HomeMy WebLinkAboutLUA70-643BEGINNING
OF FILE
FILE TITLE Wile7\10FILMED
SiA 1 °?)(611
624 70
1/ 3
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
BY
RENTON CITY COUNCIL
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Renton City Council has
fixed- the 23rd -day of March 19 70 , at
8 :00 p.m. in the Council Chambers of the Renton Municipal
Building, Renton, Washington as the time and place for a
public hearing to consider the following:
Appeal of Planning Commission denial of site plan
approval and proposed heavy equipment use in M-P
zone; property located on the east side of the rN
West Valley Highway between S.W. 37th and 38th
Streets .
Any and all interested persons are invited to be present
to voice approval , disapproval or opinions on same .
CITY OF RENTON
Helmie Nelson , City Clerk
DATE •OF PUBLICATION
March 6 , 1970
NOTICE Of PUBLIC HEARING
BY
RENTON CITY COUNCIL
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Renton City Council has
fixed the 23rd day of March 19 2_12_' at
m. in the Council Chambers of the Rentonnicipforal
b
it p• Washington as the time and p ace
Building , Renton,
public hearing to consider the following :
Appeal of Planning Commission denial of site planapprovalandproposedheavyequipmentuseinM-P
zone; property located on the east side of the
West Valley Highway between S .W. 37th and 38th
Streets .
and all interested persons are invited toon hem present
to voice approval ,
Any disapproval or opinions
CITY OF RENTON
Helmie Nelson , City Clerk
DATE •OF PUBLICATION
March 6 1970
70
4./.
711 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
BY
RENTON CITY COUNCIL
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Renton City Council has
fixed the 23rd day of March , 19 70 , at
8 :00 p.m. in the Council Chambers of the Renton Municipal
Building, Renton, Washington as the time and place for a
public hearing to consider the following:
Appeal of Planning Commission denial of site plan
approval and proposed heavy equipment use in M-P
zone; property located on the east side of the
West Valley Highway between S. W. 37th and 38th
Streets .
c'•
Any and all interested persons are invited to be present
to voice approval , disapproval or opinions on same .
CITY OF RENTON
Helmie Nelson , City Clerk
DATE OF PUBLICATION
March 6, 1970
71111
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING S 6 6 y3- 76
BY
RENTON CITY COUNCIL
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Renton City Council has
fixed the 23rd day of March , 19 70 , at
8 :0 p.m. in the Council Chambers of the Renton Municipal
Building, Renton, Washington as the time and place for a
public hearing to consider the following:
Appeal of Planning Commission denial of site plan
approval and proposed heavy equipment use in M-P
zone; property located on the east side of the
West Valley Highway between S.W. 37th and 38th
Streets .
Any and all interested persons are invited to be present
to voice approval , disapproval or opinions on same.
CITY OF RENTON
Helmie Nelson, City Clerk
DATE •OF PUBLICATION
March 6, 1970
NOTICE OF PUBLIC NEARING
BY
v. , ,—
RENTON CITY COUNCIL
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Renton City Council has
fixed the 23Zd day of Parch , 19 70 , at
8 :00 p.m. in the Council Chambers of the Renton Municipal
Building, Renton, Washington as the time and place for a
public hearing to consider the following:
Sti 6ef - 7 )
51: of ''armincr Conivissioll denial of site plan
e-;:,,..ro,/,12 c::,e F:
y,I,ioved 1Ie e;'f7 7 E?qui F)s'7ent use in ! -P
or, : r'q'or,er:t'F 7cf;,1tcc" on the :r?.3'iht 'J!T! a of the
tJt-at- V: lep Zlii;'.m,o?'+ :Jot:.'c• art . . . 37tdh and 38th
Std:ootri.
i
Any and all interested persons are invited to be present
to voice approval , disapproval or opinions on same .
CITY OF RENTON
Helmie Nelson , City Clerk
DATE OF PUBLICATION
March. 6, 2970
CERTIFICATIO N
STATE OF WASHINGTON)
ss .
COUNTY OF KING
I, ra L%-o 1 ,e.„jlereby certify that
three (3) copies of the above notice were. posted by me ,in
three conspicuous places on the property described and one
copy was posted at the City Municipal Building, Renton.,
Washington on ' date of tek/Cre.0 k4 VC) , 19 - -L4— .
Sfgne.
AiTEST:-
vi, ----
7--/E-e-4_,/ i--4---1----1- 1—
No ary. ;Public, in and for the State
of Washington, 'residing at Renton .
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
BY
RENTON CITY COUNCIL Sf 6 3 - ? )
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Renton City Council has
fixed the 23rd day of March , 19 70 . at
S :'00 p.m. in the Council Chambers of the Renton Municipal
Building, Renton, Washington as the time and place for a
public hearing to consider the following:
Appeal of Planning Commission denial of site plan
approval and proposed heavy equipment use in M-P
zone; property located on the east side of the
West Valley Highway between S.W. 37th and 38th
Streets .
Any and all interested persons are invited to be present
to voice approval , disapproval or opinions on same.
