HomeMy WebLinkAboutLUA67-410 . . .
.__T _ . ,, _ . .. _ ___________________ __________ ,
_
- •/
9 i7o, i gb, 217 r, b s1_07
rY/L z V 'V f o Hof tit 98 3 f'
IY/4 •_97Zi fe'--r. '9/'r''�4 V HH a'O ,ft/IV L 0o L. dv A0Od 00 '
b ,
.,,,\ ,
/-?1 Vrr//yoz rry/1 SIX �_
L961 8� Nfl(' ./ i
' r/Mloip y so�►� �S s5er�� aN0 � Q],II7J)6 y tt�.
40 2' t7T) rf 2i. •","1E� TY-9r�'.� �p I7%1r7, P'J '��/� p a
i .
r.' 1 n Y/Ite -r'A4 a P'7 S'PV tn.-1/ 77/rr :7' - l •/:A. '
b, 7/.2 n 7El .�'O a•?/.i rr0 7 7fY/ G*02'N2 /2 . S"L 07 u� /
. .7 'tr 3 7 n�
1 i/ //
Ob=r. a �,s b 4 / _ - . I \-.
/ N^ ?i / I/
6 , /1 / i
• /\1
/ /
Ca7. A
r 41 i IS
/ / OA. (..
\I /. / i . _ .. Al l•-•
if.:
i /
/ o ,
h.?
/
.Uc,/<,,r 9�r-Z-
'f �!
______ I'
/ 4,
"'r' f NI Zf s , -74 � S' S
! i
'emsit'<‘ !
1 ' . n
,
/ ! �; 9n(7 �►c ffr7.1 a leri f ad...
C
/ ` vvoa' .s 'd/Y 7/l/gar 4)
, - e
i(
100 SECOND AVENUE BLDG. ---- P i:ki/t
PHONE: BA. 6-4660
' raci.,./7; OG ER I. LEWIS
/ ATTORNEY AT LAW
mo SECOND AVENUE
RENTON, WASHINGTON 98055
•
Tr e. -c- L.) v- A1 -cl
1;61 CITY OV RENTON CA Q- k--\
,---, CITY VATai A-1)
CEDAR RIVV?.. PARY4
RSMTONt WASNLriGTO:4 (6 k-k - 61
Attn: Hon. Donald 014ter, 2-!ayor LLI
Members of the City Council
/ Meabers of the Planning Commission
, .'ae. Petition for rewno
R 1 to R 3
Lots 41 througb 4
// Ei11474:an4s Lake Oashington Gar.len of i' dea No, 2 together
/ , a
/ ' with adjoininv shorelands .
1,0'0 PAR2 aBREBY UOTIMM •
M 6 OUIS FRSDERIC
,
TIUDZ:RSON petitioners in the abovo v4attor feeling themseivw4 . .
a ,aggrieved by the action o2 the Vling Comraosion Oa auly 2
1900 danying the Petition to rezone.
•
\ gUREDY givr.:. NOTICP. or. APPEAL to the city council pursuant
1
to sec. 4 72 c$ the cow of the City of Renton cat t'ait;3 arc
/ day of Auguott 1967.
PHIL PODVIN
LOUIS FREVERIC AZ11)1=-1.0N
: I
i
(
Ly
•
tr., .-- .-TE;J:Ur------'---
, 10J S . 2ad St. 5leg.
i gf.Inton, Washingt= 9305
, Bg 6 4660
. •
, y
C
k---C7.___\' °C i
i u - Lii
, 1967
/
.......... .............6..........
— C "---: 6rf-."'
---------7%-i:7-7 ................. 2LbP1'2.........
)-/Alt'j f/i) )
RENTON CITY COUNCIL
) REGULAR MEETING
August 28, 1967
8:00 P.M. Office of the City Clerk
The regular meeting of the Renton City Council was called to order by D. W. Custer,
Mayor, and the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag was recited in unison.
ROLL CALL OF COUNCIL MEMBERS: Trimm, Hulse, Schellert, Dahlquist, Pedersen,
Garrett, Perry, Delaurenti, Poli and Morris. Moved by Pedersen, seconded by
Dahlquist, that absent Councilman Gianini be excused. The r::otion carried.
OFFICIALS AND DEPARTMENT HEADS PRESENT: Helmie Nelson, City Clerk, Dorothea
Gossett, City Treasurer, G. M. Shellan, City Attorney, Jack Wilson, City
Engineer, Clarence Williams, Chief of Police, M. C. Walls, Fire Chief, Gordon
Ericksen, Planning Director, Vic TeGantvoort, Street Commissioner, Jan Klippert,
Administrative Assistant to the Mayor, Anne Harker, Librarian, Sven Johnson,
Building Director and Ted Bennett, Utility Accountant.
Moved by Trimm, seconded by Poll, that the Minutes of the previous meeting of
August 21, 1967 be approved as written. The motion carried. Dahlquist questioned
action taken by the Council in referring a matter to Committee of -the.Whole::then: making
appointments for the same thing put into Committee. Perry noted it was not put into
Committee of the Whole and explained,since Mrs. Dahlquist was not present at the
prior meeting,that the matter being considered was that there is presently a 3-
member board and 6 members for the two Boards are to be recommended; the resi€,na-
tions may be accepted or the persons may be reappointed and may still wish to
resign. Dahlquist inquired regarding policy of bringing •appointees,before •the
Committee of the Whole and Mayor Custer advised that at a Committee of the Whole
meeting the majority did not think this was proper procedure. The Mayor advised
that there has been a six member board, his first appointment having been to
appoint the same 3 people to each Commission and option is now under discussion.
Morris noted that with the two appointments to the Fire Civil Service Board there
are now 3 members already on this Commission. Garrett noted that there is still
a member on the Police Commission. (See later discussion under Committee Reports)
PUBLIC HEARING: Phil Podvin appeal of Planning Commission denial of rezone from
G6000 to R-3, property located on Lake Wn. Blvd. between 86th
and 87th Streets.
