to the Planning Commission. Moved by Perry, seconded by Schellert, that the Council reconsider its action of the prior meeting as requested. Carried. Moved by Perry, seconded by Garrett, to refer the matter of the rezone to the Planning Committee to report back. Carried. Letter from Renton School District 403, Rudolph Seppi, Director of Plant 'Facilities, requested approval from the City for service to the new. Earlington Elementary School, to be located at South 132nd Street and Langston Road, King County, by the sanitary sewer system of the City, costs to be the School Districts and Late Comers Agreement to be allowed for recovery or portion of the cost. Moved by Garrett, seconded by • Morris, to grant the request with referral to the Law and Ordinance Committee to prepare the necessary documents. Councilman Barei reported that the Sanitation Committee has a recommendation for approval of this request. The motion carried. Letter from Mr. Ray Van Hollebeke, Property Management, The Boeing Company, requested permission to install a 12,000 gallon propane gas tank on property located in area North of 6th Avenue North, now under lease from the City. Drawing attached indicated the location of the tank and piping. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Bruce, to refer the request to the Property Committee for recommendation. (Fire Chief and City Engineer to be consulted) Carried. Letter from John E. Iverson, Attorney, petitioned, on behalf of Mr. and Mrs. Roger A. Hokanson, for consent to transfer and sale of their interest in the Renton Radio Cab Co., Inc. New owners are individual holders of For-Hire Licenses and will contin'.ie to operate as drivers and include: Phillip A. Schmolke, present owner, Gerald Halstead, present owner, and Michael Craig, 10931 S.E. 164th Street, Renton.. Moved by Perry, seconded by Garrett, to refer the matter to the Police and License Committee for recommendation. Carried. Letter from Jack Wilson, City Engineer, reported that the letter of intent to annex property.to Renton which ad'oins Sunset Blvd. E., between 132nd Ave. S.E. and 138th Ave. S.E. is signed by owners representing 84.74% of the assessed valuation of the property, which is located on both sided of the highway and contains approximately 13.6 acres with an assessed valuation of $15,600.00. Annexation would make the City Limits more uniform in this area. The petitioners are Alhoff, Smith & Beale and the matter has been referred to the Boundary Review Board. • Letter from Sven A. Johnson, Building Director, recommended that Revocable Sign Permit be issued for sign encroachment of public right-of-way for Montgomery Ward & Co. at 319 Williams Avenue South. Moved by Perry, seconded by Barei, to concur in the recommendation. Carried. Letter from Building Director Johnson recommended that Revokable Sign Permit be granted upon revised application of Dr. Hurley at 9112 South 3rd Street, since original sign was installed to different plans than submitted. Moved by Perry, seconded by Trimm, to concur in the recommendation of the Building Director. Carried. Letter from W.E. Bennett, Utility Accountant, submitted proposed Agreement between the City and Fire District No. 25 regarding obligation and responsibility for fire hydrant:maintenance and inspection, and consideration to be paid the City of Renton therefor. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Edwards to authorize and approve the execution. Moved by Perry, seconded by Grant to refer the document to the Fire and Water Committee for recommendation. Carried. -2- • • Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting 2-19-68. Remarks: • Councilman Maxin announced a meeting of the Planning Committee at 9:00 a.m. on Saturday, February 24, 1968. Councilman Barei requested that the Janitor oil the Chairs-around the Council table to reduce the noise. Councilman Perry noted that the tables had been removed which had been used by the City Attorney and the Press and suggested they be replaced. Mr. Robert Hall, Attorney for Mrs. Chenauer addressed the Council advising that he had been mistaken regarding photographs which were submitted to the Council on the matter. and offered apology to Planning Director Ericksen noting however, that • t•:ultiple zoning is the only feasible use for the subject property and that it is economically impossible to develop the area as R-1. After further comments in regard to the subject property Mr. Hall was advised that the matter was now in the Planning Committee which would be meeting at 9:00 a.m. tomorrow at which time his remarks might properly be addressed the Committee. As there was no further business to come before the Council, it was moved by Trimm, seconded by Schellert, to adjourn. The motion carried, and the meeting was adjourned at 12:05 p.m. Helmie Nelson, City Clerk 1).. W. CL"meter, Mayor • • • • -P Minu: ds Rentn City Council Meeting 2-26--63 COUNCIL COMIIITTEE, REPORTS: (Cont.) 'unfinished Business Councilman Maxin, Chairman of the Planning Committee, submitted report recommending that requests of C. K. Mullins and F.E. Lawrence for zoning revisions to the Compre- hensive Plan, be referred to the Planning Commission for recommendations: Moved by Schellert, seconded by Maxin, to concur in the recommendation. Carried. R•econm nded that appeal of Hazel Chenaur be allowed and R-2 zoning be granted on the cubject. property, owner agreeing to amend her application as discussed with Attorney Hall .on her behalf. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Grant, to concur in the rezone as recommended. Carried. Councilman Maxin announced a meeting of the Planning Committee on Wednesday, February at 7:00 p.m. Councilman Bruce, Chairman, Fire and Water Committee, submitted recommendation that the firm of Corneli,Iowland, Hayes and Merryfield be retained for the design and preparation of plans and specifications for Well No. 8, and that.the Mayor and City Clerk be authorized to sign the necessary agreement documents, upon approval thereof by the City Attorney. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Shane, to concur. Carried. The Fire and Water Committee recommended that the Agreement between the City and Fire District No. 25 for hydrant service and water supply be approved and the Mayor and City Clerk be authorized to sign the document. Moved by. Barei, seconded by Schellert, to concur. Carried. The Public Relations Committee met regarding the request of Local 21R, Washington ..te Council of County and City Employees, AFL-CIO for Council acknowledgment and it was recommended that the Department of Labor and Industries conduct a check for certification purposes as provided by law. Moved by Morris, seconded by Garrett to concur. Carried. .',ounailman Grant, Chairman of the Light and Power Committee reported that a formal request has been made of Mr. John Nelson, or a representative of Seattle City Light, to appear at a public hearing of the Light and Power Committee to discuss proposed franchise and power rates within the City, date for hearing to be determined. !±'_co, the Light and Power Committee submitted a proposed Resolution resolving that t-ee interests of the City would be best served by employing a Consultant to provide :ate analysis and technical assistance in-rcCard to_power problems, The-servic's to b' .._red sits. a ,:tud; of power supply and rates were.butlined with areas'to be ana1yze.a ::resin. the City' and .Pcget Power ma/work together to improve the City with. regard to itc7a of mutual concern, the studies to be coordinated with the Traffic Engineering '-partment. The Light and Power Committee will interview Consulting Firms and made cl recommendation as to the firm to conduct the study and shall report cost for such study, and at a future date, report the findings to the Council. Moved by Morris, seconded by Maxin, to concur in the proposed Resolution. Councilman Grant moved that his minority report be incorporated as item 3. of the Resolution that: In evant the City is unable to resolve the study areas to its satisfaction, the consulting firm be directed to analyze the means whereby the City could develop its own power distribution system, join with another public power utility (Seattle City Light) or public utility district. The motion to amend the original Resolution was seconded by Barei,and after discussion and dissenting voice vote roll call was requested which resulted as follows: Aye: Garrett, Perry, Bruce, Grant, Shane and Barei. No: Morris, Schellert, Trimm and Maxin. The amendment carried and subsequently the original motion approving fhe three resolution ,prolascan, Moved by Schellert, seconded by Trimm, to adjourn. Dissenting voice vote brought roll call request which was taken as follows: Aye: Barei, Maxin, Trimm. No: Garrett, Shane, Grant, Bruce, Perry, Schellert and Morris. The meeting moved to the next order of business. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Grant that the meeting be adjourned at 12:45 p.m. Carried. Councilman Grant inquired regarding the status of the request for clog control in the Highlands area. It was noted that the matter is in Committee and a study will be made and report submitted upon completion. • Councilman Grant reported a request from property owners that the vacant property to the East of 509 Tobin Avenue South be cleaned up and shrubbery cut as the litter is piling up and attention is needed. Mayor Custer advised that the owner has re- moved a house from the lot and further attention will be given the matters reported. -7- 7tieetA7 Ata4/ ,i(td/g77L/ 6c-ef7 4' () l& V Le_x enforcement of this Chapter. A careful record of such application and plats shall be kept in the office of the building inspector or proper enforcement official. 4-725: AMENDMENTS: (a) The Council may upon proper petition or upon its own motion, after a public hearing thereon and referral to and report from the City Planning :Commission, change by ordinance the district boundary lines or zone classifications as shown on the district maps. (b) The Council may upon its own motion after public hearing and referral to and report from the City Planning Commission, amend, supplement or change by ordinance the regulations herein established. (Ord. 1472; 12-18-53) (c) A petition for a change in use district boundaries or reclassification of property shall be made by the property owner, or somebody authorized on his behalf, on forms provided by and filed with the Planning Commission. The Planning Corn- mission shall cause cm investigation to be made of the matters involved in the petition. The Commission shall then call a public hearing to hear all interested parties on said petition and three (3) notices at least ten (10) days prior to such hearing shall be posted within or about the area proposed to be rezoned or reclassified, Following the hearing and after consideration of the facts of the proposal and all other pertin- ent matters, the Commission shall, within thirty (30) clays make a recommendation to the Council . If the Commission, after thorough study of the proposal and the petition, determines that the reclassification or the change in use district boundaries is advisable and in the public interest and tends to further the preservation and enjoyment of any substantial property rights of the petitioner and is not materially detrimental to the public welfare or the properties of other persons located in the vicinity thereof, and is not out of harmony with the purposes and effect of the over- all plan of the established zone classification and use district boundaries, then in such event, the Commission may recommend that the Council approve the reclassifi- cation or change in use district boundaries of said property. A filing fee of fifty dollars ($50.00) shall be paid by the petitioner upon the filing of an application for a rezoning or change in use district boundaries. A filing fee of twenty--five dollars ($25.00) shall be paid by a petitioner upon the filing of an application for any variance, temporary permit, conditional permit or special permit. • All filing fees shall be nonrefundable and shall be used to defray the cost of posting, processing and the proceedings in connection with any such petition. The aforesaid filing fees shall not be applicable to any governmental agency or political subdivision appearing as a petitioner. (Ord. 1920; 11-21-61 ) (1 ) If the Commission, following a public hearing, makes no decision on the petition or sends no recommendation to the Council within thirty (30) days, this may be taken as a disapproval of the petition and the owner may thereupon appeal as set forth hereinafter. If the Commission recommends disapproval of the 1261 enforcement of this Chapter. A careful record of such application and plats shall be kept in the office of the building inspector or proper enforcement official. 4-725: AMENDMENTS: (a) The Council may upon proper petition or upon its own motion, after a public hearing thereon and referral to and report from the City Planning _Commission, change by ordinance the district boundary Iines or zone classifications as shown on the district maps. (b) The Council may upon its own motion after public hearing and referral to and report from the City Planning Commission, amend, supplement or change by ordinance the regulations herein established. (Ord. 1472; 12-18-53) (c) A petition for a change in use district boundaries or reclassification of property shall be made by the property owner, or somebody authorized on his behalf, on forms provided by and filed with the Planning Commission. The Planning Com- mission shall cause an investigation to be made of the matters involved in the petition. The Commission shall then call a public hearing to hear all interested parties on said petition and three (3) notices at least ten (10) days prior to such hearing shall be posted within or about the area proposed to be rezoned or reclassified, Following the hearing and after consideration of the facts of the proposal and all other pertin- ent matters, the Commission shall, within thirty (30) days make a recommendation to the Council. If the Commission, after thorough study of the proposal and the petition, determines that the reclassification or the change in use district boundaries is advisable and in the public interest and lends to further the preservation and enioymerit of any substantial property rights of the petitioner and is not materially detrimental to the public welfare or the properties of other persons located in the vicinity thereof, and is not out of harmony with the purposes and effect of the over- all plan of the established zone classification and use district boundaries, then in such event, the Commission may recommend that the Council approve the reclassifi- cation or change in use district boundaries of said property. A filing fee of fifty dollars ($50.00) shall be paid by the petitioner upon the filing of an application for a rezoning or change in use district• boundaries, A filing fee of twenty--five dollars ($25.00) shall be paid by a petitioner upon the filing of an application for any variance, temporary permit, conditional permit or special permit. All filing fees shall be nonrefundable and shall be used to defray the cost of posting, processing and the proceedings in connection with any such petition. The aforesaid filing fees shall not be applicable to any governmental agency or political subdivision appearing as a petitioner. (Ord. 1920; 11-21-61 ) (1 ) If the Commission, following a public hearing, makes no decision on the petition or sends no recommendation to the Council within thirty (30) days, this may be taken as a disapproval of the petition and the owner may thereupon appeal as set forth hereinafter. If the Commission recommends disapproval of the 1261 - . . . . ... . . , . . . . • . . . • • ----y-•.- • • I • / ...:----- . . • i • • , . - .2 WA 4.2. --) . • 0 cp1:1-'t . - • 74.-Z4-7-7-T41-. ... '• I ._...J. X' ., /• ' c72.15,X c-:-.., • . . . . . . l \._,. .1 -.1 .;--'''' .',:c . ••-••— (• --: .:7-. /4 . • • - . 1 . •N ,-'\`!',.;i-,.1) -'‘ i.e., ,-., . • 1 ,,.. .;...- ---- - . • . . . . 1 . ,,,• s.,,,,• lc.lcn , 4:\ . . . • • . r , . . . - 2. . ' .------ '' • - • ,`:r..l1,.:.4..„,-):,.•-.•;.....,( •.,›". t-r r• -..,1-,)‘.••-.-)• • . 1 C3 v - ll . . 4 . . •: .,....,. 1,/,',-) ':. . • . s-Z:,:.;...1';•• \D.' 5 • -.)--•',,-, 47 • • =6'...;.-.1— . 6. . . . . 7 • . • . . . . . 8 • IN THE SUPERIOR COURT or THE STATE or WASHINGTON . . 9 IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF IMIG 10 ROBERT E. jONT:S and DIANA N JONI:I:Ss his wife; et al: ) , 11 1 • . 0 •='`.:;','::. -",•1.,, :3. PlaintifEo : ) NO. 12, . ) ye ) • • •, (, • - - ,-.,1-: . 13 ) ORD17.:T•i. TO SI-10c-I• CAUSE; I CITY CI-i-' RINTON v a munici-oal CD.r.,- ) 1,4 po-,7al-i.on; and HAZEL W. CHEI-TA1JR; ) . .;. a v.q-ido ) 15' ) . . Dsfendants, . . . 16 ) . • 17 THIS MATTER having come on rtguirly fo.e., hearing br.)foro • 18 til urideroigned judge of the above entitled court up3n the plain- . 19 tif:Vs motion for &xi ord :o 2.,equiring -te-e dc:fendants to appem..--ant3. 20 show e-aUSCD ttr,". court havin read .th..e files - and records her-ein: 21 and the a u ffidavIt in- upport of said motion: and boIng fully ad- . 22 visod in the p.:oomisos: noll therftires, 23 IT IS HER:El:1Y ORDERED tat the dcfendant.:,: be zInd a.Dpaa.f, 24 e •.,----•••:,7.,1 -"!, ...„:-.; s•-.--:'i• .:-., b -•.!f or::.: t h c Ho n„ .rr,.:1.nk D, LT a.M'a S 5 V_d,,i-.,,;.:.' r.',.2.5.'.-±1.,c! •T:?.1)o v,•::.:,..-,::Syi:5.1:let O. C o k.i r-:.: •; ' .:::,:: •: :f. -1:::-.3.., 25 in hiscP1-1:i.'trof.',mg '-„Pocm 0' . 1!212- -Dcv,I.,,,,I.:i-c:c3.nt 5 ,-.1-:i.- Cf...inty Courtho . • .. --. .26 Se.;.!..ttle.:r. Washj..p.1-11:2n:- on,:t1',e - lit1 of rcl.:,r,. .:.,ys, 196f.,.! s. iit the. 'hour, .::.,7, ,., ,;:.-:: :,:z '....-::.-:...•-.; -:.-• .1..,.: :::: • .. .•:.....,• .. . ..,-..„ i:-.:)':11 L:, . 27 of d .t1.0-,:.pa to• sho,:;- fsv......uf,:e , .if. 11F.').,./o.; . .. ,- -• ) . 28 :Thy Iff:':37 .2 1:.e Il 2. ). r;o':.: br:: •:.'.o .:•;:',z.J.:7.nc!d frc.•;:t. co::,,,t::!;,n,."...:3.71;`,"; Vi-1,-i!)1- t,..i1C .. .. • . . : " . . .• • , •• 29 re..,,,onInganci ..J.--,..)-(-,5.. . -I.S.t... w.'1. 13 -any .builrlinr:, ( t'..1-.-5its66 -t1.1al-,. cc::, 4,7.-1 L :.: : ---..': ' ,:.;A,,',N.:.-2,'. •:.::::_!:::....-.3 ' :,;. . 30 1:::-•.t. ol a 1-;C 5..::"5.c-?.-1:I r:71 'C.!7:-1:1-11:: l'.1.,'..-07'111.(3 C a,; .: ' %N. • ;;, .. 1,, .'• , t 31 ----•::.•3)6T-,F7:3:1 T ';"`,1--,..i-:1:::. C()T'r-"'t..' 1:.-1.: "'•'-) i''' 'z.'i(".y o:.. t..17.:,.in.... /,., a(1 C C; "‘, l'. i 4 1 t y •; ed by! • ;...c. .•.) . • c---..:.-....--.,.,----n • 1- ' :1-:• , ,-, , , . , .: -,:.,., I 3 6 .A., . :,1.,--,(:.-1 ATTORNEYS AT I.J.W i i 111 WILLIA•IS AVI:NUr.SOLIT:1-P.O.1- : i Aq-J-.G.,-...--..y,-. : PiLl!ntf.,Jra, a rit-rroN.WM3}i;NGTON E'S3:,'S i CA G•1n,3o • • • • • :, • • i. 3 4 • • • • 7 • • 8 • IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF. THE STATE F WM1 S: , TON 9 1.?i AND FOP, THE coU:•i` i" OF • 10 ROBERT. 1.3. tl O(_.ES and mi:ANA ) • • 3 a'�".S"�to£ his wife; L ON S ot�," a ) t^j y hr�.-�"j; • . 12 `�.Z•I,,5.6'I•i.r. .�.1'Jd ) �'t O. 4-..ass.sr zo�..sa-:'_....._..•. .r;�o�sc•,- m V 8 ) , • 13 ) CITY or RE1 lira Q' C'. I:un C?i )%9_ ) MOTION AND' AFFIDAVIT .;+r,ation'e and yZ 1 W. !iy] .y ) FOR l.l•.:ii'! \ TO SHOW AU •. a j i°, rj ..y v J 17 COME NOW he tilt ffs ?hovo' . ° Op -• i.: � c, t TiE�.,. �^-.Cl 8 the c:ou -L for an Clc.'C :, fshow r;i_LL�•'�.�. �„i_„I Lo C� the / - f y ++ :J. to £) 3� ii C. t: ! to�:J the �•S.C...C.'.1 Z11 C?.�S L�.�� to-,,NAn s This motion o based upon t ha filc,:s and ..'ocoy�9ds he `a Fo 20 and upon tho l f_I.dav:4. of the plaintiff noi.f;].rC, E. V7onor; oo 1. forth 21 L21✓f.?o • 22 ,O ,ERTS ANDERSON 27 °.t 24 • 25 r, .,•., O ) I)' 26 ( co;_t.,:A]Y or KIUG 3 • • 21 ! PO:'E.a.T E. )ONES:, _ r,; r duly L • y i i C; F Cl oath a Ca ?i ; - . • 28 / • 29 That 3?`F `s ono, of tho abo o ni•:;,;o J and 30 �•t3 vci ?.f:.1"..'. 'L:`..<;al for, and on b ha.._f of i.111 31 is is .t'.:E.C: and the co.':pD..-.._i:•t on .Lilo hcfy'i::.n and by .t., 'co.''f:u. a.t,.,J thc c_.�..-C" ? 1: , ' V),. . �: _ ` . , ` � 1. .�: -l., c'CJ ilC,i ;i; Il .lL'� ,�_�� iE.: l, + �J' .i t I'.onEri-rs 8: AF;D1:r:soN ATTC]P.N EYE;AT • �. ,. , ttt Wfu_tr.r:s Av::;:ur.sou • r'NTON, w,'. ;Nr1:CiON DCOP !; ] „ ..'i':. r': � :,-� ,._ ;': ! .,, _. . I - , . . • . . . . : . .--..:' .. '.. ..- : ..:. ' • : . . . . . . • •. ' . . . . . . . . , .. ._ .. . . .. . . . • ' , . ----„_, • .- • I. -__ . ' . • . I ‘ . . . I . • . . . . .- . . . . . . . . . . • • .. . „ • , 1 - That the City of Ronton . defendant he..7eins, 12 in 11101 -: . . 2 tion of the City Cock. of Renton by- veson of the fac .ths plain- 5 tiffs wore not given notice of any action by the City coil of . 4 .Renton prio.,o to the graning of -the R-2-classification; that if - . • 5 the defendant Hazel W. Chenaul, is pQ.naitted to build an .:a"pai-tment -. 6 • sty,uctue on the p...oemises in question:3 ; this will result in irra- 7 pb20 dam.as.a to the plai-iltiffs by reanon 'of loss of .proprty . . 8 valuei, lo3s of privacy ; overcrowding of the land; and additional 9 wate dvainage poblms. 10 ' That the. plaintifft3 desire- to have this court L'... ...me an 11 wr)de..t., requiving the defendants to appeal-, and show cause on the. 12 vatur,n date specified in id order as to why they should not be • 13 ret-ained free continuing with the invalid rezoning as is evi-. . . • 14 denticr planned; and restrained frora Issuing any building periaits 15 other-than for 'an R . classification on the prcrAises. , -. 16 17 . 'T'V.-,,-, -,3• 17,,,,: „1,...„.,,,. ._.i Eu.bo:ot J-,:. Oonc..io 18 . . 19 ' SUK;CRIBr,D & SWORN to core ue this nst day of .Januay2 1969. 20 , • MaRT L AikT)1-.--1 1 21 , • -- - ,..- 1 : 22 Ot V:it.i.shingtons, ruliding at • • 23 . • - . • , . . • 24 . . • . 25 • 26 • . . 27 • . . 28 . . 29 . 30 . . . . . . 31 • . . 32 . . . • . ROBEFM3 & MDERSON AVM M,1 E 1'F.M.LAW ' III 1,m.LA M I -.A wrn 1..,E i•7 0 t.i 1 1-P.O.fox 4:-.4 ‘.. 0(:'ir:N F 2d717),!:.:IT .. RENTON,WASIM:GT07,1 !:MOI35 YC.)"..'?. C-,r..12.);.-„R T.JI . SHO'.7 Cf,1_11: - P -,-..1 2 • LA 1, . , . . 1 • • • • • • (Copy-Receipt) (Clerk's Date Stamp) • IN TEE SUPERIOR COURT OF-THE .STATE E '. WA5 T NG T ON • IN AND FORT � COUNTYOF _ K:c NG ---- -- • ROBERw E. JONES and DIA_?A JONES, .his ;life ; ROGER A. PF,TERSOli and PATRICIA • P:[r'�T_•t S tt e GARTH 7 } •. r L�1t+l\i�,ls! y �i.t�.) C'!�..t,C 9 I 11. 11 S6 SpV �1 S..p11J and BT T 1 '" PO�'WE T 1 ' wife;e; RONA.,D Ro J...rKC. � L•I;�, 7.��) WYI_ET i.'.n'$ :ili I RIE WYLET. q his wife; ( ,� r ND`�'•< i;:iCa D }f?rc' I ]�'? �liDER 704 3i1-1 F:.A`.�;iO'•iD II. f�I.,.',v1�:t •. � •LI:_ -: : his wife; PETER A. R. YURZER and IRENE •r• :• t�= ����;'7ti �:j,C•r•s;('+•'rn „'r�pi No. FURZER, his r.,:tfe E JG-_:f.: i.).)j. ..iPlaiiftiff' =_'_ Il S�T- N hiswife; C4yY L� JUS'T >; RUTH lyA 3�4>�`:t l:. )y � �'$. ' B.{�7 n 1 JUST, his wife; and _C 1,ORG RUSK S AN PEP r, rt q RUSK, ;.�� wife, SONS V AS Plaintiffs , vs CITY OF ENT municipal > >ra . .. ��.�}. 1'�._..v.t�i'' , a (JfIY?li,r i.:1.07"1 „ . ytt�,,,..qq t., C-�i. 4 .•1; IDeiendant__�;_ and llz1l��e LJ W. i a)�'f Fi..�.\S 4'L • cry d` 1:'IE STATE OF WASHINGTON, TO THE SAID • CITYRENT ;) municipal corporation; and OF Pf.,�,�(I„ ,, ar.:t�:a's�.c_-I�zi c,,..j�nr.;,�.i , HAZEL W. CHEUt:UR, a widow, • • • YOU, AND EACII'OF YOU, ARE HEREBY SUMMONED to appear within twenty days after • the service of this summons upon you, if served within the State of Washington (or within sixty • days after said service, if served without the State of Washington), exclusive of the day of service, • and defend the above entitled action by serving a copy of your written appearance or defense upon the undersigned. If you fail to appear and defend. judgment will be rendered against you, according to the demand of the complaint, which has been or will be filed with the clerk of court, or a copy of which is herewith served upon you. • • • • ROBERT r, ANDERSON Attorne)i... for Plaintiff.... Attorney �' • 771. t'1i]. .:!_i7%)s South (P.O. BU:: 't54) • �.._ �.. �... � l __ f��'_i�l•(:C)aq �'ii:�ill�_Tir;iap?.l 9v17.!J . S .�--. Addre a • .S:'.i. ..._ �...'.:J • I'1lcn^ - • . . _ _ . _ .. . . • . . . , . . . .• . . . - . - • • . . . . , •. . , . .• .. .. • . . • , .. - . • • • . . . .. .. . • . .• .. - . , . . . . . • - . i • ..• . • .• -, . . • . . . . . , • • . . . , .• . • • . . . . . . • • .. • .• • . .- .• . • . , .. . . • • . . . . . .• . . • . • 1 _ , . . _. • • • 2 • • • . • . - . . • . . . . . . • - - . . . . . • . . 4 . . . • , . • . - 5 • • • 6 . • •• • • . . . • , 7 . . . 8 IN THE SUI=ZRTOR• COURT Or T1.17.-!„ STAT17, or WASHINCTO . • .. IN AND FOR TIIE COUNTY OF 1IIG . • 9 . • ROBERT E, JONES and DY.AP1A. ) . 3.0 ,II)N ...:,'S 3• hi.t3 W ifc?.; ROcr,.R A. VETE:P:30N and PNI' I,CIA . ) . ., li P7,:;V /ISOI his w.'!!...i!eli GAIZT71 S. POM:ILL ) . .. alid BYLLIE P0'..: 1,LY.., his 11!„101; ) 12 RO.:fAYD R WLET -.-od STP7-.:I.F: Vr:ET ) • ; Pli7YN OWD h a Al.,E ,P.AtIDI:11Z ;and ) .4.4.,IN.-. A.,A 6'4.;.i,,,:.z.-.e,•,;.,;P:-.t 3.3 Drnzlis ..,-',.D.:1'2.A11 LT,R hi.,.,;,, v 3.::-..?c-.-:3 p i7:.-2,2,TZ ) • 1-'1.3.1••••:7,Y7AZ a:.-z.c1 :LT:El-Tr. YU-112'1:37Z, 1.15.:, ) 1 4 t... 3...,',''•-, t 1-7,..7:::3':',•:';'1:,' li flEiT INC,:.3 ) . . 1.1ASTY.I.:TO'3; hi..s 1.--J-5,).n?. ; jillya.,,-3 . .,--1Ortri-• ) - - 15 BERf2, ancl PARI3APA E( RNriEV.3 hir.,. c..?if ; ) C074PLAINT FOR GARY IL JUST 1.1.nd RUT JUST, hio % # counT I 16 i...rif,F and (:-XOR(:)E RUSK- and YiNDREA ) DECLARYI'IG RUSKi. ha wifei . • ) RnONII1G 17 ) INVALID Pla.3„nt..C.ffsp ) 18 . . vs . . • ) . . 19 - , ) • . . • CITY.' OF Rr,NaloN i, a muriifiipza co'-i.-To-N73.-, ) . 20 t-Lon and NA%EL 'd. CHE?!AURv a vii(.1ow:„. ) 21 ,. Dz-,fendanta. ) • • ) 22 . ._ _ • • • , 23 CCM NOW thia -olintif. s abovzi 1-4?-ncd and fuo cause of 24 against the (1,-.: fendan-:-: ; and er,ch of thcmo cc., plain and • • 25 fo:o.0.,31: . . . . . . • . . 26 I. • . . 27 That at a:i.1 1::,.11-1,?.:-. hi.an,-.;:i.n m.F.:nt...;..on5;6 p7fil!...,ntlffs TA.or::!. and rv,.7.;,. . 28 ar..-; oT.T.-1,-...,:r.:::, of onrtan ::,:!al cat.i: loctcl. :7..n th.r? C . y of 1-...1.-..7.3non, 29 County of .r. ..1-1:2.;.2, Stat...--,! of Wtuil . 30 • D.D.'„ • . 31 Thcli: at all tf,.. I 11:.:-.,.....-:*.i..T1 I C;`:.YV::fi.On r:: "t.:.:*:.e ...-.1 fon:'.1,z...nt CITY 01" , 32 zi. rx.-si-15..c:?..D,,:i.1 col,-,-.,:-Dr--_-:.•5..ol.., c!..,..v,:ii.1.5..7,.-:ra unclr.y.9 tho 1,-,.Y.: . I F2013ERTS C.: 1.1.:ID E IV-.3 ON I 1 ATTORN7.Y6 AT LAW iti WILLIAM:,AVF:i''F. .OIJTII•P.O.I:0X CC;;T'.,. ..1%.-C:17 '...1.1.?. Ci.. ..,:7,' r.,-;(:. -: . PENTON,WASHINGTON oco:5:1 J'7..:C....,:iTa.:::::; ii:-.7.'„W.;',1.:•:::. 1:1V.-!1. 1..) - "c.,-...7.,o BA 313o ii . . . .. . • . . . . . • . - •. . .• • . . • .•• . - . . .. . I . • 1 . . . .. . . I . • - • I . . . . • - . . • . . • . . . . . . . . • . . . . . . . ... . • • . • . . . 1 - of the Sillt 3 of Washingtonl th at `.‘:h e d.,.....,fen(3 .n.t HA7,EI.2 W. CT_rr.N A1.3? :t. - • 2 a widow and a msld:..;nt of thc City of Rnton5 ColAntyof 3 ©- W.:_l,shinzton.,, and the owner of rtin rcal .pPc)p .2.-ty loc.E;Itod in 4 . said cayv mor,c., prop2rly dei-3,37.,11).Q.d • 5 Wel3t: 130 ft of thf.-?. North 11';'. of Tract 2111 . C. D„ . Hiliraancu 1., ke Wash3.,ngtr.m5 GaIN,1).211 of Dden.5 Division 6 • No. 45 ar.;.corfLing to plat racor:lad in Volul 11 of • PlfAts5 po,F.t 82 , King County 5 ';''lashil:T.,tons. ecept the . 7 North 30 fc:at a6 thc Wa3t- 30 5..fil'it (-.) mlid Tract • 2 oonvoyod to the City of Ronton by deed ro..t.,dad . 8 unde, Audito:olf; rile No. 5333178 _ 9 *.ihich land is tha oubjcct of aont-,.,o,.. sv hrrooin. . . . . 10 • . 11 That p17:1intiffi,.; na.,o tha or of cetain real ly.r:opc.f.:oty in ' • 12 th.2 vicinity of the abowi (1ad real nrop3rty5 betclen 116th 13 and 112th Avonu:?.E! SouthoaCc. end Sout11 ,--.t:73t 110n Street5 in the City 14 o..! -Renton5 b,!,....a'r-ig add-r-Jtoes i-4.3 follows ! . 15 Peon 11011j-115th s.r, P..f.nton5 Washinton Robert jOncs 11016-11F)th S.E. 5 Renton5 Washir:::;tc-m 16 Po,.•.7 .0.3. 11.022-115•:_:1-1 S.E. 5 'R.:7nt Wy2,ct 11020-115th S.E. 5 P.m-1ton.... 17 • Ale-.e_and,--iD 11014-115th 5.E. 5 Pnton5 • Furza.P 11012-2,1th S.E. 5 Renton, Waohinc.v'co 18 HaO:in2 1'1010-11S-,-h Sc:-11 ., .112ntcn5 Washingto.i. 11021-116th S.E. , Ponoll.„„ Waohinc;tc.;-.- 19 Just 11023-1:Lsth S rf.int.-)1-i5 Washingtc': . Rt.u.O.- • )..a.o2(.3..12.G1.;11 S.E.. 5 -..,,,..;-,-.•;',•:f.: D. Wat,-2.11.:151,..:3t 20 21 that Eill ::•:,aid 1-i-po?..:.-.rtioi3 so owned by plaintiffia are ucc:d by the3-il 22 hc-Aas ; thaT: plaintifas pchad said p:sopcPti.aLl p-2.-.1o:,:, to any know. . ....-- . 23 ledge of the re.-zmn ho.1.-. 1aaftav co,-.121aind o5!. . • • 24 • • IV. . . • 25 Th i•-::.;: pl..11`':,31..Icint ti.-.., Ch a D t ri)? rj 75 Ir.).c.";7 So _.,s ion LE.-?.-4 ,.:;. St().t E..% of 26 : 1.4,-i-1,°1c,V.".0:A2, tha 0.11.27cn.-A,Ant City of 7'...nnton ennctc.l ..1 a 27 o:::,dinanc::?. plan 5 1.),:l ;ad and app..i.,ow.:d by its city cossincil on the. 27-L: 28 • day of Au,i,,u2t, 1057 ; that thi ..; orinc-,3 is -37,,,,cmnn;:la in the offic. • 29 of th-i.,.. City Cl ..i.-,!‹ of so.id c.',,.:fonr..la;At city that: a c.::,.:-..:,ta:!.n sootion 30 of 1.11:13..(3. o...f.,dinan.1-•:: providos fo..o t1-2:,..; diviion of pq:y °n.::o va-.0- . 31 iou.P, types of di lute which inc2r...-.1c! 11-15 R-2 and R-3 . 32 . cled :;.7::,. Tocivy as '; la-rao:.fl.-:no-:-2. 5 '.;:i.n:.:,.,1,.-,, fi,c.13..ly diatvictil-H, POBEITTS LI: ANDER3ON (.:OPLAf..NT 1:0;', C07.1T TrZ,C.:RF,E . . ATTORNEYSATLM 1. :.,:-...1.:AP,Ii-.1',-; •'-'.-.,-.': . c.: Yll'..,A.1:11.) - Pi.:1; 2 ,II WILLI:JR:AVI:t:Lir.SOUTH-P.O.no):.e."34 i WiNTOi:,WASHINGTON SD:7;3175 . i 13A 0-ICCO . . . t.i • 1 , • r 1 e e �. ��' f e that the w4�}: 1 R2r'i�ii i(x'me d e;tricts s, • [ ';t R3 �f.�as t:41.�nc 1 district ; 3 • 2 ' of :°'1`ri1ctl.zr o that may he constructed on pot r i..:-i:i located in h4 . 3 City of Renton differ according to the zone classification. V. 5 That on c}_l c?}V;)SF.y. \eoc,'mbu4'1 270 19879 1.1io t.y of Renton } 6 , Planning Ccur—_l?_3. • ? haatrd an r }i,i_iceition by d!IfendantHazel W. �Ywhich 7 C��a car j. o R,,,Dyi`-;h6-6`J 9 a Y�c %c—nnc f::;.om l-1 to R-3 p wax, : ?tbs - quently .,12'. v." - 'L i cc h•'-1Nt°ng denied by. the 'City of Renton 8 (;S_3:?e a 1,.f..J and e:. • t.�:� I 1�i i.i ..:e. :L. �.s� •� s . 9 Planning Coni'"?1 sE:ion in that R.-4 was t i7;?. beet a2i highest, u e of h.1 10 ti• ,op.e rty i l- a .ot-i Oti°s Lhi t t h d ci c.ni, ii.:i`is .5. i'i o Chen,-zu ' ap!,oa 1,: d w�" f 1 �"�1.1 ..4 t. 11 J b: e! the Pwi_.n l ng Commission decision .'e the City Counc 12 d,:f-.f.11..ndant City of R ., ht and st`3' -:i:!73.''•';`:. d ci.£;:l.On by the Council 3 that. appeal; thatp.�rinb'-f2's l:f::)':'O not given notic:.• by the City on -i • . 14 ' Couneil •of the public hearing on the • appeals in that the City ryry o not lY c ty Cods Sen.. 1 •-a7F . .Li,� Council CS J_fi ;75:'Cl fi ::� ° ..:�:+`i.i? with `Ef:�:��viZ 1... r • 16 et al; that said a7 7c 1 was heard on `T.ebr,u Rr;y 4 l('t i. a• and the City 17 Council l . t h f: by 1 n i Hazel W. Ct r,t� `•t in concur••rt3Lr:� ± G.r rl'!. ': •La=" i�.Y:'t`7:.c.1.� C.C;,`'�'�,r�i.:�.�'i•�: ,:1:_..,. s 7+a ac.:^ QQ c e 4 . 1 .A.. r ice+ ._ n 1 ]�+�:7:��.5 jl��,•t,1i •1.J7:� Y'.:.,r: 1:'.:S (1 '� ~ Y} \' 't C ..tf.•. iu`.'i lld •1.1:�1. 1'cr-• «.C.: 1 31 .�::. _f'7?:1 t):' 1.1c �ra't_sl. Y?.• �..: :L 19 •fthat said City Coun•,.' �:• �,d;' best :(, Sy Y C"w ''? � use of ��1 is°t;3F�';%y'I�J.i�� .S't CaL ...•r."t 1.(.t C•�+'>d�• i .i,�^_ L� 6 Cci i a .toil J Lq and hq ° f ( � :.7c s2nt c f . far:.l'�y c'�.� i by a motion'In C: 20 C:?1 tTi C:£}'l..t..l•`C�.! 'i�.... (J 1•l:.i:, h ll, lt4.;� �.lJ:. \l Ll Lj 'i.i, •t.Vim 2.1 to < w that q :19 1 Crh without t'>ee to LZe second t'.'�-'.i��'"'"9�'i3: -- �...i� February , s .JtJ. y�,, City L;s.� 22 t:}i:_ly it L'I,ff 9 4!'-!' City Coll+_'..'_".a. of th5.! de _il.dci3•it City of R_:nton re- . ~• the ' ' ), h;y fa id I-. : ; W. Chcn: i"xrl ., application 23• C ''t'.��Cj 1'lt�c..''J-S:�C �i.. to Ce." �:. a ,�ii:c..• o 55 fa a 1 S r•5'4,• 24 re one• and the said def Y C:dant H z l �'4 o Cbc."stx..':`r the i:r t..t,j granted' 25 ° w.{'., • n i 3 `I - :o:. ; that sub-' t:�•^.'s3C'. ji:�..-� �,•.::r'4'd:�t.C?ii ): c1.1 j'.A , 1'>c::�:t">. t. E:l't R 2 ;:.i. '1 26 f..l'.:'ifuc ni to the ar.12.r t`:,t d 7,:ti`:•ion the City Council r,; . .i �d the i 27 •fof .1 . .e ~ . the C�1. Planning. C a , tin •-o. `mport b ' ter ': its iI' ••,l: to 't. ! .-�' \.�_. .:�.. ~.t. •y ,J 28 that on the ..;r 4 -r•,`t-,,.n - .. ly ache r 3.t_''z City Council o i n , Fehr :. ., 29 26 lnr;�\L: �:)^ ,•:%:L("?S; of C".Y}Y.'L'.:'itlant f`...z£':_� 11., Chc:nELnr to have t,h:- ,r� 1. 30 .;.'"nd in 611.-. 5"L i.o v. R 2 was r. • _::'ir' by the City Council '!' ... 31 I 't?-, j;ont nc l,-t . o O o.t^L.:• 17- ,, s 32 1 • I • f ODE.R T E E. ANDF.:SON ATTOI:!•!EYS AT LA\'. .I. ' • ,, • 11}Pill.Ll',!:s!•V.-"RUF.�OII;'H-P.0.DOY-A:;r ,,,,:1".. .._'cl._.+-Y ij .. F.!,. J'._ ~+Z.." ~.J REt''TO?; \':ASNI NGTO:1 _CIO'_ - - - • . . • ' , :- ' ': - - - : ,:- - ' --- -. . .. . .. - - ---. :. .- :_ ". . • , " . 1- • • . . : ., ., • - 1 . •. . . . .• . •- i • . " . . . • . . . • . . • . . .• . .. - 1 . . VI. . • . . - 2 That said defendant-Haz31 W.. Chenaur has no' ; applied for . . . • . • -. - . • 0 a sp.7::cia1 parinit to the. Rentoh Plannin Cw.:riission for a vx.ol,ance . • 4• '(-2 to allow a special structure to be built on the R-2 zoned propei,,ty; that noice• of tha he-aring on said special permIt 11.2A not provided • . . 6 cling to Renton City Code.' • • • . . . t7 VII. .. . . 8 " That the g•,f•anting of the R-2 rezone to dafendant Haol • . . 9 W. Chonaus. was paszed and app-.,..ovd in violation of the plaintiffsv 10 constitutional rights and its pImpose does not promote. ths hoalths il ' cafsty morals or general welfre- of th(:-,,, coTririlunity and 5..:3 thcINf0 . ., 12 . void i:-.-..nd unnforcable ; that the plaintiffs are Infomed and belie ': 13 • that it is the ints..:-!ntion of thf,-f defcndant lia2e1 W. thenaux, under ah 14 the R-2 ,,azonos to place on said lot al,. .74:51 .7:=1- .:oal) -tient house 15 . ., , , . -, _ ... • . . WA1C:2D ....,,-)7 pralTveds, will destroy for singl,a family pl'ivate home 16 ppo 05 the entire section of thc:: city in which the plaintiffst' :17 raal property is locatd5 that said apartment houce would yo chanze 18 tho tharacter of the neizhborhood "as ' to result in distul,bing n.oise 19 incident to insrased traffic and buz5in3s2; tint Said commreial 20 enterprise and the resultnt inereayed vehicular traffic would 21 ondanr children in thi.:: neighborhood and dm)rivo them of quiet 22 apd opn spacc-Is enjod by thc):;e in mcre favor,ad localitico and thcl! 23. residJ,:ntial ch,: zetii•:r of the llighbol,hood and its deslability ao, 24 a p1.20,7, of (.1taf.;:hc.,.:d siv:8le fc.-..aily moidene7.,,:s would be utterly de- • 25 - 8treyed1; that constY,uction of so.id structure would cc-73 1.4pabI:.-, 26 . - c , to plaintiffs a result of incrov,sed :l...ter drainage px- blms . 27 .4. c.,.._ __ . 111 1.14....; cli',.=de 28 VITX: " . . 29 . That .under the foro.wing eiri-ivrIst,i2.ncs sid F,T1-,uctura1, use .30 I pcxRitted undcr an R-2 Y..". 01I'D cissifit..7..on with a va:,:,iitneu .;.?ould 31 co-:-13tiT anu .=.-, ne to plaintIff hesf.,-..!in ens to th.a public!', thzCc 32 th,:: -act: Inp-1:.:c::.1 * piflp:Y2-2t!, to p.,7:::-:ILI'"c E,12cb !'.;,,:r .:t1 -3 0:2 uT,7';:7: :, ROBERTS 8: ANDERSON ATTOP&IEYS AT LAW DI%7DJJA,14::AvI:MIE:own i.p.o.rex...:J.4 CCAT.:-:-1; YI.Y? C07= 1-.)::CITE 111t4TOM,WA014930!;!.: DA 0-1,0S0 1 is therefore unreasonable and arbitrary and if en:�oic^d 'w ld h`� • ci i :1 *+ 2 detrimental c t' a public yi aJ L < l that, th: rezone classification 3 is for the s :Le plArpos of furthering l.w'3^a:1g th'c. 1's '3`li!::'W interests of i:'l' .'• 4 defendant Z-endant Hazel VI. Chenaur, 6n her assigns, are contrary which con y ° detrimental° i� the. interests c*i;K+1 of the 5 ' the � •, ng on and ut ..si?:1OT to to G c t. es 6 p i:?..1^f,s..-., hereinand of the general. public; that there • • evidence before the City P i •'•gi'i.r. Cc%im i tee. cf defendant 1 ?nt City of . i:• { Il ,.^�, -^3 passage C�W 4 h`.^i`. '.i.v/ rezone which 8 . '_tenton at .t ll `ir.�'.�-. o f or 1i.'.fo 'o . tl e 9 showed or tended tO show or even to raise a debatable issue that r •:o e • f enacted would be substantially in furtherance hera 3:;e of or of .�.1 int • : to the h lth„ safety:, morals and general welfare `I.%1 c. E3 7 �1 1 • +s would 1 J_7 Y the '.1^1?'�M,F-�C`�. C!r`. 12. • . the cOrT;:aun y o ti`� that its 1.n C't.�sICn t. wo ld further r La1 �'.N S' 13 the original comprehensive zoning . 1d . = lL t i to the City of Renton 14. that said evidence did not show the p^oaae of the rezone would qJ aa s icongestion in the 't A .47 , o. secu e safety fro:f fir,,-...„ pan ‘. 16or other dangers :, or provide adequate 1,-i iyht .and air., or prevent t h; 37 ^ y of 1G7 ' O9 avoid undue concentration of opu at r on :v 18 - or- facilitate the .adeauate provision 'Liis• Ci C „ t .n"p;nt` ation; s4 ar,„ • 19 .`iei:. or, other public vequirmentsi. that said City jy Council 1.n 20 '?a:�"i ,t; s 2 '! 5�nr+ ' 'lE: 31r �'!'• 5wc with regard to and �r7'z'°-' S?�-> S � u'1 1...'r_.( q o �, ° to h ,r ctc of the: district a .:i • 2•A• reasonable C;<�l1s.i.C.i: i'.b^4:+_r`,•«2 the character 22 • .j 7 i.-'�., JJed ?nc or' its particular "l :S.+:i?i:: •�:'..•�:jl for the particular 1..:��_ al • 23 ' f` orthe t.t. zr. of cons ._.'v: ie the value ue c: Zi0i1•- 11 1_ C;.i^�cu.i ill,�-�rS:?.-L.I.CJ:� to •�: •r' t :l 6:. 24 I use of „o ? buildings or L}?.'.ir7: `'L:St+?:r and the most appropriate uc, 25 of lands throughout the ( �: m n4 ,y, that to. the contrary:, tnf s 27 of the ors::-,J_na.� co Z1'i: �`FZon l: e zol)- 1 'teh:!!plan of the City of Renton� .. .i 28 that:, ' 29 3 health ,.,. safety, t1c��'..?, : tlo It ti+:��3:� not promote the -.:;1 :"t -4.' 30 oy.., cs, t r'a•l welfae of th,.= cot., uni s.Y J.1. • b, It will .greatly 5.F•'.'c:hL '.L eci', ;,•._,on in thec'n.J:ec to ci 32 theaa, p • l . l''fon110 t:i !r:.uthe,,Ist S ROBERTS & Ai•1DERSON ATTORNEYS AT LAW tII V/ILLT1d' fly L'E SOUTH-P.O.FOX q5 .�f%1 `�., -. .,1 t,� `,. '-.a.. )�I_r -•• RiJ TON,WA`}UUCTON SLOES: - I, L. f . 1• c It will.; by reason of such additional Con;.-7,n_,' ion in 2 s . t• he strati t s 'i�'1�:;?:�ease' the ds:go of fire and panic m J J" J. 3 de _ It L•:r',ll C�L:zs4 �; *:. d n" i .,nd; . an i5'lC.C.'. �C f7 7 "7 • 4 eo It does not facilitate ; but on the contrary diminishes 5 the adequate• provicion o1 transportation; water; se:'ia.ae ; parks . 6 and Qth r public c :i' :quir:n ant ; • 0 , 7' - f o" It is in complete disregard of the- Character of the C!;1.' is 'L.Ct as a single fai 1y dwelling district; - V• . 9 go It will depreciate the value of the buildingn owned 10 Y J e ti o •;f S 4.ry t (^ � ..�1 o v .s f n.1 t o qq �)� p:t,s ..3 .:L:_.. 3 �'.3 ..,,. .�f7:.`(:si c ::�.?,rE:.g c.:ief.l c,.4..�. �s•>17i':,;' buildings in the 1J. not borho d a . 2 h o Tt encourages pi. :i i 1 the inp ro s to .u ico ofsaidnd.land a i' • 13 will si s i s t 'n: 9 a change 1 S i ar. . d e f the neighborhood :? i-}:a 4.t ca i ..5 :'[ �,� the {:._ .. �.tq i. t" C7_: C_i • 14 that the most appropriate use of •i:i'_:. land'd. g`t''+l u• the Comm nity i' 15 to-wit ; for single J oo.ly dwelling purposes ; will �:e greatly 16 dim.iil°i hed. J 17 IX. 18 That plaintiffs' 0rJlZ s ti tut10na1 rights fis:;im been violated 19 • ill tna w they w ra not given-proper notice of the appeal by e.-.i e 20 dai}1, C ,:rye.! `'7G l<ii:r:n aaur of the original al denial by the City Planning 21 . C ci::t:l.s rdon of the defendant - city of her application ication for an Rom. • 22 rezone; that plaintiffs' c<on ;ti.tutiCista•. gh:;s have further been 23 den? =d .Lltha 5 _ c • w ?t 1 y-' vC: 'e ! ...r1a o. fs o F then �1 -.t c.L, j:a .L�)i'�1.' City�!.�.L,t:% <_<i. F�1. 1i aU `Gd .. �j_ �' !.f 5"' _ 24 • hear eng by the Renton Council vo p.::r.'ili 4 application by 6,,yEen- 25 • cic:1•b•i.' Hazel 1'7 E (;i"t�:�1i13 �0. • 26 t`�1:. F.\�a.(+�� ,fai3 plaintiffs pray for juci tit a .iy_,t the �rry�n i�tfor t..{.� i t .� 1, {• :tom. 28 r^,. final o 9 e i?..it upon -1 a -2 :' insofar �} .:'"�= J,__lAC..i. hearing i'-1 •..rl_, �.ft[ i ?`�. Nf;1'. .+� } U.�:� 29 1 1. relatesto said property of deJ.ol^:t�<.:5+ i. 1?tom....l W. (Th 'a'.tar,.7.-'1 a`7 00 judged to 2)e null quid Void 'and of no ,i o::ce or t f.. .:;e t 31 r : That T r i f o the CO4 L enter,LC._„'' U. :i...rl�i:l.!?�?, c',�l-A j l:d , :ent cec,1 .... .l.n �� deI e::i_.ant., have no l`g T J. ri..::,11 t.: to U2C the r :- lice: di ucrib :l".hc:�'_..• _. POi EU:TS t: AND.EF ON A'iTOR!'!EYS AT LAPW 1!!�/!LLTA!.is Avcuuc_scan!.rm.r...Dx/..t i:._: ,`• . ._. _ j:'c? : .: :. !_, RENro:•!,;YAs!:!PdGTON ''D . . . • . • 1;.:: • • • • • • • • • • • . 3. f'0-0 ;-1fly other purvose than Zoo R-1 clafication; 2 • Zo tho defendant Ha7.,e1 W. Chnaur aud 11,7,..roffiporTs ., • servantsi, cmployes end riXtor hearIng . , porari:iy enjoined and upon final hing ba permnfimtly enjoinctd from ur6in3 the land in question for any other purpose than that 6 rirovid-d for in the.! Renton City Code under the R-1 c1a3sifiction.f.; ;10 That the defendant City of Renton and its officers • • • a ‘ D agents se-Pwantsl, omployea and attorneys ? after heaving e • 9 rarily enjoind and uDon finai be pemanentlY (2,n1oinfiad . fro:i 10 51hr rt building pit for uLle upon th2 lend in question for, th 11 purpoc,e of allow:in the building of any strucituro other than a • 12 s'in7ucturo WY...Ch Ic penilissi3-.0.o under the Rent= City ef..-.K1(1 on en 13- R-1 2.,on5ng olns3ification of real property; • 14 • rwo raaintiffat' costa and d1sburf,3emonts herein to be • 15 16 6 . FOr Fioch othe7, and furtller r 'af as the court may 17 dom just and cquitable in no prethis:..E.,:a. 18 ROMRTS F., ANDERSON 19 • NICila21 go W-11112.1zJon 20 Attornera for PiFintiff5 •21 STAT.2 or WASHITGTON) ) SS 22 cCiu:l'IN 31 C. • • 23 ROERT E.' JoN-rs, being f:;..rst duly sum.,n on oath ,d,l-por,)Gs and :--Flynt 24 ThiAt he is of the plaintiffs abo-,A:1 nad and iAoa thif) 25 • vcfetioil for on bon;Af of that he h•;.:1.'„; .d tha focg6ing Comlt D.":*“.2'120.0, Doclarin3 Rczcdnin 26 know3 thnrof ancl 1),..115.eveo to truo. 27 • /17„ 28 29 I• supxo'i.z11..qm g !..;u0T-r.1 to bc.fon,.:, 1.11=. 21ct day of Jannay.,v1, 19$90 30 31 • •1T-A ;.2;'c. of Wi.).:-.11AnT:7on at. Rentn 32 • ROBERTS C.; ANDERSOIN1 • Cl '0Yt COURT 1172,Cni:3 ATTOUNEN'S A-r LAW 111 WILLIAMr.AVZ111.11:sclum•P.O.PDX 41;4 - 7 111114TOZ-1,WASHINGTON SOS BA 13-1BCO CERTIFICATION STATE OF WASHINGTON) ) ss COUNTY OF KING ) I, Helmie W. Nelson, the duly elected, qualified and acting City Clerk of and for the City of Renton, Washington, do hereby certify that the attached copies are true and correct copies of pages from the Renton City Council Meeting Minutes, to wit: Page 2 of February 5, 1968.j Pages 2 and 8 of February 19, 1968; Page 7 of February 26, 1968; and excerpt= from Renton City Code of Ordinances Ch I, Sec. 4-725; and Pages 4, 5 and 6 of December 27, 1967, Renton Planning Commission Meeting Minutes, appear- ing on file in the records of the Office of the City Clerk in said City. IN WITNESS WHEREOF I hereunto set my hand and the Official Seal of the City of Renton, Washington, this 24th day of January, 1969. (Seal) Helmie Nelson, City Clerk • • • Renton Planning Commission • Meeting December 27 , 1967 Minutes ' Page 4 - • is narrow and, on a hillside. Teegarden stated he felt it would be a .mistake to allow an apartment building at the end of such . a nar- 1 row street . at this time. • Forgaard asked when the Transamerica property to the south and west . of the subject. property was rezoned to R-3. The Planning Director replied this was done in 1963. . Transamerica has indicated it does • not plan to open access to the Renton Hill area or 'develop their R-3 area at this time. Comments from the audience were invited. ' Mr. Jack Newell stated he is the property owner immediately east of the applicant' s property and is definitely opposed to any multi-family residential develop-- ment .in the area; that he feels the area is• an established single family residential zone. As there were 'no further comments , it .was moved by Stredicke, • seconded by Forgaard, that the 'hearing be closed. Motion carried unanimously. • • ACTION: Moved by Teegarden, seconded by Stredicke, that the rezone applica- tion of Albert L. 'Duncalf for R-3 zoning be denied. Motion carried unanimously. The Chairman advised the applicant of his right to appeal the decision of the Planning Commission by written notice to the City Council within ten days . (c) Chenaur, Hazel W. , Appl . No. R-436-67 , rezone from R-1 to R-3; property located west. sideof 116th Ave. S.E. between S.E. 110th and 112th Sts. (westerly of McKnight Jr. High School) The rezone application was described by the Chairman; and the loca- tion of the property was pointed out by the. Planning Director on the zoning map. The Planning Director' indicated that access to the property was via an undeveloped right of way. Slides of the property were .shown. Photographs of the property submitted by ' the applicant were passed around among the Commissioners . The Planning Director stated that in 1956 the property was zoned R-3, but as it was not developed it reverted back to R-1 status under a reversion ordinance in effect at that time. The Chairman read a petition against the rezone submitted by property owners in the area and bearing 20 signatures. • The Planning Director stated that the existing Comprehensive Plan indicates this area as low to medium density multi-family resi- dential, but that the revised Comprehensive Plan now under study ' by the City Council cuts this area back- to single family residential. . ,. 1 Comments from the audience were invited. Mr. Roger Peterson, 10514 -• 113th Ave. S.E. , owner of property • 'westerly of subject property, voiced his objections to the proposed rezone. Mr. George Rusk, 11029 - 116th Ave, S.E. , stated he owns a house ' north of 110th which he had purchased with the stipulation the area was R- 1 , but had found out later that a portion of land nearby was zoned R-3 upon which two apartment houses have been constructed. 1 seS ry • Renton Planning Commission • Meeting December 27 , 1967 Minutes Page 5 • Mr. Rusk stated he was opposed to further apartment development in ' the- area. Il Mr. Robert Hall. of Seattle identified himself as attorney for the ! ! applicant, Mrs. Chenaur, - and gave a brief history of the property in question. He stated that his client is asking for the zoning which had previously been granted and which had been lost due to the reversion ordinance then in effect which has since been re_. • . pealed. He discussed the undeveloped access road about which there appeared to be some title cloud. • Mr. Hall stated this undeveloped access according to all information he has been able to get belongs • to the City of Renton. He stated the rezone is a logical one; would have no effect on the single family residential area known as Hill- crest Lane directly to the west as those houses are below his client' s property and face away from it. He stated further that cost of development of the property makes it economically unfeasible for anything but multi-family residential use. Mr. Bob Harris, 10843 - 116th Ave. S.E. spoke in opposition to the rezone due to the immediate proximity of $20 , 000 to $40 , 000 homes . Mr. Jerome Stephenson, 11430 S .E. 112th St. , asked how sewer lines could be connected to the property. The Planning Director displayed' a sanitary sewer and water lines map - for the area; and stated that due to the elevation the developer could get sewers only through • the west side of the property by obtaining easements through ad- jacent properties. He stated further that there are sewer lines along 116th Ave_, S.E. but they could not go easterly due to the elevation unless some sort of pumping system was installed. • J Mr. Clayton Chenaur discussed the history of the property; the fact that he thought he had the proper zoning, being unaware of the reversion to R-l; the access problem, the development of sewers , the cost of development being too high for other than multi-family. use. He stated that the development would be adequately served by sewers and would be screened to protect adjacent residences . He urged the Commission to grant the rezone. Stredicke stated that the area, notwithstanding the two existing apartments , has been developed for single family use and he would not be in favor of rezoning for multiple use. Messrs. Stephenson, Peterson, Rusk and Harris , previously acknowledged, spoke again in protest against the rezone, as well as Mr. Ronald Wy- let of 11020 - 115th Ave. S.E. • Mr. Robert Hall and Mr. Clayton Chenaur spoke again on behalf of the rezone request. • There being no further comments , . it was moved by Stredicke, seconded by Teegarden, that the hearing be closed. Motion carried unanimously. ACTION: rid Moved by Stredicke, seconded by Brower, that the application of Hazel W. Chenaur for rezone from R--•1 to R--3 be denied. Motion carried unanimously. • Further moved by Stredicke, seconded by Teegarden, that a communica- tion be sent to the City Council recommending that the highest use . of this property be R-1 as presently zoned. Motion carried unani- mously. • Renton Planning Commission • Meeting December 27, 1967 • Minutes • Page 6 • • The Chairman advised the applicant' s attorney of her right of . appeal of the Planning Commission decision by letter to the Cit Council within ten days. Mrs. Hall stated he understood the ap . rights of his client. 5. ADMINISTRATIVE MATTERS • • REFERRAL FROM RENTON BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT . (a) Albert Balch and Garden Park, Inc. , request for variance from height limitation. The Chairman stated that the Board of Adjustment had referred above variance application to the Planning Commission and refe_: the Commissioners to copies of Board of Adjustment Minutes as t. ' as copy of letter from the FAA relative to the matter; such cot in each Commissioner' s folder. ACTION: Moved by Brower, seconded by Racanello, that this matter be co:, sidered at the next Administrative Meeting of. the Renton Plann Commission in order to give the Commission time to study the • material submitted. Motion carried unanimously. STREET NAME PROBLEM . (b) The Chairman read a letter from Fire Chief M. C. Walls co?:. _' ing duplication of street name in Thunder Hill 42 , parcel #26 . Planning Director stated that this particular street (Thomas LE is privately owned and the City has no control over it. He su:, gested the Commission might wish to' refer the matter to the Bo of Public Works for their review. • ACTION: • Moved by Stredicke, seconded by Racanello, that a copy of Fire Walls ' letter be sent to the Mayor' s office and to the Board oJ Public Works for their action. Motion carried unanimously. APPOINTMENT OF NEW PLANNING COMMISSION MEMBER • (c) The Chairman read copy of a letter from Mayor D. W. Custe:„ • the City Council appointing Mr. Tony Mola as a member of the Planning Commission to fill the vacancy created by the resigner: of Mr. Stanley' Stone and requesting concurrence of the Council this appointment. • • RESIGNATION OF PLANNING COMMISSION MEMBER (d) Mr. Robert Brower announced that regretfully' this would ( last meeting with the Planning Commission as he had been recal' to active duty with the United States Navy, and stated it. had . a privilege to serve bri the Commission. SITE PLAN APPROVAL (Request for Information) (e) Stredicke asked if site plans had been submitted for the approval of the Planning Commission for the church located at and M. The Planning Director replied that this church had sup : their site plans as well as a variance request for parking and received approval of the site plans on March 28 , 1962 . He sta.' • finutes - Renton City Council Meeting (Cont.) 2-5-68 e Mayor Custer introduced a group of students from Renton High School Boys Club who are attending the Council meeting in participation of Student Government Week. Attendance on a voluntary basis included about 25 youths who will also be coming to City Hall during the coming week for two hours daily to observe operation of various: departments. A mock City Council meeting will be conducted by the group on Saturday, February 10th, between 10:00 a.m. and noon and Councilmen and Depart- ment Heads were invited to attend. P32=LIC BEARING: Hazel W. Chenaur appeal of R-3 rezone denial on property located on :.he West side of 116th Avenue S.E. between S .D. 110th and S.E. 112th Streets. This being the date set, the hearing was declared open. Letter from Planning • Director Erickson reported Planning Commission recommendation that,since detrimental effects could be anticipated and such rezone not being in the best interest of the surrounding residential area, R-1 be considered the best and highest use for this property. Petition containing approximately 20 signatures was attached objecting to the rezone which document had been submitted to the Planning Commission. Mr. Robert Hall, 419 Securities Building, Seattle, Attorney representing Mrs. Chenaur, stated that the proposed use is felt to be the fullest and best for the property noting the proximity of other multiple dwellings in the immediate vicinity and apartment directly behind the proposed development. He added that such housing is greatly needed, that the plans meet with the presently existing Comprehensive Plan and that the property had once been rezoned to R-3 but reverting according to an ordinance which had a one year construction commencement provision, since repealed. Topography of the area was outlined with embankment division from singly family area being noted and Attorney Hall stated developers would be able to furnish parking as required and would be willing to work out any further matters required or desirable. Film slides were shown by the Planning Director after which Councilman Shane . inquired regarding apparent drainage problems noted when visiting the site and also in regard to sewering the area. Planning Director Ericksen advised that all such details • have to be worked out prior to occupancy of the premises and all Departments concerned must approve the particular portion of the proposal which is under their jurisdiction. Discussion ensued regarding conformancy of procedures on various applications submitted and Planning Director Ericksen noted that the Commissions actions are uniform and on the basis of the Comprehensive standpoint. Specific detrimental effects were noted to be traffic congestion and loss of privacy to individual property owners on the lower sites. The Planning Director noted the project does not meet with the proposed Comprehensive Plan .Moved by Morris, seconded by Edwards that the hearing be closed. Carried. Moved by Morris, seconded by Perry, that the appeal be denied in concurrence with the Planning Commission recommendation that R-1 is the best and highest use for the property. A dissenting voice vote brought request for roll call which resulted as follows: Aye: Morris, Schellert, Delaurenti, Perry, Trim, Edwards, Maxin and Bruce. No: Garrett, Grant, Shane and Barei. The motion carried denying the appeal. COMMUNICATIONS: Application from Mr. Robert H. Schlosser, Mgr.,Cougar Den, 219 Main Avenue South, requested that Mutual Amusement Company be granted required license to operate an additional pinball device at said business location. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to refer the matter to the Police and License Committee with power to act, wh5sch`.carried after.:inquiry regarding the legali mty of pinball machines and their comparison to punch boards. Discussion ensued wherein the City .Attorney advised of Supreme Court ruling, based upon Attorney General's Opinion that they are both gaming devices and where chance predominates over skill the activity is outlawed and illegal with the three elements under which court decisions are determined being 1. consideration is paid to participate; 2. must be some kind of reward; 3. element of uncertainty exists. In further discussion City Attorney Shellan stated the City has a right, which goes back to common rule law, to license under its police power and can im- pose a license or regulatory fee. Councilman Shane felt the pinball and punch board devices should be treated equally and moved, with second by Schellert, that if pinballs are illegal they be taken out tomorrow. It was subsequently moved by Morris, seconded by Bruce, to refer the matter to the haw and Ordinance Committee to report back. Moved by Barer, seconded by Perry, to table the matter. Carried. Letter from Vern Church, Purchasing Agent, reported that specifications are now prepared and requested permission to call for bids for equipment which has been provided for in the 1968 budget. February 26th was recommended as the bid opening date. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to concur in the request and recommended bid opening date. Discussion ensued regarding the City maintenance program for city streets and the possibility of contracting such work. It was noted that cities usually do their own maintenance, and after further discussion regarding operation of the city equipment, budget, and departmental administration, question was called for on the pending motion to concur in the bid call and opening date and the motion carried. -2- Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting 2-19-68 COMMUNICATIONS : (Cont.) Letter from Jack Wilson, City Engineer, submitted statement in sum of $383.88 due Cornell, Howland, Hayes and Merryfield for work in connection with Well No. 8 to January 24, 1968. Approval for payment was recommended. Moved by Morris, seconded by Bruce, to refer the payment to the Auditing and Accounting Committee with power to act. Carried. Claim submitted by Donna and Rodney Stewart was read requesting reimbursement of $49.87 for damage to water tank elements when water was shut off and water drained out of the tank. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to refer the Claim to the City Attorney and Insurance Carrier. Carried. Document from Robert J. Hall, Attorney for Mrs. Hazel W. Chenaur, requested Council reconsideration of rezone denial noting grievance that all evidence had not been presented at the hearing, particularly exhibit of photographs and color slides as shown to the Planning Commission. Moved by Perry, seconded by Schellert, that the Council reconsider its action of the prior meeting as requested. Carried. Moved by Perry, seconded by Garrett, to refer the matter of the rezone to the Planning Committee to report back. Carried. Letter from Renton School District 403, Rudolph Seppi, Director of Plant •Faci"lities, requested approval from the City for service to the new. Earlington Elementary School, to be located at South 132nd Street and Langston Road, King County, by the sanitary sewer system of the City, costs to be the School Districts and Late Comers Agreement to be allowed for recovery or portion of the cost. Moved by Garrett, seconded by • Morris, to grant the request with referral to the Law and Ordinance Committee to prepare the necessary documents. Councilman Barei reported that the Sanitation Committee has a recommendation for approval of this request. The motion carried. Letter from Mr. Ray Van Hollebeke, Property Management, The Boeing Company, requested permission to install a 12,000 gallon propane gas tank on property located in area North of 6th Avenue North, now under lease from the City. Drawing attached indicated the location of the tank and piping. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Bruce, to refer the request to the Property Committee for recommendation. (Fire Chief and City Engineer to be consulted) Carried. Letter from John E. Iverson, Attorney, petitioned, on behalf of Mr. and Mrs. Roger A. Hokanson, for consent to transfer and sale of their interest in the Renton Radio Cab Co., Inc. New owners are individual holders of For-Hire Licenses and will contin'ie to operate as drivers and include: Phillip A. Schmolke, present owner, Gerald Halstead, present owner, and Michael Craig, 10931 S.E. 164th Street, Renton. Moved by Perry, seconded by Garrett, to refer the matter to the Police and License Committee for recommendation. Carried. Letter from Jack Wilson, City Engineer, reported that the letter of intent to annex property.to Renton which ad- oins Sunset Blvd. E., between 132nd Ave.' S.E. and 138th Ave. S.E. is signed by owners representing 84.74% of the assessed valuation of the property, which is located on both sided of the highway and contains approximately 13.6 acres with an assessed valuation of $15,600.00. Annexation would make the City Limits more uniform in this area. The petitioners are Alhoff, Smith & Beale and the matter has been referred to the Boundary Review Board. Letter from Sven A. Johnson, Building Director, recommended that Revocable Sign Permit be issued for sign encroachment of public right-of-way for Montgomery Ward & Co. at 319 Williams Avenue South. Moved by Perry, seconded by Barei, to concur in the recommendation. Carried. Letter from Building Director Johnson recommended that Revokable Sign Permit be granted upon revised application of Dr. Hurley at 91A South 3rd Street, since original sign was installed to different plans than submitted. Moved by Perry, seconded by Trirnm, to concur in the recommendation of the Building Director. Carried. Letter from W.E. Bennett, Utility Accountant, submitted proposed Agreement between the City and Fire District No. 25 regarding obligation and responsibility for fire hydrant_.maintenance and inspection, and consideration to be paid the City of Renton therefor. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Edwards to authorize and approve the execution. Moved by Perry, seconded by Grant to refer the document to the Fire and Water Committee for recommendation. Carried. -2- Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting 2-19-68 Remarks: Councilman Maxin announced a meeting of the Planning Committee at 9:00 a.m. on Saturday, February 24, 1968. Councilman Barei requested that the Janitor oil the Chairs-around the Council table to reduce the noise. Councilman Perry noted that the tables had been removed which had been used by the City Attorney and the Press and suggested they be replaced. Mr. Robert Hall, Attorney for Mrs. Chenauer addressed the Council advising that he had been mistaken regarding photographs which were submitted to the Council on the matter and offered apology to Planning Director Ericksen noting however, that tultiple zoning is the only feasible use for the subject property and that it is economically impossible to develop the area as R-1. After further comments in regard to the subject property Mr. Hall was advised that the matter was now in the Planning Committee which would be meeting at 9:00 a.m. tomorrow at which time his remarks might properly be addressed the Committee. As there was no further business to come before the Council, it was moved by Trimm, seconded by Schellert, to adjourn. The motion carried, and the meeting was adjourned at 12:05 p.m. )4x- A: Helmie Nelson, City Clerk /`'( . _ i L. W. CuJter, Mayor • • _p s f•. V Minutes - Rental City Council Meeting 2-26-63 COUNCIL COMMITTEE REPORTS: (Cont.) Unfinished Business Councilman Maxin, Chairman of the Planning Committee, submitted report recommending that requests of C. K. Mullins and F.E. Lawrence for zoning revisions to the Compre- hensive Plan, be referred to the Planning Commission for recommendations. Moved by. Schellert, seconded by Maxin, to concur in the recommendation. Carried. R'3^oamsnded that appeal of Hazel Chenaur be allowed and R-2 zoning be granted on the ^abject property, owner agreeing to amend her application as discussed with Attcrney Hall on her behalf. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Grant, to concur in the rezone as recommended. Carried. Councilman Maxin announced a meeting of the Planning Committee on Wednesday, February at 7:00 p.m. Councilman Bruce, Chairman, Fire and Water Committee, submitted recommendation that the firm of Cornell,Howland, Hayes and Merryfield be retained for the design and preparation of plans. and specifications for Well No. 8, and that the Mayor and City Clerk be authorized to sign the necessary agreement documents, upon. approval thereof by the City Attorney. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Shane, to concur. Carried. The Fire and Water Committee recommended that the Agreement between the City and Eire District No. 25 for hydrant service and water supply be approved and the Mayor and City Clerk be authorized to sign the document. Moved by Barei, seconded by Schellert, to concur. Carried. :he Public Relations Committee met regarding the request of Local 21R, Washington me Council of County and City Employees, AFL-CIO for Council acknowledgment and • it was recommended that the Department of Labor and Industries conduct a check for certification purposes as provided by law. Moved by Morris, seconded by Garrett . to concur. Carried. councilman Grant, Chairman of the Light and Power Committee reported that a formal request has been made of Mr. John Nelson, or a representative of Seattle City Light, to appear at a public hearing of the Light and Power Committee to discuss proposed franchise and power rates within the City, date for hearing to be determined. Pico, the Light and Power Committee submitted a proposed Resolution resolving that iiie interests of the City would be best served by employing a Consultant to provide :ate analysis and technical assistance in-re2rd to_power problem', The-servic�s to be seed in a ;:tud;: of power supply and rates were.outlined with areas'to be analyzed ,rein. the City' sand .Puget Power ma;work together to improve the City with regard to of mutual concern, the studies to be coordinated with the Traffic Engineering pa.rtment. The Light and Power Committee will interview Consulting Firms and made a! recommendation as to the firm to conduct the study and shall report cost for such study, and at a future date, report the findings to the Council. Moved by Morris, seconded by Maxin, to concur in the proposed Resolution. Councilman Grant moved that his minority report be incorporated as item 3. of the Resolution that: In event the City is unable to resolve the study areas to its satisfaction, the consulting firm be directed to analyze the means whereby the City could develop its own power distribution system, join with another public power utility (Seattle City. Light) or public utility district. The motion to amend the original Resolution was seconded by Barei,and after discussion and dissenting voice vote roll call was requested which resulted as follows: Aye: Garrett, Perry, Bruce, Grant, Shane and Barei. No: Morris, Schellert, Trimm and Maxin. The amendment carried and subsequently the original motion approving 'che three resolution.,pro ocalb, Moved by Schellert, seconded by Trimm, to adjourn. Dissenting voice vote brought roll call request which was taken as follows: Aye: Barei, Maxin, Trimm. No: Garrett, Shane, Grant, Bruce, Perry, Schellert and Morris. The meeting moved to the next order of business. • Moved by Schellert, seconded by Grant that the meeting be adjourned at 12:45 p.m. Carried. Councilman Grant inquired regarding the status of the request for dog control in the Highlands area. It was noted that the matter is in Committee and a study will be made and report submitted upon completion. • Councilman Grant reported a request from property owners that the vacant property to the East of 509 Tobin Avenue South be cleaned up and shrubbery cut as the litter is piling up and attention is needed. Mayor Custer advised that the owner has re- movod a house from the lot and further attention will be given the matters reported. -7- CERTIFICATION STATE OF WASHINGTON) ) As COUNTY OF KING ) I, Ilelmie W. Nelson, the duly elected, qualified and acting City Clerk of and for the City of Renton, Washington, do hereby certify that the attached copies are true and correct copies of pages from the Renton. City Council Meeting Minutes, to wit: Page 2 of February 5, 1968; Pages 2 and 8 of February 19, 1968; Page 7 of February 26, 1968; and excerpt from Renton City Code of Ordinances Ch I, Sec. 4-725; and Pages 4, 5 and 6 of December 27, 1967, Renton Planning Commission Meeting Minutes, appear— ing on file in the records of the Office of the City Clerk in said City. IN WITNESS WHEREOF I hereunto set my hand and the Official Seal of the City of Renton, Washington, this 24th day of January, 1969. (Seal) I-[elmie Nelson, City Clerk • ;jnutes - Renton City Council Meeting (Cont.) 2-5-68 Mayor Custer introduced a group of students from Renton High School Boys Club who are attending the Council meeting in participation of Student Government Week. Attendance on a voluntary basis included about 25 youths who will also be corning to City Hall during the coming week for two hours daily to observe operation of various departments. A mock City Council meeting will be conducted by the group on Saturday, February 10t'h, between 10:00 a.m. and noon and Councilmen and Depart- ment Heads were invited to attend. PJ_.LIC HEARING: Hazel W. Chenaur appeal of R-3 rezone denial on property located on the West side of 116th Avenue S.E. between S.E. 110th and S.E. 112th Streets. This being the date set, the hearing was declared open. Letter from Planning - Director Erickson reported Planning Commission recommendation that,since detrimental effects could be anticipated and such rezone not being in the best interest of the surrounding residential area, R-1 be considered the best and highest use for this property. Petition containing approximately 20 signatures was attached objecting to the rezone which document had been submitted to the Planning Commission. Mr. Robert Hall, 419 Securities Building, Seattle, Attorney representing Mrs. Chenaur, stated that the proposed use is felt to be the fullest and best for the property noting the proximity of other multiple dwellings in the immediate vicinity and apartment directly behind the proposed development. He added that such housing is greatly needed, that the plans meet with the presently existing Comprehensive Plan and that the property had once been rezoned to R-3 but reverting according to an ordinance which had a one year construction commencement provision, since repealed. Topography of the area was outlined with embankment division from singly family area being noted and Attorney Hall stated developers would be able to furnish parking as required and would be willing to work out any further matters required or desirable. Film slides were shown by the Planning Director after which Councilman Shane inquired regarding apparent drainage problems noted when visiting the site and also in regard to sewering the area. Planning Director Ericksen advised that all such details have to be worked out prior to occupancy of the premises and all Departments concerned meet approve the particular portion of the proposal which is under their jurisdiction. Diecussion ensued regarding conforrnancy of procedures on various applications submitted and Planning Director Ericksen noted that the Commissions actions are uniform and on the basis of the Comprehensive standpoint. Specific detrimental effects were noted to be traffic congestion and loss of privacy to individual property owners on the lower sites. The Planning Director noted the project does not meet with the proposed Comprehensive Plan .1Ioved by Morris, seconded by Edwards that the hearing be closed. Carried. Moved by Morris, seconded by Perry, that the appeal be denied in concurrence with the Planning Commission recommendation that R-1 is the best and highest use for the property. A dissenting voice vote brought request for roll call which resulted as follows: Aye: Morris, Schellert, Delaurenti, Perry, Trimm, Edwards, Maxin and Bruce. No: Garrett, Grant, Shane and Barei. The motion carried denying the appeal. COMMUNICATIONS: Application from Mr. Robert H. Schlosser, Mgr.,Cougar Den, 219 Main Avenue South, requested that Mutual Amusement Company be granted required license to operate an additional pinball device at said business location. _ Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to refer the matter to the Police and License Committee with power to act, whichnear•ried after.1ifiquiry regarding the Iality of pinball machines and their comparison to punch boards. Discussion ensued wherein the City Attorney advised of Supreme Court ruling, based upon Attorney General's Opinion that they are both gaming devices and where chance predominates over skill the activity is outlawed and illegal with the three elements under which court decisions are determined being 1. consideration is paid to participate; 2. must be some kind of reward; 3. element of uncertainty exists. In further discussion City Attorney Shellan stated the City has a right, which goes back to common rule law, to license under its police power and can im- pose a license or regulatory fee. Councilman Shane felt the pinball and punch board devices should be treated equally and moved, with second by Schellert, that if pinballs are illegal they be taken out tomorrow. It was subsequently moved by Morris, seconded by Bruce, to refer the matter to the Law and Ordinance Committee to report back. Moved by Barei, seconded by Perry, to table the matter. Carried. Letter from Vern Church, Purchasing Agent, reported that specifications are now prepared and requested permission to call for bids for equipment which has been provided for in the 1968 budget. February 26th was recommended as the bid opening date. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to concur in the request and recommended bid opening date. Discussion ensued regarding the City maintenance program for city streets and the possibility of contracting such work. It was noted that cities usually do their own Maintenance, and after further discussion regarding operation of the city equipment, budget, and departmental administration, question was called for on the pending motion to concur in the bid call and opening date and the motion carried. Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting 2-19-68 COMMUNICATIONS : (Cont.) Letter. from Jack Wilson, City Engineer, submitted. statement in sum of $383.88 due Cornell, Howland, Hayes and Merryfield for work in connection with Well No. 8 to January 24, 1968. Approval for payment was recommended. Moved by Morris, seconded by Bruce, to refer the payment to the Auditing and Accounting Committee with power to act. Carried. Claim submitted by Donna and Rodney Stewart was read requesting reimbursement of $49.87 for damage to water tank elements when water was shut off and water drained out of the tank. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to refer the Claim to the City Attorney and Insurance Carrier. Carried. Document from Robert J. Hall, Attorney for Mrs. Hazel W. Chenaur, requested Council reconsideration of rezone denial noting grievance that all evidence had not been presented at the hearing, particularly exhibit of photographs and color slides as shown to the Planning Commission. Moved by Perry, seconded by Schellert, that the Council reconsider its action of the prior meeting as requested. Carried. Moved by Perry, seconded by Garrett, to refer the matter of the rezone to the Planning Committee to report back. Carried. Letter from Renton School District 403, Rudolph Seppi, Director of Plant 'Facilities, requested approval from the City for service to the new Earlington Elementary School, to be located at South 132nd Street and Langston Road, King County, by the sanitary sewer system of the City, costs to be the School Districts and Late Comers Agreement to be allowed for recovery or portion of the cost. Moved by Garrett, seconded by • Morris, to grant the request with referral to the Law__and_Ordinance _Committee to prepare the necessary documents. Councilman Barei reported that the Sanitation Committee has a recommendation for approval of this request. The motion carried. Letter from Mr. Ray Van Hollebeke, Property Management, The Boeing Company, requested permission to install a 12,000 gallon propane gas tank on property located in area North of 6th Avenue North, now under lease from the City. Drawing attached indicated the location of the tank and piping. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Bruce, to refer the request to the Property Committee for recommendation. (Fire Chief and City Engineer to be consulted) Carried. Letter from John E. Iverson, Attorney, petitioned, on behalf of Mr. and Mrs. Roger A. Hokanson, for consent to transfer,and sale of their interest in the Renton Radio Cab Co., Inc. New owners are individual holders of For-Hire Licenses and will continue to operate as drivers and include: Phillip A. Schmolke, present owner, Gerald Halstead, present owner, and Michael Craig, 10931 S.E. 164th Street, Renton. Moved by Perry, seconded by Garrett, to refer the matter to the Police and License Committee for recommendation. Carried. Letter from Jack Wilson, City Engineer, reported that the letter of intent to annex property.to Renton which ad'oins Sunset Blvd. E., between 132nd Ave. S.E. and 138th Ave. S.E. is signed by owners representing 84.74% of the assessed valuation of the property, which is located on both sided of the highway and contains approximately 13.6 acres with an assessed valuation of $15,600.00. Annexation would make the City Limits more uniform in this area. The petitioners are Alhoff, Smith & Beale and the matter has been referred to the Boundary Review Board. Letter from Sven A. Johnson, Building Director, recommended that Revocable Sign Permit be issued for sign encroachment of public right-of-way for Montgomery Ward & Co. at 319 Williams Avenue South. Moved by Perry, seconded by Barei, to concur in the recommendation. Carried. Letter from Building Director Johnson recommended that Revokable Sign Permit be granted upon revised application of Dr. Hurley at 911% South 3rd Street, since original sign was installed to different plans than submitted. Moved by Perry, seconded by Trimm, to concur in the recommendation of the Building Director. Carried. Letter from W.E. Bennett, Utility Accountant, submitted proposed Agreement between the City and Fire District No. 25 regarding obligation and responsibility for fire hydrant:.maintenance and inspection,. and consideration to be paid the City of Renton therefor. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Edwards to authorize and approve the execution. Moved by Perry, seconded by Grant to refer the document to the Fire and Water Committee for recommendation. Carried. -2- • Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting 2-19-68 Remarks: Councilman Maxin announced a meeting of the Planning Committee at 9:00 a.m. on Saturday, February 24, 1968. Councilman Barei requested that the Janitor oil the Chairs-around the Council table to reduce the noise. Councilman Perry noted that the tables had been removed which had been used by the City Attorney and the Press and suggested they be replaced. Mr. Robert Hall, Attorney for Mrs. Chenauer addressed the Council advising that he had been mistaken regarding photographs which were submitted to the Council on the matter and offered apology to Planning Director Ericksen noting however, that Multiple zoning is the only feasible use for the subject property and that it is economically impossible to develop the area as R-1. After further comments in regard to the subject property Mr. Hall was advised that the matter was now in the Planning Committee which would be meeting at 9:00 a.m. tomorrow at which time his remarks might properly be addressed the Committee. As there was no further business to come before the Council, it was moved by Trimm, seconded by Schellert, to adjourn. The motion carried, and the meeting was adjourned at 12:05 p.m. Helmie Nelson, City Clerk w. Cudter, Mayor _p • 31 CjiL petition, that decision shall be final unless the owner files Notice of Appeal to the Council as specified hereinafter. Upon receiving Notice of Appeal the Council shall set- a date for hearing of the subject and shall notify the parties it deems most concerned. Three (3) notices, at least ten (10) days prior to any such hearing, shall be posted within or about the area proposed to be rezoned or reclassified. - Following this hearing the Council may follow the recommendation of the Com- , mission or refer the subject to the Commission for their reconsideration and subse- quent.report to the Council, upon receipt of which the Council shall take final - action, granting or denying reclassification, within thirty (30) days thereafter. (2) All petitions for a change of use district boundaries shall be accorn- r- ponied by a plat in duplicate, drawn to scale, showing the actual dimensions of the tract to be changed, the size, the use and location of existing buildings and build- . ings to be erected, and such other pertinent information as may be required by the Building Inspector. (Ord. 1542; 4-17-56) (3) A petition for a change in use district boundaries or reclassification of property cannot be resubmitted to the Building. Inspector, Planning Commission, or the Council for a period of six (6) months from the date of disapproval of such petition. 4-726: COMPLETION AND RESTORATION OF EXISTING BUILD- INGS: (a) Pending Permits Valid: Nothing herein contained shall require any change in the plans, construction, designated or intended use of a building, for which a building permit has heretofore been issued, or plans for which are now on -- file with the Building Inspector, a permit for the erection of which is issued within . _ one (1 ) month after the adoption of this Code, and the construction of which in either case: , _ (1 ) Shall have begun and been diligently prosecuted within one (1 ) - month from the adoption of this Code, and; • (2) Be entirely completed according to such plans as filed within one (1 ) year from the adoption of this Code. • (b) Nonconforming Uses: The lawful use of any building, structure or land existing at the time of the enactment of this Code may be continued, although such use does not conform with the provisions of this Code, provided the following con- - ditions are met: _ (1 ) Unsafe structures: Nothing in this Chapter shall prevent the strengthening or restoring to a safe condition of any portion of a building or structure declared unsafe by a proper authority. 559. 1261 • - / Minutes -• Rentrm City Council Meeting 2-26-63 ,OUNCIL COZ•MTTEE REPORTS: (Cont.) Unfinished Business Councilman Maxin, Chairman of the Planning Committee, submitted report recommending that requests of C. K. Mullins and F.E. Lawrence for zoning revisions to the Compre- hensive Plan, be referred to the Planning Commission for recommendations. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Maxin, to concur in the recommendation. Carried. neeo :aLended that appeal of Hazel Chenaur be allowed and R-2 zoning be granted on the cubject property, owner agreeing to amend her application as discussed with Attorney ' a11 on her behalf. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Grant, to concur in the rezone as recommended. Carried. Councilman Maxin announced a meeting of the Planning Committee on Wednesday, February 7:00 p.m. Councilman Bruce, Chairman, Fire and Water Committee, submitted recommendation that the firm of Cornell,Howland, Hayes and Merryfield be retained for the design and preparation of plans and specifications for Well No. 8, and that the Mayor and City Clerk be authorized to sign the necessary agreement documents, upon approval thereof by the City Attorney. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Shane, to concur. Carried. The Fire and Water Committee recommended that the Agreement between the City and Fire District No. 25 for hydrant service and water supply be approved and the Mayor and City Clerk be authorized to sign the document. Moved by Barei, seconded by Schellert, to concur. Carried. The Public Relations Committee met regarding the request of Local 21R, Washington nte Council of County and City Employees, AFL-CIO for Council acknowledgment and • it was recommended that the Department of Labor and Industries conduct a check for certification purposes as provided by law. Moved by Morris, seconded by Garrett to concur. Carried. Councilman Grant, Chairman of the Light and Power Committee reported that a formal request has been made of Mr. John Nelson, or a representative of Seattle City Light, to appear at a public hearing of the Light and Power Committee to discuss proposed franchise and power rates within the City, date for hearing to be determined. Plso, the Light and Power Committee submitted a proposed Resolution resolving that tine interests of the City would be best served by employing a Consultant to provide rate analysis and technical assistance in.reg_ard to_power problems. The"servics to be :"A LI a ;.tlid . of power supply and rates wore.butlined with areas-to be an lyzca c:irein the City' and .Puget Power mzywork together to improve the City with regard to of mutual concern, the studies to be coordinated with the Traffic Engineering -'apartment. The Light and Power Committee will interview Consulting Firms and made a recommendation as to the firm to conduct the study and shall report cost for such study, and at a future date, report the findings to the Council. Moved by Morris, seconded by Maxin, to concur in the proposed Resolution. Councilman Grant moved that his minority report be incorporated as item 3. of the Resolution that: In evant the City is unable to resolve the study areas to its satisfaction, the consulting firm be directed to analyze the means whereby the City could develop its own power distribution system, join with another public power utility (Seattle City Light) or public utility district. The motion to amend the original Resolution was seconded by Darei,and after discussion and dissenting voice vote roll call was requested which resulted as follows: Aye: Garrett, Perry, Bruce, Grant, Shane and Barei. No: Morris, Schellert, Trimm and Maxin. The amendment carried and subsequently the original motion approving the three resolution.,prc osalh. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Trimm, to adjourn. Dissenting voice vote brought roll call request which was taken as follows: Aye: Barei, Maxin, Trimm. No: Garrett, Shane, Grant, Bruce, Perry, Schellert and Morris. The meeting moved to the next order of business. • Moved by Schellert, seconded by Grant that the meeting be adjourned at 12:45 p.m. Carried. Councilman Grant inquired regarding the status of the request for dog control in the Highlands area. It was noted that the matter is in Committee and a study will be made and report submitted upon completion. • • Councilman Grant reported a request from property owners that the vacant property to the East of 509 Tobin Avenue South be cleaned up and shrubbery cut as the litter is piling up and attention Is needed. Mayor Custer advised that the owner has re- moved a house from the lot and further attention will be given the matters reported. -7- • 0 • enforcement of this Chapter. A careful record of such application and plats shall be kept in the office of the building inspector or proper enforcement official. 4-725: AMENDMENTS: (a) The Council may upon proper petition or upon its own motion, after a public hearing thereon and referral to and report from the City Planning :Commission, change by ordinance the district boundary lines or zone classifications as shown on the district maps. (b) The Council may upon its own motion after public hearing and referral to and report from the City Planning Commission, amend, supplement or change by ordinance the regulations herein established. (Ord. 1472; 12-18-53) (c) A petition for a change in use district boundaries or reclassification of property shall be made by the property owner, or somebody authorized on his behalf, on forms provided by and filed with the Planning Commission, The Planning Corn- mission shall cause an investigation to be made of the matters involved in the petition. The Commission shall then call a public hearing to hear all interested parties on said petition and three (3) notices at least ten (10) clays prior to such hearing shall be posted within or about the area proposed to be rezoned or reclassified, Following the hearing and after consideration of the facts of the proposal and all other pertin- ent matters, the Commission shall, within thirty (30) days make a recommendation to the Council. If the Commission, after thorough study of the proposal and the petition, determines that the reclassification or the change in use district boundaries is advisable and in the public interest and tends to further the preservation and enjoyment of any substantial property rights of the petitioner and is not materially detrimental to the public welfare or the properties of other persons located in the vicinity thereof, and is not out of harmony with the purposes and effect of the over- all plan of the established zone classification and use district boundaries, then in S- such event, the Commission may recommend that the Council approve the reclassifi- cation or change in use district boundaries of said property, A filingfee of fiftydollars 50,00 shall be paid bythepetitioner upon the ($ ) P filing of an application for a rezoning or change in use district boundaries. A filing fee of twenty--five dollars ($25.00) shall be paid by a petitioner upon the filing of an application for any variance, temporary permit, conditional permit or special permit. All filing fees shall be nonrefundable and shall be used to defray the cost of posting, processing and the proceedings in connection with any such petition. The aforesaid filing fees shall not be applicable to any governmental agency or political subdivision appearing as a petitioner. (Ord. 1920; 11-21-61 ) (1 ) If the Commission, following a public hearing, makes no decision on the petition or sends no recommendation to the Council within thirty (30) days, this may be taken as a disapproval of the petition and the owner may thereupon appeal as set forth hereinafter. If the Commission recommends disapproval of the 1261 • • petition, that decision shall be final unless the owner files Notice of Appeal to the Council as specified hereinafter. Upon receiving Notice of Appeal the Council shall set a date for hearing of the subject and shall notify the parties it deems most concerned. Three (3) notices, at least ten (10) days prior to any such hearing," shall be posted within or about the area proposed to be rezoned or reclassified. Following this hearing the Council may follow the recommendation of the Com- missionor refer the subject to the Commission for their reconsideration and subse- quent report to the Council, upon receipt of which the Council shall take final - action, granting or denying reclassification, within thirty (30) days thereafter. • (2) All petitions for a change of use district boundaries shall be accom- panied by a plat in duplicate, drawn to scale, showing the actual dimensions of the tract to be changed, the size, the use and location of existing buildings and build- ings to be erected, and such other• pertinent information as may be required by the Building Inspector. (Ord. 1542; 4-17-56) (3) A petition for a change in use district boundaries or reclassification of property cannot be resubmitted to the Building. Inspector, Planning Commission, or the Council for a period of six (6) months from the date of disapproval of such , petition. I - 4-726: COMPLETION AND RESTORATION OF EXISTING BUILD- INGS: • (a) Pending Permits Valid: Nothing herein contained shall require any change in the plans, construction, designated or intended use of a building, for which a building permit has heretofore been issued, or plans for which are now on file with the Building Inspector, a permit for the erection of which is issued within one (1 ) month after the adoption of this Code, and the construction of which in either case: - _ (1 ) Shall have begun and been.diligently prosecuted within one (1 ) month from the adoption of this Code, and; S • (2) Be entirely completed according to such plans as filed within one (1 ) year from the adoption of this Code. - (b) Nonconforming Uses: The lawful use of any building, structure or land existing at the time of the enactment of this Code may be continued, although such use does not conform with the provisions of this Code, provided the following con- -. - - clitions are mei: (1 ) Unsafe structures: Nothing in this Chapter shall prevent the strengthening or restoring to a safe condition of any portion of a building or i structure declared unsafe by a proper authority. 559; 1261 • •.>jinutes - Renton City Council Meeting (Cont.) 2-5-68 Mayor Custer introduced a group of students from Renton High School Boys .Club who r are._attending the Council meeting in participation of. Student Government Week. Attendance on a voluntary basis included about 25 youths who will also be coming to City Hall during the coming week for two hours daily to observe operation of various departments. A mock City Council meeting will be conducted by the group on Saturday, February 10th, between 10:00 a.m. and noon and Councilmen and Depart- ment Heads were invited to attend. P -niC HEARING: Hazel W. Chenaur appeal of R-3 rezone denial on property located on the West side of 116th Avenue S.E. between S.E. 110th and S.E. 112th Streets. This being the date set, the hearing was declared open. Letter from Planning Director Erickson reported Planning Commission recommendation that,since detrimental effects could be anticipated and such rezone not being in the best interest of the surrounding residential area, R-1 be considered the best and highest use for this property. Petition containing approximately 20 signatures was attached objecting to the rezone which document had been submitted to the Planning Commission. Mr. Robert Hall, 419 Securities Building, Seattle, Attorney representing Mrs. Chenaur, stated that the proposed use is felt to be the fullest and best for the property noting the proximity of other multiple dwellings in the immediate vicinity and apartment directly behind the proposed development. He added that such housing is greatly needed, that the plans meet with the presently existing Comprehensive Plan and that the property had once been rezoned to R-3 but reverting according to an ordinance which had a one year construction commencement provision, since repealed. Topography of the area was outlined with embankment division from singly family area being noted and Attorney Hall stated developers would be able to furnish parking as required and would be willing to work out any further matters required or desirable. Film slides were shown by the Planning Director after which Councilman Shane . inquired regarding apparent drainage problems noted when visiting the site and also in regard to sewering the area. Planning Director Ericksen advised that all such details have to be worked out prior to occupancy of the premises and all Departments concerned meet approve the particular portion of the proposal which is under their jurisdiction. Discussion ensued regarding conformancy of procedures on various applications submitted and Planning Director Ericksen noted that the Commissions actions are uniform and on the basis of the Comprehensive standpoint. Specific detrimental effects were noted to be traffic congestion and loss of privacy to individual property owners on the lower sites. The Planning Director noted the project does not meet with the proposed Comprehensive Plan .Moved by Morris, seconded by Edwards that the hearing be closed. Carried. Moved by Morris, seconded by Perry, that the appeal be denied in concurrence with the Planning Commission recommendation that R-1 is the best and highest use for the property. A dissenting voice vote brought request for roll call which resulted as follows: Aye: Morris, Schellert, Delaurenti, Perry, Trimm, Edwards, Maxin and Bruce. No: Garrett, Grant, Shane and Barei. The motion carried denying the appeal. C0101UNICATIONS: Application from Mr. Robert H. Schlosser, Mgr.,Cougar Den, 219 Main Avenue South, requested that Mutual Amusement Company be granted required license to operate an additional pinball device at said business location. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to refer the matter to the Police and License Committee with power to act,, whichncarried after:inquiry regarding the regality of pinball machines and their comparison to punch boards. Discussion ensued wherein the city :Attorney advised of Supreme Court ruling, based upon Attorney General's Opinion that they are both.gaming devices and where chance predominates over skill the activity is outlawed and illegal with the three elements under which court decisions are determined being 1. consideration is paid to participate; 2. must be some kind of reward; 3. element of uncertainty exists. In further discussion City Attorney Shellan stated the City has a right, which goes back to common rule law, to license under its police power and can im- pose a license or regulatory fee. Councilman Shane felt the pinball and punch board devices should be treated equally and moved, with second by Schellert, that if pinballs are illegal they be taken out tomorrow. It was subsequently moved by Morris, seconded by Bruce, to refer the matter to the law and Ordinance Committee to report back. Moved by Barei, seconded by Perry, to table the matter. Carried. Letter from Vern Church, Purchasing Agent, reported that specifications are now prepared and requested permission to call for bids for equipment which has been provided for in the 1968 budget. February 26th was recommended as the bid opening date. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to concur in the request and recommended bid opening date. Discussion ensued regarding the City maintenance program for city streets and the • possibility of contracting such work. It was noted that cities usually do their own maintenance, and after further discussion regarding operation of the city equipment; budget, and departmental administration, question was called for on the pending motion to concur in the bid call and opening date and the motion carried. • 9 Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting 2-19-68 COMMUNICATIONS: (Cont.) Letter from Jack Wilson, City Engineer, submitted statement in sum of $383.88 due Cornell, Howland, Hayes and Merryfield for work in connection with Well No. 8 to January 24, 1968. Approval for payment was recommended. Moved by Morris, seconded by Bruce, to refer the payment to the Auditing and Accounting Committee with power to act. Carried. Claim submitted by Donna and Rodney Stewart was read requesting reimbursement of $49.87 for damage to water tank elements when water was shut off and water drained out of the tank. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to refer the Claim to the City Attorney and Insurance Carrier. Carried. Document from Robert J. Hall, Attorney for Mrs. Hazel W. Chenaur, requested Council reconsideration of rezone denial noting grievance that all evidence had not been presented at the hearing, particularly exhibit of photographs and color slides as shown to the Planning Commission. Moved by Perry, seconded by Schellert, that the Council reconsider its action of the prior meeting as requested. Carried. Moved by Perry, seconded by Garrett, to refer the matter of the rezone to the Planning Committee to report back. Carried. Letter from Renton School District 403, Rudolph Seppi, Director of Plant 'Facilities, requested approval from the City for service to the new. Earlington Elementary School, to be located at South 132nd Street and Langston Road, King County, by the sanitary sewer system of the City, costs to be the School Districts and Late Comers Agreement to be allowed for recovery or portion of the cost. Moved by G=irrett, seconded by • Morris, to grant the request with referral to the Law and Ordinance Committee to prepare the necessary documents. Councilman Barei reported that the Sanitation Committee has a recommendation for approval of this request. The motion carried. Letter from Mr. Ray Van Hollebeke, Property Management, The Boeing Company, requested permission to install a 12,000 gallon propane gas tank on property located in area North of 6th Avenue North, now under lease from the City. Drawing attached indicated the location of the tank and piping. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Bruce, to refer the request to the Property Committee for recommendation. (Fire Chief and City Engineer to be consulted) Carried. Letter from John E. Iverson, Attorney, petitioned, on behalf of Mr. and Mrs. Roger A. Hokanson, for consent to transfer,and sale of their interest in the Renton Radio Cab Co. , Inc. New owners are individual holders of For-Hire Licenses and will contin'ie to operate as drivers and include: Phillip A. Schmolke, present owner, Gerald Halstead, present owner, and Michael Craig, 10931 S.E. 164th Street, Renton. Moved by Perry, seconded by Garrett, to refer the matter to the Police and License Committee for recommendation. Carried. Letter from Jack Wilson, City Engineer, reported that the letter of intent to annex property .to Renton which ad;oins Sunset Blvd. E., between 132nd Ave. S.E. and 138th Ave. S.E. is signed by owners representing 84.74% of the assessed valuation of the property, which is located on both sided of the highway and contains approximately 13.6 acres with an assessed valuation of $15,600.00. Annexation would make the City Limits more uniform in this area. The petitioners are Alhoff, Smith & Beale and the matter has been referred to the Boundary Review Board. • Letter from Sven A. Johnson, Building Director, recommended that Revocable Sign Permit be 'issued for sign encroachment of public right-of-way for Montgomery Ward & Co. at 319 Williams Avenue South. Moved by Perry, seconded by Barei, to concur in the recommendation. Carried. Letter from Building Director Johnson recommended that Revokable Sign Permit be granted upon revised application of Dr. Hurley at 9112 South 3rd Street, since original sign was installed to different plans than submitted. Moved by Perry, seconded by Trimm, to concur in the recommendation of the Building Director. Carried. Letter from W.E. Bennett, Utility Accountant, submitted proposed Agreement between the City and Fire District No. 25 regarding obligation and responsibility for fire hydrant:maintenance and inspection,, and consideration to be paid the City of Renton therefor. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Edwards to authorize and approve the execution. Moved by Perry, seconded by Grant to refer the document to the Fire and Water Committee for recommendation. Carried. -2- • • • Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting 2-19-68 Remarks: Councilman Maxin announced a meeting of the Planning Committee at 9:00 a.m. on Saturday, February 24, 1968. Councilman Barei requested that the Janitor oil the Chairs-around the Council table to reduce the noise. Councilman Perry noted that the tables had been removed which had been used by the City Attorney and the Press and suggested they be replaced. • Mr, Robert Hall, Attorney for Mrs. Chenauer addressed the Council advising that he had been mistaken regarding photographs which were submitted to the Council on the matter and offered apology to Planning Director Ericksen noting however, that Multiple zoning is the only feasible use for the subject property and that it is economically impossible to develop the area as R-l. After further ,comments in regard to the subject property Mr. Nall was advised that the matter was now in • the Planning Committee which would be meeting at 9:00 a.m. tomorrow at which time his remarks might properly be- addressed the Committee. As there was no further business to come before the Council, it was moved by Trimm, seconded by Schellert, to adjourn. The motion carried, and the meeting was adjourned at 12:05 p.m. • ! Helmie Nelson, City Clerk . !. . / - . W. Custer, Mayor • • • • • • • • • • • • _.p {Minu-ces - Rental City Council Meeting 2-26-63 COUNCIL C0;•"1IT TLE REPORTS: (Cont.) ' Unfinished Business Councilman Maxin, Chairman of the Planning Committee, submitted report recommending that requests of C. K. Mullins and F.E. Lawrence for 'zoning revisions to the Compre- hensive Plan, be referred to the Planning Commission for recommendations. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Maxin, to concur in the recommendation. Carried. noco:mended that appeal of Hazel Chenaur be allowed and R-2 zoning be granted on the . ^object property, owner agreeing to amend her application as discussed with Attorney Hall on her behalf. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Grant, to concur in the rezone as recommended. Carried. Councilman Maxin announced a meeting of the Planning Committee on Wednesday, February ..i:I? at 7:00 p.m. Csunci]Jnan Bruce, Chairman, Fire and Water Committee, submitted recommendation that the firm of Cornell,Howland, Hayes and Merryfield be retained for the design and preparation of plans and specifications for Well No. 8, and that the Mayor and City Clerk be -authorized to sign the necessary agreement documents, upon approval thereof by the City Attorney. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Shane, to concur. Carried. The Fire and Water Committee recommended that the Agreement between the City and Fire District No. 25 for hydrant service and water supply be approved and the Mayor and City Clerk be authorized to sign the document. Moved by Barei, seconded by Schellert, to concur. Carried. :he Public Relations Committee met regarding the request of Local 21R, Washington ..te Council of County and City Employees, AFL-CIO for Council acknowledgment and • it was recommended that the Department of Labor and Industries conduct a check for certification purposes as provided by law. Moved by Morris, seconded by Garrett to concur. Carried. .ounailman Grant, Chairman of the Light and Power Committee reported that a formal request has been made of Mr. John Nelson, or a representative of Seattle City Light, to appear at a public hearing of the Light and Power Committee to discuss proposed franchise and power rates within the City, date for hearing to be determined. Pico, the Light and Power Committee submitted a proposed Resolution resolving that tha interests of the City would be best served by employing a Consultant to provide :ate analysis and technical assistance _in .re .1r d to_power problems, The-serviceis to be .. .. .ewed in a ;tud : of power supply and rates were .outlihed with areas'to be analyze.a :_'3rein. the City and .Puget Power may work together to improve the City with regard to of mutual concern, the studies to be coordinated with the Traffic Engineering apartment. The Light and Power Committee will interview Consulting Firms and made ai recommendation as to the firm to conduct the study and shall report cost for such study, and at a future date, report the findings to the Council. Moved by Morris, seconded by Maxin, to concur in the proposed Resolution. Councilman Grant moved that his minority report be incorporated as item 3. of the Resolution that: In event the City is unable to resolve the study areas to its satisfaction, the consulting firm be directed to analyze the means whereby the City could develop its own power distribution system, join with another public power utility (Seattle City Light) or public utility district. The motion to amend the original Resolution was seconded by Darei,and after discussion and dissenting voice vote roll call was requested which resulted as follows: Aye: Garrett, Perry•, Bruce, Grant, Shane and Barei. No: Morris, Schellert, Trimm and Maxin. The amendment carried and subsequently the original motion approving =Lhe three resolution.,prcosals. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Trimm, to adjourn. Dissenting voice vote brought roll call request which was taken as follows: Aye: Barei, Maxin, Trimm. No: Garrett, Shane, Grant, Bruce, Perry, Schellert and Morris. The meeting moved to the next order of business. • Moved by Schellert, seconded by Grant that the meeting be adjourned at 12:45 p.m. Carried. Councilman Grant inquired regarding the status of the request for dog control in the Highlands area. It was noted that the matter is in Committee and a study will be made and report submitted upon completion. • Councilman Grant reported a request from property owners that the vacant property to the East of 509 Tobin Avenue South be cleaned up and shrubbery cut as the litter is piling up and attention is needed. Mayor Custer advised that the owner has re- moved a house from the lot and further attention will be given the matters reported. -7- . • • Renton .Planning Commission • Meeting December 27 , 1967 Minutes ' • • Page 5 • Mr. Rusk stated he was opposed to further apartment development in the area, �- Mr. Robert Hall of Seattle identified himself as attorney for the applicant, Mrs. Chenaur, and gave a brief history of the property in question. He stated that his client is asking for the zoning which had previously been granted and which had been lost due to the reversion ordinance then in effect which has since been re- pealed'. He discussed the undeveloped access road about which there • appeared to be some title cloud. Mr. Hall stated this undeveloped • access according to all information he has been able to get belongs . to the' City of Renton. He stated the rezone is a logical one;- would have •no effect on the single family residential area known as Hill- crest Lane directly to the west as those houses are below his client' s property and face away from it. He stated further that. cost of development of the property makes it economically unfeasible for anything but multi.-family residential use. • Mr. Bob Harris , 10843 - 116th Ave. S.E. spoke in opposition to the rezone due to the immediate proximity of $20 , 000 to $40 , 000 homes . Mr. Jerome Stephenson, 11430 S.E. 112th St. , asked how sewer lines • could be connected to the property. The Planning Director displayed a sanitary sewer and water lines map for the area; and stated that due to the - elevation the developer could get sewers only through the west side of the property by obtaining easements through ad-- • • jacent properties. He stated further that there are sewer lines along 116th Ave. S .E. but they could not go easterly due to the elevation unless some sort of pumping system was installed. • Mr.-. Clayton Chenaur discussed the history of the property; the fact. that he thought he had the proper zoning, being unaware of the reversion to R-1; the. access problem, the development of sewers , the cost of development being too high for other than multi-family use. ' He stated that the development would be adequately served by • sewers and would be screened to protect adjacent residences. He urged the Commission to grant the rezone. Stredicke stated that the area, notwithstanding the 'two existing apartments , has been developed for single family use and he would not be in favor of rezoning for multiple use. Messrs. Stephenson, Peterson, Rusk and Harris , previously acknowledged, • spoke again in protest against the rezone, as . well as Mr. Ronald Wy- let of 11020 - 115th Ave. S.E. Mr. Robert Hall and Mr. Clayton Chenaur spoke again on behalf of the rezone request. There being no further comments, . it was moved by Stredicke, seconded by Teegarden, that the hearing be closed. Motion carried unanimously. r •. ACTION: • Li Moved by Stredicke, seconded by Brower, that the application of • Hazel W. Chenaur for rezone from R-1 to R--3 be denied. Motion carried unanimously. Further moved by Stredicke, seconded by Teegarden, that a communica- tion be sent too the City Council recommending that the highest use of this property be R-1 as presently zoned. Motion carried unani mously. • c• • Renton Planning •Commission • Meeting December 27, 1967 Minutes • Page 6 • • • The Chairman advised the applicant ' s attorney of her right of appeal of the Planning Commission decision by letter to the City • Council within ten days. Mr. Hall stated he understood the appeal rights of his client. • 5. ADMINISTRATIVE MATTERS REFERRAL FROM RENTON BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT (a) Albert Balch and Garden Park, Inc. , request for variance '- from height limitation. The Chairman stated that the Board of Adjustment had referred the above variance application to the Planning Commission and referred the Commissioners to copies of Board of Adjustment Minutes as well as copy of letter from the FAA relative to the matter; such copies • in each Commissioner' s folder. ACTION: • • Moved by Brower, seconded by Racanello, that this matter be con- sidered at the next Administrative Meeting of the Renton Planning Commission in order to give the Commission time to study the material submitted. Motion carried unanimously. • STREET NAME PROBLEM • • (b) The Chairman read a letter from Fire Chief M. C. Walls concern- in duplication street name in Thunder Hill #2_.. g , parcel #26 . The Planning Director stated that this particular street (Thomas Lane) is privately owned and the City has no control over it. He sug- gested the Commission might wish to refer the matter to the Board of Public. Works for their review. ACTION: Moved by Stredicke, seconded by Racanello, that a copy of Fire Chief . Walls ' letter be sent to the Mayor ' s office and to the Board of Public Works for their action. Motion carried unanimously. APPOINTMENT OF NEW PLANNING COMMISSION MEMBER • (c) The Chairman read copy of a letter from Mayor D. W. Custer to the City Council appointing Mr. Tony Mola as a member of the Renton Planning Commission to fill the vacancy created by the resignation of Mr. Stanley Stone and requesting concurrence of the Council in this appointment, • RESIGNATION OF PLANNING COMMISSION MEMBER - (d) Mr. Robert Brower announced that regretfully' this would be his Ilast meeting with the Planning Commission as he had been recalled to active duty with the United States Navy, and stated it. had• been 1 a privilege to serve bn the Commission. SITE PLAN APPROVAL (Request for Information) (e) Stredicke asked if site plans had been submitted for the approval of the Planning Commission for the church located at 7th and M. The Planning Director replied that this church had submitted their site plans as well as a variance request for parking and had received approval of the site plans on March 28 , 1962 . He stated • -D /i . Sc.2 , fJl-vQ/"e //Aay7i 71 o,..5--- /2'7')//I `it r . 4 _ • \ ',1' .- . �'4'l,a <S d.,i` ,*- , . v 1 i. 'S. /_/�iU/ k0-zio • J/ a y,z7 vS (77 // • i i �• qtr z.• / �• • I - - ( . 1' I E 1 ...Au,'i y lb hi off/.// I« (cY 6(110/ c' / /X ` 6 /770s' (17211 '71 iihipio. , 400.it ..,....4414,1,. . - .0 f,_ . v. ' y1 . . ' •"� "t•s+ \ VP11-1-121 _ .. . ( I BMW a i i 1 ' I. 1 Vi � J © uT_iiI,,,GS�eY ! 4cY'osS' `/ - /lue s-E ".. `, - =II . - - I !i '1 i • ' ram► � , ',Ir k'., �'4 /1y;/ t,P} 4-A �^ ' a ��t ` 1' f u U /P 1i JYor± ead—e y y -rYofy f Le) 6o ) .4,'p Y- plprefer74) N . • . , _______ I7 0- kr I ' .._Aiilr.- !fir- Ili - ai V/mow /00)-7//,(e___5-7'er/), - '�o/f, //e '7A - sue, =�$ c;)7,d- 7// i_ 'y y-N /9 J `'77z-2' 62y (27 e2/ 11 RIM=--MI . / i ' . 3Sa4/�- ,,// ssp,A D / .,, Py c�y�AON r" a >/ ,= s _ : _ a �.� — Oil s -j N O/ .x( �4 ,s,apt) T 71 .1 1 .. ,,, - r.„ _ - .. ... i . _ .-,, _ . . , . _y . . 6n/ ci -v' X) -A C- - y / -)-7 ..,-) c -)? ;--' / ' A n/ / -i 3 4 . 4 V41(1111° , • i ii.. 4 / /„.S.-P�J 7ZCPI 1 , / ,. .A a N.A 0 (� wot J ' l Il• y�.• .,fir • - ;�. . �Y. A, ,g[ - _�.#• '� 1 1 i�. r" - .• U ". r . T 4•: { - Milk -4, t t Vie L.> 4/es ii-er. 1 Y -fro/4 a i_D Y c x . ,s z,6) c_ci i-AI e r- ,--�` prop r--(Y r t x x t'i t 11 ' S; 1, f - . Ai,%i ' .• '1,4 I' - .. - '' it , •Y .1 ,/,• . ; I' - f r may-- l_f0 .',7 /e / • 41 till! AY' ikY IRK $ V 1 7 — r y t 1 a V ^ /o Y 1-, 7 V !e C 6) / �/ C_ i l t/ `f Y /4-1 c)/,A a-o A- , --S'2-CJ C_ 0 Yif/e i - Ya y0,F'1,-747 bl petition, that decision shall be final unless the owner files Notice of Appeal to the Council as specified hereinafter. Upon receiving Notice of Appeal the Council shall set a date for hearing of the subject and shall notify the parties it deems most concerned. Three (3) notices, at least ten (10) days prior to any such hearing, shall be posted within or about the area proposed to be rezoned or reclassified. Following this hearing the Council may follow the recommendation of the Corn- , - mission or refer the subject to the Commission for their reconsideration and subse- quent report to the Council, upon receipt of which the Council shall take final action, granting or denying reclassification, within thirty (30) days thereafter. (2) All petitions for a change of use district boundaries shall be accom- panied by a plat in duplicate, drawn to scale, showing the actual dimensions of the _ - tract to be changed, the size, the use and location of existing buildings and build- ings to be erected, and such other pertinent information as may be required by the Building Inspector. (Ord. 1542; 4-17-56) ' (3) A petition for a change in use district boundaries or reclassification of property cannot be resubmitted to the Building. Inspector, Planning Commission, or the Council for period of six (6) months from the date of disapproval of such petition, 4-726: COMPLETION AND RESTORATION OF EXISTING BUILD- INGS: ' - (a) Pending Permits Valid: Nothing herein contained shall require any change in the plans, construction, designated or intended use of a building, for which a building permit has heretofore been issued, or plans for which are now on file with the Building Inspector, a permit for the erection of which is issued within ,_. _ one (1 ) month after the adoption of this Code, and the construction of which in either case: _ (1 ) Shall have begun and been diligently prosecuted within one (1 ) month from the adoption of this Code, and; (2) Be entirely completed according to such plans as filed within one (1 ) year from the adoption of this Code. (b) Nonconforming Uses: The lawful use of any building, structure or land existing at the time of the enactment of this Code may be continued, although such use does not conform with the provisions of this Code, provided the following con- - ditions are met: (1 ) Unsafe structures: Nothing in this Chapter shall prevent the strengthening or restoring to a safe condition of any portion of a building or structure declared unsafe by a proper authority. 559; 1261 - " ` \ ' 7 -- \ L7- \ 7_1•' \ et 2-'4, e 4A/A t' ,e - C e444), ,- 42-a/dam / - -27 - 7 in 1 to N 1 S E. 108TH ST. d' Lki (7., 41 w Ui W > w a � 2• At �► F /1&\ 4 wI ro ? 1 ) 4 0. 14 �! 4 A C,. a S.E. 11 0 TH ST. , 1 3 W r, ° ' J) c- 7 ,=3. r .:_.- y I }i it ' ---0-- 9 0 .40 '.9 0 i t11 N s, f� y & Igi • i 4 0 IA , k I I i 3 . /3 li d « a N y E. I J 4) -9 zz' I I I - I Z T14 AN/E. f 'l '" O ( \ ‘ ZT+,--{ -1' • - , W = �! ,r�..T�rt-. , � `7 I Z/F• 7 • • Kenton Planning Commission Meeting December 27 , 1967 Minutes Page 4 • is narrow and on a hillside. Teegarden stated he felt it would be a mistake to allow an apartment Ydu.i iding at the end of such a nar-- I ; • row street at this time. Forgaard asked when the Transamerica property to the south and -west of the subject . property was rezoned to R-3. . The Planning Director replied .this was done in 1963 . . Transamerica has indicated it does • not plan to open access to the Renton Hill area or develop their R-3 area at this time. Comments from the audience-were invited. Mr. Jack Newell stated he is the property owner immediately east of the applicant' s property . and is definitely opposed to any multi-family residential develop- ment in the area; that he feels the area is an established single family residential zone. • As there were no further comments , it was moved by Stredicke, seconded by Forgaard, that the hearing be closed. Motion carried unanimously. • ACTION: • • Moved by Teegarden, seconded by Stredicke, that the rezone applica- tion of Albert. L. 'Duncalf for R-3 zoning be denied. Motion carried unanimously. The Chairman advised the applicant of his right to appeal the decision of the Planning Commission by written notice to the City Council within ten days . (c) Che_naur, Hazel W. , Appl. No. R-436-67 , rezone from R-3- property located west side of 116th Ave, S.E._ between S .E 110th and 112th Sts. (westerly of McKnight Jr. High School) The rezone application was described by the Chairman; and the loca- tion of the property was pointed out by the Planning Director on the zoning map. The Planning Director indicated that access to ' the property was via an undeveloped right of way. Slides of the property were shown. Photographs of the property submitted by the applicant were passed around among the Commissioners . The Planning Director stated that in 1956 the property was zoned R-3 , but as it was not developed it reverted back to R-1 status under a reversion ordinance in effect at that time. The Chairman read a petition against the rezone submitted by property owners in the area and bearing 20 signatures. The Planning Director stated that the existing Comprehensive Plan indicates this area as low to medium density multi-family resi- dential, but that the revised Comprehensive Plan now under study by the City Council cuts this area back to single family f residential. . . Comments from the audience were invited. Mr. Roger Peterson, 10514 -• 113th Ave. S.E. , owner of property westerly of subject property, voiced his objections to the proposed rezone. Mr. George Rusk, 11029 - 116th Ave. S .E. , stated he owns a house north of 110th which he had purchased with the stipulation the area was R-1, but had found out later that a portion of land nearby was zoned R-3 upon which two apartment houses have been constructed. • OF R4,A A. 4, © z THE CITY OF RENTON MUNICIPAL BUILDING 200 MILL AVE. SO. RENTON,WASH.98055 nmelL BARBARA Y. SHINPOCH. MAYOR • DELORES A. MEAD 090 CITY CLERK • (206) 235-2500 o9 P -so sE1,105 April 7, 1982 CERTIFICATION TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN: The attached copies of all record documents, files, maps and other material relating to the zoning and rezone of that parcel of property owned by Durwood E. Blood are hereby provided pursuant to Superior Court of Washington Order No. 863212 Subpoena Duces Tecum. Hazel Chenaur Rezone 436-67 (2 files) Durwood Blood Special Permit 089-80 Concerned Citizens represented by James E. Eeckhoudt (Durwood Blood Rezone) ECF 001-81 Durwood Blood Rezone 001-81 STATE OF WASHINGTON) )SS. COUNTY OF KING ) I, DELORES A. MEAD, duly appointed, qualified and acting City Clerk of and for the City of Renton, King County, Washington do hereby Certify that the attached are true and correct copies as appearing in the public records on file in the office of the City Clerk of the City of Renton. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and the official seal of the City of Renton, Washington, this 7th day of April 1982. 'ad,. Delores A. Mead, Cityt.Clerk KAMERON C. CAY'%c ATTORNEY AT LAW P,.O. BOX 798 311 MORRIS AVE. SOUTH RENTON,WASHINGTON 98055 1206)255-0603 Concerning the enclosed subpoena, our experience indicates that there are often delays in a pending lawsuit. Rather than have a . witness appear and wait for hours or perhaps days to testify, we believe that it is better for the witness to be kept "on call. " If you will fill out the information at the bottom of this letter and return it to us before the above noted trial date, we will contact you by telephone when we have reached the point in the trial for testimony. We will do our best to avoid any unnecessary appearances on your part and try to give you as much notice as possible as to when you will be called to the witness stand. If you do not desire to remain on an "on call" basis, we will have no alternative but to require that you appear on the morning set for trial and have you wait until called as a witness. Very truly yours, KAMERON C. CAYCE KCC:ch I agree to remain "on call" and can be reached at the following telephones and addresses: Day Night (Telephone) (Telephone) • (Address) (Address) DJC Civil C1! (77!) Repro re Rights . Reserved by Daily Journal commerce. 'Cg_19 IA WI Dill (Receipt of Copy) (Date Filed by Clerk) SUPERIOR COURT OF WASHINGTON FOR KING COUNTY DURWOOD BLOOD, et ux , Plaintiff, NO. 863212 vs. HAZEL CHENAUR, SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM Defendant. THE STATE OF WASHINGTON, TO: C.I.T.Y:_.0F....RENTQN.._ALL.._DAV1D...CLEMENS.F...Act.ing Plann Director You are hereby commanded to be and appear at the Superior Court of the State of Washington, King County, in the Courtroom of Judges ._2.r 5isiin.g...JUdge..., Dept. No E.9.4.2..., in the County Courthouse, in Seattle, at ..944:10 o'clock in the .am...cim c of the .2.th... day of ..Ap.r.i1 , A. D. 19..$2then and there to give evidence in a certain cause wherein .DURWOOD...BLQQD , Plaintiff and HAZEL, CHENAUR , Defendant and you are further directed and commanded to bring with.you the following papers and documents now in your possession or under your control: All records,. documents, files , maps and other material relating .to the zoning and rezone of that parcel of property currently owned by Durwood E . Blood , legally described in the attached Quit Claim Deed . This request includes information relating to the rezone from R-1 to R-2 prior to June, 1970 , and the modification of the City maps following the decision of Stan- ley Soderland on June 23, ,1970 in King County Cause No. 704684 , wherein said rezone was set aside.. Specifically, plaintiff seeks information as to when the maps available to the public were • changed to reflect the zoning from R-2 to R-1 per said court order. • and to remain in attendance upon said Court until discharged, and HEREIN FAIL NOT AT YOUR PERIL. Witness my hand this ...2ns:1. day of .April. , 1982 (01......„.,,, KAMERON C. CAYCE ~_ Attorney.... of Record for P 1 a i tiff CAYCE...6t...F.LE.CK P.O. Box 798, Renton, WA, 98057 • 255-0603 Phone I COPY oRDii4ANCE i4O 3 -7 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON, CHANGING THE ZONING CLASSIFICATION OF CERTAIN PROPERTIES WITHIN THE CITY OF RENTON FROM RESIDENCE SINGLE FAMILY DISTRICT (R-1) TO RESIDENCE DISTRICT (R-2) WHEREAS under Chapter VII, Title IV (Building Regulations) of Ordinance No. 1628 known as the "Code of General Ordinances of the City of Renton", as amended, and the maps adopted in conjunction therewith, the property hereinbelow described has heretofore been zoned as Single Family Residence District (R-1); and WHEREAS a proper petition for change of zone classification of said property has been filed with the City Clerk on or about December 7, 1967, which petition was duly referred to the Planning Commission for investigation, study and public hearing, and a public hearing having been held thereon on or about December 27, 1967, and said matter having been duly continued and the Petitioner-Owners having duly appealed from the decision of the P1,Anning Commission and hearings having been held before the City Council of the City of Renton and Petitioner-Owner having duly amended his Petition, and said rezoning request, as amended, being in conformity with the City's Comprehensive Plan and all parties having been heard appearing in support thereof or in opposition thereto, NOW THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON, AS FOLLOWS: SECTION I: The following described property in the City of Renton is hereby rezoned to Residential District (R-2); the City Engineer and the Planning Director are hereby authorized and directed to change the maps of the Zoning Ordinance, as amended, to evidence said rezoning, to-wit: The West 130 feet of the North one-half of Tract 211, C. D. Hillman's Lake;Washington Garden of Eden Division No. 4, according to plat recorded in Volume 11 of plats, page 82, in King County, Washington, except the North 30 ft. and Nest 30 ft. of said Tract 211, conveyed to-the City of Renton by deed recorded under auditor's file No. 5383178; all situate in Renton, King County, Washington, (located behind apartments on 116th Ave. S.E. between 12th Ave. N. (SE 112th St.) and S. E. 110th St. SECTION II: This Ordinance shall be in full force and effect from and after its passage., approval and legal publication. /fin PASSED BY THE CITY COUNCIL this day of March, 196: . J )1" Hel u -1san, City. Clerk `;. , -61 APPROVED BY THE MAYOR this 4=t-h day of Ma 19680 _ P, �a�i1fe �s f Approved a to :�z Donald W. Custer, Mayor Gerard M. Shellan, City Attorney Date of Publication: MAR 2 01968 COPY I' \' ORD/NANCE NO4 ,7 3$7 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON, CHANGING THE ZONING CLASSIFICATION OF CERTAIN PROPERTIES WITHIN THE CITY OF RENTON FROM RESIDENCE SINGLE FAMILY DISTRICT (R-1) TO RESIDENCE DISTRICT (R-2) WHEREAS under Chapter VII, Title IV (Building Regulations) of Ordinance No. 1628 known as the "Code of General Ordinances of the City of Renton", as amended, and the maps adopted in conjunction therewith, the property hereinbelow described has heretofore been zoned as Single Family Residence District (R-1); and WHEREAS a proper petition for change of zone classification of said property has been filed with the._City Clerk on or about December 7, 1967, which petition was duly referred to the Planning Commission for investigation, study and public hearing, and a public hearing having been held thereon on or about December 27, 1967, and said matter having been duly continued and the Petitioner-Owners having duly appealed from the decision of the Planning Commission and hearings having been held before the City Council of the City of Renton and Petitioner-Owner having duly amended his Petition, and said rezoning request, as amended, being in conformity with the City's Comprehensive Plan and all parties having been heard appearing in support thereof or in opposition thereto, NOW THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY CV RENTON, WASHINGTON, AS FOLLORS: SECTION I: The following described property in the City of Renton is hereby rezoned to Residential District (R-2); the City Engineer and the Planning Director are hereby authorized and directed to change the maps of the Zoning Ordinance, as amended, to evidence said rezoning, to-wit: The West 130 feet of the North one-half of Tract 211, C. D. Hillman's lake Washington Garden of Eden Division No. 4, according to plat recorded in Volume 11 of plats, page 82, in King County, Washington, except the North 30 Et. and West 30 ft. of said Tract 211, conveyed to the City of Renton by deed recorded under auditor's file No. 5383178; all situate in Renton, King County, Washington, (located behind apartments on 116th Ave. S.E. between 12th Ave. N. (SE 112th St.) and S. E. 110th St. SECTION II: This Ordinance shall be in full force and effect from and after its passage, approval and legal publication. PASSED BY THE CITY COUNCIL this /kS h day of March, 196=. r! Hel” >ison, City Clerk aE APPROVED BY THE MAYOR this day of Ma 1968. Ems/ J : Approved tO � Donald W. Custer, Mayor Gerard M. 'S'h'—ell�lan, City Attorney , Date of Publication: MAR 2 0 1968 ti MEMORANDUM TO.:. - Files DATE:' :July 9,' 197E FROM: Planning.Director , , ':SUBJECT:. . Hazel Chenaur Special Permit Application.' = Telephone Conversation with John,K: Pain, `Jr. ,.: Assistant'City Attorney • 8 In accordance with telephone conversation '•.between Planning Director- and the Assistant City Attorney on above date, it was indicated a : that .the`matter of rezoning and the special permit application of . Hazel Chenaur: was essentially closed, and :the property in question remains in an. R-1 zoning classification -.:..a. ..'.**A... The'Tproperty'owner:.in :question must.-re-•initiate rezone Of the •beforea•.s ecial : ; property. p permit forApartments can be considered. . '..•"_';' '•,`- • • ` are one unions o_ ..nw an 29 N Decree herein, and defendant HazelW:,..enaur not appearing in 30 j 31 �I person or by counsel, her default having .been duly and ! regularly taken and entered herein, the ,court•haying heard 32 1,i JL01,1 T .. 1 000LTRT9 e ANDERSON 11 ATTORNEYS A7 LAW I� in WILLIAMS AVENUE SOUTH•P.O.00%4E4 10NI RENT'ON,WASHINGTON 0005E ^.11x. 5�; - "F.is t•<:'';:'�'!�,., rty,r' tb' - ;«j ' ' r+ 'rL, dw ,1i +:,xr :yi ' 'q. vF :F:t ' S1 ,5,. «, J MEMO RANDtM j. 11� O �E,�: J.u'1. '9 197 A T r T O. ,: r •F'iles . • Planrin, rector. FROM: 9'. ;; a do Per:m .t >A �c '�: atizr'°i:5� ecal'- ' SUBJ�:CT�f�� .Hazel��r'Gkien p ` J Jr ' orie���Co�nv.ersat' on 'with-: o 'Te].ep'h fr,., I r ' t e- ;J�' ar •':P,t �: 5 is �A Y•'.. >I 5, , 1'�1 �k �i ✓.1 i V' 5 irector. .'S,:,, con'versati,ori''.be.tween. `Planning D ..r; Th .ac:.c•ordance''::'wi�tt ,telephone .. v: date t`.'`w{as in dicat'ed :1;: --' Attorne :.on'."abo e and`'tlie';;,'A 's: starit': C Y Y, ,' c ion' of f':I'':'r'e z oriin arid,',;the,' p P, rm 't, :a i-i at that` the,;`matt-er::'o g. ,. e'rt in' ues'tion d' arid��th'e .. ro Y4 s t o l'T close, ., P P ':-;',',`: Hazel :Chenaiir,:''-;was'':e'ssen • ;., lass ificati �remai s I',-,' y.: t._ f'.'th �o e: '0 1 ;r z n 'i'a te:r� e `'t-•�i n°i sti.o emus• :x e, �;.::, _ `er;;,•:in'� pie �. �J"' ;�T'h�e��: �°ro'"ert` ';own :q ,��;,��,' P P:- y`' d r d �n�ts°:c an�� ,be 'cori's i e e erm' .�'' f o• r:'.`a'� `'artme ec'i.al'. P _ 5 FI' ; - • li r': vY 1' %S. ' A i 1 '„ 11�_' ",,.. ='C •''t: ti r • • w",.;.,'f' r" r.. to i' i• � Jl 'I' 'I +'1 pr jj �.1 a a lbw',?'. v%r 't+ n 4h. .'.�it .y I z,4.: I' r5 ij i `t- W� J' ni A. Y , ""ih ,y„ i w" 1,. fir:': ✓ ,'t. '`y1 • • u. �-'�z `tC3..i..,_..'-� 3Cc-�c1ri�'� CyOncl .10. o'� 1d'�n' 29. ,,,' erne`• 'rerein -and 'ceicndant Haze'1` :t ,.•„: enaur'' -not :` pec„,ring '' i' ' Person orb counsel , her. de tau ,: 31 ~. Y 1 .:having :barn .d�:'l� 'arid regularly taken grid en tex d herein:, '.the'" cour't 'having g heard, `;', I T ROBERTS:t.,�1, �� E T.SP.c'�ANDERSON: ` J V LU i•Tia\i '� I • ATTORNEYS AT LAW i — ';} f l WILL1,AMS AVENUE SOUTH'•P.O..'00X:'.; RENTON,W•ASHINGTON 90055 BA 88' 1"` 8 0 gb Ij 0V RA A rrrr: ire +/�\ - ✓VCh 1. ;1 .E {� 1I tf i 3 4_ 7 IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF KING 41 9 }. ROBERT E. JONES and DIANA JONES , ) his, wife; ROGER A. PETERSON and PATRICIA ) 10 ! PETERSON , his: wife ;,,GARTH S. POWELL ANd ) " BILLIE POWELL, his wife ; RONALD R. WYLET and ) : 11 SHERRIE WYLET, his wife ; RAYMOND H. ALEXANDER) ` NO. 704684 and DORIS ALEXANDER, his Rife; PETER: A. R. ) 12 FURZER and 'IRENE FURZER, his wife ; EUGENE. ;) HASTINGS and JEAN HASTINGS, his wife ; ) 13 JAMES E. HORNBERG and BARBARA HORNBERG, his wife ; GARY B. JUST and RUTH JUST, his wife ;. ) 14 and GEORGE RUSK and ANDREA RUSK, his wife , ) �k 15 ' Plaintiffs, ) ) JUDGMENT 16 vs. ) 17 CITY' OF. RENTON, a municipal corporation; : ) and HAZEL W. CHENAUR, a widow,' , ) 18 i . ) Defendants. ' ) 19 ) 20 THIS MATTER having come or duly and regularly for 21 hearing on this date =.before>:the, undersigned judge of the above 22 . 23 � entitled court , plaintiffs �,P_ 7'appearing by 70 . Oti) aS I� , ontof ,said plaintiffs , and being repre- 24 rented by Michael H. Williamson , of Roberts E Anderson, their 25 attorneys of record, the defendant City of 'Renton not appear- 26 ing personally or being represented°by its attorney of roco:'d, 27 ( John K. Pain , but said attorney for defendant City of Renton 28 !( 29jlhaving approved the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and Decree herein, and defendant Hazel W. enaur not appearing in 30 t( person or by counsel, her default having been duly and 31 regularly taken and entered herein, the court hiving heard 32 ROBERTS & ANDERSON JUDO MEN 1m. - l • ATTORNEYS AT LAW f1$WILLIAMS AVENUE SOUTH•P.O.BOX 4C4 RENTON.WASHINGTON 9805E BA 8-188O 9 • . . .,..;. ,.... „ , • r . „ . 1117// 1 1 sworn testimony on behalf of the plaintiffs, being fully advised , • 2 in the promises, and having heretofore made and entered herein , . j 3 its Findings Of Fact and Conclusions ' of Law, Now, Therefore, • 4 IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED by the court 5 as follows: . . ', • 6 I. , ' H 1. . DEFENDANT CHENAUR PERMANENTLY ENJOINED : That ' 7 i defendant HAZEL _W.- CHENAUR be and ,she.'is hereby permanently 8 I enjoined. from .using the real- property, , situated- in 'King County, ' 9 . Washington, and more particularly described as: 10 . West. 130 feet of the North' Half of Tit 2111 i C. D. Hillman's Lake Washington Garen of Eden,' . 11 Division No. 4, ,according to plat' recorded. in Volume 11 of. Plats, page .82i .King County, Washington, 12 EXCEPT the North 30" feet and the, West 30 feet of said Tract 2111 conveyed to the City of Renton by deed , . 13 - . recorded ",under Auditor's File No. 5383178 • . 14 for any other purpose than tat provided. for in the Renton City Code' 15 under the R-1 classification. ` 16 2. JUDGMENT FOR COSTS AGAINST DEFENDANT CHENAUR : That 17 plaintiffs be and they are hereby awarded judgment against the 18 defendant HAZEL W. CHENAUR for their' costs and disbursements herein 19 to be taxed. , 20 • 3. ' DEFENDANT CITY ENJOINED: That the defendant CITY , . 21 OF RENTON be and it is hereby permanently enjoined from iss, ing a 22 . building permit. for other than R-1 '."single residence on the above 23. described property of defendant Hazel .W. Chenaur until the proper 24 procedures as set forth in the Renton City Code are followed, . ' 25 either for a rezoning, variance, or ,special permit. .- 26 . , DONE IN OPEN COURT this 2 3 " day of J 1(4 , 1979. 27 • �--7 , ti 4 el _ ,Ve'le/-.4/1-,e9 ' 281 , t, Presented by: - . 29 1 1 � Y • x 30 Di' ,g2 n M-L t' 5 A +oved `fpr E*y and Notice of of ROBERTS & ANDERSON Pr. s . tat'ion Wa .ved: 31 Attorneys for Plaintiffs /1 ._7/72 — ---/---i . 6 7/7 0 . • 32 , . , 1 i o /.c' ., l ' of S ELLAN, PAIN, STONE G SWANSON, Attor- . neys for Def endantRos sTs & ANDERSON ATTORNEYS AT LAW City of Renton HI WILLIAMS AVENUE SOUTH.P.O.BOX 464 RENTON,WASHINGTON 98055 JUDGMENT - 2 ' HA 8-1880 0 J• 1 �!' 1 ,1l'I': t)l '1'111: t ll; :�'t"lII:\h:l . ;(1•L14:1I'' U\. \\'.k.'"; O 111\1:'1' \., tiO r,, .. ,. c F'i)Si OFFIf)F,BOX 626, 1U0'2ND„ iRtET,:,B41_Ii:01h1:,;RENT'ON•'WAtiHIN(i TON'94055 AL,PINE 58678 • - �. r' GERARD M;'SHELLA-,',CITY Al TOPNIY.' .'1: -... ': JOHN K• ►AIN, JR., ASSISTANT:i:.I A,I I..Ol NEY '{;r r . .. Jp/' `AGE.)A• U: .. - r ..,r i _, - - .. June. 26:, 1970:, • Mr Gore%,n'.Erickson. T'lannii� �;,i'a.ctor g::: • tenton, ,Washington ' Re Jone"s; :vs 'Ci ty.;.'o,f, Renton and Chenaur, ' King; County•:-Caus-e NO. 70468'4 :Dear Mr' Erickson ` • ,.Enclose:d. her,ewit;h you:: will .f ind':copy,. o,f�:J.u'dgment in the :'re'ference:d:case 3..."entered 'June 2 :197'0., concerning• the• real • "" ' •• " ,pr;.oper;'.ty. ,owned.- by Hazel Chenaur ,asi, described on, page 2' thereof. ^' Th,e'•:J'udgment wa:s'•entered, by; 'agreement,;,'of •this' office on behalf • 'o f• the: :City ,:and"`counsel;; for' plain_ti ff s 'Defendant Chenaur was '.cef-au:lted,':.out„ of-the'isuit- by,.-.reason','.•of1. •her failure to t:imely. answer the -Complaint' ,of Psl'arnti ffs' ;. Y.ou will note ,that_ `by terms: of '.paragraph' :3 :. of the, Judgment ,.`' • on- page '-' -thereof , the C ':en' ..oined.',,from- .issuing a building • permit f�'� °'other. .than a R-1 single;:"residence' on -the C'henaur '. •, " property as'.%described in the, Judgme:nt': until procedures as ' ' ' set forth 'i n the: .Renton .City',..Co'de are:'fol'lowed , either :for. a • rezoning ,:.' variance ,' or, special;permit:: • . • ;',; .T:he, eni^. rider` of` the..C`i.ty;• in tY i:s",,:ins'tanc�e:".as recited above , • „ : is'_deemed;,pro.per.',by,:reason of .,the..:fac't':that 'proper notice .was ,`not :r:;iven:; of;. the;sappeal" by ' Hazel,:C,henaur of the or.Lginal' :the'`''City ,Plann'ing.;"Commiss'i of.'•the 'application for ' an R-3 rezone , nor ••was;`prig n t`ice;•t en'. of the ,City C�ur.cil ' s reconsideration-,:of•'•the.::appea a;tr*Iji. _ time;ahe City Council granted a. rezone:.with ;;an 'R_, ,c• ic;atiaoii. ' tt 10urs A Enc• r cc • Ma, oL 'Fr.es City .clerk', :: ' ;i`. , • Iravrng: approved the FindIngs• of._ :Fact,,and `Conclusions of E4w and ' ',Decree .herein, and der"endant;Hazeh','AC,':::j",.enau'•r•not, appearirc in • • 30 iI person or by counsel, default',;having; been-duly, and 31 i a regularly, taken and enterd: herein, the"::court=having heard • JLDC; NT. - I ;: ROBERTS E;.ANDERSON. ATTORNEYS AT LAW • .III WILLIAMS AVE/:CE SOUTH P.O,OOX 4E< , RENTON„WASHINGTON 90058 'p, fy.. ., • MINUTES - RENTON CITY COUNCIL MEETING 2/10/69 CORRESPONDENCE AND CURRENT BUSINESS : (Cont . ) The City Clerk reported • that bids had been• opened on 2/4/69 at 2 : 00 p .m . for demolition of the old city hall ,building in Cedar River Park . Ten bids were received from $4 , 000 . 00 to $39 , 500 . 00 . (See tabulation sheet . attached) MOVED BY BAREI , SECONDED BY 'SCHELLERT , to authorize the Fire Department to burn the old city hall building ,to the ground . Barei felt the City could. save the money : by having the city forces burn the building which was isolated from :any, buildings. 'and the winter weather adding to .-the safety factor . Inquiries . followed regarding air pollution .laws and possibility of legality un'der ' c'ontrolled' burning ' permit and the l . cost to remove burned ., debris . MOVED BY MORRIS ,_' SECONDED BY SCHELLERT , , ' the motion and remarks be referred. to .the Property Committee for , report . �.i The referral motion 'lost and discussion on .the motion to burn -ensued , it being urged that the low bid be accepted_ in lieu thereof . Dissenting IL voice vote brought. prope'T request for :roll - call which was taken as follows : • Ayer Grant , Shane, ' Sahellert• and ;Barei . 'No : , ,Perry , Morris , Delaurenti , yr ; :; ; . Trimn, Garrett , Edwards ,,. Maxin and' Bru'ce . .' The motion failed 8 to 4 . . Motions. were proposed to award the bid' to apparent low bidder- with adequate :;i , performance bond to, be required to insure proper.. compliance and , 'after discussion regarding bid requirements , to recess:-.for ten minutes which iil failed, and to refer the bids to Committee , and, subsequently another ',�' motion to' award to low bidder with referral to the Property Committee to '. . draw up the contract and secur,e ,performance, bond and • carry out the legal 'J requirements , 'MORRIS MOVED , SECONDBY 'GRANT , 'to 'substitute the motion that the 'bids be referred to the Property Committee with '•power to act . , . Dissenting voice vote ' brought .reques,t for',roll call. which resulted as ' ' - ' follows : 'Aye : ,Morris , Schellert'," Edwards , ; Bruce ,' Grant and Barei . jj No : Perry, Delaurenti , Trimm, Garrett', Maxin ,and Shane , Mayor Custer voted aye. and the referral motion carried . . ' Letter from Epcon , Inc . , Norman E'e Lee ; Lighting Division, requested a . meeting to discuss proposed installation of area lighting. Moved. by Barei , seconded by Bruce, to . refer the', letter to the 'Committee of the Whole . It was noted the) area concerned • i's Rainier 'Avenue and Mayor , Custer stated the ,matter. to be in regard to' 'light standards for private ' . operation on street right-of-way which only the Council could handle . After various recommendations for . referral, .to- other, Committees , the pending motion carried . . Letter from. Park Director Coulon, submitted ,attached letter from H . Bartrand & Co . , requesting 21-day extension to contract completion date on C .AG . 1372-68 , landscaping and planting,, LibertyPar.k grandstand area ., (February 12 is contract completion .,date to 'be., extended) Moved by Bruce , seconded by Barei , to concur in_,the":recomme.ndat.i'o-n of the Park Director . The .motion carried . ' . AUDIENCE COMMENT : . . Richard Stredicke , 3916-10th Court 'North ,' inquiredlregarding availability of a report concerning the Show Cause Court Order , received last week on the ' Hazel Ch.enaur property rezone . City Attorney ' -Shellan' advised that no Court I Order has been entered on the Show' Cause but that. an early trial date will k4 be set and Mr . Stredicke will be, notified . OLD BUSINESS BY COUNCIL : . . • Council President Perry submitted Committee of the Whole Report which was • read with Council action taken as follows : . Recommended that the proposed Resolution from Cle ' Elum ' regarding distribu- tion of funds to cities be tabled . ' ' MOVED BY SCHELLERT , SECONDED BY MAXIN , to concur in the Committee of the Whole recommendation . Carried . Shang opposed . Barei abstained , . Recommended that the City continue using the King 'County Design Commissic.., service rather than create a' Local Design Commission . - MOVED BY GARRETT , SECONDED BY EDWARDS , to concur in the Committee of the Whole recommenda- ' 'tion . (Referral request of Richard Stredicke) The motion carried . Recommended regarding U-LID 256 ,' Kent , the City Clerk direct a letter Kent inquiring if further action is required. MOVED BY MORRIS ,. 'SECONDE: BY MAXIN , to concur . Carried , -3- . / MINUTES 'RENTON CITic, ..AJNCIL-;.MEETING ,,.(Cont'.: ) 2`/3/69' CORRESPONDENCE AND CURRENT B'JSTNESS , Application was ' read from, Bobbie R Highland requesting that license be granted, to operate - a coin.-type ,:pool , table-,,at: -Icing ' s Tavern, 207• Wells Avenue;_. South. MOVED. BY:-MORRIS,, . SECONDED BY,;'. EDWARDS', .. to refer - ' the application to.' 'the . Police' and' -Lic':ense' Committee..with power . to: act'. '" - 'The motion: Carried.:`• ' Or,der.`.to Show, Cause , . Summons &:, Complaint , was . read, filed against the : City• by Attorneys ,Roberts & Anderson,, through : Michael:-Williamson, on ', ; 'behalf of Robert E . : Jones' et" .al`,' ,,i.,n ,:r;egard , t,o;:.Hazel ' W. :;Chenaur property zoning:'and permits : MOVED BY :_BARE•I , °SECON�tED 'BY '•SHANE ,.:. to refer the :documents..'to .the Legal Department . ,'.,:'.T.he, motion,; carried,, ' , letter .from ,Bernard L Ruppert-.'• ,;,- 'Building :Director :, .requested authoriza- '' tion to attend a Conference .on F'ederal�- ;Housing'. Programs ,, February 6 and .7_ -•a;t` Corvallis State ;:University , Corvallis , 'Oregon..;.`., MOVED: BY .MORRIS , AND ! ;. • SECONDED,.BY'. SCHELLERT, to: .grant ,the request. The ..motion carried . '.Letter' from.. Traffic, Engineer , Del .Bennett ,-`L ,submitted proposed agreements -. with the Northern:,,Pacific Railwa.y•::Company: and the `City "concerning the :: ':,,.. crossings` ;,and railroad. signals on North Third and Fourth Streets which ''-:• `'" `` • •:'include costs" to.' be_. borne: by the .'City: -through. the Urban.`Arterial . Fund which -.consti'tute, part,' of ;the,:total', improvement ;of, the 'one-way couplet r project. It was recommended that :the.; .Mayor and City Clerk be authorized - to;, ,signthe":documents .and ..copy.:to'`'be •furnished;',the - Urban Arterial Board '' y • gi .. g :Department ' for payment,; � , -r..:. '`�: b the°;En sneerin MOVED By S,CHELLER'1 SECONDED ' BY,.,:MAXIN., .:.'to concur. .. . MOVED BY < BAREI., 'SECONDED ::BY. ',PERRY;,,to: refer the . ° .recommendation to the Street ' and.'Alley Committee ' for ,, report back ! The motion carried . :Shane- .opposed,,, noting . .the-. rai'lroad: 'should share costs Letter from City , Engine,er`'Wilson' r'eported: in r'egar.d. :to petition for ,. Sanitary Sewer L . I . D. in the vicinity; of' -the.;Mance Addition , ' 94th Ave . South , So,uth:•173rd, and "South `174th STreets ;•,that' the '.petition is signed _ .. by ownerstrepresenting .8521% of .':the front footage abutting the proposed- ' .'' improvement ' and 89 : 21%"of .area w'ithin ''the.'proposed`= 'improvement MOVED BY SCHELLERT,; SECONDED BY -SHANE,, to.,:refer; the. :matter'`;to ::the 'Sanitation . Committee for recommendation..` . ' The:>. motionr;carried . Letter from Don Taylor;, President;:` City ..Employees` Club, requested - permission . to. work •Lincoln ' s :Birthday:',-,' February ' 12.; ,.19.69 'rin exchange':' =:":. :- .. for December 26 , 1969 , :the'. day following Chris'tmas:_to': ,allow a four ,clay ? ;:..;?j' week end ,for :City ' Employees : ;,' MOVED,'B.Y. GARRETT; ' SECO'NDED.-BY GIANT:.,,,,t.o::`,; ,;:: ;,. t; ., authorize the exchange w:ith : referralf_to the Mayor for adminustraton ' Discussion ensued with regard to- existing.' union. .con`tract and, City ' Attorney Shellan. suggested '.a' letter 'of concurrence ;'from the- Union' be. ': : ';' ":,.' "r: secured •which Mayor Custer advised:, he would::.;,r"eques't:." The pending :motion ,:::.'„ :'^ : carried ., REPORTS OF .BID CALLS AND RECOMMENDATIONS::'FOR,`AWARDS;'•' Bids were ' opened on 1/27/69 at 2 : 00 p:m: ,:i;n the, First,::Floor Conference `. Room•, Renton Municipal Building ;;.; , for:' lighting of. t.he :small ballfield ;' . ."•,:` ' ' 'in Liberty Park, as budgeted . Letter from' the ,,park; Board was read ',:. recommending that the low basic bid of Patelco ,- Inc . in: sum of $17 , 351 . 00 - be accepted . 'MOVED BY SCHELLERT , ':'SECONDED."BY EDW.ARDS , .'to' concur" in the'';' ' ' Park Board recommendation-. Discussion ensued regarding lighting program for other areas of the city and posts ,involved with;: Liberty Park total development ., ,COVED BY GRANT , SECONDED BY -SHANE, .:,to refer the bids to • the Committee. of. the Whole , r. Park budget • funds , it was'.noted;'include_.Vorward. Thrust -State and .Federal Funds for Lake Wn. ' Beach matching' fund projects ,which "':: w_. results in double budgeting', not reflecting actual•:Jocal: expenditures'. " .,> After some further remarks regarding .the : Counciliaction•:;.,at hearing meetings in budgeting the items , Attorney Shellanb notation that the , Council does not have jurisdiction. over the Park 'Board ' s, action on bid . awards once funds have been granted in the: budget, and upon inquiry* ,. • : - `:' that control may be exercised through budgetary fund transfers within :;r, classes only , the pending motion was voted upon Dissenting voice vote ' '` brought ruling of the chair of negative majority,, and roll call was . requested which was taken'_as .follows : Aye - :Trimm, .Bruce;• Grant , Shane " and Barei . No Perry , Morris, Schellert;; Edwards;, -.Maxin And Garrett . ; ;_ The referral motion lost . Vote : ,on , the 'original,.motio"nto concur was .dis-• ' ;:';''• senting and roll call requested and, ,taken as; .follows:,::,; Aye,: Perry Schellert ,Morris , Garrett., Edwards ,'. Maxin and Trimm ,. '-(conte. next.. page) ' INTER-OFFICE MEMO To: Helmie Nelson, City Clerk Date March 4, 1968 From: Gerard K. Shellan, City Attorney . Chenaur rezoning Dear Helmie: We are handing you herewith stencil for proposed Ordinance providing for the rezoning of certain property owned by Haz W. Chenaur. We suggest that the City Engineer and the Planning Directorfche over the document prior to its 1-; submission to the Law & Ordinance Committee. We remain /,/ y u yurrard M. Shellan GMS:ds Attach cc: Mayor L & 0 Committee Pres. Council I s4 ° -S. ROBERTS ANDERSON ATTORNEYS AT LAW A.M.(MIKE)ROBERTS PHONE: ROBERT L.ANDERSON III WILLIAMS AVENUE SOUTH-P.O.BOX454 BALDWIN 8-1880 RENTON,WASHINGTON 98055 January 17 , 1969 424. ®-. '0-A..."104A.4.1/#1,0 /f4.-fdr/w7- C ) 824, 441&0160-744.0tem .4.41.0.64.44.441, Renton City Council City Hall Renton, Washington 98055 026 LA yp Gentlemen: �®y /� N This office has been retained by Robert Jones and 19 other °V: property owners in the area of 116th Avenue Southeast , near the ' McKnight Junior High School. On February 5 , 1968 , the Renton City Council heard the appeal of Hazel W. Chenaur as a result of the City Planning Commission ' s denial of "Application No. R-436-67 , rezone from R-1 to R-3" . This appeal was denied. by the City. Council during said meeting in "concurrence with the Planning Commission recommendation that R-1 is the best and highest use for the property". Sub- sequently, this meeting was formally closed. During the City Council meeting of February 19 , 1968 , Hazel Chenaur was granted a R-2 zone classification without notice of • this action to any landowners in the area. This action is in direct violation of various Renton City Ordinances . You are hereby given notice of our formal. protest of the Council 's action in granting the R-2 classification and also in re-opening the application without notice to the interested property owners in the area. • Yours truly, ROBERTS 8 ANDERSON Michael -H.. Williamson MHW:fg cc: Mr. Gerard M. Shellan City Attorney, Mr. Doyle E. Garrison Chairman, Planning Commission 64/1 ® • ,, • ' ROBERTS .8 ANDERSON ' ATTORNEYS AT LAW •PHONE: A.M.IMIKE)ROBERTSALD WIN 8-1880 III WILLIAMSIAMS AVENUE SOUTH-P.O.BOX 454 • • ROBERT L.ANDERSON RENTON,WASHINGTON 98055 • iN • 4(..„ C.04.,..'4,,( .46,44., January 17 , 1669 17' efth9 — e . Renton City Council ems, City Hall P .,. - . . • Renton, Washington. 98055 4 A 464 Gentlemen: 5 /f ... 11-4-01 RV, This office has been retained by Robert Jones and 19 other 4.// property owners in the area of 116th Avenue Southeast , near •th e McKnight Junior High School. • On February 5 , 1968 , the Renton City Council heard the appeal of Hazel W. Chenaur as a result of the City Planning Commission's denial of "Application No. R-436-67 , rezone from R-1 to R-3" . This appeal was denied . by the City Council during said meeting • in "concurrence with the Planning Commission recommendation that R-1 is the best and highest use for the property" . • Sub- sequently , this meeting was formally closed. During the City Council meeting of February 19 , 1968 , Hazel Chenaur was granted a R-2 zone classification without notice of this action to any landowners in the area. This action is in . direct violation of various Renton City Ordinances . You are hereby given notice of our formal protest of the Council's action in granting the R-2 classification and also in re-opening the application without notice to the interested property owners in the area. Yours truly, ROBERTS 6 ANDERSON ' /hei-Ok,"4 AlW4//X).9-251:yU • Michael H. Williamson • MHW:fg ` cc: Mr. Gerard M'i. Shellan City Attorney • • Mr. Doyle E . Garrison Chairman, Planning Commission — P.., " 1-C• A 4 'Y ' ' 0 Cc) tta t OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK 0 RENTON,WASHINGTON il„ .4. , CITY HALL, CEDAR RIVER PARK, RENTON, WASHINGTON 98055 • ALPINE 5-3464 " ;44' (4'7'CAPITIO-° March 20, riga Mr. Bruce Mahler, Land & Tax Agent King County Assessors Office County Court House, lUxmra 201 Seattle, Washington 98104 Dear. Sir: Enclosed is a certified copy, of Ordinance No. 2387 changing the zoning of certain properties within the City of Renton, as passed and approved on this 18th day of March, 1968 Very truly yours, CITY OF RENTON • Helmie W. Nelson City Clerk HWN/h Enclosure (1) COPY r///76/ /31° ORDINANCE NO. AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON, CHANGING THE ZONING CLASSIFICATION OF CERTAIN PROPERTIES WITHIN THE CITY OF RENTON FROM RESIDENCE SINGLE FAMILY DISTRICT (R-1) TO RESIDENCE DISTRICT (R-2) WHEREAS under Chapter VII, Title IV (Building Regulations) of Ordinance No. 1628 known as the "Code of General Ordinances of the City of Renton", as amended, and the maps adopted in conjunction therewith, the property hereinbelow described has heretofore been zoned as Single Family Residence District (R-I); and WHEREAS a proper petition for change of zone classification of said property has been filed with the City Clerk on or about December 7, 1967, which petition was duly referred to the Planning Commission for investigation, study and public hearing, and a public hearing having been held thereon on or about December 27, 1967, and said matter having been duly continued and the Petitioner-Owners having duly appealed from the decision of the Planning Commission and hearings having been held before the City Council of the City of Renton and Petitioner-Owner having duly amended his Petition, and said rezoning request, as amended, being in conformity with the City's Comprehensive Plan and all parties having been heard appearing in support thereof or in opposition thereto, NOW THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF RENTON, T ASBINGTON, AS FOLLOWS: SECTION I: The following described property in the City of Renton is hereby rezoned to Residential District (R-2); the City Engineer and the Planning Director are hereby authorized and directed to change the maps of the Zoning Ordinance, as amended, to evidence said rezoning, to-wit: The West 130 feet of the North one-half of Tract 211, C. D. Hillman's Lake Washington Garden of Eden Division No. 4, according to plat recorded in Volume 11 of plats, page 82, in King County, Washington, except the North 30 ft. and West 30 ft. of said Tract 211, conveyed to the City of Renton by deed recorded under auditor's file No. 5383178; all situate in Renton, King County, Washington, (located behind apartments on 116th Ave. S.E. between 12th Ave. N. (SE 112th St.) and S. E. 110th St. SECTION II: This Ordinance shall be in full force and effect from and after its passage, approval and legal publication. ,cam PASSED BY THE CITY COUNCIL this Jail day of March, 1968. , Helm' 1 son,;Citl3 Clerk APPROVED BY THE MAYOR this Ja-th day of Mac , 1968. • Approved as to form: Donald W. Custer,:'May_or., Gerard M. Shellan, City Attorney, Date of Pub 1 ice t ion: MAR 2 0 1968 Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting (Cont.) 3-18-68 ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS: Law and Ordinance Committee Chairman, Trimm, submitted proposed Resolution of the City of Renton appropriating $3,450.00 from excess revenue in the Library Fund unto Account 1610/606 Capital Outlay, Machinery & Equipment, Library, for the purchase of a Van for transportation service to the Library. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Delaurenti, to adopt Resolution No. 1524 as read. Carried. Councilman Trimm presented a proposed Resolution of the City of Renton authorizing transfer of $20,707.00 from Cumulative Reserve Fund 1894 unto City Hall Construction Fund #2810, Account 605, for lawn sprinkling system and lighting within the civic center site. Moved by Trimm, seconded by Barei, to adopt Resolution No. 1525 as read. The motion carried. The Committee presented a proposed Ordinance of the City of Renton changing the zoning (:ii classification of certain properties within the City from Residence Single Family. Dis- trict (R-1) to Residence District (R-2) which was read by the Clerk. (Hazel Chenaur property) Moved by Trimm, seconded by Grant, to place the document on second and final reading. Carried. After final reading, roll call vote was taken on .motion by Dela urenti,. second by Barei, to adopt as read. The vote resulted in unanimous aye vote carrying the motion and adopting Ordinance 2387 as read. Proposed Ordinance was read changing the zoning classification of the Beanbiossom and Roe property within the City from Residential District (R-2) to "Apartment Houses and Multiple Dwellings (R-4). Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Maxin, to place the docu- ment on second and final reading. Carried. After final reading, it was moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Schellert, to adopt Ordinance No. 2388 as read. Roll call vote resulted in all ayes and the motion carried. Proposed Ordinance was read changing the zoning classification of the Dean Singer property within the City from Residential District (R-2) to Residential District (R-3) . Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Barei, to place the document on second and final reading. Carried. After the final reading, it was moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Maxin, to adopt Ordinance No. 2389 as read. Carried, upon unanimous aye roll call vote. Proposed Ordinance was read changing the zoning classification of the Lorensen-Jensen properties on 132nd Ave. S.E. from General Classification District (G) to Residential District (R-3). Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Grant, to place the document on its second and final reading. Carried. Moved by Morris, seconded by Bruce, after final reading, to adopt Ordinance No. 2390 as read. Roll call vote resulted in all ayes and the motion carried. Proposed Ordinance was read changing the zoning classification of the Harris property on 132nd Ave. S.E., within the City of Renton, from Suburban Residence District (S-1) to Single Residence District (R-1). Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Barei, to place the document on second and final reading. Carried. After final reading, it was moved by Morris, seconded by Barei, to adopt Ordinance No. 2391 as read. Carried upon unanimous aye roll call vote. Proposed Ordinance was read amending Section 10-705 of Title X, (Traffic), of Ordinance No. 1628 entitled "Code of General Ordinances of the City of Renton", relating to Municipal Parking Lot #3. (Limiting to 2 hour parking rather than 24 hr. parking use) Moved by Trimm, seconded by Maxin, to place the document on second and final reading. Carried. After the final reading, it was moved by Morris, seconded by Barei, to adopt Ordinance No. 2392 as read. Carried upon unanimous roll call vote. (Publication to be withheld until new meter heads have been installed) Proposed Ordinance of the City,granting Pacific Coast RR Co. a franchise for establish- ment, maintenance and operation of its North Renton Main Line track in, upon and along Houser Way, and fixing the location, terms and conditions of such franchise, was placed on first reading. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Shane, to refer the document to the Law and Ordinance Committee to hold 30: days following publication as required by law. Carried. Moved by Garrett, seconded by Shane that the Garbage and Refuse Collection Ordinance be placed on second and final reading. Revisions were outlined, and the motion carried. After final reading, it was moved by Trimm, seconded by Shane to adopt Ordinance No. 2393 as read. Roll call vote resulted in all ayes and the motion carried. -6- /... . . i' Minu-ces - Ren .,1 City CoL- -- 1 Meeting 2-26-6 `. rat COUNCIL COMMITTEE REPORTS: (Cont.) Unfinished Business kouncilman Maxin, Chairman of the Planning Committee, submitted report recommendin.; 'a`hat requests of. C. K. Mullins and F.E. Lawrence for zoning revisions to the Compre- hencive Plan, be referred to the Planning Commission for recommendations. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Maxin, to concur in the recommendation. Carried. R•ccormsnded that appeal of Hazel Chenaur be allowed and R-2 zoning be granted on the subject property, owner agreeing to amend her application as discussed with Attorney Hall on her behalf. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Grant, to concur in the rezone as recommended. Carried. Councilman Maxin announced a meeting of the Planning Committee on Wednesday, February 3th at 7:00 p.m. Councilman Bruce, Chairman, Fire and Water Committee, submitted recommendation that the firm of Cornell,Howland, Hayes and Merryfield be retained for the design and preparation of plans and specifications for Well No. 8, and that the Mayor and City Clerk be authorized to sign the necessary agreement documents, upon approval thereof by the City Attorney. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Shane, to concur. Carried. The Fire and Water Committee recommended that the Agreement between the City and Fire District No. 25 for hydrant service and water supply be approved and the Mayor and City Clerk be authorized to sign the document. Moved by Barei, seconded by Schellert, to concur. Carried. The Public Relations Committee met regarding the request of Local 21R, Washington ..;.-e Council of County and City Employees, AFL-CIO for Council acknowledgment and it was recommended that the Department of Labor and Industries conduct a check for certification purposes as provided by law. Moved by Morris, seconded by Garrett to concur. Carried. Councilman Grant, Chairman of the Light and Power Committee reported that a formal request has been made of Mr. John Nelson, or a representative of Seattle City Light, to :spear at a public hearing of the Light and Power Committee to discuss proposed franchise and power rates within the City, date for hearing to be determined. Taco, the Light and Power Committee submitted a proposed Resolution resolving that to interests of the City would be best served by employing a Consultant to provide rate analysis and technical assistance iu.reg rd to_power prohlemS. The^servic's to be . _ eyed in a ;:•cud,; of power supply and rates ware .butlihed with areas'to be analyzsa `a~rein the City' aand .Puget Power may work together to improve the City with: regard.y_o :1tc'— of mutual concern, the studies to be coordinated with the Traffic Engineering -'apartment. The Light and Power Committee will interview Consulting Firms and made ai recommendation as to the firm to conduct the study and shall report cost for such study, and at a future date, report the findings to the Council. Moved by Morris, seconded by Maxin, to concur in the proposed Resolution. Councilman Grant moved that his minority report be incorporated as item 3. of the Resolution that: In event the City is unable to resolve the study areas to its satisfaction, the consulting firm be directed to analyze the means whereby the City could develop its own power distribution system, join with another public power utility (Seattle City Light) or public utility district. The motion to amend the original Resolution was seconded by Darei,and after discussion and dissenting voice vote roll call was requested which resulted as follows: Aye: Garrett, Perry, Bruce, Prant, Shane and Barei. No: Morris, Schellert, Trimm and Maxin. The amendment carried and subsequently the original motion approving the three resolution.,prc os ls, Moved by Schellert, seconded by Trimm, to adjourn. Dissenting voice vote brought roll call request which was taken as follows: Aye: Barei, Maxin, Trimm. No: Garrett, Shane, Grant, Bruce, Perry, Schellert and Morris. The meeting moved to the next order of business. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Grant that the meeting be adjourned at 12:45 p.m. Carried. Councilman Grant inquired regarding the status of the request for dog control in the Highlands area. It was noted that the matter is in Committee and a study will be made and report submitted upon completion. • Councilman Grant reported a request from property owners that the vacant property to the East of 509 Tobin Avenue South be cleaned up and shrubbery cut as the litter is piling up and attention is needed. Mayor Custer advised that the owner has re- moved a house from the lot and further attention will be given the matters reported. ' -7- Minutes - Rentn City Cour . Meeting 2-26-63 COUNCIL COMMITTEE REPORTS: (Cont.) Unfinished Business Councii1nari Maxin, Chairman of the pThning dotnMittee, submitted repoft recommending that requests of C. K. Mullins and F.E. Lawrence for zoning revisions to the Compre- IN) hensive Plan, be referred to the Planning Commission for recommendations. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Maxin, to concur in the recommendation. Carried. ecormended that appeal of Hazel Chenaur be allowed and R-2 zoning be granted on the subject property, owner agreeing to amend her application as discussed with Attorney ;all on her behalf. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Grant, to concur in the rezone as recommended. Carried. Councilman Maxin announced a meeting of the Planning Committee on Wednesday, February 2.3th at 7:00 p.m. Councilman Bruce, Chairman, Fire and Water Committee, submitted recommendation that the firm of Cornell,Howland, Hayes and Merryfield be retained for the design and preparation of plans and specifications for Well No. 8, and that the Mayor and City Clerk erk be authorized to sign the necessary agreement documents, upon approval thereof by the City Attorney. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Shane, to concur. Carried. The Fire and Water Committee recommended that the Agreement between the City and Fire District No. 25 for hydrant service and water supply be approved and the Mayor and City Clerk be authorized tosign the document. Moved by Barei, seconded by Scliollert, to concur. Carried. The Public Relations Committee met regarding the request of Local 21R, Washington ..te Council of County and City Employees, AFL-CIO for Council acknowledgment and it was recommended that the Department of Labor and Industries conduct a check for certification purposes as provided by law. Moved by Morris, seconded by Garrett so ccncur. Carried. Councilman Grant, Chairman of the Light and Power Committee reported that a formal request has been made of Mr. John Nelson, or a representative of Seattle City Light, to appear at a public hearing of the Light and Power Committee to discuss proposed franchise and power rates within the City, date for hearing to be determined. Also, the Light and Power Committee submitted a proposed Resolution resolving that the interests of the City would be best served by employing a Consultant to provide -ate analysis and technical assistance in regard to power problems. The-services to bl _ . .seed in a study of power supply and rates were.outlined with areas'to.be analyze, ° .i2rein. the City' and .Puget Power maj work together to improve the City with: regard to ::tc.^.^a of mutual concern, the studies to be coordinated with the Traffic Engineering °partment. The Light and Power Committee will interview Consulting Firms and made a recommendation as to the firm to conduct the study and shall report cost for such study, and at a future date, report the findings to the Council. Moved by Morris, seconded by Maxin, to concur in the proposed Resolution. Councilman Grant moved that his minority report be incorporated as item 3. of the Resolution that: In event the City is unable to resolve the study areas to its satisfaction, the consulting firm be directed to analyze the means whereby the City could develop its own power distribution system, join with another public power utility (Seattle City Light) or public utility district. The motion to amend the original Resolution was seconded by Barei,and after discussion and dissenting voice vote roll call was requested which resulted as follows: Aye: Garrett, Perry, Bruce, Grant, Shane and Barei. No: Morris, Schellert, Trimm and Maxin. The amendment carried and subsequently the original motion approving the three resolution.,proposalb. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Trimm, to adjourn. Dissenting voice vote brought roll call request which was taken as follows: Aye: Barei, Maxin, Trimm. No: Garrett, Shane, Grant, Bruce, Perry, Schellert and Morris. The meeting moved to the next order of business. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Grant that the meeting be adjourned at 12:45 p.m. Carried. Councilman Grant inquired regarding the status of the request for dog control in the Highlands area. It was noted that the matter is in Committee and a study will be made and report submitted upon completion. Councilman Grant reported a request from property owners that the vacant property to the East of 509 Tobin Avenue South be cleaned up and shrubbery cut as the litter is piling up and attention is needed. Mayor Custer advised that the owner has re- moved a house from the lot and further attention will be given the matters reported. -7- .. 4 - • • PLANNING COMMITTEE EE REPORT • February 26, 1968 • 3'; Regarding Referra.l,yof ,12--18.767--for._ n;r recommendatioegarding zoning changes ,on3tl:inedl,fin the C.B.D. Plan prepared<\y theNN. C. Jacobson Co.', Crsultan s., /he Planning Committee recommends that this matter be referred to the Planning Commission 'for. recommendation following 'study of' the proposals. Recommended that the requests of C. K. Mullins, 14816 S.E. 128th Street, King County, and F. E. Lawrence, Lots 24, and 25, Block 13, Kennydale, for zoning revisions to the Comprehensive Plan, be referred to the Planning Commission for recommendation. (Referred 2-5-68) • Hazel Chenaur appeal of rezone denial per Attorney Robert Hall - Referral �Z� of 2-19-68 for reconsideration - Recommended that R-2 be allowed. � / • I • Paul Maxin, Chai rman • • • • • • P , • 1 BEFORE THE PLANNING COMMISSION 2 . OF THE CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON 3 4 IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION ) NO. R-436-67 5 of MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION .6 HAZEL W. CHENAUR • ) ,:,,;„ 8y� 7 FOR CHANGE OF ZONING ��" 7��d1o'a' 8 ) To: The Renton City Council, and C3' 3 2 10 To: The Honorable D Custer, an .4 ' 11 To: Helmie W. Nelson, City Clerk 12 HAZEL W. CHENAUR, by and through her attorney undersigned, 13 14 feeling herself aggrieved by the decision of the Renton City 15 Council at its meeting February 5, 1968, denying her application 16 for rezone from R-1 to R-3 the following described property, does 17 hereby respectfully request and move that the City Council re- 18 • consider its decision of. February 5 ; 1968, for the following 19 reasons: 20 1. That the City Planning Director as: representative of the 21 22. City of Renton Planning Commission did not present to the City 23 .Council all evidence that it should have in its file bearing upon 24 this application for rezoning, _ particularly in failing to exhibit 25 before the City Council color slides which were used before the 26 Planning Commission and instead supplying additional and new and 27 different color slides of the ' area involved which were made 28 subsequent to the Planning Commission hearing and prior to the 29 30 rehearing before the City Council, and in failing .to produce and 31 Mtn. for Recon. - 1 MURRAY, DUNHAM & WAITT ATTORNEYS AT LAW J 419 SECURITIES BUILDING SEATTLE.WASHINGTON 98101 MAINAIN2-22-2655 • • • • 1 exhibit photographs of the tract involved which the applicant 2 provided in support Of its application. for rezoning, and other 3 pertinent data bearing upon the merits of this appi.i; T for 4 rezoning. 5 The property involved is described as foll_o - .; 1'� 0. • 6 The west 130 feet of the north one-half of !rr•.. 7 211, CD Hillman' s Lake Washington Garden of Eden olo 8 Division No. 4, according to plat recorded in %''r+aapp'� Volume 11, of plats , page 82, in King County, 9 - Washington, except the 'north 30 feet of said • Tract 211, conveyed to the, City of Renton by • 10 , deed recorded under auditor ' s file No. 5383778. 11 It is respectfully requested that this application for re- 12 consideration be placed on the agenda for hearing Monday, 13 February 19, 1968. 14 15 DATED this �r10 -day of February 1968. 16 • • 17 • Robert J. Ham 18 Attorney f or Hazel W. Chenaur 19 • 20 21 cc: Planning Director • 22 Renton City Planning Commission City Hall, 23 Renton, Washington • 24 25 • 26 • 27 • 28 . ' 29 • • 30 • 31 Mtn. for Recon. - 2 • . • MURRAY, DUNHAM & WAITT ATTORNEYS AT LAW 419 SECURITIES BUILDING • 'SEATTLE,WASHINGTON 98101 MAIN 2-2655 l s / eflo 67,11/ litre cfi,m,tx/(2 Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting 2-19-68 COMMUNICATIONS: (Cont.) Letter from Jack Wilson, City Engineer, submitted statement in sum of $383.88 due Cornell, Howland, Hayes and Merryfield for work in connection with Well No. 8 to January 24, 1968. Approval for payment was recommended. Moved by Morris, seconded by Bruce, to refer the payment to the Auditing and Accounting Committee with power to act. Carried. Claim submitted by Donna and Rodney Stewart was read requesting reimbursement of $49.87 for damage to water tank elements when water was shut off and water drained out of the tank. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to refer the Claim to the City Attorney and Insurance Carrier. Carried. Document from Robert J. Hall, Attorney for Mrs. Hazel W. Chenaur, requested Council reconsideration of rezone denial noting grievance that all evidence had not been presented at the hearing, particularly exhibit of photographs and color slides as shown to the Planning Commission. Moved by Perry, seconded by Schellert, that the Council reconsider its action of the prior meeting as requested. Carried. Moved by Perry, seconded by Garrett, to refer the matter of the rezone to the Planning Committee to report back. Carried. Letter from Renton School District 403, Rudolph Seppi, Director of Plant 'Facilities, requested approval from the City for service to the new Earlington Elementary School, to be located at South 132nd Street and Langston Road, King County, by the sanitary sewer system of the City, costs to be the School Districts and Late Comers Agreement to be allowed for recovery or portion of the cost. Moved by Garrett, seconded by Morris, to grant the request with referral to the Law and Ordinance Committee to prepare the necessary documents. Councilman Barei reported that the Sanitation Committee has a recommendation for approval of this request. The motion carried. Letter from Mr. Ray Van Hollebeke, Property Management, The Boeing Company, requested permission to install a 12,000 gallon propane gas tank on property located in area North of 6th Avenue North, now under lease from the City. Drawing attached indicated the location of the tank and piping. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Bruce, to refer the request to the Property Committee for recommendation. (Fire Chief and City Engineer to be consulted) Carried. Letter from John E. Iverson, Attorney, petitioned, on behalf of Mr. and Mrs. Roger A. Hokanson, for consent to transfer,and sale of their interest in the Renton Radice Cab Co., Inc. New owners are individual holders of For-Hire Licenses and will continue to operate as drivers and include: Phillip A. Schmolke, present owner, Gerald Halstead, present owner, and Michael Craig, 10931 S.E. 164th Street, Renton. Moved by Perry, seconded by Garrett, to refer the matter to the Police and License Committee for recommendation. Carried. Letter from Jack Wilson, City Engineer, reported that the letter of intent to annex property to Renton which ad4oins Sunset Blvd. E., between 132nd Ave. S.E. and 138th Ave. S.E. is signed by owners representing 84.74% of the assessed valuation of the property, which is located on both sided of the highway and contains approximately 13.6 acres with an assessed valuation of $15,600.00. Annexation would make the City Limits more uniform in this area. The petitioners are Alhoff, Smith & Beale and '' matter has been referred to the Boundary Review Board. Letter from Sven A. Johnson, Building Director, recommended that Revocable Sign Permit be issued for sign encroachment of public right-of-way for Montgomery Ward & Co. at 319 Williams Avenue South. Moved by Perry, seconded by Barei, to concur in the recommendation. Carried. Letter from Building Director Johnson recommended that Revokable Sign Permit be granted upon revised application of Dr. Hurley at 9112 South 3rd Street, since original sign was installed to different plans than submitted. Moved by Perry, seconded by Trimm, to concur in the recommendation of the Building Director. Carried. Letter from W.E. Bennett, Utility Accountant, submitted proposed Agreement between the City and Fire District No. 25 regarding obligation and responsibility for fire hydrant:maintenance and inspection, and consideration to be paid the City of Renton therefor. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Edwards to authorize and approve the execution. Moved by Perry, seconded by Grant to refer the document to the Fire and Water Committee for recommendation. Carried. • -2- Minutes Renton City Council Meeting 2-19-68 COMMUNICATIONS : (Cont.) Letter from Jack Wilson, City Engineer, submitted. statement in sum of $383.88 due Cornell, Howland, Hayes and Merryfield for work in connection with Well No. 8 to January 24, 1968. Approval for payment was recommended. Moved by Morris, seconded by Bruce, to refer the payment to the Auditing and Accounting Committee with power to act, Carried. Claim submitted by Donna and Rodney Stewart was read requesting reimbursement of $49,87 for damage to water tank elements when water was shut off and water drained out of the tank. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to refer the Claim to the City Attorney and Insurance Carrier. Carried. Document from Robert J. Hall, Attorney for Mrs. Hazel W. Chenaur, requested Council reconsideration of rezone denial noting grievance that all evidence had not been .) presented at the hearing, particularly exhibit of photographs and color slides as shown to the Planning Commission. Moved by Perry, seconded by Schellert, that the Council reconsider its action of the prior meeting as requested. Carried. Moved by Perry, seconded by Garrett, to refer the matter of the rezone to the Planning Committee to report back. Carried. Letter from Renton School District 403, Rudolph Seppi, Director of Plant 'Facilities, requested approval from the City for service to the new Earlington Elementary School, to be located at South 132nd Street and Langston Road, King County, by the sanitary sewer system of the City, costs to be the School Districts and Late Comers Agreement to be allowed for recovery or portion of the cost. Moved by G.Irrett, seconded by Morris, to grant the request with referral to the Law__and_Ordinance -Committee to prepare the necessary documents. Councilman Barei reported that the Sanitation Committee has a recommendation for approval of this request. The motion carried. Letter from Mr. Ray Van Hollebeke, Property Management, The Boeing Company, requested permission to install a 12,000 gallon propane gas tank on property located in area North of 6th Avenue North, now under lease from the City. Drawing attached indicated the location of the tank and piping. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Bruce, to refer the request to the Property Committee for recommendation, (Fire Chief and City Engineer to be consulted) Carried. Letter from John E . Iverson, Attorney, petitioned, on behalf of Mr. and Mrs. Roger A. Hokanson, for consent to transfer, and sale of their interest in the Renton Radio Cab Co., Inc. New owners are individual holders of For-Hire Licenses and will continue to operate as drivers and include: Phillip A. Schmolke, present owner, Gerald Halstead, present owner, and Michael Craig, 10931 S.E. 164th Street, Renton. Moved by Perry, seconded by Garrett, to refer the matter to the Police and License Committee for recommendation. Carried. Letter from Jack Wilson, City Engineer, reported that the letter of intent to annex property.to Renton which ad;oins Sunset Blvd. E., between 132nd Ave. S.E. and 138th Ave. S.E. is signed by owners representing 84.74% of the assessed valuation of the property, which is located on both sided of the highway and contains approximately 13.6 acres with an assessed valuation of $15,600.00. Annexation would make the City Limits more uniform in this area. The petitioners are Alhoff, Smith & Beale and the matter has been referred to the Boundary Review Board. Letter from Sven A. Johnson, Building Director, recommended that Revocable Sign Permit be issued for sign encroachment of public right-of-way for Montgomery Ward & Co. at 319 Williams Avenue South. Moved by Perry, seconded by Barei, to concur in the recommendation. Carried. _ - Letter from Building Director Johnson recommended that Revokable Sign Permit be granted upon revised application of Dr. Hurley at 911z South 3rd Street, since original sign was installed to different plans than submitted. Moved by Perry, seconded by Trimm, to concur in the recommendation of the Building Director. Carried. Letter from W.E. Bennett, Utility Accountant, submitted proposed Agreement between the City and Fire District No. 25 regarding obligation and responsibility for fire _ hydrant:.maintenance and inspection,, and consideration to be paid the City of Renton therefor. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Edwards to authorize and approve the execution. Moved by Perry, seconded by Grant to refer the document to the Fire and Water Committee for recommendation. Carried. -2- Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting 2-19-68 Remarks: Councilman Maxin announced a meeting of the Planning Committee at 9:00 a.m. on Saturday, February 24, 1968. Councilman Barei requested that the Janitor oil the Chairs-around the Council table to reduce the noise. Councilman Perry noted that the tables had been removed which had been used by the City Attorney and the Press and suggested they be replaced. n. Mr.. Robert Hall, Attorney for Mrs. Chenauer addressed the Council advising that he e\ had been mistaken regarding photographs which were submitted to the Council on the matter and offered apology to Planning Director Ericksen noting however, that Multiple zoning is the only feasible use for the subject property and that it is economically impossible to develop the area as R-1. After further comments in regard to the subject property Mr. Hall was advised that the matter was now in the Planning Committee which would be meeting at 9:00 a.m. tomorrow at which time his remarks might properly be addressed the Committee. As there was no further business to come before the Council, it was moved by Trimm, seconded by Schellert, to adjourn. The motion carried, and the meeting was adjourned at 12:05 p.m. Helmie Nelson, City Clerk 5 = ( W. Cuter, Mayor • -p ;jinutes - Renton City Council Meeting (Cont.) 2-5--68 Mayor Custer introduced a group of students from Renton High School Boys Club who are attending the Council meeting in participation of Student Government Week. Attendance on a voluntary basis included about 25 youths who will also be coming to City Hall during the coming week for two hours daily to observe operation of various departments. A mock City Council meeting will be conducted by the group on Saturday, February 10th, between 10:00 a.m. and noon and Councilmen and Depart- ment heads were invited to attend. P.LIC HEARING: Hazel W. Chenaur appeal of R-3 rezone denial on property located on the West side of 116th Avenue S.E. between S .E. 110th and S.E. 112th Streets. This being the date set, the hearing was declared open. Letter from Planning Director Erickson reported Planning Commission recommendation that,since detrimental effects could be anticipated and such rezone not being in the best interest of the surrounding residential area, R-1 be considered the best and highest use for this property. Petition containing approximately 20 signatures was attached objecting to tine rezone which document had been submitted to the Planning Commission. Mr. Robert Hall, 419 Securities Building, Seattle, Attorney representing Mrs. Chenaur, stated that the proposed use is felt to be the fullest and best for the property noting the proximity of other multiple dwellings in the immediate vicinity and apartment directly behind the proposed development. He added that such housing is greatly needed, that the plans meet with the presently existing Comprehensive Plan and that the property had once been rezoned to R-3 but reverting according to an ordinance which had a one year construction commencement provision, since repealed. Topography of the area was outlined with embankment division from singly family area being noted and Attorney Hall stated developers would be able to furnish parking as required and would be willing to work out any further matters required or desirable. Film slides were shown by the Planning Director after which Councilman Shane inquired regarding apparent drainage problems noted when visiting the site and also in regard to sewering the area. Planning Director Ericksen advised that all such details have to be worked out prior to occupancy of the premises and all Departments concerned mast approve the particular portion of the proposal which is under their jurisdiction. D_ic.cussion ensued regarding conformancy of procedures on various applications submitted and Planning Director Ericksen noted that the Commissions actions are uniform and on the basis of the Comprehensive standpoint. Specific detrimental effects were noted to 1 be traffic congestion and loss of privacy to individual property owners on the lower ti sites. The Planning Director noted the project does not meet with the proposed Comprehensiv- \, Flan .Moved by Morris, seconded by Edwards that the hearing be closed. Carried. Moved by Morris, seconded by Perry, that the appeal be denied in concurrence with the Planning Commission recommendation that R-1 is the best and highest use for the property. A dissenting voice vote brought request for roll call which resulted as follows: Aye: Morris, Schellert, Delaurenti, Perry, Trimm, Edwards, Maxin and Bruce. No: Garrett, Grant, Shane and Barer. The motion carried denying the appeal. COMMUNICATIONS: Application from Mr. Robert H. Schlosser, Mgr.,Cougar Den, 219 Main Avenue South, requested that Mutual Amusement Company be granted required license to operate an additional pinball device at said business location. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to refer the matter to the Police and License Committee with power to act,, which`.carried after.:inquiry regarding the legality of pinball machines and their comparison to punch boards. Discussion ensued wherein the City :Attorney advised of Supreme Court ruling, based upon Attorney General's Opinion that they are both gaming devices and where chance predominates over skill the activity is outlawed and illegal with the three elements under which court decisions are determined being 1. consideration is paid to participate; 2. must be some kind of reward; 3. element of uncertainty exists. In further discussion City Attorney Shellan stated the City has a right, which goes back to common rule law, to license under its police power and can im- pose a license or regulatory fee. Councilman Shane felt the pinball and punch board devices should be treated equally and moved, with second by Schellert, that if pinballs are illegal they be taken out tomorrow. It was subsequently moved by Morris, seconded by Bruce, to refer the matter to the haw and Ordinance Committee to report back. Moved by Barei, seconded by Perry, to table the matter. Carried. Letter from Vern Church, Purchasing Agent, reported that specifications are now prepared and requested permission to call for bids for equipment which has been provided for in tha 1968 budget. February 26th was recommended as the bid opening date. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to concur in the request and recommended bid opening date. Discussion ensued regarding the City maintenance program for city streets and the poFsibility of contracting such work. It was noted that cities usually do their own maintenance, and after further discussion regarding operation of the city equipment, budget, and departmental administration, question was called for on the pending motion to • concur in the bid call and opening date and the motion carried, _2_ • • • February 7, 1968 Murray, Dunham & Waitt . Attorneys at Lac . :;. Suite 419 Secaurities' Building Seattle, W%'shington 98101' Re: Hazel W. Chenaur Appeal of Renton Planning Commission Rezone Denial ' : .. • Gentlemen: The Renton City Council, at its regular meeting of February S$th has concurred with the Planning Commission decision that R-1 is the highest and. best•use for the property located on the,:•West side of 1.3.6th Avenue between :'S.E. 110th and S.E. 112th Streete in Renton, and the appeal for R-3 rezone has been denied. Yours very truly, ,• CITY OF RENTON ate:W. Neon . ' . ..: - Helm City Clev HWN/ cc: . Mrs.. ehenaauz . . City Council President - PlaRnning.Director' • • • • e • /c/ X February 5, . 1968 Mayor Donald W. Custer Members of the City Council Renton, Washington Re: ;Appeal of Hazel W. Chen=ur Rezone Denial; ; Appl. "No. R-436-67, .rezone, request :fermi R-1 to R•-3, property located west side of. 116th Ave. S.E. between S.E..`110th " and'; • 112th-. Sta. • Gentlemen": The Planning Commission -considered. the Hazel W. :.Chenaur: • rezone application at its meeting • of December 27, 1967. • The property in 'question has the following basic char.,- acteristic$s Total:Area- 25,116' sq. .ft.:: Existing :Zoning-mR-1 Existing ,Use-Mingle family dwelling, Principal _Access--116th,= Ave. :S:Ia: via ;SHs.,`110th' " . • Proposed .Use-V-multi-family. residential` Comprehensive Plan--low" to medium .density :muTti- - family, residential (revised Comprehensive Plan, indicates single family residential) • The property under` 'Consideration is located westerly of existing .apartment units and a :single family residence and ;easterly of: Hillcrest Lane, a: newly developed single family' residential plat. . -The .proposed rezone ;would"'al- low the construction of medium density apartments; with an. average" 'of :25 to. 30: units; anticipated. • The Planning Commission reviewed the rezone request. 'in some detail'. • ."A: 'petition,.signed by some: 20 property owners in the vicinity. protesting the rezonerequest- was also presented to the Planning. Comahission. . r Mayor and City Council :. February 5, 1968 • Page 2 Upon completion of its deliberations, the Planning Com ' mission 'determined that the zoning requested would not be appropriate. for 'the property.,in question since' detri- mental effects could 'be anticipated and- it would not'be in, the best interests of the surrounding residential area. The Planning; Commission .further recommended •t®. • the City Council ..that the -highest use of the ,property • be R-1 as presently zoned. :: Very truly_.yours p: - Gordon Y. Erickson Planning Director.. — _ ., OF � aEC�fU��R�� r ) , 0 DEC 22 1967 fr J Dec. 21, 1967 -1 ---171471174- -9 ?v To: l he ?en.vn Nanning Cvmini.44ion Miz. Cha ins:an %he undenA49.ned aite acaain.4.t .the pnvpv4ed ae5on.ini .in the vici.n.i y v4 116.th Ave. 5.6. Befueen 5.6. 110,th and 112,ih S24. cle.11_ GUe4L 130' v4 the ,with ha4 v4 itact 211 C.D. fl ilnzan'A Lahe Ula4fe.in vn 9aiden a4 &den DLvi Tian No. 4' /ccvn:li.ng ,ia piai itecvltded .in Vol 22 v j p-LatA page 82 .in King County Wa4{uni ton, 6xcepL Nvirth. 30' and Ule4.t 30' v4 4a.Ld .itact 211 conveyed ,the Gay a4 Renton by itecvaded undea. 4ud i_toJ 4,te No. 5383178 We, -the undeiAign.ed jPee-L aaea .ah.vc�Ld be used Piz. a),,,, ite4iden i_a.L vnL4, and ,the ite3vnLni 4hvu.Ld no be gitanted. Doi ,c/pf , NAP &DVS g,„„k, iod1 /, e‘ ../6t7,-,4- /17 /�(fr/ / 0 , 4,3 _ .„ . ,,,,,,,_ „ L-Te-gli'P-i u, 4 _v..M -7) /(ht / 10.40 1(• GLail 1/0.2. 7 //' 7 g ce,tric , J,e, 6?a,K)Ii,,),),. O7 % //6640,1.c-c . e 'ow ./ 1.2 A)..e.64.11 . P._, --,,,,.___ ,,,,, _ //,--__ ,,_,. ,c, ,, . ,,,, _,_,,,„,_ . - ' _ ,./7,,,,,,-_) //�.30 fe//�- , .- --z� lj/ P91:,-dez-ei . 44-d,/&-4_„i,.,#-"e____ ' // Xs 0 Ja. l/.2rd( 10--74. ---,t-. -7-1z,6 CiG\ k \ . } l a ii576 5,C-- X.-z,/,ute,-,,, (P, 167 _ 7yo�--r —'v " ./‘',/,%,(27 ,e` . //0. //S' dAe - .,- 4 .E.,v ire, ali t, Dec. 21, 1967 Olt 11DOWS • ( / / / z zis ,, ( 6,-,-7,-y---/-- // 0/2_ 6...)1__5?4 r . 4 1 2; //5 7 A., aejf r c S, -.- -i--, u(fv a i aQ ///.2 (Z7 i 3 - .'1 , c,:i OP ,A )92 raib:i[S , • I Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting (Cont.) 2-5-68 Mayor Custer introduced a group of students from Renton High School Boys Club who are attending the Council meeting in participation of Student Government Week. Attendance on a voluntary basis included about 25 youths who will also be coming to City Hall during the coming week for two hours daily to observe operation of various departments. A mock City Council meeting, will be conducted by the group on Saturday, February 10th, between 10:00 a.m. and noon and Councilmen and Depart- ment Heads were invited to attend. - PuMIC HEARING: Hazel W. Chenaur appeal of R-3 rezone denial on property located on the West side of 116th Avenue S.E. between S.E. 110th and S.E. 112th Streets. This being the date set, the hearing was declared open. Letter from Planning Director Erickson reported Planning Commission recommendation that,since detrimental effects could be anticipated and such rezone not being in the best interest of the surrounding residential area, R-1 be considered the best and highest use for this property. Petition containing approximately 20 signatures was attached objecting to the rezone which document had been submitted to the Planning Commission. Mr. Robert Hall, 419 Securities Building, Seattle, Attorney representing Mrs. Chenaur, stated that the proposed use is felt to be the fullest and best for the property noting the proximity of other multiple dwellings in the immediate vicinity and apartment directly behind the proposed development. He added that such housing is greatly needed, that the plans meet with the presently existing Comprehensive Plan and that the property had once been rezoned to R-3 but reverting according to an ordinance which had a one year construction commencement provision, since repealed. Topography of the area was outlined with embankment division from singly family area being noted and Attorney Hall stated developers would be able to furnish parking as required and would be willing to work out any further matters required or desirable. Film slides were shown by the Planning Director after which Councilman Shane inquired regarding apparent drainage problems noted when visiting the site and also in regard to sewering the area. Planning Director Ericksen advised that all such details have to be worked out prior to occupancy of the premises and all Departments concerned mu-st approve the particular portion of the proposal which is under their jurisdiction. Discucsion ensued regarding conformancy of procedures on various applications submitted and Planning Director Ericksen noted that the Commissions actions are uniform and on the basis of the Comprehensive standpoint. Specific detrimental effects were noted to be traffic congestion and loss of privacy to individual property owners on the lower sites. The Planning Director noted the project does not meet with the proposed Comprehensive Plan .Moved by Morris; seconded by Edwards that the hearing be closed. Carried. Moved by Morris, seconded by Perry, that the appeal be denied in concurrence with the Planning Commission recommendation that R-1 is the best and highest use for the property. A dissenting voice vote brought request for roll call which resulted as follows: Aye: Morris, Schellert, Delaurenti, Perry, Trimm, Edwards, Maxin and Bruce. No: Garrett, Grant, Shane and Barei. The motion carried denying the appeal. COt MUNICATIONS: Application from Mr. Robert H. Schlosser, Mgr.,Cougar Den, 219 Main Avenue South, requested that Mutual Amusement Company be granted required license to operate an additional pinball device at said business location. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to refer the matter to the Police and License Committee with power to act, whtich1:carried after.:inquiry regarding the legality of pinball machines and their comparison to punch boards. Discussion ensued wherein the City..Attorney advised of Supreme Court ruling, based upon Attorney General's Opinion that they are both gaming devices and where chance predominates over skill the activity is outlawed and illegal with the three elements under which court decisions are determined being 1. consideration is paid to participate; 2.' must be some kind of reward; 3. element of uncertainty exists. In further discussion City Attorney Shellan stated the City has a right, which goes back to common rule law, to license under its police power and can im- pose a license or regulatory fee. Councilman Shane felt the pinball and punch board devices should be treated equally and moved, with second by Schellert,, that if pinballs are illegal they be taken out tomorrow. It was subsequently moved by Morris, seconded by Bruce, to refer the matter to the Law and Ordinance Committee to report back. Moved by Barei, seconded by Perry, to table the matter. Carried. Letter from Vern Church, Purchasing Agent, reported that specifications are now prepared and requested permission to call for bids for equipment which has been provided for in the 1968 budget. -February 26th was recommended as the bid opening date. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to concur in the request and recommended bid opening date. Discussion ensued regarding the City maintenance program for city streets and the poesibility of contracting such work. It was noted that cities usually do their own aintenance, and after further discussion regarding operation of the city equipment budget, ind departmental administration, question was called for on the pending motion to concur in the bid call and opening date and the motion carried. -2- J'anuary+,'4,.::1968 . Murray, :Dut►bai't iaitt . A:tto^neys;at:Ldi;3' • . , - .zn'ite 419. Securi.ttea Bui ld.it .. - S, a1 t1:c, 'ashinggt 1n.-9t31i1';, . - iei I1azcT'tY: Chenaur-Apped3:of,;R ton - ' - ': P lining Cm isalo*c Rcorlo 'Daii l . :. ' The,Renten 6ity Coiinci` .4 It, s .egui.ar.'me tin :f .lanua '8th„ :has ' s .t.Febru iy 5, _/068 eat: 8k OQ "p.m. in the .Council. chi mbers;. City' ki'al:, . ' ' Renton,.Washington-•is;t a„ti r'c•..and-'�i):ace, c h9ari.ig ,on,the' above'.. . . . . ►t: tined3�1�e � 'It,le: requeetcd: that you xrira%orrapp `3cant, be pr,r0,! t `toy° ' 3.snu4 ,, .... . ., = ‘: - --• • ,:: of the matter:. Il@?1mi.µ,.,O.: FI,e,).son: .. : , IIWd/d ; , BEFORE THE PLANNING COMMISSION .`' 'F . OF THE CITY ,OF RENTON, WASHINGTON ' ,' IN THE MATTER OF THE ) No.. R-436-67 L APPLICATION OF ) , "' :; ; HAZEL Wo „'CHENAUR ) NOTICE OF APPEAL ,',_ FOR CHANGE OF ZONING ) �; TO: ,The Secretaryof the Planning ,. .: ing Commission of the City of Rento"ri PLEASE TAKE' NOTICE that the applicant, HAZEL We CHENAUR,. - does hereby give notice of her appeal to' the City fP , ;A„' ''N'., , Council o `,•, h ' the City.,.. Hof Renton, Washington, 'from each and every part. of the ;orders and' 'decision of the Planning Commission of the 'City of '' uy Renton, made Wednesday evening, December 27, 1967, and whereby . ' "her petition and application for reclassification of the following '^F described property from R-1 to R-3, was denied: ,., ,;; . The west 130 feet of the north one-half of i >$P ' . Tract 2114 CD Hillman ' s Lake Washington'" Garden ''' of Eden Division No. 4 accordingto ' plat• �, , ^'r. ed in, Volume 11, 6 ` ;,,.recordof page 82, in .' ,'.,.;3, r ',- ,;_;. Icing County, Washington, .except the north 30` fe,, , •, b` of said Tract 211,, conveyed to the Cityof r1°. ;� rm,. ''.—:',- Renton ly deed recorded under auditor ' s ‘file ': �' ll "v; 'L , a �1n.. ,,y; No'o 5383778, • It.Li 1 " -ice ` Iv o RT01 ,,•, y .j. r' , You are hereby requested to transmit your complet or, wig e'45 in this matter to• the City .Council of Renton. d2i1 ` F 1Y Y DATED this jr day of January 1968. ' /6";) - Robert J all , Attor for Hazel W. Chenaur, ' , cc: City. Council, City of Renton . City Hall, Renton, Washington Co _ ,_• /,/,f/kf'• . - I 'MURRAY, DUNHAM & WAITT ' • WAYN E: MURRAY ATTORNEYS AT LAW ROGER E. DUNHAM ROBERT K.WAITT SUITE 419 SECURITIES BUILDING SEATTLE,WASHINGTON 98101 • MAIN 2-2655 January 3, 1968 • )5 ' r v gl Secretary of Planning Commission of the City of Renton Renton. City Hall • ' . Renton, Washington 98055 Re: Hazel W. Chenaur - Application for Change of Zoning Dear Sir: . n345 f' ,`.. . Enclosed, -please find Notice of Appeal in duplicateCl t I •.r�' gr. ,t- -;' above-referenced matter. x. , r rylJ , x�-- Please acknowledge service by returning a copy to t i Ct uJf!.d'e'..;�F'i s:; ' •►i CLERit'a 4++'skE •ad Very truly yours, vc�c + L6J, �% . , _,..(....s.\)- ' . Robert . Hall RJH:rs . Enc. cc:.',. Mr. Clayton Chenaur Renton City Council a /�// 0V - • ,• ., • • - • -- •, : , • January 10,..1968. - . • Murray,''Dunham &`Wait't -': Attorneys.,.At:Law Suite :419, Se4uritles Buildin ,-.' . -.. , Seattle Way hington •98055- P : . . - ' - :•Re. : 'Hazel W o'C2henaur Appeal of Planning, • ' Co niissi n -denial'-of Rezone.to..R-�8' :.. Gentlemeni : The Renton City'Council, .at it regular 'meeting 'of ry_8',Janua ;-.-1968:has" ::•.: • ' set the date. of"February.`5, .l968:,as..the date..for hearing 'on your appeal. ,,•'• : - as:.above-captioned. ,: ' . .. • ' ' :' , You. and/or-applicant are:invited to .be'present;'at.:the scheduled;'meeting .;, - , ..to:'discuss .the•',matterv: . .. - ,.. _, , . - - lours'-very truly, , • . . • •- • • . CITY OF RE!�Tf l•; . . . _ ' • Halmie'W.-Nelson • City: Clerk , , : . . HWN/dui. • • . .'cc: Hazel W..•Chenaur = .. - . •• . , • City':Council'..President .. ' • . - . • H 6 fr' . 0 /OF .. ._ `11:U1?i AY, DUNHAM & WAITT WAYNE: MURRAY ATTORNEYS AT LAW ROGER E. DUNHAM ROBERT K.WAITT SUITE 419 SECURITIES BUILDING SEATTLE,WASFHINGTON 98101 MAIN 2-2655 I' January 3, 1968 dd Secretary of Planning Commission of the City of Renton Renton City Hall Renton, Washington 98055 Re: Hazel W. Chenaur - Application for Change of Zoning Dear Sir: .• 5 767,E Enclosed, please find Notice of Appeal in duplicate ;n ti, 1aw .:- ` above-referenced matter. R 7 f Please acknowledge `�'�s service by returning a copy to t` cofce'.'.UN {� ' CL;��tic'�: dir.:WE `?`' Very truly yours, c`,�,. t�- `'r Fi --� / . Robert . Hall RJH:rs Enc. cc: Mr. Clayton Chenaur Renton City Council '\ /2t...), ` il 7 . r BEFORE THE PLANNING COMMISSION • ' OF THE CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON IN THE MATTER OF THE ) No. R-436-67 ' APPLICATION OF ) HAZEL W. CHENAUR .) NOTICE OF APPEAL FOR CHANGE OF ZONING ) TO: The Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Renton PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that the applicant, HAZEL W. CHENAUR, does hereby give notice of her appeal to the City Council of the City of Renton, Washington, 'from each and every part of the order and decision of the Planning Commission of the City of Renton, made Wednesday evening, December 27, 1967, and whereby her petition and application for reclassification of the following described property from' R-1 to R-3 was denied: The west 130 feet of the north one-half of Tract 211, CD Hillman ' s Lake Washington Garden of Eden Division No. 4, according to plat recorded in Volume 11, of plats, page 82, in "`"v` King County, Washington, except the north 30 fe, '�3 , �' of said Tract 211, conveyed to the City of Rentonby deed. recorded under auditor ' s file 'd' 2: 44M19, • No. 5383778. REc ` '� 1'C i o RENT011'`�r You are hereby requested to transmit your complet . e crl aFF{CE�� / in this matter to the City Council of Renton. DATED this .y f day of January 1968. • Robert J all Attor ey for Hazel W. Chenaur cc: City Council, City of Renton City Hall, Renton, Washington . • APPLICATION FOR CHANGE OF ZONE IN THE CITY OF RENTON FOR OFFICE USE ONLY •Appl . No . k-`a3b'b-t Plan . Com . Action 'O2h �A � \2 -(-1.7 Receipt No . Ipa,q,q Appeal Filed 1- 5-0) Filing Date \A-1-10-t City Council Action Hearing Date. \l-A1-I01 Ordinance. No . & Date APPLICANT TO ANSWER ALL THE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS NEATLY AND ACCURATELY: P.O. Box 66430 Name Hazel W. Chenaur Address 400 S.W. 152nd St. , Seattle, Wh. 98166 Telephone No . CH6-152O Property petitioned for rezoning is located mmbehind apartments on 116th Ave. S.E. between 12th Ave. N (SE 112th St. ) andS, E., 110th St, Total square footage in property 32, 650.8 LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY West 130' of the North half of tract 21 1 . e n Ri 1 lman ' a rake Washillgton c; de a .den of En Division No.4, according to plat recorded in volume 11 of Plats, page 82, in Icing County, Washington, except the North 30 feetmof said tract 211, conveyed to the City of .Renton by deed recorded under auditor 's file No. 5383178 thrn.1 •\ke, u)es-k' 30 feek District Existing Zoning R-1 Single Residence/ Zoning RequestedR-3 Residence District What are the uses you propose to develop on this property? construction of apartment house Number of permanent off-street parking spaces that will be provided on property? at leash- minimum required Number required NOTE TO APPLICANT : The following factors are considered in reclassifying property . Evidence or additional infor- mation you desire to submit to substantiate your• request may be attached to this sheet . (See Application Procedure sheet Item No . 2 for specific requirements) . 1 . In what way is this proposed change in zoning in the public , interest? Increase available housing near Boeing and Pacific Car plants; relieve traffic moving through Renton; increase utilization of existing schools; increase taxation to Renton, etc. 2 . On what basis is there . a real need in this community for more zoning of the type. you request? Expansion of industry in Rainier Valley, particularly Boeing, Pacific Car & Foundry, and other business expansion resulting in•xinflux of populat ion. 3. What provision will you make to protect adjacent and surrounding properties from the detrimental effects of any uses permitted in the proposed zone? Plan attractive structure consistent with other relatively new- buildings of similar use in the area. ./..; c R4-7 \ �� RECFI\1ED 70 U nFC 7 1967 Renton Planning Dept .1967 'S.Q- DES Renton. Planning Commission Meeting December 27, . 1967. Minutes Page 4 is narrow and on a hillside. Teegarden, stated • he: felt it would be a mistake to allow an apartment 1pui'ldjng at the end of such a nar- row street. at this time. Forgaard asked when the Transamerica property to the. south and west of the subject. propertywas rezoned to R-3. . The Planning Director replied this was done in 1963 . . Transamerica has indicated it does not plan to open access to the Renton Hill area. or develop their R-3 area at this time., Comments „from the audience were invited. Mr. Jack Newell . stated he, is the property owner immediately eaet' of the applicant'.s property and is definitely opposed to any ;multi-family residential- develop- . ment:.-in the area; that he , feels the .area is' an established single family residential zone: As there were no . further comments , it •was moved by Stredicke, seconded by Forgaard, that the , hearing be closed. .Motion carried unanimously. ACTION: Moved by Teegarden, seconded by Stredicke, that the rezone applica- tion ,of Albert, L. 'Duncalf for. R-3 zoning be denied. Motion . carried unanimously. The Chairman advised the. applicant of ,his right to appeal the decision of the Planning Commission by written •notice . to the City Council., within ten days. (c) Chenaur; Hazel W. , App1. No. R-436-67 , rezone, from R-1 to R-3; property located west...side .of 116th Ave. S.E. between S.E. 330th.,. and' 112th Sts. (westerly of- McKnight . Jr. High School) The rezone application was described- by the Chairman; and the .loca- tion of the property was. pointed out by the. Planning Director on the zoning map. The Planning Director indicated that access to the 'property was via an- undeveloped right' of ' way. Slides • of. the property were shown,. Photographs of' the. property submitted by the applicant ,were. passed around .among the Commissioners . The Planning Director stated that in 1956 . the property .was zoned R-3, but as it was not developed it,. reverted back to R-1 status under a reversion ordinance in effect at. that time. The Chairman read a petition against the rezone submitted by property owners in the area and bearing 20' signatures. The' Planning Director. stated that the, existing Comprehensive Plan indicates this area as low to medium density multi-family resi- dential, ' but that the. revised Comprehensive Plan now under study by the City Council cuts this area. back to single family residential. Comments from the audience were invited. ' Mr. Roger Peterson, 10514 - 113th Ave. 'S.E. , owner of' property westerly of subject property, ., voiced: his objections to the, proposed rezone: Mr.• George :Rusk,. 11029 - 116th .Ave. ,S.E. , stated he, owns. a house north ..of 110th which ,he' had purchased with the stipulation the area was R-1, but had found out, ,later that a portion of land nearby was zoned R-3 upon- which two apartment houses have been constructed. I Renton Planning Commission Meeting December 27, 1967 Minutes Page 5 Mr. Rusk stated he was opposed to further apartment development in the . area. Mr. ,Robert Hall' of Seattle identified himself as attorney for the applicant, Mrs. Chenaur, and gave a brief history of the property in question. He stated that his client is 's,sking for the zoning which had previously been granted and ,which 'had been. lost. due to the reversion ordinance then• in, effect which has since been re- pealed. He discussed the undeveloped, access road about which there appeared to be some title cloud. Mr. Hall stated this undeveloped access according to all,-information he has been- able to get belongs. to the City of Renton. He stated the rezone is a logical one; would have• no effect on. the single family residential area known as Hill- crest Lane directly to the west as . those houses are below his client' s- property and face away from it. He stated further that cost of development of the property makes .it economically unfeasible for anything but multi-family residential used. Mr. Bob Harris, 10843 - 116th Ave.. S.E. spoke in_ opposition to the rezone due. to the immediate proximity of $20 ,000 to $40 , 000 homes . Mr. Jerome Stephenson, , 11430 S.E. 112th St. , 'asked how sewer lines could be connected to the. property. • The Planning Director displayed a sanitary sewer. and water- lines map for the area, and stated that due to the elevation the developer could get sewers only through the west side of • the property by obtaining easements through ad- jacent properties. He stated further, that there are sewer lines along 116th Ave.. S.E. but . they .could not go easterly due to the elevation unless some sort of pumping system was installed. Mr. Clayton Chenaur discussed the history of the •property; the fact. that he. thought. he had the proper zoning, being unaware, of the reversion to R-l; the access problem, . the. development of sewers , the cost of development :being too high for other than multi-family use. He stated thatrhe development would be adequately served by sewers and would be screened to protect adjacent residences. He urged the Commission to grant, the rezone.- Stredicke stated that the . area, notwithstanding the two existing apartments , has .been . developed for. single family use and he. would not be in.. favor of rezoning for multiple use. • Messrs. Stephenson, Peterson, Rusk and Harris , previously acknowledged, spoke,.again in protest against the. rezone, as well as Mr. Ronald Wy- let of 11020 - 115th Ave. S.E. Mr. Robert.Hall _and Mr. Clayton Chenaur spoke again on behalf of the rezone request. There being no further comments, , it was moved by Stredicke; seconded by Teegarden; that the hearing be closed. • Motion carried unanimously. ACTION: • Moved by Stredicke, seconded by Brower, that the application: of Hazel W. Chenaur for rezone from R-1 to R-3 be denied. Motion carried unanimously. Further moved by Stredicke, seconded by Teegarden, that a communica- tion be sent.:.to the, City Councilrecommending that the highest use of this property be R-1 -as presently zoned. Motion carried unani- mously. . Renton Planning Commission Meeting December 27, 1967 Minutes Page 6 The Chairman advised the applicant' s attorney of her right of appeal of the Planning Commission decision by letter to the City ow Council within ten days. Mr. Hall stated he, understood the appeal rights of his client. 