CITY OF RENTON
Helmie Nelson , City Clerk
DATE OF PUBLICATION
March • 6 , 1970
CERTIFICATION
STATE OF WASHINGTON)
ss .
COUNTY OF KING
I, . L,,., ,ip6/a.,4 4, ,cgLhereby certify that
three (3) copies of the above notice were posted by Me ,in
three conspicuous places on the property described and one
copy was posted at the City Municipal Building, Renton.,
kashington on ' date of titi4e.TAWr 1.1=, , 19 '7.11=,
1
Signed
ATTEST:'
No't r."y, ,Public. in aril far the State
of" .Wash.ington., 'residing .at Renton.
hda-J essitfQ'v
s' F JTi
c% amaFN
c !
March 20, 1970
Renton City Council
Renton, Washington
Dear Sirs,
5 " " 6 7
We had asked for an appeal hearing on the Planning Commission
descision to reject our use and site plan for the property located
at ;17420 West Valley Road, Renton.
We wish to withdraw our appeal as we wish to revise our site plan
and possible usage.
Thank you.
Sin erely,
6/,John T. Welch
JTW:n
V ,,
Affidavit of Publication
STATE OF WASHINGTON ss.
COUNTY OF KING
1
Toni_ Wellwood
being first duly sworn on
1
oath, deposes a'nd says that
she
is the hief Clerk
of
THE RENTON RECORD-CHRONICLE,a semi-weekly newspaper.That
said newspaper is a legal newspaper and it is now and has been for
more than six months prior to the date of publication referred to,
printed and published in the English language continually as a semi-
weekly newspaper in Renton,King County,Washington,and it is now
and during all of said time was printed in an office maintained at the
aforesaid place of publication of said newspaper. That the Renton
Record-Chronicle has been approved as a legal newspaper by order
of the Superior Court of the County in which it is published, to-wit,
King County, '
Ippeal Planning
Washington.That the annexed is
JJ NOTICE of PUBLIC HFARINC',
Cplmn.
R'` ` RENTON C TYCOUNCIL
NOTICE IS THEREBY,
GIVEN that
3- 6 /3_ 6 the Renton City Council has fixed
the 23rd day of March, 1970, 8i
as it was published in regular issues (and 00 p.m.in the Council ChaB b ..
no,
not in supplement form of said newspaper)once each issue for aperiod the Renton Municipal .Renton; Washington as the time
land place for a public hearing to
one consider the following Commission
of consecutive issues, commencing on the Appeal of Planning royal and
r denial of site plae ppment useproposedheavyqP6March70inM-P zone;property located ondayof19andendingthetheeastsideofthewestValleybetweenS.W.37th andHighway Y
38th Streets. personsdayof19bothdatesAnyandall•inter to voice
inclusive, and that such newspaper was regularly distributed to its are invited to hero al or opinions
subscribers during all of said period.That the full amount of the fee approval, disapproval
t
on same.CITY OF RENTON f`.
s
6.09 Helmie Nelson,City Clerk _-
charged for the foregoing publication is the sum of$which Published in Record-Chronicle
has been paid in full at the rate of$3.20 per folio of one hundred words March e, 1970. R-270.
for the first insertion and$2.40 per folio of one hundred words for each l.---__
subsequent insertion.
N
z Z.6._.. ' 2.Z) Z6.AZa/
Chief Clerk
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 12 day of
Mar&h ,
19
70
I
Notary Public and for the State of Washington,
re id' gat Renton,King County.
Passed by the Legislature, 1955, known as Senate Bill 281,effective
Julie 9th..1955. -
Western Union Telegraph Co.rules for counting words and figures,
adopted by the newspapers of the State.
I -
NOTICE OF PUBLIC NEARING
BY
RENTON CITY COUNCIL
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Renton City Council has
fixed the 9 q,.g day of March ,
19
70 , at
8 :00 p.m. in the Council Chambers of the Renton Municipal
Building, Renton, Washington as the time and place for a
public hearing to consider the following:
Appeal of Planning Commission denial of site plan
approval and proposed heavy equipment use in M-P
zone; property located on the east side of the
West Valley Highway between S.W. 37th and 38th
Streets.
Any and all interested persons are invited to be present
to voice approval , disapproval or opinions on same.
CITY OF RENTON
Helmie Nelson , City Clerk
DATE OF PUBLICATION
M r.:h 5, 1970 '
CERTIFICATION
STATE OF WASHINGTON)
ss .
COUNTY OF KING
I, hereby certify that
three (3) copies of the above notice were posted by me ,in
three conspicuous places on the property described and one
copy was posted at the City Municipal Building, Renton.,
Washington on date of 19
Signed
ATTEST:'
Notary, .Public in and for the 'State
of .Washi'ngton ; 'residing at Renton .
li-;- •'t / I // S 6 5'7.l `, f 5 5 f G 6 cf,:L.,_
P,J
r;
gip ,(,', y
1
1,1 Xi ':..0 i;".1 ',/,,' r.-re (..T., 7.) `P.. _c:, T a 1,1, 0 /-- /°"
1--- '-g- '
S
1 1, ./ 7- /, H •0 . / , i; . I-c
JIakiA
rL. yJb
f4 --7,-/7.22 17 1----)i
e ..,;2y- I It!y ii-:..) I
c _c g l',/,, 1 ..,.. ? /-2?
i 1 t,',.5 ._z -C" .0,--71 I'f'-' 7(
fN
9
V/ , !
r
izeZ,/,,,it,.I
ir\ 7 /1
Z z -4 / .
