HomeMy WebLinkAboutx5 Consultant Evaluation Form INSPECTION AND DESIGN SERVICES FOR MAPLEWOOD WATER TREATMENT PLANT ROOF REPAIRS
CONSULTANT EVALUATION - DECEMBER 2019
DATE:
NAME OF APPLICANT/FIRM:
NAME OF RATER:
EVALUATION OF WRITTEN SOQ/PROPOSAL
Review the firm's Statement of Qualifications/ Proposal, and evaluate the following elements; maximum
points are indicated for each item.
Firm Qualifications:
1 Identifies organizational capabilities, experience, and resources. / 6
2 Identifies relevant organizational accreditations and certificates. / 4
3 Identifies firm experience on projects (minimum 3) of similar size, / 6
scope,complexity, and budget, particularly within the last 5 years.
4 Demonstrates knowledge of operational and engineering principles / 4
required for this project.
5 Provides special skills or"bonuses". / 4
6 Demonstrates knowledge of City of Renton codes, standards, / 4
review, and permitting processes.
7 Demonstrates ability to meet insurance requirements for the / 4
Project.
SUBTOTAL / 32
Project Team Qualifications:
1 Identifies technical experience of proposed staff. / 4
2 Identifies relevant personnel accreditations and certificates. / 4
3 Identifies personnel roles and responsibilities and/or Organization / 4
Chart.
4 Identifies personnel experience on projects with similar / 4
responsibilities, particularly within the last 5 years.
5 Indicates time availability and physical location of key staff required / 6
to carry out testing and inspections.
6 Indicates time availability and physical location of testing facilities. / 6
SUBTOTAL / 28
INSPECTION AND DESIGN SERVICES FOR MAPLEWOOD WATER TREATMENT PLANT ROOF REPAIRS
CONSULTANT EVALUATION - DECEMBER 2019
Project Management Qualifications:
1 Provides evidence that the firm completes work on time and within / 4
budget.
2 Identifies project manager's experience on projects of similar size, / 6
scope,complexity,and budget, particularly within the last 5 years.
3 Provides a preliminary time schedule for carrying out various tasks. / 4
Provides time estimates for staff members used in each of the
4 / 4
major tasks
5 Demonstrates overall apparent project management ability. / 4
SUBTOTAL / 22
Project Approach Qualifications:
1 Proposes technical approach/approaches to meeting project's / 4
goals.
Demonstrates understanding of work flow and communications
2 flow during various project phases with regard to project members / 6
(e.g., City,consultant, sub-consultants, contractor, sub-contractors,
inspection firms).
3 Demonstrates ability to meet project goals, regulatory compliance, / 4
and code compliance.
4 Overall approach to project. / 4
SUBTOTAL / 18
TOTAL SCORE / 100