This being the date set, the hearing was declared open. Communication from
Planning Director Ericksen outlined Planning Commission action in its determina-
tion that the access question was of critical nature, that development of the
area as proposed would be detrimental to adjacent and surrounding properties and
it-.would:conflict with the Comprehensive Land Use Plan. Audience comment was
invited and Mr. Roger I. Lewis, Attorney for Mr. Podvin and Mr. Anderson advised
that: the subject property is suitable and logical for development as proposed,
that the area for some period has been residential with some older structures
and that this tract could well be updated to R-3 without being detrimental to
the surrounding properties. Attorney Lewis made note of Planning Commission
Minutes of 7-26-67 wherein motion to deny had been amended by addition of "it
being a premature zoning predicated upon the access problem " - - - Mr. Lewis
advised that the problem could be solved relative to both the grade and access
and it was requested that the Council grant the R-3 and if denied that the matter
be referred to Committee of the Council or back to the Planning Commission to allow
for some improvements. Mr. William Goddard, 8637 Lake Wn. Blvd. S.E. advised
that Mr. Podvin had mentioned a change in access which would involve the Goddard
property and as proposed would raise the roadway and leave the Goddard property-
without access. He also noted that petition had been submitted to the Planning
Commission objecting to the rezone.
Moved by Poli, seconded by Hulse,that the hearing be closed. Upon inquiry
Planning Director Ericksen advised the proposed zoning is in conflict with the
Comprehensive Plan. Attorney Lewis inquired whether G6000 was another way of
designating this as R-1. Planning Director Ericksen advised that the G6000
is a hold over from the original County zoning in the area but that it is
essentially equivalent to Single Family Residential the County allowing 5000 sq.
ft. and ours 6000. When annexed the G or General designation is given. Mr.
Lewis inquired whether G is used when the Commission is not sure how it is to be
used. Mr. Ericksen stated that all properties go into this classification re-
gardless of use and generally it would assume the land area designation it had
previously in the County. Mr. Ericksen stated that the entire Comprehensive Plan
is under study and hearings have been held in the past few months and that this
particular area located along the lake both on the existing and proposed plan is
proposed as Single Family Residential (R-1) . The pending motion was voted upon
and carried closing the hearing. -1-
/ _
(� ♦/ :. 4-.. Z . . - • RENTON,WASHINGTON
CITY HALL, RENTON , WASHINGTON 98055 • ALPINE 5 -3464
o
a � �
�9�spopr `o �� September 26, 1967
CAPITA
(2)
V
Members of the City Council
Renton, Washington
Gentlemen and Mrs. Dahlquist:
PLANNING COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION
re: Phil Podvin
Rezone Appeal (request for rezone
from G-6000 to R-3)
Upon completion of its review of the rezone request of
Mr. Phil Podvin, the Planning Committee recommends con-
currence with the recommendation of the Planning Commis-
sion to deny the rezone request since the proposed use
would not be in agreement with the Comprehensive Plan.
Very truly yours,
Thomas W. Trimm, Chairman
Planning Committee
( Y
•
•
October 9, .1967 '
•
Mr. Roger I. Lewis;
Attorney At; Law.-`
100 Second Avenue. Bldg.
Renton,'"Washington '.
Re: .'Appeal' of Rezorie Denial ...
,G6000.'to R-3 i. •= •.J//
Dear.,Mr.' Lewis:
This is:to.-advise that the- Renton City Council,' at its regular:,meeting
of October 2nd, hasconcurred,"in the Planning Committee recommendation
that:.the ,appeal of Mr.. Podvin .be denied inasmuch as the:zoning is. not
..: in,compliance .with the Comprehensive-.Plan.' - - . . , . - -
We .enclose: excerpt::from:the Minutes of the Council Meeting concerning •
this matter. . .
= Yours very::truly,a
CITY "OF RENTON
Heinle W.' Nelson' . . _ .
- City Clerk •
cc: 'Mr. .Podvin
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting 10-2-67
COMMUNICATIONS: Cont.)
Letter from City Engineer Wilson reported that the Petition foil Sanitilry' Seiler L.I.D.
in vicinity of area bounded by Sunset Blvd. East", 112th Avenue S.E. and Puget Sound
Power and Light Company Transmission Line right-of-way, is signed by owners who represent
70.34% of the lineal frontage upon the proposed improvement and by 63% of the owners
within the proposed district and the petition is valid. Moved by Hulse, seconded by
Schellert, to refer the matter to the Sanitation Committee for recommendation. Carried.
Petition was filed for the vacation of a portion of "Jt' Street between 9th Avenue North
and 10th Avenue North, signed by Harold R. Bean, for Globe Development Co., Inc., and
the Highlands Community Church. Moved by Hulse, seconded by Poli, to refer the petition
to the City Engineer and Street and Alley Committee for recommendation. Carried. Moved
by Trimm, seconded by Perry, to refer the matter to the Law and Ordinance Committee for
Resolution setting date for hearing. Carried.
PROCLAMATION:
Proclamation by Mayor Custer declared the week of October 8 through 14 as Oil Heat Week
in Renton, the oil industry representing a major service in the roll of community affairs.
Moved by Poll, seconded by Hulse, to concur in the Mayor's Proclamation. Carried.
APPOINTMENTS:
Letter from Mayor Custer requested concurrence in the appointment of Louise A. Craft
to position of Clerk-Dispatcher in the Renton Police Department, Civil Service Exam
to be successfully passed within four-month temporary appointment period. Moved by
Perry, seconded by nelaurenti, to concur in the appointment. Carried.
Mayor Custer submitted letter advising of appointment to Youth Guidance Committee of
Mr. Robert Trent to fill vacancy created by departure from the City of Mr. Gary Allard
former Parole Officer. Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Schellert, to concur. Carried.
Letter from Mayor Custer requested appointment confirmation for Thomas H. Cooke, James
R. Hawkins and Roger Richert, being reappointed as members of the Municipal Arts'
Commission for a period of three years. Moved by Perry, seconded by Delaurenti, to
concur in the appointments. Carried.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE REPORTS:
•Unfinished Business:
Council member Trimm, Chairman of the Planning Committee, submitted recommendation
1(
that the Phil Podvin rezone appeal be denied since the proposed use is not in agreement
with the Comprehensive Plan, upholding action of the Planning Commission in its denial
of rezone from R-1 to R-3. Moved by Morris, seconded by Poli, to concur in the Plannin
Committee recommendation. Carried.
