Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutFinal Agenda Packet CITY OF RENTON AGENDA - City Council Regular Meeting 7:00 PM - Monday, February 14, 2022 Council Chambers, 7th Floor, City Hall – 1055 S. Grady Way Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, Councilmembers are attending this meeting remotely through Zoom. Audience comments will be accommodated through Zoom. Speakers must click the link to the registration form (linked below), fill it out, and submit it by 5 p.m. on the day of the Council meeting. The public may also submit comments in writing to cityclerk@rentonwa.gov by 5 p.m. on the day of the meeting. Registration is not required for those who wish to speak during public hearings. Registration for Audience Comment Registration will be open at all times, but speakers must register by 5 p.m. on the day of a Council meeting in order to be called upon. Anyone who registers after 5 p.m. on the day of the Council meeting will not be called upon to speak and will be required to re-register for the next Council meeting if they wish to speak at that next meeting. • Request to Speak Registration Form • You may also copy/paste the following URL into your browser: https://forms.office.com/g/bTJUj6NrEE • You may also call 425-430-6501 or email jsubia@rentonwa.gov or cityclerk@rentonwa.gov to register. Please provide your full name, city of residence, email address and/or phone number, and topic in your message. • Instructions for Virtual Attendance For those wishing to attend by Zoom, please (1) click this link: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84938072917?pwd=TUNCcnppbjNjbjNRMWpZaXk2bjJnZz09 (or copy the URL and paste into a web browser) or (2) call-in to the Zoom meeting by dialing 253- 215-8782 and entering 849 3807 2917 Passcode 156708, or (3) call 425-430-6501 by 5 p.m. on the day of the meeting to request an invite with a link to the meeting. Those providing audience comments will be limited to 5 minutes each speaker unless an exception is granted by the Council. Attendees will be muted and not audible to the Council except during times they are designated to speak. Advance instructions for how to address the Council will be provided to those who sign up in advance to speak and again during the meeting. 1. CALL TO ORDER 2. ROLL CALL 3. ADMINISTRATIVE REPORT a) Administrative Report 4. AUDIENCE COMMENTS NOTICE to all participants: Pursuant to state law, RCW 42.17A.555, campaigning for any ballot measure or candidate in City Hall and/or during any portion of the council meeting, including the audience comment portion of the meeting, is PROHIBITED. 5. CONSENT AGENDA The following items are distributed to Councilmembers in advance for study and review, and the recommended actions will be accepted in a single motion. Any item may be removed for further discussion if requested by a Councilmember. a) Approval of Council Meeting minutes of February 7, 2022. Council Concur b) AB - 3067 Mayor Pavone appoints Ms. Jessica Kushneryk to the Renton Municipal Arts Commission for an unexpired term expiring on December 31, 2022. Refer to Community Services Committee c) AB - 3058 Human Resources / Risk Management Department recommends approval of the 2022-2024 AFSCME Local 2170 labor contract. Council Concur d) AB - 3068 Human Resources / Risk Management Department requests approval to waive Section 6.1 of Council Policy 800-07 regarding ordinances, in order to adopt the revised 2022 Salary Table to reflect wage increases agreed to in the 2022-2024 AFSCME Local 2170 bargaining agreement. Council Concur e) AB - 3069 Public Works Transportation Systems Division recommends approval to execute the Fuel Tax Grant Agreement, with the Washington State Transportation Improvement Board (TIB), in order to accept $5,000,000 in grant funds for the construction of the Rainier Ave S Corridor Improvements Project - Phase 4. This project improves infrastructure to the Rainier Ave S corridor between S 3rd St to NW 3rd Pl. Refer to Finance Committee 6. UNFINISHED BUSINESS Topics listed below were discussed in Council committees during the past week. Those topics marked with an asterisk (*) may include legislation. Committee reports on any topics may be held by the Chair if further review is necessary. a) Finance Committee: Vouchers; Sunset Gardens Grant with the Renton Housing Authority; 2020 Washington State Department of Health SNAP Incentive Agreement Amendment 3; Conservation Fee Payment for Coulon North Water Walk Regulatory Approval; Mackenzie Engineering, Inc. Agreement for City Hall 7th Floor Tenant Improvements Design Development and Contractor Documents; New Cingular Wireless PC, LLC at Highlands Reservoir Lease Agreement; Rainier/Grady Junction TOD Planned Action EIS Grant and Contract; American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) Spending Plan b) Planning & Development Committee: Urban Forest*; Docket 16; Docket 16D #206 - MFTE Areas* 7. LEGISLATION Resolution: a) Resolution No. 4462: Urban Forest Management Plan (See Item 6.b) Ordinance for first reading and advancement to second reading: b) Ordinance No. 6055: 2022 Salary Table Adjustment (See Item 5.d) Ordinance for first reading: c) Ordinance No. 6056: D-206 MFTE Extension (See Item 6.b) 8. NEW BUSINESS (Includes Council Committee agenda topics; visit rentonwa.gov/cityclerk for more information.) 9. ADJOURNMENT COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING AGENDA (Preceding Council Meeting) CANCELED Hearing assistance devices for use in the Council Chambers are available upon request to the City Clerk CITY COUNCIL MEETINGS ARE TELEVISED LIVE ON GOVERNMENT ACCESS CHANNEL 21 To view Council Meetings online, please visit rentonwa.gov/councilmeetings Mayor’s Office Memorandum DATE: February 14, 2022 TO: Ryan McIrvin, Council President Members of Renton City Council FROM: Armondo Pavone, Mayor Ed VanValey, Chief Administrative Officer SUBJECT: Administrative Report • In honor of February being Black History Month, the following events will be taking place virtually or in-person.  On Tuesday, February 15 at 1 p.m., the City of Bellevue will be hosting Cultural Conversations – “Story in the Cloth” Quilting Traditions and Practices in the African American Community. To register for this virtual event visit https://cityofbellevue.zoom.us/meeting/register/tJYuduytpj0iHN2a2lm3sFgfS- uCXuWXAAwW.  Northwest African American Museum is hosting The Past, Present and Future of Black History moderated by Dr. Quintard Taylor of the University of Washington with keynote speaker Lonnie Bunch III, secretary of The Smithsonian Institution. This event will be held on Thursday, February 17, at 5 p.m. For more information and to register for this virtual event, visit https://www.naamnw.org/2022-black- history-month-keynote-program.  The African Americans Reach and Teach Health (AARTH) will host African Dance & Rituals on Wednesday, February 23, from 5-6pm. For more information and to register for this event visit www.aarth.org.  The Renton African American community and the City of Renton will co-host a Black History Month celebration on Saturday, February 26, from 12-2 p.m. Planning is still in progress and more information will be available soon. • The Emergency Feeding Program/SOS will be hosting lunch pop-ups on Tuesday, February 15 and Tuesday, February 22 from 12:30-2 p.m. at 300 Rainier Avenue North. This free event is open to the unsheltered and residents with food insecurities. Amazon Fresh ready-to-eat food and drinks will be available, as well as personal hygiene kits, cleaning supplies and socks. AGENDA ITEM #3. a) Ryan McIrvin, Council President Members of Renton City Council Page 2 of 3 February 14, 2022 • On Saturday, February 19, Remember and Resist Day of Remembrance 1942-2022, will be held at the Puyallup Fairgrounds Blue Lot Parking, 311 10th Avenue SE, Puyallup starting at 10 a.m. This date marks 80 years since the signing of Executive Order 9066 that authorized the forced removal and mass incarceration of all Japanese Americans on the West Coast and beyond. At 11 a.m. the event moves to the Northwest Detention Center 1623 East J Street, Tacoma, for a continuation of the program starting at 12 p.m. Weather permitting, there will be some outdoor programming. Masks and social distancing required. To RSVP or for more information email info@seattlejacl.org. • Veterans Memorial Park offers a unique setting to reflect on names of over 2,000 US veterans etched into granite tile plaques. Each Memorial Day the City honors military veterans with a ceremony at this park. February 28 is the deadline to submit applications for a memorial tile to be completed by this year’s Memorial Day service. Application instructions are found at www.rentonwa.gov/veteransmemorialpark downloadable and paper versions of the application are also available. For more information contact the Parks and Recreation Department at 425-430-6600. • Washington State Department of Commerce has awarded the City of Renton a $1.768M grant from Connecting Housing to Infrastructure Program (CHIP). The purpose of the CHIP grant program is to fund water, sewer, and storm system infrastructure improvements that serve affordable housing projects and reimbursement of waived utility system development charges that affordable housing projects typically pay as part of the project’s permit approval. The CHIP grant funding will be used by Renton Water Utility to make off-site water system infrastructure improvements at Renton Housing Authority’s 76-unit Sunset Gardens affordable housing project, which will start construction in the spring. Part of the funding will be used as reimbursement of system development charges that were waived on the Sunset Gardens project. • Information about preventative street maintenance, traffic impact projects, and road closures happening this week can be found at http://rentonwa.gov/traffic. All projects are weather permitting and unless otherwise noted, streets will always remain open. Preventative street maintenance, traffic impact projects, and road closures will be at the following locations:  Monday, February 14 through Friday, February 18, 8:30 am to 3:00 pm. Single intermittent lane closures on Lind Avenue SW at NE 27th Street due to small cell installation. Questions may be directed to Joel McCann, 425-757-9595. AGENDA ITEM #3. a) Ryan McIrvin, Council President Members of Renton City Council Page 3 of 3 February 14, 2022  Tuesday, February 15 through Friday, February 18, 8:00 am to 3:00 pm. Crews will continue pothole repairs on Oaksdale Avenue Southwest between Southwest 16th and Southwest 27th Street, weather permitting.  Thursday, February 17. Conversion to two-way traffic on Wells Avenue South and Williams Avenue South will occur, weather permitting. Notification one week prior to the conversion date has been through reader boards, social media outreach, and in-person notification. Please visit the project webpage at https://rentonwa.gov/ww for more information.  Williams Avenue South and Wells Avenue South Conversion Project: Impacts to traffic will continue throughout this area on South 2nd Street, South 3rd Street, Wells Avenue South, Williams Avenue South, Burnett Avenue South, and Houser Way South.  Downtown Utility Improvement Project. Several roadway closures and detours are required between now and project completion in 2022. For more information on current upcoming road closures and traffic impacts or to sign up for email or text alerts visit the project website at https://rentonwa.gov/duip.  Duvall Avenue Northeast Project: Continuous right lane closure on Northbound Duvall Avenue Northeast between Northeast 7th and Northeast 10th Street through estimated project completion in February 2023.  On-going Street Closure through October 4, 2023 (City of Renton Resolution No. 4446). FULL STREET CLOSURE on Sunset Lane NE between NE 10th Street and Harrington Place NE in support the Solera Development Project (LUA20- 000305). Questions may be directed to Brad Stocco, 425-282-2373. AGENDA ITEM #3. a) February 7, 2022 REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES CITY OF RENTON MINUTES - City Council Regular Meeting 7:00 PM - Monday, February 7, 2022 Council Chambers, 7th Floor, City Hall – 1055 S. Grady Way CALL TO ORDER Mayor Pavone called the meeting of the Renton City Council to order at 7:00 PM. ROLL CALL Councilmembers Present: Ryan McIrvin, Council President James Alberson, Jr., Council Position No. 1 Carmen Rivera, Council Position No. 2 Valerie O'Halloran, Council Position No. 3 Ed Prince, Council Position No. 5 Ruth Pérez, Council Position No. 6 Kim-Khánh Vǎn, Council Position No. 7 (All councilmembers attended remotely) Councilmembers Absent: ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF PRESENT Armondo Pavone, Mayor Shane Moloney, City Attorney Jason Seth, City Clerk Judith Subia, Council Liaison Preeti Shridhar, Equity, Housing, and Human Services Administrator Chip Vincent, Community & Economic Development Administrator Martin Pastucha, Public Works Administrator Kari Roller, Finance Department Administrator Ellen Bradley-Mak, Human Resources and Risk Management Administrator Kim Gilman, HR Labor Manager Cailín Hunsaker, Parks & Trails Director Vanessa Dolbee, Planning Director Ron Straka, Public Works Utility Systems Director Deb Needham, Emergency Management Director Chief Jon Schuldt, Police Department Administrator AGENDA ITEM #5. a) February 7, 2022 REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES Commander Chad Karlewicz, Police Department (All City staff attended remotely except City Clerk Seth) PROCLAMATION a) Lunar New Year Day - February 1, 2022: A proclamation by Mayor Pavone was read declaring February 1, 2022 to be Lunar New Year Day in the City of Renton, encouraging all members of the community to join in this special observation. Tony Au and Hardy Li accepted the proclamation with appreciation. MOVED BY VǍN, SECONDED BY MCIRVIN, COUNCIL CONCUR IN THE PROCLAMATION. CARRIED. b) Black History Month - February 2022: A proclamation by Mayor Pavone was read declaring February 2022 to be Black History Month in the City of Renton, encouraging all citizens to join in learning more about the rich history of African Americans during this special observance. Tre Williams, BLM mural artist, and Dr. Linda Smith accepted the proclamation with appreciation. MOVED BY PRINCE, SECONDED BY ALBERSON, COUNCIL CONCUR IN THE PROCLAMATION. CARRIED. ADMINISTRATIVE REPORT Emergency Management Director Deb Needham reviewed a written administrative report summarizing the City’s recent progress towards goals and work programs adopted as part of its business plan for 2022 and beyond. Items noted were: • City Hall is open for in-person services at our Finance and Police Counters, Monday through Wednesday, 9 a.m. to 3 p.m. Our Municipal Court counter is open Thursday and Friday, 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m., while hearings are conducted via zoom. Our staff continues to provide (and improve) virtual and online customer services such as our Virtual Permit Counter and our Recreation Programming reservation process. Space is limited in each facility and masks are required when inside a city facility as we follow guidance that protects both you and our employees. For more information, please visit our website. • February is Black History Month and in addition to the City of Renton’s Black History Month Proclamation that will be presented at the February 7 Council meeting at 7 p.m., the following events will be taking place virtually or in-person.  The Association for the Study of African American Life and History has selected the 2022 Black History Month theme of Black Health and Wellness. African Americans Reach and Teach Health (AARTH) is hosting the following events in acknowledgement of this theme. For more information and to register for these events visit www.aarth.org. o February 5, 12:30-1:30 p.m. – Conversations on Black Wellness o February 9 and February 23, 5-6 p.m. – African Dance & Rituals  On Tuesday, February 15 at 1 p.m., the City of Bellevue will be hosting Cultural Conversations – “Story in the Cloth” Quilting Traditions and Practices in the African American Community. To register for this virtual event visit https://cityofbellevue.zoom.us/meeting/register/tJYuduytpj0iHN2a2lm3sFgfS- uCXuWXAAwW. AGENDA ITEM #5. a) February 7, 2022 REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES  Northwest African American Museum is hosting The Past, Present and Future of Black History moderated by Dr. Quintard Taylor of the University of Washington with keynote speaker Lonnie Bunch III, secretary of The Smithsonian Institution. This event will be held on Thursday, February 17, at 5 p.m. For more information and to register for this virtual event, visit https://www.naamnw.org/2022-black-history- month-keynote-program.  The Renton African American community and the City of Renton will co-host a Black History Month celebration on Saturday, February 26, from 12-2 p.m. Planning is still in progress and more information will be available soon. • Renton History Museum is hosting two new exhibits through February 11, 2022. The Annual Art Show of the Brain Injury Alliance of Washington is in the main gallery, featuring 23 pieces by 22 artists. These works demonstrate the healing power of creativity. Also in the main gallery is Life on the Rivers, an exhibit that explores the central role of the Black and the Cedar Rivers in the lives of Renton’s earliest residents, the Duwamish People, and the white settlers who came later. Renton History Museum is located at 235 Mill Ave. S.; hours are Wednesday through Friday, 10 am to 4 pm. • On Saturday, February 12, stop by Northwest Share Free Vegetarian Food Truck from 12-2pm to enjoy a free lunch. The food truck will be located at Renton Chamber of Commerce, 625 South 4th Street. Upcoming lunch distributions are scheduled for March 26, April 16, and May 7. • Preventative street maintenance will continue to impact traffic and result in occasional street closures. AUDIENCE COMMENTS • Sean Hashem, unknown, stated that he owns a property in Renton known as Times Square Renton. He explained that he would like to sell the property to someone who is looking to turn it into a distribution center, but was told the City prefers the property stay as office space. He asked that the City fully involve the public when deciding to make any zoning changes to the area. Community and Economic Development Administrator Chip Vincent clarified that distribution centers reduce the City's tax base, increase congestion due to the high volume of trucks moving to and from the centers, and have a very low employee-to- acreage ratio, which is counter to the City's goals for the area. CONSENT AGENDA Items listed on the Consent Agenda were adopted with one motion, following the listing. a) Approval of Council Meeting minutes of January 24, 2022. Council Concur. b) AB - 3056 City Clerk submitted the quarterly list of fully executed contracts & leases between 10/1/2021 - 12/31/2021, and a report of agreements expiring between 1/1/2022 – 6/30/2022. Council Concur. AGENDA ITEM #5. a) February 7, 2022 REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES c) AB - 3065 City Clerk reported bid opening on January 11, 2022, and submitted the staff recommendation to award CAG-21-261, Lift Station and Force Main Rehab Phase 2 (Group 1B) project, to the lowest responsive and responsible bidder, Gary Harper Construction, Inc., in the amount of $518,571. This project will rehabilitate the Baxter, Devil's Elbow, and East Valley lift stations. Council Concur. d) AB - 3057 Community & Economic Development Department submitted a Grant Award Letter from the Washington State Department of Commerce, to accept $250,000 in grant funds, subject to approval as to form by the City Attorney Department, and upon approval of the grant agreement, to be used for the development of the Rainier/Grady Junction TOD Subarea Plan; and to authorize execution of an agreement with BERK Consulting, Inc., in the amount of $240,000 for assistance in the development of the Rainier/Grady Junction Planned Action Environmental Impact Statement (EIS). Refer to Finance Committee. e) AB - 3062 Executive Services Department requested authorization to execute the Washington State Military Department and the Department of Homeland Security Emergency Management Performance Grant (EMPG) contracts E22-194 and E22-209, in order to accept $77,021 in grant funds for use in support of the Emergency Management division. Council Concur. f) AB - 3064 Finance Department requested approval of the targeted allocation of remaining ARPA (American Rescue Plan Act) expenditures in the amount of $11,650,000 to be used for 1) Economic Recovery - support for private sector businesses, 2) Community Response - support for residents, focusing on disadvantaged and disproportionately impacted populations, 3) Health Precautions - COVID responses to reduce the spread of the virus, and 4) City Operations - enhancement of services to increase efficiencies, sustain infrastructure, and provide improvement of City operations. The unallocated amount of $2,383,855 will be held for future consideration. Refer to Finance Committee. g) AB - 3059 Parks & Recreation Department - PPNR requested authorization to pay a required Restoration and Permitting (RAP) Conservation Fee, in the amount of $154,176.91 to King County, as part of the permit conditions for the Coulon Park North Water Walk Improvements project. Refer to Finance Committee. h) AB - 3066 Public Works Airport recommended approval of Addendum 7-22 to LAG-13-005, lease with The Landing Gear Works, in the amount of approximately $67,589.70 annually, in order to increase their leased square footage at the Airport and to bring lease rates up to market rates. Refer to Transportation (Aviation) Committee. i) AB - 3061 Public Works Facilities Division recommended execution of a 20-year lease agreement with New Cingular Wireless, PC at the Highlands Reservoir, effective February 1, 2022 to January 31, 2042. New Cingular Wireless, PC will provide a one-time administration fee of $7,500 and a monthly fee of $2,800 with 3% annual increases. Refer to Finance Committee. j) AB - 3063 Public Works Utility Systems Division recommended approval of Amendment #2 to CAG-15-196, interlocal agreement between the City of Renton and 27 other jurisdictions within the Water Resource Inventory Area (WRIA) 8. This amendment allows the City of Everett to participate as a WRIA 8 member. Council Concur. MOVED BY MCIRVIN, SECONDED BY PRINCE, COUNCIL CONCUR TO APPROVE THE CONSENT AGENDA, AS PRESENTED. CARRIED. AGENDA ITEM #5. a) February 7, 2022 REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES UNFINISHED BUSINESS a) Utilities Committee Chair Alberson presented a report concurring in the staff recommendation to approve the agreement with BHC Consultants in the amount of $702,491 for design and services during bidding for the Windsor Hills Utility Improvements project. MOVED BY ALBERSON, SECONDED BY RIVERA, COUNCIL CONCUR IN THE COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION. CARRIED. NEW BUSINESS Please see the attached Council Committee Meeting Calendar. EXECUTIVE SESSION & ADJOURNMENT MOVED BY MCIRVIN, SECONDED BY PRINCE, COUNCIL RECESS INTO EXECUTIVE SESSION FOR APPROXIMATELY 30 MINUTES TO DISCUSS LABOR NEGOTIATIONS PURSUANT TO RCW 42.30.140(4)(b), WITH NO OFFICIAL ACTION TO BE TAKEN AND THAT THE COUNCIL MEETING BE ADJOURNED WHEN THE EXECUTIVE SESSION IS ADJOURNED. CARRIED. TIME: 7:33 P.M. Executive Session was conducted, and no action was taken. The Council meeting adjourned when the executive session adjourned. Time: 8:08 P.M. Jason A. Seth, MMC, City Clerk Jason Seth, Recorder 07 Feb 2022 AGENDA ITEM #5. a) Council Committee Meeting Calendar February 7, 2022 February 14, 2022 Monday 4:00 PM Finance Committee, Chair O’Halloran – VIDEOCONFERENCE 1. Sunset Gardens Grant with the Renton Housing Authority 2. 2020 Washington State Department of Health SNAP Incentive Agreement Amendment 3 3. Conservation Fee Payment for Coulon North Water Walk Regulatory Approval 4. Mackenzie Engineering, Inc. Agreement for City Hall 7th Floor Tenant Improvements Design Development and Contractor Documents 5. New Cingular Wireless PC, LLC at Highlands Reservoir Lease Agreement 6. Rainier/Grady Junction TOD Planned Action EIS Grant and Contract 7. American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) Spending Plan 8. Vouchers 9. Emerging Issues in Finance 5:15 PM Planning & Development Committee, Chair Prince – VIDEOCONFERENCE 1. Urban Forest Management Plan 2. Docket 16 3. 2022 Work Program 4. Emerging Issues in CED CANCELED Committee of the Whole, Chair McIrvin 7:00 PM Council Meeting – VIDEOCONFERENCE AGENDA ITEM #5. a) AB - 3067 City Council Regular Meeting - 14 Feb 2022 SUBJECT/TITLE: Renton Municipal Arts Commission (RMAC) Appointment - Janna Kushneryk RECOMMENDED ACTION: Refer to Community Services Committee DEPARTMENT: Mayor Pavone STAFF CONTACT: April Alexander, Executive Assistant EXT.: x6520 FISCAL IMPACT SUMMARY: None SUMMARY OF ACTION: Mayor Pavone appoints Ms. Janna Kushneryk to the Renton Municipal Arts Commission (RMAC) for an unexpired term expiring on 12/31/22. EXHIBITS: A. Recommendation Memo STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Confirm Mayor Pavone's appointment of Ms. Kushneryk to the Renton Municipal Arts Commission. AGENDA ITEM #5. b) DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY  & ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT    M   E   M   O   R   A   N   D   U   M       DATE: February 2, 2022     TO: Armondo Pavone, Mayor        FROM: C.E. “Chip” Vincent, CED Administrator        SUBJECT: Request for New Appointment to the Renton Municipal Arts  Commission       This memorandum is to recommend appointment of Janna Kushneryk to the vacant  Commission Position on the Renton Municipal Arts Commission. If appointed, Janna will  fulfill the seat vacated by Christie Randolph and her term of service will expire on  December 31, 2022.     Janna is a Renton resident with a strong background in music and graphic design.  She  credits her eclectic taste in music as the inspiration for her musical journey and is  passionate about learning new ways to play and connect with a variety of individuals  and groups to make music. She is a graphic designer by day, currently employed by the  City of SeaTac and a passionate musician by night.  Janna has performed with the Black  Rose Irish folk rock band, Issaquah Philharmonic, and Seattle Rock Orchestra. Originally  from Florida, she is really enjoying all that the Pacific Northwest has to offer and is  excited to connect with the arts community in Renton.     The Arts Commissioners met with and have interviewed Janna about her interest in  serving on the Commission.  The Commissioners are pleased with Janna’s interest in  helping the Commission to better connect with artists and arts organizations in Renton  through concentrated outreach efforts and her offer to help capture the work of the  Commission through photography at events and public art installations.    At the February meeting of the Arts Commission, held on February 1, 2022, the  Commissioners voted to unanimously recommend the appointment of Janna to the Arts  Commission.      AGENDA ITEM #5. b) AB - 3058 City Council Regular Meeting - 14 Feb 2022 SUBJECT/TITLE: Approval of 2022-2024 AFSCME Local 2170 contract RECOMMENDED ACTION: Council Concur DEPARTMENT: Human Resources / Risk Management Department STAFF CONTACT: Ellen Bradley-Mak, Administrator EXT.: X7657 FISCAL IMPACT SUMMARY: Budget approval was initially set at a 2% COLA for 2022. A budget adjustment will be prepared to account for the additional budget funds needed based on the agreed contract terms. The additional budgeted amount for wages and benefits will be $1,312,119 for 2022. The CPI calculation will be added into the biennial budget for years 2023 and 2024. SUMMARY OF ACTION: The City and the American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees (AFSCME Local 2170), began bargaining for a successor Collective Bargaining Agreement to the 2019-2020 agreement on September 22, 2021, and reached a tentative agreement on January 14, 2022. The agreement was ratified by an AFSCME Local 2170 member vote on February 4, 2022. The major economic issues focused on wages and the parties agreed to the following: 1.The parties agreed to a three (3) year agreement, from 2022-2024. 2.Effective January 1, 2022, wages shall be increased by 6.00% over the existing base wages of 2021. The 6% increase for pay periods that have already been processed will be retroactively paid to all AFSCME represented employees who were employed on or after January 1, 2022. 3.Effective January 1, 2023, wages shall be increased by 100% of the 2022 Seattle-Tacoma-Bellevue June to June CPI-U with a minimum of 1.5% and a maximum of 4.5%. 4.Effective January 1, 2024, wages shall be increased by 100% of the 2023 Seattle-Tacoma-Bellevue June to June CPI-U with a minimum of 1.5% and a maximum of 4.5%. 5.Effective April 1, 2022, 1% of the employee’s base pay will fund a Voluntary Employees’ Beneficiary Association (VEBA) account. 6.Effective April 1, 2022 the Employer shall make a deposit equal to 3% of each eligible employee’s base wage into a deferred compensation account. 7.An increase of $0.50 to the hourly rate for standby pay and the addition of a mileage reimbursement for employees utilizing their own personal vehicle for callouts, in compliance with IRS tax regulations. EXHIBITS: A. 2022-2024 AFSCME contract redline and salary table B. 2022-2024 AFSCME contract final version STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Adopt the Agreement between the parties: the 2022 -2024 AFSCME Local 2170 contract, and authorize the Mayor and City Clerk to sign. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AGREEMENT By and Between CITY OF RENTON and LOCAL 2170, WASHINGTON STATE COUNCIL OF COUNTY AND CITY EMPLOYEES AMERICAN FEDERATION OF STATE, COUNTY AND MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEES, AFL-CIO January 1, 201922 – December 31, 20204 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS PREAMBLE ..................................................................................................................................................... 8 ARTICLE 1 – RECOGNITION AND BARGAINING UNIT .................................................................................... 8 1.1. Union Recognized ......................................................................... 8 1.2. Temporary/Supplemental Employees........................................... 9 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 3 1.3. Excluded Positions ...................................................................... 11 1.4. New Positions ............................................................................. 12 1.5. Executive Board Meetings .......................................................... 12 1.6. Job Classification Changes .......................................................... 12 1.8. Reclassification Reviews ............................................................. 13 ARTICLE 2 – UNION MEMBERSHIP AND DUES DEDUCTION ....................................................................... 15 2.1. Payroll Deduction ....................................................................... 15 2.2. PAC Program ............................................................................... 16 2.3. Hold Harmless Agreement .......................................................... 17 2.4. Refunds ....................................................................................... 17 2.5. New Employees .......................................................................... 17 2.6. Union Officer List ........................................................................ 17 ARTICLE 3 – HOURS OF WORK .................................................................................................................... 18 3.1. Work Week ................................................................................. 18 3.2. Work Day .................................................................................... 18 3.3. Work Schedules .......................................................................... 18 3.4. Meal and Rest Periods ................................................................ 20 3.5. Clean-Up Time ............................................................................ 21 ARTICLE 4 –OVERTIME ................................................................................................................................ 21 4.1. Overtime ..................................................................................... 21 4.2. Call-back Pay ............................................................................... 24 4.3. Extended Shift Overtime ............................................................. 25 4.4. Shift Differential ......................................................................... 26 4.5. Standby ....................................................................................... 26 4.6. Uniform Allowance ..................................................................... 27 4.7. Acting Pay ................................................................................... 29 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 4 ARTICLE 5 – SICK LEAVE .............................................................................................................................. 29 5.1. Sick Leave Accrual ....................................................................... 29 5.2. Sick Leave Cash Out .................................................................... 30 5.3. Long Term Disability Plan ............................................................ 30 5.4. Notification Requirements .......................................................... 31 5.5. Abuse of Sick Leave ..................................................................... 31 ARTICLE 6 – HOLIDAYS ................................................................................................................................ 34 6.1. Observed Holidays ...................................................................... 34 6.2. Holiday Pay ................................................................................. 35 6.3. Holidays Falling on Scheduled Day Off ........................................ 36 6.4. Holidays Falling on Weekends .................................................... 37 6.5 Regular Part-time ........................................................................ 37 6.6. Personal Holiday Use/Cash Out .................................................. 37 ARTICLE 7 – VACATIONS .............................................................................................................................. 38 7.1. Accrual Rate ................................................................................ 38 7.2. Maximum Vacation Accumulation .............................................. 38 7.3. Vacation Requests ...................................................................... 39 7.4 Cash Out Upon Separation ......................................................... 39 ARTICLE 8 – BEREAVEMENT LEAVE ............................................................................................................. 39 ARTICLE 9 – INSURANCES ............................................................................................................................ 40 Definitions: ................................................................................................ 40 9.1. Health Insurance ......................................................................... 40 9.2. Life Insurance.............................................................................. 43 9.3. Federal/State Healthcare Options .............................................. 44 9.4. COBRA ........................................................................................ 44 ARTICLE 10 – JURY DUTY ............................................................................................................................. 44 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 5 ARTICLE 11 – EDUCATION AND CONFERENCE ............................................................................................ 45 11.1. Time Off and Financial Reimbursement ...................................... 45 11.2. Valid Business Expenses .............................................................. 45 11.3. Access to Training ....................................................................... 45 ARTICLE 12 – SALARIES ............................................................................................................................... 45 12.1. Salaries ....................................................................................... 45 12.2. Step Increases ............................................................................. 46 ARTICLE 13 - LONGEVITY ............................................................................................................................. 47 13.1. Longevity Pay Calculation ........................................................... 47 13.2. Longevity Pay Date ..................................................................... 48 ARTICLE 14 – DEFERRED COMPENSATION .................................................................................................. 48 ARTICLE 15 – PAY PERIOD ........................................................................................................................... 48 ARTICLE 16 – MANAGEMENT RIGHTS ......................................................................................................... 49 ARTICLE 17 – UNION ACTIVITIES ................................................................................................................. 50 17.1. Paid Release Time ....................................................................... 50 17.2. Facility Access ............................................................................. 51 17.3. Union Communication ................................................................ 51 17.4. Training Time .............................................................................. 51 17.5. Negotiations ............................................................................... 51 ARTICLE 18 – LABOR/MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE .................................................................................... 52 ARTICLE 19 – WORK STOPPAGES AND EMPLOYER PROTECTION ............................................................... 52 19.1. Uninterrupted City Services ........................................................ 52 19.2. Work Stoppage ........................................................................... 53 19.3. Disciplinary Action for Work Stoppage ....................................... 53 ARTICLE 20 – NON-DISCRIMINATION.......................................................................................................... 54 ARTICLE 21 – RECRUITMENT AND SELECTION PROCESS ........................................................................... 54 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 6 21.1. Posting of Vacancies ................................................................... 54 21.2. Selection Process ........................................................................ 55 21.3. Eligible Candidate Pool ............................................................... 56 21.4. Promotional Opportunities ......................................................... 56 ARTICLE 22 – PROBATIONARY PERIOD ....................................................................................................... 57 22.1. 12-Month Probationary Period ................................................... 57 22.2. 6-Month Probationary Period ..................................................... 57 ARTICLE 23 – GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE ....................................................................................................... 58 23.1. Definition .................................................................................... 58 23.2. Grievance Process ....................................................................... 58 23.3. Employer Grievance .................................................................... 61 23.4. Grievance Documentation .......................................................... 61 23.5. Grievance Timelines .................................................................... 61 ARTICLE 24 – HEALTH, SAFETY AND PRODUCTIVITY ................................................................................... 62 24.1. Quality and Safety of Work ......................................................... 62 24.2. Working Conditions .................................................................... 62 24.3. Rain Gear .................................................................................... 62 24.4. Custodial Services ....................................................................... 63 24.5. Safety Shoes ............................................................................... 63 ARTICLE 25 – SAVINGS CLAUSE ................................................................................................................... 65 ARTICLE 26 – ENTIRE AGREEMENT ............................................................................................................. 66 ARTICLE 27 – PRIORITY OF FEDERAL, STATE AND CITY LAWS ..................................................................... 66 ARTICLE 28 – VOLUNTEERS ......................................................................................................................... 67 ARTICLE 29 – DISCIPLINE ............................................................................................................................. 68 29.1 Discipline .................................................................................... 68 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 7 29.2 Demotion .................................................................................... 68 ARTICLE 30 – LEAVE DONATION ................................................................................................................. 69 ARTICLE 31 – LAYOFF AND RECALL ............................................................................................................. 69 31.1. Layoff and Recall ......................................................................... 69 31.2. Definitions .................................................................................. 70 31.3. Departmental Review ................................................................. 72 31.4. Human Resources Risk Management Review ............................. 73 31.5. Notice of Layoff .......................................................................... 74 31.6. Bumping Rights ........................................................................... 75 31.7. Recall Rights ................................................................................ 75 ARTICLE 32 – FINGERPRINTING ................................................................................................................... 79 ARTICLE 33 – DURATION OF AGREEMENT .................................................................................................. 81 APPENDIX A – AFSCME CLASSIFICATIONS IN ALPHABETICAL ORDER (with Job Grades) ............................ 83 APPENDIX B – SALARY INDEX FOR 2022 ..................................................................................................... 85 APPENDIX C – Telework Reopener ............................................................................................................. 93 APPENDIX D – INDEX .......................................................................................................................... 94 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 8 PREAMBLE This Agreement is between the City of Renton (hereinafter called the Employer) and Local 2170, Washington State Council of County and City Employees, American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO (hereinafter called the Union) for the purpose of setting forth a mutual understanding of the parties as to conditions of employment for those employees for whom the Employer recognizes the Union as the exclusive collective bargaining representative. The Employer and the Union shall cooperate to provide the public with efficient, cost-effective, and courteous delivery of public services, to encourage good attendance of employees, and to promote a climate of labor relations that will aid in achieving a high level of efficiency and productivity in all departments of City government. The parties will work together to address and adapt to the inevitable issues of change, to devise varying methods and work procedures adapted to the changing circumstances of their particular areas of responsibilities. ARTICLE 1 – RECOGNITION AND BARGAINING UNIT 1.1. Union Recognized Pursuant to RCW 41.56.060 the Employer hereby recognizes the Washington State Council of County and City Employees/ AFSCME Council 2 and its affiliated local (hereafter Union) as the exclusive bargaining representative for all limited term, probationary and regular Renton City employees in those classifications listed in Appendix A. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 9 Limited term employees have all rights under this contract with the exce ption of bumping (see City Policy #330-11, dated 10/15/2005). If a limited term position is converted to a regular position, the incumbent shall remain in the position and shall be converted as well (and will be eligible for bumping rights). A limited term employee shall have their time in the limited term position count toward their overall classification and City seniority. A regular employee who applies for and is appointed to a limited term position shall have the right to return to their previous classification should the limited term position not be converted to regular status and there is a vacant position available in their previous classification. All employees of the Employer in classifications covered by this Agreement are eligible to be members of the Union. 1.2. Temporary/Supplemental Employees The City shall not combine or overlap temporary/supplemental employees in such a way as to create the equivalent of a regular position, orposition or avoid the time constraints set herein. In the case of layoffs, Temporary/ Supplemental employees may not be hired to perform bargaining unit work in work units where layoffs have occurred while there is an active recall list. The City will issue a quarterly report listing all actively employed supplemental employees utilized by the City at the time the report is generated. This report will be issued quarterly beginning October AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 10 1, 2019 or if the 1st falls on a holiday, within 4 days following the holiday. 1.2.1 Non Seasonal Temporary/Supplemental Employees- When filling a known vacancy of an AFSCME represented position, Temporary/Supplemental employees shall be employees hired directly by the City or through an agency contracted with the City. Such employees shall be employed no more than the equivalent of six (6) months (182 consecutive days) in a rolling 12-month period. An extension of up to an additional 6 months is available with union concurrence. Overtime shall be offered to regular employees prior to temporary employees being utilized, unless no qualified regular employees are available. The City will notify the Union prior to the use or hiring of a supplemental or tTemporary employee under this clause. It is understood that the use of Temporary/Supplemental employees as provided for in this section shall not be deemed as supplanting bargaining unit work. 1.2.2 Seasonal Temporary/ Supplemental Employees- It is understood that the use of seasonal employees as provided for in this section shall not be deemed as supplanting bargaining unit work. Effective July 1, 2019 seasonal employees performing work limited to the following positions will not work longer than 6 months (182 consecutive days) in a calendar year. In 2020 onward, the seasonal period is set as being between April 1 and October 31: AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 11 • Custodial Assistant • Golf Course Laborer and Pro-Shop • Parks Laborer • Transportation Laborer • Golf Course Laborer and Pro-Shop Supplemental positions are limited to 1500 hours in a calendar year and the employment period is between March 1- and November 30. 1.2.3 Interns- Use of Interns performing bargaining unit work citywide is limited to one-year terms of employment, and each intern shall not work longer than 1,040 hours during that year. The employment year for interns will be measured from the date of hire forward. Hiring of interns is done within City guidelines. The City will notify the Union of internship descriptions involving bargaining unit work. Interns must be enrolled in school and assisting, not supplanting, bargaining unit work. 1.3. Excluded Positions The Union recognizes the following positions as being excluded from the represented classifications listed in Appendix A: 1.3.1. All positions in the Human Resources & Risk Management Department. 1.3.2. All clerical or secretarial positions designated as “confidential” in each department. Only one “confidential” designation will be allowed in each department. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 12 1.4. New Positions Should it become necessary to establish a new job classification within the bargaining unit during the term of this Agreement, the City will create the classification. The salary for any new classification within the bargaining unit shall be subject to negotiations. The Union shall be notified of any newly created classifications in the City, which are not recognized by other bargaining units, including the City’s initial determination regarding bargaining unit status. Disagreements regarding the appropriateness of their inclusion or exclusion from the bargaining unit will be referred to the Public Employment Relations Commission for resolution. 1.5. Executive Board Meetings The Union will provide a calendar of all regularly scheduled Executive Board meetings for the next calendar year in December of the preceding year to the Human Resources & Risk Management Administrator. 1.6. Job Classification Changes Changes to existing position classifications and position descriptions shall be provided to the Union president and secretary ten (10) working days prior to the next regularly scheduled Executive Board meeting. The Union shall respond to the changes, in writing, within ten (10) working days of the meeting, unless an extension is mutually agreed upon. If the Union’s written response is not provided within the timeframe above, management may move forward with the changes that have been submitted. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 13 1.7. Point Factor Method (PFM): In an effort to objectively compare positions for internal equity, the City has utilized a Point Factor Method (PFM)to help in determining a position’s pay grade. Internal equity compares positions according to requirements for similar skill, education/training, and responsibility, and if the jobs are performed under similar working conditions. The PFM uses factors that are commonly found in positions, and each factor is broken into point values based on the varying levels of difficulty or effort needed to complete them. The position’s point value is then compared to other positions to select an appropriate grade. Effective January 1, 2022, HRRM staff will utilize the Point Factor Method in conjunction with external market data when determining a grade placement due to a Reclassification, as part of a market study, or when creating a new position. If no external market data exists, the PFM will be used to determine the grade placement based on the internal equity analysis solely. Any PFM analysis will be shared with the affected employees and the union. 1.78. Reclassification Reviews An employee may request a position review for proper classification placement when the employee believes that there has been significant change in duties and responsibilities of the AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 14 position. Reclassification reviews will be done in accordance with City Policy #320-05 (Request for Reclassification), as established July 7, 2009, to the extent that such does not conflict with the agreement. A Position Description Questionnaire (PDQ) form must be fully completed and requires review by the employee’s supervisor, the Division Director and the Department Administrator. A market study will be conducted by HRRM staff as part of the reclassification process for those positions that meet the definition for requiring a reclassification. The deadline for submittal of the PDQ to the employee’s supervisor is May 1. The Department shall forward the request to the Human Resources Department within 30 days of the initial request. If the Department does not forward the request within 30 days, the employee may submit the request directly to the Human Resources Department to ensure the submission deadline is met. The Human Resources Department will notify the employee within seven (7) working) working days of the receipt of the request. Requests submitted to Human Resources by the July 1 deadline and subsequently approved shall be included in the following year’s budget. Those approved by the City Council shall have an effective date of January 1 of that budget year. Any delays in the reclassification process shall not affect the implementation date and all pay shall be retroactive to January 1 of that budget year. Any appeals will be reviewed by the Human Resources and Risk Management Administrator for a final decision. Human Resources AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 15 will meet with the Union regarding salary placement of any revised position(s). Once a request to reclassify a position has been submitted and reviewed, no further consideration will be given to reclassifying the position for a twenty-four (24) month period following submission. 1.9 Job Description and Salary Updates Work will be done to reflect current duties, job description revisions shared per the Union review process, and then HR staff will conduct a market study, with wage adjustment negotiated for those deemed under market, for any titles that either have not received a market study since 2017 or, at the time the market study was completed, there were not enough matches. Position titles that do not have a minimum of 4 matches from comparable cities will be evaluated using the PFM and their salary adjustments negotiated based on internal equity. The work shall be completed no later than July 31, 2023. ARTICLE 2 – UNION MEMBERSHIP AND DUES DEDUCTION 2.1. Payroll Deduction The Employer agrees to deduct from the paycheck of each employee, who has so authorized it in writing, the regular monthly dues uniformly required of members of the Union. The amounts deducted shall be transmitted monthly to the Union on behalf of the employees involved. Employees may cancel their payroll deduction by written notice to the Union in accordance with the terms and conditions of their signed payroll authorization card. The AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 16 Union will provide timely notice to the City of the cancellation of their dues authorization by a bargaining unit member. Every effort will be made to end the deduction effective on the first payroll, but not later than the second payroll, after the City’s receipt of notice of cancellation from the Union. Authorizations for Payroll Deduction are valid whether executed in paper form or electronically. The Employer shall provide to the Union monthly a complete list of all bargaining unit members that includes employee name, home address, job title, hire date into current bargaining unit, monthly salary, hourly wage, and whether the employee has authorized the deduction of Union dues. The Union may change the fixed dollar amount, which will be the regular monthly dues, once each calendar year during the life of this agreement. The Union will give the City thirty (30) calendar days’ notice of any such change in the amount of uniform dues to be deducted. 2.2. PAC Program The Employer agrees to deduct from the wages of any employee who is a member of the Union a PEOPLE deduction as provided for in a written authorization. Such authorization must be executed by the employee and may be revoked by the employee at any time by giving written notice to both the Employer and the Union. The City will allow AFSCME, Local 2170 the option to have funds deducted from member’s paychecks twelve (12) times annually to allow contributions to the AFSCME PAC program. The City will send a check once a month to Washington State Council of County and AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 17 City Employees, AFSCME Council 2. The Employer agrees to remit any deductions made pursuant to this provision to the Union together with an itemized statement showing the name of each employee from whose pay such deductions have been made and the amount deducted during the period covered by the remittance. 2.3. Hold Harmless Agreement The Union will indemnify, defend, and hold the Employer harmless against any claims made and against any suit instituted against the Employer on account of any actions by the Employer in administering recognition, union membership and dues deduction. 2.4. Refunds The Union agrees to refund to the Employee any amounts paid to it in error upon presentation of proper evidence thereof. 2.5. New Employees The Employer will furnish to the Local Union Treasurer the names of all new employees in the bargaining unit as specified in Article 1, Section 1.1, within five (5) working days of hire. Newly hired employees shall be granted 30 minutes to meet with their Steward or another officer of the Union. 2.6. Union Officer List The Union agrees to furnish the Employer with a list of Union Officers and Shop Stewards and to maintain such list in a current status. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 18 ARTICLE 3 – HOURS OF WORK 3.1. Work Week The work week shall consist of seven (7) days beginning immediately after 12:00 midnight on Saturday and ending at 12:00 midnight the following Saturday. The regular work week shall consist of forty (40) hours, exclusive of lunch, within the work week. Exceptions to this shall be alternative work schedules, and work weeks which, when utilized, shall be reduced to writing and signed off by the Employer, employee and the Union. The City or the employee may discontinue alternative/flex work schedules and work weeks in accordance with Article 3, Section 3.3.3. Discontinuation of alternative/flex work schedules shall not require the approval of the Union. 3.2. Work Day A regular workday shall consist of not more than ten (10) hours, exclusive of lunch, unless otherwise provided for through an agreed upon alternative work schedule. 3.3. Work Schedules 3.3.1. Normal Work Week – The normal work week shall be five (5) consecutive days of not more than eight (8) hours per day, Monday through Friday, exclusive of the lunch period, except where the work day or work week is different and accepted as a condition of employment or mutually agreed upon in writing between the Union, employee and the Employer. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 19 3.3.2. Flextime and Alternative Work Schedules – Employees may work flex-time or alternative work schedules, with prior supervisory approval. Flexible work schedules shall be mutually agreed upon between the Employer and the employee. All flex-time and alternative work schedules shall be reduced to writing and signed off by the Employer, employee and the Union. Flex-time schedules, by example only, shall be schedules that provide for daily or weekly adjustable work hours. Alternative work schedules, by example only, shall be schedules that allow for schedules other than 5 consecutive days (Monday through Friday) of 8 hours work. 3.3.3. Schedule Changes – Work schedule changes may be initiated by the Employer or the employee. When schedule changes of thirty (30) days or more are initiated by the Employer, employees will receive written notice of the change thirty (30) calendar days prior to the effective date of the change. Except in emergency situations and situations that are unforeseen or unanticipated, employees will receive written notice a minimum of two working days before all other schedule changes initiated by the Employer. If written notice is not received as outlined herein the employee shall receive pay at one and one-half (1½) times their normal hourly rate for the first shift worked on the new schedule. The City will not manipulate work schedules for the sole purpose of avoiding the payment of overtime. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 20 Work schedule changes initiated by the employee may take place immediately with the concurrence of the supervisor, provided that the change does not create an undue hardship in the department or disservice to the public. 3.3.4. Consecutive Hours Worked – Employees shall not work more than sixteen (16) consecutive hours during any consecutive twenty-four (24) hour period. 3.4. Meal and Rest Periods Meal Period – There shall be an unpaid meal period of not less than one-half (1/2) hour nor more than one (1) hour during the regular workday. If an employee is required to work two (2) or more hours beyond his or her regular work day the employee shall be entitled to an additional paid meal period of one-half (1/2) hour. For each additional four (4) hour overtime increment beyond the two (2) hours, the employee shall receive an additional meal period of one- half (1/2) hour. If the Employer furnishes meals, the employee shall eat them on his or her own time. Whenever possible the meal period shall be scheduled near the middle of the workday. An employee may voluntarily waive their unpaid meal period with written approval from their supervisor. The documentation showing that it was a voluntary waiver at the employee’s request will be retained by HRRM in compliance with Department of Labor’s Wage and Hour regulations. This voluntary waiver is to be used occasionally and is not intended to be a regular on-going change to the employee’s work schedule/shift. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 21 3.4.1. 3.4.2. Rest Period – Except in emergency situations, there shall be one fifteen (15) minute rest period during each four (4) hour period of the workday whenever feasible. Emergency situations are defined as situations where injury to persons, loss of life and/or serious public or private property damage are possible. 3.5. Clean-Up Time Employees whose work requires personal clean-up prior to leaving the Employer’s premises or job site shall be allowed necessary time for doing so prior to meal breaks, not to exceed five (5) minutes, and the end of the shift, not to exceed ten (10) minutes. Work schedules shall be arranged so employees may take advantage of this provision where it is applicable. ARTICLE 4 –OVERTIME 4.1. Overtime 4.1.1. Allocation of Overtime – The Employer shall determine when and by whom overtime will be worked. Whenever feasible, the Employer will request volunteers from among the employees with the requisite skills to perform the work, before requiring employees to work overtime. Overtime opportunities AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 22 will be allocated as equally as possible among employees within a work unit. 4.1.2. Overtime Rate – Except as otherwise provided in this Article, all hours worked in excess of the employee’s scheduled workday, when worked upon the direction or approval of the employee’s supervisor, shall be paid at the rate of one and one-half (1½) times the employee’s straight-time hourly rate or compensated by granting one and one-half (1½) times the number of excess hours worked as compensatory time. Overtime shall be based on compensated hours and in accordance with FLSA regulations. The employee shall make his or her choice (overtime pay or compensatory time) known to his or her supervisor not later than the end of the work week in which the work was performed. 4.1.3. Compensatory Time – Compensatory time off, when granted, shall be at a time convenient to the employee and consistent with the operating needs of the Employer. Compensatory time off shall be taken under this Article as required by the Fair Labor Standards Act, if such continues to be applicable to local government employees. Compensatory time banks shall not exceed one hundred (100) hours. Employees may cash out compensatory time during any pay period throughout the calendar year. Any compensatory time over forty (40) hours as of December 31 will be automatically cashed out at the AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 23 employee’s regular rate of pay and paid on the January 10 paycheck. Employees with forty (40) hours or less shall be allowed to carry over the time into the following year. 4.1.4. Computing Overtime – The nearest one-quarter (1/4) hour shall be used in computing overtime. 4.1.5. Meeting Attendance Outside of Normal Work Schedule – With supervisory approval, each employee that is required to attend a meeting on their normally scheduled workday before or after their regularly scheduled shift shall be allowed to modify their schedule during the work week of the meeting so that the work week does not exceed their regularly scheduled hours. This Section does not prohibit employees that modify their time, as above, from receiving overtime as otherwise provided in this Article for hours worked outside of their normally scheduled work day that fall on non-modified days. 4.1.6. Extended Consecutive Day Overtime– Employees required to work on a regularly scheduled day off shall be paid at the rate of time and one-half (1 ½) for the first twelve (12) hours and the rate of two times (2x) their regular rate of pay, consistent with Section 4.3 below, for any hours worked in excess of twelve (12) hours. Employees required to work on a second consecutive day shall be paid at two (2) times their regular rate of pay for all hours worked. If during the workweek, a half day (or more) of holiday, vacation, AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 24 sick leave and comp-time are taken, this does not count as paid work when determining the consecutive days for purposes of double time. 4.1.7. The following positions are set up as program oriented and as a condition of hire these positions may perform evening and weekend work as programs require. These positions may require a voluntary shifting of schedule within the workday and this shift will not trigger overtime. These positions are not subject to daily overtime but will be paid weekly overtime for compensable hours in excess of the normally scheduled work week. • Senior Program Specialist and Program Specialist • Neighborhood Program Coordinator • Farmer’s Market Coordinator • Program Assistant • Recreation Coordinator • Recreation Specialist 4.1.6.• Recreation Assistant 4.2. Call-back Pay Call-back shall be defined as all time worked in excess of a scheduled shift, which is not an extension of that shift, and is unanticipated, unforeseen, and not a regular function of the employee’s work schedule. “Unanticipated, unforeseen” shall include, but not be limited to, work that is performed where the employee has been notified after the conclusion of their regular AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 25 work day and the work is performed prior to the start of their next regular work day. Employees who are required to report to the work site or the field shall be paid a minimum of two (2) hours at a rate of two times (2x) their regular hourly rate of pay, starting from the time they answer the phone through the time they return home (portal to portal). Employees who are not required to report to the work site or field but can address the issue(s) from home shall be paid for one (1) hour of work at two times (2x) their regular hourly rate so long as the time is spent working and not merely informational, i.e., schedule change. Employees who qualify for the one (1) hour call back pay shall not be subject to the provisions of paragraph 4.5 of this Article regarding the suspension of standby pay. Employees who work more than one (1) hour without reporting to the worksite or field shall be paid at (2x) their regular hourly rate for all hours worked at home and will be subject to the provisions of paragraph 4.5 of this Article regarding the suspension of standby pay. Recreation staff involved in conducting scheduled recreation programs/events shall be excluded from this provision. Employees who must attend regularly scheduled meetings after their normal work hours shall be paid a one (1) hour minimum at the time and one-half (1½) rate. 4.3. Extended Shift Overtime Employees required to work more than four (4) hours beyond the end of their scheduled workshiftwork shift shall be paid at two AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 26 times (2x) their regular rate of pay for all time worked beyond the first four hours of overtime. 4.4. Shift Differential A shift differential of $1.00 shall be paid for all hours worked by an employee when fifty percent (50%) of his or her regular workday is between 12:00 midnight and 8:00 a.m. When such shift is requested by the employee and approved by the Employer, this provision shall not apply. 4.5. Standby The Employer reserves the right to establish a standby program. Based on service needs, each department may establish a roster of qualified personnel who would be available for callback during an emergency situation. Personnel identified as on standby shall be required to carry a cell phone or other device and be able to respond immediately to call-back situations without restrictions or impairments. Employees on standby shall receive standby pay as follows: Starting with the first full pay period following ratification and adoption of the successor agreement standby pay shall be paid at $23.940 per hour. Only the employee carrying the standby phone at the time of the callout, and driving their own personal vehicle, is eligible for reimbursement at the standard federal mileage rate. The reimbursement would be for their drive to the worksite due to a callback (roundtrip) from the employee’s home address or a maximum of 30 miles each way, whichever is less. Travel time for distance between home and regular or main job is considered a taxable fringe benefit and will be added to their AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 27 paycheck. Travel time for distances between home and temporary work location (if not regular or main job), or main job and temporary work location, are not considered a taxable fringe benefit. To request mileage reimbursement, the employee must submit a written claim verifying mileage, travel location(s) and the date(s) of call-back(s). Standby allowance shall be suspended upon callback and the provisions of Section 4.2 of this Article shall prevail. Standby periods shall be determined by the Employer. Standby pay is not available during the employee’s regular work hours. Management reserves the right to transfer the standby assignment when the employee is unavailable for their standby assignment. Qualified personnel shall be determined by the Employer and assigned by on a rotational basis. Every effort will be made to establish the roster on a volunteer basis. If insufficient volunteers exist, placement on the roster shall be mandatory. 4.6. Uniform Allowance The City of Renton shall furnish standard clothing of the City’s choice and design to all field staff in the Maintenance Services and Transportation Maintenance Divisions of Public Works. Eligible staff in these divisions shall have an allowance of $300 per calendar year to purchase any combination of the following items: T-Shirts Long Sleeve Button Down Shirt Long Sleeve T-Shirts Long Jeans** Sweat Shirts (1) Stocking Cap AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 28 Collared Shirt ** The purchase of long jeans must not exceed $150. A newly hired employee will be able to access this $300 clothing allowance upon hire. Clothing damaged or contaminated on-duty shall be cleaned or replaced at the City’s discretion, however the City will not exceed $175 in replacement costs per employee, per calendar year. The City of Renton shall furnish standard clothing of the City’s choice and design to the Court Security Officer to include: (5) Shirts with Court Security language and name (1) Light-Weight Jacket with Court Security language and name (3) Pairs of Black pants Clothing will be replaced once per year or as needed for the Court Security Officer. All clothing items bearing a Renton insignia and in the employee’s possession remain the property of the City and must be returned when leaving employment with the City. If the insignia-bearing items are not returned by the employee, the employee will be subject to a pro rata deduction of the current year’s utilized benefit (not to exceed $300) from the employee’s final paycheck. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 29 4.7. Acting Pay When an employee is asked to assume the duties of a position at a higher salary grade on a temporary basis, the employee shall receive a premium equal to five percent (5%) of their base salary, provided the temporary promotion will extend for at least fifteen (15) calendar days. ARTICLE 5 – SICK LEAVE 5.1. Sick Leave Accrual Sick leave is available when an employee is absent as a result of personal illness or injury, or when medically necessary to care for the employee’s child, parent, parent-in-law, spouse, domestic partner or a domestic partner’s child, and grandparent, as provided by the Family Care Act of Washington (FCA), WAC 296-130, and/or the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), the Washington State Family Leave Act (FLA), or any qualified FMLA covered reason. 5.1.1. Upon employment, new full time employees shall receive twenty-four (24) hours sick leave. At the end of the first three months of full time employment an additional twenty-four (24) hours sick leave shall be granted. At the completion of six full months of employment, employees shall accrue sick leave at the rate of eight (8) hours per month. Employees who resign or are terminated prior to completing six full months of employment shall reimburse the Employer for any used but unearned sick leave. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 30 5.1.2. Sick leave accrual shall be prorated based on the employee’s regularly scheduled weekly hours of work, divided by 40. 5.1.3. Employees shall be allowed to use sick leave in increments of fifteen (15) minutes. 5.2. Sick Leave Cash Out For employees hired before January 1, 1994, cash payment of accrued, unused sick leave shall be made upon a PERS I employee’s resignation, retirement, discharge (unless discharge is a result of the employee’s conviction of any criminal statutes relating to or connected with his/her employment), or death. Such payment shall be limited to 50% of accumulated but unused sick leave, to a maximum of 960 hours. In the event of death, payment shall be made to the estate of the employee. Employees hired on or after January 1, 1994, shall not be eligible for cash out of any accrued but unused sick leave. 5.3. Long Term Disability Plan All employees will be enrolled in an Employer-sponsored long-term disability plan with a benefit equal to 60% of base salary after a maximum waiting period of 90 calendar days. If an LTD claim is approved by the carrier, employees will be permitted to use any accrued leave balance they have at 40%, bringing the combination of the LTD benefit and accrued leave payment to 100% of their pre- disability earnings. The Employer will pay the premiums necessary to fund the benefits of the plan. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 31 5.4. Notification Requirements 5.4.1. Sick leave may be taken in lieu of vacation time whenever an employee is on vacation and becomes sick or hospitalized. A doctor’s certificate of the illness must be furnished by the employee in a timely manner to substantiate such sickness or disability. This exchange will not alter the employee’s scheduled vacation except by mutual agreement with the Employer. 5.4.2. The Employer may require a signed statement from the employee’s Health Care Provider for absences of three (3) days or longer or if the City reasonably suspects sick leave abuse. 5.4.3. An employee who will be out on sick leave must notify his or her immediate supervisor or other designated person of the absence prior to the start of said leave, or as soon as possible. 5.5. Abuse of Sick Leave Use of sick leave is restricted to the purposes set forth in Section 5.1 of this Article. Employees found to be abusing sick leave privileges shall be subject to disciplinary action, pursuant to Article 16, Section 16.3. 5.6 WA State Paid Family Medical Leave AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 32 5.6.1 Eligible employees are covered by Washington’s Family and Medical Leave Program, RCW 50A.04. Eligibility for leave and benefits, which began January 1, 2020, is established by Washington law and is therefore independent of this Agreement. Premiums for benefits are established by law, will total four-tenths of one percent (0.4%) of employees’ wages (unless otherwise limited by action of the State). Employees will pay through payroll deduction the full cost of the premiums associated with family leave benefits and forty-five percent (45%) of the cost of the premiums associated with the medical leave benefits, as determined under RCW 50A.04.115 5.6.2 Use of sick leave: For better consistency across leave plans, sick leave may be used for family members, including spouse, child, grandchild, parent, or grandparent, as these relationships are defined in the State PFML. Leave may be taken for siblings only for State Accrued Sick Leave, and PFML. 5.6.3 Coordination with PFML: Employees who are approved by the State for a benefit under PFML will be permitted to use their accrued leave balance as a “Supplemental Benefit” to bring them to full base pay, in accordance with provisions outlined by the State. Employees will have the option to 1) use accrued leave exclusively and forgo the PFML, or 2) use PFML exclusively and forgo use of AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 33 accrued leave, or 3) use their accrued leave as a Supplemental Benefit in combination with their PFML to bring them to full base pay. Employees may change their election effective the first day of any pay period, by notifying HR and completing a new election form. For those employees, electing option 3 above, the procedures for a Supplemental Benefit will be similar to the City’s existing procedures for Workers’ Comp Time Loss, with the accompanying leave buy back. Employees will submit leave time to the City for a Supplemental Benefit for the full number of hours not worked. They will submit the full amount of the PFML benefit they receive to the City in a timely manner. The amount of the PFML benefit will be used to “buy back” a portion of the accrued leave that was taken as a Supplemental Benefit. In order to use accrued leave as a “Supplemental Benefit” the employee must, in advance, sign an agreement to submit the PFML benefit amount to the City as soon as practical, and in no case later than 30 days of receipt. Any employee electing this option and failing to return the PFML benefit amount(s) received will be in violation of City policy and the Union Contract and may be subject to discipline. When necessary, the Union will support the bargaining unit members in meeting their “check return” obligation. If leave balances with the City are exhausted, the employee will move to option 2 above. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 34 ARTICLE 6 – HOLIDAYS Employees shall receive holidays in accord with the following: 6.1. Observed Holidays The following days shall be observed as legal holidays: 6.1.1. January 1 (New Year’s Day) 6.1.2. Third Monday in January (Martin Luther King, Jr. Day) 6.1.3. Last Monday in May (Memorial Day) 6.1.3.6.1.4. June 19th (Juneteenth) 6.1.4.6.1.5. July 4 (Independence Day) 6.1.5.6.1.6. 1st Monday in September (Labor Day) 6.1.6.6.1.7. November 11 (Veterans’ Day) 6.1.7.6.1.8. 4th Thursday in November (Thanksgiving) 6.1.8.6.1.9. 4th Friday in November (day after Thanksgiving) 6.1.9.6.1.10. December 25 (Christmas Day) 6.1.10.6.1.11. The day before Christmas shall be a holiday for employees wWhen Christmas Day occursis observed on a Tuesday, Wednesday or Friday, the previous day shall be a holiday. The day after Christmas shall be a holiday for City employees Wwhen Christmas day occurs on a Monday, Wednesday, or Thursday the next day shall be a holiday. When Christmas day occurs on a Saturday, the two preceding working days shall be observed as holidays. When Christmas Day AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 35 occurs on a Sunday, the two working days following shall be observed as holidays. 6.1.11.6.1.12. Two personal holidays of employee’s choice. Existing employees will be eligible for the two (2) personal holidays from the beginning of the year. Upon employment, new employees will be eligible for one (1) day (8 hours) of personal holiday to use. After being employed for six (6) months, the employee will be eligible for the second day (8 hours) of personal holiday to use. Except, if the employee begins employment on/or after July 1st, they will not be eligible for the second personal holiday in that year. 6.1.12.6.1.13. Any other day proclaimed by the Governor for all political subdivisions of the State;State, or by the Mayor of the City. 6.2. Holiday Pay 6.2.1. Working on Holidays - Holiday situations are as follows: 6.2.1.1. For employees working on an observed holiday, the observed holiday shall be considered the holiday. 6.2.1.2. For employees working on an actual holiday but not the observed holiday, the actual holiday shall be considered the holiday. 6.2.1.3. For employees working on both the actual holiday and the observed holiday, only the actual holiday shall be considered a holiday. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 36 6.2.2. Pay Rates for Working on Holidays: Employees scheduled to work in one of the three (3) situations listed above shall receive one and one-half (1½) times their regular rate of pay for all hours worked on the holiday and the employee shall be permitted to: 6.2.2.1. Schedule an alternate day off within the same calendar year (up to eight (8) hours) with prior approval from his or her supervisor which does not cause significant operational disruption for the department; or 6.2.2.2. Receive up to eight (8) hours holiday pay for that holiday worked. 6.2.3. The decision to grant holiday pay or a compensatory day off shall be determined in advance. 6.2.4. Employees scheduled in advance to work on a holiday shall be scheduled for a minimum of four (4) hours. 6.3. Holidays Falling on Scheduled Day Off Whenever the actual holiday or the observed holiday falls on an employee’s regularly scheduled day off, the employee shall be allowed to use eight (8) hours, in one (1) hour increments, at anytime before the end of the year. If both the actual holiday and the observed holiday occur on regularly scheduled days off the employee shall be granted only eight (8) hours off with pay. Unused holidays granted under this provision shall have no cash value. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 37 6.4. Holidays Falling on Weekends When a holiday falls on a Saturday, the preceding Friday shall be observed as the Holiday. When a holiday falls on a Sunday, the following Monday shall be observed as the holiday. For employees regularly scheduled Saturday and/or Sunday, holidays shall be observed on the actual holidays. If an employee is scheduled to work on both an observed holiday and the actual holiday, they will be compensated as described in Section 6.2 of this Article. 6.5 Regular Part-time All regular part-time employees subject to the provisions of this Agreement shall receive holiday leave at a pro-rated amount based on the number of hours scheduled in their work week divided by forty (40) hours. 6.6. Personal Holiday Use/Cash Out Personal Holiday hours may be used in 15 minute increments. Personal Holiday hours not used by the employee by December 31 will be cashed out at the employee’s hourly base rate for that same year, and paid on the January 10 pay check. Eligible Personal Holiday hours not used by the employee at time of employment separation for any reason will be cashed out at the employee’s current hourly base rate and paid in the employee’s final paycheck. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 38 ARTICLE 7 – VACATIONS 7.1. Accrual Rate The following vacation benefits shall be provided: Length of Service Days per Year Hours per Pay Period Hours per Year 0 through 5 years 12 4 96 6 through 10 years 18 6 144 11 through 15 years 21 7 168 16 through 20 years 24 8 192 21 and subsequent years 27 9 216 7.1.1 Regular part-time employees subject to the provisions of this Agreement shall be provided vacation benefits at a pro-rated amount based on the number of hours scheduled in their workweek divided by forty (40) hours. 7.1.2 Employees may use accrued vacation leave in increments of fifteen (15) minutes. 7.2. Maximum Vacation Accumulation The maximum accumulation of vacation time for an employee shall not exceed twice the current annual accrual limit as provided in above Section 7.1. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 39 7.3. Vacation Requests Requests for vacation leave are subject to supervisory approval. Except in emergency situations, requests for vacation leave shall be submitted in writing, at least the workday prior to the requested time off. Vacation requests shall be responded to within one week unless submitted less than two weeks in advance. For vacation requests submitted less than two weeks in advance, a response within one working day after receipt is required. 7.4 Cash Out Upon Separation Vacation accrued but unused during the term of the employee’s employment with the city will be cashed out at the employee’s hourly base rate at the time the employee separates from city employment. ARTICLE 8 – BEREAVEMENT LEAVE Up to three days with pay shall be given to employees for each instance of a death of the employee’s mother, father, step-parent, legal guardian, spouse/domestic partner, child, stepchild, child of a domestic partner, mother-in-law, father-in-law, sister, brother, brother-in-law, sister-in-law, grandchild, or grandparents. The number of hours of bereavement leave allowed regular part-time employees covered by this Agreement shall be adjusted to reflect the number of scheduled hours in their workweek. All requests for extended bereavement leave shall be approved by the Department Administrator in advance. Employees may use accrued vacation, compensatory time, and/or personal holiday AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 40 hours to cover extended bereavement leave. Sick leave may be used if all other leave banks are exhausted. ARTICLE 9 – INSURANCES Definitions: REHBT: Renton Employees’ Healthcare Board of Trustees REHP: Renton Employees’ Healthcare Plan Funding Goal: It is the responsibility of the Renton Employees’ Healthcare Board of Trustees to establish and maintain fund goals in relationship to the Renton Employee’s Healthcare Plan. Plan Member: An eligible Renton employee, along with their dependents, that is covered under the Renton Employees’ Healthcare Plan. Premiums: The contributions made to the REHP by both the City and the employees to cover the total cost of purchasing the REHP. Contributions made by employees for co-pays, lab fees, ineligible charges, etc., are not considered premiums for the purpose of this Article. 9.1. Health Insurance 9.1.1. Participation - The City and the Local/Union/Guild agree to jointly manage the REHP during the term of this agreement. The REHBT is comprised of AFSCME Local 2170; Police Guild; and the City, and will meet at AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 41 least quarterly to review the REHP including costs associated with the REHP. Medical coverage shall be provided in accord with the laws of the State of Washington, RCW 41.26.150 and federal plans: Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act and the Health Care and Education Affordability Reconciliation Act of 2010. The Local/Union/Guild agrees to continue participation in the REHBT and to identify and support cost containment measures. 9.1.2. Plan Coverage - The City will provide a medical/dental, vision, and prescription drug insurance plan for all eligible employees including all bargaining unit members and their eligible dependents. 9.1.3. Premiums - For- For the calendar years 201922 through calendar year 20204, the total cost of the plan shall be divided as follows: YEAR CITY EMPLOYEES 20192022 9291% 89% 20203 91% 9% 2024 91% 9% Employee premiums will be based upon the following categories: • Employee • Employee/1 • Employee/2+ AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 42 • Employee/Spouse or Domestic Partner • Employee/Spouse or Domestic Partner/1 • Employee/Spouse or Domestic Partner/2+ 9.1.4. Projected Costs –The plan contributions shall be calculated by the percentage of actual plan cost increase that occurred in the previous year and based on consideration of Actuarial projections. The year in review shall be from July 1st to June 30th. 9.1.5. Alternative Plan Coverage – City contributions for the alternative plan will be at the same cost share percentage as the self-funded plan capped at the dollar amount contributed to the self-funded plan. 9.1.6. Renton Employees’ Healthcare Board of Trustees – The REHBT includes members from each participating Union. Each union will have a maximum of one (1) vote, i.e. the Police Guild has two (2) bargaining units but only receives one (1) vote on the REHBT. The City only receives one (1) vote also. If all bargaining units participate, the voting bodies would be as follows: AFSCME – 2170; Police Guild; and the City for a total of three (3) votes. 9.1.7. Plan Changes – The members of the REHBT shall have full authority to make plan design changes without further concurrence from bargaining unit members and the City Council during the life of this agreement. 9.1.8. Voting – Changes in the REHP will be determined by a majority of the votes cast by REHBT members. A tie AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 43 vote of the REHBT members related to a proposed plan design change will result in continuing the current design. 9.1.9. Surplus – Any surplus in the Medical Plan shall remain available only for use by the Renton Employees’ Health Plan Board of Trustees for either improvements in the Plan, future costs increase offsets, rebates to participants, or reduction in employee contributions. 9.2 Cadillac Tax If by 2022 the Cadillac Tax required by the Affordable Care Act is still in effect and will require additional funding of the Renton Employees’ Healthcare Plan, the parties agree to meet and negotiate changes to the plan in such a way as to address the impacts of the Cadillac Tax. 9.32. Life Insurance The Employer shall furnish to the employee a group term life insurance policy in the amount of the employee’s annual salary plus longevity, rounded to the nearest $1,000 including double indemnity and limited to a maximum benefit of $50,000. The Employer shall furnish a group term life insurance policy for $1,000 for the employee’s spouse and $1,000 for each dependent. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 44 9.43. Federal/State Healthcare Options In the event of a Federal/State healthcare option, the REHBT shall have the option to review the proposed Federal/State option and take appropriate actions. 9.54. COBRA When an employee or dependents health care benefits ceases based on a qualifying event, the employee or dependent shall be offered medical and dental benefits under the provision of Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (COBRA). ARTICLE 10 – JURY DUTY When an employee is called for jury duty, or is subpoenaed as a witness in any litigation/administrative hearing process in which the employee is not a party, such time shall be considered as time worked and paid at the appropriate salary level of the employee. Employees shall be required to give reasonable advance notice of such subpoena or other legal requirement to appear and provide the City with a copy of the subpoena or other legal document requiring the employee’s presence. The copy of the subpoena or legal document will be given to the City in advance of the hearing or jury duty or if that is not possible, then the copy must be furnished within 72 hours after the hearing or jury duty date. All monies received as witness or jury fees must be signed over to the City excluding any mileage/expense reimbursements. Employees will be required to call their supervisor when less than a normal workday is required by jury or witness duty. The supervisor shall determine if the employee shall be required to report to work and shall take into consideration the travel time of the employee. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 45 ARTICLE 11 – EDUCATION AND CONFERENCE 11.1. Time Off and Financial Reimbursement Employees will be granted reasonable amounts of time off and financial reimbursement for attending training programs whenever such training is work-related and attendance is required by the Employer. 11.2. Valid Business Expenses Employees who conduct authorized, official City business or participate in conferences as official representatives of the Employer while outside the City shall be reimbursed for all valid business expenses. 11.3. Access to Training The Employer is committed to the principle of training for all employees. Whenever feasible, training shall be made available for each employee within a classification within a division to prepare them to perform all the job duties associated with that classification. Equal access to training opportunities to the extent that operational requirements permit shall be provided. ARTICLE 12 – SALARIES 12.1. Salaries 12.1.1. Effective January 1, 201922, wages shall be increased by 3.56% over the base wages of 201821. The 6% increase for pay periods that have already been processed will be retroactively paid AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 46 to all AFSCME represented employees who were employed on or after January 1, 2022.Retro activity will be paid no later than the October 25th, 2019 paycheck for those AFSCME represented bargaining unit employees actively employed as of June 21, 2019.The parties understand and agree that the “me too” language of the 2021 contract extension is no longer active and that the current contract is focused on future wage adjustments. 12.1.2.12.1.1. Effective July 1, 2019January 1, 2023, wages shall be increased by 3.75100% of the 2022 Seattle- Tacoma-Bellevue June to June CPI-U with a minimum of 1.5% and a maximum of 4.5%over the base wages of 2018. 12.1.3. Effective January 1, 20204, wages shall be increased by 100% of the 2023 Seattle-Tacoma-Bellevue June to June CPI-U with a minimum of 1.5% and a maximum of 4.5%.3.25% over the base wages of 2019. 12.1.4.12.1.2. Effective July 1, 2020, wages shall be increased by 3.5% over the base wages of 2019. 12.2. Step Increases All anniversary step increases shall begin being paid upon the payday following the anniversary date and thereafter during the life of this Agreement. There is no acceleration of steps. 12.3 VEBA One (1) percent of employee’s base pay in lieu of One (1) percent of the existing Deferred Compensation Benefit (Article 14) to fund a AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 47 City selected and contracted Voluntary Employees’ Beneficiary Association (VEBA) plan/vendor. Funding of the VEBA plans for employees will be effective April 1, 2022. Funding of the VEBA account will occur in each pay period where the employee has pay from the City for at least half of their scheduled hours and the City will handle the transfer of funds. During a pay period where the employee does not have pay for at least half of their scheduled hours, they will not have the VEBA contribution (except for leaves covered by FMLA and/or PFML). These funds are provided by the employer and are a Mandatory Employee Contribution to VEBA. ARTICLE 13 - LONGEVITY 13.1. Longevity Pay Calculation Effective June 1, 2019 employees shall receive monthly longevity pay in accordance with the following scale: Years of Service 5 years 2.0% of the monthly Grade a14, step E 10 years 3.0 % of the monthly Grade a14, step E 15 years 4.0% of the monthly Grade a14, step E 20 years 5.0% of the monthly Grade a14, step E 25 years 6.0% of the monthly Grade a14, step E 30 years 7.0% of the monthly Grade a14, step E AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 48 Regular part-time employees covered by this Agreement shall receive a pro-rated amount of this scale based on the number of hours scheduled in their workweek. 13.2. Longevity Pay Date Longevity will be paid as follows based on adjusted service date: • If the employee’s Adjusted Service Date is on or between the 1st and the 15th, the employee will receive their longevity allowances on the 25th of that month. • If the employee’s Adjusted Service Date is on or between the 16th and the 31st, the employee will receive their longevity allowances on the 10th of the next month. ARTICLE 14 – DEFERRED COMPENSATION Effective April 1, 2022 Tthe Employer shall make a deposit equal to four three percent (43%) of each eligible employee’s base wage into a deferred compensation account selected by the employee from the accounts provided by the City, each pay period. Prior to April 1, 2022, the Employer shall make a deposit equal to four percent (4%). ARTICLE 15 – PAY PERIOD Employees shall be paid twice each month and any employee who is laid off or terminated shall be paid all monies due on the next following payday. All employees shall be paid on the 10th and 25th day of each month. If the 10th or 25th day of the month falls on a holiday or weekend period, the employees shall be paid on the last business day prior to that period. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 49 All employees will participate in payroll direct deposit. The employer will provide computer stations in convenient work locations to enable employees to access and print their electronic pay stubs during working hours. ARTICLE 16 – MANAGEMENT RIGHTS Subject only to the limitations expressly stated in this Agreement, the Union recognizes the prerogative of the Employer to operate and manage its affairs in accord with its responsibilities, powers, and authority, including but not limited to the following: 16.1. The right to establish reasonable work rules. 16.2. The right to schedule overtime in a manner most advantageous to the Employer. 16.3. The right to discipline and/or discharge employees for just cause. 16.4. The right to determine work schedules, to establish the methods and processes by which work is to be performed and the number of employees necessary to perform the work. 16.5. The right to assign work and determine the duties performed by employees in classifications included in the bargaining unit. 16.6. The employer shall retain the right to determine whether layoffs are necessary and in which departments, divisions, and classifications they will occur. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 50 16.7 Application of the management rights as detailed above to employees in the Municipal Court shall reside with the Presiding Judge. The presiding judge of the Renton Municipal Court or their judicial designee will maintain full responsibility for discipline, termination, layoff and recall decisions subject to the provisions of this agreement. It is understood that judicial and administrative duties of the presiding judge cannot be delegated to persons in either the legislative or executive branches of government. Further, it is understood by both parties that every incidental duty connected with operations enumerated in a job classification is not always specifically described. ARTICLE 17 – UNION ACTIVITIES 17.1. Paid Release Time With prior notice, the Employer will grant employees who are Union officials, or members who are appointed to a joint management committee, reasonable time off with pay for the purpose of attending scheduled meetings with City officials. Additionally, members may have 30 minutes prior to the meeting to prepare and 30 minutes after the meeting to debrief. The Shop Steward or alternate Shop Steward and/or one Union official will be granted reasonable time off with pay by the immediate supervisor to investigate grievances. Notwithstanding the above, only two employees per work section shall be released to attend AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 51 Union meetings during the workday and must code their time as union business. 17.2. Facility Access The designated Staff Representative of the Union shall be allowed access at all reasonable times to all facilities of the Employer wherein the employees covered under this contract may be working. Access shall be granted for the purpose of conducting necessary official local Union business and investigating grievances; provided there is minimal interruption to normal work processes. 17.3. Union Communication The Employer shall permit the reasonable use of bulletin boards, e- mail, and interoffice mail by the Union for the posting of notices or communications relating to official Union business. 17.4. Training Time Union officials may request reasonable time off with pay to attend training that is beneficial to both labor and management. Approval will be at the discretion of the employee’s Department Administrator or designee for the scheduling of time, the appropriateness of the leave shall be at the discretion of the Human Resources Department. 