5. ADMINISTRATIVE MATTERS REFERRAL FROM RENTON BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT (a) Albert Balch and Garden Park, Inc. , request for variance from height limitation. The Chairman stated that the Board of Adjustment had referred the above variance application to the Planning Commission and referred the Commissioners to copies of Board of Adjustment Minutes as well as copy of letter from the FAA relative to the matter; such copies in each Commissioner' s folder. ACTION: Moved by Brower, seconded by Racanello, that this matter be con- sidered at the next Administrative Meeting of the Renton Planning Commission in order to (jive the Commission time to study the material submitted. Motion carried unanimously. STREET NAME PROBLEM (b) The Chairman read a letter from Fire Chief M. C. Walls concern- ing duplication of street name in Thunder Hill #2 , parcel #26 . The Planning Director stated that this particular street (Thomas Lane) is privately owned. and the City has no control over it. He sug- gested the Commission might wish to refer the matter to the Board of Public Works for their review. ACTION: Moved by Stredicke, seconded by Racanello, that a copy of Fire Chief Walls ' letter be sent to the Mayor' s office and to the Board of Public ,Works for their action. , Motion carried unanimously. APPOINTMENT OF NEW PLANNING COMMISSION MEMBER (c) The Chairman read copy of a letter from Mayor D. W.. Custer to the City Council appointing Mr. Tony Mola as a member of the , Renton Planning Commission to fill the vacancy- created by the resignation of Mr. Stanley Stone and requesting concurrence of the Council in this appointment. RESIGNATION. OF PLANNING COMMISSION MEMBER (d) Mr. Robert Brower announced that regretfully this would be his last meeting with the Planning Commission as he had been. recalled to active duty with the United States Navy, and stated it had been a privilege..to serve bn",.the Commission. SITE PLAN APPROVAL (Request for Information) (e) Stredicke asked if site plans had been submitted for the approval of the Planning Commission for the church located at 7th and M. The Planning Director replied that this church had submitted their site plans as well as a variance request for parking and had received approval of the site plans on March 28 , 1962 . . He stated RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION PUBLIC HEARING MEETING DECEMBER 27, 1967 AGENDA 1. ROLL CALL 2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES , MEETING OF DECEMBER 13, 1967 3. BUSINESS CONTINUED FROM MEETING OF NOVEMBER 22 , 1967 : REZONE APPLICATION (a) Barger., Lyle L. , Appl, No. R-433-67 , rezone from R-1 to R-3 ; property located at 2502-04 9th Pl. N. Total Area--app. 10 ,000 sq. ft. Existing Zoning--R-1 Existing Use--duplex family dwellings Principal Access--9th Pl. N. Proposed Use--multi-family residential Comprehensive Plan--multi-family residential 4 . NEW BUSINESS : REZONE APPLICATIONS (a) Singer, Dean A.. , Appl.. No. R-434-67 , rezone from R-2 to R-4 ; property located on H. St. between llth and 12th Aves. N. Total Area--27 , 590 sq. ft. . Existing Zoning--R-2 Existing Use--duplex family dwellings Principal Access--llth Ave. N. , 12th Ave. N. , H St. Proposed Use--multi-family residential Comprehensive Plan--multi-family residential (b) Duncalf, Albert L. , Appl . No. R-435-67 , rezone. from R-1 to R-3; property located on east side of Cedar St. between S . 7th St. and S. 8th St. (extended westerly) Total Area--7, 975 sq. ft. . Existing Zoning--R-1 Existing Use--single family dwelling Principal Access--Cedar St. Proposed Use--multi-family residential Comprehensive Plan—multi-family residential (revised Comprehensive Plan indicates single family residential) (c) Chenaur, ' Hazel W. , Appl. No. R-436-67 , rezone from R-1 to R-3; property located west side of 116th Ave. S .E. between S .E. 110th and 112th Sts. (westerly of McKnight Jr. High School) Total. Area--25 ,116 sq. ft. Existing Zoning--R-1 Existing Use--single, family dwelling Principal Access--116th Ave. S.E. via S.E. 110th St. R/W Proposed Use--multi-family residential Comprehensive Plan--low to medium density multi-family residential (revised Comprehensive Plan indicates single family residential) 5, ADMINISTRATIVE MATTERS : (a) Referral from Renton Board of Adjustment re Albert Balch and Garden Park Inc® , request for variance from height limitation. (b) Let4er from Fire Chief M. C. Walls re street name in Thunder Hill #2, parcel #26. , . (c) Letter from Mayor D. W. Custer re: Appointment of Mr. Antone Mola to Planning Commission. Renton Planning Commission Meeting December 13, 1967 Minutes Page 2 (c) Chenaur, Hazel W. , Appl. No. R-436-67 , rezone from R-1 to R-3; property located west side of 116th Ave. S.E. between S.E. 110th and 112th Sts. (westerly of McKnight Jr. High School) The Planning Director pointed out the location of the property on the zoning map and stated that the property at one time was zoned • R-3 but had reverted to R-1. The existing Comprehensive Plan indicates low to medium density multi-family residential for the property, but the revised Comprehensive Plan indicates the area as single family residential. The slides mentioned above were shown. 4. DATE NEXT FIELD TRIP : It was decided that each Commission member would inspect the above properties individually and the official field trip would be dis- pensed with for this agenda. 5. ADMINISTRATIVE MATTERS : (a) CALENDAR OF MEETINGS FOR 1968 : Copies of the Calendar of Meetings of the Planning Commission for 1968 were distributed to Commission members and will be distributed to City Departments, City Council members, news media, etc. (b) DISCUSSION OF PLANNING MATTERS: The Planning Director stated, for the information of the Commission, that the Planning Department, in cooperation with the Engineering and Building Departments, has revised the Subdivision Ordinance and it will be presented to the Planning Commission for its con- sideration. He stated the Commission might wish to set some study session meetings for next year to review this material. Teegarden stated he felt some work could be done to standardize zoning ordinances and zoning terms throughout the valley, area. Racanello stated he felt some work should be done to upgrade the Renton Zoning Ordinance.; that we may not have enough zoning clas- sifications to cover the type of developments proposed and to encourage private urban renewal. He stated further he felt there should be another zoning classification between L-1 and M-P and that perhaps the Commission could study this possibility. Stredicke stated he felt that in connection with the Planning Commission' s action concerning the preliminary plat of Interlake Addition No. 2 considered at the public hearing meeting of Novem- ber 22, 1967 , that a further motion to deny the application should have been made. Garrison stated that a motion to deny was unneces- sary as the motion to approve lost; therefore, the application was denied and the applicant was advised of his right to appeal. • Stredicke inquired as to the status of the restrictive covenants concerning the Richards rezone. The Planning Director stated that after several meetings with Mr. Richards, a declaration of restrictive covenants had been drafted in accord with the wishes of both Mr. Richards and the Planning Commission. AFFIDAVIT • Hazel W. Chenaur being duly Sworn, declare that I am the owner of the 'property involved in this application and that the foregoing statements and answers herein contained and the information - herewith submitted are in all respects true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief. Subscribed and sworn before me • this 7 & day of December 19 67. - Notary Public in and for the State of Washington, residing at SePtt1e • C , . e- (N.a'm - (Signatur,e of Owner) p p P.O. Box 66430 /3-3w-/� 400 Sr W. 152nd Street (Address) (Mailing Address ' {9 nn.%.'r. CPP4-i-1 onT . ir'lg'tOn Qs3 1.66 • "(�.•\Y ‘�•. ., (City) (State) • • `r.. ry J i. �� - CH6-15 2 0 • "£•, (Telephone) • (OFFICE USE ONLY) CERTIFICATION This is to certify th - e foregoing application has been inspected by me and has been fo orough and complete in every particular and to conform to l e 4 regulations of the Renton Planning . Department gover 4g � r1ir3 of such application. CJ 2 • Date received DEC 7 1967 , 19 BY: . /72 yNG DEP '• • Renton Planning Dept. APPLICATION FOR . CHANGE OF ZONE HAZEL W. CHENAUR TABLE : of` =, CONTENTS Page 1. Application for change of zoning 2. Affidavit of .owner 3. Plot plan 1 = 50° and vicinity plan (1" 200° � ): Y ) . 4. Copy :of: existing zoning map of Renton showing proposed change ; 5. - Portion of King County Assessor ' s map '(S.E. 45-23-5) showing property in. vicinity; Scale 1' = 100 ' 6. Photographs of property involved (/ \ Rk.\\\ID /6/, UGC '! 1967\'° -------"-- -- ---- 441 911/�/N'� • • NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING .RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION RENTON, WASHINGTON A PUBLIC HEARING WILL BE HELD BY THE RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION AT ITS REGULAR MEETING IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS, CITY HALL, RENTON, WASHINGTON ON DECEMBER 27, 1967 , AT 8 : 00 P . M. TO CONSIDER THE FOLLOWING PETITIONS : 1. REZONE FROM R-2 TO R-4 ; property located on H St, between llth and 12th Aires. N. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lots 4 and 5, Block 42 , Corrected Plat of Renton Highlands No. 2 , according to Plat recorded in Vol. 57 of Plats, Page 92 to 98 , Records of King County, Washington. 2. REZONE FROM R-1 TO R-3; property located on Cedar St. between S. 7th St. and dead-end. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Tract 4 of Highland Addition to the Town of Renton, as per plat recorded in Vol . 17 of Plats, page 32 , Records of King County, Washington; except the north 100 feet thereof; less coal and mineral rights and the right to explore and mine same. eINt'v 3. REZO NE FROM R-1 TO R-3 ; property located vicinity of 116th Ave, S.E. between S.E. 110th and 112th Sts. LEGAL DESCRIPTION : West 130 feet of the north half of Tract 211 , C.D. Hillman' s Lake Washington Garden of Eden Division No. 4 according to plat recorded in Vol. 22 of Plats , Page 82, in King County, Washington, except the north 30 feet and the west 30 feet of said Tract 2] ] conveyed to the City of Renton by deed recorded under Auditor' s File No. 5383178. • • i:. r;4,' • ALL PERSONS INTERESTED OR OBJECTING TO SAID. PETITIONS ARE INVITED TO BE PRESENT AT THE PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING ON N � Decembex 21, 1967 AT 8 : 00 P .M . TO VOICE THEIR PROTESTS OR OBJECTIONS TO SAME . • PUBLISHEp James E. Denzer , SECRETARY ---n- =- 11ex 14 , Lq67 RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION CERTIFICATION 1 , -.Tames T` Ba7q.1-adt- , HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THREE COPIES OF THE ABOVE DOCUMENT WERE POSTED BY ME IN THREE CONSPICUOUS PLACES ON THE PROPERTY DESCRIBED ABOVE AS PRESCRIBED BY LAW . ATTEST :• Subscribed ����. y TT sworn ,� he and ril `.> I (,Nh_1/4„;;2, 7,-=--,- , . /,�/ f�f=? �`- to fore me, a Notary PubIic j on the L,thday of December • • 1; x, 1 ; INTER-OFFICE MEMO fi7 March 24, 1966 \..,4 Date From: Gerard M. Shellan, City Attorney Deparmental Account No . To: Helmie Nelson, City Clerk Expenditure Account No . Re: Gilbert rezoning Dear Helmie: Enclosed you will find stencil for proposed rezoning ordinance for Kenneth Gilbert. Weinotice that according to the file that this property is to be rezoned to single residential district (R-1). However, the cover letter dated March 21, 1966 addressed to the Mayor and the Council shows that the property is rezoned to SR-1, which would be a different classification. All other documents, including the Notice of Hearing\ show rezoning request to R-1. Would you please clear this with the Planning Director, and make the necessary correction on the Ordinance in the event that the R-1 rezoning-;. 1 is incorrect. Please advise. �Q „k i ,. -.------; We remain0, e 1'�` Very_truly yours, � G�� UGAN & SHEL N rd M. S; lan, City Attorney , GMS:ds 1 cc: Mayor I Attach. Planning Director , / IIc_ ‘ /2, ..,/ i II X ./ / ( . 1 , r _ , , , __.,:. ,r , ...., s',J �.._ a r,, ;�-.,t,..� \ 1 Ll_j S \I_____&31 Ill 7 C2_4_2:-•`-':: , Z,37 GI,e. &GI ,,,,p,.,,,/- , , I i I I i 1 \...m. ---1--r--....' '-- I i I I 1 L_____. _,---±-, • irf_8i___,-i 2" ' 5r 4 ?Jr __. I nt _.-J •-•• ••••••:••••.71 -"----- ...„,,--•., ___ I ) , za I izra I TZT4•1' -• ' --••••• \ % • 4o . , I i I1,I'"'''' • 1 ' 1 \ \ ____ I \ ‘ I I \ • I\ ,r 255 282 Z74 •Z‘ol 254 .., 241 Z5b ' Z 25 .., ,. 205 tall' ,,,,,::‘, ---. - 1 1 ,, '117 ' 1111 t 3 a I 1 / I I .5 7 , 4 _,_____ 111 •,,,, /:\ ' ' -----:-Si_r_ E-- I 10,,align,iMillMEMMI 3,,,;,'; ._•.4.1):L,2!?_i 1 1 ' I 11111 • 11111 RR i • , • 3‘ //\...T.!.,.,...,... . - I . , 1 . -C3 283 273 262 253 242 235 224 Es osirom L . - ME KAM —- ---rc ..---T, 1 1 7 i ' • /4) ''.). \'`,A .ii;l:;-•''' i re•v, .•,,..-f 1......i.',,, / 7,.... 1,.,.. ,, . __r_u_u_i_j, ] , , um ' -I- 1 __I . . ,,,, •AA i 1 ; 2(1 . 0 1 ism 1 f ,,,,), 293 2 2 a ZG3 52- 41 4 225 imemilla,- 'L i . . 1 - ' > --H 1 4 raw Sem> / %/ /- ' iii111 'Z'el ,,. . , , ,, . • 7„ _ . 104 • 5 - —?v, ' ..1. •‘-‘, , in , lops -,...., .. --)..,:.- •, ' -1 R mia / / 1 -,.. i..••• r.:.".... A.I ism,1-•• i,..*•••..':. MEL .:....,..r...i •• • • ,_.L.... , --M ! 285 271 1 244 ill . .., 244 Millimi ‘11 5 ii•Illig 17- --",i I II i-tl, '''."(1'',II. -\ ,--•-\,. ----4 , ,..‘• /40% . MEM 11111.r?..mull INN Il ..i, 81' ' 10'" .1:<.. I • • I .9 ------ " --• -, . 0 Illidig''': . ill k •-• ' i '' -— i -o ..-- ..t.', '...:•: ". ....... •-• ikirij..:1.: '... ....: I_i •-•:i 1 0.: , ,...1:1K` • 1,7, IS . :..-, '4,- 1 t L'i:,:- .11111,', s'>, I - • 01--;mit. KW 9ffi= ./ . 3 .. aik. . . .. ,, 91 V - • • 4. ' , 1 .''. i 291 266 270 265 ME 232 227 214 209 , ,, ...,11k., . . ,MaN , ,, , 4. • diti, . '', t " • / 4v, - • ‘P`L'-.--.1 "411,'• itio. , • , II III i...-...:',•_::*p ;,:, , -... •,./, 0 1... p_..., •SE , -1- .so' . . el, • i- R-3 6 ' .: rik, 4 ,,iiin 1 - 1 i I I . ill „7-• .... 0 3 • .......1_ 1- , , = L__I et 1..,..11 . I 'IL 2 T.- , ., ••• , in .- )1L'' iiiiiMIN...,. •'.1.•'•'''e ',• — . 41' ..1' ,. .iv - /• Nur, •i•--:-,673-- 1.... . ;_j_. • All , • . L.. _ 1111I I . , • ;• . 'TIT; 1, . . , 7 n ,ii$,-;..ziq ,. k: - ' ,... • . aid V l'a ..... . . ON, . ..1,...!.. ' 269 tea 268 I 2'7 , 247 250 •25 '.4 L9,. Z 1 1 13'4 •../ 0.i -- .'..I\ z MO° .,'•••• N-- -7-1 r. .....,„ , ill .34' .. tli ,,s'r '!' ' PI . . 4 '-'. 1 . a 7 II . i'-- , ...,„ ... ni . jgeti. ii, -____-... -_ _ • . -----A7MF---- ---._ ___ • 1111 III .,i- ' ii. ,111111.AV NI1•• ;04-r•-' zr -,i-, (af IP' a • 4., 45 R3 ▪ , . • , • 8 1 /4 ,z? -,-: ' , .i.,11 ._, ,, . ,.!., .,•.„,,, -/ . , .. 4401 • Eirtocujii.ina wpm, , .7.1 - • 4tl'ilia. , mit V /*•' ;.4.4 M-M• • 0111. MP " EU / nuf ,f5 Mai -I n211 it, -cell th ..,. ao 55 ::• •',.• P.,-.. , --9.\\ \ / -._• ____ 40' ttilm , PI_ r; t" //, 44,11,4tiottalrgill iN' nreremne, 101 . ... ' t - ) , .„,,ci ff • \ , (-...-.) ,......1.,,,, . , , r '' ' ;'-`1" - 7 I . ,.„. , _ . '• - •P. •••,, a mu ......i.. ,,,,. .,..N,.,,,::„...1; L ,..!.. .,,,, ° •- \ 1, • \ , . ••• - or,A... 10"ti. AVE n1 f \ 0\ V. \ ( . ''',. I.;.;i.I(1 •.':1.-Ora . _i Q . 7 ' 1-si KM F•SO---1 • iiimpAill 1 IMMO d• '..an DPA,.... v•- . r• .411 ,,.:: 1.-'. . • .j ;, 1981.13.ggela.. . ,,i .2 Cain mionarre... \ 4.v.\ '''. -'.vt mygil illa 11 1 11 I pl Fil.:"g 4 E,-) )6-1 ,,• :7: . F.; Fr tiOn ..I.-.-'cl,,:c:: B, 'AVE.,'1S,.1:':. ,„ ‘1\ '' ) W1, 33 - E, -'.''''.,:.i.,1. .-.•;•,.--,a m,a•e.r.s N - d. AVE ri ' 1 Ii•,.N..,iCii, ,..,.•.04:. 7 4i 1l -.l.i•tl•i..e, °ffil N •--\ . mot -i,/araummen- nn n ' ii • •- -"Hr•-•".. Alf,p ,, .., ,,,, ______,__.- z,,...1-: OP I • et.',‘ ILICIMMICIM Mr. alai Ex II Ai "-mil imill n) 411, ' WI \\ 1\ . ,A, .ci•9, stir- ,- , mg .,: la • ip,.. .....,..„..r. . . im ' , -I-. , .,• ,aht,.., ,-65:\ ,..; ......... .,.:.......i g :::I iro.„ ,. ..1,,... .. .. ,:,,,„,,.. „ . \ ,,, . .,..y,,,_.. ._,,,,.. ..,_,: 2, p... if 0 ose a• A „,,., ,.- ,. .f,tel 'cr . .. . . . ..... .... . . .i. , . .'•; . IP aik747110 - 1 - ' I dn..: . " 4,, ", IQ -,. lit._ , 4 ••'_r. * ' .'el .- * , • s 4. 7' • • lo I‘t,„ la tt ' I i I'1 --,-••., ...,'31* . • NA, "'•••• •I''''•I 4"ilia i . . v- 7''.. \I ' ) d ' , ••• 4 , " ••••, - . - " tit/Ott d _j ... ,• ,, ' 3 " 8/8R/fga 1 i'v " !'•:,.. ' 11 If it.s''"41/ -14 .-..-•*- •C: ....-ildWi . NEI PLAVORouNO Tell W ' . ". 'b 4.1 im he 0,r " IL__ , -.• . • . 'lb.0 ot,14.3 nig,i'e,,it., :. - irig,„uvkiji, . .. imeammossPlIwillp. . ' ---ti.T.(----• : - **0 - ''.4•11 7 -AVIX.# ilP Ms .4„edi , IS 7 " /411" % • ' * '' "''1*I ei n s$ 'l',4r : - iMirgt 0 A6 di As, ,i, nim .0 • \ TIMIC., dirATO i•it NValt,:`- , . '''#.,'it,vw,”...I , , , Irk' Ile d VP filial affeeell , bAtIliti, 4 - ' ' '''' 21 UV, \ tn ili i i URN, lk-a\.1=1,I.' :45 .0, 0.4411 ,A4 • , ,_•„. , ifol., ..,. ,,,,,,,,, 3 g 1110‘,,P. .,_,,_ . i a I dikWi ) 1 elk II • , O.. ton i \ i i , iktolow,,a-se 141!..!VISS.--'.• u• 'allrill CAR \ / .• '''" • EL .--tp,9A..._ am=: ' - ME•1! 11411111n.9,11.11. „, IA ,„53, =le,-,wil,, ,ifilMizEin 4 , 6 .. It U.•.....ES v ,,,...li„. ,. Iva" ", WI , ... , . ___1 ... ,,,,,.„. ..., „::,....\,v, ,,,...41:1: ..• „.-- _ fl- , 10' e I,4,11. . ; 4- 1 '-'i co. h-,.-'; ,,,/ t ik`''' .+,..44 ,...,,i_,‘ At. 'at'Vr9,. III '..' '-'5 -, q. ... .•.., . , ,, _4kh i, ' . ,6. // i r io ,,- ..„........ itint-• ,;; .,":"1","..1,... E14:1,74.4:r______'-,..,...--/_ zo ........? 4 ' I •1111 . • . •IM 1 / • f-1 i \ IR 1 !, V4 1,1 . ; 1111., 'C "1// ' // Loci r ,., / / „., /7 ks7 --1,9--C _. \ \ \, \id \ ' ------ •_-__---:---- , ,Ir __ ,,T2 ION.--4111,1 Al F es.:), .„,,,„.,,,,,___„_, ...,,,,„.„, ., :-...i :,,,,,, , GRdEN,vvb.. .....-rori 1 1 4 • I / / 1 j• / /. ., CE 'ERY I / I - - i- f .� 1 I• o - . 2 - h'v - i V)- . . � w — 1 - cr,N y Wi I A4, • / - r!, ) oo < - { t t + I. to f { �R <, 3 i � �ENTOiy oKD /QtZ I i _cr.% . - 1 o A s.- as7 ao ion Z. ' h ►-Nr � YNT�N / I� ,IS D w Z l ,, , = 0 �.. a 0 ,; o b1 i 9c o� h, . •A Z,.‘Pi r v) • ;�. fi •D . N W 0% • `0 (...1 y.a-.7r-S3E. t 1 0O/` ,p [ • dk fO.O3 80 `.�_C�q go S9 97:eV t •�' I ' ,._ ��.T • C _1 b 4a r I �� ;j I '\ Z i .tv. O- 32-•.2 4, 409. 9.3 / 4C£07 al y �2 `I p[ l - -- �- I i1• ' - 1 II5TH. AVE. SE. I`/e ,, o� z �� .tea �0, ;�� �/ �l k, V ,� .59.97 7S 73 74490 Lj7 <" Us ...,i k �',� e,8 _ ro v 3cu NIp -c. p N i, 7s Ac.,to.7 7S 74 74 `0 Uio! /B2 Z C 7 l7 ' I f do A. o-.92- 2 i r —i i SS 7 /o .9S // ).'+ t { 4i �/ / C -in o - ` III 1 i. O0/ 8d i ` 4_ I O • v c �j `f.• / t- f ll N t \ ! goo: :, ",.. t tq W __L01,-- . i ti `- ti I v 80 - 9 01 i . o7 I. 0 • 0 i . - I a 01 0 c p� . w • t e O 0 • I _ I `� lA t 59 .5 /o a �5 �.(6 r 30 i 3 •7 0,6: so ' yo 92w •�4 9b t iS 0 6 p Jtrtz i- /48•S L /48•-c r i j. �- --- -1 - - `; o' - • f ` .��H raw ctry 4..;,,,-cs one s' 7 `116 T H . i ;AV '." 'S E _ ' . s — — - D C�h- .. o0 2 vs/ t — I I - - --t319.70 • . r —�_ t9 80 • , • , �M ro�v"<• �.eo i4sy S.W 4 4- - 2 �tl.« , r i. i , t :.` Y•� 1s t rt ,•ti a 1 • f} r 1 �...r. 't_ ✓_ }. - i_ , Il •• f- 4 :_�l�' .. _ .e i`..w • - .,-- •v C ?—) 1 IA ci M ., 14 R -X E c. V. RI Z0Mr r' stir- t Z — zT- 4 /R -- 4 6 - 7 CA e h 4 yf R C A Ir/sA7 /2. 7 47 4•44'i — Deti :14 ge c. X -.,/ l itylle X/r4c9 4 c t%v%, — b e. a . et e ,,Le % . - 4 .1 ie ,flee 4.41 140 Lfif48 G ® an► ce• P4 C" AO Pt4s. C.ft. , lee t s R. 2,-. // Asd... . .. .✓ t_ ,:7.` r_ 2 /:44A I I I , liL _' 1\ \ � 1 1 Z95 262 274 � 2G 1 Z34 241 ' 29b I 2!29 F t __ 2O� t "s a /i 4 y1'•4r 1 I H -71-1 ,___ __, �� I -I--b 1 I -1-----�I , ?i.1 i•• r • -. 11 I4 S 4-1 9 \\__ tai 'v-• / 1/ f 59~ 242.E Lj5,1 224 • II •� so.^_- '1 289 r273 �262 �._._. I • e IL_.,..-. - �� ill' '. ) 1 t____ ! o -,_-:1.:1,.,.. , .-,' „, , Ja • 1 Z, 4'2zol 2 4� _25 •L - 'i�- -- -�..L.I —� A./Q./ i : s 1 I 3 :r.. � Qhn 29L LalS LTI 2G4 251 I 244 � , a • }----- R -- tf • 4. : !' t dd. — �i zs zsa ,I xTo ! zcs 34 T; tlaz 227 214 ' 209 : 4v I-1...._1 i 1 . 1 I _...4_.__.1_ 1 :I , 0V, .......-. ..."*"....‹I, r „) i \ e . 17,1 ! 77 -. R-SE_G25.. ' r � ' Ley°L� - �- - ^ ...\ 4 -----,-- . ' .. Lt- ---• : i 249 ; 24�0 Z31 22B 213 f >, i �` I /di ;,..-J , i---t- , _ , , ;.. . . . , , __n...,1.16, - �/ M • • -t tel .:, . . .. LNI 1 r. 269 266 _ _ _ Z9 n / 4i —.� . 4 .,,,,, „,:..\-,,,. \\\ ___.__` , _ — A` �\'ter • ' 1rli [ 1i.. 4 I R-3 lin. Q �y \ t t • , * r p• (H �j 1 '11 7 J • , . .. ‘.•, \ (N.,..,.., --i • // a /1 o e* / �� de„sol , tr d ,,, P 4a .v....'4 _ , • • : . 'I' alit , .. .f.iip till PA , l 'I`i'v . . _. 9I, - porig Q T �i Z Ni + \ t.— a ..4.wig �/erg 1 ' �aQ9 ;, A - 5 _1 i=7-...,114*. \ , • 'I:\ IIIMLtk Et;rt. . ... ..,' r, If *IrS ', :r, . ,0, A 1 .r.,4 i i 1 _i., , \, \ \ , o 0 Opp-��pp��ppppe �7� .� y ;•-- -r\ ‘ t��lCOO m a ai -- 30042 Fig \ \\ da. nom r r� e, �1:3o °'� a", 5'� ,111111 is .� P i �,► Aces es e'a„eln "ice`' �, pp 11:"Igaia,"E r,.�' pubm / A=� - . , ♦ s 1.'i r • +11 ie ,1..�1--- eYY� � �� e'`. ,'1 t 4 '•` '' a w� , '._ 1nl ;k .:,rt�a; ' I ms p�����A sea I 1 : . ... ...fff «4„ - ,I( us_ 4 \ .16- e �Ivi� � o_ ss�A gilfts 0\4 �'0 i _ �..; wn s ..b gra 6, IN, m„,„„7 . ...102.ii IA * A al .I •. �, lai�, �art�•�Am���,��,�,��_ls .�,rT ' ag 41 o n��. -..• AN ' 01Q ,' • ,�S C���IRI��"�`!•�`d �- .1 :1 ' ^ IQ iTA t':.F` .. 'pit oA "�,, es a s c�11 dr uLIN • , .... .Zm. d e,t. amone. I,s � :lea . .L MiNiR d' ISM w�' +,mom© piS 0 o� i i �� ;� ' , s.„ee�o m- figs Oe t - 2al 260 259 I c 99 c Do •..L-i I • g\ I \ }. 14?. . I r\ —� no 97 rr sr. 9 , ,..._:._-2-.1-17—E--— ----1---____—:—___.' mil no in . ..., 0 , 4/4°, \ L/G — 255 w 1111 Ilt u1:,7 }I71.11r I •luau.. i } o m 295 252 zra z61 zsa ui za1' 11gg % • • }+ 1}• // // lie= „ • — — r jL u ' 9E. 1111 •� ��Yli7��lM F>.1��lfi�te CAW®14 i1t�b _ •• ,root } / �- j''IL 242 'L35 224 �-� • �� _} ° • 283 273 262 �I ,sue • ' 1 'n i • c..., 1.:...;. I I ...i{ i..... ten,. -.+.+_- ��/ •:} 1 r 5z 225 <_ I111111 s\. `; 293 224 2 2 263 „ IN j • I wI ? N1' e _ • s . I `` �� �e � d rl'-�� 1 S 104.. ' � ■V1■•",aywt�l. ■I >E1 to al_t,I 1.C , _ ~ �. 4'\.'\,`.P /1'49//' i, } III E. •,+'„•'.ice i i`: - �`\,° / ,q•/ ,...: Ii.T. ': ' IL\_.i i..... 26'4 121 •1EIg' ! \,22 285 I A -- - ,eri , • sum 32 227 214 N°•,• '�` ` ,i ..,�2v 291 286 270 265 ,11 ■01. vE ' -__ _. �.., .mi r. 6_,-,; i— i i i • i ,,u.,:::-., ° • Ii' � „4 I i t i11 .. •I•• Lcna • • t r L '.C a 1 It"`T '/J , 111011 a °1 I e _. ! + �v !3••AVE -I-- •n iJi :� \ ., 289 285 z66! 267 248 247 .250• a29 ,. n .�� -_ SI r' =€%..~ , ,I11-f \Imo^-- ,e. II �2� 111• "' .141IrIl ® �W Q� e it° EMI _ _•z, •._3_.�....a._a _ — _ __ -12 TN — a� _ �II �- r�'',�� •�"9 l� o. t Ilrxb .J k ! If Rl t 6, c 43 !Y/' Q. :- -�• �I U ,i i S '4 + , „, O "Cr` ,!� n„. .. _ a-.-,..� !°,, . cr''''',4.a.=' " .�, +40 39 /' '0 ,r .. ,} 'e T til?� y ®�r'• Y ,�•,_4__11t444 \\i., . . , a- p,l L I ' I ,/C h,� k r• ' • .... 8 m 1:° . ®° '�a ate} I, I 0, // � -' ' 1 r.35 t• .L f1.712 •1 T d'e !,� VA._ •I.^E� v :' ' 4,4S7:111 IIIIW. 'S',., . ri')z°,/,,,i.3\;• ':‘/,-, . ;37 .;11:41:6 1":2:4'urt':.: :: lir i. 1\ • 1 1 rillo-: ,3i' ..... .. ?. ID•1• AVE N. \ _,• , �,�e.''_\\ • � .o ):—' ..' °�L .. .-te r . , + 1O:.TN AVE(t) o�ooam�mm�®m�• 11� ` NM 14 I I �I''i'I19 V ll_. ;i...Y" s s� ��, ��� n_����� Ell F :.f; f.l. ,i, l oam' ',,Yi 'w��o®® •N� ,�e1, 4v�N /� I`I �� •� +'3'I tllf�_r�m° �-. CI 'jam ar. . mn: n , ,,. q --N,., ,.,11 w Dm..,.t,tii 1 (` , FpF 'am.Q01O�9nvOm� 1 .15Qo ,., `'4:111�.��' .' •dilIOYOI�•III. ea tl �l ISpew-pm - ., ,- 1111-PAR413„:8=. IIILF k Cill � +� , !, fx ffor r/f' II'I'� aee �. 4YE � � Ron, 4 _ �:11 ill 7 ,. V , �. , . .. N. °�m _ �� ,�O AVE NE v •N II r s abLii .+: . ® CLAY440UND D v YN A v F ...°.•.. .. b ��Spmgv °^��� d. .11, gfa .,,;j4t,aD,Iply ti0p�' � ` � d 'D em®�_�/ Q��°. O0 if i',. �� I�A I ,`� AVE6T� �ta:!n t.r.i1 G ., eIII • ,�� 1111 ,`���'p a ,, o,0 6uP a� • ae A DNo� D�1m ��d�0 0 « _rosin J . 1V•IIihf 111: .i \ IIIMINff yw©asl9I A tL ,` N 5,9 'e>•, r m pie l ' I .i ,k,,,, ,.,. i ., __F.7.-a, 11111 DIA, ,, us..kli.ri,v\ i El c ,:N� \�i I` /f \ \ .•' • 474. &®3>- ,I; a; III 1S4O �4 4 i• 1 ;' 777- 1 • al — A _JO O t ,9)) ' i • g � ' • \ k 4--1-: iy. �/ `l ' C7' 1\� j . W . / . II ^.., - n°J . 1 I i• �a.r.`.., j l\ .7 .,\\ -- �ty/.r7� 7 s.�,^' nre�•.,. P. '- ', . ,/ i F ��� G ' _., .., L 0 I.1 �) . _ C `` tip' ;'_Y /1—� �1, Y e o CEM -TE 1 �i� \\ SE / ty I • �U / � �. 1+.',.'. .#..; _ .. .. • ..*•. •A •-r.. .J.� L -.ram onmimoi .. I . Y' 55 "9 9y91X L ; �i'!Z/ _..i; t.117ZE1 .7a. :a cF-«�r N '- AV ' • N/o/ V + /o/ -III ri v. D ^' \ - • Pi < ' 6/ /o/ mi. tee . 1 cm S a • a c - �Q �U- - ' 2/ rr' ' �.• c- \I I ,...2• • Wig I C^ 1 � ' (D _ / ,`v rS cv �� 7/, OZ I :y6`f'-6B�' � I ' C /. iC' • 1 eire •I‘ /1.'", , 3' a �� NI a ,, 1 0 oZ 'c' o/pr 1. ,' _ /o/ V C ¢ 'z z I�- Q Cb .%0L4. 6/re - ..''' ._ .. 6 6t N :.yc.6c.... , , yeti E•e ,15 ,/- - o% , \ �o.gti o 0 ' 1"4 4 'H_; i s 1.4' e '11 1 . ♦ • -► ��r , r0.36 4G .� (N L 9 z ',,\ $1 .. /2'06• •z_S"•.N aE-6B %✓ »1► n / J V ' WO D G � .0 t7 o < s �, I \ M. ' \ 0 I - is,S -2 !A , A. . \ 4. -1. -. . 00, -7-514 . , 0 ✓ o c C O . I, b ff.poi 1 I r 'I�.11 � I - • a — Off,^0^ TT—'— -S9 - nn/ ���\ N I I ,A;• 4v z •11 -f ! • p ! � I ,1 ' o Ito i ' /^/a/ //1/ ' �yJ Iw ._ - _ IN - — _- - _ mac... !I • • W 1 < _ wl V C 41 i - v \ / x Al ., L--- .70 ; r F�• I 1 t\ r �� r b• �E/YTOiy oK0 /Qt2 70 • .o.0 2B 1 0 1` -- I t F F--�... <« N. o- 3, -S 3 - ASS 7 - L--�� 4 2.- a r • • (v E ea - 60 \ io- .YEN T0N <...�s r.S o n D .s 6 7 w N ..... ...... 1 , %, , Ct7F ti � d F.,-;-: . .,.. I ^'D y \ N \ `� (Y NO-3,-S3E..riZ " 0 'i I •:, vy ° , o \ v ^ ���<- 1 fG.03 N 80 / ., %_R eo 59 97 �+_/ .`t a b! '� C) 1 { Z iV O- 32 .?/L 409. 93 J C� �,+CEo7`1 -L 2 0!%' t• L_ -- - - - • --- f' l� t15TH. AVE. SE. Ne _ o° ems' • ` W�� f/ J • F .". V .59.97 7S .. 7.5 7s,90 , 7.0 19<-` ^ r r 7. k -8 - J - , • I:‘ II h V t 4, "N, . 1 . dr ., i t 7S Re.,/'ors 7s 74 74 NO !Jro! /BZZ GIs/ , .. a E H0 iv. 0-.3z- 2/_-- . SS'7 /0,9.9S 1 t� I ,6 / ,i ii, ^ i ' i ,- '• ' tv • v • O JJd t Ib ' \ ! i� V 1 -.I - ♦,a � ' i I N ��ao s _ �.1, S' 1,— j \ 1:t.f,Z),r,, i - f .4 \ • ji° �a" t 5 1 16 34 13 -7 v 6- a0 y0 192.: . Ye) 0.S O - 1 o CV 1 .lb- - . •eo'' 'V etr'y 4.0. • cs oe. ;s47 ''116 TH. 4 ' AVE'.• 'SE r wNO°.3�- 'w { 1 I'-4-----i 3 19.7 0 ��--/L 3d' . . 1,.�1.► d" .a, s _ - �� - �9 ao • ,� �M raw �ko i usy P S,R4 4- 2 3 ._ _ �_ r __ _ — __ __.X i___ __ r. f•;'4, -+- — ;'. T —_ _- . __ ^7 a f• -- -I �_•--' ,r' I ( • �. Y OPDINANCE NO. 1703 AN ORDIN:.NCE OF THE CITY OF R NTON, WASHINGTON, AMENDING TIDING SECTION L-725 (e) (3) OF TITLE IV, (BUILDING Rr;GIrL.TIONS), OF ORDINANCE NO. 1628 ENTITLED "CODE OF GENERAL ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF Ri NTMT'ON"i BE IT ORDAINED BY Tit MAYOR AND THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OP R"NON AS FOLLOWS: SECTION I: Exiting Section 1. 725 (c) (3) of Chapter 7, of Title IV "Building Regulations)of Ordinance No, 1628 entitled "Code of General Ordinances of the City of Renton" reading as follows i "Section 4-725 (c) (3)• Any ordinance granting and providing such chansLe in use district boundaries or re-classification of property, after petition thereof by the property owner or owners, as hereinabove provided, shall remain effective for a period of one year unless the property owner or any one of the property owners originally petitionin , as the case may bd, have comenced a change of use during that p,,:riod. If no change of use has been consummated within that times the ord- inance granting such change in use district boundaries or re.. classification shall be null and void, in which case the use and classification in existence prior to the filing of said petition shall become effective again as to such property" BE AND THE SPINE IS HEREBY AMENDED TO READ AS FOLLOWS: Section L-725 (c) (3) As Amended: Any ordinance granting and providing such change in use district boundaries or reclassification of property, after petition therefor by the property owner or owners as hereinabove provided, shall remain effective for a period of one year from the effective date of such ordin- ance, unless the property owner or any one of the owners originally petitioning, or their successors in interest, as the case may be, have commenced a change of use during said one year period. If no change of use has been commenced within said time, the ordinance granting such change in use district boundaries or re- classification shall be null and void, in which case the use and classification in existence immediately prior to the filing of said petition shall become ef- fective again as to such property. The term "commenced a change of use" means (a) the physical �.1teration requiring a building permit; or (b) substantial evidence of occupancy, operation, usage or conduct based on such reclassification. However, the owner or owners of property so rezoned or reclassified may petition the Planning Commission, at least thirty (30) days prior to the expiration of said one year period, for an extension of such time limit. Such petition rust be submitted in writing stating the specific reasons or reason for such re- quest. The Planning Commission may thereupon, if it specifically finds proper cause to exist, extend such period up to but not to exceed twelve (12) months, and any such extension shall be subject to final approval by the City Council. SECTION II: This Ordinance shall be in full force and effect from and after its passage, approval and legal publication. PASSED BY THi° CITY COUNCIL this 18th day of November, 1958. /s/ E.L. Alexander City Clerk APPROVED BY THE MAYOR this 18th day of November, 1958. /s/ Joe R. Baxter Mayor Approved as to form: Gerard M. Shellan, City Attorney • • • • • . , ••,. • . ; ••.•'• .• • .t „.; •. •' • (t..) ( ) ••AT''• : Tit) t(,";••.:„tr., .• ' • . • • .; ••• • -.-- .i 1,1311 r.):.•;!E ' • . . , • to :.-.-)..;c;3•I • • 'A, ;" ":,ife,r;) .'" • . • • , • • • : ::-• •••,- • 101 rf; : • , • ,:•••• •-•.•• - , . . • J.. .1. ttir.) -• : ' tij , . . • ; ••• • J J• • : •• . ; 1• : . • : f " ••; . 1 cru .;'A •.• iso.; : • --•• :If 1'),# t ' •. .11 2. • :: c, • •• r!')U ff•!. , ;• ,• ,, slf,:t„...; 1 d (10 :14.0 t",;!'` A1(.1.1 !'")C..t) 101 evil *IT cr.,nrr.t t ; '7:1-11:..'"0 f f?rf,t :),c _1 4 i) .1).f.1•• •) t.s . V.40. -t:10;nc.4. CJ F.)I-Ctt r:L ifj rilrzaw.: ,11!. -; et '.c.!rp..:ICS e41•1 t finiLjel.e „ •.: {1.1: t 11j:07 ..fi:.sc 1. ! .1 Col 11.1- "10 •\.:3 ;11 rf. ;.stv. '11; r311.111V:).11 1.:;;If2f.4; . ,rHO:. fd (43) • 1!? " .1 • 00:1Cilinci. its onti-Jblv9 ",fr; r.1.7.4).rr•N-.) .111.4"; Sr! .:) C 41 6tft p„..1 '361 (1,-,0,Eqr,v1 ritiO hxi -c)^. r?. Sr 11,1 `!.:E• • 0 : 5sr '• •Icc ftici (0,-3 1:" ; ; ••'• •• .1 ;",;.i.t1'. 1 e /14dr: ytt:s, N:!,•••;•;; , . . 7,r,i:Arii.it•rtC.; • ,•,"r••II. OW00.. a .14 • (fJ•s.ir •. i•t ••••••t, • • oJ c.,.•5 'XXV f';'1,:/•;1.'1. hic:17;Z) ORDINANCE NO. 1921 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON, REVOKING AND ELIMINATING PARAGRAPHS (3) (a) and (b) OF SECTION 4-725 OF TITLE IV (BUILDING REGULATIONS) OF ORDINANCE NO. 1628 ENTITLED "CODE OF GENERAL ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF RENTON" BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF RENTON AS FOL7.:;IS: SECTION I : Existing paragraphs (3) (a) and (b) of Section 4-725 of TITLE IV (BUILDING REGULATIONS) of "Code of General Oidinances of the City of Renton" reading as follows: (3) Any ordinance granting and providing such change in use district boundaries or reclassification of property, after petition therefore by the property owner or owners as hereinabove provided, shall remain effective for a period of one (1) year from the effect- ive date of such ordinance, unless the property owner or any one of the owners originally petitioning, or their successors in interest, as the case may be, have commenced a change of use during said one (1) year period. If no change of use has been commenced within said time, the ordinance granting such change in use district boundaries or reclassification shall be null and void, in which case the use and classification in existence immediately prior to the filing of said petition shall become effective again as to such property. The term "commenced a change of use" means (a) The physical alteration requiring a building permit; or (b) Substantial evidence of occupancy, operation, usage or con- duct based on such reclassification. However, the owner or owners of property so rezoned or reclassified may petition the Planning Com- mission, at least thirty (30) days prior to the expiration of said one (?) year period, for an extension of such time limit. Such' petition must be submitted in writing stating the specific reason or reasons for such request. The Planning Commission may thereupon, if it specifically finds proper cause to exist, extend such period up to but not to exceed twelve (12) months , and any such extension shall be subject to final approval by the City Council. be and the same are hereby repealed and cancelled in all respects. SECTION II: All other parts and provisions of said Section not in- consistent with the foregoing shall remain in full force and effect. SECTION III : This Ordinance shall be in full force and effect from and after its passage, approval and legal publication. PASSED BY THE CITY COUNCIL this 21st day of November, 1961. /s/ Helmie Nelson Helmie Nelson, City Clerk APPROVED BY THE MAYOR this 21st day of November, 1961. /s/ Frank Aliment Frank Aliment-Mayor APPROVED AS TO FORM: /s1 Gerard M. Shellan DATE OF PUBLICATION: November 29, 1961 Gerard M. Shellan, City Attorney f [( • � n 1 SE. IOSTH ST. • • • • • a VI 4O. I4 A C. i S.E. II 0 Tl-1 ST. • • • • • • . •• • • • • • • • •_41._0_. • • • • • • • • • • • • • • o • • • • • • • • • 4 •., - • • • e • • e • • • • • 4 • • o • • • • • • • • • 4 • • • • • • • • e • • • 4 • • • • • • o . • • • • • • 4 • • • • • • ORDINANCE #1759 •°•°•°•••.• • • • • • • • 4 • • • • • • • • e • • • 4 DATED 5/12/59 •° •• •° •• •••° —• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •L••. • • • • • • • •• •• • • • • • • • • •• • • 4 °•° R-1To R-3 ° ° ° ° ° ° e e e • e • • o • • • • 4 •• • • • • • • • • • • • 4/1 REVERTED TO R-1 � •�'•` °• • •` I DATED 5/12/60 --- ' . - .--- - -... • • • . • - • Y • 1 tom • • . f v • 1 SE. 108TH ST. .• `'_ :. • .:..:: . .. • .i.•••.:.:i....:?;;!...i,...::::'::::,..';•..!::.:.....ii:..,.......-..?::•...,..i..:.-..•••••••••:;•ii...•::••,:.•:!:...::::::: ::•;•.::::••••••!::: ::...i::::.:::::;:i.:::;:,...:..:......:1.,........::::...:•::::•.;•••:,••••• ......:„. . . . . ,. .:.• :.. . ..„:..::....i...,.:......... T :• 'oo0 0 0 0 o o' o 0 0e o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 • O O O O O O O O O O .. ."." ..."•••••.• • O O O O O O O O O O O 4�• .:.:.:0 O O O O O 0 '� • O O 0 0 O ° O O • O A L• O 4 o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 i 0'�I i. o 0 �^o o e o 0 0 .�0 0 O 0 O 0 O O ^_ . :.:? 0 0 0 0 0 O 0 1,.„ ° O O O O O 0 O O O O 0 0 O O O • e o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o e o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 k • :. o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0, 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 't N 57 0p°p00p90T9040A'� ORDINANCE #1 7 DATED10/25/56 - 1 E].. : S1ToR-1 r. . 0 0 0 t < .... °p°p S-1 TO R-3 . OF R4,4 4, �� z THE CITY OF. RENTON MUNICIPAL BUILDING 200 MILL AVE. SO. RENTON,WASH. 98055 o NIL BARBARA Y. SHINPOCH, MAYOR • DELORES A. MEAD 9-0 to. CITY CLERK • (206) 235-2500 O��TEC SEP1°It P April 7, 1982 CERTIFICATION TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN: The attached copies of all record documents, files, maps and other material relating to the zoning and rezone of that parcel of property owned by Durwood E. Blood are hereby provided pursuant to Superior Court of Washington Order No. 863212 Subpoena Duces Tecum. Hazel Chenaur Rezone 436-67 (2 files) Durwood Blood Special Permit 089-80 Concerned Citizens represented by James E. Eeckhoudt (Durwood Blood Rezone) ECF 001-81 Durwood Blood Rezone 001-81 STATE OF WASHINGTON) )SS. COUNTY OF KING ) I, DELORES A. MEAD, duly appointed, qualified and acting City Clerk of and for the City of Renton, King County, Washington do hereby Certify that the attached are true and correct copies as appearing in the public records on file in the office of the City Clerk of the City of Renton. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and the official seal of the City of Renton, Washington, this 7th day of April 1982. Delores A. Mead, Cit Clerk KAMERON C. CAYL.t ATTORNEY AT LAW P.O.. BOX 798 ( 311 MORPIS AVE.SOUTH RENTON,WASHINGTON 98055 (2061 255O603 Concerning the enclosed subpoena, our experience indicates that there are often delays in a pending lawsuit. Rather than have a witness appear and wait for hours or perhaps days to testify, we believe that it is better for the witness to be kept "on call. " If you will fill out the information at the bottom of this letter and return it to us before the above noted trial date, we will contact you by telephone when we have reached the point in the trial for testimony. We will do our best to avoid any unnecessary appearances on your part and try to give you as much notice as possible as to when you will be called to the witness stand. If you do not desire to remain on an "on call" basis, we will have no alternative but to require that you appear on the morning set for trial and have you wait until called as a witness. Very truly yours, KAMERON C. CAYCE KCC:ch I agree to remain "on call" and can be reached at the following telephones and addresses: Day Night (Telephone) (Telephone) • (Address) (Address) MC Civil C12 (772) Rolm- --~-lion Rights .-- çHAJ R .er. d b, Datt, Journ; Comm.rc. aol (Receipt of Copy) (Date Flied by Clerk) SUPERIOR COURT OF WASHINGTON FOR KING COUNTY DURWOOD BLOOD, et ux , Plaintiff, NO. 863212 vs. HAZEL CHENAUR, SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM Defendant. THE STATE OF WASHINGTON, TO: C.I.T.Y...OF....RE.N.TQN...AND...DAUID...CLEMENS.,...Acting Plan' Director You are hereby commanded to be and appear at the Superior Court of the State of Washington, King. County, in the Courtroom of -Fudge( ..P.residin.g...J.udge..., Dept. NoE9 4 2 , in the County Courthouse, in Seattle, at ..9400 o'clock in the .am...cm= of the .7.th... day of ..Ap.r.i1 , A. D. 19..82then and there to give evidence in a certain cause wherein .DURW.O.OD...BLQQD , Plaintiff and HA Z L, CHENAUR , Defendant and you are further directed and commanded to bring with.you the following papers and documents now in your possession or under your control: All records,. documents, files , maps and other material relating .to the zoning and rezone of that parcel of property currently owned by Durwood E . Blood , legally described in the attached Quit Claim Deed . This request includes information relating to the rezone from R-1 to R-2 prior to June, 1970 , and the modification of the City maps following the decision of Stan- ley Soderland on June 23, 1970 in King County Cause No. 704684 , wherein said rezone was set aside.. Specifically, plaintiff seeks information as to when the maps available to the public were changed to reflect the zoning from R-2 to R-1 per said court order. • and to remain in attendance upon said Court until discharged, and HEREIN FAIL NOT AT YOUR PERIL. Witness my hand this ...2.nd. day of .April , 1952 KAMERON C. CAYCE Alai tiff Attorney.... of Record for CAYCE...&...E.LECI{ P.O. Box 798, Renton, WA, 98057 255-0603 Phone OF R�� 4, 40 © THE CITY OF RENTON MUNICIPAL BUILDING 200 MILL AVE. SO. RENTON,WASH.98055 - oOM= BARBARA Y. SHINPOCH, MAYOR • PLANNING DEPARTMENT 90 235- 2550 O9.TF0 sEP.1 . MEMORANDUM February 24 , 1981 TO: Mr. Fred Kaufman, Hearing Examiner FROM:) Roger J. Blaylock, Associate Planner RE: " Durwood E. Blood Appeal of Environmental Determination Please find attached the complete file of the rezone request for Mr. Durwood E. Blood, R-001-81 . This includes all of the applications and the departmental comments along with the Environmental Review Committee' s environmental determination. In addition please reference the original rezone file for supplemental background information of Hazel W. Chenaur, R-436-67. r F R O . v \% 0v1,,l('14: op rn [p) ('ITY AT 1'()RN EV • I:I,;NTON, WASH]N“TON o POST OFFICE BOX 626, 100 2ND STREET BUR DING, RENTON, WASHINGTON 98055 ALPINE 5.8678 a S ` GERARD M. SHELLAN, CITY ATTORNEY . 2Si ,,� - JOHN K. PAIN, JR., ASSISTANT C,I1 Al TORNEY '''r CAc-,,A', 0. June 26 , 1970 Mr. Gordon Erickson Planning t.0 t cctor City Hall Renton, Washington Re : Jones vs City of Renton and Chenaur . King County Cause No. 704684 Dear Mr. Erickson: Enclosed herewith you will find copy of Judgment in the reference case entered June 23 , - 1970 , concerning the real • property owned by Hazel Chenaur as described on page 2 thereof. The Judgment was entered by agreement of this office on behalf of the City and counsel for plaintiffs. Defendant Chenaur was defaulted out of the suit by reason of her failure to timely answer the Complaint of Plaintiffs . You will note that by terms of paragraph 3 of the Judgment , • on page thereof , the City is enjoined from issuing a building permit for other than a R-1 single residence on the Chenaur property as described in the Judgment until procedures as set forth in the Renton City Code are followed , either for a rezoning , variance , or special permit. The enirinder of the City in this instance as recited above is deemed proper by reason of the fact that proper notice was not r'i ven of the appeal by Hazel Chenaur of the original . _enia;i by the City Planning Commissi of the application for .t-1 R-3 rezone , nor was prior n tice % en of ,_he City Counci l' s reconsideration of the appea . at. w 'i time the City Council granted a rezone with an R- c gs�i, icaton. • ),E , tr ours , l I , r l �Jr. /' ,.- ` JEKP:ds ``� t/ ( . ' i -: - `_ cc : M�.vor , Pres . City Clerk 4` f A N • 1 sworn testimony on behalf of the plaintiffs, being fully advised 2 in the premises, and :laving heretofore made and entered herein 3 its Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, Now, Therefore, 4 IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED by the court 5 as follows: 6 1. DEFENDANT CHENAUR PERMANENTLY ENJOINED : That I 7 defendant HAZEL W. CHENAUR be and she is hereby permanently 8 enjoined from using the real property, situated in King County, 9 Washington, and more particularly described as: 1U West 130 feet of the North Half. of Tract 2111 , C . D. Hillman's Lake Washington Garden of Eden, 11 Division No. 4, according to plat recorded in Volume 11 of Plats, page 82, King County, Washington, 12 EXCEPT the North 30 feet and the West 30 feet of said Tract 2111 conveyed to the City of Renton by deed 13 recorded under Auditor's File No. 5383178 14 for any other purpose than tat provided for in the Renton City Code 15 under the R-1 classification. 16 2 . JUDGMENT FOR COSTS AGAINST DEFENDANT CHENAUR : That 17 plaintiffs be and they are hereby awarded judgment against the 18 defendant HAZEL W. CHENAUR for their costs and disbursements herein 19 to be taxed. 20 3 . DEFENDANT CITY ENJOINED : That the defendant CITY 21 OF RENTON be and it is hereby permanentl enjoined from iss ing a 22 building permit for other than R-1 single residence on the above 23 i described property of defendant Hazel W. Chenaur until the proper 24 procedures as set forth in the Renton City Code are followed, 25 either for a rezoning, variance, or special permit. 26 DONE IN OPEN COURT this ;? 5 day of .�i:> .= , 1970. 27 28 Presented by: 29 /5 30 'ems:�.. ,r�- ll.:il.4::i —1-r 1 11��J.t'l`.S=U 7' App'owed f,f r Ea'rry and Notice of c ROBERTS 8 ANDERSON Pr `t i:ation G;4ved: 31 ' Attorneys for Plaintiffs r, } t,?jam;/ (' •/7.7 0 32 , of SgELLAN, PAIN, STONE 5 SWANSON, Attor- neys for YSDefe ndantiosERTs & ANDERSON City of Renton ATTORNEYSATLAW I11 WILLI AMS AVENUE SOUTH P.O.BOX 404 RENTON,WASHINGTON 98055 JUDGMENT - 2 9A 8-1880 a - 7rov PrCHYLD 1 I /U• 2 197C 3 4 5 6 • 7 i IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF KING 8 ' 9 ROBERT E. JONES and DIANA JONES , ) j his wife ; ROGER A. PETERSON and PATRICIA ) 10 I PETERSON , his wife ; GARTH S . POWELL ANd ) BILLIE POWELL, I his wife ; RONALD R. WYLET and ) 11 SHERRIE WYLET , his wife ; RAYMOND H. ALEXANDER) NO. 704684 and DORIS ALEXANDER, his wife ; PETER A. R. ) • 12 FURZER and IRENE FURZER, his wife ; EUGENE ) HASTINGS and JEAN HASTINGS, his wife ; ) 13 JAMES E . HORNBERG and BARBARA HORNBERG , his ) wife ; GARY B. JUST and RUTH JUST, his wife ; ) 14 and' GEORGE RUSK and ANDREA RUSK, his wife , ) , 15 Plaintiffs , ) ) JUDGMENT 16 vs . ) • • ) 17 . CITY OF RENTON, a municipal corporation; ) and HAZEL W. CHENAUR, 'a widow, ) 18 ) Defendants . ) 19 ) 20 THIS MATTER having come on duly and regularly for 21 hearing on this :date .before .the, under Signed• judge of the above 22 entitled court , plaintiffs appearing by e ,�P j' Zr . �Oiu.aS 23 24 , ore of said plaintiffs , and being repre- sented by Michael H. Williamson, of Roberts E Anderson, their 25 attorneys of record, the defendant City of Renton not appear- 26 ing personally or being represented by its attorney of record, • 27 John K. Pain, but said attorney for defendant City of Renton 28 having approved the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and 29 Decree herein, and defendant Hazel W. .enaur not appearing in 30 person or by counsel, her default having been duly and 31 32 ' regularly taken and entered herein, the court. having heard I JUDC� 'LNT. - 1 • ROBERTS & ANDERSON ATTORNEYS AT LAW HI WILLIAMS AVENUE SOUTH•P.O.BOX 44 RENTON,WASHINGTON 98055 BA 8-1880 1 MEMORANDUM TO: Files ` DATE: July 9 , 1970 FROM: Planning Director SUBJECT : Hazel Chenaur Special Permit Application Telephone Conversation with John K. Pain, Jr. , Assistant City Attorney In accordance with telephone conversation between Planning Director and the Assistant City. Attorney on above date, it was indicated that the matter- of rezoning and the special permit application of Hazel Chenaur was essentially closed, and the property in question remains in an R-1 zoning classification. The property owner ih question must re-initiate rezone of the property before a special permit for apartments can be considered. MINUTES - RENTON CITY COUNCIL MEETING 2/10/69 CORRESPONDENCE AND CURRENT BUSINESS : (Cont . ) The :,' ty Clerk reported that bids had been opened on 2/4/69 at 2 : 00 p .m for del,olition of the old city hall building in Cedar River Park. T bids we received from $4 , 000 . 00 to $39 , 500 . 00 . (See tabulation• shreet: . attached) MOVED BY BAREI , SECONDED BY SCHELLERT , to authorize t Fire Department `.o burn the old city hall building to the ground . arei felt the Cit . could save the money by having the city forces urn the building which was isolated from any buildings and the win r weather adding to the sa_ ety factor . Inquiries followed regardi , air pollution laws and possibil ,.ty of legality under controlled burni, g permit and the cost to remove burn--A debris . MOVED BY MORRIS , SECONp- D BY SCHELLERT , the -motion and remar be referred to the Property _ mmittee for report . The referral motion to t and discussion on the mo • on to burn ensued , .it being urged that the low bid be accepted in lieu -' hereof . Dissenting voice vote brought proper 'i_equest for roll cal which was taken as follows : Aye : Grant, Shane , Schelle -t and Barei , No :,, Perry , Morris , Delaurenti , Trimxi, Garrett , Edwards , Maxi, and Bruce . he motion failed 8 . to 4 . Motions were proposed to award the bid to parent low bidderith adequate performance bond to be required ,..o insure proper compliance and , after discussion regarding bid requirements ,, o recess for ten minutes which failed , and to refer the bids to Co m ' tee , and subsequently another motion to award to low bidder with a erral to the Property Committee to draw up the contract and secure pe.'for :.nce bond and carry out the legal requirements , MORRIS MOVED , SEC,'' D BY G ° NT , to substitute the motion that the 'bids be referred 'to th Propert ,ommittee with power to act . Dissenting voice vote brought equest for ro]l call which.:,:resulted as follows : Aye : Morris , Sche ert , Edwards , B uce , Grant end Barei . No : Perry, Delaurenti , Tr , Garrett , Maxin Ad Shane . Mayor Custer voted aye and the referra_®®motion carried . Letter from Epcon , Inc.. , Norman E . Lee , Lighting Di ' sa.on.,. •reques.ted a meeting to discuss proposed installation of area 1ighw.' ng: Moved. by Barei , seconded by : uce , to refer the. letter to the Co mittee of `the Whole . It was not.-'d the area concerned is Rainier Avenu- and Mayor Custer stated th- matter to be. in regard to light standard , for private operation on street right-of-way which only the Council coule handle . After various recommendations for referral to other Committee the pending motion' carried . Letter fro!: Park Director Coulon , submitted attached letter from H . Bertrand Co . , requesting 21-day extension to contract completion d to on C .AG . 1372-68 , landscaping and planting , Liberty Park grandstand ar-:a . (Febru-ry 12 is contract completion date to be. extended) Moved by Bruce , seco , ed by Barei , to concur in the recommendation of the Park Director . The motion carried . . AUDIENCE COMMENT : Richard Stredicke , 3916-10th Court North , inquired regarding availability of a report concerning the Show Cause Court Order , received .lat week on the Hazel Chenaur property rezone . City Attorney Shellan advised that no Court Order has been entered on the Show Cause but that an early trial date will be set and Mr . Stredicke will be notified . OLD BUSINESS BY COUNCIL : Council President Perry submitted Committee of the Whole Report which was read with Council action taken as follows : Recommended that the proposed Resolution from Cle Elum regarding distribu-. tion of funds to cities be tabled. MOVED BY SCHELLERT , SECONDED BY MAXIN , to concur in the Committee of the Whole recommendation . Carried. Shanr opposed. Barei abstained. Recommended that the City continue using the King County Design Commission service rather than create a Local Design Commission . MOVED BY GARRETT , SECONDED BY EDWARDS , to concur. in the Committee of the Whole recommenda- tion . (Referral request of Richard Stredicke) The motion carried . Recommended regarding U-LID 256 , Kent , the City Clerk direct a letter to Kent inquiring if further action is required. MOVED BY MORRIS , SECONDE:. BY MAXIN , to concur . Carried . -3- I ,% MINUTES - RENTON CITY , _ JNCIL MEETING (Cont . ) 2/3/69 CORRESPONDENCE AND CURRENT BUSINESS Application was read from Bobbie R. Highland requesting that license be granted to operate a coin-type pool table at King ' s Tavern , 207 Wells Avenue South . MOVED BY MORRIS , SECONDED BY EDWARDS , to refer the application to the Police and License Committee with power to act . The motion carried. One.vne,u C Order to Show Cause , Summons & Complaint , was read, filed against the City by Attorneys Roberts & Anderson , through Michael Williamson , on behalf of Robert E . Jones et al , in regard to Hazel W. Chenaur propert zoning and permits . MOVED BY BAREI , SECONDED BY SHANE , to refer the documents to the Legal Department . The motion carried. Letter from Bernard L. Ruppert , Building Director , requested authoriza- tion to attend a Conference on Federal Housing Programs , February 6 and 7 at Corvallis State University , Corvallis , Oregon. MOVED BY MORRIS , AND SECONDED BY SCHELLERT, to grant the request . The motion carried. Letter from Traffic Engineer , Del Bennett , submitted proposed agreements with the Northern Pacific Railway Company and the City concerning the crossings and railroad signals on North Third and Fourth Streets which include costs to be borne by the City through the Urban Arterial Fund which constitute part of the total improvement of the one-way couplet project . It was recommended that the Mayor and City Clerk be authorized to sign the documents and copy to be furnished the Urban Arterial Board by the Engineering Department for payment . MOVED BY SCHELLERT , SECONDED BY MAXIN , to concur. MOVED BY BAREI , SECONDED BY PERRY ,to refer the recommendation to the Street and Alley Committee for report back . The motion carried . Shane opposed, noting the railroad should share costs . Letter from City Engineer Wilson reported in regard to petition for Sanitary Sewer L . I .D. in the vicinity of the Mance Addition , 94th Ave . South., South 173rd and South 174th STreets , that the petition is signed by owners representing 85 . 21% of the front footage abutting the proposed improvement and 89 . 21% of area within the proposed improvement . MOVED BY SCHELLERT , SECONDED BY SHANE , to refer the matter to the Sanitation ' Committee for recommendation . The motion carried . Letter from Don Taylor, President , City Employees Club, requested permission to work Lincoln ' s Birthday, February 12 , 1969 in exchange for December 26 , 1969, the day following Christmas to allow a four day week end for City Employees . MOVED BY GARRETT , SECONDED BY GRANT , to authorize the exchange with referral to the Mayor for administration . Discussion ensued with regard to existing union contract and- City - rAttorney Shellan suggested a letter of concurrence from the Union be secured which Mayor Custer advised he would request. The pending motion carried . REPORTS OF BID CALLS AND RECOMMENDATIONS FOR AWARDS Bids were opened on 1/27/69 at 2 : 00 p.m. in the First Floor Conference Room, Renton Municipal Building , for lighting of the small ballfield in Liberty Park , as budgeted . Letter from the Park Board was read recommending that the low basic bid of Patelco , Inc . in sum of $17 , 351 . 