Councilman Delaurenti, Chairman of the Fire and Water Committee,submitted report recom-
mending that Waterline bid W-242, between "E" Street and Sunset Blvd. E., South of 6th
Avenue North, be awarded to low bidder,U:Phi1 Gesner, d/b/a,'General Pipeline Construction
Co, 11025- 142nd S.E., Renton, in sum of $4,801.78. Further recommended that Water _
Project W-245 Bid for Watermain in 132nd Ave. S,E. between 4th Avenue North and S.E.
136th Street, be awarded to W. C. Frost Construction Co., 8005 South 222nd Street, ,Kent,
in sum of $8,916.46. Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Gianini, to concur. Carried.
The Fire and Water Committee recommended that the Agreement with Cornell, Howland, Hayes
and Merryfield,for engineering services on Cedar River Park Well No. 8, be accepted any}:,
the Mayor and Clerk be authorized to execute same. Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by ' i-
Schellert, to concur. The motion carried.
Councilman Poli, Chairman of the Light and Power Committee, reported that after some -`.
months of negotiation an Ordinance has been prepared granting unto the Puget Sound Power }
and Light Company a Franchise for operation within the City during ,a 30 year period. It '"
was recommended that the document be referred to the Law and Ordinance Committee. Moved -'
by Delaurenti, seconded by Schellert, to concur in the recommendation. Carried.
New Business:
Moved by Hulse, seconded by Delaurenti, that City of Renton Vouchers,Nos. 0015 through
0098, having been previously approved by the Auditing and Accounting Committee, be
approved by the Council for payment at this time. Carried. ( Fund breakdown on the
following page.)
-4-
AWN
RENTON CITY COUNCIL
REGULAR MEETING
August .28g 1967
8:00 P.M. Office of the City Clerk
t _
The regular meeting of the Renton City Council was called to order by D. W. Custer,
Mayor, and the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag was recited in unison.
ROLL CALL OF COUNCIL MEMBERS: Trimm, Hulse, Schellert, Dahlquist, Pedersen,
Garrett, Perry, Delaurenti, Poli and Morris. Moved by Pedersen, seconded by
Dahlquist, that absent Councilman Gianini be excused. The motion carried.
OFFICIALS AND DEPARTMENT HEADS PRESENT: Helmie Nelson, City Clerk, Dorothea
Gossett, City Treasurer, G. M. Shellan, City Attorney, Jack Wilson, City
Engineer, Clarence Williams, Chief of Police, M. C. Walls, Fire Chief, Gordon
Ericksen, Planning Director, Vic TeGantvoort, Street Commissioner, Jan Klippert,
Administrative Assistant to the Mayor, Anne Harker, Librarian, Sven Johnson,
Building Director and Ted Bennett, Utility Accountant.
Moved by Trimm, seconded by Poll, that the Minutes of the previous meeting of
August 21, 1967 be approved as written. The motion carried. Dahlquist questioned
action taken by the Council in referring a matter to Committee of .the.Whole:then:.making
appointments for the same thing put into Committee. Perry noted it was not put into
Committee of the Whole and explained,since Mrs. Dahlquist was not present at the
prior meeting,that the matter being considered was that there is presently a 3-
member board and 6 members for the two Boards are to be recommended; the resina-
tions may be accepted or the persons may be reappointed and may still wish to
resign. Dahlquist inquired regarding policy of brin_ging •appointeee,before •the
Committee of the Whole and Mayor Custer advised that at a Committee of the Whole
meeting the majority did not think this was proper procedure. The Mayor advised
that there has been a six member board, his first appointment having been to
appoint the same 3 people to each Commission and option is now under discussion.
Morris noted that with the two appointments to the Fire Civil Service Board there
are now 3 members already on this Commission. Garrett noted that there is still
a member on the Police Commission. (See later discussion under Committee Reports)
PUBLIC HEARING: Phil Podvin appeal of Planning Commission denial of rezone from
G6000 to R-3, property located on Lake Wn. Blvd. between 86th
and 87th Streets.
This being the date set, the hearing was declared open. Communication from
Planning Director Ericksen outlined Planning Commission action in its determina-
tion that the access question was of critical nature, that development of the
area as proposed would be detrimental to adjacent and surrounding properties and
it-would:conflict with the Comprehensive Land Use Plan. Audience comment was
invited and Mr. Roger I. Lewis, Attorney for Mr. Podvin and Mr. Anderson advised
that: the subject property is suitable and logical for development as proposed,
that the area for some period has been residential with some older structures
and that this tract could well be updated to R-3 without being detrimental to
the surrounding properties. Attorney Lewis made note of Planning Commission
Minutes of 7-26-67 wherein motion to deny had been amended by addition of "it
being a premature zoning predicated upon the access problem " - - - Mr. Lewis
advised that the problem could be solved relative to both the grade and access
and it was requested that the Council grant the R-3 and if denied that the matter
be referred to Committee of the Council or back to the Planning Commission to allow
for some improvements. Mr. William Goddard, 8637 Lake Wn. Blvd. S.E. advised
that Mr. Podvin had mentioned a change in access which would involve the Goddard
property and as proposed would raise the roadway and leave the Goddard property-
without access. He also noted that petition had been submitted to the Planning
Commission objecting to the rezone.
Moved by Poli, seconded by Hulse,that the hearing be closed. Upon inquiry
Planning Director Ericksen advised the proposed zoning is in conflict with the
Comprehensive Plan. Attorney Lewis inquired whether G6000 was another way of
designating this a`s R-1. Planning Director Ericksen advised that the G6000
is a hold over from the original County zoning in the area but that it is
essentially equivalent to Single Family Residential the County allowing 5000 sq.
ft. and ours 6000. When annexed the G or General designation is given. Mr.
Lewis inquired whether G is used when the Commission is not sure how it is to be
used. Mr. Ericksen stated that all properties go into this classification re-
gardless of use and generally it would assume the land area designation it had
previously in the County. Mr. Ericksen stated that the entire Comprehensive Plan
is under study and hearings have been held in the past few months and that this
particular area located along the lake both on the existing and proposed plan '
proposed as Single Family Residential (R-1) . The pending motion was voted upon
and carried closing the hearing. -1- ,
Minutes - Renton City Council Meeting 8-28-67
PUBLIC HEARING: Podvin Appeal of Planning Commission rezone denial (Cont.)