17.5. Negotiations Six (6) members of the Union shall be granted paid release time to participate in negotiations occurring during their normally scheduled work hours. The Union agrees that a bargaining team that is as broadly representative as possible of the various work AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 52 sites, departments, classifications, and demographics is a goal when selecting the participants for the Union bargaining team. ARTICLE 18 – LABOR/MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE The Employer and the Union agree that a need exists for closer cooperation between labor and management, and that from time to time suggestions and complaints of a general nature affecting the Union and the Employer need consideration. To accomplish this end, the Employer and the Union agree that not more than three (3) authorized representatives of the Union shall function as one- half of a Labor/Management Committee; the other half being not more than three (3) representatives of the Employer named for that purpose. The parties agree to allow expanded participation in Labor/Management Committee discussions, when necessary, by mutual agreement. Said committee shall meet as requested by either party for the purpose of discussing and facilitating the resolution of all problems which may arise between the parties other than those for which another procedure is provided by law or by other provisions of this Agreement. It is understood and agreed that the purpose of this committee does not include the hearing of formal grievances brought under the provisions of Article 23 of this Agreement. ARTICLE 19 – WORK STOPPAGES AND EMPLOYER PROTECTION 19.1. Uninterrupted City Services The Employer and the Union agree that the public interest requires efficient and uninterrupted performance of all City services and to this end pledge their best efforts to avoid or eliminate any conduct AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 53 contrary to this objective during the term of this Agreement or any extension mutually agreed upon. Specifically, the Union shall not cause or condone any work stoppage including any strike, slowdown, non-bona fide sick leave absence, refusal to perform any customarily assigned duties, refusal to cross a picket line on City premises (unless same is sanctioned by the King County Labor Council), or other interference with City functions by employees under this Agreement. Any concerted action by any employee in any bargaining unit shall be deemed a work stoppage if any of the foregoing activities has occurred. Should any such activity occur, the Union agrees to take appropriate action immediately to end such interference. 19.2. Work Stoppage Upon notification in writing by the Employer to the Union that any of its members are engaged in a work stoppage, the Union immediately shall order, in writing, such members to cease engaging immediately in such work stoppage and shall provide the Employer with a copy of such order. In addition, a responsible official of the Union shall publicly order such Union employees to cease engaging in such a work stoppage. 19.3. Disciplinary Action for Work Stoppage Regardless of any penalty to which the Union is subject under this Section, any employee who commits any act prohibited in this section may be subject to the following penalties: 19.3.1. Oral reprimand 19.3.2. Written reprimand 19.3.3. Suspension (notice to be given in writing) AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 54 19.3.4. Discharge It is understood that these penalties are not necessarily sequential. Disciplinary action resulting from violation of this Article will be tailored to the nature and severity of the offense. ARTICLE 20 – NON-DISCRIMINATION The Employer and the Union agree that they shall not discriminate against any employee because of race, color, religion, national origin, ethnic group, age, gender, marital status, sexual orientation, genetic information, disability status, veteran/military status, union affiliation, non-affiliation or union activities as sanctioned by this contract, and/or any other protected class or characteristic under federal, state, or local law. ARTICLE 21 – RECRUITMENT AND SELECTIO N PROCESS 21.1. Posting of Vacancies Whenever the Employer determines to fill a vacant bargaining unit position, the Employer will post the announcement on the City’s website and provide the announcement to the Union’s Executive Board. Vacancies may be posted as internal only recruitments for at least seven (7) working days or external recruitments for at least ten (10) working days. Any City employee may apply for a vacant position. All bargaining unit employees who apply and meet the selection criteria shall be tested in accordance with procedures set forth in the job announcement. Recruitments that are posted AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 55 internally and then re-posted externally will be considered the same recruitment. A bargaining unit applicant failing to advance during an internal only recruitment will not be considered during any subsequent external recruitment for the vacant position. Internal postings that result in only one employee passing the selection process may be re-posted externally. An internal applicant that has passed the prior internal selection process will be considered during the subsequent external process. Any bargaining unit employee not meeting the selection criteria may request, and will receive in writing, the selection criteria used, and the criteria that they did not meet. 21.2. Selection Process 21.2.1. Selection Procedure. The filling of vacancies will be done in an objective, fair and impartial manner. The Employer will determine the selection procedure which may include written, practical, and oral examinations. Selection criteria will bear a direct relationship to job performance and constitute bona fide occupational qualifications necessary to properly and efficiently function in the position. All qualified applicants will go through a consistent selection procedure and be informed of the passing point for any administered exam. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 56 21.2.2. Process Review. In the event that a bargaining unit applicant is not selected, that employee may request, and shall be given in writing, his or her itemized score and placement according to test results within one week of the request. 21.3. Eligible Candidate Pool A candidate that passes the selection process as specified in Section 21.2 above has been determined to be qualified for the position and will have their application remain in the “eligible candidate pool” for that particular recruitment. Hiring managers may offer a position to any candidate who passes the selection process and has their name in the eligible candidate pool. The Employer may use the eligible candidate pool for a period of up to twelve (12) months to fill vacancies for the same position or another position in the same job classification. 21.4. Promotional Opportunities Whenever a promotional opportunity within the bargaining unit is created through the conversion of an existing filled position to a new classification with higher duties, the Employer shall give only employees within the same classification and section an opportunity to apply for the promotion. The Employer will distribute an announcement of the promotional opportunity to the Union President and employees in the same classification and section as the position to be restructured. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 57 Eligible employees may apply for the position by submitting an application within the seven (7) working day posting period. The Employer will award the promotion to the most qualified employee in accordance with Section 21.2 of this Article. ARTICLE 22 – PROBATIONARY PERIOD 22.1. 12-Month Probationary Period New employees shall serve a probationary period during their first twelve months of employment. During this time, they are considered “At Will” employees and serve at the pleasure of the Employer. Employees terminated during their first twelve months of employment shall not have recourse to the grievance procedure. 22.2. 6-Month Probationary Period Existing City employees who are promoted shall serve a six-month probationary period. In the event a promoted employee fails to pass probation: Series Position: The employee will return to his/her lower classification in the series. Non-Series Position: The employee shall be eligible to return to his/her previous position, if it has not been filled. If the position has been filled, the employee may be eligible to return to his/her previous position if the current incumbent fails their probationary period. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 58 ARTICLE 23 – GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE 23.1. Definition Grievance is hereby defined as the question or challenge raised by an employee or the Union as to the correct interpretation or application of this Agreement by the Employer. It is the purpose of this clause to provide the employees and the Union with an orderly and effective means of achieving consideration of any grievance, which may arise during the life of this Agreement. 23.2. Grievance Process The following steps are agreed upon as the appropriate order of contact: Step 1. An employee and/or his/her Union representative must present a grievance within fifteen (15) working days of occurrence or when the Union or employee knew or should have known of the occurrence to the supervisor, manager, or the official of the Employer most immediately involved. If, however, the grievance concerns a payroll matter involving the computation of the employee’s wages the grievance must be presented within thirty (30) calendar days of occurrence or when the Union or employee knew or should have known of the occurrence. The parties shall have fifteen (15) working days to resolve the grievance. The parties agree to meet to discuss the grievance at the request of either party. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 59 Step 2. The employee and/or Union representative shall present the grievance within 15 working days of the Step 1 response in writing to the employee’s Department Administrator. The parties agree to meet to discuss the grievance at the request of either party. The Department Administrator shall attempt to resolve the matter within 15 working days of the receipt of the written grievance and provide their response in writing to the Union and the grievant. Step 3. If not resolved at Step 2, the employee (grievant) shall refer the matter in writing to the Union Grievance Committee for investigation and determination of whether the grievance shall be advanced. Advancement or settlement of a grievance beyond Step 2 of the Grievance Procedure shall be the sole authority of the Union Grievance Committee. The Grievance Committee shall be given reasonable time off with pay for this purpose. Step 4. If not resolved by the Department Administrator and advanced by the Grievance Committee, the grievance shall be presented, in writing, together with all pertinent materials to the Mayor or Judge within ten (10) working days of the Administrator’s response. The Mayor, Chief Administrative Officer, or designated representative shall schedule a meeting with the Union for the purpose of hearing and reviewing the merits of the grievance. The Mayor, Chief Administrative Officer, or designated AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 60 representative, shall attempt to resolve the grievance within ten (10) working days of receipt of the material. Step 5. In the event that the grievance is not resolved at Step 4, the matter may, within twenty (20) working days after the Step 4 decision has been rendered, be referred by either party to the arbitration process. If the matter is not referred to arbitration within this period, it shall be considered resolved. If referred to arbitration: (1) the arbitrator’s decision shall be final and binding, (2) the arbitrator shall be empowered to render a decision based on interpretation of the contract only and shall not add or delete from the provisions of this Agreement, (3) the arbitrator shall render a decision within thirty (30) days of hearing, (4) the arbitrator shall be selected by a joint request of a list of names (Washington) from the Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service (F.M.C.S.). Upon receipt, the parties shall eliminate names alternately until one name remains, (5) it is agreed that the costs shall be borne equally between the parties with the exception that if the matter is a question of procedural arbitrability, the losing party shall bear all expenses for the services of the arbitrator. Except as provided above, each party shall be responsible for paying their own costs and fees incurred in the matter. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 61 23.3. Employer Grievance The following procedure shall be observed if the Employer files a grievance against the Union for an alleged violation of the contract: Step 1. The Mayor or his/her designated representative shall present the grievance in writing to the Union Staff Representative within 10 days of occurrence. The Union shall attempt to resolve the matter within thirty (30) days of receipt. Step 2. If the matter is not satisfactorily resolved at Step 1, the Employer may within twenty (20) working days refer the matter to arbitration using the procedure outlined in Section 23.2, Step 5. 23.4. Grievance Documentation Written submissions shall include the specific article(s) of the contract, which were allegedly violated, the specific facts and the remedy sought. 23.5. Grievance Timelines Grievances shall be properly filed and processed within the timetables outlined at each step. If these timetables are violated by the Union, the grievance shall be deemed waived. If violated by the Employer, the grievance shall be advanced to the next step. Through mutual agreement, the parties may put timelines on abeyance or extend them for a set period of time. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 62 ARTICLE 24 – HEALTH, SAFETY AND PRODUCTIVITY 24.1. Quality and Safety of Work All work shall be done in a competent, productive, and professional manner. Work shall also be done, in accord with State, Federal, and City safety codes and with ordinances and rules relating to this subject. 24.2. Working Conditions It shall not be considered a violation of this Agreement if any employee refuses to work with unsafe equipment, where adequate safeguards are not provided, or when the facilities and services are not being maintained in a reasonably sanitary condition. It shall be a requirement of the employee to immediately report all unsafe conditions in accordance with the City procedures to his/her supervisor upon becoming aware of those conditions. Per City Policy #700-60 dated August 23, 2017, page 4, AFSCME shall select at least one representative and one alternate from each of the following areas: public works, community services/parks, and city hall (collectively known as the Department Representatives). In addition to the Department Representatives, Local 2170 shall have a designated member on the Safety Committee as appointed by the Local Executive Board. 24.3. Rain Gear Where necessary, employees furnished rain gear by the Employer will be provided up to one (1) set of new rain gear annually, provided that new rain gear will not be issued until used rain gear is returned by the employee to the appropriate supervisor. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 63 24.4. Custodial Services The Employer shall provide custodial services to employee restrooms and lunchrooms to insure sanitary conditions. 24.5. Safety Shoes Regular employees in positions listed below shall be entitled to a $205 shoe allowance annually for the purchase of shoes or boots. The allowance shall be paid once annually to all active employees listed below as of the first paycheck in March and is subject to tax. New employees shall be eligible for a shoe allowance upon hire, provided however, should the employee fail to successfully pass their probationary period, the value of the allowance shall be withheld from their final paycheck. Reimbursement up to $205 can be provided on a more frequent basis if shoes are damaged or contaminated on duty and subject to supervisor approval. This allowance may not be combined with a safety shoe reimbursement received in 2019. Nothing in this clause negates the foot protection requirement as described in the Personal Protective Equipment Policy #700-12. Safety shoes required for titles not listed below will be subject to the mutual agreement of the Union and the Employer as to whether incumbent employees are eligible for the allowance. • Airport Maintenance Worker • Airport Operations Specialist • Airport Operations and Maintenance Supervisor • Building Inspector • Capital Project Coordinator AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 64 • Code Compliance Inspector, Lead Code Compliance Inspector • Construction Inspector, Construction Inspector Supervisor • Custodian, Maintenance Custodian, Lead Maintenance Custodian, Custodial Maintenance Supervisor • Electrical Technician • Facilities Supervisor • Facilities Technician I1 and II2 • Fleet Management Technician • Golf Course Maintenance Worker I,II,III1,2,3 • Grounds Equipment Mechanic • HVAC Systems Technician • Lead Electrical/Control Systems Technician • Lead Vehicle & Equipment Mechanic • Lift Station Technician • Maintenance Services Worker I,II,III1,2,3 and Lead Maintenance Services Worker • Pavement Management Technician • Parks Maintenance Assistants 1&2, Parks Maintenance Worker I,II,III,1,2,3 Lead Parks Maintenance Worker, Parks Maintenance Supervisor • Signal/Electronic Systems Technician I,II,III1,2,3 , Signal/Electronic Systems Supervisor • Solid Waste Maintenance Worker AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 65 • Street Maintenance Services Supervisor • Traffic Maintenance Worker I,II1, ,2, Senior Traffic Maintenance Worker, Traffic Signage & Marking Supervisor • Vehicle & Equipment Mechanic • Waste Water/Surface Water Maintenance Supervisor • Water Maintenance Services Supervisor • Water Meter Technician • Water Quality/Treatment Plan Operator • Water Utility Maintenance Supervisor • Water Utility Inspector SCADA Technician • Water Utility Maintenance Technician For positions not named above, a request for reimbursement of safety footwear up to $175 is available once per year, upon the completion and approval of the Hazard Assessment for PPE Certification form by the City’s Safety Officer. The purchase shall meet the standards of protection required such as toe protection, punction resistance, electrical protection, etc. City staff are prohibited from using a City-issued Purchase Card for this purchase. ARTICLE 25 – SAVINGS CLAUSE If any Article of this Agreement or any addenda thereto should be held invalid by operation of law or by any tribunal of competent jurisdiction, or if compliance with or enforcement of any Article AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 66 should be restrained by such tribunal, the remainder of this Agreement and addenda should not be affected thereby and the parties shall enter into immediate collective bargaining negotiations for the purpose of arriving at a mutually satisfactory replacement of such Article. ARTICLE 26 – ENTIRE AGREEMENT The Agreement expressed herein in writing constitutes the entire Agreement between the parties is intended to replace the prior agreement and no oral statement shall add to or supersede any of its provisions. The parties acknowledge that each has had the unlimited right and opportunity to make demands and proposals with respect to any matter deemed a proper subject for collective bargaining. The results of the exercise of that right and opportunity are set forth in this Agreement. Therefore, unless otherwise agreed, the Employer and the Union, for the duration of this Agreement, each voluntarily and unqualifiedly agree to waive the right to oblige the other party to bargain with respect to any subject or matter not specifically referred to or covered in this Agreement. All wages and/or benefits being received prior to this contract by members covered in this Agreement shall not be reduced except where specifically modified by this Agreement. ARTICLE 27 – PRIORITY OF FEDERAL, STATE AND CITY LAWS It is understood and agreed by and between the parties that in negotiations and collective bargaining and in the administration of AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 67 all matters covered by this Agreement, the parties hereto and the City employees are governed by the provisions of applicable State laws, City Ordinances and Resolutions. If there is a conflict between any provision of this Agreement and State law, the latter shall prevail. Provided, however, the Employer agrees that no Ordinance or Resolution shall modify or change any article or section of this Agreement during the life of said Agreement. ARTICLE 28 – VOLUNTEERS The City and Union agree that volunteer programs can be mutually beneficial to the City, employees, and citizens of Renton. The parties recognize that volunteer programs provide a sense of community involvement and require a commitment of time and service on behalf of the volunteer. To that end, the City is committed to working in partnership with the Union to build successful volunteer programs. The use of volunteers will not supplant bargaining unit positions. No bargaining unit member shall be laid off as a result of volunteer programs. The City and the Union will meet in a labor-management forum and come to mutual agreement prior to implementing any new volunteer programs. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 68 ARTICLE 29 – DISCIPLINE 29.1 Discipline The City shall not discipline or discharge an employee without just cause. Employees shall be given the opportunity to have a Union Representative present at meetings where disciplinary proceedings will take place. The City agrees with the principles of progressive discipline. Disciplinary action generally includes the following progressive steps: 29.1.1. Oral reprimand (which shall be reduced to writing although not placed in the employee’s personnel file) 29.1.2. Written reprimand 29.1.3. Suspension 29.1.4. Discharge Disciplinary action will be tailored to the nature and severity of the offense. Management maintains the right to take disciplinary action, as they deem appropriate. 29.2 Demotion The term “demotion” as used in this provision means the involuntary reassignment of an employee from a position in one job classification to a lower paying position in another job classification. In any case involving demotion, the employee shall have the right to due process. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 69 ARTICLE 30 – LEAV E DONATION A Leave Donation Program has been established to assist employees faced with a serious medical illness or injury to themselves or an immediate family member. The Leave Donation Program will be administered in accordance with City Policy #350-12 (Leave Donation), as revised effective August 23, 2017. Time that can be donated includes vacation, comp-time and personal holiday. The following exception applies as a benefit above and beyond those granted by the Policy. State-Registered domestic partners shall be considered family when considering qualifying events for donation. Donated leave may be: vacation, compensatory time, personal holidays, and sick leave. Sick leave donation is capped at 40 hours per recipient per calendar year. The donator ’s bank cannot drop below 80 hours. ARTICLE 31 – LAYO FF AND RECALL 31.1. Layoff and Recall The Employer shall retain the Right to determine whether lay-offs are necessary and in which department(s) and classification(s) they will occur. City employees in other departments are not eligible to exercise bumping rights to displace any Court employees regardless of seniority or job classification. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 70 31.2. Definitions 31.2.1. Adjusted Hire Date: The date used to determine “City Seniority.” The Adjusted Hire Date is calculated on the employee’s length of continuous service with the City in a regular full-time or part-time position. Part-time employees will have their length of continuous service adjusted for longevity purposes. Seniority earned as a regular, part-time employee shall be prorated. The City will calculate the number of compensated hours in any regular position and divide the total by full time equivalent hours (i.e., 2080 hours per year) to determine the employee’s adjusted hire date for purpose of seniority. 31.2.2. Bumping Rights: An employee’s ability to move into the same classification or another classification, in which he/she has previously achieved regular status, based on his/her overall seniority. 31.2.3. Classification: A classification is a position or group of positions performing similar duties that have the same title, class code, and salary range. 31.2.4. Classification Series: A series of related classifications with an entry level and one or more additional levels as defined in City Policy #320-01, Classification Series. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 71 31.2.5. Initial Probationary Period: The probationary period served by a new employee when hired into a regular position with the City. 31.2.6. Layoff: A reduction in the workforce due lack of funds, lack of work, or the result of a reorganization. 31.2.7. Recall List (also called “Reemployment List,” “Rehire List,” or “Layoff List”): A list of employees who have been laid off from a specific classification and who are eligible for recall. 31.2.8. Original Hire Date: The first day an employee started working for the City, either in a regular status or non- regular status position. 31.2.9 Previously Held Position: A position within the City’s classification system to which the employee has been formally appointed and successfully completed probation. 31.2.10. Probationary Employee: An employee in their initial probationary period who has not achieved regular employee status. 31.2.11. Recall (also called “Reinstatement”): When an employee on the recall list returns to the classification from which he/she was laid off or to a lower classification in which they previously achieved regular employee status. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 72 31.2.12. Seniority: 31.2.12.1 City Seniority, or “Adjusted Hire Date,” is an employee’s length of continuous service with the City in a regular full-time or part- time position. 31.2.12.2 Classification Seniority is the date that the employee was appointed to his/her current position. Classification seniority shall be prorated as described under the definition of Adjusted Hire Date. 31.3. Departmental Review 31.3.1. Each department may periodically review its budget and projected workload to determine if layoffs are necessary. 31.3.2. If it becomes necessary to initiate organizational change for any reason that results in the reduction of employees, the Department Administrator will discuss the organizational change with the Mayor or designee and the Human Resources Risk Management Administrator prior to making any changes. The AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 73 Department Administrator will determine which classifications will be affected. 31.3.3. The Mayor will have final authority to eliminate positions and/or lay off employees. 31.4. Human Resources Risk Management Review 31.4.1 Once the Department Administrator has determined which classification(s) will be affected, Human Resources Risk Management (HRRM) will determine which employee(s) shall be laid off. 31.4.2. No lay-off or reduction to a lower classification shall be executed so long as there are non-regular (temporary) employees, whether full-time or part time, performing substantially similar job duties in a specific department/division. 31.4.3. For the purpose of the initial layoff, classification seniority shall be the determining factor. Employees shall be laid off from their department or major division in the inverse order of their classification seniority in the classification in which the work force is being reduced. New employees in the affected classification, serving in their initial probationary period, shall be separated before any regular Union employee is laid off in the work unit. 31.4.4. At no time shall layoff, bumping, or recall result in a promotion. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 74 31.4.5. Tie-Breakers: In the event two or more employees have the same classification seniority, City seniority shall prevail. In the event two or more employees have the same City seniority, a tie-breaker will be used to determine the employee with the least seniority. The tie-breaker will be the last four digits of the employee’s social security number. The employee with the lowest number shall be considered the employee with the lowest seniority. 31.4.6. It is understood that classifications may change title. If a classification has been re-titled or a new classification created and the duties are substantially the same, the employee shall be considered having “previously achieved regular employee status” in the re-titled or new classification. 31.5. Notice of Layoff 31.5.1 It is the City’s intent to provide employees with notice of any layoff at least thirty (30) calendar days in advance of the intended layoff date. When such a time period is not possible, employees shall be provided with at least two weeks (14 calendar days) notice or receive two weeks’ pay in lieu of notification. 31.5.2 Layoffs resulting from the biennial budget process shall not be final until such time as the budget is adopted by the City Council. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 75 31.6. Bumping Rights 31.6.1. An employee who is laid off may replace another employee in an equal or lower classification series in which the employee works or has previously achieved regular employee status, provided such employee has greater City seniority than the employee whom he/she seeks to replace, and provided the replacing employee is qualified to perform the work without further training. 31.6.2. An employee who is laid off may not replace another employee in the same classification in the same workgroup from which they are in the process of being laid off. 31.6.3. The requirement to have previously worked in a classification shall not apply to employees bumping down to a lower compensated position within a recognized classification series (e.g., Maintenance Service Worker, Fire Inspector, etc.). 31.6.4. If the employee is not eligible to bump into another classification based on his/her City seniority, the employee shall be laid off and have his/her name placed on the recall list. 31.7. Recall Rights AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 76 31.7.1. The name of any employee who is laid off shall be placed on the recall list for a period of two (2) years. 31.7.2. Employees who are laid off may be recalled to the original classification from which they were laid off or to a lower classification in which they previously achieved regular status with the City, provided they are qualified at the time to perform the work in the classification to which they are recalled without further training. 31.7.3. When there is a recall during the life of the recall list, employees who are still on the list shall be recalled in the inverse order in which they were laid off. 31.7.4. The City shall not hire new employees in a given classification as long as there are still employees on the recall list eligible for recall to that classification. 31.7.5. If employees bump into another classification or if employees are recalled to a lower classification in a series, they shall have the right to return to the classification from which they were originally laid off as long as their name remains on the recall list. 31.7.6. An employee who bumps into the same classification but in a different department/division shall have no recall rights to the position from which he/she was originally laid off from. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 77 31.7.7. Employees shall be responsible for keeping HRRM informed of a current e-mail, phone number, and postal mailing address. HRRM will provide notice of recall using e-mail and certified mail. Employees who are recalled to a position shall have seven (7) calendar days from the date they receive notification by certified mail of the recall to respond to HRRM and either accept or reject the position. 31.7.8. Employees who reject, or fail to respond to, a recall offer back to the original classification from which they were laid off shall have their names removed from the recall list. 31.7.9. Seniority dates will be handled as follows during the event of recall, or rehire into a different regular position. For the purposes of this section, “regular position” also includes Limited Term positions: 31.7.9.1 City seniority: Employees who have been recalled or rehired into a regular position within the recall period shall retain their City seniority as of the date of layoff and shall begin accumulating additional City seniority when recalled or rehired back to work. 31.7.9.2 Classification seniority: Employees who have been laid off shall begin accumulating additional classification seniority when AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 78 recalled to the classification from which they were laid off. Employees who are rehired into a different regular position within the recall period shall begin accumulating classification seniority in the “new” classification as of their date of rehire. 31.7.9.3 Employees affected by layoffs: Employees who bump into a different classification as part of a layoff shall retain their classification seniority as of the date of layoff and shall begin accumulating additional classification seniority when recalled back to the classification from which they were originally laid off. City seniority shall continue to accumulate as long as the employee remains continuously employed in a regular position. 31.7.9.4 Accrual rates: Longevity, vacation, and sick leave accrual rates shall be the same as they were on the date of the layoff. 31.7.10 Employees recalled, or rehired into a different regular position within the recall period, shall have their sick leave balance restored to the amount he/she had at the time of the layoff, excluding any cashed out hours. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 79 ARTICLE 32 – FINGERPRINTING 32.1. Fingerprint Check Requirements All union members who have authorized access to or direct responsibility for configuring and maintaining computer systems and networks that could access Criminal Justice Information (CJI) and/or have access to the Criminal Justice Information System (CJIS) network must pass a fingerprint check prior to unescorted access. Fingerprint check results will be provided to the Police Chief or designee for review and determination to pass or fail access. 32.2. Fingerprint Check Passed Employees moving into a position that requires a fingerprint check must be fingerprinted and successfully pass prior to receiving a formal written offer. 32.3. Fingerprint Check Failed If access is denied, management will attempt to transfer the employee to a non-CJI/CJIS access location. The union member may also request alternative employment for which he/she qualifies, if available. It is understood that in order to continue the employment of a member denied access, the city may need to place the member in an alternate job or job site without posting the position. Failure to be granted access shall not be considered part of the discipline process. The union and the city shall utilize the Labor/Management Committee process to negotiate any potential impacts. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 80 32.4. Right of Appeal Members denied access by the Chief of Police will have the right of appeal. Appeal may be made in writing or by scheduling a meeting with the Police Chief. If a meeting is requested a good faith attempt will be made to meet within ten (10) business days to hear the appeal. The Police Chief will issue a final determination within five (5) business days of the appeal meeting or receipt of a written appeal, if no meeting was requested. In the case of transfer or promotion the position being applied for will not be filled until the appeal has been heard and decided by the Police Chief. Members will have the right to be assisted in the appeal, be it a meeting or written form, by an AFSCME Council 2 Representative or designee. 32.5 Document Destruction All documents will be destroyed after the final report has been provided to Human Resources or after any appeal process is completed. The final report presented to Human Resources will not be kept in the Personnel file. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 81 ARTICLE 33 – DURATION OF AGREEMENT This Agreement shall become effective January 1, 201922, and shall remain in full force and effect until and through December 31, 20204. Signed this _____ day of __________________, 201922 at Renton, Washington. LOCAL 2170, WASHINGTON STATE COUNCIL CITY OF RENTON OF COUNTY AND CITY EMPLOYEES, AMERICAN FEDERATION OF STATE, COUNTY, AND MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEES, AFL-CIO. ______________________________ _____________________________________ Denis LawArmondo Pavone, Mayor Patrick MillerJayson Gallaway, Local 2170 President ______________________________ _____________________________________ Ellen Bradley-Mak, Mark Watson, Staff Representative HRRM Administrator Washington State Council of County & City Employees ______________________________ _____________________________________ Kim Gilman, HR Labor Manager Christian DeMarco, Member Jayson Gallaway, 2nd Vice President ______________________________ _____________________________________ Janna Dinkelspiel, Senior Employee Kristina Raabe, Member Relations Analyst ______________________________ _____________________________________ Kari Roller, Financial Services Manager Young Yoon, Member Kristin Trivelas, Fiscal Services Director Manuel Cruz, Member Ann Fowler, Member Stephanie Rary, Member AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 82 ____________________________________ Kevin Hiatt, Member ATTEST: ______________________________ Jason Seth, City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: ______________________________ Shane Moloney, City Attorney AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 83 APPENDIX A – AFSCME CLASSIFICATIONS IN ALPHABETICAL ORDER (with Job Grades) a03 *Accounting Assistant I1 a05 *Accounting Assistant 2II a07 *Accounting Assistant 3III a09 *Accounting Assistant 4IV a19 Accounting Supervisor a09 Administrative Secretary 1I a23 Airport Operations &Maintenance Supervisor a11 Airport Maintenance Worker a13 Airport Operations Specialist a31 Assistant Airport Manager a17 *Assistant Planner a21 *Associate Planner a21 Building Inspector/Combination a21 Building Inspector/Electrical a23 Building Plan Reviewer a20 Business Coordinator-Airport a23 *Business Systems Analyst a27 *Senior Business Systems Analyst a28 Capital Project Coordinator a21 Case Manager a113 City Clerk Specialist a15 City Clerk Specialist 2 a226 *Civil Engineer I1 a2630 *Civil Engineer 2II a2933 *Civil Engineer III3 a30 Client Technology Services & Support Supervisor a15 Client Technology Services Specialist 1 a19 Client Technology Services Specialist 2 a19 Code Compliance Inspector a12 Communications Specialist I1 a21 Communications Specialist 2II a21 Construction Inspector a15 Court Operations Specialist a01 Court Security Officer a21 Custodial Maintenance Supervisor a26 Construction Inspector Supervisor a01 Custodian a24 Database Technician a17 Digital Media Communications Specialist a18 Development Services Representative a20 *Economic Development Specialist a19 Electrical Technician a21 Emergency Management Coordinator a19 Energy Plans Reviewer/ a13 *Engineering Specialist I1 a19 *Engineering Specialist 2II a23 *Engineering Specialist III 3 a25 Facilities Coordinator a21 Facilities Supervisor a13 *Facilities Technician 1I a15 *Facilities Technician 2II a18 Farmers Market Coordinator a11 Fleet Management Technician a21 *GIS Analyst I1 a23 *GIS Analyst 2II a26 *GIS Analyst 3 a01 Golf Course Associate a04 *Golf Course Maintenance Worker 1I a08 *Golf Course Maintenance Worker 2II a12 *Golf Course Maintenance Worker 3III a09 Golf Course Operations Assistant a15 Grounds Equipment Mechanic a07 Hearing Examiner’s Secretary a20 Housing Repair Coordinator a08 Housing Repair Technician a20 Human Services Coordinator a19 HVAC Systems Technician a08 Judicial Specialist a12 Judicial Specialist 2 a10 Judicial Specialist/Trainer a24 Lead Building Inspector a22 Lead Code Compliance Inspector a24 Lead Construction Inspector a04 Lead Custodian a25 Lead Electrical Control Systems Technician a16 Lead Golf Course Maintenance Worker a11 Lead Maintenance Custodian a16 Lead Maintenance Services Worker AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 84 a08 Lead Office Assistant a16 Lead Park Maintenance Worker a19 Lead Vehicle & Equipment Mechanic a18 Lead Water Utility Pump Station Mechanic a10 Legal Assistant a15 Lift Station Technician a17 Maintenance Buyer a07 Maintenance Custodian a04 *Maintenance Services Worker 1I a08 *Maintenance Services Worker 2II a12 *Maintenance Services Worker 3III a09 Mechanic’s Assistant a22 Neighborhood Program Coordinator a214 *Network Systems Specialist a32 Network Systems Manager a01 *Office Assistant I a03 *Office Assistant II a05 *Office Assistant III a17 Paralegal a21 Park Maintenance Supervisor a01 *Parks Maintenance Assistant 1 a03 *Parks Maintenance Assistant 2 a04 *Parks Maintenance Worker 1I a08 *Parks Maintenance Worker 2II a12 *Parks Maintenance Worker 3III a23 Pavement Management Technician a11 Payroll Analyst a10 Permit Technician a13 Permit Services Specialist a23 Plan Reviewer a15 Planning Technician a326 Principal Civil Engineer Aa03 Print & Mail Assistant a07 Print & Mail Operator a13 Print & Mail Supervisor a04 Pro Shop Assistant a10 Probation Clerk a18 Probation Officer a16 Program Assistant a25 *Program Development Coordinator 1 I a29 *Program Development Coordinator 2II a13 Program Specialist a25 Property Services Agent a23 Property Services Specialist a20 Assistant Public Records Officer a117 Public Records Specialist a08 Purchasing Assistant a11 Records Management Coordinator a09 Records Management Specialist a18 Recreation Program Coordinator a079 Recreation Assistant a11 Recreation Specialist a14 Recreation Systems Technician a05 Secretary I a07 Secretary 2II a24 *Senior Economic Development Specialist a258 *Senior Network Systems Specialist a22 Senior Paralegal a28 *Senior Planner a15 Senior Program Specialist a29 *Senior Systems Analyst a17 Senior Service Desk Technician a13 Service Desk Technician a13 *Signal/Electronics Systems Tech 1I a17 *Signal/Electronics Systems Tech 2II a21 *Signal/Electronics Systems Tech 3III a04 Solid Waste Maintenance Worker a23 Street Maintenance Services Supervisor a26 *Systems Analyst a08 *Traffic Maintenance Worker 1I a12 *Traffic Maintenance Worker 2II a15 *Traffic Maintenance Worker, Senior a21 Traffic Signage & Marking Supervisor a24 Transportation Planner a22 Utility Accounts Supervisor a32 Utility/GIS Engineer a15 Vehicle & Equipment Mechanic a23 Waste Water Maintenance Services Supv. a213 Water Maintenance Services Supervisor a11 Water Meter Systems Specialist a07 Water Meter Technician a17 Water Quality/Treatment Plant Operator a19 Water Utility Instrument/SCADA Tech a26 Water Utility Maintenance Supervisor a15 Water Utility Maintenance Technician *Classification Series AGENDA ITEM #5. c) APPENDIX B - SALARY TABLE (see next four pages) AGENDA ITEM #5. c) COLA 6.0% Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual a40 10,331 123,972 10,847 130,164 11,397 136,764 11,976 143,712 12,580 150,960 a39 10,097 121,164 10,598 127,176 11,118 133,416 11,683 140,196 12,275 147,300 - a38 9,839 118,068 10,331 123,972 10,847 130,164 11,397 136,764 11,976 143,712 a37 9,613 115,356 10,097 121,164 10,598 127,176 11,118 133,416 11,683 140,196 a36 2428 Principal Civil Engineer 9,369 112,428 9,839 118,068 10,331 123,972 10,847 130,164 11,397 136,764 a35 9,145 109,740 9,613 115,356 10,097 121,164 10,598 127,176 11,118 133,416 a34 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 9,839 118,068 10,331 123,972 10,847 130,164 a33 2475 Civil Engineer 3 8,707 104,484 9,145 109,740 9,613 115,356 10,097 121,164 10,598 127,176 a32 2425 Utility/GIS Engineer 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 9,839 118,068 10,331 123,972 a31 2078 Assistant Airport Manager 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 9,145 109,740 9,613 115,356 10,097 121,164 a30 2512 Client Technology Sys & Support Super.8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 9,839 118,068 a30 2474 Civil Engineer 2 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 9,839 118,068 a29 2570 Program Development Coordinator 2 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 9,145 109,740 9,613 115,356 a29 2451 Senior Systems Analyst 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 9,145 109,740 9,613 115,356 a28 2422 Senior Planner 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 a28 2480 Capital Project Coordinator 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 a28 2416 Senior Network Systems Specialist 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 a27 2452 Senior Business Systems Analyst 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 9,145 109,740 a26 2473 Civil Engineer I 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 a26 2506 GIS Analyst 3 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 a26 2417 Systems Analyst 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 a26 3473 Water Utilities Maintenance Supervisor 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 a25 2481 Facilities Coordinator 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 a25 3484 Lead Electrical/Ctrl Systems Technician 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 a25 2470 Program Development Coordinator 1 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 a25 2170 Property Services Agent 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 a25 8179 Signal/Electronic Systems Supervisor 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 a24 2420 Database Technician 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a24 3450 Lead Building Inspector 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a24 3469 Lead Construction Inspector 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a24 2403 Senior Economic Development Specialist 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a24 2419 Network Systems Specialist 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a24 2476 Transportation Planner 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a23 8475 Airport Ops & Maintenance Supervisor 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2429 Building Plan Reviewer 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2421 Business Systems Analyst 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2472 Engineering Specialist 3 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2505 GIS Analyst 2 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE AFSCME, Local 2170 Effective January 1, 2022 STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E AGENDA ITEM #5. c) COLA 6.0% Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE AFSCME, Local 2170 Effective January 1, 2022 STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E a23 8175 Pavement Management Technician 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2450 Plan Reviewer 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2484 Property Services Specialist 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 8001 Street Maintenance Services Supervisor 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 8002 Waste Water Maint. Services Supervisor 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 8000 Water Maintenance Services Supervisor 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a22 2430 Lead Code Compliance Inspector 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 a22 5197 Neighborhood Program Coordinator 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 a22 5002 Senior Paralegal 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 a22 6129 Utility Accounts Supervisor 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 a21 2424 Associate Planner 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 3452 Building Inspector/Combination 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 3451 Building Inspector/Electrical 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 2016 Case Manager 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 2200 Communications Specialist 2 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 3472 Construction Inspector 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 8008 Custodial Maintenance Supervisor 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 5130 Emergency Management Coordinator 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 3089 Facilities Supervisor 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 5111 GIS Analyst 1 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 8006 Parks Maintenance Supervisor 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 3483 Signal/Electronics Systems Technician 3 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 8004 Traffic Signage & Marking Supervisor 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 8011 Water Meter Technician Services Supervi 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a20 2079 Business Coordinator - Airport 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 a20 2402 Economic Development Specialist 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 a20 2487 Housing Repair Coordinator 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 a20 2489 Human Services Coordinator 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 a19 6128 Accounting Supervisor 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 2612 Client Technology Services Specialist 2 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 2427 Code Compliance Inspector 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 7182 Electrical Technician 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 3453 Energy Plans Reviewer 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 2471 Engineering Specialist 2 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 3485 HVAC Systems Technician 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 7172 Lead Vehicle & Equipment Mechanic 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 8178 Water Utility Instr./SCADA Technician 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a18 3456 Development Services Representative 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 a18 5195 Farmers Market Coordinator 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 a18 2015 Probation Officer 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 a18 2083 Recreation Program Coordinator 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 a17 2423 Assistant Planner 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 8374 Maintenance Buyer 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 5001 Paralegal 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 5012 Public Records Specialist 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 3482 Signal/Electronics Systems Technician 2 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 3470 Water Quality/Treatment Plant Operator 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 2205 Digital Communications Specialist 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a16 8284 Lead Golf Course Maintenance Worker 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) COLA 6.0% Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE AFSCME, Local 2170 Effective January 1, 2022 STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E a16 8074 Lead Maintenance Services Worker 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 a16 8080 Lead Parks Maintenance Worker 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 a16 5194 Program Assistant 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 a15 4014 City Clerk Specialist 2 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 2613 Client Technology Services Specialist 1 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 6167 Court Operations Specialist 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 7181 Facilities Technician 2 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 7184 Grounds Equipment Mechanic 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 8174 Lift Station Technician 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 5122 Planning Technician 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 5180 Senior Program Specialist 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 8574 Senior Traffic Maintenance Worker 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 7170 Vehicle & Equipment Mechanic 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 3474 Water Utility Maintenance Technician 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a14 5161 Asset Management Systems Technician 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 a14 5160 Recreation Systems Technician 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 a13 8474 Airport Operations Specialist 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 3471 Engineering Specialist 1 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 7180 Facilities Technician 1 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 3487 Housing Maintenance Technician 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 6263 Permit Services Specialist 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 7110 Print & Mail Supervisor 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 5179 Program Specialist 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 3481 Signal/Electronics Systems Technician 1 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a12 2201 Communications Specialist 1 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a12 8283 Golf Course Maintenance Worker 3 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a12 6166 Judicial Specialist 2 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a12 8173 Maintenance Services Worker 3 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a12 8083 Parks Maintenance Worker 3 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a12 8573 Traffic Maintenance Worker 2 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a11 8473 Airport Maintenance Worker 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 5014 City Clerk Specialist 1 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 7173 Fleet Management Technician 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 8183 Lead Maintenance Custodian 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 6265 Payroll Analyst 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 5007 Public Records Specialist 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 2486 Recreation Specialist 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 8109 Water Meter System Specialist 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a10 6164 Judicial Specialist/Trainer 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 a10 6165 Legal Assistant 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 a10 6263 Permit Technician 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 a10 6163 Probation Clerk 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 a09 6131 Accounting Assistant 4 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 a09 6151 Administrative Secretary 1 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 a09 8286 Golf Course Operations Assistant 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 a09 8070 Mechanic's Assistant 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 a09 2085 Recreation Assistant 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 a08 8282 Golf Course Maintenance Worker 2 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) COLA 6.0% Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE AFSCME, Local 2170 Effective January 1, 2022 STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E a08 7126 Housing Repair Technician 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 6162 Judicial Specialist 1 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 6109 Lead Office Assistant 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 8172 Maintenance Services Worker 2 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 8082 Parks Maintenance Worker 2 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 8375 Purchasing Assistant 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 8572 Traffic Maintenance Worker 1 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a07 6132 Accounting Assistant 3 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 a07 8184 Maintenance Custodian 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 a07 7112 Print & Mail Operator 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 a07 6142 Secretary 2 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 a07 8110 Water Meter Technician 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 a06 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 a05 6134 Accounting Assistant 3 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 a05 6130 Office Assistant 3 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 a05 6141 Secretary 1 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 a04 6160 Court Security Officer 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 8281 Golf Course Maintenance Worker 1 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 8181 Lead Custodian 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 8171 Maintenance Services Worker 1 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 8081 Parks Maintenance Worker 1 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 6282 Pro Shop Assistant 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 8576 Solid Waste Maintenance Worker 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a03 6136 Accounting Assistant 1 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 a03 6120 Office Assistant 2 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 a03 8079 Parks Maintenance Assistant 2 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 a03 7111 Print & Mail Assistant 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 a02 4,061 48,732 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 a01 8182 Custodian 3,955 47,460 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 a01 6281 Golf Course Associate 3,955 47,460 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 a01 6111 Office Assistant 1 3,955 47,460 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 a01 7079 Parks Maintenance Assistant 1 3,955 47,460 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 $6,638 Completion of 5 Yrs Completion of 10 Yrs Completion of 15 Yrs Completion of 20 Yrs Completion of 25 Yrs Completion of 30 Yrs The City contributes 4% of employee's base wage per year to a deferred compensation account. (Article 14) 6% Step a14E $398 per month 7% Step a14E $465 per month 4% Step a14E $266 per month 5% Step a14E $332 per month 3% Step a14E $199 per month LONGEVITY PAY Step a14, E = 2% Step a14E $133 per month AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 94 APPENDIX DC – Tele work Reopener During this current round of negotiations, both parties have a continued interest in creating a Telework program that benefits the City and the employees. expressed an interest in a future teleworking program. To this end, either party may reopen this Agreement for the purpose of bargaining over issues related to working conditions contained in a revised Telework Policy, to be shared with the Union in light of a newly proposed teleworkingno later than July 1, 2022. In the meantime, any rejected Telework applications shall be shared with the Union. program and resulting policy from the City. City will distribute the policy for union review by November 1, 2019. APPENDIX GD – INDEX A abuse of sick leave ........................ 39 accrual ........................................... 37 Accrual ........................................... 46 accrual rate ................................... 46 accrual rates .................................. 86 acting pay ...................................... 37 adjusted hire date ..................... 78, 80 alternative work schedules ....... 26, 27 alternative/flex work schedules ..... 26 anniversary .................................... 54 arbitration ................................. 68, 69 at will ............................................. 65 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 95 B base rate ................................... 45, 47 bereavement leave ........................ 47 biennial budget process ................. 82 bulletin boards ............................... 59 bumping rights .......................... 78, 83 bumps ............................................ 84 C callback .......................................... 34 call-back ........................................ 32 candidate pool ............................... 64 cash out ......................................... 38 cashed out hours ........................... 86 Christmas Day ................................ 42 city seniority ..... 78, 80, 82, 83, 85, 86 classification 20, 21, 53, 58, 64, 76, 77, 78, 79, 81, 82, 83, 84, 85, 86 classification seniority ............... 80, 85 classification series ........................ 78 Classification Series ........................ 92 clean-up time ................................ 29 COBRA ........................................... 52 compensated hours ....................... 30 compensatory ................................ 30 compensatory time ........................ 30 conferences ................................... 53 consecutive hours worked ............. 28 continuous service .................... 78, 80 co-pays .......................................... 48 D deferred compensation ................. 56 demotion ....................................... 76 dental ....................................... 49, 52 disability plan ................................. 38 discharge ............................ 38, 57, 76 disciplinary action ..................... 62, 76 discipline ................................... 57, 76 double time ................................... 32 dues .......................................... 23, 25 E emergency situations .......... 27, 29, 47 employee contributions ................. 51 employment practices ................... 62 entire agreement .......................... 74 excluded positions ......................... 19 Executive Board .................. 20, 62, 70 extended overtime ........................ 31 Extended Overtime ........................ 33 F F.M.C.S. .......................................... 68 Fair Labor Standards Act ................ 30 Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service ........................................ 68 fingerprint ...................................... 87 flexible work schedules .................. 27 flex-time ........................................ 27 FMLA.............................................. 37 G grievance ................ 65, 66, 67, 68, 69 grievance procedure ..................... 66 grievances ........................... 58, 59, 60 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 96 group term ..................................... 51 H health insurance ............................ 48 health, safety and productivity ..... 70 holiday .......................... 43, 44, 45, 56 holiday pay .................................... 44 Holiday Pay ................................... 43 holidays falling on scheduled day off ................................................... 44 holidays falling on weekends ........ 45 hourly ..................... 27, 30, 33, 45, 47 hours of work ................................ 26 I Independence Day ......................... 42 initial probationary period ............. 79 insurance .................................. 49, 51 J July 4 .............................................. 42 jury duty ........................................ 52 just cause .................................. 57, 76 L Labor Day ....................................... 42 labor/management committee ...... 60 layoff .................................. 77, 79, 82 layoff and recall ............................ 77 Leave Donation Program ............... 77 life insurance ................................. 51 limited term .............................. 16, 17 Limited Term .................................. 85 longevity ................................... 51, 55 long-term disability ........................ 38 lunch period ................................... 26 M management rights ....................... 57 Martin Luther King, Jr. Day ............. 42 meal and rest periods .................... 28 meal period.................................... 28 medical ............................... 49, 52, 77 medical leave ................................. 37 membership................................... 25 Memorial Day ................................ 42 N new employees .............................. 25 New Year’s Day .............................. 42 non-discrimination ........................ 62 O officers ........................................... 25 oral reprimand .......................... 61, 76 orientation ..................................... 62 original hire date ............................ 79 overtime ...... 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 34, 57 P PAC program .................................. 24 pager ............................................. 34 paid release time ...................... 58, 59 part-time....................... 45, 46, 47, 55 pay period ...................................... 56 pay stubs ........................................ 57 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 97 PERS ............................................... 38 PERS I ............................................. 38 personal holiday ............................ 45 personal holidays ........................... 43 position review .............................. 21 posting of vacancies ...................... 62 Preamble ....................................... 16 premium ................................... 37, 50 previously held position ................. 79 priority of Federal, State and City Laws ........................................... 74 probationary employee ................. 79 probationary period ............ 65, 79, 81 promoted ....................................... 65 promotion ..................... 37, 64, 65, 81 promotional opportunity ............... 64 pro-rated ............................ 45, 46, 55 public interest ................................ 60 R rain gear ........................................ 70 recall .............................................. 79 recall list ........................................ 79 recall rights ................................... 83 reclassification reviews .................. 22 Recognition and Bargaining Unit .. 16 reduction ...................... 51, 79, 80, 81 reemployment list .......................... 79 regular part-time ........................... 47 REHBT ........................... 48, 49, 50, 52 rehire list........................................ 79 REHP ......................................... 48, 50 reinstatement ................................ 79 Renton Employees’ Healthcare Board of Trustees ............................. 48, 50 Renton Employees’ Healthcare Plan ................................................... 48 rest period ..................................... 29 S safety shoes ................................... 71 salaries .......................................... 53 savings clause ................................ 73 selection process ............................ 63 seniority .............................. 78, 80, 85 shift differential ............................. 34 shop steward ................................. 58 sick leave ................ 32, 37, 38, 39, 61 sick leave cash out ......................... 38 staff representative ............ 59, 69, 89 standby .......................................... 34 steel toed boots ............................. 71 stewards ........................................ 25 suspension ................................ 61, 76 T Thanksgiving .................................. 42 tie-breaker ..................................... 82 time banks ..................................... 30 training ..................................... 53, 59 U union activities ............................... 62 union membership and dues deduction ................................... 23 union recognized ........................... 16 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 98 V vacancies ....................................... 63 Vacancies ....................................... 62 vacation ........................ 31, 39, 46, 47 Vacation Cash Out ......................... 47 Veterans’ Day ................................ 42 volunteers ........................... 29, 35, 75 W wages .................................. 24, 66, 74 work day ................. 26, 28, 31, 33, 47 work schedules ................... 26, 27, 57 work stoppage .......................... 60, 61 work week .................... 26, 30, 31, 45 workday ....... 28, 29, 30, 31, 34, 52, 58 written reprimand .................... 61, 76 A abuse of sick leave ......................... 26 accrual ........................................... 24 Accrual ........................................... 30 accrual rate .................................... 30 accrual rates .................................. 66 acting pay ...................................... 24 adjusted hire date ..................... 58, 60 alternative work schedules ....... 15, 16 alternative/flex work schedules ..... 15 anniversary .................................... 38 Appendix A – AFSCME Classifications ................................................... 70 Appendix B – Salary Index for 2013 73 Appendix C – Index ........................ 79 arbitration ................................. 51, 52 at will ............................................. 48 B base rate ................................... 30, 31 bereavement leave ........................ 32 biennial budget process ................. 62 bulletin boards ............................... 42 bumping rights .......................... 58, 63 bumps ............................................ 64 C callback .......................................... 23 call-back ......................................... 21 candidate pool ............................... 47 cash out ......................................... 25 cashed out hours ........................... 66 Christmas Day ................................ 27 city seniority ..... 58, 60, 62, 63, 65, 66 classification 11, 12, 38, 41, 48, 57, 58, 59, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66 classification seniority ............... 60, 65 classification series ........................ 58 Classification Series ........................ 71 clean-up time ................................. 18 COBRA ........................................... 36 compensated hours ....................... 19 compensatory ........................... 19, 20 compensatory time ................... 19, 20 conferences ................................... 37 consecutive hours worked ............. 17 continuous service .................... 58, 60 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 99 co-pays .......................................... 33 D deferred compensation ................. 40 demotion ....................................... 57 dental ....................................... 33, 36 disability plan ................................. 25 discharge ............................ 25, 41, 56 disciplinary action ..................... 45, 56 discipline ................................... 41, 56 double time ................................... 21 dues .......................................... 13, 14 E emergency situations .......... 17, 18, 31 employee contributions ................. 35 employment practices ................... 45 entire agreement ........................... 54 excluded positions ......................... 11 Executive Board ............ 11, 12, 46, 53 extended overtime ........................ 21 Extended Overtime ........................ 22 F F.M.C.S. .......................................... 51 Fair Labor Standards Act ................ 20 Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service ........................................ 51 fingerprint ...................................... 67 flexible work schedules .................. 16 flex-time ........................................ 16 FMLA.............................................. 24 G grievance ................ 48, 49, 50, 51, 52 grievance procedure ...................... 49 grievances ................................. 42, 43 group term ..................................... 36 H health insurance ............................ 33 health, safety and productivity ...... 53 holiday .................... 27, 28, 29, 30, 40 holiday pay .................................... 29 Holiday Pay .................................... 28 holidays falling on scheduled day off ................................................... 29 holidays falling on weekends ......... 29 hourly ..................... 17, 19, 21, 30, 31 hours of work ................................. 15 I Independence Day ......................... 27 initial probationary period ............. 59 insurance ............................ 33, 34, 36 J July 4 .............................................. 27 jury duty ........................................ 36 just cause .................................. 41, 56 L Labor Day ....................................... 27 labor/management committee ...... 43 layoff ................................... 57, 59, 62 layoff and recall ............................. 57 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 100 Leave Donation Program ............... 57 life insurance ................................. 36 limited term ................................ 9, 10 Limited Term .................................. 65 longevity ................................... 36, 39 long-term disability ........................ 25 lunch period ................................... 16 M management rights ........................ 40 Martin Luther King, Jr. Day ............. 27 meal and rest periods .................... 17 meal period.................................... 17 medical ............................... 33, 36, 57 medical leave ................................. 24 members in good standing ............ 10 membership................................... 14 Memorial Day ................................ 27 N new employees .............................. 15 New Year’s Day .............................. 27 non-discrimination ......................... 45 O officers ........................................... 15 oral reprimand .......................... 45, 56 orientation ..................................... 45 original hire date ............................ 59 overtime ........... 17, 18, 19, 20, 22, 41 P PAC program .................................. 14 pager ............................................. 23 paid release time ...................... 41, 43 part-time....................... 30, 31, 32, 39 pay period ...................................... 40 pay stubs ........................................ 40 PERS ............................................... 25 PERS I ............................................. 25 personal holiday ............................ 30 personal holidays ........................... 27 position review .............................. 12 posting of vacancies ....................... 45 Preamble ......................................... 9 premium ................................... 24, 34 previously held position ................. 59 priority of Federal, State and City Laws ............................................ 55 probationary employee ................. 59 probationary period ............ 48, 59, 61 promoted ....................................... 48 promotion ........................... 24, 48, 61 promotional opportunity .......... 47, 48 pro-rated ............................ 30, 31, 39 public interest ................................ 44 R rain gear ........................................ 53 recall .............................................. 59 recall list ........................................ 59 recall rights .................................... 63 reclassification reviews .................. 12 Recognition and Bargaining Unit ...... 9 reduction ...................... 35, 59, 60, 61 reemployment list .......................... 59 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 201922 – 20204 Page 101 regular part-time ........................... 32 REHBT ..................... 32, 33, 34, 35, 36 rehire list........................................ 59 REHP ............................. 32, 33, 34, 35 reinstatement ................................ 59 religious tenets .............................. 10 Renton Employees’ Healthcare Board of Trustees ............................. 32, 35 Renton Employees’ Healthcare Plan .............................................. 32, 33 rest period ..................................... 18 right of non-association ................. 10 S safety shoes ................................... 54 salaries ........................................... 38 Salary Survey ................................. 77 savings clause ................................ 54 selection process ........................... 46 seniority ........................ 23, 58, 60, 65 shift differential ............................. 22 shop steward ................................. 42 sick leave ................ 21, 24, 25, 26, 44 sick leave cash out ......................... 25 staff representative ............ 42, 52, 69 standby .......................................... 23 steel toed boots ............................. 54 stewards ........................................ 15 suspension ................................ 45, 56 T Thanksgiving .................................. 27 tie-breaker ..................................... 62 time banks ..................................... 20 training ............................... 37, 38, 42 U uniform allowance ......................... 23 union activities ............................... 45 union membership and dues deduction ................................... 13 union recognized ............................. 9 V vacancies ....................................... 46 Vacancies ....................................... 46 vacation ........................ 21, 26, 30, 31 Vacation Cash Out ......................... 31 Veterans’ Day ................................ 27 volunteers ........................... 19, 23, 56 W wages ............................ 14, 38, 50, 55 work day ................. 16, 17, 20, 21, 31 work schedules ............. 15, 16, 17, 41 work stoppage ............................... 44 work week .............. 15, 16, 19, 20, 30 workday ....... 17, 18, 19, 20, 22, 37, 42 written reprimand .................... 45, 56 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AGREEMENT By and Between CITY OF RENTON and LOCAL 2170, WASHINGTON STATE COUNCIL OF COUNTY AND CITY EMPLOYEES AMERICAN FEDERATION OF STATE, COUNTY AND MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEES, AFL-CIO January 1, 2022 – December 31, 2024 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 2 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 3 TABLE OF CONTENTS PREAMBLE ............................................................................. 9 ARTICLE 1 – RECOGNITION AND BARGAINING UNIT ............... 9 ARTICLE 2 – UNION MEMBERSHIP AND DUES DEDUCTION ... 16 2.1. Payroll Deduction ....................................................................... 16 2.2. PAC Program ............................................................................... 17 2.3. Hold Harmless Agreement .......................................................... 18 2.4. Refunds ....................................................................................... 18 2.5. New Employees .......................................................................... 18 2.6. Union Officer List ........................................................................ 18 ARTICLE 3 – HOURS OF WORK .............................................. 19 3.1. Work Week ................................................................................. 19 3.2. Work Day .................................................................................... 19 3.3. Work Schedules .......................................................................... 19 3.4. Meal and Rest Periods ................................................................ 21 3.5. Clean-Up Time ............................................................................ 22 ARTICLE 4 –OVERTIME .......................................................... 22 4.1. Overtime ..................................................................................... 22 4.2. Call-back Pay ............................................................................... 25 4.3. Extended Shift Overtime ............................................................. 26 4.4. Shift Differential ......................................................................... 27 4.5. Standby ....................................................................................... 27 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 4 4.6. Uniform Allowance ..................................................................... 28 4.7. Acting Pay ................................................................................... 30 ARTICLE 5 – SICK LEAVE ........................................................ 30 5.1. Sick Leave Accrual ....................................................................... 30 5.2. Sick Leave Cash Out .................................................................... 31 5.3. Long Term Disability Plan ............................................................ 31 5.4. Notification Requirements .......................................................... 32 5.5. Abuse of Sick Leave ..................................................................... 32 5.6 WA State Paid Family Medical Leave .......................................... 33 ARTICLE 6 – HOLIDAYS .......................................................... 35 6.1. Observed Holidays ...................................................................... 35 6.2. Holiday Pay ................................................................................. 36 6.3. Holidays Falling on Scheduled Day Off ........................................ 37 6.4. Holidays Falling on Weekends .................................................... 37 6.5 Regular Part-time ........................................................................ 38 6.6. Personal Holiday Use/Cash Out .................................................. 38 ARTICLE 7 – VACATIONS ....................................................... 39 7.1. Accrual Rate ................................................................................ 39 7.2. Maximum Vacation Accumulation .............................................. 39 7.3. Vacation Requests ...................................................................... 40 7.4 Cash Out Upon Separation ......................................................... 40 ARTICLE 8 – BEREAVEMENT LEAVE ....................................... 40 ARTICLE 9 – INSURANCES ..................................................... 41 Definitions: ................................................................................................ 41 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 5 9.1. Health Insurance ......................................................................... 41 9.2. Life Insurance.............................................................................. 44 9.3. Federal/State Healthcare Options .............................................. 44 9.4. COBRA ........................................................................................ 44 ARTICLE 10 – JURY DUTY ...................................................... 44 ARTICLE 11 – EDUCATION AND CONFERENCE ....................... 45 11.1. Time Off and Financial Reimbursement ...................................... 45 11.2. Valid Business Expenses .............................................................. 45 11.3. Access to Training ....................................................................... 46 ARTICLE 12 – SALARIES ......................................................... 46 12.1. Salaries ....................................................................................... 46 12.2. Step Increases ............................................................................. 47 12.3 VEBA ........................................................................................ 47 ARTICLE 13 - LONGEVITY....................................................... 47 13.1. Longevity Pay Calculation ........................................................... 47 13.2. Longevity Pay Date ..................................................................... 48 ARTICLE 14 – DEFERRED COMPENSATION ............................. 48 ARTICLE 15 – PAY PERIOD ..................................................... 49 ARTICLE 16 – MANAGEMENT RIGHTS ................................... 49 ARTICLE 17 – UNION ACTIVITIES ........................................... 50 17.1. Paid Release Time ....................................................................... 50 17.2. Facility Access ............................................................................. 51 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 6 17.3. Union Communication ................................................................ 51 17.4. Training Time .............................................................................. 51 17.5. Negotiations ............................................................................... 52 ARTICLE 18 – LABOR/MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE ............... 52 ARTICLE 19 – WORK STOPPAGES AND EMPLOYER PROTECTION ............................................................................................ 53 19.1. Uninterrupted City Services ........................................................ 53 19.2. Work Stoppage ........................................................................... 53 19.3. Disciplinary Action for Work Stoppage ....................................... 54 ARTICLE 20 – NON-DISCRIMINATION .................................... 54 ARTICLE 21 – RECRUITMENT AND SELECTION PROCESS ....... 54 21.1. Posting of Vacancies ................................................................... 54 21.2. Selection Process ........................................................................ 55 21.3. Eligible Candidate Pool ............................................................... 56 21.4. Promotional Opportunities ......................................................... 56 ARTICLE 22 – PROBATIONARY PERIOD .................................. 57 22.1. 12-Month Probationary Period ................................................... 57 22.2. 6-Month Probationary Period ..................................................... 57 ARTICLE 23 – GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE ................................. 58 23.1. Definition .................................................................................... 58 23.2. Grievance Process ....................................................................... 58 23.3. Employer Grievance .................................................................... 61 23.4. Grievance Documentation .......................................................... 61 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 7 23.5. Grievance Timelines .................................................................... 61 ARTICLE 24 – HEALTH, SAFETY AND PRODUCTIVITY .............. 62 24.1. Quality and Safety of Work ......................................................... 62 24.2. Working Conditions .................................................................... 62 24.3. Rain Gear .................................................................................... 63 24.4. Custodial Services ....................................................................... 63 24.5. Safety Shoes ............................................................................... 63 ARTICLE 25 – SAVINGS CLAUSE ............................................. 66 ARTICLE 26 – ENTIRE AGREEMENT ........................................ 66 ARTICLE 27 – PRIORITY OF FEDERAL, STATE AND CITY LAWS. 67 ARTICLE 28 – VOLUNTEERS ................................................... 67 ARTICLE 29 – DISCIPLINE ....................................................... 68 29.1 Discipline .................................................................................... 68 29.2 Demotion .................................................................................... 68 ARTICLE 30 – LEAVE DONATION............................................ 69 ARTICLE 31 – LAYOFF AND RECALL ........................................ 69 31.1. Layoff and Recall ......................................................................... 69 31.2. Definitions .................................................................................. 69 31.3. Departmental Review ................................................................. 72 31.4. Human Resources Risk Management Review ............................. 73 31.5. Notice of Layoff .......................................................................... 74 31.6. Bumping Rights ........................................................................... 74 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 8 31.7. Recall Rights ................................................................................ 75 ARTICLE 32 – FINGERPRINTING ............................................. 79 ARTICLE 33 – DURATION OF AGREEMENT ............................. 81 APPENDIX A – AFSCME CLASSIFICATIONS IN ALPHABETICAL ORDER (with Job Grades) ..................................................... 83 APPENDIX B – SALARY INDEX FOR 2022 ................................ 85 APPENDIX C – Telework Reopener ........................................ 89 APPENDIX D – INDEX ............................................................ 90 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 9 PREAMBLE This Agreement is between the City of Renton (hereinafter called the Employer) and Local 2170, Washington State Council of County and City Employees, American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO (hereinafter called the Union) for the purpose of setting forth a mutual understanding of the parties as to conditions of employment for those employees for whom the Employer recognizes the Union as the exclusive collective bargaining representative. The Employer and the Union shall cooperate to provide the public with efficient, cost-effective, and courteous delivery of public services, to encourage good attendance of employees, and to promote a climate of labor relations that will aid in achieving a high level of efficiency and productivity in all departments of City government. The parties will work together to address and adapt to the inevitable issues of change, to devise varying methods and work procedures adapted to the changing circumstances of their particular areas of responsibilities. ARTICLE 1 – RECOGNITION AND BARGAINING UNIT 1.1. Union Recognized Pursuant to RCW 41.56.060 the Employer hereby recognizes the Washington State Council of County and City Employees/ AFSCME Council 2 and its affiliated local (hereafter Union) as the exclusive bargaining representative for all limited term, probationary and regular Renton City employees in those classifications listed in Appendix A. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 10 Limited term employees have all rights under this contract with the exception of bumping (see City Policy #330-11, dated 10/15/2005). If a limited term position is converted to a regular position, the incumbent shall remain in the position and shall be converted as well (and will be eligible for bumping rights). A limited term employee shall have their time in the limited term position count toward their overall classification and City seniority. A regular employee who applies for and is appointed to a limited term position shall have the right to return to their previous classification should the limited term position not be converted to regular status and there is a vacant position available in their previous classification. All employees of the Employer in classifications covered by this Agreement are eligible to be members of the Union. 1.2. Temporary/Supplemental Employees The City shall not combine or overlap temporary/supplemental employees in such a way as to create the equivalent of a regular position or avoid the time constraints set herein. In the case of layoffs, Temporary/ Supplemental employees may not be hired to perform bargaining unit work in work units where layoffs have occurred while there is an active recall list. The City will issue a quarterly report listing all actively employed supplemental employees utilized by the City at the time the report is generated. This report will be issued quarterly beginning October 1, AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 11 2019 or if the 1st falls on a holiday, within 4 days following the holiday. 1.2.1 Non Seasonal Temporary Employees-When filling a known vacancy of an AFSCME represented position, Temporary employees shall be employees hired directly by the City or through an agency contracted with the City. Such employees shall be employed no more than the equivalent of six (6) months (182 consecutive days) in a rolling 12-month period. An extension of up to an additional 6 months is available with union concurrence. Overtime shall be offered to regular employees prior to temporary employees being utilized, unless no qualified regular employees are available. The City will notify the Union prior to the use or hiring of Temporary employee under this clause. It is understood that the use of Temporary/Supplemental employees as provided for in this section shall not be deemed as supplanting bargaining unit work. 1.2.2 Temporary Supplemental Employees- It is understood that the use of seasonal employees as provided for in this section shall not be deemed as supplanting bargaining unit work. Effective July 1, 2019 seasonal employees performing work limited to the following positions will not work longer than 6 months (182 consecutive days) in a calendar year. In 2020 onward, the seasonal period is set as being between April 1 and October 31: • Custodial Assistant AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 12 • Parks Laborer • Transportation Laborer Golf Course Laborer and Pro-Shop Supplemental positions are limited to 1500 hours in a calendar year and the employment period is between March 1 and November 30. 1.2.3 Interns- Use of Interns performing bargaining unit work citywide is limited to one-year terms of employment, and each intern shall not work longer than 1,040 hours during that year. The employment year for interns will be measured from the date of hire forward. Hiring of interns is done within City guidelines. The City will notify the Union of internship descriptions involving bargaining unit work. Interns must be enrolled in school and assisting, not supplanting, bargaining unit work. 1.3. Excluded Positions The Union recognizes the following positions as being excluded from the represented classifications listed in Appendix A: 1.3.1. All positions in the Human Resources & Risk Management Department. 1.3.2. All clerical or secretarial positions designated as “confidential” in each department. Only one “confidential” designation will be allowed in each department. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 13 1.4. New Positions Should it become necessary to establish a new job classification within the bargaining unit during the term of this Agreement, the City will create the classification. The salary for any new classification within the bargaining unit shall be subject to negotiations. The Union shall be notified of any newly created classifications in the City, which are not recognized by other bargaining units, including the City’s initial determination regarding bargaining unit status. Disagreements regarding the appropriateness of their inclusion or exclusion from the bargaining unit will be referred to the Public Employment Relations Commission for resolution. 1.5. Executive Board Meetings The Union will provide a calendar of all regularly scheduled Executive Board meetings for the next calendar year in December of the preceding year to the Human Resources & Risk Management Administrator. 1.6. Job Classification Changes Changes to existing position classifications and position descriptions shall be provided to the Union president and secretary ten (10) working days prior to the next regularly scheduled Executive Board meeting. The Union shall respond to the changes, in writing, within ten (10) working days of the meeting, unless an extension is mutually agreed upon. If the Union’s written response is not provided within the timeframe above, management may move forward with the changes that have been submitted. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 14 1.7. Point Factor Method (PFM) In an effort to objectively compare positions for internal equity, the City has utilized a Point Factor Method (PFM)to help in determining a position’s pay grade. Internal equity compares positions according to requirements for similar skill, education/training, and responsibility, and if the jobs are performed under similar working conditions. The PFM uses factors that are commonly found in positions, and each factor is broken into point values based on the varying levels of difficulty or effort needed to complete them. The position’s point value is then compared to other positions to select an appropriate grade. Effective January 1, 2022, HRRM staff will utilize the Point Factor Method in conjunction with external market data when determining a grade placement due to a Reclassification, as part of a market study, or when creating a new position. If no external market data exists, the PFM will be used to determine the grade placement based on the internal equity analysis solely. Any PFM analysis will be shared with the affected employees and the union. 1.8. Reclassification Reviews An employee may request a position review for proper classification placement when the employee believes that there has been significant change in duties and responsibilities of the AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 15 position. Reclassification reviews will be done in accordance with City Policy #320-05 (Request for Reclassification), as established July 7, 2009, to the extent that such does not conflict with the agreement. A Position Description Questionnaire (PDQ) form must be fully completed and requires review by the employee’s supervisor, the Division Director and the Department Administrator. A market study will be conducted by HRRM staff as part of the reclassification process for those positions that meet the definition for requiring a reclassification. The deadline for submittal of the PDQ to the employee’s supervisor is May 1. The Department shall forward the request to the Human Resources Department within 30 days of the initial request. If the Department does not forward the request within 30 days, the employee may submit the request directly to the Human Resources Department to ensure the submission deadline is met. The Human Resources Department will notify the employee within seven (7) working days of the receipt of the request. Requests submitted to Human Resources by the July 1 deadline and subsequently approved shall be included in the following year’s budget. Those approved by the City Council shall have an effective date of January 1 of that budget year. Any delays in the reclassification process shall not affect the implementation date and all pay shall be retroactive to January 1 of that budget year. Any appeals will be reviewed by the Human Resources and Risk Management Administrator for a final decision. Human Resources will meet with the Union regarding salary placement of any revised position(s). AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 16 Once a request to reclassify a position has been submitted and reviewed, no further consideration will be given to reclassifying the position for a twenty-four (24) month period following submission. 1.9 Job Description and Salary Updates Work will be done to reflect current duties, job description revisions shared per the Union review process, and then HR staff will conduct a market study, with wage adjustment negotiated for those deemed under market, for any titles that either have not received a market study since 2017 or, at the time the market study was completed, there were not enough matches. Position titles that do not have a minimum of 4 matches from comparable cities will be evaluated using the PFM and their salary adjustments negotiated based on internal equity. The work shall be completed no later than July 31, 2023. ARTICLE 2 – UNION MEMBERSHIP AND DUES DEDUCTION 2.1. Payroll Deduction The Employer agrees to deduct from the paycheck of each employee, who has so authorized it in writing, the regular monthly dues uniformly required of members of the Union. The amounts deducted shall be transmitted monthly to the Union on behalf of the employees involved. Employees may cancel their payroll deduction by written notice to the Union in accordance with the terms and conditions of their signed payroll authorization card. The Union will provide timely notice to the City of the cancellation of their dues authorization by a bargaining unit member. Every effort will be made to end the deduction effective on the first payroll, but AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 17 not later than the second payroll, after the City’s receipt of notice of cancellation from the Union. Authorizations for Payroll Deduction are valid whether executed in paper form or electronically. The Employer shall provide to the Union monthly a complete list of all bargaining unit members that includes employee name, home address, job title, hire date into current bargaining unit, monthly salary, hourly wage, and whether the employee has authorized the deduction of Union dues. The Union may change the fixed dollar amount, which will be the regular monthly dues, once each calendar year during the life of this agreement. The Union will give the City thirty (30) calendar days’ notice of any such change in the amount of uniform dues to be deducted. 