00 be accepted . MOVED BY SCHELLERT , SECONDED BY EDWARDS , to concur in the Park Board recommendation. Discussion ensued regarding lighting program for other areas of the city and costs involved with Liberty Park total development. MOVED BY GRANT, SECONDED BY SHANE , _to refer the bids to . the Committee. of- the Whole . Park budget funds , it was noted, include_F.orward Thrust , .State and Federal Funds for Lake Wn. Beach matching fund projects ,which results in double budgeting , not reflecting actual local expenditures . After some further remarks regarding the Council action at hearing meetings in budgeting the items , Attorney Shellanb notation that the Council does not have jurisdiction over the Park Board ' s action on bid awards once funds have been granted in the budget , and upon inquiry , that control may be exercised through budgetary fund transfers within classes only , the pending motion was voted upon . Dissenting voice vote brought ruling of the chair of negative majority and roll call was requested which was taken as follows : Aye : Trimm, Bruce , Grant, Shane and Barei . No : Perry, Morris , Schellert , Edwards , Maxin and Garrett . The referral motion lost . Vote on the original motion to concur was dis- senting and roll call requested and taken as follows : Aye : Perry , Schellert ,Morris , Garrett, Edwards , Maxin and Trimm. (cont . next: page) Jn • a IA 1/1 CERTIFICATION STATE OF WASHINGTON) ) ss COUNTY OF KING ) I, Helmie W. Nelson, the duly elected, qualified and acting City Clerk of and for the City of Renton, Washington, do hereby certify • that the attached copies are true and correct copies of pages from the Renton City Council Meeting Minutes, to wit: Page 2 of February 5, 1968; Pages 2 and 8 of February 19, 1968; Page 7 of February 26, 1968; and excerpt from Renton City Code of Ordinances Ch I, Sec. 4-725; and Pages 4, 5 and 6 of December 27, 1967, Renton Planning Col-mission Meeting Minutes, appear- ing on file in the records of the Office of the City Clerk in said City. IN WITNESS WHEREOF I hereunto set my hand and the Official Seal of the City of Renton, Washington, this 24th day of January, 1969. ) ,/) /i .; (Seal) Helmie Nelson, City Clerk kahh isC) JAN 27 1969 9 2NiNG DEj • •• • • • Renton Planning Commission • Meeting December 27 , 1967 Minutes Page 4' • is narrow and on a hillside. Teegarden stated he felt -it would be a mistake to allow an apartment building at the end of such a nar- row street . at this time. Forgaard asked when the Transamerica property to the south and west of the subject. property was rezoned to R-3. . The Planning Director replied this was done in 1963 . Transamerica has indicated it does not plan to open access to the Renton Hill area or develop their R-3 area at this. time. Comments from the audience were invited. Mr. Jack Newell stated he is the property owner immediately east of the applicant' s property and is definitely opposed to any multi-family residential develop- ment ..in the area; that he feels the area is an established single family residential zone. • As there were no further comments , it was moved by Stredicke, seconded by Forgaard, that the hearing be closed. Motion carried unanimously. • • ACTION: • Moved by Teegarden, seconded by Stredicke, that the rezone applica- tion of Albert L. Duncalf for R-3 zoning be denied. Motion carried unanimously. The Chairman advised the applicant of his right to appeal the decision of the Planning Commission by written notice to the City Council within ten days . • (c Chenaurs Hazel W. An- 1 . No. R-436-67 rezone from R-1 to • R 3;__ property located west side of 116th Ave. S.E. between S.E. 0th and 112th Sts. (westerly of McKnight Jr. High School) The rezone application was described by the Chairman; and the loca- tion of the property was pointed out by the- Planning Director on the zoning map. The Planning Director indicated that access to the property was via an undeveloped right of way. Slides of the property were shown. Photographs of the property submitted by the applicant were passed around among the Commissioners . The • Planning Director stated that in 1956 the property was zoned R-3 , but as it was not developed it reverted back to R--1 status under a reversion ordinance in effect at that time. The Chairman read a petition against the rezone submitted by property owners in the area and bearing 20 signatures. • The Planning Director stated that the existing Comprehensive Plan indicates this area as low to medium density multi-family resi- dential , but that the revised Comprehensive Plan now under study by the City Council cuts this area back to single family residential • Continents from the audience were invited. Mr. Roger Peterson, 10514 - 113th Ave. S.E. , owner of property westerly of subject property, voiced his objections to the proposed rezone. Mr. George Rusk, 11029 - 116th Ave. S.E. , stated he owns a house north of 110th -which. he had purchased with the stipulation the area was R-1 , but had found out later that a portion of land nearby was zoned R--3 upon which two apartment houses have been constructed. • • • • • Renton Planning Commission • • Meeting December 27 , 1967 Minutes Page .5 Mr. Rusk stated he was opposed to further apartment development in the area. Mr. Robert Hall of Seattle identified himself as attorney for the • applicant, Mrs. Chenaur, and gave a brief history of the property ii in question. He stated that his client is asking for the zoning which had previously •been granted and which had been lost due to the reversion ordinance then in effect which has sinbe been re- pealed.. He discussed the undeveloped access road about which there appeared to be some title cloud. Mr. Hall stated this undeveloped ' access according to all information he has been able to get belongs to the City of Renton. He stated the rezone is a logical one; would have no effect on the single family residential . area known as Hill-- crest .Lane directly to the west as those houses are below his client' s property and face away from it. He stated further that cost of development of the property makes it economically unfeasible for anything but multi-family residential use. Mr. Bob Harris , 10.843 - 116th Ave. S .E. spoke in opposition to the • rezone due to the immediate proximity of $20 , 000 to $40 , 000 homes . Mr. Jerome Stephenson, 11430 S .E. 112th St. , .asked how sewer lines • could be connected to the property. The Planning Director displayed a sanitary sewer and water lines map for the area; and stated that • due to the -elevation the developer could get sewers only through the west side of the property by obtaining easements through ad- jacent properties. He stated further that there are sewer lines along 116th Ave. S .E. but they could not go easterly due to the ] elevation unless some sort of pumping system was installed. Mr. Clayton Chenaur discussed the history of the property; the fact that he thought he had the proper zoning, being unaware of the reversion to R-1 ; the access problem, the development of sewers , the cost of development being too high for other than multi--family use. He stated that the development would be adequately served by sewers and would be screened to protect adjacent residences . He urged the Commission to grant the rezone. • Stredicke stated that the area, notwithstanding the two existing apartments , has been developed for single family use and he would not be in favor of rezoning for multiple use'. Messrs. Stephenson, Peterson, Rusk and Harris , previously acknowledged, spoke again in' protest against the rezone, as well as Mr. Ronald Wy- let of 11020 - 115th Ave. S.E. Mr. Robert Hall and Mr . Clayton Chenaur spoke again on behalf of the rezone request. There being no further comments , . it was moved by Stredicke, seconded by Teegarden, that the hearing be closed., Motion carried unanimously. )/'\ . ACTION: Li _ Moved by Stredicke, seconded by Brower, that the application of • Hazel W. Chenaur for rezone from R-1 to R-3 be denied. • Motion carried unanimously. Further moved by. Stredicke, seconded by Teegarden, that a communica- tion be sent to the City Council recommending. that the hi.ahest use of this property be R--1 as presently zoned. Motion carried unani- mously. • • Renton Planning Commission • • Meeting December 27, 1967 Minutes Page. 6 The Chairman advised the applicant' s attorney of` her right of __ ' appeal of the Planning Commission decision by letter to the City Council within ten days. Mr. Hall stated he understood the .apeal . rights of his client. - 5. ADMINISTRATIVE MATTERS • REFERRAL FROM RENTON BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT . ) Albert Balch and Garden Park, Inc. , request for variance '- - .l f .m height limitation. The 4. airman stated that the Board of Adjustment had referred t e above , ariance application to the Planning Commission and ref -red the Co 'issioners to copies of Board of Adjustment Minutes a well as copy • letter from the FAA relative to the matter; suc copies in each Co' missioner' s folder. ACTION: Moved by Brower_ seconded by Racanello, that this m. ter be con- sidered at the n:'xt .Administrative Meeting of the :enton Planning Commission in ord to give the Commission time t study the • material submitted. Motion carried unanimously. • STREET NAME PROBLEM • - (b) The Chairman read letter from Fire ief M. C. Walls conce_rn- ing duplication of stree name in Thunder Hill #2 , parcel #26 . The Planning Director stated . at this part ' ular street (Thomas Lane) is privately owned and the ity has no control over it. He sug- gested the Commission might ,ish to refer the matter to the Board of Public Works for their rev' ew. ACTION: • Moved by Stredicke, seconded b R`vanello, that a copy of Fire Chief Walls' letter be sent to the yor ' office and to the Board of Public Works for their actior . Moti.° carried unanimously. APPOINTMENT OF NEW PLANNI COMMISSION \EMBER (c) The Chairman read ropy of a letter f orn Mayor D. W.. Custer to • the City Council appo ° 'sting Mr. Tony Mola ..s a member of the Renton Planning Commission ►o fill the vacancy crea, ed by .the resignation of Mr. Stanley Ston . and requesting concurrene of the Council in this appointment. RESIGNATION OF s ANNING COMMISSION MEMBER (d) Mr. Robe, t Brower announced that regretfully his would be his last meetin. 'with the Planning Commission as he had\.een recalled to active : ty with the United States Navy, and stat it. had been a privile,r to serve On the Commission. - / APPROVAL SITE P (Request for Information) • (e) Aedicke asked if site plans had been submitted for , he approval of the Planning Commission for the church located •.•t 7th a : M. The Planning Director replied that this church had \, omitted eir site plans as well as a variance request for parking a had received approval of the site plans on March 28 , 1962 . He st ed Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting 4-1-68 COMMUNICATIONS: (Cont.) Letter from F. A. Storey, 11007 - 109th Ave. S.E. noted agreement at the March 12th meeting of the Legislative Joint Committee on Highways held in the Renton City Council. Chambers that the State had an obligation to help provide a Pedestrian Walkway at the North Ren n Interchange Clover Leaf and it was requested that a meeting be set with proper City ficials to further this goal. Moved by Delaurenti, sec°•. c"ry Perry, to refer this comm 'cation to the Street and Alley Committee and Cj. Engineer to report back. Carried. • ,"° Letter from Peter V. Gull Secretary, Newport Hill -ewer District reported pending annexation to Newport Hills ler District of an Tea north of and adjacent to the Renton City Limits and it appear' g the annex . ion will be completed and the District requested to serve the areas this s er,� plan had been submitted to City Engineer Wilson wherein service utilizes the p ro-Rped Metro May Creek Trunk. A portion of the planned 15 or 13 inch line will li; n theNeity limits from 108th S.E. and S.E. 94th St. intersection to 110th S.E. and ath Street in section and:will be capable of serving areas both in the City and the area north of May eek. Permission was requested to construct and maintain t necessary lines, the Distri t desiring to cooperate with the City to the end that he serve::NI,basin be properly serve b these lines regardless of political divisio , the line to be made available for local us eithin the City upon proper contrib ion to the cost by the users. Moved by Perry, secondee<by Morris, to refer the vellilest to the Sanitation Committee and the City Engineer to repo4I back. The motion carried. Letter from City Engineer Wilson reported regarding the Hazel Chenaur petition for right-of-way vacation of 30 ft. street adjoining the west i of the North of Tract 211 of the Ca D. Hillmans Lake Washington Garden of Eden Division No. 4., that the sub- division represents 507 of the total frontage abutting said right of way failing to meet the _minimum requirement of signatures which is 2/3 of the property ownerships 41 abutting. Moved by Garrett, seconded by Schellert, that the petitioner be notified that the petition as submitted is not valid. Carried. Claim was read from Marvin L. Sherertz for damage to automobile on March 25th when oncoming car forced his auto into unfilled shoulder which was incompleted due to sidewalk and curbing 'on under construction. In coming off the shoulder vehicle struck unbarricaded water shut o cilit ierg-thenreniTTE-1767-71777790.786 is claimed. Location of incident a . 0 bloc: 001-�B-roson Way North. Moved by Delaurenti, and se nded-b rry, to refer the Claim to the City Atta- e , and Insurance Agency. Carried. 0001 Letter from Cl yngineer Wilson reported regarding Christopherson et all let-er of intent to annex pro erty in vicinity of 103th Ave. S.E. and S.E. 164th St et, to Renton, advised that ' gnatures thereon represent 91.54% of the assesse valuation of the subject property • ich area contains approximately 6.71 aj�r0 with a total assessed valuation of Annexation of this property would create a more uniform city limits line in tillarea. Moved by Schellert,�,sce onded by Maxin, that April 8th be set for preliminary eting with property o�• ers concerned and that the owners be notified. Shane questions annexation of " additional property noting services needed by present areas. It 1• noted that the process of law must be enacted and when requested the City must t ce ac-n accordingly granting the property owner the right provided by law. The motion c ried. Letter from Park Director Coulon advise hat since 11 bids received on the landscaping of the South 2nd Street Traffic Islas were in exce of the amount authorized by the Council, it was recommended that al¢ bids be rejected an that the landscape plan be redesigned to meet the budget a rOcation. Moved by Perry, econded by Grant, to concur in the recommendation. Intent of rejecting and modifying was nfirmed and Grant inquired if the redesign would requore additional cost. Mayor Custer adv ,, ed it would not, but that it would be a ques 'on of deleting part of the sprinkling syst and some of the cement and rock to me the $9,000.00 sum. Grant had withdrawn his s Qnd and Barei offered second to toe pending motion. Shane objected and Grant noted the. discussions heretofore regarding elimination of sources of revenue and things that hay to be cut out to balance and stated forthe record at this time he would like to see the ' slands in front of , e high school retained as presently landscaped. Question was calls for on the pe •ing motion and dissenting verbal vote resulted in two requests for roll -all which r 'ulted as follows: Aye: Garrett, Morris, Schellert, Delaurenti, 'Perry, Trimn 4 I'I Maxin nd Bruce. No: Grant, Shane and Barei. The motion carried. Discussion ensued I reg ding the vote and school districts participation at one time and change of heart by reason of hazard involved in maintenance and fact that water is not available. -2- Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting 3/18/68 COMMUNICATIONS: .. Letter from City Engineer Wilson submitted and recommended for payment, Progress Estimate due L. R. Gaudio Well Drilling Co. in sum of $11,936.83, C.AG. 1248-67, Well No. 8, Cedar River Park. Moved by Morris, seconded by Barei, to concur with referral to the Auditing and Accounting Committee with power to act. Carried. Letter from City Clerk Nelson reported the necessity, pending receipt of tax money, to borrow funds for operating the following 'City Funds, Loan from City H�1.1 Con- struction Fund until June 30, 1968 @ 3% interest was recommended, fo istribution as follows: Cur- . 4t Fund - $300,000.00; City Street Fund, $140,0 .00 and Library Fund, $ 70,000.00. .•eferral to the Law and Ordinance Committer for required Resolution was also recommended. Moved by Morris, second doby Schellert, to concur. The motion carried. Application was read from Me ,ose Tavern owner, ,Jam�'. Natucci, requesting that Regal Amusement Co. be granted requi - d license to o� "rate a coin-type pool table at said business located at 819 Walla Wa. ,a Avenue. by Morris, seconded by Schellert to refer the application to the Po`r'ce andl®®License Committee with power to act. The motion carried. Letter from City Engineer Wilson eparte regarding Honeycreek Park Sanitary Sewer L.I.D. Petition, that the docu t contain signatures representing 54.42% of the frontage in the proposed se ce area and du to irregularities in signing, such as wives signing for husbandst was recommended hat the Council adopt a Resolution as necessary to createV '57 e Sanitary Sewer L.I.D. oved by Edwards, seconded by Maxin, to refer the mar to the Law and Ordinance ommittee for proper Resolution. The motion carried. Letter from Mrs osalie Evans requested No-Fee Permit to a •ota the use of the Volkswagen bu' ding by St. Luke's Episcopal Church for a rummage sale,May 9, 10 and llth. Move' 'y Delaurenti, seconded by Bruce, to grant the request. City Clerk Nelson re. rted that Mr. Fletcher had decided not to lease the building for paint storage rending repair of his fire damaged store building. The motion carried. Letter from M. C. Walls, Fire Chief, requested to call for bids on painting interior of both fire stations and exterior of the main station. April 8th was recommended for bid opening date. Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Schellert, to concur.Carried. Letter from Attorneys Murray, Dunham & Waitt, Attorneys at Law, petitioned the:'City, on behalf of Mrs. Hazel Chenaur, for the vacation of 30 ft. right-of-way strip to the East of 115th Avenue S.E., abutting Mrs. Chenaur's property. $100.00 filing fee was paid as required. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Bruce, to refer the petition to the City Engineer to verify the signatures and report back. Carried. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to refer the matter to the Property Committee.Carried. -tier from City Attorney Shellan submitted copy of letter received from the Boeing Company regarding a secondary water supply for the Renton Plant. It was suggested that Council approve same as a matter of record, the City Engineer having given his signatory approval heretofore. Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Schellert, to refer the matter to the Committee of the Whole. Carried. _� Letter from Mr. T. Nelson, Masseur whose business is located at 118 P Avenue in Renton, submitted ` -. observations and objections to proposed Or ce regulating Massage Parlors, Healt alons and Public Bath Houses. Mr. son felt the restrictions were not reasonable for t`'' _ City and that the fees wer ut of line compared to the Business License Fees for other -type of businesses. e felt the wording was detrimental to the subject businesses and tha- he local po ce under existing statutes handle quite efficiently any problems which -., ha, resulted in complaint, and the scope of requirements being such that an attorn- ' would not advise his client to sign. It was suggested that the Council meet wi -!' :artie to be affected prior to enactment of such prohibitive Ordinances. Moved b orris, secon -d by Delaurenti to refer this letter to the Law and Ordinance Commi e for recommendatio ., The motion carried. Committee Chairman.Trimm noted th every Councilman had recei' -.d a copy of this Ordinance and it .was: being held f ' ..review until after March 28th an: meeting is to be held then on this at 7:30 . . Parties concerned have been notified, -. 4 anyone interested is invited to end. Le from Chester Biesen, Executive Secretary, Association of Washington Cities, announced that the Seattle Chamber of Commerce is holding an "Association Day" luncheon on Friday, April 5th. Invitation was extended to attend. -2- Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting (Cont.) 3-18-68 ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS: Law and ' ante Committee Chairman, Trimm, submitted proposed Res of tion of the City of Renton app •ri in $3,450.00 from excess revenue -the Library Fund unto Account 1610/606 Capita achinery art-'- ment, Library, for the purchase of a Van for transportation serviceto h�L-i ir-axy, Moved by Schellert, seconded by Delaurenti, to adopt Re ion No. 1524 as read. Carr Councilman Trimm prese a proposed Resolution of the City of Renton authorizing transfer of $20 . 0 from Cumulative Reserve Fund 1894 unto City Hall Construction Fund #2810, ccount 605, for lawn sprinkling system and lighting within the civic center site. Moved by Trimm, seconded Barei. to adopt Resolution No. 1525 as read. The motion cad 3 ® 8 4 8 T e Committee 'resented a 24.44qpg awn e of the City of Renton changing the zoning classification o certain ro erties wit in t e Ci from Residence Sin le Famil Dis- trict R-1 to Resi ence District R-2 whit was rea y the Clerk. Hazel Chenaur property Moved by Trim, seconded by Grant, to place the document on second and-Tinal reading. Carried. After final reading, roll call vote was taken onmotion by Dela-' urenti,. second by Barei, to adopt as read. The vote resulted in unanimous ayes carrying the motion and adopting Ordinance 2387 as read. Proposed Ordinance was read changing the zoning classification of the Beanblossom and Roe property within the City from Residential District (R-2) to "Apartment Houses and Multip .- Dwellings (R-4) . Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Maxin, to place the docu- ment on - -cond and final reading. Carried. After final reading, it was oved by Delaurenti, seconded by Schellert, to adopt Ordinance No. 2388 as read Roll call vote resulte• 'n all ayes and the motion carried. Proposed Ordinanc- was read changing the zoning classification . ' the Dean Singer property within the ity from Residential District (R-2) to Residential District (R-3) . Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Barei, to place the documea on second and final reading. Carried. Afte• the final reading, it was moves toy Delaurenti, seconded by Maxin, to adopt Ordinance o . 2389 as read. Carried, Pon unanimous aye roll call vote. Proposed Ordinancewas read chazclassificationp e wing the zoning of the Lorensen-Jensen properties on 132nd Ave. S.E. fro General Classification District (G) to Residential District (R-3) . Moved by Delaurenti seconde)4y Grant, to place the document on its second and final reading. Carried. 'ved tf Morris, seconded by Bruce, after final reading, to adopt Ordinance No. 2390 as ••ad. Roll call vote resulted in all ayes and the motion carried. Proposed Ordinance was read changin:r'the zonin: classification of the Harris property on 132nd Ave. S.E., within the q_1 y of Renton, ``,.om Suburban Residence District (S-1) to Single Residence District (•4). Moved by Delau•`; ti, seconded by Barei, to place the document on second and f' o.l reading. Carried. ' ter final reading, it was moved by Morris, seconded by Bare;, to adopt Ordinance No. 23° as read. Carried upon unanimous aye roll call vpfe. Proposed Ordinance was read amending Section 10-705 of Title ` -, (Traffic), of Ordinance No. 1628 entitled "C.ode of General Ordinances of the City of Re on", relating to Municipal Parking of #3. (Limiting to 2 hour parking rather than .4 hr. parking use) Moved by Trimm, conded by Maxin, to place the document on second aad final reading. Carried. After he final reading, it was moved by Morris, seconded b -.Barei, to adopt Ordinan a No. 2392 as read. Carried upon unanimous roll call vot (Publication to be withh d until new meter heads have been installed) Proposed rdinance of the City,granting Pacific Coast RR Co. a franchise for -stablish- ment, m intenance and operation of its North Renton Main Line track in, upon a'‘,d along House Way, and fixing the location, terms and conditions of such franchise, wa placed on f rst reading. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Shane, to refer the document to the Law and Ordinance Committee to hold 30:.days following publication as required by lava. Carried. Moved by Garrett, seconded by Shane that the Garbage and Refuse Collection Ordinance be placed on second and final reading. Revisions were outlined, and the motion carried. After final reading, it was moved by Trimm, seconded by Shane to adopt Ordinance No. 2393 as read. Roll call vote resulted in all ayes and the motion carried. -6- :''' '.=":',..''''.:." ''''''''' '''.• (-: ';'':1`-........'''.:' .'2-1-iii:e.....:'-.•. .':i '...?:Z:;:" ';,;.':'-! ''''':..,:i.':: ::.. .,.''..':-..,:.:.:,..,',';;.:,',.:•,'?:,';,.-., -.„ ',..:.:. •'...,.,..-:::-,:;.,,..':',::„.;,,.: '''':;. -,• ''''- ,' . . - ' .•.• • MTJR3AY,' �?'�.J'LTITAM '& WAITT'.. WAl 4TTG�RNEYS.AT LAW R E:DUNHAM, _ •I r' { ",SUITE.AI9 STGURbTIES BUILDI. - _R�B ERT.K.WAI T,T" - ,•t' _, NG •SEATTLE• _ SNAS�INC3T0 �M r. AI '2 ' o t� . The':ir1onorab1e :D. :Ct ter'',.•, Mayor:.-of'.`-Rat ,iY'1 an . :e`' Re ton,.C'3''t COtz : LB'n$° •'o,: The ...it.. .c,ie'i ;;•_ f ii,,ntd :: :1Z ----) .. n =`: ' a = `'a La► d :Quit. C1aibsed..;to. the Cit ' ;l- - Ro • Set'•Ailey. arid. other:,_:?u'�l.,i• c , ' - n• orr:. e - • • -�isea':'tlf,; put,' poses _ .'Gs fir' a*t pia' behal,.-,of:'`. • .c h ent' Haze-. W..''Chaltiatzr , file .sanders n4i, • .- . , . ' +a, ct •fu1l. : etittons e x o. Re 'ton• •to a• bandon,• • • .. vacate :and.: quit-•'c ,al: , . he' following"±deac,r,.beci','r: ,►l propert 's.: ' -thie -Weans 40 feet of '^ghee:.'•North-'.h 1f'oi ''Tract . - ' :,, ''t211 G.' I>.,`.Uil1 n,e.,Lake-:v4aahington' .Gardeen . -:'. '.Ede n- 3 • vz.esten 'No.,'.9a' •EXCE?I' th.e.._North. .. ' - i :. .. . 30'''''- er*t 'share f; -`81tu t0d: in' the' 'Ci'ty:'',of Rtn:,.,. 'to a Kin Count '•c ashington.'.• 'rhi i ' r ' rt 'was cozw + y.e;d 'b Heerbert::T... Iriaaccsan":a.aid Melba , 8:. .Hack n,. :his wi e,..':.' ea:''the' ,Ci,tyr .of .Renton ,urtauant-, tea` uit l a'im Deed •'gated; ' ruary-,L2 ,-; .1 5•"0;' 'recorcded `antler -- }in •Count 'auditor's -'' • :5'306226` :dated;.:Jul 14,.: `:19• ei1 -' ` :.''r-.'.'.'.'f'•'.'1'''-:,,'.'-''.•7*.:i'.':"*'.:•':-'''''''''-.'-•.,:.•-''..'.`'-:-••;.-'::•,•''',:.'-:''*.•3''-:',-'''-'-•'••:•,••''-:'':';'•'-''':.'''''-'.:...''.':,A'. rentl. •the' ek•ans later:'.ccarrected the description.. b• , oee d_' a1e o-,dated','.i ebruary, 28, , 1858,. 'recorcieed,, under:.Audi . r. .Na 5383178 ' ::i+ corded February 2, .1,162,. rhich ,.altere.4,- ; .. 'they.-description' .of•'the grant-,.to •ih .uda' 'ohUy ,t3 e..W1es.t 3C.: rather than''.: + ':. eet+:"''oi` : See:''North halt iii•••Tract. ;11,. as:,'above' _ - -' escribed. u : , fl i' The ionc l i€ no ,dobt. ;fa lliar- with the ocati+on :ts - . + , .. . -i. ., . a t� ... � - ^ „ • � - • . • To: The Eton. D. Custer, Mayor, and March 7, noB • • To; The Renton City Council, and To: The City Clerk of Renton Page two 30 foot strip of land imoediately to the West of the land recently rezoned under Renton Planning Commission Appli- cation No. R-436-57, and to the East of 115th Avenue S.E. , and the property abutting thereon. The reasons for this, application are as follow:it 1. rd.".'Lee jer.operty to the. West has not been developec:i af3 originally Contemplated and no rJoubt, because' Of terrain, a road shall never be eorey-vleted be- tween .E. 110th Street and .112th Street as originally contemplated. 2. By deeding the property bac'e to the Grantors, ivaca- the pal:Ale right-of-way, the City of Renton will benefit by (a) placing the properet.se baet on tile tax roles and, (b) avoidinq liability for niain- tenance, u. eck9 or repair, or, r.1:etential injuries arising out of the ownership of the strip involved. 3. The applicant shall benefit to the extent thzzt the strip, involved rritir be used for the private in9rees and aggress, and perhaps, parizine for the occupants of buildinge to:be constructed cin the West 100 feet (el'? the North half of Tract 211. It is respectfully submitted that this petition for vacation of the public right-of-way involved ii in the best ,interest •of the City of Renton and the abutting property on it. Very truly. yours, Robert J. flaIl Attorney for: Eazel B. Chenaur • RE's7V Ran:vr Oclerr.1\ cc: City of Renton Traffic Engineer tiAlvt-0 MAR 11 1968 Renton Planning. Conellission .... ............ . 4t. • I 1 BEFORE THE PLANNING COMMISSION 2 OF THE CITY OF RENTON, ' WASHINGTON 3 4 IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION ) NO. R-436-67 1 of ) MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION 6 HAZEL W. CHENAUR ) 7 FOR CHANGE OF ZONING 8 ) 9 To: The Renton City Council, and 10 To: The Honorable D. Custer, Mayor, and 11 Helmie W. Nelson, City Clerk 12 13 HAZEL W. CHENAUR, by and through her attorney undersigned, 14 feeling herself aggrieved by the decision of the Renton City 15 Council at its meeting February 5, 1963, denying her applic0t.i. i. 16 for rezone from R-1 to R-3 the following described property, does 17 hereby respectfully request and move that the City Council re- 18 consider its decision of February 5, 1968, fox .the following 19 reasons: 20 21 1. That the. City Planning Director as re, r_esentative of the 22 City of Renton Planning Commission did not present to the City 23 Council all evidence that it should have in its file bearing upon 24 this application for - rezonin g, particularly in failing to exhibitP 25 '�) before the City Council color slides which were used before the co. 26 26 /' ' tanning Commission and instead supplying additional and new any 27 28 different color slides of the area involved which were made 29 subsequent to the Planning Commission hearing and prior to Lhe 30 rehearing before the City Council, and in failing to produce and 31 Mtn. for Recon. - 1 MURRAY, DUNHAM & WAITT ATTORNEYS AT LAW 419 SECURITIES BUILDING SEATTLE.WASHINGTON 98101 MAIN 2-2655 y , X-/ 1 exhibit photographs of the tract involved which the applicant 2 provided in support of its application for rezoning, and other 3 pertinent data hearing upon the merits of this application for 4 rezoning. 5 The property involved is described as follows: 6 The west 130 feet of the north one-half of Tract 7 211, CD Hillman' s Lake Washington Garden of Eden Division No. 4, according to plat recorded in 8 Volume 11, of plats , page 32, in King County, 9 Washington, except the north 30 feet of said Tract 211, conveyed to the City of Renton by 10 deed recorded under auditor ' s file No. 5333778. 11 It is respectfully requested that this apdlication for re 12 consideration be }-laced on the agenda for hearing Monday, 13 February 19, 1968. 14 DATED this day of February 1968. 15 16 17 /s/ Robert J. Hall Robert J. Hail 18 Attorney for dazei W. Chena.ur 19 20 21 cc: Planning Director 22 Renton City Planning Commission City Hall, 23 Renton, Washington 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 Mtn. for Recon. - 2 MURRAY, DUNHAM & WAITT ATTORNEYS AT LAW 419 SECURITIES BUILDING SEATTLE,WASHINGTON 98101 MAIN 2-2655 ® O .: . CITY- CLERK:" •' RENT.ON,WASHINGTON' : - 0 - ,0 , CITY HALL, CEDAR RIVER PARK„'RENTON, WASHINGTON. 98055 , • 'ALPINE.5-3464 February 7, 1.968_. .-_ °RT.CAPITAo-Cc- . . - . • 'Murray, Dunham & Waitt .•. - - . - , . Attorneys at Late • ' •- .- , . Suite -41.9 Securit3.es building -. _,_ : . . . . , . Seattle,' eshington -98101 � _—` _ ��____._._._-_ , .: . . . R •Hazel W W. Chenaur Appeal'of Renton ' , : ` ' : • , .Planning:Conmtdsaion Rezone Denial - .. - ,- - . -- ••Gentlemen e . - ' . -. The-Renton City Council, .at . s regular meeting of February.Sth, has-. . concurred, with the Planning Cothmiesian decision that R-1 is the''highest ' ' - ' • and test use f or:'the property located on the West side of 116th Avenue, , . ., between S.E. 110th:and S.E-'• 112th Streets. in Renton, and-the appeal. for . R-3 rezone hna been denied.' , " . .: :. - . . • . Yours vary:truly,' . . • CITY OF RENTON -: • : ..,-/ -;(--L)-1/h'i-- .4.•,./___ __}. - . . . . '. ' . • Helmie W. Nelson City Clerk HWN/dm• " - ', ccs Mrs. Chenaur . . . - , . City Council' Pres3 ent ' Planning Director/.. .' : . .. OF "RC PECENEb 'o •' =- °EB '.8 1968 _ • . ... . Minutes - Rentn City Council Meeting 2-26--68 COUNCIL COMMITTEE REPORTS: (Cont.) Unfinished Business Councilman Maxin Chairman of the Plann' - , submitted report recommending that requests "of C. . u it aw ence for zoning revisions to the Compre- hensive Plan, be ref -o the Planning Commission of co► meada=t sj4.4oved by Schellert, seconde !y Maxin, t9 concur in the recommendation. Carried. ✓.I4i9 s9 • ra s!� �/ d Recommended t .Gt appeal of Hazel Chenaur be allowed and R-2 zoning be granted on the subject property, owner agreeing to amend her application as discussed with Attorney Hall on her behalf. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Grant, to concur in the rezone as recommended. Carried. a Councilman Maxin announced a meeting of the Planning Committee on Wednesday, Febr ary • 28th at 7:00 p.m. - . Cou'qcilman Bruce, Chairman, Fire and Water Committee, submitted recommendati that the 'rm of Cornell,Howland, Hayes and Merryfield be retained for the desi and prepa ..'cion of plans and specifications for Well No. 8, and that the Mayo, and City • Clerk b= authorized to sign the necessary agreement documents, upon approval thereof by the Ci'k., Attorney. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Shane, to concu ,. Carried. The Fire and dater Committee recommended that the Agreement between .- e City and Fire District . o. 25 for hydrant service and water supply be approved and the Mayor and City Clerk •e authorized to sign the document. Moved by Bare', seconded by Schellert, to concur. Carried. The Public Relation. Committee met regarding the request of •Lo al 21R, Washington State Council of County and City Employees, AFL-CIO for Coun 1 acknowledgment and it was recommended that the Department of Labor and Industr conduct a check for certification purposes as provided by law. Moved by Morr s, seconded by Garrett to concur. Carried. Councilman Grant, Chairman of the Light and Power Com •_'ttee reported that a formal request has been made of Mr, John Nelson, or a repreOntative of Seattle City Light, to appear at a public hearin: of the Light and Powe Committee to discuss proposed franchise and power rates within the City, date fo hearing to be determined. Also, the Light and Power Commi '_ee submitted a roposed Resolution resolving that the interests of the City would b•c. best serve y employing a Consultant to provide rate analysis and technical assist's,nce in-regard to_power problems. The"services to be rendered in a study of power supply: and rapes were .outlined with areas'to'be analyzed wherein. the City and .Paget Power may 4,ork t6gether to improve the City with. regard to items of mutual concern, the studies 't,o be coordinated with the Traffic Engineering Department. The Light and Power Committee will interview Consulting Firms and made a recommendation as to the firm to cog' t the study and shall report cost for such study, and at a future date, report he ':'ndings to the Council. Moved by Morris, seconded by.h� in, concur in the proposed Resolution. Councilman Grant moved that his m,�•fnority reaort be incorporated as item 3. of the Resolution that: In event the City is unable to resolve the study areas to its satisfaction, the consulting f. Cm be directed to analyze the means whereby the City could develop its own power distribution syste' join with another public power utility (Seattle City Light,)or public utility `istrict. The motion to amend the original Resolution was seconded by Barei,and aft;r discussion and dissenting voice vote roll call was reques' ed which resulted as fol",ows: Aye: Garrett, Perry, Bruce, Grant, Shane and Barei. No: Morris, Schellert, Tr nor and Maxin. The amendment carried and subsequen'✓ y the original motion approvii : bhe three resolution ,proposalsa Moved by Schellert seconded by Trim, to adjourn. Dis\\tinting voice vote brought roll call request whit l'was taken as follows: Aye: Barei, M , in, Trimm. No: Garrett, Shane, Grant, Br ce, Perry, Schellert and Morris. The me- ing moved to the next order of business. Moved by Sc 411ert, seconded by Grant that the meeting be adj:.urned at 12:45 p.m. Carried. Councilor .1 Grant inquired regarding the status of the request fo_' dog control in the Highlan '• area. It was noted that the matter is in Committee and kt study will be made and report submitted upon completion. Councilman Grant reported a request from property owners that the vac'r.nt property to the East of 509 Tobin Avenue South be cleaned up and shrubbery cut s the litter is piling up and attention is needed. Mayor Custer advised that the owner has re- moved a house from the lot and further attention will be given the matters reported. ..7- Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting 2-19-68 Remarks: Councilman Maxin announced a meeting of the Planning Committee at 9:00 a.m. on Saturday, February 24, 1968. Councilman Barei requested that the Janitor oil the Chairs-around the Council table to reduce the noise. Councilman Perry noted that the tables had been removed which had been used by the City Attorney and the Press and suggested they be replaced. r. Robert Hall, Attorney for Mrs. Chenauer addressed the Council advising that he mjad. _l been mistaken regarding photographs which were submitted to the Council on the :'_-tter and offered apology to Planning Director Ericksen noting however, that ?'utiple zoning is the only feasible use for the subject property and that it is f economically impossible to develop the area as R-1. After further comments in regard to the subject property Mr. Hall was advised that the matter was now in the Planning Committee which would be meeting at 9:00 a.m. tomorrow at which time his remarks might properly be addressed the Committee. As there was no further business to come before the Council, it was moved by Trimm, seconded by Schellert, to adjourn. The motion carried, and the meeting was adjourned . 12:05 p.m. h.c././..,..,.1/4,L, )v ii, 0_ 4.,ed IL,' Helmie Nelson, City Clerk /// -✓ L. i•?. C _.;cPr, Mayor Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting 2-19-68 COMMUNICATIONS: (Cont.) Letter from Jack Wilson, City Engineer, submitted statement in sum of $383.88 due Cornell, Howland, Hayes and Merryfie1d for work in connection with Well No. 8 to January 24, 1968. Approval for payment was recommended. Moved by Morris, seconded by Bruce, to refer the payment to the Auditing and Accounting Committee with power to act. Carried. Claim submitted by Donna and Rodney Stewart was read requesting reimbursement of $49.87 for damage to water tank elements when water was shut off and water drained out of the tank. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to refer the Claim to the City Attorney and Insurance Carrier. Carried. Document from Robert J. Hall, Attorney for Mrs. Ijaz 1 W. Chenaur, requested Council reconsideration of rezone denial noting grievance that all evidence had not been presented at the hearing, particularly exhibit of photographs and color slides as shown to the Planning Commission. Moved by Perry, seconded by Schellert, that the 411:!!) Council reconsider its action of the prior meeting as requested. Carried. Moved by Perry, seconded by Garrett, to refer the matter of the rezone to the Planning Committee to report back. Cardin. Letter from Renton School District 403, Rudolph Seppi, Director of Plant 'Facilit'es. requested approval trom the -city for service to The new EarUngton Elementary 5'bn1 to be located at South 132nd Street and Langston Road, King County, by the sanitary sewer system of the City, costs to be the School Districts and Late CIT4ers greement tope allowed tor recovery or portion of the cost. Moved by Garrett, seconded by Morris, to grant the request with referral to the Law andOrdinance Committee to prepare the necessary documents. Councilman Barei reported that theeSanitation Committee has a recommendation for approval of this request. The motion carried. Letter from Mr. Ray Van Hollebeke, Property Management, The Boeing Company, requested permission to install a 12,000 gallon propane gas tank on property located in area North of 6th Avenue North, now under lease from the City. Drawing attached indicated the location of the tank and piping. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Bruce, to refer the request to the Property Committee for recommendation. (Fire Chief and City Engineer to be consulted) Carried. Letter from John E. Iverson, Attorney, petitioned, on behalf of Mr. and Mrs. Roger A. Hokanson, for consent to transfer,and sale of their interest in the Renton Radice Cab Co., Inc. New owners are individual holders of For-Hire Licenses and will continue to operate as drivers and include: Phillip A. Schmolke, present owner, Gerald Halstead, present owner, and Michael Craig, 10931 S.E. 164th Street, Renton. Moved by Perry, seconded by Garrett, to refer the matter to the Police and License Committee for recommendation. Carried. Letter from Jack Wilson, City Engineer, reported that the letter of intent to annex property to Renton which ad-'oins Sunset Blvd. E., between 132nd Ave. S.E. and 138th Ave. S.E. is signed by owners representing 84.74% of the assessed valuation of the 10X property, which is located on both sided of the highway and contains approximately 01110, 13.6 acres with an assessed valuation of $15,600.00. Annexation would make the City Limits more uniform in this area. The petitioners are Alhoff, Smith & al Bee_.and 4-'�- e matter has been referred to the Boundary Review Board. �— Letter from Sven A. Johnson, Building Director, recommended that Revocable Sign Permit be issued for sign encroachment of public right-of-way for Montgomery Ward & Co. at 319 Williams Avenue South. Moved by Perry, seconded by Barei, to concur in the recommendation. Carried. Letter from Building Director Johnson recommended that Revokable Sign Permit be granted upon revised application of Dr. Hurley at 9112 South 3rd Street, since original sign was installed to different plans than submitted. Moved by Perry, seconded by Trimm, to concur in the recommendation of the Building Director. Carried. Letter from W.E. Bennett, Utility Accountant, submitted proposed Agreement between the City and Fire District No. 25 regarding obligation and responsibility for fire hydrant:_maintenance and inspection, and consideration to be paid the City of Renton therefor. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Edwards to authorize and approve the execution. Moved by Perry, seconded by Grant to refer the document to the Fire and Water Committee for recommendation. Carried. -2- Minutes - Renton City Cou.,il Meeting (Cont.) 2-5-68 Mayor Custer introduced a group of students from Renton High School Boys Club who are attending the Council meeting in participation of Student Government Week. Attendance on a voluntary basis included about 25 youths who will also be coming to City Hall during the coming week for two hours daily to observe operation of various departments. A mock City Council meeting will be conducted by the group on Saturday, February 10th, between 10:00 a.m. and noon and Councilmen and Depart- ment i;eads were invited to attend. IA: P':3L1C HEARING: Hazel W. Chenaur appeal of R-3 rezone denial on property located on :he West side of 116th Avenue S .E. between S.E . 110th and S .E. 112th Streets. This being the date set, the hearing was declared open. Letter from Planning Director Erickson reported Planning Commission recommendation that,since detrimental effects could be anticipated and such rezone not being in the best interest of the surrounding residential area, R-1 be considered the best and highest use for this property. Petition containing approximately 20 signatures was attached objecting to the rezone which document had been submitted to the Planning Commission. Mr. Robert Hall, 419 Securities Building, Seattle, Attorney representing Mrs. Chenaur, stated that the proposed use is felt to be the fullest and best for the property noting the proximity of other multiple dwellings in the immediate vicinity and apartment directly behind the proposed development. He added that such housing is greatly needed, that the plans meet with the presently existing Comprehensive Plan and that the property had once been rezoned to R-3 but reverting according to an ordinance which had a one year construction commencement provision, since repealed. 41 Tcpcgraphy of the area was outlined with embankment division from singly family area bei:ig noted and Attorney Hall stated developers would be able to furnish parking as ik required and would be willing to work out any further matters required or desirable. 4) Film slides were shown by the Planning Director after which Councilman Shane inquired regarding apparent drainage problems noted when visiting the site and also in regard to sewering the area. Planning Director Ericksen advised that all such details NI have to be worked out prior to occupancy of the premises and all Departments concerned k mrc-t approve the particular portion of the proposal which is under their jurisdiction. Discussion ensued regarding conformancy of procedures on various applications submitted and Planning Director Ericksen noted that the Commissions actions are uniform and on thi b:sis of the Comprehensive standpoint. Specific detrimental effects were noted to be traffic congestion and loss of privacy to individual property owners on the lower sites. The Planning Director noted the project does not meet with the proposed Comprehensive 7_=n .Moved by Morris, seconded by Edwards that the hearing be closed. Carried. Moved b Morris, seconded by Perry, that the ap earl be denied in concurrence with the Planning omission recommendation that R-1 is the est and highest use f__ h�nroperty. A dissenting voice vote rou request for roll call which resulted as follows: Ay?: Morris, Schellert, Delaurenti, Perry, Trimm, Edwards, Maxin and Bruce. Nc: Garrett, Grant, Shane and Barei. The motion carried denying the appeal. CCMMUNICATIONS: Application from Mr. Robert H. Schlosser, Mgr.,Cougar Den, 219 Main Avenue South, requested that Mutual Amusement Company be granted required license to operate an additional pinball device at said business location. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to refer the matter to the Police and License Committee with power to act, whieh.carried after inquiry regarding the legality of pinball machines and their comparison to punch boards. Dis ssion ensued wherein the City, Attorney advised of Supreme Court ruling, based upon At rney General's Opinion that they are both gaming d ices and where chance predomi tes over skill the activity is outlawed and illegal with three elements under which court decisions are determined being 1. consideration is paid` o participate; 2. must be some kind of reward; 3. element of uncertainty exists. In furthe discussion City Attorney Shellan stated the City has a right, which goes back to common ru law, to license under its police power and can im- pc�e a license or regulatory fee. Cou ilman Shane felt the pinball and punch board devices should be treated equally and mo , with second by Schellert, that if pinballs are illegal they be taken out tomorrow. t was subsequently moved by Morris, seconded by :truce, to refer the matter to the Law and Ordinance Committee to report back. Moved by Barei, seconded by P ry, to table the matter. Carried. dee,Letter from Vern Church, Purchasing Agent, reported that specifications are now prepared and requested permission to call for bids for equipment which has been provided for in the 1968 budget. February 26th was recommended as the bid o ning date. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to concur in the request and recommende bid opening date. Discussion ensued regarding the City maintenance program fo ity streets and the pec^ibility of contracting such work. It was noted that cities usual y do their own maintenance, and after further discussion regarding operation of the 'ty equipment, budget, and departmental administration, question was called for on the pending otion to concur in the bid call and opening date and the motion carried. -2- ��:.. - .. . - February $-, '1968 : Mayor Donald. '.. Custer:, Members of the City Council. • - - • - - Renton, "Washington , : • - Re.: Appeal :of .Hazel-W. Chenaur Rezone Denial, ' - - App1. 14 o, R-436-67, rezone request .from : ' . R-4- to"'R-3;. property 'located, west side = ' ' of .'116 th Ave: 4..E. ire tween S.E. 110th .and 112th Sts. _ Ge- ntloinen:The planning' Commission considered .the. Hazels:W. Chenaur • ' ' rezone application at its."Meeting of December 27,- 1967-. ' - . The property in question has . the following basic 'char,7 a.cteristicsr : , ' . • : Total Area--26,116 sq. ft. 4 existing. Zoning--P0;.1. • : : . ... : - ' Existing .Use—single ,family. dwelling-: - Principal• Accerss---116th Ave. :S.E. Via S.a: .al0th" C _ ,{ • (f'. - Proposed Use--inulti�-fazzily residential :, : : A� - : . Comprehensive Plan--low to medium density multi- .. :, - family residential (revised Comprehensive Plan. indicates /� S• -. _ . . • single fam .ly residential'. - The property under consideration is located westerly of . t . existing apartment .units and a-"single 'family' residence • '•, _/1. :4, and eas y terl of Hillcrest Lane, a newlydeveloped single , . ' family- .residential plat: The proposed rezone Would al,- ' V ' , low. the Construction of medium density s artMents With ' . ' . ' an: average? of 25 to 30, units 'anticipated. - :. . The Planning. :COmnaission. reviewed the rezone request in '. :. some. detail. ' ' A .petition signet by sate 20 property ,owners. . , in the vicinity .protesting -the rezone :request-was also ' - - - ' . .• presented to. the Planning Commission . Mayor and City Council February 5, 1968 Page 2 Upon completion of its deliberations, the Planning Com- mission determined that the zoning requested would not be appropriate for the property in question since detri- mental effects could be anticipated and it would not be in the best interests of the surrounding residential area. The Planning Commission further recommended to- the City Council that the highest use of the property be R-1 as presently zoned. Very truly yours, Gordon Y. Ericksen Planning Director �'J pF R� .,;U- � �4 A 13X6-1:S31 , ,S' 11/_ C.) S. ® 1 OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK • RENTON,WASHINGTON �i a kita 9 CITY HALL, CEDAR RIVER PARK, RENTON, WASHINGTON 98055 • ALPINE 5-3464 o -P926'',,5 of,�` January, 4, 1968 CAPITA Murray, Dunham & Waitt - Attorneys at Law Suite 419 Securities Building Seattle, Washington 98101 Re: Hazel W. Chenaur Appeal.of Renton P,anning Commission Rezone Denial . Gentlemen: The Renton City Counci.l, at its regular meeting of January 8th, has , set February 5, 1968 at 8:00, p.m. in the Council. Chambers, City Hall, Renton, Washington as the time and place for hearing on the above- captioned appeal. It is requested that you and/or applicant be present.for discussion of the matter. Yours very ..truly, CITY Or RENTON Helmie •W W. Nelson City Clerk '' '/ 1/" .. ,4i 6,A 6 j„,,,,,i_ — — ,z_ c_.,/, . ,/,,Ag, BEFORE THE PLANNING COMMISSION v 1, __ ,., , OF THE CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON IN THE MATTER OF THE ) No. R-436-67 ICATI'OF ) 4` ' ' HAZEL W.- CHENAUR ) NOTICE OF APPEAL OR CHANGE OF ZO ) TO: The Secretary of the Planning Commission of t it of Renton .., ' PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that the appli , HAZEL W. CHENAUR, does hereby give notice of her appeal to i of the City of Renton, Washington, from each and every part of the <.. 'order' and decision of the Planning Commission of the City of,,,z Renton, made Wednesday evening, December 27, 1967, 'and whereby , ' ` her petition and application for reclassification of the following ' described property from R-1 to R-3 was denied: The west 130 feet of the north one-half of Tract 211, CD Hillman ' s Lake Washington Garden - of Eden Division No. 4, according to plat 40».1-. ,. , , z _., recorded in Volume 11, of plats, ,page 82, in ei, ,5'6?'° ' ,, ;King County,. Washington, except the north 30 f , '1? ' v -of said Tract 211, conveyed to the City of A� ,,,� ` ,_ Rent only deed recorded under auditor ' s file vp No. 5383778. ,a� {'tiW8 RECE1V �. C^� k pv O RE 10n,•• ; ' You are hereby requested to transmit your complet `�ecgrt�. , ` ° in this matter to the City Council of Renton, �-4eerG -"`'''' DATED this Jrday of January 1968. Robert J bball _-. Attoror Hazel W. Chenaur`,. Cc: City Council, City of Renton City Hall, Renton, Washington ,' -c,c �- /P..✓, �' / / ,.. .. ' �/�/ �%y , C, r '� S..,i•� , , ' - e?. .,/5/h/ ,, fl,J`�,�. i ? is ,i_)`id Jy' ,' '''', .._((/ •. - 4, BEFORE THE PLANNING' COMMISSION ' OF THE ,CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON : • IN THE MATTER OF THE )' , .. :No. , R-436-67 APPLICATION OF, ) ,. . HAZEL W. CHENAUR • ) : - ,:NOTICE OF.APPEAL,.' , ` . FOR CHANGE OF ZONING '). . . .:TO:; : The Secretary of the _:.Planning Commission of the City of . Renton _ PLEASE TAKE.;NOTICE that the, applicant, HAZEL:W. .:CHENAUR, does hereby give notice of her :appeal to ,the 'City -.Council of. • the City of Renton, ,Washington,__^from each and every. part'. of the: ^ order and decision of the, Planning Commission of the City .of ' Renton, made' Wednesday evening, December 27, 1967,,. and whereby her `petition and application ;.for reclassification of the following . • described property .from :R--1 to R-3 was denied: ' The west 13,0 feet,:of, the north one-half of : , • Tract' 211, CD Hillman ' s Lake. Washington .Garden':. .: ` - of Eden Division, No:.'- 4, .. according to plat: recorded. in: Volume :11,.:-of ; plats, page 82,-:in . King County,. Washington,- except the north 30 `-feet•, < ' • , of. said Tract' 211, conveyed. to, the, City. of , g, .�\• - ,Rentonby deed recorded under auditor 's. file AS9 �' '=.; - No. 5383778. : : . ' - g RE= CEIi`' . j. r� of ICJ�� • You'. are hereby requested:•to transmit your complete: - � oCI Rl4'S � �f34OtT� �e; in this. matter to the City: Council of Renton. • ��cc'i692 DATED 'this .3Y y ;o day ,Of 1968. Hall . _ Attorney, for Hazel' W. 'Chenaur cc,: . .