Moved by Hulse, seconded by Poll, that the Planning Commission action be upheld
denying the rezone. Moved by Schellert, in regard for Attorneys request, to refer
the matter to the Planning Committee for recommendation; The motion was seconded
by Pedersen and carried. Hulse opposed.
COMMUNICATIONS:
Letter of intent to an 'ex property located East of 132nd Ave. S.E. and South of 116th
Avenue S.E., was submitted by Mr. Ivan Gibeault and read by the City Clerk. Moved by
Hulse, seconded by Schellert, to refer the letter to the City Engineer for checking
signatures for validity of ownership and for recommendation as to boundaries. Carried.
Letter from Vern Church, Purchasing Agent requested appropriation of excess revenue,
received from insurance through damage to city automotive equipment settlements, in
sum of $486.91, into Equipment Rental Account 3600/506 to bring the budgetary account
into proper balance. Moved by Schellert, seconded by Delaurenti, to concur in the
request with referral to the Law and Ordinance Committee for necessary Resolution.
The motion carried.
Letter from Gene Coulon, Park Director, requested transfer of $183.10 from Cumulative
Reserve Fund 1990 unto the Park Department Account 6120/303 M. & 0. to pay for energy
used in the Liberty Park ballfield lighting system. Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by
Perry, to concur in the request with referral to the Law and Ordinance Committee for
proper Resolution. Carried.
Letter from Del Bennett, Traffic Engineer, submitted and recommended for payment in
sum of $11,807.79, final estimate for work performed by General Service Electric, Inc.
on C.AG. 1070-66, Rainier Avenue Traffic Signal System Contract, ASP #8. The work was
completed on 8-25-67 and accepted by the Traffic Engineering Division on 8-28-67 and
Council acceptance as of this date was recommended with commencement of the thirty day
lien period. If no liens are filed against the project and upon proof of payment of
tax liabilities,the retained amount of $4,434.99 may thereafter be released to the
Contractor. Moved by Poli, seconded by Hulse, to concur in the recommendations with
referral to the Auditing and Accounting Committee with power to act. Carried.
Letter from Park Director Coulon submitted and recommended for payment, final estimate
for work performed by Ricardi Construction on the Talbot Hill Shelter Contract. Amount
due this date, $3,036.72. The work was accepted by the Parks and Recreation Department
on 8-25-67 and acceptance by the Council as of 8-28-67 with commencement of the 30-day
retention period was recommended. If after 30 days no liens or claims are filed against
the project and upon proof of payment of tax liabilities the retained amount of
$3,601.95 may be released to Contractor. Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Perry, to
concur with referral to the Auditing and Accounting Committee with power to act. The
motion carried.
Letter from Del Bennett requested permission to call for bids for traffic signal
installation at intersection of 116th Avenue S.E. and the Easterly approach to the
North Renton Interchange. This project is included in the Traffic Engineering Capital
Improvement Budget for 1967. September 18th was recommended as date for bid opening.
Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Poll, to concur in the recommendations and grant the
bid call for 9-18-67. Carried.
Petition signed by 34 persons requested installation of stop signs at the intersection
of "K" Street and 10th Avenue North. Moved by Poli, seconded by Perry, to refer the
matter to the Traffic Engineer and the Street and Alley, Committee. Carried.
Letter from Jan Klippert, Admin. Assistant to the Mayor, reported that the City's
H.U.D. application for beautification funds through the U.S. Dep't. of Housing and
Urban Development has been withdrawn, no funds being available to the City in .1967.
Upon Council recommendation the application will be resubmitted. on October 1, 1967
to request consideration for 1968. Moved by Delaurenti, seconded by Perry, to concur
in the report and to authorize and recommend that the application be resubmitted on
October 1st. Carried.
Letter from Arvin 0. Basnight, Director, Dep't. of Transportation, F.A.A. advised that
$15,459.00 has been allocated,under the Federal Aid Airport Program,to the Renton
Municipal Airport in response to request for Land acquisition - North Clear Zone. A
Representative will be in communication in the near future to outline requirements
for establishing a realistic work schedule for the project, delay in undertaking the
work causing projects to be revaluated in competition for limited funds available.
-2-
I \
August 28, 1967
The Honorable Donald W. Custer, Mayor
Members of the City Council
Renton, Washington 98055
Re: Phil Podvin Rezone Appeal, Appl. No. R-410-67,
rezone from G-6000 to R-3; property located on
Lake Washington between S.E. 86th and 87th Ste.
Gentlemen and Mrs. Dahlquist:
The Planning Commission reviewed the rezone request of Mr. Phil Pod-
vin at its July 26, 1967 public hearing meeting. The property under
consideration has the following general characteristics:
Total Area--12,800 sq. ft.+
tRistin Zonin --G-6000
Pr no pal Access--Lake Washington Blvd. (via 15' easement)
Proposed Use--multi-family residential
bompre eTerie Plan--single family residential
The proposed rezone request to R-3 is to allow construction of an
apartment building. The area is Presently developed predominately
for single family, residential use. The access to the property is
presently via a 15-foot easement and requires crossing of the ex-
isting railroad tracks and use of the railroad right-of-way.
The Planning Commission members, in their study of the area, felt
that the access question was of 'a critical nature and there appears
to be no way such access could be improved under the existing cir-
cumstances. The Planning Commission also felt that development of
this area for proposed apartment use would have detrimental effects
on the adjacent and surrounding properties and was, not in the best
interests of the area nor in accord with the Comprehensive Land Use
Plan.
Upon completion of its review, the Planning Commission concluded
that the best use for the property in question is for R-1 single
family residential purposes and that the proposed R-3 zoning would
be in conflict with the Comprehensive Plan.
Very truly yours,
Gordon Y. Ericksen
Planning Director
cc: Mayor D. W. Custer
•
.. . August 9, 1967 +�'
•
•
M . Roger . Lewis
ttorney at Law '
100.Second Avenue'
Renton. Washington
•
Re: ...Phil:Podv .n Louis s F. Anderson '
•
•
' Appeal of Planning••Coramiss on
Rezone Denial - 7;26-67 /
Dear.lir. Lewis: i
The._Renton"•.Cf,ty Council,; at' its :regular mee;bng of .August;7, 1967 has . s
• set the date of-August'.28, 1967 in he- Counci.1''Chambers, Ctty.:Hall
Rentcin, Washington at 8:00 p.m.' as .time and places for:public hearing f
on the above-captioned 'appeal.