5. ___- ozSS
ky g. _ oFf
f___,, c.<0,/i ,1
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
BY
RENTON CITY COUNCIL
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Renton City Council has
fixed the 23rd day of march , 19 70 , at
8 :00 p.m. in the Council Chambers of the Renton Municipal
Building, Renton, Washington as the time and place for a
public hearing to consider the following:
of Rle,ininc Comission denial of site plan
i')',rova.f r.'rle 12rocsoC t31?ea7%1 eavipr ent use in M-P
Tone ' p.ropmrt7; 2.f7c4itee On lahm rdr7Mt :'Z 'a;4 of rho
Uest Vi11.ef' V hF:a i :ai:>F.`t"1! .^''. «7tJ and 38th
Ztreets!
Any, and all interested persons are invited to be present
to voice approval , disapproval or opinions on same.
CITY OF RENTON
Helmie Nelson , City Clerk
DATE• OF PUBLICATION
Narch G, 2970
CERTIFICATION
STATE OF WASHINGTON)
ss .
COUNTY OF KING
I, hereby certify that
three (3) copies of the above notice were. posted by me in
three conspicuous places on the property described and one
copy was posted at the City Municipal Building, Renton,
Washington on date of 19
S1}ned
ATTEST:
Notary Public, in and for the State
of Washington , residing at Renton .
L
e ---- .,2 )) / ‘7 0
i
i
i
1
o ti ( ni • (0 tl n/ii755/ o' 4
0,415.76pN° • A)47
6 I)
1
t..... \'''' - • ''..z-, ',t9 -..›
e, 5'.,--,',:',":;,, -.,.`",,,i -\a'•,
ti? --
i 1/17e ) ' ye 19 r,-e 7 /, s
Cl I 0-` 7 R-e 7 l'o 0}
i
yliiii- y--0 / , ')fiy 0 „a -(‘, I ( a y i 41
s
A
1 mc7Y / j3cf---
4
5
s
APPLICATION FOR SITE APPROVAL IN M-P ZONE
CITY OF RENTON
FOR OFFICE USE ONLY
Appl. No. SA - bt\3--10 Hearing Date 2111•10
Filing Date G- 0 Plan. Coma Action UNketo
ag
APPLICANT TO ANSWER ALL THE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS NEATLY AND ACCURATELY:
Name Nilo Willard Address 1.3B44 last St. S_R_ Penton
Telephone No . BA 8-4088
Property petitioned is located on Test Valley '?oad
between ti;.E. 180th Street and Highway 405
Total square footage in property 155,100 more or less
LEGAL^DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY That portion of Section 25, TM:). 23 N., Range 4
East, :'7.''. described as follows: The North 271.25 ft, of the South 601.1 ft. of
Government Tot '7; Less, Pe inning at the Northwest corner of said tract: thence
Southwesterly along the easterly narsin of the "Nest valley road, 60 ft.; thence
southerly, at right antes to said road mar?in, 67 ft.; thence northerly 123 ft.
to a point 88 ft. east of point of ben_iantng: thence westerly 88 ft. to point of
benlnnin,r; less the east 15 ft.; also, less State Ni.hwav 7-)eat. aaui sition.
Existing Zoning a;r*g
What are the uses you propose to develop on this property?
Penair _Shop (R-1, ,Section 11) and Sales Doom (E-1, Section 141
Number of permanent off-street parking spaces that will be provided ori'
property? Nine
Number required Nine
Renton Planning Department
1968
1
Renton Planning Commission
Meeting February ll, 1970
Minutes - Page 3
The applicant was advised of his right to appeal the decision
of; the Planning Commission to the City Council in writing withintendays.
SITE PLAN APPROVAL
b) WILLARD, MIKE, App1. .No. SA-643-70; site approval for
motor vehicle and machinery repair shop and sales room inM-P zone; property located east side of West Valley HighwaybetweenSW37thand38thSts. (continued from January 28, 1970)
The Chairman described the site approval application and statedthematterhadbeencontinuedtopresenthearinginorderto
allow time for the applicant to discuss the application further
with the planning staff and also to allow for the appearance
before the Commission of the property owner, Mr. John Welch.
The Planning Director stated that since the last Commission
meeting, the staff has met with the applicant and the property
owner. Discussions were held concerning the actual use of the
site as well as the site plan itself. The questions essentially '
remain the same--first, is the proposed use permissible in- the
M-P zone; and secondly, is the site plan acceptable in the
opinion of the Planning Commission.
Audience comments were invited. Mr. John Welch, property owner,
stated that inasmuch as the property is zoned M-P, he did not
think it was necessary for the use to be approved by the Com'-
mission. The Chairman replied that some city officials had
felt the proposed use was questionable in the Manufacturing
Par( zone and the matter had been referred to the Planning
Commission to resolve. Normally, the Planning Commission must
approve all site plans in M-P zones, but in this case the ques-
tion of permissibility of use must also be resolved.