- City Council, :City of Renton ' City Hall, Renton, ; Washington. (If CFrUED ') :. JAN '8 '1968 Renton Planning Commission Meeting December 27 , 1967 Minutes Page 4 i arrow and on a hillside. Teegarden stated he felt it would be a mi ake to allow an apartment building at the end of such a nar- row st -et at this time. Forgaard as -d when the Transamerica property to the south and - t of the subjec , property was rezoned to R-3 . The Planning Di tor replied this wa- done in 1963 . Transamerica has indicat- - it does not plan to open . cess to the Renton Hill area or de - 'op their R-3 area at this time. Comments from the audience were invited. Mr . ack Newell stated he is the property owner i -diately east of e applicant' s property and is definitely opposed any multi- - ily residential develop- ment in the area; that he fe- s the a - -a is an established single family residential zone. As there were no further come. s , 't was moved by Stredicke, seconded by Forgaard, that t• - heari • be closed. Motion carried unanimously. ACTION: Moved by Teegarde. , seconded by Stredicke, tha' the rezone applica- tion of Albert Duncalf for R-3 zoning be denie. Motion carried unanimously. The Chai • an advised the applicant of his right to appea the decisi. of the Planning Commission by written notice to t' - City Counc 1 within ten days . (c) Chenaur, Hazel W. , Appl. No. R-436-67 , rezone from R-1 to R-3; property located west side of 116th Ave. S.E. between S.E. 110th and 112th Sts. (westerly of McKnight Jr. High School) The rezone application was described by the Chairman; and the loca- tion of the property was pointed out by the Planning Director on the zoning map. The Planning Director indicated that access to the property was via an undeveloped right of way. Slides of the property were shown. Photographs of the property submitted by the applicant were passed around among the Commissioners . The Planning Director stated that in 1956 the property was zoned R-3 , but as it was not developed it reverted back to R-1 status under a reversion ordinance in effect at that time. The Chairman read a petition against the rezone submitted by property owners in the area and bearing 20 signatures. The Planning Director stated that the existing Comprehensive Plan indicates this area as low to medium density multi-family resi- dential, but that the revised Comprehensive Plan now under study by the City Council cuts this area back to single family residential. Comments from the audience were invited. Mr. Roger Peterson, 10514 - 113th Ave. S.E. , owner of property westerly of subject property, voiced his objections to the proposed rezone. Mr. George Rusk, 11029 - 116th Ave. S.E. , stated he owns a house north of 110th which he had purchased with the stipulation the area was R-1 , but had found out later that a portion of land nearby was zoned R-3 upon which two apartment houses have been constructed. Renton Planning Commission Meeting December 27, 1967 Minutes Page 5 • Mr. Rusk stated he was opposed to further apartment. development in , the area. , Mr.. .Robert Hall"" of Seattle identified himself as attorney for the , applicant, Mrs. Chenaur, ' and gave a brief history of the property in question. He stated that his . client is 'asking for the zoning which had previously been granted and ,which -had been. lost. due to the reversion ordinance then in effect which has sinbe been re- pealed. He discussed the undeveloped access road about which there appeared to be some title cloud. Mr. iHall stated this undeveloped_ access according to a11.. information he has been_ able to get belongs to the City of Renton. He stated the rezone is a logical one; would have- no . effect on the single family residential area known as Hill- crest Lane directly to the west ..as ' those houses are below his client° s. property and face away from it. He stated further that cost of development of the property makes .it economically unfeasible for anything but multi-family residential use. Mr. Bob Harris, '10843 - 116th Avem. S.E. spoke in_ opposition to the rezone due. to the immediate proximity of $20 ,000 - to $40 ,000 homes . Mr. Jerome Stephenson, ,. 11430 S.E. 112th St. , 'asked how sewer lines could be connected- to the- property. ' The Planning Director displayed a sanitary sewer. and water lines map- for the area, and stated that due to the elevation the developer . could get sewers ..only through the west side of the property by obtaining easements through ad- jacent properties. He stated further that there are sewer lines along 11,6th Ave. S.E. but . they . could not- go easterly due to the elevation unless some sort of pumping system was installed. Mr. Clayton Chenaur• discussed the history of the property; the fact' that he. thought he had- the proper zoning, being unaware, of the reversion to R-1; the access problem, :the. development of sewers , the cost of development .being too high for other than multi,-family - use. He stated that- the development would be adequately served by sewers . and would be. scr.eened to protect adjacent residences. He urged. the Commission to grant, the rezone.- Stredicke stated that the , area, notwithstanding the two existing apartments , has been .developed for. single family -use and' he. would not be in,. favor of rezoning for multiple use. Messrs. Stephenson, Peterson, Rusk- and Harris , previously acknowledged, spoke,.again in protest against the., rezone, as well as Mr. Ronald Wy- let of 11020 - 115.th Ave. S.E. Mr. Robert. Hall, and Mr. Clayton Chenaur spoke again on behalf of the rezone request. There being no further,. comments , ,it was-moved by Stredicke, seconded by Teegarden; that the hearing be closed Motion carried unanimously. ACTION: Moved b Stre 1 • he application of azel .. Chenaur for rezone from R-1 to R-3- be denied. Motion , carrie unanimous y. Further. moved by. Stredicke, seconded by Teegarden, that a communica- tion be. sent,.to the. City Council .;recommending that . the highest' use of this property be R-1 as presently zoned. Motion carried unani mously. Renton Planning Commission Meeting December 27, 1967 Minutes Page 6 The Chairman advised the applicant ' s attorney of her right of appeal of the Planning Commission decision by letter to the City . Council within ten days. Mr. Hall stated he understood the appeal rights of his client. - 1 4 - 1 - _.`I VE MATTERS REFERRAL FROM RENTON BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT (' Albert Balch and Garden Park, Inc. , request for variance fr.k height limitation. The C ,irman stated that the Board of Adjustment 11.4 referred the above ""riance application to the Planning Commission and referred the Comm`' ssioners to copies of Board of Adjustme )� Minutes as well as copy o ` letter from the FAA relative to the tter; such copies in each Co lissioner' s folder. ACTION: Moved by Brower, seconded by Racanello, the'' this matter be con- sidered at the ne' .t Administrative Meetin of the Renton Planning Commission in orde to give the Commission time to study the material submitted. Motion carried una:'imously. STREET NAME PROBLEM (b) The Chairman read a .. etter from Fire Chief M. C. Walls concern- ing duplication of street " .ame in hunder Hill #2 , parcel #26. The Planning Director stated th ,t t 2s particular street (Thomas Lane) is privately owned. and the C , ; has no control over it. He sug- gested the Commission might w'/,h to refer the matter to the Board of Public Works for their re i/ et,. ACTION: Moved by Stredicke, seco. ded by Raca, ello, that a copy of Fire Chief Walls ' letter be sent y the Mayor' s 'office and to the Board of Public ,Works for their/ action. , Motion carried unanimously. APPOINTMENT OF NEW .°'CANNING COMMISSION M. BER (c) The' Chairma . 'read copy of a letter fro. Mayor D. W. Custer to the City Counci . appointing Mr. Tony Mola a ' . a member of the Renton Planning Commi/ion to fill the vacancy crea -d by the resignation of Mr. Stanle/ Stone and requesting concurren of the Council in this appointment. RESIGNATIO ' OF PLANNING COMMISSION MEMBER (d) Mr Robert_.Brower announced that regretfully t`'7.is would be his last m eting with the Planning Commission as he had 0,een, recalled to ac ive duty with the United States Navy, and state:, it had been ia pr'vilege_ to serve bn' the Commission. ' SI E PLAN APPROVAL (Request for Information) e) Stredicke asked if site plans had been submitted for 1,. e ///4( approval of the Planning Commission for the church located 7th and M. The Planning Director replied that this church had submitted their site plans as well as a variance request for parking and had received approval of thesite ,plans on March 28 , 1962 . . He stated RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION PUBLIC HEARING MEETING DECEMBER 27 , 1967 AGENDA 1. ROLL CALL 2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES , MEETING OF DECEMBER 13, 1967 3. BUSINESS CONTINUED FROM MEETING OF NOVEMBER 22 , 1967 : REZONE APPLICATION (a) Barger, Lyle L. , Appl. No. R-433-67 , rezone from R-1 to R-3; property located at 2502-04 9th Pl. N. Total Area--app. 10 , 000 sq. ft. Existing Zoning--R-1 Existing Use--duplex family dwellings Principal Access--9th P1. N. Proposed Use--multi-family residential Comprehensive Plan--multi-family residential 4. NEW BUSINESS : REZONE APPLICATIONS (a) Singer, Dean A. , Appl. No. 'R-434-67 , rezone from R-2 to R-4 ; property located on H, St. between llth and 12th Dives. N. Total Area--27 , 590 sq. ft. Existing Zoning--R-2 Existing Use--duplex family dwellings Principal Access--llth Ave. N. , 12th Ave. N. , H St. Proposed Use--multi-family residential Comprehensive Plan--multi-family residential (b) Duncalf, Albert L. , Appl. No. R-435-67 , rezone. from R-1 to R-3; property located on east side of Cedar St. between S . 7th St, and S. 8th St. (extended westerly) Total Area--7, 975 sq. ft. Existing Zoning--R-1 Existing Use--single family dwelling Principal Access--Cedar St. Proposed Use--multi-family residential Comprehensive Plan--multi-family residential (revised Comprehensive Plan indicates single family residential) (c) Chenaur, Hazel W. , Appl. No. R-436-67 , rezone from R-1 to R-3; property located west side of 116th Ave. S .E. between S.E. 110th and 112th Sts. (westerly of McKnight Jr. High School) Total Area--25 ,116 sq. ft. Existing Zoning--R-1 Existing Use--single, family dwelling Principal Access--116th Ave. . S.E. via S.E. 110th St. R/w Proposed Use--multi-family residential Comprehensive Plan--low to medium density multi-family residential (revised Comprehensive Plan indicates single family residential) 5. ADMINISTRATIVE MATTERS : (a) Referral from Renton Board of Adjustment re Albert Balch and Ga den Park Inc. , request for variance from height limitation. (b) Let+ber from Fire Chief M. C. Walls re street name in Thunder Hill #2 , parcel #26. • (c) Letter from Mayor D. W. Custer re: Appointment of Mr. Antone Mola, to Planning Commission. -. ,,. , 1 " ,..,„, , , 0,' R[CEIVED `4,'\.\ , , DEC .22 U67 Dec. 21, 1967 ,o Cz 1.,. -- fat \,...'A/ ,.5... _Dt....?.. ." To: The 'Renton. NCl/M i.ng Conv�u.o.4Lon � 1 Irk Cluzi n The unden,a.i .ned ai..e aaac:nA t .tAe pnopo4 ed ae3on.ing .i n the vicinity 4 116.th. Ave. 5.6. Between 5.6. 110 h and 112.6. Ste. GUeA:t 130' o f the non;fh Aa4 o f £'act 211 C.D. 1/.iitnan'z La/Re Uiai/uncon Cowden o4 6den DLvL. Lon No. 4 z4ccorcd i.r. to plat izecoirded .in Vol 22 of pLat4 page 82 in King County Wa4h.ington, xcept Noirth. 30' and GUe4t 30' o f A0%n' ttcact 211 conveyed the City o f Renton by aecoirded widen. Audi-to/us (Lie No. 5383178 ' We, the undeiz sL n.ed (ee,C th i4 cz.ea 41wu.Ld be a aed Poa. 4.e4iden La l on.C6, and the ae�oni 4/ou td n ponied.not be anted. N>91CC ADD%'ASS �i v i? 1/0 7 x;3b,- /DG -, `/ .,�v�, -� /. 0 es' `/3 - (/ ix .4" �' �. -; I( ' 2 7 /G T 1 ax-( , Jc`, L 1V -w, (;v)41 o x y //664 S. ' -/ z,e- -, C1)21 au-&()j-W)29 /c?..i.z41,6 4 . c, -- //©! — //s , S z,• • i ,-� ,/, . �✓� j&? //- ..3o fe//,i 0y n�.. ��,5/ ,4,,,„„,..4_, , /. „ .,,,,. „,, ,,.,,.. ,....,, ,,,A„, d), , : _ ,,,,_ ,,,,„ ) 1 ,',7 ,:;-y,, z/i,/_41---- //,,;. e - /7-57 — • - ' ,,;--w-%- 7 / /trer,44' 1<-*" '7,/ - ,-- / (s--g ,S' ,--- F.-e, z.Z.6)-7-.._ (6/6/51 . 1.1 'mac, ('iiJ i //,,,/, , 2" / - ,✓ lemon 1%.121 7 " 6/4.) L / / deal // 0 Z'2-. //S� `� ) ��� ,"-' 1:-L_ //O P /41" fl. G - -j- 2-1r�4 c.i, l-U , NAIL ADOWS -`(_/'' Le---6,--*MzI6A-7/...- 6-✓ //G/ 2 //s Tom/ �7 vt� S�e_c2,,, .z- (ie4,-,4 . ° /�,�-- // 0/Z . //�r 2- /�, `Z.�e . Ste' i" M/ �I / / / / t- , .� siej 'Ai d/d �.U( / 5 _ �/loyi,,,, .‘d ;.734, , cif ‘77.),/,..0 . , .,,,,A.-' 1/4—.)/(4.4.4--d---.--, -27/ /2 -L' 4 • 1 2 /(qq/ 7 s/ - //2- /e;;"to,.- • , Cti6S ....1VG(/ )?L-1;e\/;4/( . . 0 1? "--- -',:.1. 4 .-,'.7-7 , / iff r4.- dit..i'''./..-'i-1-'. 41 /1e')/77:)%4.hrl:<...I( '47/i';,-<(;b.. /e:1",.... .3 - //I.-4/ •,c-/ ... ''''''4-...'".., • �`�� OFF • . c dFPA Renton Planning Commission Meeting December 13, 1967 . Minutes Page 2 (c) Chenaur, Hazel W. , Appi. No. R-436-67 , rezone from R-1 to R-3; property located west side of 116th Ave. S.E. between S.E. 110th and 112th Sts. (westerly of McKnight Jr. High School) The Planning Director pointed out the location of the property on the zoning map and stated that the property at one time was zoned • R-3 but had reverted to R-l. The existing Comprehensive Plan indicates low to medium density multi-family residential for the property, but the revised Comprehensive Plan indicates the area as single family residential. The slides mentioned above were shown. 4, DATE NEXT FIELD TRIP: It was decided that each Commission•member would inspect the above properties individually and the official field trip would be dis- pensed with for this agenda. 5. ADMINISTRATIVE MATTERS : (a) CALENDAR OF MEETINGS FOR 1968 : Copies of the Calendar of Meetings of the Planning Commission for 1968 were distributed to Commission members and will be- distributed to City Departments, City Council members, news media, etc. (b) DISCUSSION OF PLANNING MATTERS: The Planning Director stated, for the information of the Commission, (1 that the Planning Department, in cooperation with the Engineering and Building Departments, has revised the Subdivision Ordinance and it will be presented to the Planning Co for i s on- sideration. He stated the Commission might wish to set some study session meetings for next year to review this material. Teegarden stated he felt some work could be done to standardize zoning ordinances and zoning, terms throughout the valley are. Racanello stated he felt some work should be done to upgrade the Renton Zoning Ordinance.; that we may not have enough zoning clas- si ica ions o cover e type of developments proposed and to encourage private urban renewal. He stated further he felt there should be another zoning classification between L-1 and M-P and that perhaps the Commission could study this posAiul1l6y. Stredicke stated he felt that in connection with the Planning Commission' s action concerning the preliminary plat of Interlake Addition No. 2 considered at the public hearing meeting of Novem- ber 22, 1967, that a further motion to deny the application should have been made. Garrison stated that a motion to deny was unneces- sary as the motion to approve lost; therefore, the application was denied and the applicant was advised of his right to appeal. Stredicke inquired as to the status of the restrictive covenants concerning the Richards rezone. The Planning Director stated that after several meetings with Mr. Richards, a declaration of restrictive covenants had been drafted in accord with the wishes . of both Mr. Richards and the Planning Commission. AFFIDAVIT I, Hazel W. Chenaur being duly sworn, declare that I am the owner' of the property involved in this application and that the foregoing statements and answers herein contained and the information herewith submitted are in all respects true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief. Subscribed and sworn before me this 77.71 day of December , 19 67. Notary Public in and for the State of Washington, residing at Seattle )( Q22„ ."„ ) (Name) - (Signature of Owner) P.O. Box 66430 /57, �a `'� �J'. Let..4, ;4,L,/A 400 S. W. 152nd Street (Address) (Mailing Address) Seattle, Washington 98166 (City) (State) CH6-1520 (Telephone) (OFFICE USE ONLY) CERTIFICATION This is to certify tha he foregoing application has been inspected by me and bas been fo o - horough and complete in every particular and to conform t • he ,}I 4 , regulations of the Renton Planning Department gave 4151446j 1 • of such application. (� (�wv�LLLllll1111 � G . Date received DEC 7 1967 , 19 BY: G DEPPI -•S+ Renton Planning Dept. APPLICATION FOR CHANGE OF ZONE HAZEL W. CHENAUR TABLE of CONTENTS Page 1. Application for change of zoning 2. Affidavit of owner 3. Plot plan (1" = 50 ' ) and vicinity plan (1" = .200 ' ) 4. Copy of existing zoning map of Renton showing proposed change 5. . Portion of King County Assessor ' s map (S.E.. 45-23-5). showing property in vicinity; Scale 1 ' = 100 ' 6. Photographs of property involved OF RECCIII " ED DEC7 BF , .A. a J. -i.7'4 . , • , — I .3 -CiikilkNgilarP6190 . ' ---1- 5883 V ,,178 ,, , .., V01..zrf.dit.A, PACEZetar ,_. . . , (-I . ..., . . • . . . ..." • ,.,. • . ",. 1.• - • I -6A; II .. . . „ • • • , . ..9 • 71,i g 0 •,. - „. • • Pl , c\il m o • , • • - ,•,,,, . 1 , ''''' • -4.D I P , . - . . . . : .. 1,47..]___,,,.''•,,...,.....;.‘,,,,,, -'. It; clO1,f) • .,. ,„,.„ CY ... .. 0 . . ... , . ... , .. . ..,,, ,. 1 7C1 0 • • • , . . . • . .. . . • • QUIT CLAIM DEED , •• , , • - _ . . . , ... . . „.,.. .. . ..• .... . • • - -, THIS INDENTURE WITNESSETH: That we, Herbert.T.,. Hackman and . .. ., .. . . . . Melba- B. Hackman, wife ' , of King County, State of Washington, for and , in consideration of the sum of One ($1.00) Dollar to us in hand paid and' in further .. consideration of the general public welfare and the special benefits accruing to us - therefrom,, do, by these presents grant, convey and quit-Claim to the City of Renton) a,municipaltorporation of the State of Washington, for street, alley and any other ' . .public uses and purposes, the following lots, pieces and parcels of land lying and ...„,: being in said King. County„ State of Washington, and described as follows: . OP . . • .... , . . 1 • 0 -1,"5/1/1 • .• . ' . • "The north 30 feet and th s -110) fee't ofiTract 211, C. D. Hillman's • . '.-- . ,„.. - ., ,. .. 1...,::,/•.,,,• ' '• Lake Washington Garden of Eden, Division No. 14." • '.,_.•-• . ;. , . .„ . .• . .. , . • , ..... . ...,.,. . .- . .. . . .. -' • , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • . . ,,.. . . , , . ,... li . -,,:- . • . . • • • . . .. ... , . . . • •• k . • . 1`. .‘.,,., TO'HAVE AND TO •_ HOLD the said described premises unto the said City of Renton; its'successor or successors for the use of the 'public fprever. . • : 1 , r,r, • .,-,. WITNESSETH our hands and seals thisA:- day o , 5/25"):U4% e / 195 ,-• r it, • P . . - \ N ., • .. ei,44.1:-442,EAL) , , . • i . . 71/2"--at, ,/g.) 21c,t•772,2,-,,,/ (SEAL) - !;r1 . , - P WITNESSES: 'I...0: . . . N. STATE OF WA.SHINGTON)ss • ' • COUNTY OF KING ) - ,._ , . .. . __. •-... .;;.',•••• 5..,••? (---e,2 ,...----...,/,7 . . . • el;), ,::::;!.: L....4:: :7;e1.1-2C&C . , -.., a Notaryublic in and 'for the aaid-State„ . ' 14f- do'hereby certify that gn this .:4— day of •-,"15-- , 195 .S' $ personally appeared before me 7',-vvl-W--7-z,z- ,7-' .7--4.--,-,,,e--„--,0,., _-R. ,,," . to me known to be the individual. s. . described in and who executed the within " instrument, and acknowledged thaT--- -e;-7 signed and sealed the same as .2.6.6,2_, .. ' ' - Ri P. free and voluntary act and 'deed, for the uses and purposes therein, . - -. a •• mentionpd. •'••:,,.. „:,•:, ---. . . . . , ..•tv-5 it-. IN1caT54TWHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand' ard affixed my official seal the. ' - • HI;day.,411cNta41:44cthis. certificate first above written@ . .. ' ' ' .f,',.!'---.'p':::..:°; •nr;',-, %.`-`-;--#Ae, - -!. , .. . . _., --;-.'-cS',.•,-,'''\ ''',%", ", -''.'; • ..e .....--_,?..„ • v.-:‘, • ' :!..,,,,44-....,.4,:-,,-",i,,..k ..;,,V-Pi,,, . .. . .,„. ,i..f.',7„g:P6T('-o', ,:r,'11;,•:,, ,- • • , tiq- ,,,,,v,,.,g: ,. .. ' `,"•,:'-fi. '''01;°I t•,::,'i'c,. ,. . , Potary Public in and for the State of . . ; , ,,,,;.o,,„.. ••,- ,07.(4...., ,.: Washington . NI: .;°-:.:.:%,..c'4,.77,1\.),4„?-..;. ',.,,,,,,,,,,,•:::: Rmnidtrm at in said County. ,,,,4,,''r,,,,,:,,:,^'!t,:, '..P',,,:l • - . • 0'C'.:'in V,,,f-:,;:;•!;:iiikl..,tor Record d'..• .., 7. 19;,;/• . ,.... .,i,..'0...p1,1M, Rotary Public In and,fot• the State aft . • 14 , •, ,, , ., .. tra5fnnuton ResidIng at&atm' • . • , • . Nip:, •••' Q ixi 110.1 Of ()4......,0-7 ,,,te..,;;:2",c,. ,. ‘,.," Filed lor Rorocord _.s.:53a...2 19 6,2, •/0 3(4;M. P(141h Ai.•MOP RI Vt7o ent'''V*,4.11',110,r _ NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION RENTON, WASHINGTON A PUBLIC HEARING WILL BE HELD BY THE RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION AT ITS REGULAR MEETING IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS, CITY HALL, RENTON, WASHINGTON ON DECLc'f13i;R 27, , 1967 , AT 8 : 00 P .M. TO CONSIDER THE FOLLOWING PETITIONS ; 1. IIEZO? FROM R_.2 TO R,--4 a property located on I St. betw ern 1lth and 12th Aver. N. LEGAL DESCRIPTION a Lots 4 and 5, nook 42 , Corrected Plat of Renton highlands No. 2, according to Plat recorded in Vol. 57 of Pats, Page 92 to 38, Records of ding County, Washington, 2. RZZONE PROM .R 1 TO R 3; property located on Cedar St. between S. 7th St. and dead-end. LEGAL I) :SCRIPTIONe Tract 4 of highland Addition to the Town of Fenton, as per plat recorded in Vol. 17 of Plats, page 32, Records of Xing County, 'Washington n except the north 100 feet thereof; leas coal and: rainea:a1 rights and tha right to explore and saint same. 3. 'REZONE FROH :-1 TO R--3; property located vicinity of 116th Ave. between S.E. 110th and 112th Sts. LEa L DESCRIPTION; West 130 feet of the north half of Tract 211, C.D. Hillman's Lake Washington Garden of Eden Division No. 4 according to plat recorded in Vol. 22 of. flats, Page 82, in 'King County, Washington, except that north 30 feet and the west 30 .feet of said Tract, 2) ) conveyed to the: City of Renton by deed .recorded under Auditor' s File No. 5333178. ALL PERSONS INTERESTED OR OBJECTING Tq SAID PETITIONS ARE INVITED TO BE PRESENT AT THE PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING ON i:eorr er 27, 1967 AT 8 : 00 P.M , TO VOICE THEIR PROTESTS OR OBJECTIONS TO SAME . ' James ` • D nzer , SECRETARY PUBLISHED December 14, 1967 RENTON PLNNING COMMISSION CERTIFICATION I, James L, Magstedt , HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THREE COPIES OF THE ABOVE DOCUMENT WERE POSTED BY ME IN THREE CONSPICUOUS PLACES ON THE PROPERTY DESCRIBED ABOVE AS PRESCRIBED BY LAW . ATTEST : subscribed end sworn SIGN t4 befo�me, a Notary Public, on t d a y of L ee: &arr (: APPLICATION FOR CHANGE OF ZONE IN THE CITY OF RENTON FOR OFFICE USE ONLY A 1 1 _ 'f pp No . � AV.-b Plan . Com . Action ��,���� ��-z�,6`t Receipt No . 1p7.41ka1 Appeal Filed 1-5-- VC ' Filing Date \'2,. R-b`t City Council Action -)e,1,\1_6, 2-5-(05 Hearing Date \2_). -(o-7 Ordinance. No . 4, Dater 23it 3-7.0-b% APPLICANT TO ANSWER ALL THE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS NEATLY AND ACCURATELY : P.O. Box 66430 Name Hazel W. Chenaur Address 400 S.W. 152nd St. , Seattle, W"n. 98166 Telephone No . CH6-1520 Property petitioned for rezoning is located milbehind apartments on 116th Ave. S.E. between 12th Ave. N (SE 112th St. ) and S. E. 110th St. Total square footage in property 32, 650.8 LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY West 130 '\ of the North half of t-rac,t 21 1 , r n Hillman ' s Lake Washington Garden of Eden Division No.4, according to plat recorded in Volume ll of Plats, page 82, in King County, Washington, except the North 30 feet of said tract 211, conveyed to the City of .Renton by deed recorded under auditor s file No. 5383178 ,,,t\ a, k c v P sk 3 o 4-Pet District Existing Zoning R-1 Single Residence/ Zoning Requested R-3 Residence District What are the uses you propose to develop on this property? construction of apartment house Number of 'permanent off-street parking spaces that will be provided on property? at leas minimum required Number required NOTE TO APPLICANT: The following factors are considered in reclassifying property . Evidence or additional infor- mation you desire to submit to substantiate your request may be attached to this sheet . (See Application Procedure sheet Item No . 2 for specific requirements) . 1 . In what way is this proposed change in zoning in the public interest? Increase available housing near Boeing and Pacific Car plants; relieve traffic moving through Renton; increase utilization of existing schools; increase taxation to Renton, etc: 2 . On what basis is there , a real need in this community for more zoning of the type you request? Expansion of industry in Rainier Valley, particularly Boeing, Pacific Car & Foundry, and other business expansion resulting in,Anflux of population. 3 . What provision will y.ou make to protect adjacent and surrounding properties from the detrimental effects , of any uses permitted in the proposed zone? Plan attractive structure consistent, with other relatively new buildings of similar use in the area_ , RECEIVE') 10 * c-z �-d� �tkil o�a�� bY CJ 2 Cc»rt ac.lc- ov, . b_ a3-``td AFC 7 1967\';'' I Renton Planning Dept . 1967 2�NG D EP I\1\> ). I // / MINUTES - RENTON CITY _ _ JNCIL MEETING (Cont . ) 2/3/69 CORRESPONDENCE AND CURRENT BUSINESS Application was read from Bobbie R. Highland requesting that license be granted to operate a coin-type pool table at King ' s Tavern, 207 Wells Avenue South . MOVED BY MORRIS , SECONDED BY EDWARDS , to refer the application to the Police and License Committee with power to act . The motion carried. CVe,rAu C Order to Show Cause , Summons & Complaint , was read, filed against the City by Attorneys Roberts & Anderson , through Michael Williamson, on behalf of Robert E . Jones et al , in regard to Hazel W. Chenaur propert zoning and permits . MOVED BY BAREI , SECONDED BY SHANE , to refer the documents to the Legal Department . The motion carried. Letter from Bernard L. Ruppert' , Building Director , requested authoriza- tion to attend a Conference on Federal Housing Programs , February 6 and 7 at Corvallis State University , Corvallis , Oregon . MOVED BY MORRIS , AND SECONDED BY SCHELLERT , to grant the request . The motion carried . Letter from Traffic Engineer , Del Bennett , submitted proposed agreements with the Northern Pacific Railway Company and the City concerning the crossings and railroad signals on North Third and Fourth Streets which include costs to be borne by the City through the Urban Arterial Fund which constitute part of the total improvement of the one-way couplet project. It was recommended that the Mayor and City Clerk be authorized to sign the documents and copy to be furnished the Urban Arterial Board by the Engineering Department for payment . MOVED BY SCHELLERT , SECONDED BY MAXIN , to concur. MOVED BY BAREI , SECONDED BY PERRY , to refer the recommendation to the Street and Alley Committee for report back . The motion carried. Shane opposed , noting the railroad should share costs . Letter from City Engineer Wilson reported in regard to petition for Sanitary Sewer L . I . D. in the vicinity of the Mance Addition , 94th Ave . South., South 173rd and South 174th STreets , that the petition is signed by owners representing 85 . 21% of the front footage abutting the proposed improvement and 89 . 21% of area within the proposed improvement . MOVED BY SCHELLERT , SECONDED BY SHANE , to refer the matter to the Sanitation ' Committee for recommendation . The motion carried . Letter from Don Taylor, President , City Employees Club, requested permission to work Lincoln ' s Birthday, February 12 , 1969 in exchange for December 26 , 1969 , the day following Christmas to allow a four day week end for City Employees . MOVED BY GARRETT , SECONDED BY GRANT , to authorize the exchange with referral to the Mayor for administration . Discussion ensued with regard to existing union contract and, City - \ttorney Shellan suggested a letter of concurrence from the Union be secured which Mayor Custer advised he would request. The pending motion carried . REPORTS OF BID CALLS AND RECOMMENDATIONS FOR AWARDS Bids were opened on 1/27/69 at 2 : 00 p .m. in the First Floor Conference Room, Renton Municipal Building , for lighting of the small ballfield in Liberty Park , as budgeted . Letter from the Park Board was read recommending that the low basic bid of Patelco , Inc . in sum of $17 , 351 . 00 be accepted . MOVED BY SCHELLERT , SECONDED BY EDWARDS , to concur in the Park Board recommendation . Discussion ensued regarding lighting program for other areas of the city and costs involved with Liberty Park total development . MOVED BY GRANT, SECONDED BY SHANE , _to refer the bids to . the Coinmittee. of- tlhe Whole . Park budget . funds , it was noted, include_Forward Thrust , _State and Federal Funds for Lake Wn. Beach matching fund projects ,which results in double budgeting , not reflecting actual local expenditures . After some further remarks regarding the Council action at hearing meetings in budgeting the items , Attorney Shellanb notation that the Council does not have jurisdiction over the Park Board ' s action on bid awards once funds have been granted in the budget , and upon inquiry , that control may be exercised through budgetary fund transfers within classes only , the pending motion was voted upon . Dissenting voice vote brought ruling of the chair of negative majority and roll call was requested which was taken as follows : Aye : Trimm, Bruce , Grant , Shane and Barei . No : Perry, Morris , Schellert , Edwards , Maxin and Garrett . The referral motion lost . Vote on the original motion to concur was dis- senting and roll call requested and taken as follows : Aye : Perry , Schellert ,Morris , Garrett', Edwards , Maxin and Trimm. (cont . next page) ez III vi CERTIFICATION STATE OF WASHINGTON) ) ss COUNTY OF KING ) I, Itelmie W. Nelson, the duly elected, qualified and acting City Clerk of and for the City of Renton, Washington, do hereby certify that.the attached copies are true and correct copies of pages from the Renton City Council Meeting Minutes, to wit: Page 2 of February 5, 1968; Pages 2 and 8 of February 19, 1968; Page 7 of February 26, 1968; and excerpt from Renton City Code of Ordinances Ch I, Sec. 4-725; and Pages 4, 5 and 6 of December 27, 1967, Renton Planning Commission Meeting Minutes, appear— ing on file in the records of the Office of the City Clerk in said City. IN WITNESS WHEREOF I hereunto set my hand and the Official Seal of the nity of Renton, Washington, this 24th day of January, 1969. (Seal) I-Ie.lmie Nelson, City Clerk OF Rg_A\I ED °2 JAN 27 1969 4iNiNG DE:C> • • ti • • • • Renton Planning Commission Meeting December 27 , 1967 . • . Minutes Page 4 • • is narrow and on a hillside. Teegarden stated he felt it would' be a mistake to allow an apartment building at the end of such a nar- row .street . at this time. Forgaard asked when the Transamerica property to the south and west of the subject. property was rezoned to R-3. . The Planning Director replied this was done in 1963. Transamerica has indicated it does not plan to open access to the Renton Hill area or develop their R-3 area at this time. • Comments from the audience were invited. Mr. Jack Newell stated he is the property owner immediately east of the applicant' s property and is definitely opposed to any multi-family residential develop- ment .in the area; that he feels the area is an established single family residential zone. • As there were no further comments , it was moved by Stredicke, seconded by Forgaard, that the hearing be closed. Motion carried unanimously. • ACTION:• Moved by Teegarden, seconded by Stredicke, that the rezone applica- • tion of Albert L. Duncalf for R-3 zoning be denied. Motion carried unanimously. The Chairman advised the applicant of his right to appeal the decision of the Planning Commission by written notice to the City • Council within ten days . • • (c) Chenaur, Hazel W. , Au- 1 . No. R-436-67 rezone from R-1 to 1231_ roperty located west side of 116th Ave. S.E. between S.E. 1fOth and 112th Sts. (westerly of McKnight Jr. High School) The rezone application was described by the Chairman; and the loca- tion of the property was pointed out by the Planning Director on the zoning map. The Planning Director indicated that access to the property was via an undeveloped right of way. Slides of the property were shown. Photographs of the property submitted by the applicant were passed around among the Commissioners . The Planning Director stated that in 1956 the property was zoned R-3 , but as it was not developed it reverted back to R-1 status under a reversion ordinance in effect at that time. The Chairman read a petition against the rezone submitted by property owners in the area and bearing 20 signatures . • The Planning Director stated that the existing Comprehensive - Plan indicates this area as low to medium density multi-family resi- dential, but that the revised Comprehensive Plan now under- study by the City Council cuts this area back to single family residential. Comments from the audience were invited. Mr. Roger Peterson, 10514 - 113th Ave. S.E. , owner of property westerly of subject property, voiced his objections to the proposed rezone. Mr. George Rusk, 11029 - 116th Ave. S.E. , stated he owns a house north of 110th -which he had purchased with the stipulation the area • was R-1, but had found out later that a portion of land nearby was zoned R--3 upon which two apartment houses have been constructed. • • • Renton Planning Commission Meeting December 27 , 1967 Minutes Page 5 Mr. Rusk stated he was opposed to further apartment- development in the area. Mr. Robert Hail of Seattle identified himself as attorney for the i 1 applicant, Mrs. Chenaur, and gave a brief history of the property .--. .in question. He stated that his client is asking for the zoning which had previously •been granted and which had been lost due to the reversion ordinance then in effect which has since been re- pealed. He discussed the undeveloped, access road about which there appeared to be some title cloud. • Mr. Hall stated this undeveloped ' access according to all information he has been able to get belongs to the City of Renton. He stated the rezone is a logical one; would. have no effect on the single family residential . area known as Hill-- crest .Lane directly to the west as those houses are below his client' s property and face away from it. He stated further that cost of development of the property makes it economically unfeasible for anything but multi--family residential use. • Mr. Bob Harris , 10.843 - 116th Ave. S.E. spoke in opposition to the rezone due to the immediate proximity of $20 , 000 to $40 , 000 homes . Mr . Jerome Stephenson, 11430 S .E. 112th St. , 'asked how sewer lines ' • could be connected to the property. The Planning Director displayed a sanitary sewer and water lines map for the area; and stated that due to the -elevation the developer could get sewers only through the west side of the property by obtaining easements through ad- jacent properties . He stated further that there are sewer lines along 116th Ave. S .E. but they could not go easterly due to the ' j elevation unless some sort of pumping system was installed. ` 1 Mr. Clayton Chenaur discussed the history of the property; the fact that he thought he had the proper zoning, being unaware of the ' reversion to R---1; the access problem, the development of sewers , the cost of development being too high for other than multi-family use. - He stated that 'the development would be adequately served by sewers and would be screened to protect adjacent residences. He urged the Commission to grant the rezone. Stredicke stated that the area, notwithstanding the two existing apartments , has been developed for single family use and he would not be in favor of rezoning for multiple use. Messrs. Stephenson, Peterson, Rusk and Harris , previously acknowledged, spoke again in protest against the rezone, as well as Mr. Ronald Wy- let of 11020 - 11.5th Ave. S.E. Mr. Robert Hall and Mr . Clayton Chenaur spoke again on behalf of the rezone request. • There being no further comments , . it was moved by Stredicke, seconded by Teegarden, that the hearing be closed, Motion carried unanimously. ACTION : )/f\ : . _ Moved by Stredicke, seconded by Brower, that the application of • ' Hazel W. Chenaur for rezone from R- l to R--3 be denied. Motion 71 carried unanimously. Further moved by. Stredicke, seconded by Teegarden, that a communica- tion be sent to the City Council recommending' that the highest use ' 4of this property be R--1 as presently zoned, Motion carried undrii • - mously, • • • Renton Planning Commission • • Meeting December 27, 1967 Minutes Page. 6 The Chairman advised the applicant' s attorney of' her right of appeal of the Planning Commission decision by letter to the City Council within ten days. Mr. Hall stated he understood the appeal • . rights of his client. 5. ADMINISTRATIVE MATTERS • REFERRAL FROM RENTON BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT .. ) Albert Balch and Garden Park, Inc . , request for variance '- f .m height limitation. The . airman stated that the Board of Adjustment had referred t►e above ariance application to the Planning Commission and ref-.-red the Co lissioners to copies of Board of Adjustment Minutes a: well as copy • letter from the FAA relative to the matter; suc copies in each Co, missioner' s folder. ACTION: • Moved by Brower seconded by Racanello, that this m. ter be con- sidered at the n;:xt Administrative Meeting of the :enton Planning Commission in ord_ to give the Commission time t study the material submitted. Motion carried unanimously. STREET NAME PROBLEM (b) The Chairman read letter from Fire ief M. C. Walls concern- ing duplication of stree name in Thunder Hill #2 , parcel #26 . The Planning Director stated at this part ' . ular street (Thomas Lane) is privately owned and the ity has no control over it. He sug- . gested the Commission might ,ish to r=fer the matter to the Board • of Public Works for their rev; ew. • ACTION: Moved by Stredicke, seconded b R``anello, that a copy of Fire Chief Walls ' letter be sent to the yor' . office and to the Board of • Public Works for their actio! . Moti. \ carried unanimously. APPOINTMENT OF NEW PLANNI COMMISSION `iEMBER ' (c) The Chairman read ' opy of a letter t- om Mayor D. W.. Custer to • the City Council appo ` ° ting Mr. Tony Mola :.s a member of the Renton • Planning Commission ro fill the vacancy creased by the resignation of Mr. Stanley Ston,, and requesting concurren e of the Council in this appointment. • RESIGNATION OF e ANNING COMMISSION MEMBER (d) Mr. Robe/ Brower announced that regretfully',4his would be his last meetinl.'with the Planning Commission as he had`.een recalled to active . ty with the United States Navy, and stag\.. it. had been a privile� - to serve bh the Commission. \ SITE P / APPROVAL (Request for Information) (e) stredicke asked if site plans had been submitted for he approval of the Planning Commission for the church located 7th a • M. The Planning Director replied that this church had omitted eir site plans as well as a variance request for parking a had received approval of the site plans on March 28 , 1962 , He st: ed Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting 4-1-68. COMMUNICATIONS: (Cont.) Letter from F. A. Storey, 11007 - 109th Ave. S.E. noted agreement at the March 12th meeting of the Legislative Joint Committee on Highways held in the Renton City Council. Chambers that the State had an obligation to help provide a Pedestrian Walkway at the North Ren n Interchange Clover Leaf and it was requested that a meeting be set with proper City icials to further this goal. Moved by Delaurenti, sec dewy Perry, to refer this comm 'cation to the Street and Alley Committee and Ci. Engineer to report back, Carried. Letter from Peter V. Gull c Secretary, Newport Hill ewer District reported pending annexation to Newport Hills wer District of an rea north of and adjacent to the Renton City Limits and it appear' g the anne ion will be completed and the District requested to serve the areas this s er, plan had been submitted to City Engineer Wilson wherein service utilizes the ppposed Metro May Creek Trunk. A portion of the planned 15 or 18 inch line will li; 'n th sity limits from 108th S.E. and S.E. 94th St. intersection to 110th S.E. anath Street int • section and will be capable of serving areas both in the City and the area north of May-tAreek. Permission was requested to construct and maintain t necessary lines, the Distri, desiring to cooperate with the City to the end that a drainage basin be properly serve these lines regardless of political divisio , the line to be made available for local us vithin the City upon proper contril3p ion to the cost by the users. Moved by Perry, secon d by Morris, to refer the nest to the Sanitation Committee and the City Engineer to re back. The motion carried. Letter from City Engineer Wilson reported regarding the Hazel Chenaur petition for right-of-way vacation of 30 ft. street adjoining the west 2 of the North of Tract 211 of the Ca D. Hillmans Lake Washington Garden of Eden Division No. 4., that the sub- division represents 50% of the total frontage abutting said right of way failing to meet the minimum requirement of signatures which is 2/3 of the property ownerships abutting. Moved by Garrett, seconded by Schellert, that the petitioner be notified that the petition as submitted is not valid. Carried. , . 417 Claim was read from Marvin L. Sherertz for damage to automobile on March 25th when oncoming car forced his auto into unfilled shoulder which was incompleted due to sidewalk and curbing 'tion under construction. In coming off the shoulder vehicle struck unbarricaded water shut o ac it 4.r tre vehic a for whic 9UT86 is claimed. Location of incident appa. . 00 bloc;moo..Bronson Way North. Moved by Delaurenti, and se nd ry r to refer the Claim to the City y Attorney and Insurance Agency. Carried. Letter from C y_ Engineer Wilson reported regarding Christopherson et al:. let er of intent to annex`pareperty in vicinity of 108th Ave. S.E. and S.E. 164th St set, to Renton, advised thatNApatures thereon represent 91.54% of the assesse valuation of the subject properthtich area contains approximately 6.71 aces with a' total assessed valuation of $43,�Q_.00. Annexation of this propertwo ld create a more uniform city limits line in thi area. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Maxin, that April 8th be set for preliminary sting with property o�� ers concerned and that the owners be notified. Shane questions annexation of apy additional property noting services needed by present areas. It w noted t the process of law must be enacted and when requested the City must t ce as ion accordingly granting the property owner the right provided by law. The motion c ried. Letter from Park Director Coulon advise hat since�ll bids received on the landscaping of the South 2nd Street Traffic Islands were in exces^ of the amount authorized by the Council, it was recommended that acI bids be rejected an that the landscape plan be redesigned to meet the budget a Y"ocation. Moved by Perry, conded by Grant, to concur g in the recommendation. Intent of rejecting and modifying was firmed and Grant inquired if the redesign would requ' a additional cost. Mayor Custer adv . ed it would not, but that it would be a ques 'on of deleting part of the sprinkling syss and some of the cement and rock to meet the $9,000.00 sum. Grant had withdrawn his se nd and Barei offered second to t e pending motion. Shane objected and Grant noted t .,; discussions heretofore regarding elimination of sources of revenue and things that hav- to be cut out to balance and stated forthe record at this time he would like to see the' ' slands in front of e high school retained as presently landscaped. Question was cane. for on the pe •ing motion and dissenting verbal vote resulted in two requests for roll',.all which r ulted as follows: Aye: Garrett, Morris, Schellert, Delaurenti, Perry, Trimr4, Maxin nd Bruce. No: Grant, Shane and Barei. The motion carried. Discussion ensued ! reg ding the vote and school districts participation at one time and change of heart ` by reason of hazard involved in maintenance and fact that water is not available. -2- Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting 3/18/68 COMMUNICATIONS: Letter from City Engineer Wilson submitted and recommended for payment, Progress Estimate due L. R. Gaudio Well Drilling Co. in sum of $11,936.83, C.AG. 1248-67, Well No. 8, Cedar River Park. Moved by Morris, seconded by Barei, to concur with referral to the Auditing and Accounting Committee with power to act. Carried. Letter from City Clerk Nelson reported the necessity, pending receipt of tax money, to borrow funds for operating the following 'City Funds. Loan from Cit 1 Con- struction Fund until June 30, 1968 @ 3% interest was recommended, fo istribution as follows: Cur ' -,t Fund - $300,000.00; City Street Fund, $140,0 ,• .00 and Library Fund, $ 70,000.00. .'eferral to the Law and Ordinance Committg€for required Resolution was also r-,.ommended. Moved by Morris, second derby Schellert, to concur. The motion carried. /-,- / Application was read from Me ose Tavern owner, ,J,,�' ' Natucci, requesting that Regal Amusement Co. be granted requi --d license to o gate a coin-type pool table at said business located at 819 Walla Wa. ,a Avenue. ; Roved by Morris, seconded by Schellert to refer the application to the Po`V'ce afl'License Committee with power to act. The motion carried. Letter from City Engineer Wilson y�=pprtef., regarding Honeycreek Park Sanitary Sewer L.I.D. Petition, that the doc fit contain- signatures representing 54.42% of the frontage in the proposed ser ce area and du-\to irregularities in signing, such as wives signing for husbands it was recommended _hat the Council adopt a Resolution as necessary to create -e Sanitary Sewer L.I.D. oved by Edwards, seconded by Maxim, to refer the ma- er to the Law and Ordinance Committee for proper Resolution. The motion carried. % Letter from Mrs_''osalie Evans requested No-Fee Permit to a' .aka the use of the Volkswagen bu' ding by St. Luke's Episcopal Church for a rummage sale,May 9, 10 and llth. Move•. 'sy Delaurenti, seconded by Bruce, to grant the request. City Clerk Nelson re. rted that Mr. Fletcher had decided not to lease the building for paint storage rending repair of his fire damaged store building. The motion carried. Letter from M. C. Walls, Fire Chief, requested to call for bids on painting interior of both fire stations and exterior of the main station. April 8th was recommended for bid opening date. Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Schellert, to concur.Carried. Letter from Attorneys Murray, Dunham & Waitt, Attorneys at Law, petitioned the+'City, . on behalf of Mrs. Hazel Chenaur, for the vacation of 30 ft. right-of-way strip to the East of 115th Avenue S.E., abutting Mrs. Chenaur's property. $100.00 filing fee was paid as required. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Bruce, to refer the petition to the City Engineer to verify the signatures and report back. Carried. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to refer the matter to the Property Committee.Carried. -tier from City Attorney Shellan submitted copy of letter received from the Boeing Company regarding a secondary water supply for the Renton Plant. It was suggested that Council approve same as a matter of record, the City Engineer having given his signatory approval heretofore. Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Schellert, to refer the matter to the Committee of the Whole. Carried. �� Letter from Mr. T. Nelson, Masseur whose business is located at 118 P Avenue in Renton, submitted observations and objections to proposed Or 'gdice regulating Massage Parlors, Healt alons and Public Bath Houses. Mr. on felt the restrictions were not reasonable for t City and that the fees wer ut of line compared to the Business License Fees for othe type of businesses. e felt the wording was detrimental to the subject businesses and tha he local po 'ce under existing statutes handle quite efficiently any problems which h resulted in complaint, and the scope of requirements being such that an attorn ould not advise his client to sign. It was suggested that the Council meet wi artie to be affected prior to enactment of such prohibitive Ordinances. Moved b orris, secon d by Delaurenti to refer this letter to the Law and Ordinance Commi e for recommendatio The motion carried. Committee Chairman.Tr.imm noted th every Councilman had recei d a copy of this Ordinance and it .was: being held fo' .review until after March 28th an meeting is to be held then on this at 7:30 . . Parties concerned have been notified, anyone interested is invited to end. Let from Chester Biesen, Executive Secretary, Association of Washington Cities, announced that the Seattle Chamber of Commerce is holding an "Association Day" luncheon on Friday, April 5th. Invitation was extended to attend. -2- Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting (Cont.) 3-18-68 ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS: Law and ' ance Committee Chairman, Trimm, submitted proposed Res ol tion of the City of Renton app ing $3,450.00 from excess revenue ' -the Library Fund unto Account 1610/606 Capita la chinery & ment, Library, for the purchase of a Van for transportation sere' — o h=Librar Moved by Schellert, seconded by Delaurenti, to adopt Re n No. 1524 as read. Carri Councilman Trimm prese a proposed Resolution of the City of Renton authorizing transfer of $20 - 00 from Cumulative Reserve Fund 1894 unto City Hall Construction Fund 4281 ,O ccount 605, for lawn sprinkling system and lighting within the civic center site. Moved by Trimm, seconded by Bare_, to adopt Resolution No. 1525 as read. r The motion trio 13 ® /� T}ie Committee resented a '. + �,-nance of the Cityof Renton chap in the zonin classification o certainproperties wit in t e Cityfrom Residence Single FamilyDis- trict R-1 to Residence District R-2 whic was read y the Clerk. (Hazel Chenaur property ove y rimm, secon e y rant, to place the document on second amend final reading. Carried. After final reading, roll call vote was taken on ,motion by Dela-' urenti,. second. by Barei, to adopt as read. The vote resulted in unanimous aye votg carrying the motion and adopting Ordinance 2387 as read. Proposed Ordinance was read changing the zoning classification of the Beanblossom and Roe property within the City from Residential District (R-2) to "Apartment Houses and Multip .- Dwellings (R-4). Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Maxin, to place the docu- ment on --cond and final reading. Carried. After final reading, it was oved by Delaurenti, seconded by Schellert, to adopt Ordinance No. 2388 as read Roll call vote resulte• 'n all ayes and the motion carried. Proposed Ordinanc- was read changing the zoning classification the Dean Singer property within the ,ity from Residential District (R-2) to R . idential District (R-3) . Moved by Delaurenti, s=conded by Barei, to place the docume - on second and final reading. Carried. Afte' the final reading, it was move y Delaurenti, seconded by Maxin, to adopt Ordinance . 2389 as read. Carried,, u on unanimous aye roll call vote. Proposed Ordinance was read cha ingzoning the clas" sification of the Lorensen-Jensen properties on 132nd Ave. S.E. fro General Classaication District (G) to Residential District (R-3) . Moved by Delaurenti seconded4y Grant, to place the document on its second and final reading. Carried. ved y Morris, seconded by Bruce, after final reading, to adopt Ordinance No. 2390 as ad. Roll call vote resulted in all ayes and the motion carried. Proposed Ordinance was read changin the zonin classification of the Harris property on 132nd Ave. S.E., within the C' y of Renton, om Suburban Residence District (S-1) to Single Residence District ( ). Moved by Delau ti, seconded by Barei, to place the document on second and f' 1 reading. Carried. ter final reading, it was moved by Morris, seconded by Bare}}', to adopt Ordinance No. 23 as read. Carried upon unanimous aye roll call vole. Proposed Ordinance wa , read amending Section 10-705 of Title (Traffic), of Ordinance No. 1628 entitled "Cole of General Ordinances of the City of Re .on", relating to Municipal Parking 1.,ot #3. (Limiting to 2 hour parking rather than .4 hr. parking use) Moved by Trimm, 6conded by Maxin, to place the document on second akd final reading. Carried. After he final reading, it was moved by Morris, seconded b Barei, to adopt Ordinan a No. 2392 as read. Carried upon unanimous roll call vot-'. (Publication to be withh td until new meter heads have been installed) Proposed rdinance of the City,granting Pacific Coast RR Co. a franchise fore stablish- ment, intenance and operation of its North Renton Main Line track in, upon a,d along House Way, and fixing the location, terms and conditions of such franchise, wa placed on f rst reading. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Shane, to refer the document to the Law/and Ordinance Committee to hold 30: days following publication as required by 1.t. Carried. Moved by Garrett, seconded by Shane that the Garbage and Refuse Collection Ordinance be placed on second and final reading. Revisions were outlined, and the motion carried. After final reading, it was moved by Trimm, seconded by Shane to adopt Ordinance No. 2393 as read. Roll call vote resulted in all ayes and the motion carried. -6- ''':' '. . ' . :-. % ' - - . ' _ ) .. . ii." n 'ep- re' 11-' ..‘) ' '''.:(1 .:,,-.1,7...•v.-,.!v.-,..'...:.,.,,.. ...-,.K, : -i, .,,. t, .e.:0. .1..‘ ..'-.,-„.........-.,-.,_,,::,:•::::,._•:::,:.:...:." ' Mt... A. ,.1).J•N'iiM •$c..WAITT . WAi tUR Ar _ 'ATTORNEYS AT LAW tFE�'D U'N FIRM i - ' +. _ - BERT IC.VdA1TT - !SUITE 419 S?CCV R!YIES BUILDING� �j SEATTLE,WASHINOTON 98101 .. - MAIN 2-2655 _ - To;•.:' The donorable';D. Cuater,, Mayor of' Renton, 'a.14 .r To s The 'Re»ton. City ..Council, and e, k•; o•t, a t� , , 'Ta.m The '•C�t• �1 r � ,R � xi.�. - �..