•
Yours very truly,
CITY OF RCNTON
Helmie W. Nelson ,
City Clerk
•
•
•
100 COND AVENUE BLDG 1 '/ PHONE: BA. 6-4660
J"y��1 ^' /A"!�- R O G ER I. LEWIS
4 t1� ATTORNEY AT LAW
�lY 100 SECOND AVENUE
k` RENTON, WASHINGTON 98055
TO: CITY OF RENTON
CITY HALL
CEDAR RIVER PARK
RENTON, WASHINGTON
Attn: Hon. Donald Custer, Mayor
Members of the City Council
Members of the Planning Commission ,
Re . Petition for rezone
. R 1 to R 3
Lots 41 through 48
Block A.
Hillman 's Lake Washington Garden of Eden No . 2 together
with adjoining shorelands .
YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED
That the undersigned PHIL PODVIN and LOUIS FREDERIC
ANDERSO1 . !petitioners in the above matter feeling themselves
aggrieved by the action of the Planning Commission on July 26 ,
1967 , denying the Petition to rezone.
HEREBY give NOTICE OF APPEAL to the city council pursuant
to sec. 4- 728 of tie code of the City of Renton dated this 3rd
day of August, 1967 .
PHIL PODVIN
LOUIS FREDERIC ANDERSON
By
hR '. LEW
1 0 . 2nd St. Bldg.
,enton, Washington 98055
A 6 4660
1 LED
AUG r 1967
C1T.cic. .............
APPLICATION FOR CHANGE OF ZONE IN .THE CITY OF RENTON
FOR OFFICE USE ONLY
Application No. : Sec. -Twp. -R.
Date of Filing : Area Map
PlanrZom. ( Action:i n Kroll Page
Date: 1.2,6-‘1 Receipt No. 53L\5
City Council Action:
Date: Ord. :
APPLICANT TO ANSWER ALL THE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS NEATLY AND ACCURATELY:
Name of Applicant Ph l •Pnr3v; Address 1 2n e 7 aPI,,:;:,1,11i- tvn
Telephone No.
C9.�
Property Petitioned for rezoning is situated on 8625 Lake `ie,shi:three£, _
between 5/ -C 51� (?'P Street and Water P:Y'ort -Flee Wash_ Street.
Legal Description of Subject Property 1 a•zS 45...A 6_,2,7—A8 B1 ce A
Auk. , n
11r
ryl
-
.M
-
Lots 41 through 48 inclusive of Block A, C . D . Hillman ' s Lake Washington
Garden of Eden, Division #2, as recorded in Vol . 11 of Plats , Page 64 ,
Records of King County, ,Washington; together with--.s=e_co declass shore-
lands adjoining . k-fir
•i•;,!'� ‘cc; 1967 1.
�y e
/NG bE.?-r
Existing Zoning G--6000_ _ -- Zoning Requested R--3
What are the uses you propose to develop on this property?_ _m1t-i ple_ __ __
dwelling -nits
Number Of permanent off-street parking spaces that will be provided on
this property?_ _one_ s ace Loar_e .oh unit Number required
-- ----- - - -- -
NOTE TO APPLICANT: The__following_ factors _are
considered _in_ reclassifying property. Evidence
or additional information. you_,desire to submit_ to
substantiate your request May be attached to these
sheets:
1. In what way is this proposed change in zoning in the public interest?
• Rent;aI.cunits .fom Boe-j_TIP workers tiers
2. : On what basis is there a real need in this community for more zoning
of' the type you request? So poop3_e working .in Renton could. live, ncare r_ -
- -- - [:ovm ^_rta wou1_n.- pot.. air.! - to d-ri tre. imrE nl:v c r _mcy rn-i_L s 'i o work - - - -
3. Do you consider the property involved in this application to be more
suit-able for the uses permitted in the proposed zone than for the uses
permitted in the present classification: Please explain:
More poOple could enjoy water front then now on .s.ik,7le_units- _-_ --_
4.- What prOVR:sion Would you make to protect adjacent and surrounding prop-
erty from the detrimental effects of any uses permitted in the proposed
toilet _-- Will build to-_Renton.._ __ode.. . -- -
• Renton Planning ,Commission
Meeting July. 26, 1967
Minutes
. Page- 2
3 . NEW BUSINESS
FINAL -PLAT-APPLICATIONS
(a) and (b) VICTORIA PARK.#LAND 02 , , TRANSAMERICA :DEVELOPMENT COMPANYt
APPL. ' NOS . : FP-413-67 AND 414=67;' PROPERTY LOCATED GENERALLY IN-THE
SOUTHEAST AREA OF 14TH AVE . S. AND ' TALBOT ' ROAD .
The Planning Director stated . that some.,.changes had ' been • requested by.
the Planning Department on.. the plats . The, revised plats - had come in
too late. to be,.reviewed .by' the Planning and- Engineering Departments;
and he. requested these matters be continued for two weeks .
ACTION : .
Moved by. Stredicke, seconded by Sterling, that the final plat applica-
tions . for Victoria Park Nos . 1 and 2 be,. continued to the meeting of
August 9; 1967 . . Motion carried unanimously .
REZONE 'APPLICATIONS
Y:r(c). PODVIN, PHIL, APPL . NO. R-410-67, REZONE FROM G-6000 TO R-3; .
PROPERTY LOCATED ON LAKE WASHINGTON BETWEEN S .E'. 86TH AND 87TH STS .
The Chairman described the rezone application and read a letterof
protest from David and Pearl. Martin 'of- 8609 Lake Washingto-nBlvd .
accompanying a' petition containing the signatures of 11 property -
owners in- the area . The Planning Director pointed- out the location .
1 of. the property on the. zoning map and, stated ' thatraccess to the prop-
erty was over the.. railroad. right-of-way. and consisted of- a 15-foot'
easement , The area is ..predominately single family residential , in
nature.. He stated that there would be significant-access-problems .
if. the property were developed. as ' proposed for multi=family use,
it Mr . Podvin, the applicant , spoke in behalf of the rezone,,application
and stated he• would be willing to donate. five , feet of ' his property
to widen the access .