Cones-iderable discussion ensued among Commission members, the
Plajnning Director and Mr. Welch concerning his proposed use,
which in essence would be the remanufacture and sale of heavymachinery. The Chairman made the point that the proposed use
lay; on a fine line of being a wrecking yard operation. Mr.
Welch stated that he would abide by the fencing, screening
and! setback requirements of the zone, and if they were vio-
lated, the matter could come under the enforcement arm of the
city' s ordinances. The Chairman stated that the City AttorneyhadIbeenconsultedonthematter, and he had informed the
Planning Department that the permissibility of the use was
not; a legal matter; that it was the prerogative of the Plan-
ning Commission to hear all the facts and determine whether or
not! a proposed use was or was not allowable in the zone.
Discussion followed concerning similar uses in the immediate
area of subject property; it being pointed out that the major-
ity, of these uses are in the city of Tukwila and not under the
control of Renton. The Leber Ink operation to the north is in
the ' city of Renton. Zoning was granted prior to the enactment
of the M-P ordinance, but the applicant accepted B-P (Business
Parking) zoning on that portion of the property fronting WestValleyHighwayuponwhichnostructuresarepermitted. It was
Mr. ,Welch' s contention that his proposed use is permitted under
the {M-P ordinance under that section which states that permitted
use include any use allowable in the L-1 zone together with
such machinery and products manufacturing uses as specified in
Section 4-713 (a) of the Zoning ordinance.
Renton Planning Commission
Meeting February 11, 1970
Minutes - Page 4
Additional audience comments were invited. Mr. Leo Scarsella,
property owner directly 'south of subject property, stated he
would have no objection to the operation provided it were
cleaned up. With reference to poor condition of subject prop-
erty, the Planning Director stated that in accordance with
Commission wishes a letter addressed to W. C. Bogard, District
Engineer, Washington State Highway Commission, Department of
Highways, dated February 2, 1970, was hand delivered to Mr.
Bogard' s office. The letter requested information concerning
the State Highway Department' s intentions relative to the re-
moval of decrepit houses and litter presently on state right-
of-way adjacent subject property. To date, there has been no
reply to this letter.
Referring back to discussion of Section 4-712 : L-1 (Light
Industry) from which the uses permitted in M-P are derived,
the Planning Director stated the Commission' s authority to
decide permissibility of use is contained in (a) Use Permitted:
item (20) , "Other uses which can be reasonably considered simi-
lar or related to the uses listed above (items 1 through 19) ,
upon approval of the Planning Commission.
The Chairman stated the M-P section of the Zoning ordinance is
a fairly new one and was established in order to control indus-
trial development by uses and setbacks, landscaping and screen-
ing. The Earlington Industrial Park was cited as an excellent
example of this use and the avoidance of unsightly manufacturing
uses through application of said controls. At the present time,
wrecking yards are permitted only in the H-1 (Heavy Industry)
district.
Ross stated he felt that to reach a determination of the Com-
miSsion' s definition of the use of this property is paramount
and the Commission should handle this now, keeping in mind the
long term effect the use will have on the city generally and
the adjacent properties in particular.
ACTION:
MOVED BY DENZER, SECONDED BY ROSS, THAT THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S
DETERMINATION OF PROPOSED USE WITH REFERENCE TO APPLICATION NO.
SA-643-70 IS THAT THE STORAGE, REMANUFACTURE AND SALE OF HEAVY
EQUIPMENT IS NOT PERMISSIBLE IN THE MANUFACTURING PARK ZONING
DISTRICT.
On the question, Poff stated that while he is in favor of reduc-
ing, the amount of objectionable sights and noises that go with
this type of land use, that when the Commission talks in terms
ofgood planning one of the main definitions is a certain con-
tinuity of land use in this area. In his opinion, in this case
the' property owner is a victim of circumstances beyond his con-
trol in that when he first acquired the property his proposed
wrecking yard use was permitted in the L-1 district. This use
was repealed and transferred to the H-1 district before he could
put his plans into effect. Poff stated further that he is for
good planning., but he did not think it was fair to make one man
the[ victim of historical circumstances; hence' he was opposed to
the] motion. It was noted by the Planning Director that prior
to rezoning to M-P, the area in question was zoned G allowing
residential uses only.
PENDING MOTION. TO DENY PERMISSIBILITY OF PROPOSED USE. IN M-P
ZONE CARRIED; ONE VOTE DISSENTING .
Renton Planning Commission
Meeting February 11, 1970
Minutes - Page 5
MOVED BY DENZER, SECONDED BY FORGAARD, THAT THE HEARING ON
THE WILLARD SITE PLAN APPROVAL APPLICATION BE CLOSED. MOTION
CARRIED.
ACTION:
MOVED BY FORGAARD, SECONDED BY DENZER, THAT THE SITE PLAN AP-
PROVAL APPLICATION OF MIKE WILLARD BE DENIED AS IT HAS BEEN
DETERMINED BY THE PLANNING COMMISSION THAT THE PROPOSED USE
IS NOT PERMITTED IN THE MANUFACTURING PARK ZONING DISTRICT.