�:�_. ' : -• 'Foe_: .,cat of •Land 'quit.. Clalmeti :to 'the Cif: - , Tot' Renton'-tor'.Street.'Alley' arird.:-ot.her_>public' ,. •%tib a- and_ zr ass . .• ,,,, < un' bian*if of,', y :Clt.ont,_,Haaa1.:rl..:Cheina.ur, the, .u:ndersi'naa hereby respect.fix;lly. pet.itaon�c:' ne xty :o: •`Renton:to''abandon,' .. vacate .and.: quit claLit'.the;,fol-lowing::'destribt; t, real' pr 'o 4rty.is : ''•the 'feat,40; feet'.:of'''the.`North-%ha,lf of::Tract. . . ..• : 1I211-, 'C.`:.L . .iliUman'a Lak+a--',vTashin ton .Garden ( . fE i•a s �o XCEITt .. North, . . xxon 4 - _e . . _ - 3Q- feet'•thereof; : 9ituatQd 3n the City::Ot• R t n- ... .. :-.:,-.::' - . I ton, King,',County,`• 4-ashington. • . . his' •property„ was coiive'grod-..b• y,.lierber-t.,T.. .iieakinan'''and• I elba:' • . • ' - : B:- Hackman, his :wife,••.to :,the City.of tentO.ti.•pfar, drat: tb•.: _, .., . : '. . Quit. Claim Deed• dated: Februarr.28,,• ,.3:95J recorded under` . ' zing, County,.Auditor'&-:No:.,.5.'3.06226, :seated' July-"'1.4,' -:`1961: . Appa3 ently, :''the Pack ina. later _. correeted the .de•escript :ioti: .. ' . by deed''' also-dated. February, 28, 1858,. recorded• under::'Audi • . ' . .tor'.a..No. .53 33,18, :recorded. February. 2.; =,1962 which',altered;., :•::..' , ._ , the. rdescript`ion.'..o f .-the grant ,•to ,include. :only the. West-`30-: r rather -than' 40'feet"-of he., L orth ''hal f Of', Tract.;'it.•;,as•'above,' ` described._ : . • . ' . - • ''The Council • i -no.- dc2,bt.:.£ai iliar-''with the loeata.on of•:this'' 1 - D '' O' To: The Hon. D. Custer, Mayor, and March 7, 1,.,d0 To: The Renton City Council, and To: The City Clerk of Renton Page two 30 foot strip of land immediate/y to the West of the land recently rezoned under Renton Planning Commission Appli- cation No. R-436-67, and to the East of 115th Avenue S.E. , and the property abutting thereon. The masons for this application are as follows: 1. ThQ. 2ropi,nrty to the West has not been developed as originally contemplated and no 'doubt,. because - of terrain, a road shall never be -.-:ompleted be- tween 0.E. 110th Street and S.R. 112th Street as . originally contemplated. 2. By deeding the property bach to thc Grantors, vaca- • the public right-of-wak, th City of Renton will benefit by (a) placing the propertv bacit on the tax roles and, (b) avoiding liability for main- tonancc, up!.:se2 or repair, or, zi-Aential injuries arising out of the ownership of the strip involved. 3. The applicant shall benefit to the extent the.t the strip involved may -be used for the private inoress and ogcjress, and perhaps, paricin.j for the occupants • of buildings to be constructed on the West 100 feet of the North half of Tract 211. It is respectfully submitted that this petition for vacation of the public right-of-way involved is in 'the best interest of tho City of Renton and the abutting property on it. Very truly yours, Robert J. Hall Attorney for Hazel B. Chenaur cot City of Renton Traffic Engineer 6CMItt ()/ Renton Planning. Commission • MAR 1.1. 1968 -0 ........ ...... . • cY/k N4*q_ligY 1 BEFORE THE PLANNING CO__ ISSION 2 OF THE CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON 3 4 IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION ) NO. R-436-67 5 • of • ) MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION 6 HAZEL W. CHENAUR ) 7 FOR CHANGE OF ZONING 8 9 To: The Renton City Council, and 10 To: The Honorable D. Custer, Mayor, and 11 Helmie W. Nelson, City Clerk 12 13 HAZEL W. CHENAUR, by and through her attorney undersignec, 14 feeling herself aggrieved by the decision of the Renton City 15 Council at its meeting February 5, 1963, denying her applicati. L 16 for rezone from R-1 to R-3 the following described property, does 17 hereby respectfully request and move that the City Council re- 18 consider its decision of February 5, 1968, fox .the fol] owing 19 reasons: 20 21 1. •That the. City Planning Director as re, r_esentative of the 22 City of Renton Planning Commission did not present to the City 23 Council all evidence that it should have in its file bearing upon 24 this application for ' rezonin g, particularly in failing to exhibit 25 before the City .Counci] color slides which were used before the /� G 26 ?).anning Commission and instead supplying additional and new anc 27 28 different' color Slides of the area involved which were made 29 subsequent to the• P&anning. Commission hearing and prior to the 30 rehearing before the City Council, and in failing to produce and 31 Mtn. for Recon. MURRAY, DUNHAM & WAITT ATTORNEYS AT LAW 419 SECURITIES BUILDING SEATTLE,WASHINGTON 98101 MAIN 2-2655 r ' C/e rL.r ,7,4 1 exhibit photographs of the tract invnl ved which the .#pplicant 2 provided in support of its application for rezoning, and other 3 pertinent data bearing upon the merits of this application fox 4 rezoning. 5 The property involved is described as follows: 6 The west 130 feet of the north one-half of Tract 7 211, CD Hillman ' s Lake Washington Garden of Eden Division No. 4, according to plat recorded in 8 Volume 11, of plats , page 82, in King County, 9 Washington, except the north 30 feet of said Tract 211, conveyed to the City of Renton by ANO 10 deed recorded under auditor ' s file No. 5383778. 11 It is respectfully requested that this application for re- 12 consideration be idaced on the agenda for hearing Monday, 13 ?ebruary 19, 1966. 14 DATED this day of February 1968. 15 16 17 /s/ Rbert J. Hall Ai Robert J. Hall 18 Attorney for Hazel W. Chenaux 19 20 21 cc: Planning Director 22 Renton City Planning Commission City Hall, 23 Renton, Washington 24 25 26 Al: 27 28 29 30 31 Mtn. for Recon. - 2 MURRAY, DUNHAM & WAITT ATTORNEYS AT LAW 419 SECURITIES BUILDING SEATTLE,WASHINGTON 98101 MAIN 2-2655 440 -: OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK . RENTON,WASHINGTON CITY HALL, CEDAR RIVER PARK, RENTON, WASHINGTON 98055 • ALPINE.5-346.4 o • AoRT of February 7, 1968 • CAPITAL ' • • Murray, Dunham & Waitt :.Attorneys at Law :` Suite" 419 Securities wilding ` Seattle,' Washington "98101 : _- - R _.: Hazel W. Chenaur Appeal'of .Renton Planning Commission Rezone Denial Gentlemen The Renton City Council, at; a regular meeting of February 5th•'has., ; • concurred with the Planning Commission decision, that R-1 is the highest . . and best use for the.property located on the West side of 116th Avenue between S.E. 110th.and" S.E. 112th Streets,.in Renton, and_the"appeal for R-3 rezone has been denied.' Yours very:truly, CITY OF RENTON " . Helmie W. Nelson - City Clerk HWN/dm " cc: Mrs., Chenaur City Council President : Planning Director/ ; • ; • RECENEb 0 /1;?, - E8 8 . 1968 Minutes - Renirn City Council Meeting 2-26-68 COUNCIL COMMITTEE REPORTS: (Cont.) c Unfinished Business . Councilman Maxin Chairman of the Kann' , submitted report recommending that requests of C. . u i - w ence for zoning revisions to the Compre- hensive Plan, be ref o the Planning Commission f or r 0n•naFfda4�s Moved by Schellert, seconde y Maxin, t co cur in the recommendation. Carried. • /44h !� e!�/� / e'er l Recommended t t appeal of Hazel Chenaur be allowed and R-2 zoning be granted on the subject property, owner agreeing to a e d her application as discussed with Attorney Hall on her behalf. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Grant, to concur in the rezone as recommended. Carried. Councilman Maxin announced a meeting of the Planning Committee on Wednesday, Febr ary • 28th at 7:00 p.m. - . Cou cilman Bruce, Chairman, Fire and Water Committee, submitted recommendati that the 'rm of Cornell,Howland, Hayes and Merryfield be retained for the desi_, and prepa Lion of plans and specifications for Well No. 8, and that the Mayor and City • Clerk b authorized to sign the necessary agreement documents, upon approval thereof by the Ci Attorney. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Shane, to concu . Carried. The Fire and ater Committee recommended that the Agreement between 'i' e City and Fire District .. o. 25 for hydrant service and water supply be approv'd and the Mayor and City Clerk •e authorized to sign the document. Moved by Bare', seconded by Schellert, to concur. Carried. The Public Relatio'k. Committee met regarding the request of •Lolcal 21R, Washington State Council of County and City Employees, AFL-CIO for Coun ' 1 acknowledgment and it was recommended that the Department of Labor and Industr'es conduct a check for certification purposes as provided by law. Moved by Morr' , seconded by Garrett to concur. Carried. Councilman Grant, Chairman of the Light and Power Comril--ttee reported that a formal request has been made of Mr . John Nelson, or a repre 'entative of Seattle City Light, to appear at a public hearin: of the Light and Power' Committee to discuss proposed franchise and power rates wit in the City, date fa hearing to be determined. Also, the Light and Power Commi ':ee submitted a roposed Resolution resolving that the interests of the City would b•u best serve y employing a Consultant to provide rate analysis and technical assist.nce in-re , rd to_power problems. The'services to be rendered in a study.. of power supply. and rates were .butlihed with areas'to be analyzed wherein the City' and .Puget Power may ;,ork t gether to improve the City with regard 'to items of mutual concern, the studies ..o be coordinated with the Traffic Engineering Department. The Light and Power Committee will interview Consulting Firms and made . a recommendation as to the firm to cop6°1t the study and shall report cost for such study, and at a future date, reportthe -:'ndings to the Council. . Moved by Morris, seconded by p�xin, `. concur in the proposed Resolution. Councilman Grant moved that his rr nority reort be incorporated as item 3. of the Resolution that: In event the C (y is unable to resolve the study areas to its satisfaction, the consulting f am be directed to analyze the means whereby the City could develop its own power §Istribution oyster,. join with another public power utility (Seattle City Ligh t) or public utility i str.i ct. The motion to amend the original Resolution was s�,conded by Barei,and after discussion and dissenting voice vote roll call was reque ted which resulted as follows: Aye: Garrett, Perry, Bruce, Grant, Shane and Barei/ No: Morris, Schellert, Tr'nm and Maxin. The amendment carried and subsequen'' y the original motion approv:i ': the three resolution.,proposals. Moved by Schellert seconded by Trimm, to adjourn. Dissenting voice vote brought roll. call request whic/was taken as follows: Aye: Barer, M‘_ in, `Timm. No: Garrett, Shane, Grant, Brice, Perry, Schellert and Morris. The me ing moved to the next order of business. • Moved by Scl -llert, seconded by Grant that the meeting be adji,urned at 12:45 p.m. Carried. Councilor .• Grant inquired regarding the status of the request fo ' dog control in the Highlan , area. It was rioted that the matter is in Committee and study will be made and report submitted upon completion. Councilman Grant reported a request from property owners that. the vacant property to the East of 509 Tobin Avenue South be cleaned up and shrubbery cut s the litter is piling up and attention is needed. Mayor Custer advised that the owner has re- moved a house from the lot and further attention will be given the matters reported. -7- Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting 2-19-68 Remarks: Councilman Maxin announced a meeting of the Planning Committee at 9:00 a.m. on Saturday, February 24, 1968. Councilman Barei requested that the Janitor oil the Chairs-around the Council table to reduce the noise. Councilman Perry noted that the tables had been removed which had been used by the C ty Attorney and the Press and suggested they be replaced. I fr, Robert Hall, Attorney for Mrs. Chenauer addressed the Council advising that he OwF ' had been mistaken regarding photographs which were submitted to the Council on the m-:tter and offered apology to Planning Director Ericksen noting however, that : Fu=tiple zoning is the only feasible use for the subject property and that it is economically impossible to develop the area as R-1. After further comments in regard to the subject property Mr. Hall was advised that the matter was now in the Planning Committee which would be meeting at 9:00 a.m. tomorrow at which time his remarks might properly be addressed the Committee. As there was no further business to come before the Council, it was moved by Trimm, seconded by Schellert, to adjourn. The motion carried, and the meeting was adjourned 12:05 p.m. h.(Jr,,, ,,.., )47: //e,L 4.4 i L.• Helmie Nelson, City Clerk L. 17. C __car, Mayor Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting 2-19-68 COMMUNICATIONS: (Cont.) Letter from Jack Wilson, City Engineer, submitted statement in sum of $383.88 due Cornell, Howland, Hayes and Merryfie3d for work in connection with Well No. 8 to January 24, 1968. Approval for payment was recommended. Moved by Morris, seconded by Bruce, to refer the payment to the Auditing and Accounting Committee with power to act. Carried. Claim submitted by Donna and Rodney Stewart was read requesting reimbursement of $49.87 for damage to water tank elements when water was shut off and water drained out of the tank. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to refer the Claim to the City Attorney and Insurance Carrier. Carried. Document from Robert J. Hall, Attorney for Mrs. ljaz 1 W. Chenaur, requested Council reconsideration of rezone denial noting grievance that all evidence had not been presented at the hearing, particularly exhibit of photographs and color slides as V w� I shown tothePlanning Commission. MovedbyPerry, secondedby Schellert, that the Councilreconsider itsactionof the prior meetingas requestedCarriedMoved Gby Perry, seconded by Garrett, to refer the matter of the rezone to the Planning Committee to report back. Carried. Letter from Renton School District 403, Rudolph Seppi, Director of Plant Facilities. requested approval from the citytor service to the new EErIington Elementary SC'h�1, to be located at South 132nd Street and Langston Road, King County, by the sanitary sewer system of the City, costs to be the School Districts and Late Cdflffers Agreement to be allowed for recovery or portion of the cost. Moved by Garrett, seconded by Morris, to grant the request with referral to the Law and Ordinance Committee to prepare the necessary documents. Councilman Barei reported that the Sanitation Committee has a recommendation for approval of this request. The motion carried. Letter from Mr. Ray Van Hollebeke, Property Management, The Boeing Company, requested permission to install a 12,000 gallon propane gas tank on property located in area North of 6th Avenue North, now under lease from the City. Drawing attached indicated the location of the tank and piping. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Bruce, to refer the request to the Property Committee for recommendation. (Fire Chief and City Engineer to be consulted) Carried. Letter from John E. Iverson, Attorney, petitioned, on behalf of Mr. and Mrs. Roger A. Hokanson, for consent to transfer,and sale of their interest in the Renton Radio Cab Co., Inc. New owners are individual holders of For-Hire Licenses and will continne to operate as drivers and include: Phillip A. Schmolke, present owner, °(;?:' Gerald Halstead, present owner, and Michael Craig, 10931 S.E. 164th Street, Renton. Moved by Perry, seconded by Garrett, to refer the matter to the Police and License Committee for recommendation. Carried. Letter from Jack Wilson, City Engineer, reported that the letter of intent to annex property to Renton which adToins Sunset Blvd. E., between 132nd Ave. S.E. and 138th Ave. S.E, is signed by owners representing 84.74% of the assessed valuation of the w property, which is located on both sided of the highway and contains approximately Die 13.6 acres with an assessed valuation of $15,600.00. Annexation would make the City Limits more uniform in this area. The petitioners are Alhoff. Smith & Beale_and '-' ' I/I�� matter has been referred to the Boundary Review Board. I/ Letter from Sven A. Johnson, Building Director, recommended that Revocable Sign Permit be issued for sign encroachment of public right-of-way for Montgomery Ward & Co. at 319 Williams Avenue South. Moved by Perry, seconded by Barei, to concur in the recommendation. Carried. Letter from Building Director Johnson recommended that Revokable Sign Permit be granted upon revised application of Dr. Hurley at 911% South 3rd Street, since original sign was installed to different plans than submitted. Moved by Perry, seconded by Trimm, to concur in the recommendation of the Building Director. Carried. Letter from W.E. Bennett, Utility Accountant, submitted proposed Agreement between the City and Fire District No. 25 regarding obligation and responsibility for fire hydrant.maintenance and inspection, and consideration to be paid the City of Renton therefor. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Edwards to authorize and approve the execution. Moved by Perry, seconded by Grant to refer the document to the Fire and Water Committee for recommendation. Carried. -2- Minutes - Renton City Co4.,.i1 Meeting (Cont.) 2-5-68 Mayor Custer introduced a group of students from Renton High School Boys Club who are attending the Council meeting in participation of Student Government Week. Attendance on a voluntary basis included about 25 youths who will also be coming to City Hall during the coming week for two hours daily to observe operation of various departments. A mock City Council meeting will be conducted by the group on Saturday, February 10th, between 10:00 a.m. and noon and Councilmen and Depart- ment reads were invited to attend. P':TLIC 1EEARINC: Hazel W. Chenaur appeal of R-3 rezone denial on property located on the West side of 116th Avenue S.E . between S .E . 110th and S .E . 112th Streets. This being the date set, the hearing was declared open. Letter from Planning Director Erickson reported Planning Commission recommendation that,since detrimental effects could be anticipated and such rezone not being in the best interest of the surrounding residential area, R-1 be considered the best and highest use for this property. Petition containing approximately 20 signatures was attached objecting to the rezone which document had been submitted to the Planning Commission. Mr. Robert Hall, 419 Securities Building, Seattle, Attorney representing Mrs. Chenaur, stated that the proposed use is felt to be the fullest and best for the property noting the proximity of other multiple dwellings in the immediate vicinity and apartment directly behind the proposed development. He added that such housing is greatly needed, that the plans meet with the presently existing Comprehensive (� P1..in and that the property had once been rezoned to R-3 but reverting according to `�J an ordinance which had a one year construction commencement provision, since repealed. Topography of the area was outlined with embankment division from singly family area bei:ig noted and Attorney Hall stated developers would be able to furnish parking as it required and would be willing to work out any further matters required or desirable. Film slides were shown by the Planning Director after which Councilman Shane inquired regarding apparent drainage problems noted when visiting the site and also 1 in regard to sewering the area. Planning Director Ericksen advised that all such detail N have to be worked out prior to occupancy of the premises and all Departments concerned must approve the particular portion of the proposal which is under their jurisdiction. Discussion ensued regarding conformancy of procedures on various applications submitted and Planning Director Ericksen noted that the Commissions actions are uniform and on th basis of the Comprehensive standpoint. Specific detrimental effects were noted to L i._ be traffic congestion and loss of privacy to individual property owners on the lower sites. The Planning Director noted the project does not meet with the proposed Comprehens ve 27.7n .Moved by Morris, seconded by Edwards that the hearing be closed. Carried. Moved b- Morris, seconded by Perry, that the appeal be denid in concurrence with the Planning Ccarnission recommendation that R-1 is th best and hi hest us f r rope - A dissenting voice vote rou request for roll call which resulted as follows: Ay?: Morris, Schellert, Delaurenti, Perry, Trimm, Edwards, Maxin and Bruce. Nc: Garrett, Grant, Shane and Barei. The motion carried denying the appeal. CC MUNICATIONS: Application from Mr. Robert H. Schlosser, Mgr.,Cougar Den, 219 Main Avenue South, requested that Mutual Amusement Company be granted required license to operate an additional pinball device at said business location. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert, to refer the matter to the Police and License Committee wi power to act, which' carried after .inquiry regarding the legality of pinball machines an their comparison to punch boards. Dis9vssion ensued wherein the City Attorney advised of reme Court ruling, based upon Atey General's Opinion that they are both gaming d vices and where chance predominates over skill the activity is outlawed and illegal with the three elements under which court decisions are determined being 1. consideration is paid o participate; 2. mu t be some kind of reward; 3. element of uncertainty exists. In furthe discussion City torney Shellan stated the City has a ri.sht, which goes back to common ru law, to 1' nse under its police power and can im- pose a license or regulatory fee. Cou ilman Shane felt the pinball and punch board devices should be treated equally and mo , with second by Schellert, that if pinballs are illegal they be taken out tomorrow. t 'was subsequently moved by Morris, seconded by :truce, to refer the matter to the law and Ordinance Committee to report back. Moved by Barei, seconded by P 'ry, to table e matter. Carried. Letter from Vern Church, Purc asing Agent, reported th specifications are now prepared and requested permission to call for bids for equipment which has been provided for in the 1968 budget. Febru y 26th was recommended as the bid opening date. Moved by Morris, seconded by Schellert o concur in the request and recommended bid opening date. Discussion ensued regarding the City maintenance program for city streets and the pec-ibility of contracting such work. It was noted that cities usually do their own maintencnce, and after further discussion regarding operation of the city equipment budget, and departmental administration, question was called for on the pending motion to con2ur in the bid call and opening date and the motion carried. -2- - . - - • February 5P� 1968 �. • • Mayor Donald W. Custer Members 'of the City Council Renton,', Washington .. Re: Appeal of HIazel, W. Chenaur Rezone :Denial, Appi. Ito. R-436-67, rezone request .from R_1. to.. .R-3; property located, west side , S.E.- of 116th Ave. between S. . .110th and 112tI1 Sts. .. G ntleman The Planning Commission' considered .thae. hazel W. Chenaur rezone application at its meeting of December 27, '1967. 1 The property in question;'haas:. the following basic char- acteristics: Total Area--25,116 sq. ft.. ,. . existing Zoning-_R-'1 -,xisting ,Use--single . family dwelling Principal 'Access-e116th Ave. S.E.'. via S.E. 110th . . 1 C : �;• Proposed' Use--multi--family residential . h�:'� ' Comprehensive Plan--low 'to,medium density multi-� ' ,!' family_•"residential (revised' , ll ,ee -. 'Comprehensive Plan indicates: : / F, : :single family residential)` • ! / v The property under .consideration.:is located westerly of • ;r) existing apartment unity and a::single family residence (?( ! and. easterly of : Rilicrest Lane, a newly developed single , , ' _family residential plat. The proposed rezone would al- . .., i low the construction of medium density apartments with an''average of 25 to 30. units 'anticipated. • ' The Planning Commission reviewed the rezone request in some .detail. A petition signed by some 20 property .owners.. ''in the vicinity .protesting, the rezone ,request was also presented to: the Planning Commission. ' • • ' c. Mayor and City Council February 5, 1968 Page 2 Upon completion of its deliberations, the Planning Com- mission determined that the zoning requested would not be appropriate for the property in question since detri- mental effects could be anticipated and it would not be in the best interests of the surrounding residential area. The Planning Commission further recommended to' the City Council that the highest use of the property be R-1 as presently zoned. Very truly yours, Gordon Y. Ericksen Planning Director I \ r Th / OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK • RENTON, WASHINGTON CITY HALL, CEDAR RIVER PARK, RENTON, WASHINGTON 98055 • ALPINE 5-3464 - o 9�sAoR0- January 4, 1968 CAPITPkof Murray, Dunham & Wa itt . Attorneys at Law Suite 419 Securities Building Seattle, Washingt)n 98101 Re: Hazel W. Chenaur Appeal. of Renton P'aiming Commission Rezone Denial Gentlemen: The Renton City Council, at its regular meeting of January 8th, has set February 5, 1968 at 8:00 p.m. in the Council. Chambers, City Hall, Renton, Washington as the tine and place for hearing on the above- captioned appeal. . It is requested that you and/or applicant be present for discussion of the matter. Yours very •truly, CITY OE RENTON, Helmi.e'i . .Nelson City Clerk HWN/dm '' a, LtotV , . . - _ . ,__,,, , , , , ktii -v , __ . , „,,<,,e. , _ ___. - ,z_fr47 //fAg ____ BEFORE THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON IN THE MATTER OF THE ) No. R-436-67 , ICATI OF ) i' HAZEL W. ' CHENAUR ) NOTICE OF APPEAL OR CHANGE OF ZO ) . TO: The Secretary of the Planning Commission of t it of Renton PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that the appli HAZEL W. CHENAUR, does hereby give notice of her appeal to i of the City of Renton, Washington, from each and every part of the .'. order and decision of the Planning Commission of the City of Renton, made Wednesday evening, December 27, 1967, and whereby ' '. her petition endapplication for reclassification of the following described property from R-1 to R-3 was denied: The west 130 feet of the north one-half of Tract 211, CD Hillman ' s Lake Washington Garden ` „: of Eden Division No.. 4, according to plat y recorded in Volume 11, of plats, page 82, in Yoe- Ding County, Washington, except the north 30 fe, w; .;•y -of said Tract 211, conveyed to the City of ,�� ; � `;,�4. "Rentonby deed recorded under auditor ' s file :a , ' 4q No. 5383778. ,,v" `) :(' ` You"are hereby requested to transmit your completw-c?^eT , c E t;y err ', in this matter to the City Council of Renton, ' `'c4,?21G1nk `' DATED this jrday of January 1968. d r Robert J all ,',' Attori or Hazel W. Chenaur' : cc: City Council, City of Renton , City Hall, Renton, Washington •,' '0,..c ....- /174„4.--744,t,4-,,..*i, , • 9- G F ✓/// �, ' +fix " ; BEFORE THE PLANNING COMMISSION • 'OF_ THE CITY...OF 'RENTON WASHINGTON : IN THE MATTER OF. THE )._:: No. R-436-67 APPLICATION OF: : : HAZEL W. CHENAUR ) -.:NOTICE OF APPEAL.. FOR CHANGE OF ZONING " ': :- TO: The Secretary of. the Planning commission of the City, of:. Renton PLEASE 'TAKE.:NOTICE, ;:that ,the,l appl icant, HAZEL .W. :,CHENAUR, " does hereby give:_notice' of her:Lappeal.' to the 'City-'Council"::of . the .City, of Renton, ,Washington,;-:from each and .every- part : of the > ' ,order: and decision of the Planning Commission of:. the City of ; -, Renton; -made' Wednesday:"•evening, December ' 27, "1967,':..and -whereby • her petition-'and' application '.for :reclassification 'of the 'following described' property. from, R-1':to, R-3: was denied: The. west, 130 feet of the north one-half of Tract 211,' CD: 'Hillman' s; Lake- Washington :Garden'• :. , of Eden Division :No.. .4, . according to ;plat. ; • recorded in Volume'11, of plats, ' page 82, ,iri King .County, Washington, except• the north 30 _-fee; \�- ' , of. .said• Tract' 211, conveyed- to the, City of' i s �.`\ Renton bar .deed recorded under auditor 's. file - .. imi 1938 .:,\ No.. 53837.78.:- - , ` . ; `' . - D El.�., , :RE :;' :� You are .hereby• requested 'to transmit" your 'complete, ,, - c4 o RI4�S offIGE :� . . .. sue.;�� ��;. • in this matter to ,the City.' C,ouncil: of Renton. , DATED: this da of Januar 1968. : 3YcP y : y • .,. � • ... '- - -_• %s%:Robe ". �Iall . _ • . ' ; . =. Attorney for Hazel W. =Chenaur. ` cc, ,. City Council, :City_ of- Renton,:, _ • , .City'Hall, Renton, Washington - , , , :RECrUD o JAN .8: I96g Renton Planning Commission Meeting December 27 , 1967 Minutes Page 4 i arrow and on a hillside. Teegarden stated he felt it would be a mi ake to allow an apartment building at the end of such a nar- row st et at this time. Forgaard as d when the Transamerica property to the south and - t of the subjec property was rezoned to R-3. The Planning Di - tor replied this wa done in 1963. Transamerica has indicat- - it does not plan to open cess to the Renton Hill area or de - op their R-3 area at this time. Comments from the audie ce were invited. Mr sack Newell stated he is the property owner imhdiately east of e applicant' s property and is definitely opposed any multi- ily residential develop- ment in the area; that he fe- s the a - -a is an established single family residential zone. As there were no further comme. s, 't was moved by Stredicke, seconded by Forgaard, that t- - heari - be closed. Motion carried unanimously. ACTION: Moved by Teegarden, seconded by Stredicke, tha' the rezone applica- tion of Albert . Duncalf for R-3 zoning be denies Motion carried unanimously. The Chai an advised the applicant of his right to appea the decisi of the Planning Commission by written notice to t' - City Counc 1 within ten days. *(c) Chenaur, Hazel W. , Appl . No. R-436-67 , rezone from R-1 to 1 R-3; property located west side of 116th Ave. S.E. between S.E. Tt0th and 112th Sts. (westerly of McKnight Jr. High School) The rezone application was described by the Chairman; and the loca- tion of the property was pointed out by the Planning Director on the zoning map. The Planning Director indicated that access to the property was via an undeveloped right of way. Slides of the property were shown. Photographs of the property submitted by the applicant were passed around among the Commissioners . The Planning Director stated that in 1956 the property was zoned R-3 , but as it was not developed it reverted back to R-1 status under a reversion ordinance in effect at that time. The Chairman read a petition against the rezone submitted by property owners in the area and bearing 20 signatures . The Planning Director stated that the existing Comprehensive Plan indicates this area as low to medium density multi-family resi- dential, but that the revised Comprehensive Plan now under study by the City Council cuts this area back to single family residential. Comments from the audience were invited. Mr. Roger Peterson, 10514 - 113th Ave. S.E. , owner of property westerly of subject property, voiced his objections to the proposed rezone. Mr. George Rusk, 11029 - 116th Ave. S.E. , stated he owns a house north of 110th which he had purchased with the stipulation the area was R-1 , but had found out later that a portion of land nearby was zoned R-3 upon which two apartment houses have been constructed. Renton Planning Commission Meeting December 27, 1967 Minutes . Page 5 . Mr. Rusk stated he, was opposed to further apartment.. development in , the area. , Mr.. .Robert Hall- of Seattle identified himself as attorney for the applicant, Mrs.. Chenaur, and gave a brief history of the property in question. He stated that his client is asking for the zoning which had previously been granted and ,which 'had been. lost. due to the reversion ordinance then in effect which has since been re- pealed. He discussed the undevelopediaccess road about which there appeared to be some title cloud. '. Mr. Hall stated this undeveloped access according to all, information he has been. able to get belongs. to the City of Renton. He stated the rezone is a logical one; would have no effect on_ the single family residential-area known as Hill- crest Lane directly to the. west..as those houses are below his client° s. property and face away from it. He stated further that cost of development of. the property makes .it economically unfeasible for anything but multi-family residential use. Mr. Bob Harris, 10843 - 116th Ave:. S.E. spoke in. opposition to the rezone due. to the immediate proximity of $20 ,000 - to $40 ,000 homes . Mr. Jerome Stephenson, ,. 11430 S.E. 112th St. , 'asked how sewer lines could be connected- to the: property. The Planning Director displayed a sanitary sewer. and water lines map- for the area, and stated that due to the elevation the developer could get sewers . only through the west side of the property by obtaining easements through ad- jacent properties. He stated further that there are sewer lines along 11.6th Ave, S.E. butthey . could not go easterly due to the elevation unless some sort of pumping system was installed. Mr. Clayton Chenaur' discussed the history of the property; the fact. that. he. thought he had- the proper zoning, being unaware., of the reversion to R-1; the access problem, the. development of sewers , the cost of development .being too., high for other than multi,-family - use. He stated that ;he development would be adequately served by . sewers ' and would be screened to protect adjacent residences. He urged- the Commission to grant, the rezone. Stredicke stated that the area, notwithstanding the two existing apartments, has been.developed for single family .use and- he. would not be in.. favor of rezoning for multiple use: Messrs. Stephenson, Peterson, Rusk- and Harris , previously acknowledged, spoke..again in protest agailist the., rezone, as well as Mr. Ronald Wy- let of 11020 - 115th Ave. S.E. Mr. Robert: Hall ,and Mr. Clayton Chenaur spoke again on behalf of the rezone request. There being no further, comments, , it was -moved by Stredicke, seconded by Teegarden, that the hearing be closed. - Motion carried unanimously. ACTION: Moved b Stre the application of daze .. Chenaur for rezone from R-1 to R-3 be denied. Motion , carried unanimously. Further moved by Stredicke; seconded by Teegarden, that a communica- tion be. sent,.to the, City Council .;recommending that. the highest' use. of this property be R-1 - as presently zoned. Motion carried unani mously. . , Renton Planning Commission Meeting December 27, 1967 Minutes Page 6 . The- Chairman- advised the applicant ' s attorney of her right of appeal of the Planning Commission decision by letter to the City . Council within ten days. Mr. Hall stated he. understood the appeal rights of his client. • ._ _,... D ,_ , . — * A IVE MATTERS • REFERRAL FROM RENTON BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT ( Albert Balch and Garden Park, Inc. , request for variance fr.Y height limitation. The C'',, irman stated that the- Board of Adjustment h.4 referred the above :.riance application to the Planning Commission and referred the Comm'Assioners to copies of Board of Adjustmerli Minutes as well as copy. o letter from the FAA relative to the Atter; such copies in each Co lissioner' s -folder. ACTION: Moved by Brower, , seconded by Racanello, th,'' this matter be- con- sidered at the net Administrative Meetin;; of the Renton Planning Commission ,in orde . to give the Commission time to study the material submitted. ' Motion carried unanimously. STREET NAME PROBLEM (b) The Chairman read a . etter from Fire Chief M. C. Walls concern- ing duplication of street ').ame in. hunder Hill #2 , parcel #26 . The Planning Director stated th;.t t ,Is particular street (Thomas Lane) is privately owned. and the Cis - has no control over it. He sug- gested the Commission might w' .h to refer the matter to the Board of Public Works for their re ) e,.. ACTION: Moved by Stredicke, seco.:ded by Raca ello, that a copy of Fire Chief Walls ' letter be sent • the Mayor' s 'Affice and to the Board of Public ,Works for their. action. , Motion carried unanimously. APPOINTMENT OF NEW ;°'CANNING COMMISSION MEMBER (c) The Chairma .: read copy. of. a letter fro, Mayor D. W.. Custer tO the City Counci ' appointing Mr. Tony Mola a ' a member of the, Renton Planning Commi sion to fill the vacancy- crea ',-d by the resignation of Mr., Stanie Stone and requesting concurren `'7 of the Council in this appoint:ent. RESIGNATIOi . OF PLANNING COMMISSION MEMBER (d) Mrs Robert_Brower announced that regretfully t\is would be his last meting with the Planning Commission as he had 'een; recalled to acive duty• with the United States Navy, and state:, it had been a pr"vilege- to serve blithe Commission. S E PLAN APPROVAL (Request for Information) e) Stredicke asked if site plans had been submitted for >, e ///4( , approval of the Planning Commission . for the church located 7th and M. The- Planning Director replied that this church had submitted their site plans as well as a variance, request for parking and had received approval of thesite ,plans on March 28 , 1962 . . He stated RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION PUBLIC HEARING MEETING DECEMBER 27 , 1967 AG E N D A 1. ROLL CALL 2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES , MEETING OF DECEMBER 13, 1967 3. BUSINESS CONTINUED FROM MEETING OF NOVEMBER 22 , 1967 : REZONE APPLICATION (a) Barger, Lyle L. , Appl. No. R-433-67, rezone from R-1 to R-3; property located at 2502-04 9th P1. N. Total Area--app. 10 , 000 sq. ft. Existing Zoning--R-1 Existing Use--duplex family dwellings Principal Access--9th P1. N. Proposed Use--multi-family residential Comprehensive Plan--multi-family residential 4 . NEW BUSINESS : REZONE APPLICATIONS (a) Singer, Dean A.. , Appl. No. R-434-67 , rezone from R-2 to R-4 ; property located on H. St. between llth and 12th Aves. N. Total Area--27 , 590 sq. ft. Existing Zoning--R-2 Existing Use--duplex family dwellings Principal Access--llth Ave. N. , 12th Ave. N. , H St. Proposed Use--multi-family residential Comprehensive Plan--multi-family residential (b) Duncalf, Albert L. , Appl. No. R-435-67 , rezone. from R-1 to R-3; property located on east side of Cedar St. between S . 7th St. and S. . 8th St. (extended westerly) Total Area--7, 975 sq. ft. Existing Zoning--R-1 Existing Use--single family dwelling Principal Access--Cedar St. Proposed Use--multi-family residential Comprehensive Plan--multi-fancily residential (revised Comprehensive Plan indicates single family residential) JAr (c) Chenaur, Hazel W. , Appl. No. R-436-67 , rezone from R-1 to R-3; property located west side of 116th Ave. S .E. between S .E. 110th and 112th Sts. (westerly of McKnight Jr. High School) • Total Area--25 ,116 sq. ft. Existing Zoning--R-1 Existing Use--single, family dwelling Principal Access--116th Ave. . S.E. via S.E. 110th St. R/W Proposed Use--multi-family residential Comprehensive Plan--low to medium 'density multi-family residential (revised Comprehensive Plan indicates single family residential) 5. ADMINISTRATIVE MATTERS : (a) Referral from Renton Board of Adjustment re Albert Balch and Garden Park Inc. , request for variance from height limitation. (b) Let' er from Fire Chief M. C. Walls re street name in Thunder Hill #2 , parcel #26. , • (c) Letter_ from Mayor D. W. Custer re: Appointment of Mr. Antone Mola, to Planning Commission. :� Ec �V DEC .22 Mr- Dc. 21, 1967 , (.\(6 4._ .,4;" 1, <4.e:///NG13 :_____,,,,,,,<y/ PA To: The Renton Planning ComMu.44.Lon . l Char The undeaai ned aae agai.nw.t ,the paopo4ed ae3oni.ng, .in. -the vicLn.i y o4 116 h Ave. 5.6. Between 5.6. 110ih, and 112,th Spa. GUe ; 130' o -the noa:Dz luzq o/ £'act 211 C.D. //LCLinan'a Lahe Waah region 9aitden o/ &en DLvi.,o,ion No. 4 Accoad t. .to pia) aecoaded in Vol 22 (.4. plat page 82 .i..n King, Courz 4 (Ua4/trepan, • - ' &xcep.t Noath 30' and UJe4,t 30' 4 aai.d /tact 211 conveyed the City o4 'Renton by aecoaded undea Audi vna &L.e No. 5383178 We, .the undelw ned jeei .h.ii altea .ah.ou,Ll be used j°oa ae4LleniLa-1 only, •and .the aes,on.i.n., :ahvwLd not be g anued. ADDS' SS ' t� PO 7),,6_ax), 0L,,,,z, • /0gii-, . /74..A,/„ . ,i-/ -i- , to Y 1/3 - // 64 `-4-f-ce- d'Pc . i 11 . 110.2. 7 • /U TgaAt-f& iptdi,e, ir/ (:„.1,v14.1 a77(=> Az.z_tclit • ,, ,, x • // 6 tif elze. s e -id-a-re7,z-, ,m, ,p,--E-6-- ik./..0_.__ __ .. . ...,(..... ,,J . „7 //0,8,_ „.-_ 6,e,- 4_e, ..c. z, . /6_,,, ,,,i ._,(„4,,,I,. pz.",__..)1,&iel,„47.---) //hl.3a Je//, ,Gti77�- 4,0„, �6-JZ"--1 44-0=.,e..— // >'3 o .a. //.r Z �r -' - 2x2' CiL"\AAIL., 4' , \ : • ) 1 o a L/ — i/L .-: 74 5, , 6°,,z4,(7-Le.-- i -1,k, ;',1 //, ifz6Z------ // ,72 o - //57 -- • - ' , ‘ V , ,::6.t>rer)---. K-.- ' :f" -- s--.(‘ ,S -E- ai,C1.,.. _ (GO . • .Zb.,(,,-; • (.,(:''.4,.4 .0_,t7 ; -27r 4/�/ l z'x i f4 z- S6 /F 77 vJ ) ai,/ g7. eced-1-- . i/ o2_•1_. //s-- / _ . w .r' //!/ 2 i/J he . J4 ..`''' / -,,,, e . NAIL ADD?6SS ' (----1,, ,e-_-.--)e- ---'' . 6------;-e_e---)f_p-,. //o/ z z/5" ' ./9i2. : 5Ze /‘a-i--z7-, 1-'ex--24 s/' ; - C-,jce__5 4. / 1-iiki. M' t_.// // / /J7-h, axe,. -i--, ._,,,_ --,./7) . X "—P)/L.<7 . . /' 27 ( Ca / ) "L �it- . e`—.. /( /7 S //Z- / e . ` , .2g, .. ,;?L, 4 . . // c(( ‘ s.),00 . /..zifri_ _ t: /.. . , ,,;;:).:.,, ,. ._),....7 .. ,77 , „ . r___ . ,::::) .• :,, , , _ /4.,,e/ i &4:/ ..c.a/1::Z... . .//:, ',.z„----J-, I//4_4 ( .7,;:),,,e.4,zi e,,...,Zi,i;,,,, ,.-,•ej lel„. .,..5 - / • . .. . • ;.. , k-ci OFF . 6 -r). t I-, Fc �.) o • . z . , , =,-!. "--.... '96T 1, AG OFAAR Renton Planning Commission Meeting December 13, 1967. Minutes Page 2 . (c) Chenaur, Hazel W. , Appl. No. R-436-67 , rezone from R-1 to R-3; property located west side of 116th Ave. S.E. between S.E. 110th and 112th Sts. (westerly of McKnight Jr. High School) The Planning Director pointed out the location of the property on the zoning map and stated that the property at one time was zoned • R-3 but had reverted to R-1. The existing Comprehensive Plan indicates low to medium density multi-family residential for the property, but the revised Comprehensive Plan indicates the area as single family residential. The slides mentioned above were shown. 4. DATE NEXT FIELD TRIP: It was decided that each Commission•member would inspect the above properties individually and the official field trip would be dis- pensed with for this agenda. 5. ADMINISTRATIVE MATTERS : (a) CALENDAR OF MEETINGS FOR 1968 : Copies of the Calendar of Meetings of the Planning Commission for 1968 were distributed to Commission members and will be- distributed to City Departments, City Council members, news media, etc. (b) DISCUSSION OF PLANNING MATTERS: The Planning Director stated, for the information of the Commission, that the Planning Department, in cooperation with the Engineering and Building Departments, has revised the Subdivision Ordinance and it will be presented to the Planning Co for ids on- sideration. He stated the Commission might wish to set some study session meetings for next year to review this material. Teegarden stated he felt some work could be done to standardize zoning ordinances and zoning terms throughout the valle'�y are. Racanello stated he felt some work should be done to upgrade the Renton Zoning Ordinance.; that we may not have enough zoning clas- s' Ica ions o cove ype of developments proposed and to encourage private urban renewal. He stated further he felt there should be another zoning classification between L-1 and M-P and that perhaps the Commission could study this posgi,Allt.y. Stredicke stated he felt that in connection with the Planning Commission' s action concerning the preliminary plat of Interlake Addition No. 2 considered at the public hearing meeting of Novem- ber 22, 1967, that a further motion to deny the application should have been made. Garrison stated that a motion to deny was unneces- sary as the motion to approve lost; therefore, the application was denied and the applicant was advised of his right to appeal. Stredicke inquired as to the status of the restrictive covenants concerning the Richards rezone. The Planning Director stated that after several meetings with Mr. Richards, a declaration of restrictive covenants had been drafted in accord with the wishes of both Mr. Richards and the Planning Commission. • AFFIDAVIT I, Hazel W. Chenaur being duly sworn, declare that I am the owner' of the property involved in this application and that the foregoing statements and answers herein contained and the information herewith submitted are in all respects true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief. Subscribed and sworn before me this 7 & day of December , 19 67_ Notary Public in and for the State of Washington, residing at Seattle ( a ) ( ignature of Owner) P.O. Box 66430 /.5 vd_ 7a 7:1-1 f� ith& 400 S. W. 152nd Street (Address) (Mailing Address) Seattle, Washington 98166 (City) (State) CH6-1520 (Telephone) (OFFICE USE ONI,Y) CERTIFICATION This is to certify th he foregoing application has been inspected by me and bas been fo horough and complete in every particular and to conform t • he /� , regulations of the Menton Planning Department gove g �i f 1/�' 1 ' of such application. - Date received DEC 7 1967 , 19 BY: � Renton Planning Dept. APPLICATION FOR CHANGE OF ZONE HAZEL W. CHENAUR TABLE of CONTENTS Page 1. Application for change of zoning ', 2. Affidavit of owner 3 . Plot plan ,(1" = 50 ' ) and vicinity plan (1" = 200 ' ) 4. Copy of existing zoning map of Renton showing proposed change 5. Portion of King County Assessor 's map (S.E.' 45-23-5) showing property in vicinity; Scale 1 ' = 100 ' 6. Photographs of property involved . • RECD 6 DEC 7, 1967 "2* .k.' ''"' .VE1L44CtZi BICE •tii • , , t _5 46144leM4iffebt) • ' - • , -• --i . ...---1, 5883 i 78 • . ,,--. voi 4-144( — YI , . ... . . „. , • . . ...._, - , . . . , ! ' 1 •:, f ' .• ., et 9 iI- • 001 . . . , • . tr„ H. cA •,• , .., . i , • , . • ...., 1 - ' ,..' . • . • ., . . • . . . ..,.,. ... . . ., . .. . • 0 . • . • . , .• .".E,447,,,:i ',,,- •,1.7,-.-_ ' , 1 4 . ... . . ,.„ ... .. , .„ CH :73 I 01 CD CI i rxii go ••• er''.,-. ''''[;::'''.'',.. . •• . . l' F-1 4-' 1 CD .1-1 . — .. . . .. : ,"::.-Y ',•'''',.. I ' • :.• , , -,,,t,k i. ., . ,;.• 1: , II CD ' . ' • 1 ., .., • - . • - ''.' . .. . . , .,. ,• . . . -1,,,,,• , - ' , .- • " . . :- • ..,.,„ . . • . .. , ,, •. - QUIT CLAIM DEED ., , . . .. . .. . . . . . . . . , . .. • . . ,. ... i THIS INDENTURE WITNESSETH: 'That we, Herbert.T. 'Hacicrian and . -- . • ; ..,- . . i .,,,•,. . , .• i ''. . Pleiba'B. Haekman, wife . , of King County, State of Washington, for and ... • , .in'epnaideration of the sum of One ( 1.00) Dollar to us in hand paid and in further .- _, -,, consideration Of the general public welfare and the special benefits accruing to us ', . . .therefrom; do, by these presents' grant, convey and quit-claim to the City of Renton, . - a,munibipal'oorporation of the State of WAShington„ for street, alley and any other A . public uses and purposes, the following lots, pieces and parcels of land lying and, ' ..,-..being in -said King. County„ State of Washington, and described as follows:,, / 'pie riue.,(1•Zpim...F ,OP • , ,/ )/. . , ', .,,,.,,, ‘•,, . . r „ -; •• .„ . ' lt) ,• .-+. • , e .'/, .. .. • : ',e.,.. r. "The north 30 feet and th s 40) feet ofli-fract 211, C. D. Hillman's • ' ,. _ , Lake Washington Garden of Eden, Division No. 4." . . . ,. . .., . . . . . , . . . .. ,. . , . . , . . . ,., . . • ., , , • • .'• ' '. ••. ' :- ' : ''' f:. ,-..., ..:• . . - • .. . - .. . . , . ,. . . .. .-. - • ,. . , . r- ... ,. . , . . . . ' . .• . „- . „.„,. . . .. ',•• • - ... ... . . . . .. ,. „ ... 0. . . -. .. . . „ •. ,.. . • • . , . . . ..,;.-.' 70YHAVE AHD TO HOLD the said described premises unto the said City of Renton; .. ' . . ' its' successor or successors for the use of the 'public forever. .- . .:?.. .• • . • • . ., WITNESSETH our hands and seals thista day o , ,46-W64.!1/1'e , 195 7O' , ,. . . ;1. . . . , V: 7?"2-e--/I-4_, A' 2,4c..t., (SEAL) . . .. : ,.., • ' WITNESSES: • , .' STATE OF WASHINGTON)ss . . . : . • •COUNTY OF KING ) ,. . • ' . i...i• , . . . . C.:17.---->f, . , .. • , . . 'V. . - , I.;:'' O. .._,..;,. 4,,...... -2-?:zepa-leare,4 •', a Notary Public in and l'oi.-the said State, do'hereby Certify that 9n this .:-.4— d5. of ' - . --z-,.,,, .-) , 195 .S' p personally .,•:.,i?, pf.,•appeared before me Xv-h -W-5-z,,,--- 7 )44%---2- .57.--,--,02...,--7_-- ...--47-- ,-/-- ••• :0.,. ' Wt to' me known to be the individual, s. . described in and who executed the withip . '''',, ' XI• ':f - . ''• instrument, and acknowledged that --etege,,f signed and sealed the same as free'and voluntary act and '6.eed, for the uses And purposes therein. „ ' ' ,, 141;mentioned. -,-' !-.,-- . , • . • ., t.y. . , .4.r... . . ....,„ ....-. ,.:XNAIT;g4AVEREdbl, I have hereunto set my hand' ard affixed my official seal the ..day4liC„Nt-NA4*}. this certificate- first above written. e, '. , '. '•. '..,: ',,,,,,:",:r. t.)1;•?.-1,"..:` i4-4''''''''' '' ' .. • . . '4,si,.• • , ''1. • 7,'. e.,‘:*„.........,-,?.---:,,:>.-), •:-..V''' C' . ,„-- - 2,-----'' .-c,,,."---../A-= • , , .. . , . mect t‘,..,i ,, !4u gOtary Public in and of • '. , , , • • ,,;,,,, • , ,..n.-.1,-,2i ,-,,,,;,,,,..„,C.,;:',,F.',,,,,''',,',' • Washington at in said County. .' ' -. ,'IfN• • Ot'i'ill,..,,r-z‘i4i4d1 or Record d4'-' cf.' '1.,.'$' .19 44:,. ,./.‘4,,!,;u05,M; liotary„ Public !nand for the State a/ of ,9 ,.‘4 „ _. „ ty . NagunOtisa Reitling at Beaton; • • Filed for Rorecord ,..,..13,/,,,.2 19 6,R, .A,3.„?‘,M. , , • - . 1114,6, PN4I'll g:;MOPRiSfiCoisiX ,icti;-6,,,- _ , rA , NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION RENTON, WASH.INGTON A PUBLIC HEARING WILL BE. HELP BY THE RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION AT ITS REGULAR MEETING IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS, CITY HALL, RENTON, WASHINGTON ON DECEMBLR 27, , 1967 , AT 8 : 00 P .M. TO CONSIDER THE FOLLOWING PETITIONS ; -�- 1. REZONE; FROM I- 2 TO R-4; property located on If St. between llth and I2th Ayes. t . LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lots 4 and 5, "flock 42 , Corrected. Plat of Penton highlands No. 2, according to Plat recorded in Vol. 57 of Plata, Page 92 to SII, Records of King County, Washington. 2. REZONE FROM T --1 TO R--3; property located on Cedar St. between S. 7th St• and dead-end. LEGAL DESCRIPTION F IPTION& Tract 4 of igh1ai d Addition to the Town of Renton., as per plat recorded in Vol. 17 of Plats, page 32, Records of Ring County, Washington° except the north 100 feet thereof; less coal and. mineral rights and tha right to explore and mine same. G1NJ/4\a v C 3. REZONE FRO : R.-1TO R-3 property, located vicinity of 116th Ave. n.,E between S.X. 110th and 112th 5ts. LECAL DESCRIPTION; West 130 feet of the north half of 'Tract 211,. C.D. Hillman's Lake Washington Garden of Eden Division No. 4 according to plat recorded in Vol. 22 of Plats, Pace ' 82, in King County, Washin:Iton, except the north 30 feet and the west 30 feet of said, Traci 21 ) conveyed to the City of Renton by dewed recorded under Auditor' s Pile No. 5383178. ALL PERSONS INTERESTED OR OBJECTING Tq SAID PETITIONS ARE INVITED' TO BE PRESENT AT THE PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING ON December 27, 1967 AT 8 : 00 P .M. TO VOICE THEIR PROTESTS OR OBJECTIONS TO SAME . `Tames E . D' nzer , SECRETARY PUBLISHED December 14, 1967 RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION CERTIFICATION James L. Magstadt , HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THREE COPIES OF THE ABOVE DOCUMENT WERE POSTED BY ME IN THREE CONSPICUOUS PLACES ON THE PROPERTY DESCRIBED ABOVE AS PRESCRIBED BY LAW. ATTEST : Subscribed 4nd sworn SIGN � ^ to befo me a Notary ,Public' oil the S xtn day of DOC�:I!oG APPLICATION FOR CHANGE OF ZONE IN THE CITY OF RENTON FOR OFFICE USE ONLY Appl . No . Plan . Com . Action eve \2-21-1(,7 Receipt No . ViAcik Appeal Filed Filing Date City Council Action „C"nve,k Hearing Date . \Z_an-.o ( Ordinance No . $ Date$ :RUT 5—ap_bq Qe� .� C�r� ¶- l 2 (, AAA APPLICANT TO ANSWER ALL THE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS NEATLY AND ACCURATELY : P.O. Box 66430 Name Hazel W. Chenaur Address 400 S.W. 152nd St. , Seattle, Wh. 98166 Telephone No . CH6-1520 Property petitioned for rezoning is located xbehind apartments on 116th Ave. S.E. between 12th Ave. N (SE 112th St. ) and S. E. 110th St. Total square footage in property 32, 650. 8 LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY West 1301\ of the North half of trart 211 , (' n uillman ' � T31_e Washj atQn Garden of Eden Division No.4 accordin, plat recorded in Volume 1 of Plats, page 82, in King County, Washington, except the North 30 feet,of said tract 211, conveyed to the City of Renton by deed recorded under auditor Cs file No. 5383178 aY\ Jc-Lp, W e sk 3 0 �eek- District Existing Zoning R-1 Single Residence/ Zoning Requested R-3 Residence District What are the uses you propose to develop on this property? construction of apartment house Number of permanent off-street parking spaces that will be provided on property? at leas minimum required Number required NOTE TO APPLICANT : The following factors are considered in reclassifying property . Evidence or additional infor- mation you desire to submit to substantiate your request may be attached to this sheet . (See Application Procedure sheet Item No . 2 for specific requirements) . 1 . In what way is this proposed change in zoning in the public interest? Increase available housing near Boeing and Pacific Car plants; relieve traffic moving through Renton; increase utilization of existing schools; increase taxation to Renton, etc: 2 . On what basis is there a real need in this community for more zoning of the type you request? Expansion of industry in Rainier Valley, particularly Boeing, Pacific Car & Foundry, and other business expansion resulting in -:influx of population. 3 . What provision will you make to protect adjacent and surrounding properties from the detrimental effects of any uses permitted in the proposed zone? Plan attractive structure consistent with other relatively new buildings of similar n e in the area. R RECFIII�o �0 a!_t byy 2 Cow r� nFC 7 1967 Renton Planning Dept . 1967