Slides .. of the property in question were shown ;
F
Mr. Walter England, 8605 : Lake Washington Blvd . , and Mr. George; Hauth
of 8611 Lake Washington Blvd . ' spoke in opposition to the , rezone' appli
cation stating the.. area, should' remain. single . famiiy , residential in •
nature . .
. Discussion followed concerning interpretation ' of- the use shown by the-
'Comprehensive Plan for this area and the fact ' that this' area isshown
on the proposed revised Comprehensive Plan as. Park . Racanello moved
to continue this hearing . until after the meeting on. the revised Com- .
prehensive Plan. Motion died for- lack- of second . Stredicke' stated
the same people ' opposing this multiple residential ,application ,were
against -.the green belt . proposal,- which represents R-1 zoning, and that,
-he was at a loss:,to ' understand. just. what - the people protesting really
wanted. , It was moved by. Denzer, seconded by Sterling, that the hear-
ing be closed. . Motion , carried, with Stredicke and: Racanello dissent •
-
ing ,
_ACTION :
It was moved by Stredicke, .seconded, by Brower, that the , application
of Phil Podvin ' for R-3 zoning be denied as it is in conflict 'with
the Comprehensive Plan; . and that the ' Planning Commission ,recommend
to the City ' Council that the highest use' of the property be Rol :
Renton Planning Commission
Meeting July- 26, 1967
Minutes -
Page - 3
Stone. moved that Stredicke ' s . motion be -amended to state • that - Mr .
Podvin,' s application .be- denied at this time - as . it is- premature
predicated on the access problem which, according to photographs
viewed, - indicates extremely- steep ingress=egress across a railroad
track and- a very definite view obstruction - at- the railroad track
at .the crest of • the hill . The- motion to amend was carried unani-
mously. The pending motion, as amended, to deny the rezone appli-
t cation request carried unanimously .
The Chairman advised the applicant of his - right to appeal the - decision
of- the Planning Commission by letter addressed to - the City Council
within ten days . .
(d) ' HOLMES, JAY E. , APPL . NO. • R-411-67, REZONE FROM G-6000 TO L-1;
PROPERTY LOCATED ON GRADY WAY -BETWEEN 86TH AND ' 87TH. AVES . ' S .
The Chairman - described the rezone.,,application. ., Slides - of- the property
in question were shown . As there were no . comments- either- from the
Commission or the- audience on - this application, - it was moved by.
Stredicke, seconded- by- Stone, .that.-.the hearing -be..closed. Motion
carried unanimously. .
ACTION :
It was moved by Stredicke, seconded by Denzer, that the rezone appli -
cation of Jay. £. - Holmes for rezoning to L-1 be , approved-. and forwarded.
to the City Council as it -agrees - with - the Comprehensive Plan . Motion
carried unanimously, ,
(e) REALTY - INVESTORS, - INC . ; APPL . NO, 'R-412-67, REZONE FROM Rr4 TO
B-1 ; PROPERTY LOCATED ON L ST. BETWEEN 12TH AVE ., N . AND 11TH PL.
The - Chairman- described the rezone - application. Slides . of the property
. in question were shown. The Planning Director pointed out the loca
tion of- the property on the --zoning map and stated that the property
is made -I of three lots comprising .a frontage of somewhat over 225 ' , .
• 100 ' in depth. .
Stone stated that as there may be a possible . conflict ,on his part
with reference to this application, ..he -would abstain from comment
or voting on the application.
•
The applicant , Mr . - Hallie -Smiley, spoke . on - behalf of' the rezone,
stating that he was unable to get - all the necessary financing for
a ,proposed _ apartment development - on the property . and that he hoped
to use - a portion of - it for the construction of offices . including a
real estate -office for his own use . • He said he was still planning
the apartment construction when financing problems had been worked
out . It was noted that offices were allowed in R-2 and R-3 by special
permit from the Planning Commission, and . the applicant was asked if- he ,
would accept a - lesser residential zoning . . Mr . Smiley replied •that he
would prefer not . to give up the , R-4 zoning already on, the, property .
Discussion followed,.concerning uses .in.. the surrounding areas , , defini-
tion of the term . "professional" - offices as applied to the real estate
business, and the- amount of- usable - land• area of - the property under-
discussion -due to the power line . running across . the
Stredicke moved the hearing be - closed; Sterling seconded. Motion ,
carried unanimously .
ACTION :
Stredicke stated , that :,he - felt -the best use; of this - property is ,.mul- .
tiple family residential , that the logical cutoff line for business •
N ,
Renton Planning Commission
- - Meeting July- 26, 1967
Agenda •
Page 2'
Planning and Engineering - Department staffs - have met with the developers
and their . engineers for -plat review. Some' minor- changes were requested,
The- Engineering Department, however., ' has not- had an opportunity to check
Out the changes,,.due to the, late -submittal of the revisions. Request
continuation of this matter for two weeks .
REZONE APPLICATIONS
. (c). Podvin, Phil, Appl. -.No. R-410-67, rezone- from G-6.000 - to R-3; '
property located on Lake Washington between.. S.E. 86th and 87th Sts. •
Total Area--12-, 800 - sq.
Existing Zoning--G-6000
• Principal- Access--Lake. Washington -Blvd.
Proposed Use--multi-family -residential
Comprehensive Plan--single family - residential
Staff- Comments: The property in. question is located on Lake Washing-
ton in. a predominately-'single- family residential area. - Development
of the property- for proposed apartments would result - in. problems ..for
the residents of the area. Access to the property- is questionable and
requires crossing of existing railroad right-of-way. Recommendation:
Recommend denial - as proposed- use- would - not be suitable under. existing
conditions.
Commission Comments: Commission members in review- of, the area felt
that the access question was-.of a critical nature. There appeared
o be no way- such- access could be improved under- existing- circum-
stances. Commission members felt proposed rezone. was not- feasibl.e-.
Recommendation: Denial.
•
(d) Holmes , Jay. E. -, Appl. . No. R-411-67, rezone-- from G-6000 to L-1; '
property located - on.Grady Way- between 86th and 87th Ayes: S.