MOTION CARRIED.
The applicant, Mr. Willard, and the property owner, Mr. Welch,
were advised of their right to appeal the decision of the Plan-
ning Commission to the City Council in writing within ten days.
4. NEW BUSINESS FOR PLANNING COMMISSION CONSIDERATION AT PUBLIC
HEARING MEETING OF FEBRUARY 25, 1970
The Planning Director described briefly the following items
of new business and pointed out property locations on the
zoning map. These matters will be considered by the Planning
Commission at the public hearing meeting of February 25, 1970.
PRELIMINARY PLAT APPLICATION
a) ZIEGENFUSS ADDITION, Appl. No. PP-645-70; property located
on Shattuck Ave. S. and S. 35th St. , north of Mance Addition.;
proposed plat to contain five lots
REZONE APPLICATION
b) CHRISTOPHERSON, WARREN, Appl. No. R-644-70; rezone from
G to B-1; property located on Rainier Ave. S. between S. 6th
and 7th Sts.
5 . ADMINISTRATIVE MATTERS
a) Field Trip Date
The Chairman stated that inasmuch as there were just two items
of new business on the agenda, he would recommend dispensing
with the formal field trip.
ACTION:
MOVED BY ROSS, SECONDED BY FORGAARD, THAT THE PLANNING COMMIS-
SION VIEW THE SITES OF ZIEGENFUSS ADDITION AND CHRISTOPHERSON
REZONE INDIVIDUALLY. MOTION CARRIED.
b) Study Session Date
The Chairman stated the next study session would be held on
Wednesday, February 18, 1970 , 7: 30 P.M.
c) Referral from City Council
The Planning Director stated. the City Council has requested
that the Planning Commission review the feasibility of ex-
cluding multi-family residential uses in L-1 and H-1 zones
and make a recommendation to Council. This matter was dis-
cussed last year and an ordinance amendment was drafted and
forwarded to the Council Planning Committee on June 2, 1969.
MEMORANDUM;
TO: Fi'1'es DATE s Februa 10, 1. .7
FROM:' Dic k tHa
SUBJECT. -Willard-Welch Prropert
SA-643-7.0._,
Mr Welch,:,,•owner: of..,sub j:ect property,.,.has'.been'negotiating ;to
purchase the 'piece 'of";property at. the" northwest'corner,:of.''his
property; however, :'he':feels that'.the .asking, price."•is'.'prohibitive-,. '
espec. alry" i;f.. the= Planning"_Commi'ss'fon .will not:•allow<me`.to,. use','
my property.'"
MEMORAN.DUM
TO:: Gordon:Er"icksen, DATE: February 6, ;.:1970 :.
FROM Dick 'Hans'en'
SUBJECT.:' Willard . Site* •Approval .
Mr. Willard ,called. this noon:;and-:would.'like you , to..:call. him
this afternoon at 288'-4088
He. has,-contacted the, ,property. owners , toa the north, and south ' of: .
his property and"-Would''.like .to "talk''. to you about the:: po'ss:ibility
of :all property •owners-'.:in,::the. area from th'e city to. •
3 ;W.'.`43rd;::Street_ and :from .°West Valley Road.'.to .th.e_.'Rail:road tracks
pet.i.tioning:.• for: .a rezone'•:,.to. H:-1 with .restrictive' 'Covenants on
the •60':` adjacent .Wes.t Val-ley Road _sim.ilar to, the requirements.:.
MEMORANDUM
0 : Files, t DATE'::. Feb.ruary:.4,,.", 1970•
FROM Dick" Hansen
SUBJECT: Willard -Site' Approval
Mr: Willard:. and .-:M •-Welch''-=(property,.'owner), were in ,the Office ,. '
today_. :to ':discuss -t.he.'pending` site approval , I _request,ed. some
changes in :the. parking layout , including two: curb .cuts:, - additional
pa:rking': Stalls and. paving ,of,,:the `are'a originally :ind icated
as graveled area._ I also requested a landscaping plan, _including
the parking strip-,in the; plan: They• agreed to submit new .plans
reflecting, .these.:changea.
When. I `asked ::them. eiactly';.what type .of.;use they-,.-intended 'for the-,
property,..:-Mr ' Willard "told;, Me .it was 'intended-:;to:..be the. repair'`.
and reconditioning .of .equipment.;: mainly ,diesel engines and`, fork:. `
lifts
Mr. ';:W'elch:-.,said' that 'he. intended .'to, contact.'.th;e ;'adjace,nt property ,
Owner, to:, the'. `south : a-nd°pe:rhaps the .•two .of their=. could develop` their
property:" jointly,: in'.a "manner•'that would agree . with the. Planning
Commission's recommendations However he "said-•.that':hp,"was •sure ,
that the southerl ro. ert. ow.ner. had...mu;ch "..-the- sain'e.,:use in mind -Y P P Y
for his property:
Mr: ::Welch also .felt: .•that': .the_P.lanning , Commiss:ion had set.,-'a: :.