2.2. PAC Program The Employer agrees to deduct from the wages of any employee who is a member of the Union a PEOPLE deduction as provided for in a written authorization. Such authorization must be executed by the employee and may be revoked by the employee at any time by giving written notice to both the Employer and the Union. The City will allow AFSCME, Local 2170 the option to have funds deducted from member’s paychecks twelve (12) times annually to allow contributions to the AFSCME PAC program. The City will send a check once a month to Washington State Council of County and City Employees, AFSCME Council 2. The Employer agrees to remit any deductions made pursuant to this provision to the Union together with an itemized statement showing the name of each AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 18 employee from whose pay such deductions have been made and the amount deducted during the period covered by the remittance. 2.3. Hold Harmless Agreement The Union will indemnify, defend, and hold the Employer harmless against any claims made and against any suit instituted against the Employer on account of any actions by the Employer in administering recognition, union membership and dues deduction. 2.4. Refunds The Union agrees to refund to the Employee any amounts paid to it in error upon presentation of proper evidence thereof. 2.5. New Employees The Employer will furnish to the Local Union Treasurer the names of all new employees in the bargaining unit as specified in Article 1, Section 1.1, within five (5) working days of hire. Newly hired employees shall be granted 30 minutes to meet with their Steward or another officer of the Union. 2.6. Union Officer List The Union agrees to furnish the Employer with a list of Union Officers and Shop Stewards and to maintain such list in a current status. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 19 ARTICLE 3 – HOURS OF WORK 3.1. Work Week The work week shall consist of seven (7) days beginning immediately after 12:00 midnight on Saturday and ending at 12:00 midnight the following Saturday. The regular work week shall consist of forty (40) hours, exclusive of lunch, within the work week. Exceptions to this shall be alternative work schedules, and work weeks which, when utilized, shall be reduced to writing and signed off by the Employer, employee and the Union. The City or the employee may discontinue alternative/flex work schedules and work weeks in accordance with Article 3, Section 3.3.3. Discontinuation of alternative/flex work schedules shall not require the approval of the Union. 3.2. Work Day A regular workday shall consist of not more than ten (10) hours, exclusive of lunch, unless otherwise provided for through an agreed upon alternative work schedule. 3.3. Work Schedules 3.3.1. Normal Work Week – The normal work week shall be five (5) consecutive days of not more than eight (8) hours per day, Monday through Friday, exclusive of the lunch period, except where the work day or work week is different and accepted as a condition of employment or mutually agreed upon in writing between the Union, employee and the Employer. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 20 3.3.2. Flextime and Alternative Work Schedules – Employees may work flex-time or alternative work schedules, with prior supervisory approval. Flexible work schedules shall be mutually agreed upon between the Employer and the employee. All flex-time and alternative work schedules shall be reduced to writing and signed off by the Employer, employee and the Union. Flex-time schedules, by example only, shall be schedules that provide for daily or weekly adjustable work hours. Alternative work schedules, by example only, shall be schedules that allow for schedules other than 5 consecutive days (Monday through Friday) of 8 hours work. 3.3.3. Schedule Changes – Work schedule changes may be initiated by the Employer or the employee. When schedule changes of thirty (30) days or more are initiated by the Employer, employees will receive written notice of the change thirty (30) calendar days prior to the effective date of the change. Except in emergency situations and situations that are unforeseen or unanticipated, employees will receive written notice a minimum of two working days before all other schedule changes initiated by the Employer. If written notice is not received as outlined herein the employee shall receive pay at one and one-half (1½) times their normal hourly rate for the first shift worked on the new schedule. The City will not manipulate work schedules for the sole purpose of avoiding the payment of overtime. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 21 Work schedule changes initiated by the employee may take place immediately with the concurrence of the supervisor, provided that the change does not create an undue hardship in the department or disservice to the public. 3.3.4. Consecutive Hours Worked – Employees shall not work more than sixteen (16) consecutive hours during any consecutive twenty-four (24) hour period. 3.4. Meal and Rest Periods 3.4.1 Meal Period – There shall be an unpaid meal period of not less than one-half (1/2) hour nor more than one (1) hour during the regular workday. If an employee is required to work two (2) or more hours beyond his or her regular work day the employee shall be entitled to an additional paid meal period of one-half (1/2) hour. For each additional four (4) hour overtime increment beyond the two (2) hours, the employee shall receive an additional meal period of one-half (1/2) hour. If the Employer furnishes meals, the employee shall eat them on his or her own time. Whenever possible the meal period shall be scheduled near the middle of the workday. An employee may voluntarily waive their unpaid meal period with written approval from their supervisor. The documentation showing that it was a voluntary waiver at the employee’s request will be retained by HRRM in compliance with Department of Labor’s Wage and Hour regulations. This voluntary waiver is AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 22 to be used occasionally and is not intended to be a regular on-going change to the employee’s work schedule/shift. 3.4.1. Rest Period – Except in emergency situations, there shall be one fifteen (15) minute rest period during each four (4) hour period of the workday whenever feasible. Emergency situations are defined as situations where injury to persons, loss of life and/or serious public or private property damage are possible. 3.5. Clean-Up Time Employees whose work requires personal clean-up prior to leaving the Employer’s premises or job site shall be allowed necessary time for doing so prior to meal breaks, not to exceed five (5) minutes, and the end of the shift, not to exceed ten (10) minutes. Work schedules shall be arranged so employees may take advantage of this provision where it is applicable. ARTICLE 4 –OVERTIME 4.1. Overtime 4.1.1. Allocation of Overtime – The Employer shall determine when and by whom overtime will be worked. Whenever feasible, the Employer will request volunteers from among the employees with the requisite skills to perform the work, before requiring employees to work overtime. Overtime opportunities AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 23 will be allocated as equally as possible among employees within a work unit. 4.1.2. Overtime Rate – Except as otherwise provided in this Article, all hours worked in excess of the employee’s scheduled workday, when worked upon the direction or approval of the employee’s supervisor, shall be paid at the rate of one and one-half (1½) times the employee’s straight-time hourly rate or compensated by granting one and one-half (1½) times the number of excess hours worked as compensatory time. Overtime shall be based on compensated hours and in accordance with FLSA regulations. The employee shall make his or her choice (overtime pay or compensatory time) known to his or her supervisor not later than the end of the work week in which the work was performed. 4.1.3. Compensatory Time – Compensatory time off, when granted, shall be at a time convenient to the employee and consistent with the operating needs of the Employer. Compensatory time off shall be taken under this Article as required by the Fair Labor Standards Act, if such continues to be applicable to local government employees. Compensatory time banks shall not exceed one hundred (100) hours. Employees may cash out compensatory time during any pay period throughout the calendar year. Any compensatory time over forty (40) hours as of December 31 will be automatically cashed out at the AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 24 employee’s regular rate of pay and paid on the January 10 paycheck. Employees with forty (40) hours or less shall be allowed to carry over the time into the following year. 4.1.4. Computing Overtime – The nearest one-quarter (1/4) hour shall be used in computing overtime. 4.1.5. Meeting Attendance Outside of Normal Work Schedule – With supervisory approval, each employee that is required to attend a meeting on their normally scheduled workday before or after their regularly scheduled shift shall be allowed to modify their schedule during the work week of the meeting so that the work week does not exceed their regularly scheduled hours. This Section does not prohibit employees that modify their time, as above, from receiving overtime as otherwise provided in this Article for hours worked outside of their normally scheduled work day that fall on non-modified days. 4.1.6. Consecutive Day Overtime– Employees required to work on a regularly scheduled day off shall be paid at the rate of time and one-half (1 ½) for the first twelve (12) hours and the rate of two times (2x) their regular rate of pay, consistent with Section 4.3 below, for any hours worked in excess of twelve (12) hours. Employees required to work on a second consecutive day shall be paid at two (2) times their regular rate of pay for all hours worked. If during the workweek, a half day (or more) of holiday, vacation, sick leave and AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 25 comp-time are taken, this does not count as paid work when determining the consecutive days for purposes of double time. 4.1.7. The following positions are set up as program oriented and as a condition of hire these positions may perform evening and weekend work as programs require. These positions may require a voluntary shifting of schedule within the workday and this shift will not trigger overtime. These positions are not subject to daily overtime but will be paid weekly overtime for compensable hours in excess of the normally scheduled work week. • Senior Program Specialist and Program Specialist • Neighborhood Program Coordinator • Farmer’s Market Coordinator • Program Assistant • Recreation Coordinator • Recreation Specialist • Recreation Assistant 4.2. Call-back Pay Call-back shall be defined as all time worked in excess of a scheduled shift, which is not an extension of that shift, and is unanticipated, unforeseen, and not a regular function of the employee’s work schedule. “Unanticipated, unforeseen” shall include, but not be limited to, work that is performed where the employee has been notified after the conclusion of their regular AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 26 work day and the work is performed prior to the start of their next regular work day. Employees who are required to report to the work site or the field shall be paid a minimum of two (2) hours at a rate of two times (2x) their regular hourly rate of pay, starting from the time they answer the phone through the time they return home (portal to portal). Employees who are not required to report to the work site or field but can address the issue(s) from home shall be paid for one (1) hour of work at two times (2x) their regular hourly rate so long as the time is spent working and not merely informational, i.e., schedule change. Employees who qualify for the one (1) hour call back pay shall not be subject to the provisions of paragraph 4.5 of this Article regarding the suspension of standby pay. Employees who work more than one (1) hour without reporting to the worksite or field shall be paid at (2x) their regular hourly rate for all hours worked at home and will be subject to the provisions of paragraph 4.5 of this Article regarding the suspension of standby pay. Recreation staff involved in conducting scheduled recreation programs/events shall be excluded from this provision. Employees who must attend regularly scheduled meetings after their normal work hours shall be paid a one (1) hour minimum at the time and one-half (1½) rate. 4.3. Extended Shift Overtime Employees required to work more than four (4) hours beyond the end of their scheduled work shift shall be paid at two times (2x) AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 27 their regular rate of pay for all time worked beyond the first four hours of overtime. 4.4. Shift Differential A shift differential of $1.00 shall be paid for all hours worked by an employee when fifty percent (50%) of his or her regular workday is between 12:00 midnight and 8:00 a.m. When such shift is requested by the employee and approved by the Employer, this provision shall not apply. 4.5. Standby The Employer reserves the right to establish a standby program. Based on service needs, each department may establish a roster of qualified personnel who would be available for callback during an emergency situation. Personnel identified as on standby shall be required to carry a cell phone or other device and be able to respond immediately to call-back situations without restrictions or impairments. Employees on standby shall receive standby pay as follows: Starting with the first full pay period following ratification and adoption of the successor agreement standby pay shall be paid at $3.40 per hour. Only the employee carrying the standby phone at the time of the callout, and driving their own personal vehicle, is eligible for reimbursement at the standard federal mileage rate. The reimbursement would be for their drive to the worksite due to a callback (roundtrip) from the employee’s home address or a maximum of 30 miles each way, whichever is less. Travel time for distance between home and regular or main job is considered a taxable fringe benefit and will be added to their AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 28 paycheck. Travel time for distances between home and temporary work location (if not regular or main job), or main job and temporary work location, are not considered a taxable fringe benefit. To request mileage reimbursement, the employee must submit a written claim verifying mileage, travel location(s) and the date(s) of call-back(s). Standby allowance shall be suspended upon callback and the provisions of Section 4.2 of this Article shall prevail. Standby periods shall be determined by the Employer. Standby pay is not available during the employee’s regular work hours. Management reserves the right to transfer the standby assignment when the employee is unavailable for their standby assignment. Qualified personnel shall be determined by the Employer and assigned by on a rotational basis. Every effort will be made to establish the roster on a volunteer basis. If insufficient volunteers exist, placement on the roster shall be mandatory. 4.6. Uniform Allowance The City of Renton shall furnish standard clothing of the City’s choice and design to all field staff in the Maintenance Services and Transportation Maintenance Divisions of Public Works. Eligible staff in these divisions shall have an allowance of $300 per calendar year to purchase any combination of the following items: T-Shirts Long Sleeve Button Down Shirt Long Sleeve T-Shirts Long Jeans** Sweat Shirts (1) Stocking Cap AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 29 Collared Shirt ** The purchase of long jeans must not exceed $150. A newly hired employee will be able to access this $300 clothing allowance upon hire. Clothing damaged or contaminated on-duty shall be cleaned or replaced at the City’s discretion, however the City will not exceed $175 in replacement costs per employee, per calendar year. The City of Renton shall furnish standard clothing of the City’s choice and design to the Court Security Officer to include: (5) Shirts with Court Security language and name (1) Light-Weight Jacket with Court Security language and name (3) Pairs of Black pants Clothing will be replaced once per year or as needed for the Court Security Officer. All clothing items bearing a Renton insignia and in the employee’s possession remain the property of the City and must be returned when leaving employment with the City. If the insignia-bearing items are not returned by the employee, the employee will be subject to a pro rata deduction of the current year’s utilized benefit (not to exceed $300) from the employee’s final paycheck. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 30 4.7. Acting Pay When an employee is asked to assume the duties of a position at a higher salary grade on a temporary basis, the employee shall receive a premium equal to five percent (5%) of their base salary, provided the temporary promotion will extend for at least fifteen (15) calendar days. ARTICLE 5 – SICK LEAVE 5.1. Sick Leave Accrual Sick leave is available when an employee is absent as a result of personal illness or injury, or when medically necessary to care for the employee’s child, parent, parent-in-law, spouse, domestic partner or a domestic partner’s child, and grandparent, as provided by the Family Care Act of Washington (FCA), WAC 296-130, and/or the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), the Washington State Family Leave Act (FLA), or any qualified FMLA covered reason. 5.1.1. Upon employment, new full time employees shall receive twenty-four (24) hours sick leave. At the end of the first three months of full time employment an additional twenty-four (24) hours sick leave shall be granted. At the completion of six full months of employment, employees shall accrue sick leave at the rate of eight (8) hours per month. Employees who resign or are terminated prior to completing six full months of employment shall reimburse the Employer for any used but unearned sick leave. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 31 5.1.2. Sick leave accrual shall be prorated based on the employee’s regularly scheduled weekly hours of work, divided by 40. 5.1.3. Employees shall be allowed to use sick leave in increments of fifteen (15) minutes. 5.2. Sick Leave Cash Out For employees hired before January 1, 1994, cash payment of accrued, unused sick leave shall be made upon a PERS I employee’s resignation, retirement, discharge (unless discharge is a result of the employee’s conviction of any criminal statutes relating to or connected with his/her employment), or death. Such payment shall be limited to 50% of accumulated but unused sick leave, to a maximum of 960 hours. In the event of death, payment shall be made to the estate of the employee. Employees hired on or after January 1, 1994, shall not be eligible for cash out of any accrued but unused sick leave. 5.3. Long Term Disability Plan All employees will be enrolled in an Employer-sponsored long-term disability plan with a benefit equal to 60% of base salary after a maximum waiting period of 90 calendar days. If an LTD claim is approved by the carrier, employees will be permitted to use any accrued leave balance they have at 40%, bringing the combination of the LTD benefit and accrued leave payment to 100% of their pre- disability earnings. The Employer will pay the premiums necessary to fund the benefits of the plan. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 32 5.4. Notification Requirements 5.4.1. Sick leave may be taken in lieu of vacation time whenever an employee is on vacation and becomes sick or hospitalized. A doctor’s certificate of the illness must be furnished by the employee in a timely manner to substantiate such sickness or disability. This exchange will not alter the employee’s scheduled vacation except by mutual agreement with the Employer. 5.4.2. The Employer may require a signed statement from the employee’s Health Care Provider for absences of three (3) days or longer or if the City reasonably suspects sick leave abuse. 5.4.3. An employee who will be out on sick leave must notify his or her immediate supervisor or other designated person of the absence prior to the start of said leave, or as soon as possible. 5.5. Abuse of Sick Leave Use of sick leave is restricted to the purposes set forth in Section 5.1 of this Article. Employees found to be abusing sick leave privileges shall be subject to disciplinary action, pursuant to Article 16, Section 16.3. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 33 5.6 WA State Paid Family Medical Leave 5.6.1 Eligible employees are covered by Washington’s Family and Medical Leave Program, RCW 50A.04. Eligibility for leave and benefits, which began January 1, 2020, is established by Washington law and is therefore independent of this Agreement. Premiums for benefits are established by law, will total four-tenths of one percent (0.4%) of employees’ wages (unless otherwise limited by action of the State). Employees will pay through payroll deduction the full cost of the premiums associated with family leave benefits and forty-five percent (45%) of the cost of the premiums associated with the medical leave benefits, as determined under RCW 50A.04.115 5.6.2 Use of sick leave: For better consistency across leave plans, sick leave may be used for family members, including spouse, child, grandchild, parent, or grandparent, as these relationships are defined in the State PFML. Leave may be taken for siblings only for State Accrued Sick Leave, and PFML. 5.6.3 Coordination with PFML: Employees who are approved by the State for a benefit under PFML will be permitted to use their accrued leave balance as a “Supplemental Benefit” to bring them to full base pay, in accordance with provisions outlined by the State. Employees will have the option to 1) use accrued leave exclusively and forgo the PFML, or 2) use PFML exclusively and forgo use of accrued leave, or 3) use AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 34 their accrued leave as a Supplemental Benefit in combination with their PFML to bring them to full base pay. Employees may change their election effective the first day of any pay period, by notifying HR and completing a new election form. For those employees, electing option 3 above, the procedures for a Supplemental Benefit will be similar to the City’s existing procedures for Workers’ Comp Time Loss, with the accompanying leave buy back. Employees will submit leave time to the City for a Supplemental Benefit for the full number of hours not worked. They will submit the full amount of the PFML benefit they receive to the City in a timely manner. The amount of the PFML benefit will be used to “buy back” a portion of the accrued leave that was taken as a Supplemental Benefit. In order to use accrued leave as a “Supplemental Benefit” the employee must, in advance, sign an agreement to submit the PFML benefit amount to the City as soon as practical, and in no case later than 30 days of receipt. Any employee electing this option and failing to return the PFML benefit amount(s) received will be in violation of City policy and the Union Contract and may be subject to discipline. When necessary, the Union will support the bargaining unit members in meeting their “check return” obligation. If leave balances with the City are exhausted, the employee will move to option 2 above. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 35 ARTICLE 6 – HOLIDAYS Employees shall receive holidays in accord with the following: 6.1. Observed Holidays The following days shall be observed as legal holidays: 6.1.1. January 1 (New Year’s Day) 6.1.2. Third Monday in January (Martin Luther King, Jr. Day) 6.1.3. Last Monday in May (Memorial Day) 6.1.4. June 19th (Juneteenth) 6.1.5. July 4 (Independence Day) 6.1.6. 1st Monday in September (Labor Day) 6.1.7. November 11 (Veterans’ Day) 6.1.8. 4th Thursday in November (Thanksgiving) 6.1.9. 4th Friday in November (day after Thanksgiving) 6.1.10. December 25 (Christmas Day) 6.1.11. When Christmas Day is observed on a Tuesday, Wednesday or Friday, the previous day shall be a holiday. When Christmas day occurs on a Monday or Thursday the next day shall be a holiday. When Christmas day occurs on a Saturday, the two preceding working days shall be observed as holidays. When Christmas Day occurs on a Sunday, the two working days following shall be observed as holidays. 6.1.12. Two personal holidays of employee’s choice. Existing employees will be eligible for the two (2) personal holidays from the beginning of the year. Upon AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 36 employment, new employees will be eligible for one (1) day (8 hours) of personal holiday to use. After being employed for six (6) months, the employee will be eligible for the second day (8 hours) of personal holiday to use. Except, if the employee begins employment on/or after July 1st, they will not be eligible for the second personal holiday in that year. 6.1.13. Any other day proclaimed by the Governor for all political subdivisions of the State, or by the Mayor of the City. 6.2. Holiday Pay 6.2.1. Working on Holidays - Holiday situations are as follows: 6.2.1.1. For employees working on an observed holiday, the observed holiday shall be considered the holiday. 6.2.1.2. For employees working on an actual holiday but not the observed holiday, the actual holiday shall be considered the holiday. 6.2.1.3. For employees working on both the actual holiday and the observed holiday, only the actual holiday shall be considered a holiday. 6.2.2. Pay Rates for Working on Holidays: Employees scheduled to work in one of the three (3) situations listed above shall receive one and one-half (1½) times AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 37 their regular rate of pay for all hours worked on the holiday and the employee shall be permitted to: 6.2.2.1. Schedule an alternate day off within the same calendar year (up to eight (8) hours) with prior approval from his or her supervisor which does not cause significant operational disruption for the department; or 6.2.2.2. Receive up to eight (8) hours holiday pay for that holiday worked. 6.2.3. The decision to grant holiday pay or a compensatory day off shall be determined in advance. 6.2.4. Employees scheduled in advance to work on a holiday shall be scheduled for a minimum of four (4) hours. 6.3. Holidays Falling on Scheduled Day Off Whenever the actual holiday or the observed holiday falls on an employee’s regularly scheduled day off, the employee shall be allowed to use eight (8) hours, in one (1) hour increments, at anytime before the end of the year. If both the actual holiday and the observed holiday occur on regularly scheduled days off the employee shall be granted only eight (8) hours off with pay. Unused holidays granted under this provision shall have no cash value. 6.4. Holidays Falling on Weekends When a holiday falls on a Saturday, the preceding Friday shall be observed as the Holiday. When a holiday falls on a Sunday, the AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 38 following Monday shall be observed as the holiday. For employees regularly scheduled Saturday and/or Sunday, holidays shall be observed on the actual holidays. If an employee is scheduled to work on both an observed holiday and the actual holiday, they will be compensated as described in Section 6.2 of this Article. 6.5 Regular Part-time All regular part-time employees subject to the provisions of this Agreement shall receive holiday leave at a pro-rated amount based on the number of hours scheduled in their work week divided by forty (40) hours. 6.6. Personal Holiday Use/Cash Out Personal Holiday hours may be used in 15 minute increments. Personal Holiday hours not used by the employee by December 31 will be cashed out at the employee’s hourly base rate for that same year, and paid on the January 10 pay check. Eligible Personal Holiday hours not used by the employee at time of employment separation for any reason will be cashed out at the employee’s current hourly base rate and paid in the employee’s final paycheck. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 39 ARTICLE 7 – VACATIONS 7.1. Accrual Rate The following vacation benefits shall be provided: Length of Service Days per Year Hours per Pay Period Hours per Year 0 through 5 years 12 4 96 6 through 10 years 18 6 144 11 through 15 years 21 7 168 16 through 20 years 24 8 192 21 and subsequent years 27 9 216 7.1.1 Regular part-time employees subject to the provisions of this Agreement shall be provided vacation benefits at a pro-rated amount based on the number of hours scheduled in their workweek divided by forty (40) hours. 7.1.2 Employees may use accrued vacation leave in increments of fifteen (15) minutes. 7.2. Maximum Vacation Accumulation The maximum accumulation of vacation time for an employee shall not exceed twice the current annual accrual limit as provided in above Section 7.1. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 40 7.3. Vacation Requests Requests for vacation leave are subject to supervisory approval. Except in emergency situations, requests for vacation leave shall be submitted in writing, at least the workday prior to the requested time off. Vacation requests shall be responded to within one week unless submitted less than two weeks in advance. For vacation requests submitted less than two weeks in advance, a response within one working day after receipt is required. 7.4 Cash Out Upon Separation Vacation accrued but unused during the term of the employee’s employment with the city will be cashed out at the employee’s hourly base rate at the time the employee separates from city employment. ARTICLE 8 – BEREAVEMENT LEAVE Up to three days with pay shall be given to employees for each instance of a death of the employee’s mother, father, step-parent, legal guardian, spouse/domestic partner, child, stepchild, child of a domestic partner, mother-in-law, father-in-law, sister, brother, brother-in-law, sister-in-law, grandchild, or grandparents. The number of hours of bereavement leave allowed regular part-time employees covered by this Agreement shall be adjusted to reflect the number of scheduled hours in their workweek. All requests for extended bereavement leave shall be approved by the Department Administrator in advance. Employees may use accrued vacation, compensatory time, and/or personal holiday AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 41 hours to cover extended bereavement leave. Sick leave may be used if all other leave banks are exhausted. ARTICLE 9 – INSURANCES Definitions: REHBT: Renton Employees’ Healthcare Board of Trustees REHP: Renton Employees’ Healthcare Plan Funding Goal: It is the responsibility of the Renton Employees’ Healthcare Board of Trustees to establish and maintain fund goals in relationship to the Renton Employee’s Healthcare Plan. Plan Member: An eligible Renton employee, along with their dependents, that is covered under the Renton Employees’ Healthcare Plan. Premiums: The contributions made to the REHP by both the City and the employees to cover the total cost of purchasing the REHP. Contributions made by employees for co-pays, lab fees, ineligible charges, etc., are not considered premiums for the purpose of this Article. 9.1. Health Insurance 9.1.1. Participation - The City and the Local/Union/Guild agree to jointly manage the REHP during the term of this agreement. The REHBT is comprised of AFSCME Local 2170; Police Guild; and the City, and will meet at least quarterly to review the REHP including costs associated with the REHP. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 42 Medical coverage shall be provided in accord with the laws of the State of Washington, RCW 41.26.150 and federal plans: Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act and the Health Care and Education Affordability Reconciliation Act of 2010. The Local/Union/Guild agrees to continue participation in the REHBT and to identify and support cost containment measures. 9.1.2. Plan Coverage - The City will provide a medical/dental, vision, and prescription drug insurance plan for all eligible employees including all bargaining unit members and their eligible dependents. 9.1.3. Premiums - For the calendar years 2022 through calendar year 2024, the total cost of the plan shall be divided as follows: YEAR CITY EMPLOYEES 2022 91% 9% 2023 91% 9% 2024 91% 9% Employee premiums will be based upon the following categories: • Employee • Employee/1 • Employee/2+ • Employee/Spouse or Domestic Partner • Employee/Spouse or Domestic Partner/1 • Employee/Spouse or Domestic Partner/2+ AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 43 9.1.4. Projected Costs –The plan contributions shall be calculated by the percentage of actual plan cost increase that occurred in the previous year and based on consideration of Actuarial projections. The year in review shall be from July 1st to June 30th. 9.1.5. Alternative Plan Coverage – City contributions for the alternative plan will be at the same cost share percentage as the self-funded plan capped at the dollar amount contributed to the self-funded plan. 9.1.6. Renton Employees’ Healthcare Board of Trustees – The REHBT includes members from each participating Union. Each union will have a maximum of one (1) vote, i.e. the Police Guild has two (2) bargaining units but only receives one (1) vote on the REHBT. The City only receives one (1) vote also. If all bargaining units participate, the voting bodies would be as follows: AFSCME – 2170; Police Guild; and the City for a total of three (3) votes. 9.1.7. Plan Changes – The members of the REHBT shall have full authority to make plan design changes without further concurrence from bargaining unit members and the City Council during the life of this agreement. 9.1.8. Voting – Changes in the REHP will be determined by a majority of the votes cast by REHBT members. A tie vote of the REHBT members related to a proposed plan design change will result in continuing the current design. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 44 9.1.9. Surplus – Any surplus in the Medical Plan shall remain available only for use by the Renton Employees’ Health Plan Board of Trustees for either improvements in the Plan, future costs increase offsets, rebates to participants, or reduction in employee contributions. 9.2. Life Insurance The Employer shall furnish to the employee a group term life insurance policy in the amount of the employee’s annual salary plus longevity, rounded to the nearest $1,000 including double indemnity and limited to a maximum benefit of $50,000. The Employer shall furnish a group term life insurance policy for $1,000 for the employee’s spouse and $1,000 for each dependent. 9.3. Federal/State Healthcare Options In the event of a Federal/State healthcare option, the REHBT shall have the option to review the proposed Federal/State option and take appropriate actions. 9.4. COBRA When an employee or dependents health care benefits ceases based on a qualifying event, the employee or dependent shall be offered medical and dental benefits under the provision of Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (COBRA). ARTICLE 10 – JURY DUTY When an employee is called for jury duty, or is subpoenaed as a witness in any litigation/administrative hearing process in which the employee is not a party, such time shall be considered as time AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 45 worked and paid at the appropriate salary level of the employee. Employees shall be required to give reasonable advance notice of such subpoena or other legal requirement to appear and provide the City with a copy of the subpoena or other legal document requiring the employee’s presence. The copy of the subpoena or legal document will be given to the City in advance of the hearing or jury duty or if that is not possible, then the copy must be furnished within 72 hours after the hearing or jury duty date. All monies received as witness or jury fees must be signed over to the City excluding any mileage/expense reimbursements. Employees will be required to call their supervisor when less than a normal workday is required by jury or witness duty. The supervisor shall determine if the employee shall be required to report to work and shall take into consideration the travel time of the employee. ARTICLE 11 – EDUCATION AND CONFERENCE 11.1. Time Off and Financial Reimbursement Employees will be granted reasonable amounts of time off and financial reimbursement for attending training programs whenever such training is work-related and attendance is required by the Employer. 11.2. Valid Business Expenses Employees who conduct authorized, official City business or participate in conferences as official representatives of the Employer while outside the City shall be reimbursed for all valid business expenses. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 46 11.3. Access to Training The Employer is committed to the principle of training for all employees. Whenever feasible, training shall be made available for each employee within a classification within a division to prepare them to perform all the job duties associated with that classification. Equal access to training opportunities to the extent that operational requirements permit shall be provided. ARTICLE 12 – SALARIES 12.1. Salaries Effective January 1, 2022, wages shall be increased by 6% over the base wages of 2021. The 6% increase for pay periods that have already been processed will be retroactively paid to all AFSCME represented employees who were employed on or after January 1, 2022.The parties understand and agree that the “me too” language of the 2021 contract extension is no longer active and that the current contract is focused on future wage adjustments. 12.1.1. Effective January 1, 2023, wages shall be increased by 100% of the 2022 Seattle-Tacoma-Bellevue June to June CPI-U with a minimum of 1.5% and a maximum of 4.5%. 12.1.2. Effective January 1, 2024, wages shall be increased by 100% of the 2023 Seattle-Tacoma-Bellevue June to June CPI-U with a minimum of 1.5% and a maximum of 4.5%. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 47 12.2. Step Increases All anniversary step increases shall begin being paid upon the payday following the anniversary date and thereafter during the life of this Agreement. There is no acceleration of steps. 12.3 VEBA One (1) percent of employee’s base pay in lieu of One (1) percent of the existing Deferred Compensation Benefit (Article 14) to fund a City selected and contracted Voluntary Employees’ Beneficiary Association (VEBA) plan/vendor. Funding of the VEBA plans for employees will be effective April 1, 2022. Funding of the VEBA account will occur in each pay period where the employee has pay from the City for at least half of their scheduled hours and the City will handle the transfer of funds. During a pay period where the employee does not have pay for at least half of their scheduled hours, they will not have the VEBA contribution (except for leaves covered by FMLA and/or PFML). These funds are provided by the employer and are a Mandatory Employee Contribution to VEBA. ARTICLE 13 - LONGEVITY 13.1. Longevity Pay Calculation Effective June 1, 2019 employees shall receive monthly longevity pay in accordance with the following scale: Years of Service 5 years 2.0% of the monthly Grade a14, step E 10 years 3.0 % of the monthly Grade a14, step E AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 48 15 years 4.0% of the monthly Grade a14, step E 20 years 5.0% of the monthly Grade a14, step E 25 years 6.0% of the monthly Grade a14, step E 30 years 7.0% of the monthly Grade a14, step E Regular part-time employees covered by this Agreement shall receive a pro-rated amount of this scale based on the number of hours scheduled in their workweek. 13.2. Longevity Pay Date Longevity will be paid as follows based on adjusted service date: • If the employee’s Adjusted Service Date is on or between the 1st and the 15th, the employee will receive their longevity allowances on the 25th of that month. • If the employee’s Adjusted Service Date is on or between the 16th and the 31st, the employee will receive their longevity allowances on the 10th of the next month. ARTICLE 14 – DEFERRED COMPENSATION Effective April 1, 2022, the Employer shall make a deposit equal to three percent (3%) of each eligible employee’s base wage into a deferred compensation account selected by the employee from the accounts provided by the City, each pay period. Prior to April 1, 2022, the Employer shall make a deposit equal to four percent (4%). AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 49 ARTICLE 15 – PAY PERIOD Employees shall be paid twice each month and any employee who is laid off or terminated shall be paid all monies due on the next following payday. All employees shall be paid on the 10th and 25th day of each month. If the 10th or 25th day of the month falls on a holiday or weekend period, the employees shall be paid on the last business day prior to that period. All employees will participate in payroll direct deposit. The employer will provide computer stations in convenient work locations to enable employees to access and print their electronic pay stubs during working hours. ARTICLE 16 – MANAGEMENT RIGHTS Subject only to the limitations expressly stated in this Agreement, the Union recognizes the prerogative of the Employer to operate and manage its affairs in accord with its responsibilities, powers, and authority, including but not limited to the following: 16.1. The right to establish reasonable work rules. 16.2. The right to schedule overtime in a manner most advantageous to the Employer. 16.3. The right to discipline and/or discharge employees for just cause. 16.4. The right to determine work schedules, to establish the methods and processes by which work is to be performed and the number of employees necessary to perform the work. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 50 16.5. The right to assign work and determine the duties performed by employees in classifications included in the bargaining unit. 16.6. The employer shall retain the right to determine whether layoffs are necessary and in which departments, divisions, and classifications they will occur. 16.7 Application of the management rights as detailed above to employees in the Municipal Court shall reside with the Presiding Judge. The presiding judge of the Renton Municipal Court or their judicial designee will maintain full responsibility for discipline, termination, layoff and recall decisions subject to the provisions of this agreement. It is understood that judicial and administrative duties of the presiding judge cannot be delegated to persons in either the legislative or executive branches of government. Further, it is understood by both parties that every incidental duty connected with operations enumerated in a job classification is not always specifically described. ARTICLE 17 – UNION ACTIVITIES 17.1. Paid Release Time With prior notice, the Employer will grant employees who are Union officials, or members who are appointed to a joint management committee, reasonable time off with pay for the purpose of attending scheduled meetings with City officials. Additionally, members may have 30 minutes prior to the meeting to prepare and 30 minutes after the meeting to debrief. The Shop AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 51 Steward or alternate Shop Steward and/or one Union official will be granted reasonable time off with pay by the immediate supervisor to investigate grievances. Notwithstanding the above, only two employees per work section shall be released to attend Union meetings during the workday and must code their time as union business. 17.2. Facility Access The designated Staff Representative of the Union shall be allowed access at all reasonable times to all facilities of the Employer wherein the employees covered under this contract may be working. Access shall be granted for the purpose of conducting necessary official local Union business and investigating grievances; provided there is minimal interruption to normal work processes. 17.3. Union Communication The Employer shall permit the reasonable use of bulletin boards, e- mail, and interoffice mail by the Union for the posting of notices or communications relating to official Union business. 17.4. Training Time Union officials may request reasonable time off with pay to attend training that is beneficial to both labor and management. Approval will be at the discretion of the employee’s Department Administrator or designee for the scheduling of time, the appropriateness of the leave shall be at the discretion of the Human Resources Department. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 52 17.5. Negotiations Six (6) members of the Union shall be granted paid release time to participate in negotiations occurring during their normally scheduled work hours. The Union agrees that a bargaining team that is as broadly representative as possible of the various work sites, departments, classifications, and demographics is a goal when selecting the participants for the Union bargaining team. ARTICLE 18 – LABOR/MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE The Employer and the Union agree that a need exists for closer cooperation between labor and management, and that from time to time suggestions and complaints of a general nature affecting the Union and the Employer need consideration. To accomplish this end, the Employer and the Union agree that not more than three (3) authorized representatives of the Union shall function as one- half of a Labor/Management Committee; the other half being not more than three (3) representatives of the Employer named for that purpose. The parties agree to allow expanded participation in Labor/Management Committee discussions, when necessary, by mutual agreement. Said committee shall meet as requested by either party for the purpose of discussing and facilitating the resolution of all problems which may arise between the parties other than those for which another procedure is provided by law or by other provisions of this Agreement. It is understood and agreed that the purpose of this committee does not include the hearing of formal grievances brought under the provisions of Article 23 of this Agreement. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 53 ARTICLE 19 – WORK STOPPAGES AND EMPLOYER PROTECTION 19.1. Uninterrupted City Services The Employer and the Union agree that the public interest requires efficient and uninterrupted performance of all City services and to this end pledge their best efforts to avoid or eliminate any conduct contrary to this objective during the term of this Agreement or any extension mutually agreed upon. Specifically, the Union shall not cause or condone any work stoppage including any strike, slowdown, non-bona fide sick leave absence, refusal to perform any customarily assigned duties, refusal to cross a picket line on City premises (unless same is sanctioned by the King County Labor Council), or other interference with City functions by employees under this Agreement. Any concerted action by any employee in any bargaining unit shall be deemed a work stoppage if any of the foregoing activities has occurred. Should any such activity occur, the Union agrees to take appropriate action immediately to end such interference. 19.2. Work Stoppage Upon notification in writing by the Employer to the Union that any of its members are engaged in a work stoppage, the Union immediately shall order, in writing, such members to cease engaging immediately in such work stoppage and shall provide the Employer with a copy of such order. In addition, a responsible official of the Union shall publicly order such Union employees to cease engaging in such a work stoppage. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 54 19.3. Disciplinary Action for Work Stoppage Regardless of any penalty to which the Union is subject under this Section, any employee who commits any act prohibited in this section may be subject to the following penalties: 19.3.1. Oral reprimand 19.3.2. Written reprimand 19.3.3. Suspension (notice to be given in writing) 19.3.4. Discharge It is understood that these penalties are not necessarily sequential. Disciplinary action resulting from violation of this Article will be tailored to the nature and severity of the offense. ARTICLE 20 – NON-DISCRIMINATION The Employer and the Union agree that they shall not discriminate against any employee because of race, color, religion, national origin, ethnic group, age, gender, marital status, sexual orientation, genetic information, disability status, veteran/military status, union affiliation, non-affiliation or union activities as sanctioned by this contract, and/or any other protected class or characteristic under federal, state, or local law. ARTICLE 21 – RECRUITMENT AND SELECTIO N PROCESS 21.1. Posting of Vacancies Whenever the Employer determines to fill a vacant bargaining unit position, the Employer will post the announcement on the City’s AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 55 website and provide the announcement to the Union’s Executive Board. Vacancies may be posted as internal only recruitments for at least seven (7) working days or external recruitments for at least ten (10) working days. Any City employee may apply for a vacant position. All bargaining unit employees who apply and meet the selection criteria shall be tested in accordance with procedures set forth in the job announcement. Recruitments that are posted internally and then re-posted externally will be considered the same recruitment. A bargaining unit applicant failing to advance during an internal only recruitment will not be considered during any subsequent external recruitment for the vacant position. Internal postings that result in only one employee passing the selection process may be re-posted externally. An internal applicant that has passed the prior internal selection process will be considered during the subsequent external process. Any bargaining unit employee not meeting the selection criteria may request, and will receive in writing, the selection criteria used, and the criteria that they did not meet. 21.2. Selection Process 21.2.1. Selection Procedure. The filling of vacancies will be done in an objective, fair and impartial manner. The Employer will determine the selection procedure which may include written, practical, and oral examinations. Selection criteria will bear a direct AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 56 relationship to job performance and constitute bona fide occupational qualifications necessary to properly and efficiently function in the position. All qualified applicants will go through a consistent selection procedure and be informed of the passing point for any administered exam. 21.2.2. Process Review. In the event that a bargaining unit applicant is not selected, that employee may request, and shall be given in writing, his or her itemized score and placement according to test results within one week of the request. 21.3. Eligible Candidate Pool A candidate that passes the selection process as specified in Section 21.2 above has been determined to be qualified for the position and will have their application remain in the “eligible candidate pool” for that particular recruitment. Hiring managers may offer a position to any candidate who passes the selection process and has their name in the eligible candidate pool. The Employer may use the eligible candidate pool for a period of up to twelve (12) months to fill vacancies for the same position or another position in the same job classification. 21.4. Promotional Opportunities Whenever a promotional opportunity within the bargaining unit is created through the conversion of an existing filled position to a AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 57 new classification with higher duties, the Employer shall give only employees within the same classification and section an opportunity to apply for the promotion. The Employer will distribute an announcement of the promotional opportunity to the Union President and employees in the same classification and section as the position to be restructured. Eligible employees may apply for the position by submitting an application within the seven (7) working day posting period. The Employer will award the promotion to the most qualified employee in accordance with Section 21.2 of this Article. ARTICLE 22 – PROBATIONARY PERIOD 22.1. 12-Month Probationary Period New employees shall serve a probationary period during their first twelve months of employment. During this time, they are considered “At Will” employees and serve at the pleasure of the Employer. Employees terminated during their first twelve months of employment shall not have recourse to the grievance procedure. 22.2. 6-Month Probationary Period Existing City employees who are promoted shall serve a six-month probationary period. In the event a promoted employee fails to pass probation: AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 58 Series Position: The employee will return to his/her lower classification in the series. Non-Series Position: The employee shall be eligible to return to his/her previous position, if it has not been filled. If the position has been filled, the employee may be eligible to return to his/her previous position if the current incumbent fails their probationary period. ARTICLE 23 – GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE 23.1. Definition Grievance is hereby defined as the question or challenge raised by an employee or the Union as to the correct interpretation or application of this Agreement by the Employer. It is the purpose of this clause to provide the employees and the Union with an orderly and effective means of achieving consideration of any grievance, which may arise during the life of this Agreement. 23.2. Grievance Process The following steps are agreed upon as the appropriate order of contact: Step 1. An employee and/or his/her Union representative must present a grievance within fifteen (15) working days of occurrence or when the Union or employee knew or should have known of the occurrence to the supervisor, manager, or the official of the Employer most immediately involved. If, however, the grievance AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 59 concerns a payroll matter involving the computation of the employee’s wages the grievance must be presented within thirty (30) calendar days of occurrence or when the Union or employee knew or should have known of the occurrence. The parties shall have fifteen (15) working days to resolve the grievance. The parties agree to meet to discuss the grievance at the request of either party. Step 2. The employee and/or Union representative shall present the grievance within 15 working days of the Step 1 response in writing to the employee’s Department Administrator. The parties agree to meet to discuss the grievance at the request of either party. The Department Administrator shall attempt to resolve the matter within 15 working days of the receipt of the written grievance and provide their response in writing to the Union and the grievant. Step 3. If not resolved at Step 2, the employee (grievant) shall refer the matter in writing to the Union Grievance Committee for investigation and determination of whether the grievance shall be advanced. Advancement or settlement of a grievance beyond Step 2 of the Grievance Procedure shall be the sole authority of the Union Grievance Committee. The Grievance Committee shall be given reasonable time off with pay for this purpose. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 60 Step 4. If not resolved by the Department Administrator and advanced by the Grievance Committee, the grievance shall be presented, in writing, together with all pertinent materials to the Mayor or Judge within ten (10) working days of the Administrator’s response. The Mayor, Chief Administrative Officer, or designated representative shall schedule a meeting with the Union for the purpose of hearing and reviewing the merits of the grievance. The Mayor, Chief Administrative Officer, or designated representative, shall attempt to resolve the grievance within ten (10) working days of receipt of the material. Step 5. In the event that the grievance is not resolved at Step 4, the matter may, within twenty (20) working days after the Step 4 decision has been rendered, be referred by either party to the arbitration process. If the matter is not referred to arbitration within this period, it shall be considered resolved. If referred to arbitration: (1) the arbitrator’s decision shall be final and binding, (2) the arbitrator shall be empowered to render a decision based on interpretation of the contract only and shall not add or delete from the provisions of this Agreement, (3) the arbitrator shall render a decision within thirty (30) days of hearing, (4) the arbitrator shall be selected by a joint request of a list of names (Washington) from the Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service (F.M.C.S.). Upon receipt, the parties shall eliminate names alternately until one name remains, (5) it is agreed that the costs shall be borne equally between the parties with the exception that if AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 61 the matter is a question of procedural arbitrability, the losing party shall bear all expenses for the services of the arbitrator. Except as provided above, each party shall be responsible for paying their own costs and fees incurred in the matter. 23.3. Employer Grievance The following procedure shall be observed if the Employer files a grievance against the Union for an alleged violation of the contract: Step 1. The Mayor or his/her designated representative shall present the grievance in writing to the Union Staff Representative within 10 days of occurrence. The Union shall attempt to resolve the matter within thirty (30) days of receipt. Step 2. If the matter is not satisfactorily resolved at Step 1, the Employer may within twenty (20) working days refer the matter to arbitration using the procedure outlined in Section 23.2, Step 5. 23.4. Grievance Documentation Written submissions shall include the specific article(s) of the contract, which were allegedly violated, the specific facts and the remedy sought. 23.5. Grievance Timelines Grievances shall be properly filed and processed within the timetables outlined at each step. If these timetables are violated by AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 62 the Union, the grievance shall be deemed waived. If violated by the Employer, the grievance shall be advanced to the next step. Through mutual agreement, the parties may put timelines on abeyance or extend them for a set period of time. ARTICLE 24 – HEALTH, SAFETY AND PRODUCTIVITY 24.1. Quality and Safety of Work All work shall be done in a competent, productive, and professional manner. Work shall also be done, in accord with State, Federal, and City safety codes and with ordinances and rules relating to this subject. 24.2. Working Conditions It shall not be considered a violation of this Agreement if any employee refuses to work with unsafe equipment, where adequate safeguards are not provided, or when the facilities and services are not being maintained in a reasonably sanitary condition. It shall be a requirement of the employee to immediately report all unsafe conditions in accordance with the City procedures to his/her supervisor upon becoming aware of those conditions. Per City Policy #700-60 dated August 23, 2017, page 4, AFSCME shall select at least one representative and one alternate from each of the following areas: public works, community services/parks, and city hall (collectively known as the Department Representatives). In addition to the Department Representatives, Local 2170 shall have a designated member on the Safety Committee as appointed by the Local Executive Board. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 63 24.3. Rain Gear Where necessary, employees furnished rain gear by the Employer will be provided up to one (1) set of new rain gear annually, provided that new rain gear will not be issued until used rain gear is returned by the employee to the appropriate supervisor. 24.4. Custodial Services The Employer shall provide custodial services to employee restrooms and lunchrooms to insure sanitary conditions. 24.5. Safety Shoes Regular employees in positions listed below shall be entitled to a $205 shoe allowance annually for the purchase of shoes or boots. The allowance shall be paid once annually to all active employees listed below as of the first paycheck in March and is subject to tax. New employees shall be eligible for a shoe allowance upon hire, provided however, should the employee fail to successfully pass their probationary period, the value of the allowance shall be withheld from their final paycheck. Reimbursement up to $205 can be provided on a more frequent basis if shoes are damaged or contaminated on duty and subject to supervisor approval. Nothing in this clause negates the foot protection requirement as described in the Personal Protective Equipment Policy #700-12. Safety shoes required for titles not listed below will be subject to the mutual agreement of the Union and the Employer as to whether incumbent employees are eligible for the allowance. • Airport Maintenance Worker • Airport Operations Specialist AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 64 • Airport Operations and Maintenance Supervisor • Building Inspector • Capital Project Coordinator • Code Compliance Inspector, Lead Code Compliance Inspector • Construction Inspector • Custodian, Maintenance Custodian, Lead Maintenance Custodian, Custodial Maintenance Supervisor • Electrical Technician • Facilities Supervisor • Facilities Technician 1 and 2 • Fleet Management Technician • Golf Course Maintenance Worker 1,2,3 • Grounds Equipment Mechanic • HVAC Systems Technician • Lead Electrical/Control Systems Technician • Lead Vehicle & Equipment Mechanic • Lift Station Technician • Maintenance Services Worker 1,2,3 and Lead Maintenance Services Worker • Pavement Management Technician • Parks Maintenance Assistants 1&2, Parks Maintenance Worker 1,2,3 Lead Parks Maintenance Worker, Parks Maintenance Supervisor AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 65 • Signal/Electronic Systems Technician 1,2,3, Signal/Electronic Systems Supervisor • Solid Waste Maintenance Worker • Street Maintenance Services Supervisor • Traffic Maintenance Worker 1,2, Senior Traffic Maintenance Worker, Traffic Signage & Marking Supervisor • Vehicle & Equipment Mechanic • Waste Water/Surface Water Maintenance Supervisor • Water Maintenance Services Supervisor • Water Meter Technician • Water Quality/Treatment Plan Operator • Water Utility Maintenance Supervisor • Water Utility Inspector SCADA Technician • Water Utility Maintenance Technician For positions not named above, a request for reimbursement of safety footwear up to $175 is available once per year, upon the completion and approval of the Hazard Assessment for PPE Certification form by the City’s Safety Officer. The purchase shall meet the standards of protection required such as toe protection, punction resistance, electrical protection, etc. City staff are prohibited from using a City-issued Purchase Card for this purchase. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 66 ARTICLE 25 – SAVINGS CLAUSE If any Article of this Agreement or any addenda thereto should be held invalid by operation of law or by any tribunal of competent jurisdiction, or if compliance with or enforcement of any Article should be restrained by such tribunal, the remainder of this Agreement and addenda should not be affected thereby and the parties shall enter into immediate collective bargaining negotiations for the purpose of arriving at a mutually satisfactory replacement of such Article. ARTICLE 26 – ENTIRE AGREEMENT The Agreement expressed herein in writing constitutes the entire Agreement between the parties is intended to replace the prior agreement and no oral statement shall add to or supersede any of its provisions. The parties acknowledge that each has had the unlimited right and opportunity to make demands and proposals with respect to any matter deemed a proper subject for collective bargaining. The results of the exercise of that right and opportunity are set forth in this Agreement. Therefore, unless otherwise agreed, the Employer and the Union, for the duration of this Agreement, each voluntarily and unqualifiedly agree to waive the right to oblige the other party to bargain with respect to any subject or matter not specifically referred to or covered in this Agreement. All wages and/or benefits being received prior to this contract by members covered in this Agreement shall not be reduced except where specifically modified by this Agreement. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 67 ARTICLE 27 – PRIORITY OF FEDERAL, STATE AND CITY LAWS It is understood and agreed by and between the parties that in negotiations and collective bargaining and in the administration of all matters covered by this Agreement, the parties hereto and the City employees are governed by the provisions of applicable State laws, City Ordinances and Resolutions. If there is a conflict between any provision of this Agreement and State law, the latter shall prevail. Provided, however, the Employer agrees that no Ordinance or Resolution shall modify or change any article or section of this Agreement during the life of said Agreement. ARTICLE 28 – VOLUNTEERS The City and Union agree that volunteer programs can be mutually beneficial to the City, employees, and citizens of Renton. The parties recognize that volunteer programs provide a sense of community involvement and require a commitment of time and service on behalf of the volunteer. To that end, the City is committed to working in partnership with the Union to build successful volunteer programs. The use of volunteers will not supplant bargaining unit positions. No bargaining unit member shall be laid off as a result of volunteer programs. The City and the Union will meet in a labor-management forum and come to mutual agreement prior to implementing any new volunteer programs. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 68 ARTICLE 29 – DISCIPLINE 29.1 Discipline The City shall not discipline or discharge an employee without just cause. Employees shall be given the opportunity to have a Union Representative present at meetings where disciplinary proceedings will take place. The City agrees with the principles of progressive discipline. Disciplinary action generally includes the following progressive steps: 29.1.1. Oral reprimand (which shall be reduced to writing although not placed in the employee’s personnel file) 29.1.2. Written reprimand 29.1.3. Suspension 29.1.4. Discharge Disciplinary action will be tailored to the nature and severity of the offense. Management maintains the right to take disciplinary action, as they deem appropriate. 29.2 Demotion The term “demotion” as used in this provision means the involuntary reassignment of an employee from a position in one job classification to a lower paying position in another job classification. In any case involving demotion, the employee shall have the right to due process. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 69 ARTICLE 30 – LEAV E DONATION A Leave Donation Program has been established to assist employees faced with a serious medical illness or injury to themselves or an immediate family member. The Leave Donation Program will be administered in accordance with City Policy #350-12 (Leave Donation), as revised effective August 23, 2017. The following exception applies as a benefit above and beyond those granted by the Policy. State-Registered domestic partners shall be considered family when considering qualifying events for donation. Donated leave may be: vacation, compensatory time, personal holidays, and sick leave. Sick leave donation is capped at 40 hours per recipient per calendar year. The donator’s bank cannot drop below 80 hours. ARTICLE 31 – LAYO FF AND RECALL 31.1. Layoff and Recall The Employer shall retain the Right to determine whether lay-offs are necessary and in which department(s) and classification(s) they will occur. City employees in other departments are not eligible to exercise bumping rights to displace any Court employees regardless of seniority or job classification. 31.2. Definitions 31.2.1. Adjusted Hire Date: The date used to determine “City Seniority.” The Adjusted Hire Date is calculated on the employee’s length of continuous service with the City in a regular full-time or part-time position. Part-time AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 70 employees will have their length of continuous service adjusted for longevity purposes. Seniority earned as a regular, part-time employee shall be prorated. The City will calculate the number of compensated hours in any regular position and divide the total by full time equivalent hours (i.e., 2080 hours per year) to determine the employee’s adjusted hire date for purpose of seniority. 31.2.2. Bumping Rights: An employee’s ability to move into the same classification or another classification, in which he/she has previously achieved regular status, based on his/her overall seniority. 31.2.3. Classification: A classification is a position or group of positions performing similar duties that have the same title, class code, and salary range. 31.2.4. Classification Series: A series of related classifications with an entry level and one or more additional levels as defined in City Policy #320-01, Classification Series. 31.2.5. Initial Probationary Period: The probationary period served by a new employee when hired into a regular position with the City. 31.2.6. Layoff: A reduction in the workforce due lack of funds, lack of work, or the result of a reorganization. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 71 31.2.7. Recall List (also called “Reemployment List,” “Rehire List,” or “Layoff List”): A list of employees who have been laid off from a specific classification and who are eligible for recall. 31.2.8. Original Hire Date: The first day an employee started working for the City, either in a regular status or non- regular status position. 31.2.9 Previously Held Position: A position within the City’s classification system to which the employee has been formally appointed and successfully completed probation. 31.2.10. Probationary Employee: An employee in their initial probationary period who has not achieved regular employee status. 31.2.11. Recall (also called “Reinstatement”): When an employee on the recall list returns to the classification from which he/she was laid off or to a lower classification in which they previously achieved regular employee status. 31.2.12. Seniority: 31.2.12.1 City Seniority, or “Adjusted Hire Date,” is an employee’s length of continuous service with the City in a regular full-time or part- time position. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 72 31.2.12.2 Classification Seniority is the date that the employee was appointed to his/her current position. Classification seniority shall be prorated as described under the definition of Adjusted Hire Date. 31.3. Departmental Review 31.3.1. Each department may periodically review its budget and projected workload to determine if layoffs are necessary. 31.3.2. If it becomes necessary to initiate organizational change for any reason that results in the reduction of employees, the Department Administrator will discuss the organizational change with the Mayor or designee and the Human Resources Risk Management Administrator prior to making any changes. The Department Administrator will determine which classifications will be affected. 31.3.3. The Mayor will have final authority to eliminate positions and/or lay off employees. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 73 31.4. Human Resources Risk Management Review 31.4.1 Once the Department Administrator has determined which classification(s) will be affected, Human Resources Risk Management (HRRM) will determine which employee(s) shall be laid off. 31.4.2. No lay-off or reduction to a lower classification shall be executed so long as there are non-regular (temporary) employees, whether full-time or part time, performing substantially similar job duties in a specific department/division. 31.4.3. For the purpose of the initial layoff, classification seniority shall be the determining factor. Employees shall be laid off from their department or major division in the inverse order of their classification seniority in the classification in which the work force is being reduced. New employees in the affected classification, serving in their initial probationary period, shall be separated before any regular Union employee is laid off in the work unit. 31.4.4. At no time shall layoff, bumping, or recall result in a promotion. 31.4.5. Tie-Breakers: In the event two or more employees have the same classification seniority, City seniority shall prevail. In the event two or more employees have the same City seniority, a tie-breaker will be used to determine the employee with the least seniority. The tie-breaker will be the last four digits of the AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 74 employee’s social security number. The employee with the lowest number shall be considered the employee with the lowest seniority. 31.4.6. It is understood that classifications may change title. If a classification has been re-titled or a new classification created and the duties are substantially the same, the employee shall be considered having “previously achieved regular employee status” in the re-titled or new classification. 31.5. Notice of Layoff 31.5.1 It is the City’s intent to provide employees with notice of any layoff at least thirty (30) calendar days in advance of the intended layoff date. When such a time period is not possible, employees shall be provided with at least two weeks (14 calendar days) notice or receive two weeks’ pay in lieu of notification. 31.5.2 Layoffs resulting from the biennial budget process shall not be final until such time as the budget is adopted by the City Council. 31.6. Bumping Rights 31.6.1. An employee who is laid off may replace another employee in an equal or lower classification series in which the employee works or has previously achieved regular employee status, provided such employee has greater City seniority than the employee whom AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 75 he/she seeks to replace, and provided the replacing employee is qualified to perform the work without further training. 31.6.2. An employee who is laid off may not replace another employee in the same classification in the same workgroup from which they are in the process of being laid off. 31.6.3. The requirement to have previously worked in a classification shall not apply to employees bumping down to a lower compensated position within a recognized classification series (e.g., Maintenance Service Worker, Fire Inspector, etc.). 31.6.4. If the employee is not eligible to bump into another classification based on his/her City seniority, the employee shall be laid off and have his/her name placed on the recall list. 31.7. Recall Rights 31.7.1. The name of any employee who is laid off shall be placed on the recall list for a period of two (2) years. 31.7.2. Employees who are laid off may be recalled to the original classification from which they were laid off or to a lower classification in which they previously achieved regular status with the City, provided they are qualified at the time to perform the work in the AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 76 classification to which they are recalled without further training. 31.7.3. When there is a recall during the life of the recall list, employees who are still on the list shall be recalled in the inverse order in which they were laid off. 31.7.4. The City shall not hire new employees in a given classification as long as there are still employees on the recall list eligible for recall to that classification. 31.7.5. If employees bump into another classification or if employees are recalled to a lower classification in a series, they shall have the right to return to the classification from which they were originally laid off as long as their name remains on the recall list. 31.7.6. An employee who bumps into the same classification but in a different department/division shall have no recall rights to the position from which he/she was originally laid off from. 31.7.7. Employees shall be responsible for keeping HRRM informed of a current e-mail, phone number, and postal mailing address. HRRM will provide notice of recall using e-mail and certified mail. Employees who are recalled to a position shall have seven (7) calendar days from the date they receive notification by certified mail of the recall to respond to HRRM and either accept or reject the position. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 77 31.7.8. Employees who reject, or fail to respond to, a recall offer back to the original classification from which they were laid off shall have their names removed from the recall list. 31.7.9. Seniority dates will be handled as follows during the event of recall, or rehire into a different regular position. For the purposes of this section, “regular position” also includes Limited Term positions: 31.7.9.1 City seniority: Employees who have been recalled or rehired into a regular position within the recall period shall retain their City seniority as of the date of layoff and shall begin accumulating additional City seniority when recalled or rehired back to work. 31.7.9.2 Classification seniority: Employees who have been laid off shall begin accumulating additional classification seniority when recalled to the classification from which they were laid off. Employees who are rehired into a different regular position within the recall period shall begin accumulating classification seniority in the “new” classification as of their date of rehire. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 78 31.7.9.3 Employees affected by layoffs: Employees who bump into a different classification as part of a layoff shall retain their classification seniority as of the date of layoff and shall begin accumulating additional classification seniority when recalled back to the classification from which they were originally laid off. City seniority shall continue to accumulate as long as the employee remains continuously employed in a regular position. 31.7.9.4 Accrual rates: Longevity, vacation, and sick leave accrual rates shall be the same as they were on the date of the layoff. 31.7.10 Employees recalled, or rehired into a different regular position within the recall period, shall have their sick leave balance restored to the amount he/she had at the time of the layoff, excluding any cashed out hours. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 79 ARTICLE 32 – FINGERPRINTING 32.1. Fingerprint Check Requirements All union members who have authorized access to or direct responsibility for configuring and maintaining computer systems and networks that could access Criminal Justice Information (CJI) and/or have access to the Criminal Justice Information System (CJIS) network must pass a fingerprint check prior to unescorted access. Fingerprint check results will be provided to the Police Chief or designee for review and determination to pass or fail access. 32.2. Fingerprint Check Passed Employees moving into a position that requires a fingerprint check must be fingerprinted and successfully pass prior to receiving a formal written offer. 32.3. Fingerprint Check Failed If access is denied, management will attempt to transfer the employee to a non-CJI/CJIS access location. The union member may also request alternative employment for which he/she qualifies, if available. It is understood that in order to continue the employment of a member denied access, the city may need to place the member in an alternate job or job site without posting the position. Failure to be granted access shall not be considered part of the discipline process. The union and the city shall utilize the Labor/Management Committee process to negotiate any potential impacts. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 80 32.4. Right of Appeal Members denied access by the Chief of Police will have the right of appeal. Appeal may be made in writing or by scheduling a meeting with the Police Chief. If a meeting is requested a good faith attempt will be made to meet within ten (10) business days to hear the appeal. The Police Chief will issue a final determination within five (5) business days of the appeal meeting or receipt of a written appeal, if no meeting was requested. In the case of transfer or promotion the position being applied for will not be filled until the appeal has been heard and decided by the Police Chief. Members will have the right to be assisted in the appeal, be it a meeting or written form, by an AFSCME Council 2 Representative or designee. 32.5 Document Destruction All documents will be destroyed after the final report has been provided to Human Resources or after any appeal process is completed. The final report presented to Human Resources will not be kept in the Personnel file. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 81 ARTICLE 33 – DURATION OF AGREEMENT This Agreement shall become effective January 1, 2022 and shall remain in full force and effect until and through December 31, 2024. Signed this _____ day of __________________, 2022 at Renton, Washington. LOCAL 2170, WASHINGTON STATE COUNCIL CITY OF RENTON OF COUNTY AND CITY EMPLOYEES, AMERICAN FEDERATION OF STATE, COUNTY, AND MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEES, AFL-CIO. ______________________________ _____________________________________ Armondo Pavone, Mayor Jayson Gallaway, Local 2170 President ______________________________ _____________________________________ Ellen Bradley-Mak, Mark Watson, Staff Representative HRRM Administrator Washington State Council of County & City Employees ______________________________ Kim Gilman, HR Labor Manager Christian DeMarco, Member ______________________________ _____________________________________ Janna Dinkelspiel, Senior Employee Kristina Raabe, Member Relations Analyst ______________________________ _____________________________________ Kristin Trivelas, Fiscal Services Director Manuel Cruz, Member Stephanie Rary, Member AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 82 ATTEST: ______________________________ Jason Seth, City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: ______________________________ Shane Moloney, City Attorney AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 83 APPENDIX A – AFSCME CLASSIFICATIONS IN ALPHABETICAL ORDER (with Job Grades) a03 *Accounting Assistant 1 a05 *Accounting Assistant 2 a07 *Accounting Assistant 3 a09 *Accounting Assistant 4 a09 Administrative Secretary 1 a23 Airport Operations &Maintenance Supervisor a11 Airport Maintenance Worker a13 Airport Operations Specialist a31 Assistant Airport Manager a17 *Assistant Planner a21 *Associate Planner a21 Building Inspector/Combination a21 Building Inspector/Electrical a23 Building Plan Reviewer a20 Business Coordinator-Airport a23 *Business Systems Analyst a27 *Senior Business Systems Analyst a28 Capital Project Coordinator a21 Case Manager a13 City Clerk Specialist a15 City Clerk Specialist 2 a26 *Civil Engineer 1 a30 *Civil Engineer 2 a33 *Civil Engineer 3 a30 Client Technology Services & Support Supervisor a15 Client Technology Services Specialist 1 a19 Client Technology Services Specialist 2 a19 Code Compliance Inspector a12 Communications Specialist 1 a21 Communications Specialist 2 a21 Construction Inspector a15 Court Operations Specialist a01 Court Security Officer a21 Custodial Maintenance Supervisor a01 Custodian a17 Digital Communications Specialist a18 Development Services Representative a20 *Economic Development Specialist a19 Electrical Technician a21 Emergency Management Coordinator a13 *Engineering Specialist 1 a19 *Engineering Specialist 2 a23 *Engineering Specialist 3 a25 Facilities Coordinator a21 Facilities Supervisor a13 *Facilities Technician 1 a15 *Facilities Technician 2 a18 Farmers Market Coordinator a11 Fleet Management Technician a21 *GIS Analyst 1 a23 *GIS Analyst 2 a26 *GIS Analyst 3 a01 Golf Course Associate a04 *Golf Course Maintenance Worker 1 a08 *Golf Course Maintenance Worker 2 a12 *Golf Course Maintenance Worker 3 a09 Golf Course Operations Assistant a15 Grounds Equipment Mechanic a20 Housing Repair Coordinator a20 Human Services Coordinator a19 HVAC Systems Technician a08 Judicial Specialist a12 Judicial Specialist 2 a22 Lead Code Compliance Inspector a24 Lead Construction Inspector a25 Lead Electrical Control Systems Technician a16 Lead Golf Course Maintenance Worker a11 Lead Maintenance Custodian a16 Lead Maintenance Services Worker a16 Lead Park Maintenance Worker a19 Lead Vehicle & Equipment Mechanic a10 Legal Assistant a15 Lift Station Technician a17 Maintenance Buyer a07 Maintenance Custodian a04 *Maintenance Services Worker 1 a08 *Maintenance Services Worker 2 a12 *Maintenance Services Worker 3 a22 Neighborhood Program Coordinator AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 84 a24 *Network Systems Specialist a17 Paralegal a21 Park Maintenance Supervisor a01 *Parks Maintenance Assistant 1 a03 *Parks Maintenance Assistant 2 a04 *Parks Maintenance Worker 1 a08 *Parks Maintenance Worker 2 a12 *Parks Maintenance Worker 3 a23 Pavement Management Technician a13 Permit Services Specialist a23 Plan Reviewer a15 Planning Technician a36 Principal Civil Engineer a03 Print & Mail Assistant a13 Print & Mail Supervisor a04 Pro Shop Assistant a16 Program Assistant a25 *Program Development Coordinator 1 a29 *Program Development Coordinator 2 a13 Program Specialist a17 Public Records Specialist a08 Purchasing Assistant a18 Recreation Program Coordinator a09 Recreation Assistant a11 Recreation Specialist a14 Recreation Systems Technician a07 Secretary 2 a24 *Senior Economic Development Specialist a28 *Senior Network Systems Specialist a22 Senior Paralegal a28 *Senior Planner a15 Senior Program Specialist a29 *Senior Systems Analyst a13 *Signal/Electronics Systems Tech 1 a17 *Signal/Electronics Systems Tech 2 a21 *Signal/Electronics Systems Tech 3 a23 Street Maintenance Services Supervisor a26 *Systems Analyst a08 *Traffic Maintenance Worker 1 a12 *Traffic Maintenance Worker 2 a15 *Traffic Maintenance Worker, Senior a21 Traffic Signage & Marking Supervisor a24 Transportation Planner a22 Utility Accounts Supervisor a15 Vehicle & Equipment Mechanic a23 Waste Water Maintenance Services Supv. a23 Water Maintenance Services Supervisor a11 Water Meter Systems Specialist a07 Water Meter Technician a17 Water Quality/Treatment Plant Operator a19 Water Utility Instrument/SCADA Tech a26 Water Utility Maintenance Supervisor a15 Water Utility Maintenance Technician *Classification Series AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 85 APPENDIX B – SALARY INDEX FOR 2022 COLA 6.0% Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual a40 10,331 123,972 10,847 130,164 11,397 136,764 11,976 143,712 12,580 150,960 a39 10,097 121,164 10,598 127,176 11,118 133,416 11,683 140,196 12,275 147,300 - a38 9,839 118,068 10,331 123,972 10,847 130,164 11,397 136,764 11,976 143,712 a37 9,613 115,356 10,097 121,164 10,598 127,176 11,118 133,416 11,683 140,196 a36 2428 Principal Civil Engineer 9,369 112,428 9,839 118,068 10,331 123,972 10,847 130,164 11,397 136,764 a35 9,145 109,740 9,613 115,356 10,097 121,164 10,598 127,176 11,118 133,416 a34 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 9,839 118,068 10,331 123,972 10,847 130,164 a33 2475 Civil Engineer 3 8,707 104,484 9,145 109,740 9,613 115,356 10,097 121,164 10,598 127,176 a32 2425 Utility/GIS Engineer 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 9,839 118,068 10,331 123,972 a31 2078 Assistant Airport Manager 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 9,145 109,740 9,613 115,356 10,097 121,164 a30 2512 Client Technology Sys & Support Super.8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 9,839 118,068 a30 2474 Civil Engineer 2 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 9,839 118,068 a29 2570 Program Development Coordinator 2 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 9,145 109,740 9,613 115,356 a29 2451 Senior Systems Analyst 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 9,145 109,740 9,613 115,356 a28 2422 Senior Planner 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 a28 2480 Capital Project Coordinator 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 a28 2416 Senior Network Systems Specialist 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 a27 2452 Senior Business Systems Analyst 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 9,145 109,740 a26 2473 Civil Engineer I 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 a26 2506 GIS Analyst 3 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 a26 2417 Systems Analyst 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 a26 3473 Water Utilities Maintenance Supervisor 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 a25 2481 Facilities Coordinator 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 a25 3484 Lead Electrical/Ctrl Systems Technician 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 a25 2470 Program Development Coordinator 1 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 a25 2170 Property Services Agent 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 a25 8179 Signal/Electronic Systems Supervisor 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE AFSCME, Local 2170 Effective January 1, 2022 STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 86 a24 2420 Database Technician 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a24 3450 Lead Building Inspector 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a24 3469 Lead Construction Inspector 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a24 2403 Senior Economic Development Specialist 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a24 2419 Network Systems Specialist 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a24 2476 Transportation Planner 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a23 8475 Airport Ops & Maintenance Supervisor 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2429 Building Plan Reviewer 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2421 Business Systems Analyst 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2472 Engineering Specialist 3 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2505 GIS Analyst 2 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 8175 Pavement Management Technician 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2450 Plan Reviewer 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2484 Property Services Specialist 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 8001 Street Maintenance Services Supervisor 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 8002 Waste Water Maint. Services Supervisor 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 8000 Water Maintenance Services Supervisor 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a22 2430 Lead Code Compliance Inspector 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 a22 5197 Neighborhood Program Coordinator 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 a22 5002 Senior Paralegal 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 a22 6129 Utility Accounts Supervisor 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 a21 2424 Associate Planner 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 3452 Building Inspector/Combination 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 3451 Building Inspector/Electrical 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 2016 Case Manager 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 2200 Communications Specialist 2 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 3472 Construction Inspector 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 8008 Custodial Maintenance Supervisor 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 5130 Emergency Management Coordinator 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 3089 Facilities Supervisor 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 5111 GIS Analyst 1 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 8006 Parks Maintenance Supervisor 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 3483 Signal/Electronics Systems Technician 3 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 8004 Traffic Signage & Marking Supervisor 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 8011 Water Meter Technician Services Superv 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a20 2079 Business Coordinator - Airport 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 a20 2402 Economic Development Specialist 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 a20 2487 Housing Repair Coordinator 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 a20 2489 Human Services Coordinator 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 a19 6128 Accounting Supervisor 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 2612 Client Technology Services Specialist 2 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 2427 Code Compliance Inspector 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 7182 Electrical Technician 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 3453 Energy Plans Reviewer 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 2471 Engineering Specialist 2 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 3485 HVAC Systems Technician 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 7172 Lead Vehicle & Equipment Mechanic 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 8178 Water Utility Instr./SCADA Technician 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a18 3456 Development Services Representative 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 a18 5195 Farmers Market Coordinator 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 a18 2015 Probation Officer 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 a18 2083 Recreation Program Coordinator 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 a17 2423 Assistant Planner 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 8374 Maintenance Buyer 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 5001 Paralegal 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 5012 Public Records Specialist 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 3482 Signal/Electronics Systems Technician 2 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 3470 Water Quality/Treatment Plant Operato 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 2205 Digital Communications Specialist 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 87 a16 8284 Lead Golf Course Maintenance Worker 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 a16 8074 Lead Maintenance Services Worker 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 a16 8080 Lead Parks Maintenance Worker 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 a16 5194 Program Assistant 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 a15 4014 City Clerk Specialist 2 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 2613 Client Technology Services Specialist 1 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 6167 Court Operations Specialist 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 7181 Facilities Technician 2 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 7184 Grounds Equipment Mechanic 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 8174 Lift Station Technician 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 5122 Planning Technician 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 5180 Senior Program Specialist 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 8574 Senior Traffic Maintenance Worker 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 7170 Vehicle & Equipment Mechanic 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 3474 Water Utility Maintenance Technician 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a14 5161 Asset Management Systems Technician 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 a14 5160 Recreation Systems Technician 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 a13 8474 Airport Operations Specialist 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 3471 Engineering Specialist 1 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 7180 Facilities Technician 1 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 3487 Housing Maintenance Technician 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 6263 Permit Services Specialist 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 7110 Print & Mail Supervisor 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 5179 Program Specialist 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 3481 Signal/Electronics Systems Technician 1 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a12 2201 Communications Specialist 1 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a12 8283 Golf Course Maintenance Worker 3 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a12 6166 Judicial Specialist 2 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a12 8173 Maintenance Services Worker 3 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a12 8083 Parks Maintenance Worker 3 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a12 8573 Traffic Maintenance Worker 2 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a11 8473 Airport Maintenance Worker 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 5014 City Clerk Specialist 1 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 7173 Fleet Management Technician 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 8183 Lead Maintenance Custodian 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 6265 Payroll Analyst 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 5007 Public Records Specialist 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 2486 Recreation Specialist 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 8109 Water Meter System Specialist 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a10 6164 Judicial Specialist/Trainer 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 a10 6165 Legal Assistant 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 a10 6263 Permit Technician 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 a10 6163 Probation Clerk 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 a09 6131 Accounting Assistant 4 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 a09 6151 Administrative Secretary 1 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 a09 8286 Golf Course Operations Assistant 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 a09 8070 Mechanic's Assistant 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 a09 2085 Recreation Assistant 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 a08 8282 Golf Course Maintenance Worker 2 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 7126 Housing Repair Technician 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 6162 Judicial Specialist 1 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 6109 Lead Office Assistant 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 8172 Maintenance Services Worker 2 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 8082 Parks Maintenance Worker 2 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 8375 Purchasing Assistant 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 8572 Traffic Maintenance Worker 1 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 88 a07 6132 Accounting Assistant 3 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 a07 8184 Maintenance Custodian 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 a07 7112 Print & Mail Operator 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 a07 6142 Secretary 2 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 a07 8110 Water Meter Technician 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 a06 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 a05 6134 Accounting Assistant 3 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 a05 6130 Office Assistant 3 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 a05 6141 Secretary 1 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 a04 6160 Court Security Officer 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 8281 Golf Course Maintenance Worker 1 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 8181 Lead Custodian 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 8171 Maintenance Services Worker 1 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 8081 Parks Maintenance Worker 1 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 6282 Pro Shop Assistant 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 8576 Solid Waste Maintenance Worker 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a03 6136 Accounting Assistant 1 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 a03 6120 Office Assistant 2 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 a03 8079 Parks Maintenance Assistant 2 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 a03 7111 Print & Mail Assistant 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 a02 4,061 48,732 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 a01 8182 Custodian 3,955 47,460 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 a01 6281 Golf Course Associate 3,955 47,460 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 a01 6111 Office Assistant 1 3,955 47,460 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 a01 7079 Parks Maintenance Assistant 1 3,955 47,460 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 $6,638 Completion of 5 Yrs Completion of 10 Yrs Completion of 15 Yrs Completion of 20 Yrs Completion of 25 Yrs Completion of 30 Yrs 3% Step a14E $199 per month LONGEVITY PAY Step a14, E = 2% Step a14E $133 per month 4% Step a14E $266 per month 5% Step a14E $332 per month The City contributes 4% of employee's base wage per year to a deferred compensation account. (Article 14) 6% Step a14E $398 per month 7% Step a14E $465 per month AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 89 APPENDIX C – Tele work Reopener During this current round of negotiations, both parties have a continued interest in creating a Telework program that benefits the City and the employees. To this end, either party may reopen this Agreement for the purpose of bargaining over issues related to working conditions contained in a revised Telework Policy, to be shared with the Union no later than July 1, 2022. In the meantime, any rejected Telework applications shall be shared with the Union. AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 90 APPENDIX D – INDEX A abuse of sick leave ......................... 