Total Area--36 ,400 - sq. ft.
Existing Zoning--G-6000
Principal..Access=-Renton -Junction Way
• . Proposed Use--light industry
Comprehensive. Plan--light industry
• Staff Comments : Proposed use-. is realistic and in, accordance- with the
Comprehensive- Plan. Recommend approval.,
Commission Comments : Recommend approval..
(e) Realty- Investors, - Inc. , Appl. -No. R-412-67 , rezone from R-4 to
B-1; property located- on•L St,. between 12th Ave.. N. and llth- P1.
Total Area--2.3,560 sq. ft.
Existing Zoning--R-4-
Principal Access--L St. and- 12th Ave. N. -
Proposed Use--business
Comprehensive .Plan--high density multi-family residential
• Staff Comments : , Proposed rezone- to B-1 is to allow- use of a, portion
of theproperty fronting, on .l2th Ave. N. for a: real._estate office.
Property owner- has indicated -that- this is ..the extent of his proposed
business development at this time. . Previously; it was-,his intention
to develop the- property for R-4 apartments; however_, various; problems .
were. encountered and the proposed project.:apparently - is...still pending.
Recommendation: . Rezone-only-that--portion of the- property: required-
for the proposed use. Proposed use would- not affect the total devel-
opment of the-:area to- any appreciable--extent; access control, however,
would be- required:
Ai
a.
PETITION FOR REZONING PROPERTY IN THE CITY OF RENTON
We, the undersigned property owners, herewith petition the City Council to rezone
from O�ip6'v - J D ict 'othrough 48, BloDl st-r',)ct{tl afc'Id
owing territory in the Ci -y"of Rentons
Lake Washington Garden of Eden Liu. 2, together with shoreia-r"' ices acj311ii---
- ing, situated in the County of, King and State of Washington
We understand that the following uses, among others, will be permitted if this area
The property may be used
is rezoned
for the purpose or erecting thereon
multiple dwelling units .
NAME AND ADDRESS LEGAL DESCRIPTION
Phil Podvin Lot 45 -46- 47 48 Block A.
12017 Ashworth Ave No. Hillman ' s Lake Wash,
Seattle Wash '08133 Garden Of Eden # 2 Ane Ajoning
Shore lands
RF
4, palEo °
��� 23 q tiG"7
AFFIDAVIT
PHIL PODVIN being duly sworn, declare that I
am the owner of the property involved in this application and that the fore-
going statements and, answers herein contained and the information herewith-
submitted are in all respects true and correct to the best of my khowle4ge
and belief.
Subscribed and sworn to me this
(r, day of /1)/(aita_,/ 190
Notary Public in and for the State
Seattle.
of Wash j7n,:eing at ::•• •,t)2571.
( • _ Trignature of Owner)
-A--7 ,••=,r11/.16(-11.0.rth 10' th Street.
• "I' ,t 12017 Ashworth Avenue North
UklArersithip (Mailing Address)
I, co. ,
c
sv../e Seattle, - Washington
"""" •-•,\ (City) (State)
Emerson 3-7697
(Telephone) '
(OFFICE USE ONLY)
CERTIFICATION
This is to certify that the foregoing application has been inspected by gle and
has been found to be thorough and complete in every particular and to Conform
to the rules and regul - the Planning Department governing the filing
of such application. 0 /1/?,
eigNb
Date received , 19 BY;
... . ................
'
PETITION R)R REZONING PROPERTY IN THE CITY OF RENTON
We, the undersigned property owners, herewith petition the City Council to rezone
from Ag 0 District Ptrthe foll-
owing terrotory on the City of Rentong Tracts 1. A A 4 r
Hillmanls Lake Washington Garden of Edon Addition to Seattle No. 20 as per plat •
recorae in olume 11 of Plats on page 64, records of King County; TOGETHER WITH
s 0 0'' .4 V.&W i OW aoutzing . ereon;
situate in the County of King State of W sh ----------------------
We understand that the following uses, among others, will be permitted if this area
is rezoned
NAME AND ADDRESS
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
Lorn.s ric Anderson, 15051 N.E. Bellevue-Redmond Road, Bellevue, Washington
Margit Anne Jackson, 2412 East Miller, Seattle, W^ 4
°C)
g50
3101,A
.........
--------------
r IN G
y f M
• A F F I D A �? I T
I , LOUIS FREDRIC ANDERSON and MARGIT ANNE JACKSON being duly, sworn, declare that I
am the owner of the property involved in this application and that the fore-
going statements and answers herein contained and. the information herewith
submitted are in all respects true and correct to the best of my knowledge
and belief.
Subscribed and sworn to me this
44, day of .April 19 67 .
•
Notary Public in a.rid for the. State
Seattle. �, •
of Was ��^n -0ia,iR)r`eid�z.ng at K,, i e !!ram ��-,� 9_,,,,A,-„,_)
•
• (Name) "<."0r:';,,,`,Ac_. • (Signature of Owner) .
(LFA) 15051 N. EoBellevue-Redmond Road,Bellevue,Wn
1908 North 36th, Seattle, Wash. 98103
(Address) (Mailing Address) . '•
' (MAJ) 2412:Ea6t Miller, Seattle, Washington
. (City) (State)
SHerwood 6-7837 and E./1st 9.1372 respectively..
' (Telephone)
. (OFFICE 'USE ONLY) .
CERTIFICATION
•
This is to certify that the foregoing application has been inspected by me and
has been found to be thorough and complete in every particular and to conform
to the rules and regula, „%ons of the Planning Department governing .the filing
of such applicatio.-� -
' ''.\ ' g\W.b 16
Date received j �,,,,, , 19 BY:
z_ .mow•,�_
92 .<7
David J. and Pearl M. Martin
8609 Lake Wash. Blvd. , S. E.
Renton, Washington.
July 10, 1967
To: Renton City Council
Renton, Wash.
Re: July 26th Rezoning Hearing.
Dear Sirs:
Due to the fact that we will be on a planned vacation on
the date of July 26th, 1967, we wish to send in our
written protest against the rezoning of Mr. Podvin's
property here on Lake Wash. This includes the lots forty
five through forty nine and an adjacent tract mentioned,
forty one through forty four, owned by a Mr. Anderson.