president `for ' the. area• when they •granted' the "H-1 .rezone ,.just. '
north:'-Of .his;_ property .
k
Februar 'Z.••':19?•0
W. C Bogard, :Dis.trict:':'Engineer'.'
Washington'State..':Hi'c hway: Commission:'
Department •.of Hi" hwa s _
6431`'.Carso- 'Avnenue' s .
sett e` ashin- ton 981a8
D ar Mr` Bo d , Q Vgar •.
he•Renton Planning Commission is'. presently considering
ite• approval application for-property :Zoned M--P: ,,(Manus , ,
facturing Park}:: located.:: -,the :east' side`o`f.'the.,West'.Val- -
ley Highway, between 'SW 3:7th;and' 38th Str®ets,_:in .Renton.,
Air: ,John"T.,: belch.,' `418:".S: :..04'th, Seattle,., is .the ,'pr,operty
7--.::''
The -Commission; was-' advised t iat .the State` i ghway 'Depart
mont ,recently., purchased.._a ,twenty-•foot.
way fronting. thi:s,-property >.''.Presently.:-.there.:are s'ev'eral:':•,
decrepit' 'houses:and..`considerable:-fitter onthis','`right-of-
way,.•. and `the:,'.Commission,-requests".'information•,:as., to,;wher . :,._''.':.
you will undertake 'the::removal:of`=s• aid buildings :`and
e
pCrr '. .
r :truly
y ;
onstide re:d
9'7A '•
hitter.;
will . again .bebcuary 114:: 1 -. . '--
aPplication .
dnesday,. e ;
cgive''us so,,,
te :a?Proval
ssion on: Weion::. ou 'an
Tht sei-;
Planning or+m
ciiate';any: infosrmsioant::
on- that :dae:
yd we,would .
appt "to :the Co,mithat -we• can;,:re
Ve :trulour
Gor of r
c
n.. •
Plannin Director:
cc': Plannin' Commission Chairman. ,
Mr °'John T. 'Welch
Renton Planning Commission
Meeting January 28, 1970
Minutes - Page 5
Discussion ensued concerning the feasibility of the new construc-
tion as requested by the applicant, and the Planning Director
stated he felt it would 'be desirable to have the plan checked
by the Fire Department with reference to access for emergency
vehicles due to the close proximity of the new building to the
existing one.
The Chairman stated he felt the hearing should be continued for
two weeks to allow the planning staff time to check with the
Fire Department and also give the applicant an opportunity to
submit more detailed drawings of his proposed construction.
ACTION:
MOVED BY MOLA, SECONDED BY ROSS, THAT THE SPECIAL PERMIT APPLI-
CATION OF LYLE BARGER BE CONTINUED TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE MEETING
OF FEBRUARY 11 , 1970. MOTION CARRIED.
SITE APPROVAL APPLICATIONS
e) J. W. PHILLIIPS CO. , INC. , Appl. No. SA-641-70; site approval
for warehouse, offices and service shop in M-P zone; property
located on southwest corner of SW 7th St. and Powell Ave. SW
in Earlington Industrial Park
The Chairman described the application; the Planning Director
pointed out location of the property on the zoning map. The
Planning Director stated the plan as presented does conform to
the setback and parking requirements; however, the landscaping
plan is not satisfactory in that the plantings shown are too
sparse for the area to be covered. The Planning Director recom-
mended that the Commission approve the site plan subject to re-
submittal of the landscape plan and approval thereof by the Plan-
ning Department.
Audience comments in favor of the application were invited.
Mr. Douglas Mulvanney, architect, appeared on behalf of the
applicant. He stated he would be willing to revise the land-
scape plan in accordance with the wishes of the Planning Com-
mission and the Planning Director.
There were no audience comments in opposition to the application.
MOVED BY DENZER, SECONDED BY MOLA, THAT THE HEARING BE CLOSED.
MOTION CARRIED.
ACTION:
MOVED BY DENZER , SECONDED BY STERLING, THAT THE PLANNING COMMISSION
APPROVE THE SITE PLAN APPLICATION OF J . W. PHILLIPS CO. , INC. SUB-
JECT TO RESUBMITTAL OF THE LANDSCAPE PLAN AND SUBSEQUENT APPROVAL
BY THE PLANNING DIRECTOR. MOTION CARRIED.
f) WILLARD, MIKE, Appl. No. SA-643-70; site approval for motor
vehicle and machinery repair shop and sales room in M-P zone;
property located east side of West Valley Highway between SW
37th and. 38th Sts.
The Chairman described the site approval application. The Plan-
ning Director pointed out property location on the zoning map.