32 accrual ........................................... 30 Accrual ........................................... 39 accrual rate .................................... 39 accrual rates .................................. 78 acting pay ...................................... 30 adjusted hire date ............... 69, 71, 72 alternative work schedules ....... 19, 20 alternative/flex work schedules ..... 19 anniversary .................................... 47 APPENDIX A – AFSCME Classifications ................................................... 83 APPENDIX B – SALARY INDEX FOR 2022 ............................................ 85 APPENDIX C – Telework Reopener . 89 APPENDIX D – Index ....................... 90 arbitration ................................. 60, 61 at will ............................................. 57 B base rate ................................... 38, 40 bereavement leave ........................ 40 biennial budget process ................. 74 bulletin boards ............................... 51 bumping rights .......................... 70, 74 bumps ............................................ 76 C callback .......................................... 27 call-back ......................................... 25 candidate pool ............................... 56 cash out ......................................... 31 cashed out hours ........................... 78 Christmas Day ................................ 35 city seniority 69, 71, 73, 74, 75, 77, 78 classification 13, 14, 46, 50, 57, 68, 69, 70, 71, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77, 78 classification seniority ............... 72, 77 classification series ........................ 70 Classification Series ........................ 84 clean-up time ................................. 22 COBRA ........................................... 44 compensated hours ....................... 23 compensatory ................................ 23 compensatory time ........................ 23 conferences ................................... 45 consecutive hours worked ............. 21 continuous service .................... 69, 71 co-pays .......................................... 41 D deferred compensation ................. 48 demotion ....................................... 68 dental ....................................... 42, 44 disability plan ................................. 31 discharge ............................ 31, 49, 68 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 91 disciplinary action ..................... 54, 68 discipline ................................... 49, 68 double time ................................... 25 dues .......................................... 16, 18 E emergency situations .......... 20, 22, 40 employee contributions ................. 44 employment practices ................... 54 entire agreement ........................... 66 excluded positions ......................... 12 Executive Board .................. 13, 55, 62 Extended Shift Overtime ................ 26 F F.M.C.S. .......................................... 60 Fair Labor Standards Act ................ 23 Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service ........................................ 60 fingerprint ...................................... 79 flexible work schedules .................. 20 flex-time ........................................ 20 FMLA.............................................. 30 G grievance .......... 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62 grievance procedure ...................... 58 grievances ................................. 51, 52 group term ..................................... 44 H health insurance ............................ 41 health, safety and productivity ...... 62 holiday .......................... 36, 37, 38, 49 holiday pay .................................... 37 Holiday Pay .................................... 36 holidays falling on scheduled day off ................................................... 37 holidays falling on weekends ......... 37 hourly ..................... 20, 23, 26, 38, 40 hours of work ................................. 19 I Independence Day ......................... 35 initial probationary period ............. 70 insurance .................................. 42, 44 J July 4 .............................................. 35 Juneteenth ..................................... 35 jury duty ........................................ 44 just cause .................................. 49, 68 L Labor Day ....................................... 35 labor/management committee ...... 52 layoff ............................. 69, 70, 71, 74 layoff and recall ............................. 69 Leave Donation Program ............... 69 life insurance ................................. 44 limited term ................................ 9, 10 Limited Term .................................. 77 longevity ................................... 44, 47 long-term disability ........................ 31 lunch period ................................... 19 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 92 M management rights ........................ 49 Martin Luther King, Jr. Day ............. 35 meal and rest periods .................... 21 meal period.................................... 21 medical ............................... 42, 44, 69 medical leave ................................. 30 membership................................... 18 Memorial Day ................................ 35 N new employees .............................. 18 New Year’s Day .............................. 35 non-discrimination ......................... 54 O officers ........................................... 18 oral reprimand .......................... 54, 68 orientation ..................................... 54 original hire date ............................ 71 overtime ...... 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 27, 49 P PAC program .................................. 17 pager ............................................. 27 paid release time ...................... 50, 52 part-time....................... 38, 39, 40, 48 pay period ...................................... 48 pay stubs ........................................ 49 PERS ............................................... 31 PERS I ............................................. 31 personal holiday ............................ 38 personal holidays ........................... 35 position review .............................. 14 posting of vacancies ....................... 54 Preamble ......................................... 9 premium ................................... 30, 43 previously held position ................. 71 priority of Federal, State and City Laws ............................................ 67 probationary employee ................. 71 probationary period ...... 57, 70, 71, 73 promoted ....................................... 57 promotion ........................... 30, 57, 73 promotional opportunity .......... 56, 57 pro-rated ............................ 38, 39, 48 public interest ................................ 53 R rain gear ........................................ 63 recall .............................................. 71 recall list ........................................ 71 recall rights .................................... 75 reclassification reviews .................. 15 Recognition and Bargaining Unit ...... 9 reduction ...................... 44, 70, 72, 73 reemployment list .......................... 71 regular part-time ........................... 40 REHBT ........................... 41, 42, 43, 44 rehire list........................................ 71 REHP ......................................... 41, 43 reinstatement ................................ 71 Renton Employees’ Healthcare Board of Trustees ............................. 41, 43 Renton Employees’ Healthcare Plan ................................................... 41 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AFSCME, Local 2170 Contract 2022 – 2024 Page 93 rest period ..................................... 22 S safety shoes ................................... 63 salaries ........................................... 46 savings clause ................................ 66 selection process ........................... 55 seniority .............................. 70, 71, 77 shift differential ............................. 27 shop steward ................................. 51 sick leave ................ 24, 30, 31, 32, 53 sick leave cash out ......................... 31 staff representative ............ 51, 61, 81 standby .......................................... 27 steel toed boots ............................. 63 stewards ........................................ 18 suspension ................................ 54, 68 T Thanksgiving .................................. 35 tie-breaker ..................................... 73 time banks ..................................... 23 training ............................... 45, 46, 51 U union activities ............................... 54 union membership and dues deduction ................................... 16 union recognized ............................. 9 V vacancies ....................................... 55 Vacancies ....................................... 55 vacation ........................ 24, 32, 39, 40 Vacation Cash Out ......................... 40 Veterans’ Day ................................ 35 volunteers ........................... 22, 28, 67 W wages .................................. 17, 59, 66 work day ................. 19, 21, 24, 26, 40 work schedules ................... 19, 20, 49 work stoppage ............................... 53 work week .................... 19, 23, 24, 38 workday ....... 21, 22, 23, 24, 27, 45, 51 written reprimand .................... 54, 68 AGENDA ITEM #5. c) AB - 3068 City Council Regular Meeting - 14 Feb 2022 SUBJECT/TITLE: Adopt ordinance authorizing 2022 salary table, with salary increases for AFSCME and nonrepresented regular employees RECOMMENDED ACTION: Council Concur DEPARTMENT: Human Resources / Risk Management Department STAFF CONTACT: Ellen Bradley-Mak, Administrator EXT.: X7657 FISCAL IMPACT SUMMARY: The 2022 budget was initially approved with a 4% increase for Non -Represented regular employees. An additional 2% increase effective March 1, 2022 is $259,171, and a budget adjustment will be prepared by Finance for this additional amount. SUMMARY OF ACTION: For many years, annual salary scale adjustments for Non -Represented regular employees have been based on negotiated adjustments for AFSCME and authorized at the time of council adoption of successor AFSCME collective bargaining agreements. As the recently negotiated AFSCME contract includes a 6% wage adjustment for 2022, an additional 2% added to the Non -Represented salary schedule effective March 1, 2022, will continue this practice. The attached amended ordinance includes both the 6% adjustment for AFSCME effective January 1, 2022, and the additional 2% added to the Non -Represented salary scale effective March 1, 2022. EXHIBITS: A. Ordinance, with 2022 Salary Table dated 3/1/22 STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Waive the requirement in Section 6.1 of Council Policy 800-07 for ordinances to be reviewed by Council committee prior to adoption; and conduct first and second reading at the same Council meeting, and adopt the ordinance that amends the 2022 Salary Table to reflect the wage increases agreed to in the 2 022-2024 AFSCME collective bargaining agreement, for AFSCME employees. In keeping with the city's past practice, this salary increase will also apply to Non-Represented regular employees. AGENDA ITEM #5. d)   1  CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON    ORDINANCE NO. ________    AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON, AMENDING THE 2022  CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE FOR NON‐REPRESENTED CITY EMPLOYEES,  AFSCME LOCAL 2170 CITY EMPLOYEES, RENTON POLICE DEPARTMENT –  COMMISSIONED OFFICERS, AND RENTON POLICE DEPARTMENT – NON‐ COMMISSIONED EMPLOYEES.    WHEREAS, the City Council has approved changes in compensation that impact the City  of Renton Salary Table for 2022; and  WHEREAS, the City Council desires to amend the 2022 City of Renton Salary Table to  incorporate the changes in compensation;   NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON, DO  ORDAIN AS FOLLOWS:  SECTION I. The City Council hereby adopts the amended 2022 City of Renton Salary  Table, attached hereto and incorporated by this reference as Exhibit A.  SECTION II. The Salary Table is intended to be consistent with all applicable collective  bargaining agreements.  In the event of conflicts, applicable collective bargaining agreements  control.   SECTION III. This ordinance shall be in full force and effect five (5) days after publication  of a summary of this ordinance in the City’s official newspaper.  The amended Salary Table shall  be retroactively effective and replace the previously adopted Salary Table starting on January 1,  2022, for AFSCME Local 2170 represented employees and effective March 1, 2022, for non‐ represented employees.  Once effective, the amended Salary Table shall remain in effect until  AGENDA ITEM #5. d) ORDINANCE NO. ________  2  changes are authorized by the City Council.  The summary of this ordinance shall consist of this  ordinance’s title.      PASSED BY THE CITY COUNCIL this _______ day of February, 2022.                         Jason A. Seth, City Clerk    APPROVED BY THE MAYOR this _______ day of February , 2022.                         Armondo Pavone, Mayor    Approved as to form:             Shane Moloney, City Attorney  Date of Publication:      ORD‐HR:2207:2/7/2022     AGENDA ITEM #5. d) ORDINANCE NO. ________  3          EXHIBIT A  2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE  AGENDA ITEM #5. d) COLA 6% Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual e10 1030 Mayor (1)15,963 191,556 15,963 191,556 e09 1005 City Council President (2)(7)2,050 24,600 e09 1000 City Council Members (2)1,750 21,000 e08 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 12,780 153,360 13,425 161,100 e11 1020 Municipal Court Judge (6)15,051 180,614 15,051 180,614 Salary effective July 2020 - June 30, 2022 Salary is 95% of District Court Judge Salary m53 1035 Chief Administrative Officer (3)14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 16,768 201,216 17,609 211,308 m52 14,105 169,260 14,819 177,828 15,576 186,912 16,364 196,368 17,182 206,184 m51 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 16,768 201,216 m50 13,425 161,100 14,105 169,260 14,819 177,828 15,576 186,912 16,364 196,368 m49 1400 City Attorney (3)13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 m49 1109 Parks & Recreation Administrator (3)13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 m49 1105 Community & Economic Development Administrator 13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 m49 1036 Deputy Chief Administrative Officer (3)13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 m49 1101 Finance Administrator (3)13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 m49 1107 Equity, Housing & Human Services Administrator (3)13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 m49 1104 Human Resources & Risk Mgmt Administrator (3)13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 m49 1110 Judicial Administrative Officer 13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 m49 1103 Public Works Administrator (3)13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 m49 1201 Police Chief (3)13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 m48 12,780 153,360 13,425 161,100 14,105 169,260 14,819 177,828 15,576 186,912 m47 12,470 149,640 13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 m46 1535 Police Deputy Chief (4)12,165 145,980 12,780 153,360 13,425 161,100 14,105 169,260 14,819 177,828 m46 1405 Prosecution Director 12,165 145,980 12,780 153,360 13,425 161,100 14,105 169,260 14,819 177,828 m45 11,869 142,428 12,470 149,640 13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 m44 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 12,780 153,360 13,425 161,100 14,105 169,260 m43 11,295 135,540 11,869 142,428 12,470 149,640 13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 m42 1401 Sr Assistant City Attorney 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 12,780 153,360 13,425 161,100 m41 1212 Information Technology Director 10,754 129,048 11,295 135,540 11,869 142,428 12,470 149,640 13,102 157,224 m40 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 12,780 153,360 m39 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 11,295 135,540 11,869 142,428 12,470 149,640 m38 2178 Airport Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 2011 City Clerk/Public Records Officer 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1204 Communications & Engagement Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1575 Development Services Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1501 Economic Development Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 2044 Emergency Management Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1207 Facilities Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1210 Fiscal Services Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 2463 HR Labor Relations & Compensation Manager 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1406 Lead Prosecutor 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE NON-REPRESENTED Effective March 1, 2022 STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E ELECTED OFFICIALS MANAGEMENT & SUPERVISORY (NON-UNION) AGENDA ITEM #5. d) COLA 6% Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE NON-REPRESENTED Effective March 1, 2022 STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E m38 1571 Maintenance Services Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 8084 Parks and Trails Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1208 Parks Planning and Natural Resources Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1502 Planning Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 2031 Police Commander (5)9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1214 Recreation Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1570 Utility Systems Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1572 Transportation Systems Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m37 2148 Application Support Manager 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 11,295 135,540 11,869 142,428 m37 2175 ITS and Maintenance Manager 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 11,295 135,540 11,869 142,428 m37 2176 Transportation Design Manager 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 11,295 135,540 11,869 142,428 m37 2075 Transportation Operations Manager 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 11,295 135,540 11,869 142,428 m37 2177 Transportation Planning Manager 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 11,295 135,540 11,869 142,428 m37 2172 Utility Engineering Manager 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 11,295 135,540 11,869 142,428 m36 2074 Building Official 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 m36 2021 Current Planning Manager 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 m36 2073 Development Engineering Manager 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 m36 2020 Long Range Planning Manager 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 m35 1402 Assistant City Attorney 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 11,295 135,540 m34 2023 Construction Manager 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 m34 2462 Human Resources Benefits Manager 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 m34 2413 Network Systems Manager 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 m34 2460 Organizational Development Manager 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 m34 2409 Risk Manager 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 m33 5015 Budget & Accounting Manager 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 m33 1578 Community Development & Housing Manager 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 m33 2174 Property & Technical Services Manager 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 m33 3072 Water Maintenance Manager 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 m32 4480 Capital Projects Manager 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 m32 1577 Economic Development Manager 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 m32 3073 Fleet Manager 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 m32 4470 Parks Planning Manager 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 m32 3071 Street Maintenance Manager 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 m32 3083 Urban Forestry and Natural Resources Manager 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 m32 3070 Waste Water/Special Operations Manager 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 m31 3086 Facilities Manager 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 m31 8010 Parks Maintenance Manager 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 m30 2407 GIS Manager 8,196 98,352 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 m30 2033 Police Manager 8,196 98,352 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 m29 2202 Communications Manager 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 m29 3084 Golf Course Manager 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 m29 1522 Human Services Manager 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 m29 1404 Prosecuting Attorney 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 m29 2087 Recreation Manager 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 m28 6031 Financial Operations Manager 7,803 93,636 8,196 98,352 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 m28 5254 Permit Services Manager 7,803 93,636 8,196 98,352 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 m28 1116 Tax & Licensing Manager 7,803 93,636 8,196 98,352 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 m27 3011 Enterprise Content Manager 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 m27 2578 Housing Programs Manager 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 m26 7,425 89,100 7,803 93,636 8,196 98,352 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 m25 2086 Head Golf Professional 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 m25 2562 Senior Benefits Analyst 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 AGENDA ITEM #5. d) COLA 6% Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE NON-REPRESENTED Effective March 1, 2022 STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E m25 2563 Senior Employee Relations Analyst 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 m25 2410 Senior Finance Analyst 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 m25 2561 Senior Risk Analyst 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 m25 2479 Solid Waste Coordinator 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 m24 5112 Deputy City Clerk/Public Records Officer 7,071 84,852 7,425 89,100 7,803 93,636 8,196 98,352 8,609 103,308 m23 3562 Benefits Analyst 6,891 82,692 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 m23 3563 Employee Relations Analyst 6,891 82,692 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 m23 2080 Recreation Supervisor 6,891 82,692 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 m23 2461 Risk Analyst 6,891 82,692 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 m22 2404 Community Events Coordinator 6,729 80,748 7,071 84,852 7,425 89,100 7,803 93,636 8,196 98,352 m22 1510 Court Services Supervisor 6,729 80,748 7,071 84,852 7,425 89,100 7,803 93,636 8,196 98,352 m22 8007 Golf Course Supervisor 6,729 80,748 7,071 84,852 7,425 89,100 7,803 93,636 8,196 98,352 m22 2091 Museum Manager 6,729 80,748 7,071 84,852 7,425 89,100 7,803 93,636 8,196 98,352 m21 2218 Tax & Licensing Auditor, Senior 6,562 78,744 6,891 82,692 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 m20 6,402 76,824 6,729 80,748 7,071 84,852 7,425 89,100 7,803 93,636 m19 6150 City Council Liaison 6,249 74,988 6,562 78,744 6,891 82,692 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 m19 6103 Executive Assistant 6,249 74,988 6,562 78,744 6,891 82,692 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 m18 5416 Payroll Technician 3 6,092 73,104 6,402 76,824 6,729 80,748 7,071 84,852 7,425 89,100 m17 5000 Legal Analyst 5,947 71,364 6,249 74,988 6,562 78,744 6,891 82,692 7,244 86,928 n16 multiple Administrative Assistants (All Depts)5,778 69,336 6,070 72,840 6,367 76,404 6,695 80,340 7,029 84,348 n16 5118 Finance Analyst 3 5,778 69,336 6,070 72,840 6,367 76,404 6,695 80,340 7,029 84,348 n16 2217 Tax & Licensing Auditor 2 5,778 69,336 6,070 72,840 6,367 76,404 6,695 80,340 7,029 84,348 n15 5,628 67,536 5,919 71,028 6,216 74,592 6,532 78,384 6,866 82,392 n14 5,496 65,952 5,778 69,336 6,070 72,840 6,367 76,404 6,695 80,340 n13 5115 Finance Analyst 2 5,360 64,320 5,628 67,536 5,919 71,028 6,216 74,592 6,532 78,384 n13 2662 Human Resources Specialist 5,360 64,320 5,628 67,536 5,919 71,028 6,216 74,592 6,532 78,384 n13 5032 Payroll Technician 2 5,360 64,320 5,628 67,536 5,919 71,028 6,216 74,592 6,532 78,384 n13 2216 Tax & Licensing Auditor 1 5,360 64,320 5,628 67,536 5,919 71,028 6,216 74,592 6,532 78,384 n12 5,234 62,808 5,496 65,952 5,778 69,336 6,070 72,840 6,367 76,404 n11 2488 Assistant Golf Professional 5,102 61,224 5,360 64,320 5,628 67,536 5,919 71,028 6,216 74,592 n10 5114 Finance Analyst 1 4,980 59,760 5,234 62,808 5,496 65,952 5,778 69,336 6,070 72,840 n10 5216 Payroll Technician 1 4,980 59,760 5,234 62,808 5,496 65,952 5,778 69,336 6,070 72,840 n09 4,861 58,332 5,102 61,224 5,360 64,320 5,628 67,536 5,919 71,028 n08 4,739 56,868 4,980 59,760 5,234 62,808 5,496 65,952 5,778 69,336 n07 4,625 55,500 4,861 58,332 5,102 61,224 5,360 64,320 5,628 67,536 n06 4,510 54,120 4,739 56,868 4,980 59,760 5,234 62,808 5,496 65,952 n05 4,401 52,812 4,625 55,500 4,861 58,332 5,102 61,224 5,360 64,320 n04 4,296 51,552 4,510 54,120 4,739 56,868 4,980 59,760 5,234 62,808 n03 4,195 50,340 4,401 52,812 4,625 55,500 4,861 58,332 5,102 61,224 n02 4,093 49,116 4,296 51,552 4,510 54,120 4,739 56,868 4,980 59,760 NON-UNION (CLERICAL, OTHER) AGENDA ITEM #5. d) COLA 6% Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE NON-REPRESENTED Effective March 1, 2022 STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E n01 5138 Office Specialist 3,998 47,976 4,195 50,340 4,401 52,812 4,625 55,500 4,861 58,332 $6,638 Completion of 5 Yrs Completion of 10 Yrs Completion of 15 Yrs Completion of 20 Yrs Completion of 25 Yrs Completion of 30 Yrs (1)In addition to salary receives annual car allowance of $4800 or use of a city vehicle. (2) (3)Not eligible for Longevity/Education or Uniform Allowance (4)Not eligible for Longevity/Education or Uniform Allowance Eligible for 3% cash premium or 3% into deferred compensation per employee's discretion for passing physical fitness. (5)Receive Education/Longevity & Uniform Allowance based on Union Contract. Eligible for 3% deferred compensation for passing physical fitness. Eligible for P2 paid job injury leave based on Union Contract. (6)4 year term (7)Council president to be paid $300/month above council members salary. for Management and Non-Represented employees; except for CAO receives 11% per year. 5% Step a14E $332 per month 6% Step a14E $398 per month 7% Step a14E $465 per month Council members salary set per Salary Commission effective 4/1/20. Council receives 2% of salary for deferred comp. If members are prohibited from participating in PERS, they receive an extra 1.4 % of salary for deferred compensation. The City contributes 4% of employee's base wage per year to a deferred compensation account 3% Step a14E $199 per month 4% Step a14E $266 per month 2% Step a14E $133 per month NON-REPRESENTED LONGEVITY PAY as of 1/1/2021 Step a14, E = AGENDA ITEM #5. d) COLA 6.0% Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual a40 10,331 123,972 10,847 130,164 11,397 136,764 11,976 143,712 12,580 150,960 a39 10,097 121,164 10,598 127,176 11,118 133,416 11,683 140,196 12,275 147,300 - a38 9,839 118,068 10,331 123,972 10,847 130,164 11,397 136,764 11,976 143,712 a37 9,613 115,356 10,097 121,164 10,598 127,176 11,118 133,416 11,683 140,196 a36 2428 Principal Civil Engineer 9,369 112,428 9,839 118,068 10,331 123,972 10,847 130,164 11,397 136,764 a35 9,145 109,740 9,613 115,356 10,097 121,164 10,598 127,176 11,118 133,416 a34 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 9,839 118,068 10,331 123,972 10,847 130,164 a33 2475 Civil Engineer 3 8,707 104,484 9,145 109,740 9,613 115,356 10,097 121,164 10,598 127,176 a32 2425 Utility/GIS Engineer 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 9,839 118,068 10,331 123,972 a31 2078 Assistant Airport Manager 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 9,145 109,740 9,613 115,356 10,097 121,164 a30 2512 Client Technology Sys & Support Super.8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 9,839 118,068 a30 2474 Civil Engineer 2 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 9,839 118,068 a29 2570 Program Development Coordinator 2 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 9,145 109,740 9,613 115,356 a29 2451 Senior Systems Analyst 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 9,145 109,740 9,613 115,356 a28 2422 Senior Planner 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 a28 2480 Capital Project Coordinator 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 a28 2416 Senior Network Systems Specialist 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 a27 2452 Senior Business Systems Analyst 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 9,145 109,740 a26 2473 Civil Engineer I 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 a26 2506 GIS Analyst 3 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 a26 2417 Systems Analyst 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 a26 3473 Water Utilities Maintenance Supervisor 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 a25 2481 Facilities Coordinator 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 a25 3484 Lead Electrical/Ctrl Systems Technician 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 a25 2470 Program Development Coordinator 1 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 a25 2170 Property Services Agent 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 a25 8179 Signal/Electronic Systems Supervisor 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 a24 2420 Database Technician 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a24 3450 Lead Building Inspector 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a24 3469 Lead Construction Inspector 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a24 2403 Senior Economic Development Specialist 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a24 2419 Network Systems Specialist 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a24 2476 Transportation Planner 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a23 8475 Airport Ops & Maintenance Supervisor 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2429 Building Plan Reviewer 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2421 Business Systems Analyst 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2472 Engineering Specialist 3 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2505 GIS Analyst 2 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 8175 Pavement Management Technician 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2450 Plan Reviewer 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2484 Property Services Specialist 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 8001 Street Maintenance Services Supervisor 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE AFSCME, Local 2170 Effective January 1, 2022 STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E AGENDA ITEM #5. d) COLA 6.0% Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE AFSCME, Local 2170 Effective January 1, 2022 STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E a23 8002 Waste Water Maint. Services Supervisor 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 8000 Water Maintenance Services Supervisor 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a22 2430 Lead Code Compliance Inspector 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 a22 5197 Neighborhood Program Coordinator 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 a22 5002 Senior Paralegal 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 a22 6129 Utility Accounts Supervisor 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 a21 2424 Associate Planner 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 3452 Building Inspector/Combination 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 3451 Building Inspector/Electrical 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 2016 Case Manager 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 2200 Communications Specialist 2 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 3472 Construction Inspector 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 8008 Custodial Maintenance Supervisor 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 5130 Emergency Management Coordinator 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 3089 Facilities Supervisor 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 5111 GIS Analyst 1 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 8006 Parks Maintenance Supervisor 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 3483 Signal/Electronics Systems Technician 3 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 8004 Traffic Signage & Marking Supervisor 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 8011 Water Meter Technician Services Supervi 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a20 2079 Business Coordinator - Airport 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 a20 2402 Economic Development Specialist 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 a20 2487 Housing Repair Coordinator 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 a20 2489 Human Services Coordinator 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 a19 6128 Accounting Supervisor 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 2612 Client Technology Services Specialist 2 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 2427 Code Compliance Inspector 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 7182 Electrical Technician 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 3453 Energy Plans Reviewer 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 2471 Engineering Specialist 2 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 3485 HVAC Systems Technician 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 7172 Lead Vehicle & Equipment Mechanic 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 8178 Water Utility Instr./SCADA Technician 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a18 3456 Development Services Representative 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 a18 5195 Farmers Market Coordinator 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 a18 2015 Probation Officer 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 a18 2083 Recreation Program Coordinator 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 a17 2423 Assistant Planner 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 8374 Maintenance Buyer 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 5001 Paralegal 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 5012 Public Records Specialist 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 3482 Signal/Electronics Systems Technician 2 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 3470 Water Quality/Treatment Plant Operator 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 2205 Digital Communications Specialist 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a16 8284 Lead Golf Course Maintenance Worker 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 a16 8074 Lead Maintenance Services Worker 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 a16 8080 Lead Parks Maintenance Worker 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 a16 5194 Program Assistant 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 a15 4014 City Clerk Specialist 2 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 2613 Client Technology Services Specialist 1 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 6167 Court Operations Specialist 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 7181 Facilities Technician 2 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 AGENDA ITEM #5. d) COLA 6.0% Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE AFSCME, Local 2170 Effective January 1, 2022 STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E a15 7184 Grounds Equipment Mechanic 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 8174 Lift Station Technician 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 5122 Planning Technician 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 5180 Senior Program Specialist 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 8574 Senior Traffic Maintenance Worker 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 7170 Vehicle & Equipment Mechanic 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 3474 Water Utility Maintenance Technician 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a14 5161 Asset Management Systems Technician 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 a14 5160 Recreation Systems Technician 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 a13 8474 Airport Operations Specialist 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 3471 Engineering Specialist 1 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 7180 Facilities Technician 1 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 3487 Housing Maintenance Technician 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 6263 Permit Services Specialist 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 7110 Print & Mail Supervisor 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 5179 Program Specialist 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 3481 Signal/Electronics Systems Technician 1 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a12 2201 Communications Specialist 1 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a12 8283 Golf Course Maintenance Worker 3 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a12 6166 Judicial Specialist 2 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a12 8173 Maintenance Services Worker 3 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a12 8083 Parks Maintenance Worker 3 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a12 8573 Traffic Maintenance Worker 2 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a11 8473 Airport Maintenance Worker 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 5014 City Clerk Specialist 1 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 7173 Fleet Management Technician 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 8183 Lead Maintenance Custodian 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 6265 Payroll Analyst 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 5007 Public Records Specialist 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 2486 Recreation Specialist 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 8109 Water Meter System Specialist 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a10 6164 Judicial Specialist/Trainer 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 a10 6165 Legal Assistant 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 a10 6263 Permit Technician 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 a10 6163 Probation Clerk 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 a09 6131 Accounting Assistant 4 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 a09 6151 Administrative Secretary 1 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 a09 8286 Golf Course Operations Assistant 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 a09 8070 Mechanic's Assistant 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 a09 2085 Recreation Assistant 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 a08 8282 Golf Course Maintenance Worker 2 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 7126 Housing Repair Technician 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 6162 Judicial Specialist 1 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 6109 Lead Office Assistant 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 8172 Maintenance Services Worker 2 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 8082 Parks Maintenance Worker 2 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 8375 Purchasing Assistant 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 8572 Traffic Maintenance Worker 1 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a07 6132 Accounting Assistant 3 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 a07 8184 Maintenance Custodian 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 a07 7112 Print & Mail Operator 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 a07 6142 Secretary 2 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 AGENDA ITEM #5. d) COLA 6.0% Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE AFSCME, Local 2170 Effective January 1, 2022 STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E a07 8110 Water Meter Technician 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 a06 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 a05 6134 Accounting Assistant 3 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 a05 6130 Office Assistant 3 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 a05 6141 Secretary 1 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 a04 6160 Court Security Officer 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 8281 Golf Course Maintenance Worker 1 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 8181 Lead Custodian 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 8171 Maintenance Services Worker 1 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 8081 Parks Maintenance Worker 1 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 6282 Pro Shop Assistant 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 8576 Solid Waste Maintenance Worker 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a03 6136 Accounting Assistant 1 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 a03 6120 Office Assistant 2 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 a03 8079 Parks Maintenance Assistant 2 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 a03 7111 Print & Mail Assistant 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 a02 4,061 48,732 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 a01 8182 Custodian 3,955 47,460 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 a01 6281 Golf Course Associate 3,955 47,460 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 a01 6111 Office Assistant 1 3,955 47,460 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 a01 7079 Parks Maintenance Assistant 1 3,955 47,460 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 $6,638 Completion of 5 Yrs Completion of 10 Yrs Completion of 15 Yrs Completion of 20 Yrs Completion of 25 Yrs Completion of 30 Yrs The City contributes 4% of employee's base wage per year to a deferred compensation account. (Article 14) 6% Step a14E $398 per month 7% Step a14E $465 per month 4% Step a14E $266 per month 5% Step a14E $332 per month 3% Step a14E $199 per month LONGEVITY PAY Step a14, E = 2% Step a14E $133 per month AGENDA ITEM #5. d) Grade Code Monthly Annual Monthly Annual Police Chief See Management & Supervisory Matrix, Grade m49 Police Deputy Chief See Management & Supervisory Matrix, Grade m46 Police Commander See Management & Supervisory Matrix, Grade m38 pc61 3035 Sergeant*9,384 112,609 9,853 118,240 (15% over Police Officer)*Step increase at 24 months pc60 4131 Patrol Officer II 6,097 73,165 6,614 79,363 7,134 85,613 7,646 91,747 8,161 97,932 pc59 4130 Patrol Officer I 5,738 68,861 6,225 74,699 6,715 80,575 7,196 86,347 7,681 92,172 Percent Interpreters ------------------------3% Detectives --------------------------4% Traffic Assignment----------------4% Motorcycle Assignment------------- 2% Canine Officer ---------------------3% Corporal Assignment ------------7.5% Field Training Officer ------------4% Training Officer--------------------4% SWAT Assignment ----------------4% SRO Assignment-------------------4% Civil Disturbance Unit -----------Paid at rate of double time with 3 hrs minimum when called to emergency. Crisis Communication Unit------Paid at rate of double time with 3 hrs minimum when called to emergency. Percentage (of base wage) Percentage (of base wage) - - - - - Patrol Officer II: Effective 1-1-18 Patrol Officer II and Sergeant had 6.25% added to their base pay to reflect the additional 109 hours worked in a calendar year. This is reflected in the ranges above. Effective January 1, 2008, Sergeants assigned to Investigation and Traffic Unit will not receive the 3% premium if they have been in the position of Sergeant for 24 months. NOTE: Please refer to the current labor agreement for specific information. AA Degree (90 credits)4% BA Degree/Masters Degree 6% The City contributes 2.0% of employee's wage base toward deferred compensation. (Appendix A.2.3) The City will contribute 3.0% of employee's wage base toward deferred compensation for passing physical fitness. (Article 6.8.4, and Appendix A.2.4) Beginning 1-1-2020 the City will contribute 1% of employee's wage base to a VEBA plan. (Article 14.11) Completion of 10 Yrs 4% Completion of 15 Yrs 6% Completion of 20 Yrs 10% Completion of 25 Yrs 12% Completion of 30 Yrs 14% MONTHLY EDUCATIONAL INCENTIVE PAY (Appendix B) Position Title HAZARD DUTY AND PREMIUM PAY (Article 6.7 and 6.8) MONTHLY LONGEVITY PAY (Appendix B) Years of Service Completion of 5 Yrs 2% 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE POLICE DEPARTMENT - Commissioned Officers In Negotiations STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E AGENDA ITEM #5. d) Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual pn70 6,008 72,096 6,495 77,940 7,137 85,644 7,843 94,116 8,256 99,072 pn69 5,861 70,332 6,337 76,044 6,963 83,556 7,652 91,824 8,055 96,660 pn68 5,718 68,616 6,182 74,184 6,793 81,516 7,465 89,580 7,858 94,296 pn67 4140 Community Engagement Coord.5,579 66,948 6,031 72,372 6,628 79,536 7,283 87,396 7,667 92,004 pn66 5,443 65,316 5,884 70,608 6,466 77,592 7,106 85,272 7,480 89,760 pn65 5,310 63,720 5,741 68,892 6,308 75,696 6,932 83,184 7,297 87,564 pn64 5,181 62,172 5,601 67,212 6,155 73,860 6,763 81,156 7,119 85,428 pn63 5,054 60,648 5,464 65,568 6,004 72,048 6,598 79,176 6,946 83,352 pn58 6178 Police Service Specialist Supv 6,454 77,448 6,776 81,312 Step A(15% above Specialist, Step E) Step E (5% above Supervisor, Step A) pn57 6182 Police Service Specialist Lead 6,032 72,384 6,032 72,384 (7.5% above Specialist, Step E) pn54 4138 Police Community Prgm Coord 4,993 59,916 5,396 64,752 5,928 71,136 6,390 76,680 6,710 80,520 pn54 4120 Crime Analyst 4,993 59,916 5,396 64,752 5,928 71,136 6,390 76,680 6,710 80,520 pn56 4133 Electronic Home Detention Coord 4,926 59,112 5,316 63,792 5,854 70,248 6,436 77,232 6,756 81,072 pn53 3432 Evidence Technician 4,700 56,400 5,073 60,876 5,583 66,996 6,142 73,704 6,458 77,496 pn61 4121 Domestic Violence Victim Advocate 4,661 55,932 5,063 60,756 5,627 67,524 6,186 74,232 6,513 78,156 pn60 4,445 53,340 4,828 57,936 5,364 64,368 5,898 70,776 6,205 74,460 pn52 4135 Animal Control Officer 4,433 53,196 4,793 57,516 5,270 63,240 5,795 69,540 6,086 73,032 pn62 6181 Police Service Specialist 4,088 49,056 4,416 52,992 4,860 58,320 5,346 64,152 5,612 67,344 pn51 6183 Police Secretary 3,829 45,948 4,133 49,596 4,550 54,600 5,008 60,096 5,254 63,048 pn51 4137 Parking Enforcement Officer 3,829 45,948 4,133 49,596 4,550 54,600 5,008 60,096 5,254 63,048 Interpreter Premium………………………………..………………….…………….3% of base pay (Article 6.5.2) 2.5% of base pay (Article 6.5.3) 4% of base pay (Article 6.5.1) Double time with 3 hrs min (Article 6.4) NON- COMMISSIONED PREMIUM PAY (Articles 6.4 and 6.5) Public Records Act Premium…………………………………………………………… Field Training Officer, FTO (Police Service Specialist)…………........… Crisis Communication Unit………………………………………..…...……… POLICE NON-COMMISSIONED- MONTHLY LONGEVITY INCENTIVE PAY SCHEDULE (Article 12, Appendix B.1) Years of Service Percentage (of base wage) 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE POLICE DEPARTMENT - Non-Commissioned Officers In Negotiations STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E CITY OF RENTON C:\Users\manthony\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\INetCache\Content.Outlook\1Q2VXWBW\2022 Salary Table 1-14-2022\Police Non-Comm 2022 Salary Table 1-14-2022 Page 10 of 12 AGENDA ITEM #5. d) - Beginning 1/1/2020 the City will contribute 1% of the employee's base wage to a VEBA plan. (Article 14.10) - The City will contribute an additional 3.0% of employee's wage base toward deferred comp for passing physical fitness prior to beginning of each calendar year. (Article 6.8.3) Completion of 25 Yrs 12% Completion of 30 Yrs 14% MONTHLY EDUCATIONAL INCENTIVE PAY SCHEDULE (Appendix B.2) Percentage (of base wage) AA Degree (90 credits)4% BA/BS Degree or Masters Degree 6% - The City contributes 4.5% of the employee's base wage to a deferred comp account. (Appendix A.3) Completion of 10 Yrs 4% Completion of 15 Yrs 6% Completion of 20 Yrs 10% Completion of 5 Yrs 2% CITY OF RENTON C:\Users\manthony\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\INetCache\Content.Outlook\1Q2VXWBW\2022 Salary Table 1-14-2022\Police Non-Comm 2022 Salary Table 1-14-2022 Page 11 of 12 AGENDA ITEM #5. d) Grade STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E h07 14.50 14.75 h08 15.00 15.25 15.50 15.75 16.00 h09 16.25 16.50 16.75 17.00 17.25 h10 17.50 17.75 18.00 18.25 18.50 h11 18.75 19.00 19.25 19.50 19.75 h12 20.00 20.50 21.00 21.50 22.00 h13 22.50 23.00 23.50 24.00 24.50 h14 25.00 25.50 26.00 26.50 27.00 h15 27.50 28.00 28.50 29.00 29.50 h16 30.00 30.50 31.00 31.50 32.00 h17 32.50 33.00 33.50 34.00 34.50 h18 35.00 35.50 36.00 36.50 37.00 h19 37.50 38.00 38.50 39.00 39.50 h20 40.00 40.50 41.00 41.50 42.00 h21 42.25 42.50 42.75 43.00 43.25 h22 43.50 43.75 44.00 44.25 44.50 h23 45.00 45.50 46.00 46.50 47.00 h24 47.50 48.00 48.50 49.00 49.50 h25 50.00 51.00 52.00 53.00 54.00 h26 55.00 60.00 65.00 70.00 75.00 h27 80.00 85.00 90.00 95.00 100.00 h28 105.00 110.00 115.00 120.00 125.00 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE SUPPLEMENTAL EMPLOYEE WAGE TABLE AGENDA ITEM #5. d) AB - 3069 City Council Regular Meeting - 14 Feb 2022 SUBJECT/TITLE: Fuel Tax Grant Agreement with the Washington State Transportation Improvement Board for the Rainier Avenue South Corridor Improvements Project – Phase 4 RECOMMENDED ACTION: Refer to Finance Committee DEPARTMENT: Public Works Transportation Systems Division STAFF CONTACT: Heather Gregersen, Program Development Coordinator EXT.: 7393 FISCAL IMPACT SUMMARY: The Transportation Systems Division was awarded funding by the Washington State Transportation Improvement Board (TIB) for the Rainier Avenue South Corridor Improvements Project – Phase 4 (TIP No. 21- 22) in the amount of $5,000,000. An allocation of dollars from Fund 305 has been set aside and will be assigned as a local match when the agreements for federal funding already secured for the project become available in June 2022. SUMMARY OF ACTION: The City has been awarded a $5,000,000 grant from the Washington State Transportation Improvement Board (TIB) to fund the construction of the Rainier Avenue South Corridor Improvements Project – Phase 4. Construction is scheduled to begin in June 2022 afte r federal funding secured for the project becomes available and the right-of-way acquisition phase is complete. The Rainier Avenue South Corridor Improvements - Phase 4 project (TIP No. 21-22) continues the infrastructure improvements to the Rainier Avenue South corridor between S 3rd St to NW 3rd Pl (approximately 1000 ft north of Airport Way). This phase includes wider ADA accessible sidewalks with the streetscape, installation of pedestrian operated High-Intensity Activated Crosswalk (HAWK) signals, intersection signal upgrades, northbound and southbound Business and Access Transit (BAT) lanes between S 3rd St and S 2nd St, transit facility upgrades, a portion of a regional trail, and access management. The project also includes reconstruction of the existing substandard traffic signals, upgraded traffic signal timing and coordination, and landscaped buffers and medians. The Rainier Avenue South Corridor Improvements - Phase 4 project was previously awarded an FHWA Surface Transportation Program (STP) grant for Design in the amount of $2,600,000 in 2014 and another for Right of Way Acquisition in the amount of $3,000,000 in 2020. EXHIBITS: A. Fuel Tax Grant Agreement B. Funding Status Form STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Authorize the Mayor and City Clerk to execute the Fuel Tax Grant Agreement in the amount of $5,000,000 with the Washington State Transportation Improvement Board and all subsequent amendments to the agreements necessary to accomplish the Rainier Avenue South Corridor Improvements – Phase 4 project. AGENDA ITEM #5. e) AGENDA ITEM #5. e) Washington State Transportation Improvement Board 8-1-102(038)-1 Fuel Tax Grant Agreement Fuel Tax Agreement Page 1 of 5 November 2012 City of Renton 8-1-102(038)-1 Rainier Avenue S/N S 3rd St (SR 900) to NW 3rd Pl STATE OF WASHINGTON TRANSPORTATION IMPROVEMENT BOARD AND City of Renton AGREEMENT THIS GRANT AGREEMENT (hereinafter “Agreement”) for the Rainier Avenue S/N, S 3rd St (SR 900) to NW 3rd Pl (hereinafter “Project”) is entered into by the WASHINGTON STATE TRANSPORTATION IMPROVEMENT BOARD (hereinafter “TIB”) and City of Renton, a political subdivision of the State of Washington (hereinafter “RECIPIENT”). 1.0 PURPOSE For the project specified above, TIB shall pay 19.3940 percent of approved eligible project costs up to the amount of $5,000,000, pursuant to terms contained in the RECIPIENT’S Grant Application, supporting documentation, chapter 47.26 RCW, title 479 WAC, and the terms and conditions listed below. 2.0 SCOPE AND BUDGET The Project Scope and Budget are initially described in RECIPIENT’s Grant Application and incorporated by reference into this Agreement. Scope and Budget will be further developed and refined, but not substantially altered during the Design, Bid Authorization and Construction Phases. Any material alterations to the original Project Scope or Budget as initially described in the Grant Application must be authorized by TIB in advance by written amendment. 3.0 PROJECT DOCUMENTATION TIB requires RECIPIENT to make reasonable progress and submit timely Project documentation as applicable throughout the Project. Upon RECIPIENT’s submission of each Project document to TIB, the terms contained in the document will be incorporated by reference into the Agreement. Required documents include, but are not limited to the following: a) Project Funding Status Form b) Bid Authorization Form with plans and engineers estimate c) Award Updated Cost Estimate d) Bid Tabulations e) Contract Completion Updated Cost Estimate with final summary of quantities f) Project Accounting History 4.0 BILLING AND PAYMENT The local agency shall submit progress billings as project costs are incurred to enable TIB to maintain accurate budgeting and fund management. Payment requests may be submitted as AGENDA ITEM #5. e) Washington State Transportation Improvement Board 8-1-102(038)-1 Fuel Tax Grant Agreement Fuel Tax Agreement Page 2 of 5 November 2012 often as the RECIPIENT deems necessary, but shall be submitted at least quarterly if billable amounts are greater than $50,000. If progress billings are not submitted, large payments may be delayed or scheduled in a payment plan. 5.0 TERM OF AGREEMENT This Agreement shall be effective upon execution by TIB and shall continue through closeout of the grant or until terminated as provided herein, but shall not exceed 10 years unless amended by the Parties. 6.0 AMENDMENTS This Agreement may be amended by mutual agreement of the Parties. Such amendments shall not be binding unless they are in writing and signed by persons authorized to bind each of the Parties. 7.0 ASSIGNMENT The RECIPIENT shall not assign or transfer its rights, benefits, or obligations under this Agreement without the prior written consent of TIB. The RECIPIENT is deemed to consent to assignment of this Agreement by TIB to a successor entity. Such consent shall not constitute a waiver of the RECIPIENT’s other rights under this Agreement. 8.0 GOVERNANCE & VENUE This Agreement shall be construed and interpreted in accordance with the laws of the state of Washington and venue of any action brought hereunder shall be in the Superior Court for Thurston County. 9.0 DEFAULT AND TERMINATION 9.1 NON-COMPLIANCE a) In the event TIB determines, in its sole discretion, the RECIPIENT has failed to comply with the terms and conditions of this Agreement, TIB shall notify the RECIPIENT, in writing, of the non-compliance. b) In response to the notice, RECIPIENT shall provide a written response within 10 business days of receipt of TIB’s notice of non-compliance, which should include either a detailed plan to correct the non-compliance, a request to amend the Project, or a denial accompanied by supporting details. c) TIB will provide 30 days for RECIPIENT to make reasonable progress toward compliance pursuant to its plan to correct or implement its amendment to the Project. d) Should RECIPIENT dispute non-compliance, TIB will investigate the dispute and may withhold further payments or prohibit the RECIPIENT from incurring additional reimbursable costs during the investigation. 9.2 DEFAULT RECIPIENT may be considered in default if TIB determines, in its sole discretion, that: AGENDA ITEM #5. e) Washington State Transportation Improvement Board 8-1-102(038)-1 Fuel Tax Grant Agreement Fuel Tax Agreement Page 3 of 5 November 2012 a) RECIPIENT is not making reasonable progress toward correction and compliance. b) TIB denies the RECIPIENT’s request to amend the Project. c) After investigation TIB confirms RECIPIENT’S non-compliance. TIB reserves the right to order RECIPIENT to immediately stop work on the Project and TIB may stop Project payments until the requested corrections have been made or the Agreement has been terminated. 9.3 TERMINATION a) In the event of default by the RECIPIENT as determined pursuant to Section 9.2, TIB shall serve RECIPIENT with a written notice of termination of this Agreement, which shall be served in person, by email or by certified letter. Upon service of notice of termination, the RECIPIENT shall immediately stop work and/or take such action as may be directed by TIB. b) In the event of default and/or termination by either PARTY, the RECIPIENT may be liable for damages as authorized by law including, but not limited to, repayment of grant funds. c) The rights and remedies of TIB provided in the AGREEMENT are not exclusive and are in addition to any other rights and remedies provided by law. 9.4 TERMINATION FOR NECESSITY TIB may, with ten (10) days written notice, terminate this Agreement, in whole or in part, because funds are no longer available for the purpose of meeting TIB’s obligations. If this Agreement is so terminated, TIB shall be liable only for payment required under this Agreement for performance rendered or costs incurred prior to the effective date of termination. 10.0 USE OF TIB GRANT FUNDS TIB grant funds come from Motor Vehicle Fuel Tax revenue. Any use of these funds for anything other than highway or roadway system improvements is prohibited and shall subject the RECIPIENT to the terms, conditions and remedies set forth in Section 9. If Right of Way is purchased using TIB funds, and some or all of the Right of Way is subsequently sold, proceeds from the sale must be deposited into the RECIPIENT’s motor vehicle fund and used for a motor vehicle purpose. 11.0 INCREASE OR DECREASE IN TIB GRANT FUNDS At Bid Award and Contract Completion, RECIPIENT may request an increase in the maximum payable TIB funds for the specific project. Requests must be made in writing and will be considered by TIB and awarded at the sole discretion of TIB. All increase requests must be made pursuant to WAC 479-05-202 and/or WAC 479-01-060. If an increase is denied, the recipient shall be liable for all costs incurred in excess of the maximum amount payable by TIB. In the event that final costs related to the specific project are less than the initial grant award, TIB funds will be decreased and/or refunded to TIB in a manner that maintains the intended ratio between TIB funds and total project costs, as described in Section 1.0 of this Agreement. AGENDA ITEM #5. e) Washington State Transportation Improvement Board 8-1-102(038)-1 Fuel Tax Grant Agreement Fuel Tax Agreement Page 4 of 5 November 2012 12.0 INDEPENDENT CAPACITY The RECIPIENT shall be deemed an independent contractor for all purposes and the employees of the RECIPIENT or any of its contractors, subcontractors, and employees thereof shall not in any manner be deemed employees of TIB. 13.0 INDEMNIFICATION AND HOLD HARMLESS The PARTIES agree to the following: Each of the PARTIES, shall protect, defend, indemnify, and save harmless the other PARTY, its officers, officials, employees, and agents, while acting within the scope of their employment as such, from any and all costs, claims, judgment, and/or awards of damages, arising out of, or in any way resulting from, that PARTY’s own negligent acts or omissions which may arise in connection with its performance under this Agreement. No PARTY will be required to indemnify, defend, or save harmless the other PARTY if the claim, suit, or action for injuries, death, or damages is caused by the sole negligence of the other PARTY. Where such claims, suits, or actions result from the concurrent negligence of the PARTIES, the indemnity provisions provided herein shall be valid and enforceable only to the extent of a PARTY’s own negligence. Each of the PARTIES agrees that its obligations under this subparagraph extend to any claim, demand and/or cause of action brought by, or on behalf of, any of its employees or agents. For this purpose, each of the PARTIES, by mutual negotiation, hereby waives, with respect to the other PARTY only, any immunity that would otherwise be available to it against such claims under the Industrial Insurance provision of Title 51 RCW. In any action to enforce the provisions of the Section, the prevailing PARTY shall be entitled to recover its reasonable attorney’s fees and costs incurred from the other PARTY. The obligations of this Section shall survive termination of this Agreement. 14.0 DISPUTE RESOLUTION a) The PARTIES shall make good faith efforts to quickly and collaboratively resolve any dispute arising under or in connection with this AGREEMENT. The dispute resolution process outlined in this Section applies to disputes arising under or in connection with the terms of this AGREEMENT. b) Informal Resolution. The PARTIES shall use their best efforts to resolve disputes promptly and at the lowest organizational level. c) In the event that the PARTIES are unable to resolve the dispute, the PARTIES shall submit the matter to non-binding mediation facilitated by a mutually agreed upon mediator. The PARTIES shall share equally in the cost of the mediator. d) Each PARTY agrees to compromise to the fullest extent possible in resolving the dispute in order to avoid delays or additional incurred cost to the Project. e) The PARTIES agree that they shall have no right to seek relief in a court of law until and unless the Dispute Resolution process has been exhausted. AGENDA ITEM #5. e) Washington State Transportation Improvement Board 8-1-102(038)-1 Fuel Tax Grant Agreement Fuel Tax Agreement Page 5 of 5 November 2012 15.0 ENTIRE AGREEMENT This Agreement, together with the RECIPIENT’S Grant Application, the provisions of chapter 47.26 Revised Code of Washington, the provisions of title 479 Washington Administrative Code, and TIB Policies, constitutes the entire agreement between the PARTIES and supersedes all previous written or oral agreements between the PARTIES. 16.0 RECORDS MAINTENANCE The RECIPIENT shall maintain books, records, documents, data and other evidence relating to this Agreement and performance of the services described herein, including but not limited to accounting procedures and practices which sufficiently and properly reflect all direct and indirect costs of any nature expended in the performance of this Agreement. RECIPIENT shall retain such records for a period of six years following the date of final payment. At no additional cost, these records, including materials generated under the Agreement shall be subject at all reasonable times to inspection, review or audit by TIB personnel duly authorized by TIB, the Office of the State Auditor, and federal and state officials so authorized by law, regulation or agreement. If any litigation, claim or audit is started before the expiration of the six (6) year period, the records shall be retained until all litigation, claims, or audit findings involving the records have been resolved. Approved as to Form Attorney General By: Signature on file Guy Bowman Assistant Attorney General Lead Agency Transportation Improvement Board Armondo Pavone, Mayor Date Executive Director Date Print Name Print Name AGENDA ITEM #5. e) bla Attest _____________________________ Jason A. Seth City Clerk Approved as to Legal Form By: __________________________ Shane Maloney City Attorney clb 2-2-2022 (1883) nk AGENDA ITEM #5. e) Transportation Improvement Board Project Funding Status Form TIB Funding Status Report Agency Name RENTON TIB Project Number: 8-1-102(038)-1 Project Name:Rainier Avenue S/N S 3rd St (SR 900) to NW 3rd Pl Verify the information below and revise if necessary. Return to: Transportation Improvement Board ● PO Box 40901 ● Olympia, WA 98504-0901 PROJECT SCHEDULE Target Dates Construction Approval Contract Bid Award Contract Completion 05/15/2022 09/15/2022 09/30/2024 PROJECT FUNDING PARTNERS List additional funding partners and amount. Funding Partners Amount Revised Funding RENTON 9,327,314 WSDOT Regional Mobility – 4A 2,000,000 PSRC STP Construction – 4A 4,500,000 PSRC STP Construction - 4B 4,793,000 TOTAL LOCAL FUNDS 20,620,314 Signatures are required from two different agency officials. Return the originally signed form to the TIB office. Mayor or Public Works Director Signature Date Mayor Armondo Pavone Mayor Printed or Typed Name Title Financial Officer Signature Date Kari Roller Finance Administrator Printed or Typed Name Title AGENDA ITEM #5. e) 1  CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON     RESOLUTION NO.______    A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON, ADOPTING THE CITY OF  RENTON URBAN FOREST MANAGEMENT PLAN 2022‐2032.    WHEREAS, the Growth Management Act encourages planning for open space and  recreational needs of a community to be integrated with planning for other needs; and  WHEREAS, the City of Renton Urban Forest Management Plan 2022‐2032 (the “Plan”) is  compatible with the intent of the City's adopted Comprehensive Plan; and  WHEREAS, the City began the update process for the Plan in April of 2021; and  WHEREAS, the Plan has been developed with extensive community outreach in  conjunction with residents, property owners, stakeholders, local businesses, community  partners, public and private agencies and institutions, and non‐profit organizations; and  WHEREAS, urban forests provide environmental benefits, opportunities for  recreation, community connections, natural resources and habitat, offering places for quiet  reflection, and experiencing nature; and  WHEREAS, the Plan is a comprehensive update of the 2009 Urban and Community  Forestry Development Plan and therefore supersedes and replaces the 2009 plan. It represents  a collaborative effort between the Parks and Recreation and Community and Economic  Development Departments with support from all City departments, and reflects the public's  desire to provide the opportunity for the community to connect to, participate in, support, and  encourage a healthy environment and active lifestyle; and  WHEREAS, the Plan creates a 10 year vision for trees on public property in the City of  Renton – the urban forest; describes current and future needs; and identifies policies,  AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) RESOLUTION NO. ________ 2  implementation strategies, and a maintenance program to enhance and sustain trees as a  critical piece of green infrastructure for a livable community; and  WHEREAS, updating and adopting the Plan maintains the City's status as an Arbor  Day Foundation ‘Tree City USA;’ and  WHEREAS, the Plan was developed in conjunction with citizen feedback and a  collaborative team; and  WHEREAS, this matter was duly referred to the Parks Commission, Planning Commission,  and Planning & Development Committee for investigation, study, and review; and  WHEREAS, the Planning Commission held a public hearing on December 1, 2021,  considered all relevant matters, and heard all parties in support or opposition, and  subsequently forwarded a recommendation to the City Council; and  WHEREAS, the Plan was subject to a State Environmental Procedure Act (SEPA)  review pursuant to Chapter 43.21C RCW and successfully passed a Washington State  Department of Commerce 60‐day review;  NOW THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON, DO RESOLVE  AS FOLLOWS:  SECTION I. The City Council hereby adopts the Plan, attached hereto as Exhibit A and  incorporated by this reference, and directs the Administration to draw up a work program  to begin implementing the Plan. The Plan shall remain in full force and effect until further  revised, amended, and modified as provided by law.  AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) RESOLUTION NO. ________ 3  PASSED BY THE CITY COUNCIL this ______ day of _____________________, 2022.  ______________________________  Jason A. Seth, City Clerk  APPROVED BY THE MAYOR this ______ day of _____________________, 2022.  ______________________________  Armondo Pavone, Mayor  Approved as to form:  ______________________________  Shane Moloney, City Attorney  RES‐P&R:1901:2/7/2022  AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) RESOLUTION NO. ________ 4            EXHIBIT A    CITY OF RENTON   URBAN FOREST MANAGEMENT PLAN 2022‐2032  AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON Urban Forest Management Plan 2022-2032 AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) This page intentionally left blank AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This project was made possible thanks to the support and contributions of the following City of Renton Staff and Officials: Mayor Armondo Pavone Chief Administrative Officer Ed VanValey City Council Ryan McIrvin, City Council President James Alberson Valerie O’Halloran Ruth Pérez Edward Prince Carmen Rivera Kim-Khánh Văn Judith Subia, City Council Liaison Parks Commission Shun Takano, Chair Cynthia Burns Al Dieckman Larry Reymann Timothy J. Searing Troy Wigestrand Marlene Winter Planning Commission Shannon Matson, Chair Charles Seil, Vice Chair Josephine Bayan, Secretary Dana Rochex David Fleetwood James Alberson Kevin Poole Mara Fiksdal Sunayana Kannur Executive Services (ES) Maryjane Van Cleave, Communications & Engagement Director David Neubert, Communications Manager Sheila Cowley, Communications Specialist 1 City Attorney Shane Moloney Community & Economic Development (CED) Chip Vincent, Administrator Angie Mathias, Long Range Planning Manager Human Resources & Risk Management (HR&RM) Ellen Bradley-Mak, Administrator Parks and Recreation (PR) Kelly Beymer, Administrator Erica Schmitz, Parks Planning and Natural Resources Director Ian Gray, Urban Forestry & Natural Resources Manager Public Works (PW) Martin Pastucha, Administrator Collaborative Team Members Angelea Weihs, Associate Planner (CED Planning Division) Cailín Hunsaker, Parks & Trails Director (PR Parks & Trails Division ) Drey Hicks, Neighborhood Program Coordinator (ES Communications & Engagement Division ) Gary Del Rosario, GIS Analyst 2 (ES Information Technology Division ) Joseph Farah, Utility Engineering Manager (PW Utilities Division ) Kelsey Urban, Risk Manager (HR&RM) Patrick Zellner, Street Maintenance Manager (PW Maintenance Service s Division) Vanessa Dolbee, Plan ning Director (CED Planning Division) Vangie Garcia, Transportation Planning Manager (PW Transportation Engineering Division) This Plan was produced by PlanIT Geo, Inc. (PlanIT Geo) and Peninsula Environmental Group in collaboration with the City’s Urban Forestry & Natural Resources Manager, Ian Gray, and the Collaborative Team. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON URBAN FOREST MANAGEMENT PLAN 10-YEAR UPDATE January 2022 AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA Urban Forest Management Plan 10-year Update Jan2022 i | P a g e TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Summary .............................................................................................................................................. I Introduction ........................................................................................................................................................... 4 Benefits of the Urban Forest ............................................................................................................................ 5 Historical Background ........................................................................................................................................ 9 Current State of Renton’s Urban Forest ...................................................................................................... 13 Urban Tree Canopy Cover ......................................................................................................................................................... 15 Urban Tree Canopy Cover Change ..................................................................................................................................... 18 Urban Tree Equity ......................................................................................................................................................................... 20 Structure of the Public Tree Population ........................................................................................................................ 24 Public Tree Population Size Class Distribution (Relative Age) ....................................................................... 28 Value and Benefits of the Public Tree Population................................................................................................. 30 Renton’s Urban Forestry Program ............................................................................................................... 34 Current Urban Forest Management Challenges ..................................................................................... 35 Programs Managing Renton’s Urban Forest ............................................................................................ 39 Program Organization ................................................................................................................................................................ 39 Interdepartmental Management of Trees ................................................................................................................... 39 Parks Planning and Natural Resources Urban Forestry Program ............................................................... 40 Urban Forest Benchmark Comparisons ........................................................................................................................ 44 Urban Forest Audit ........................................................................................................................................................................ 47 Program Needs .................................................................................................................................................... 49 Public Tree Maintenance ......................................................................................................................................................... 49 Urban Forestry Program Staffing to Support Sustainable Management .............................................. 57 Workflows and Standard Operating Procedures .................................................................................................... 62 Tree Canopy Cover Goals .......................................................................................................................................................... 64 Tree Planting Initiative ............................................................................................................................................................... 75 Post-Planting Care and Young Tree Maintenance ................................................................................................ 80 Funding Mechanisms ................................................................................................................................................................ 86 Community Engagement ........................................................................................................................................................ 93 Urban Forestry Goals, Objectives, and Strategies ................................................................................ 103 Goals, Objectives, and Strategies ...................................................................................................................................... 104 Key Strategies ................................................................................................................................................................................. 107 Evaluation ........................................................................................................................................................... 108 Implementation Schedule .............................................................................................................................. 111 Summary and Conclusion .............................................................................................................................. 112 Appendices ............................................................................................................................................................. A Appendix A. Implementation Schedule.......................................................................................................................... B Appendix B. Solutions Workbook and Possible Guidelines for Tree and Sidewalk Conflicts ..... F Appendix C. Guidance to Develop a Tree Advisory Committee ..................................................................... Q Appendix D. 2021 Urban Forest Audit System Results ........................................................................................... T Appendix E. Risk Tree Management Plan ................................................................................................................... EE Appendix F. Urban Forest Pest Ready Assessment ............................................................................................. QQ Appendix G. References ........................................................................................................................................................... VV AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA Urban Forest Management Plan 10-year Update Jan2022 ii | P a g e TABLES AND FIGURES TABLES Table 1. Distribution of public trees by Site Design ............................................................................................................................. 24 Table 2. Public tree genera diversity (top 10) ........................................................................................................................................... 25 Table 3. Public tree species diversity (top 10)........................................................................................................................................... 26 Table 4. Summary of Renton’s tree size distribution compared to the ideal distribution ..................................... 29 Table 5. Summary of ecosystem services, benefits, and values of Renton's public trees ...................................... 30 Table 6. Summary of the annual benefits provided by Renton’s public trees* .............................................................. 32 Table 7. Summary of the benefits and services of trees in natural areas ............................................................................ 33 Table 8. Annual investments in the management of street and park trees ...................................................................... 41 Table 9. Summary of the 2022 budget for the Urban Forestry Program’s Administration* ................................. 42 Table 10. Arbor Day Foundation Tree City USA communities examined during the benchmarking… ......... 45 Table 11. Summary of phase 1 benchmarking research results (Tree City USA dataset) .......................................... 46 Table 12. Summary of phase 2 benchmarking research results (2014 Census, Hauer et al.) ................................. 46 Table 13. Outcomes of the urban forest auditing process for Renton, WA ........................................................................ 47 Table 14. Public tree maintenance needs by Site Design based on an analysis of August 2021… .................... 50 Table 15. Current and recommended maintenance regimen for Renton’s public tree population… ........... 53 Table 16. Assumptions for estimating the additional costs to effectively maintain the public tree… ............ 53 Table 17. Recommended streets for priority tree maintenance by Community Planning Area ...................... 56 Table 18. Estimated staff and associated costs to maintain public trees on a 7 -year rotation .......................... 59 Table 19. Summary of costs .................................................................................................................................................................................. 59 Table 20. Comparison of in-house and contracted pruning for a 7-year public tree pruning cycle ............. 60 Table 21. Summary of the current and future Urban Forestry Program services and budgets ........................... 61 Table 22. Long-term tree canopy goals (by 2042) and planting targets by Community Planning Area ..... 67 Table 23. Summary of the recommended tree canopy goals and planting targets for Renton ....................... 74 Table 24. Parcel tax options and provisions for Renton's Urban Forestry Program ................................................... 89 Table 25. Summary of financing options for Renton’s urban forest ........................................................................................ 91 Table 26. Renton’s urban forest benchmark values ........................................................................................................................ 109 Table 27. Evaluation, monitoring, and reporting techniques to achieve the urban forestry goals ................ 110 Table 28. Description of possible alternative solutions for tree and construction conflicts .................................. M Table 29. Urban Forest Pest Ready Assessment from the WA State Urban Forest Pest Readiness… ...........QQ AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA Urban Forest Management Plan 10-year Update Jan2022 iii | P a g e FIGURES Figure 1. Framework of the Urban Forest Management Plan ......................................................................................................... 2 Figure 2. Overview of the ecosystem benefits and services provided by trees in communities … ........................ 5 Figure 3. The street tree pictured adds $7,593 to the price of the house it fronts and $7,098 to th e… ........... 7 Figure 4. Depiction of the various types of landscapes that comprise Renton's urban forest ............................. 14 Figure 5. Maintenance responsibility of trees comprising Renton's urban forest ......................................................... 15 Figure 6. Renton’s 2018 Tree Canopy Assessment results ............................................................................................................... 15 Figure 7. Map displaying Renton's tree canopy and vegetative area for possible tree plantings (2018) ...... 16 Figure 8. Existing tree canopy cover by Community Planning Area ....................................................................................... 17 Figure 9. Existing tree canopy cover by Zoning Type (consolidated classifications) ................................................... 17 Figure 10. Citywide tree canopy cover change ........................................................................................................................................ 18 Figure 11. Tree canopy cover change by Community Planning Area....................................................................................... 18 Figure 12. Tree canopy cover change by Zoning Type (conso lidated classifications).................................................. 18 Figure 13. Example of canopy cover differences in two Renton neighborhoods ......................................................... 20 Figure 14. Map displaying the Tree Equity Scores by Census Block Groups in Renton… ........................................... 21 Figure 15. Comparison of Tree Equity Scores for cities near Renton, WA ........................................................................... 22 Figure 16. Count of Census Block Groups for each Tree Equity Score range .................................................................... 22 Figure 17. Public tree genera diversity ........................................................................................................................................................... 25 Figure 18. Public tree species diversity .......................................................................................................................................................... 26 Figure 19. Leaf profiles of the most common public trees (not to scale)............................................................................. 26 Figure 20. Distribution by Diameter (DBH) class within site design classifications .................................................... 28 Figure 21. Distribution of public trees by diameter (DBH) class compared to the ideal distribution............. 28 Figure 22. Illustration of the benefits and services provided by public trees ................................................................... 32 Figure 23. Structure of Renton's Urban Forestry Program ............................................................................................................. 39 Figure 24. a) Relationship between pruning cycle length and condition class rating… ............................................ 51 Figure 25. As the years between street tree pruning increases, tree health and safety decrease … ................. 52 Figure 26. Recommended priority tree maintenance by street corridor and planning area ..............................55 Figure 27. Renton's 10-year and 20-year canopy goals .................................................................................................................... 66 Figure 28. Map displaying the Possible Planting Area by Community Planning Area and an … ........................ 67 Figure 29. Map displaying the Census Block Groups most suitable for trees due to high possibl e…area . 69 Figure 30. Map displaying the Census Block Groups with the lowest existing tree canopy cover ................. 70 Figure 31. Map displaying Census Block Groups most suitable for tree plantings to address …runoff ............ 71 Figure 32. Map displaying higher concentrations of minority populations for increasing tree…cover ......... 72 Figure 33. Map displaying Census Block Groups with underserved populations for increasing…canopy. . 73 Figure 34. Examples of the types of tree pruning ................................................................................................................................. 82 Figure 35. Types of pruning cuts and the proper branch cutting technique .................................................................. 82 Figure 36. Example of trees directionally pruned for clea rance from power lines ..................................................... 83 Figure 37. Example of branches to be pruned for newly planted trees to promote good structure ............. 84 Figure 38. Renton's Urban Forest Management Plan project website (RentonForestryPlan.com) ................. 93 Figure 39. Infographic summarizing the first public surve y ......................................................................................................... 94 Figure 40. Infographic summarizing the second public survey ................................................................................................ 94 Figure 41. Story maps can visualize urban forest stories, maps, and data for the public ........................................ 97 Figure 42. Example of the plan implementation, evaluation , and revision process ................................................... 111 Figure 43. Proposed decision matrix for tree and construction conflicts .............................................................................. F Figure 44. Example of alternative solutions for tree and construction conflicts ............................................................. O AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Tables and FIgures iv | P a g e This page intentionally left blank AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA Urban Forest Management Plan 10-year Update Jan2022 0 | P a g e DEFINING THE URBAN FOREST "Urban forestry can be defined as the art, science, and technology of managing trees and forest resources in and around community ecosystems for the physiological, sociological, economic, and aesthetic benefits trees provide to society." Helms, 1998 Any inhabited area that has trees and vegetation is considered an urban forest. Renton’s Urban Forest Management Plan focuses on the City-owned trees in public rights-of-way, natural areas, and parks, but also has implications for the trees on private property and attention to these are addressed through community outreach and education efforts. The concept of urban and community forest management developed in the 1960s out of the death and devastation of the elm tree population throughout the United States due to Dutch Elm disease. The discipline of urban forestry strongly advocates for species and age diversity in a city’s tree population so that the elm tree devastation of the 1960s does not happen again. Unfortunately, native and invasive pests and diseases continue to spread. During the last three decades, urban forestry has evolved as researchers and practitioners learn more about the structure and function of trees and their unique role in providing environmental, economic, and social benefits to urban areas. Urban forestry provides each of these benefits in differing circumstances as infrastructure, as part of design and development, and as efficient and productive providers of economic development. In fact, there are very few areas of urban management and its various departments that aren’t affected and benefited by the urban forest. Residents traditionally have indicated that they consider the trees in the community a priority. In urban environments, street and park trees are sometimes the only day-to-day interaction with nature that many residents may enjoy. As Renton continues to grow, the urban forest needs a strong advocate. This will happen with the education and support of the City’s constituency, staff, and elected officials via an approved Urban Forest Management Plan. The urban forest is unique in the array of benefits it provides to the community, and a plan will effectively collect and showcase these values. While a plan is useful in helping educate and ensure future viability, it also will set up useful parameters for the daily operations and care of the urban forest. A fresh look at all urban forestry-related policies currently in place will bring into focus what is necessary for day-to-day activities to ensure long-term viability and safety of the urban forest. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA Urban Forest Management Plan 10-year Update Jan2022 1 | P a g e This page intentionally left blank AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Defining the Urban Forest 2 | P a g e URBAN FOREST MANAGEMENT PLAN EXECUTIVE SUMMARY AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA Urban Forest Management Plan 10-year Update Jan2022 I | P a g e EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The City of Renton is dedicated to building a thriving urban forest for a healthy and vibrant place to live, work, and play. The nearly 117,000 City street, park, and natural area trees throughout Renton are an asset that bring value and benefits to the community. Furthermore, trees on private property provide added benefits. Together, these public and private trees constitute an “urban forest”. This resource provides environmental benefits, adds to property values, and contributes to an enhanced quality of life for all of Renton’s residents. Realizing the urban forest is a valued asset, the City of Renton’s Community Services Department at the time, led by the Urban Forestry & Natural Resources team, invested in a collaborative planning process to update its 2009 Urban Forest Management Plan to provide the framework for the Urban Forestry Program over the next 10 years. This Plan will serve as a road map to support the long-term dedication to maintain and enhance the urban forest. The Plan will provide an integrated approach to preserving, sustaining, diversifying, and regenerating Renton’s urban forest into the future. By conducting an in-depth review of existing City codes, policies, and plans regarding the urban forest as well as gathering input from the community, the goals, objectives, strategies, actions, and monitoring techniques will be developed for urban forest management Citywide. Participation from the community is instrumental to the development of this Plan. This forward-looking plan provides mission and vision statements, goals, and objectives. It builds upon foundations in the Renton Comprehensive Plan, the Parks, Recreation and Natural Areas Plan, Business Plans, and neighborhood plans. The aim is to ensure the safety, well-being, and economic future of Renton’s citizens, as well as preserving the sustainability of the urban forest. The Urban Forest Management Plan proposes steps to protect trees, forestry assets (which are actual City assets), and the health of Renton’s citizens through urban forestry services. Criteria for prioritizing resources to achieve best value and best management practice have been used in the development of the listed improvements with short-term, medium-term, and long-term timeframes. For Renton to remain “ahead of the curve” the City must proactively engage in planning for regular planting of new trees and maintaining existing trees that is guided by the urban forest vision and tree canopy cover goals. The City of Renton Urban Forestry Program is dedicated to this vital resource and implementation of the Urban Forest Management Plan in an effort to sustain and enhance it for all neighborhoods and future generations. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Planning Approach II | P a g e PLANNING APPROACH The purpose of the 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan is to answer the fundamental components of adaptive management: what do we have, what do we want, how do we get what we want, and how are we doing. Developing the Plan required input from City staff, stakeholders, residents, data sources, thoughtful analysis, a coordinated vision, and time. What do we have? The first step of the process is to complete a baseline assessment of the urban forest, the resources to manage it, and the people that influence and benefit from it. The six elements completed in planning process provide the foundation for setting goals and measuring progress. What do we want? The Plan is shaped by knowing what the urban forest needs, the resources required to manage it, and what the community wants. This was informed by public engagement through websites and social media, public surveys, presentations, staff interviews, and development of the urban forest vision and supporting goals. How to get what we want? The goal, action, and target framework lay out the road map to achieve a shared vision that supports the needs of all members of the community. Actions are strategic, measurable, attainable, realistic, and time-bound (SMART) and have been developed through extensive research, data analyses, stakeholder consultations, community engagement, benchmarking research, and gap analyses during the planning process. How are we doing? The City needs to continually monitor progress towards the vision and goals. The Urban Forest Management Plan includes guidance for implementing actions. The planning approach for this Plan provides the framework for continual monitoring and evaluation of efforts using the U.S. Forest Service’s Urban Forest Audit System. Updates to this audit will inform any necessary changes to strategies in an adaptive management approach. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA Urban Forest Management Plan 10-year Update Jan2022 III | P a g e KEY FINDINGS STATE OF THE URBAN FOREST ❖ 27,456 public street, park, or Maplewood Golf Course trees ❖ 89,528 natural area trees ❖ 116,984 total public trees ❖ 29.3% canopy (up 0.6% from 2010) ❖ Tree Equity Score of 83 out of 100 ❖ 90 unique genera, Acer most common (27%) ❖ 281 unique species, bigleaf maple most common (15%) ❖ Public trees provide $220,000 in annual ecosystem benefits and services ❖ Public trees have a replacement value of $122.6 million THE URBAN FORESTRY PROGRAM ❖ Parks and Recreation Department’s Parks Planning and Natural Resources Division ❖ 2.50 full-time employees (2021) ❖ 48% of public trees are in fair condition (2021) ❖ 22% of street trees need clearance pruning, 19% need structural pruning (2021) ❖ $8.13 budget per public tree (2021) ❖ 1.15 public trees per capita (2021) ❖ Urban Forest Audit: 65% overall ❖ Challenges include sustainable management, program efficiencies, risk tree management, and tree policies/regulations/enforcement ❖ A 7-year pruning cycle requires 3,922 trees pruned per year at a cost of approximately $706,011 annually ❖ Initial cost of an in-house arborist crew and fleet is $581,780 with an annual cost of $270,698 ❖ Tree Planting Initiative recommends 30% canopy by 2032 (5,250 total trees) and 33% by 2042 (18,852 total trees). 60% of plantings should be City-led or approximately 315 trees per year for the 30% canopy goal and 570 trees per year for the 33% canopy goal. COMMUNITY VIEWPOINTS AND PRIORITIES ❖ 38% feel the health of the urban forest has declined in the last 10 years ❖ 44% support increasing overall funding to the Urban Forestry Program for tree planting and maintenance initiatives ❖ 8% support increasing the funding to the Urban Forestry Program for tree planting and maintenance initiatives by redistributing the current program funding ❖ 47% support the additional funding be used for proactive street tree pruning AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Key Findings IV | P a g e URBAN FOREST MANAGEMENT GOALS AND OBJECTIVES GOAL 1: Proactively manage public trees, continue to grow and expand a healthy canopy, maintain public safety, and optimize urban forest benefits. Objectives 1.1 Make data-driven management decisions. 1.2 Sustainably manage the public tree population. 1.3 Establish a strategy for increasing tree canopy cover through City and public efforts. 1.4 Effectively manage tree risk. GOAL 2: Achieve environmental justice through a partnership with the City and its residents to improve well-being, human health, local economies, and urban forest sustainability. Objectives 2.1 Create an urban forestry public outreach program that addresses all communities. 2.2 Increase capacity through trained citizens. GOAL 3: Strengthen policies for preserving the environmental benefits, management, and the character of Renton's urban forest. Objectives 3.1 Strengthen policies for protecting the urban forest. 3.2 Improve workflows and operations for sustainable urban forest management. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA Urban Forest Management Plan 10-year Update Jan2022 V | P a g e URBAN FOREST MANAGEMENT PLAN FRAMEWORK VISION Renton’s urban and community forest will be healthy, diverse, and sustainable, reinforcing the City’s strong commitment to community trees. This strong commitment to trees will benefit the well-being of Renton’s residents and set an example for other Urban Forestry programs in the region. GUIDING PRINCIPLES ❖ Recognize that the trees of the urban forest are more than aesthetic enhancements. ❖ Recognize trees as the backbone of the urban ecosystem and an essential part of the community’s green infrastructure. ❖ Promote the health and growth of the urban forest by following scientifically established best management practices for tree selection, planting, watering, and pruning. ❖ Promote a robust urban forest through policies and practices that reduce its vulnerability to known diseases or pest infestations, and future threats, including the anticipated effects of climate change. ❖ Engage in a continuous process of long- range planning for the growth and maintenance of the urban forest. ❖ Promote public appreciation of the urban forest through educational outreach programs. ❖ Support local businesses, institutions, organizations, and individuals in their efforts to grow and maintain the urban forest through community education. ❖ Proceed in a manner that is inclusive and transparent. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Call to Action VI | P a g e CALL TO ACTION The urban forest is an important green infrastructure asset for neighborhoods across Renton. However, the capacity of urban forests to support healthy and resilient communities is constrained and challenged by stressors such as climate change impacts, urban development pressures, altered soils, invasive species, and resource shortages. Now more than ever there is a critical need to sustain large, healthy, genetically appropriate trees and shrubs on public and private land through long-term planning and budgeting, inclusive decision-making, and strategic policy development that supports adaptive management. Thus, comprehensive urban forest support must extend well beyond tree planting initiatives. Management of Renton’s urban forest should be a shared priority among its citizens, community groups, institutions, and City departments. All of these groups have important roles to play. Successful management frameworks must recognize that the urban forest is part of a complex system that includes the built environment and is influenced by human activities and policies and practices that shape Renton. Furthermore, decision-making must be made in the context of future uncertainty associated with climate change. With this understanding, along with the input from staff and residents of Renton, the following priority strategies for implementing the City’s Urban Forest Management Plan were developed: KEY STRATEGIES The planning process identified 22 strategies following development of the program goals and objectives. Five strategies were identified as being of higher priority that will position Renton as a leader in urban forestry across the state and perhaps the nation and will guid e the City towards a sustainable urban forest than others. 7-Year Pruning Cycle Program One of the more critical strategies identified was the need for an improved public tree pruning program on a recommended 7-year rotation. The strategy requires additional funding and the creation of an in-house arborist crew. Feedback from the community and City staff expressed support for the structure of this strategy. Tree Planting Initiative To grow an urban forest that is sustainable and resilient to climate change, pests and diseases, and urban development pressures, a strategic planting initiative guided by short- and long-term canopy goals and planting targets are needed. The Plan contains the guidance for finalizing canopy goals, identifying priority planting areas, and developing the tree planting initiative. Tree Stewards Program A shared commitment to the urban forest and vision is essential to the long-term success and impact of the Plan. A community of tree stewards will increase Urban Forestry Program capacity and support the Tree Planting Initiative along with other programs and services. No-Net-Loss Perhaps more important than tree canopy cover goals and planting initiatives is the foundation of sound policies to preserve the existing urban forest. With this key strategy, tree replacement, retention, removal, mitigation, and enforcement protocols are solidified. In addition, alternative solutions to tree and sidewalk conflicts are explored and guidance for formally adopting a decision checklist and solutions toolkit is provided. Enforce Tree Regulations Throughout the planning effort, concerns were expressed and identified relating to the protection of trees from construction damage, illegal removals, maintenance malpractice. The actions supporting this strategy expand the enforcement efforts by increasing capacity as well as community education to prevent instances from occurring in the first place. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA Urban Forest Management Plan 10-year Update Jan2022 VII | P a g e RENTON’S URBAN FOREST MANAGEMENT PLAN -2022-2032- VISION Renton’s urban and community forest will be healthy, diverse, and sustainable, reinforcing the City’s strong commitment to community trees. This strong commitment to trees will benefit the well-being of Renton’s residents and set an example for other Urban Forestry programs in the region. MISSION The City of Renton will grow a thriving urban forest through strategic management, diverse partnerships, and a strong commitment to protect and enhance the community’s natural resources. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA Urban Forest Management Plan 10-year Update Jan2022 1 | P a g e PLAN PURPOSE AND FRAMEWORK The main tenets of this Plan focus on ensuring public safety, increasing operational efficiencies, facilitating short- and long-term sustainable urban forest planning, validating budgets and programs, ensuring equitable distribution of green resources and services, and standardizing methodology for asset management of the urban forest. The planning process consisted of two phases; the needs assessment conducted as part of the planning process and the development of goals, objectives, and strategies in the Urban Forest Management Plan. The first phase establishes a baseline from which short- and long-term strategies can be developed and monitored over time. The needs of the urban forest and the programs that manage it were evaluated through an audit of existing conditions and operations to establish a baseline for measuring progress. This diligent approach to Renton’s urban forest management gauges the City’s readiness and available resources to achieve optimal levels of urban forest management and sustainability. Through this iterative approach, a comprehensive understanding was gathered of the urban forest, the programs that manage it, and the community that benefits from and shapes it to inform strategic goals and actions. In adhering to best management practice as framed by the eight guiding principles listed on page ‘V’, the urban forest stands a chance of being a sustainable and resilient resource. This will require an integrated ecosystem management approach. That system is based on the recognition that the urban forest is a resource which should be viewed as a tangible asset which confers broad benefits to all citizens of the City of Renton and compliments the biodiversity values of the surrounding natural environment. Urban forests face unprecedented challenges in a warming environment with ever expanding development needs. In order to preserve the urban forest and the myriad benefits conferred, the residents of Renton will need to be vigilant and remain committed to sound environmental standards which will ensure that generations to come will enjoy the same. If Renton is to be a leader and environmental champion, the stewardship of its green infrastructure and the fundamental role played by trees in that ecology is paramount. This ten-year Urban Forest Management Plan is an important piece of that larger mission. All community stakeholders should be involved in bringing this to fruition and safeguarding the future of trees in our neighborhoods. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Plan Purpose and Framework 2 | P a g e PLANNING APPROACH The systematic evaluation of the City of Renton’s urban forest management processes, resources, staffing, structure, and policies was conducted by completing the six planning elements: 1) Existing Policies and Plans, 2) City Workflows and Operations, 3) Baseline Conditions, 4) Urban Forest Benchmarks, 5) Community Engagement, and 6) Urban Forest Audit System. The City’s project team evaluated the outcomes and findings of these planning elements and the urban forestry consultants revised these based on feedback to provide a comprehensive analysis that informs the baseline assessment and recommendations for the Urban Forest Management Plan. Figure 1. Framework of the Urban Forest Management Plan PLANNING ELEMENTS PRIMARY PLANNING FRAMEWORK OUTCOMES EXISTING POLICIES AND PLANS GOALS CITY WORKFLOWS AND OPERATIONS BASELINE CONDITIONS OBJECTIVES URBAN FOREST BENCHMARKS COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT STRATEGIES URBAN FOREST AUDIT SYSTEM PRIMARY FRAMEWORK Understanding the benefits and functions of the urban forest, the City has developed this Urban Forest Management Plan. “Without a plan, the governments and individuals responsible for taking care of an urban forest will not be effective in meeting the tru e needs of the trees and the community. A plan establishes a clear set of priorities and objectives related to the goal of maintaining a productive and beneficial community forest.” │ American Public Works Association, 2007 The optimal approach to managing an urban forest is to develop an organized, proactive program using information to set goals and measure progress. This information can be utilized to establish priorities, plan strategically, draft cost-effective budgets, and ultimately minimize the need for costly, reactive solutions to crises or urgent risk mitigation. Based on the results of the research, incremental steps to achieve these improvements were developed that can be applied as the City continues to progress. ACHIEVE THE URBAN FOREST VISION AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA Urban Forest Management Plan 10-year Update Jan2022 3 | P a g e The goals of the Urban Forest Management Plan focus on preserving, maintaining, and enhancing the urban forest to ultimately benefit the residents of Renton. The framework for this Plan supports the urban forestry vision: Renton’s urban and community forest will be healthy, diverse, and sustainable, reinforcing the City’s strong commitment to community trees. This strong commitment to trees will benefit the well-being of Renton’s residents and set an example for other Urban Forestry programs in the region. Goals Goals supporting the urban forest vision are provided based on strengths and opportunities identified during the planning process. Each goal is supported by objectives and strategies the City and partners will use to attain the goal. Objectives Objectives define the steps to attain the identified goals. Strategies Strategies and actions are specific, measurable, attainable, realistic, and time-bound. Recommendations As information and findings are detailed in each of the Plan’s sections, a discussion of recommendations is included to support the goals, objectives, and strategies. Evaluation Using the Urban Forest Audit System and the Implementation Schedule, progress and success can be evaluated and annually reported. The evaluation using the audit provides the information necessary for adaptive management. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Introduction 4 | P a g e INTRODUCTION A healthy urban forest supports the City of Renton’s goals of balancing economic vitality with environmental equity and social well-being by enhancing public green space, increasing city attractiveness and livability, and fostering civic pride. Studies show that trees and other vegetation filter pollutants, increase property values, attract visitors, improve health and promote community unity through events like Arbor Day. The Renton Urban Forest Management Plan (“Plan”) update is the collaborative effort from City departments to create a proactive work plan that guides the City’s urban forestry and natural resource management programs. This Plan builds upon existing programs and establishes the focus and direction for the next 10 years. The state of Renton’s urban forest, from the downtown core to new and existing commercial and residential districts, has been reviewed. Interaction between different City departments in recent years was key to developing appropriate strategies to incorporate the varied priorities affected by trees in the urban landscape. Nearly all departments in the City interact with the Urban Forestry Program, benefit from the urban forest, or are impacted in some way. To ensure the program’s vision and mission statements, various issues and opportunities were reviewed— from public safety to current tree regulations— to accurately capture public concerns with trees and vegetation. The intention of this Plan is to create a road map for the future of the Urban Forestry Program. The previous plan suggested creating an Inter-departmental Team over the course of the 10-year plan. This was never implemented. To realize the maximum benefits afforded by the urban forest and make the community a great place to live, work and play, a more consistent approach is needed. There is a need for continued work on the forestry ordinance. The Plan proposes a new Tree Planting Initiative (TPI) to be more proactive and equitable about replacing trees that are lost and to preserve and enhance tree canopy cover equitably. Best management practices also point to the need for a Tree Risk Plan (TRP) and ideally an in-house arborist crew. Although the urban forest provides a broad range of ecosystem services— direct and indirect benefits provided to the City, its citizens, the region, and the planet— we tend to take the benefits for granted because they are not assigned a dollar value. That is changing and many of the benefits are not only tangible but measurable. Local cities, state, and national sources continue to increasingly find great value in urban forests. Unfortunately, these green assets are often overlooked in the land development process and destroyed for a fraction of their larger economic and ecosystem values. It is critical to bear in mind that long-term management of these natural assets brings a higher return than their elimination or the upfront maintenance costs. The fact is that trees — “green infrastructure”— increase in value over time, unlike gray infrastructure like roads, poles, pipes, and sidewalks. Figure 2 below begins to highlight the benefits of trees in communities, emphasizing the role they play in maintaining community health, well-being, safety, environments, and local economies. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA Urban Forest Management Plan 10-year Update Jan2022 5 | P a g e BENEFITS OF THE URBAN FOREST The quality of life of the citizens in any community depends on the urban forest, as trees make a vital and affordable contribution to the sense of community, pedestrian-friendly neighborhoods, energy savings, and air quality. Trees are one of the few infrastructure investments that grow in value over time. Tree canopy is a valuable component of Renton’s urban ecosystem. Trees in urban settings are important to improving urban life, as well as human physical and emotional well -being. Research suggests that human beings have an innate affiliation to natural settings, a concept described as biophilia (Kellert and Wilson 1993). Studies link access to living trees, outdoor air, and natural light to increased employee and student productivity, faster hospital recoveries, less crime, and an overall reduction in stress and anxiety. Thus, expanding the urban forest is part of the solution to Renton’s social, environmental, and economic problems— it is integral to enhancing public health programs, increasing land values and local tax bases, providing job training and employment opportunities, reducing costs of city services, increasing public safety, improving air quality, offsetting carbon emissions, managing stormwater runoff, mitigating water shortages, and conserving energy. The following data was derived from Alliance for Community Trees.1 11 Alliance for Community Trees. 2011. Benefits of trees and urban forests: A research list. www.actrees.org Figure 2. Overview of the ecosystem benefits and services provided by trees in communities (Source: City of Renton) AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Benefits of the Urban Forest 6 | P a g e REDUCE STRESS AND IMPROVE THE QUALITY OF LIFE Neighborhoods with generous canopies of trees are good for public health. Greater contact with natural environments correlates with lower levels of stress, improving performance. Students’ concentration levels go up when they are able to look out onto a green landscape. Studies show that children with attention deficit disorder function better after activities in green settings. A green environment impacts worker productivity. Workers without views of nature from their desks claimed 23% more sick days than workers with views of nature. Residents of areas with the highest levels of greenery were 3 times as likely to be physically active and 40% less likely to be overweight than residents living in the least green settings. CLEAN THE AIR AND BREATHE EASIER Shade trees reduce pollution and return oxygen to the atmosphere. In addition to carbon dioxide, trees’ leaves or needles absorb pollutants, such as ozone, nitrogen dioxide, sulfur dioxide, and some particulate matter. SAVE ENERGY AND LOWER ENERGY COSTS FOR BUILDINGS As natural screens, trees can insulate homes and businesses from extreme temperatures, keep properties cool, and reduce air conditioning utility bills . A 20% canopy of deciduous trees over a house results in annual cooling savings of 8 to 18 percent and annual heating savings of 2 to 8 percent. By planting shade trees on sunny exposures, residents and businesses can save up to 50% on hot- day energy bills. POSITIVELY INFLUENCE CLIMATE TO ENSURE SUSTAINABILITY Trees absorb carbon dioxide and store carbon in wood, which helps to reduce greenhouse gases. Carbon emissions from vehicles, industries, and power plants are a primary contributor to increased air temperatures in metropolitan areas. Trees in the United States store 700 million tons of carbon valued at $14 billion with an annual carbon sequestration rate of 22.8 million tons per year valued at $460 million annually. REDUCE THE NEED FOR STREET MAINTENANCE Shaded streets last longer and require far less pavement maintenance, reducing long- term costs. Canopy diminishes pavement fatigue, cracking, rutting, and other damage. A study from University of California at Davis found that 20% shade cover on a street improves pavement condition by 11%, which is a 60% savings for resurfacing over 30 years. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA Urban Forest Management Plan 10-year Update Jan2022 7 | P a g e RAISE PROPERTY VALUES Trees are sound investments, for businesses and residents alike, and their value increases as they grow. Sustainable landscapes can increase property values up to 37%. The value of trees appreciates over time, because the benefits grow as they do. For businesses, trees have added value, including higher revenues. Shoppers seek out leafy promenades that frame storefronts. Research shows that shoppers spend more—between 9 and 12 percent more—on products in tree-lined business districts. A study by Donovan & Butry in 2008 shows trees increase value to the home they reside but also contribute to increased property values of adjacent homes and properties. As an additional benefit, increased property values resulting from trees lead to quicker home sales (Wolf 2007). CONSERVE WATER AND SOIL A tree’s fibrous roots, extending into the soil, are premier pollution filtration and soil erosion prevention systems. Intensely urbanized areas are covered with a large number of impermeable surfaces. In contrast to an impervious hardscape, a healthy urban forest can reduce annual stormwater runoff up to 7%. Highly efficient trees also utilize or absorb toxic substances such as lead, zinc, copper, and biological contaminants. One study estimated that eliminating the need for additional local stormwater filtration systems would result in savings exceeding $2 billion. COOLER PAVEMENT DIMINISHES URBAN HEAT ISLANDS Broad canopy trees lower temperatures by shading buildings, asphalt, and concrete. They deflect radiation from the sun and release moisture into the air. The urban heat island effect is the resulting higher temperature of areas dominated by buildings, roads, and sidewalks. Cities are often 5° to 10°F hotter than undeveloped areas, because hot pavement and buildings have replaced cool vegetated land. In addition, high temperatures increase the volatility of automobile oil and oil within the asphalt itself, releasing the fumes into the atmosphere. Shade trees can reduce asphalt temperatures by as much as 36°F, which diminishes the fumes and improves air quality. PROTECT WILDLIFE AND RESTORE ECOSYSTEMS Planting and protecting trees can provide habitat for hundreds of birds and small animals. Urbanization and the destruction of valuable ecosystems have led to the decline of many of species. Adding trees, particularly native trees, provides valuable habitat for wildlife. Figure 3. The street tree pictured adds $7,593 to the price of the house it fronts and $7,098 to the seven houses within 100 feet, giving a total value of $14,691. The dotted line represents the tree’s 100-ft radius sphere of influence. (Donovan & Butry, 2008) AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Benefits of the Urban Forest 8 | P a g e BUILD SAFE COMMUNITIES AND DECREASE CRIME Police and crime prevention experts agree that trees and landscaping cut the incidence of theft, vandalism, and violence by enhancing neighborhoods. Thriving trees on well-maintained streets indicate pride of ownership. Public housing residents with nearby trees and natural landscapes reported 25% fewer acts of domestic aggression and violence. Apartment buildings with high levels of greenery had 52% fewer crimes than those without any trees. Buildings with medium amounts of greenery had 42% fewer crimes. CALM TRAFFIC AND MAKE NEIGHBORHOODS SAFER AND QUIETER People drive more slowly and carefully through tree-lined streets, because trees create the illusion of narrower streets. One study found a 46% decrease in crash rates across urban arterial and highway sites after landscape improvements were installed. The presence of trees in a suburban landscape reduced the cruising speed of drivers by an average of 3 miles per hour. Faster drivers and slower drivers both drove at decreased speeds in the presence of trees. Trees reduce noise pollution, buffering as much as half of urban noise. By absorbing sounds, a belt of trees 100 feet wide and 50 feet tall can reduce highway noise by 6 to 10 decibels. Buffers composed of trees and shrubs can reduce 50% of noise. A comprehensive analysis of the ecosystem services and benefits provided by the trees inventoried in 2020 are provided in the Value and Benefits of the Public Tree Population section. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA Urban Forest Management Plan 10-year Update Jan2022 9 | P a g e HISTORICAL BACKGROUND First was the Forest. The Duwamish were the first people known to inhabit the present-day location of the City of Renton. At that time, dense stands of old -growth trees, including Douglas fir, western red cedar, and western hemlock, blanketed the hills above fertile river valleys. The land was abundant with natural resources. Trees were harvested in limited quantities to build longhouses and large dugout canoes. Lumber and Coal Harvesting. Renton’s first white settler, Henry Tobin, came to this area in 1853 with business interests in lumber. After his neighbor discovered coal the following year, Tobin, Dr. R.H. Bigelow, and two other early settlers formed the Duwamish Coal Company and built a sawmill at the junction of the Cedar and Black Rivers. Timber from the mill was used to shore up coal-mine tunnels. The mill burned during the Indian War of 1855, temporarily halting mining operations. More white settlers arrived in the 1860s and began clearing trees, often by burning, to open land for farming and dairy. New coal seams were discovered in outlying areas and Renton’s rivers provided important shipping connections from Lake Washington to Seattle and beyond. The small settlement near the lake became an important stopover for lodging, food, and supplies. Significant coal discoveries in Renton in the 1870s changed the farming community into a rugged mining town. Active logging operations resumed with the opening of the Parker sawmill. The timber was again used to support mine shafts, but also to construct homes and businesses. The City of Renton is Born. Erasmus Smithers filed the first square-mile plat of the town of Renton in 1875. The town was named in honor of Captain William Renton, the most successful lumber merchant of the time who heavily financed Renton’s early coal industry. The City of Renton incorporated in 1901 with a population of approximately 1,300. Additional transportation improvements and industrial establishments spurred growth throughout the 20th century. The most dramatic growth period occurred with the influx of wartime industry workers at Boeing and PACCAR between 1940 and 1950, when the population rose from 4,500 to over 16,000. Forest clearing continued to make way for the airport, industrial areas, commercial centers, and housing. Urban Forestry’s Early Beginnings in Renton. Early urban forestry in Renton included tree planting funded by various federal grants and maintained by the Public Works Department. No formal maintenance program was in place during the years prior to 1980. Trees were managed and maintained on a reactive, emergency basis. During the early 1980s a Street Tree Committee was formed to address many urban tree issues. They offered recommendations to City Council and developed regulations for planting and maintaining trees. Mature trees in the downtown business district growing in small sidewalk cut-outs resulted in damage to the sidewalks. A street tree ordinance was drafted but never adopted. In 1982, Renton’s Parks Department took over responsibility for trees in the downtown area from Public Works. The Parks Department spearheaded and established a routine vegetation management program that included improved standards for evaluations, street tree pruning, removals, and replacements. In the 1980s and 1990s, tree maintenance reverted to the improper practice of rounding -over trees (a form of topping) to keep large-maturing sizes in scale with buildings and overhangs. Tree removal and sidewalk replacement was an expensive result of trees that became too large in limited planting spaces. Unregulated tree planting in neighborhoods was customary. Residential streets, planted mainly with ornamental cherry and purple leaf plum trees, were eventually topped by residents. Public Works struggled with the resulting “bushy” trees. Street sweeping proved difficult and both vehicles and trees were needlessly damaged. Public safety was also being compromised by trees blocking streetlights. The conflict between nature and AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Historical Background 10 | P a g e civilization was apparent. Nearly every City department and many residents were affected by a lack of proper tree planning and design during this period and struggled to find an effective solution to public safety issues. In the 1990s, the City’s aggressive program of acquiring additional natural areas provided important watershed and wildlife habitat. However, development pressures resulted in encroachments, unauthorized use, and trash disposal by both private residents and developers within natural areas. Besides topping in such areas, whole tree removal was occurring without City authorization. Natural area lands were being partially occupied by a few residents, mostly because they were not aware of property line locations. Discarded yard waste and house plants contributed to the establishment of invasive plants such as ivy. Urban Forestry Awakening During the 1990s. In 1992, a tree ordinance was again proposed but was never brought to City Council for adoption and never resurrected again. The problems that had been occurring with trees in the built environment, the lack of good design standards and unregulated maintenance continued unabated. Protecting the public has been a paramount concern of City departments despite some of the controversy that has ensued. It often takes an incident to occur before a hazard is recognized. In 1997, 65 mature bigleaf maples along Maple Valley Highway were removed by the City after several tree limbs fell, temporarily closing the highway and the Maplewood Golf Course main entrance. After careful assessment of their condition, it was determined that the maples posed a significant risk to public safety. While there was public outcry at their removal, many local residents praised the City for being proactive. In 1998, a Beautification Program was adopted by City Council. City leaders recognized that trees were an important and integral part of the community consistent with City goals. The plan included urban forestry components such as a tree ordinance (not completed), public education and awareness, a tree inventory, a tree management policy, an adopt -a-park program, marketing plan, and a method for measuring performance. The 21st Century. By 2000, the City of Renton’s population grew to 50,052 and to over 80,000 in 2009. Through a series of annexations, Renton’s boundaries have expanded to 22.3 square- miles. Rapid development has replaced the old growth forests of the past. Subsequently, an awareness of the pace of development, loss of City trees, salmon recovery, and better water quality both locally and regionally have driven an interest in urban forest conservation, enhancement, and programming. Tree maintenance continued to be shared by Public Works and the Community Services Departments. Public Works regularly maintained trees in neighborhoods where branches interfered with sweeper trucks during the winter. Otherwise, most of the street trees were maintained by Public Works crews on a reactive basis following calls or complaints. Community Services crews provided more frequent maintenance of trees in the downtown core, collaborating with Public Works on tree and sidewalk conflicts and tree plantings in sidewalk openings. Storm damage to trees was coordinated citywide by the Public Works Department with Community Services providing support. T ree maintenance service contracts issued by the Community Services Department required tree work performed by International Society of Arboriculture (ISA) Certified Arborists to assure proper maintenance to City trees. The Beautification Program continued to move forward and in 2002 Renton’s first City Forester was hired under the title, Parks Maintenance Manager, and worked in the Community Services Department. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA Urban Forest Management Plan 10-year Update Jan2022 11 | P a g e 2002 to 2009. • Staff training in arboriculture and introduction to proper tree and vegetation management to Community Services and Public Works staff. Elimination of all rounding-over (topping) of public trees. • Cooperative partnerships with Puget Sound Energy (PSE) to reduce tree and electric wire conflicts. On Park Avenue, ash trees were removed by PSE and PSE donated “wire- friendly” trees. • In 2003, the City’s began inventorying its public trees. • Eliminated planting large maturing trees in small sidewalk cut-out sections. Utilizing larger 4 x 8 foot cut-out sections and planting smaller-maturing trees. • Completed a city-wide tree inventory and assessment for street trees, park trees and trees in natural areas. Street trees and park trees were located using global positioning satellite (GPS) coordinates and integrated into the City’s graphic information system (GIS). • Budgeting in the Capital Improvement Program for Forestry Program Development and Tree Maintenance. • Adopted Tree Retention [Protection] Regulations for new development. • Renton’s first certified arborist trained in 2006 under the ISA certification program. • Added tree-related policies to the City’s Comprehensive Plan that regulated street trees along new or reconstructed streets and the landscape of new property developments. • City staff from multiple departments met to form the Urban and Community Forest Task Force, hired consultants and initiated the process for preparation of the Renton Urban and Community Forestry Development Plan. • Presentations to elected officials and organizations of the Renton Urban and Community Forestry Development Plan. Recognition. In 2008, for the first time, the City of Renton achieved Tree City USA status for efforts in urban forestry programming. This award is given annually by the National Arbor Day Foundation in cooperation with the National Association of State Foresters and the USDA Forest Service. Renton can now place Tree City USA signs at community entrances to show visitors that Renton cares about its environment and is dedicated to preserving a quality lifestyle. The annual Tree City USA award presentation and Arbor Day celebration offer excellent publicity opportunities—reaching large numbers of people with information about tree care and conservation. Becoming a Tree City USA, Renton now qualifies to receive awards of state and federal agency grants. In 2009, the Maplewood Golf Course became Washington’s second municipal golf course to be designated a “Certified Audubon Cooperative Sanctuary” by Audubon International. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Historical Background 12 | P a g e 2009 to Present. • The City completed its first ever high-resolution urban tree canopy assessment in 2011 finding 28.6% of the City is covered by the canopy of trees when viewed from above. • In 2018, the City updated its tree canopy assessment finding the urban forest covers 29.3% of Renton— up 0.7% in six years (2011 and 2017 imagery used). • The Urban Forest Inventory and Resource Analysis Summary Report was completed in 2021. • This document updates the 10-year urban forest management plan through 2032. • Renton has been a Tree City USA recipient for 14 years, including 11 Growth Awards in the process. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Current State of Renton’s Urban Forest 13 | P a g e CURRENT STATE OF RENTON’S URBAN FOREST Urbanization creates significant changes in land use and land cover, affecting the structure, pattern, and function of ecosystems. The public is increasingly concerned about how these changes influence daily life and affect the sustainability of “quality of life” for future generations. Improving air quality, cooling urban heat islands, reducing stormwater runoff, and building resiliency against pests, diseases, climate change, and storm events are challenges facing the City of Renton. Rapid growth in Renton, with a population of over 10 7 thousand people, is accelerating these problems. The problems need solutions as the City tries to protect and restore environmental quality while enhancing economic opportunity. Renton is a vibrant city that will continue to grow. As it grows, it should also continue to invest in its tree canopy. This is no easy task, given financial constraints and trends toward higher density development that may put space for trees at a premium. The challenge ahead is to better integrate the green infrastructure with the gray infrastructure by increasing tree planting, providing adequate space for trees, and designing plantings to maximize net benefits over the long term, thereby perpetuating a resource that is both functional and sustainable. To make informed decisions about its tree canopy and the strategies to preserve and enhance it, analyses of the urban forest were completed as part of the planning process. These analyses look at the various types of landscapes that comprise the urban forest along with the ownership type and the maintenance responsibility. These various landscapes are depicted in Figure 4 on the following page. The most extensive data on the Citywide urban forest was gathered from two urban tree canopy assessments in 2011 and 2018. The Citywide urban forest is measured with these high-resolution urban tree canopy (UTC) assessments using various imagery and GIS processes. The primary goal of this type of assessment is to identify a baseline and benchmark of the City’s tree canopy and analyze the land cover class across a range of geographic boundaries. This analysis identifies areas for tree canopy preservation as well as the opportunities for new urban tree canopy cover. A bottom-up assessment of Renton’s urban forest was also completed using the City’s updated public tree inventory database. This dataset focuses on the trees that are the City’s responsibility to maintain and are located along streetscapes within the public right -of-way, in public parks, and on public properties. Based on these datasets, Renton has a total of 27,456 public trees along streets, in parks, and in the Maplewood Golf Course, and a total of 89,528 trees in natural areas. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Current State of Renton’s Urban Forest 14 | P a g e THE URBAN FOREST EXTENT AND LANDSCAPES CITYWIDE OPEN SPACE WATERWAYS CAMPUSES PARKS YARDS PRIVATE PROPERTY DOWNTOWN STREETS Figure 4. Depiction of the various types of landscapes that comprise Renton's urban forest AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 15 | P a g e URBAN TREE CANOPY COVER The analysis of Renton’s urban forest begins at the largest scale, the urban tree canopy cover. Renton’s 2018 Urban Tree Canopy Assessment utilized 2017 high-resolution imagery to evaluate the extent of and opportunities for tree canopy cover. Currently, 29.3% of the City’s land area is covered by the canopy of trees across public and private boundaries. Another way to look at the extent of this resource— of the 14,935 total land acres in Renton, 4,382 acres are covered by tree canopy— equivalent to the area of over 3,300 NFL-sized football fields. The assessment also identified areas for potential new tree canopy—tree planting—and a total of 20% (3,030 acres) of Renton’s land area is either grass, low- lying shrubs, or impervious surfaces. Figure 6. Renton’s 2018 Tree Canopy Assessment results CITYWIDE TREE CANOPY ASSESSMENT RESULTS (2018) STREETS, MEDIANS, BACKUP LOTS, ALLEYS  City Maintained  or Other PARKS, OPEN SPACE, NATURAL AREAS  City  Maintained PRIVATE PROPERTY  Owner or Other  Maintained PUBLIC TREES PRIVATE TREES TREE MAINTENANCE RESPONSIBILITY Figure 5. Maintenance responsibility of trees comprising Renton's urban forest Existing Tree Canopy Cover, 29% Total Possible Planting Area, 20% Total Unsuitable Area, 50% AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Current State of Renton’s Urban Forest 16 | P a g e Tree Canopy Possible Vegetative Planting Area Possible Impervious Planting Area Unsuitable Impervious Water Figure 7. Map displaying Renton's tree canopy and vegetative area for possible tree plantings (2018) TREE CANOPY AND VEGETATIVE AREA FOR POSSIBLE TREE PLANTINGS (2018) AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 17 | P a g e The tree canopy assessment was further analyzed to identify areas with more or less tree cover and areas where there are potential opportunities for more canopy to exist. The charts below summarize these metrics by Community Planning Areas and Zoning Type followed by analyses of canopy cover change from 2010 to 2017. EXISTING TREE CANOPY COVER (%) BY COMMUNITY PLANNING AREA 11%14%17%22% 32% 69% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% Center Downtown Center Village Industrial Commercial Residential Resource Conservation EXISTING TREE CANOPY COVER (%) BY ZONING TYPE 31% 47% 13% 29% 25% 34% 39% 29%31% 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% 50% Figure 9. Existing tree canopy cover by Zoning Type (consolidated classifications) Figure 8. Existing tree canopy cover by Community Planning Area AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Current State of Renton’s Urban Forest 18 | P a g e URBAN TREE CANOPY COVER CHANGE + 0.6% 4,200 4,250 4,300 4,350 4,400 AcresUTC 2010 (Acres)UTC 2017 (Acres) +2.1%+2.5%+1.0%+2.1%+3.6% -0.7% -2.1% 0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 3,000 AcresUTC 2010 (Acres)UTC 2017 (Acres) TREE CANOPY CHANGE IN RENTON (2010-2017) TREE CANOPY CHANGE BY COMMUNITY PLANNING AREAS (2010-2017) TREE CANOPY CHANGE BY ZONING TYPE (2010-2017) Figure 10. Citywide tree canopy cover change Figure 11. Tree canopy cover change by Community Planning Area Figure 12. Tree canopy cover change by Zoning Type (consolidated classifications) -0.9% -1.9% +2.1% -2.4% +2.0% +1.6% -0.9%+4.2% -0.2% 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1,000 AcresUTC 2010 (Acres)UTC 2017 (Acres) AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 19 | P a g e Results The Citywide tree canopy cover based on 2017 imagery is 29.3% meaning of the 14,935 total land acres in Renton, there are 4,382 acres covered by tree canopy when viewed from above. The 2018 assessment also identified possible planting areas, those areas that are grass and low-lying shrubs and impervious areas such as parking lots that could theoretically be spaces for new trees. The combination of these possible planting areas is referred to as Total Possible Planting Area or Total PPA. Citywide, the Total PPA is comprised of 18% (2,714 acres) vegetative planting area and 2% (316 acres) impervious planting area. At a finer scale, tree canopy cover across Community Planning Areas varies between 13% in City Center to 47% in Cedar River. Across Zoning Types, the tree canopy varies but resembles a similar distribution among the types of zoning classes found in other community studies. For example, the Resource Conservation Zoning Type has the highest amount of tree canopy cover compared to its total land area with 69%. The Residential Zoning Type canopy cover is less than half the amount of Resource Conservation but is the second highest of the Zoning Types with 32% tree canopy cover. It should be noted that while Residential has the second highest percentage of tree canopy, it holds the highest amount of actual canopy cover acres with 2,510 acres of canopy whereas Resource Conservation has 863 acres of canopy cover. When comparing canopy cover from the two assessments (2011 assessment using 2010 imagery and 2018 assessment using 2017 imagery), it was found that the canopy cover Citywide has increased by 0.6% in the seven-year timespan. This change from 28.7% in 2010 to 29.3% in 2017 was further analyzed by Community Planning Area, Zoning Type, and all other geographies included in the study. Across the Community Planning Areas, the greatest amount of canopy loss between the two time periods was experienced in East Plateau (2.4% decrease) and the highest amount of canopy gain was observed in Valley (4.2% increase). Between 2010 and 2017, City Center experienced a 2.1% growth in canopy. Observing canopy cover change across Zoning Types, the greatest loss of canopy was observed in the Resource Conservation Zoning Type (2.1% decrease) and the greatest increase in canopy was found in the Commercial Zoning Type (3.6% increase). Discussion/Recommendations To inform localized urban forest management, the tree canopy metrics were summarized by various planning boundaries including Land Use, Zoning Type, Community Planning Areas, Watersheds, Census Block Groups, and Catchments. With finer scale analyses of the existing tree canopy and possible planting area compared to historical cover amounts (2010) in Community Planning Areas and Zoning Types, urban forest management strategies can be developed to support the Plan’s vision. For example, the Commercial Zoning Type experienced a 3.6% increase in tree canopy cover, likely due to planning and development requirements and the City’s tree ordinance requiring tree preservation and planting. Also, the overall canopy cover increase is largely attributable to the annexation of the Benson planning area. Further analyses of existing canopy cover, possible planting space, tree equity (in the following section), and factors influencing changes were conducted to inform the canopy cover goals presented in the Tree Planting Initiative and Tree Canopy Cover Goals sections. Comprehensive reports were prepared for the 2011 and 2018 tree canopy assessments where additional details regarding canopy cover, possible planting space, canopy cover change, and ecosystem benefits are provided. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Current State of Renton’s Urban Forest 20 | P a g e URBAN TREE EQUITY The surface temperatures during a heat wave can vary dramatically by city and by neighborhood. A big reason for the difference across city neighborhoods is shade and the canopy of trees that line some sidewalks but not others. Through analyses and local assessments, it is observed that a city’s wealthier areas zoned for single-family homes typically attract more city services, like wide sidewalks and trees. As time progresses, that disparity becomes more than a matter of aesthetics. Research shows shade and water evaporation from trees can lower surrounding air temperatures by six degrees or more. While it is well known that shade from a tree can help keep the ground temperatures cooler, as climate change continues to affect the region, the stakes are likely to get higher. In certain cases that shade could be the difference between life and death, especially for the sick, elderly, and disabled people. Studies show that just an extra degree during a heat wave increase mortality 2-3 percent (Dr. Feinstein, Sustainability and Resilience Policy Director, SPUR, 2021). Many areas lack adequate tree canopy perhaps due to a series of consecutive policies championed by local authorities, codification through federal actions, and decisions to disinvest in neighborhoods where people of color resided as regions grew rapidly in population and infrastructure. A pattern was created that is replete in the urban studies literature (J. Wolch et al 2005). Other possible factors may include the competition for limited physical space, and the increasing dominance of private real estate in driving development processes and occupying areas with pavement that might otherwise contain green space. Specifically in Renton, trees are generally sparse in socioeconomically disadvantaged areas and more prominent in wealthier neighborhoods. The tree canopy and associated benefits of the urban forest are not equally shared and experienced by all communities. Whatever the cause for canopy disparity, the purpose of this tree equity study is to state the baseline conditions, identify priorities, and establish goals for increasing tree canopy cover equitably while overcoming and contending with urban planning and development, the effects of climate change, exotic tree pests and diseases, limited resources, and other factors. Focused on addressing this canopy cover inequity, the American Forests organization created the Tree Equity Score (TES, TreeEquityScore.org) tool that measures tree equity across 150,000 U.S. neighborhoods and 486 municipalities in urban areas. Each community’s TES indicates whether there are enough trees for everyone to experience the health, economic, and climate benefits that trees provide. The scores are based on how much tree canopy and surface temperature align with income, employment, race, age, and health factors. A 0- to-100-point system makes it easy to understand how a community is doing. With the knowledge the score provides, Renton’s community leaders, tree advocates, and residents alike can address climate change and public health through the lens of social equity, attract new resources, factor the scores into technical decisions, guide implementation of the 2022 Urban Forest Management Plan, and track progress toward achieving tree equity. A score of 100 represents tree equity. Figure 13. Example of canopy cover differences in two Renton neighborhoods AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 21 | P a g e Figure 14. Map displaying the Tree Equity Scores by Census Block Groups in Renton, WA (TreeEquityScore.org) Tree Equity Scores 0 – 63 64 – 79 80 – 89 90 – 99 100 Census Block Groups TREE EQUITY SCORES BY CENSUS BLOCK GROUPS (TREEEQUITYSCORE.ORG) AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Current State of Renton’s Urban Forest 22 | P a g e 91 88 86 84 83 83 80 78 76 73 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 TREE EQUITY SCORE COMPARISONS Figure 15. Comparison of Tree Equity Scores for cities near Renton, WA 9 23 16 19 6 0 5 10 15 20 25 100 90-99 80-89 64-79 0-63Count of Census Block GroupsTree Equity Score Ranges DISTRIBUTION OF TREE EQUITY SCORES AMONG RENTON’S CENSUS BLOCK GROUPS Figure 16. Count of Census Block Groups for each Tree Equity Score range AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 23 | P a g e Results Based on the criteria evaluated for each Census Block Group in Renton, the Citywide Tree Equity Score is currently at a score of 83 out of 100. This score is based on a combination of metrics for 73 Census Block Groups (CBG) comprising the City (refer to Figure 14). Compared to nine other cities in the region, Renton’s TES is slightly above the average of 81 but ranks fifth out of the ten total cities used in the study. As shown in the previous figure (Figure 16), only nine of the CBGs are attaining complete tree equity with a score of 100 and six CBGs have a TES less than 63. The majority (23 or 31%) of CBGs have a TES between 90 and 99. Discussion/Recommendations In the past few years, regional partners are increasingly acknowledging and confronting the past practices, current perceptions, and accelerating progress to ensure that communities, landscapes, and policies are more intentional about enhancing historically disinvested areas. Ambitious goals to increase tree canopy in areas of greatest need are drafted for the City’s review and adoption. These goals will grow a more equitable urban forest that provides cooling, public health, habitat, energy saving, and other benefits. In addition, the City should commit to plant and maintain trees, update and align policies and procedures to grow and protect public and private trees, and engage the citizens of Renton to become advocates and stewards of the City’s urban forest. Although the City will oversee and monitor these canopy goals, the effort will inevitably require extensive support from all City departments, community-based organizations, and others aiming to prepare for a changing climate. As a first step, this Plan provides guidance to prioritize resilient, climate-appropriate trees, preserve and conserve mature trees, and properly manage resources to ensure that trees thrive in the urban environment. The cooperation of the City, partners, organizations, property owners, and others is instrumental to meeting these goals, and the Tree Planting Initiative and Tree Canopy Cover Goals sections provide the approach to formally establish a tree canopy goal that will guide this shared commitment. A shared commitment to tree canopy cover and equity goals will lessen the tensions that exist between gray and green infrastructure in Renton. The opportunities and challenges for advancing an equity-centered approach to expanding tree canopy are innumerable, though the adoption and implementation of tree canopy goals is an immediate opportunity to advance such approaches. An urban tree canopy goal that addresses equity will need to demonstrate its value to enable community members to do more than they ultimately would have been able to accomplish without it. Disinvested communities in the region want more equitable policies, living-wage jobs, higher household incomes, safer neighborhoods, affordable housing, a more usable and connected urban network, pedestrian infrastructure, more frequent transit service, better funding for schools, and specific initiatives to engage youth and families, among other things. Showing the value of an equity-based tree program and canopy goal that helps to advance these well-known needs will create an immediate and Citywide constituency for making Renton more sustainable through actions at the neighborhood level. The Citywide and local- level canopy goals aim to address these concerns and opportunities. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Current State of Renton’s Urban Forest 24 | P a g e STRUCTURE OF THE PUBLIC TREE POPULATION For an understanding of the urban forest that is directly managed by the City, analyses of public tree inventory datasets were completed. Tree composition data is essential since the types of trees present in a community greatly affect the amount of benefits produced, tree maintenance activities, budgets, planting goals, canopy connectivity, and the City’s ability to respond to threats from invasive pests and diseases. Table 1. Distribution of public trees by Site Design Results The public tree population is comprised of street and park trees. Of the total 29,289 public trees with Site Design values, there are 11,309 street trees, over 6,000 trees in unimproved right-of-way, more than 8,000 park trees in maintained areas, 2,134 trees in natural areas, and 817 trees on City properties. The inventory database does not include the 89,528 total natural area trees or trees in unmaintained areas of public parks. Discussion/Recommendations The extent and distribution of public trees across the City impacts the structure of the maintenance program and the demand for services. To manage the urban forest for health and public safety, it is recommended street trees be pruned on a 7-year cycle meaning each street tree is pruned within a 7-year timeframe to address clearance issues, structural defects, diseased/decayed/damaged/dying limbs, and other routine maintenance. Currently, the City primarily contracts pruning and removals with approximately 350 trees pruned by contractors and 400 trees pruned by the Urban Forester, Inspecting Arborist, or Parks & Trails crews. Approximately 300 trees are removed annually. With 750 trees pruned each year, the City is on a pruning rotation of approximately 37 years for all 27,456 public trees (street, park, golf course trees) or 15 years for only the street tree population. Site Design Count % Street 11,309 39% Park 8,008 27% Unimproved Right-of-Way 6,068 21% Natural Area 2,134 7% Parking Lot 826 3% City Building 817 3% Not Available 127 0% TOTAL 29,289 100% AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 25 | P a g e Table 2. Public tree genera diversity (top 10) Genus Count % Acer 8,010 27% Pseudotsuga 3,133 11% Populus 2,932 10% Alnus 2,203 8% Thuja 2,004 7% Prunus 1,775 6% Pyrus 988 3% Salix 953 3% Fraxinus 847 3% Pinus 809 3% Other species 5,642 19% TOTAL 29,296 100% Acer 27% Pseudotsuga 11% Populus 10%Alnus 8% Thuja 7% Prunus 6% Pyrus 3% Salix 3% Fraxinus 3% Pinus 3% Other 19% Figure 17. Public tree genera diversity PUBLIC TREE GENERA DIVERSITY Acer → maples Pseudotsuga → Douglas-firs Populus → cottonwoods Alnus → alders Thuja → red cedars Prunus → plums, cherries, peaches, others Pyrus → pears Salix → willows Fraxinus → ash trees Pinus → pines AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Current State of Renton’s Urban Forest 26 | P a g e The following provides a summary of the top ten species identified during the 2021 tree inventory data analysis. Note the values differ slightly from the 2021 Urban Forest Inventory and Resource Analysis Summary Report due to everchanging conditions and routine maintenance. Table 3. Public tree species diversity (top 10) Common Name Count % Bigleaf maple 4,322 15% Douglas-fir 3,132 11% Black cottonwood 2,771 9% Red alder 2,198 8% Red maple 1,920 7% Western red cedar 1,529 5% Callery pear 977 3% Norway maple 870 3% Pacific willow 693 2% Purple leaf plum 650 2% Other species 10,245 35% TOTAL 29,307 100% Bigleaf Maple 15% Douglas-fir 11% Black cottonwood 9% Red alder 8% Red maple 7% Western red cedar 5%Callery Pear 3% Norway maple 3% Pacific willow 2% Purple leaf plum 2% Other 35% Figure 18. Public tree species diversity PUBLIC TREE SPECIES DIVERSITY Bigleaf maple Douglas-fir Black cottonwood Red alder Red maple Western red cedar Callery pear Norway maple Pacific willow Purple leaf plum Figure 19. Leaf profiles of the most common public trees (not to scale) AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 27 | P a g e Results Based on the inventory data there exists a total of 90 unique genera with the top five comprised of Acer (27%), Pseudotsuga (11%), Populus (10%), Alnus (8%), and Thuja (7%). The top five genera make up 63% (18,282 trees) of the 29,296 total live trees recorded in the 2021 inventory update. Regarding species diversity, there exists a total of 281 unique tree species. The top ten species comprise 65% of the inventory consisting of bigleaf maple (15%), Douglas-fir (11%), black cottonwood (9%), red alder (8%), red maple (7%), western red cedar (5%), callery pear (3%), Norway maple (3%), pacific willow (2%), and purple leaf plum (2%). The composition of a tree population should follow the 10-20-30 Rule for species diversity—a single species should represent no more than 10% of the community forest, a single genus no more than 20%, and a single family no more than 30%. Based on this rule, bigleaf maple (Acer macrophyllum) and Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii) exceed the recommended 10% maximum for a single species in a population, comprising a combined 26% of the inventoried tree population. Regarding the genus threshold, maples (Acer) exceed the recommended 20% maximum for a single genus in a population, comprising 27% of the inventoried trees. Discussion/Recommendations Bigleaf maple dominates the tree population at 15%. After bigleaf maple, Douglas-fir makes up the second highest portion at 11%. For a sustainable and resilient urban forest, Douglas-fir, bigleaf maples, and maples in general, should be limited in new tree installations. As a result of the large quantity of Acer (maple) in the City’s population, along with its susceptibility to Asian longhorned beetle (ALB, Anoplophora glabripennis), verticillium wilt, and granulate ambrosia beetle (Xylosandrus crassiusculus), the planting of Acer should be limited to minimize the potential for loss in the event that these pests appear in the City’s urban forest. Regarding the second most prominent specices, Douglas-fir faces Rhabdocline needlecast, Swiss needlecast, and twig blight which all affect the condition and performance of the trees if not addressed. Therefore, this species should be limited in new plantings. Low species diversity (large proportion of the population consisting of trees of the same species) can lead to severe losses in the event of species-specific epidemics such as the devasting results of Dutch elm disease (DED, Ophiostoma novo-ulmi) and more recently, emerald ash borer (EAB, Agrilus planipennis). Asian longhorned beetle is a major threat to Renton’s urban forest, over 25% of the tree population is comprised of trees in the Acer (maple) genus. Tree species diversity is crucial to the resilience of the community forest from these and future unknown threats. The Tree Planting Initiative section provides the guidance for strategic planning and planting of the urban forest to reduce susceptibility and maintain sustainability. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Current State of Renton’s Urban Forest 28 | P a g e PUBLIC TREE POPULATION SIZE CLASS DISTRIBUTION (RELATIVE AGE) The distribution of tree ages influences the structure of the urban forest as well as the present and future costs to the City or property owners. An uneven-age urban forest offers continued flow of benefits and a more uniform workflow allowing managers to more accurately allocate annual maintenance funds. The inventoried trees were categorized into the following diameter size classes: young trees (0-6 inches DBH or diameter at breast height measured at 4.5 feet), established (7-12 inches DBH), maturing (13-18 and 19-24 inches DBH), and mature trees (25-30 and >30 inches). Since tree species have different lifespans and mature at different diameters, heights, and crown spreads, actual tree age cannot be determined from diameter size class alone. However, general classifications of size can be extrapolated into relative age classes. YOUNG ESTABLISHED MATURING MATURE 19% 30% 24% 11% 7%8% 40% 25% 15% 10% 6%4% 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% 0-6in 7-12in 13-18in 19-24in 25-30in >30in City Distribution Ideal Distribution (Richards, 1993) Figure 21. Distribution of public trees by diameter (DBH) class compared to the ideal distribution PUBLIC TREE SIZE DISTRIBUTION COMPARED TO THE IDEAL DISTRIBUTION Figure 20. Distribution by Diameter (DBH) class within site design classifications PUBLIC TREE SIZE DISTRIBUTION FOR VARIOUS SITE DESIGNS - 200 400 600 800 1,000 1,200 1,400 1,600 1,800 2,000 City Building Natural Area Park Parking Lot Street Unimproved ROW 0-3"4-6"7-12"13-18"19-24"25-30">30" AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 29 | P a g e Results The diameter classes were chosen so that the tree population could be analyzed according to Richards’ ideal distribution (1983).2 Based on the analysis, the distribution trends towards less ideal; young trees comprise less than half the recommended distribution with 19% instead of 40%. Renton’s distribution of trees in the 7-12-inch and 13-18-inch size classes exceed the ideal distribution but the trees 19 inches or greater in diameter closely resemble the ideal distribution. Discussion/Recommendations Richards proposed an ideal diameter size class distribution for street trees based on observations of well-adapted trees. Richards’ ideal distribution suggests that the largest fraction of trees (approximately 40% of the population) should be young (less than 8 inches DBH), while a smaller fraction (approximately 10%) should be in the large-diameter size class (greater than 24 inches DBH). A tree population with an ideal distribution would have an abundance of newly planted and young trees, and lower numbers of established, maturing, and mature trees. Table 4. Summary of Renton’s tree size distribution compared to the ideal distribution In the public tree population, Renton has too few young trees and an overabundance of established trees (7-18 inches in diameter) and a slightly overabundant population of mature trees (>25 inches in diameter) suggesting an overly maturing tree population. A goal for Renton’s urban forest should be to have an uneven-aged distribution of trees at the street, park, and Citywide levels. An aging tree population poses a potential increase in maintenance and removal demands and may leave a void in tree canopy and associated benefits if tree planting levels are not elevated. The City is below the threshold for young trees and it will also suffer a loss of ecosystem services that were provided by the mature trees if tree plantings do not increase. It is recommended that Renton support a strong planting and maintenance program to ensure that young, healthy trees are in place to fill in gaps in tree canopy and replace older declining trees. The City must promote tree pre servation and proactive tree care to ensure the long-term survival of older trees. Additionally, tree planting and tree care will allow the distribution to normalize over time. The distribution of individual tree ages within a tree population influences pr esent and future costs as well as the flow of benefits. An ideal age/size distribution in the tree population allows managers to allocate annual maintenance costs uniformly over many years and assures continuity in overall tree canopy coverage and associated benefits which are often dependent on the growing space of individual trees (e.g., open grown versus restricted growing areas). As stated earlier, the City’s public tree maintenance program is influenced by the size classes and relative age, among other factors. The City should support the tree canopy cover goals recommended in this Plan to increase the number of new trees in the 0-6-inch range, strengthen tree regulations to protect the medium to large trees, and proactively remove and replace the declining large trees that pose potential risks as they approach senescence. 2 Richards, N. A. 1983. “Diversity and Stability in a Street Tree Population.” Urban Ecology 7(2):159–171. 0-6in LOW 7-12in HIGH 13-18in HIGH 19-24in IDEAL 25-30in IDEAL >30in HIGH AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Current State of Renton’s Urban Forest 30 | P a g e VALUE AND BENEFITS OF THE PUBLIC TREE POPULATION The urban forest plays an important role in supporting and improving the quality of life in communities. A tree's shade and beauty contribute to a community’s quality of life and soften the often hard appearance of urban landscapes and streetscapes. When properly maintained, trees provide communities abundant environmental, economic, and social benefits that far exceed the time and money invested in planting, pruning, protection, and removal. Not only do the trees growing along the public streets constitute a valuable community resource, they are actual City assets. They provide numerous tangible and intangible benefits such as pollution control, energy reduction, stormwater management, property value increases, wildlife habitat, education, and aesthetics. Benefit Analysis of Renton’s Public Trees The services and benefits of trees in the urban and suburban setting were once cons idered to be unquantifiable. However, by using extensive scientific studies and practical research, these benefits can now be confidently calculated using tree inventory information. Tree benefit values for the City of Renton’s trees are summarized in this Plan using the findings from Renton’s Urban Forest Inventory & Resource Analysis Summary Report, which was published in January of 2021, and calculated using the U.S. Forest Service’s i-Tree’s Streets and i-Tree Eco applications. The results of Renton’s tree inventory provide insight into the overall health of the City’s public trees and the management activities needed to maintain and increase the benefits of trees into the future. The 2021 inventory report calculated benefits for 116,994 trees representing three main tree populations in Renton: street and park trees (public rights -of-way and landscaped parks), natural areas (various forest types such as wetlands, steep hillsides, and riparian), and the Maplewood Golf Course (owned and maintained by the City of Renton). The following sections summarize the benefits of these tree populations analyzed in the 2021 report. To identify the dollar value provided and returned to the community, the City’s tree inventory data were formatted for use in the i-Tree Canopy and i-Tree Eco benefit-cost assessment tools. These applications analyze an inventoried tree population’s structure to estimate the costs and benefits of that tree population. The assessment tools create annual benefit reports that demonstrate the value the City’s trees provide. Table 5. Summary of ecosystem services, benefits, and values of Renton's public trees Tree Population Method Total # of Trees Annual Benefits per Tree ($) Annual Benefits per Capita ($)* Total Annual Benefits Replacement Value Street and Park Trees i-Tree ECO 25,772 $2.34 $0.66 $60,147 $30,600,000 Natural Area Trees i-Tree Canopy 89,528 $1.73 $1.52 $155,141 $90,000,000 Maplewood Golf Course Extrapolated 1,694 $2.34 $0.04 $3,964 $2,000,000 TOTAL 116,994 $1.88 $2.22 $219,252 $122,600,000 *Annual Benefits per Capita ($) based on an estimated population of 90,000 people at the time of the study AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Current State of Renton’s Urban Forest 31 | P a g e Stormwater: Presents reductions in annual stormwater runoff due to rainfall interception by trees measured in gallons. Air Quality: Quantifies the air pollutants (ozone [O3], nitrogen dioxide [NO2], sulfur dioxide [SO2], particulate matter less than 10 micrometers in diameter [PM10]) deposited on tree surfaces, and reduced emissions from power plants (NO2, PM10, volatile organic compounds [VOCs], SO2) due to reduced electricity use in pounds. The potential negative effects of trees on air quality due to biogenic volatile organic compounds (BVOC) emissions is also reported. Energy: Presents the contribution of the urban forest towards conserving energy in terms of reduced natural gas use in the winter (measured in therms [thm]) and reduced electricity use for air conditioning in the summer (measured in Megawatt- hours ([MWh]). Aesthetic/Other Benefits: Shows the tangible and intangible benefits of trees reflected by increases in property values (in dollars). Carbon Stored: Tallies all of the carbon dioxide (CO2) stored in the urban forest over the life of its trees as a result of sequestration. Carbon stored is measured in pounds. Carbon Sequestered: Presents annual reductions in atmospheric CO2 due to sequestration by trees and reduced emissions from power plants due to reductions in energy use. This is measured pounds and has been translated to tons for this report. The model accounts for CO2 released as trees die and decompose and CO2 released during the care and maintenance of trees. Importance Value (IV): IVs are calculated for species that comprise more than 1% of the population. The Streets IV is the mean of three relative values (percentage of total trees, percentage of total leaf area, and percentage of canopy cover) and can range from 0 to 100, with an IV of 100 suggesting total reliance on one species. IVs offer valuable information about a community’s reliance on certain species to provide functional benefits. For example, a species might represent 10% of a population but have an IV of 25% due to its substantial benefits, indicating that the loss of those trees would be more significant than just their population percentage would suggest. Replacement Value: Replacement values are estimates of the full cost of replacing trees in their current condition, should they be removed for some reason. Replacement values are based on the Council of Tree and Landscape Appraisers (CTLA) Guide for Plant Appraisal, which uses a trunk formula methodology. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Current State of Renton’s Urban Forest 32 | P a g e Figure 22. Illustration of the benefits and services provided by public trees Street and Park Tree Benefits A total of 25,772 trees were inventoried as part of the inventory covering Renton’s streets and parks. The tree inventory data was processed using i-Tree ECO, which estimated that these areas have 654.7 acres of canopy cover. The annual benefits provided by these trees is over $60,000 and the total replacement value is nearly $3 million. Table 6. Summary of the annual benefits provided by Renton’s public trees* Benefits Total ($) Quantity Annual $/tree Annual $/capita Avoided Stormwater $ 18,948.62 13,846,782 gal $ 0.74 $ 0.21 Carbon Sequestered $ 24,124.00 141.5 tons $ 0.94 $ 0.27 Air Quality $ 17,074.35 5,549.33 lbs $ 0.66 $ 0.19 Carbon Stored $ 2,287,708 (lifetime) 13,414 tons Total Annual Benefit $ 60,146.97 $2.34 $0.67 *Distribution of benefits per tree and per capita based on 25,772 trees and a population of ~90,000 people AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 33 | P a g e Natural Area Tree Benefits Renton has approximately 854 acres of natural areas, with an estimated 89,528 trees covering 84% of that acreage (721 acres). These trees provide the same ecosystem benefits of street and park trees; however, they are not typically in conflict with the built environment and therefore they are maintained less often and left to live longer lives. As such, i-Tree Canopy does not calculate a monetary value for avoided stormwater because stormwater in natural areas is more likely to flow into streams and wetlands than city stormwater drains. Table 7. Summary of the benefits and services of trees in natural areas Benefits Total ($) Quantity Avoided Stormwater N/A 461,306.84 gallons Carbon Stored $ 3,687,700.00 216,221.31 tons Carbon Sequestered $ 146,840.00 860.97 tons Air Quality $ 8,301.00 48,356.65 lbs TOTAL $3,842,841 Maplewood Golf Course Tree Benefits As a part of Renton’s Urban Forest Inventory & Resource Analysis Summary Report, 1,684 trees were inventoried and analyzed. The benefits for these trees were extrapolated from the average annual benefits provided by Renton’s street and park trees. It was estimated the trees inventoried on Maplewood Golf Course provide $3,964 in annual environmental benefits and have a replacement value of $2,000,000. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Current State of Renton’s Urban Forest 34 | P a g e RENTON’S URBAN FORESTRY PROGRAM AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Current Urban Forest Management Challenges 35 | P a g e CURRENT URBAN FOREST MANAGEMENT CHALLENGES OVERVIEW The City of Renton has a unique urban form and character. Its size, layout, and development density influence the landscape and has created a charming and livable city. Renton’s citizens show pride in their city, and their neighborhoods are well cared for. The City’s climat e is ideal for a wide range of plants and street trees and many of the City’s streets and landscapes exhibit a unique and rich planting character. Some of the City’s historic neighborhoods and its newest developments have a rich urban forest that illustrates Renton’s potential to be an even greater tree-filled city guided by a strategic plan— a city that can be truly ‘ahead of the curve’. Urban trees can play a significant role in making cities resilient to weather and climate extremes, and in protecting human and ecosystem health and safety. To do so, trees must be consciously selected, planted, and managed as the central component of an urban forest where individual trees are maintained as part of a greater system with the purpose of improving the urban environment and enhancing the benefits of that ecosystem. Yet the ability of Renton’s trees to achieve the desired maximum return of benefits is limited due to poor maintenance and management stemming from insufficient municipal budgets, underdeveloped urban forest management systems and programs, limited training of tree care professionals, and a lack of enforcement of tree-management best practices to support tree health. Consequently, long-term tree health is compromised resulting in limiting the beneficial functions of trees, leaving trees more susceptible to pests and disease, and leading to premature tree death. The impact of this is compounded for disadvantaged communities in Renton. As stated by Jad Daley, president and CEO of American Forests, “The single greatest threat from climate change to people in cities is extreme heat.” In turn, urban trees in Renton face multiple challenges to surviving and thriving. Trees that die years prematurely will not create the root systems and canopies needed to reach their benefit potential and maximize their return on investment. Planting and maintaining an urban forest that exists in concert with other green infrastructure must include management by trained individuals, the use of tree inventory data, an understanding of baseline conditions and forecasted environmental changes, collaboration among departments to mainstream urban forest management, a community with a shared vision for the urban forest, and a roadmap for management provided in a plan. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Current Urban Forest Management Challenges 36 | P a g e CHALLENGES IN MAINTAINING AND MANAGING PUBLIC TREES There are a total of 27,456 public street and park trees and 89,528 natural area trees in Renton that are the responsibility of the City to maintain and manage. In 2009, the Community Services Department maintained 1,000 street trees within the downtown core and all park trees with the goal of pruning trees on a five-year cycle. Maintenance was split between City staff for routine care and private contractors for larger trees and more technical arboriculture work. The Public Works Street Division maintained the public right -of-way by responding to tree clearance issues and downed limbs from any of the 3,200 trees in the right-of-way at the time. Sustainable Management – Pruning Cycles Today, the Urban Forestry Program manages and administers general forestry maintenance contracts for public tree planting, trimming, removals, consultancy, watering, and inspections and the Public Works Street Division continues to prune trees for clearance and address downed limbs in the public right-of-way. Parks & Trails crews also manage many tree issues on an as needed basis within park areas and along trails. This structure provides a more holistic approach to public tree management by extending maintenance beyond the downtown core trees but the budgets inhibit efficient proactive management and compromise sustainability. One measure of sustainable management is the number of years it takes to prune all public trees, also referred to as the pruning cycle. Currently, the City is on an approximate 37-year pruning cycle compared to the recommended 7-year cycle. The impact of deferred maintenance is seen in the condition of the inventoried public tree population with nearly half rated as fair in condition and only a third in good condition. Compounding the issue, both the Parks & Trails Division and the Public Works Street Division have limited in resources and have extensive demands to meet in regards to parks and trails maintenance and sidewalk repairs & replacements, respectively. Program Efficiencies Having public tree maintenance responsibilities shared across departments can utilize limited resources efficiently but only if the workflows are clear and understood. An example where the workflow is complicated and inefficient lies within tree clearance issues for both public and private trees impacted the right-of-way. These tree issues are received through Renton Responds, staff observations, calls, or through Verra Mobility (the City’s traffic signal company). If the clearance issue is the result of a tree branch, Public Works Transportation Maintenance address the issue if it is a minor branch, or the issue is sent to code compliance for private trees and to Urban Forestry for public trees. For minor public tree clearance issues, Urban Forestry will sometimes address the problem with a pole saw from the ground, but the number of requests continue to backlog and Urban Forestry had to build a dedicated worklist and contract for less urgent tree clearance work of both public and private trees. For private trees, Code Compliance could require the property owner to remedy the issue but for single private trees the process and burden is onerous— the resident would need to pay for a right-of-way use permit in addition to the cost of trimming, so it is often avoided and instead the tree is queued and eventually addressed but results in significant backlogs. Risk Tree Management One of the unique challenges of managing Renton’s urban forest stems in part from the nature of trees in the Pacific Northwest – trees grow exceptionally tall. Small pockets of remnant stands of second growth trees can still be seen even today at the edge of new developments. They can be more prone to branch failures than other tree species during storms. In addition to large tree size, the prevalence of particular species in the urban forest population presents more opportunities for possible damages and consequences as a result of the failure of a tree or tree part. Other native species like bigleaf maples and black cottonwoods can also be problematic as they are also large trees and are prone to decay. They comprise a large proportion of the AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 37 | P a g e public tree population, especially in natural areas. There are also large specimen trees like pin oaks, tulip trees, cedars, and sycamores on city streets which require thoughtful management. Tree Related Policies and Regulations Trees can be found mentioned in several City codes, regulations, and plans. Regulations to guide tree planting and maintenance are limited and do not sufficiently address the concerns of many City staff and the public. For example, there are limited regulations about planting trees near street lights. Though section 4-4-070F.2 of Renton Municipal Code provides some guidelines for planting near objects in the right-of-way, additional detailed language could address concerns. Removing trees during construction of subdivisions became a problem after 2000 when the City experienced a period of rapid development. An emergency rule was invoked in late 2006 followed by adoption of the tree retention regulation in 2007 to deal with loss of canopy cover in new development. Legislation affecting the City of Renton is not only local in nature. Other state and federal legislation impacts trees in the city directly or indirectly. One of these is the Evergreen Communities Act which passed the State Legislature in 2008. This act specifically benefits urban forestry across the state for local jurisdictions. Regulations exist for planting, pruning, and removing street trees. A new Street Tree Regulation has been developed to provide guidance on maintenance and planting. Additional regulations will be incorporated into the Renton Municipal Code to improve tree protection and preservation. Regulations include plan review for street tree planting, pruning and removal; spacing guidelines and tree species selection for street trees; permits for land use, clearing and tree removal; and hazardous tree mitigation. Though significant improvements have been made, there still exist some inconsistencies or gaps in the policies and regulations for Renton’s trees. Tree Retention Requirements When calculating tree retention density requirements on residential parcels, credit is given for every six (6) inches of tree diameter at breast height (DBH) for larger trees retained, as opposed to 1 for 1 replacement or retention. The upside is that for correcting violations by replanting, every inch of diameter must be replaced. For infrastructure projects however, the replacement value is 1 for 1. This does not quickly replace the diameter of larger trees lost due to infrastructure projects. Also, the main elements for tree preservation are retention density and landmark size (trees greater than 30 inches DBH).3 Industry recommendations and benchmarking research in other cities show a landmark tree size classification should be reduced to at least 24 inches DBH (Swiecki, et al. 1991). Tree Removal Permits All permitting for tree removals is coordinated through the Community and Economic Development Department. As is often the case for municipalities with less stringent tree preservation ordinances, tree value lost after removal for development is not always sufficiently captured in replacement tree planting. Urban Forestry divisions are not always looped in consistently during the design, land use and construction permi tting process. In Renton however, this improved after the tree ordinances were reviewed in 2019 and the Urban Forestry Division was more explicitly included in both land use discussion and construction permitting . Many cities require removal permits for any tree over six (6) inches DBH, and removals are not granted unless the tree is dead, diseased, structurally compromised, exceeded growth space, is less important than planned infrastructure, or poses an unacceptably high level of risk. Lost tree value can be recouped in the permitting process and is highly recommended and desired by 3 Public (SEPA exempt) utilities and public ROW expansions are exempt from tree density; however, street trees are required per RMC 4-4-070, landscaping. Thus far, the proposed tree ordinance does not intend to apply the proposed tree credit system to public ROW trees. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Current Urban Forest Management Challenges 38 | P a g e the City, but, would likely require a full-time development review arborist. Tree Protection during Construction Currently, Best Management Practices (BMPs) for protecting tre es on construction sites are inconsistently adhered to by contractors and the monitoring of tree protection zones (TPZ) is insufficient due to poor understanding of the BMPs on the part of the contractors and the inability for the City’s inspection team to provide 24/7 oversite on all development projects. Alternative Solutions to Tree and Sidewalk Conflicts Many municipalities habitually apply linear streetscape designs which limit retrofits and alternative solutions to tree and sidewalk conflicts. Renton has made some use of flexible design, however these types of designs could be considered more often. Flexible design would allow more sidewalks to meander around trees, parcels could be developed around healthy existing trees, and additional right-of-way easements/frontages could be obtained rather than blindly applying the ‘safe streets’ or ADA retrofit designs. The Urban Forestry Program is actively discussing potential changes to Code and regulations with Community & Economic Development. ADDRESSING THE CHALLENGES These issues and challenges recognized in Renton are exacerbated in disadvantaged areas of communities with limited resources. The City needs this comprehensive plan to preserve and expand the urban forest which results in an equitable distribution of tree canopy, associated benefits, and urban forestry opportunities. The City, its partners, and the community support a plan for the urban forest that sustains the resource and provides benefits to all who live, work, and recreate in the City. To address these challenges, the Urban Forest Management Plan 10-year Update offers Renton an opportunity to study, evaluate, and plan for improving urban forest management toward the goal of supporting human and ecosystem health and well-being. The urgency of protecting the urban forest has risen sharply as drought, pests, disease, climate impacts and budget cuts lead to rapidly rising tree mortality. To address and reverse tree die-off and the loss of ecosystem benefits, Renton needs a robust system of professional management of public trees and improved support of resident engagement in the care and expansion of the urban forest, both public and private. When making improvements to the urban forest, efforts should be prioritized to improve environmental justice, equity, access, and levels of service for underserved and vulnerable areas. These considerations may include additional tree plantings for more equitable distribution of urban forest cover and benefits, intensive tree management, diverse outreach approaches, and unique stewardship programs. Renton’s Urban Forest Management Plan is a crucial planning effort to build a more sustainable resource and a healthy community, among other core urban forest management elements. This strategic plan for Renton’s urban forest aims to help guide how the City might think about strengthening City Code, policies, ordinances, standards, practices, and procedures; analyzes staffing structures and authority; identifies opportunities for su stained and diversified funding; provides guidance for routine and systematic inventories and assessments; identifies tree maintenance efficiencies and planting/canopy goals and priorities; addresses storm, disaster, and risk management needs; and strengthens community outreach, education, and engagement. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 39 | P a g e PROGRAMS MANAGING RENTON’S URBAN FOREST PROGRAM ORGANIZATION Renton’s urban forest is managed by the Parks Planning and Natural Resources Division in the Parks and Recreation Department (previously referred to as the Community Services Department). This division is dedicated to the health and protection of the environmental resources, public safety, and community education for all to enjoy the 711 acres of natural areas, 27,456 public trees along streets, in parks and the golf course and 89,528 trees in natural areas. In addition, the Division provides landscaping and maintenance within the right-of-way and on facility grounds at 50 locations. The Urban Forestry Program within the Division is focused on programming, inventory data collection and management, tree planting, training, tree inspections, arboriculture related support for tree code enforcement, volunteer restoration projects, arboriculture related support for site plan reviews, and events like Arbor Day and Earth Day. These essential duties and responsibilities are overseen by the Urban Forestry and Natural Resources Manager and supported by a contracted inspecting arborist, a part-time administrative person, and a part-time supervisor. Parks and Recreation Department Parks Planning and Natural Resources Division Urban Forestry Program Supervisor (0.25 FTE) Urban Forestry and Natural Resources Manager (1.00 FTE) Contracted Inspecting Arborist (1.00 FTE) Administrator (0.25 FTE) Figure 23. Structure of Renton's Urban Forestry Program INTERDEPARTMENTAL MANAGEMENT OF TREES There are a wide range of management activities necessary to maintain an urban forest and many of these overlap between city departments and divisions. The overlap is often based on the location of a tree on publicly managed land or on private property. In the City of Renton, public trees on streets, in parks, and in natural areas are the responsibility of the Urban Forestry Program. Trees on private property fall under the Department of Community and Economic Development’s (CED) Planning Division, and trees in the public space are managed or AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Programs Managing Renton’s Urban Forest 40 | P a g e supported by the Parks Planning and Natural Resources Division, Parks & Trails Division, Public Works Maintenance, and Public Works Transportation Systems. The CED Planning Division oversees private property development, ordinance enforcement, and zoning, with trees on private property assigned to this department. Likewise, Parks Planning and Development and Public Works manage public space infrastructure such as streets and sidewalks, and street trees are organized within these departments. While organizing tree management in this manner is a natural fit for the responsibilities of each department or division, it does not necessarily coincide with the expertise and skills of each department, nor does it orchestrate a holistic management of the urban forest. As such, it is important to review the current structure of the Renton urban forest for its benefits and tree management limitations, and to explore if alternative management structures may improve City efficiency and ultimately, lead toward a safer and sustainable urban forest. PARKS PLANNING AND NATURAL RESOURCES URBAN FORESTRY PROGRAM The Urban Forestry Program is responsible for the direct management of 27,456 street, park, and golf course trees and 89,528 trees in natural areas. Trees located along streets are referred as street trees. These trees are found between the sidewalk and cu rb in a planting strip or in sidewalk cut-outs. Street trees are also found within the street right -of-way where no street exists (dedicated right-of-way), where no sidewalk and curb exists (unimproved right-of-way), and in some alleys. Street trees require permission to prune, remove, or otherwise treat however, property owners can water and mulch street trees without permission and the City encourages these activities for a healthy tree population. These regulations for planting, pruning, and removing street trees did not always exist. Previously, many street trees were poorly or improperly maintained, tree removals were made without notice, and poor tree selection and placement happened when planting. The Street Tree Regulation was developed to address these concerns and to provide guidance. Regulations include the following: ❖ Plan review for street tree planting, pruning and removal ❖ Spacing guidelines and tree species selection for street trees ❖ Permits for land use, clearing and tree removal ❖ Hazardous tree mitigation The Urban Forestry Program manages the application for Arbor Day Tree City USA awards and Arbor Day/Earth Day celebrations. The City has received the Tree City USA award for 14 years and is eligible to submit applications for Arbor Day Foundation’s Growth Award, which has been awarded for 11 consecutive years. The Growth Award recognizes Tree City USA communities that demonstrate higher levels of tree care and community engagement. The Urban Forestry Program also oversees the permitting process that receives requests for street tree pruning, removal, inspection, or other requests. The tree(s) associated with a request is identified in the City’s asset management software and inspections are conducted by the Urban Forestry Program’s contracted Inspecting Arborist or other qualified personnel. The maintenance or removal of street trees as requested through the permitting process are staged and prioritized by the City or addressed by the adjacent property owner. In addition to service requests, the Urban Forestry Program also conducts proactive pruning of street and park trees. Previously, the street trees were managed by the Community Services Department and the Public Works Street Division. The Community Services Department maintained approximately 1,000 street trees within the downtown core and all park trees on a five-year pruning cycle using staff and private contractors. Private contractors were mostly utilized for larger trees and more technical work. The Public Works Street Division was responsible for 3,200 trees within the City right-of-way with maintenance occurring on a reactive basis meaning staff responded to clearance issues or downed limbs or trees. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 41 | P a g e Program Budget Today, the public street and park trees are managed by the Urban Forestry Program with an overall budget of $951,000 (2021). Of the total investment, 26% is attributed to administration ($250,000), 17% to consulting arborist inspection services ($157,000), 14% to contract pruning ($134,000), and 11% to professional services ($100,000— only in recent years for inventory and management plan updates, otherwise it would be spent on pruning, removal, and planting) and contract landscape watering ($100,000). The remaining 22% ($210,000) is used for tree removals ($85,000), storm damage on-call / debris clean up ($70,000), tree planting ($35,000), purchasing trees and planting supplies ($15,000), and pest management ($5,000). Table 8. Annual investments in the management of street and park trees Investments (2021) Percent Allocated Total ($) $/tree $/capita Funding Source* Purchasing Trees & Related Planting Supplies 2% $15,000 $0.55 $0.15 FIL Planting Trees 4% $35,000 $1.27 $0.34 OP Contract Pruning 14% $134,000 $4.88 $1.32 OP Pest Management 1% $5,000 $0.18 $0.05 OP Removal 9% $85,000 $3.10 $0.84 OP Storm Damage On-Call / Debris Clean Up 7% $70,000 $2.55 $0.69 OP Professional Services** 11% $100,000 $3.64 $0.99 OP Contract Landscape Watering 11% $100,000 $3.64 $0.99 CON Consulting Arborist Inspection Services 17% $157,000 $5.72 $1.55 CON Administration+ 26% $250,000 $9.11 $2.46 W&B TOTALS 100% $951,000*** $34.64 $9.37 *Funding Source Descriptions: FIL → Fee-in-Lieu fund – separate fund, use restricted to capitalizable purchases for tree planting (ref. RMC 9-13). OP → Forestry Operating / Maintenance – total maintenance operating funds budget is $425,000. CON → Externally Contracted Services – funds with separate dedicated budgets; inspection and irrigation. W&B → Wages and Benefits – estimated, separate from Forestry maintenance budget fund. Based on Urban Forestry Manager at 100%, Parks Planning & Natural Resources Director at 25%, and Support Staff at 10%. **Professional Services: Years 2020, 2021, and 2023 for tree inventory update, management plan update, and LiDAR canopy cover study which would otherwise normally be spent on pruning, removals, and planting. ***Note: Budget does not include the tree-related work of the Parks & Trails crews— funded through a separate budget. +Administration: See Table 9 for summary of 2022 Administration costs. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Programs Managing Renton’s Urban Forest 42 | P a g e 2022 Program Administration Costs Based on a November 2021 analysis, the administration costs for the 2022 Urban Forestry Program are provided in the table below: Table 9. Summary of the 2022 budget for the Urban Forestry Program’s Administration * Title 2022 Salary 2022 Benefits 2022 Total Urban Forestry & Natural Resources Manager (100%) $130,957 $55,251 $186,208 Parks Planning & Natural Resources Director (25%) $39,290 $18,262 $57,551 Administrative Secretary 1 (10%) $7,776 $4,775 $12,550 TOTAL $178,022 $78,287 $256,309 *Details and Assumptions: • The percentages assigned to each of the staff represent the amount of time and budget attributed to urban forestry. • The Urban Forestry & Natural Resources Manager and the Administrative Secretary’s benefits remain the same from 2021 to 2022. • The Parks Planning & Natural Resources Director benefits were adjusted (increased) to a full family’s cost as a conservative measure. • A 4% salary increase across the board for non-represented staff at the beginning of 2022. • A 4% salary increase for AFSCME to mirror the non-represented increase. Service Requests for Street, Park, and Natural Area Trees When a service request for a street, park, or natural area tree is received through Renton Responds or through other channels, the Urban Forestry Program uses the house and street address for locating trees and to check if they are in the City’s tree inventory database. This location information is collected in Renton Responds and is used for public and private tree inspections. The Urban Forestry Program’s contracted Inspecting Arborist inspects trees and evaluates the tree in terms of general condition and any obvious problems. Prescriptions for treatment are entered into a work order database only for public trees using a prioritization procedure. Actual maintenance can take upwards of a year or longer to occur, depending on the urgency of the risk posed by the tree. Following an inspection, a response is emailed, or other communications used, to relay information of any action to be taken by either the City or by the property owner. Some of the more frequent private tree issues encountered include dangerous trees on adjacent property, inspection of trees from Community and Economic Development Department staff requests (code compliance, permit applications and development regulations), and providing general information to property owners about adjacent city trees. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 43 | P a g e Risk Tree Management The City has actively managed risk trees for over 12 years with a concerted effort beginning in 2009. At that time, the City recognized the need to develop a long-range plan for the maintenance of the urban forest. To that end, more management information regarding Renton’s urban forest would be required and the City’s first public tree inventory was created. This inventory was updated in 2020. With this data, the City’s Urban Forestry Program drafted the first specified risk tree management plan for Renton’s public trees . The Risk Tree Management Plan draft is provided in Appendix E and adopting the plan is a strategy in this Urban Forest Management Plan. Regularly updated tree inventory data will help create inspections lists and a more proactive inspection rotation for species with a riskier failure profile and lower recorded condition ratings. Mainstreaming Urban Forest Management To ensure sustainability and interdepartmental coordination, a ‘green team’ could be established to coordinate efforts across the City. This would enable unified messaging, consistent workflows, improved efficiencies, strengthened and frequent communication, and improved knowledge transfer. This team may consist of members of the Collaborative Team for the Urban Forest Management Plan project among others key staff. This idea as part of the previous urban forest plan in 2009 but never came to fruition. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Programs Managing Renton’s Urban Forest 44 | P a g e URBAN FOREST BENCHMARK COMPARISONS Urban forest benchmarking research provides an understanding of the level of effort and capacity necessary to satisfy the City’s adopted goals, identifies industry trends and best practices, enables the creation of realistic goals, and provides the metrics for measuring change. Benchmarking Data Sources Several data sources were reviewed and compiled to paint a picture of how Renton measures up against industry standards and communities of a similar size or geographic location and how its own operations have changed over time. Phase 1 of the benchmarking process uses the Arbor Day Foundation’s Tree City USA 2019 dataset and compares statistics provided by the City of Renton to other regional cities that also participate in the Tree City USA program. Using this dataset helps better understand how Renton’s urban forestry budget and activities compare to relevant cities. Relevant cities are determined by 1) proximity (nationwide), 2) proximity (statewide), 3) population size (nationwide), 4) population size (statewide), and finally 5) within 200 miles and most similar population size (best match). The Tree City USA dataset is largely focused on: urban forestry budgets, per capita funding information, and volunteer hours. The data further describes the number of trees planted, removed, and pruned by City staff. This data is useful in determining adequacy of urban forestry program funding as well as understanding workloads of those City employees involved in urban forestry operations. Phase 2 of benchmarking involves comparing Renton’s urban forestry operations to findings from an in-depth study conducted by researchers Richard Hauer and Ward Peterson (2014). In this study, researchers interviewed urban forestry programs in various regions across the U.S. and among varying population classes. Specific study focus areas include: community and staff profiles, funding, tree management policy and planning, volunteers and partnerships, contracting tree care activities, community tree populations, tree operations and management, and assistance programs. Data from this study was compared to data obtained from the City of Renton for the purposes of determining program health as compared to accurate data across a range of scales and locations. View the 2014 study by Hauer et al. at https://www.uwsp.edu/cnr/Pages/Forestry---MTCUS.aspx. Phase 3 of benchmarking is comprised of presenting the above information to the City and making clarifications in order to ensure the highest quality analysis. This phase al so includes internal quality controls to ensure data comparisons are as accurate as possible. In this phase, data discrepancies and caveats are identified to ensure relevant and compatible comparisons are made. Information gathered during this process informed the development of realistic and attainable goals and strategies in the City’s Urban Forest Management Plan. Understanding the urban forest policies, management approaches, budgets, and programs of comparable communities and nationwide averages provides comparative data to benchmark the City’s performance, present and future. While existing tree data describe the current conditions, benchmarks offer guidance to bring Renton’s urban forestry policies and practices into alignment with similar-sized cities in Washington and nationwide, enhancing urban forest management. A summary of research into policies and actions of these cities follows. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 45 | P a g e Data Descriptions, Discrepancies, and Limitations The benchmarking research is based on data reported by communities to the agencies summarizing the metrics. For the Tree City USA and 2014 Urban and Community Forestry Census records, the method for reporting budgets and activities may vary among communities since each community forestry program is unique. The reporting methodology for budgets, staffing, and activities may differ resulting in less accurate comparisons. Some communities may only report staffing numbers based on the primary program while others may include supporting departments, contractors, and technical service providers. These differences in reporting would also affect the budget comparisons. In addition, the methods for reporting activities for each community may vary. Some communities may only report on the in -house activities conducted by the lead department whereas other communities may report on activities conducted by supporting departments, utility companies, and other sources. Since the historical reporting methods for Renton are unknown, the values used in the comparison study are based on 2019 Tree City USA records and 2021-2022 budgets. Due to the number of discrepancies and the limitations of this analysis, the benchmarking research is meant to serve as an initial starting point in developing the Urban Forest Management Plan. The metrics are not meant to imply overall management effectiveness. Interpretations for each metric were provided and used to guide goals and strategies within the Urban Forest Management Plan. It is recommended the City verify and finalize benchmarking values in order to measure Plan implementation progress and inform reporting. Table 10. Arbor Day Foundation Tree City USA communities examined during the benchmarking research City State Population Proximity (miles) Renton Washington 102,153 0 Yakima Washington 94,440 100 Everett Washington 111,215 35 Bellingham Washington 90,110 89 Kirkland Washington 89,557 13 Auburn Washington 81,720 12 Kent Washington 129,600 5 Bellevue Washington 145,300 9 Redmond Washington 65,860 14 Shoreline Washington 55,730 20 Olympia Washington 51,600 46 Burien Washington 50,997 6 Lacey Washington 50,170 42 Tacoma Washington 216,279 19 Bothell Washington 46,657 19 Edmonds Washington 42,170 24 Bremerton Washington 41,235 22 Issaquah Washington 39,378 9 Lynnwood Washington 38,511 23 Longview Washington 38,100 98 Wenatchee Washington 34,329 87 Snoqualmie Washington 13,752 19 TOTAL 1,628,863 713 Average 74,039 32 AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Programs Managing Renton’s Urban Forest 46 | P a g e Table 11. Summary of phase 1 benchmarking research results (Tree City USA dataset) 2019 TREE CITY USA - RENTON 2019 TREE CITY USA - REGIONAL $925k (Urban) Forestry budget $800k Average forestry budget $9.06 Per capita forestry budget $10.42 Average per capita budget $647k Tree planting, initial care, maintenance, and removal budget $630k Average tree planting, initial care, maintenance, and removal budget $278k Program management budget $121k Average program management budget 357 Trees pruned 1,025 Average trees pruned 298 Trees removed 130 Average trees removed 129 Trees planted 1,695 Average trees planted Table 12. Summary of phase 2 benchmarking research results (2014 Census, Hauer et al.) 2014 CENSUS - RENTON 2014 CENSUS – POPULATION GROUP (100-250K) $925k (Urban) Forestry program budget (2021) $1.4M Average forestry budget 0.20% Of total budget for forestry 0.52% Of total budget for forestry 117k Estimated public trees 74k Average count of public trees $7.91 Budget per tree $44.85 Average budget per tree 1.23 Public trees per capita 0.51 Average public trees per capita 47k Public trees per staff 14k Average public trees per staff 711 Acres of parks and open space 1,284 Average acres of parks and open space $126M Value of public trees $98M Average value of public trees AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 47 | P a g e URBAN FOREST AUDIT To develop this Plan, nearly 40 documents, plans, and resources were gathered and reviewed by applying the U.S. Forest Service’s Urban Forest Sustainability and Management Audit’s Discovery Matrix. This matrix includes a total of 11 urban forest categories, each containing a multitude of supporting elements. All resources were reviewed to identify references regarding each of the categories and supporting elements. There are a total 275 instances where the 40 resources reference the 11 categories and supporting elements. The number of resources referencing elements of urban forest sustainability and management demonstrate Renton’s readiness for changes driven by this Plan. Recommendations in this Plan align with components of these supporting resources. For a complete list of categories, elements, rankings, and supporting resources, see Appendix D. Based on the analysis of findings from the project planning and research, Renton scored a 65% in terms of urban forest sustainability and management as defined by the U.S. Forest Service, partners, and planning consultants. The City of Renton scored relatively high when compared to other urban forestry audits completed by the consultants for other communities of similar size. Overall, the City scored highest in the Decision and Management Authority, Community, Professional Capacity and Training, and Inventory categories — all of which are above 75%. The Urban Forest Management Plan provides the guidance to maintain these strengths and to address shortcomings as opportunities. Based on the audit of 129 subcategories (11 primary categories), Renton is achieving “Adopted Common Practice” for 53 (42%) of these. 59 subcategories (23%) are “In Development”. Applying the multipliers of 2 for Adopted Practice and 1 for In Development results in a total score of 165 out of 254 possible points, or 65% (detailed in the following table). Table 13. Outcomes of the urban forest auditing process for Renton, WA # Description SOC* (% Achieved) Base** (% Achieved) Overall Rating Overall (% Achieved) 1 Management Policy, Ordinances 75% 50% 18 64% 2 Professional Capacity and Training 100% NA 13 81% 3 Funding and Accounting 75% NA 7 58% 4 Decision, Management Authority 100% 50% 7 88% 5 Inventories NA 63% 20 77% 6 Urban Forest Management Plans NA 25% 11 46% 7 Risk Management 100% 50% 15 83% 8 Disaster Planning NA 67% 6 43% 9 Standards and BMPs*** 75% 56% 33 55% 10 Community 100% NA 24 86% 11 Green Asset Evaluation NA NA 11 55% TOTAL 89% 51% 165 65% *Standard of Care (SOC) elements represent the minimum group of urban forestry management “best practices” that a municipality should consider for implementation. SOC refers to the degree of prudence and caution required of an individual who is under a duty of care (i.e., legal obligation of the controlling authority, owner, or manag er) to minimize risk. Neither state, regional, nor national minimum management components have been established for SOC but these are interim recommendations for consideration. (NA = not applicable) **Base Practices (BP) elements represent additional urban forest management activities or components that may effectively expand a program beyond the SOC group (see footnote above). These elements are typically precursors to other “non-core” elements in the category. (NA = not applicable) ***Best Management Practices (BMPs) AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Programs Managing Renton’s Urban Forest 48 | P a g e Discussion The main purpose of the urban forest audit is to apply the research and findings gathered throughout the planning effort to inform the Plan’s goals, objectives, and strategies. This audit or “gap analysis” enables the Urban Forestry Program to control different aspects of its program with data. This gap analysis identified the shortcomings that the Urban Forestry Program should overcome and by quantifying them, the program can make improvements. It also enables effective monitoring of Plan strategies in that the audit categories and elements can be revisited at key intervals in the Plan implementation process to measure progress and adapt strategies accordingly. The information provided in the table above describe the current conditions of Renton’s urban forest, the programs that manage it, and the community framework. As recommended in the Plan’s monitoring methods, the City should use this framework to evaluate implementation progress, report successes, and inform changes to Plan actions. Many of the urban forest audit elements were given a rating of “In Development” as they previously did not exist but are addressed in this Urban Forest Management Plan. This means that the City is already well underway in advancing its program and its Urban Forest Audit score. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 49 | P a g e PROGRAM NEEDS PUBLIC TREE MAINTENANCE Urban forest management priorities should in part be determined by the current maintenance practices and how well they support program goals and the Plan’s goals. Some maintenance practices are specific to local climate conditions and number of trees to manage. Others, such as maintaining an optimal pruning cycle are relatively consistent for all tree management programs. As such, the City’s pruning cycle can be used to identify funding and staffing needs. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 50 | P a g e Current Public Tree Condition and Maintenance Needs Tree characteristics and outside forces affect the management needs for urban trees. An analysis of the condition and maintenance requirements enables managers to plan the urban forest, prioritize maintenance, and target outreach to property owners and the community as a whole. Tree condition indicates how well trees are managed and how well they perform given site-specific conditions. Tree maintenance needs are inventoried for public safety reasons and for the health and longevity of the trees. Understanding the maintenance needs assists tree managers in establishing daily work plans. The condition of individual trees was catalogued in the City’s inventory database in numerical values. Dead trees were given a rating of “0”, poor condition trees a rating of 10- 40, fair condition given 50-60, good condition with a rating of 70-90, and trees in excellent condition were given a rating of 100. Several factors are considered when assigning a condition value to a tree, including root characteristics, branch structure, trunk, canopy, foliage condition, and the presence of pests. Table 14. Public tree maintenance needs by Site Design based on an analysis of August 2021 inventory data Parking Lot (242 Trees) Street (3,578 Trees) Unimproved ROW (1,712 Trees) Structural Prune 25% Clearance Prune 22% Crown Cleaning 39% Clearance Prune 23% Structural Prune 19% Tree Removal 21% Thinning Prune 17% Thinning Prune 18% Other 12% Other Maintenance 35% Other Maintenance 40% Other Maintenance 29% City Building (113 Trees) Park (2,777 Trees) Natural Area (765 Trees) Crown Cleaning 32% Crown Cleaning 28% Add Mulch 36% Clearance Prune 29% Thinning Prune 18% Crown Cleaning 21% Tree Removal 12% Add Mulch 16% Structural Prune 13% Other Maintenance 27% Other Maintenance 38% Other Maintenance 31% Nearly half of the public tree population with a condition rating is in the “Fair” condition class with a numerical value of 50 through 60. With 48% of trees in fair condition, it perhaps is an indicator of less than optimal tree maintenance, poor tree species for a given site, insufficient monitoring or plant health care, natural and human-caused defects, a maturing public tree population, or a combination of factors. Across all Site Designs— the type of site in which trees are planted and growing — 22% of trees require crown cleaning, a pruning practice that addresses dead, dying, decayed, diseased, and damaged limbs. This type of maintenance can be more effectively managed with overall reduced costs if the public trees were pruned on a shorter cycle. (0), Dead, 3% (10-40), Poor, 15% (50-60), Fair, 48% (70-90), Good, 33% (100), Excellent, 0.3% PUBLIC TREE CONDITION PUBLIC TREE MAINTENANCE NEEDS BY SITE DESIGN AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 51 | P a g e Identifying Optimal Pruning Cycles A study (Miller et al. 20154) was conducted for Milwaukee, Wisconsin to determine the optimum pruning cycle by comparing the marginal cost of pruning to its marginal return. For example, a portion of Milwaukee was inventoried to record tree condition and calculate tree value. Since condition class influences tree value, the date of last pruning and average condition class for each work unit inventoried was subjected to regression analysis. This analysis determines the relationship between pruning and condition class (see Figure 24 below). Marginal costs were calculated based on the loss of tree value, using condition classes, for each one -year extension of the pruning cycle. Marginal returns are the savings in pruning costs for each one -year extension of the pruning cycle. For Milwaukee, the relationship between marginal cost and return indicates that the optimum pruning cycle for the city is five years, assuming the management goal is to provide the highest-value tree population for dollars expended. The point at which marginal costs and marginal returns intersect i.e., the optimal pruning cycle. 4 Miller, R. W., Hauer, R. J., & Werner, L. P. (2015). Urban Forestry: Planning and Managing Urban Greenspaces, Third Edition. 64 66 68 70 72 74 76 78 80 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14Condition Class (%)Number of years since last pruning 0 20,000 40,000 60,000 80,000 100,000 120,000 140,000 160,000 180,000 200,000 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14Dollars Pruning cycle length (Years) Ŷ = 76.7 + 0.196X - 0.074X2* Marginal cost Marginal return a b Figure 24. a) Relationship between pruning cycle length (number of years since last pruning) and condition class rating. Asterisk (*) indicates regression is significant at the 0.05 level. b) Marg inal cost (loss of tree value) and marginal return (savings in pruning costs) for pruning cycle lengths. For this study, the optimal pruning cycle is where marginal costs and marginal returns intersect— at 5 years. Figure recreated from Miller and Sylvester (1981). - The Costs of Maintaining and Not Maintaining the Urban Forest: A Review of the Urban Forestry and Arboriculture Literature (Jess Vogt, Richard J. Hauer, and Burnell C. Fischer, 2015) OPTIMAL PRUNING CYCLES AND COSTS OF DEFERRED MAINTENANCE AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 52 | P a g e An Optimal Pruning Cycle for Renton’s Public Trees As illustrated in the 2015 study for Milwaukee (Figure 24), a 5- to 7-year pruning cycle is the optimal intersection of efficiency and safety. If each public tree were to be maintained within a 5- to 7-year window, research shows the trees would be in a safer condition while limiting city expenses. Based on the analysis (Figure 24), a pruning cycle on a shorter timeframe has a higher cost to a city but does not correlate to a proportional increase in safety. Conversely, a longer timeframe lowers costs to a city, but also decreases tree safety. For Renton specifically, the pruning of public trees is on an estimated 37-year cycle based on an estimated 750 trees pruned per year and a total of 27,456 public street, park, and golf course trees (excludes 89,528 trees in natural areas). Numerous studies have shown the detrimental effects a delayed pruning cycle can have on a community’s tree population as well as the increased risks to public safety. Not pruning street trees or pruning on such a long rotation is referred to as deferred maintenance. The costs for deferred maintenance have been closely examined by researchers. Prolonged deferred maintenance has a triple negative effect on costs— it reduces the health and sustainability of the urban forest, it costs the residents and adjacent property owners as the associated benefits of trees are diminished as tree health declines, and costs the City in terms of increased callouts and liability management. Maintenance can be linked to tree success both at the beginning and end of its lifespan. Early in a tree’s life, during the establishment and immature (i.e., juvenile) phases, maintenance must be adequate to ensure early survival and establishment in the urban landscape. Presumably, any post-planting maintenance performed on a tree that improves its chances of survival to maturity or lengthens the time that tree spends in its mature phase (where benefits are produced in the greatest amount) increases the monetary value of that tree. The cost of not maintaining trees early in life may translate to greater maintenance costs down the road; this is deferring maintenance (and its costs) to the future in order to save on maintenance costs today. Later in a tree’s life, maintenance may aim to extend the tree’s lifespan or preve nt tree failure. In this way, late-stage maintenance can defer removal costs. If maintenance does prolong a tree’s useful life (i.e., delays the onset of senescence and a tree’s removal), it increases the amount of benefits it produces over its lifespan. Alternatively, removing the low-hanging limbs on an aging tree can prevent these limbs from failing and damaging people or property, and thereby avoid subsequent repair- or liability-related costs. Tree pruning to remove high-risk limbs and removal of the entire tree can be considered a type of maintenance that potentially saves money due to avoided litigation costs. With a complete inventory of the public tree population, the City should determine the costs and optimal schedule for pruning all public trees, specifically street trees, on a rotation. The following analysis is based on determining what funding may be needed to maintain the entire public tree population on a 7-year pruning cycle, to create a baseline for the City to measure its progression towards a sustainable urban forest. Based on a market comparison of the costs of program pruning, guidance for implementing programmed pruning is provided for street, park, and golf course trees (27,456 trees as of 2021). TREE HEALTH  SAFETY  COSTS ↑ PRUNING ROTATION ↑ Figure 25. As the years between street tree pruning increases, tree health and safety decrease and costs increase TIME → → → Impacts AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 53 | P a g e Table 15. Current and recommended maintenance regimen for Renton’s public tree population (street, park, golf course trees) Public Street, Park, and Golf Course Trees (2021) Total Tree Count 27,456 trees (2021) Annual Budget Tree Count Current Cycle (~37 Years) $134,000 750 per year trees per year 20-Year Cycle $247,104 1,373 $113,104 more cost 623 more trees 10-Year Cycle $494,208 2,746 $360,208 more cost 1,196 more trees 7-Year Cycle $706,011 3,922 per year trees per year 2 FTE In-House Arborist Crew (7.5-Year Cycle) 4,176 hours (2,088 each) per year 3,654 trees per year Cycle Gap between 37-Year & 7-Year Cycle $572,011 3,172 more per year more trees Table 16. Assumptions for estimating the additional costs to effectively maintain the public tree population Renton Estimate Industry Average Lowest Cost Estimate Highest Cost Estimate $179/tree $180/tree $70.35/tree $200/tree 3,172 more trees 3,172 more trees 3,172 more trees 3,172 more trees $566,782 $571,011 $233,170 $634,457 The tables above provide a summary of the costs to support programmed pruning of the public tree population. It should be noted that there are assumptions to the estimated costs for public tree maintenance. Table 15 above uses the estimated maintenance cost of $180 per tree based on market research and the City’s annual pruning budget ($134,000) and number of trees pruned (750). Also, the market research on costs for street tree maintenance found that the estimates are based on existing grid pruning programs that have been implemented for a number of years. The City of Renton largely has not been maintaining street trees on a recommended rotation. Therefore, the per tree cost for grid pruning in Renton may be greater in the first rotation due to deferred maintenance causing increased maintenance needs and associated time. For this study, the cost estimates detailed above are used and summarized in Table 16 for a 7-year rotational programmed pruning cycle compared to the current cycle and budget. The table includes intermediate cycles for consideration and include 20- and 10-year cycle estimates and all scenarios assume every public tree needs to be pruned at some point. A recommended programmed pruning cycle is typically five to seven years depending on the city’s size, number of trees, types of trees, history of programmed pruning, available funding, staffing resources, and other factors. For this study, a rotation of seven years is recommended. RECOMMENDED PUBLIC TREE PRUNING ROTATION AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 54 | P a g e Based on the local costs and industry estimates, the costs to pru ne one-seventh of the public street, park, and golf course tree population (27,456 trees) would increase by $572,011. This requires the pruning of 3,922 trees annually— 3,172 more trees than the current average. It should be noted that the costs associated with programmed pruning do not include the costs for tree removals among other management activities. Alternatively, if the City were to secure an in-house arborist crew, it is estimated a two-person (FTE) crew would be able to prune approximately 3,654 trees annually (based on working hours and average pruning time per tree). For two full-time arborists the costs for salary and fringe benefits equate to approximately $168,000 annually (not including costs for fleet, operation and maintenance, or gear). This Plan recognizes the need for increased staffing in order to reach optimal pruning rotations. The Urban Forestry Program Staffing to Support Sustainable Management section details the necessary staff and added costs. To summarize the analysis and calculations, 27,456 trees are along streets, in maintained areas of parks, or on the Maplewood Golf Course. A 7-year pruning cycle requires 3,922 trees to be pruned annually. Using the industry average of $180 per tree, the City would need a total annual budget of $706,011 to maintain this pruning rotation if it were to contract tree pruning, but with a two-person (FTE) in-house arborist crew, a 7.5-year pruning cycle can be achieved. The cost estimates for pruning do not account for the maintenance and management of the 89,528 trees in natural areas that occurs primarily along the wildland-urban interface and trails in the form of storm damage cleanup and removals. Priority Maintenance Corridors A complete overhaul of the public tree maintenance budget and the necessary staff to support a 7-year pruning rotation should be implemented using a phased approach. It is recommended the City identify priority roadways and neighborhoods for public tree maintenance based on density of trees in the rights-of-way, condition and maintenance history of trees, frequency of disadvantaged communities (e.g., lower than median income, housing value, and other factors), planned roadway construction, density of tree species requiring frequent maintenance, among other factors. The following map provides an example of the potential priority street corridors for the City to consider to incrementally implement the 7-year pruning rotation. These corridors can also be the starting point for establishing the framework of the in-house arborist crew. The priority streets were identified using the public tree inventory dataset, the Tree Equity Scores of Census Block Groups, and the tree canopy cover within each Community Planning Area. All Community Planning Areas except for Cedar River and Kennydale have Census Block Groups with a Tree Equity Score that is less than the recommended 80 out of 100. A total of 19 priority street corridors were identified. Based on this prioritization, approximately 2,626 trees would be maintained in the first cycle of proactive maintenance with 1,027 trees in City Center, 497 trees in Cedar River, 313 trees in Kennydale, 308 trees in Highlands, 197 trees in East Plateau, 194 trees in Valley, 40 trees in Benson, 35 trees in West Hill, and 15 trees in Talbot (Table 17). Given the large number of trees in City Center’s priority streets, the Urban Forestry Program may decide to address only the trees in City Center rather than address all trees across Community Planning Areas until adequate funding is secured. Tree maintenance should be addressed in these areas first— as funding permits— until adequate funding is secured and the in-house arborist crew is established. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 55 | P a g e Figure 26. Recommended priority tree maintenance by street corridor and planning area │ Priority Tree Maintenance Street 0 – 63 Tree Equity Score 64 – 79 Tree Equity Score Community Planning Areas ● Public trees Tree points on map are a sample. Map does not depict every public tree in the inventory database RECOMMENDED PRIORITY PUBLIC TREE MAINTENANCE CORRIDORS AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 56 | P a g e Table 17. Recommended streets for priority tree maintenance by Community Planning Area Community Planning Area Priority Street Corridor Tree Count Valley SW 34th St Oakesdale Ave SW Lind Ave SW 108 trees 26 trees 60 trees Talbot Shattuck Ave S 15 trees Benson SE 164th St 40 trees Cedar River (No low TES areas) Maple Valley Hwy 497 trees East Plateau Hoquiam Ave NE 156th Ave SE Duvall Ave NE 86 trees 19 trees 92 trees Highlands NE Sunset Blvd NE 4th St 154 trees 154 trees Kennydale (No low TES areas) Aberdeen Ave NE 313 trees West Hill Stevens Ave NW 35 trees City Center W Perimeter Rd Logan Ave N S Grady Way Rainier Ave N Rainier Ave S 2 2nd St 380 trees 281 trees 113 trees 33 trees 125 trees 95 trees Tree Count Total 2,626 trees Public Tree Maintenance Recommendations The Urban Forestry Program should continue to maintain its inventory of public trees to prioritize tree maintenance and removals and to inform future tree plantings. Nearly half of the public tree population’s overall health is in fair condition and only a third is in good condition. Shortening the pruning cycle for all public trees would likely improve the condition of the trees, reduce clearance issues, and improve public safety. A 7-year pruning cycle is the optimal rotation. A shorter timeframe has a higher cost to a city but does not correlate to a proportional increase in safety. Conversely, a longer timeframe lowers costs to a city, but also decreases tree health, public safety, and depletes urban forest ecosystem benefits. A 7-year pruning cycle would require the pruning of 3,922 trees per year— an increase of 3,172 trees compared to Renton’s current average number of trees pruned annually. The total annual budget required for a 7-year pruning cycle is estimated at $706,011 if contracted and does not include the maintenance and management of trees in natural areas. An in-house arborist crew of two full- time employees would cost the City $168,000 annually for salary and fringe benefits (not including fleet, gear, or operations and maintenance costs) and the staff would be able to prune the 27,456 street, park, and golf course trees on a 7.5-year cycle. It is recommended the City make incrementally progress towards a 7-year pruning cycle by prioritizing street corridors in each of the City’s Community Planning Areas and prune as many trees as the budget allows. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 57 | P a g e URBAN FORESTRY PROGRAM STAFFING TO SUPPORT SUSTAINABLE MANAGEMENT When it comes to program staffing, many cities struggle with the issue of being understaffed. The programs may be fulfilling their duties within the limited staffing and resources but they are not performing services that fully capture sustainable urban forest management. Determining and maintaining optimal staffing levels is critical to a program’s efficiency. Optimal staffing depends on several factors including number of public trees, authority and responsibility defined in municipal code, internal and external expectations, customer service (i.e., the public), operations, and existing programs. The concept of being understaffed also plays a critical role in employees’ behaviors, attitudes, and directly affects individual productivity. If a program is understaffed, it typically encounters excess overtime, morale issues, absenteeism, employee burnout, and have a difficulty with relief coverage and training requirements. One of the most effective techniques for a city to utilize in determining the optimal staffing level is to complete an area workload assessment by looking at the number of public trees managed divided by the total number of staff and using the ratio as a comparison to industry standards and averages for communities of similar size. The following section provides this analysis and a recommendation for optimal staffing. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 58 | P a g e Urban Forestry Program Staffing Levels Compared to Industry Recommendations The number of staff available to perform annual tree maintenance, inspections, and ordinance / policy enforcement is a critical element of a sustainable forest. To measure whether staffing is at a level where sustainable management can occur, the ratio of staff to the number of public trees is often used. Based on research and industry standards, the optimal ratio for public tree maintenance is 1 staff for every 2,000 trees. A less aggressive ratio of 1 staff for every 10,000 trees is also found in the research. But, according to the 2014 Urban and Community Forestry Census of Tree Activities (Hauer et al. 2014), communities with a population between 100,000 to 249,000 people have an average of 11.8 full-time employees for urban forest management (tree maintenance and all other services). Communities with a population of 50,000 to 99,999 people have an average of 6.3 full-time employees. For Renton, assuming all tree maintenance would be done in-house rather than contracted, the Urban Forestry Program’s arborist crew should contain at least two staff (1 staff for every 10,000 trees managed of 27,456 street and park trees). Currently, the Urban Forestry Program has a total of 2.50 full-time employees consisting of the full-time Urban Forestry and Natural Resources Manager (1.00), a full-time Contracted Inspecting Arborist (1.00), a part-time Supervisor (0.25), and a part-time Administrator (0.25). It is assumed the City would still need to contract very large tree removals. Alternatively, the City may continue to contract tree maintenance and removals but supplement the program with one arborist crew on a less rigorous tree pruning cycle. With the contracted tree maintenance budget and one arborist crew, the public tree population (street and park trees) could be pruned on a 7-year rotation. This would require a total of two arborists though it is recommended a crew supervisor and a seasonal staff member also be considered in the future. The estimated costs for salaries, fleet/equipment, operation and maintenance, and gear are provided in the following table. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 59 | P a g e Table 18. Estimated staff and associated costs to maintain public trees on a 7-year rotation Recommended Staff Hours per Staff Cost per Hr per FTE # of New Staff Total Cost Estimated Cost per Staff B) Arborist 2,088 $40.23 2 $168,000 $84,000 Subtotal -- -- 2 $168,000 $84,000 Equipment Hours Cost/Unit # of Units Total Cost Annual Cost F350 or equivalent pickup with dump bed, flasher kit, extended cab, HD tow kit 1 $60,000 1 $60,000 -- F350 Pickup hours (O&M) 1,000 $16.94 1,000 -- $16,940 Vermeer 1800 brush chipper with winch 1 $55,000 1 $55,000 -- Chipper hours (O&M) 1,000 $16.94 1,000 -- $16,940 Terex High Ranger bucket truck with 60+ foot boom length 1 $250,000 1 $250,000 -- Bucket truck hours (O&M) 1,000 $16.94 1,000 -- $16,940 Mid-size Vermeer stump grinder SC 382 or equivalent 1 $30,000 1 $30,000 Stump grinder hours (O&M) 1,000 $16.94 1,000 -- $16,940 Heavy duty equipment trailer Capable of hauling trees or stump grinder 1 $10,000 1 $10,000 Equipment trailer hours (O&M) 1,000 $16.94 1,000 -- $16,940 Watering rig (500+ gal) Palettized or tow-behind, with pump and hose reels 1 $2,000 1 $2,000 Watering rig hours (O&M) 1,000 $16.94 1,000 -- $16,940 Subtotal -- -- -- $410,000 $101,640 Gear Hours Cost/Unit # of Units Total Cost Annual Cost PPE -- $200 2 $400 $150 Uniforms -- $250 2 $500 $188 Chainsaw -- $800 2 $1,600 $400 Rake -- $25 2 $50 $13 Shovel -- $25 2 $50 $13 Brush Bucket -- $40 2 $80 $20 Cart -- $50 2 $100 $25 Other (e.g. blower) -- $500 2 $1,000 $250 Subtotal -- -- 16 $3,780 $1,058 TOTAL COST $581,780 ANNUAL COST $270,698 Table 19. Summary of costs Line Item Cost Annual Staff Cost $168,000 Vehicle and Equipment Purchase $410,780 Annual Operating Costs (supplies, clothing, equipment, rental, etc.) $102,698 Annual Training, Certifications, and Membership Costs $2,000 AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 60 | P a g e Urban Forestry Program Staffing Recommendations Based on the needs of Renton’s public tree population, industry standards, and benchmarking research of analogous communities, it is recommended the City secure an in-house arborist crew of two arborists and consider supporting the crew with a crew supervisor and seasonal technician in the future. This recommendation is in alignment with the Task Force’s recommendation in the 2009 Urban and Community Forestry Development Plan. This would enable the City to prune the public street and park tree population on a 7-year rotation (3,900 trees per year). With an in-house crew, the budget for contracted tree maintenance and removals should be focused on annual large tree removals (300 per year on average) and other contracted services outside of routine tree maintenance. The estimated initial cost for an in-house arborist crew including fleet, equipment, and gear is $581,780 with an annual cost of $270,698 (plus an additional $2,000 for annual trainings, certifications, and membership costs). The annual cost accounts for salary and fringe benefits, equipment operation and maintenance (O&M) costs, and gear replacement. The 2009 Task Force agreed on the importance of a dedicated full-time city arborist crew. The greatest advantages of an in-house crew are in relation to emergency storm damage response and accomplishing tree work for other emergency situations when contract crews are unavailable. The arborist crew would prune all street and park trees on a 7 -year rotation and would also be responsible for the management of all trees on public grounds— street, park, properties, and natural areas. Other City crews could supplement the arborist crews for special projects such as pruning trees along sweeper routes in the winter using Public Works staff . The arborist crew would provide support for other nontree related activities whenever their equipment might be needed such as assisting Public Works with installing banners or backing- up other City departments such as Parks & Trails crews when needed. The Funding Mechanisms section of the Plan provides considerations for funding the in -house arborist crew. It is recommended the City explore feasible near-term feasible such as using approximately 75% of the operating budget to fund the two new FTEs and convert ing the inspecting arborist contract ($157,000) to a further FTE. The City’s ARPA (American Rescue Plan Act, 2021) funds could potentially support the fleet for the arborist crew. As shown in the table below, to achieve a 7-year pruning cycle for public trees, the City can deploy an in-house arborist crew of two full-time employees and reduce costs compared to contracting all programmed pruning. Table 20. Comparison of in-house and contracted pruning for a 7-year public tree pruning cycle In-House Arborist Crew Contracted Difference Annual Public Tree Pruning (~3,900 trees/year) $272,698 $705,960 ($433,262) AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 61 | P a g e Program Budget Final Recommendations In the Urban Forest Management Plan, guidance for proactively pruning public trees on a 7-year cycle, establishing an in-house arborist crew, finalizing tree canopy goals, and achieving planting targets is provided. To accomplish these recommendations that improve overall urban forest sustainability and tree equity across neighborhoods, the City should evaluate its current and necessary budgets for the Urban Forestry Program. The following table outlines the potential costs and the budget necessary to support full implementation of the Plan: Table 21. Summary of the current and future Urban Forestry Program services and budgets Line Item Current Annual Budget Future Annual Budget Future Budget Notes Purchasing Trees & Related Planting Supplies $15,000 $85,500 570 trees per year at $150/tree Planting Trees $35,000 -- Led in-house Contract Pruning $134,000 $134,000 Contractor support Pest Management $5,000 $5,000 Continued management Removal $85,000 $85,000 Contractor-led Storm Damage On-Call / Debris Clean Up $70,000 $70,000 In-house support Professional Services $100,000 $100,000 May reduce until new services needed (e.g., updated inventory and management plan) Contract Landscape Watering $100,000 $100,000 Continued management Consulting Arborist Inspection Services $157,000 $157,000 Continued management Administration $250,000 $256,309 Adjusted for 2022 (see Table 9) In-House Arborist Crew Annual Cost -- $272,698 ~3,900 trees pruned/year, includes salary, fringe, and O&M costs TOTALS $951,000 $1,265,507 $314,507 increase from 2021 The table above summarizes the 2021 Urban Forestry Program budget and services compared to the recommended budget for planting, in-house maintenance, and all other services listed. To achieve the long-term tree canopy goal of 33%, a total of 570 City-led plantings are needed which can be completed in-house with the new arborist crew. Given the in-house arborist crew would prune approximately 3,900 public trees per year for a 7-year pruning cycle, it is likely the Contract Pruning budget could be reduced and the rate of removals will likely decrease due to enhanced maintenance. In addition, the Professional Services budget may decrease until updated services are needed such as an updated public tree inventory and updates to this management plan. Lastly, the Contract Landscape Watering budget may decrease since it is recommended the City purchase a watering rig for the in-house arborist crew. With the budgets listed in the table above, there is an overall budget increase in the amount of $314,507, but as stated earlier, the amount of increase may be reduced by adjusting budgets of particular line items. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 62 | P a g e WORKFLOWS AND STANDARD OPERATING PROCEDURES Consistent protocols are needed for impervious surface conflicts, sidewalks specifically, along with budgetary considerations. Poor historic tree species selection, the growth of the trees, and the size of some planting sites has resulted in multiple locations around the City where the infrastructure conflict is a result of the trees outgrowing their space causing surface upheaval and basal flare. Currently, neither Urban Forestry nor Public Works has the means in terms of staffing or resources to deal with replacing all the trees and sidewalks on their own, but the mandate by the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) to eliminate all sidewalk hazards remains. Updated protocols between Public Works, Parks & Trails crews, and the Urban Forestry Program are needed where the conflict is addressed using a joint approach. Updated protocols would require a dedicated fund. The City of Renton Walkway Program provides for the removal and replacement of existing curb and gutter, sidewalks, and curb ramps, where such facilities have deteriorated or have been damaged and is also responsible for new installations. There are many older neighborhoods with damaged or deteriorated infrastructure or lacking curb ramps up to current ADA standards. These deficiencies are being addressed by this program to provide safe and convenient non-motorized facilities for pedestrians but the funding averages $250,000 which is less than adequate to fully comply with ADA requirements. More recent assessments of meeting needs for compliance are substantial. Impacts of other infrastructure upgrades, such as widening lanes for buses, which impact street trees should be more thoughtfully planned and designed. It is not a sustainable practice to simply remove mature trees and replant on a one for one basis. The management practice to actively address hazards within the public right-of-way by repairing sidewalks and removing and replacing trees as needed is important to provide mobility throughout the City and maintain canopy cover. Often, root pruning is the main approach to preserve a tree and fix a sidewalk, but this practice comes with the potential to impact tree health and tree longevity. If a tree cannot be safely preserved after root pruning, it requires removal. However, alternative materials and methods are becoming more common to repair sidewalk issues in lieu of tree removal. New sidewalk materials and technologies can be used that reinforce the structural integrity of concrete to allow tree roots to grow underneath sidewalks and increase useful longevity like suspended pavement systems and structural soils. In some cases, tree planting areas can be expanded to allow more growing space like meandering sidewalks, bulb-outs, or increased tree well sizes. All of these methods should be within the solutions “toolbox” before tree removal is allowed, but they are not all currently codified as available City options and agreed upon by City staff as acceptable City standards. Therefore, Appendix B, provides the draft framework for tree and sidewalk conflicts and alternative solutions for the City to consider. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 63 | P a g e Recommendations for Tree and Sidewalk Conflicts The City should formally adopt the decision checklist and protocols provided in Appendix B and include alternative solutions in design guidelines and standards. Alternative solutions may offer cost savings in some instances though generally, the City’s Walkway Program is underfunded. In most Washington cities that are responsible for sidewalk repair and replacement, funding comes from the General Fund or through a ballot-approved Sales and Use Tax. Sales tax rates for funding sidewalk programs average 0.2%. In Seattle, the responsibility is placed on the adjacent property owner but the “Levy to Move Seattle” was approved by voters in 2015 to help fund sidewalk maintenance and improvement projects. In addition to local funds, Seattle also seeks state or federal grants. Grant funding may be available for sidewalk repair but is not a consistent long-term option. One local example of a grant to fund the program is in Sumner where Sound Transit is funding sidewalk replacements as part of their station access improvement grant, costing approximately $1.4 million. Other funding options or mechanisms include special citywide assessments, bonds, improvement districts, gas tax, or tax incremental financing. In Cheney, a voter-approved tax on electrical and natural gas services funds maintenance of residential streets and sidewalks. The 4% electric and natural gas tax generates roughly $380,000 annually. Whenever new development triggers frontage improvements there are opportunities for improved street tree planting and would be an appropriate time to levy enhanced use fees. The City should explore these options such as the Sales and Use Tax option if General Funding is not available to fully cover sidewalk repair and replacement per ADA requirements. The alternative is to place the responsibility of sidewalk repair and replacement on the adjacent property owner. This option may not sit well with property owners and would likely require a permitting system. An example is in Seattle again where it is the property owner’s responsibility unless the sidewalk damage is caused by City infrastructure such as a City-owned tree or sewer line. In this scenario, the City takes the responsibility for making the repairs. Source: City of Renton, WA 2009 Urban and Community Forestry Development Plan AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 64 | P a g e TREE CANOPY COVER GOALS To guide efforts towards the urban forest vision, communities with tree canopy assessment data often set tree canopy cover goals based on the existing tree canopy cover amount and the aim to provide an equitable distribution of canopy cover and associated benefits. For Renton, the planning consultants conducted an analysis of tree canopy cover data and Tree Equity Scores (TreeEquityScore.org) to develop draft canopy goals that would increase canopy cover and address tree equity. This section provides the guidance to refine the goals, establish incremental targets, and formally adopt a Citywide canopy goal that is shared by the City, its partners, and all property owners within Renton. Progress towards these canopy goals should be tracked, measured, and shared to guide urban forest management and maintain community interest and support. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 65 | P a g e Canopy Goals – Purpose and Approach Across the U.S., cities are setting goals— some based on careful study of current canopy, community needs, and availability of planting space, other base their goals on the principle that more trees are better than fewer, set ambitious campaign goals, then work to mobilize efforts to meet it. Generally, the U.S. Forest Service recommends canopy cover of 40-60% in northwestern communities and in 1997, the American Forests organization established a benchmark of 40% after analyzing the tree canopy in dozens of cities from 1992 to 1997 and working closely with the research community. While incredibly valuable and groundbreaking at the time, technology and research have significantly evolved over the past 20 years, leading to a consensus that more nuanced approaches to canopy goal setting are necessary. Supporting this statement, U.S. Forest Service Research Forester Greg McPherson of the Pacific Southwest Research Station adds, “Tree canopy cover targets are difficult to specify broadly because the opportunities to create canopy are highly variable among cities, even within a climatic region or land use class.” Tree canopy targets are best developed for specific cities and should consider constraints to creating canopy such as: ❖ Development densities (i.e., dense development patterns with more impervious surfaces have less opportunity for cover); ❖ Land use patterns (i.e., residential areas may have more opportunity for canopy than commercial areas, but canopy cover tends to be less in residential areas of disadvantaged communities versus wealthy ones); ❖ Ordinances (i.e., parking lot shade ordinances promote cover over some impervious areas); and ❖ Climate (i.e., canopy cover in desert cities is often less than tropical cities). Within those parameters, quantifiable data can be used so a tree canopy goal achieves specific objectives, such as reaching the canopy percentage necessary to reduce urban h eat island temperatures to a specific range, or to reduce stormwater runoff by a projected amount. According to a national analysis by U.S. Forest Service researchers, a 40-60% urban tree canopy is attainable under ideal conditions in forested states. 20% in grassland cities and 15% in desert cities are realistic baseline targets, with higher percentages possible through greater investment and prioritization. It is important to note, however, that urban tree canopy percentage is just one of many criteria to consider. A robust tree canopy comprised of largely invasive species, for example, is not a healthy urban forest. Age and species diversity, condition of trees and equitable distribution across income levels, to name a few, should also be considered (Leahy, American Forests, 2017). Citywide and Zoning Type Tree Canopy Goals The following presents the proposed canopy goals though the City and partners should evaluate and refine these for approval by staff and City Council. For the City of Renton, the development of canopy goals was driven by tree canopy cover data, benchmarking research, Tree Equity Scores, analysis of existing and potential resources, City input, and community feedback. Using this integrated approach, the City of Renton’s ambitious and achievable goal is 33% tree canopy cover in 20 years (2042), with an intermediate goal of 30% by 2032. To achieve this, the City must preserve the existing canopy and increase its coverage by four percent, up from 29%, and plant approximately 950 trees annually or a total of 19,000 trees. These new trees would collectively grow the canopy throughout the City to an area equivalent to nearly 415 football fields and would provide additional ecosystem services and benefits in the amount of AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 66 | P a g e approximately $215,000 annually. These calculations and estimates are based on industry research and practices though there are some assumptions including; ❖ A no-net-loss strategy, meaning the number of public trees removed along with removals on private property or through development are replaced. ❖ Trees that mature into large canopy-bearing trees are planted wherever feasible. Calculations use an average tree canopy diameter of 40 feet equating to a surface area of 1,257 square feet. ❖ Includes City-led, partner, volunteer, and private tree plantings. In this study and canopy goal scenario, it is recommended the City plant 60% of the necessary trees or approximately 570 trees per year. ❖ The City only has approximately 1,700 public street planting sites available as of the 2021 inventory so new planting sites will need to be created by converting impervious surfaces to planting sites and/or planting in parks and natural areas. ❖ Assumes a potential for young tree mortality post-planting. Within the framework of this Urban Forest Management Plan 10-year Update, an intermediate tree canopy cover goal after year 10 was also drafted. By the end of the year 2032, if the City as a whole were to plant 525 trees each year for 10 years, a total of 5,250 trees would be planted resulting in an increase in canopy to 30%, up from 29% currently. Again, using the 60-40 split regarding tree planting numbers and allocation, the City would plant 3,150 trees in 10 years. The overall added benefit from City-, partner-, and community-led plantings after year 10 is estimated at nearly $60,000 annually once the trees are all established. To achieve these goals, the existing tree canopy must be preserved through policy enforcement, property owner education, proper tree maintenance, pest and disease management, soil conservation/protection, and urban forestry oversight on site designs and plans. The following provides the calculated process of establishing the 20-year canopy goal for Renton: The amount of tree canopy cover and available planting space was analyzed by City Zoning Type and Community Planning Area. A percentage of total possible planting area (vegetative and impervious) to be planted was assigned to each Zoning Type and Community Planning Area based on the total amount of plantable space, the existing canopy, limitations of the Zoning Type/Planning Area, available resources, and other City needs. This approach realizes the unique opportunities, limitations, extent, resources, and characteristics found among various city zoning classes and planning areas. Canopy goals and planting targets must not be standardized across the City, they should be specific to the area. This method was applied and summarized in the following table. 2017 2022 2032 2042 29% 30% 33% 5,250 trees 19,000 trees Figure 27. Renton's 10-year and 20-year canopy goals PROPOSED TREE CANOPY COVER GOALS 27% AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 67 | P a g e Table 22. Long-term tree canopy goals (by 2042) and planting targets by Community Planning Area Community Planning Area Total Possible Planting Area (%) % of Total Possible Planting Area to be Planted Modeled Canopy % (% of Total PPA) Number of Trees to Reach Goal Annual Added (Net) Eco- Benefits ($) Benson 19% 15% 33% 2,868 $32,525 Cedar River 17% 15% 49% 1,094 $12,407 City Center 22% 20% 18% 2,933 $33,262 East Plateau 18% 20% 33% 1,666 $18,891 Highlands 17% 15% 28% 2,470 $28,011 Kennydale 24% 20% 38% 1,795 $20,360 Talbot 26% 20% 44% 2,578 $29,233 Valley 19% 20% 33% 2,570 $29,148 West Hill 33% 20% 38% 877 $9,947 TOTAL 33% 18,852 $213,783 24% 17% 22% 33% 19% 18% 17% 19% 26% Figure 28. Map displaying the Possible Planting Area by Community Planning Area and an example of PPA planting targets in Highlands PLANTING TARGETS TO IDENTIFY CANOPY GOALS AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 68 | P a g e Priority Planting Areas to Achieve Canopy Goals and Tree Equity Once the City finalizes local and Citywide tree canopy goals, it is recommended to establish priority areas based on a variety of themes and community needs. Themes may include ownership type (public and private), areas of low existing tree canopy, Tree Equity Scores (TreeEquityScore.org), and greatest amount of available planting space while other themes may address air quality, stormwater reduction, and water quality. Others may evaluate opportunities to address disadvantaged areas, densely populated regions, and human health factors such as asthma cases, median age, and mental health. In any planting prioritization scenario, the scale may include U.S. Census Bureau Census Block Groups, Zoning Type, Community Planning Areas, and Citywide. Using the 2018 Tree Canopy Assessment, the regional TreePlotter CANOPY software application (pg-cloud.com/KingCD-Cities), and analyses in a Geographic Information System (GIS), a series of recommended prioritization techniques is provided. The description of the prioritization techniques and scenarios is provided below followed by a series of corresponding priority maps. ❖ Census Block Groups (CBGs) with the greatest possible planting area. CBGs with the highest percent of total area available for possible planting. Includes vegetative and impervious possible planting areas. ❖ CBGs with low amounts of tree canopy cover. CBGs with the lowest percentage of existing tree canopy cover. ❖ Tree planting in Census Blocks to reduce stormwater runoff. Trees can be integrated to help manage stormwater, specifically when targeting impervious surfaces. This indicator uses available planting area on impervious surfaces and available planting areas within 100 feet of all surface water bodies. ❖ Tree planting in neighborhoods with high populations of minorities. Tree canopy is negatively correlated with the percentage of minority residents. Planting trees in communities with higher percentages of minority residents can support environmental equity. ❖ Tree planting in neighborhoods with underserved populations. Tree canopy is positively correlated with higher median income. Planting trees in lower income communities can support environmental equity. CBG suitability is based on the percentage of residents living below the poverty level. View the maps on the following pages for examples of the listed planting priority techniques. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 69 | P a g e Priority Planting Areas: Addressing Available Planting Space Suitability Very High High Medium Figure 29. Map displaying the Census Block Groups most suitable for trees due to high possible planting area AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 70 | P a g e Figure 30. Map displaying the Census Block Groups with the lowest existing tree canopy cover Priority Planting Areas: Addressing Low Existing Tree Canopy Cover Suitability Very High High Medium AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 71 | P a g e Figure 31. Map displaying Census Block Groups most suitable for tree plantings to address stormwater runoff Priority Planting Areas: Addressing Stormwater Runoff Suitability Very High High Medium AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 72 | P a g e Figure 32. Map displaying higher concentrations of minority populations for increasing tree canopy cover Priority Planting Areas: Addressing Tree Cover in Minority Neighborhoods Suitability Very High High Medium AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 73 | P a g e Figure 33. Map displaying Census Block Groups with underserved populations for increasing tree canopy cover Priority Planting Areas: Addressing Tree Cover in Underserved Neighborhoods Suitability Very High High Medium AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 74 | P a g e Recommendations for Tree Canopy Cover Goals Cities around the world are using tree canopy goals, usually in the form of percent tree canopy cover, to guide urban forest management and meaningfully improve the livability of their communities. Urban tree canopy (UTC) is ideal for goal setting because it can represent the complex distribution and benefits of an urban forest within a single metric. Urban tree canopy goals must walk a careful line of ambition, inspiration, and practicality. Measuring, tracking, and improving urban tree canopies is an essential component of sustainable urban living. As the world’s population continues to urbanize the value of healthy UTC is only going up. Unfortunately, the global urban canopy trend is moving in the opposite direction. A worldwide analysis showed urban forest cover on average is slightly, but significantly decreasing. The United States is also losing urban tree canopy, to the tune of 175,000 acres or 36 million trees a year. That represents a loss of $96 million in tree benefits a year, and those benefits, like heat reduction and public health improvements, are growing in necessity. Urban tree canopies are in perpetual motion as growth and regeneration push against destructive forces, both natural and anthropogenic. These include development expansion, old age, disease, pests, and fire. Reversing this course starts with knowing the extent of the urban tree canopy and then establishing a goal for growth. “By knowing the amount of and direction in which urban tree cover is moving, urban forest management plans can be developed to provide desired levels of urban tree cover and forest benefits for current and future generations.” (Nowak, et al. 2018) For Renton, before setting and adopting a tree canopy cover goal, the current coverage must be understood using the latest Urban Tree Canopy assessment. The 2018 UTC assessment provides the baseline data for the urban forestry consultants and the City to establish recommended canopy goals and tree planting priorities or targets. Based on the assessment data, City input, community feedback, and benchmarking research the recommended tree canopy goals for the City of Renton are provided in the following table: Table 23. Summary of the recommended tree canopy goals and planting targets for Renton Goal Metric Current Canopy (2017) Short-Term Canopy Goal Long-Term Canopy Goal Canopy % 29% 30% 33% Goal Year -- 2032 2042 Total Trees to Reach Goal City-Led -- 3,150 11,400 Public-Led -- 2,100 7,600 Total Trees -- 5,250 19,000 Total Trees per Year to Reach Goal City-Led -- 315 570 Public-Led -- 210 380 Total Trees per Year -- 525 950 Future Added Benefits -- $60,000 $215,000 UTC assessments should be a periodic process and research recommends conducted follow up assessments every 5 to 8 years to track canopy change, assess performance, and adapt priorities to changing needs and budgets. Tree planting priority areas should be revisited annually and informed by the public, new data, analysis, available resources, and other factors. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 75 | P a g e TREE PLANTING INITIATIVE Tree planting is critical to the health and longevity of Renton’s urban forest. However, tree planting should be methodically planned with a specific purpose in mind. One of the best ways to do this is to define and adopt an official planting initiative guided by a planting strategy. The first step in developing a planting strategy is to define the goals. Often times, this goal aligns with a citywide tree canopy cover goal and the timeframe to achieve it. An effective tree planting initiative and program address three main questions: where to plant, what to plant, and how to plant? It is important to develop an overall planting strategy where the initial planting efforts are concentrated on streets and areas with the greatest need for improvement. Tree species and planting location designations are significant components of a municipal tree care program because of the long-term impact of these decisions. Success of a continuing tree planting program will be judged by the health of the trees after planting and the amount of money spent on planting and maintaining the new trees. With a small amount of planning, healthy trees with greater life expectancy can be established with minimal up-front investment and relatively minor maintenance costs. This Tree Planting Initiative provides guidelines for the implementation of an organized and comprehensive tree planting strategy that results in the prioritization of tree planting locations and the expansion of Renton’s urban tree canopy within the confines of available resources. Information on suitable planting locations in the City is provided in the previous section and general recommendations on choosing suitable trees for each site follow. Where to Plant There are numerous opportunities to plant more trees on public property in the City of Renton. Historically, the locations of new tree plantings on City-owned rights-of-way in Renton have been based on constituent requests, the replacement of dead or dying trees (where feasible), and project-specific plantings (e.g., streetscape improvement projects). With the updated tree inventory, City managers now also know the exact location of additional planting sites that are available throughout the City. Renton’s street and park tree inventory includes 1,789 available planting sites as of January 2021. Moreover, the development of a prioritization scheme based on canopy data allows the City to begin significant tree planting efforts in high priority areas of the City. According to the January 2021 inventory analysis report, the current stocking level is 93.5%, based on a total 27,561 suitable planting sites, including 25,772 trees, 1,315 vacant sites, and 474 stumps. “Stocking” is a traditional forestry term used to measure the density and distribution of trees. In this case it means that, of the total number of available planting sites identified in the tree inventory along the public right-of-way, 93.5% currently have a tree present. Note that this value only considers the currently available planting areas along the street right-of-way, and not impervious surfaces that could become planting locations. Moreover, this value does not incorporate potential planting locations in parks or other civic spaces. Of the total public trees in the inventory, 724 trees were recommended for removal (in 2021 inventory analysis report). These recommended removals represent a future increase in total number of potential planting sites. An important benchmark in maintaining a sustainable urban forest is to keep it at least 90% stocked, such that no more than 10% of the existing planting sites remain vacant. The City should make every effort to budget for tree planting in the future to maintain the urban forest at least 90% stocked and to continue increasing its canopy. Planting locations throughout the City were identified and prioritized as part of the urban tree canopy analysis (Priority Planting Areas to Achieve Canopy Goals and Tree Equity Section). Potential planting locations included all viable areas of the City that were classified as grass/open space, impervious (parking lots), and bare ground in the urban tree canopy analysis. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 76 | P a g e Tree Planting Parameters Trees are an important part of the City, but they must coexist with various other aspects of the built environment. To provide ample space for a growing tree while also maintaining public safety and protecting other City infrastructure, the City should use the following minimum guidelines when choosing new planting locations: ❖ New tree wells in existing sidewalks provide a minimum of 18 square feet of open soil (ex. a 3’ x 6’ tree well). ❖ New tree wells in new sidewalks should provide a minimum of 36 square feet of open soil (ex. a 6’ x 6’ tree well), and at least 1,000 gross cubic feet of soil value space for each tree, providing any soil volume under paved surfaces through suspended pavements or structural cells. ❖ To reduce infrastructure conflicts and maintain visibility and access to important public safety features, trees should be planted a minimum of: o 20 feet away from any intersection, crosswalk, or stop sign; o 5 feet away from any fire hydrant or utility pole; o 10 feet from any streetlight; o 3 feet from any driveway or walkway; and o 1 foot away from any underground utilities (ex. gas and water). o The width of the sidewalk must also be taken into account, as per American with Disabilities Act (ADA) regulations a 3 foot sidewalk width must remain. o Trees must be spaced out in such a way that they have room to grow. Trees are spaced at least 20 feet on center (i.e., measured trunk to trunk). What to Plant The City must determine which tree species will be planted in each specific site. The phrase “right tree, right place” is the most important concept in planting. Many factors must be considered in choosing a species for a site that maximizes the health and survivability of the tree, and the benefits provided by that tree. Trees in urban environments must withstand particularly challenging conditions, such as high temperatures, drought, flooding, air pollution, soil salt, and limited growing space both above and below ground. Trees have different characteristics suitable for different landscapes, sites, and microclimates. It is recommended that all characteristics be recognized, including, but not limited to, the desired function (e.g., seasonal flowering, shade canopy, wind resistance), mature size and shape for the intended location, soil conditions, root structure, maintenance requirements, potential pest problems, and survivability in the face of climate change. Equally important to selecting the right tree is choosing the right spot to plant it. Blocking an unsightly view or creating shade may be a priority, but it is important to also consider how a tree may impact existing structures and utilities as it grows taller, wider, and deeper. For example, if the tree’s canopy, at maturity, will reach overhead utility lines, it is best to choose another tree or a different location. Taking the time to consider location before planting can prevent power disturbances and improper utility pruning practices. Historically, there has been some mismatch of tree species selection with available planting sites in Renton. There are some large growing trees under power lines, and there are some small growing trees planted in sites suitable for larger trees. Large trees in small spaces can damage sidewalks and curbs, require severe pruning for overhead utility lines and street clearance, and often have a much shorter service life due to the restricted growing area. Small trees in large spaces limit the use of mature shade trees on public streets. It is well known that larger growing trees provide the most environmental and economic benefits, and appropriate areas to plant AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 77 | P a g e them rarely exist in older, well developed communities. Proactive planning should be made to plant the “right tree in the right place” in the vacant sites, considering available growing space, presence of utilities, and traffic and pedestrian clearance issues, while obtaining the desired aesthetic effects and function of the street tree. Planting the proper type of tree for each planting area will result in a more effective, healthy, and attractive urban forest. Tree Species Diversity At the scale of the entire urban forest, species diversity in new plantings should be of major importance. Planting a variety of species can decrease the impact of species-specific pests and diseases by limiting the number of susceptible trees in a population. Moreover, planting a wide variety of tree species can help limit the impacts from physical events, as different tree species react differently to stress. Species diversity helps withstand urban forest impacts from drought, ice, flooding, strong storms, and wind. As stated in the Structure of the Public Tree Population section, at the genus level, maples (Acer) account for 27% of the total public tree population and bigleaf maples and Douglas-firs exceed the 10% threshold with 15% and 11% respectively. The dangers of planting monocultures have proven to be devastating. One of Renton’s goals should be to increase species diversity throughout the City, such that no species represents more than 10% and that no one genus comprises more than 20% of the population. Consideration should be given to large trees that provide shade, are aesthetically pleasing, and provide food or habitat for native insects and wildlife. Although the City should consider focusing efforts on planting species that are native to the region, particularly in the face of climate change, the wider effort should focus on urban-tolerant and/or wind-resistant species, regardless of origin. Tree Species Selection Matching a species to its favored climatic and soil conditions is the most important task when planning for a maintainable and survivable landscape. Plants that are well matched to their environmental conditions are much more likely to resist pathogens, insect pests, and severe storm damage and will therefore require less maintenance overall and be more likely to survive. In addition to considering site characteristics (such as climate, precipitation, native vegetation, availability of space) and soil characteristics (such as soil texture, structure, drainage, pH, water availability, and road salt), specific physical tree features must also be scrutinized to ensure public safety. Some considerations for street trees are the amount of litter dropped by mature trees, the maintenance required, and public acceptance. In the face of climate change, plummeting insect popu lations, and mass extinctions, the City should focus efforts on planting species indigenous to the region. Planting species that are native to the region whenever possible will provide additional benefits to the ecosystem at large. Above all, given the tough growing conditions in an urban environment, tree species should be selected for their durability and low maintenance requirements. These attributes are highly dependent on site characteristics as well as species characteristics. How to Plant The steps taken to properly plant trees must continue to be clearly outlined for City crews and/or contractors performing the work. Planting oversight and/or post planting inspections must continue to be performed to ensure that the work meets the guidelines set fort h by the City. The tree planting methodology outlined in this section is supported by industry standards and best practices, including the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) Z60.1-2014 American Standard for Nursery Stock, and the American National Standards Institute (ANSI): Standard A300. Standard Practices for Tree, Shrub and other Woody Plant Maintenance. These standards and best practices detail the methods and protocols for selecting healthy planting stock, handling trees during transport and planting, preparing the planting site, planting the tree, mulching, and young tree pruning. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 78 | P a g e Key Considerations for a Tree Planting Plan A planting strategy is crucial to urban forest sustainability and should be based on data, available resources, partnerships, and community input. Some of the more common goals that define a planting strategy include: ❖ Equitable Distribution. With this goal, planting priorities are assigned to areas determined to be the most in need based on the goal of an even distribution of benefits provided by trees. Beyond equal distribution, an area defined to be "in -need" is determined locally and can be a combination of priorities or focused on one specific priority. It is recommended the City utilize the guidance provided in the Tre e Canopy Cover Goals section to identify areas of low tree equity that are most suitable for planting. ❖ Areas of Predicted Future Canopy Loss. Older neighborhoods with a more established tree canopy can anticipate significant losses in future years. One met hod to planning future planting efforts is to target these replanting areas now to aid in a less drastic succession of trees over time. ❖ Benefits-Based Plantings. Areas that have a specific issue like poor air or water quality, or a large percentage of older residents sensitive to heat stress, may work to plant trees based on the anticipated benefits in years to come. ❖ Regular, Methodical Planting in Concert with Cyclical Tree Care Efforts. Planting may be most effective if it follows the City’s inventory, in that trees are planted where they are removed. Regular methodical planting can also be considered a worthy goal. ❖ Species Diversity. Planting strategies should not only identify where to plant but also what is being planted. Species diversity in Renton can quickly become an issue if data is not used to make decisions on the types of trees to plant. Neighborhood -level and Citywide planting plans should detail how biodiversity will be maintained with short- and long-term strategies. ❖ Inventory-Driven Plantings. In addition to tree canopy assessment data or data pertaining to the spatial location of existing tree canopy and possible planting space, a city may also utilize or conduct inventories of available public planting spaces. Often times, these types of inventories identify planting spaces based on criteria such as minimum width, distance from existing tree, distance from intersection, among others. Most planting space inventories catalogue the relative size of the growing space (small, medium, large). ❖ Partners in Planting. Renton’s planting strategy should also include who is doing the planting. This work can be done by City partners, neighborhood groups, community tree stewards, developers, and other interested parties, thus allowing the City to focus on specialized care (pruning, removals, assessments). Future tree plantings should focus on maintaining or increasing species diversity and reducing reliance on any particular species. Renton’s public tree population is primarily in fair or better condition with over 280 distinct species. The City should continue to focus resources on preserving existing and mature trees to promote health, strong structure, and tree longevity. Structural and training pruning for young trees will maximize the value of this resource, reduce long-term maintenance costs, reduce risk, reduce storm damage, and ensure that as trees mature, they provide the greatest possible benefits over time. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 79 | P a g e Tree Planting Recommendations • Increase genus and species diversity in new and replacement tree plantings to reduce reliance on abundant groups. At a minimum, strive for no species representing more than 10% of the overall population and no genus representing more than 20% of the overall population. • Use available planting sites to improve diversity, increase benefits, and further distribute the age distribution of street and park trees. • Prioritize planting replacement trees for those trees that have previously been removed. • Identify additional planting sites for trees and use the largest stature tree possible where space allows. • Prioritize successional planting of important species, as determined by relative performance index (RPI) and the relative age distribution. • Species that are adequately represented by established age distributions but lack recent plantings should receive priority care. • Prioritize structural pruning for young trees and ensure maintenance plans and associated budgets are prepared as trees become established. • Regularly inspect trees to identify and mitigate structural and correctable defects to reduce the likelihood of tree and branch failure. • Consider opportunities to further support wildlife habitat and pollinators when making decisions on the species of tree(s) to plant. • Create or update a recommended master tree list for City projects and to provide as a recommendation to the public for private property plantings. Include attributes such as tree size at maturity, primary feature, soil requirements, space requirements, recommended location(s), native/nonnative classification, description, and any concerns. • Consider preparedness planning for invasive pests and deleterious effects of climate change including wildfire, stormwater, and extreme weather events. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 80 | P a g e POST-PLANTING CARE AND YOUNG TREE MAINTENANCE The urban forest within Renton plays a significant role in maintaining the health and vitality of urban life. It provides a wealth of benefits to neighborhoods and residents through the reduction of energy consumption, the removal of pollutants from the ai r and water, reduction in stormwater flows, increased valuation of private property, increased worker productivity, reduction in stress and violent crime, as well as providing recreational opportunities and aesthetic diversity. At the same time stresses from the urban environment including air pollution, damage by vehicles, increased impervious surface, soil compaction, and maintenance neglect reduce the diversity and magnitude of these benefits and may lead to tree-related problems. The inherently close interaction between people and trees in the City requires active and diligent management of the urban and community tree and forest resources to ensure public safety. To enhance tree canopy and associated benefits, trees need to be properly planted and maintained. The City of Renton can use the following information to make any updates to tree policies. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 81 | P a g e Tree Maintenance Best Practices The following provides an overview of tree maintenance best practices. It is not intended to be an extensive or comprehensive summary of best practices. All tree maintenance practices should follow the American National Standards Institute’s (ANSI) A300 Standards (Parts 1-10). Reasons for Tree Pruning 1. Pruning for Safety Involves removing branches that could fall and cause injury or property damage, trimming branches that interfere with lines of sight on streets or driveways, and removing branches that grow into utility lines. Safety pruning can be largely avoided by caref ully choosing species that will not grow beyond the space available to them and have strength and form characteristics that are suited to the site. 2. Pruning for Health Involves removing diseased or insect‐infested wood, thinning the crown to increase airf low and reduce some pest problems, and removing crossing and rubbing branches. Pruning can best be used to encourage trees to develop a strong structure and reduce the likelihood of damage during severe weather. Removing broken or damaged limbs encourages wound closure. 3. Pruning for Form Improves the structure of trees and removes branches that are more likely to fail. Branches that are poorly attached may be broken off by wind and accumulation of snow and ice. Branches removed by such natural forces often result in large, ragged wounds that rarely seal. 4. Pruning for Aesthetics Involves enhancing the natural form and character of trees or stimulating flower production. To reduce the need for pruning it is best to consider a tree’s natural form. It is very difficult to impose an unnatural form on a tree without a commitment to constant care. Common Types of Tree Pruning 1. Crown Cleaning Consists of the selective removal of dead, dying, diseased, and weak branches from a tree’s crown. No more than 25% of the live crown should be removed in any one year, even for young trees. 2. Crown Thinning Primarily for hardwoods, thinning is the selective removal of branches to increase light penetration and air movement throughout the crown of a tree. The intent is to maintain or develop a tree’s structure and form. To avoid unnecessary stress and prevent excessive production of epicormic sprouts, no more than one‐quarter of the living crown should be removed at a time. If it is necessary to remove more, it should be done over successive years. Branches with strong U‐shaped angles of attachment should be retained. Branches with narrow, V‐shaped angles of attachment often form included bark and should be removed. 3. Crown Raising The practice of removing branches from the bottom of the crown of a tree to provide clearance for pedestrians, vehicles, buildings, lines of site, or to develop a clear stem for timber production. After pruning, the ratio of the living crown to total tree height should be at least two‐thirds. On young trees temporary branches may be retained along the stem to encourage taper and protect trees from vandalism and sunscald. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 82 | P a g e 4. Crown Reduction Most often used when a tree has grown too large for its permitted space. This method, sometimes called drop crotch pruning, is preferred to topping because it results in a more natural appearance, increases the time before pruning is needed again, and minimizes stress (see drop crotch cuts in the next section). Crown reduction pruning, a method of last resort, often results in large pruning wounds. Figure 34. Examples of the types of tree pruning Tree Pruning Cuts Pruning cuts should be made so that only branch tissue is removed and stem tissue is not damaged. To find the proper place to cut a branch, look for the branch collar that grows from the stem tissue at the underside of the base of the branch. On the upper surface, there is usually a branch bark ridge that runs parallel to the branch angle, along the stem of the tree. A proper pruning cut does not damage either the branch bark ridge or the branch collar. A proper cut begins just outside the branch bark ridge and angles down away from the stem of the tree, avoiding injury to the branch collar. Image source: Arbor Day Foundation Image source: Pennsylvania State University Urban Forestry Extension Figure 35. Types of pruning cuts and the proper branch cutting technique AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 83 | P a g e Utility Tree Maintenance Best Practices Utility Tree Pruning Overview The City should work with the utility companies to ensure proper pruning practices are followed and that open communication between the company, the city, and the public are maintained. The International Society of Arboriculture provides guidelines for maintaining trees near power lines (Best Management Practices – Utility Pruning of Trees, G. Kempter). Maintaining power lines free of tree growth is based on a consistent, planned trimming cycle of the utility vegetation management company. This approach improves electric service to all the customers who get their power from that line. A sensible approach to trimming trees means having a thorough maintenance plan that improves the safety and reliability of electric service to residents. Residents and the City staff should not attempt to trim any vegetation growing near or on any overhead power lines. Utility Tree Maintenance Techniques 1. Directional Pruning Removes entire branches and limbs to the main trunk of the tree and future growth is directed away from the power lines. Reduction cuts are used for removing these branches and limbs and should be pruned properly back to a lateral branch that is at least one-third the diameter of the branch being removed. This allows for good wound closure and protects apical dominance and reduces sprouts. Avoid topping or rounding over trees. This removes more foliage than directional pruning, increases the number of tree wounds, stresses the tree, causes unstable decay, and increases water sprouts. 2. Right Tree Right Place Selecting the right tree for the site can reduce potential safety hazards and improve the reliability of the electric service. Smaller trees near power lines do not need to be excessively pruned and do not lose their natural form. 3. Recommended Trees Trees potentially suitable for planting adjacent to power lines should be shorter and slow growing to prevent clearance issues. Photo source: Pennsylvania State University Urban Forestry Extension Figure 36. Example of trees directionally pruned for clearance from power lines AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 84 | P a g e Young Tree Maintenance Best Practices Proper pruning is essential in developing a tree with a strong structure and desirable form. Trees that receive the appropriate pruning measures while they are young will require less corrective pruning as they mature. Young Tree Maintenance Techniques 1. Consider the Nature Form and Desired Growth Accentuate the natural branching habit of a tree and correct any structural problems over time, if needed, to not stress the tree. 2. Pruning in 1-2 Years after Planting Prune as little as possible after planting to ensure there are enough temporary branches to produce food for new growth of roots, trunk, and branches. Prune only dead, broken, malformed, or diseased branches. Remove codominant leaders to maintain one dominant trunk. Prune for clearance if absolutely necessary. Keep size of branch removed to less than one inch in diameter. 3. Pruning 2-3 Years after Planting Prune any dead, broken, malformed, or diseased branches. Remove any suckers from the base of the tree. Next, determine the permanent branch structure by considering: • Remove, thin, or cut back any competing leaders • Remove crossing or rubbing branches, keep the branch that maintains the natural form • Thin excessively crowded branches but do not lions-tail • Remove branches with narrow angles between the branch and trunk (consider species) • Remove branches to maintain well-spaced branches along the trunk. Ideal mature trees will have lateral branches that are 18-24 inches apart (depending on species) • Avoid pruning near time of bud break • Prune flowering trees after flowering 1. Prune competing leader 2. Prune malformed branches 3. Remove crossing branches 4. Remove water sprouts 5. Remove branches with poor angles 6. Prune broken or damaged branches 7. Prune temporary branches over time 8. Remove suckers 9. Apply 2-3” of mulch Photo source: Pennsylvania State University Urban Forestry Extension Figure 37. Example of branches to be pruned for newly planted trees to promote good structure AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 85 | P a g e Tree Planting Best Practices The following provides an overview of best practices that should be considered and followed before during and after planting trees. • Trees to be planted should be selected from an approved tree planting list developed to maintain and enhance species diversity that are suitable for the Renton, WA Plant Hardiness Zone and changing climates. • Planting material will conform to the latest version of the American Standard for Nursery Stock (American National Standards Institute [ANSI] Z60.1). Trees to be planted should be of standard quality or better, and should be true to name and type of their species variety. • Trees should not be planted in tree lawns less than 2 feet in width or in planting pits less than 5 feet long by 5 feet wide. • Trees should not be planted within 50 feet of any major intersection, or within 20 feet of a fire hydrant, a driveway, or a pole supporting a light. • The burlap and twine from balled-and-burlap trees should be removed from the tree and the tree pit. Wire tree baskets may remain on the root ball, but the top one-third should be clipped and removed from the planting hole. • Mulch should be placed around trees in a minimum 3-foot circle and 3-inch depth to protect trees from lawnmower damage and competition from turf; mulch will be kept away from tree trunks. • Newly planted trees should be irrigated weekly during droug hts in the growing season for three years. Tree Irrigation Considerations and Best Practices: • Current limiting factor is budget for watering newly planted trees. • With dry and increasingly hot summers this is a critical requirement for new tree establishment. • Establishing new trees requires 4-5 years of supplemental irrigation during the summer months. • 400 trees currently (2021) costs $100,000, so every 100 new trees planted requires an additional $25,000. • Development of a certain size or where frontage improvements trigger tree planting should be required to install permanent in-ground irrigation systems. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 86 | P a g e FUNDING MECHANISMS Urban forests are an essential component of a municipality’s infrastructure. Well-managed urban forests boost community livability and build resilience through a myriad of ecosystem services. However, the budgets afforded to urban forestry programs do not always represent this “essential” status and forestry managers often need to work with budgets that are below the ir needs. Urban forestry budgets are also prone to large swings in need, as is currently being observed with the emerald ash borer causing spikes in tree removal demand. It can also be difficult to finance singular, capital intensive projects, like a public tree inventory, that provide critical data for forest planning and management. The general fund has long been the core of urban forestry program funding across the county and it remains a stable and popular option today (making up 72% of urban forestry funding in 2014). The general fund is also beholden to many other community needs and it is often stretched thin to meet all these demands. The best strategy for overcoming these budgetary challenges is to leverage a variety of sources, both public and private, to supplement allocations from the general fund. A diverse portfolio of funding streams allows urban forestry programs to weather resource restrictions and provide higher levels of service, like advancing from reactive to proactive maintenance cycles and implementing the Urban Forest Management Plan. Street Tree Fund According to section 9-13-8.B.3 Tree Removal of Renton’s Municipal Code, in lieu of planting replacement trees, and at the sole discretion of the City arborist, the permittee for a tree removal request may contribute to the City’s tree fund a dollar amount equal to the value of the replacement trees, including installation costs. These fees along with Routine Vegetation Management Permit fees ($105 plus a 3% technology fee), building permit fees received, tree removal mitigation fees, and stormwater fees could all contribute to a general tree maintenance operating fund.. Stormwater Utility Stormwater management has been a growing financial burden for many communities across the country, even before the effects of climate change have begun to take hold. To pay for the increasing costs, cities have been implementing user fees for stormwater management services. These charges are called stormwater fees or stormwater utility fees because they are modeled after the way municipalities have historically billed residents for other utility services like water and sewer. Stormwater fees provide local governments with a stable source of revenue to pay for their growing stormwater management costs, Urban forests are a well-documented complement to grey infrastructure for treating and mitigating stormwater. Therefore, many communities include urban forestry in stormwater fee payouts. Stormwater taxes that are assessed based on a property’s impervious surface area also provide additional motivation for owners to plant and maintain trees to minimize their fees or receive credits to their utility bill. Requirements for a Comprehensive Street Tree Program Different communities use different methods to calculate what to charge for the storm water services they provide. Due to the complexity of creating a stormwater utility structure that is outside of the scope of urban forest management planning, the following explanation provides a simplified overview of a common fee calculation process that addresses the most important elements other methods share. Many stormwater fees are based on the amount of impervious cover a property contains. Roofs, driveways, patios, and parking lots all usually count towards the total, but public sidewalks and roadways are not factored in. Properties with more impervious cover generate more stormwater runoff which puts a greater demand on the municipal stormwater system, compared to AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 87 | P a g e properties with less impervious cover. Because properties with lots of impervious surface require more stormwater service, they pay larger stormwater fees. Municipalities use different approaches to estimate the impervious cover on each of the residential, commercial, and institutional properties their stormwater management system serves. In some instances, they will visit properties to take measurements in the field but, more often, they use aerial imagery and computer software to calculate coverages using in-house information technology staff or consultants. Municipalities often calculate a representative value to represent the runoff from their residential properties. They do this by carefully measuring the impervious cover from a sample of typical single-family residential parcels to determine a median area measured in square feet. This value is called an ERU, short for Equivalent Residential Unit. The ERU essentially represents a base billing unit. Properties with very little impervious cover may be charged some fraction of an ERU, whereas properties with lots of impervious cover may be charged multiple ERUs. Municipalities take many factors into account when setting their base ERU billing rate, but the basic process involves two steps: 1. Adding up the impervious cover totals for each of the properties in their community and dividing this number by the ERU size they calculated earlier to determine the total number of ERUs in their service area and then, 2. Dividing their estimated annual stormwater budget by the total number of ERUs to reveal how much they need to charge per ERU to cover their annual stormwater costs. The nationwide average stormwater fee for single-family residential properties is currently $5.85 monthly (Campbell, 2019). The national average stormwater utility fee for single-family residential properties is based on a 2019 survey of 1,716 stormwater utility programs across 40 U.S. stat es and the District of Columbia. As of 2016, there are a total of 122 municipalities in the State of Washington that have a stormwater utility (Campbell, 2019). The City of Renton has an established stormwater utility and bills properties stormwater fees based on their land use and level of imperviousness. Whether a portion of the annual amount received therein could be used for funding part of the Urban Forestry program might be worth exploring. Tree planting, tree maintenance, and plant health care all contribute to sustaining and enhancing tree canopy cover in the City— which research shows tree canopy reduces stormwater runoff volume in communities. Special Assessment Districts Many properties in Renton are included in unique special financing districts of different types, especially in newer or redeveloping areas of the City. These districts are ordinarily initiated by the developer of a property, but are approved by City Council. The purposes of these districts may include financing of public improvements, ongoing maintenance and operations, or a combination. In general, these districts either serve to reimburse the developer for public improvements they are required to provide or to augment public faci lities and services which might not otherwise be available to most City residents. Most districts obtain their revenue via a property tax, although some may also charge fees or collect assessments. Residential districts have an eventual time limit for debt service, but in some cases they may operate more or less in perpetuity to provide maintenance and/or services. In Renton, several special assessment districts may be considered, including Business Improvement Districts (BIDs), General Improvement Districts (GIDs), Special Improvement Maintenance Districts (SIMDs), and Local Improvement Districts (LIDs). Others include water districts, fire protection districts, sanitation districts, and parks and recreation districts. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 88 | P a g e Focusing on areas with higher concentrations of street trees or maintenance needs, such as business districts, may capture property owners who are more willing to pay for tree care. This approach may be more politically palatable and could potentially lead to a citywide special assessment district where existing districts could be consolidated and organized into separate benefit zones, each with its own budget. Requirements for a Comprehensive Street Tree Program Special assessments are usually calculated per linear foot, based on the idea that benefits to property owners are directly related to street frontage. In some cases, special assessments include additional metrics such as building and/or lot square footage to account for the added benefit associated with larger buildings that have more occupants. Parcel Tax A parcel tax is a special tax levied for the provision of special benefits. Revenues from special taxes must be used for the specific purpose for which they are intended, so a parcel tax would create a dedicated funding stream for street trees. Similar to a special assessment, a parcel tax cannot be based on the value of property; however, the amount levied on each parcel does not need to be directly related to the benefits provided. Cities have the flexibility to levy parcel taxes as they see fit, but they are typically based on lot square footage or levied as a flat tax, with the same amount per parcel. Parcel taxes are designed to encompass entire cities and therefore, are good candidates for a citywide street tree program, as opposed to the district-level approach that often occurs under special assessments. Parcel taxes typically fund more than just street trees. For example, a tree maintenance tax per parcel may include provisions for the maintenance of parks and open space and improvements to recreation facilities. A parcel tax requires strong public support, as it must be approved by voters, rather than just the majority of property owners, as with a special assessment. Because a parcel tax must be voted on in a general election, rather than via mail-in ballot, it is likely to receive heightened political attention. However, general elections capture the votes of renters, who may be more apt to approve a tax borne by property owners. Requirements for a Comprehensive Street Tree Program A parcel tax for urban forestry operations and maintenance (O&M) may be levied as a flat tax, or it may be based on lot size (square footage). This study evaluated the parcel tax amount required to finance a City-operated street tree program according to both approaches. Renton currently has approximately 27,276 parcels Citywide. In the case of a flat parcel tax, the City would need to levy approximately $28 per parcel per year to cover the full costs of the public tree maintenance program that follows a 7-year pruning cycle. To fund the tree maintenance and the in-house arborist crew, a flat parcel tax of approximately $44 per parcel per year is required. Renton’s parcels total approximately 660 million square feet. To annually fund the public tree maintenance 7-year pruning cycle, a parcel tax levied according to lot size would translate to an annual tax of $0.00117 per square foot and $0.00182 to fund the tree maintenance and in- house arborist crew annually. For a typical 2,500-square foot lot (25 feet wide and 100 feet deep), a parcel tax based on lot size would amount to $2.93 to fund tree maintenance annually or $4.55 to fund annual tree maintenance and the in-house arborist crew. Another approach to consider is the average parcel lot area of 24,128 square feet ($28.22 - $43.91 per year) or classifications of parcels by counts within area (square feet) ranges. Considerations and adjustments to these numbers must be made for properties with multiple right-of-way trees, HOA-managed trees, and maintenance responsibility stated in plat plans. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 89 | P a g e Table 24. Parcel tax options and provisions for Renton's Urban Forestry Program Metric Annual Tree Maintenance for 7- Year Cycle Tree Maintenance and In- House Arborist Crew # of Parcels 27,276 27,276 Recommended Budget $774,000 $1,199,682 Flat Tax (budget by parcel) $28 $44 Parcel Square Feet (sq. ft.) 656,665,036 656,665,036 Tax by Lot Size $0.00117 $0.00182 Typical Parcel (2,500 sq. ft.) Annual Tax $2.93 $4.55 Average Parcel Size (sq. ft.) 24,128 24,128 Average Parcel Size Annual Tax $28.22 $43.91 General Obligation Bonds Local governments commonly use General Obligation (GO) bonds to fund the construction and improvement of projects involving real property (e.g., buildings, infrastructure and parks). GO bonds typically carry low interest rates, making them attractive for capital projects, which may include tree planting. However, funding is available for discrete projects, often over a limited time rather than an extended period. In addition, ongoing maintenance is ineligible for GO bond funding pursuant to federal tax law. Washington cities may pay debt service from GO bonds through property taxes (in proportion to the estimated value of the goods or transaction concerned), where assessments are based on property value. As a result, the issuance of GO bonds requires majority voter approval. GO bonds may be a tool for financing the planting of street trees in Renton as part of a larger package of capital improvements, as bonds are typically issued for large amounts. For example, voters may approve a Road Repair and Street Safety Bond, with funds designated for streetscape and street safety improvements that included street tree planting. GO bonds may include tree planting among streetscape improvements through street enhancement programs such as “complete streets” programs. However, these bonds may allocate funding for street tree planting to the streets program, rather than the City’s Urban Forestry Program. A bond specifically focused on a major street tree planting effort may be appropriate in the future. Requirements for a Comprehensive Street Tree Program Because GO bonds only fund capital costs, they could only be used to finance tree planting and establishment activities under a comprehensive city-operated street tree program. Additional Financing Options Parking Benefit District Parking Benefit Districts (PBDs) generate revenue within a special district for improvements and services related to streets, streetscapes, and landscapes. Because revenue derives from parking meters, visitors to PBDs fund the majority of improvements. As a result, local governments may create PBDs via ordinance without requiring a vote of property owners, setting them apart from other special assessment districts. Although only commercial areas with parking meters provide revenue, improvements may be implemented beyond PBD boundaries. The ordinance that creates the PBD determines the share of revenue that must be applied to improvements within the district, known as the “local return” portion. A committee of residents, property owners, and business owners advises the local agency administering the PBD on how to expend revenue. Adjustments to City policy regarding the agency receiving excess meter revenue may be required to enable the use of this financing option for a street tree program. While activities may include street tree planting and maintenance, a PBD is likely to cover other improvements related to neighborhood beautification. It is possible to create a dedicated AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 90 | P a g e funding stream for improvements, including street tree planting, sidewalk m aintenance, and the installation of street furniture and light fixtures. This may present an opportunity to finance a portion of Renton’s public tree maintenance costs; however, this strategy requires additional analysis to determine the likely amount of revenue to be generated for street trees, along with the potential for adding parking meters in new areas of the City. General Fund Renton’s General Fund has historically funded a share of street tree planting, establishment, and maintenance activities through the Capital Improvement Plan (CIP). However, appropriations have not kept pace with the needs of urban forest management to keep it sustainable. Because the General Fund is not a dedicated funding stream with a consistent budget amount, and is subject to changing economic conditions and political support, the General Fund is a volatile funding source. Nonessential services are the first target for cuts when expenditures exceed revenues, and there is no guarantee that one year’s appropriations will equal the next, as the City’s current funding for public trees demonstrates. Given the current status, reliance on Renton’s General Fund is not ideal for long-term planning of a program that will require a substantial commitment of resources (e.g., new staff, funding for partners). A mixed General Fund and Special Assessment model is often considered an appropriate compromise but can lead to decreases in General Fund budget allocations over time, as the assessment bears a large share of the burden of maintenance. Partnerships A number of opportunities for partnerships exist to help implement a public tree program in Renton and cover a portion of the costs. Continued collaboration with the Green Cities Partnership, WA Department of Natural Resources, community groups, and corporations would advance the City’s planting agenda, particularly if Urban Forestry does not have the resources to conduct all the work. Many communities across the country partner with local non-profit organizations (NPOs) that conduct tree planting. Based on conclusions from the needs assessment conducted as part of the Plan, a non-profit organization devoted to the planting and stewardship of public and private trees in Renton does not exist. The Plan provides recommendations and action steps to pursue in an effort to establish additional partners and support from entities such as NPOs. Public agencies, such as the U.S. Forest Service and regional air quality management districts, may also provide grant funding, although these are typically one-time contributions rather than a sustainable funding source. As an alternative or addition to NPOs and public agencies, corporate partnerships may present an opportunity for financing a share of Renton’s street tree planting and maintenance activities. Communities often establish adopt-a-tree programs and a corresponding fund that accepts donations for street tree activities, but a formal corporate partnership program could be a component of corporate social responsibility programs, particularly for Renton-based businesses. In particular, large goals like increasing the City’s tree canopy may attract corporate partners interested in environmental stewardship and a positive public image. Emphasizing the benefits of street trees, such as clean air and water, may expand the pool of funders to areas like public health. For example, large health or fitness corporations may contribute substantial funds for projects and programs that promote increased access to trails for fitness purposes. Development of a corporate partnership program would likely require significant fundraising and outreach efforts on Urban Forestry’s part and may place the City in competition with NPOs with highly organized fundraising programs based in Renton such as conservancies and park foundations. Some funders may prefer to contribute to NPOs, and therefore, it may benefit the City to partner closely with the NPO or support the establishment of an NPO. Ideally, corporate contributions would be consistent so that the City could rely on a sustainable funding stream. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 91 | P a g e Table 25. Summary of financing options for Renton’s urban forest Financing Options Attributes Process Opportunities Challenges Feasible Options Tree Fund Routine Vegetation Management Permit fees ($100), building permit fees received, tree mitigation fees, and stormwater fees could all contribute to a general tree maintenance operating fund. Enforcement of the Code generates monies from restitution. Building permit and stormwater fees would need evaluated and adjusted to accommodate supporting a Tree Fund. Monitoring Code violations would generate revenue for the Tree Fund. Potential use of funds for tree maintenance. The City is growing and revenue from fees could benefit the Tree Fund. Forestry staffing levels are inadequate to monitor Code violations. Fees would need evaluated, adjusted, and approved. Funds used for tree maintenance do not directly affect all contributors to the fee programs. Stormwater Utility A fee to manage stormwater based on impervious area. A fee from all developed parcels to support the stormwater program. Trees reduce stormwater volumes. Planting trees could qualify property owners a credit. An extensive analysis for the appropriate utility fee structure is required. Special Assessment Districts Special assessment for landscaping, open space improvements, acquisition, and maintenance. City agency / property owners initiate via petition, City agency administers; based on benefits calculated in engineer’s report; >50% of property owners in proposed district must approve via (mail) ballot. Citywide district possible for all street trees; individual districts more feasible in areas with many trees, high maintenance needs, and/or political support. Typically funds more than just street trees. Parcel Tax Assessment levied independent of property value, can be equal amount per parcel or dependent on lot size. 2/3 of voters (not just property owners) must approve via election ballot. Tax can be directly related to program costs; maintenance taxes deductible for property owners. 2/3 voter approval; potential competition from other services (e.g., schools); flat tax distributes cost inequitably. General Obligation (GO) Bond Low-interest loan for capital projects; repaid by levying tax revenue. 2/3 voter approval required. Frequently used tool in municipal government. Funding provided for set period; maintenance ineligible for funding. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 92 | P a g e Additional Options Parking Benefit District (PBD) Revenue from parking meters for range of right-of-way improvements. Enacted via local ordinance specifying boundaries, rates, use of funds; City administers with committee input. No ballot approval required; visitors bear burden over residents. Typically funds more than trees. General Fund City’s primary funding pool for wide range of municipal services. Annual budget via City’s legislative process. History of funding for tree planting and establishment. Not a guaranteed source of funding; no guaranteed funding amount; funds at risk if budget shortfalls. Partnerships Non-profits, corporate partners, grant funding; for tree planting and establishment. Various, depends on City’s processes. Decrease costs, increase capacity, develop a tree steward organization and program. Union resistance, sustainable funding stream required. Carbon Offsets The WA Climate Commitment Act (May 2021) creates a “cap and invest” program with a statewide cap on greenhouse gas emissions and auctions or allocates emissions allowances which supports climate resiliency programs. The WA Department of Ecology is developing the program and regulations. House Bill 1216 (HB1216) promotes urban forestry programs that will be facilitated through the WA Department of Natural Resources. WA is only the second state to pass an economy- wide carbon cap program, after CA. In CA, projects must plant at least 1,000 trees as offset projects to enable the sale of carbon credits. WA may adopt similar requirements. Also, HB1216 presents opportunities. Many trees (5,000+) must be planted to cover costs of an offset program. Creates two types of street trees, offset program trees require higher oversight. Does not support tree maintenance. Pest Control Fee A fee for forestry related services such as pest control and replanting. A forestry fee specific to pest control added to the public service utility billing as a levy. Opportunity to offset costs of managing and recovering from tree pests and diseases. Increased fee may require voter approval. The City must analyze pest control costs to establish the appropriate fee amount. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 93 | P a g e COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT The urban forest is a resource that benefits and belongs to the City’s residents. In order to care for it, the passion that is so frequently used to talk about trees can be harnessed to build stewardship around Renton’s trees. Approximately 71% of Renton’s tree canopy is located on either residential (32%), commercial (22%), or industrial (17%) land (see the Urban Tree Canopy Cover section). Thus, success in improving or maintaining tree canopy must include not only the municipal government, but also a populace that understands the value of trees and tree canopy to the community and the environment and how to plant and care for trees. Engagement to Inform the Plan Throughout the development of the Urban Forest Management Plan, engagement opportunities and activities were held to gather feedback and input that would inform the vision, goals, and strategies. The engagement sessions launched with a project website (RentonForestryPlan.com) where information about the Plan and supporting studies was provided along with upcoming engagement events and other project information. During the development of the Plan, the residents of Renton were invited to share their “Rooted in Renton Tree Story” using an interactive mapping feature on the project website to map the location of their favorite park, favorite tree, tree story, potential planting site, and/or tree issue. A total of 10 stories were mapped and eight photos shared. The favorite trees included sugar maples for their fall color, a Akebono cherry, the City’s largest London planetree, a higan cherry, and a 67-inch tulip tree in Tonkin Park. Tree stories captured the benefits of cottonwoods providing food and habitat for birds and wildlife, the history of Nishiwaki’s gift of the Taiwan cryptomeria in Liberty Park, a success story resulting from tree regulations with the replacement of a horse chestnut tree that was removed in error by a contractor of which the City was reimbursed, and the Yoshino cherry planted in memorial. In addition to the interactive map, two online surveys were hosted on the project website in July and September 2021. The first survey gathered 123 responses and focused on identifying viewpoints and perceptions relating to the urban forest cover, health, benefits, and programs. The second survey’s primary objectives were to gather input on developing the Plan’s goals, strategies, and future programs. A total of 64 responses were received. Figure 38. Renton's Urban Forest Management Plan project website (RentonForestryPlan.com) AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 94 | P a g e Public Survey #1 There were 123 responses to the first survey and respondents primarily live in Renton (55%) and own a home (82%) or live and work in the City (17%) and reside in the Highlands (22%), City Center (17%), or Benson (13%) neighborhoods. Respondents were primarily white/Caucasian (76%) in the 35-44 (27%) or 55-64 (23%) age class and trees are present in their normal routine such as daily commutes, park visits, and street trees. The majority of respondents have planted, maintained, watered, and pruned trees and feel there should be drastically more canopy coverage (41%) or slightly more (38%) because they feel the number of trees has decreased in the past 10 years (59%) as well as the overall health (38%). The primary concern for tree- related issues is the sidewalk and pavement cracking due to roots. New plantings should be focused in all areas of the City such as right-of-way, parks, private property, commercial, schools, and subdivisions. Respondents feel that the greatest benefit of trees is their ability to improve air and water quality and quality of life, along with the aesthetic value and benefits to wildlife. Public Survey #2 The second survey received 64 responses primarily from City Center (19%), Benson (18%), or Highlands (17%), and respondents were in the 35-44 year old age class (30%) or the 65 and older age class (28%), and own a home in Renton (86%). Of the respondents, 44% support adding more funding to the Program’s budget than what is already in place for tree planting and maintenance initiatives. 34% desire the additional funding to be used in neighborhoods with low tree canopy cover and 47% support more City funding for an improved proactive pruning program for all street trees. To further gauge the public’s opinion on priorities, each respondent had a theoretical $100 to spend on five potential services: tree removals and replacements; planting in public parks; street tree plantings; Tree Preservation Ordinance enforcement; and removal and replacement of trees that are dead, dying, or undesirable species. The majority of respondents would allocate $5 to $24 towards each of the five services except for street tree planting where the majority would allocate $25 to $49 of their $100. 75% of respondents view planting more trees in public areas as a priority and 69% would like to see additional trees be set aside in tree preservation tracts, retained, or replanted after developing forested land. The primary opportunities for the City to address in relation to citizen priorities is public tree planting to increase tree canopy (31%), maintenance (31%), planting in underrepresented neighborhoods (30%), and addressing sidewalk cracking due to roots (30%). Figure 39. Infographic summarizing the first public survey Figure 40. Infographic summarizing the second public survey AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 95 | P a g e Engagement to Implement the Plan There are multiple ways to engage the public to improve the care of and expanse of local tree canopy. First, topics or messages must be defined, prioritized, and limited in number. More effective communication occurs through choosing a few strong messages and repeating them over and over. After messages are chosen, avenues of targeted communication to deliver those messages can be determined and implemented. Important topics and messages that should be considered for Renton are as follows: ❖ Current Canopy Extent and Value of Renton’s Trees. The message should present the current canopy level and benefits the canopy provides. This is typically the first message to send out to the public, as all other messages should connect back to this one. This can also be a way to “roll out” the Urban Forest Management Plan to the public. Include information such as why Renton needs tree canopy, what the current canopy level is, and the plans to improve the management of the trees that comprise the canopy. Educating local business owners on the impact that a shady commercial district can have on sales and educating property owners about the impact that trees have on property values are other useful methods for boosting the desire for increased canopy along main thoroughfares and neighborhood streets while also engaging the public. The important value of mature trees could be also highlighted, as people often do not realize that the large tree they have is a value to their property, the community, wildlife, and the environment. ❖ How You Can Get Involved. What are the next steps you want people to take? The City should decide the answer and insert this “ask” in every outreach piece or effort. The City could organize a tree giveaway (usually saplings) at Arbor Day for people to plant on private property. Or the City could create an Adopt-A-Tree program, whereby residents sign up to take care of a street tree, including providing regular water and mulch. Another option for getting the community involved is to create a Heritage Tree Program where residents are encouraged to find and nominate the largest or otherwise significant trees in the City. Lastly, citizens can donate funds or volunteer at a tree planting event. ❖ Tree Threats. Public and private trees can die, decline, or become safety risks as a result of insect and disease infestation as well as inadequate maintenance. With education, the residents of Renton can become aware of the common threats to the tree canopy and what they can do to help. The City should provide education on existing tree pest and disease concerns and what the City is doing about these threats on public land, and options for management on their own land. Since the majority of the trees that comprise the City’s urban tree canopy are on private property, it is vital for the City to educate the public on how to detect insect and disease threats, provide information about management and treatment options, and relay the importance of reforestation in the event trees are removed. Informing residents about tree removals and other significant tree work is essential for maintaining the City’s relationship with the commun ity. When an established public tree has to be removed, the City should continue its current practice of notifying abutting or adjacent property owners of the pending removal. ❖ General Tree Care Education for Property Owners. There are several actions people take that are detrimental to trees at all stages of life, including improper mulching and pruning. Easy tips and tidbits of information to share with residents for trees on their own properties can help improve tree maintenance and increase tree health and survival rates. Some examples include: AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 96 | P a g e o Demonstrate how to properly mulch a tree. Too often mulch is placed around tree trunks in a “mulch volcano”, which is extremely detrimental to the tree. A simple message of how to mulch properly can improve tree health and longevity. o Provide guidance on how and when to prune trees. Incorrect pruning can lead to poor tree structure or wounds that may never heal. o Explain proper tree planting and tree care techniques. This could be e specially helpful for homeowners who are considering planting a tree in their yard but are unsure where to start. o Encourage recycling or composting leaves on-site. Use Multiple Avenues of Communication There are numerous avenues to convey urban forestry messages and accomplishments of the program to the residents, such as: ❖ Social Media. Social media sites such as Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter can create buzz and promote involvement in the current urban forestry activities occurring locally. To reach even more people, the City should consider coordinating with allied community gardens, non-profits, educational institutions, and business to get messages posted on their social media sites as well. ❖ Website. The City of Renton’s Urban Forestry webpage contains important information about the urban forestry program, including details about tree planting, the tree inventory, tree regulations, among other things. The website should be maintained regularly to make sure information is up to date. The project website for the Urban Forest Management Plan (RentonForestryPlan.com) can also be maintained going forward to continue outreach and education. ❖ Presentations to City leadership and local business and neighborhood groups. Identify key audiences, partners, and potential champions for the urban forestry program. Making short presentations at regular or special meetings where they are relieves individuals from having to go to yet another meeting in the evenings. Initial outreach could be based on letting the audience know about Renton’s urban forest and the work called for in this Plan. Be sure to have an “ask” at the end of the presentation. What do you want them to do next? This work often unearths new partners and funding sources that can otherwise go untapped. ❖ Do a survey. Once a year, create a short online survey to identify what urban forestry issues people in Renton are concerned or care about. The survey can also be used to gauge people’s reactions to new urban forest management procedures and regulations, and their willingness to participate in volunteer work or to donate funds or other resources. Questions about public trees and tree canopy can be part of the annual public survey. ❖ Cultivate partnerships for communication. Partnerships can be initiated with organizations that can help promote, enhance, and preserve Renton’s urban forest. Organizations can include local businesses, local utilities, regional non -profits, homeowner associations, neighborhood associations, and schools and other educational institutions. Other audiences to engage can include youth groups, landscape architect firms, faith-based groups, and nurseries and landscape contractors. Actions that can be taken by each partner should be defined before approaching them for support. ❖ Encourage Renton Technical College to become a Tree Campus USA. The College is not yet a Tree Campus, USA. If they were to pursue this distinction and join the City’s Tree City, USA legacy, then two powerful entities would be supporting Renton’s urban forest. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 97 | P a g e One standard the College would need to achieve annually is for students to participate in one or more Service Learning Projects. These projects are intended to provide an opportunity to engage the student population with trees. College students could help the City’s Urban Forestry Program perform many tasks, such as tree planting, tree care, and public outreach. ❖ Publish and promote an annual State of the Urban Forest Report. An annual “State of the Urban Forest Report” can be produced using updated tree inventory data, tree planting statistics, i-Tree tools, and other program information. It should provide information on the number and condition of public trees, as well as maintenance, planting, and management accomplishments. It should also present a summary of the current year’s annual work plan and identify emerging issues and budget or resource needs. ❖ Add signage to the landscape. Signs placed in high traffic areas can spark interest in trees and the urban forest. Something as simple as species name or a notable fact about a tree can encourage people to learn more and to get more involved. ❖ Create Story Maps. The story about Renton’s urban forest, the programs that manage it, and the community that shapes and benefits from it can be told through maps that illuminate and contextualize the story. Maps are the visual representation of where events happen. As such, maps and stories complement each other, and story maps serve as an integrated presentation. Story maps use geography as a means of organizing and presenting information. They tell the story of a place, event, issue, trend, or pattern in a geographic context. They combine interactive maps with other rich content—text, photos, illustrations, video, and audio—within intuitive user experiences. Content may include the Urban Tree Canopy Assessment, the tree inventory and 2021 analysis summary report, programs and events, and content from the Urban Forest Management Plan such as tree canopy goals, ecosystem benefits, and the urban forest vision, goals, objectives, and strategies. Figure 41. Story maps can visualize urban forest stories, maps, and data for the public AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 98 | P a g e Create a Volunteer Corps Consider implementing a “Young Tree Care” volunteer program to assist with new tree planting and new tree care such as watering, mulching, and pruning. This type of program is more involved than an “Adopt-A-Tree” program, as the young tree care volunteers are specially trained to care for young trees and to serve as advocates and educators within their networks. As such, this type of program involves initial and continuing training, frequent mentoring, and overall coordination of the process and volunteers. It also provides yet another engagement opportunity and encourages partnership opportunities with a variety of groups, such as neighborhood associations, master gardeners, scout troops, church affiliated groups, youth groups, high school community service programs, and others to accomplish new and young tree care tasks. Trees to include in a “Young Tree Care” program are generally less than 6 inches in diameter. These younger trees sometimes have branch structures that can lead to potential problems as the tree ages, such as codominant leaders, multiple limbs attaching at the same point on the trunk or crossing/interfering limbs. If these problems are not corrected, they may worsen as the tree grows, which increases risk and creates potential liability. With direction from City staff, young tree care volunteers could be trained to carry out the young tree training program. Beyond pruning, young trees need watering and mulching to become established, and may require fertilization and other Plant Health Care (PHC) treatments until they reach maturity. This program can create “tree stewards” for Renton and be modeled after similar and successful programs like those found in other municipalities such as the Tacoma Tree Foundation’s Tree Stewards or in other states such as Portland’s Neighborhood Tree Stewards. The “tree stewards” or a volunteer corps could also be used to support the urban forest management program in other ways. Volunteers could develop and/or staff Arbor Day and Earth Day events, post and manage tree messages on social media, help update the inventory, and/or locate planting sites in neighborhoods. Explore Partnerships Establish partnerships to fund and accomplish the young tree training program and some mature tree care activities. For instance, the utility companies may support tree growth regulator applications for trees under their lines; businesses or developers may pay into a fund to “adopt” or maintain trees in parks, commercial areas, and newly built streets; residents may help water mature street trees during times of drought. The City should continue to maintain and strengthen partnerships with agencies and organizations that provide technical service and grant opportunities. For example, the WA Department of Natural Resources Urban and Community Forestry Program provides Community Forestry Assistance Grants, King County has set an ambitious goal of planting three million trees by 2025 to mitigate climate change, and Washington State University Extension Forestry in the Puget Sound Region offers technical support. These partners among many other local, regional, and national partners can support Renton in implementing the Urban Forest Management Plan. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 99 | P a g e Public Education Public education is one of the true keys to reaching the goals of an urban forestry program. Only by educating the public, City officials, developers, and contractors working within City limits will a community be able to achieve urban forest protection and planting goals. Ordinances and guidelines alone will not guarantee success since builders, contractors, and others often have their own priorities and agendas, and trees and ordinances are often nothing more than a nuisance to them. Cooperation from all concerned parties can be improved by requesting various community stakeholders, such as City Council members and neighborhood groups, to attend educational sessions to learn about the current state of Renton’s urban forest, plans for urban forest management and planting, and the importance of all of it to the future of the community. To gain support for Renton’s Urban Forestry Program, various public outreach campaigns aimed at educating the residents of Renton should be established. Where there is understanding and acceptance of the Urban Forestry Program as a whole, there will be increased support for the planting portion of the program. Based on examples of public relations efforts by urban foresters in other communities, the following types of activities are suggested for the City to undertake: ❖ Hold a seminar or public meeting to discuss the tree inventory project, its results, and its importance for the City. ❖ Develop monthly evening or weekend seminars related to tree care and landscaping; bring in guest experts from various disciplines in the green industry. ❖ Write a monthly “Tree Talk” article for local newspapers or social media. ❖ Develop a Tree Care door hanger brochure to go to each residence where new trees are planted; educating residents about proper tree care could help eliminate trunk damage and improper mulching and pruning of new trees. ❖ The City could start giving away one-gallon tree seedlings to any volunteers who get involved with City projects. This is a great reward and a way to spread the word about trees. Renton could capitalize on the idea and attach the same Tree Care door hanger brochure or a different informational brochure to each of these trees. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 100 | P a g e ❖ Co-host tree planting programs with the local garden club, local non-profits, or groups. ❖ Map the locations of fruit-bearing trees in the City and coordinate with groups that harvest the fruit for homeless and food insecure organizations. ❖ Embrace story telling within the urban treescape. Connect the trees to the history of the area through complementary art, placards, or signage. Consider establishing tree walks that highlight some of Renton’s greatest tree specimens and provides tree identification training. ❖ Encourage citizen science activities that involve the urban forest. For example, the Nature Conservancy’s “Healthy Trees Healthy Cities” app can be used to monitor tree health and check trees for pests. Local professors and non-profit groups that work with citizen science may be able to help plan projects and recruit citizen scientists. ❖ Expand the annual Arbor Day celebration to help it become a community tradition. The Arbor Day celebration could be further developed as an all-day Saturday event, preferably held in a popular park/public space setting in the City. Expanding on short programs on planting and pruning trees and including children’s programs about trees can help increase public interest in the City’s tree programs. Additionally, the City could invite contractors to conduct demonstrations on tree planting, trimming, landscaping, and species selection. Organizers could also set up booths with tree information. Refer to the National Arbor Day Foundation (ArborDay.org) for publications that provide great Arbor Day ideas to assist in planning of this event. Establish a Tree Committee Forming a Community Tree Advisory Committee (TAC)— also referred to as a tree commission, tree board, urban forestry commission, beautification committee, environmental advisory committee, community forestry commission, among others depending on the jurisdiction — is one step Renton can take to sustain an urban forestry program and increase community engagement. The powers and responsibilities of a Tree Advisory Committee are based on Washington statutes and are assumed by the local government. By forming and empowering a tree committee, Renton can place the responsibility for important community decisions in the hands of unpaid volunteers with designated powers. The formation of the committee can be a crucial element in developing broad-based support for community trees and ensuring long-term success and growth of Renton’s Urban Forestry Program. Proposed Responsibilities of the Tree Advisory Committee The Tree Advisory Committee should reflect the values and standards of the community and should help champion an urban forestry effort. The recommended roles and responsibilities of Renton’s Tree Committee may include the following: ❖ Reduce involvement of a municipal council for tree-related matters. ❖ Administer tree removal appeals processes. ❖ Advise community leaders and staff on administering the urban forest. ❖ Stimulate and organize tree planting and maintenance. ❖ Participate in a Landmark Trees Program. ❖ Support urban forest inventories, management plans, and ordinances. ❖ Settle community disputes caused by tree removal, planting, or maintenance. Additional guidance and information for considering a Tree Advisory Committee is provided in Appendix C. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 101 | P a g e Environmental Justice The equitable distribution of resources is a key driver of environmental justice. This Urban Forest Management Plan aims to grow the urban forest and address the fact that existing canopy resources and associated benefits are unequally distributed. Urban tree canopy expansion and maintenance requires a financial investment on the part of the City, primarily from tax dollars. As a result, tree canopy coverage tends to be larger and more established in wealthier neighborhoods, and tree canopies are often less than ideal in communities that are economically disadvantaged. Along with funding, community support for the urban forest and this Plan are necessary to succeed. Communication should begin months before a tree planting starts and should build trust between the entity spearheading the tree plantings and the community the tree planting is taking place in. Connecting with trusted community leaders to introduce the idea of an expanded tree canopy, holding outreach events at an earlier stage in the plan, and taking local opinion into account when it comes to tree species selection can develop a partnership, rooted in trust, with the area’s residents. But a big part of keeping that trust is staying consistent through action. Following up with these communities to hear and address any concerns while consistently maintaining the new plantings will help ensure a fully developed urban forest. The framework of the Urban Forest Management Plan guarantees the presence of environmental justice principles in Renton’s Urban Forestry Program. The Tree Planting Initiative and Citywide tree canopy cover goals to be finalized by the City will address community equity and environmental justice by identifying areas in most need of tree canopy cover, tree plantings, and urban forestry services. And, as the City expands its network of partners, all populations within a neighborhood will be better represented. Support the City’s Volunteer Coordinator To streamline community education and engagement across the City’s programs and projects that influence the natural environment (i.e., Urban Forestry, stormwater, recycling, among others) and to achieve goals of the Urban Forest Management Plan, the Parks and Recreation Department’s volunteer coordinator (“Recreation Program Coordinator”) should be supported with partnerships, organizations, the potential Tree Advisory Committee, and adjunct staff support. The management of volunteers, events, messaging, partnerships, and programs will build support for the Urban Forestry Program through volunteers and ensure all demographics and cultures have an equal opportunity to experience and discuss the City’s urban forest. Community Engagement Recommendations Outreach and engagement with the community of Renton begins with clear messaging and information gathered from the Urban Forest Management Plan. To make a greater impact and to fully recognize all communities in Renton, it is recommended the City identify a local non - profit community organization with a mission that supports the urban forest. In addition to a community partner, a City Tree Committee adds capacity and creates more advocates for the Urban Forestry Program. Lastly, a community of tree stewards that are trained in tree planting and post-planting care will increase Urban Forestry Program capacity and build support for long-lasting impacts. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Program Needs 102 | P a g e GOALS AND STRATEGIES FOR A SUSTAINABLE URBAN FOREST AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Urban Forestry Goals, Objectives, and Strategies 103 | P a g e URBAN FORESTRY GOALS, OBJECTIVES, AND STRATEGIES Trees are an integral part of the community and the ecological systems in which they exist. They provide significant economic, social, and ecological benefits, such as carbon sequestration, reduction of urban heat islands, energy savings, reduction of stormwater runoff , improvement of water quality, enhancement of human health and wellness, and increase the value of properties. Planting and maintaining trees help Renton become more sustainable and reduce the negative impacts on the ecosystem from urban development. Trees are as necessary as water, infrastructure, and energy to sustaining healthy communities. The health of the urban forest is directly linked to the health of the community. Through research, staff interviews, data analyses, benchmarking research, community engagement, and urban forest auditing, the City identified three specific goals with each having several objectives to accomplish each goal. The objectives were further divided into strategies. The Current State of Renton’s Urban Forest and Renton’s Urban Forestry Program sections provide the context, discussions, and recommendations that led to the development of the goal-objective-strategy framework. The Implementation Schedule in Appendix A breaks down the strategies into actions and tasks which are proposed to occur over a ten-year period. Through this process, the Urban Forest Management Plan can be followed each year to culminate into the vision for Renton’s urban forest. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Urban Forestry Goals, Objectives, and Strategies 104 | P a g e GOALS, OBJECTIVES, AND STRATEGIES GOAL 1: Proactively manage public trees, continue to grow and expand a healthy canopy, maintain public safety, and optimize urban forest benefits. Objectives 1.1 Make data-driven management decisions. Strategies 1.1A Maintain the public tree inventory 1.1B Utilize current and future canopy assessments 1.2 Sustainably manage the public tree population . Strategies 1.2A Establish an interdepartmental green team 1.2B Establish and implement a 7-year pruning cycle program 1.2C Improve workflows for tree clearance issues 1.2D Ensure newly planted trees receive post- planting care and young tree training 1.3 Establish a strategy for increasing tree canopy cover through City and public efforts. Strategies 1.3A Formally establish the Tree Planting Initiative 1.3B Increase Citywide tree canopy cover 1.3C Grow a sustainable and resilient urban forest 1.4 Effectively manage tree risk. Strategies 1.4A Adopt the Risk Tree Management Plan 1.4B Institute a formal rotation for risk tree inspections AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 105 | P a g e GOAL 2: Achieve environmental justice through a partnership with the City and its residents to improve well-being, human health, local economies, and urban forest sustainability. Objectives 2.1 Create an urban forestry public outreach program that addresses all communities. Strategies 2.1A Maintain Tree City USA recognition 2.1B Maintain active communications with diverse audiences 2.1C Provide education and training workshops 2.1D Implement program services through the lens of environmental justice 2.2 Increase capacity through trained citizens. Strategies 2.2A Create a volunteer corps or tree stewards program 2.2B Establish a Community Tree Advisory Committee 2.2C Effectively manage volunteers and events AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Urban Forestry Goals, Objectives, and Strategies 106 | P a g e GOAL 3: Strengthen policies for preserving the environmental benefits, management, and the character of Renton's urban forest. Objectives 3.1 Strengthen policies for protecting the urban forest. Strategies 3.1A Protect trees during public construction projects 3.1B Apply a no-net-loss approach to tree canopy cover 3.1C Use tree canopy assessment data for tree management policies 3.1D Update and strengthen tree ordinances 3.2 Improve workflows and operations for sustainable urban forest management. Strategies 3.2A Enforce tree regulations 3.2B Engage more consistently in all tree removal permit requests AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 107 | P a g e KEY STRATEGIES The planning process identified 22 strategies following development of the program goals and objectives. This rich number of strategies will position Renton as a leader in urban forestry across the state and perhaps the nation and will guide the City towards a sustainable urban forest. There were five significant strategies identified as being of higher priority than others. These were predicated upon resolving public safety issues, inefficiencies, community engagement, policy gaps, and urban forest sustainability. 7-Year Pruning Cycle Program One of the more critical strategies identified was the need for an improved public tree pruning program on a recommended 7-year rotation. The strategy requires additional funding and the creation of an in-house arborist crew. Feedback from the community and City staff expressed support for the structure of this strategy. Tree Planting Initiative To grow an urban forest that is sustainable and resilient to climate change, pests and diseases, and urban development pressures, a strategic planting initiative guided by short- and long-term canopy goals and planting targets is needed. The Plan contains the guidance for finalizing canopy goals, identifying priority planting areas, and developing the tree planting initiative. Tree Stewards Program A shared commitment to the urban forest and vision is essential to the long-term success and impact of the Plan. A community of tree stewards will increase Urban Forestry Program capacity and support the Tree Planting Initiative along with other programs and services. No-Net-Loss Perhaps more important than tree canopy cover goals and planting initiatives is the foundation of sound policies to preserve the existing urban forest. With this key strategy, tree replacement, retention, removal, mitigation, and enforcement protocols are solidified. In addition, alternative solutions to tree and sidewalk conflicts are explored and guidance for formally adopting a decision checklist and solutions toolkit is provided. Enforce Tree Regulations Throughout the planning effort, concerns were expressed and identified relating to the protection of trees from construction damage, illegal removals, and maintenance malpractice. The actions supporting this strategy expand the enforcement efforts by increasing capacity as well as community education to prevent instances from occurring in the first place. Key Strategies 7-year pruning cycle program The Tree Planting Initiative Tree Stewards Program No-net-loss Enforce tree regulations AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Evaluation 108 | P a g e EVALUATION MONITORING PLAN This Urban Forest Management Plan will be updated and revised periodically to reflect changes in the urban forest resource structure and function, to incorporate changes in industry standards, to consider community response, and to measure the progress of the urban forest partners in implementing the recommendations and reaching the established goals. This process should be implemented by the City Collaborative Team (or similar) using the Evaluate, Monitor, Report, and Revise methodology. Knowing how the City of Renton and its partners are doing will require a continual process of evaluation. This section presents examples of how to monitor, analyze, and revise the Plan, which will keep stakeholders informed of the status of the Urban Forest Program. To monitor progress toward implementing the Plan recommendations, an evaluation similar to the U.S. Forest Service’s Urban Forest Audit conducted to develop the initial Plan should be completed. This evaluation will identify progress and shortfalls compared to the baseline audit. In addition, a report card could be created based on outcomes of the audit and distributed to the public every two to three years. This will measure the progress toward implementing the Plan actions. The following example provides a suggested reporting structure to measure success toward accomplishing each goal. Other indicators to measure progress may need to be developed to ensure a thorough and accurate evaluation. Evaluate The U.S. Forest Service’s Urban Forest Audit System provides a framework for routine evaluations of the urban forest, the programs that manage it, and the community that shapes and benefits from it. The deliverables to this Urban Forest Management Plan project include guidance for completing the audit. It is recommended the City Collaborative Team (or similar) complete a bi-annual audit to inform any alterations to actions and strategies. This audit system consists of 11 categories of urban forest management, sustainability, and community. Within the 11 categories are approximately 130 elements. Each element was ranked or scored based on the consultants’ evaluations in 2022 for the Urban Forest Management Plan. The City Collaborative Team (or similar) should complete an update to this ranking bi-annually to inform Plan reporting, monitoring, and revision as described in the following sections. Monitor Measuring accomplishment of the actions will require ongoing analysis. The outcomes of the Urban Forest Audit System in the “Evaluate” section can be used to monitor change over time. These benchmark values should be tracked, and a state of the urban forest report should be prepared and distributed to the public every 2 to 5 years. Analysis may include an updated public tree inventory, i-Tree benefits analyses, or urban tree canopy assessments. The state of the urban forest report should include the benchmark values as reported in the Plan and the Urban Forest Audit System as of 2021, so that the City can measure and compare changes to the urban forest. The report should reflect changes to the audit system that are measured. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 109 | P a g e Renton’s Urban Forest Benchmark Values Table 26. Renton’s urban forest benchmark values URBAN TREE CANOPY (UTC) COVER (2017) UTC 29.3% Recommended Canopy Goal (short-term) 30% by 2032 Recommended Canopy Goal (long-term) 33% by 2042 Total Number of Trees to Plant (short-term) 5,250 (525 trees per year) Total Number of Trees to Plant (long-term) 19,000 (950 trees per year) City-led Plantings to Reach Canopy Goals (60% of total plantings) 315 trees/year for 30% canopy 570 trees/year for 33% canopy PUBLIC TREE COUNTS (2021) Total Public Trees Managed 116,984 Public Street/Park/Golf Course Trees (inventoried) 27,456 Public Natural Area Trees (sampled) 89,528 TREE SPECIES DIVERSITY (SPECIES EXCEEDING 10%) Public Trees (2021) Bigleaf maple (15%), Douglas-fir (11%) TREE BENEFITS Citywide (UTC Assessment) 2017: $2.4 million (annual) Inventoried Public Trees 2021: $220,000 (annual) Inventoried Public Trees Replacement Value 2021: $122.6 million TREE AND BUDGET DISTRIBUTION (2021) Public Trees per Capita 1.15 Budget per Capita, Budget per Tree $9.37, $8.13 Urban Forestry Program FTEs 2.50 Total Public Trees per Staff 46,800 MANAGEMENT ACTIVITIES (2020) Public Trees Pruned 758 Public Trees Removed 247 Public Trees Planted 200 Trees Watered 400/week Trees Inspected 3,700 Completed Work Orders 1,000+ Number of Volunteers and/or Hours TBD URBAN FOREST AUDIT SYSTEM (TOTAL SCORE OF 2021): 65% Management Policy and Ordinances 64% Professional Capacity and Training 81% Funding and Accounting 58% Decision and Management Authority 88% Inventories 77% Urban Forest Management Plans 46% Risk Management 83% Disaster Planning 43% Standards and Best Management Practices 55% Community 86% Green Asset Evaluation 55% PUBLIC PERCEPTION (2021) Health of the urban forest in the past 10 years 38% feel the health has declined Count of trees in the urban forest in the past 10 years 59% feel the number has declined Amount of urban tree canopy cover 48% want drastically more canopy AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Evaluation 110 | P a g e Report Based on the evaluation of Plan implementation progress, the City Collaborative Team (or similar) should track, record, and report on the metrics described below that are measures or indicators of success for each goal and supporting actions. Note, the ser ies of urban forestry goals to address the resource, the programs, and the people and are not listed in any particular priority or order. Table 27. Evaluation, monitoring, and reporting techniques to achieve the urban forestry goals 1 GREEN ASSET MANAGEMENT: Proactively manage public trees, continue to grow and expand a healthy canopy, maintain public safety, and optimize urban forest benefits. ❖ Report the ecosystem benefits of the inventoried tree population. ❖ Report the number of public trees pruned, removed, and planted. ❖ Report the number of trees managed for pests and diseases. ❖ Report the number of trees planted in stormwater management projects. ❖ Report progress towards canopy goals and tree planting targets. ❖ Report the volume of woody biomass utilized. ❖ Report the condition, structure, and diversity of the public trees. ❖ List audit score and actions/targets achieved, ongoing, and not started. 2 COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT: Achieve environmental justice through a partnership with the City and its residents to improve well-being, human health, local economies, and urban forest sustainability. ❖ List the existing and potential outreach platforms and initiatives. ❖ List existing and potential partners. ❖ Report the number of planting events and trees planted. ❖ Report the history/count of Tree City USA and supporting awards. ❖ Report the number of volunteers, events, and volunteer hours. ❖ Report the number of private tree plantings as feasible. ❖ Report the number of trainings, workshops, and attendees. ❖ Report the results of public surveys. ❖ Recognize exemplary urban forest stewards. ❖ List audit score and actions/targets achieved, ongoing, and not started. 3 TREE MANAGEMENT POLICY: Strengthen policies for preserving the environmental benefits, management, and the character of Renton's urban forest. ❖ List existing and potential partners. ❖ List all City and partner-led planning efforts. ❖ Describe related planning efforts. ❖ Establish a Citywide canopy goal and local planting targets. ❖ List recommended changes to City Code, policies, and manuals. ❖ List audit score and actions/targets achieved, ongoing, and not started. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 111 | P a g e Revise Completion of this Plan is a critical step towards meeting the vision for Renton’s urban forest. Continual monitoring, analysis, and reporting will help to keep urban forest partners involved and focused on accomplishing the actions. Plans are typically revised every 10 to 15 years; hence, the Plan will need formal revision to respond and adapt to changes as they develop. Formal revision of the Plan should coincide with the update of the City’s Comprehensive Plan and other relevant planning efforts. Recommendations and goals of each should be compared. Revisions to the Plan should occur with major events, such as newly discovered pests or diseases, changes in program budget and resources, or significant changes to industry standards or legal codes. ACT AND REPORT EVALUATE AND REVISE ACT AND REPORT EVALUATE AND REVISE Years 1-5 Year 5 Years 6-10 Year 10 Annual Action Plans and Reports Urban Forest Audit and Plan Amendments Annual Action Plans and Reports Urban Forest Audit and Plan Update Monthly Activities and Annual Report Updated Benchmarks and Plan Actions Monthly Activities and Annual Report Updated Benchmarks and Plan Actions IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE The Appendix contains the Implementation Schedule which is the yearly program for the next ten years. It takes the strategies, shown under the goals and objectives, and subdivides each strategy into actions and tasks. In addition, the Implementation Schedule shows a budget estimate with a total by year. The Schedule is the main piece of the Plan that can be easily adapted to changing conditions, providing more or less activity in any given year. The Implementation Schedule will be used by City staff to guid e activities occurring in the current year and to plan for succeeding budget years. It provides the reader with information on how each program strategy is to be accomplished. Figure 42. Example of the plan implementation, evaluation, and revision process AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Summary and Conclusion 112 | P a g e SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION Renton has a rich forestry history that strongly influenced the City’s early development. Today, with all of the original vegetation gone, the urban forest plays an important role in making life richer for Renton citizens and visitors, and attracting new b usinesses. To resolve many of the issues with the built and the natural environments experienced today, this Urban Forest Management Plan is timely. With dedication, Renton’s urban forest will once again provide the value of the historic landscape. The Urban Forest Management Plan is a roadmap for a strategic approach to manage Renton’s urban forest. The Plan contains goals and supporting actions that are critical to the long-term vitality of the forest. However, in order for the Urban Forest Management Plan to actually have an impact on the forest resource, it requires stewardship and financial resources to begin implementation. Further, it needs to be institutionalized as a document requiring implementation with a sense of urgency to get things started. Co mpletion of the Urban Forest Management Plan clearly demonstrates that City leadership understands that a healthy urban forest is critical to guaranteeing the long-term health and vitality of the community, and that it is not a luxury but an absolute necessity. In order to accomplish the goals, the approach to overall implementation should adhere to the guiding principles of the Plan: ❖ Recognize that the trees of the urban forest are more than aesthetic enhancements. ❖ Recognize trees as the backbone of the urban ecosystem and an essential part of the community’s green infrastructure. ❖ Promote the health and growth of the urban forest by following scientifically established best management practices for tree selection, planting, watering, and pruning. ❖ Promote a robust urban forest through policies and practices that reduce its vulnerability to known diseases or pest infestations, and future threats, including the anticipated effects of climate change. ❖ Engage in a continuous process of long-range planning for the growth and maintenance of the urban forest. ❖ Promote public appreciation of the urban forest through educational outreach programs. ❖ Support local businesses, institutions, organizations, and individuals in their efforts to grow and maintain the urban forest through community education. ❖ Proceed in a manner that is inclusive and transparent. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 113 | P a g e AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 A | P a g e APPENDICES APPENDIX A. IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE B A 10-year annual work plan to achieve the urban forest vision and goals. APPENDIX B. SOLUTIONS WORKBOOK AND POSSIBLE GUIDELINES FOR TREE AND SIDEWALK CONFLICTS F A decision checklist and solutions kit for consideration in dealing with tree and hardscape conflicts. Supports tree preservation and canopy goals along with City ADA requirements. APPENDIX C. GUIDANCE TO DEVELOP A TREE ADVISORY COMMITTEE Q To increase Urban Forestry Program capacity and support, the guidance for establishing a volunteer committee of tree advocates is provided. APPENDIX D. 2021 URBAN FOREST AUDIT SYSTEM RESULTS T To inform the development of the Plan’s goals, objectives, and strategies, the U.S. Forest Service’s Urban Forest Sustainability and Management Audit System was implemented. This evaluation or audit identifies the City’s urban forest management strengths and opportunities and provides a framework for monitoring Plan implementation and success. APPENDIX E. RISK TREE MANAGEMENT PLAN EE The draft strategy to manage tree risk and public safety is included for City consideration and adoption. APPENDIX F. URBAN FOREST PEST READY ASSESSMENT QQ The State of WA developed the Urban Forest Pest Readiness Playbook and includes an assessment worksheet to gauge and prepare communities for potential tree pest outbreaks. Completing the assessment worksheet is a Plan action (Action #1.5A.5) and completing it will close the gap in readiness and response capabilities. APPENDIX E. REFERENCES VV Provides a list of the resources, research, and studies referenced in and supporting the Plan in the order they are provided. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices B | P a g e Strategies and Actions YR2022 YR2023 YR2024 YR2025 YR2026 YR2027 YR2028 YR2029 YR2030 YR2031 1.1 Make data-driven management decisions 1.1A Maintain the public tree inventory Action 1.1A.1 Track all maintenance history of public trees Action 1.1A.2 Add newly planted trees to the inventory Action 1.1A.3 Quantify the ecosystem benefits of the public trees Action 1.1A.4 Monitor and assess the public tree population for risk and tree pests/diseases 1.1B Utilize current and future canopy assessments Action 1.1B.1 Plant trees based on themes such as low tree canopy cover, low tree equity, and environmental conditions Action 1.1B.2 Update policies and design guidelines to preserve existing tree canopy cover Action 1.1B.3 Prepare scope of work and RFP for updated canopy assessment Action 1.1B.4 Execute contract and complete the canopy assessment $10,000 $10,000 Action 1.1B.5 Refine canopy goals and planting priorities 1.2 Sustainably manage the public tree population 1.2A Establish an interdepartmental green team Action 1.2A.1 Identify key members Action 1.2A.2 Finalize members, meeting intervals, team objectives Action 1.2A.3 Meet regularly to address workflows, communications, knowledge sharing Action 1.2A.4 Tree managing staff should engage in City department planning such as updates to the City’s comprehensive plan 1.2B Establish and implement a 7-year pruning cycle program Action 1.2B.1 Finalize the annual costs for a 7-year pruning cycle Action 1.2B.2 Finalize the annual costs for the in-house arborist crew Action 1.2B.3 Finalize the framework for the pruning program (City grids, priority areas, in-house vs. contracted) Action 1.2B.4 Submit budget request for pruning program Action 1.2B.5 Submit budget request for in-house arborist crew Annual staff cost $168,000 $168,000 $168,000 $168,000 $168,000 $168,000 $168,000 $168,000 $168,000 Vehicle and equipment purchase $410,000 Annual operating costs $102,698 $102,698 $102,698 $102,698 $102,698 $102,698 $102,698 $102,698 $102,698 Annual training, certifications, and membership costs $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 Action 1.2B.6 Prune 3,654 public trees annually and adjust as the population grows $134,000 1.2C Improve workflows for tree clearance issues Action 1.2C.1 Document existing workflows and procedures Action 1.2C.2 Identify inefficiencies and resource needs Action 1.2C.3 Increase public education on private tree right-of-way encroachment Action 1.2C.4 Formalize standard operating procedures between departments Action 1.2C.5 Utilize in-house arborist crew for all public tree clearance requests 1.2D Ensure newly planted trees receive post-planting care and young tree training Action 1.2D.1 Establish maintenance plans for new plantings Action 1.2D.2 Plant trees using the right tree, right place approach Action 1.2D.3 Educate the public and gather local community input on public tree plantings Action 1.2D.4 Acquire commitments from the local community and property owners to water new trees Action 1.2D.5 Utilize the newly developed community tree steward program APPENDIX A. IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 C | P a g e Strategies and Actions YR2022 YR2023 YR2024 YR2025 YR2026 YR2027 YR2028 YR2029 YR2030 YR2031 1.3 Establish a strategy for increasing tree canopy cover through City and public efforts 1.3A Formally establish the Tree Planting Initiative Action 1.3A.1 Finalize tree canopy goals and priority planting areas and themes Action 1.3A.2 Establish a Citywide tree planting plan and strategies $6,000 Action 1.3A.3 Identify local community partners for planting, maintenance, and funding 1.3B Increase Citywide tree canopy cover Action 1.3B.1 Increase tree canopy cover with City-led plantings (570 trees per year, $150 per tree)$50,000 $85,500 $85,500 $85,500 $85,500 $85,500 $85,500 $85,500 $85,500 $85,500 Action 1.3B.2 Increase tree canopy cover through partnerships and property owner-led plantings (380 trees per year) 1.3C Grow a sustainable and resilient urban forest Action 1.3C.1 Monitor and analyze the inventory for species diversity Action 1.3C.2 Update a Recommended Tree List for City-led projects Action 1.3C.3 Work with local nurseries to expand tree species options Action 1.3C.4 Strengthen storm and disaster preparations, mitigations, and recovery strategies, protocols, and mechanisms Action 1.3C.5 Complete the WA Urban Forest Pest Readiness Playbook Assessment (UFMP Appendix F) 1.4 Effectively manage tree risk 1.4A Adopt the Risk Tree Management Plan Action 1.4A.1 Update the draft Risk Tree Management Plan Action 1.4A.2 Acquire approval from Risk Management Action 1.4A.3 Implement the Risk Tree Management Plan 1.4B Institute a formal rotation for risk tree inspection Action 1.4B.1 Maintain an inventory of public trees Action 1.4B.2 Apply industry standards and best practices and implement the Risk Tree Management Plan AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices D | P a g e Strategies and Actions YR2022 YR2023 YR2024 YR2025 YR2026 YR2027 YR2028 YR2029 YR2030 YR2031 2.1 Create an urban forestry public outreach program that addresses all communities 2.1A Maintain Tree City USA recognition Action 2.1A.1 Maintain accurate records for the application Action 2.1A.2 Submit annual application Action 2.1A.3 Arbor Day Celebration and Proclamation Action 2.1A.4 Submit application for Tree City USA Growth Award Action 2.1A.5 Acquire 10 Growth Awards for Sterling Tree City USA status 2.1B Maintain active communications with diverse audiences Action 2.1B.1 Develop a community outreach plan with collaboration from City departments Action 2.1B.2 Formalize messaging for various audiences (property owners, developers, HOAs, youth, tree companies) Action 2.1B.3 Update the City's website with UFMP information Action 2.1B.4 At least quarterly, share information and updates Action 2.1B.5 Gather feedback and input using public surveys to inform future messaging 2.1C Provide education and training workshops Action 2.1C.1 Use the outreach plan (Action 2.1B.1) to finalize topics, audiences, approach Action 2.1C.2 Identify existing resources and tools for workshops Action 2.1C.3 Identify and collaborate with community partners Action 2.1C.4 Support youth education of environmental topics, engage schools with Arbor Day events Action 2.1C.4 Lead or support at least one training or education material annually $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 2.1D Implement program services through the lens of environmental justice Action 2.1D.1 Identify local community groups and partners to represent all neighborhoods Action 2.1D.2 Identify low canopy neighborhoods for targeted engagement Action 2.1D.3 Explore with partners the 3-30-300 rule for community greening Action 2.1D.4 Develop strategies to remove barriers to participation for all community members Barriers to address include ADA communications compliance, internet access, languages, transportation 2.2 Increase capacity through trained citizens 2.2A Create a volunteer corps or tree stewards program Action 2.2A.1 Identify a local community partner to support urban forestry and the tree stewards program Action 2.2A.2 Establish a training curriculum and gather available resources View an example Tree Steward Manual here https://treesvirginia.org/images/pdfs/2020TreeStewardManualver03.pdf Action 2.2A.3 Announce the program and set up an online or in-person training event 2.2B Establish a Community Tree Advisory Committee Action 2.2B.1 Organize interested citizens and outline challenges and opportunities Action 2.2B.2 Hold informal meetings with concerned citizens and local officials Action 2.2B.3 Meet with the City Attorney to finalize the framework Action 2.2B.4 Finalize the powers, authority, and responsibilities Action 2.2B.5 Draft the ordinance and the staff report for adopting the ordinance Action 2.2B.6 Seek the Council's approval of the ordinance at a public hearing 2.2C Effectively manage volunteers and events Action 2.2C.1 Identify needs and interests from multiple departments Action 2.2C.2 Work with the City's Volunteer Coordinator to strengthen the outreach plan (Action 2.1B.1) Action 2.2C.3 Identify opportunities to increase capacity for the Volunteer Coordinator (e.g., seasonal, Tree Committee, volunteers)AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 E | P a g e Strategies and Actions YR2022 YR2023 YR2024 YR2025 YR2026 YR2027 YR2028 YR2029 YR2030 YR2031 3.1 Strengthen policies for protecting the urban forest 3.1A Protect trees during public construction projects Action 3.1A.1 Continue to review tree and sidewalk conflicts Action 3.1A.2 Update and standardize construction design standards (4-4-130.H.9) to include requirements of ANSI A300 Construction Management Standard - Part 5 Action 3.1A.3 Perform construction project inspections to ensure proper tree protection requirements are implemented and maintained Action 3.1A.4 Establish a fee schedule for violation of Tree Protection Zones (TPZ) Action 3.1A.5 Add definition to support role of Urban Forestry Program provided to Code Compliance 3.1B Apply a no-net-loss approach to tree canopy cover Action 3.1B.1 Update the 1 to 1 tree replacement requirement for CIP or infrastructure projects with the same requirements as residential parcels requiring every inch be replaced Action 3.1B.2 Require 30% tree retention include best specimen trees, especially landmark trees, and the percentage is calculated prior to roadway overlay Action 3.1B.3 Amend landmark trees minimum diameter to 24 inches or greater Action 3.1B.4 Require a permit for the removal of any trees greater than 6 inches DBH for development projects Action 3.1B.5 Add alternative solutions for tree and sidewalk conflicts to include low impact design (LID) options for surface water mitigation Action 3.1B.6 Develop a fee-in-lieu of payment for the value of any trees removed from the development site and not planted back into the landscape Action 3.1B.7 Update the method for tree value calculation using CTLA trunk-formula method or increase the inch fee to $250 per inch 3.1C Use tree canopy assessment data for tree management policies Action 3.1C.1 Evaluate causes for canopy loss from the 2010 and 2017 assessments, specifically the loss on Resource Conservation land (-2.1%) Action 3.1C.2 Update policies to include long-term and intermediate Citywide and local canopy goals 3.1D Update and strengthen tree ordinances Action 3.1D.1 Prepare or modify a report that proposes necessary Code updates and additions Action 3.1D.2 Coordinate with Planning Department and others to prepare new Code docket items Action 3.1D.3 Share with the public the adopted changes to tree-related Code 3.2 Improve workflows and operations for sustainable urban forest management 3.2A Enforce tree regulations Action 3.2A.1 Enforce tree protection during construction, inspect Tree Protection Zones, inspect tree retentions Action 3.2A.2 Continue to support the contracted Inspecting Arborist or utilize potential in-house arborist crew Action 3.2A.3 Update contractor business license requirements Require a Renton Tree Regulations competency test Require Certificate of Insurance Fine for no business license is increased to $1,000 Tree code violations result in loss of license Action 3.2A.4 Consolidate tree-related policies, guidelines, best practices, and standards into a tree manual for multiple audiences. 3.2B Engage more consistently in all tree removal permit requests Action 3.2B.1 Evaluate the feasibility of tree removal permitting to be managed by Urban Forestry Action 3.2B.2 Explore the costs and funding mechanisms for a full-time development review arborist Green Asset Management Goal Costs $184,000 $774,198 $368,198 $358,198 $358,198 $358,198 $358,198 $368,198 $358,198 $358,198 Community Engagement Goal Costs $0 $0 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 Tree Policy Goal Costs $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 Total Costs $184,000 $774,198 $370,198 $360,198 $360,198 $360,198 $360,198 $370,198 $360,198 $360,198 AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices F | P a g e APPENDIX B. SOLUTIONS WORKBOOK AND POSSIBLE GUIDELINES FOR TREE AND SIDEWALK CONFLICTS Decision Matrix The development of Renton’s Urban Forest Management Plan identified the need to clarify the decision process to address tree and sidewalk or construction conflicts. A clear decision matrix can help to reduce inter- and inner-department uncertainty and establish or adhere to consistency and fairness. The City’s departments have standard operating procedures and checklists for evaluating conflicts at a project site, but these traditionally have not been available to the public. To make the decision process around the retention or removal of trees more transparent and consistent, a clarified process, decision matrix, and solution toolkit should be developed to highlight the key decision points. Proposed Decision Matrix for Tree and Construction/Sidewalk Conflicts Initial Assessment The following applies to tree removal requests and proposed projects. The initial assessment of trees, sidewalks (or other infrastructure), and site at the service request location or project location provides consistency and predictability by collecting the appropriate information. It is recommended to have the Urban Forestry Program involved in the initial assessment process and/or a City staff member with an International Society of Arboriculture Certified Arborist accreditation. • Tree Preservation Potential. What is the tree quality or health, and is it worth preserving? Is the tree designated as a significant tree or Landmark Tree? • Tree Mitigation Exploration. If the request to remove the tree is a result of infrastructure damage and the tree exhibits poor health or vigor, can the tree’s health or vigor be mitigated by any means other than removal? • Public Safety Risk. Is the tree a potential hazard that cannot be mitigated by any means other than removal? This includes any tree or tree part that poses a high risk of damage to persons or property located in public places. Use the International Society of Arboriculture’s tree risk evaluation standards. • Initial Assessment Timing. It is recommended that the initial assessment be conducted within 3-4 weeks of receiving a service request for removal. If the assessment is required PUBLIC INVOLVEMENT SERVICE REQUEST RECEIVED CITY PROPOSED PROJECT DEVELOPER PROJECT OTHER PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION SOLUTIONS FURTHER EVALUATION INITIAL ASSESSMENT Figure 43. Proposed decision matrix for tree and construction conflicts AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 G | P a g e due to a proposed project, the assessment should occur no later than 30% design or equivalent of design effort (e.g., during the Environmental Assessment period). • Tracking. Consider tracking service requests in the City’s asset software or simil ar program. • For an example Initial Assessment Checklist, see the Example Initial Assessment Checklist further below. Initial Tree Decision If the tree removal request was made due to the condition of the tree or other reason not relating to the damage or impediment of infrastructure such as sidewalk, the Urban Forester or representative may conduct the initial tree decision. If infrastructure is part of the assessment and/or the tree removal request was initiated for a proposed project, the City Engineer or appropriate staff should also be part of the initial tree decision. The appropriate staff will visit the tree and/or proposed project location and assess the tree (and sidewalk, if applicable) conditions. The following actions will result from the assessment: • Remove Tree. The tree removal request was made not as a result of the tree impacting or damaging infrastructure and the tree is identified as unhealthy or unsafe with no remediation possible. - Remove the tree and consider the “no net loss” policy of replacing the tree. Some cities implement a 2:1 replacement to removal ratio. The replacement policy should be based on City Code. Replacement of trees can occur on site, same street, or City - approved location. A fee in-lieu should also be considered as an option as described in City Code. - Removal of the tree should be prioritized based on other work orders, the risk assessment of the tree, and other factors. - The service request, decision, work order, tree information, and tree removal information should be tracked in the City’s asset software or similar program. • Retain Tree. Based on the assessment, the tree is not in decline or the issues can be remediated. Alternatively, if the tree in question is designated as a Landmark Tree or significant tree, the tree may be preserved depending on the tree condition and presence of hazards or risks as described in the City policies and manuals. - Document the decision, inform the property owner or project developer. - Conduct the remediation activity to the tree if needed. - Prioritize and track this information in the asset software or similar program. - Conduct follow-ups with the property owner and monitor the tree if necessary. • Remove Tree and Replace Sidewalk. The service request or proposed project identifies a tree that is causing sidewalk conflicts and the tree has been deemed unhealthy and no remediation is possible. The City should reference City Code as to what is defined as unhealthy or hazardous. - Remove the tree and consider the “no net loss” policy of replacing the tree. Some cities implement a 2:1 replacement to removal ratio. The requirement to replace the tree will be the City and Urban Forester’s discretion. The replacement policy should be based on City Code. Replacement of trees can occur on site, same street, or City- approved location. A fee in-lieu should also be considered as an option as described in City Code. - Removal of the tree should be prioritized based on other work orders, the risk assessment of the tree, and other factors. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices H | P a g e - The service request, decision, work order, tree information, and tree removal information should be tracked in the City’s tree inventory software or similar program. - Replace the sidewalk using appropriate design standards and materials and consider designing according to standards that will protect any replacement trees and provide ample soil volume and root space for the new or existing trees. • Retain Tree and Maintain Sidewalk. A tree in question is in conflict with infrastructure and the assessment determined that the tree is to be retained and the infrastructure (i.e., sidewalk) is to be corrected. The sidewalk will be of standard width and a tree pit of standard width (at minimum) can be installed or retained. - Coordinate with Public Works the timing and approach for maintaining the sidewalk. Be sure to consider alternative sidewalk amendments such as width reduction, alternative materials, among other solutions. - If any root pruning is needed to amend the sidewalk, the Urban Forester and/or a Certified Arborist hired by the City should evaluate to determine the appropriate root pruning, branch pruning, soil amendments, and other maintenance required. - Documentation in City’s asset software as stated before is recommended. • Evaluate Tree and/or Sidewalk Further. During the initial tree decision, it is not appropriate for extensive explorations of pavement, soils, or tree root systems. There are limitations to the initial assessment and decision. The purpose of the initial assessment is to identify where these future actions are requ ired so that the appropriate schedule and funding can be determined. - Documentation in City’s asset software as stated before is recommended. Further Evaluation The team conducting further evaluation may include an arborist, landscape architect, engineer, or other professionals with expertise relevant to the project details and situation. In addition to collecting information about the trees and infrastructure (i.e., sidewalk) the following additional items may be considered: Level of impact, future risks, cost/benefit, anticipated sidewalk maintenance if the tree is kept, public/environmental benefit, community values, policy guidance, neighborhood context, historic districts, planned construction, funding forecasts. Solutions The following best practices and approaches are provided as examples. The City should review and update these as new or improved practices and materials emerge. • If Tree Removed, Obtain Valuation. If the tree must be removed, the City should provide guidelines to replace the removed tree. Guidelines should be based on City Code. Ideally, the tree would be replaced at the same location if the site is suitable for trees in the first place. If not possible, the City should have a procedure in place for the relocation of replacement trees. • If Tree is Retained, Determine Management Approach. Since the initial assessment offered the opportunity to closely examine the tree and the site, future management approaches and decisions should be discussed and documented. These include future tree replacement species for when the tree does over mature and decline or conduct corrective actions to provide clearance for pedestrians, vehicles, utilities, and signs. • Identify Potential Sidewalk Solutions. The Alternative Solutions Toolkit Overview section provides information and resources regarding sidewalk solution options. Information gathered during the initial assessment and subsequent site visits will support the AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 I | P a g e selection of options that should be presented to City staff to ensure goals of sidewalk repair and tree preservation are kept. • Identify Opportunities to Improve Conditions for New Trees. When trees are planted by the City, the appropriate tree species for the location should be determined and the City should adhere to best practices in site and tree pit preparation to provide enough soil volume to support tree root growth and minimize future pavement damage by roots. If a tree is being planted at or near where the tree removal request was made, an evaluation of why the request was made should be considered. This may include such things as inadequate soil volume, insufficient growing space, tree leaf litter, messy fruit, poor structure, allergies, screening of shade-intolerant garden or landscape vegetation, or a combination of factors. Project Implementation Whether the sidewalk repair is occurring at a location where the tree is retained or removed, the sidewalk must adhere to the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) requirements and City standards and is the responsibility of the City. Tree repaving projects, curb and gutter repairs, and other Capital Projects should also adhere to this evaluation process. All matters relating to the removal or remediation of the tree will be conducted by the City unless the responsibility of tree maintenance in public rights-of-way changes. Regarding tree maintenance, mitigation, or removal, the City should involve the public by: • Providing a public notice prior to the initial tree assessment. • Share the results of the initial assessment. • Share the solution decision. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices J | P a g e EXAMPLE INITIAL ASSESSMENT CHECKLIST [CITY LOGO] [City of ####] Trees and Sidewalks Operations Plan Initial Street Tree and Sidewalk Assessment Checklist DATE Prepared By: The purpose of this document is to outline INITIAL ASSESSMENT for locations where sidewalk work is located within the dripline of an existing street tree. Project Location/Address Tree Species/Diameter Street Classification/Type Tree Asset Inventory ID Sidewalk Segment # Is this assessment along a corridor project? An [ENGINEER] and [ARBORIST] will look at the site and assess the condition of the sidewalk and the tree. If the tree has the following characteristics, it should be removed/replaced pursuant to SMC 15.43.030 (C): The City's policy is to retain and preserve street trees whenever possible. Accordingly, street tree removal shall not be permitted unless the Director determines that a street tree: 1. Is a hazardous tree; 2. Poses a public safety hazard; 3. Is in such a condition of poor health or poor vigor that removal is justified; or 4. Cannot be successfully retained, due to public or private construction or development conflicts. Initial Assessment 1. Is the tree healthy and worthy of preservation? □ Yes □ No Describe:_______________________________________________________________________ 2. Poor Health – Is this tree in a condition of poor health or poor vigor that cannot be mitigated by any means other than removal? □ Yes □ No Describe:_______________________________________________________________________ 3. Hazardous Tree— Defined in [CITY CODE CITATION] any tree or tree part that poses a high risk of damage to persons using, or property located in the public place, as determined by the [AUTHORITY] according to the tree hazard evaluation standards established by the International Society of Arboriculture. □ Yes □ No Describe:_______________________________________________________________________ AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 K | P a g e 4. Minimum Standards—Is there enough space for a [6 foot wide sidewalk and a 5 foot wide] planting strip? □ Yes □ No Describe:_______________________________________________________________________ 5. Public Safety Hazard—Does the tree present a public safety hazard that cannot be mitigated by any means other than removal? • Does the tree location obstruct the visibility for pedestrians, cyclists, and/or cars at an intersection? • Is the tree impacting a curb ramp such that it no longer meets City of [CITY] ADA requirements? • Is the tree potentially impacting private property? □ Yes □ No Recommendation for this tree: □ –Remove Tree / Replace Sidewalk A tree is identified to be removed if it is not healthy or if it is hazardous as identified in the Street Tree Ordinance. □ –Keep Tree and Maintain Sidewalk A tree will be kept and the sidewalk will be maintained if a sidewalk of standard width and a tree pit of standard width (at a minimum) can be installed or retained around a healthy tree. □ –Evaluate Sidewalk and/or Tree Further [DEPARTMENT] views trees and sidewalks as important public infrastructure assets. [DEPARTMENT] intends to keep healthy trees and have accessible sidewalks. If standard widths cannot be met then [DEPARTMENT] will take the time and resources to evaluate if alternative approaches (such as sidewalk width reduction, alternative sidewalk materials, adjustments to the tree pit and/or tree root pruning) can be used to retain a tree and provide an accessible sidewalk at problem locations. NEXT STEPS If Tree is REMOVED –Replace the removed tree with the minimum 2:1 replacement ratio. Identify if the replacement trees can be located in the same location or on the same street as the removed tree. If not, replacements should be planted as close to the removal as geographically feasible. Identify the estimated cost to remove the tree(s), repair the sidewalk, and plant replacement trees. If Tree is KEPT –Estimate the cost of the sidewalk repair that would achieve the desired lifecycle for the repair. Estimate sidewalk and tree maintenance needs/costs and any maintenance to the tree that is being retained (e.g., root pruning, branch pruning, soil amendments). If EVALUATE Further – Use Tree and Sidewalk Evaluation Form (IN DEVELOPMENT) and/or the tree risk assessment should follow ISA TRAQ guidelines: http://www.isa‐ arbor.com/education/onlineresources/basictreeriskassessmentform.aspx Arborist Engineer Title Tile Date Date Use this space to draw a sketch of the location. Identify existing clearances from nearby infrastructure. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices L | P a g e Alternative Solutions Toolkit Overview MATERIAL DESIGN ROOT TREE Paving and Other Surface Materials These materials can be used to create a walkable surface or to delineate space for people and/or the tree. Infrastructure-Based Design Solutions These design considerations can be employed to support a tree and/or sidewalk. Rootzone-Based Materials These tools can support tree health and guide tree growth below ground. Tree-Based Solutions These solutions are focused on tree selection and tree maintenance. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 M | P a g e Table 28. Description of possible alternative solutions for tree and construction conflicts TOOL TYPE TOOLS PROACTIVE RESPONSIVE COST* EXPECTED USEFUL LIFE $ $$ $$$ $$$$ Month Year Decade Century MATERIAL PAVING AND OTHER SURFACE MATERIALS Asphalt P R $-$$$ M Y D C Expansion Joints P R $ M Y D C Pavers P R $$-$$$ M Y D C Pervious Concrete P R $$$-$$$$ M Y D C Reinforced or Thicker Slab P R $$-$$$ M Y D C Rockery / Wall P R $$-$$$$ M Y D C Beveling P R $-$$ M Y D C Porous Asphalt P R $-$$$ M Y D C Shims P R $ M Y D C Tree Guards and Tree Rails P R $$-$$$ M Y D C Decomposed Granite P R $-$$ M Y D C Mudjacking (Concrete Leveling) P R $$-$$$$ M Y D C DESIGN INFRASTRUCTURE-BASED DESIGN SOLUTIONS Monolithic Sidewalk P R $$$ M Y D C Pavement Thickness P R $$$ M Y D C Tree Pit Sizing P R $ M Y D C Bridging P R $$$$ M Y D C Curb Bulbs P R $$$-$$$$ M Y D C Curb Realignment P R $$$-$$$$ M Y D C Curving or Offset Sidewalk P R $$-$$$ M Y D C Easement P R $-$$$ M Y D C Suspended Pavement Systems P R $$$-$$$$ M Y D C Lowered Sites P R $$$-$$$$ M Y D C Soil Volume P R $-$$$ M Y D C AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices N | P a g e TOOL TYPE TOOLS PROACTIVE RESPONSIVE COST* EXPECTED USEFUL LIFE $ $$ $$$ $$$$ Month Year Decade Century ROOT ROOTZONE-BASED MATERIALS Mulch P R $ M Y D C Root Barriers P R $ M Y D C Continuous Trenches P R $$$ M Y D C Foam Underlay P R $-$$ M Y D C Modified Gravel Layer P R $ M Y D C Root Paths P R $-$$ M Y D C Soil Modification P R $-$$ M Y D C Steel Plates P R $$-$$$ M Y D C Structural Soils P R $$-$$$ M Y D C Subsurface Aeration / Irrigation P R $$ M Y D C TREE TREE-BASED SOLUTIONS City Forestry Street Tree List P R $ M Y D C Corrective Pruning P R $-$$ M Y D C Root Pruning P R $-$$ M Y D C *General cost notes: • Sidewalk material costs, when given in linear feet, assume 6-foot sidewalk width • Costs are planning-level costs and will vary for actual construction • Costs do not include design, permitting, or other "soft" costs • Costs not included in tool costs but which would be necessary with use of some solutions include: o Drainage structure and connection o Curb ramps AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 O | P a g e BEVELING POROUS ASPHALT SHIMS TREE GUARDS/RAILS ASPHALT JOINTS PAVERS/RUBBER PERVIOUS CONCRETE DECOMPOSED GRANITE MUDJACKING BRIDGING BULBOUTS Figure 44. Example of alternative solutions for tree and construction conflicts AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices P | P a g e CURB REALIGNMENT EASEMENT SUSPENDED PAVEMENT ROOT BARRIERS CORRECTIVE PRUNING ROOT PRUNING ROOT SHAVING FOAM UNDERLAY MOD. GRAVEL LAYER STRUCTURAL SOILS ROOT PATHS Source of Material Examples & Images: AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 Q | P a g e APPENDIX C. GUIDANCE TO DEVELOP A TREE ADVISORY COMMITTEE To increase the capacity and voice for residents in managing the trees in Renton, guidance is provided for the City to consider the benefits of establishing a Community Tree Advisory Committee. This document provides specific recommendations and considerations for the City of Renton. Overview Forming a Community Tree Advisory Committee (TAC)— also referred to as a tree commission, tree board, urban forestry commission, beautification committee, environmental advisory committee, community forestry commission, among others depending on the jurisdiction — is one step Renton can take to create and sustain an urban forestry program. The powers a nd responsibilities of a Tree Advisory Committee are based on Washington statutes and are assumed by the local government. By forming and empowering a tree commission, Renton can provide an opportunity for important community decisions to include the perspectives of the communities of Renton. The formation of the TAC can be a crucial element in developing broad-based support for community trees and ensuring long-term success and growth of Renton’s urban forestry program. Proposed Responsibilities of the Tree Advisory Committee The Tree Advisory Committee should reflect the values and standards of the community and should help champion urban forestry efforts. The recommended roles and responsibilities of Renton’s TAC could include the following: ❖ Periodic review of Urban Forestry Program activities. ❖ Participate in an advisory capacity for tree removal appeals processes. ❖ Act as a sounding board for administrative issues in urban forest management. ❖ Stimulate and help organize volunteer tree planting and maintenance events. ❖ Assist with a possible ‘Heritage’ or ‘Historic’ trees program. ❖ Support urban forest management generally in an advisory capacity. ❖ Help identify, facilitate and recommend solutions to tree-related community disputes. The proposed responsibilities of the TAC would be customized to suit the task, but Renton ordinances creating either the Senior Citizen Advisory Group or the Equity Commission could serve as useful references. Formation of the Tree Advisory Committee Formation of the Tree Advisory Committee and development of a comprehensive urban forestry program usually take place together. The creation of Renton’s TAC is recommended at this stage due to the opportunities that have arisen during the development of the City’s current Urban Forest Management Plan (UFMP). The UFMP project began in May 2021 and is anticipated to be completed by February 2022 and throughout this planning effort, community members and organizations have been educated and engaged to support the development of the UFMP. This public engagement has increased awareness of and support for the City’s urban forestry efforts. The engaged community members may now be interested in actively participating on the TAC. Renton’s citizens who have been active in public engagement activities for the Urban Forest Management Plan can provide valuable insight on a TAC. The requirements relating to membership of committees are identified in the City of Renton municipal code Title II Commissions and Boards. Members shall be appointed by the mayor and approved by City Council. It is recommended that the City of Renton identify and explore specific sectors of the community to recruit diverse members of various backgrounds and experiences. The following steps are recommended for Renton to organize citizens and form the Tree AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices R | P a g e Advisory Committee: ❖ Hold informal meetings with concerned citizens and local officials to discuss ideas and plans. Discuss with the City Attorney’s office legal requirements to establish a Tree Advisory Committee. ❖ Organize interested citizens and informally outline opportunities for a TAC to address and advise on specific occurrences or situations (such as tree failures, tree preservation, tree removals, tree removal permit denials, pruning, sidewalk damage, or tree planting) that have caused community conflict or liability. Describe benefits that are expected to result from an organized tree program (such as lower community liability, higher real estate values, more attractive commercial areas, healthier trees, and increased community fellowship). ❖ Contact other communities with Tree Advisory Committees or other experts, such as the Washington Community Forest Council, Extension Forestry, and the State of Washington Urban and Community Forestry program for advice and support. ❖ Liaise with Forestry Staff. It can be the case that a staff member sits on the committee in a non-voting capacity— this provides an important link to the municipal process. ❖ Identify and agree upon the powers, authority, and responsibilities of the TAC, through meetings with municipal council members, officials, and the City Attorney’s office. ❖ Involve community members through public hearings and other opportunities for public participation and response. ❖ Develop or rewrite the ordinance that legally establishes the TAC and defines its authority and powers. ❖ Seek the council's approval of the ordinance according to the City’s procedure. Establishment of the Tree Advisory Committee by Ordinance Municipal ordinances establishing and empowering Tree Advisory Committees should contain the following sections: ❖ Number of committee members, ❖ Experience or expertise required of members, ❖ Place of residence, ❖ Compensation, if any, ❖ Length of terms, ❖ Rotation of terms, ❖ Vacancies, ❖ Advisory duties, ❖ Primary focus areas. Additionally, ordinances establishing Tree Advisory Committees can: ❖ Mandate a municipal arborist or forester position, ❖ Mandate and outline the creation of a municipal forestry master plan, ❖ Outline required standards and guidelines for tree planting and maintenance. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 S | P a g e Supporting the Tree Advisory Committee ❖ Consider training members through the Arbor Day Foundation’s Tree Board University. o An online training course consisting of eight courses: 1) Tree Board 101 2) Partnerships and Collaboration 3) Engaging in the Political Process 4) Community Forestry Planning 5) Communications and Marketing 6) Financing, Budgeting, Grants, Fundraising 7) Getting Things Done 8) Moving Forward ❖ Utilize additional resources such as the Arbor Day Foundation’s Tree Board flier. ❖ Keep the Tree Advisory Committee informed of the progress in implementing the Urban Forest Management Plan. ❖ Consider including a member(s) on the Urban Forest Management Plan implementation team. ❖ Upon establishment the TAC should establish By-Laws to instill cooperation and success. ❖ Keep the TAC current on urban forestry research, technology, tools, and ideas. ❖ Communicate programs, events, strengths, challenges, and opportunities. Summary A Tree Advisory Committee for Renton’s urban forest can have a great impact on a community's appearance and image as well as its public safety and comfort. Tree committees can help champion comprehensive and expert programming to manage and sustain public trees. They can help facilitate the provision of long-term, stable community involvement for a valuable, long-lived resource. By forming the Tree Advisory Committee in Renton, the attractiveness of the community and its quality of life and environment might be enhanced and further sustained. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices T | P a g e APPENDIX D. 2021 URBAN FOREST AUDIT SYSTEM RESULTS Urban Forest Audit Scoring Key Not Practiced (0) In Development (1) Adopted Practice (2) Management Policy Category Component Evaluated Description or Criteria for Evaluation 1.00 Approved Policy Statements Written policy statements approved by a governing body. 1.01 Climate Change (Sustainability) Also referred to as Sustainability. With reference to urban trees. Addresses the long-term health and productivity of the natural resource. 1.02 No Net Loss Can refer to trees, basal area, or canopy. 1.03 Risk Management Should reference: ANSI A300 Part 9, ISA BMP, and prioritization funding mechanisms. 1.04 Tree Canopy Goals Overall community/campus goal, or by designated “zone”. 1.05 Tree Protection Construction and/or landscape maintenance. 1.06 Utility Utility pruning, planting, and installation policy (e.g. boring vs. trenching). 1.07 Human Health – Physical & Psychological Recognizes and addresses the human health benefits of the natural resource (e.g., exercise, air quality, stress management, shade). Could also include Urban Heat Island (UHI) policies. 1.08 Wildlife Diversity/Habitat/Protection Mammals, birds, or reptiles. 1.09 Performance Monitoring Recognizes the annual or biennial calculation of metrics (e.g. some component of ecosystem services) for the purpose of tracking management performance. 1.10 Ordinance (Private) Tree protection and management for trees on private property. 1.11 Ordinance (Public) Tree protection and management for public trees. 1.12 Development Standards US Green Building Council’s LEED® rating systems (or similar internationally) LEED v4 BD+C (Sustainable Sites) LEED 4 ND (Neighborhood Pattern & Design, Green Infrastructure) ASLA’s SITES® Rating System 1.13 High-Conservation Value Forests Programs or policies for identification, acquisition, and/or protection of groups of trees or forests that provide unique public benefits. 1.14 Urban Interface (WUI) Programs or policies that improve management of the urban interface for fire and/or invasive species. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 U | P a g e Capacity and Training Category Component Evaluated Description or Criteria for Evaluation 2.00 Professional Management Provision for professional consultation. 2.01 Certified Arborist - Staff International Society of Arboriculture 2.02 Certified Arborist - Contracted International Society of Arboriculture 2.03 Certified Arborist - Other Resource International Society of Arboriculture 2.04 Other Professional - Advising/directing UF management This could be a professional in an allied field like Landscape Architecture. 2.05 Municipal Forestry Institute Graduate of Society of Municipal Arborist’s MFI program or similar 2.06 USFS Urban Forestry Institute or similar Attendance at USFS UFI or similar 2.07 Campus/city arborist – ISA CA instructor for CEUs Arborist routinely provides ISA CEU presentations/workshops. 2.08 Tree Board University or similar On-line training modules from Oregon U&CF for Tree Board/Advisory Council or similar 2.09 Organizational Communications Process, procedures, and protocol for cross-professional communications within the organization (all departments “touching” trees). AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices V | P a g e Funding and Accounting Category Component Evaluated Description or Criteria for Evaluation 3.00 Urban Forestry Budget 3.01 Budgeted Annually Budget authorized/required for tree board, tree maintenance, and/or tree planting. 3.02 Contingency Budget Process A protocol is in place to prioritize urban forestry management activities during budget shortfalls; e.g. during times of limited funding for: 1) risk management, 2) young tree care, 3) mulching. 