We wish to point out that Mr. Podvin does not have legal
access or easement of any kind to his property and never
has had. We have a deed and have papers to prove that we
have owned and paid taxes on the East fifteen feet of
his property, which includesthe road in back of his land,
for many years. This was a former Northern Pacific Railway
property purchased many years ago in a separate trans-
action and picked up by a few of us here during a County
tax-land sale for back taxes. Most of us now own our
fifteen feet in back of our homes, but not Mr. Podvin.
The narrow road leading into this area has been posted as
a 'Private Road' for many years and is not adequate for
more than' the immediate home owners, m it does not go
through and the turn arounds are executed in driveways
and etc.
The view for everyone would also be restricted if such a
structure as a apartment house was allowed and none of
the home owners here or above the area wgnt it.
ncerel urs
A' REIFIIE `o
UL 9 Nei
�9 '`
0GU41 e qS
' vk
AGAINST
PETITION ilai REZONING PROPERTY IN THE CITY OF RENTON _ _
We, the undersigned property owners, herewith petition the City Councilto rezone
from Residential ee District to R 3 District, the foll -
owing territory in the City of Rentons -
Lots 45, 46, 47, and 48 of Lake Wash. Garden of Eden Div
#2 -(Blk A Hillman' s) Also Tract of lots 41, 42, 43, and 44;
We understand that the fol lowing uses, among others, will be permute " i f this area .
is rezonedo __ __.__. ,�
14.
/ . ,
NAME AND ADDR SS LEGAL DESCRIPTION
v i/ / /I 14%...7-5 ,2'•f r l.#4etesii 02.5
, ;.�62,4-/ -ram .cam ./e ,j 6 - d 4 I c';� 37 7
,,L ,,,--e,,
s - ...-5._.„ A__„4
,„, ,_,,,,_ ..._
_ _
_ _
-6-,, ® s_ 7 , t -
12
G
,57, e 0 _, 2.,kd Zt,)el..- .. AD_,e-1,•-etitk_ `:•--rii..-,:vij' ; , L1-1- 3_(r ,
,4`��--7� ( ) a r.- _-____ `.____�.__._.__,________ __.,
L , i)1k),A, 1(01-1 ,se,,, ,-P G$e
is G iI ,10 U a)0,e1,, 49,0j _ -- it,
iep — r--0_,.. a_9._,,,. , yQ.S"_
___..„_(
1
17//c
c1A--/ 9/L, - i-z.er,,,
Fey-s- Mi, ',/;/a/i 7/e,Le' z_o 6-6- — ,5- .
.______________________ _
r (/:
A__,- .„7
252-, __, ,,41 7-, _5 .1------///<' - , -.
(,p 4,,,,,,,,,,,d
1
. _ r
•- - . -
f . 2 7 c>. ti-7,--, _i_„_,_e 6', , c4.----ZE.,- s- 8 _-,3-)V/
/L� a Z
0
• •
c
, V _ . .
5- . 7 ... . .
. ,,...
. ,,
/ -. -
. .
.):;:.'"-7. ,i. , .. - • %,_...i •••: -: //•.. 7/,. , ,./ • .
• .
: • • •
• .. . .
/7 xl..-el...--- --)1'' -•-•-•..."‘_.'9-/ ._.„- - _____)c-4-‘, .- . .
. . , .
.---- . - . . .. .. _.•
. • • -
• F‘ .. 7 2.4-1-1 i.;-- My. J.3 Z.. I).P, S.L-- , ...„
'',...'
-
....
_z• ,_,
•
.,.,. •
C5 /4/e ivieisw,it-es- x) szv -, - .
../ 0 f- 6 5' — •
— —
. .
, .
• .
• .
. .,
.. .
-,: , • ..
. .
, • .
• . __ ____ _
----•-----------
-
•
- J- • .
•
/
. .
_....--
- . . _..
Ifilil yor
20, 20,;(7 A,:.....et":o
.. .
.. .
. .
. . . _
, * .
, .
...
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION
RENTON, WASHINGTON
A PUBLIC HEARING WILL BE HELD BY THE RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION AT ITS
REGULAR MEETING IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS, CITY HALL, RENTON, WASHINGTON
ON JULY 26, , 19 67 , AT 8 :00 P.M. TO CONSIDERYealftWannit
THE FOLLOWING PETITIONS : .
numumnxilmecommx
X1X CX °®4104
1 . REZONE FROM G-6000 TO R-3, property located on Lake Washington
Immm
between S.E. 86th and 87th Sts . LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lots 41 thru
48 inclusive of Block A, C. D. Hillman' s Lake Washington Garden of
Eden, Division #2, as recorded in Vol . 11 of Plats, Page 64, Records
of King County, Washington ; together with second class shorelands
adjoining.
2. REZONE FROM G -6000 TO L-1 , property located. on Grady Way between
. 86th and 87th Ayes . S. LEGAL DESCRIPTION : Lots 19 thru 31
inclusive, Block 27, C. D. Hillman' s Earlington Gardens Division
#1, as recorded in Vol . 17 of Plats, Page 74 , Records of King
County, Washington. .
3. REZONE FROM R-4 TO B-1 , property located on L St . between 11th P1 .
and 12th Ave. N. LEGAL DESCRIPTION : Lots 1 to 3 inclusive, Block 1 ,
Graceland Terrace, according to Plat recorded in Vol . 60 of Plats,
Page 64, Records of King County, Washington.
ANY AND ALL PERSONS INTERESTED OR OBJECTING TO SAID PETITIONS
ARE INVITED TO BE PRESENT AT THE PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING ON
JULY 26, , 1967 , AT 8 : 00 P.M. TO VOICE THEIR PROTEST OR OBJECT
TION TO SAME.
JAMES E. DENZER ,SECRETARY
PUBLISHED July 13, 1967 RENTON PLANNING COMMISSION
CERTIFICATION
I, James L. Magstadt , Hereby certify that three (3) copies of the
above document were posted by me in thre nspicuous places on the prop-
erty described abo&66as prescribed by 1
Subscrih d:sworn to
ATTEST: - : :� SI ..
befo e,_,a-Nti ;, ub�lic, on the
/1` Lday fa 'u yltA157.