Slides of the property were shown. The Planning Director stated
the question before the Commission is two-fold; first, is the
proposed use allowable in the M-P zone with reference to Sec-
tion 4-712 (a) (20) ; and second, does the site plan as presented
meet the approval of the Planning Commission as required under
the M-P zone. The applicant' s proposed use of heavy equipment
Renton Planning Commission
Meeting January 28, 1970
Minutes Page 6
repair and storage would appear to be allowed only in the H-1
zone, and this question will be resolved by the Planning Com-
mission:
Mr. Mike Willard, 13844 SE 171st Street, the applicant, spoke on
behalf of the application. He stated there have been consider-
ablel problems concerning filling the property and he realized
that' the development looks poor at the present time. The State
Highway Department has purchased twenty feet of width fronting
the property for the realignment of the West Valley Highway,and Mr. Willard stated he has just received permission from
the State Highway Department to remove the unsightly old houses
on the property.
Considerable discussion followed among Commission members, the
Planning Director and Mr. Willard concerning his use of the
property. It was determined that Mr. John Welch is the actual
owner of the property, is paying for the fill and improvements,
will construct the proposed building; Mr. Willard is leasing
the property from Mr. Welch and had been requested to appear
for him.
It was agreed by Commission members that it would be desirable
for Mr. Welch to appear before the Commission in support of the
application.
I
Mr. Leo Scarsella, property owner adjacent directly south of
subject property, was present in the audience and was concerned
overHthe proposed use and the poor appearance of the develop-
ment. He stated he was in the construction business himself
and certainly not opposed to anyone in the construction industry,
but that applicant's use of the property was a detriment to the
area., The Chairman stated the Commission would, in the course
of the hearings, determine whether or not the use was permittedand. allowable in the M-P zone.
ACTION:
movEp BY MOLA, SECONDED BY DENZER , THAT THE SITE APPROVAL APPLI-
CATION OF MIKE WILLARD BE CONTINUED TO THE FEBRUARY 11 , 1970
MEETING, AND THAT THE PROPERTY OWNER BE REQUESTED TO ATTEND
SAID 'MEETING. MOTION CARRIED.
FURTHER ACTION:
MOVED BY POFF, SECONDED BY MOLA, THAT A LETTER BE DIRECTED TO THE
STATE' HIGHWAY DEPARTMENT ASKING WHEN THEY WILL REMOVE THE DECREPIT
HOUSES AND LITTER ON THE RIGHT-OF-WAY PURCHASED BY SAID DEPARTMENT
AT SUBJECT LOCATION. MOTION CARRIED.
With further reference to item (f) above, the Planning Director
stated the plan presented does not include landscaping. Ster-
ling felt the plan itself was insufficient for adequate Commis-
sion consideration and requested the applicant to submit addi-
tional data.
5. ADMINISTRATIVE MATTERS
a) Study Session Date
The Chairman stated the next study session will be held on Wed-
nesday, February 4, 1970, 7 : 30 P.M. , third floor conference
room. , Topics for discussion will be the Willard site approval
application and the Subdivision Ordinance.
1
I
Renton Planning Commission
Meeting January 14, '1970
Minutes 7 Page 2
use Of the land and would be more desirable from their standpoint,1
His client realizes that some concessions wtth reference to set-
backs and right-of-way allowances would 'have 'to be' made -but feels
this can be accomplished 'in the 1, 1- -zoning Classification rather
thanIthe more restrictive M-P classification.
It was noted by the Planning. Director that property located to thenorthandwestofsubjectpropertyhasbeenzonedMP (The Glacier
Park Company Orillia properties) .I
1
The Chairman stated this matter will be reviewed by the Planning
Commission on the next field trip; formal consideration' to be con-
tinued to the meeting of January 28, 1970.
1
5. NEW BUSINESS FOR PLANNING •COMMISSION_ CONSIDERATION _AT PUBLIC
HEARING MEETING OF JANUARY 28, 1970
The following items of new business were described by the Planning
Director and the location of each pointed out on ,:the. zoning 71a-
FINAL PLAT APPLICATION
a) GLENCOE 3, Appl. No- FP!..638-70; proposed plat located between
Union Avenue NE and Anacortes Avenue NE' -north Of 'NE 24th 'Street
REZONE APPLICATIONS
b) HIATT, DANIEL D App1., ,,No.-11:-640.-70;,, rezone from_ G to B-1;
property located west side of Union Avenue NE' southerly of NE 4th
Street
1
c) POWERS, FRANK J. , JR.. AND JOHN_ H. vAppl: No. R-642-70; rezone
from G-6000 to L-1; property located on SW 13th Street between
Seneca and Lind Avenues SW
SPECIAL PERMIT APPLICATION
d) BARGER, LYLE L. , Appl. No. SP-639-70; special permit for
apartment use in R-.2 zone; property located on Ferndale Circle
NE and NE 9th Street
1
SITE APPROVAL APPLICATIONS
e) J. W. PHILLIPS CO. , INC-, Appl. No. SA--.641-'70; site approval
for warehouse,' offices and service shop 1n14,43_ zone; property
lo9ated on southwest corner of SW 7thStreet and 'Powell Avenue SW
in Earlington- Industrial Park
C' (f) WILLARD,.. MIKE, Appl. No. SA--6430;_ site ,approval for motor
vehicle and machinery repair 'shop- and sales room' 'in .MP zone;
property located east side of West Valley Highway' between ex-
tension of S. 174th and 175th StreptsAold designation)
With reference to item (f) ahove, Secretary Sterling 'indicated
that copy of a letter from the" Assistant Building Director to the
applicant had been forwarded to the Planning Department. This
letter stated that' the , business located at 3720 West Valley Road
is not approved by the zoning ordinance for 'storage of 'heavy
equipment and car wrecking as' the area is zoned M-P.' The' letter
listed additional violations of city ordinances including moving
of building from one location to another without permit and prior
approval by the Planning Commission. The applicant believes that
I
1
Renton Planning Commission
Meeting January 14, 1970
Minutes _ Page 3
his proposed use is allowable .in an...M-P -zone and -is requestinghis
Commission .site approval. ' This-item -will 'be on the
agenda for the next field trip.