3.03 Funding Calculated from Community Attribute Budget in terms of per capita, per tree, or for performance (e.g. per tree weighted by size class or age. 3.04 Funding Based on Performance Monitoring Budget connected with/based on ecosystem service (ES) monitoring and performance. 3.05 Urban Forestry Line Item Is the budget specific to urban forest management? 3.06 Green Asset Accounting Maintain green infrastructure data in the “unaudited supplementary disclosure of an entity’s comprehensive annual financial report (CAFR)”. GASB 34 implementation for municipalities. Authority Category Component Evaluated Description or Criteria for Evaluation 4.00 Authority 4.01 Urban Forest Manager Professional urban forest manager with authority over the program and day-to-day activity. Including designated budget line item. 4.02 Staff Authority Designated staff with authority over the program and day-to-day activity. Including designated line item. 4.03 Communication Protocol Established protocol and mechanism(s) for communication among all members of the urban forest management “community” in your municipality or organization (e.g. manager, department under control, advisory board, finance, field operations, public, NGOs, business community, developers). 4.04 Tree Board, Commission, or Advisory Council Establishes a board for public participation (advisory or with authority). AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 W | P a g e Inventories Category Component Evaluated Description or Criteria for Evaluation 5.00 Inventories and Assessments 5.01 Canopy Inventory (UTC) Periodic (≤5 year) canopy inventory and assessment. Public & private. 5.02 Ecosystem Services Recent (≤5 year) ecosystem services (ES) inventory & assessment? Public: 100% or street trees; Public & Private: Sample; or Campus. Or, are ES calculated annually or biennially based on partial re- inventory and projected growth as a monitoring tool. 5.03 Public Trees   Evaluate below  5.04 Street Trees Is there a recent (5 year) inventory? 5.05 Parks/Riparian Areas Is there a recent (5 year) inventory? 5.06 Other Public Trees Public facility landscaped areas, Industrial parks, green space. 5.07 Continuous inventory on a cycle (≤5 years; i.e. panel) Partial re-inventory to support continuous forest inventory, growth projections, and the calculation of ecosystem services for the purpose of long- term monitoring of urban forest management performance (e.g. carbon or leaf surface). 5.08 Private Trees   Evaluate below  5.09 Campus (Educational) Is there a recent (5 year) inventory? 5.10 Corporate Is there a recent (5 year) inventory? 5.11 Other Private Property Is there a recent (5 year) inventory? 5.12 Continuous inventory on a cycle (≤5 years; i.e. panel), inventory software Partial re-inventory to support continuous forest inventory, growth projections, and the calculation of ecosystem services for the purpose of long-term monitoring of urban forest management performance (e.g. carbon or leaf surface). 5.13 Green Stormwater Infrastructure (GSI) BMP stormwater mitigation practices and locations (e.g. Washington DC) 5.14 Spatial Inventory data includes Lat/Long (i.e. GIS). Should address the spatial relationship between the natural resource and people (i.e. residents, visitors, activities) that would help manage the resource for benefits associated with proximity (air quality, recreation, stress mitigation, improved educational opportunity). 5.15 Maintenance and Planting Records Maintained Planting details (nursery, species, size, cost, contractor, etc.) maintained with inventory or as separate database or recordkeeping system. Also pruning and removal histories. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices X | P a g e Plans Category Component Evaluated Description or Criteria for Evaluation 6.00 Management Planning Activities 6.01 Annual Maintenance Calendar An annual calendar that defines typical activity by season. To support scheduling. 6.02 Public Trees   Evaluate below  6.03 Street Tree Management Is there a recent (5 year) plan for street trees? 6.04 Parks/Riparian Area Management Is there a recent (5 year) plan ? 6.05 Other Public Trees Public facility landscaped areas, Industrial parks, green space. 6.06 Private Trees   Evaluate below  6.07 Campus (Educational) Is there a recent (5 year) plan for Campus trees? 6.08 Corporate Is there a recent (5 year) plan? 6.09 Other Private Property Is there a recent (5 year) plan? 6.10 Green Infrastructure Is there a plan for green infrastructure (i.e. nodes & linkages)? Large-scale projects. 6.11 Other Written Plans Other natural resource plans (e.g. tree canopy). May be a component of another plan. 6.12 Tree Planting Is there a recent (3 year) tree planting plan? ). May be a component of another plan. 6.13 UF as Part of a Comprehensive Plan Is any UF management plan referenced in the comprehensive plan (i.e. county or municipality) or master plan (i.e. Campus)? 6.14 Urban Forest Planning and Management Criteria and Performance Indicators Criteria and indicators based on A Model of Urban Forest Sustainability (Clark, J.R., Matheny, N.P., Cross, G., and Wake, V. 1997 Journal of Arboriculture.) or on work of W.A. Kenney, P.J.E. van Wassenaer, and A.L. Satel in Criteria and indicators for strategic urban forest planning and management. (2011) AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 Y | P a g e Risk Management Category Component Evaluated Description or Criteria for Evaluation 7.00 Risk Management Activities 7.01 TRAQ Attained At least one staff or consultant is TRAQ. 7.02 Annual Level 1 (ANSI A300 Part 9 & ISA BMP) All trees in high occupancy areas visited annually. 7.03 Mitigation Prioritization A protocol for prioritizing mitigation following Level 1 and Level 2 assessments. Reflects the controlling agency’s threshold for risk. 7.04 Occupancy Areas Mapped Has TRAQ staff/consultant discussed/mapped occupancy levels with controlling authority? 7.05 Recordkeeping, Reporting, and Communications A process has been put in place to maintain records on requests, inspections, evaluations, and mitigation of risk; and on the communications among the managers related to those risk assessments. 7.06 Standard of Care Adopted Controlling authority has adopted a Standard of Care (SOC) or risk management policy. 7.07 Tree Risk Specification Is there a written specification that meets requirements of ANSI A300 (Part 9)? And, has it been discussed with the controlling authority with relevance to the controlling authority’s threshold for acceptable risk? 7.08 Urban Tree Risk Management The community has prepared and follows a comprehensive program for urban tree risk management. 7.09 Invasive Management Plan to address and manage invasive: plants, insects, and disease. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices Z | P a g e Disaster Planning Category Component Evaluated Description or Criteria for Evaluation 8.00 Disaster Planning Activities 8.01 Response/Recovery Mechanism Staff knowledge of the municipality’s protocol for requesting disaster resources through the county or state with access to mutual aid and EMAC. 8.02 Urban Forestry as part of the County Disaster Plan The UF plan (8.3) is incorporated into the county/municipal disaster plan; specifically in reference to debris management and risk mitigation. 8.03 Urban Forestry Disaster Plan A separate/specific plan within the urban forestry management program (i.e. who to call, priorities). 8.04 Pre-disaster Contracts Contracts are in place for critical needs. 8.05 Mitigation Plan A mitigation plan has been developed for pre-disaster, recovery, and post-disaster. 8.06 EMAC Mission Ready Packages (MRP) Municipality has published disaster resources with state EM and participates in inter-state Mutual Aid to support Urban Forest Strike Teams (UFST). 8.07 Urban Forest Strike Team Participation in the UFST project. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 AA | P a g e Standards and Best Management Practices Category Component Evaluated Description or Criteria for Evaluation 9.00 ANSI Standard & BMP Activities 9.01 ANSI Standards Reference and adherence to ANSI Standards for arboricultural practices (A300), safety (Z133), or Nursery Stock (ANSI Z60.1) (any or all). 9.02 Ages/Diameter Distribution Specific management for the development of an age-diverse tree population 9.03 Arborist Standards Standards of practice for arborists (i.e. Certification). 9.04 Best Management Practices (BMPs) Establishes or references tree maintenance BMPs (i.e. written comprehensive standards & standards). 9.05 Fertilization and Mulching Fertilization or mulching standards required for conserved & planted trees. 9.06 Lightning Protection Systems BMP written to the ANSI A300 Standard. 9.07 Planting Planting and transplanting standards required/specified. 9.08 Pruning Pruning standards required for conserved & planted trees. 9.09 Removal Infrastructure damage, stump grinding, etc. 9.10 Support Systems (Guying and Bracing) BMP written to the ANSI A300 Standard. 9.11 Tree Risk Tree risk assessment procedures; ISA BMP or equivalent. 9.12 Construction Management Standards Written standards for: tree protection, trenching/boring in CRZs, pre-construction mulching, root or limb pruning, watering (any or all). 9.13 Design Standards Standards for design that specifically require trees; standards for tree placement (i.e. location), soil treatment, and/or drainage. 9.14 Genus/Species Diversity Suggests or requires diversity of plant material. 9.15 Green Stormwater Infrastructure (GSI) BMPs for site level GI practices like rain gardens and swales. Small- scale projects. 9.16 Inventory Data Collection Community has adopted or developed applicable standards for local urban tree inventory data collection to support QA/QC. 9.17 Minimum Planting Volume Minimum required root zone volume. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices BB | P a g e Standards and Best Management Practices (continued) Category Component Evaluated Description or Criteria for Evaluation 9.00 ANSI Standard & BMP Activities 9.18 Minimum Tree Size Minimum caliper for tree replacements, and/or minimum size of existing trees to receive tree density or canopy credit. 9.19 Root Protection Zone (CRZ) Defines adequate root protection zone; Critical Root Zone (CRZ). 9.20 Safety Safety logs, trainings, reference to ANSI Z133 Safety Standard 9.21 Topping Prohibits topping or other internodal cuts (public & private). 9.22 Tree Species List Identifies and publishes a list of the most desirable, recommended, and/or preferred species (may include native and non-native species); alternatively, a list of species prohibited. 9.23 Tree Quality Standards Written standards for tree selection at nursery in addition to Z60.1. 9.24 Utility Right-of-Way ( ROW) Management Requirements for planting, pruning, and/or removal of trees within a utility ROW. 9.25 Urban Agriculture Enabled urban food forestry practices. 9.26 Wood Utilization Larger diameter material is processed for wood products. 9.27 Third-party forest products certification compliance Examples: American Tree Farm System (ATFS), Forest Stewardship Council™ (FSC®) 9.28 Energy generation Local or regional use of chips or other woody debris for co- generation facilities. 9.29 Composting of Leaf and/or Other Woody Debris Leaves and small woody debris are captured and used on-site or processed by someone by composting for reuse. 9.30 Watering Standards AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 CC | P a g e Community Category Component Evaluated Description or Criteria for Evaluation 10.00 Activities that Build Community 10.01 Social Media Website or Similar Does your community/campus use social media platforms or similar to document and publicize your urban forestry program, activity, or events? 10.02 Education The urban forest is used as an educational laboratory for class activity; Kids in the Woods, PLT, high school, or college level. 10.03 Private Property Tree Program Does your community sponsor this program locally? 10.04 Tree Inventory and Management Software Public access to the community tree resource via an on-line mapping program (i.e. any Web Map Service; WMS). 10.05 Public Perception Is public management consistent with private property requirements for tree protections and care? Does the Campus/public tree management reflect neighborhood norms? 10.06 Recognition Programs Programs that raise awareness of trees or that use trees to connect the community to significant events or activities. 10.07 Arbor Day Celebration Whether or not associated with Tree City USA. 10.08 Arboretum designation Internal or third party arboretum designation. 10.09 Significant trees For example: size, history. 10.10 Memorial/Honorarium Tree planting or tree care programs than honor/memorialize individuals, organizations, or events. 10.11 Social Media Does your community/campus make use of Twitter, Facebook, Blogs for internal or external outreach? 10.12 Active Communications Press releases, regular news articles (print), “State of the Urban Forest” reports, periodic analysis of threats and opportunities. 10.13 Tree Care Are volunteers trained and used for basic tree care (e.g. mulching, pruning, planting). 10.14 Tree Campus USA®, Tree City USA®, Tree Line USA® Community/campus meets current qualifications for any of these programs. 10.15 Volunteer Opportunities Ad hoc or scheduled. Any/all age groups. Tree Campus USA student activities. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices DD | P a g e Green Asset Evaluation Category Component Evaluated Description or Criteria for Evaluation 11.00 Observed Outcomes (Activity, Health) 11.01 Deadwood Look for evidence of periodic or ad-hoc deadwood removal (i.e. lack of dead limbs ≥ 2” in the trees or on the ground). 11.02 Genus Diversity No genera exceed 20% of population; make specific observations for Acer, Quercus, Fraxinus, Ulmus and other local species of concern. 11.03 Mature Tree Care Mature trees are retained in the landscape, and are of acceptable risk; i.e. veteran tree management. 11.04 Mulching Evidence of adequate (i.e. spatial extent, depth, and material) roots zone mulching for all age classes. 11.05 Planting Site Volume Optimization Are species & sites matched for optimization of above ground canopy; right tree in the right spot concept. 11.06 Rooting Volume Optimization Are species & sites matched for optimization for below ground rooting volume; right tree in the right spot concept. 11.07 Species Diversity No species/cultivars exceed 10% of population; make specific observations for Acer, Quercus, Fraxinus, Ulmus and other local genera of concern. Also evaluate the role of regionally local native species. 11.08 Soil Compaction Observe evidence of soil compaction by users or staff during maintenance. Include “desire” lines and construction activity at time of evaluation. 11.09 Tree Health Rate the overall tree health in all size (age) classes; look for crown dieback, decay, foliage density & color. 11.10 Young Tree Pruning Look for evidence of periodic (e.g. every 3 years to year 9) structural pruning (e.g. subordination cuts, dominant central leader, co- dominant stems lower that 20’). AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 EE | P a g e APPENDIX E. RISK TREE MANAGEMENT PLAN CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON COMMUNITY SERVICES DEPARTMENT URBAN FORESTRY & NATURAL RESOURCES AUGUST 2020 TREE RISK MANAGEMENT PLAN AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices FF | P a g e Trees are a valuable asset to the community of Renton, beautifying our city and linking us to the natural environment. They also provide other benefits such as purifying our air, reducing energy consumption and costs, and reducing storm water runoff. However, a structurally defective tree in the urban setting can present a safety risk to people and property. Dying and defective trees can also increase wildfire risks - less of a concern in the South Puget Sound but one to be aware of in a changing climate. City of Renton Forestry is responsible for managing trees located on city street rights-of-way (street trees), parks, natural areas and city owned property. One of these responsibilities includes reducing the risks trees can pose to people and property. This is accomplished by identifying and evaluating defective city trees, assessing and quantifying the safety risks and taking the appropriate actions to reduce these risks. The City of Renton Urban Forestry Management Plan defines this process as Hazard Tree Management. Renton’s urban forest has grown since the first management plan in 2011 and there have been advances and changes in arboriculture; some as simple as dropping the terminology including “hazard” in favor of “risk”. This document is part of a new update to this management process and is redefined as a Tree Risk Management Plan. The purpose of this document is to inform the public of the City’s Tree Risk Management Plan. This plan provides guidelines, procedures and practices in the management of city trees that may present a safety risk to people and property. The city has actively managed risk trees for over 12 years with a concerted effort beginning in 2009. At that time, the city recognized the need to develop a long-range plan for the maintenance of the urban forest. To that end, more management information regarding Renton’s urban forest would be required and the city’s first public tree inventory was created. This inventory was updated in 2020. This document is the city’s first specified risk tree management plan. INTRODUCTION RISK TREE MANAGEMENT IN RENTON HISTORY Figure 1. An Oak tree in Maplewood Park dropped a 70' foot long 2' foot diameter branch during a hot day on an afternoon in late July of 2020 AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 GG | P a g e In 2011, the city published and City Council officially adopted the City of Renton Community and Urban Forest Development Plan. This plan did not include risk tree management specifically, but one of four major stated goals included increasing public safety by better management of the urban forest. Best management practice recommends clear definitions of tree hazards and use of International Society of Arboriculture (ISA) evaluation processes and forms for assessing risk trees. A risk plan should also explain a process of designating certain trees as “Monitor” trees; trees to be evaluated for tree risks once per year and after storm events. This process could serve the city well and the current City Forester recognized the need for a comprehensive risk tree management plan. There are new standards and tools for assessing risk trees and Renton’s urban forest is growing and aging. New assessmen t technologies such as resistance drill testing and sonic imaging could become part of the City Forester’s toolkit to assess decay pockets and the internal structural integrity of trees. The ISA has developed the new Tree Risk Assessment methodology, which differed from past evaluation techniques and has been standardized in the tree care industry. These changes and challenges in managing Renton’s urban forest, advancements in technology and arboricultural practices, and the forestry program's continuing efforts to provide the best urban forestry management services for the city brings us to today and the 2020 Tree Risk Management Plan. One of the unique challenges of managing Renton’s urban forest stems in part from the nature of trees in the Pacific Northwest - they grow tall here. Captain Renton, the city's namesake, made his fortune from timber harvested in the area, especially Douglas Fir trees. Small pockets of remnant stands of second growth trees can still be seen even today at the edge of new developments. They can be more prone to branch failures than other tree species during storms. In addition to large tree size, the prevalence of particular species in the urban forest population presents more opportunities for possible damages and consequences as a result of the failure of a tree or tree part. Other native species like Big Leaf Maples and Black Cottonwoods can also be problematic as they are also large trees and are prone to decay. They comprise a large proportion of the public tree population, especially in natural areas. We also see large specimen trees like Pin Oaks, Tulip Trees, Cedars and Sycamores on city streets which require thoughtful management. Therein lies the challenge and one of the justifications for a clearly defined tree risk management strategy. The result is that maintaining healthy tree populations requires more intensive management versus less “problematic” trees. This more intensive management comes at little higher cost to the community as well as accepting a little higher degree of tree related risk. RENTON’S LOGGING LEGACY AND 'TALL TREES' IN THE PACIFIC NORTHWEST Figure 2. Typical group of 'urban' Douglas Fir trees on NE Sunset Blvd. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices HH | P a g e Beyond adopted city policy, best management practice for risk trees should be no exception. The City of Renton Urban and Community Forestry Development Plan adopted by City Council established improving public safety as an important goal. The following procedures have been developed to guide the city in the implementation of the Tree Risk Management Plan in the next iteration of the city's 10-year urban forest management plan in 2021. A potential risk tree will be evaluated by the City Forester. The tree will be evaluated using the International Society of Arboriculture’s (ISA) Tree Risk Assessment Methodology (www.isa-arbor.com). This is the industry standard for evaluating a risk tree. It includes evaluating potential targets of a tree failure, defects in the tree that may fail, the probability the defect(s) may fail and finally the potential consequences if the defective tree part fails. The culmination of the assessment results in a Risk Rating; Low, Moderate, High or Severe. Other factors that are considered in determining the risk include; the occupancy rate of a target in the impact zone, whether a tree a strong or weak-wooded tree species, the possible exposure of the tree to strong wind events, a history of failures, topography and wildfire risk in a potential future wildfire control area. A risk tree is defined by the following industry terms. ➢ A Risk Tree is a tree with a defect present that has a likelihood of failure of Proba ble or Imminent, a target occupancy rate greater than Rare and/or located in a moderate or high wildfire risk area as determined by the City Forester. PRACTICES RISK TREE AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 II | P a g e The city is responsible for managing all trees located on public property. These include trees located on city street right-of- ways (street trees), parks natural areas and other city properties. However, trees are living, growing organisms that do not adhere to our people- made boundaries. A small young tree beginning its life clearly on a property, grows in diameter with age and may grow over a property line. In these cases of “border trees”, is it the city’s or the private property owner’s responsibility to manage the tree? The following guidelines define a City Tree and the responsibility for management of city/private property border trees. ➢ The city will review the management responsibility of any tree with at least half of its trunk diameter measured at 4.5 feet above grade located on a city right-of-way, easement or property. o If necessary, a professional survey will be performed to provide clarification. o In cases where there is clearly mutual responsibility, the city will work with the property owner to reach a mutually acceptable arrangement. There are trees located on private property that may pose an unacceptable risk to city property or the right-of- way. If the city identifies a risk tree on private property or is informed of a risk tree on private property, the following guidelines and collaboration with Code Compliance will direct city action. ➢ A risk tree located on private property, as determined by the City Forester, will be mitigated by the property owner or the city through a code compliance notice and order process as defined in the City of Renton Code. o In general, it includes a process of notifying the property owner and agreeing on mitigation strategy within a given time frame. RISK TREES LOCATED ON PRIVATE PROPERTY CITY TREE Figure 3. Example of a "border tree". AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices JJ | P a g e In a natural setting trees die or fall creating space for a new tree to grow in its place. In the urban setting, it is people that must manage this process. Dead, diseased or declining trees need to be removed when they become an unacceptable risk. People must plant trees to replace removed trees. The city values all trees, however at a certain point tree removal may be the best management practice to reduce risks to people and property, protect the urban forest from insect pests and disease, unacceptable wildfire risks and introduce renewal by planting replacement trees. The following tree removal guidelines will help direct public tree removal decisions in the City of Renton. ➢ A city tree will only be removed if it is an imminent threat to public safety , dead, dying, diseased, surpassed its service life, or in conflict with a more important city project as determined by the City Forester ➢ Tree Removal Notification Process o Written notice is sent to adjacent property owners and residents of impending tree work o If needed, a tree removal notice stating the removal reasons will be posted by the City Forester on the tree prior to the scheduled removal. o If necessary, the City Forester will notify the Community Services Administrator, the Mayor and City Council when a tree deemed of particular importance by the City Forester is removed. There are two ways Risk Trees are identified by the city; random observation and periodic inspections. The primary way risk trees are identified is through the city’s periodic tree pruning and inventory programs. The goal is that each year 1/6th of the city’s trees in a particular geographic area or planning district are pruned. Prior to the actual pruning, City Forestry performs a basic w alk around inspection of trees in the scheduled area. Through this inspection process Risk Trees may be identified. Further, as the pruning work is being completed on a tree, problems may be identified by the pruner and it is their responsibility to notify City Forestry for further evaluation. The City may also periodically perform a complete inventory of city trees or a special project that may reveal a Risk Tree. TREE REMOVAL Figure 4. "Renewal of the urban forest". Replacement tree planting in the downtown core. IDENTIFICATION OF RISK TREES AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 KK | P a g e There are cases where a city staff person, by chance observation, identifies a potential risk tree during their normal work activities. A city forestry crew or contractor may be pruning a tree and identify a problem. A city staff person may notice a problem with a tree. The inspection of a request for service from the public may reveal a potential risk tree. Once a potential Risk Tree is identified the following procedures are implemented. 1. A Tree Risk Assessment is scheduled for the tree of concern. 2. The tree receives a Basic Tree Risk Assessment resulting in one of three of the outcomes. a. Arboricultural treatments to mitigate the risks of defective tree part(s) will be scheduled and completed, up to and including complete tree removal. b. The tree will be scheduled for an advanced tree risk assessment. c. The tree will be placed on the Risk Tree Monitoring Program. As described above, an International Society of Arboriculture (ISA) Tree Risk Assessment is the industry standard for assessing risk trees and quantifying tree risk. In addition to detailing the methodology for performing a Tree Risk Assessment, the ISA qualifies arborists to perform a Tree Risk Assessment (http://www.isa- arbor.com/certification/becomeQualified/becomeQualified.aspx). This includes a training and testing program whereby upon the successful completion of the program, an arborist is given the designation of Tree Risk Assessment Qualified. All Tree Risk Assessments performed as part of this program are performed by ISA Tree Risk Assessment Qualified arborists. Figure 5. Conks (fungal fruiting bodies) like the one pictured here are an indicator of decay working in the tree. In this case, the Ganoderma fungus decayed the base of this aspen resulting in the tree failing. in the tree failing. HOW RISK TREES ARE MANAGED TREE RISK ASSESSMENT AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices LL | P a g e TREE PRUNING The city’s standard tree pruning specifications include the pruning of defective branches that may pose an unacceptable risk of failing. A tree pruner will be directed to prune the defective branch(s) from the tree and as a result reduce the risks of these defective branches failing. In some cases, a more aggressive pruning practice called “Reduction” pruning may be specified. Reduction pruning includes the arboriculturally correct practice of pruning the terminal portions of scaffold and lateral branches to shorten the length of the branches, spread of the tree, and height of the tree. This treatment is used in cases where there may be significant root or trunk defects, or multiple scaffold branch defects. Shortening the length of branches and/or the height of the tree increases the amount of force that is required to break a tree part and as a result reduces the probability and risk the tree part will fail. For large specimen trees which still retain ecosystem value should they be stabilized despite damage suffered, additional mitigation strategies like cabling and bracing may be considered. ADVANCED TREE RISK ASSESSMENT A Basic Tree Risk Assessment is the first assessment performed after a potential risk tree is identified. The basic assessment is completed from the ground and is primarily a visual assessment. If the City Forester finds it is needed, then an Advanced Tree Risk Assessment will be performed on the tree. This may include an inspection with an aerial lift truck and possibly the use of advanced diagnostic tools such as a Resistograph and a Tomograph. TREE RISK MITIGATION ARBORICULTURAL TREATMENTS & PRACT ICES Figure 6. To safely retain this Oak tree, reduction pruning and cabling was performed to reduce the risk of further failure. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 MM | P a g e RESISTOGRAPH & TOMOGRAPH USES Decay is very common in trees and particularly in older trees. The amount of decay in a tree part or more importantly the amount of soundwood around a decayed tree part is the most important variable in assessing the probability that a decayed tree part may fail. The Resistograph and Tomograph are two tools used to measure soundwood and decay present in a tree part. Both of these tools provide more information for assessing the risk a tree part may fail. The findings these tools provide do not provide the “end all” answer to what management treatment should be taken. They do provide more information for the assessor to quantify failure risk and the final management decision to be taken is a culmination of the findings of these tests and other conditions present with the tree. RESISTOGRAPH A Resistograph drills into the wood of a tree part and measures and records the resistance being applied on the drill bit as it drills into the tree part. The result is a visual measurement of the “sound” and “unsound” wood where the tree part was drilled. Figure 7. Tomograph measurements being taken on a tree in Jones Park, Renton, Washington. Figure 8. Resistograph tape showing the thickness of sound wood. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices NN | P a g e TOMOGRAPH A Tomograph uses soundwaves to measure the “soundness” of a tree part. Unlike the Resistograph, the Tomograph provides a graphic representation of the “soundness” of the wood around the whole tree part measured, is a more accurate measure and provides more information with which to make a probability of failure judgement. RISK TREE MONITORING PROGRAM Risk Trees that have an ISA Risk Rating of Moderate or higher, even after arboricultural treatments have been completed, will be assigned to the city’s Risk Tree Monitoring Program. Using the city’s computerized tree inventory, each of these trees will be designated as Risk Monitor trees. Each of these trees will receive a Tree Risk Assessment every year. The findings of the annual assessment will direct further action such as arboricultural treatments, advanced tree risk assessment, retention on the Tree Risk Monitoring Program or if the condition of the tree warrants, removal. TREE REMOVAL Ultimately a tree may have declined or may have been damaged to a point that removal and planting a new tree is the best management decision. Figure 9. Tomograph chart illustrating the "soundness" of the tree part measured. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 OO | P a g e If you see a tree that you believe may pose a risk to public safety report your concern to City Forestry in the following ways. Be prepared to provide the address and general location of the tree of concern. The tree will be inspected by City Forestry and inform you of the findings. ➢ Call the Forestry Division at (425) 430-6601 to report your concern. ➢ Post a request to the city via the Renton Responds app. ➢ Send the City Forester an email via the City’s website by going to: (www.rentonwa.gov/urbanforestry) and navigate down to the "Request Tree Assistance”. HOW CAN YOU HELP? AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices PP | P a g e • Andrew G. Pleninger (Consulting Arborist, Aspen Tree Service) and Ben Carlsen (Natural Resource Manager, City of Aspen): coauthors of the original document from which this risk plan was adapted. • International Society of Arboriculture, Champlain, IL. Publication illustrations on pages 3 & 5. • Photos on cover page and in figures 1,2,4,6 & 7 courtesy of Ian Gray, Renton Urban Forestry & Natural Resources Manager, August 2020. • Photos in figures 3 &5 courtesy of Ben Carlsen and Andrew Pleninger. REFERENCES & ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 QQ | P a g e APPENDIX F. URBAN FOREST PEST READY ASSESSMENT The Washington State Urban Forest Pest Readiness Playbook provides a set of actions that towns, cities, counties, and urban forestry programs should take to address the threat of forest pests. The purpose of the playbook is to close a gap in readiness and response capabilities between community leaders managing urban forests and state and federal responders. After using the playbook a city should have an understanding of your progr am’s preparedness, documentation of what is known, and a path forward for improving pest readiness capabilities. Initial funding for the Urban Forest Pest Readiness Playbook was provided by U.S. Department of Agriculture Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service Plant Protection and Quarantine. The resource is available at www.invasivespecies.wa.gov and an interactive worksheet was provided as part of the Urban Forest Management Plan Project. The following provides the framework of the Urban Forest Pest Ready Assessment section of the playbook. The playbook should be utilized during and after completing the assessment to develop actions specific to the evaluation. Table 29. Urban Forest Pest Ready Assessment from the WA State Urban Forest Pest Readiness Playbook Urban Forest Pest Ready Assessment Understanding Risk # Question Yes Points No/Not Sure? Tree Resources 1a Has your community ever conducted a tree canopy analysis? 1 See Action 6 in the Playbook 1b Has your city ever performed or does your city currently have a tree-by-tree inventory containing data on individual trees' species, sizes, conditions, and locations? 3 1c Is the inventory less than 10 years old? 1 1d Is the inventory less than 5 years old? 1 1e Does your inventory data include all or a significant majority of all managed street and park trees? 2 1f Is your inventory held in a geospatial database with location data? 2 1g Is your data able to be shared with others outside your organization? 2 Pests of Concern 2 Have you identified priority pest species that are a concern for your community based on an understanding of common tree species in your urban canopy? 1 See Action 3 in the Playbook Risk Analysis 3 Have you considered neighboring jurisdictions and/or nearby natural resource economies like agriculture and forestry as part of your assessment of priority pests? 1 See Action 7 in the Playbook AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices RR | P a g e Pest Pathways Do you have an understanding of local hot spots for pest introduction to your community including (check yes if no hot spots exist): 4a Locations where there is an influx of new residents or popular destinations for out-of-state visitors 1 See Action 4 in the Playbook Transportation corridors and storage facilities for commercial movement of forest and agriculture products 1 Commercial ports (check yes if there are no commercial posts) 1 4b Have you documented the locations and supplementary information about size of these pest introduction hot spots? 1 4c Has your community identified trees or locations that are particularly pest vulnerable? 1 Pest Prevention 5a Does your city staff use Best Management Practices to prevent the spread and introduction of pests? 1 See Action 13 in the Playbook 5b Do you or partners provide training for local contractors on tree care or Best Management Practices to prevent the spread and introductions of pests? 1 Actions 3, 4, 6, 7, 13 Understanding risk subtotal 0 of 21 Capacity to Support a Response # Question Yes Points No/Not Sure? Emergency Preparedness 1 Do you have one or more staff that have been trained in Incident Command Systems (ICS)? 1 See Action 18 in the Playbook Response Experience 2a Have you participated in an invasive forest pest response in the last ~20 years? 1 See Action 17 & 20 in the Playbook 2b Do you know the basic components of a pest response that a lead action entity would run in the event of a pest confirmation? 2 AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 SS | P a g e Know Who to Call 3 Have you integrated the contact information for USDA- APHISPPQ, USDA Forest Service, Washington Invasive Species Council, Washington Department of Natural Resources, Washington Department of Agriculture and/or Washington State University into your own systems so that a team member can easily know who to call if a pest is detected in your area? 2 See Detection & Reporting Section in the Playbook Supporting Organizations 4a Have you worked with Washington Invasive Species Council, Washington State Department of Agriculture, or Washington State Department of Natural Resources state agency staff in the past to support your program (could include training, consultation, workshops, grants, one-on-one discussions)? 1 See Playbook overview 4b Do you know which partners and stakeholders to engage in order to garner support for a response? 1 See Action 9 in the Playbook Sufficient Funding 5 Do you know what funding options, both internal and external, are available to you to respond to a pest? 1 See Action 5 in the Playbook Tree Management Are you actively enhancing your managed street trees, parks, and natural areas: 6 To prevent invasive species establishment 1 See Action 16 & 19 in the Playbook To diversity tree plantings 1 To restore areas after significant tree removal (for example removal of damaged trees, invasive trees, hazard trees, or a forest pest response) 1 Actions 5, 9, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 Capacity to Support a Response subtotal 0 of 12 Ability to Expedite Informed Decision-Making # Question Yes Points No/Not Sure? Urban Forestry Staff 1a Do you have a staff person(s) or department(s) responsible for urban tree management? 1 See Action 1 in the Playbook 1b Would you consider most of your non-urban forestry- related departments to be informed on how their work impacts your urban forests? 1 AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices TT | P a g e Local Authority Do you have any urban forestry management: 2a Plan(s) 1 See Action 2 in the Playbook Policies 1 City Code 2 2b Does your urban forestry management plan, policy, or codes include information on pest management? 3 See Action 12 of the Playbook Permitting Processes 3 Are you familiar with permitting processes regarding (+1 for at least 4 of 7): • Public involvement/notices • Environmental and water quality • Endangered species • Property access requirements • Pesticide registrations and applicator licenses • Plant quarantine compliance • Waste management practices • Historical site/archaeological permitting 1 See Action 8 & 15 in the Playbook Leadership 4 Do you have elected officials currently serving that have demonstrated concern for urban forest pests or invested in urban forest pest-related initiatives? 3 See Action 11 in the Playbook Actions 1, 2, 8, 11, 12, 15 Ability to Expedite Informed Decision-Making subtotal 0 of 13 Community Support to Expand Your Impact # Question Yes Points No/Not Sure? Diverse Team 1a Do you have experience bringing together diverse groups of stakeholders across departments and topics? 1 See Action 9 in the Playbook Do you have access to people with the following expertise or role involved in this assessment (+1 for each category filled): 1b Tree or urban forest expert 1 City planner 1 Tree care professional or other community stakeholders 1 AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Renton, WA 10-year Urban Forest Management Plan Update Jan2022 UU | P a g e Messaging 2 Do you know the appropriate messaging and languages/ channels/forums to use when communicating with the populations and neighborhoods most likely to be impacted by a pest detection? 1 See Action 10 in the Playbook Public Awareness 3 Do you have information in public outreach materials that you distribute that covers the issues and risk of urban forest pests? 1 See Action 10 in the Playbook Early Detection 4 Do you promote the implementation of and recruitment to early pest detection network (such as Master Gardeners, Washington Pest Watch)? 2 See Action 14 in the Playbook Actions 9, 10, 14 Community Support subtotal 0 of 8 Urban Forest Pest Ready Scorecard Subtotal Total Bench- mark Understanding Risk 0 of 21 12 Capacity to Support a Response 0 of 12 8 Ability to Expedite Informed Decision-Making 0 of 13 7 Community Support to Expand Your Impact 0 of 8 5 AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) Appendices VV | P a g e APPENDIX G. REFERENCES Kellert, S.R., Wilson, E.O. 1993. The Biophilia Hypothesis. Island Press, Washington, DC. 484 pp. Donovan, G.H., Butry, D.T., 2009. The value of shade: estimating the effect of urban trees on summertime electricity use. Energy Build. 41, 662–668. Wolch, J. et al 2005. Parks and Park Funding in Los Angeles: An Equity-Mapping Analysis, Urban Geography, 26:1, 4-35. Richards, N. A. 1983. “Diversity and Stability in a Street Tree Population.” Urban Ecology 7(2):159– 171. Richards, N.A. 1993. Reasonable guidelines for street tree diversity. Journal of Arboriculture 19:344–349. Swiecki, T.J., and Bernhardt, E.A. 2001. Guidelines for Developing and Evaluating Tree Ordinances. Miller, R. W., Hauer, R. J., & Werner, L. P. (2015). Urban Forestry: Planning and Managing Urban Greenspaces, Third Edition. Hauer R. J. and Peterson W. D. 2014. Municipal Tree Care and Management in the United States: A 2014 Urban & Community Forestry Census of Tree Activities. Special Publication 16-1, College of Natural Resources, University of Wisconsin – Stevens Point. 71 pp. Nowak, D.J., Greenfield, E.J. 2018. Declining urban and community tree cover in the United States. Urban Forestry & Greening 32 (2018) 32-55. Kempter, G.P. 2004. Best Management Practices – Utility Pruning of Trees. International Society of Arboriculture. Campbell, W.C. 2019. Western Kentucky University Stormwater Utility Survey. Clark, J.M., Matheny, N.P., Cross, G., Wake, V. 1997. A Model of Urban Forest Sustainability. Journal of Arboriculture 23(1). 14 pp. 2018 Urban Tree Canopy Assessment, PlanIT Geo and the City of Renton, WA. 40 pp. 2021 Urban Forest Inventory & Resource Analysis Summary Report, Davey Resource Group and the City of Renton, WA. 72 pp. AGENDA ITEM # 7. a) RENTON, WA URBAN FOREST MANAGEMENT PLAN 10-YEAR UPDATE JANUARY 2022 AGENDA ITEM # 7. a)   1  CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON    ORDINANCE NO. ________    AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON, AMENDING THE 2022  CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE FOR NON‐REPRESENTED CITY EMPLOYEES,  AFSCME LOCAL 2170 CITY EMPLOYEES, RENTON POLICE DEPARTMENT –  COMMISSIONED OFFICERS, AND RENTON POLICE DEPARTMENT – NON‐ COMMISSIONED EMPLOYEES.    WHEREAS, the City Council has approved changes in compensation that impact the City  of Renton Salary Table for 2022; and  WHEREAS, the City Council desires to amend the 2022 City of Renton Salary Table to  incorporate the changes in compensation;   NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON, DO  ORDAIN AS FOLLOWS:  SECTION I. The City Council hereby adopts the amended 2022 City of Renton Salary  Table, attached hereto and incorporated by this reference as Exhibit A.  SECTION II. The Salary Table is intended to be consistent with all applicable collective  bargaining agreements.  In the event of conflicts, applicable collective bargaining agreements  control.   SECTION III. This ordinance shall be in full force and effect five (5) days after publication  of a summary of this ordinance in the City’s official newspaper.  The amended Salary Table shall  be retroactively effective and replace the previously adopted Salary Table starting on January 1,  2022, for AFSCME Local 2170 represented employees and effective March 1, 2022, for non‐ represented employees.  Once effective, the amended Salary Table shall remain in effect until  AGENDA ITEM # 7. b) ORDINANCE NO. ________  2  changes are authorized by the City Council.  The summary of this ordinance shall consist of this  ordinance’s title.      PASSED BY THE CITY COUNCIL this _______ day of February, 2022.                         Jason A. Seth, City Clerk    APPROVED BY THE MAYOR this _______ day of February , 2022.                         Armondo Pavone, Mayor    Approved as to form:             Shane Moloney, City Attorney  Date of Publication:      ORD‐HR:2207:2/7/2022     AGENDA ITEM # 7. b) ORDINANCE NO. ________  3          EXHIBIT A  2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE  AGENDA ITEM # 7. b) COLA 6% Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual e10 1030 Mayor (1)15,963 191,556 15,963 191,556 e09 1005 City Council President (2)(7)2,050 24,600 e09 1000 City Council Members (2)1,750 21,000 e08 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 12,780 153,360 13,425 161,100 e11 1020 Municipal Court Judge (6)15,051 180,614 15,051 180,614 Salary effective July 2020 - June 30, 2022 Salary is 95% of District Court Judge Salary m53 1035 Chief Administrative Officer (3)14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 16,768 201,216 17,609 211,308 m52 14,105 169,260 14,819 177,828 15,576 186,912 16,364 196,368 17,182 206,184 m51 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 16,768 201,216 m50 13,425 161,100 14,105 169,260 14,819 177,828 15,576 186,912 16,364 196,368 m49 1400 City Attorney (3)13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 m49 1109 Parks & Recreation Administrator (3)13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 m49 1105 Community & Economic Development Administrator 13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 m49 1036 Deputy Chief Administrative Officer (3)13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 m49 1101 Finance Administrator (3)13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 m49 1107 Equity, Housing & Human Services Administrator (3)13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 m49 1104 Human Resources & Risk Mgmt Administrator (3)13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 m49 1110 Judicial Administrative Officer 13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 m49 1103 Public Works Administrator (3)13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 m49 1201 Police Chief (3)13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 15,963 191,556 m48 12,780 153,360 13,425 161,100 14,105 169,260 14,819 177,828 15,576 186,912 m47 12,470 149,640 13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 15,196 182,352 m46 1535 Police Deputy Chief (4)12,165 145,980 12,780 153,360 13,425 161,100 14,105 169,260 14,819 177,828 m46 1405 Prosecution Director 12,165 145,980 12,780 153,360 13,425 161,100 14,105 169,260 14,819 177,828 m45 11,869 142,428 12,470 149,640 13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 14,459 173,508 m44 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 12,780 153,360 13,425 161,100 14,105 169,260 m43 11,295 135,540 11,869 142,428 12,470 149,640 13,102 157,224 13,762 165,144 m42 1401 Sr Assistant City Attorney 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 12,780 153,360 13,425 161,100 m41 1212 Information Technology Director 10,754 129,048 11,295 135,540 11,869 142,428 12,470 149,640 13,102 157,224 m40 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 12,780 153,360 m39 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 11,295 135,540 11,869 142,428 12,470 149,640 m38 2178 Airport Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 2011 City Clerk/Public Records Officer 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1204 Communications & Engagement Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1575 Development Services Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1501 Economic Development Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 2044 Emergency Management Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1207 Facilities Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1210 Fiscal Services Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 2463 HR Labor Relations & Compensation Manager 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1406 Lead Prosecutor 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE NON-REPRESENTED Effective March 1, 2022 STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E ELECTED OFFICIALS MANAGEMENT & SUPERVISORY (NON-UNION) AGENDA ITEM # 7. b) COLA 6% Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE NON-REPRESENTED Effective March 1, 2022 STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E m38 1571 Maintenance Services Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 8084 Parks and Trails Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1208 Parks Planning and Natural Resources Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1502 Planning Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 2031 Police Commander (5)9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1214 Recreation Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1570 Utility Systems Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m38 1572 Transportation Systems Director 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 12,165 145,980 m37 2148 Application Support Manager 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 11,295 135,540 11,869 142,428 m37 2175 ITS and Maintenance Manager 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 11,295 135,540 11,869 142,428 m37 2176 Transportation Design Manager 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 11,295 135,540 11,869 142,428 m37 2075 Transportation Operations Manager 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 11,295 135,540 11,869 142,428 m37 2177 Transportation Planning Manager 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 11,295 135,540 11,869 142,428 m37 2172 Utility Engineering Manager 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 11,295 135,540 11,869 142,428 m36 2074 Building Official 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 m36 2021 Current Planning Manager 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 m36 2073 Development Engineering Manager 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 m36 2020 Long Range Planning Manager 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 11,581 138,972 m35 1402 Assistant City Attorney 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 11,295 135,540 m34 2023 Construction Manager 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 m34 2462 Human Resources Benefits Manager 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 m34 2413 Network Systems Manager 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 m34 2460 Organizational Development Manager 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 m34 2409 Risk Manager 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 11,021 132,252 m33 5015 Budget & Accounting Manager 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 m33 1578 Community Development & Housing Manager 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 m33 2174 Property & Technical Services Manager 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 m33 3072 Water Maintenance Manager 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 10,754 129,048 m32 4480 Capital Projects Manager 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 m32 1577 Economic Development Manager 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 m32 3073 Fleet Manager 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 m32 4470 Parks Planning Manager 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 m32 3071 Street Maintenance Manager 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 m32 3083 Urban Forestry and Natural Resources Manager 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 m32 3070 Waste Water/Special Operations Manager 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 10,493 125,916 m31 3086 Facilities Manager 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 m31 8010 Parks Maintenance Manager 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 10,236 122,832 m30 2407 GIS Manager 8,196 98,352 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 m30 2033 Police Manager 8,196 98,352 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 9,987 119,844 m29 2202 Communications Manager 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 m29 3084 Golf Course Manager 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 m29 1522 Human Services Manager 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 m29 1404 Prosecuting Attorney 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 m29 2087 Recreation Manager 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 9,746 116,952 m28 6031 Financial Operations Manager 7,803 93,636 8,196 98,352 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 m28 5254 Permit Services Manager 7,803 93,636 8,196 98,352 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 m28 1116 Tax & Licensing Manager 7,803 93,636 8,196 98,352 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 9,506 114,072 m27 3011 Enterprise Content Manager 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 m27 2578 Housing Programs Manager 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 9,272 111,264 m26 7,425 89,100 7,803 93,636 8,196 98,352 8,609 103,308 9,042 108,504 m25 2086 Head Golf Professional 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 m25 2562 Senior Benefits Analyst 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 AGENDA ITEM # 7. b) COLA 6% Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE NON-REPRESENTED Effective March 1, 2022 STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E m25 2563 Senior Employee Relations Analyst 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 m25 2410 Senior Finance Analyst 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 m25 2561 Senior Risk Analyst 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 m25 2479 Solid Waste Coordinator 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 8,825 105,900 m24 5112 Deputy City Clerk/Public Records Officer 7,071 84,852 7,425 89,100 7,803 93,636 8,196 98,352 8,609 103,308 m23 3562 Benefits Analyst 6,891 82,692 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 m23 3563 Employee Relations Analyst 6,891 82,692 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 m23 2080 Recreation Supervisor 6,891 82,692 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 m23 2461 Risk Analyst 6,891 82,692 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 8,401 100,812 m22 2404 Community Events Coordinator 6,729 80,748 7,071 84,852 7,425 89,100 7,803 93,636 8,196 98,352 m22 1510 Court Services Supervisor 6,729 80,748 7,071 84,852 7,425 89,100 7,803 93,636 8,196 98,352 m22 8007 Golf Course Supervisor 6,729 80,748 7,071 84,852 7,425 89,100 7,803 93,636 8,196 98,352 m22 2091 Museum Manager 6,729 80,748 7,071 84,852 7,425 89,100 7,803 93,636 8,196 98,352 m21 2218 Tax & Licensing Auditor, Senior 6,562 78,744 6,891 82,692 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 7,990 95,880 m20 6,402 76,824 6,729 80,748 7,071 84,852 7,425 89,100 7,803 93,636 m19 6150 City Council Liaison 6,249 74,988 6,562 78,744 6,891 82,692 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 m19 6103 Executive Assistant 6,249 74,988 6,562 78,744 6,891 82,692 7,244 86,928 7,611 91,332 m18 5416 Payroll Technician 3 6,092 73,104 6,402 76,824 6,729 80,748 7,071 84,852 7,425 89,100 m17 5000 Legal Analyst 5,947 71,364 6,249 74,988 6,562 78,744 6,891 82,692 7,244 86,928 n16 multiple Administrative Assistants (All Depts)5,778 69,336 6,070 72,840 6,367 76,404 6,695 80,340 7,029 84,348 n16 5118 Finance Analyst 3 5,778 69,336 6,070 72,840 6,367 76,404 6,695 80,340 7,029 84,348 n16 2217 Tax & Licensing Auditor 2 5,778 69,336 6,070 72,840 6,367 76,404 6,695 80,340 7,029 84,348 n15 5,628 67,536 5,919 71,028 6,216 74,592 6,532 78,384 6,866 82,392 n14 5,496 65,952 5,778 69,336 6,070 72,840 6,367 76,404 6,695 80,340 n13 5115 Finance Analyst 2 5,360 64,320 5,628 67,536 5,919 71,028 6,216 74,592 6,532 78,384 n13 2662 Human Resources Specialist 5,360 64,320 5,628 67,536 5,919 71,028 6,216 74,592 6,532 78,384 n13 5032 Payroll Technician 2 5,360 64,320 5,628 67,536 5,919 71,028 6,216 74,592 6,532 78,384 n13 2216 Tax & Licensing Auditor 1 5,360 64,320 5,628 67,536 5,919 71,028 6,216 74,592 6,532 78,384 n12 5,234 62,808 5,496 65,952 5,778 69,336 6,070 72,840 6,367 76,404 n11 2488 Assistant Golf Professional 5,102 61,224 5,360 64,320 5,628 67,536 5,919 71,028 6,216 74,592 n10 5114 Finance Analyst 1 4,980 59,760 5,234 62,808 5,496 65,952 5,778 69,336 6,070 72,840 n10 5216 Payroll Technician 1 4,980 59,760 5,234 62,808 5,496 65,952 5,778 69,336 6,070 72,840 n09 4,861 58,332 5,102 61,224 5,360 64,320 5,628 67,536 5,919 71,028 n08 4,739 56,868 4,980 59,760 5,234 62,808 5,496 65,952 5,778 69,336 n07 4,625 55,500 4,861 58,332 5,102 61,224 5,360 64,320 5,628 67,536 n06 4,510 54,120 4,739 56,868 4,980 59,760 5,234 62,808 5,496 65,952 n05 4,401 52,812 4,625 55,500 4,861 58,332 5,102 61,224 5,360 64,320 n04 4,296 51,552 4,510 54,120 4,739 56,868 4,980 59,760 5,234 62,808 n03 4,195 50,340 4,401 52,812 4,625 55,500 4,861 58,332 5,102 61,224 n02 4,093 49,116 4,296 51,552 4,510 54,120 4,739 56,868 4,980 59,760 NON-UNION (CLERICAL, OTHER) AGENDA ITEM # 7. b) COLA 6% Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE NON-REPRESENTED Effective March 1, 2022 STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E n01 5138 Office Specialist 3,998 47,976 4,195 50,340 4,401 52,812 4,625 55,500 4,861 58,332 $6,638 Completion of 5 Yrs Completion of 10 Yrs Completion of 15 Yrs Completion of 20 Yrs Completion of 25 Yrs Completion of 30 Yrs (1)In addition to salary receives annual car allowance of $4800 or use of a city vehicle. (2) (3)Not eligible for Longevity/Education or Uniform Allowance (4)Not eligible for Longevity/Education or Uniform Allowance Eligible for 3% cash premium or 3% into deferred compensation per employee's discretion for passing physical fitness. (5)Receive Education/Longevity & Uniform Allowance based on Union Contract. Eligible for 3% deferred compensation for passing physical fitness. Eligible for P2 paid job injury leave based on Union Contract. (6)4 year term (7)Council president to be paid $300/month above council members salary. for Management and Non-Represented employees; except for CAO receives 11% per year. 5% Step a14E $332 per month 6% Step a14E $398 per month 7% Step a14E $465 per month Council members salary set per Salary Commission effective 4/1/20. Council receives 2% of salary for deferred comp. If members are prohibited from participating in PERS, they receive an extra 1.4 % of salary for deferred compensation. The City contributes 4% of employee's base wage per year to a deferred compensation account 3% Step a14E $199 per month 4% Step a14E $266 per month 2% Step a14E $133 per month NON-REPRESENTED LONGEVITY PAY as of 1/1/2021 Step a14, E = AGENDA ITEM # 7. b) COLA 6.0% Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual a40 10,331 123,972 10,847 130,164 11,397 136,764 11,976 143,712 12,580 150,960 a39 10,097 121,164 10,598 127,176 11,118 133,416 11,683 140,196 12,275 147,300 - a38 9,839 118,068 10,331 123,972 10,847 130,164 11,397 136,764 11,976 143,712 a37 9,613 115,356 10,097 121,164 10,598 127,176 11,118 133,416 11,683 140,196 a36 2428 Principal Civil Engineer 9,369 112,428 9,839 118,068 10,331 123,972 10,847 130,164 11,397 136,764 a35 9,145 109,740 9,613 115,356 10,097 121,164 10,598 127,176 11,118 133,416 a34 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 9,839 118,068 10,331 123,972 10,847 130,164 a33 2475 Civil Engineer 3 8,707 104,484 9,145 109,740 9,613 115,356 10,097 121,164 10,598 127,176 a32 2425 Utility/GIS Engineer 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 9,839 118,068 10,331 123,972 a31 2078 Assistant Airport Manager 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 9,145 109,740 9,613 115,356 10,097 121,164 a30 2512 Client Technology Sys & Support Super.8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 9,839 118,068 a30 2474 Civil Engineer 2 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 9,839 118,068 a29 2570 Program Development Coordinator 2 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 9,145 109,740 9,613 115,356 a29 2451 Senior Systems Analyst 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 9,145 109,740 9,613 115,356 a28 2422 Senior Planner 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 a28 2480 Capital Project Coordinator 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 a28 2416 Senior Network Systems Specialist 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 9,369 112,428 a27 2452 Senior Business Systems Analyst 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 9,145 109,740 a26 2473 Civil Engineer I 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 a26 2506 GIS Analyst 3 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 a26 2417 Systems Analyst 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 a26 3473 Water Utilities Maintenance Supervisor 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 8,922 107,064 a25 2481 Facilities Coordinator 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 a25 3484 Lead Electrical/Ctrl Systems Technician 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 a25 2470 Program Development Coordinator 1 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 a25 2170 Property Services Agent 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 a25 8179 Signal/Electronic Systems Supervisor 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 8,707 104,484 a24 2420 Database Technician 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a24 3450 Lead Building Inspector 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a24 3469 Lead Construction Inspector 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a24 2403 Senior Economic Development Specialist 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a24 2419 Network Systems Specialist 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a24 2476 Transportation Planner 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 8,496 101,952 a23 8475 Airport Ops & Maintenance Supervisor 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2429 Building Plan Reviewer 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2421 Business Systems Analyst 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2472 Engineering Specialist 3 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2505 GIS Analyst 2 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 8175 Pavement Management Technician 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2450 Plan Reviewer 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 2484 Property Services Specialist 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 8001 Street Maintenance Services Supervisor 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE AFSCME, Local 2170 Effective January 1, 2022 STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E AGENDA ITEM # 7. b) COLA 6.0% Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE AFSCME, Local 2170 Effective January 1, 2022 STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E a23 8002 Waste Water Maint. Services Supervisor 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a23 8000 Water Maintenance Services Supervisor 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 8,282 99,384 a22 2430 Lead Code Compliance Inspector 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 a22 5197 Neighborhood Program Coordinator 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 a22 5002 Senior Paralegal 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 a22 6129 Utility Accounts Supervisor 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 8,084 97,008 a21 2424 Associate Planner 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 3452 Building Inspector/Combination 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 3451 Building Inspector/Electrical 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 2016 Case Manager 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 2200 Communications Specialist 2 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 3472 Construction Inspector 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 8008 Custodial Maintenance Supervisor 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 5130 Emergency Management Coordinator 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 3089 Facilities Supervisor 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 5111 GIS Analyst 1 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 8006 Parks Maintenance Supervisor 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 3483 Signal/Electronics Systems Technician 3 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 8004 Traffic Signage & Marking Supervisor 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a21 8011 Water Meter Technician Services Supervi 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 7,887 94,644 a20 2079 Business Coordinator - Airport 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 a20 2402 Economic Development Specialist 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 a20 2487 Housing Repair Coordinator 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 a20 2489 Human Services Coordinator 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 7,692 92,304 a19 6128 Accounting Supervisor 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 2612 Client Technology Services Specialist 2 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 2427 Code Compliance Inspector 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 7182 Electrical Technician 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 3453 Energy Plans Reviewer 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 2471 Engineering Specialist 2 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 3485 HVAC Systems Technician 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 7172 Lead Vehicle & Equipment Mechanic 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a19 8178 Water Utility Instr./SCADA Technician 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 7,506 90,072 a18 3456 Development Services Representative 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 a18 5195 Farmers Market Coordinator 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 a18 2015 Probation Officer 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 a18 2083 Recreation Program Coordinator 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 7,321 87,852 a17 2423 Assistant Planner 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 8374 Maintenance Buyer 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 5001 Paralegal 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 5012 Public Records Specialist 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 3482 Signal/Electronics Systems Technician 2 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 3470 Water Quality/Treatment Plant Operator 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a17 2205 Digital Communications Specialist 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 7,143 85,716 a16 8284 Lead Golf Course Maintenance Worker 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 a16 8074 Lead Maintenance Services Worker 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 a16 8080 Lead Parks Maintenance Worker 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 a16 5194 Program Assistant 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 6,970 83,640 a15 4014 City Clerk Specialist 2 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 2613 Client Technology Services Specialist 1 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 6167 Court Operations Specialist 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 7181 Facilities Technician 2 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 AGENDA ITEM # 7. b) COLA 6.0% Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE AFSCME, Local 2170 Effective January 1, 2022 STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E a15 7184 Grounds Equipment Mechanic 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 8174 Lift Station Technician 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 5122 Planning Technician 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 5180 Senior Program Specialist 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 8574 Senior Traffic Maintenance Worker 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 7170 Vehicle & Equipment Mechanic 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a15 3474 Water Utility Maintenance Technician 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 6,802 81,624 a14 5161 Asset Management Systems Technician 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 a14 5160 Recreation Systems Technician 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 6,638 79,656 a13 8474 Airport Operations Specialist 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 3471 Engineering Specialist 1 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 7180 Facilities Technician 1 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 3487 Housing Maintenance Technician 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 6263 Permit Services Specialist 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 7110 Print & Mail Supervisor 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 5179 Program Specialist 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a13 3481 Signal/Electronics Systems Technician 1 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 6,471 77,652 a12 2201 Communications Specialist 1 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a12 8283 Golf Course Maintenance Worker 3 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a12 6166 Judicial Specialist 2 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a12 8173 Maintenance Services Worker 3 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a12 8083 Parks Maintenance Worker 3 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a12 8573 Traffic Maintenance Worker 2 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 6,313 75,756 a11 8473 Airport Maintenance Worker 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 5014 City Clerk Specialist 1 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 7173 Fleet Management Technician 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 8183 Lead Maintenance Custodian 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 6265 Payroll Analyst 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 5007 Public Records Specialist 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 2486 Recreation Specialist 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a11 8109 Water Meter System Specialist 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 6,158 73,896 a10 6164 Judicial Specialist/Trainer 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 a10 6165 Legal Assistant 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 a10 6263 Permit Technician 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 a10 6163 Probation Clerk 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 6,013 72,156 a09 6131 Accounting Assistant 4 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 a09 6151 Administrative Secretary 1 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 a09 8286 Golf Course Operations Assistant 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 a09 8070 Mechanic's Assistant 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 a09 2085 Recreation Assistant 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 5,863 70,356 a08 8282 Golf Course Maintenance Worker 2 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 7126 Housing Repair Technician 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 6162 Judicial Specialist 1 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 6109 Lead Office Assistant 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 8172 Maintenance Services Worker 2 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 8082 Parks Maintenance Worker 2 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 8375 Purchasing Assistant 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a08 8572 Traffic Maintenance Worker 1 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 5,726 68,712 a07 6132 Accounting Assistant 3 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 a07 8184 Maintenance Custodian 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 a07 7112 Print & Mail Operator 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 a07 6142 Secretary 2 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 AGENDA ITEM # 7. b) COLA 6.0% Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE AFSCME, Local 2170 Effective January 1, 2022 STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E a07 8110 Water Meter Technician 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 5,579 66,948 a06 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 5,447 65,364 a05 6134 Accounting Assistant 3 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 a05 6130 Office Assistant 3 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 a05 6141 Secretary 1 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 5,312 63,744 a04 6160 Court Security Officer 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 8281 Golf Course Maintenance Worker 1 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 8181 Lead Custodian 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 8171 Maintenance Services Worker 1 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 8081 Parks Maintenance Worker 1 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 6282 Pro Shop Assistant 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a04 8576 Solid Waste Maintenance Worker 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 5,186 62,232 a03 6136 Accounting Assistant 1 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 a03 6120 Office Assistant 2 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 a03 8079 Parks Maintenance Assistant 2 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 a03 7111 Print & Mail Assistant 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 5,057 60,684 a02 4,061 48,732 4,259 51,108 4,476 53,712 4,697 56,364 4,934 59,208 a01 8182 Custodian 3,955 47,460 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 a01 6281 Golf Course Associate 3,955 47,460 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 a01 6111 Office Assistant 1 3,955 47,460 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 a01 7079 Parks Maintenance Assistant 1 3,955 47,460 4,155 49,860 4,364 52,368 4,583 54,996 4,813 57,756 $6,638 Completion of 5 Yrs Completion of 10 Yrs Completion of 15 Yrs Completion of 20 Yrs Completion of 25 Yrs Completion of 30 Yrs The City contributes 4% of employee's base wage per year to a deferred compensation account. (Article 14) 6% Step a14E $398 per month 7% Step a14E $465 per month 4% Step a14E $266 per month 5% Step a14E $332 per month 3% Step a14E $199 per month LONGEVITY PAY Step a14, E = 2% Step a14E $133 per month AGENDA ITEM # 7. b) Grade Code Monthly Annual Monthly Annual Police Chief See Management & Supervisory Matrix, Grade m49 Police Deputy Chief See Management & Supervisory Matrix, Grade m46 Police Commander See Management & Supervisory Matrix, Grade m38 pc61 3035 Sergeant*9,384 112,609 9,853 118,240 (15% over Police Officer)*Step increase at 24 months pc60 4131 Patrol Officer II 6,097 73,165 6,614 79,363 7,134 85,613 7,646 91,747 8,161 97,932 pc59 4130 Patrol Officer I 5,738 68,861 6,225 74,699 6,715 80,575 7,196 86,347 7,681 92,172 Percent Interpreters ------------------------3% Detectives --------------------------4% Traffic Assignment----------------4% Motorcycle Assignment------------- 2% Canine Officer ---------------------3% Corporal Assignment ------------7.5% Field Training Officer ------------4% Training Officer--------------------4% SWAT Assignment ----------------4% SRO Assignment-------------------4% Civil Disturbance Unit -----------Paid at rate of double time with 3 hrs minimum when called to emergency. Crisis Communication Unit------Paid at rate of double time with 3 hrs minimum when called to emergency. Percentage (of base wage) Percentage (of base wage) - - - - - Patrol Officer II: Effective 1-1-18 Patrol Officer II and Sergeant had 6.25% added to their base pay to reflect the additional 109 hours worked in a calendar year. This is reflected in the ranges above. Effective January 1, 2008, Sergeants assigned to Investigation and Traffic Unit will not receive the 3% premium if they have been in the position of Sergeant for 24 months. NOTE: Please refer to the current labor agreement for specific information. AA Degree (90 credits)4% BA Degree/Masters Degree 6% The City contributes 2.0% of employee's wage base toward deferred compensation. (Appendix A.2.3) The City will contribute 3.0% of employee's wage base toward deferred compensation for passing physical fitness. (Article 6.8.4, and Appendix A.2.4) Beginning 1-1-2020 the City will contribute 1% of employee's wage base to a VEBA plan. (Article 14.11) Completion of 10 Yrs 4% Completion of 15 Yrs 6% Completion of 20 Yrs 10% Completion of 25 Yrs 12% Completion of 30 Yrs 14% MONTHLY EDUCATIONAL INCENTIVE PAY (Appendix B) Position Title HAZARD DUTY AND PREMIUM PAY (Article 6.7 and 6.8) MONTHLY LONGEVITY PAY (Appendix B) Years of Service Completion of 5 Yrs 2% 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE POLICE DEPARTMENT - Commissioned Officers In Negotiations STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E AGENDA ITEM # 7. b) Grade Code Position Title Monthly Annual Monthly Annual pn70 6,008 72,096 6,495 77,940 7,137 85,644 7,843 94,116 8,256 99,072 pn69 5,861 70,332 6,337 76,044 6,963 83,556 7,652 91,824 8,055 96,660 pn68 5,718 68,616 6,182 74,184 6,793 81,516 7,465 89,580 7,858 94,296 pn67 4140 Community Engagement Coord.5,579 66,948 6,031 72,372 6,628 79,536 7,283 87,396 7,667 92,004 pn66 5,443 65,316 5,884 70,608 6,466 77,592 7,106 85,272 7,480 89,760 pn65 5,310 63,720 5,741 68,892 6,308 75,696 6,932 83,184 7,297 87,564 pn64 5,181 62,172 5,601 67,212 6,155 73,860 6,763 81,156 7,119 85,428 pn63 5,054 60,648 5,464 65,568 6,004 72,048 6,598 79,176 6,946 83,352 pn58 6178 Police Service Specialist Supv 6,454 77,448 6,776 81,312 Step A(15% above Specialist, Step E) Step E (5% above Supervisor, Step A) pn57 6182 Police Service Specialist Lead 6,032 72,384 6,032 72,384 (7.5% above Specialist, Step E) pn54 4138 Police Community Prgm Coord 4,993 59,916 5,396 64,752 5,928 71,136 6,390 76,680 6,710 80,520 pn54 4120 Crime Analyst 4,993 59,916 5,396 64,752 5,928 71,136 6,390 76,680 6,710 80,520 pn56 4133 Electronic Home Detention Coord 4,926 59,112 5,316 63,792 5,854 70,248 6,436 77,232 6,756 81,072 pn53 3432 Evidence Technician 4,700 56,400 5,073 60,876 5,583 66,996 6,142 73,704 6,458 77,496 pn61 4121 Domestic Violence Victim Advocate 4,661 55,932 5,063 60,756 5,627 67,524 6,186 74,232 6,513 78,156 pn60 4,445 53,340 4,828 57,936 5,364 64,368 5,898 70,776 6,205 74,460 pn52 4135 Animal Control Officer 4,433 53,196 4,793 57,516 5,270 63,240 5,795 69,540 6,086 73,032 pn62 6181 Police Service Specialist 4,088 49,056 4,416 52,992 4,860 58,320 5,346 64,152 5,612 67,344 pn51 6183 Police Secretary 3,829 45,948 4,133 49,596 4,550 54,600 5,008 60,096 5,254 63,048 pn51 4137 Parking Enforcement Officer 3,829 45,948 4,133 49,596 4,550 54,600 5,008 60,096 5,254 63,048 Interpreter Premium………………………………..………………….…………….3% of base pay (Article 6.5.2) 2.5% of base pay (Article 6.5.3) 4% of base pay (Article 6.5.1) Double time with 3 hrs min (Article 6.4) NON- COMMISSIONED PREMIUM PAY (Articles 6.4 and 6.5) Public Records Act Premium…………………………………………………………… Field Training Officer, FTO (Police Service Specialist)…………........… Crisis Communication Unit………………………………………..…...……… POLICE NON-COMMISSIONED- MONTHLY LONGEVITY INCENTIVE PAY SCHEDULE (Article 12, Appendix B.1) Years of Service Percentage (of base wage) 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE POLICE DEPARTMENT - Non-Commissioned Officers In Negotiations STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E CITY OF RENTON C:\Users\manthony\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\INetCache\Content.Outlook\1Q2VXWBW\2022 Salary Table 1-14-2022\Police Non-Comm 2022 Salary Table 1-14-2022 Page 10 of 12 AGENDA ITEM # 7. b) - Beginning 1/1/2020 the City will contribute 1% of the employee's base wage to a VEBA plan. (Article 14.10) - The City will contribute an additional 3.0% of employee's wage base toward deferred comp for passing physical fitness prior to beginning of each calendar year. (Article 6.8.3) Completion of 25 Yrs 12% Completion of 30 Yrs 14% MONTHLY EDUCATIONAL INCENTIVE PAY SCHEDULE (Appendix B.2) Percentage (of base wage) AA Degree (90 credits)4% BA/BS Degree or Masters Degree 6% - The City contributes 4.5% of the employee's base wage to a deferred comp account. (Appendix A.3) Completion of 10 Yrs 4% Completion of 15 Yrs 6% Completion of 20 Yrs 10% Completion of 5 Yrs 2% CITY OF RENTON C:\Users\manthony\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\INetCache\Content.Outlook\1Q2VXWBW\2022 Salary Table 1-14-2022\Police Non-Comm 2022 Salary Table 1-14-2022 Page 11 of 12 AGENDA ITEM # 7. b) Grade STEP A STEP B STEP C STEP D STEP E h07 14.50 14.75 h08 15.00 15.25 15.50 15.75 16.00 h09 16.25 16.50 16.75 17.00 17.25 h10 17.50 17.75 18.00 18.25 18.50 h11 18.75 19.00 19.25 19.50 19.75 h12 20.00 20.50 21.00 21.50 22.00 h13 22.50 23.00 23.50 24.00 24.50 h14 25.00 25.50 26.00 26.50 27.00 h15 27.50 28.00 28.50 29.00 29.50 h16 30.00 30.50 31.00 31.50 32.00 h17 32.50 33.00 33.50 34.00 34.50 h18 35.00 35.50 36.00 36.50 37.00 h19 37.50 38.00 38.50 39.00 39.50 h20 40.00 40.50 41.00 41.50 42.00 h21 42.25 42.50 42.75 43.00 43.25 h22 43.50 43.75 44.00 44.25 44.50 h23 45.00 45.50 46.00 46.50 47.00 h24 47.50 48.00 48.50 49.00 49.50 h25 50.00 51.00 52.00 53.00 54.00 h26 55.00 60.00 65.00 70.00 75.00 h27 80.00 85.00 90.00 95.00 100.00 h28 105.00 110.00 115.00 120.00 125.00 2022 CITY OF RENTON SALARY TABLE SUPPLEMENTAL EMPLOYEE WAGE TABLE AGENDA ITEM # 7. b)   1  CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON  ORDINANCE NO.  AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON, AMENDING  SUBSECTIONS 4‐1‐220.B AND 4‐1‐220.D OF THE RENTON MUNICIPAL CODE, BY  EXTENDING TO THE RAINIER/GRADY JUNCTION TOD SUBAREA AND SOUTH LAKE  WASHINGTON SUBAREA THE MULTI‐FAMILY HOUSING PROPERTY TAX  EXEMPTION, ADOPTING THE ELIGIBLE AREAS FOR MULTI‐FAMILY HOUSING  INCENTIVES MAP, AUTHORIZING CORRECTIONS, PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY,  AND ESTABLISHING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.    WHEREAS, on December 22, 2003, the Renton City Council passed Ordinance No. 5061  (codified in RMC 4‐1‐220) establishing a limited property tax exemption to encourage multi‐ family housing development in designated residential targeted areas; and  WHEREAS, the provisions of RMC 4‐1‐220, Property Tax Exemption for Multi‐Family  Housing in Residential Targeted Areas, have been successful in encouraging increased residential  opportunities and in stimulating new construction of multi‐family housing in the City’s priority  community revitalization and redevelopment areas and encouraging more affordable multi‐  family housing in the City; and  WHEREAS, the City seeks to amend RMC 4‐1‐220 to extend, as modified, the property tax  exemption to additional residential targeted areas to encourage additional future multi‐family  housing projects; and  WHEREAS, this matter was duly referred to the Planning Commission for investigation  and study, and the matter was considered by the Planning Commission; and  WHEREAS, pursuant to RCW 36.70A.106, on January 7, 2022, the City notified the State  of Washington of its intent to adopt amendments to its development regulations and requested  expedited review; and  AGENDA ITEM # 7. c) 2  ORDINANCE NO. ________    WHEREAS, the Planning Commission held a public hearing on January 19, 2022,  considered all relevant matters, and heard all parties appearing in support or in opposition, and  subsequently forwarded a recommendation to the City Council;  NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF RENTON, WASHINGTON, DO  ORDAIN AS FOLLOWS:  SECTION I. All portions of the Renton Municipal Code in this ordinance not shown in  strikethrough and underline edits remain in effect and unchanged.  SECTION II. Subsections 4‐1‐220.B and 4‐1‐220.D of the Renton Municipal Code are  amended as shown below. All other provisions in 4‐1‐220 remain in effect and unchanged.  B. DEFINITIONS:  In construing the provisions of this Section, the following definitions shall be  applied:  1. “Administrator” means the Department of Community and Economic  Development Administrator, or any other City office, department, or agency that  shall succeed to its functions with respect to this Section.  2. “Affordable housing” means residential housing that is rented by a low‐ income household whose monthly housing costs, including rent and utilities other  than telephone, do not exceed thirty percent (30%) of the household’s monthly  income. For the purposes of housing intended for owner occupancy, “affordable  housing” means residential housing that is within the means of and purchased by  low‐ or moderate‐income households.  3. “Downtown” refers to a geographical area depicted in the Eligible Areas  for Multi‐Family Housing Incentives Map (“Map”), a copy of which shall be  AGENDA ITEM # 7. c) 3  ORDINANCE NO. ________    maintained kept in the Office of the City Clerk, and which was originally adopted as  Attachment A to Ordinance No. 5760. The boundaries of the Downtown Eligible Area  shown on the Map are hereby made part of this Section, which shall be read and  interpreted in light of the contents of the Map.  4. “Household” means a single person, family, or unrelated persons living  together.  5. “Low‐income household” means a single person, family, or unrelated  persons living together whose adjusted income is at or below sixty percent (60%) of  the median income, as further defined in subsection C.1.c.ii(a) of this Section.  6. “Median income” means the median family income adjusted for family size  for King County, as reported by the United States Department of Housing and Urban  Development (HUD). In the event that HUD no longer publishes median income  figures for King County, the City may use or determine such other method as it may  choose to determine the King County median income, adjusted for household size.  7. “Mixed‐use” means a multi‐family housing residential project with at least  one other nonresidential use in one or more multi‐family housing buildings in the  project, such as retail, office, entertainment, schools, conference centers, or a use  approved in writing by the Administrator. The purpose of the mixed‐use requirement  is to implement the intent of the land use district, maximize the efficient use of land,  support transit use, and encourage the development of well‐balanced, attractive,  convenient, and vibrant urban residential neighborhoods. The additional use  excludes any accessory functions related to the residential use. Unless otherwise  modified or waived in writing by the Administrator, the nonresidential mixed‐use  AGENDA ITEM # 7. c) 4  ORDINANCE NO. ________    shall occupy at a minimum the ground floor along the street frontage with a depth  of at least thirty feet (30') for any building in the project.  8. “Moderate‐income household” means a single person, family, or unrelated  persons living together whose adjusted income is at or below eighty percent (80%)  of the median income, as further defined in subsection C.1.c.ii(b) of this Section.  9. “Multi‐family housing” means one or more new buildings designed for  permanent residential occupancy, each with four (4) or more dwelling units.  10. “Permanent residential occupancy” means multi‐family housing that  provides either owner occupancy, or rental accommodation that is leased for a  period of at least one month but excluding transient rental accommodations that  predominantly offer accommodation on a daily or weekly basis, for example, hotels  and motels.  11. “Permanently affordable homeownership” means a dwelling unit that is  affordable housing as defined according to RCW 43.185A.010; including but not  limited to built by or sold to a qualified non‐profit organization; and subject to a  ninety‐nine (99)‐year ground lease or deed restriction, to be executed at initial sale  and each successive sale.   12. “Rainier/Grady Junction TOD Subarea” refers to a geographical area  depicted in the Eligible Areas for Multi‐Family Housing Incentives Map (“Map” ), as  it exists or may be amended, a copy of which shall be kept in the Office of the City  Clerk. The boundaries of the Rainier/Grady Junction TOD Subarea shown on the Map  are hereby made part of this Section, which shall be read and interpreted in light of  the contents of the Map.   AGENDA ITEM # 7. c) 5  ORDINANCE NO. ________    13. “South Lake Washington” refers to a geographical area depicted in the  Eligible Areas for Multi‐Family Housing Incentives Map (“Map”), as it exists or may  be amended, a copy which shall be kept in the Office of the City Clerk. The  boundaries of the South Lake Washington shown on the Map are hereby made part  of this Section, which shall be read and interpreted in light of the contents of the  Map.  14. “Sunset Area” refers to a geographical area depicted in the Eligible Areas  for Multi‐Family Housing Incentives Map (“Map”), as it exists or may be amended, a  copy of which shall be maintained kept in the Office of the City Clerk, and which was  originally adopted as Attachment A to Ordinance No. 5760. The boundaries of the  Sunset Eligible Area shown on the Map are hereby made part of this Section, which  shall be read and interpreted in light of the contents of the Map.   D. PROJECT ELIGIBILITY:  To qualify for exemption from property taxation under this Section, the project  shall satisfy all of the following requirements:  1. Location: The property shall be located in one of the designated  “residential target areas” listed below in subsection D.1.a or b of this Section which  are targeted for low‐ or moderate‐income housing serving households at or below  eighty percent (80%) of the median income. If a part of any legal lot is within a  residential target area, then the entire lot shall be deemed to lie within the  residential target area.  a. Sunset Area: In the Sunset Area and within the Center Village (CV),  Residential Multi‐Family (RMF), or the Residential‐14 (R‐14) Zone; or  AGENDA ITEM # 7. c) 6  ORDINANCE NO. ________    b. Downtown: In the Downtown and within the Center Downtown (CD)  Zone or Residential‐14 (R‐14) Zone.   c. Rainier/Grady Junction TOD  Subarea: In the Rainier/Grady Junction  TOD Subarea and within the Commercial Arterial (CA) or Commercial Office (CO)  Zone.  d. South Lake Washington: In the South Lake Washington and within the  Urban Center‐1 (UC‐1), or the Urban Center‐2 (UC‐2) Zone.  2. Size and Structure:  a. If the project is located in the Downtown and within the Residential‐14  (R‐14) Zone, or in the Sunset Area and within either the Residential Multi‐Family  (RMF) Zone or the Residential‐14 (R‐14) Zone, the project shall (i) consist of a  minimum total of ten (10) new dwelling units of multi‐family housing, and (ii) be  located within a new residential structure(s) or a new mixed‐use development as  allowed by the RMC for the specific zone. At least fifty percent (50%) of the space  within the project shall be intended for permanent residential occupancy.  b. If the project is located in the Downtown and within the Center  Downtown (CD) Zone, or in the Sunset Area and within the Center Village (CV) Zone,  the following applies:  i. If the project is located in the Downtown and within the Center  Downtown (CD) Zone, the project shall (a) consist of a minimum total of thirty (30)  new dwelling units of multi‐family housing and (b) be a new structure(s) and (c) be a  mixed‐use development, unless the Administrator waives one or more of these  requirements. If the Administrator waives the mixed‐use development requirement,  AGENDA ITEM # 7. c) 7  ORDINANCE NO. ________    the multi‐family housing shall be located in a new residential structure(s). At least  fifty percent (50%) of the space within the project shall be intended for permanent  residential occupancy.  ii. If the project is located in the Sunset Area and within the Center  Village (CV) Zone, the project shall (a) consist of a minimum total of thirty (30) new  dwelling units of multi‐family housing and (b) be located in a new structure(s) and  (c) be a mixed‐use development, unless the Administrator waives the minimum  number of new units requirement or the mixed‐use development requirement. The  Administrator cannot waive the new structure(s) requirement. If the Administrator  waives the mixed‐use development requirement, the multi‐family housing shall be  located in a new residential structure(s). At least fifty percent (50%) of the space  within the project shall be intended for permanent residential occupancy.  iii. If one hundred percent (100%) of the housing units in a  homeownership project are affordable housing, the project shall (a) consist of a  minimum of ten (10) new dwelling units of multi‐family housing and (b) be located  within a new residential structure(s) or a new mixed‐use development as allowed by  the RMC for the specific zone. At least fifty percent (50%) of the space within the  project shall be intended for permanent residential occupancy. The project shall  designate and sell at least fifty percent (50%) of total housing units as affordable for  households at or below eighty percent (80%) of median income, and designate and  sell any remaining housing units as affordable for households at or below one  hundred twenty percent (120%) of median income. In addition, the housing units  affordable for households at or below eighty percent (80%) of median income shall  AGENDA ITEM # 7. c) 8  ORDINANCE NO. ________    remain affordable in perpetuity through a community land trust or other similar  model acceptable to the City.  iv. Market‐rate townhome projects are not eligible for the exemption.   c. If the project is located in the Rainier/Grady Junction TOD Subarea and  within the Commercial Arterial (CA), Commercial Office (CO) Zone, or in the South  Lake Washington and within the Urban Center‐1 (UC‐1), or the Urban Center‐2 (UC‐ 2) Zone, the following applies:  i. If the project is located in the Rainier/Grady Junction TOD Subarea  or South Lake Washington and within the Commercial Arterial (CA), Commercial  Office (CO), Urban Center‐1 (UC‐1), or the Urban Center‐2 (UC‐2) Zone, the project  shall (a) consist of a minimum total of one hundred (100) new dwelling units of multi‐ family housing, subject to subsection  D.2.c.ii of this Section, and (b) be a new  structure(s) and (c) be a mixed‐use development, unless the Administrator waives  one or more of these requirements. If the Administrator waives the mixed‐use  development requirement, the multi‐family housing shall be located in a new  residential structure(s). At least fifty percent (50%) of the space within the project  shall be intended for permanent residential occupancy.  ii. If one hundred percent (100%) of the housing units in a  homeownership project are affordable housing, the project shall (a) consist of a  minimum of ten (10) new dwelling units of multi‐family housing and (b) be located  within a new residential structure(s) or a new mixed‐use development as allowed by  the RMC for the specific zone. At least fifty percent (50%) of the space within the  project shall be intended for permanent residential occupancy. The project shall  AGENDA ITEM # 7. c) 9  ORDINANCE NO. ________    designate and sell at least fifty percent (50%) of total housing units as affordable for  households at or below eighty percent (80%) of median income, and designate and  sell any remaining housing units as affordable for households at or below one  hundred twenty percent (120%) of median income. In addition, the housing units  affordable for households at or below eighty percent (80%) of median income shall  remain affordable in perpetuity through a community land trust or other similar  model acceptable to the City.   iii. Market‐rate townhome   projects   are   not   eligible   for   the  exemption.  3. Compliance Monitoring: Any applicant/owner with affordable housing  units in the project shall demonstrate experience and/or ability to provide affordable  housing and provide a third‐party entity to document compliance with the  affordable housing requirements for the annual reports further defined in  subsection K of this Section.  4. Exception for Existing Residential Structure: In the case of an existing  occupied residential structure that is proposed for demolition and redevelopment as  new multi‐family housing, the project shall provide as a minimum number of  dwelling units in the new multi‐family housing project, the greater of:  a. Replace the existing number of dwelling units and, unless the existing  residential rental structure was vacant for twelve (12) months or more prior to  demolition, provide for a minimum of four (4) additional dwelling units in the new  multi‐family housing project; or  AGENDA ITEM # 7. c) 10  ORDINANCE NO. ________    b. Provide the number of dwelling units otherwise required in subsection  D.2 of this Section.  5. Completion Deadline: The project shall be completed within three (3)  years from the date of approval of the contract by the City Council as provided in  subsection F.2 of this Section or by any extended deadline granted by the  Administrator as provided in subsection I of this Section.   SECTION III. The amended Eligible Areas for Multi‐Family Housing Incentives Map  (“Map”), as shown on Attachment A, is adopted by reference as if fully set forth herein. A copy of  Map shall be kept in the City Clerk’s office.  SECTION IV. Upon approval of the City Attorney, the City Clerk is authorized to direct the  codifier to make necessary corrections to this ordinance, including the corrections of scriveners or  clerical errors; references to other local, state, or federal laws, codes, rules, or regulations; or  ordinance numbering and section/subsection numbering and references.  SECTION V. If any section, subsection, sentence, clause, phrase or work of this  ordinance should be held to be invalid or unconstitutional by a court or competent jurisdiction, such  invalidity or unconstitutionality thereof shall not affect the constitutionality of any other section,  subsection, sentence, clause, phrase, or word of this ordinance.  SECTION VI.   This ordinance shall be in full force and effect five (5) days after publication of  a summary of this ordinance in the City’s official newspaper. The summary shall consist of this  ordinance’s title.  AGENDA ITEM # 7. c) 11  ORDINANCE NO. ________    PASSED BY THE CITY COUNCIL this day of , 2022.          ______________________________  Jason A. Seth, City Clerk     APPROVED BY THE MAYOR this day of , 2022.        ______________________________  Armondo Pavone, Mayor    Approved as to form:        Shane Moloney, City Attorney    Date of Publication:  ORD‐EHHS:2203:2/2/2022     AGENDA ITEM # 7. c) 12  ORDINANCE NO. ________              ATTACHMENT A  ELIGIBLE AREAS FOR MULTI‐FAMILY   HOUSING INCENTIVES MAP  AGENDA ITEM # 7. c) Edmonds Ave NEMain Ave SN 3rd St NE 12th St S Puget Dr S 7th St S 2nd St SWLan gstonRd Ho u se rW aySNE 16th S t N 4th St WilliamsAveNWilliams Ave SWellsAveSSunsetBlvdNETaylo r P l NWWells Ave NNE 3rd StHouserWayBypass Monroe Ave NES 21st St NE7th St Taylor Ave NWLind Ave SWNE 2nd St NE10th St N 6th St ShattuckAveSLogan AveNRainierAveSBronso n W a y N S 4th S t S 3rd St Park Ave NAberdeenAveNES G rad y Wa yHardieAveSW BensonRdSPuget Dr SEN 8th St NE 4th St NE Park D r Burnett AveSSW Suns et Blv d Airport WayR e nto n AveS LoganAveSS 4th Pl N 10th S t Garden Ave NN1 0 th P l LoganA ve N S 3 rd P lRainierAveN SunsetBlvdNMonroeAveNES L a n g s t o n R d GardenAveNHouser Way NLakeWashing t onBl vdNM a ple V alley H wy Talbot Rd SSW 7th St SW 16th St Oakesdale Ave SW¥405 ¥405 ¥405 ¥UV169 Sunset Downtown Eligible Areas for Multi-Family Tax Exemption Incentives 0 750 1,500 Feet° MFTE Eligible Areas Downtown South Lake Washington Sunset Rainier/Grady Junction TOD Subarea Parks & Open Space City limits Rainier/Grady Junction TOD Subarea South Lake Washington AGENDA ITEM # 7. c)