6 . ADMINISTRATIVE MATTERS
a) Field Trip Date
The Chairman stated the next. field .tr.ip...to..view the items of new
business would be held on Saturday,.. January 17, 1-970; Commissioners
to meet at the' Renton Inn Coffee Shop at '8 :.30 A.M.
b) Study Session Date
Chairman Teegarden stated that each Commissioner has been supplied
with copies of the preliminary' drafts of the proposed Subdivision
Ordinance and Planned Unit Development Ordinance', and urged all
members to study the documents. . The Chairman set the date of Wed-
nesday, January 21, 1970, for the' next' 'study 'session'. ' Commissioners
will meet at 7 : 30 P.M. , third 'floor conference room.
c) Operation Breakthrough
Commission members were supplied copy .of a letter from the Building
Director to the Mayor and City Council. regarding "Operation Break-
through" . A possible pilot site for- factory produced homes is
being considered in the county northeast of Kennydale'.' The plan-
ning staff will keep the Commission advised of any 'further develop-
ments. in this proejct.
d) ASPO National Conference
The Planning Director stated that the. Nation.al .Conference. .of the
American Society of Planning' Officials will' 'be"held ' in New York
City, 'April 4 to 9, 1970. The Chairman' stated"that 'if both a
staff member and a. Planning Commission member attended this
national convention,' nearly all' the funds'.aalocated''in the 1970
budget for travel expenses would 'b'e expended"; 'Therefore, he was
in favor of just a staff member a.ttending-..to. allow'"a majority of
Commission members to attend local. ..planning' :confe'rences and
seminars.
As there was no further official. .busines.s .•bef.ore' the.' Commission,
it was MOVED BY DENZER, SECONDED BY STERLING, ..THA'Z THE MEETING BE
ADJOURNED . MOTION CARRIED.
The meeting was adjourned at 9 : 35 P.M.
i Q
y . 'j2._e__,L4_,::„ _.._j
John' C. Sterling, Secretary 7- )
Clark Teegarden, Chairman
January 7, 1970
CRX1'IuIRD MAIL
639628
MUMS RMCsxhT WUZSTED
Mt. Miehael S. Willard
Contractors Machinery
3720 West Valley Road
tenton. Washington
Dear sir:
Your business located at the above address is not approved by the zoning
ordinances for storage of heavy equipment and car wrecking. This area is
MU 4 zone whereas your business can only be allowed in H•I zone. You
received by hand on December 30, 1969 a copy of a memorandum from the
Planning Department to this effect.
The following are additional violations of certain city ordinances:
Moving building from one location to another without
permit and prior approval by Planning Commission.
No application for temporary location of building.
No application for building permit for work on the
building.
No application for electrical permit for work on
the building.
No application for plumbing permit for work on the
building.
In October Ron Nelson and I stopped and left a notice for you to contact
this department. about this building but received no word from you. For
these reasons a stop work notice was posted on this building.
Sincerely,
W. E. Crews
Assistant Building Director
WEC/mp .
cc: Planning Department e
v I .
FI 1
v/ / h
1__——__ 1>i
I O
I G
1 I I LL
J W
c2I
Q
1 ZrB
O•\
Q c•
0\
1—
aC.' >.
I 1
HaL I
j/< C
n Mike Willard 1
1
W
i 31
1 i I W ,x Site Approval
y
jaM—PL J
c.‘,17.21 1,1 / J4_ ___ 1 .,,.____
iI S,
1 i1 \ , , FlV
N i I IIttI
i , 1.....t..1En I
1 ____,:.' \Li I i 1.1.11 1.1.1. i 1 ' 'L ,_ I100 I°.1 L ... ,
E._ i 11n
1 1.._
1
i
4,,'
Q
N:
I
12 ip
ij IJ L --I'-":- N!i r I 4
1
1
Site Approval in M-P zone HEARING DATE January 28, 1970
APPLICANT ; Mike Willard FILE NO. SA-643-70
LOCATION ' Located on the east side of the West Valley Road between the ,
extension of S 174th and 175th Streets .
TOTAL AREA 3 1/2 acres
PRINCIPAL ACCESS West Valley Road
EXISTING ZONING Manufacturing Park
EXISTING USE Storage and repair of heavy construction equipment .
PROPOSED USE Sales and repair of vehicles and machinery 1.
1 f
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN Light Industrial & Manufacturing Park
COMMENTS__
I
i
1
1
i•
ENDING
OF FILE
FILE TITLE